Demand for Money in the Selected OECD Countries: A Time Series Panel Data Approach and Structural Breaks

Munich Personal RePEc Archive

Demand for Money in the Selected

OECD Countries: A Time Series Panel Data Approach and Structural Breaks

Kumar, Saten and Chowdhury, Mamta and Rao, B.

Bhaskara

Auckland University of Technology

10 April 2010

Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/22204/

MPRA Paper No. 22204, posted 19 Apr 2010 17:58 UTC

! "

# $

% "

& & ' ⁽ )(*+ ) ,

% "

,

- #(" , (( ./$0

)

)1 , . , 1 )1 ,

,

! 0 2 3#.4

" # $++ /5(

($ ,

$% &

/ ) )

(678 ) ) ' ,

) 9

) 9 '

, , , ) : ;

) )

(678 3 ,

, ) )

$ - )

,,

, , ) )

) ^* 2 <

(678" ,, )

) , )

) ⁺

) )

) )

= , *885" 3 (66*" & *88(" '

*886 "⁵% 3 &

*> ,, ) ? . 3 (66+"

# 2 (66(" > (666" $ # *88@" *88+"

A , 2 , , ! (667" B C (66D? (66E" , $ , B 1

*88D" .= (6E+" & 4 ,, (66@"

+3 ) ,

) )

) ) - ) & 1. ' *88D" *886" '

*886)" & 1. B *886" F B *886"

)

5 *885" = #* #+ #5" , (E7+1*88( )

) 3 (66*"

#( , (6@8G(676 ) ) ) , =

(6E8 & < *88(" ) )

#( , (6E7 ) ) ) , = , (66@%

) , , '

) )

) , , , ) )

, ) ) H )

B ) , , 3 ,

(( ./$0

) )

% *88@" ./$0 , )

(678 (6E8 )

) ) - :

) =,

,

: ) ) )

) - , ,

, ) , , % )H , ,

) * ) , :

+ , ,

- , ) 5

D

'% ( ) !

,

, ) ,

, ? # *88+" C

*88+" > ) *885" B 1> = $ *88@" 4 $ *88@" 3

*886" 0 *887" / ) 1> )) *887" $ *88E"

C *88E" > > *88E" > *88E" ' *886)"

' *886" ; % *886"^D/ )

D ) (666 *88(" '

0 C > *885" , ,

, , ,

( * + I ("

it i i it i it it

M =α +α Y +α r ε

( * + I 5 *"

it i i it i it i it it

M =α +α Y +α r α E +ε

( * + I 5 D +"

it i i it i it i it i it it

M =α +α Y +α r α E +α π +ε

M Y r E

= π i t ) ,

8 "

it N i t

ε σ

) ( )

, % H ,

) B 1> = $

*88@" ) 8 * ) 0 *887" = ( 7 %

= , H ,

) ) =, , ,

./$0 =, ) ) ,

& , = )

) ) ) (

, # *88+" 0 *887" > > *88E"

3 *886" ; % *886" ) ./$0

# *88+" ,, , 0.4

#( , (6 ./$0 (6D7 (66@ %

, ( 8E 1

18 8* 3 *886" 2 < , 3#.4 < (666"

, 0.4 - = #* = $ / / ,

$//$" ; $; ' , ) > 2 '

, (6651*88+ ,

/ = / 0

*887" - , (66D J("1*885 J*" ,

- 2 *888? # *88+ & *88@"

$

* +

, ++ +

,

+ & & (

* +

B 1> =

$ *88@"

(6EE1(66E?

#8

*7 , ,

/- (? B## 8 (E8

@ E8"K 8 *88

* 88"K

18 885

* 68"K 18 88D

( 78"KK

$ <

(6D@"

0

*887"

(66D -("1

*885 -*"?

#*

(8 /

$

/- *? 2

# L

&

( 7+8

*( @+"K ( 658

(5 6*"K ( 7E8

(7 E8"K

18 868 5 D8"K 18 878

* ++"K 18 8@8

+ 88"K

:

/ /

) ) /

#

*88+"

(6D71(66@M

#(

(6 ./$0

$

/- (? 0.4 ( 876 5 86"K

18 8**

+ @7"K

%

8 E@8

> ) *885" (6761*888?

#( L #*

@ B$$

$

/- *? 2 8 7E8

(( 5E"K 8 5*8

D D*"K

18 8D8

* +@"K 8 8(8

8 ++"

' #(

)

#*

$ *88E" (65E1*88+?

#(

(D 4

$

/- (? 2 8 658

D8 *8"K

18 88E

(( 5+"K ,

4 C

*88+"

(6761(666?

#*

E

$

/- +? ' N N

,

) 8 + ( 5

'

*886)"

(6781*88D?

#(

(5

$

/- (? 2

# L

&

( (58

*8 E5"K 8 668

+* 88"K 8 6@8

@8 (6"K

18 8*8 D @8"K 18 8(8

* 7D"K 18 8(8

D *5"K

0 #(

)

' *886" (6781*887?

#(

((

$

/- +? B## ( (68 O8 88PK ( (@8 O8 88PK

18 D5+

O8 88PK 18 D(*

O8 88PK

=

#(

)

; %

*886"

*88+ -("1

*88E -+"?

#+

/ /- (? 0.4 ( @78

D 68"K

18 868 + (*"K

#+

> *88E" (6E81*88D

#( L #*

+D )1 /- (? 2 8 E@

+* 76"K ( 88

58 +7"K

18 8*8

@ @+"K 18 8(8

* 7@"K

# ,,

) ,

- 1 , K DQ : ' *886" ,1

- ) C *88+" , 0.4 B## B## '

, 0 . 4 - B ; # # B ; #

# ' : 1 , = , '

*886"

) #+" / ^@ ,

) ( 7+ ( 65

0 / /

) , ) ) /

> > *88E" #( #*

#+" 2 FMOLS A (666 #

*88@ (( / ⁷ ,

) ; % *886"

#+ / , 0.4 -

#+ ( @7 , *88+ *88E

, *88( ( *8 ,

=, ) ,

)

; , - 2 *885? # *88+

& *88@" ' *886)" M1 ,

(5 , (6781*88D : ,

#(

) ' *886" ((

, B## - (6781*887

$ ) ) 4 1 , (65E1

*88+ $ *88E" 2 , 3#.4

8 65 1 18 88E > *88E"

(6E81*88D 2 , 3#.4 #(

#* +D )1 ) 8 6

( #( #* , 1

=,

> )

, = , ' *886" # 1B

2 *88@" ) SGMM B

) H , ) ./$0

@ / $ , $; ' , ) / > 4 4 # 2

' , )

7 & 3 3 B : : 4 = )

2 ,

, : , , = ,

, ) ,

% *88@"

.% / +

% - (( ./$0 , (67DJ(1*88EJ5

$ A , : # = ,

; , )

, ) ) ^E

0 ) ,, = ,

) #(

% ) ; M Y r E π

, 4 4 $ *88* 44$" & *888" : 2

*88+ :2 " 03 3 χ^* 03" 22 3 χ^* 22" > *888"

, ) * )

M E 44$ :2 03 22 &

) 1 H DQ : >

) H * ) DQ 3 Y

r 1 ) DQ = ,

44$ (Q 3 π = , >

% = , >

) ) )

I(1) = , π > , ,, π 1

, , - ("

+"

- (" +" ) +

H , 7 ) )

E :3 % & ) , ) M1 (66E H ./$0

= , 3 B B : "

3 , ) :3 % &

'

/ ( $0123$4'55637

44$ & :2 03 22 >

M ^{8 +7D}

8 @5@"

8 5EE 8 @E7"

( @7*

8 6D+"

6 *57 8 6E8"

E *D+

8 668"

E 7E(

8 888"K

Y ^{1* +76}

8 886"K

+ +*8 8 666"

18 D76 8 *E("

*6 D+@

8 87E"KK

(6 75D 8 575"

(8 +7(

8 888"K

r 1* DD@

8 88D"K

18 5(5 8 +58"

18 (E7 8 5*@"

*5 D88 8 **("

(8 DD*

8 6D7"

(8 +8+

8 888"K

E ^{* 58E}

8 66*"

* 585 8 66*"

+ @@5 ( 888"

6 7E8 8 67*"

@ 65D 8 667"

E *E(

8 888"K

π 15 E5+

8 888"K

15 86*

8 888"K

1D 8DD 8 888"K

@* +6D 8 888"K

D8 77D 8 888"K

@ DE5 8 888"K

M

∆ ^{1(7 (68}

8 888"K

1E 8@(

8 888"K

1(5 785 8 888"K

(6D 6@5 8 888"K

(6* E(6 8 888"K

* E88 8 88+"K

Y

∆ ^{1(5 7*8}

8 888"K

17 5+6 8 888"K

1(+ @56 8 888"K

(7E 78(

8 888"K

(E+ *8*

8 888"K

+ +68 8 888"K

r

∆ ^{1(E 88+}

8 888"K

1(* 5(6 8 888"K

1(D ++6 8 888"K

*8@ +*+

8 888"K

*6@ D*7 8 888"K

5 (*@

8 888"K

E

∆ ^{16 8+7}

8 888"K

1( +*5 8 86+"KK

1E (++

8 888"K

(85 (+5 8 888"K

6E @68 8 888"K

D 85(

8 888"K

π

∆ ^{1(D (@5}

8 888"K

16 D(*

8 888"K

1(D (+*

8 888"K

*(E 8EE 8 888"K

7@( +*D 8 888"K

E 8@6 8 888"K

- M 2 ) ) , , K KK H

DQ (8Q , & *88D" 2 & *88D" ,

DQ . , ν , σ (" , σ ,

ρρ +" (8Q :

ADF , H

DQ ) ) (" +"

= ,

) ,

.

+ $0123$4'55637

' /

/- ( /- +

2 ν 1 18 777 1( 7E*KK

2 σ 1 1( (6@ 8 *+5

2 ρρ1 1( @6@KK 18 5EE

2 031 * E@DK + ++7K

B , σ 1 1@ 5E+K 1* +55K

B , ρρ1 1* E7@K 1( 6+5KK

B , 031 + *@DK + 7*@K

- M ) N8 (" K KK

, DQ (8Q

) 5 , , , ,

2 3#.4 ⁶ /

1 - (" +" )

DQ 8 E78 8 E*D ,

=, ) )

) ) - +" , =

: - +" = DQ

) . ) )

, , ,

7

+ $0123$4'55637

/- ( /- +

' / #

Y ^{8 E78}

58 *8"K

8 E*D +8 +6"K

r 18 8D5

(+ (E"K

18 8(*

(( 5*"K

E 18 8+8

* 6E"K

π 18 E8E

8 5+"

- 1 , K

DQ

7% & * (

% =

, (( ./$0 3 ) ,

./$0 (6@8 (678

, :

) ,

6/ , , , )

) , -

, % *88@" ) )

, ) D , ) , ⁽⁸

/=, ) )

) ,

./$0 ) (6E@J(

A , # = , " )

(6E8 ) >

2

8 $0123$4'55637

$ (" *" +" 5" D" @" 7" E" 6" (8" (("

&

0

(6E7 J+

(665 J*

(6E+

J*

(665 J*

(66(

J5

(6E+

J(

(6E7 J(

(6E5 J+

(6EE J(

(66@

J+

(6E@

J(

M ) , $ ) (" ((" = , ("

*" $ +" A , 5" D" : @" # = 7" E" , 6" (8"

; (*"

$ : ; " ) (668

) , )1 ,

) ) , , ,,

, 3 ) (6E@J( )

, : )1 , , (67DJ(1(6EDJ5

(6E@J(1*88EJ5 , ,

) ) :

) )

) )1 , (67DJ(1(6EDJ5

(6E@J(1*88EJ5 $ $

) (665J* )1 ,

(67DJ(1(665J( (665J*1*88EJ5

& )

=, )1 , : )

10 , ) , ) ) )

, ) +8

, (67D , # , )

) ) )1 ,

) , ,

) =, ) M1

, , ) )

, $ - ) =, )1 ,

)

) ) )

) - )

)1 , , )

)1 , , ) @

9

+ 4

2 1' )1 , 2 1' )1 ,

$

/ &

$

4 &

$ $

/ &

$

4 &

$ (67DJ(1

(6EDJ5

(67DJ(1 (6EDJ5

(67DJ(1 (665J(

(6E@J(1

*88EJ5

(6E@J(1

*88EJ5

(665J*1

*88EJ5

2 υ1

/- ( /- +

( @77KK 1( 7@7KK

* 876K 1+ 8(*K

( E66KK ( 8+6

1* 5D6K 1( **6

* +(+K

* 8@8K

1D (+EK 18 @**

2 σ1

/- ( /- +

1* 6(@K

* 8EEK

* (8+K + 5(@K

1( 58@

1+ 8++K

1( @EDKK 1* +65K

15 7(*K 18 *@+

1+ 6*5K 18 6E+

2 ρρ1

/- ( /- +

15 88DK 18 DD*

1+ 77EK

* 87@K

1@ (68K 1+ @65K

1( ((7 1( 78*KK

1( 8+5 1+ @66K

1( ((D 15 ((7K

2 031

/- ( /- +

+ DD8K

* (E6K

5 8E(K

* *+7K

15 5*7K 1* 5(+K

* ((+K

* @7DK

+ E(7K + 7@*K

* 8+5K

* 88@K B , σ1

/- ( /- +

1* 5*+K

* +E*K

1* 8D6K

* 575K

18 D+(

1( 6E7K

1+ *E8K 1+ +D*K

1+ *@@K

* 75EK

1D +87K 1( ED@KK B ,ρρ1

/- ( /- +

1+ 85@K 1( +(+

1( +8D 18 EDD

1D 6E(K 1* ED5K

1* +6DK 1* **(K

1* @87K 18 *E@

18 7DD 1( D5*

B , 031

/- ( /- +

* ((7K ( 6EEK

+ 77DK + 886K

1D (E6K 15 (E8K

* *E+K + *65K

* E7EK 1* *88K

* 8E@K + E@(K

- A , # = ,

) $ ) $ : ;

) N8 (" DQ (8Q ( 6@ ( @5 , K KK

, DQ (8Q

: )1 , H )

H DQ = , - +"

)1 , (665J*1*88EJ5 , υ, , σ , σ ,ρρ1

DQ , σ (8Q

, 03 D Q

, )1

, ,

)1 , )

) 7 =,

DQ = , +"

+" , 1 ,

) /

- (" )1 , " , 1 ,

8 6* 8 @@

) " 8 887 8 87D 3

) )1 , ) 3

) 8 E( 8 78

) 8 7( 8 @* )

8 885 8 86E 8 8(8 8 8D(

) , , , 1 ,

, 7 )

/ - +" ,,

. ) , =,

1

=

1

4 +

0 , C ) M #"

)1 ,

,

Y r E π

/- ( /- + /- ( /- + /- + /- +

$

(67DJ(1 (6EDJ5

8 6(@

*( 88"K

( 8((

(5 6E"K

18 887 (5 ++"K

18 88E (+ ++"K

18 (@@

* *@"K

18 (+5 ( *7"

(6E@J(1

*88EJ5

8 @D@

*+ *8"K

8 7ED (6 7*"K

18 87D (( 7D"K

18 8D*

(8 85"K

18 (DD ( 5E"

18 568 8 57"

/ &

$

(67DJ(1 (6EDJ5

8 E8D (5 *E"K

8 7@@

(* 55"K

18 885 (* (6"K

18 887 (8 6@"K

18 +85 + E8"K

18 (5(

8 *5"

(6E@J(1

*88EJ5

8 788 (+ E("K

8 @((

(8 @("K

18 86E 6 D6"K

18 8D6

@ D*"K

18 8ED ( @E"KK

18 6@D ( 77"KK 4 &

$

(67DJ(1 (665J(

8 78D ++ 7*"K

8 766

*5 7+"K

18 8(8 7 5("K

18 886

@ ED"K

18 8@*

( @D"KK

18 +5(

8 E*"

(665J*1

*88EJ5

8 @(@

(D E("K

8 7(D (* 85"K

18 8D(

@ 76"K

18 85(

7 65"K

18 8(+

+ (8"K

18 *7@

( D5"

- A , # = ,

) $ ) $ : ; 1

, K KK DQ (8Q ,

2%

, , , - 2 , 3#.4 "

#(" , (( ./$0

/ , , (67DJ( *88EJ5

,

%

. )1 ,

1 : =

, ,

)

, )

) & ,

, )1 , , )

) )1 ,

, ) ,

, )

,

) 2 ,, )

, ) ' -

) ) / , ) )

) ) ) H

,

:

YR ' B02 0 :3 1*886

RR (1+ , 0 :3 1*886

MR ' ,, 0 :3 1*886

ER ' = 0 :3 1*886

πR ' B02 0 :3 1*886

M

) B02

( * ( -

& 1. # B *886" S> )

<Journal of Economic Studies +@ *(@1*+D

& 1. # ' > *88D" S )

, <Applied Economics +7 77+176*

& & > *88D"Econometric Analysis of Panel Data $ M A % +

& 4 *88(" S 1 <Journal of Monetary

Economics 57 +(G55

& A *888" S , , & &

" / (D , ,

, < A : 2 ,, (@(1(7E

1111111111111111111111 *88@" S , ,,

, <Econometric Reviews *5 (D(G(7+

& A & 4 ,, , 3 (66@" S& ,’ Southern Economic Journal @+ 56@GD8@.

$ 2 (6D@" S , < : M 3 # / "

- $ 2 M $

$ , B # B 1 4 *88D" S3

<The Manchester School 7+ 7+717D+

$ $ *88E" S4 1 4 1 M

, ,, < ) ,MNN N N

0 $ ' >1/ ' & *887" S4 1 /

) = <Eastern European Economics,5D 7D165

0 A C C > 0 0 *885" S' ,

<Journal of Economics and Business D@ *571*7*

/ ) : 1> )) *887" S

< ) ,MNN )

3 A *886" S# $//$

/ <Applied Economics 5( (*D61(*@7

3 # (66*" S# ,

’American Economic Review E* 57*16*

B 1> = $ 4 *88@" S/ ,

T , *7 (6EE16E <Applied Econometrics and

International Development @ (1(D

> *888" S , <Econometric

Journal + (5E1(@(

> *88E" S/ , )1

<Economics Bulletin, (D (1(D

> > *88E" S0 / <Economic

Systems +* *751*E5

> ) *885" S# M , ,, <Applied

Economics Letters (( DD(1DDD

> (666" S# M , < )

,MNN ) ;N N , ,

: 2 # > F *88+" S , <Journal of Econometrics ((D D+175

$ (666" S , 1) ,

<Journal of Econometrics 68 (155

4 $1$ $ $ 2 *88@" S# ,

< )

4 4 $ 3 $ $ *88*" S , M ,

, , , <Journal of Econometrics (8E (1*5

# 0 *88@" S - ) ,

, M <Applied

Economics +E (DED1(D6*

# 1B 2 4 4 *88@" S: / U

,, 1 1 , ) , < >/: % 2 ,

85 / B : :

# $ 0 *88+" S$ ) , 0.4 1

<Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics @D @@D1@E8

# 2 (66(" S 1 $ )

) $ < ) ,MNN H,N N N N 1

A *88+" S 1 = A ,

<Journal of Policy Modeling *D +D61+7D

> *885" S (E7+1*88(M C '

<Cliometrica ( 5D1@(

. 0 3 4 (66+" S3

, , ! <Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking, *D *7+G6*

.= 4 (6E+" S3 )

M (6@+G(676 <Journal of Economic Studies (8 **15(

2 , , 2 ! B (667" S B M

, , , <The Manchester School @D 7(1E6

2 2 *888" S3 .4 ,

& & " (D , ,

, A : 2 ,, 6+1(+8

111111111111111111111 *885" S2 M , , , ,

, ,, 222 , <Econometric Theory,

+;D76G@*D

2 # > & A *88D" S , < 0

2 , (M / 5*N*88D 0 & ) 3

B

2 % (678" S , , ,

<Quarterly Journal of Economics E5 (671*(@

' & & *886 " S: ) U< )

,MNN , ) 1 N(D7(DN

111111111111111111111111111111111 *886)" S , ,,

<Economic Modelling *@ (8(*1 (8(7

' & & ; 2 *886" S0 M

B## , ,, ) < )

,MNN , N,N, N , , N(D8+8

; ' % B & *886" S# M

< ) ,MNN , N N, )

*88(" S , <IMF Staff

Papers, 47 ++5G+@D

111111111111111111111111111 (666" S M

, , 1 < :#3 % 2 ,

7%2N66N@5 % 0$M : # 3 "

# *886" S0 <Applied Economics,5( (*@61(*7@

C *88E" S4

12 M , , <Annals of Economics and

Finance 6 77168

C # *88+" S0 #* , M

, , < / 3 0 2 ,

(56 J M J "

C A 4 (66D" S: 42 1 ) U & / ,

0 ) H 65**

111111111111111 (66E" S# ) M , <Empirical

Economics *+ +E71588

% A *88@" S , , ) <

Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics @E (8(1(+*

F > B 21 *886" S ,

/ 1D <International Research Journal of Finance and Economics ++ (@E1(77