( #)* +-,.%'* /#0
132547698:;=<=>@?A69BDCE<
FHGJILKNM0OGNM0KQPRGQSUTWV9IXKQPYZ[M\M]G_^`M]a9abM]YcILPRZNadVdYeKNM]S_OgfRM\hIeKNMiadPYjIkS@M]l]PRS@M$ILKQPgImIeKNM
^bORhLadS@^nV5S@MmV9GQl\ORokMkS@VdYcIehLVdZNp@IeVdORGqKQPRY Z[M\M]Gsr[ORa5P7hLV9t]V9GNuiORhYcIehvPgIeV9wyx/V9GQu0VdGILOzSNVdYcIeVdGQl{I
l=a5PRYLYeM]YbO7wWV9GDl=ORokMYeV9GQl\M|qOhea5S0|P7hn}e} ~EYcM]MRTQPRokORGNuXO7ILKNM\hvY\TNbV5P7GQlvKQV~j]R {T@3MYj
S@OV9uRILY~jR7/ {T7PRGQSkHpDP7Ki~c]R e {KNMnP7GQPRa9x@YeVdYO7wDIeKNM^bORhLadSV9GDl=ORokMnS@V5YjILheVdZNp@ILV9OG
V5YokO7IeVdfgPgILM]SXZ/xIeKNMwyORada9Og^nVdGNuRM]xpNM]YcIeVdORGl\PRGX^bMbQGQSXVdGkIeKNMSNP7ILP M\f/V5S@M\GDl=M]YO7w
r[OgfRM\heIjx)ILhLPRrQYv/pDlvKsP0pNMYjILV9OGl\P7GsZDMwyORpNGQSwyORhHV9GQYcILPRGQl=MmV9GqbPRpNokORab~j]R {Y
V5S@M]PXO7wl=OG/fRM\hLuRM]GQl=M l=adpNZQY]
FHG'IeKNM0O7IeKQM\hKQPRGQSUTWP7GM=/ILM\GQYeV9fMkM\okrNVdheV5l\PRaa9V9IeM]hLP7IepNhLM$VdGfM]YcIeVduP7IeM]YHILKNM0YeORpNhvl=MY
O7wWuRhLOg^IeKP7GDSzl\ORG/fRM]heuM\GQl\M3ILKNhLORpNuKiILKNMM]YcIeVdo$PgILV9OGzORw^`Ohea5S@^nV5S@Ml=hLOYLYnl=ORpQGILhex
uRhLOg^IeK$hLM\uheMYeYeVdORGQYWpQYeVdGNuM\/rQa9V5l=V9IeadxXwyORhLopNa5PgILM]S$uheOg^ILKXokO@S@M]adY ~YeM\MT/PRokORGNuORIeK@
M\hvY]TPRGN/V9^TnOokM\hTWPRGQS|'M\Vda ~c]R R =TPRGQSJ3pQhea5P7p@w3PRGQSHpQPRK¡~j]R HwyORhmPRG
M=/ILM\GQYeV9fMP7GQSiV9GDYcVduRKIcwypQa¢YcpQhefM\x$ORG£e^nKxiS@OkuRhLOg^IeK0hvPgILM]YnS@V9¤"M\h{]¥ {
¦ Y$HpQPRK.~jRR YcIehLM]YLYcMY\TWuRhLOg^IeKJhLM\uheMYeYeVdORGQYPAfM\hvP7uMkPl=hLOYLYIeKQMzl\heOYeYc§YeM]l=IeVdORG
ZNp@IILKNM\x.l]P7G¨ORGNadx©uRVdfRM'PrNV5l{ILpNhLM'ORwIeKQM'Z[M\KDPAfVdORhzO7wIeKNMJl=OGQS@V9IeVdORGQPRaoXMP7GT
GNORIkORw3ILKNM^nKNORadMS@VdYcIehLVdZNp@IeVdORG¢KQVdY$PRhcILVdl\a9MzV9adadpQYjILhLP7IeMYkKNOg^ªIehvPRSNV«ILV9OGQP7al\heOYeYc
l=OpNGIehLxquheOg^ILKheM]uRhLM]YLYcVdORGQYl]P7GJZ[M0pQYeM]SJIeOsPRGQP7adx/t\M$ILKNM0VdokoXMS@V5PgIeMzYcOpNhvl=M]YO7w
IeKQMi^bORhLadSN^nVdS@MiV9GDl=ORokMzS@VdYcIehLVdZNp@IeVdORG¬S@x/GQP7okV5l\YmOgfRM]hIeKQMir[M\hLV9O@S©RA®[R¯@
¦ Y
° rQa9OnM$rNhLOgfV5S@MY PRGqM\/IeM\GDYcVdfRM$YeM=IO7wrQP7hvP7okM\IehLVdlXP7GQS'GNOGNrQPRhLPRoXM\IehLVdlokM=IeKQO/SQY\T
V9ImV5YPGDPgIepQhLPRa±YjIvPgILVdYcIeV5l\PRa`l=OokrNp@IeVdGNuqM\G/f/V9hLORGNokM]GIILOsVdG/fRM]YcIeVduP7IeM$VdGIeM\hLGQP7IeVdORGQPRa
uRhLOg^IeKzS@V9¤[M]heM]GQl=MYP7GQSzlvKQPRGNuRMY`VdGzIeKNM^bORhLa5S0VdGQl=OokMSNVdYcIehLV9ZQp@IeVdORG
KNMXP7GQPRa9x@YeVdYYcILPRhcIvYn^nV9IeKsPRGM]YcIeVdo$PgIeVdORGORwP0l=a5PRYLYeVdl]P7a¢l\heOYeYc§l\ORpNGILhex$uheOg^ILKheM\
uRhLM]YLYeV9OGYcpQlvK'PRY3wyORpNGDSsZ/x²M\okrNadMz~c]R ^nKNOiVdG/fRMYjILV9uPgIeMYnILKNM$l=ORhLhLM\a5PgIeVdORGZ[M=
Ij^bM\M\GMpQV9rNokM]GIVdG/fRMYjILoXM]GI3P7GQSiM]l\ORGNOoXV5luRhLOg^IeK¢T/PRGQSzV«IvYl=OokrQPgILV9ZNVdadV«Ijxi^nV«ILK
IeKQMi/ORadOg^³~c]¯7 HuheOg^ILKqokO@S@M\a±wyheOo´^nKNV5lvKJP7GM=@rNadV5l=V9Il=ORG/fM\hLuRM\GDl=MXM]pQPgILV9OG
V5Y$S@M\hLV9fM]SUKNMM]YcIeVdo$PgILM]S¬okO/SNM\aP7GDS_ILKNMpNGQS@M]headx/V9GNuJSNP7ILPP7hLMiIeKNM]G¬pDYcMS_ILO
pQP7GILV«wyxJILKNMVdoXokMS@VdP7IeMYeORpNhvl=MYXO7wM]PRlvKl=OpNGIehLx"YkS@V9¤[M]heM]GIeV5P7anuRhLOg^IeK¬r[M\hewyORhe
o$P7GQl\MR}µGsP)YeM]l\ORGQSYcIeM]rT[P)GNORGNrDP7hvP7okM=ILheV5ll=OpNGIeM\hewPRl=IepQPRaM=@M]hLl\VdYeMVdY3rNhLORr[OYeM]S
lvKQPRGNuRMY±VdG0ILKNM^`Ohea5S$VdGQl=OokM S@V5YcIehLV9ZNpNIeVdORGKNM M=¤"M]l=ILYORw¢IeKQM S@V9¤"M\hLM\GInfAPRheV5P7ZQa9MY
P7hLMMYjILV9o$P7IeM]SsZ/xPRrNrNadx/V9GNuzRM]heGQM\a²SNM\GQYeV«IjxokM\IeKNO@SNY]KNMXrNheO@l\M]S@pNhLMrQheOgf/V5S@M]YHP
f/VdYepQPRa9adxql\a9MP7hhLM\rNhLM]YeM\GIvPgIeVdORG'O7wn^nKNM]heM$VdGIeKQM0S@M\GDYcV9IjxqORwnV9GQl\ORokM]YIeKNM0Yer[M]l=V9QMS
wPRl=IeOhLYmM=@M\heIILKNMzuRhLM]PgILM]YcIVdoXrDPRl{I¡~E/M]MzPRadYeOsHV¶3PRhLS@ODT·NOhcILV9GTPRGQS¸¢M\okVdM\p@
~jR 3wyORhPRGPRGQP7adx@YcV5YO7wbIeKQM)M=¤"M]l=ILYORwbVdGQYcIeV9Iep@ILV9OGQP7abP7GQSqadPRZDOho$P7hLRM\I wPl{ILORhvY
ORGiIeKQM¹HzS@V5YjILheVdZNp@ILV9OGzORw^P7uM]Y]T"]7ºA®"]R @»
¼ ½ ¾¿\ÀÁÂÃÅÄÇÆmÀ$ÈmÁÃÉmÁ3ÀÊnÁÌËÎÍ0Ï ÐW¿\ÆmÀ
Ñ]Ò`ÓiÒ"Ô7ÕÓiÒ"ÔgÖN×RرÓ0Ò/Ù@ÚN×@Û@ÜJÝÎÛQÞØ@ßNÕRàáeâ±Ó0ã[ä
M]YcIeVdo$PgIeMYnl=O/M=å)l\V9M]GIvYbwyORhnPXa9VdGNMP7hheM]uRhLM]YLYcVdORG0rNheOZNadM\oæwyhLORoçSNP7ILP â
P7GQS
ã
PRGQSzl\P7a5l=pQadP7IeM]YbILKNMè/éQê7ë/èkIvP7ZNadM
·NOa9adOg^nVdGNu$P7GN/Vd^TQnOoXM]h]TDP7GQS|'M\Vda±~jR R {TD¢M]oXrQa9M)~c]R `M]YcIeVdo$PgILM]Y3PXadV9GQM]P7h
ìRí[îï²ðñ]ðí[îòNó²ìíDî"ô[õöA÷[õ/î²ìõ0ögõ/÷DöAõ/øø]ðEíDî T7Oh
÷Qögí/ùkñ]úJögõ/÷DöAõ/øø]ðEíDî
pDYcVdGNuSNP7ILP wyORh
gkl\ORpNGIehLVdM]YP7GQSl\OgfRM\hLVdGNuILKNMrDM]heVdO@S']RA®"]R¯@TgILKQPgIV5YO7wIeKQMwyORhLoz
û[ü²ý¡þQÿ_þ$ü_þ $üJþ$üvü
^nKNM]heM ü V5YPGNOheo$PRa9adxS@V5YjILheVdZNp@ILM]SM]hehLORh²IeM]heohLMDM]l{ILV9GQu PHl=ORpQGILhexµYcr[M]l\V«[l`YeKNO@lv"
KNMS@M]rDM]GQS@M]GIHfAPRheV5P7ZQa9MV5YIeKQMa9Ou)S@V«¤"M\hLM\GDl=MO7wWORpNIerNp@IHrDM]h^`Ohe/VdGNu7µP7uM3r[M\hvYcOG
OgfRM]h3ILKNM$r[M\hLV9O@SU$KNMXQhvYjIwyOpNhV9GDS@M\r[M\GQSNM\GIfgP7hLVdPRZNa9MYk~ P7hLMkheMYcr[M]l=
IeVdfRM]a9xILKNMa9OuPRheV9IeKNoÅORw PAfM\hvP7uRM)YeKQPRheMYmORw3hLM]P7aMpQV9rNokM]GI)PRGQS_hLM]PRabGQORGNMpQV9r@
okM\GI`VdG/fRMYjILoXM]GI`VdG)heMP7aDORp@ILrNp@I]TILKNMHadORuP7hLV«ILKNo ORwUIeKNMPAfRM]hLPRuRMr[M\hvl=M\GIvP7uRMnORwUIeKNM
^bORhLVdGNuR§PRuRM±r[ORrQpNadP7IeVdORGkILKQPgI±V5YVdG)YcMl=OGQSNP7hLxYLlvKNO/ORa/wyOhIeKNM3rDM]heVdO@S]RA®@¯@TgPRGQS
IeKQM3adORuPRheV9IeKQo ORwUIeKNM P7GNG/pQPRaDPAfRM]hLPRuRMuRhLOg^IeKkhvPgILMO7wUILKNM3^bORhL/V9GNuR§PRuRMr[ORrNpNa5PgILV9OG
rNadpQYPRGiM\/OuRM]GNORpQYbhvPgILM ORw¢ILM]lvKNGNOa9OuRV5l\PRa[rQheOuRhLM]YLY`PRGQSPXSNM\rNhLM]l\VdP7IeVdORG0hvPgILMRT@Z[O7ILK
O7wIeKQM\oçZ[M\VdGNu$l=OGQYcILP7GIPRl\heOYeYl\ORpNGIehLVdM]Y]
KNMYcMfgPRheV5P7ZNadM]Y3heMQM]l=IHS@V9¤[M]heM]GQl=MY3VdGwPl{IeOhHPl\l=pQopNa5PgILV9OGPl=hLOYLYl=OpNGIehLV9MY3PRGQS
P7hLM$M=@r[M]l=IeM]SqILOsl=OGILheOaWwyORhuheOg^ILK'SNV«¤"M\hLM\GQl\M]YVdGJM]pNVdadV9ZNhLVdpNozKNMkQwIeK_fgP7hLV9
P7ZQa9M0~ nV5YnILKNMadORuP7hLV«ILKNo³ORwORp@ILrNp@I3r[M\h ^`Ohe/VdGNu7µP7uMHr[M\hvYeORGPgIILKNMZ[M\uV9GQGNV9GQu
O7wILKNM)r[M\hLV9O@SUTWP7GQS'V5YM\/r[M]l=IeMSsILOsl\PRr@IepQheMkILKNM0¶M]O@l=a5PRYLYcV5l\PRal=ORG/fM\hLuRM\GDl=MXM=¤"M]l{I
S@pNMIeO0SNV9okVdGNVdYeKNVdGNu0hLM=ILpNhLGQYnILO)heM]rNhLO/SNpQl=VdZNadMwPRl=IeORhvY]TNIeKDPgI3ILM\GQSQYILO$wPAfROhrDO/OheM]h
l=OpNGIehLV9MY\mKNMma5PRYcIwyORpNhM\/OuRM]GNORpQYHfgP7hLVdPRZNadM]YX~ ! P7hLMXSNpNokoXVdM]Y wyOhheM\
YerDMl{IeVdfRM]a9xqYcpNZNµ@PRKQP7hvP7G ¦ wyhLVdl]PNT¢¸²PgILV9G ¦ okM]heV5l\PzP7GQSqILKNM#"bP7hLV9ZQZDMP7GT%$`PRYcI ¦ YcV5PNT
P7GDSILKNMnV9GDS@pQYcIehLVdPRa9Vdt\MSml\ORpNGIehLVdM]YO7w[IeKNM3F&$'"brNa9pDY}jYchvP7M]aEKNM]YeMfgP7hLVdPRZNa9MYWP7ada9Og^
Z[MM]YLYcM]GILVdPRa9adx)VdGIeM\hvl=OGIeVdGNM\GILPRaE
²OM]YcIeVdo$PgIeMzYcpDlvK_PopNa9IeVdrNadM0adV9GQM]P7hmheM]uRhLM]YLYcVdORG¢T¢^bM$QhvYjIhLM]PS'IeKNMiSNPgIvP¢M]okrNa9M
~jR ²P7GQPRa9x/t\MSPRGQSILKQPgIPRheMYjILORhLM]SmV9G ÖNÕ(NÙDÛÕ P7GQSXS@M\QGNMZDORIeKmIeKNMnVdGQS@M]rDM]GQS@M]GI
P7GDS)ILKNMS@M\r[M\GDS@M\GI3fgP7hLV5P7ZNadM]Y]
)
ÝßNÕ/×+*á,]ÖNÕ-(QÙDÛÕ/.0*@×RÖ%,7ä
â@Ý
)1 Ó2/34576
ã@Ý
)1 Ó4-6
/Ml=ORGDSUT²^bM$adOPRSsIeKQM ÔgÖ@×Ö[Ô
pQPRGILa9VdZJP7GQS'pQYeM$ILKNMkwyORada9Og^nVdGNu ° rNa9OnM)l=O@S@MkILKQPgI
l=OokrNp@IeMYILKNMadV9GNMP7hhLM\uheMYeYeVdORGXO7w
ã
OG
â
TP7GDS$YjILORhLM]YWILKNMfgP7adpNM]Y±O7w[IeKNMHM]YcIeVdo$PgIeMS
rQPRhLPRoXM\IeM]hLYPRY^bM\adaPRYbILKNM\VdhhLM]YerDMl{ILV9fM YcILPRGQSNP7hvSiM\hLheOh]T98§µYjIvPgIeV5YcIeV5l7TNP7GDS;:QfgPRa9pNM
ÛQÞÒ@ßN×Rß/ãá,RÔAÖN×Ö[Ô<,Rä
=
Ò`ÓjÒ"Ô7ÕÓjÒ"ÔgÖ@×RØ`ÓjÒ/Ù/ÚN×/Û9>7ÝNÛNÞ]Ø@ß@Õà áeâÓcã"ä
KNV5YpDP7GIeadM=IP7a5YcOirNhLOgfV5S@MYHPYHPRGsORpNIerNp@IILKNMwyOa9adOg^nVdGNu ¦ ¶ F@? ¦ ~¦ ¶3PRa9x@YeVdYF3w
? ¦ hLVdPRGQl=MA IvP7ZNadMIeKDPgI3P7adadOg^Y`pDYbIeO$VdG@wyM\h
A
IeKQP7I¢IeKQM`okO@S@M\a@PYV9IV5Y²Yer[M]l=V9QMSP7adadOg^YpQY¢IeO M=@rNa5P7VdGP7Z[ORpNIR9B.O7w@IeKQM`fgP7hLV9
P7GQl\M3M=@KNVdZNV9IeMS0VdG)ILKNM PRGNG/pQP7aUPAfM\hvP7uRMnuheOg^ILK)hvPgIeMHO7w¢VdGQl\ORokMHr[M\h^bORhL/V9GNuR
P7uRM r[M\hvYcOGiOgfM\hbIeKNMr[M\hLVdO/S
A
IeKQP7IXILKNMl=O/M=å)l\V9M]GIkORGIeKQMzVdGNV9IeV5P7anadM\fM\aO7w V9GQl\ORokMrDM]hk^`Ohe/VdGNu7µP7uM)rDM]hc
YcOG~
VdYmYcVduRGNV9Dl]P7GIeadxsGNM]uP7IeVdfRMDCWILKQPgIXVdY]TIeKNM]heM0VdYXPIeM]GQS@M]GQl=xqwyORhmrDO/ORh
l=ORpQGILheVdM]Y`ILO$uRhLOg^wPRYcIeM\hnOGPAfRM\hvP7uMnIeKDP7GheV5lvKl=ORpQGILheVdM]Y
A
IeKQP7IHILKNMXYeO@l=V5P7a²heM\IepNhLGQY3IeOzM]pNVdrNokM\GI VdG/fRMYjILoXM]GIHVdGqS@M]fRM\adORrQV9GNuzl=OpNGIehLV9MY
P7hLMHfM\hLx)KNVduRK~YeM\MP7a5YeOX²M\okrNadM$]R
A
IeKQP7I¢IeKQM±fgP7hLVdPRZNadMheMQM]l=IeVdGNuILKNM`Pl\l\pNopNa5PgILV9OGO7wNK/pNo$P7Gml\P7rQV«IvP7aTVdGl\ORGIehvPRYcI
IeOkrNhLM\f/V9OpQYhLM]YepNa«IvY\T@V5YGNORI3YcVduRGNV9Dl]P7GIeadx)S@V9¤[M]heM]GInwyhLORo³NTNM\ILl7
è é ê ë è E9E E9E H<I I
L9L9L7L9L9L9L9L7L9L9L9L9L7L9L9L7L7L9L7L9L+L9L7L7L9L7L9L+L9L9L+L9L7L9L7L7L9L+L9L7L9L7L7L9L+L9L9L7L7L7L9L+L9L9L7L7L7L9L9L+L9L7L7L9L
M
ÕàßNÕQÔ/Ô@ÞNRØ 4-5/.PO9Q9R O 4S.P24R T9T.PT9O9R 5/.P5959575
M
ÕQÔ/Þ*+KQ×@Û@Ô 2/.0UVR9O W9X 5/.P59T9W
Y
NÖ@×@Û
ë
×ß"Þ7×RÖ"Þ!NRØ 4-T/.0UVT9W R9R 5/.4R+U
G7KDÛ7Ö"ÞÙDÛÕ
M
ÝZ5/.PO759T959Q
M\[
2 ÝZ5/.PX4Q9Q95
è *^]!K"ÔgÖNÕ7*
M\[
2 ÝZ5/.PR7O459X
E ÖN×7ØV*@×ß^*`_/ß/ßVNß ÝZ5/.4-O959O9T
J è M è G9_
Y _ M E a ÕRÖN× E _ E ÖN×RØV* a Ö I ÖNÕQÔgÖ J I ÚN×@Û!KNÕ
L9L9L7L9L9L9L9L7L9L9L9L9L7L9L9L7L7L9L7L9L+L9L7L7L9L7L9L+L9L9L+L9L7L9L7L7L9L+L9L7L9L7L7L9L+L9L9L7L7L7L9L+L9L9L7L7L7L9L9L+L9L7L7L9L
Ò 1
5Ó6/Ý U.P2759Q9O 5.PR+UV29Q 5/.P5957595 Q.PW9W+U 5/.P5959575
Ò 1
4UÓ6/Ý 5/.P27Q9292 5.P59T9Q+U 5/.PQ9O7T+U R.4292 5/.P5959575
Ò 1
2Ó6/Ý 5/.PTDU9UVX 5.P59W9T9Q 5/.PT9O7W9W Q.0UV29W 5/.P5959575
Ò 1
TÓ6/Ý 5/.P57W9R+U 5.P59Q9T9T 5/.4T7W+U 4%.P29W9T 5/.P2457X
Ò 1 U±Ó6/Ý
I
5/.0U9U\494 5.P2+UVX95
I
5/.4UVR7W
I
4%.PR9R9X 5/.P59R9O7X
Ò 1 QÓ6/Ý
I
5/.PT9O7X4 5.P59Q+UVT
I
5/.PX+UVX7X
I
R.PT9T95 5/.P5959575
Ò 1 WÓ6/Ý
I
5/.P2957T9X 5.P59X929X
I
5/.P24R7X
I
2.0UVW4 5/.P54WDU
Ò 1
RÓ6/Ý 5/.P57W+UV2 5.P59X45 5/.P59W7R9W 5.PR9O9T 5/.0UVT957T
Ò 1
XÓ6/Ý 5/.PT7O45 5.494R9Q 5/.P2957R9X T.PT929X 5/.P5954U
Ò 1
OÓ6/Ý 5/.4-W494 5.494R9R 5/.4RDUVR 4%.PT9W9X 5/.4R9Q7R
b ÄæÆmÏÀXÐWÁÃdc7ÂÊbÐÏÂfehgÀÊnÆji ÁlknmiÀÂfi¿\Êpo
q'rPs tuv@w<xySz{u|~}VywVu }V{0fy%wVy /}VP0}VnySz7ySx}}^u
{pud}V@y\}Vxj/y%w</yxu/u/ Z
·NOa9adOg^nVdGNuJ3Ma5PJ·NpQM\GIeM_~c]R¯R =T`^bMP7hLMGNOg^ PRZNadMIeO_pQP7GILV«wyxIeKNMVdokoXMS@V5PgIeM
S@M\IeM\hLokV9GDP7GILYkORwHuRhLOg^IeK¬P7GQSl\ORG/fRM]heuM\GQl\MiS@pNhLVdGNusILKNMr[M\hLV9O@SU©KNMYeORpNhvl=MYXO7w
IeKQMuRhLOg^IeKS@V9¤[M]heM]GIeV5P7a¢^nV9IeKhLM]Yer[M]l{I3IeO0PkK/x/rDORIeKNM\IeV5l\PRa¢hLM\rNhLM]YeM\GILP7IeVdfRMM]l\ORGNOoxT
ZQPYcV5l\PRa9adxIeKQM)PAfRM\hvP7uMml\ORpNGIehLxOgfM\h IeKNM$r[M\hLVdO/ST²P7hLM$l=OoXrQp@IeMSqpDYcVdGNuzIeKNM)PRZDOgfM
rQPRhLPRoXM\IeM]hbMYjILV9o$P7IeM]Y]
KNM3wyORada9Og^nVdGNul\O/SNM3S@M]l\ORokr[OYeM]YMPRlvK)l\ORpNGIehLx"Y±uRhLOg^IeK$hvPgILM3S@V9¤[M]heM]GILVdPRaQ^nV9IeKiheM\
YerDMl{I¢ILOnIeKQM±YePRokrNa9M`PAfRM\hvP7uM²VdGIeOnDfRMwPl{IeOhLY]"IeKQM±l=OGILheVdZNp@ILV9OGO7w@rNK/x@YcV5l\PRaRl\PRrNV9ILP7a
IeVdORGORwbK/pNo$P7Gl\PRrNV9ILP7a`PRl\l\pNopQadP7IeVdORGTUILKNM)¶M]O@l=a5PRYLYcV5l\PRal=ORG/fM\hLuRM\GDl=MM\¤[Ml{ITPRGQS
IeKQMV9okrQPl{IO7wWPmN@M]SzM=¤"M]l=IheMQM]l=IeVdGNu$S@V«¤"M\hLM\GDl=M]YVdGM=å)l=VdM\GDl=xR
Ù^¡N×RÙNÝWá/áeâ
1
Ó4-6
I
("Õ×RØáeâ
1
Ó46[ää7¢]Ò
1
2Ó6Dä£Wááeâ
1
Ó276
I
("Õ×Rرácâ
1
Ó¤2D6[ä/ä+¢Ò
1
TÓ¥6[ä
¦
×à/ßVN
¦
Ö7§NÝácâ
1
Ó¤T76
I
([Õ/×gرácâ
1
ÓT76Qä/ä7¢]Ò
1
U±ÓP6
§^¡N×RÙNÝWáeâ
1
ÓPU96
I
("Õ/×7رácâ
1
ÓPU96Dä/ä+¢AÒ
1
QÓ¥6
¨
NRØ@ÚNÕRß/àNÕRØ
¨
ÕÝáeâ
1
Ó¤Q+6
I
("Õ×7رácâ
1
Ó¤Q76Qä/ä+¢AÒ
1
WÓ¥6
F[ÞAâNÕ7*Ýá/áeâ
1
Ó¤W76
I
([Õ/×7رájâ
1
ÓW76Dä/äD¢AÒ
1
RÓP6[ä£Wá/ájâ
1
Ó¤R+6
I
(DÕ/×RØácâ
1
ÓPR76[ää+¢Ò
1
XÓ6Dä
£á/ácâ
1
Ó¤X76 I ("Õ/×RØáeâ
1
ÓX76Dä/äD¢AÒ
1
O76Dä£Wááeâ
1
ÓO76 I ("Õ×Rرácâ
1
Ó¤OD6[ä/ä+¢Ò
1
45Ó6Dä
q'r©q ª«0w ¥}^y~¬{y%w @ySySz90}Dz+}VP }V¥u/d®°¯±d®pP®p}V
ty ¥ySx}V¥u
ѧ
¨
ß"ÞAÖ±Ó
¨
ß"ÞAÖ[Ü_Ý{*@ÕRØÒ
¦
ÔRÕ@Û²áeâ[ÑUÓ§`Ó³²±Ó*DÜä
YjIvP7heILYPRGqVdGIeM\hvPRl=IeVdfRMmIeO/ORaWwyOhRM\hLGNM]aS@M\GQYeV9IjxZQP7GDS@^nVdS@IeKYcM]a9Ml{IeVdORG
pQYeV9GNukILKNM| ¦ @´VdGNukokM=IeKQO/S
F+§%Ý{*@ÕRØNÕQÔgÖáeâDÑÓ§`Ó²Ó~*DÜä
l=OoXrQp@IeMYILKNMRM]heGQM\aDSNM\GQYeV«IjxXM]YcIeVdo$PgILM3ORG)PuRhLVdSXpQYeV9GQuIeKNMH| ¦ ´
V9GQu$oXM\IeKNO@S
ÑF+§±ÓFD§DÛWÓµF+§9K"ÜÝ°*@Õ7Ø
¨
ÞáeâDÑÓ§`Ós×/Û7Ù9§Q×Ó#²Ó~*DÜä
l=OoXrQp@IeMYXIeKNMRM]heGQM\anS@M\GDYcV9Ijx_M]YcIeVdo$PgILMPRGQSrDOV9GIj^nV5YcMl=OG@DS@M]GQl=M
V9GILM\hLfAPRadYOGzPkuheV5S)pDYcVdGNukIeKQM| ¦ @´±V9GQuXokM\IeKNO@S
/pNrQrDOYcM^bMP7hLMuRVdfRM]GzP$YLP7okrNadMO7wWV9GDS@M\r[M\GQSNM\GI]T[VdSNM\GIeV5l\PRa9adxiS@V5YcIehLV9ZNpNIeM]ShLM]PRa9Vdt]P7
IeVdORGDY²ORwDPhvP7GDS@ORo%fgP7hLVdPRZNadM Ñ
$ü Ü-¶
ü·
¶Og^TgV9w[PHYcokO/O7ILKRM]heGQM\awypNGQl{ILV9OGj¸º¹»¼½¾
¿ÁÀ
V5Yl=M]GILM\hLM]SP7hLORpQGQS0MPRlvKORZDYcM]hefgPgILV9OG
$ü
PRGQSzV«w^bMPAfRM]hLPRuRM3OgfM\hILKNM]YeMwypNGQl=IeVdORGQY
VdGiILKNMORZDYcM]hefgPgILV9OGQY]T^bMORZ@IvP7VdG0ILKNMRM]heGQM\aS@M]GQYcV9Ijx)MYjILV9o$PgILMS@M=DGNM]SPRYbwyOa9adOg^Y
Â
à ¿
~ÅÄ[ ý
ÆSÇ
¶
È
ü·
¸lÉ A«Ê
ü
Ç Ë
~jA
^nKNM]heM IeKQMRM\hLGNM]a"wypNGQl{ILV9OGVdYnP$Yex/oXokM\IehLVdl rNhLORZQPRZNVda9V9Ijx)S@M\GDYcV9Ijx)wypNGDl{IeVdORG¢
´hvPRl=IeV5l\PRaQP7rNrQa9V5l\P7IeVdORG$O7wM\hLGNM\a[S@M\GDYcV9IjxmMYjILV9o$P7IeVdORG)V5Y`l\hepDl=V5P7ada9xXS@M\r[M\GQSNM\GIbOGkIeKNM
lvKNOVdl\MO7wUILKNMHYeokOORIeKNVdGNurDP7hvP7okM=ILM\h
Ç ¦ okM]PYcpNhLMORwUPl\l\pNhLPl=xmV9G)OhLSNM\hILOPRYLYeM]YLY
KNOg^Çl=adOYeM\adx à ¿
~ÅÄ[ MYjILV9o$P7IeM]YfÃW~ÅÄ[ V5Y IeKNM$}µGILM\uRhvPgILM]S@pQP7hLM]SÌ$hLheOh]T%Í9ÎdÏ)~
Ç ý
ÐÒÑ
Â
à ¿
~ÅÄ[
Ê
ÃW~ÅÄ[ ¥Ó SÔ
IJ/IeORGQMH~jRR YeKNOg^Y¢IeKQP7IWPHSNPgIvPgµS@hLV9fM\GZQPRGQS@^nV5S/IeK ÂÇ
ILKQPgI
PRYex/okr@IeORIeV5l\P7adadx)okV9GNVdokV9t]M]YpÍ9ÎdÏ)~
Ç
bV5YnuRVdfRM]GiZ/x
ÂÇ ý P7hLuoXVdG«ÕÖ0~
Ç ~E
^nV9IeKhÕÖi~
Ç ý ÐÒÑ
Â
à ¿
~×Ä" ¥Ó
Ê Æ ¼
Ø
¶
ü·
Â
Ã
¿DÙ
ü ~×Ä ü IeKNM0l\heOYeYfAPRa9V5SNP7IeVdORG'wypNGQl=IeVdORGT
P7GDS0^nKNM]heM
Â
Ã
¿!Ù
ü
~×Ä
ü ý ~c~
ƳÊ
Ç ¼ Ø ü0Ú·Û
¸
ÑÜD¼½Ý
¿ Ó
´P7hLP7GQS²pNhLadPlvK)~jR "rNhLOgf/VdS@MbP7GOgfM\hLf/V9M]^qOgfM\hILKNMbM=@VdYcIeVdGNuHZQP7GQSN^nVdS/ILKYeM\adM]l{
IeVdORGokM\IeKNO@SNY]n|qMXlvKNO/OYeMKNM\hLMIeO0rDM]hcwyOheo³IeKNMX¸MPRYcIH@pQP7hLM]Y«"`hLOYLYp?PRa9V5SNPgILV9OG
l=hLV9IeM\hLVdORGV9GDYjILM]PRSORwjTQwyOh3VdGQYcILP7GDl=MRTDIeKQMbVdPYcMSÞ"? ORhIeKNMk/okOORIeKNMSÞ"? l\heV9IeM]heV5P
IeKDPgIGNM]M]SM\V9IeKQM\hPzfRM]hexsadPRheuMkYLP7okrNadM)YeV9t]MXOhrQPAx^nV9IeKJPa5P7hLuRMkfgP7hLVdPRGQl=M0IeVdadaET
GNORIeMHIeKQP7IbV9IbhLM\o$PRV9GQYbS@V9å)l=pNa9I`ILOmhLM]l\ORokokM\GQS)ORGQl\MHP7GDS$wyORhP7ada"PrQPRhcILVdl\pNa5P7h±ZDP7GQS/
^nV5S/IeKYcM]a9Ml{ILORhFHGQMXYeKNORpQadSILKNM\hLM=wyOheMkl=OokrQP7hLMIeKQMXhLM]YepNa9IeVdGNuiSNM\GQYeV«IjxMYjILV9o$P7IeM]Y
S@M\IeM\hLokV9GQM]SzZ/x0S@V9¤[M]heM]GI3YeM\adM]l=IeVdORGzokM=IeKQO/SQY\
FHpNhuOPRaET@KNM]heMTNV5YQhvYjInILO)YcM]a9Ml{I3P7GOr@IeVdo$P7aZQPRGQS@^nV5S/IeKPRGQSYcMl=OGQSiIeO$M]YcIeVdo$PgILM
RM]heGQM\aHSNM\GQYeV«ILV9MYzO7wIeKQMq^bORhLadSVdGQl\ORokMqS@V5YcIehLV9ZNpNIeVdORGÇ|qMqQhvYjIza9OPRSILKNMsGQM]l=MYj
YLP7hLxXadVdZNhLPRheVdM]Y]WKNM
Ô(N9NÖ+§QÕß
pQPRGIeadV9Z0PRp@IeOo$PgIeV5l\PRa9adxka9OPRSNY±IeKQM
âÙDÛ7Nß@Õ
P7GQS)IeKNM
¡NÕßØQÕ@Û
pDP7GIeadV9ZDY\KNM ÙDÛ7NRÖ
pQP7GILa9VdZsV5Y pQYcMSwyOh uhLPRrNKNVdGNu$ILKNMkheMYcpNa9IeVdGNuzl=hLOYLY
fgP7adVdSQPgIeVdORGP7GDSzSNM\GQYeV«Ijx)wypNGQl{ILV9OGQY]
ÛQÞÒ@ßN×Rß/ãá,RÔ(N9NÖ7§NÕß\,ä
ÛQÞÒ@ßN×Rß/ãá,\ÙQÛ7NÖ%,ä
/Ml=ORGDSUT^bMl\PRa9aQIeKNMHpDP7GIeadM=I
*@ÕRØ/Ò
¦
ÔRÕ@Û
IeKDPgI±GNM]M]SNYIeKNM3pNGNVdfAPRheV5PgILMSNPgIvPfRMl{ILORhPRY
VdGNrNp@IP7GDSILKQPgI^nVda9aOrDM]GqPzYcM]a9Ml{IeVdORG'Z[OA^nKNVdlvKqO7¤"M\hvY xRORpsIeKNM$lvKNOVdl\MmZ[M=Ij^bM\M]G
S@V9¤[M]heM]GIZDP7GQS@^nV5S/ILKYeM\adM]l=IeOhLY]TPRY^bM\adaPRY IeKQM$rDOYeYeV9ZQV9adV«IjxILOlvKQP7GNuMmrDP7hvP7okM=ILM\hvY
YepQlvKzPYbIeKNMM\hLGNM\aT/IeKQMYcMP7hvlvK0uRhLV5SUT@M=Ivl7 ¦ okOGNuXIeKNM]ozTNIeKNM¸<"? l=hLV«ILM\hLVdPQ
ß
W95Ýâ
1
Ó¤Q76.Pà-("×âácâ
1
Ó¤QD6[ä
ß
X9QÝácâ
1
Ó¤Q76/.¥£ã"ä.Pà-([×âWáeâ
1
Ó¤Q+6.á£ã"ä
= § ¨ ß"ÞÖ%4UÓ
¨
ß[ÞAÖ%4>Ý7*@Õ7Ø/Ò
¦
Ô7Õ/Ûá
ß
W+5Dä
= § ¨ ß"ÞÖV2Ó
¨
ß[ÞAÖV2^>Ý7*@Õ7Ø/Ò
¦
Ô7Õ/Ûá
ß
X+QDä
FHZ/f/V9OpQYcadxRTRIeKNM"?¡wypNGDl{IeVdORG0VdY`GNO7IbokV9GNVdokV9t]M]S$^nV9IeKQV9G$ILKNMHPRp@IeOo$PgIeV5l\PRa9adxkYcM]a9Ml{IeMS
hvP7GNuMHORw²ZQPRGQS@^nV5S/IeKKQMZQP7GQSN^nVdS/ILK0ILKQPgIokVdGNVdoXVdt\MYIeKQMf"? l\heV9IeM]heVdORGiVdYZ[M\adOg^
IeKQMqYeM\adM]l{ILM]S©adOg^bM\h)Z[ORpNGDSU |'MsopDYjIzV9GQl\heMPRYeMIeKQMqYeM]P7hvlvKuRhLVdS¬wyOh
Ç }§wORGQM
Ç
S@V5YcrQadPAxM]S$ILKQPgI3YeKNOg^©ILKNM¸² "?¨wypQGQl{ILV9OGzVdGiIeKNMpNrQrDM]hna9M\wI]T@ILKNMYcM]a9Ml{ILM]SiORr@ILV9o$P7a
ZQPRGQS@^nV5S/IeKkVdGmILKNMnpNrNr[M\hhLVduRKI]TgILKNMnhLM]YepNa«ILV9GQu M\hLGNM\aNSNM\GQYeV«IjxM]YcIeVdokP7IeMnVdGILKNMnadOg^`M]h
adM=wI]TWP7GDSqYeORokMkV9GNwyORhLokP7IeVdORGP7Z[ORp@IILKNM)YcMP7hvlvKsuheV5SqPRGQSsIeKNM$M\hLGNM\aVdGsILKNM$adOg^`M]h
hLV9uKIKNMuRhvP7rNKQVdl]P7aUS@V5YcrNa5PAx)V5YnYcKQOg^nGiVdG·²VduRpQheMkR
KNMOr@IeVdo$P7aZQPRGQS@^nV5S/IeK©l\ORhLheMYcr[ORGQSNV9GNuqIeOILKNM^bORhLadSrDM]h)^bORhLVdGNuR§PRuRM)r[M\hvYcOG
VdGQl=OoXMzS@V5YjILheVdZNp@ILV9OGJV9G¡RVdYIeKNM]heM\wyORhLM0 RºN}§ImV5YXYjILORhLM]SVdG
§ ¨ ß"ÞAÖ%4
¶3O7ILM
IeKDPgIILKNMX/KQM]PgILKNM\hHP7GQSâORGNMY~jRQ {DYcM]a9Ml{IeOh3lvKNOYcM]GzZ/x3V¶3PRhLS@ODTD·QORheIeVdGTDPRGQS
¸M]okV9M]p@q~jR QGQSNYPXZQPRGQS@^nV5S/IeKMpDP7a"IeO$ ºRN|'MORr[M\GPXYeM]l\ORGQSzYeM\adM]l{ILV9OG
Z[OAV9GXORhvS@M]h²ILOl=ORokrNpNIeMIeKQMnORr@ILV9o$P7a@ZDP7GQS@^nV5S/ILKXl\ORhLheMYcr[ORGQSNV9GNuHIeO ILKNMn^`Ohea5Sr[M\h
^bORhLVdGNuR§PRuRMnr[M\hvYcOG)ORp@ILrNp@IV9G']¯N²KNM a9Og^bM\h`ZDOpNGQSiO7wILKNMYcMP7hvlvK$uRhLVdS0VdY`GNOg^
YeM=I¢ILO3 NA¯P7GQS ILKNM`l\ORhLheMYcr[ORGDS@V9GQunORr@ILV9o$P7aZQP7GDS@^nVdS@IeKOZ@ILPRV9GNMSZ/xHadM]PYjIYepQPRheMY
l=hLOYLYfgPRa9V5SNPgILV9OGsV5Y GNOg^M]pQPRa²ILOz Q]Q KNM]heMmVdYPRrNrQP7hLM\GILa9xokORhLMmYcIehLpQl{ILpNhLMVdG
IeKQMQGQP7aSNVdYcIehLV9ZQp@IeVdORGPRYnl\ORokrQPRheMS)ILOmILKNMVdGNV«ILVdPRa¢S@V5YjILheVdZNp@ILV9OG
"`ORGNDS@M\GDl=MkV9GILM\hLfAPRadYl]P7GZ[M)S@M\hLV9fM]SqpNGQS@M]hYcOokM$heMYjILheV5l{ILV9fMXPYeYepNokr@IeVdORGDY$~YeM\M
ãåäPRhLSNa9Mk]NA ±PRGQSz^nheV9IcILM\GPRY
æç Â
à ¿
~×Ä"
Êéè
¼'êë ì
Â
à ¿
~×Ä" %í¸í
ÆSÇ Â
à ¿
~×Ä[
è
¼'êëSì
Â
à ¿
~×Ä[ Sí¸í
ÆSÇ îï
~º
^nKNM]heM
è ¼ êë
VdYILKNM)~j
Êñð
pDP7GIeVda9MORw²ILKNMYjIvP7GQSQP7hvS0GNOheo$PRa"SNVdYcIehLV9ZQp@IeVdORG
}µG
°
rNadOnMTl=OG@DS@M]GQl=M'V9GILM\hLfAPRadYPRheMl=OokrNp@IeMSÎpQYcVdGNu *@ÕRØ
¨ Þ çKNMwyOa9adOg^nVdGNu
pQP7GILa9M\Iil=O@S@M'l=ORokrNpNIeM]Y)IeKNM'l=OG@DS@M]GQl=MVdGIeM]hefgP7a5Y$wyOh)ILKNMsOr@IeVdo$P7a3ZDP7GQS@^nV5S/ILK
rNhLM\f/VdORpQYea9xiYcM]a9Ml{IeMSZ/x0adM]PRYcI3YLpDP7hLM]Ynl=hLOYLYnfgP7adV5SNPgILV9OGTQYeM\adM]l{ILV9GQu)PòP7pQYLYcV5P7GM\he
GNM]aETQPkS@V5YLl=hLM=IeVdt]P7IeVdORGzZNVdG^nV5S/ILK
Ô
TQPRGQSiYeVduRGNV9Dl\PRGQl=MadM\fM\a%ó ý ]Q
*/Ýáá("×Râá
ß
W95Qä I (²ÞØá
ß
W95Nä/ä .Pà727595
=
F+§<W95WÓ
¨
Û7N9W75Ó
¨
K/ÙVW959>Ý+*@Õ7Ø
¨
ÞUá
ß
W95
¨
ß"ÞÖ\4UÓP5/.45WÓ,]à/×DKS,"ÓP*Dä
|'MrNhLORr[OYeMbGQOg^ILOS@M]l\ORokr[OYeMlvKQP7GNuM]YWVdGkIeKNM3^`Ohea5SVdGQl\ORokMS@V5YjILheVdZNp@ILV9OG$ORGXIeKNM
ZQPYcV5YO7wYeV9okrNadMl=OpNGIeM\hewPRl=IepQPRaS@M\GDYcV9IeVdM]Y]`OheMYerDMl=V9Dl\PRa9adxRTDP7GQSPRYrNheOrDOYcMS0Z/x
HMXa5P·NpNM]GIeM~jR¯ {T"^nKQP7I^bORpQadSsIeKNM$S@M]GQYeV«IjxORw`VdGQl=OoXMkKQPAfMZ[M\M]GqVdG]R¯kVdG
PiKx/r[O7ILKNM=ILVdl]P7aW^`Ohea5S^nKNM]heMIeKNMkhLM\a5PgILV9fMVdGQl=OoXMXO7w`M]PRlvKql=ORpQGILhexlvKQPRGNuRMSORGQa9x
S@pNMIeOkwPRl=IeOh3PRl]l=pNompNadP7IeVdORGTQ^nV«ILKP7adaM]l\ORGNOoXVdM]Y3S@VdYerNa5PAx/V9GNu)PAfM\hvP7uM3Z[M\KQPAf/VdORhnVdG
IeM]heo$YHO7w±PRa9aWO7ILKNM\hHfgP7hLVdPRZNa9MYL|'MXYeV9ompNa5PgIeMIeKNhLM\MXYcpDlvKsl=OpNGIeM\hewPRl=IepQPRaSNM\GQYeV«ILV9MY\
FHGNM)V5YIeKNMzS@M\GQYeV9IjxPYS@M\QGNMS_P7Z[OgfRM ¦ GNO7ILKNM\hXV5YIeKQMiS@M]GQYcV9Ijx'IeKQP7ImOGNM)^bORpNa5S
KQPAfMHOZQYcM]hefM]S0V9G]¯V«wIeKNMhLM\a5PgILV9fMHVdGQl\ORokMO7w²MPRlvKl=OpNGIehLx)lvKQP7GNuM]SiORGNadx0S@pQM
Least Squares CV
1 2 3 4
0.01+h*E-2
-4 -3 -2 -1
-2.72+criterion*E-2
Density Estimate
0.7 0.8 0.9 1
x
1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5
fh
optimal h:
0.0390019
Range of h:
0.02 0.0544646
Points:
10
---
Kernel K:
gau
Binwidth d:
0.00184367
·V9upNhLM_R¸²<"?´wyORh$ILKNMs^bORhLa5S@^nVdSNMV9GDl=ORokMr[M\hi^`Ohe/VdGNu7µP7uMir[M\hvYeORG©VdG ]R
GNOheo$P7adVdt\M]SihLM\a5PgIeVdfRMHIeOXILKNMo$Pg@V9ompNo
àßVN
¦
*[ÞÔgÖ.µâÙQÛ
M\okrNVdhLVdl]P7aUokO@S@M\aV5YnP7ZQa9MILOXrQheMS@Vdl=I]
}µGsP)QhLYcI YcIeM]rT"^`MXl=OoXrQp@IeMIeKNMXheM]adP7IeVdfRMr[M\h ^bORhLVdGNuR§PRuRMrDM]hLYeORGsV9GQl\ORokMpQGQS@M\h
IeKQMiP7Z[OgfRMiPRYLYcpNokr@ILV9OGQYPRGQSILKNM0OZQYcM]hefM]SJS@M]GQYeV«Ijx'V9G¨]¯@TWP7GDS'IeKNM]GM]YcIeVdo$PgILM
IeKQMml=OhehLM]Yer[ORGQS@VdGNu$l=OpNGIeM]hcwPl{IepDP7a²SNM\GQYeV«Ijx«"`ORokrQPRheVdGNukIeKQM]YeMS@M\GDYcV9IeVdM]Y3^nV«ILKIeKNM
S@M]GQYcV9IjxMYjILV9o$PgILM]YWl=OhehLM]Yer[ORGQS@VdGNu3IeO IeKNMhLM]PRa^bORhLa5SVdGiRRHP7GQSi]¯uRVdfRM]YPl=adM]PRh
f/VdYepQPRa[VdGQYeV9uKIbORw¢IeKQMYeORpQhLl\M]Y`O7w¢ILKNM^`Ohea5S$VdGQl=OokMSNxGDP7okVdl]Y\¹3GNV9fgPRheV5PgILM S@M]GQYeV«Ijx
M]YcIeVdo$PgILM]YP7hLMnl=OoXrQp@IeMSpQYeVdGNu
*/ÕRØQÕQÔgÖ
KQVdYpQPRGIeadM=IORGNadxPRrNrNhLOA/Vdo$PgILM]Y¢IeKNMnM\he
GNM]aNS@M\GQYeV9IjxZxILKNM| ¦ ´VdGNuHokM\IeKNO@SUWKNV5Y²okM\IeKNO@SmKQPRY²IeKQMYcILP7IeV5YjILVdl]P7a/M=å)l\V9M]GQl=x
O7w"RM]heGQM\a@okM=ILKNO@SNY^nKNVdadMnZDM]V9GNul\ORokrNp@IvPgILV9OGQP7ada9xml=ORokrQPRhLPRZNadM`ILOKNV5YjILORuRhvP7ookM\IeK@
O@SNYbPRYV9I`r[M\hewyORhLo$Y±YeokOORIeKNVdGNuOrDM]hLP7IeVdORGQY±ORGkILKNMHZQV9G0l\ORpNGIvYhvPgIeKQM\hILKQP7G)IeKNMHhLPA^
SNP7ILPkPRYVdGzIehvPRS@V9IeVdORGQPRaURM]heGNM]aUS@M\GQYeV9Ijx0M]YcIeVdo$PgILV9OG'~EYcM]M ãåäP7hvS@adMP7GQS@l=ORIcIR {}§I
V5YmPRadYeOr[OYLYcVdZNadM$IeOqM\fgP7adpQPgILM)ILKNMiS@M]GQYeV«IjxM]YcIeVdo$PgILMiPgIkP7ada±OZQYcM]hefgP7IeVdORGQYZ/xpQYeV9GQu
*@ÕRØ/âNÕQÔgÖ
V9GQYcIeMPRSiO7w
*@Õ7ØQÕQÔgÖ
¦
4Ýáeâ
1
Ó¤Q76.0£Ù^¡N×RÙ.¥£D§^¡/×RÙ.0£
¦
×àß.¥£
¨
N7Ø@Ú.0£9FQÞAâ.¥£([Õ/×gرáeã[ää
.à("×âáeâ
1
Ó¤Q76.0£Ù^¡@×7Ù'.0£+§7¡N×RÙ.¥£
¦
×Ràß.á£
¨
NRØ/Ú.¥£+F[ÞAâ.0£("Õ×Rرácã[ää
F+§/Ù@ßNÕ+*/Ý9*@ÕRØNÕQÔgÖá
¦
4UÓ0§
¨
ß"ÞÖ^2Ó,]à/×DKS,[Ó*Dä
¦
2Ýáeâ
1
Ó¤Q76.0£Ù^¡N×RÙ.¥£D§^¡/×RÙ.0£
¦
×àß.¥£-("Õ×RØácã"ää
.à("×âáeâ
1
Ó¤Q76.0£Ù^¡@×7Ù'.0£+§7¡N×RÙ.¥£
¦
×Ràß.á£([Õ/×7ØáeãDä/ä
F+§VF@×
¨
Ý9*@ÕRØQÕNÔgÖá
¦
2W
¨
ßDÞAÖ^2WÓ-,\àN×KS,UÓ¥*[ä
¦
TÝáeâ
1
Ó¤Q76.0£
¨
NRØ@Ú.¥£("Õ×RØácã"ää.¥à-("×7âácâ
1
ÓQ76.¥£
¨
N7Ø/Ú.á£("Õ×7ØáeãDä/ä
F+§
¨
NRØ/Ú@Ý9*@ÕRØNÕQÔgÖá
¦
TÓ0§
¨
ß"ÞÖ^2Ó,]à/×DKS,[Ó*Dä
F+§<X9QÝ7*@ÕRØQÕQÔAÖá
ß
X9QW
¨
ßDÞAÖ^2WÓ-,\àN×KS,UÓ¥*[ä
KNM'P7Z[OgfRMS@M]GQYcV9IjxM]YcIeVdo$PgIeMY0PRheMsSNVdYerNa5PAxRM]S¬VdG.·V9upNhLMq @ ²OSNVdYcIeVdGNuRpQVdYeKIeKNM
S@M]GQYcV9IeVdM]Y]Tb^`MlvKNO/OYeMzIeOJl=Oa9OhXIeKNM]o ^nV9IeK¬IeKQMpDP7GIeadM=I ÔRÕÖ("×QÔ¡ ²M]lvKNGNV5l\PRa9adxRT
ÔRÕÖ("×QÔ¡
KQP7GQSNa9MYo$PRYefRMl{IeOhLYHILKQPgIml\ORGILPRV9G'G/pNokM\hLVdl]P7aVdG@wyORhLo$PgILV9OGsILOl=ORGILheOa
IeKQM`uhLPRrNKNV5l\P7aS@VdYerNa5PAxO7w@IeKQM`SNP7ILPr[ORVdGILY]²KNV5Y²M=@rNa5P7VdGQYILKNM±GDP7okM±ORwNIeKNM±wypNGQl=IeVdORG
HM\GQYeV«IjxsM]YcIeVdokP7IeMY PRheMXS@hvPA^nGqPRYYeORadVdSsa9VdGNMY PRGQSsl\ORG@[S@M\GQl\MkV9GIeM]hefgPRadY PRYSNPYcKNMS
adV9GNMY\
F+§<W95ÝQÔRÕÖ!("×NÔ¡á¤F+§VW95WÓ-,ÛQÞ]ØNÕ,"Ó-,{ÒDÛ!K@Õ,Rä
¨
Û7N9W95ÝDÔRÕÖ!([×QÔ¡á
¨
Û7N7W95Ó-,AÛNÞØNÕ,[Ó-,\ÒNÛ!KNÕ,"Ó,]ÖD§UÞ]ØS,"Ó,-*×QÔ§NÕ+*,ä
¨
K/Ù<W95ÝDÔRÕÖ!([×QÔ¡á
¨
K/ÙVW95Ó-,AÛNÞØNÕ,[Ó-,\ÒNÛ!KNÕ,"Ó,]ÖD§UÞ]ØS,"Ó,-*×QÔ§NÕ+*,ä
F+§<X9QÝQÔRÕÖ!("×NÔ¡á¤F+§VX9QWÓ-,ÛQÞ]ØNÕ,"Ó-,=ßNÕ7*,ä
F+§VF@×
¨
ÝDÔRÕÖ!([×QÔ¡á¤FD§VF/×
¨
Ó-,AÛNÞØNÕ,[Ó-,]ã/Õ@ÛÛ7N
¦
,ä
F+§
¨
NRØ/Ú@ÝDÔRÕÖ("×QÔ¡áF+§
¨
NgØ@ÚÓ,gÛNÞØ@Õ,UÓ,]àßNÕÕ7ØS,7ä
F+§/Ù@ßNÕ+*/ÝDÔRÕÖ("×QÔ¡áF+§Ù@ß/Õ7*Ó,gÛNÞØ@Õ,UÓ,ô([×à@Õ7Ø@Ö/×,Rä
Density Confidence Intervals
0.7 0.8 0.9 1
Income in 1960 and 1985
1 2 3 4
density estimates
1960 plus factor accumulation effect
0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
Income (60 and factor accumulation)
1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5
Y
Predicted vs 1985
0.7 0.8 0.9 1
Income (Predicted & 85)
1 2 3 4
Y
1960 plus Neoclassical convergence effect
0.7 0.8 0.9 1
Income (60 and convergence)
1 2 3 4 5 6
Y
·V9upNhLMm @¹GNVdfgP7hLVdP7IeMX3M]GQYcV9Ijxµ$±YcIeVdokP7IeMY3P7GDSÌ"`ORG@[S@M\GQl\M}µGIeM]hefgP7a5Y]¹rNr[M\h a9M\wI]
´WM\hH^`Ohe/VdGNu7µP7uMrDM]hLYeORGsV9GQl\ORokMVdGR~YeORadVdSsZNadpNMmadVdGNM 3^nV«ILKsr[ORVdGIj^nVdYeMml\ORG@N
S@M]GQl=MkVdGILM\hLfgP7a5Y$~SNPYcKNMSsZQa9pNM$adVdGNM]Yv P7GQS'VdGR¯q~yhLM]S'YeORadVdSqa9VdGNMA {)¹rQrDM]hheVduRKI]
nMP7aH~heMSJadV9GNMA PRGQSJrNhLM]S@V5l{ILM]S¡~o$P7uRM]GILPadV9GNMA r[M\hm^`Ohe/VdGNu7µP7uMkrDM]hLYeORGJVdGQl=OokM
S@M]GQYcV9IeVdM]Y±V9Gs]R¯@¸Og^bM\hadM=wIP7GQSkhLV9uKI]´WM\h^bORhL/V9GNuR§PRuRMbrDM]hLYeORG$VdGQl\ORokMVdG]R
~YeORadV5S)ZNadpNM a9VdGNM `P7GDS)l=OpNGIeM\hewPRl=IepQPRaDVdGQl\ORokM SNM\GQYeV«ILV9MY±VdGsR¯V«wWl=OpNGIehLV9MY^bORpNa5S
KQPAfMS@V«¤"M\h±ORGNadxmVdGkwPRl=IeOhPRl\l\pNopQadP7IeVdORG~yadM=wI{ ORh±V9GkILKNM3¶M]O@l=a5PRYLYcV5l\PRaNl=ORG/fM\hLuRM\GDl=M
M=¤"M]l=I~yhLV9uKIv { à/ß^N
¦
*[ÞÔAÖ.µâÙDÛ
KNV5Y VdYPlvKNV9M]fRMSIeKNhLORpQuRKILKNM$l=OoXo$PRGQS
¨
ßNÕ/×RÖNÕ7*[ÞÔÙDÛ×ã
3KNMkl=ORoko$P7GDS Ô§<N
¦
P7adadOg^Y²pDYIeOYcr[M]l\V«wyxIeKNMSNP7ILP YcM\ILYILKQPgI^nVda9a@Z[MrNadO7IcILM]SXVdGmMPRlvKXrNa9ORIO7wQILKNMnS@V5YcrNa5PAxR
¦ wILM\h Ô§<N
¦
KQPRYbZ[M\M\Gl]P7ada9MSUT/ORGNMl=OGIehLORa5YILKNMadPAxORp@IbO7w²IeKNMS@V5YerNadPAx$Z/x
ÔRÕÖ/à^NRÙ@Ö
*[ÞÔAÙS4]Ý
¨
ßNÕ/×RÖNÕ7*[ÞÔÙDÛ×ãWáô2WÓ2Dä
Ô§<N
¦
á*[ÞÔAÙS4"Ó-4UÓ-4UÓPF+§VW95Ó
¨
Û+N9W75Ó
¨
K/Ù^W95WÓFD§VX9QNä
Ô§<N
¦
á*[ÞÔAÙS4"Ó-4UÓ¤2ÓPF+§VX9QÓFD§Ù@ß@Õ7*Qä
Ô§<N
¦
á*[ÞÔAÙS4"Ó¤2Ó-4UÓPF+§VW95ÓFD§^F@×
¨ ä
Ô§<N
¦
á*[ÞÔAÙS4"Ó¤2Ó¤2ÓPF+§VW95ÓFD§
¨
N7Ø@ÚDä
ÔRÕÖ/àVN7Ù@Öá¤*[ÞÔAÙS4UÓ-4"Ó-4"Ó-,=Ö"ÞÖNÛÕ,UÓ,õNÕgØ"Ô/ÞAÖã`ö9NRØVF[Þ*/ÕRØ
¨ Õ ß
Ø@ÖNÕßÚN×@ÛNÔ<,"Ó
,]âQÛ×RÒNÕ@Û,UÓ-,
ß Ø ¨
N(DÕÞØ÷4-O9W95¡×RØV*4O9X9Q,UÓ-,]ãQÛ×RÒQÕ@Û,"Ó
,-*@ÕRØ"Ô/ÞAÖ/ã¡ÕQÔAÖ"Þ("×Ö@ÕQÔ<,ä
ÔRÕÖ/àVN7Ù@Öá¤*[ÞÔAÙS4UÓ-4"Ó¤2WÓ-,=Ö"ÞÖNÛÕ,UÓ,J/ß/Õ7*DÞ
¨
Ö@Õ7*JÚ[ÔZ4O9X9Q,UÓ-,]âQÛ×RÒQÕ@Û,"Ó
, ß Ø ¨
N-("ÕæáJ/ß@Õ7*[Þ
¨
Ö@Õ7*ø°X9QDäV,ä
ÔRÕÖ/àVN7Ù@Öá¤*[ÞÔAÙS4UÓ¤2WÓ-4"Ó-,=Ö"ÞÖNÛÕ,UÓ,94O+W95'ÙDÛ!K"Ô`F@×
¨
ÖVNß.×
¨9¨
KD(<KDÛ×RÖ"Þ!NRØ
Õ7F9F/Õ
¨
Ö%,UÓ,]âQÛ×RÒNÕ@Û,"Ó,
ß Ø ¨
N("Õ áôW95¡×RØ^*{F/×
¨
ÖVNߨ×
¨7¨
KD(<KDÛ×Ö"Þ!NRØ"äV,ä!>
ÔRÕÖ/àVN7Ù@Öá¤*[ÞÔAÙS4UÓ¤2WÓ¤2WÓ-,=Ö"ÞÖNÛÕ,UÓ,94O+W95'ÙDÛ!K"Ô
é
Õ9N
¨
Û×QÔ/Ô/Þ
¨
×@Û
¨
NRØ@Ú@Õß/àNÕRØ
¨ Õ
Õ7F9F/Õ
¨
Ö%,UÓ¤>
,]âQÛ×RÒQÕ@Û,"Ó-,
ß Ø ¨
N("Õ áôW95¡×RØV*
¨
NRØ/ÚNÕß/àNÕ7Ø
¨
ÕDäV,RäD>
KNM`pNrNr[M\h¢adM=wIO7wQ·VduRpNhLM± nS@V5YcrQadPAx@YZ[O7ILKIeKQM`S@M]GQYcV9Ijx M]YcIeVdokP7IeMORw@IeKNM±rDM]h²^bORhL/V9GNuR
P7uMrDM]hLYeORGmV9GQl\ORokMnVdGiRR3IeOuRM\IeKNM]h^nV«ILKmILKNMl=OhehLM]Yer[ORGQS@VdGNu l=ORGNDS@M\GDl=MnVdGILM\hLfgP7a5Y
~YeORadV5SP7GQSsSNPRYeKNM]SZQa9pNMXadV9GNMYL =TUP7GQSILKNMr[M\h ^bORhLVdGNuR§PRuRMrDM]hLYeORGVdGQl\ORokMmS@M]GQYeV«Ijx
M]YcIeVdo$PgILM)V9G.]R¯~yhLM]SadV9GQM {FHGJIeKNM0ORGNM)KDP7GQSUTWILKNMiSNVdYcIehLV9ZQp@IeVdORGJORwV9GQl\ORokM0P7I
IeKQMiZ[M\uV9GNGQV9GNuqO7wILKNMzrDM]heVdO@S_P7rNr[M]PRhLYIeOqZDMzpNGNVdokO@SNP7aTokOYcImORwIeKNMzM]l\ORGNOokV9MY
l=adpQYcIeM]heVdGNuzV9G'^nKQPgIOGNMmokVduRKIl\PRa9aPzokVdSNSNa9M\VdGQl=OokMXl\adPYeY]kFHGsIeKNM$ORIeKNM]h KDP7GQSUT
IeKQMmpNGDS@M\hLa9x/VdGNuiSNM\GQYeV«IjxVdGR¯kYeM\M]o$YILOiZ[MXl\ORGQYeV5YjILM\GI3^nV9IeKqP0opNa9IeVdokO@SNP7aS@V5Yj
IehLVdZNp@IeVdORG$YepNuRuM]YcIeVdGNu IeKQP7I±l=OpNGIehLV9MYwyORada9Og^¬S@V«¤"M\hLM\GI±S@M]fRM]a9OrNokM\GIrQPgILKQYPRGQSILKQPgI
IeKQM\xXIeM]GQSkIeOml=adpQYjILM\h`V9GIeOmS@V«¤"M\hLM\GIbV9GQl\ORokM3l\adPYeYeM]Y]KQMrDOrNpNa5PgILV9OG$O7wM]l\ORGNOokV9MY
VdG©]R¯0YeM\M]o$YIeOKQPAfM)PgIadM]PYjIILKNheM]M$okO/SNM]Y]iKNM)VdGNV9IeV5P7a`oXV5SNS@adM)VdGQl=OokM)l=a5PRYLY
fgP7GNV5YeKNM]SUiYcOoXMl=OpNGIehLV9MYml]P7pNuKImpNr¬P7GQS~ùjORVdGNM]SPql\a9pNZO7w3hLV5lvKl=OpNGIehLV9MYmPRGQS
O7ILKNM\hvY3wyM\a9IVdGIeOP)r[OgfRM]hcIjxzIehvP7r¢KNVdY V5YHIeKNM'£e^nVdGÌ´WMP7@Ye¥0Yel\M\GQPRheVdO)Vda9adpQYcIehvPgIeMS
P7okOGNuO7ILKNM\hvYZ/x)HpQP7K~jR { ¦ I`adM]PYjIT7ILKNMHYcIehLpQl{ILpNhLMO7w"IeKQM3^bORhLadS@^nV5S@MnVdGQl=OokM
S@V5YjILheVdZNp@ILV9OGsVdG_]¯$SNOMY3GQO7I3QIPRGx/okORhLM^nV9IeKNVdGILKNMkl=ORokrNpNIeM]Sql=OG@DS@M]GQl=MmV9G@
IeM]hefgPRadYl\ORhLheMYcr[ORGDS@V9GQumILO$IeKQMVdGQl=OoXMmS@M\GQYeV9Ijx0M]YcIeVdo$PgILMV9G]RNbKNM\hLMVdYHP$fRM]hex
Yex/YcIeM]o$PgIeV5lXYcKNV9wIOgfRM]h3ILV9okMY\kKNV5YYcpNuuRMYjIvY PiuRhLM]P7IPRokORpNGIO7w`okOZNV9adV9Ijx^nV«ILKNVdG
IeKQMYcx@YcIeM\o³P7GQSzOgfRM]hbIeKNMr[M\hLV9O@SipNGQS@M]h3YcIepQS@x
|©KNM]heM)S@O/MY IeKNV5YokORZNVdadV«IjxqM=NPRl=Ieadxsl=OoXMXwyhLORo)%|©KQP7ImP7hLMmIeKNM$okOYcIVdoXr[ORheILPRGI
hLV9uKI S@VdYerNa5PAxiORw·²VduRpQheMm )YcKNOg^YHP)l=OpNGIeM]hcwPl{IepDP7aVdGQl=OokMmS@M]GQYcV9IjxzM]YcIeVdokP7IeMILKQPgI
IeKQM0M\okrNVdhLVdl]P7a±okO@S@M]a`MYjILV9o$PgILM]S_PRZDOgfM)KQPYZ[M\M\GP7ZNadM)ILOrNhLM]S@V5l{ImIeORuM=ILKNM\hm^nV«ILK
IeKQMV9GDl=ORokMSNM\GQYeV«IjxzM]YcIeVdo$PgILMV9GJR¯@ ¦ a«ILKNORpQuRKTDIeKNMoXO@S@M]a²PRrNrDMP7hvYIeO0ZDMPRZNadM
IeO0rNheMS@V5l{IILKNMwyORhLo$PgILV9OGzORwWIeKNMIj^`O$okO@S@M]YwyORhnILKNMKNVduRKQM]YcI3V9GDl=ORokMl\adPYeYeM]Y]TQPRGQS
IeKQM\hLM=wyORhLMIeOil\P7rNIepNhLMRT"PgI3adM]PYjIrDP7heIeV5P7ada9xTNIeKQMml=OG/fRM\hLuRM]GQl=MrNKQM\GNOoXM]GNORG¢TQV9IHV5YpNG@
P7ZQa9MnILONIILKNMr[OgfRM]hcIjxIehvP7rXIeKQP7IbPRheOYcMnS@pNhLVdGNuIeKNMHrDM]heVdO@SUWKNMadOg^`M]ha9M\wIbS@V5YerNadPAx
YepNuRuM]YcILY²IeKQP7I±S@V9¤[M]heM]GQl=MYWV9GXwPRl=IeOhWPl\l\pNopNa5PgILV9OGILORuM=IeKQM\h^nV9IeKmIeKNMS@V9¤"M\hLM\GQl\M]YWVdG
M=å)l\V9M]GQl=x0PYbrNheOA@VdM]S$Z/xkILKNMl=ORGILV9GNM]GILP7aUS@pQoXokVdM]Y]TNo$PAx$ZDMrQPRhcILVdPRa9adx$hLM]YerDOGQYcVdZNadM
wyORh ILKNVdY ^bM]PRa«ILKIehvP7r¢bp@IHILKNV5Yl\P7GQGNO7IM=@rNa5P7VdGILKNM$P7adaWYcIeOhex/ORokM\IeKNVdGNuzM\a5YcMXVdY
uROV9GQu)ORGT"P7GDS}na9MPAfRMKNM]heMIeKNV5YHVdYLYcpQMwyORhHwyp@IepQheMmM=@rNadORhvPgIeVdORG¢·²VdGQPRa9adxRT[IeKQMadOg^`M]h
hLV9uKIS@V5YcrNa5PAxXV9ada9pDYjILhLP7IeM]YbPl\ORadadPRrQYeV9GNuOgfRM\h±IeVdokMHORwUIeKNM ^`Ohea5SkVdGQl=OoXMS@V5YjILheVdZNp@ILV9OG
IeOiP$S@M\uM\GNM]hLP7IeMr[ORVdGIHa9VdokV«In}§wPRa9a¢M]l=OGNORokVdM]Yn^bM\hLMS@V5YcrQadPAx/VdGNu)PAfRM]hLPRuRM ZDM]KQPAf/V9Oh
VdG$IeM]heo$Y`O7wUwPRl=IeOh]Y±Pl\l=pQopNa5PgILV9OG)P7GQS$M\å)l=VdM\GQl\xRT/rDO/Oh`l=OpNGIehLV9MY^bORpNa5S)l]PgILlvK$pQr
^nV9IeKheV5lvKzORGNMY\
q'r©ú ûlv«0}V0w<¥}^y¬y%w<yS;ySz90}DüzD}V }V¥u
F+§%Ý{*@ÕRØNÕQÔgÖÙ±ácâ[ÑÓ§`Ó³²±Ó*DÜä
l=OoXrQp@IeMYPompNa9IeVdfAPRheV5PgILMJS@M\GQYeV9Ijx¡M]YcIeVdo$PgIeMOGÎP¬uRhLV5S.pQYeVdGNu¬IeKNM
| ¦ ´VdGNu$okM=IeKQO/S
à[ÔÝ¡à/ß
¨
NRØ@ÖVNDK/ßV2Wáeâ±Ó
¨
ÑUÓ
¨
N@ÛNÜä
uRM]GNM\hvPgILM]YP$l=OGILORpNhrNadO7InwyhLORo³PXº7§SNV9okM\GDYcVdORGQPRaUSNPgIvPXYeM=I
â
¦ adaPRZDOgfMwyORhLopNa5PRYUl]P7GZDM±M]PRYeVda9xuM\GNM]hLPRa9Vdt\MSILOopQa«ILV9fgP7hLV5PgIeMWOZQYcM]hefgP7IeVdORGQY
Ñ
kü Ü-¶
ü·
T
P7GDS#Ä üý ~×Ä üD Ä üý ¥þ``KNMM\hLGNM\a"wypNGDl{IeVdORG~¸ KDPRYILO$ZDMhLM\rNa5PRl\M]SzZ/xiPkompNa«ILV«
fgP7hLVdP7IeMRM]heGQM\a\¸
ý
±FHGNMILPRRMYbPkrQheO@S@pQl=InRM\hLGNM]a
¸ ý É Ä Ê
$ü
Ç Ë ý ¸ ý É Ä Ê
$ü
Ç
Ä ý Ê
$üý
Ç ý Ë ý ý
ÿ
ü·
¸ É Ä Û Ê
$üÛ
Ç Û Ë ~y/
^nKNM]heM
Ç ý ~Ç
Ç ý =
KNMwyOa9adOg^nVdGNu$pDP7GIeadM=IHl\ORokrNp@ILM]YIj^`OR§S@VdokM\GQYeVdORGQPRaS@M\GQYeV9Ijx0M]YcIeVdo$PgILM]YnwyOh3S@V9¤[M]hc
M\GISNPgIvP0YeM=IvY3f/V5P$IeKQMwypNGQl=IeVdORG
*@Õ7ØQÕQÔgÖÙ
TQ^nKNM\hLMILKNMmM\hLGNM\a²VdYòPRpQYeYeV5P7GP7GDSIeKNM
ZQPRGQS@^nV5S/IeKlvKNOYeM\G¬P7hLZNV9IehvP7hLV9adx'IeOJ ¯NKNMYcpQhcwPl=MzO7wHMPRlvKZNV9fgPRheV5PgILMzS@M]GQYeV«Ijx
KNM0wypNGQl{ILV9OG à/ß
¨
N7Ø@ÖVNDK@ß^2
PRa9adOg^YpDYILOsuRM]GNM\hvPgILM0l=OGIeORpQhLYml=ORhLhLM]YerDOGQS@VdGNuIeO'P
ZNVdfgP7hLVdP7IeMS@M\GDYcV9Ijx)M]YcIeVdo$PgILMR
ÛQÞÒ@ßN×Rß/ãá,]àßN×RÙ9§UÞ
¨
,Rä
ÒUÞV4Ý
ß
W95
ß
X7Q
ß@ÝßVN
¦
Ô¢ácÒUÞV4Rä
*/Ýáá("×RâácÒUÞV4Rä
I
(²ÞØácÒ"ÞV47ä/ä .Pà7275
F+§S4Ý9*/ÕRØQÕQÔgÖÙ±ácÒUÞV4"Ó¤5.P5+QÓ,\àN×!KS,[Ó*[ä
¨
4Ýá4%3PQDä.ô¢("×âá¤FD§S4
1
ÓPT76Dä .à 45
à[Ô<4Ýàß
¨
NRØ@Ö^NDK@ßV2WáF+§%4UÓ
¨
4Rä
ÒUÞ!2Ý
ß
W95
¦ 4
*/Ýáá("×RâácÒUÞ!2Qä I (²ÞØácÒ"Þ!2Nä/ä .Pà7275
F+§/Ù@ßNÕ+*/Ý9*@ÕRØNÕQÔgÖÙ±ájÒUÞ2ÓP5/.¥57QÓ,]à/×DKS,[Ó*Dä
¨
2Ýá4%3PQDä.ô¢("×âá¤FD§/Ù/ßNÕD*
1
ÓT76Dä.¥à45
à[ÔAÙ@ßNÕ+*/Ýà/ß
¨
NRØ@ÖVNDK/ßV2á¤F!§/Ù/ß@Õ7*Ó
¨
2Dä
ÒUÞ!TÝ
ß
W95
¦ 2
*/Ýáá("×RâácÒUÞ!TQä
I
(²ÞØácÒ"Þ!2Nä/ä .Pà7275
F+§VF@×
¨
Ý9*@ÕRØQÕNÔgÖÙ±ácÒ"Þ!TWÓ¤5d.P57QWÓ-,\àN×KS,UÓ¥*[ä
¨
TÝá4%3PQDä.ô¢("×âá¤FD§VF/×
¨1
ÓT+6[ä .à<45
à[Ô!F@×
¨
Ýà/ß
¨
N7Ø@ÖVNDK@ß^2WáF+§9F@×
¨ Ó ¨ TDä
ÒUÞU@Ý
ß
W95
¦ T
*/Ýáá("×RâácÒUÞU[ä
I
(²ÞØácÒ"ÞUDä/ä .Pà7275
F+§
¨
NRØ/Ú@Ý9*@ÕRØNÕQÔgÖÙ±ájÒUÞ-U±ÓP5/.¥57QÓ,]à/×DKS,[Ó*Dä
¨
U@Ýá4%3PQDä.ô¢("×âá¤FD§
¨
NRØÚ
1
ÓT76Dä.¥à45
à[Ô
¨
NRØ/Ú@Ýà/ß
¨
NRØ@ÖVNDK/ßV2á¤F!§
¨
N7Ø@ÚÓ
¨
U"ä
*[ÞÔAÙ<2Ý
¨
ßNÕ/×RÖNÕ7*[ÞÔÙDÛ×ãWáô2WÓ2Dä
)
ÝDÔRÕÖ("×QÔ¡á
ß
W95
ß
W95WÓ-,ÛQÞ]ØNÕ,"Ó-,=ßNÕ7*,ä
Ô§<N
¦
á*[ÞÔAÙ<2WÓ-4UÓ-4UÓjà[ÔV4UÓ
) ä
Ô§<N
¦
á*[ÞÔAÙ<2WÓ-4UÓ¤2Ójà[ÔÙ@ß/Õ7*Ó
) ä
Ô§<N
¦
á*[ÞÔAÙ<2WÓ¤2Ó-4UÓjà[ÔF@×
¨ Ó ) ä
Ô§<N
¦
á*[ÞÔAÙ<2WÓ¤2Ó¤2Ójà[Ô
¨
NgØ@ÚÓ
) ä
ÔRÕÖ/àVN7Ù@Öá¤*[ÞÔAÙ<2Ó-4"Ó-4"Ó-,=Ö"ÞÖNÛÕ,UÓ,
a
Þ]ÚN×Rß"Þg×RÖNÕ±õNÕRØ[Ô@ÞAÖ/ã_[ÔAÖ"Þ("×Ö@Õ,UÓ
,]âQÛ×RÒNÕ@Û,UÓ-,
ß Ø ¨
N(DÕ á4O9W95QäV,UÓ-,]ãNÛ×RÒQÕ@Û ,UÓ,
ß Ø ¨
N("Õ á4O9X9QQäV,ä
ÔRÕÖ/àVN7Ù@Öá¤*[ÞÔAÙ<2Ó-4"Ó¤2WÓ-,=Ö"ÞÖNÛÕ,UÓ,2+õõNÕRØ[Ô@ÞAÖ/ã_DÔgÖ"Þ("×RÖNÕ,UÓ
,]âQÛ×RÒNÕ@Û,UÓ-,
ß Ø ¨
N(DÕ á4O9W95QäV,UÓ
,]ãQÛ×RÒNÕ@Û,UÓ-,J/ßNÕ7*[Þ
¨
Ö@Õ+*
ß Ø ¨
N("ÕÎÞ]Ø÷4O7X9Q,ä
ÔRÕÖ/àVN7Ù@Öá¤*[ÞÔAÙ<2Ó¤2WÓ-4"Ó-,=Ö"ÞÖNÛÕ,UÓ,2+õõNÕRØ[Ô@ÞAÖ/ã_DÔgÖ"Þ("×RÖNÕ,UÓ
,]âQÛ×RÒNÕ@Û,UÓ-,
ß Ø ¨
N(DÕ á4O9W95QäV,UÓ-,]ãNÛ×RÒQÕ@Û ,UÓ, H × ¨ Ö9Nß è
¨9¨
KD(VKDÛ×Ö"ÞNRØS,ä
ÔRÕÖ/àVN7Ù@Öá¤*[ÞÔAÙ<2Ó¤2WÓ¤2WÓ-,=Ö"ÞÖNÛÕ,UÓ,2+õõNÕRØ[Ô@ÞAÖ/ã_DÔgÖ"Þ("×RÖNÕ,UÓ
ß ¨ , é
Õ9N
¨
Û×QÔ/Ô/Þ
¨
×@ÛÒö^NRØ@Ú@Õß/àNÕRØ
¨
Õ,ä
à/ßVN
¦
*DÞÔgÖ.µâÙDÛ
KNMP7Z[OgfRMzpDP7GIeadM=Ika9MPRSNYmILO'·VduRpNhLMzºQ_KNMS@VdYerNa5PAxJV9GIeKNMpNrQrDM]hXadM=wI$Z[OA_VdY
IeKQMZNVdfgP7hLVdP7IeMS@M]GQYeV«IjxM]YcIeVdo$PgILMO7wr[M\hH^`Ohe/VdGNu7µP7uM r[M\hvYeORGVdGQl=OoXMYVdG_]R$PRGQS
]¯Ns}§w3okOYcImOZQYeM\hLfAP7IeVdORGQYml=OGQl=M]GILhLP7IeMzP7adORGNuILKNMz¯{ adVdGNMRTILKNM\G¬l=OpNGIehLV9MYVdG
IeKQM S@V5YcIehLV9ZNpNIeVdORG)hLM\o$P7VdG)^nKNM]heM3IeKNM]x)YjIvP7heIeMSUW}µG)heMP7adV«IjxTr[O/ORh~yhLVdlvK[ ±l\ORpNGIehLVdM]Y±SNO
l=OGQl=M]GIehvPgIeMbpNGQSNM\h3~EP7Z[OgfRM IeKQMn¯{adVdGNMRW¶ORIeMP7a5YeO3ILKQPgI^nKQP7IeM]fRM\hILKNMl=a5PRYLYO7w"V9G@
l=OokM±wyhLORo ^nKQVdlvKXPHl\ORpNGIehLxYcILP7heILYWS@V5YerNadPAx@YZ[O7IeKkl\P7ILlvKNVdGNuHpNrXPRGQSmadPRuRuRVdGNuHZDM]KNV9GDS
M]Yer[M]l=V5P7adadxs^nKNM]GPl\ORpNGILhex'YjIvP7heIeM]S'VdG'IeKNM)okV5SNS@adM)VdGQl=OoXM)l\adPYeY]iKQVdYl\ORhLheOZDOR
hvPgIeMYWIeKQMM\okM\hLuRM]GI£jIj^nVdG$rDMP7@Ye¥VdGkIeKQM3l=hLOYLYjµl=OpNGIehLxS@V5YjILheVdZNp@ILV9OG)S@O@l=pNokM\GILM]SUT
wyORhVdGQYcILP7GDl=MRT@Z/xiHpQPRKq~c]R =KNV5YnS@M]GQYcV9Ijx$M]YcIeVdo$PgILMPRadYeOml\ORhLheOZDOhLP7IeMYIeKQM Ml=OR
GNOoXV5lKNV5YjILORhLVdPRGYGNO7ILV9OGzORwWl\ORG/fRM]heuM\GQl\M l\a9pQZQYCNIeKQP7I3VdYO7wl=ORpQGILheVdM]Ynl]PgIvlvKNV9GQuXpQr
^nV9IeK$ORGQMPRGNO7ILKNM\h±ZNp@IORGQa9xm^nV«ILKNV9G$rDP7heIeV5l=pNa5P7hYepNZNuheOpNrQY]¢}§w"ORGNMnV5YcOadP7IeMYIeKNM¶3M\O7
l=a5PRYLYeVdl]P7al=OGfM\hLuRM]GQl=MmM=¤"M]l{IT¢ILKNM\G^bMkORZ@IvP7VdGsILKNM)S@M\GDYcV9IjxM]YcIeVdo$PgILM)S@VdYerNa5PAxRMSVdG
IeKQMHadOg^`M]hhLV9uKIbZDOAUW¶ORIeM KNOg^opQlvK$ILKNM uRhvP7rNK$hLO7IvPgIeMY±l\ORpNGIeM]hcµl=adO@lv/^nVdYeMRKNVdY
Vda9adpQYcIehvPgIeMYHPir[O7IeM]GIeV5P7awyORh rDO/Ohl\ORpNGILheVdM]YIeOzOgfRM\heILPRRMILKNhLORpNuKIeKNMk¶M]O@l=a5PRYLYcV5l\PRa
l=OG/fRM\hLuRM]GQl=MXM=¤"M]l=I]z}µGwPRl=I]T²IeKNM$Ij^nVdGJr[M]P7@YYLl=M]GQP7hLV9OPRheV5YcMYo$P7VdGNa9x'Z[M]l\PRpQYeM$O7w
S@V9¤[M]heM]GQl=MY V9GsIeKNMkPRl]l=pNompNadP7IeVdORGORw±hLM\rNhLO@S@pQl=VdZNadMwPl{IeOhLYX~YeM\MmIeKQMmadOg^`M]h3adM=wIS@V5Yj
rNa5PAxN { ã Og^bM\fRM]h]T7IeKNMokO@S@M]aDPRYV«IbVdYYer[M]l=V9QMS$S@O/M]YGQO7I±rNhLOgf/VdSNMPrDM]hcwyMl{INIbO7w[IeKNM
S@V5YjILheVdZNp@ILV9OGS@x/GQP7okV5l\YHPgI^bORhL0pNGQSNM\hILKNMr[M\hLV9O@SpNGDS@M\h YjILpQS@xR}µGrQPRhcILVdl\pNa5P7hTNV«I
S@O/M]Y3GNO7IP7ada9Og^ÎpQY3IeO)hLM]l\OgfRM]h3P7GQSzILO0M\/rQadPRV9GILKNMwyOheo$PgILV9OGO7wWIeKQMr[OgfRM\heIjx)ILhLPRr
VdGiILKNMhLM]P7aSNVdYcIehLV9ZQp@IeVdORG
ILV9adaET²l=ORpQGILM\hewPRl=IepQPRa¢VdGQl=OoXMkS@x/GQPRoXV5l\YPYHl\ORokrNp@ILM]SsPRGQSsPRGQP7adx/t\MSP7Z[OgfRMXP7ada9Og^
pQY²IeO rNhLOgf/VdS@M`M=@rNa5P7GQP7IeVdORGQY¢IeOHIeKQM`hLM\upNadPRheV9IeVdM]YlvKQPRhLPl{IeM]heVdt\VdGNunILKNMbM\fROa9pNIeVdORGORwNIeKNM
^bORhLadS0V9GQl\ORokMS@V5YjILheVdZNp@ILV9OG ¦ a9IeKNOpNuRKiIeKQVdYV5YnPGQM\^¨YcIeM]rV9GzpNGQS@M]hLYcILPRGQS@VdGNukl=hLOYLY
l=OpNGIehLxqrDPgIcILM\hLGQYORwuRhLOg^IeKTopDlvK_heM]o$P7VdGQYIeOqZDMzS@ORGQMR ¦ IXa9MPRYcI]TIeKNV5YXP7heIeV5l=adM
rNhLOgf/VdS@MYHPRGsM\/M]hLl\VdYeM^nKQVdlvK'P7ada9Og^YHpQY IeOYcIepQS@xIeKNMXheOa9MXO7wbYcr[M]l\V«DlmM=@rNa5P7GDPgIeOhex
wPRl=IeOhLY$VdG©M=@rNa5P7VdGNVdGNuJORZDYcM]hefM]SrQPgIeIeM\hLGQY$ORwl\heOYeYcµl=ORpQGILhexJVdGQl\ORokMsS@V5YjILheVdZNp@ILV9OG
S@x/GQPRoXV5l\Y]
Bivariate Density Estimate
0.7 0.8 0.9 1
Income (1960)
0.7 0.8 0.9 1
Income (1985)
2D Density Estimate
0.7 0.8 0.9 1
Income (1960)
0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
Factor Accumulation
2D Density Estimate
0.7 0.8 0.9 1
Income (1960)
0.7 0.8 0.9 1
predicted Income in 1985
2D Density Estimate
0.7 0.8 0.9 1
Income (1960)
0.7 0.8 0.9 1
Neoclassical Convergence
·V9upNhLMzºQ "`OGIeORpQhLYmO7w`VdfgP7hLVdP7IeM3M]GQYeV«Ijxh$`YjILV9o$P7IeM]Y]KQMi/µPg@V5YmV5YXIeKQMzr[M\h
^bORhLVdGNuR§PRuRMrDM]hLYeORGVdGQl=OokM±VdG)]RNKQM±x§P7@VdYUV5YhLM]Yer[M]l{ILV9fM\adx""IeKNM`rDM]h²^bORhL/V9GNuR
P7uMmr[M\hvYeORG'V9GQl\ORokMkV9G¬]¯q~ypNrQrDM]ha9M\wIv {T²IeKQMXrQheMS@Vdl=IeMSsVdGQl=OokMXVdG]¯~pNrNr[M\h
hLV9uKI{ {TQPRGQSiIeKNMhLM\a5PgILV9fMV9GQl\ORokMO7wWM]PlvKzl\ORpNGILhex0lvKDP7GNuM]SiORGNadxiS@pQMIeOkwPRl=IeOh3PRl=
l=pQopNa5PgILV9OGs~yadOg^`M]h±adM=wI{ ±PRGQSkIeOIeKNM ¶M]O/l\adPYeYeV5l\P7a[l=OGfM\hLuRM]GQl=MnM\¤[Ml{I ~a9Og^bM\h`heVduRKI{
^nV9IeKP7adaUM]l\ORGNOoXVdM]YnSNVdYerNa5PAxVdGNukPAfRM]hLPRuRM3Z[M\KDPAfVdORh à/ßVN
¦
*[ÞÔgÖ.§âÙDÛ
P7pNokOaET[|~j]R {´±heO@S@pQl=IeVdf/V«IjxzuRhLOg^IeKT"l=OG/fRM\hLuRM]GQl=MPRGQS^bM\a9wP7hLMR^nKQPgIHIeKNM
adORGNukhLpNGSNPgIvPXYeKNOg^T !#"$#%'&(¢~ ¯R =U]R ®"]R¯@
bVdPRGQlvKNVTnJH~c]R/7 =.¢MYjILV9GQuJwyORh0l\ORG/fRM]heuM\GQl\MRM]fV5S@M]GQl=MwyhLORo GNORGNrDP7hvP7okM=ILheV5l
ompNa«ILV9okO@SNPRa9V9Ijx$IeMYjIvY\T*)+,-./*10! 322./465.#789;:=<~ {NºRºg®N
HMza5P·NpNM]GIeMRT ¦ 3~c]¯R ="bPgIvlvK@§pNrTuheOg^ILKP7GDSl=OG/fRM\hLuRM]GQl=MiV9GIeKQMF&$'"bT
>?A@BDCEF9##,+969@2=#GHJIBKLMONÎ~¶OgfM\omZDM]hv =
HM]YLS@ORVdu7IvY\T ¦ ~j]7/ {å"`KQP7GQuRM]Y VdGILKNMk^`Ohea5SVdGQl=OoXMkS@V5YjILheVdZNp@ILV9OG ¦ GQORGNrQPRhLP7
okM=ILheV5l±PRrNrNhLOPlvKHILOHlvKQPRa9adM\GQuRMWIeKQMb¶3M\O@l=a5PRYLYcV5l\PRaRl=OG/fRM\hLuRM]GQl=MPRheupNokM\GI]T´±KQ
KNMYcV5Y]TV$pNhLORr[M]PRGi¹GQV9fM\hvYcV9Ijx)}µGQYcIeV9Iep@ILM=µ·a9OheM]GQl=MTVâRpNGQMR
HVQ¶3PRhLS@ODT!âQdTR·QORheIeVdGTR¶7_9TP7GQSX¸M]oXVdM\pN"TN~j]R {@¸¢PRZDOho$PRheM=IWV9GQYcIeV9IepNIeVdORGQY
PRGQS¬IeKNMS@V5YjILheVdZNp@ILV9OG¡O7w^P7uM]Y]T]7ºA®"]R @P_YeM\okVdrQP7hvP7okM\IehLVdlPRrNrNhLOPlvKT
.#78;(P~E¯R =U]N{®"]RRQ
HpNhea5P7pNwjT"""P7GDSqHpQP7K¢TDm[W~jRR {KNMGNM\^M]oXrQV9hLVdl]YORwuRhLOg^IeKTCHF9#,+99
@2=#RQSTU"9U7WV;10XYF9=9U=ZA[\J55F9#].5^S_-³~©âPRGpDP7hLx@ =
ãåäPRhLSNa9MT|s~jRQ { _$7U`-Ubadc6`-Te#,T9ZfXgU7h`ji!2./k7l78=9mUn_TZ
_2.Ubab#{TQ¶M]^poOhe"
ãåäPRhLSNa9MTb|bP7GQS©@l\O7IeI]Tn ~jR {¨@oXO/ORIeKNVdGNuJVdG©Zx^`M]V9uKI0PAfRM\hvP7uV9GQuspQYeV9GQu
hLORpNGDS@M]SirDOV9GIvY\TB>A!2.,-7q7W/*_7q7WF9789&UN/]®" 7Q
PRGN/V9^T/¶^òX9T/nOoXM]h]TdT@P7GQSk|'M\VdaT/m/¶"~j] { ¦ "`ORGILheVdZNp@ILV9OGkIeOILKNM3M]om
rNVdhLVdl]YO7wMl=ORGQORokVdluRhLOg^IeKTArs,T7l#/tVg)-,-./u10 .v9g:-w&~ R {D/]®
º/
´P7hL"TQ [¹[PRGQS²pNhLadPlvKTD ¦ W~j] {@´hvPRl=IeV5l\PRarDM]hcwyOheo$PRGQl=MORwYcM]fRM\hvP7a²SNPgIvP
S@hLVdfRM\GzZQPRGQS@^nV5S/IeKYeM\adM]l{ILORhvY\Tu>A!2.,-7q7W/?_7q7WF97W9H&Q R¯N{®N gQ
HpQPRKTN[~jRR {^nVdGzr[M]PR@Y\uheOg^ILKiP7GDSzl\ORG/fRM]heuM\GQl\M3VdGoXO@S@M]adYO7wSNVdYcIehLV«
ZNpNIeVdORGT3c`Tx.)-,-./y:-w.(U7¯A®[¯R¯N
/KNMPgILKNM\hTR"!âDAPRGQSjâROGNM]Y]TgJ+"HN~jRNA { ¦ heM]a9V5P7ZNadM`SQPgILP7ZDPRYeM]SZDP7GQS@^nV5S/ILKmYeM\adM]l{
ILV9OG)okM=IeKQO/S$wyORhbRM\hLGNM]aDS@M]GQYcV9IjxkM]YcIeVdo$PgIeVdORG¢T.)-,-/z10x7h`=!V/._7q7WF978/
_z$#7WV{ZB_#9x|~}²~º =QRºA®@RRQ
ILORGNMT7"HDâDN~j]7/ { ¦ G$PRYex/okr@IeORIeV5l\P7adadxORr@ILV9o$P7a@^nVdGQS@Og^YcM]a9Ml{IeVdORGXhLpNa9MbwyOhRM\hLGNM]a
S@M]GQYeV«Ijx)MYjILV9o$P7IeM]Y]T T/9H0x_7q7WF97W9:=<U 7¯®" 7//
)-,-/?09&wN¯®@7Q
²M\okrNadMRT%âDW~c]R =$±pNVdrNokM\GIHVdG/fRM]YcIeokM]GIP7GDSIeKQMk/Oa9Og^okO@S@M]aETA60O5 6
x@2=#9}wNºA®/ @