• Keine Ergebnisse gefunden

Religion in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Aktie "Religion in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland "

Copied!
33
0
0

Wird geladen.... (Jetzt Volltext ansehen)

Volltext

(1)
(2)

Religion in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland

herausgegeben von

Christian Albrecht, Julia Angster,

Reiner Anselm, Andreas Busch, Hans Michael Heinig und Christiane Kuller

9

(3)
(4)

Tim Schedel

Religiöse Sprache und Atomkraft

Strategien des Protestantismus zur anwaltschaftlichen Vermittlung in gesellschaftlichen Konfliktfeldern

Mohr Siebeck

(5)

Tim Schedel, geboren 1988; Studium der Ev. Theologie in Neuendettelsau, Berlin, Wien und Greifswald; 2016 Kirchliches Examen der Evangelisch-Lutherischen Landeskirche in Bayern; Wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter im DFG Projekt »Der Protestantismus in den ethischen Debatten der Bundesrepublik Deutschland 1949–1989« an der LMU München;

Wissenschaftlicher Assistent an der Ev.-Theol. Fakultät der CAU Kiel; 2020 Promotion zum Dr. theol. an der LMU München; derzeit Vikar in Altenholz bei Kiel.

orcid.org/0000-0001-8312-9034

ISBN 978-3-16-159674-2 / eISBN 978-3-16-159675-9 DOI 10.1628/978-3-16-159675-9

ISSN 2364-3684 / eISSN 2568-7417 (Religion in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland) Die Deutsche Nationalbibliothek verzeichnet diese Publikation in der Deutschen Nati- onalbibliographie; detaillierte bibliographische Daten sind über http://dnb.dnb.de abrufbar.

© 2021 Mohr Siebeck Tübingen. www.mohrsiebeck.com

Das Werk einschließlich aller seiner Teile ist urheberrechtlich geschützt. Jede Verwertung außerhalb der engen Grenzen des Urheberrechtsgesetzes ist ohne Zustimmung des Verlags unzulässig und strafbar. Das gilt insbesondere für die Verbreitung, Vervielfältigung, Übersetzung und die Einspeicherung und Verarbeitung in elektronischen Systemen.

Das Buch wurde von Hubert & Co. in Göttingen auf alterungsbeständiges Werkdruckpapier gedruckt und gebunden. Den Umschlag entwarf Uli Gleis in Tübingen. Umschlagabbildung:

Günter Zint. https://panfoto.de.

Printed in Germany.

(6)

Meinen Kindern gewidmet

(7)

(8)

% "

=B969GCB89F9CFA89GT::9BH@=7<9B*989BG=GH89FT::9BH@=7<95B? C7<

K5F9B8=9965HH9BIA8=9N=J=@9&IHNIB;89FHCA?F5:HK9B=;U69FF5G7<9B8

<716BJCB;9;9BG9=H=;9F5B?G5;IB;;9DFR;H /9BB5I7<89FT::9BH@=7<95B?

=B89FF;IA9BH5H=CBG:U<FIB;89F+HI8=9B=7<HG=7<H65FK=F8GCG9=9F=A.CF KCFHIAGCIA:5GG9B89FIB8IAGC<9FN@=7<9FNIAIG8FI7?;96F57<H

=9JCF@=9;9B89+HI8=9KIF89=A/=BH9FG9A9GH9FJCB89FJ5B;9

@=G7<,<9C@C;=G7<9B 5?I@HRH 89F $I8K=;%5L=A=@=5BG-B=J9FG=HRH %UB7<9B IBH9F89A,=H9@[.CAT::9BH@=7<9B96F5I7<F9@=;=TG9F+DF57<9 9F(FCH9G H5BH=GAIGNK=G7<9BBK5@HG7<5:HIB8.9FA=HH@IB;=B89FHCA?F5:H8965HH989F IB89GF9DI6@=?9IHG7<@5B8Z5@G=GG9FH5H=CB5B;9BCAA9B UF8=9(I6@=?5 H=CBKIF898=9+HI8=9BIF;9F=B;:U;=;U69F5F69=H9H

%9=B9FGH9F5B?;96U<FHGCA=HA9=B9BC?HCFJ5H9F(FC: F *9=B9FB G9@A F@=9WA=F69=89F9HF9IIB;89G(FCACH=CBGJCF<569BG89BBTH=;9BF9=

F5IA IA 85G (FC>9?H >9BG9=HG JCB GH5FF9B .CF;569B A=H 9=;9B9B !899B IB8 F5;9GH9@@IB;9BNI9BHK=7?9@BIB8NIJC@@9B89B -B88C7<<5HH99F=AA9F9=B

;IH9G9GDUFK5BB9G5B;96F57<HK5F9=B9Ba;9:CFAH9B =BK9=G`NI;969B IB885A=H89BCFHG7<F=HH89FF69=HNIG=7<9FB 9=89B=A.9F@5I:9=B9F=G G9FH5H=CB B=7<H NI J9FA9=89B89B ,=9:DIB?H9B :5B8 9F GH9HG 8=9 F=7<H=;9B 5I:

AIBH9FB89B/CFH98=9=AA9F5I7<JCB9=B9FD9FGTB@=7<9B/9FHG7<RHNIB;;9 DFR;HK5F9B 2I@9HNH85B?9=7<=<A:UF8=969GCB89F9#C@@9;=5@=HRH8=98IF7<

=9BGH69GDF97<IB;9B'69FG9A=B5F9D9FGTB@=7<9B=B@58IB;9BIB88=9@9;9B 8RF9B@C7?G9A=B5F9=B58C=G9FB5A$9<FGHI<@BG9@A?I@H=J=9FHKIF89 UF89B?C@@9;=5@9BIGH5IG7<IB88=9F9IB8G7<5:H85B?9=7<89A;9G5AH9B ,95AF BB9F=989F=?9 C::A5BBIB8%=7<59@F989FA=H89B9B=7<;9 A9=BG5A=B89FCFG7<9F;FIDD95F69=H9H9IBG9F9B =@:G?FR:H9B"C<5BB5 9@@

AIH<+CD<=9*CH<F989F=79+H5G=?IB8,<9F9G5-@@A5BBIBG9F9F+9?F9HRF=B +IG5BB529B;@9FGCK=989B$9<FGHI<@?C@@9;9B$I?5G5J=8%9M9FF 9BF=?

%9M9F%5;=GH9FIB8&=?@5G+7<@9=7<9F

9F9=GH;9A9=BG7<5:H@=7<9BF69=H9BGIB8CFG7<9BGJCB(FC:9GGCF=BB9B 6NK (FC:9GGCF9B=A.9F6IB8A=H/=GG9BG7<5:H@=7<9B%=H5F69=H9FBK9<H9B=7<H BIF5A$9<FGHI<@GCB89FB5I7<=A(FC>9?H3@$@=B3AB/<B7A;CA7<23<

3B67A163< 30/BB3< 23@ C<23A@3>C0:79 S =B 89A 8=9 +HI8=9 9BH GH5B8 UF DFC8I?H=J9 F69=HGH5;9 IB8 5A=?56@9 69B89 =A +HI8=9B<5IG +7<TBK5;85B?9=7<(FC: F <F=GH=5B@6F97<H(F5?H=G7<9,<9C@C;=9%UB

(9)

):=B:=?

.!!!

7<9B A=H 89B %=H5F69=H9F=BB9B &=7C@5 @@9F "IB (FC: F BB9HH9 5IW A5BBIB8F #5H<5F=B5 9FFA5BB(FC: F B8F95GIG7<(C@=H=?K=GG9B G7<5:HTHH=B;9BA=H(<=@=D+A9HG(FC: F 5BG%=7<59@ 9=B=;P::9BH@=

7<9G*97<HTHH=B;9BA=H%5@H9 5?9A5BB(FC: F <F=GH=5B9#I@@9F&9I 9F9IB829=H;9G7<=7<H9F:IFHA=HF %5F=IG 9=8F=7<$I=G9(CG7<A5BBIB8 F *9BS+AC@5FG?=(FC: F @5I8=5$9DD#=F7<@=7<929=H;9G7<=7<H9%UB 7<9BA=HF "CB5H<5B+D5BCGGCK=9(FC: F %5FH=B$5I69+MGH9A5H=G7<9 ,<9C@C;=9 THH=B;9B A=H &=?C@5G #9=H9@ IB8 $M8=5 $5ILA5BB !B 8=9G9A 2I;985B?9=7<<F=GH=5B@6F97<H5I7<:UF85G2K9=HF9:9F5HNIF=GG9FH5H=CB

=B 89A 9F 8=9 ;9A9=BG5A9 29=H IB8 A9=B9 F69=H NIA 6G7<@IGG 89F (FC

>9?HD<5G9BC7<9=BA5@5I:DC=BH=9FH9/9=G9KUF8=;H9 (FC: F 5F=5(9NNC@=

'@;=5H=*9@=;=CBGK=GG9BG7<5:HIB8(FC: F $CF9B, +HI7?9B6FI7?&9I9G ,9GH5A9BH85B?9=7<:UF89B 9A9=BG5AA=H*9=B9FBG9@AAC 89F=9FH9BG=9A9=B*=;CFCGIA5@G9=BK=GG9BG7<5:H@=7<9G57<;9GDFR7<=B89A G=9G=7<5@G(FU:9B89NIFU7?B5<A9BIAA=F5@G(FU:@=B;8=9%T;@=7<?9=HNI F9UGG=9F9B;569B

@G%=H;@=989FB89G 9F5IG;969F?F9=G9G85B?9=7<89B69H9=@=;H9B(FC>9?H

@9=H9B89B89FCFG7<9F;FIDD9GCK=9(FC: F "I@=5B;GH9F&9I9F9IB829=H

;9G7<=7<H9 %5BB<9=A :UF 8=9 I:B5<A9 A9=B9F =GG9FH5H=CBGG7<F=:H =B 8=9

*9=<9&3:757=<7<23@C<23A@3>C0:793CBA16:/<2 I7<85B?9=7<89B%=H 5F69=H9B89B89G.9F@5;G%C<F+=9697?:UF8=9;IH92IG5AA9B5F69=HIB8=<F9 J9F@9;9F=G7<9+CF;:5@H69=89F 9F5IG;5698=9G9GI7<9G UF8=9:=B5BN=9@@9 -BH9FGHUHNIB;8IF7<FI7??CGH9BNIG7<UGG96985B?9=7<A=7<;9FB969=8F9=

!BGH=HIH=CB9B69=A9=B9F:;/!/B3@89F$%-GCK=969=89FJ5B;9@=G7<9B

#=F7<99IHG7<@5B8G#IB869=A9=B9A>9HN=;9BF69=H;969F89FJ5B;9

@=G7<$IH<9F=G7<9B#=F7<9=B&CF889IHG7<@5B8&CF8?=F7<9

(:5FF9FUBH9F*=7<H9F5@G29=HN9I;985B?9=7<:UF8=9+7<=@89FIB;89G#CB :@=?H:5@@G/M<@IB889ACHC;F5:9BUBH9F2=BH85B?9=7<:UF8=9F@5I6B=G G9=BCHC5@GI7<7CJ9FBIHN9BNI8UF:9B

@G K=7<H=;9B /9;69;@9=H9FB 5IW9F<5@6 89F ;9B5BBH9B #CBH9LH9 K=@@ =7<

A9=B9B@5B;>R<F=;9B+HI8=9B:F9IB89B85B?9B 5F5@85I89%CB5T<A9

@=LIB8 9BF=9HH99;K=HNF @5I8=5#U<B9FF5WA5BBIB8,C6=5GF5W A5BB"I@=5B+7<5FD:&=?@5G+7<@9=7<9FIB8"C<5BB9G/9=89A5BB

(FC: F BBC 8N5F8 (CD?9G &9I9G ,9GH5A9BH #=9@ 85B?9 =7< 85:UF 85GG=7<=A/=BH9FG9A9GH9F5@GG9=BGG=GH9BH5F69=H9B8IF:H9IB8:UF J=9@9GA9<F 9A#=9@9F%=HH9@65I5B89F,<9C@C;=G7<9B5?I@HRH85B?9=7<

85GGG=989Ba#IFN5F69=H9F`G7<B9@@IB8<9FN@=7<=BH9;F=9FH9BIB85I7<5@G.=?5F BC7<K=@@?CAA9B<9=W9B %9=B9A.=?5F=5HGA9BHCF(5GHCF=F?FCW9@H9B

<C@N85B?9=7<85:UF85GG=7<;9A9=BG5AA=H=<A#=F7<9IB8,<9C@C;=9NI G5AA9B89B?9B?5BB

UF8=99;@9=HIB;5I:A9=B9B;5BN9B$969BGK9;85B?9=7<A9=B9F5A=

@=9 %9=B9FFCWAIHH9F@=G569H<+7<989@:UF8=9;965@@H9$969BG:F9I898=9 G=96=G=BG<C<9@H9F=BG=7<HFR;H %9=B9F+7<K9GH9FIB8A9=B9A+7<K5;9F

(10)

):=B:=?

!0 15F5IB8@9L5B89F2M@@585B?9=7<:UF8=9;9A9=BG5A929=H=B89F/=B 89FB57<A5B7<9A@5B;9B,5;5A+7<F9=6H=G7<85G/CFH373@/03<2G9<F9FBGH

;9BCAA9BKIF89 %9=B9B@H9FB5F8MIB8B8F95G+7<989@85B?9=7<:UF

=<F9$=969IB8UFGCF;9=<F9B*5HIB8=<F9-BH9FGHUHNIB;=B5@@9B$969BG@5

;9B /=9;FCW=<F.9F8=9BGH8IF7<=<F@=969JC@@9G9;@9=H9BA9=B9G$969BG=GH

@RGGHG=7<=B/CFH9BB=7<H5IG8FU7?9B

9F56G7<@=9W9B895B?;=@HA9=B9FF5IF +H9D<5B=9F=D9BHFC;+7<989@

*9@=;=CBGK=GG9BG7<5:H#=9@ 5B?=<F9FK9=HF9=7<9B89B#CAD9H9BN=A9 F9=7<89FIB=J9FG=HRF9BCFG7<IB;K5FG=98=969GH9-BH9FGHUHNIB;IB8;9=GH=;9 +D5FF=B;GD5FHB9F=B 8=9 =7< A=F 5@G C?HCF5B8 KUBG7<9B ?CBBH9 5B? =<F9F

;9@96H9B$9=89BG7<5:H:UF8=9/=GG9BG7<5:HK5FG=9A=FGH9HG9=B9;FCW9%CH=

J5H=CBIB85I7<9=B.CF6=@8 -B885B?=<F9F$=969?CBBH9BK=F=B89F(FCAC H=CBGN9=HB=7<HBIF5@G/=GG9BG7<5:H@9FGCB89FB5I7<5@G(55FK57<G9BIB885 A=H9FI:IB;IB85A=@=9;@9=7<9FA5W9B=BIBG9F9A$969B*5IA;969B IG 8FI7?85JCB=GH8=9G7<TB9#C=BN=89BN85GG=7<8=9G9GI7<5BIBG9F9A C7<

N9=HGH5; 56G7<@=9W9 -B8 BC7< G7<TB9F =GH 85GG 8=9 @9HNH9B "5<F9 NK5F 5I7<

8IF7< 89B 6G7<@IGG 9=B9F (FCACH=CB ;9DFR;H K5F9B 569F BC7< J=9@ A9<F 8IF7< 8=9 BHGH9<IB; 97<H9B $969BG 5<9F K=8A9 =7< 8=9G9G I7< IBG9F9F ,C7<H9F%5F@99B,<9F9GIB8IBG9F9A+C<B89F=A?CAA9B89B96 FI5F85G$=7<H89F/9@H9F6@=7?9BK=F8

I;G6IF;5A ,=A+7<989@

(11)
(12)

"!$ &!

-/4-/1

.!!

.(1$*(,*$(12,&

=B:U<FIB;NIA,<9A5

9GH5@HIB;89G9A9=BK9G9BG8IF7<T::9BH@=7<9*989

-BH9FGI7<IB;GN=9@989F+HI8=9IB8F69=HG<MDCH<9G9

I:65I89F+HI8=9

V$@=B3AB/<B7A;CAC<23@<3<3@573US3AB/<2A/C4</6;3

23@=@A16C<5

%=7<59@+7<UF=B;^["5<F989FB;GHZIB8[9?9BB9B

;9;9B89BHCAGH55HZ

,<CA5G#FC@@^[(FCH9GH5BH=GAIGIB8#9FB9B9F;=9Z

(9;;M*9B;9F9F?5^[HCA9GD5@H9BZ

$I=G9+7<F5AA^[J5B;9@=G7<9#=F7<9IB8

BH=#/9K9;IB;Z

FHF5;5IG89FCFG7<IB;G@=H9F5HIF

73;3B6=27A163<'BMBH>437:3@23@)<B3@AC16C<5

(FCH9GH5BH=GAIG5@GU69F;9CF8B9H9CFG7<IB;GD9FGD9?H=J9

9F'D9F5HCFa*9@=;=TG9+DF57<9`

!B8=J=8I5@=G=9FIB;5@GB5@MG9F5GH9F

.(1$*($ ,20)9.%(&)$(1#$0?%/($#*("'$,

1-+0> <

73@4=:5A53A16716B323AV4@732:7163<B=;AU7<

23<A>KB3< 3@/6@3<

=9HCAIHCD=9B89Fa$=B?G=BH9@@9?HI9@@9B`

(13)

93,7?>A0=E04.394>

0!!

F=989B8IF7<8=9CA69^5G=BJ9FH=9FH9&5FF5H=J

89F89B5I9F*9;=9FIB;

IG89A+7<5HH9B89FCA69^=9F?@RFIB;

89FTHH=B;9F7<HN9<B

5N=H=9FAT;@=7<IB;JCB9GH5@HIB;GFRIA9B

8IF7<85Ga:F=98@=7<9HCA`

73@7A7A23AV4@732:7163<B=;AU7<

23<4@M63< 3@/6@3<

29=H;9G7<=7<H@=7<9F#CBH9LH^P@DF9=G?F=G9IB8

[F9BN9B89G/57<GHIAGZ

a/M<@`5@G(5F58=;A5:UF8=9#F=G=G

5N=H5GBHN5I69FH+9=B89Ga:F=98@=7<9BHCAG`

.(1$*/-1$01 ,1(0"'$$! 11$,!$(1/8&$62/

1-+)/ %1%/ &$(,#$,$/ '/$,

$4/@@3@&716B3@C<22733D/<53:7A163<3;37<23<C;+G6:

=9(<5G9JCF89A5I69;=BB =9(@5HN69G9HNIB;IB88=9*C@@989F9J5B;9@=G7<9B(:5FF9F UBH9F*=7<H9FIB8$CH<5F+DRH<^

=9'::9B6IF;9F.9F9=B65FIB;

5G(FC:=@*=7<H9FG=B89F965HH9 /<23A07A16=4/<A+=:45/<5372:/<2 =9[Q69F@9;IB;9BNIA5I89G#9FB?F5:HK9F?G=B/M<@Z =9[985B?9BNIAFBH985B?:9GHZ 9F;9A9=BG5A9F=9:89F=G7<T:9589B/UFHH9A69F;G 5G(FC:=@ 9=8@5B8G=B89F965HH9 7397@16:7163<'B3::C<5</6;3<

=9F;IA9BH5H=CBG<=@:989Fa-AK9@H695I:HF5;H9B`

5G/CFH89F+MBC8989FJ5B;9@=G7<9B

$5B89G?=F7<9=B589B =9F?@RFIB;89G*5H9G89FJ5B;9@=G7<9B

#=F7<9=B9IHG7<@5B8 =9IB?H=CB?=F7<@=7<9F+H9@@IB;B5<A9B=B89F965HH9

(14)

93,7?>A0=E04.394>

0!!!

</:GA3V&3:757LA3'>@/163UHE7A163<<E/:BA16/4B

C<2*3@;7BB:C<5 =9a*9=BH9;F5H=CBGC89F#CBHFC@@8=A9BG=CB`89G

a!B8=J=8I5@=G=9FIB;GH<9CF9AG`

'::9B<9=H5@GJ9FA=HH9@B89#CADCB9BH9

89FaF9@=;=TG9B+DF57<9`

5B8@IB;G@9B?IB;5@G5BK5@HG7<5:H@=7<9#CADCB9BH9

89FaF9@=;=TG9B+DF57<9`

5N=HBK5@HG7<5:H@=7<9.9FA=HH@IB;8IF7<aF9@=;=TG9+DF57<9`

.(1$*$/9%%$,1*("'$$!/ 2"'?/$*(&(90$/./ "'$>

3@7A9CAA7=<A7;>C:AM@53</03@;/AT [@5I69BIB8/=GG9BZ^=9aF=989BGDF9=GF989`

[*9@=;=CB=B89FP::9BH@=7<?9=HZ 5GaDCGHGR?I@5F929=H5@H9F`5@G9;9BGH5B8H<9C@C;=G7<9F#F=H=?

J03@A3BHC<5A9=<H3>B3V@3:757LA3@'>@/163U Q69FG9HNIB;5@G?CCD9F5H=J9I:;5695B89F+7<K9@@9 5G#CBN9DH89Fa2K9=GDF57<=;?9=H`89FP::9BH@=7<9B,<9C@C;=9 5G#CBN9DH89F-B69GH=AAH<9=HaF9@=;=TG9F+DF57<9`

'16:CAA03B@/16BC<5

$=H9F5HIFJ9FN9=7<B=G )<D3@L443<B:716B3%C3::3<

J5B;9@=G7<9G29BHF5@5F7<=J=B9F@=B

$5B89G?=F7<@=7<9GF7<=J89FJ5B;9@=G7<9B#=F7<9=B589B#5F@GFI<9 /9=H9F9IBJ9FT::9BH@=7<H9%5H9F=5@=9B

*3@L443<B:716B3%C3::3<C<2'39C<2K@:7B3@/BC@

+30:7<9A

&5A9BGF9;=GH9F +57<F9;=GH9F

(15)
(16)

#5D=H9@

"#

(,%:'/2,&62+'$+

<A9T;EHA:MH@+;8@4

3AB/:BC<523A3;37<E3A3<A2C@16L443<B:7163&323

#5IA9=B,<9A5<5H8=9T::9BH@=7<9965HH9=B89F@9HNH9B29=HA9<F;9DFR;H 5@G 8=9 F5;9 B57< ?@=A5:F9IB8@=7<9B CFA9B 89F B9F;=9;9K=BBIB; 5B;9 G=7<HG89G#@=A5K5B89@G %=@@=CB9B%9BG7<9BK9@HK9=H:C@;9B5B89B@72/GA 4=@CBC@389A.CF6=@889FG7<K98=G7<9B+7<U@9F=BIB8#@=A55?H=J=GH=BF9H5 ,<IB69F;IB8;9<9BNIA9ACBGHF=9F9B5I:8=9+HF5W9 +C=GH85G,<9A5=B NK=G7<9B=B89F6F9=H9BP::9BH@=7<?9=H89B%98=9BIB889F,5;9GDC@=H=?5B;9

?CAA9B #@=A5D5?9H9KIF89B69G7<@CGG9BDC@=H=G7<9(F=CF=HRH9BB9I;9G9HNH 9FIG65I89F#9FB9B9F;=9=GH=B8=9G9F=G?IGG=CBNIA=B89GH=B9IHG7<@5B8

?9=B,<9A58=96G7<5@HIB;89FB@5;9B6=GJ=9@A9<FK9=H9F<=B;9G9@@

G7<5:H@=7<9F#CBG9BG I7<8=99J5B;9@=G7<9#=F7<969H9=@=;HG=7<5B89B(FC H9GH9B#=F7<9BJ9FHF9H9F89ACBGHF=9F9BA=H5I:89B+HF5W9B@RIH9B:F9=H5;GNI 9;=BB89F9ACBGHF5H=CB9B8=9@C7?9B@5GG9B8=9#=F7<HIFAI<F9B69=89F GMA6C@HFR7<H=;9B -<FN9=H :UB: JCF NKT@: GH9<9B IB8 <5@H9B B857<H9B NIA ,<9A589G#@=A5K5B89@G56

=9 9K9;IB;@72/GA 4=@ CBC@3 8=9BH 5@G 5?HI9@@9G IB8 9=B8FU7?@=7<9G 9=GD=9@:UF8=99GH5@HIB;89G9A9=BK9G9BG8IF7<T::9BH@=7<9*989=B@=69 F5@9BIB889AC?F5H=G7<9B+H55H9B 9BB;FIB8@9;9B89G<5F5?H9F=GH=?IA8=9 G9F+H55H9B=GH89F;FIB8GRHN@=7<9P::9BH@=7<?9=HG7<5F5?H9FJCB(5F@5A9BHGG=H NIB;9BIB89F=7<HGJ9F<5B8@IB;9B969BGCK9F89B8=9+=HNIB;GDFCHC?C@@9IB8 -FH9=@9 J9FT::9BH@=7<H C7< =GH 8=9 9GH5@HIB; 89G 9A9=BK9G9BG 8IF7< T:

:9BH@=7<9*989B=7<HBIF*9DFRG9BH5BH9BIB8*9DFRG9BH5BH=BB9B89G+H55H9G=A

=BGH=HIH=CB9@@9B*5<A9BJCF69<5@H9BGCB89FB?5BBJCB5@@9BUF;9F=BB9BIB8 UF;9FB 8IF7< 85G T::9BH@=7<9 =BHF9H9B :UF C89F ;9;9B 9=B9B 69GH=AAH9B +H5B8DIB?H9FK=F?HK9F89B

5F=B ?CAAH 89F FIB8;985B?9 9=B9F T::9BH@=7<9B IG<5B8@IB; 89G 9 A9=BKC<@G5@GI:;56989G.C@?9GNIAIG8FI7? !ABG7<@IGG5B89B5BH=

?9B(<=@CGCD<9BIB8+H55HGH<9CF9H=?9F=79FC9FK9=GHG=7<8=99GH5@HIB;89F

;9A9=BG5A9B+57<9@3A>C0:71/5@GI:;56989G;5BN9B.C@?9G@3A>=>C:7 5GGG=7<9J5B;9@=G7<9<F=GH=BB9BIB8<F=GH9B5@G,9=@8=9G9F9A9=BG7<5:H 5B89B965HH9BIA8=99GH5@HIB;89G9A9=BK9G9BG69H9=@=;9B=GH:UFG=7<

;9BCAA9B?9=B9FGH5IB@=7<9F9:IB8 @@9F8=B;GK=F8GCKC<@69=89B#@=A5

(17)

,;4?0749704?@92

DFCH9GH9B5@G5I7<69=89B=B8=9G9F-BH9FGI7<IB;69G7<F=969B9B965HH9BIA 8=9HCA?F5:H89IH@=7<85GGG=7<(FCH9GH5BH=BB9BIB8(FCH9GH5BH9B=B69GCB89 F9F/9=G9NI9=B9F9H9=@=;IB;5B89B9H<=G7<9B965HH9BIA85G9A9=BKC<@

;98FRB;HG5<9BIB8G=7<5I:GD9N=:=G7<9FH85F=B9B;5;=9FH9B I:FIB8@5;9 8=9G9F9C657<HIB;=GH8=9BB5<A98=9G9F+HI8=985GG8IF7<8=99GH=AAIB;

8=9G9G'C@>:CA5I:89FACH=J5H=CB5@9B69B9IB885G 9FJCF<969B89F+D9N=:=?

89F 965HH9B69H9=@=;IB; DFCH9GH5BH=G7<9F ?H9IF9 ?CB:9GG=CBGGD9N=:=G7<9 +HFI?HIF9B 9F?5BBH K9F89B ?TBB9B IB8 5I: 8=9G9A /9; 9=B9 #CBHIF=9FIB;

a89G`(FCH9GH5BH=GAIGAT;@=7<K=F8

@G 9=B9 .CF@RI:9F=B 89F <9IH=;9B #@=A5G7<IHN69K9;IB; ?5BB 8=9 B H=5HCA?F5:H69K9;IB; 5B;9G9<9B K9F89B 8=9 =B 89B 9F "5<F9B 9BHGH5B8

!<F9 C7<D<5G9<5HH98=99K9;IB;56A=H89B(FCH9GH9B;9;9B85G;9 D@5BH9B8@5;9F69=CF@969B85BB%=HH989F9F"5<F9A=H(FCH9GH9B;9;9B 8=9/=989F5I:69F9=HIB;G5B@5;969=/57?9FG8CF: &57<89A5HCA5F9B-B;@U7?

JCB ,G7<9FBC6M@ J9F@CF 8=9 HCA?F5:H =<F9B 69F9=HG GH5F? 9FC8=9FH9B

*U7?<5@H=B89F9JT@?9FIB;JC@@GHRB8=; !B89FC@;9JCB,G7<9FBC6M@GH=;

A5H=G=9FH9B5I7<F?@RFIB;9BJ9FG7<=989B9F@5B89G?=F7<@=7<9F+MBC89BGCK=9 89G*5H9G89F#8=9#9FB?F5:H5@GG7<TD:IB;GK=8F=;9,97<BC@C;=9

C7<B=7<H=AA9FK5FG=7<8=989IHG7<9P::9BH@=7<?9=HK5FG=7<5I7<8=9

#=F7<9U69F8=96@9<BIB;89FHCA?F5:H5@G)I9@@989FB9F;=9;9K=BBIB;GC 9=B=; .=9@A9<F=GH89F965HH9BGH5B8<9IH9B8DIB?H9=B9FG9<FK97<G9@F9=

7<9B9B95@C;=98=99;9BGH5B889F<=9FJCFNIB9<A9B89BB5@MG9=GH 5<9F K=F8 89F C?IG 8=9G9F +HI8=9 B=7<H 5I: 8=9<B75HCA?F5:H69K9;IB; 56

;9F=7<H9HGCB89FB5I:8=99F;96B=GC::9B9965HH9IA8=9HCA?F5:H:F5;9=B89F IB89GF9DI6@=?6=G=B8=9%=HH989F9F"5<F9 /9=@8=9HCA?F5:H=B8=9G9F (<5G9BC7<B=7<HA=H89IH@=7<9F6@9<BIB;?CB:FCBH=9FHK5F?5BB9=B6F9=H9F9G

%9=BIB;GGD9?HFIA >9BG9=HG 89F (C@5F=HRH JCB$@= C<2 =<B@/ 3@<3<3@573 B57<;9N9=7<B9HK9F89B

9FA5H9F=9@@99;9BGH5B88=9G9F-BH9FGI7<IB;=GH89ANI:C@;98=9HCA

?F5:H8965HH9=B89FIB89GF9DI6@=?9IHG7<@5B8JCB89BB:RB;9B89FN=J=@9B

&IHNIB;89F,97<B=?%=HH989F9F"5<F96=G=B8=9%=HH989F9F"5<F9 569=K=F889FC?IG5I:85GDFCH9GH5BH=G7<9B;5;9A9BH=B8=9G9F965HH9

;9@9B?H -A85G'C@>:CA89F965HH9B69H9=@=;IB;8=9G9F,9=@;FIDD9=AFCG 5@@9F (5FH=N=D5BH9B <9F5IGNI:=@H9FB K=F8 5@G =GH=B?H=CBGA9F?A5@ 89F DFCH9G H5BH=G7<9B?H9IF9=B8=9G9F965HH98=9.9FK9B8IB;JCBaF9@=;=TG9F+DF57<9`

5B5@MG=9FH =9G9 K=F8 <=BG=7<H@=7< =<F9F 8965HH9B@9=H9B89B IB?H=CB =B 89B

@=7?;9BCAA9BKC69=NIIBH9FGHF9=7<9B=GH85GG9GG=7<969BIA9=B9BT:

:9BH@=7<9B96F5I7<aF9@=;=TG9F+DF57<9`<5B89@H9 9;9BGH5B889FB5@MG9=GH 5@GC?9=BaF9@=;=TG9F`=BB9B8=G?IFGGCB89FB85G/5<FB9<A9B89F;9B9F9@@9B 9GH5@HIB;G5I:;56989G9A9=BK9G9BG:UF8=9G=7<8=9DFCH9GH5BH=G7<9B?

H9IF95@G,9=@89F;9G9@@G7<5:H@=7<9BP::9BH@=7<?9=H5I:GD9N=:=G7<9/9=G99B;5

;=9FH9B

(18)

491K3=@92E@8'308,

=9F;96B=GG98=98IF7<8=99G7<F9=6IB;IB8B5@MG989G<=GHCF=G7<9B 5@@69=GD=9@G;9KCBB9BKIF89BK9F89B85BB=B9=B95?HI9@@9CFG7<IB;G:F5;9 U69F:U<FH !BK=9K9=H DFR;H 89F T::9BH@=7<9 96F5I7< F9@=;=TG9F +DF57<9 89B (FCH9GH5BH=GAIG<9IH9IB8K9@7<9%T;@=7<?9=H9B9FT::B9BG=7<=<A858IF7<

)<B3@AC16C<5AH73:323@'BC273C<2@037BA6G>=B63A3

=9G9 +HI8=9 J9F:C@;H 8F9= -BH9FGI7<IB;GN=9@9 2IBR7<GH N9=7<B9H G=9 9=B9B N9=H;9G7<=7<H@=7<=B:CFA=9FH9BQ69F6@=7?U69F8=99G7<=7<H989F#9FBH97<B=?

=B89FIB89GF9DI6@=?IB88=985A=HJ9F6IB89B9B965HH9B BG7<@=9W9B8IB H9FGHF9=7<H G=9 U69F 8=9 B5@MG9 89F 9=HFR;9 DFCH9GH5BH=G7<9F ?H9IF9 =B 89F HCA?F5:H8965HH989F9BGD9N=:=G7<9F;IA9BH5H=CBGGHF5H9;=9B +7<@=9W@=7<8=G

?IH=9FHG=985G(CH9BH=5@IB88=9F9BN9B9=B9FF9@=;=TG9BF;IA9BH5H=CBG:U<

FIB;=B89BDC@=H=G7<9B965HH9B89GGR?I@5F9B+H55H9G FIB8@5;98=9G9F56 G7<@=9W9B89B=G?IGG=CBG=B88=9F;96B=GG989F9FGH9B69=89B-BH9FGI7<IB;G N=9@9 a=G?IGG=CBGD5FHB9F`G=B85?HI9@@9BGRHN98=9G=7<A=H89A#CAD@9L a=9*C@@9JCB*9@=;=CB=B89FP::9BH@=7<?9=H`5IG9=B5B89FG9HN9B

@GU69F;9CF8B9H9GB5@MG9F5GH9F:IB;=9FH85Ga!B8=J=8I5@=G=9FIB;GH<9CF9A`

-@F=7< 97?G G 8=9BH NIBR7<GH 9=B9F ;FC69B +MGH9A5H=G=9FIB; 89G <=GHCF=

G7<9B%5H9F=5@GK=F8569F69NU;@=7<G9=B9F$9=GHIB;G:R<=;?9=H?F=H=G7<<=BH9F :F5;H @G%9H5D9FGD9?H=J9=GH9=B89N=8=9FHH<9C@C;=G7<9GCFG7<IB;G=BH9F9GG9 NI B9BB9B IF7< 8=9 I:5F69=HIB; 89F DFCH9GH5BH=G7<9B 9H9=@=;IB; 5B 89F HCA?F5:H8965HH9 GC@@ 9=B9 5B5@MH=G7<89G?F=DH=J :IB8=9FH9B63=:=57A163 3 AB7;;C<5 23A $@=B3AB/<B7A;CAJCF;9BCAA9B K9F89B $9=H9B8 =GH 8569= 8=9 FIB85BB5<A985GGG=7<89F(FCH9GH5BH=GAIGU69F8=9<9H9FC;9B99G5AH<9=H G9=B9F?H9IF969GH=AA9B@RGGH

!B89FIB?H=CB5@G5B5@MH=G7<9G!BGHFIA9BHG7<RF:H8=9,<9CF=997?G89B C?IG89F+HI8=9 5GDFCH9GH5BH=GAIGH<9CF9H=G7<9!BH9F9GG9GH9<H5@GU69F;9 CF8B9H9 CFG7<IB;G:F5;9 =A =BH9F;FIB8 9=89 (9FGD9?H=J9B 69;@9=H9B 8=9 8F9= -BH9FGI7<IB;GN=9@9 GH9HG K9F89B 569F =B 89F BIB :C@;9B89B H<9H=G7<9B 5FGH9@@IB;89FG9@69BB=7<H9LD@=N=H;9B5BBH

,C@67AB=@7A163<'97HH35G"5<F=B89A89FIB89GF9DI6@=?8=9BI?

@95F9CFG7<IB;8IF7<8=9a(5F=G9F.9FHFR;9`K=989F;9GH5HH9HKIF896=@89H89B 9;=BB 89G -BH9FGI7<IB;GN9=HF5IAG 8=9G9F 9B89H A=H 89F 9G7<F9=6IB; 89G

#CB:@=?H:5@@GIA85G;9D@5BH9#9FB?F5:HK9F?=B/M<@%=HH989F9F"5<F9

=B <=GHCF=G7<9F Q69F6@=7? U69F NK9= 9?589B =GH =A *5<A9B 9=B9F H<9C@C

;=G7<9H<=G7<9B=GG9FH5H=CBBIF?IFGCF=G7<9BH@5B;7<5F5?H9F=GH=G7<9F5@@69=

GD=9@9NI@9=GH9B =9/5<@89F=AQ69F6@=7?F9:9F=9FH9B+7<K9FDIB?H9GC@@H9 85<9F8=9G</;7923@30/BB3IA8=9#9FBH97<B=?=B8=9G9B69=89B"5<FN9<B H9BK=989F;969B8569==GH>98C7<MB5A=?=A+=BB9JCB'B7;;C<5AE/<23:NI J9FGH9<9B 9BB/>@7;/D7AB/GH9<H=AFCWH9=@89FDI6@=N=GH=G7<9BI:5F69=

HIB;9BNIA,<9A5BIF8=9BHK=7?@IB;89F<B7/B=;9@/4B03E35C<5=AC?IG 9= 89B 5FGH9@@IB;9B 89F BH=5HCA?F5:H69K9;IB; 6@9=6H >98C7< 8=9 F5;9

(19)

,;4?0749704?@92

IBH9F69@9I7<H9HK9@7<9J5@=89BF;IA9BH98=99:UFKCFH9F89F#9FBH97<B=?

=B8=9965HH99=B6F=B;9B?CBBH9B I:;FIB88=9G9F-BH9F69@9I7<HIB;89F(FC +9=H9=GH9GN=9@:U<F9B8=B89F<=GHCF=G7<9B+?=NN9;9F5898=9>9B=;9B(<5G9B 89FHCA?F5:H;9G7<=7<H9<9FJCFNI<969B=B89B9BG=7<9=B9DCG=H=J9=BGH9@

@IB;JCB!B8=J=8I9BIB8FIDD9B;9;9BU69F8=9G9F,97<B=?6=@89H9 9F29=H F5IA89F+?=NN9KIF89A=H89A2=9@;9KR<@H89B$@=H3AA23A'B7;;C<5AC;

A16EC<5AJCB9=B9FU69FK=9;9B89B9:UFKCFHIB;NI9=B9FU69FK=9;9B89B6

@9<BIB;89FHCA?F5:H56NI6=@89B =9<=GHCF=G7<9+?=NN9GC@@;9B5I5B89A

>9B=;9B^5I:;FIB889FMB5A=?B5HUF@=7<BIF<MDCH<9H=G7<NI69GH=AA9B89B

^(IB?H9B89B5B89AG=7<8=9@5C;3<B323@$@=C<223@=<B@/'37B3273 +//536/:B3< =9G9F(IB?HJ9FGDF=7<H:UF9=B9B5@MG989F965HH9B69H9=@=

;IB;DFCH9GH5BH=G7<9F?H9IF989B;FTWH9BF?9BBHB=G;9K=BB I:89B9FGH9B

@=7? =GH 8=9G9 5IG;9;@=7<9B9 $5;9 NK=G7<9B 89F P@DF9=G?F=G9 IB8 89F FCW89ACBGHF5H=CB=BCF@969BNIJ9FCFH9B

<88EFG8E58<GFG;8F8?4HG8G74;8E

<A8A4?LF8IBA854GG8A58<GER:8A<FG<@$B@8AG78EHF:8:?<6;8A;8<G78EE:H@8AG8 4@8E>8AAGA<FE8<6;FG8A <8F8E$B@8AGJ<E79TE7<85HA78FE8CH5?<>4A<F6;8GB@>E49G78 54GG8<A78E$<GG878E8E!4;E858FG<@@G

,C@>@=B3AB/<B7A163<30/BB3<03B37:75C<52IBR7<GH=GH:9GHNI<5@H9B85GG8=9 9H9=@=;IB;89F9J5B;9@=G7<9B#=F7<95B89FHCA?F5:H8965HH98IF7<8=99 G7<F9=6IB;IB8B5@MG989F965HH9B69=HFR;99=BN9@B9F=B8=J=8I9@@9F?H9IF9 69N=9<IB;GK9=G9 F9A=9B IB8 !BGH=HIH=CB9B U69F=B8=J=8I9@@9 ?H9IF9 89G 6IB89G89IHG7<9B(FCH9GH5BH=GAIG56;96=@89HK9F89BGC@@ (FCH9GH5BH=G7<9?

H9IF9K5F9B9=B,9=@89F<9H9FC;9B9BFIDD989FBH=5HCA?F5:H69K9;IB; -B H9F89A.CF69<5@H89F9K5@H:F9=<9=H69H9=@=;H9BG=9G=7<5BB5<9NI5@@9B?H=

CBG:CFA9B 89F 9K9;IB; K=9 69=GD=9@GK9=G9 !B:CFA5H=CBGJ9F5BGH5@HIB;9B

>IF=GH=G7<9B IG9=B5B89FG9HNIB;9B 9ACBGHF5H=CB9B IB8 5ID@5HN69G9HNIB

;9B I:89F5B89F9B+9=H9<5HH98=9#9FBH97<B=?5I7<9:UFKCFH9F8=9=B89F 9J5B;9@=G7<9B #=F7<9 9B;5;=9FH K5F9B IB8 =<F9 F;IA9BH9 5I: DFCH9GH5BH=

G7<9BCF9B9=B6F57<H9B 5<9F69GH9<H8=9 9F5IG:CF89FIB;85F=B=GH=B?H=

CBGA9F?A5@989F9H9=@=;IB;<9F5IGNI:=@H9FB8=95IGG5;9?FR:H=;;9BI;G=B8 IA9=B9B9=HF5;5@G89N=8=9FH>@=B3AB/<B7A163A<5/53;3<B=B89FHCA?F5:H 8965HH9NIA5F?=9F9B @G9=BGC@7<9G=GH=B?H=CBGA9F?A5@?5BB8=9.9FK9B 8IB;9=B9FA>3H747A163<'>@/16369GH=AAHK9F89B 5JCB5IG;9<9B8K=F85@G 'D9F5HCFNIF 9IF=GH=?89G<=GHCF=G7<9B%5H9F=5@G8=9aF9@=;=TG9+DF57<9`:9GH

;9G9HNH /=9 969B 69= 89B Q69F@9;IB;9BHC@ 67AB=@7A163< '97HH3 5B;9:U<FH KIF89 K9F89B 8=9 965HH9B NI 89A>9B=;9B 29=HDIB?H 89F HCA?F5:H8965HH9 5B5@MG=9FH5BK9@7<9A8=9BH=DC89BG=7<=B9=B9F+=HI5H=CB89FF9@5H=J9BIG

;9KC;9B<9=H89FF;IA9BH9K=989F:=B89B =9G9IG;9KC;9B<9=H?5BBG=7<

5I7<=B9=B9F+H5;B5H=CB89F965HH9K=89FGD=9;9@B !B8=9G9F+=HI5H=CB=GH9=B

!BH9F9GG9BG5IG;@9=7< BC7< AT;@=7< IB8 A5B7<A5@ 9=B9 .9FA=HH@IB;G=BGH5BN BTH=;

(20)

491K3=@92E@8'308,

<8MJ8<G8E58<GFG;8F8?4HG8G74;8E

8E_E8?<:<SF8A*CE46;8^<FG74FERA:8A4H9-8EFS;AHA:<A;RE8AG 4;8E8<:A8GF<8F<6;

4?F&C8E4GBE9TE7<8A4?LF878E8<GER:8IBA<A7<I<7H8??8AHA7T58E<A7<I<7H8??8A>G8HE8A 78F5HA78FE8CH5?<>4A<F6;8A'EBG8FG4AG<F@HF<A78EGB@>E49G7854GG878E8E!4;E8

,C;=;>:3F&3:757=<7<23@I443<B:716937B9F,<9A9B?CAD@9L&3:757=<7<

23@I443<B:716937BKIF898IF7<8=9F=989BGDF9=GF98989G(<=@CGCD<9B"UF;9B 569FA5GIB88IF7<89GG9BK9=H9F9Q69F@9;IB;9BNIA,<9A5B9I=B8=9

;9G9@@G7<5:H@=7<9965HH99=B;96F57<H '::9BG=7<H@=7<9F.9F6=B8IB;GDIB?HNIF JCF@=9;9B89B +HI8=9 =GH 569FA5G_ L=CA 9=B9FJ03@A3BHC<5A<=BE3<275937B JCBaF9@=;=TG9F+DF57<9`=B89BDC@=H=G7<9B965HH9B89FP::9BH@=7<?9=H =9G9F

=G?IGG=CBG=ADI@GK=F85I:;9BCAA9BIB8NI89B6=G85HC9FN=9@H9BF;96B=G G9B=B9NI;;9G9HNH Q69F8=9=G?IGG=CB89F,<9G9B 569FA5G_569F5I7<

U69F 8=9 IG9=B5B89FG9HNIB; A=H K9=H9F9B (FC;F5AA9B 89F 5?589A=G7<9B ,<9C@C;=9NIA,<9A5aP::9BH@=7<?9=H`K9F89B%T;@=7<?9=H9BIB8F9BN9B89F aF9@=;=TG9B +DF57<9` =B 89F P::9BH@=7<?9=H 8=G?IH=9FH 58IF7< K=F8 89F FU 7?9BG7<@5;89F<=GHCF=G7<9BI:5F69=HIB;NI9=B9F5?HI9@@9BCFG7<IB;G:F5;9 JC@@NC;9B

<87E<GG8E58<GFG;8F8?4HG8G74;8E

<87HE6;458E@4F<A<G<<8EG8<F>HFF<BAH@)8?<:<BA<A78EO998AG?<6;>8<G7<8<AG;8B

?B:<F6;8A'EB:E4@@8AJ8<G8E:89T;EGHA74HF:84E58<G8GJHE785<8G8G8<A8:HG84F<FH@

7<8E:85A<FF878E*GH7<8<A7<84>GH8??8G;8B?B:<F6;C;<?BFBC;<F6;846;7854GG88<AMH5<A 78A

5G2IG5AA9BB9<A9B89F8F9=F69=HGH<9G9B=B.9F6=B8IB;A=H89AU69F;9 CF8B9H9BDFCH9GH5BH=GAIGH<9CF9H=G7<9B!BH9F9GG989F+HI8=9F9GI@H=9FH=B:C@;9B 89F9F?9BBHB=G@9=H9B89F MDCH<9G9

HE6;7<8A4?LF878E854GG8A58G8<?<:HA:CEBG8FG4AG<F6;8E>G8HE84A78AHF8<A4A78E F8GMHA:8A H@ 7<8 GB@>E49G $<GG8 78E 8E !4;E8 FB?? 7<8 :8A8E8??8 #8<FGHA:F9R;<:>8<G _E8?<:<SF8E*CE46;8^<AS998AG?<6;8A854GG8AT58ECET9GJ8E78A A78@_E8?<:<SF8*CE46;8^

4?F FC8M<9<F6;8 E:H@8AG4G<BAFFGE4G8:<8 78F 'EBG8FG4AG<F@HF ;8EIBE:8;B58A J<E7 >SAA8A HAG8E8MH:A4;@84H97<8E:85A<FF878E;<FGBE<F6;8AA4?LF8HA778E<F>HFF<BA4>GH8??8E AFRGM87<8$S:?<6;>8<G8A78E-8EJ8A7HA:IBA_E8?<:<SF8E*CE46;8^<A78EO998AG?<6;>8<G 4HF:8?BG8GJ8E78AHA7<A8<A8E8<:8A8A"BAM8CG<BAMH@HF7EH6>:85E46;GJ8E78A

C40/C23@'BC273

9F I:65I 89F +HI8=9 9FG7<@=9WH G=7< 8IF7< 8=9 G?=NN=9FH9B -BH9FGI7<IB;G N=9@9K=F8569FBIB7<<C139LD@=N=9FH

5G 9FGH9 5IDH?5D=H9@7<:37BC<5 8=9BH =B G9=B9A K9=H9F9B CFH;5B; 89F H<9CF9H=G7<9BIB8=9FIB;89F-BH9FGI7<IB; 2IBR7<GH6=9H9H8=99GH5B8G5I:

B5<A989F69GH9<9B89BCFG7<IB;NIA,<9A59=B9BCF=9BH=9F9B89BQ69F6@=7?

IB8G7<RF:H8=99=;9B9F5;9GH9@@IB;#5D BG7<@=9W9B8K9F89B8=98F9=

A9H<C8=G7<9B+HUHND:9=@9F89F-BH9FGI7<IB;JCF;9GH9@@H#5D

(21)

,;4?0749704?@92

5GNK9=H9 5IDH?5D=H9@73/<CA9L>475937B23AV4@732:7163<B=;AUS GH9@@H8=9A6=J5@9BN89FHCAH97<B=?85F +HFI?HIF=9FHK=F885G 5IDH

?5D=H9@8IF7<:UB:D=GC89B=B89B9B8=9@4=:5A53A16716B3#5D IB88=9

@7A7A#5D 89F5A6=J5@9BH9B,97<B=?89Ga:F=98@=7<9BHCAG`B57<;9 N9=7<B9H K9F89B !B 89B >9K9=@G @9HNH9B -BH9F?5D=H9@B K=F8 NIF (9FGD9?H=J G7<RF:IB;9=B92ICF8BIB;JCB@4=:5IB8@7A7A=A,<9CF=9F5GH9F89F!B8=J=

8I5@=G=9FIB;GH<9CF=997?GJCF;9BCAA9B#5D IB8#5D 5G 8F=HH9 5IDH?5D=H9@$@=B3AB/<B7A163 30/BB3<037B@K53 HC@ B=;9@/4B 4@/537<23< 3@/6@3<@9B?H89BC?IG5I:9=BN9@B9?H9IFG;FIDD9B89G (FCH9GH5BH=GAIG 8=9 8IF7< =<F9 IBH9FG7<=98@=7<9B 5@HIB;9B NIF HCA?F5:H IB88=9IBH9FG7<=98@=7<9B(CG=H=CB9B=A'F;5B=;F5AA89G(FCH9GH5BH=GAIG8=9

=J9FG=HRH 89GG9@69B 566=@89B =9 5IG 8=9G9A !BH9F9GG9 ;9KR<@H9B ?H9IFG

;FIDD9BG=B8=98IF7<89B;9D@5BH9B5I89G#9FB?F5:HK9F?9Ga/M<@`IB A=HH9@65F69HFC::9B9B9A9=B89B89G#5=G9FGHI<@GA=HC?IG5I:=<F9B/CFH :U<F9F=B89F+57<9(:5FF9FUBH9F*=7<H9F#5D IB889FNIGHRB8=;9$5B 89G6=G7<C: =B 89F a/M<@#CBHFCJ9FG9` =G7<C: 5BG/C@:;5B; 9=8@5B8

#5D 5G 8F=HH9 ,9=@?5D=H9@ 6F=B;H 8=9 F;IA9BH5H=CB 89F ?=F7<@=7<9B a-AK9@H695I:HF5;H9B`GCK=9+H9@@IB;B5<A9B?=F7<@=7<9FF9A=9BNIF5FGH9@

@IB;#5D 9A@9HNH9B,9=@?5D=H9@89G8F=HH9B 5IDH?5D=H9@G?CAAH9=B9 +7<5FB=9F:IB?H=CB NI G ?CBHIF=9FH 8=9 69G7<F=969B9B 965HH9B69=HFR;9 89F DFCH9GH5BH=G7<9B?H9IF9=B89AIB?H=CBIB8+HF5H9;=9JCBaF9@=;=TG9F+DF5 7<9`=B89B9=HFR;9B8IF7<J9FG7<=989B9,<9CF=9AC89@@95B5@MG=9FHK9F89B

#5D

5GJ=9FH9 5IDH?5D=H9@3@L443<B:716330@/C16V@3:757LA3@'>@/163UJ9F 6=B89H85G6=G<9FF5F69=H9H9A=H9=B9F5?HI9@@9BCFG7<IB;G:F5;9 I:FIB8

@5;989FF;96B=GG9JCB9G7<F9=6IB;IB8B5@MG989G<=GHCF=G7<9B5@@69=

GD=9@GK=F88=G?IH=9FHK9@7<9%T;@=7<?9=H9B89FT::9BH@=7<996F5I7<aF9@=;=

TG9F+DF57<9`:UF89B(FCH9GH5BH=GAIG<9IH96=9H9H =95FGH9@@IB;89FQ69F

@9;IB;9B89G(<=@CGCD<9B"UF;9B 569FA5G8=9BH8569=85NI5I:8=95?HI9@@9

=G?IGG=CB<=BNI@9=H9B#5D 29BHF5@9F(IB?H=A =B6@=7?5I:8=9F5;9 GH9@@IB;89F+HI8=9=GH8=9CF89FIB; 569FA5G_B57<9=B9FNK=B;9B89BQ69F G9HNIB;F9@=;=TG9F9<5@H9=BDC@=H=G7<9B965HH9B 5<9F8=G?IH=9FH85GNK9=H9 ,9=@?5D=H9@J9FG7<=989B9#CBN9DH=CB9BNIFQ69FG9HNIB;aF9@=;=TG9F+DF57<9`

#5D 6G7<@=9W9B8 6UB89@H 8=9 +7<@IGG69HF57<HIB; 8=9 F;96B=GG9 89F -BH9FGI7<IB;IB8GH9@@H9=B99=;9B9#CBN9DH=CB:UF89BT::9BH@=7<9B96F5I7<

aF9@=;=TG9F+DF57<9`NIF=G?IGG=CB#5D

(22)

0>?,9/>,@19,380/0=:=>.3@92

?/-1$01 ,1(0+202,#$/,$,$/&($><

$01 ,#0 2%, '+$#$/-/0"'2,&

8FG4A7F4H9A4;@878EBEF6;HA:

/=9GC969B85F;9@9;HKIF89GH9<H8=9+HI8=9JCF89FI:;569NI69GH=AA9B

=BK=9K9=HaF9@=;=TG9+DF57<9`5@GGD9N=:=G7<9F;IA9BH5H=CBGGHF5H9;=989G(FC H9GH5BH=GAIG =B DC@=H=G7<9B 965HH9B DFR;9B8 K5F @G ;99=;B9H9G -BH9FGI 7<IB;G:9@8NIFIF7<8F=B;IB;8=9G9FI:;569BGH9@@IB;KIF898=99H9=@=;IB;

DFCH9GH5BH=G7<9F?H9IF9=B89FHCA?F5:H8965HH989FIB89GF9DI6@=?:9GH;9 G9HNH @@9F8=B;G=GH9G8=9;FIB8@9;9B8998=B;IB;:UF9=B9GC@7<9B5@MG9 89F F5;9 B57<NI;9<9B C6 89F (FCH9GH5BH=GAIG =B 9=B9F 965HH9 8=9 K9=H9 ,9=@989F9G9@@G7<5:HIA:5GGH9B/BAK16:716DFR;9B8K5F

=9G9FIB8@5;9B5F69=HKIF898IF7<9=B9*9=<9JCB5?HI9@@9B.9FT::9BH@=

7<IB;9B;9@9=GH9H I:;5698=9G9G,9=@?5D=H9@G=GHGCA=H9=B9BQ69F6@=7?U69F 8=9 69GH9<9B89 K=GG9BG7<5:H@=7<9 95F69=HIB; 89G ,<9A5G a(FCH9GH5BH=GAIG IB8#9FB9B9F;=9`NIJ9FG7<5::9B !B89F+IAA=9FIB;89GCFG7<IB;GGH5B89G K=F88=9K=GG9BG7<5:H@=7<9FIB8@5;9A5F?=9FH5I:K9@7<9F89F<=GHCF=G7<89 G?F=DH=J9,9=@89F9=;9B9B+HI8=95I:65IH 2I89A?5BB=AI:N9=;9B6=G<9F IBH9F69@9I7<H9H9F GD9?H9 =BB9F<5@6 89G +D9?HFIAG a(FCH9GH5BH=GAIG IB8

#9FB9B9F;=9`8=99=;9B9CFG7<IB;G:F5;9;9G7<RF:HK9F89B

=9FIB8@5;989FB9I9F9B$=H9F5HIFNIA,<9A5K=9G=95BG7<@=9W9B8JCF

;9GH9@@HK=F8=GH89F=AA9BG99GH5B85B(I6@=?5H=CB9B8=969;@9=H9B8NI89B

<=GHCF=G7<9B(FCH9GH9B=B89B9FIB89F"5<F9BJ9FT::9BH@=7<HKIF89B AB:5B;GH5B89B;CC?IA9BH989F(FCH9GHH9=@B9<A9FG9@6GH=BK9@7<9B 8=99=;9B9B?H=CB9B69G7<F=969BKIF89B =BNI?5A9BF;IA9BH5H=CBG<=@

:9B=B89B9B85GH97<B=G7<9<=E6=E89F9K9;IB;8IF7<8=9.9FA=HH@IB;

JCBLD9FH9BK=GG9B;9GHRF?HKIF89

=99FGH9B5?589A=G7<9B6<5B8@IB;9BNIA,<9A5JCB6@9=69B89A/9FH K5F9B9=BIGNI;89F=GG9FH5H=CB89G+CN=C@C;9B=9H9F*I7<H89FIBH9F 89A,=H9@*=<+G6:</16=@:303<DI6@=N=9FHKIF89 2I89A=GH8=9 56=@=H5

-:? 5FCJ %.$ : .L;? "8<A"8EA>E49GJ8E><A .L;?HA74H6;FBAFGA<E:8A7F 8GEB998A8TE:8E58E<6;G8AE8<5HE:< E

-:? 5FCJ * : <8894;E8A78E

'?HGBA<H@J<EGF6;49G 8EZ*6;A8??8ETG8EY<8AR6;FG8HF8<A4A78EF8GMHA:<A78EA8E :<87<F>HFF<BA <A$8@BE4A7H@ <A?G8EA4G<I58E<6;G78FO>B AFG<GHGFE8<5HE:<F6;8E 4?G8EA4G<I$4:4M<AE8AACHA>G8E4A>9HEG4 $ $+ '$"$A8E:<8CB?<G<>B;A84F<F -B@5TE :8E?<6;8A,A:8;BEF4@MHE8A8E:<8CB?<G<F6;8A.8A78<F6;8E+4F6;8A5T6;8E<F6;8E 4?G8EA4G<IE4A>9HEG4 $ <8'8G<G<BA E4:8A4A8<A'4E?4@8AGMHE

<A7HFGE<8??8A AJ8A7HA: 78E GB@8A8E:<8 \ FC8>G8 MH .L;? "4E?FEH;8 &

"1: "8EA8A8E:<8$8AF6;,@J8?G"S?A

)-BA.L;?A46;BE?858A TE:8E:8:8AGB@CEB:E4@@HA7AH>?84E8 AGFBE:HA:$TA6;8A <8G8E)H6;GI8E94FFG84H6;78AEG<>8?MHEAG<4GB@>E49G58 J8:HA:<A8<A8@IBA<;@HA7)B?4A7)BG;;8E4HF:858A4A75H6;I:? AG<GB@

(23)

,;4?0749704?@92

H=CBGG7<F=:H89G-AK9@HIB8,97<B=?<=GHCF=?9FG"C57<=A*58?5IC4AB735C<2

@7A323@23CBA163<B=;E7@BA16/4BNIB9BB9B *I7<HIB8*58?5I@5G G9B NK5F +MAD5H<=9 :UF 8=9 BH=5HCA?F5:H69K9;IB; 9F?9BB9B 5F69=H9B 8=9 ,<9A5H=? =A 9;9BG5HN NIF $=H9F5HIF 89F ?H=J=GH=BB9B IB8 ?H=J=GH9B A=H 9=B9FK=GG9BG7<5:H@=7<9B%9H<C8=?5I:

,FCHN 89F ,9B89BN NIF ?F=H=G7<9B 9K9FHIB; 89F HCA?F5:H 8=9 H9=@K9=G9 C::9B IB8 H9=@K9=G9 =B8=F9?H ;9RIW9FH K=F8 GH9@@9B 8=9G9 /9F?9 9=B9 IA:5G G9B89+5AA@IB;JCB<=GHCF=G7<9B5H9BIB8$=H9F5HIFNIA,<9A585F 5<9F 6=9H9BG=99=B9K9FHJC@@9FIB8@5;9:UF5?HI9@@9+HI8=9B

69B:5@@G=AC?IGJCB+HI8=9BGH9<H8=9-BH9FGI7<IB;89G(FCH9GH5BH=GAIG

=BG9=B9F9H9=@=;IB;5B89B;9G9@@G7<5:H@=7<9B965HH9B89FIB89GF9DI6@=?

@G 5?HI9@@9F9 %CBC;F5D<=9B <=9FNI G=B8 GCKC<@ 89F Q69F6@=7? %5FH=B F9G7<5HG3@$@=B3AB/<B7A;CA7<23@C<23A@3>C0:793CBA16:/<2S NIB9BB9B5@G5I7<8=9+HI8=93@D3@:=@3<37;;3::/C037<3CBA16:/<2 A37BJCB,<CA5GFCW6T@H=B; =9DFCH9GH5BH=G7<99H9=@=;IB;7<>=:7B7 17A=A-BH9FGI7<IB;GN9=HF5IAK=F8JCBNK9=+5AA9@6RB89B5B<5B85IGG5;9

?FR:H=;9F 5@@GHI8=9B 69@9I7<H9H 2IA 9=B9B JCB 89A 5B8);0@M163 3@

23CBA163 $@=B3AB/<B7A;CA C<2 273 A=H7/:3< 3E35C<53< 7< 23< 3@ C<2 3@ /6@3<NIA 5B89F9B 8IF7< 8=9 I:G5HNG5AA@IB;73 $=:7B7A73@C<5 23A$@=B3AB/<B7A;CA<BE719:C<53<7<23@C<23A@3>C0:793CBA16:/<27<23<

3@C<2 3@/6@3< 9BK=7<H=;GH9B9NI;GDIB?H=A*5<A9B8=9G9F -BH9FGI7<IB;GH9@@9B8=9.9FT::9BH@=7<IB;9B89FCFG7<9F;FIDD93@$@=B3A

>E49G58J8:HA:<A)B?4A7)BG;8EF : <8FBM<4?8A8J8:HA:8A<A8HGF6;?4A7F8<G <A4A75H6;E4A>9HEG4 $ * \

)!H9FG<8:HA7"E<F878E78HGF6;8AGB@J<EGF6;49G\ -8E 7ERA:G8?G8EA4G<I8A<A78E"8EAG86;A<>HA778E,EFCEHA:78EAH>?84E8A"BAGEBI8EF8)8<A 58>58<4@5HE: )47>4HI8ES998AG?<6;G8:8@8<AF4@@<G78@';LF<>8E#BG;4E 4;A8<A8:8>TEMG8HA7<@8FF4L<FG<F6;8A*G<?I8E94FFG8-8EF<BAF8<A8F&CHF]

#H9FG<8:HA74??78E78HGF6;8AGB@J<EGF6;49G$TA6;8A

$ 8E 'EBG8FG4AG<F@HF <A 78E HA78FE8CH5?<> 8HGF6;?4A7 \

#8<CM<:I:? 4H6; 'EBG8FG4AG<F@HFHA7I4A:8?<F6;8"<E6;8<A78A8E

!4;E8A<AK8?*6;<?7G8G?89*<8:9E<87"4E?;E<FG<4A#4@@8EFLA4@<F6;818<G8A <8 8E !4;E8 <A 78A 58<78A 78HGF6;8A 8F8??F6;49G8A 4@5HE:8E 8<GER:8 MHE *BM<4? HA7 18<G:8F6;<6;G84EFG8??HA:8A4@5HE:* \

+8EI8E?BE8A8<@@8? ?4H58<A8HGF6;?4A7F8<GSG G<A:8A

* #&: ,@5ET6;8 8E78HGF6;8

'EBG8FG4AG<F@HFHA77<8FBM<4?8A8J8:HA:8A<A78A8EHA78E!4;E8AE58<G8AMHE

><E6;?<6;8A18<G:8F6;<6;G8)8<;84EFG8??HA:8ASGG<A:8A

"H 4 : <8'B?<G<F<8EHA:78F'EBG8FG4AG<F@HF AGJ<6>?HA:8A<A 78EHA78FE8CH5?<>8HGF6;?4A7<A78A8EHA78E!4;E8A

(24)

0>?,9/>,@19,380/0=:=>.3@92

B/<B7A;CA7<23<3B67A163<30/BB3<23@C<23A@3>C0:793CBA16:/<2S 85F=B89F9B#CBH9LH8=9G9+HI8=99BHGH5B8

&57<8=9G9A?B5DD9BQ69F6@=7?U69F8=95@@;9A9=B9$=H9F5HIFK9F89B=A C@;9B89B8=9>9B=;9B(I6@=?5H=CB9BF9:9F=9FH8=989B9B;9F;9:5GGH9B,<9A9B

?CAD@9La(FCH9GH5BH=GAIGIB8#9FB9B9F;=9`J9F<5B89@B

!716/3:'16M@7<5SQ/6@323@<5ABPC<2Q393<<3<5353<

23<B=;AB//BP

!AI:G5HN/6@323@<5AB695BGDFI7<H89F29=H;9G7<=7<H@9F%=7<59@

+7<UF=B; 8=9 <=GHCF=G7<9 I:5F69=HIB; 89G 9@8GD/<53:7A163 7@163 C<2 B=;3<3@573NI =B=H==9F9B =9 $9=H@=B=9 89G I:G5HN9G =GH 85GG 8=9 9F

"5<F989B

8:<AA8<A8F<AA8E><E6;?<6;8A#8EACEBM8FF8F58M8<6;A8A4A78FF8AIBE?RH9<:8@A7CHA>G

;8HG8MH@<A78FG"BAF8AF74ET58E;8EEF6;G74FF8F8<AHA:8?SFG8FA8E:<8CEB5?8@:<5G2[3 HA774FFF<6;7<8"<E6;8<A<;E8E:8F8??F6;49G?<6;8AHA>G<BA@<G78@+;8@44HF8<A4A78E F8GM8A@HFFHA7<;E8A$<G:?<878EA<?7HA:F4A:85BG8&E<8AG<8EHA:HA74?GF6;H?7<:<FG

B<5B88F9=9F=G?IFG969B9B?5BB8=9G9BHK=7?@IB;B57<;9N9=7<B9HK9F89B

=99FGH9=GH8=9[/9@H5B;GHZ 5A=H69N9=7<B9H+7<UF=B;8=9B;GHJCF89F 29FGHTFIB; 89F /9@H 8=9 BIB H97<B=G7< AT;@=7< =GH 569= K=F8 8=9 8=9G9F B;GH=B<RF9BH9+D5BBIB;89IH@=7<5GG8=9C6>9?H=JA9GG65F9+H9=;9FIB;89G /C<@GH5B89GA=H89F/5<FB9<AIB;9=B9G9F<T<H9B*=G=?CGJ9F6IB89B=GH

=9NK9=H969B9F=7<H9H89BC?IG5I:8=9#CCD9F5H=CB89F9J5B;9@=G7<9B

#=F7<9A=H89B&9I9B+CN=5@9B9K9;IB;9B&+ =9G9JC@@NC;G=7<JCF 5@@9AU69F85G9F9=HGH9@@9BJCB=G?IGG=CBG&KC;3<

*<8;8,; $=:?0>?,9?4>8@>,7>K-0=20:=/90?0:=>.3@92>;0=>;06?4A0 A7<8F8@

"4C<G8?J<E74H97<858FG8;8A78A-8ES998AG?<6;HA:8A78EBEF6;8E:EHCC88<A:8:4A:8A

* $!4;E878EA:FG <88I4A:8?<F6;8A"<E6;8A<A78EHA78FE8 CH5?<>HA778E"BA9?<>GH@7<8GB@8A8E:<8\<A$<GG8<?HA:8AMHE"<E6;?<6;8A 18<G:8F6;<6;G8 * \ I:? 9TE 78A AFCEH6; 78E 8EFG@4?<:8A "4EG<8EHA:

*

* !4;E878EA:FG* 9

* !4;E878EA:FG* \

* !4;E878EA:FG* Z<8854GG8H@78AHF54H78E"8EA8A8E

:<85<?78G7458<8<A8A"H?@<A4G<BAFCHA>G78AA;<8E:<A:8F74EH@B57<8 A7HFGE<8:8F8??

F6;49G<;E8A#858AFFG4A74E74H6;HAG8E<AF4GM8<A8E4?F:89R;E?<6;5MJ ?858AF587EB;?<6;

8E46;G8G8A+86;AB?B:<84H9E86;G8E;4?G8AJB??G8 Y

* !4;E8 78E A:FG * \ 0>077>.3,1?74.30 =4>09 @9/ /40

"0@09&:E4,7090B02@9209

-:? * !4;E878EA:FG* 8EIBE;85HA:+ * 4F%4EE4G<I74FF

78E'EBG8FG4AG<F@HF7HE6;F8<A8B998A8A'4EG<M<C4G<BAFFGEH>GHE8A:8AH<A8EAF6;?HFFC4EGA8E J4E <FG :8?RH9<: <8F ?<8:G MH@ 8<A8A A4;8 7HE6; 74F 8E8<GFG8??8A IBA )RH@?<6;>8<G8A MH@4A78E8A7HE6;78AAFCEH6;<F>HFF<BA8A4H9>BA>E8G8AT;A8AB78EBE8A)4H@MH :858A -:? 74MH5FCJ !+ "<E6;8AG4:8HA7>478@<8A 8E'EBG8F

(25)

,;4?0749704?@92

@G8F=HH9GDFR;9B89G@9A9BH:U<FH+7<UF=B;8=9[$9;=H=A5H=CBG?F=G9B57<

89F29=H89G&5H=CB5@GCN=5@=GAIGZ5B IG89F9=;9B9B(5GG=J=HRHKR<F9B889F

&+29=H9FKR7<GH85GGH5F?998UF:B=G[+723@AB/<2;9;9B9=B99L=GH9BN698FC

<9B89BHK=7?@IB;ZNI@9=GH9B

=B95IG:U<F@=7<9IG5F69=HIB;8=9G9FBGRHN9@9=GH9H+7<UF=B;85BB

=B89F%CBC;F5D<=9Q393<<3<5353<23<B=;AB//BP733D/<53:7A163<7@

163<7<23@C<23A@3>C0:793CBA16:/<2C<2273=<4:79B3C;273B=;3<3@573

S

=9#9FBH<9G98=9G9F+HI8=9=GH

74FF78E"BA9?<>GH@7<8GB@8A8E:<8<A8HGF6;?4A7>H?GHE8??HA7E8?<:<SF6B7<8EGJ4EHA7 74FF7<8"<E6;84HF<;E8EJ8?G4AF6;4H?<6;8AHA7FBM<4?8G;<F6;8A+E47<G<BA;8E4HFA>ATC 9HA:FCHA>G84A7<87<F>HEF<I8A*GE4G8:<8A78EGB@>E49G:8:A8E5BG

!A9FGH9B+7<F=HHN9=;H+7<UF=B;5I:85GG=B89F965HH9<RI:=;7<F=GH@=7<?CB BCH=9FH9 +7<@5;KCFH9 K=9 [DC?5@MDH=?Z [(FCD<9H=9Z IB8 [9K5<FIB; 89F +7<TD:IB;Z:=9@9B 29BHF5@G7<9=BHNIG9=B85GGJ=9@99B;5;=9FH9<F=GH=BB9B IB8 <F=GH9B ,9=@ 89F 9K9;IB; K5F9B IB8 85<9F :UF 9=B9@3:757LA1=273@B3

@5C;3<B/B7=<69GCB89FG5BG7<@IGG:R<=;K5F9B !AA=HH@9F9B89F8F9= 5IDH

?5D=H9@K=F88=9[DC@=H=G7<9#=F7<9ZG?=NN=9FH69=GD=9@GK9=G9U69F89B*U7?

;F=::89F#=F7<9B5I:85G@0323A"/B7=</:A=H7/:7A;CA RI:=;9*9?IFG95I:

8=99?9BB9B89#=F7<9IB8=9HF=7<CB<C9::9F^DFR;H9B8=9F

;IA9BH5H=CB89F9J5B;9@=G7<9B#=F7<9969BGCK=989F.9FK9=G5I:89B%5B;9@

5B9?9BBHB=GAIH89F=B89F&+29=HNIH5;9HF5H -AGCGHRF?9FG9=>9HNH85G H=H9@;969B89393<<3<5353<23<B=;AB//B;9:CF89FH +7<@=9W@=7<J9FK9=GH89F IHCF 5I: 8=9 .9F6=B8IB; 89F 9J5B;9@=G7<9B #=F7<9B A=H 89F [B9I9B3B4

G4AG<F@HF 4H9 78@ .8: MHE AFG<GHG<BA4?<F<8EHA: 78E 4H8EE89?8K<BA A %BE58EG E<87 E<6;8EF : 8F8??F6;49G?<6;8%8HBE<8AG<8EHA:78F'EBG8FG4AG<F@HF<A78E%46;>E<8:F M8<G B6;H@8E BEH@ MHE 8F6;<6;G8 78F FBM<4?8A 'EBG8FG4AG<F@HF $TAFG8E

* \

* !4;E878EA:FG* \

* !4;E878EA:FG*

* $Z8>8AA8A:8:8A78AGB@FG44GY <88I4A:8?<F6;8A"<E6;8A

<A 78E HA78FE8CH5?<> 8HGF6;?4A7 HA7 7<8 "BA9?<>G8 H@ 7<8 GB@8A8E:<8 \ 8HGF6;8F$HF8H@5;4A7?HA:8AHA78E<6;G8%8H8B?:8SGG<A:8A -:? 9TE J8<G8E8 P58E?8:HA:8A 78F -8E94FF8EF*+ )8M8AF<BA MH $<6;48? *6;TE<A:

Z8>8AA8A :8:8A 78A GB@FG44GY <A 18<GF6;E<9G 9TE I4A:8?<F6;8 G;<>

* \

* 8>8AA8A:8:8A78AGB@FG44G*

-:? * 8>8AA8A:8:8A78AGB@FG44G*07?,9>.3,@74.30):=,@>

>0?E@9209Q?:8090=240@9/'30:7:240* \

* 8>8AA8A:8:8A78AGB@FG44G40;:74?4>.304=.30* \ +8<?>4C<G8?,>=-0/0>",?4:9,7>:E4,74>8@>* \

(26)

78A4H8E"BAE47\9

?5E86;G;E<FG<4A9 9

?GA8ETAG8E9

@8EL4E?

A78EF8A.<?;8?@

AF8?@)8<A8E9 9 9 \ EG@4AA*G894A

H8E8E;4E7

478ETAG8E 4;E'8GE4 4EA8E"BAE47 4EG;"4E?\

86>,?E<6;\

\\\

86>8EAF;8<@?<F458G;

879BE7*GEB;@8<AE<6;\

?B6;EAFG\

B;E%<8?F

BA;B8998E<8GE<6;9 BEA$4K

SF6;8A*G894A E4A7G#8B9 E4HA58>.8EA8E HAG9HV$4E>HF

4AM;E<FG<4A 78.<GG$4E:E8G 8??JB"4E?8<AM

<898A546;8E4AF

<8F8?)H7B?9

B8E<A:$4AG8H998?AF8?@

58E?8)H7B?9

58E?8<AE4HA"4G;4E<A4

;E>84AF=SE:

<78@T??8E<E>

<AFG8<A?58EG9

<?5<A:8E4AF9

<F6;8E!B;4AA8F9

<GF6;8A"?4HF E4A>;4E?8F H>HL4@4E4A6<F

4H?J4?7 85;4E7G?<F458G;

8E58E*BC;<89

<778AFAG;BAL B??J<GM8E8?@HG SE?<6; A4

E49E<87E<6;.<?;8?@

E878E$<6;48?

E8F6;4G$4EG<A EBV5S?G<A:+;B@4F

458E@4F!TE:8A9 \ 9

46>8E!SE:

R98?8.B?9 4;A#BG;4E 4;A&GGB\9

4GGEHC<8G8E

4HF6;<?7.B?9<8G8E 8<7?4A74AF.B?9:4A:9

\9 8<A8@4AA.<A9E<87 8<AG8?E<6;

8<F8A58E:.8EA8E\

8<CCTAG;8E 8E58EG,?E<6;

8E@?8*<8:9E<87 8EGM8<AE<6;

<G?8E7B?9

(27)

",809>=024>?0=

B99@4AAAA8E<878E<>8 9

B99@4AA"?4HF B;8AF88!8AF B;?98?7.<A9E<87 S;A8?BE<4A9 BA86>8E$4EG<A

!R:8E*4E4;

!R;A<6;8A+E4H:BGG

!B4F4AF

!BA4F4AF9

!HA:$4GG;<4F

"4AGM8A546;E<87E<6;.<?;8?@

"8<G8?%<>B?4F

"<A:$4EG<A#HG;8E9

"?H@54AF

"SEGA8E,?E<6; !

"EB??+;B@4F9

"EB?M<>,7B

"H;A+;B@4F"

"TCC8EF;E<FG<4A9

"TFG8EF4AAF!TE:8A

#4F;*6BGG

#4H58$4EG<A\

#8CC?4H7<4

#<87>88E;4E7

#SF8E8BE:

#BE8AM)B58EG9

#HG;8E$4EG<A9

$4<8E8EA;4E7

$4EK"4E?

$4GG;8F!B46;<@

$847BJF8AA<F9

$8<GA8E#<F89

$8L8E5<6;"?4HF$<6;48?

$8L8E$4:<FG8E8A7E<>

%SFF?8E8EA7

&8;?>84EEL

&8F8E"HEG

&8K?8&GGB8E;4E7

&CC8A;8<@8E)B58EG

&GGB%<6B?4HFH:HFG

'4AA8A58E:.B?9;4EG '<FGA8E;E<FGBC;9 'B??46>8G?89

)47>4H!B46;<@9

)4C;48?#HGM )4J?F!B;A9 )86;8A58E:8?@HG;

)8A7GBE99+EHGM9 )8A:8E8E>4'8::L9 )8HG8E4AF)<6;4E7

)<6;G8ETAG8E9 9

)<GF6;?<8GE<6;

)SAG:8A.<?;8?@BAE47 )BG;*G<8?BJ"?4HF

)H6;G<8G8E9 9 9 )H7?B994AFIBA

)HCC4AF"4E?

*6;RH5?8.B?9:4A:

*6;RH98?88E@4AA

*6;878?+<@

*6;<998E4AF.<?;8?@

*6;<?7GK8?

*6;?8<FF<A:*G8C;4A

*6;BA;4E7G'4H?9

*6;BA;4E7G$4<8EBEA8?<4

*6;A8<78E8EG;B?7

*6;TE<A:$<6;48?\9

*6;E4@@#H<F8\

*6;H58EG"?4HFIBA

*6;J4EM4AF'8G8E

*6;J4EM*<8:9E<87

*885B;@+;B@4F

*88J4?7E<87E<6;

*@8GF';<?<C

*CRG;#BG;4E9 \

*GE4HVE4AM!BF89\9

*HAFG8<A4FF9

+4H58EG%<?F 9 +8??8E7J4E7 +;4?8E)<6;4E7 9 +;BFEHAB

+;HA58E:E8G4 +<??<6;'4H?

(28)

",809>=024>?0=

+<F6;?8E!QABF +EB8?GF6;EAFG\

-<687B@8BE:E<87E<6;

-S:8?8.B?9:4A:9

.458?+;B@4F9 .4?>8E$4EG<A .858E AB .858E$4K

.8<A:4EG'8G8E9

.8<MFR6>8E4E?E<87E<6;IBA 9

.<::8EF;4HF%BE58EG

18<?<A:8EBE<F 1<??8V8ABEFG 1<@@8E@4AA)4<A8E 1TA7BE9 E@:4E7

(29)

*8CG8@58E 4?F"E<F8A=4;E 4?F*6;J8??8A=4;E

5F6;E86>HA:4GB@4E8AH>?84E8

5FG<@@HA:MH@"..L;?9

??:8@8<A:T?G<:>8<G

??:8@8<AI8E5<A7?<6;>8<G\

?GCEBG8FG4AG<F6;8&EG;B7BK<8

@5<I4?8AM\

@GFGER:8E9 9

A:FG\9

\ AG;EBCB?B:<89

AG<4GB@>E49G58J8:HA:\9 \

\

AJ4?GF6;49G9 9

>4030,@.3-8E@<GG?HA:

4AJ4?GF6;49G?<6;8 CB>4?LCG<>

E58<GF@4E>G

E:H@8AG4G<BAF;<?98\

GB@5B@58>4030.4998A4GB

@4E8AH>?84E8

GB@CEB:E4@@9 H9>?REHA:

H9FG<8:

HF;4A7?HA:9

HGBE<GRG

8:E8AMG;8<GIBA)B;FGB998A 9

8?<85<:>8<G 8FG<@@G;8<G7HE6;BGG

8M8H:8A9 E8AAFGB9989BFF<?8>4030E7S?

EB>7BE9\

EHGE84>GBE_*6;A8??8EETG8E^9

HA78F@<A<FG8E<H@

\ 9TEGB@9E4:8ABEF6;HA:9

\ 9TE.<EGF6;49G HA78FG4:

HA78FJ8;E\

TE:8E<A<G<4G<I8\\

,*,9 9

;E<FGB?B:<89

\ ;E<FGHF!8FHF9 9

\

8@B>E4G<8 9

8@BAFGE4G<BA9 9

\\

8A>F6;E<9G 8E*C<8:8?\9 8HGHA:FB998A;8<G9

<?8@@49 \

<AM8?94??\

"9

>4030,@.3)4G78E"*LAB78

"

?F4FF\

@4AM<C4G<BA9 A8E:<8\9

9

\ 58JHFFGF8<A

\ >BAFH@I8E5E4H6;\ 9

(30)

&,.3=024>?0=

\ CEB:E4@@

ADH8G8"B@@<FF<BA AGF6;8<7HA:9

9 9 9 9 AGM4H58EHA:\\

9 \ E7S?\9

\ O?CE8<F>E<F8\9 E>?REHA:78ESGG<A:8E6;GM8;A

\

F6;4GB?B:<89 G;<>9 \9 9

\\9 9 \\

9 \

\ *BM<4?8G;<>\

I4A:8?<H@9

KC8EG8\

>4030 ,@.3*46;I8EFGRA7<:8E

4>G8A 4;EFGH;?\998>G9 4E@4??

8FF8A;8<@

BEF6;HA:4GB@4E8AH>?84E8

\\

BEGF6;E<GG

\ F>E<G<>9

E8<;8<G9 9 9

\9 9

\>4030 ,@.38J4?G9

\ )8?<:<BAF9

\ )<F>4AG8 9 E8<F8GMHA:

9 \

=4/,D>1:=@?@=0

E<878A\\

9 ES@@<:>8<G H>HF;<@4

HF<BAFE84>GBE9

,ESVG8E4AMHA8;@8A78E,A 94??9

?4H58\

9 \

\

85BG\

8@8<AJ8F8A9 8@8<AJB;?9

\

8A8E4?<F<8EHA:9 8A8E4G<BA9

8E<6;G9

8F8GM 8J4?G9 9

\ 9E8<;8<G9 9

\ *G44GF:

8J<FF8A BE?858A

=09E09/0>*,.3>?@8>\

4?GHA:9

\ 9 \ 8HE<FG<>

\ 78EHE6;G9

<EBF;<@49

BE<MBAG4?89

@C?<>4G<BA A7<I<7H8??8E'EBG8FG4AG<F@HF A7<I<7H4?<F<8EHA:\\

\ FCEBM8FF9 \

\ FG;8BE<8FG;8BE8@9 9\>4030 ,@.3E8<F8GMHA:AGM4H58EHA:

)8<AG8:E4G<BA

A7HFGE<89 9 \

\\\

AFG<GHG<BA\\

\ 9

(31)

&,.3=024>?0=

!8F4=4

"4@@8E9TEO998AG?<6;8-8E4AGJBEGHA:

"<E6;?<6;8E'EBG8FG4AG<F@HF9 9

"B;RF<BA9

"B@C?8@8AG4E<GRG

"B@CEB@<FF

"BAF8AF9 9

"BAG8KGH8??8+;8B?B:<8

"BBC8E4G<BA9 9

\ >BBC8E4G<I8P58EF8GMHA:9

\

"E<F89 9 >4030,@.3 E7S?O?CE8<F> HA7,@

J8?G>

#4<8A

#8:<G<@4G<BA

#8GMG:T?G<:>8<G

#<58E4?<GRG9 9

$4E6>B?F;8<@9

$8;E;8<GF@8<AHA:

$8G4C;8E9

$BE4?<F<8EHA:

%4G<BA4?FBM<4?<F@HF%*

9 9

%+&9

%858A9B?:8A\

%8H8*BM<4?88J8:HA:8A9

%BE@4?94??\

"@/20\9

&58EE;8<A9

#1109-@=20=)0=049-,=@92\

9

&998A;8<G O998AG?<6;8+;8B?B:<8\

O998AG?<6;8E'EBG8FG4AG<F@HF 9

&C8E4GBE9 \

'4E<F8E-8EGER:8\9 '4E?4@8AG

'4EG<>H?4E<GRG9 9 '4G8EA4?<F@HF

\ ?<58EGRE8E9 '4GG

\ 4GB@4E8F

\ IBAE:H@8AG8A '94EE8E'4FGBE9 \

9 '9?<6;G9 \

\

';<?BFBC;<89 9 9 '?4GM58F8GMHA:\\

9

'?HE4?<F@HF9 9 9

\ $8<AHA:FC?

'?HGBA<H@9 'B?<G<>58E4GHA:

'B?<G<F<8EHA:

'B?<M8<9 \ 'BFGFR>H?4E\\

'ERF8AM

'EBG8FG4AG<F@HFG;8BE<8\

'FL6;B?B:<8

(H8??8

)4G78E"\

\ ")4GFIBEF<GM8A78E )86;8AF6;49G

)86;G98EG<:HA:9 9 )8:8A8E4G<BA9

)89?8K<I8$B78EA<F<8EHA:

\

)8<AG8:E4G<BA\9

\

)<F<>B\

9 \

(32)

&,.3=024>?0=

*46;4E:H@8AG9 9

*46;I8EFGRA7<:8E

*4>E4?<F<8EHA:*4>E4?<GRG9 9

*R>H?4E<F<8EHA:

*4@4E<G8E

*6;SC9HA:9 \9

\\

9 9

\ 8J4;EHA:78E*

9

\ F6;SC9HA:FJ<7E<:

*6;H?79

*6;J46;84?F&5=8>G78ETEFCE4 6;89

*88?FBE:8

*<6;8E;8<G9 9 9 9 9

*BHI8ERA<GRG

*C4AAHA:9 9 9 9

*CE46;?BF<:>8<G

*'9

*LAB78

\ 547<F6;8#4A78F><E6;8

\

\ "9

\ "

+4?4E9

+86;A<>\\\

9 \

\

\ 8AG 9

+E4AFM8A78AM9 +F6;8EAB5L?

P58E:4A:FG86;AB?B:<858MB:8A4H9 GB@>E49G

P58EF6;HFF9

P58EF8GMHA:_E8?<:<SF8E*CE46;8^9

\\

,@J8?G

\ 584H9GE4:G89 \

\ 58JHFFGF8<A

\ F6;HGM9

\ M8EFGSEHA:

,A58FG<@@G;8<G\

9 9 9 \

,E4A\

\ %*,E4ACEB:E4@@I8E8<A 9

,GBC<8\

-8E4AGJBEGHA:\\

\9

\

\ 74F'E<AM<C- 9

-8E@<GG?HA:9 9 9 9 \ 9 9

\ 4AJ4?GF6;49G?<6;8- \

-8EFS;AHA:9 9

-8EG<>4?89 -8EGE4H8A

.46>8EF7BE9

.4998A4GB@4E8AH>?84E8\

\

.<78EFG4A7\

9

.<E>F4@>8<G .<EGF6;49G

\9 9 \9

.<FF8A9 \\

\

.<FF8AF6;49G

\

.B;?FG4A79

.L;?9 \\

\\

1<I<?:8F8??F6;49G 1<I<?E8?<:<BA9

(33)

&,.3=024>?0=

1H>HA9G\

9 9 9

1J4A:\

9 9 9

Referenzen

ÄHNLICHE DOKUMENTE

Ausgehend von der Feststellung, dass das Verständnis von Gesetz und Evangelium nach dem Ersten Weltkrieg insbesondere in ethischer Perspektive steht, stellt sich folgende

Ob oder in- wiefern das Politische säkular ist, ob oder inwiefern das theologisch zu integrie- ren ist und was eine solche Integration genau beinhaltet – diese Fragen waren und sind

Protestantische Akteure können beispielsweise für sich in Anspruch nehmen, aus Verantwortung für den ihnen übertragenen Auftrag zur evangeliumsgemäßen Gestaltung der Welt zu

Der Teil B) stellt den Hauptteil der Arbeit dar, der sich wiederum in drei Ka- pitel gliedert. Im ersten Kapitel führe ich in die institutionellen Ursprünge der

Ferner bitten wir Sie auch kurz darzulegen, welche Maßnahmen nach Ihrer Kenntnis von der Kommune und/ oder an- deren Wohlfahrtsverbänden/ Organisationen für die regionale

(1) Lehrerinnen und Lehrer, die der Selbstständigen Evangelisch-Lutherischen Kirche angehören, können die kirchliche Bevollmächtigung für die Erteilung Evangelischen

La asistencia financiera para las visitas necesarias en la realizaciön de Proyectos de Investigaciön ConJunta, serä dividida entre el CONACYT y la DFG de la siguiente manera:. -

4 Lamdre, „Der Pfad und seine Frucht“, wird dem in- dischen Asketen Virupa zugeschrieben... Autorität), Vajrayana (Diamantfahrzeug) und Tantrayana (Tantrafahrzeug). Sie