• Keine Ergebnisse gefunden

Axion Dark Matter Search with Optical Interferometers

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Aktie "Axion Dark Matter Search with Optical Interferometers"

Copied!
22
0
0

Wird geladen.... (Jetzt Volltext ansehen)

Volltext

(1)

1 / 22

Axion Dark Matter Search with Optical Interferometers

Ippei Obata (physical cosmology group, MPA)

PRL 123, 111301 (2019) arXiv:1903.02017 PRL 121, 161301 (2018) arXiv:1805.11753 Collaborators :

Koji Nagano (JAXA), Tomohiro Fujita (ICRR)

Yuta Michimura, Yuka Oshima, Taihei Watanabe, Masaki Ando (University of Tokyo)

2020.10.6 MPA Cosmology seminar

(2)

2 / 22

Overview

Axion

Optical Interferometry

n Important old problem n Candidate for dark matter

n Most recent technological innovation such as gravitational wave detectors n Possible to test a tiny tiny signal of phase modulation

Apply!

KAGRA

→ Pioneering a new phase of axion search!

(3)

3 / 22

What is Axion?

A pseudo NG boson of PQ mechanism in order to solve the strong CP problem in QCD physics

n A scalar field with small mass, tiny interactions

(Peccei & Quinn, 1977, …)

A plentitude of axion-like particles provided by the compactifications of extra dimensions

(Witten 1984, …)

→ candidate for cold dark matter

QCD Axion

Axion-like particles (ALPs, string axion)

L QCD ✓G G, ˜ | ✓ | . 10 10

<latexit sha1_base64="bJu1+snspvXOIkIVF6PGD8Z8Ph0=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="bJu1+snspvXOIkIVF6PGD8Z8Ph0=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="bJu1+snspvXOIkIVF6PGD8Z8Ph0=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="bJu1+snspvXOIkIVF6PGD8Z8Ph0=">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</latexit>

! ✓ e↵ = ✓ + /f ⌧ 1

(4)

4 / 22

Conventional Way for Axion Search

n Axion generically couples to photon via the topological term

n Axion is converted into photon under the background magnetic field (“axion-photon conversion”)

a : axion : photon

B : magnetic field

<latexit sha1_base64="OVtWiG3tcWk+WMKFlxB00RnYhvo=">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</latexit>

g a

4 aF µ⌫ F ˜ µ⌫ = g a aE · B

<latexit sha1_base64="X8TUyTGzEyphurVJHrZ7uBf+enc=">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</latexit>

(5)

5 / 22

Axion-photon Conversion Experiments (1)

ADMX 2014

n A resonant haloscope using a strong magnet.

n It can probe the power signal of QCD axion dark matter with mass around μeV ~ meV.

Axion Haloscope l ADMX (Axion Dark Matter eXperiment), HAYSTAC

l MADMAX (MAgnetized Disc and Mirror Axion eXperiment) l

MADMAX

(6)

6 / 22

Axion-photon Conversion Experiments (2)

CAST 2017

l CAST (CERN Axion Solar Telescope)

l IAXO (International Axion Observatory) : Next generation of CAST Axion Solar Telescope

n A telescope to search for axion particles thermally produced in the Sun.

n The strong magnet converts the solar axion flux into X-rays.

n Possible to probe the axion-photon coupling with broad mass range.

(7)

7 / 22

<latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="0dnZNZP1XXfjIhOeEE22dEuB0KA=">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</latexit>

a

<latexit sha1_base64="HGtvbh8aCF6huNaoUXsPGfEGSJ8=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="HGtvbh8aCF6huNaoUXsPGfEGSJ8=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="HGtvbh8aCF6huNaoUXsPGfEGSJ8=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="HGtvbh8aCF6huNaoUXsPGfEGSJ8=">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</latexit>

nasa-fermi-mission n Axion-photon conversion will modify the spectrum of cosmic rays.

n The prediction depends on the uncertainty of magnetic field in the cluster background.

B

<latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit>

B

<latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit>

B

<latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit>

B

<latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">AAACjnichVG7SgNBFD1Z3/GRqI1gEwwRsQg3IiqCKNpY5mFMJIrsrpO4ZLO77G4CMVgL2ioWVgoW4i/Y2fgDFvkEsVSwsfBmExTfd5iZO2fOuTOHq1i65rhEdZ/U1t7R2dXd4+/t6x8IBAeH1h2zbKsirZq6aWcV2RG6Zoi0q7m6yFq2kEuKLjJKcaVxn6kI29FMY82tWmKrJBcMLa+psstQYnk7GI5FyYvQe0JfkTBaETeDN9jEDkyoKKMEAQMu5zpkODxyiIFgMbaFGmM2Z5p3L7APP2vLzBLMkBkt8lrgU66FGnxu1HQ8tcqv6DxtVoYQoXu6oie6o2t6oNdfa9W8Go2/VHlXmlphbQcOR1Iv/6pKvLvY/VD9oVCY7fE2JsVBLvOnOxd5zHmuNHZpeUjDr9qsUNk7fUrNJyO1cbqgR3Z6TnW6Za9G5Vm9TIjkGfw/tupbsj4VjVE0lpgOLy23mtaNUYxhgjsziyWsIo40vytwhGOcSEFpRlqQFptUydfSDONTSKtvfFOSWA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="r3bRx2fHW+bvKpZqO8DQ8MF79F4=">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</latexit>

Astronomical Observation of Axion-Photon

(8)

8 / 22

Overview of Target Spaces

Conlon+ 2017 (prospect)

Huge Discovery Space

(9)

9 / 22

The problem is…

<latexit sha1_base64="z8+41JxWEETn1s4whp6PXkYHlZ0=">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</latexit>

B

<latexit sha1_base64="D2vrh2HHxlnicCvfHxt3O6XsG7g=">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</latexit>

g a

4 aF µ⌫ F ˜ µ⌫ = g a aE ·

n In order to get better sensitivity, the more powerful superconducting magnets would be needed.

n In parallel with these experiments, we might as well suggest another

(perhaps more economical?) experimental approach to axion DM.

(10)

10 / 22

Axion DM Search

without the external magnetic field

g a

4 aF µ⌫ F ˜ µ⌫ = g a aE · B

<latexit sha1_base64="X8TUyTGzEyphurVJHrZ7uBf+enc=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="vA8HwRbbe41WMdLUAYdHmf5x42w=">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</latexit>

a(t) = a 0 cos(mt + )

(11)

11 / 22

Modulation of Photon Polarization

<latexit sha1_base64="nxV0dfHyliF+a8gHzakQsFvJ2Wo=">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</latexit>

c L/R = r

1 ± g a a 0 m a

k sin(m a t + )

n Axion dark matter differentiates the phase velocities of the circular-polarized photons

n This velocity difference provides the rotation of linear-polarized photon

slightly oscillates!

<latexit sha1_base64="DGJExm2+tqT22sPScnRJrq4AXyk=">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</latexit>

c L > c R

(12)

12 / 22

Axion Search with Resonant Cavity

K.Nagano, T.Fujita, Y.Michimura, IO

n As a carrier wave, we input the linearly-polarized monochromatic laser light.

n The linear cavity consists of front and end mirrors. The cavity is kept to resonate with a phase measurement.

n The signal is detected in detection port (a) or (b) as polarization modulation.

(13)

13 / 22

Inside Cavity

n Electric vector inside cavity is represented as the superposition of reflected beams:

E cav (t) = t 1 E 0 e ikt e L e R

X 1 n=1

A n (t) 1 p 2

✓ 1 1

◆ , 8 <

:

A n+1 (t) ⌘ A n (t)R 1 T (t 2L(n 1))

⇥ R 2 T (t 2L(n 1/2)) (n 1) A 1 = 1

<latexit sha1_base64="3qMJ4YypK/CF++8pXCiPlqxgPt4=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="HQoevR4ETQKgPb4y3Fugn+EC6NY=">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</latexit>

R i ⌘

✓ 0 r i

r i 0

(i = 1, 2) ,

T (t) ⌘ e i L (t) 0 0 e i R (t)

! ,

L/R (t) ⌘ kL ⌥ k Z t

t L

c(t 0 )dt 0

(14)

14 / 22

E cav (t) = t 1 E 0 e ikt

1 r 1 r 2 e L e R

✓ 1 + i (t) 0

0 1 i (t)

◆ 1 p 2

✓ 1 1

= t 1

1 r 1 r 2 [E p (t) E s (t)]

<latexit sha1_base64="HUszis9ZbdNjMvAWwzqULwQVwv8=">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</latexit>

Inside Cavity

(2kL

<latexit sha1_base64="91kZCL8pg/LzRQY2ILBW3PcEq3o=">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</latexit>

= 2⇡ N )

1 ( * r i ' 1)

<latexit sha1_base64="8QHWHGNAAB9jbt47Wf6nKy6Cqh8=">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</latexit>

n When the resonant condition is met, the beam is accumulated inside cavity:

r i 2 + t 2 i = 1

<latexit sha1_base64="dL743SVwYYJ6whnKb1XGW3r5XtI=">AAACoHichVFNLwNRFD3GV9VXy0ZiM9EQIWnelIRIJMLGjqKKopkZDy+mM5OZ1wqNtcQfsBALEkT8BTsbf8DCTxBLEhsLt9NJBMGdvLn3nXfOfe/kGq4lfMnYY41SW1ff0Bhpija3tLa1x+Idi75T9EyeMR3L8ZYM3eeWsHlGCmnxJdfjesGweNbYmaqcZ0vc84VjL8g9l68V9C1bbApTlwTlY3EvL9ZT6qAqgzyuavlYgiVZEOrPQguLBMKYdWK3WMUGHJgoogAOG5JqCzp8+nLQwOAStoYyYR5VIjjnOECUtEVicWLohO7Qf4t2uRC1aV/p6Qdqk26xaHmkVNHLHtg1e2H37IY9sfdfe5WDHpW37FE2qlru5tuPuubf/lUVKEtsf6r+UBjEDnjLA/wwl/3TncQmRgNXgly6AVLxa1Y7lPaPX+bH5nrLfeycPZPTM/bI7sirXXo1L9J87gRRGpX2fTA/i8VUUhtKptLDiYnJcGgRdKMH/TSZEUxgGrPI0L27OMUlrpQeZVqZUdJVqlITajrxJZSVDx2il5g=</latexit>

(15)

15 / 22

(t) =

Z 1

1

c(m)H a (m)e imt dm 2⇡

<latexit sha1_base64="ZDe3d135SBNcymkB9Qe5Out0/cM=">AAAC3nichVG/axRBFP6yMTE5Y3LGJmCzeEQugsfcKSiCEJImnfnh5SK3yTo7N5cM2V/szh2cy7UJBIJlAlYKFmJtZ2fjP2ARbLUQywg2Fr7bXRANxhl23pvvfd+b/XhO6KpYM3YyZAxfGBm9ODZeuDRxeXKqeGV6PQ46kZB1EbhBtOHwWLrKl3WttCs3wkhyz3Flw9ldHNQbXRnFKvAf6V4oNz2+7au2ElwTZBcfWi3pam6FO6qs58wHpqV8vUVHW/fs5FaW9DOSKcrenLlkcwpyK1GepkI74iJpef2kZoWqb9rFEquwdJlnk2qelJCv5aD4DhZaCCDQgQcJH5pyFxwx7SaqYAgJ20RCWESZSusSfRRI2yGWJAYndJfObbo1c9Sn+6BnnKoFveLSF5HSxCz7yF6zU/aBvWFf2c9/9krSHoN/6VF0Mq0M7amDmbUf/1V5FDV2fqvOUTjETnmPb8r9ZuNcdxpt3EtdKXIZpsjAr8g6dJ8ena7dX51NbrCX7Bs5fcFO2Hvy6ne/i1crcvU5CjSq6t+DOZus1yrV25Xayp3S/EI+tDFcw3WUaTJ3MY8lLKNO777FJ3zGF+OJsWccGs8yqjGUa67ij2Uc/wJQfrJl</latexit>

Frequency Response in Signal

L

<latexit sha1_base64="2ryuB0MvjL/ZVS41t/yfLoQ7RHw=">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</latexit>

= 10 6 m

Longer length

&

Higher finesse is better

GW detectors!

(t 2 1 , t 2 2 ) [ppm] = (3.1 ⇥ 10 5 , 3.1 ⇥ 10 5 ) LIGO

<latexit sha1_base64="9Dt+2hAifrT4a7D6MUqLRn0rLiw=">AAACz3ichVHLahRBFD1pH4njI6NuBDeFQ8JEwnC7E1EEYTCbLDOJk4nMo+luK7FIv+iumSQOCdlJ/IEsXCkoiL/gzo0LtxHyCeIyATcuvNPTIDEYb1Nd954651Ydrhv7KtVEhyPGufMXLo6OXSpcvnL12njx+o3lNOomnqx7kR8lK66TSl+Fsq6V9uVKnEgncH3ZcNfnBueNnkxSFYVP9FYs24GzFqpV5TmaIbtYLWvb7FjTQttWx5oSLdFsabmp+3EcbLfFI1GeqZgtrQKZCpM696bFyXrKLpaoQlmI04mZJyXksRAVP6GFZ4jgoYsAEiE05z4cpPw1YYIQM9ZGn7GEM5WdS2yjwNousyQzHEbX+b/GVTNHQ64HPdNM7fEtPq+ElQITdEAf6Ii+0Ef6Tr/+2auf9Ri8ZYt3d6iVsT3+6tbSz/+qAt41nv9RnaFwmZ3xnt6VL5uNM91prOJB5kqxyzhDBn69YYfei/2jpYeLE/1Jeks/2OkbOqTP7DXsHXvvanLxNQo8KvPvwZxOlq2KOVOxarOl6uN8aGO4jTso82Tuo4p5LKDO977HVxzgm1EzNowdY3dINUZyzU2cCGPvNwVYp6E=</latexit>

H a (m) = i k m

4r 1 r 2 sin 2 ( mL 2 )

1 r 1 r 2 e i2mL ( e imL )

<latexit sha1_base64="0nJN/B5SbbmW+GiBbb9+BOWE3o8=">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</latexit>

mL = ⇡

<latexit sha1_base64="RJY9Cg3Fsx2yFC/c802ykhXqDWA=">AAAClnichVE9S8NQFD3G7/rRqovgEiyKOJRXFRRBEUV0cKjW2pa2SBKf+jBfJGlBi7Pg6uCgDgoO4l9wc/EPOPgTxLGCi4O3aUC0WG9I3nnnnXNfDle1deF6jL00Sc0trW3tHZ2hru6e3nCkr3/LtYqOxlOapVtORlVcrguTpzzh6TxjO1wxVJ2n1YOl6nm6xB1XWOamd2jzgqHsmWJXaIpHVNaQ1+Q5OW+L7UiUxZhfcj2IByCKoBJW5AF57MCChiIMcJjwCOtQ4NKTQxwMNnEFlIlzCAn/nOMYIfIWScVJoRB7QN892uUC1qR9tafruzW6RafXIaeMEfbM7liFPbF79so+/+xV9ntU/+WQVrXm5fZ2+HQw+fGvy6DVw/63q4FDJbWvy47zk1y6YToPu5jxUwlKaftMNa9W61A6Oq8kZzdGyqPshr1R0mv2wh4pq1l6127X+cYFQjSq+O/B1IOtiVh8MjaxPhVdWAyG1oEhDGOMJjONBawigRTda+AMl7iSBqV5aVlaqUmlpsAzgB8lJb4AoWaU8w==</latexit>

Response function of signal

(16)

16 / 22

SN Ratio

(coherent time of axion DM) n We assume the sensitivity is determined by the quantum shot noise

SNR = 8 >

> >

<

> >

> :

p T obs 2 p

S shot (m) c 0 (T obs . ⌧ ) (T obs ⌧ ) 1/4

2 p

S shot (m) c 0 (T obs & ⌧ )

<latexit sha1_base64="5pKkKwsFgQ6fxNITnm/hgkE6nkY=">AAADhnicpVE9b9RAEB3HfBzmIwc0SDQWp6ALxbEOQUFISCdoqFByl8sF3R6Wvbd3WcVfePdOhJUrCiQENQUVSBSIv0BHwx+gyE9AlEFKQ8Gc7YCSiFAwlr2zb96b8dP4SSCkImTbmDGPHT9xsnLKOn3m7LnZ6vkLazIep4x3WBzE6brvSR6IiHeUUAFfT1LuhX7Au/7mvWm9O+GpFHG0qrYS3g+9USSGgnkKIbe6SxV/onT7QSuz79jU5yMRaYYNZWbRwTD1mKbycar0qqsLauzLDEMvFHh7D5cbscqyejifZXTAA+XZzCU2tev7lTYNuJRShDZV3njepnRvzgFiXn6kneuL/zNspNLfsyzKo0Fpzq3WSIPkYR9OnDKpQRnLcfUTUBhADAzGEAKHCBTmAXgg8emBAwQSxPqgEUsxE3mdQwYWasfI4sjwEN3E7whvvRKN8D7tKXM1wykBvikqbZgjX8kHskO+kI/kG/n511467zH9ly08/ULLE3f2xaX27j9VIZ4KNv6ojlD4yM55D6/x573uke4UDOFW7kqgyyRHpn5Z0WHy9PVO+3ZrTl8l78h3dPqWbJPP6DWa/GDvV3jrDVi4KufgYg4nawsN50aDrCzWmnfLpVXgMlyBOm5mCZpwH5ahA8zoG8+Ml8Yrs2I2zJvmUkGdMUrNRdgXZvMXnfDyJg==</latexit>

⌧ = 2⇡

mv 2 ⇠ 1yr(10 16 eV/m)

<latexit sha1_base64="iM0HP8QqD9Lf4MfCUGMTc8OI0FY=">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</latexit>

a(t) =

<latexit sha1_base64="JtwBL1waeojHPjf99OW6+6InLus=">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</latexit>

a 0 cos(mt + )

Kimble+ 2001

<latexit sha1_base64="ITBYd/rUq7RwOb19XypCx5k45Z8=">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</latexit>

p T i ⌘ t 1 t i 1 r 1 r 2

(i = 1, 2)

n The SNR for axion DM is improved with the measurement time

<latexit sha1_base64="hDFJexehNQmLjSmYnhSeBB2Np+A=">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</latexit>

p T i shot ⇠ E vac

E 0 ! p

S shot (m) =

q k 2P 0

p T i | H a (m) |

(17)

17 / 22

Potential Sensitivity Curves

T obs = 1 year

<latexit sha1_base64="LRSn53J/NGAGR7V/ikWY/iMY0B4=">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</latexit>

(18)

18 / 22

The problem is…

n In order to apply our method to the real GW detector, some optics need to be added for detection port.

n As a geometrical demerit of linear cavity, the sensitivity is lost by a parity-flipping effect on the reflection of mirror.

In case

<latexit sha1_base64="lmg9Tm604oXO8tfy6YYS+EmtdGc=">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</latexit>

m ⇠ L 1

the rotation signal is most accumulated since the oscillatory turning point

matches with the reflection-timing.

,

the rotation signal is not so accumulated…

(19)

19 / 22

Axion DM Tabletop Experiment

@Tokyo University DANCE: Dark matter Axion search with riNg Cavity Experiment

with Y.Oshima, T.Watanabe, Y.Michimra, K.Nagano, IO, T.Fujita, M.Ando

Laser

Photo Detector

n A bowtie-like mirror configuration can sustain the rotational

orientation of photon polarization

(DANCE Act-1: Proto-type experiment)

(20)

20 / 22

First Data of DANCE Act-1 (2020.8)

First Data (assuming 1-year obs. from now) DANCE Act-1 (target sensitivity)

DANCE

Yuka Oshima’s talk @ autumn conference in the Physical Society of Japan

←current CAST limit

(21)

21 / 22

Summary & Outlook

p We suggest an experimental scheme to search for axion dark matter with the linear optical cavity used in gravitational wave detectors.

p We found that these sensitivities can reach beyond the current limit with a wide range of axion mass and our new scheme can coexist with the observation run for gravitational waves.

p We also suggest a tabletop experiment to search for axion DM.

p Achieving the target sensitivity of DANCE is still ongoing…

(22)

22 / 22

Summary & Outlook

p Possible to probe QCD axion DM by interferometers?

p Application of our scheme to other projectable axion experiments? (e.g. LSW experiment)

p Constraining axion DM birefringence from astrophysical or

cosmological measurements? (e.g. CMB)

Referenzen

ÄHNLICHE DOKUMENTE

In addition, a small fraction of the interaction energy is emitted from the crystals in the form of scintillation light which is measured in coincidence with the phonon signal by

Thus, as mentioned before, the requirements on the direct detection experiments comprise very low background conditions, a method to distinguish background events from signal

An event contains pulses from the phonon and the corresponding light detector(s) of all detector modules on the same digitizer module, which registered a signal above the

Contributions of the three types of nuclei present in a CaWO 4 target to the total rate of WIMP interactions, as a function of the WIMP mass and for a cross-section of 1 pb,

7π 2 T ν 4 ρ dr (T ), (45) where the energy density of dark radiation ρ dr includes contributions of axions from thermal processes in the early universe, of axions from decays

inner crystal replaced by 73 Ge crystal sensitive to spin-dependent interactions. 70 Ge de-enriched by factor &gt;50 new copper holder system no soldering

•  Particle physics part (PPP): Model for dark matter particle (spin, mass) à cross section, branching ratio and energy distribution for a given final state particle.

An indirect search for the presence of dark matter particles in the halo of the Milky Way with data that were recorded with the High Energy Stereoscopic System (H.E.S.S.) is