Indeterminacy in the Small Open Economy Ramsey Growth Model

W?_i|ih4?@U) ? |i 54@** Ti? ,UL?L4) +@4ti) BhL| L_i*

@h! `i_ih

#iT@h|4i?| Lu ,UL?L4Ut O4ML*_| N?iht|) ih*?

5T@?_@ih 5|h

f.Hih*?

Bih4@?)

@hU Sc bbb

,ALMK@BM

Wklv sdshu frqvwuxfwv d vpdoo rshq hfrqrp| yhuvlrq ri wkh wzr vhf0 wru Ehqkdele0Iduphu +4<<9, lqghwhuplqdf| prgho1 Lw fdq eh vkrzq wkdw vxqvsrw htxloleuld dulvh dw vljqlfdqwo| orzhu pdjqlwxghv ri lq0 fuhdvlqjuhwxuqv wr vfdoh wkdq lq wkh ruljlqdo forvhg hfrqrp| prgho1 Ixuwkhupruh/ li d pl{ ri h{whuqdolwlhv dfurvv vhfwruv lv dgplwwhg/ lqgh0 whuplqdf| fdq eh rewdlqhg hyhq zlwk ghfuhdvlqj djjuhjdwh uhwxuqv wr vfdoh1

L kdyh ehqhwwhg iurp glvfxvvlrqv zlwk Mhvv Ehqkdele/ Plfkdho Exugd/ Dpduw|d Odklul dqg Dqguhdv Uxsslq1 Doo uhpdlqlqj huuruv duh p| rzq1 D uhvhdufk judqw iurp wkh Ghxwvfkh Iruvfkxqjvjhphlqvfkdiw lv judwhixoo| dfnqrzohgjhg1 Wklv surmhfw zdv dovr vxs0 sruwhg e| wkh Vrqghuiruvfkxqjvehuhlfk 6:6 %Txdqwlndwlrq xqg Vlpxodwlrq ‚Rnrqrplvfkhu Sur}hvvh%1 MHO fodvvlfdwlrq= I7/ H651



 W?|hL_U|L?

ih |i T@t| ui )i@htc i @i |?itti_ @ hi@* Lu 4L_i*t | 4*|T*i i^*Mh@ @?_ t?tTL|t |@| U@ti iUL?L4U ?t|@M*|) |L| @?} |L hi*) L? tLU!t |L u?_@4i?|@*t Ai Lh! M) i?@MM @?_ 6@h4ih Ebbec bbS

@?_ L|iht @t _i4L?t|h@|i_ |@| |i LUUhhi?Ui Lu ?_i|ih4?@U) t ?L|

hit|hU|i_ |L ?hi@*t|U tTiU@* U@tit M| |@| |t Ti?L4i?L? U@? LUUh ? EhiThiti?|@|i @}i?| ihtL?t Lu _)?@4U }i?ih@* i^*Mh4 4L_i*t L?Ui

|i @tt4T|L? Lu TihuiU| 4@h!i|t t @M@?_L?i_

Ai ?|i?| Lu |t T@Tih t |L _ii*LT @ |L tiU|Lh LTi? iUL?L4) 4L_i*

| i |ih?@*|it ? ThL_U|L? Ai 4L_i* t |ihiuLhi t4*@h ? |t UL?

t|hU|L? |L i?@MM @?_ 6@h4ih<t EbbS 4L_i* Lu @ U*Lti_ iUL?L4) OL iihc | ** Mi tL? |@| ? |i LTi? iUL?L4) ihtL? ?_i|ih4?@U) t LM|@?i_ ?L| L?*) @| *Lih hi|h?t |L tU@*i |@? ? |i U*Lti_ iUL?L4) U@ti M| @*tL @| ?t}?€U@?| *ii*t |ihiLu At @tTiU| Lu |i 4L_i* t Lu 4 TLh|@?Ui t?Ui hiUi?| i4ThU@* Lh! @t _i4L?t|h@|i_ |@| @}}hi}@|i tU@*i iUL?L4it @hi U*Lti |L UL?t|@?| W? T@h|U*@hc |iti it|4@|it TL?| |L @*

it |@| @hi |LL *L |L }i @ ?4Mih Lu i t|?} ?_i|ih4?@U) 4L_i*t @ tUi?| i4ThU@* uL?_@|L?^ 6h|ih4Lhic ?_i|ih4?@U) _Lit ?L| hi

^hi @? i*@t|U *@MLh tTT*) Mi@Lh Ai hi@tL? uLh |t U@h@U|iht|U

? |i Thiti?| 4L_i* t |@| TihuiU| U@T|@* 4@h!i|t @**L |i t4LL|?} Lu UL?t4T|L? @ ?|ih?@|L?@* *i?_?} @?_ MLhhL?} Atc |i hi_Ui_

uLh4 Lu |i 4L_i* MiUL4it t4*@h |L |i U*Lti_ iUL?L4) ihtL? | *?

i@h |*|) At @Mti?Ui Lu Uh@|hi 4@!it |i UL?t|hU|L? Lu @*|ih?@|i

?it|4i?| T@|t @@*@M*i |L| |i ?ii_ |L Uh|@* UL?t4T|L?² Atc

?_i|ih4?@U) @htit uhL4 @ ULhhiU| ti^i?Ui Lu ThUi igiU|t ? |i Thiti?Ui Lu i |ih?@*|it Aiti 4@) i** Mi 4?4@* ? t3i t?Uic ?*!i ? |i U*Lti_

iUL?L4) @h@?|c |i UL4Ti|?} UL?t4T|L? t4LL|?} igiU| 4t| ?L| Mi Lgti|

w@h EbbH it|@M*ti_ |@| ? @ t4@** LTi? iUL?L4) i?_L}i?Lt }hL|

4L_i*c ?_i|ih4?@U) @htit 4Lhi t|h@}|uLh@h_*) |@? ? U*Lti_ iUL?L4) ihtL?t aiL? EbbH tLt |@| ? @ L?i tiU|Lh 4L_i* | |L !?_t Lu U@T|@* E|h@_i_ @?_ ?L?|h@_i_ U@T|@* }LL_tc ?_i|ih4?@U) @htit @| *Lih

?Uhi@t?} hi|h?t |L tU@*i |@? ? i?@MM @?_ 6@h4ih<t Ebbe L?i tiU

4Vhh iru h{dpsoh Edvx dqg Ihuqdog +4<<:,/ Exuqvlgh +4<<8, dqg Kduulvrq +4<<;d,1

5Vhh dovr Ehqkdele dqg Qlvklpxud +4<<9/ 4<<:,1

2

|Lh 4L_i* `i_ih EbbHM hiTLh|t @ t4*@h hit*| ? @ |L tiU|Lh }i?ih@*

i^*Mh4 4L_i* |@| @*tL @**Lt |i i?_L}i?Lt ULUi Lu *ithi

Ai hi4@?_ih Lu |t T@Tih t Lh}@?3i_ @t uL**Lt 5iU|L? 2 Thiti?|t

|i 4L_i* Ai i^*Mh4 _)?@4Ut @?_ ?_i|ih4?@U) @hi _tUtti_ ? 5iU|L? ? iUL?L4U ?|ihThi|@|L? Lu |i 4@? hit*| t Lgihi_ ? 5iU|L?

e 5iU|L? D UL?U*_it

2 L_i*

Ai 4L_i* t M@ti_ L? |i i?@MM @?_ 6@h4ih EbbS |L tiU|Lh LT|4@*

}hL| iUL?L4) Ai ?Li* @tTiU| ihi t |@| @}i?|t @hi @**Li_ |L MLhhL

@?_ *i?_ ?|ih?@|L?@**) `i @tt4i |@| |i iUL?L4) t |LL t4@** |L @giU|

|i Lh*_ ?|ihit| h@|i Oi?Uic |i ?|ihit| h@|i u@U?} |i UL?|h) t T@h@

4i|hU OLtiL*_t @hi hiThiti?|i_ M) @ t?}*i @}i?| |@| 4@ 43it *ui|4i

|*|) Ai @}i?| L?t |i t|LU! Lu U@T|@* @?_ hiUiit ?UL4i uhL4 @}it

@?_ |i hi?|@* Lu U@T|@* tihUit |L |i €h4 tiU|Lh 6h4t ThL_Ui i|ih

|i UL?t4T|L? }LL_ Lh |i ?it|4i?| }LL_ ,@U €h4 @t @UUitt |L @?

i |ih?@**) ?Uhi@t?} ELh _iUhi@t?} hi|h?t |L tU@*i |iU?L*L}) ** 4@h!i|t

@hi TihuiU|*) UL4Ti||i @?_ u@U|Lht Lu ThL_U|L? @hi UL4T*i|i*) 4LM*i Mi|ii? |i iUL?L4)<t tiU|Lht L?t4ih }LL_t @hi |h@_i@M*i ihi@t | t

@tt4i_ |@| U@T|@* }LL_t @hi ?L?|h@_i@M*it

2 AiU?L*L})

Ai ThL_U|L? |iU?L*L}) Lu @ |)TU@* €h4 ? |i ?it|4i?| }LL_ tiU|Lh t^e

+_|^U '^kEg_|^UkEu^U_|^3klwUkg_|^ku^3k_| ^ljU E&_|^UkE,^U_|^3k k 5Efc E

*i |@| Lu |i |)TU@* ThL_Uih Lu |i UL?t4T|L? }LL_ t }i? M) +_| '^kEg_|^kEu_| ^3klwkg_|^ku^3k_| ^lj E&_|^kE,_| ^3k E2 Oihi &^U_| @?_ ,_|^U _i?L|i |i U@T|@* @?_ *@MLh tihUit ti_ M) |i ?__

@* €h4 ? |i ?it|4i?| }LL_ ThL_U?} tiU|Lh g_|^U t |i @ih@}i t|LU! Lu

6Wkh g|qdplfv ri wkh prgho duh sulqflsdoo| xqdhfwhg dv orqj dv wkhuh lv dw ohdvw rqh qrqwudgdeoh lqyhvwphqw jrrg1

7Wkh qxpehu ri upv lq hdfk vhfwru lv xqlw|1

U@T|@* ? |t tiU|Lhcg|t|@?_t uLh |i t|LU! Lu U@T|@* ? |i UL?|h) wU ?_

U@|it tiU|LhtTiU€U i |ih?@*|it @?_jU _i?L|it |i _i}hii Lu iUL?L4)_i i |ih?@*|it uLh |i UMh@?U Lu |i €h4t Ai hi4@??} @h@M*it @hi _i

€?i_ hitTiU|i*) @?_ |i ?_i _i?L|it |i UL?t4T|L? }LL_ ThL_U?}

tiU|Lh `i @tt4i |@| |i |h@_i@M*i UL?t4T|L? }LL_ t |i ?4ih@hi

? t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 wi| M) |c o| @?_ R| _i?L|i |i @}i h@|ic |i U@T|@* hi?|@* h@|i @?_ |i hi*@|i ThUi Lu ?it|4i?| }LL_t W? t)44i|hU UL4Ti||i i^*Mh4c |i €h4t ** hi U@T|@* @?_ *@MLh |L t@|tu) |i i^@*|itG

_|' EkR_|V^w_|^Ukg_|^ku^3k_| ^lnwUnjUu^3_| E |' EkEV|^wkg_|^ku^3k_| ^lnwnju^3_| Ee o|'kR|V^w_|^Ukg_|^ku^3k_| ^lnwUnjUg_|^3 ED o_|'kEV_|^wkg_|^ku^3k_| ^lnwnjg_|^3 ES W? EESc i @*hi@_) @i ti_ |i _i€?|L? uLh |i hi*@|i u@U|Lh ?|i?t

|it

V| g_|^U g_| ' u^U_|

u_| @?_ V| g_| g_| ' u_|

u_| Aiti i^@|L?t U@? Mi UL4M?i_ |L )i*_ |i hi*@|i ThUi

R| ' EV|^wV^3w_| ^Ukg_|^ku^3k_| ^lwnj3wU3jU E.

6h|ihc L|T| ? |i |L tiU|Lht t4T*€it |L

t_|^U 'V^nw_| ^Ukg_|^ku^3k_| ^lnwUnjU EH

@?_ t_| ' EV_|^nwkg_|^ku^3k_| ^lnwnj Eb

22 hiuihi?Uit

Ai hiThiti?|@|i @}i?| @t Thiuihi?Uit Lih ti^i?Uit Lu UL?t4T|L? }i?

M)

e

Lf '

"

]

f

LE| e^34|_| Ef

ihi _|c @?_ 4 : f t|@?_ uLh UL?t4T|L? @?_ |i |4i _tUL?| u@U|Lh LE| @t |i t@* ThLTih|it `i ?Lh4@*3i |i € i_ *@MLh tTT*) |L ?|) Ai hiThiti?|@|i ?__@* L?t |i U@T|@* t|LU! @?_ *i?_t |t tihUit |L

|i €h4t Ai @}i?|<t ?|ih|i4TLh@* M_}i| UL?t|h@?| _U|@|it

(u|'(|n|nR|U||o|g| E

ihi(| t |i @4L?| Lu uLhi}? _iM| @?_t |i Lh*_ ?|ihit| h@|i^D `i uh|ih 4TLti |i t|@?_@h_ t4T*u)?} @tt4T|L? uLh t4@** LTi? iUL?L4) 4L_i*t |@| |i i |ih?@* ?|ihit| h@|i t t|@|L?@h) @?_ i^@* |L |i |*|) _tUL?| h@|iG o|B ''4 Ai U@T|@* @UU4*@|L? |iU?L*L}) t }i?

M) u

g|'U|Bg| E2

| B : f |i h@|i Lu U@T|@* _iThiU@|L? `i U@? @?@*)3i |i @}i?|<t LT|43@|L? ThLM*i4 M) uLh4*@|?} |i O@4*|L?@?

K|' dLE| nb|E|no|g|4(||R|U| n \|EU|Bg|o e^34| E

ihi \_| @?_ b_| @hi |i t@_L ThUit @ttLU@|i_ | |i |L UL?t|h@?|t E @?_ E2 Ai €ht| Lh_ih UL?_|L?t @hi

LE| 'b| Ee

\_| 'b_|R_| ED

bu|4b|'4b| ES

8Qrwh wkdw wkh ghflw rq wkh fxuuhqw dffrxqw lv jlyhq e|

Gw@ (Gw. Fw \_w=^F

Wklv htxdwlrq fdq eh frpelqhg zlwk wkh JGS lqfrph dffrxqwlqj uhodwlrq zw. uwNw@ \_w^F. sw\_w^L

wr |lhog +44,1 Ixuwkhupruh \_w^L @ Lw=

D

\u| 4\|'o|b|nB\| E.

|<"*4 b|(| e^34|' f EH

|<"*4 \|R|g| e^34|' f Eb ES 4T*it b^u|' fc |t |i UL?t|@?U) Lu UL?t4T|L? @*L?} |i LT|4@*

T@| At t @ t|@?_@h_ hit*| ? t4@** LTi? iUL?L4) ihtL?t Lu |i +@4ti) }hL| 4L_i*^S W| 4T*it |@| UL4T*i|i UL?t4T|L? t4LL|?} t hi@*3i_

|hL} ?|ih?@|L?@* *i?_?} @?_ MLhhL?} 6h|ih4Lhic t?Ui i^@|L?

Ee _hLTt L| Lu |i t)t|i4c |i Uh@|hi Lu |i |*|) u?U|L? @t ?L

?i?Ui L? |i 4L_i*<t _)?@4Ut

,^*Mh4 _)?@4Ut

5?Ui |i 4L_i* t hiUhtic |i _)?@4Ut Lu UL?t4T|L?c hi*@|i ThUi @?_

_iM| U@? Mi _i|ih4?i_ L?Ui U@T|@* @?_ |i t@_L ThUi @hi _i|ih4?i_

 #)?@4Ut

wi| t _i€?i >_| *? \_| @?_ &_| *?g_| Ai 4L_i* hi_Uit |L E2c E.c

@?_ ED U U@? Mi |h@?tuLh4i_ |L

&u|'e^{EnwU *? V|nEkEnwUnjU3&|}B E2f

>u_|' EBn4ke^{wU*? V|nEkEnwUnjU3&|} E2

@?_ |i t|@|U i^@|L?

e^>| 'bEe^{*? V|w}e^{3wU*? V|nkEwnj3wU3jU&|} E22 Ai *@t| i^@|L? @**Lt |i T@h|@* _ih@|it Lu *?V|| hitTiU| |L>|@?_

&| |L Mi _ihi_ Ai ?L?*?i@h t)t|i4 t |i? A@)*Lh@TThL 4@|i_ @ML|

|i t|i@_) t|@|i ₅

7

>u_|

&u|

6 8'a

% >|>

&|&

&

c E2

9Vhh iru h{dpsoh Eodqfkdug dqg Ilvfkhu +4<;<,1

S

ihi |i 4@|h a t }i? M)^. a

5

7 ^{wUnwEBn4wV*E3VU} EBn4^kkE nw_Unj_U n ^kwU_w^Ew_Unw^nj_V*E3V^3wU3jUl

BEnwU

wUnwV*E3V B^kkE nw_Unj_U n^kEnw_w^U_U^Ew_nw^nj_V*E3V^3wU3jUl

6 8

#i€?|L?  EihuiU| uLhit}| i^*Mh4 W? |i 4L_i* iUL?L4)c @ TihuiU| uLhit}| i^*Mh4 t @ ti| Lu ti^i?Uiti&|c >|j@?_ @? ?|@* U@T|@*

t|LU! &Ef :f t@|tu)?} EH |hL} E22

#i€?|L? 2 EW?_i|ih4?@U) Ai i^*Mh4 t ?_i|ih4?@|i u |ihi i t|t @? ?€?|i ?4Mih Lu TihuiU| uLhit}| i^*Mh4 ti^i?Uit i&|c >|j

&_|t @ Thi_i|ih4?i_ @h@M*i @?_ iL*it UL?|?Lt*) Ai ULt|@|i>_|t

@ ?L?Thi_i|ih4?i_ @h@M*ic |@| tc |t ?|@* @*i t ?L| }i? M) t|Lh)

@?_ | 4@) 4T ?t|@?|@?iLt*) ? hitTL?ti |L ?i ?uLh4@|L? Ai t|i@_) t|@|i t ?_i|ih4?@|i u ML| i}i?@*it Lu a @hi ?i}@|i^H W? |t U@tic

|i €ht| Lh_ih UL?_|L?t @?_ |i |h@?tiht@*|) UL?_|L?t @hi ?L| tUi?|

|L _i|ih4?i @ ?^i tL*|L? *|T*U|) Lu |t tLh| ?_U@|it |@| |i h@|L?@* i TiU|@|L?t i^*Mh@ ?L*i h@?_L4 @h@M*it |@| @hi ?hi*@|i_

|L |i iUL?L4)<t u?_@4i?|@*t t4T*) MiU@ti @}i?|t Mi*ii | |L Mi tL

2 @*Mh@|L?

Bi? |i i4ThU@* U@h@U|ih Lu |i hiUi?| _iM@|i L? |i T*@tM*|) Lu

?_i|ih4?@U) 4L_i*tc @ ?4ihU@* tL*|L? tii4t @_t@M*i OLiihc ii?

uLh @?@*)|U@* tL*|L?tc |iti T@h@4i|ih @*it }i @ }_i*?i |L h*i L|

4T*@tM*i T@h@4i|ih tT@Uit^b Ai uL**L?} A@M*i t44@h3it Mi?U4@h!

T@h@4i|ih @*it

:Wkh vwhdg| vwdwh lv jlyhq e|

@

. =

;Wkh prgho lv dovr lqghwhuplqdwh li erwk hljhqydoxhv duh srvlwlyh1 Krzhyhu/ lq wklv udwkhu xqlqwhuhvwlqj fdvh wkh prgho lv xqvwdeoh dqg wudqvyhuvdolw| frqglwlrqv duh xowlpdwho|

ylrodwhg +xqohvv wkh v|vwhp grhv qrw vhwwoh rqwr vrph vwdeoh f|foh,1

<Wkhvh uhvxowv duh/ krzhyhu/ odujho| xqdhfwhg e| wkh sduwlfxodu qxphulfdo fkrlfhv1

.

Wdeoh 4

k B 4

fef ff ffD

Aiti ULUit @hi t|@?_@h_ ? +i@* t?itt )U*i U@*Mh@|L? Ai) 4T*) @ *@MLh t@hi Lu t |) TihUi?|c @? @??@* U@T|@* _iThiU@|L? h@|i Lu

|i? TihUi?|c @? @??@* |*|) _tUL?| h@|i Lu €i TihUi?|c @ U@T|@*%L|T|

h@|L Lu 2S @?_ @ UL?t4T|L? t@hi L? L|T| Lu .D TihUi?| `i uh|ih hit|hU|wUcjUcwc @?_j i@U ?L| |L i Uii_ ff U t ? *?i | hiUi?|

i4ThU@* Lh! M) @t @?_ 6ih?@*_ Ebb. @t i** @t O@hhtL? EbbH@

Ai *@||ih hiTLh|t t*}|*) ?i}@|i @*it uLh w +i@*t|U U@T|@* t@hi U@*Mh@|L?t @**L t |L 4@!i |i T*@tM*i @tt4T|L?tG

tt4T|L?  kE nwU njU  @?_kE nwU 

tt4T|L?  U@? Mi ?|ihThi|i_ @t hit|hU|?} ETLt|i i |ih?@*|it |L Mi Lu 4L_it| t3i L?*)

W?_i|ih4?@U) @?_ tU@*i iUL?L4it

W? |t tiU|L? |i t3i Lu hi|h?t |L tU@*i |@| t ?ii_i_ |L }i?ih@|i ?_i

|ih4?@U) ** Mi @?@*)3i_ Wu @** uLh i |ih?@*|it @hi 3ihLc |i iUL?L4) UL**@Ttit |L |i L?i tiU|Lh 4L_i*c |i i^*Mh4 t ?^i @?_ |i _)?@4Ut

@hi _i}i?ih@|i wi| t €ht| UL?t_ih |i U@ti Lu tiU|Lh tTiU€U i |ih?@*|it L?*)

W?_i|ih4?@U) i? 'U'f `i t|@h| | |i T@h@4i|ih UL?€}

h@|L? |@| @t Mii? tMiU|i_ |L tL4i hiUi?| i4ThU@* @?@*)tt @?_ i4 ThU@* UL?€h4@|L?G |i Thiti?Ui Lu tiU|Lh tTiU€U i |ih?@*|it L?*) Ai UL?t4T|L? }LL_ tiU|Lh TL|i?|@**) i M|t tU@*i _tiUL?L4it Etii uLh i

@4T*i O@hhtL?c bbH@c Lh @t @?_ 6ih?@*_c bbH

`i? 'U'f c |i |h@Ui Lu |i a@ULM@?a t }i? M)

|oa' kB4wn4wUE4n EkB nkBwwUE4nB kBw nBw_Uk

*i |t _i|ih4?@?| t

(e|a' BE4n EkBEBn4EE nwUk kBwn E4n EkBwU

H

UIFUB +

71.7*

6}hi G W?_i|ih4?@U) | tiU|Lh tTiU€U i |ih?@*|it

6}hi  hiTLh|t |i |LTL*L}U@* U@tit uLh ?L?3ihL Ewc wU UL4M?@|L?t }i? |i U@*Mh@|L? ? A@M*i ^f Ai _@h! UL?i ?_U@|it t|@M*i i^*Mh@

MLi |t hi}L?c |i 4L_i* t ?t|@M*i i*L |i UL?ic |i _)?@4Ut @hi Lu t@__*i|)Tic |tc |i 4L_i* t _i|ih4?@|i wi| t uh|ih ?it|}@|i |i

?_i|ih4?@U) UL?_|L?t^ 6hL4 tt4T|L? c |i ?4ih@|Lh ? (e|a t

43Glhuhqw fdoleudwlrqv wkdq wkh rqhv lq Wdeoh 4 gr qrw dowhu wkh txdolwdwlyh uhvxowv/

udwkhu rqo| fkdqjh wkh h{dfw srvlwlrq ri wkh wkuhh wrsorjlfdo uhjlphv1

44Vwdeoh +xqvwdeoh, htxloleuld/ wkxv wzr hljhqydoxhv zlwk qhjdwlyh +srvlwlyh, uhdo sduwv/

duh dvvrfldwhg zlwk d srvlwlyh ghwhuplqdqw dqg d qhjdwlyh +srvlwlyh, wudfh1 Wkh hljhqydoxhv vsolw durxqg }hur/ h1j1 d vdggoh/ li wkh ghwhuplqdqw lv qhjdwlyh1

b

@*@)t TLt|i Atc ?L?t@__*iTL?| Mi@Lh LUUht uLh^2 w :

#4n EkB kB

$

w_U

?iUitt@h) UL?_|L? uLh 4*|T*U|) t |@| |i tiU|Lh tTiU€U i |ih?@*|it

@hi Lu LTTLt|i t}? 6hL4 6}hi c i U@? @*tL tii |@| @t w ?Uhi@titc |i _)?@4Ut U@?}i uhL4 @ t?! E|i t|@?_@h_ ?_i|ih4?@U) U*@tt€U@|L? |L

@ tLhUi W? L|ih Lh_tc |ihi i t|t @ u?U|L? w^W 'w^WEw_U^W tU |@| |i i^*Mh4 @t @ t4T*i T@h Lu 4@}?@h) i}i?@*it @?_ @ OLTu MuhU@|L?

|@!it T*@Ui W? |t T@h@4i|hU ?i}MLhLL_c |i i^*Mh4 t t|@M*i uLh w w^W @?_ ?t|@M*i uLh w : w^W W? T@h|U*@hc |i |h@Ui @?tit i?

w_U^W ' kB4

4E4n EkBw^W3kB4kB²

Atc M) UL?|?|)c u |i ?i}@|i ETLt|i i |ih?@*|) T@h@4i|ihw t ?

€?|it4@**) U*Lti |L 3ihLc @ TLt|i E?i}@|i @*i uLhw_U ** @*@)t i t|t tU |@| ?_i|ih4?@U) t TLttM*iG^ ?_i|ih4?@U) @htit @| h|@**) 3ihL _iT@h|hit uhL4 |i UL?t|@?| hi|h?t |L tU@*i U@ti LhiLihc |i i^*M h4 MiUL4it @ t@__*i @*L?} |i t|h@}| *?i w^r@__,e '^4nE3kB_kB w_U^r@__,e |

|t MuhU@|L? TL?|c L?i i}i?@*i T@ttit |hL} 4?t ?€?|) Aihi uLhic ?_i|ih4?@U) t t@|t€i_ U*Lti |L |i MuhU@|L? ML?_@h) 6?@**)c | tL*_ Mi ?L|i_ |@| }i? |i hit*|t M) O@hhtL? EbbH@c | t T*@tM*i |L hit|hU|w wU W? |t U@ti |i 4L_i*<t @ih@}i i |ih?@*|it @hi ?i}@|i ?

|i ?_i|ih4?@U) hi}L? W? |i U*Lti_ iUL?L4) @h@?| Lu |L tiU|Lh 4L_i*

| tiU|Lh tTiU€U i |ih?@*|it ?_i|ih4?@U) t LM|@?i_ @| w_U : f.^e Ai uL**L?} 4@? hLTLt|L? Lu |i T@Tih t44@h3it |i hit*|t

hLTLt|L?  Ai t4@** LTi? iUL?L4) |L tiU|Lh 4L_i* | tiU|Lh tTi U€U i |ih?@*|it }i?ih@|it ?_i|ih4?@U) @| h|@**) UL?t|@?| hi|h?t |L tU@*i 6Lh T*@tM*i T@h@4i|ih UL?t|i**@|L?tc |i Lih@** iUL?L4) i M|t _iUhi@t?} hi|h?t |L tU@*i

6Lh @__|L?@* ?_iht|@?_?} Lu |i ?_i|ih4?@U) 4iU@?t4c UL?t_ih

|i uL**L?} |L tTiU@* U@tit

45Wklv lv htxlydohqw wr C oq w@Cw? 3=

46Uhfdoo wkdw dw F @ L @ 3 wkh prgho pxvw eh ghwhuplqdwh/ khqfh/ wkh ruljlq lwvhoi lv qrw lqfoxghg1 Qxphulfdo fdoleudwlrqv qg lqghwhuplqdf| dw L 3=334=

47Kduulvrq +4<<;e, dqg Zhghu +4<<;f, vkrz wkdw lw lv wkh lqfuhdvlqj uhwxuqv lq wkh lqyhvwphqw vhfwru wkdw gulyh wkh uhvxow1

f

#)?@4Ut i? w ' 'U'f W? |t U@tic |i |h@Ui Lu a MiUL4it 4 : fc |tc |i t|i@_) t|@|i U@? ?iih Mi @ t?! Ai _i|ih4?@?| t }i?

M)

(e|a ' BE4nB EE nw_Uk wU

Bi? @tt4T|L? c r}? (e|a'r}? wU Oi?Uic TLt|i tiU|Lh@* i |ih

?@*|it ? |i ?it|4i?| tiU|Lh 4T*) |@| |i t|i@_) t|@|i t @ tLhUi

|ihti |i i^*Mh4 t @ t@__*i TL?| @?_ t ?^i

#)?@4Ut i? wU ' 'U'f W? |t U@tic |i |h@Ui Lu a MiUL4it 4 :f @}@? Ai _i|ih4?@?| t }i? M)

(e|a ' Ek E4nB E4n EkB kw

W| uL**Lt |@| r}? (e|a'r}? w Oi?Uic TLt|i tiU|Lh@* i |ih?@*|it

? |i UL?t4T|L? }LL_ tiU|Lh 4T*) |@| |i t|i@_) t|@|i t @ tLhUi

|ihti |i i^*Mh4 t @ t@__*i TL?| Ai ?i | hLTLt|L? hit|@|it

|i hit*|

hLTLt|L? 2 6Lh ?_i|ih4?@U) |L LUUhc tiU|Lh tTiU€U i |ih?@*|it 4t|

Mi Thiti?| ? ML| tiU|Lht LhiLihc tiU|Lh tTiU€U _tiUL?L4it Lu tL4i tLh|

@hi ?iUitt@h) uLh ?L?t@__*i i^*Mh@ |L Mi t|@M*i

#)?@4Ut i? w''f Wu _iT@h|hit uhL4 UL?t|@?| hi|h?t @hi *4

|i_ |L |i ?it|4i?| tiU|Lhc |i |h@Ui u |i 4@|h a MiUL4it

|oa '4 kBjU

wU

@?_ |i _i|ih4?@?| t }i? M)

(e|a' BE4nB EE nwUnjUk

wU

Bi? tt4T|L? c @ ?iUitt@h) UL?_|L? uLh ?_i|ih4?@U) t w_U : fc L|ihti |i _i|ih4?@?| Lu |i a@ULM@? t ?i}@|i 6h|ihc |i |h@Ui t

?i}@|i uLh

w_U kB 4 j_U Ai uL**L?} ThLTLt|L? t44@h3it |i hit*|



hLTLt|L? 5TTLti |i ThL_U|L? u?U|L? ? |i UL?t4T|L? }LL_

tiU|Lh t UL?t|@?| hi|h?t |L tU@*i W?_i|ih4?@U) hi^hit TLt|i tiU|Lh tTiU€U @?_ TLt|i @}}hi}@|i i |ih?@*|it ? |i ?it|4i?| }LL_t ThL_U?}

tiU|Lh Ai t|i@_) t|@|i t @ t?! u wU*jU kB*4

#)?@4Ut i? w_U'_U'f Wu |i ?it|4i?| }LL_ tiU|Lh LTih@|it ?_ih UL?t|@?| hi|h?t @?_ i |ih?@*|it @hi Thiti?| ? |i UL?t4T|L? }LL_ tiU|Lhc

|i |h@Ui @?_ _i|ih4?@?| MiUL4i

|oa' jE4n EkB n4w w

@?_

(e|a' Ek E4nB E4n EkB

kw

TLt|i _i|ih4?@?| t }i? uLh @** w :fW?_i|ih4?@U) t LM|@?i_ uLh j 4n EkB

4 w

Atc @ t|@M*i t|i@_) t|@|i hi^hit ?i}@|i @}}hi}@|i i |ih?@*|it wi| t t44@h3i |iti hit*|t

hLTLt|L? e 5TTLti |i ThL_U|L? u?U|L? ? |i ?it|4i?| }LL_ tiU

|Lh t UL?t|@?| hi|h?t |L tU@*i W?_i|ih4?@U) hi^hit TLt|i tiU|Lh tTiU€U

@?_ ?i}@|i @}}hi}@|i i |ih?@*|it ? |i UL?t4T|L? }LL_t ThL_U?} tiU

|Lh Ai t|i@_) t|@|i t @ t?! u j*w EkB*4

e W?|ihThi|@|L?

W| @t Mii? tL? ? |i ThiUi_?} tiU|L? |@| ?_i|ih4?@U) U@? Mi LM

|@?i_ @| T*@tM*i T@h@4i|ih @*it Ai 4iU@?t4 |@| *i@_t |L ?_i

|ih4?@U) _giht tL4i@| |L |@| ? |i U*Lti_ iUL?L4) 4L_i* wi| t UL?t_ih |i _tUhi|i |4i ihtL? Lu |i 4L_i* Ai ?|ih|i4TLh@* ,*ih i^@|L? t }i? M)

b|R| ' b|n

 n4do|nn EBR|no

2

Wu @}i?|t Mi*ii ? hi@*3?} U@T|@* }@?t M) hi@**LU@|?} hitLhUit Lih |4ic

|i) ** t|@h| ?it|?} |L_@) @?_ ThU@ti 4Lhi UL?t4T|L? }LL_t ? |i u|hi Wu hi|h?t |L tU@*i ? |i ?it|4i?| }LL_ tiU|Lh @hi tUi?|*) }c

|i hi*@|i ThUi ** €ht| u@** E@t @ hit*| Lu |i tiU|LhtTiU€U TLt|i i

|ih?@*|it @?_ |i? hti^D Ai i TiU|i_ ThUi T@| t ti*uu*€**?} At t U*i@h t?Uic @t @ hit*| Lu |t hi@**LU@|L?c ML| b| @?_ R| 4Li ? LTTL t|i _hiU|L? Atc |i igiU| Lu ?Uhi@t?} hi|h?t L? hi*@|i ThUit 4t|

Mi tUi?|*) t|hL?} |L LihUL4i |i @}i?|<t _ithi |L t4LL| UL?t4T

|L? 6h|ih4Lhic O@hhtL? EbbHM @?_ `i_ih EbbH@c bbHU tL |@|

| t }i?ih@**) tUi?| |L @tt4i ?Uhi@t?} hi|h?t ? |i ?it|4i?| }LL_

ThL_U?} tiU|Lh L?*)

N?*!i |i i?@MM @?_ 6@h4ih EbbS ti|Tc ? |i t4@** LTi? iUL?L4)

|ihi @hi ?L ULt|t Lu uLhi}L?i UL?t4T|L? @*L?} @*|ih?@|i T@|t ihuiU|

?|ih?@|L?@* U@T|@* 4@h!i|t @**L |i TihuiU| t4LL|?} Lu UL?t4T|L?G

|i t@_L ThUi Lu i@*| b t @ UL?t|@?| AihiuLhic u @}i?|t @?| |L ? Uhi@ti ?it|4i?|c |i hi@*3@|L? Lu UL?t4T|L? t ?@giU|i_ ,i? i?

|*|) @t Uh@|hi @*|ih?@|i i^*Mh@ U@? i@t*) Mi UL?t|hU|i_^S Ai hi_Ui_ uLh4 Lu |i 4L_i* MiUL4it t4*@h |L |i U*Lti_ iUL?L4) ihtL?

| *?i@h |*|) @?_ L?*) 4?Lh _iT@h|hit uhL4 UL?t|@?| hi|h?t |L tU@*i

@hi ?ii_i_ |L ThL_Ui |i ti*uu*€**?} ThUi _)?@4Ut W?_i|ih4?@U) ii?

|@|it uhL4 @? @TThLTh@|i ti^i?Ui Lu ThUi igiU|t |@| @hti ? |i Thiti?Ui Lu i |ih?@*|it W? @ t4@** LTi? iUL?L4) 4L_i* tU @t |i Thiti?|c |i i

|ih?@*|it 4t| Mi L?*) 4?4@* ? t3i |L ?|@|i |t ThUi ti^i?Ui Atc

?_i|ih4?@U) t LM|@?i_ @| 4U *Lih @*it |@? ? |i U*Lti_ iUL?L4)

@h@?| OLiihc u tiU|Lh tTiU€U i |ih?@*|it @hi UL?t_ihi_ L?*)c ?_i|ih 4?@U) hi^hit |@| |i 4L_i* 4t| TLttitt tL4i uLh4 Lu @ _@4Ti??} igiU|

t4*@h |L |i OL|| @?_ Uuii EbHH ti@hU i |ih?@*|) 4L_i*^. N?*itt

|t ?i}@|i igiU| t Thiti?|c U@T|@* }@?t UL*_ Mi uLh@h_i_ @_ ?€?|4

@?_ |i iUL?L4) L*_ ii?|@**) _iT@h| uhL4 |t t|i@_) t|@|i i^*Mh4

48Lw fdq eh vkrzq wkdw wkh surgxfwlrq srvvlelolw| iurqwlhu lv frqyh{ dv orqj dv wkhuh lv lqfuhdvlqj uhwxuqv lq dw ohdvw rqh vhfwru +vhh Kduulvrq/ 4<<;e,1

49Lq wkh forvhg hfrqrp| yhuvlrq dq lqyhvwphqw errp uhtxluhv dq rxwzdug vkliw ri oderu vxsso| wr eh deoh wr surgxfh pruh ri wkh lqyhvwphqw jrrg zkloh dw wkh vdph wlph vdwlvi|lqj frqvxpswlrq vprrwklqj1 Wklv phfkdqlvp lv frpsohwho| devhqw khuh1

4:Krzlww dqg PfDihh +4<;;, kdyh wzr h{whuqdolwlhv +rqh srvwlyh/ rqh qhjdwlyh, lq wkhlu prgho1 Wkh dxwkruv dfwxdoo| exlog rq uhvxow nqrzq iurp Olyldwdq dqg Vdpxhovrq +4<9<, wkdw vwdwlrqdu| vwdwhv duh hlwkhu vdggohv ru xqvwdeoh1



uLhiih +iU@** |i _tUhi|i |4i ,*ih i^@|L?G u @}i?|t ?Uhi@ti |ih _i 4@?_ uLh ?it|4i?| }LL_tc |i hi*@|i ThUi u@**t @t @ UL?ti^i?Ui Lu |i TLt|i tiU|LhtTiU€U i |ih?@*|it Aihi t ?L 4iU@?t4 |@| UiU!t |i ThUi _)?@4Ut t?Ui b t UL?t|@?| W? |i UL?|?Lt |4i U@ti Lu |i t4@**

LTi? iUL?L4)c E. t |i hi*i@?| ,*ih i^@|L? Ai Uh@|hi Lu |*|) t ?L *L?}ih @? @h}4i?| `i? ?it|4i?| ?Uhi@titc R| u@**t @t @ hit*|

Lu |i TLt|i tiU|Lh tTiU€U i |ih?@*|it W?|ih|i4TLh@* i^*Mh4 ?L hi^hit |@| |i t@_L ThUi Lu U@T|@* @TThiU@|it OLiihc |i ThUi u@** Lu U@T|@* ?_Uit uh|ih ?it|4i?| @U||)c i?Uic |i ThLUitt L*_

@TT*) Lih @?_ Lih @}@? AL hiihti |i ?€?|i @TThiU@|L? @?_ |L h*i L| @? *|4@|i L*@|L? Lu |i |h@?tiht@*|) UL?_|L?tc tL4i uLh4 Lu ?i}

@|i i |ih?@*|it 4t| Mi ti| ? 4L|L? At t |i hit*| Lu hLTLt|L?  Atc ?|ih|i4TLh@* i^*Mh4 ii?|@**) hi^hit @ _iThiU@|L? @?_ |i iUL?L4) 4Lit M@U! |L@h_t |i t|i@_) t|@|ic }?} hti |L @? @*|ih?@|i i^*Mh4 |h@iU|Lh)

D 544@h)

At T@Tih Thiti?|t @ t4@** LTi? iUL?L4) ihtL? Lu |i i?@MM @?_

6@h4ih EbbS |L tiU|Lh LT|4@* }hL| 4L_i* | tiU|Lh tTiU€U i |ih?@*

|it W| t tL? |@| ?_i|ih4?@U) t UL?t_ih@M*) i@tih |L LM|@? ?_ih

|t hi}4i |L| TihuiU| Lh*_ U@T|@* 4@h!i|t |@? ? |i U*Lti_ iUL?

L4) @h@?| 6h|ih4Lhi |i hit*| t ?L| _iTi?_i?| L? @ } *@MLh tTT*) i*@t|U|) *|L} |i 4L_i* t }*) t|)*3i_c | U*i@h*) }it @? ?_

U@|L? |@| LTi??} T ?|ih?@|L?@* U@T|@* 4@h!i|t U@? Mi _it|@M*3?}

Lhi }i?ih@**)c | @t Mii? tL? |@| |i |L tiU|Lh t4@** LTi? iUL?L4) ihtL?t Lu |i LT|4@* }hL| 4L_i* @i *itt _i}i?ih@|i _)?@4Ut |@? |t L?i tiU|Lh hi*@|it

+iuihi?Uit

do @tc 5t@?|L @?_ aL? B 6ih?@*_ Ebb.G +i|h?t |L 5U@*i ? N5 hL_U|L?G ,t|4@|it @?_ W4T*U@|L?tc aLh?@* Lu L*|U@* ,UL?L4)

fDc 2eb2H

e

d2o i?@MMc aitt @?_ +L}ih , 6@h4ih EbbeG W?_i|ih4?@U) @?_

W?Uhi@t?} +i|h?tc aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4U AiLh) Sc be

do i?@MMc aitt @?_ +L}ih , 6@h4ih EbbSG W?_i|ih4?@U) @?_

5iU|Lh5TiU€U , |ih?@*|itcaLh?@* Lu L?i|@h) ,UL?L4Ut .c e2

ee

deo i?@MMc aitt @?_ k@3L t4h@ Ebb.G W?_i|ih4?@U) N?_ih L?t|@?| +i|h?t |L 5U@*ic #iT@h|4i?| Lu ,UL?L4Ut i vLh! N?

iht|)c 44iL

dDo i?@MMc aitt @?_ k@3L t4h@ EbbSG W?_i|ih4?@U) @?_

5?tTL|t | L?t|@?| +i|h?t |L 5U@*ic V 5|@hh i?|ih uLh T T*i_ ,UL?L4Ut ,UL?L4U +iti@hU +iTLh| rbSee

dSo *@?U@h_c *ih a @?_ 5|@?*i) 6tUih EbHbG wiU|hit L? @UhLi UL?L4Utc WA hittc @4Mh_}i

d.o h?t_ic h@} EbbSG hL_U|L? 6?U|L? +i}hittL?tc +i|h?t |L 5U@*i @?_ , |ih?@*|itc aLh?@* Lu L?i|@h) ,UL?L4Ut .c ..2f

dHo BU!i?i4ihc aL? @?_ *T OL*4it EbHG L?*?i@h tU**@|L?tc

#)?@4U@* 5)t|i4tc @?_ uhU@|L?t Lu ViU|Lh 6i*_tc 5Th?}ihVih*@}c i vLh!

dbo O@hhtL?c 5@hL? B EbbH@G hL_U|L? , |ih?@*|it @?_ W?_i|ih 4?@U) ? @ AL 5iU|Lh L_i*G AiLh) @?_ ,_i?Uic #iT@h|4i?| Lu ,UL?L4Ut @h?@h_ L**i}ic `Lh!?} @Tih rbHfD

dfo O@hhtL?c 5@hL? B EbbHMG W?_i|ih4?@U) ? @ L_i* | 5iU

|Lh 5TiU€U , |ih?@*|itc #iT@h|4i?| Lu ,UL?L4Ut @h?@h_ L**i}ic

`Lh!?} @Tih rbHf.

do OL||c i|ih @?_ + hit|L? Uuii EbHHG 5|@M*|) Lu ,^*Mh@

| , |ih?@*|itc "@h|ih*) aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4Utfc 2S2..

d2o aiL?c aL?}!)L EbbHG W?_i|ih4?@U) @?_ t?itt )U*it ? @ 54@**

Ti? ,UL?L4)c #iT@h|4i?| Lu ,UL?L4Ut Nwc 44iL

do k3?i|tLc vh EbbHG ,*i4i?|t Lu TT*i_ uhU@|L? AiLh)c 5Th?}ihVih*@}c i vLh!

D

deo w@hc 4@h|)@ EbbHG BhL| @?_ ,^*Mh4 W?_i|ih4?@U)G Ai hL*i Lu U@T|@* 4LM*|)c #iT@h|4i?| Lu ,UL?L4Ut Nwc 44iL dDo w@|@?c tt@? @?_ @* 5@4i*tL? EbSbG L|it L? Ah?T!itG

5|@M*i @?_ N?t|@M*ic aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4U AiLh) c eDee.D

dSo `i_ihc @h! EbbH@G 6U!*i L?t4ihtc #h@M*i BLL_t @?_ t?itt )U*itc aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4U AiLh) Hc .D.

d.o `i_ihc @h! EbbHMG W?_i|ih4?@U) ? @ AL 5iU|Lh 54@** Ti?

,UL?L4) T|4@* BhL| L_i*c #iT@h|4i?| Lu ,UL?L4Ut O4ML*_|

N?iht|) ih*?c 44iL

dHo `i_ihc @h! EbbHUG ?4@* 5Th|tc AiU?L*L}) 5LU!t @?_ |i t

?itt )U*icaLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4U #)?@4Ut @?_ L?|hL*c EuLh|UL4?}

S