1 / 22
Axion Dark Matter Search with Optical Interferometers
Ippei Obata (physical cosmology group, MPA)
PRL 123, 111301 (2019) arXiv:1903.02017 PRL 121, 161301 (2018) arXiv:1805.11753 Collaborators :
Koji Nagano (JAXA), Tomohiro Fujita (ICRR)
Yuta Michimura, Yuka Oshima, Taihei Watanabe, Masaki Ando (University of Tokyo)
2020.10.6 MPA Cosmology seminar
2 / 22
Overview
Axion
Optical Interferometry
n Important old problem n Candidate for dark matter
n Most recent technological innovation such as gravitational wave detectors n Possible to test a tiny tiny signal of phase modulation
Apply!
KAGRA
→ Pioneering a new phase of axion search!
3 / 22
What is Axion?
A pseudo NG boson of PQ mechanism in order to solve the strong CP problem in QCD physics
n A scalar field with small mass, tiny interactions
(Peccei & Quinn, 1977, …)
A plentitude of axion-like particles provided by the compactifications of extra dimensions
(Witten 1984, …)
→ candidate for cold dark matter
QCD Axion
Axion-like particles (ALPs, string axion)
L QCD ✓G G, ˜ | ✓ | . 10 10
✓
<latexit sha1_base64="bJu1+snspvXOIkIVF6PGD8Z8Ph0=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="bJu1+snspvXOIkIVF6PGD8Z8Ph0=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="bJu1+snspvXOIkIVF6PGD8Z8Ph0=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="bJu1+snspvXOIkIVF6PGD8Z8Ph0=">AAADJHichVG/axRBFH63/kg8f+SijWAzeuSQROOsCIogBCPEwiKXeLnITTxm92Zvh8z+cGf2NG6uFuzFwkpBQfwX7Gws7CRFGnuxjGChhe92V0SD8S2788333vfefjwnVlIbSrcr1r79Bw6OjR+qHj5y9NhEbfL4io7SxBUtN1JRsupwLZQMRctIo8RqnAgeOEq0nfX5Ub49EImWUXjbbMRiLeD9UHrS5Qapbu1JgwXc+C5X2a1hN2NGPDBZc/7GcEiYTmMtDGHGF4aTBWak6olsYXiOsHsp75HNIrNJmBJaaxkQm97NztsUtazaKLIskX3f8CSJ7hfEryHC83DItbL7DGGxLy942EsRu1ur01maB9kN7BLUoYzFqPYWGPQgAhdSCEBACAaxAg4anw7YQCFGbg0y5BJEMs8LGEIVtSlWCazgyK7jt4+3TsmGeB/11LnaxSkK3wSVBKboFn1Nd+h7+oZ+pj/+2SvLe4z+ZQNPp9CKuDvx+OTyt/+qAjwN+L9VeygcrM7r7kyLR532nu4MeHAldyXRZZwzI79u0WHw8OnO8tWlqaxBX9Av6PQ53abv0Gs4+Oq+bIqlZ1DFVdl/L2Y3WLk4ayNuXqrPXS+XNg6n4Aycxc1chjm4CYvQwrnfK6cr05UZ65X1wfpobRWlVqXUnIA/wvr0E4fRy78=</latexit>! ✓ e↵ = ✓ + /f ⌧ 1
4 / 22
Conventional Way for Axion Search
n Axion generically couples to photon via the topological term
n Axion is converted into photon under the background magnetic field (“axion-photon conversion”)
a : axion : photon
B : magnetic field
<latexit sha1_base64="OVtWiG3tcWk+WMKFlxB00RnYhvo=">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</latexit>
g a
4 aF µ⌫ F ˜ µ⌫ = g a aE · B
<latexit sha1_base64="X8TUyTGzEyphurVJHrZ7uBf+enc=">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</latexit>
5 / 22
Axion-photon Conversion Experiments (1)
ADMX 2014
n A resonant haloscope using a strong magnet.
n It can probe the power signal of QCD axion dark matter with mass around μeV ~ meV.
Axion Haloscope l ADMX (Axion Dark Matter eXperiment), HAYSTAC
l MADMAX (MAgnetized Disc and Mirror Axion eXperiment) l …
MADMAX
6 / 22
Axion-photon Conversion Experiments (2)
CAST 2017
l CAST (CERN Axion Solar Telescope)
l IAXO (International Axion Observatory) : Next generation of CAST Axion Solar Telescope
n A telescope to search for axion particles thermally produced in the Sun.
n The strong magnet converts the solar axion flux into X-rays.
n Possible to probe the axion-photon coupling with broad mass range.
7 / 22
<latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">AAACk3ichVE7S8NQGD3Gd31VRRBcxFIRh/JFBEWXUh1cBF99SBVJ4m2N5kWSFrQ4C05uok4KDuJfcHPxDzj0J4hjBRcHv6YVH6B+IbnnnnvOd3P4VMfQPZ+o3CA1NjW3tLa1hzo6u7p7wr19Kc8uuJpIarZhuxlV8YShWyLp674hMo4rFFM1RFrdm6uep4vC9XTbWvP3HbFpKnlLz+ma4jOV2sgrpqlshSNyjIIapg8g/wQR1GvJDt9hA9uwoaEAEwIWfMYGFHj8ZCGD4DC3iRJzLiM9OBc4RIi9BVYJVijM7vE3z7tsnbV4X+3pBW6NbzH4ddk5jCg90g1V6IFu6Ynefu1VCnpU/2WfV7XmFc5Wz/Hg6uu/LpNXHzufrj8cKqsD3fq4OMqm/0znI4fpIJXOKZ2AqebVah2KB6eV1ZmVaGmUruiZk15Sme45q1V80a6XxcoFQl9H9TtITcRkisnLk5F4oj60NgxhBGM8mSnEsYAlJPneXZzgDOfSgDQrJaT5mlRqqHv68a2kxXfQ75Sn</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">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</latexit>
a
<latexit sha1_base64="HGtvbh8aCF6huNaoUXsPGfEGSJ8=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="HGtvbh8aCF6huNaoUXsPGfEGSJ8=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="HGtvbh8aCF6huNaoUXsPGfEGSJ8=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="HGtvbh8aCF6huNaoUXsPGfEGSJ8=">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</latexit>→
nasa-fermi-mission n Axion-photon conversion will modify the spectrum of cosmic rays.
n The prediction depends on the uncertainty of magnetic field in the cluster background.
B
<latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit>B
<latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">AAACjnichVG7SgNBFD1Z3/GRqI1gEwwRsQg3IiqCKNpY5mFMJIrsrpO4ZLO77G4CMVgL2ioWVgoW4i/Y2fgDFvkEsVSwsfBmExTfd5iZO2fOuTOHq1i65rhEdZ/U1t7R2dXd4+/t6x8IBAeH1h2zbKsirZq6aWcV2RG6Zoi0q7m6yFq2kEuKLjJKcaVxn6kI29FMY82tWmKrJBcMLa+psstQYnk7GI5FyYvQe0JfkTBaETeDN9jEDkyoKKMEAQMu5zpkODxyiIFgMbaFGmM2Z5p3L7APP2vLzBLMkBkt8lrgU66FGnxu1HQ8tcqv6DxtVoYQoXu6oie6o2t6oNdfa9W8Go2/VHlXmlphbQcOR1Iv/6pKvLvY/VD9oVCY7fE2JsVBLvOnOxd5zHmuNHZpeUjDr9qsUNk7fUrNJyO1cbqgR3Z6TnW6Za9G5Vm9TIjkGfw/tupbsj4VjVE0lpgOLy23mtaNUYxhgjsziyWsIo40vytwhGOcSEFpRlqQFptUydfSDONTSKtvfFOSWA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit>B
<latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">AAACjnichVG7SgNBFD1Z3/GRqI1gEwwRsQg3IiqCKNpY5mFMJIrsrpO4ZLO77G4CMVgL2ioWVgoW4i/Y2fgDFvkEsVSwsfBmExTfd5iZO2fOuTOHq1i65rhEdZ/U1t7R2dXd4+/t6x8IBAeH1h2zbKsirZq6aWcV2RG6Zoi0q7m6yFq2kEuKLjJKcaVxn6kI29FMY82tWmKrJBcMLa+psstQYnk7GI5FyYvQe0JfkTBaETeDN9jEDkyoKKMEAQMu5zpkODxyiIFgMbaFGmM2Z5p3L7APP2vLzBLMkBkt8lrgU66FGnxu1HQ8tcqv6DxtVoYQoXu6oie6o2t6oNdfa9W8Go2/VHlXmlphbQcOR1Iv/6pKvLvY/VD9oVCY7fE2JsVBLvOnOxd5zHmuNHZpeUjDr9qsUNk7fUrNJyO1cbqgR3Z6TnW6Za9G5Vm9TIjkGfw/tupbsj4VjVE0lpgOLy23mtaNUYxhgjsziyWsIo40vytwhGOcSEFpRlqQFptUydfSDONTSKtvfFOSWA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit>B
<latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit>Astronomical Observation of Axion-Photon
8 / 22
Overview of Target Spaces
Conlon+ 2017 (prospect)
Huge Discovery Space
9 / 22
The problem is…
<latexit sha1_base64="z8+41JxWEETn1s4whp6PXkYHlZ0=">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</latexit>
B
<latexit sha1_base64="D2vrh2HHxlnicCvfHxt3O6XsG7g=">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</latexit>
g a
4 aF µ⌫ F ˜ µ⌫ = g a aE ·
n In order to get better sensitivity, the more powerful superconducting magnets would be needed.
n In parallel with these experiments, we might as well suggest another
(perhaps more economical?) experimental approach to axion DM.
10 / 22
Axion DM Search
without the external magnetic field
g a
4 aF µ⌫ F ˜ µ⌫ = g a aE · B
<latexit sha1_base64="X8TUyTGzEyphurVJHrZ7uBf+enc=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="vA8HwRbbe41WMdLUAYdHmf5x42w=">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</latexit>
a(t) = a 0 cos(mt + ⌧ )
11 / 22
Modulation of Photon Polarization
<latexit sha1_base64="nxV0dfHyliF+a8gHzakQsFvJ2Wo=">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</latexit>
c L/R = r
1 ± g a a 0 m a
k sin(m a t + ⌧ )
n Axion dark matter differentiates the phase velocities of the circular-polarized photons
n This velocity difference provides the rotation of linear-polarized photon
slightly oscillates!
<latexit sha1_base64="DGJExm2+tqT22sPScnRJrq4AXyk=">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</latexit>
c L > c R
12 / 22
Axion Search with Resonant Cavity
K.Nagano, T.Fujita, Y.Michimura, IO
n As a carrier wave, we input the linearly-polarized monochromatic laser light.
n The linear cavity consists of front and end mirrors. The cavity is kept to resonate with a phase measurement.
n The signal is detected in detection port (a) or (b) as polarization modulation.
13 / 22
Inside Cavity
n Electric vector inside cavity is represented as the superposition of reflected beams:
E cav (t) = t 1 E 0 e ikt e L e R
X 1 n=1
A n (t) 1 p 2
✓ 1 1
◆ , 8 <
:
A n+1 (t) ⌘ A n (t)R 1 T (t 2L(n 1))
⇥ R 2 T (t 2L(n 1/2)) (n 1) A 1 = 1
<latexit sha1_base64="3qMJ4YypK/CF++8pXCiPlqxgPt4=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="HQoevR4ETQKgPb4y3Fugn+EC6NY=">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</latexit>
R i ⌘
✓ 0 r i
r i 0
◆
(i = 1, 2) ,
T (t) ⌘ e i L (t) 0 0 e i R (t)
! ,
L/R (t) ⌘ kL ⌥ k Z t
t L
c(t 0 )dt 0
14 / 22
E cav (t) = t 1 E 0 e ikt
1 r 1 r 2 e L e R
✓ 1 + i (t) 0
0 1 i (t)
◆ 1 p 2
✓ 1 1
◆
= t 1
1 r 1 r 2 [E p (t) E s (t)]
<latexit sha1_base64="HUszis9ZbdNjMvAWwzqULwQVwv8=">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</latexit>
Inside Cavity
(2kL
<latexit sha1_base64="91kZCL8pg/LzRQY2ILBW3PcEq3o=">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</latexit>= 2⇡ N )
1 ( * r i ' 1)
<latexit sha1_base64="8QHWHGNAAB9jbt47Wf6nKy6Cqh8=">AAACsnichVG7bhNBFD1ZXsEBYqBBohlhBQUK6+5mFSdUETSUeeA44I2s2cnEGWVf2YelxKJG8AMUVCBRIApakOho+IEU+QREGSQaCu6ujRBFwh3NzJ0z59yZo+sngclyoqMJ68zZc+cvTF6sTV26fGW6fvXaehYXqdJtFQdxuuHLTAcm0u3c5IHeSFItQz/QHX/3QXnfGeg0M3H0KN9P9GYo+5HZNkrmDPXqDa/fF7bw9gq5JWY9XytZZFqkPSO8zIR6T9h3mEXNxYV5x50X1CRq2Y5dJk7LnXOFzUgZDYxjOa5/hoctxFAoEEIjQs55AImMRxc2CAljmxgylnJmqnuNp6ixtmCWZoZkdJfXPp+6YzTic1kzq9SKXwl4pqwUmKFDekfH9JXe0zf6dWKtYVWj/Ms+7/5Iq5Pe9Isbaz//qwp5z7HzV3WKwmd2xXt8Vz/rdk51l2MbC5Urwy6TCin9qlGFwcHL47V7qzPD2/SGvrPT13REX9hrNPih3q7o1Veocav+9EOcnKw7TXuu6ay4jaX746ZN4iZuYZY708ISHmIZbX73OT7gIz5ZrvXEkpYaUa2JseY6/gkr+A3J1J9s</latexit>
n When the resonant condition is met, the beam is accumulated inside cavity:
r i 2 + t 2 i = 1
<latexit sha1_base64="dL743SVwYYJ6whnKb1XGW3r5XtI=">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</latexit>
15 / 22
(t) =
Z 1
1
c(m)H a (m)e imt dm 2⇡
<latexit sha1_base64="ZDe3d135SBNcymkB9Qe5Out0/cM=">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</latexit>
Frequency Response in Signal
L
<latexit sha1_base64="2ryuB0MvjL/ZVS41t/yfLoQ7RHw=">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</latexit>= 10 6 m
Longer length
&
Higher finesse is better
→ GW detectors!
(t 2 1 , t 2 2 ) [ppm] = (3.1 ⇥ 10 5 , 3.1 ⇥ 10 5 ) LIGO
<latexit sha1_base64="9Dt+2hAifrT4a7D6MUqLRn0rLiw=">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</latexit>
H a (m) = i k m
4r 1 r 2 sin 2 ( mL 2 )
1 r 1 r 2 e i2mL ( e imL )
<latexit sha1_base64="0nJN/B5SbbmW+GiBbb9+BOWE3o8=">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</latexit>
mL = ⇡
<latexit sha1_base64="RJY9Cg3Fsx2yFC/c802ykhXqDWA=">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</latexit>
Response function of signal
16 / 22
SN Ratio
(coherent time of axion DM) n We assume the sensitivity is determined by the quantum shot noise
SNR = 8 >
> >
<
> >
> :
p T obs 2 p
S shot (m) c 0 (T obs . ⌧ ) (T obs ⌧ ) 1/4
2 p
S shot (m) c 0 (T obs & ⌧ )
<latexit sha1_base64="5pKkKwsFgQ6fxNITnm/hgkE6nkY=">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</latexit>
⌧ = 2⇡
mv 2 ⇠ 1yr(10 16 eV/m)
<latexit sha1_base64="iM0HP8QqD9Lf4MfCUGMTc8OI0FY=">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</latexit>
a(t) =
<latexit sha1_base64="JtwBL1waeojHPjf99OW6+6InLus=">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</latexit>a 0 cos(mt + ⌧ )
Kimble+ 2001
<latexit sha1_base64="ITBYd/rUq7RwOb19XypCx5k45Z8=">AAACzXichVFNaxRBEH0Zo8Y1mlUvQi6DS0IUs/QsiiIoIV68ma/NRnbC0NPpTZrMV3p6FuK4uQbyB3LISYkH8S948yJe1UN+gniM4MWDtbMDosFYQ09Xv3qvuh/lJ4FKDWNHQ9aZ4bPnzo9cqFwcvXR5rHrl6nIaZ1rIpoiDWK/4PJWBimTTKBPIlURLHvqBbPmbj/v1VlfqVMXRktlO5GrI1yPVUYIbgrzqIzfd0iZ3Q242BA/ypZ6nerYrtzLVtd21juYiN55jCM2dae052mtQ3Z5SD53bjZtetcbqrAj7ZOKUSQ1lzMXVd3CxhhgCGUJIRDCUB+BI6WvDAUNC2CpywjRlqqhL9FAhbUYsSQxO6Cb91+nULtGIzv2eaaEWdEtAS5PSxgT7wt6wY/aBvWVf2c9/9sqLHv23bNPuD7Qy8cb2ri/++K8qpN1g47fqFIVP7IL37JbcbbdOdWfQwf3ClSKXSYH0/YpBh+7z/ePFBwsT+SR7xb6R05fsiL0nr1H3u3g9LxcOUKFROX8P5mSy3Kg7d+ts/k5tZrYc2gjGcQNTNJl7mMETzKFJ9x7iIz7hs/XUyqwX1s6Aag2Vmmv4I6zdX4pLquo=</latexit>
p T i ⌘ t 1 t i 1 r 1 r 2
(i = 1, 2)
n The SNR for axion DM is improved with the measurement time
<latexit sha1_base64="hDFJexehNQmLjSmYnhSeBB2Np+A=">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</latexit>
p T i shot ⇠ E vac
E 0 ! p
S shot (m) =
q k 2P 0
p T i | H a (m) |
17 / 22
Potential Sensitivity Curves
T obs = 1 year
<latexit sha1_base64="LRSn53J/NGAGR7V/ikWY/iMY0B4=">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</latexit>
18 / 22
The problem is…
n In order to apply our method to the real GW detector, some optics need to be added for detection port.
n As a geometrical demerit of linear cavity, the sensitivity is lost by a parity-flipping effect on the reflection of mirror.
In case
<latexit sha1_base64="lmg9Tm604oXO8tfy6YYS+EmtdGc=">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</latexit>