Canover-educationaccountforthepositiveassociationbetweeneducationandwithin-groupswageinequality?Anote Budria,Santiago MunichPersonalRePEcArchive

(1)

Munich Personal RePEc Archive

Can over-education account for the positive association between education and within-groups wage inequality? A note

Budria, Santiago

2005

Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/92/

MPRA Paper No. 92, posted 04 Oct 2006 UTC

(2)

! " # $

% ! " & '

( ! ! " &

% ) *

( ! ' + ( " &

( , "

- . % ( % $ "

!" #$%" & %

' / 0# 1 2 )* ( &(3443(445467

* /8 &7" !

" - % 0 %

% . * 9444(:94% 8 % * " * - ;:<5(395 =4< 4<<" 8 ,- ;:<5(395 =4< 4>4"

( - ! ? " "

(3)

'( &

. $ $

! !

/ ' % 599>% % 3445% * % 3443% 344>7" &

! @ $ + / %

344<% " ><=7- ' ! !

! $ ! %

! "

& ! ! '

"

% ,

$ ! ( " %

!

%

"

& ' , (

$ " & $ (

5" !

( ' 7 '

5 % A B ' /34447 ! '

( " 8 % ) /34447"

(4)

! 2 ! $ % 7

' 2 ! / ! % 599:% 5999%

0 B % 34447" & % , % $ (

% ( ' $

! "

& $ - (

! ! C &

! %

3"

& , ! (

" 3 $ (

$ " :

' " , "

%( #

& ' /34457

) * / )*7" &

! ' % , %

38 % /599D7% A /59997% * /34437 8 # (

! /344:7" * /344>% " :D<7 % E ( '

' 2 ! ' $ $ ! F"

(5)

' % " ' *

% $ !

! /* % 3443% 344>7"

! 56 D4% '

! 5< 64 '% " &

3%4D< "

& , ( ^:" 8

% ' + !

' + ' + 2 ! $ " % $

)*%

•

• !

" "

& $ ( / !

GH$ H% 34437"

57 @ ' ( + ' @ + ! !

$

:& ! - 2 ! % H % ' + ( "

8 % 0 B /34447"

(6)

37 @ $ + ' @ + ! ! $ ^>

:7 @ ( + ' @ + $

@ + $ % % , $

' 2 ! "

% @ ' ( +% @ $ +

@ ( + ' % % 5D"D% >3": 3<"5 "

( ) )

! $ $ " &

%

#" , % ""

, !

% % " & ,

@ +^<"

> ( ' %

$ , "

< )* ! " &

0(9= /I 0% 344:7"

7 5 /

$

""

$

#"

%

#"

%

&_' + _'( + _' + _'( + _' + _'

=

(7)

& , (

%

"" % % (

D"

- ' ( / 57%

$ / 37 ( / :7"

8 5 3 $

=" & , " &

! % (

" '%

$ "

% , % $ (

! "

(((((((((( 8 5 3 ! ((((((

& % & ! 5 3 !

$ " 1 $

D & ( B B

/59697% 0 B /34447 /344:7"

=1 % " "%

% % " ! "

/37

$

""

$

""

$

#"

%

#"

%

&_' + _'( + _' + _'( + _' + _'* + _') + _'

=

(8)

( " & % , % "94("54 % ":3>

% ">6: 5% "::: 3%

"3=: :" & ! %

( % ! ⁶"

(((((((((( & ! 5 3 ! ((((((

& & ! 5 3 ( 8( $

$ " % $

( "

% ! (

, "

I %

$ (

" % % $

! ' ! ! ( "

$(

.

! " # $

% ! "

61 % ( 2 " & (

8( 4"44 5% 4"44 3% 4"4> :"

(9)

& ' !

( (

" & , ' %

! " , ! " !

% ! ' ( 2 ! %

" "% ! ⁹" , $ %

( !

$ $ ! "

% $

+ $ !

'

* "

*

& ! 5

IJ $

+ , θK"54 θK"34 θK":4 θK">4 θK"<4 θK"D4 θK"=4 θK"64 θK"94

& .& .L (!-!^... "==D^... "6>6^... "6=6^... "9D:^... 5"44:^... 5"4:6^... 5"4=4^... 5"4=9^... 5"544^...

/"4>=7 /"5337 /"4D=7 /"4<:7 /"4>97 /"4<67 /"4>:7 /"4>:7 /"4><7 /"4D>7

** . I10 .L ($/%^... "363^... ":46^... "::>^... ":6=^... ":96^... ">5:^... ">53^... ">59^... ":69^...

/"4:57 /"4=37 /"4>=7 /"4>>7 /"4:>7 /"4:47 /"4397 /"4::7 /"4:>7 /"4>97

1 - 7^... 5M N 7 IJ ' ( ! N 7 $

! <44 "

9 /34457 " & % " &

! % ! ( 2 ! %

% , "

(10)

& ! 3

IJ $ 5

& .& .L (!$%^... "D63^... "6>D^... "6>:^... "9<6^... 5"4=9^... 5"4>4^... 5"49D^... 5"4=D^... 5"5D<^...

/"4=<7 /"5957 /"5547 /"4=67 /"49:7 /"46D7 /"4D47 /"4D>7 /"4=D7 /"5557

** . I10 .L ( !'^... "593^... "3>>^... "3>6^... ":43^... ":3D^... ":5:^... ":3D^... ":46^... ":4>^...

/"4:=7 /"49:7 /"4:97 /"4>=7 /"4>=7 /"4:D7 /"4>>7 /"4:<7 /"4<>7 /"4DD7

1 - 7^... 5M N 7 IJ ' ( ! N 7 $

! <44 "

& ! :

IJ $ 3

& .& .L (!00^... "===^... "6>6^... "69<^... "9<D^... 5"4:4^... 5"4><^... 5"4D6^... 5"4=6^... 5"554^...

/"4>97 /"53=7 /"4=<7 /"4<:7 /"4>D7 /"4<67 /"4>37 /"4>37 /"4>=7 /"4D=7

** . I10 .L (-$/^... ":<3^... ":95^... ">34^... "><3^... ">=>^... ">DD^... ">=D^... ">><^... ">:5^...

/"4::7 /"4D67 /"4<D7 /"4>>7 /"4:47 /"4:>7 /"4:47 /"4::7 /"4:D7 /"4>=7

1 - 7^... 5M N 7 IJ ' ( ! N 7 $

! <44 "

& ! >

IJ $ :

& .& .L (!1$^... "6><^... "6>6^... "94D^... "96=^... 5"4:3^... 5"4>3^... 5"464^... 5"496^... 5"556^...

/"4>97 /"5337 /"4D:7 /"4D37 /"4>97 /"4<67 /"4>67 /"4>D7 /"4>97 /"4D=7

** . I10 .L (-'/^... ":3<^... ":3>^... ":<<^... ">4<^... ">55^... ">:=^... ">>=^... ">>9^... "><>^...

/"4:>7 /"4=<7 /"4<57 /"4<47 /"4:67 /"4:>7 /"4:<7 /"4:67 /"4:97 /"4<47

1 - 7^... 5M N 7 IJ ' ( ! N 7 $

! <44 "

2

! % " /599:7% J ! ' " I C%

! + 36% 3<9 3=6"

(11)

! % " " GH$ H /34437% & O ! % I % J !

! % P % 8"% " A " / 7%,

- " . / 0 1 2 / * ! %

% Q7

% I"% Q" ) ' #" ( /34457% )

. - B ! R . &

0 %- " - 3D/57% =(>4"

' % " /599>7% # 59D:(596=-

R . %- D3% >4<(><6"

% " /344:7% ( %- =4% <49(<:5"

0 % *" " B /34447% & (

Q ! ' %- - + 59% 5=9(96"

8 % O" ." # ( ! /344:7% . 8

I & C%3 - 54/57% =:(69"

A % 8"% " " B /59997%, 4 5 6 /

/ " % * % J %

5(<>"

A % #" )" B ' /34447% I J ! ' - (

%- - + 59% 5>9(5<6"

% O" O" /34457% * 5963(599>-

$ %- " - 3D% 55< 5:>"

(12)

% O" O" /344<7% 0 #

0 ! R . % 7"" - 34/>7%

>><(>D<"

% " /599D7% # $ Q%,# + - 2 %

53/57% >=(D>"

I 0 /344:7%,-/ - 8 , :-

344: " I 0- * "

* % *" *" /34437% . (. ' J ' % -

3 =<% :5 :="

* % *" *" /344>7% 0 . # $ C R

. 8 % 3 - %

55/:7% :<<(:=5"

% *"O"% )" *"&" /59997% I ( % J ! 8 %7"" - :5/557% 5>:= 5><:"

B % ." 1"&" B /59697% & -

% ! + 3>% D39(D9<"

(13)

3

& ! 5

0 $ &

"94 "54 "94 "<4 "<4 "54 "=4 ":4 "=4 "<4 "<4 ":4 8( ^{/ 7}

/ ( 7

& 10 .0 I0 J ":3> "49= "33= "593 "4D= "53< "45D

I0 J # &) I1&.IJ 5 ">6: "46D ":9= "3<: "45= "3:D "45>

I0 J # &) I1&.IJ 3 "::: "464 "3<: "5=: "4:6 "5:< "449

I0 J # &) I1&.IJ : "3=: "46D "56= "5=> "4>6 "53D "453

1 - / 7 & 8( $ /"54% "34%S% "947 "

*( T 4"4<- <M N ( T 4"45- 5M "

& ! 3

0 $

"94 "54 "94 "<4 "<4 "54 "=4 ":4 "=4 "<4 "<4 ":4 8( ^{/ 7}

/ ( 7

& 10 .0 I0 J "5:= "435 "55D "4=6 "45> "4D> ":45

I0 J # &) I1&.IJ 5 "553 "433 "5:> "4=6 "444 "4=6 "334

I0 J # &) I1&.IJ 3 "4=6 ("4>: "533 "4<D "444 "4<> "3>6

I0 J # &) I1&.IJ : "53> "4:6 "46D "493 "4:D "4<D "5=5

1 - / 7 & 8( $ /"54% "34%S% "947 "

*( T 4"4<- <M N ( T 4"45- 5M "

(14)

4

8 5

IJ $

0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90 1.00 1.10 1.20

OLS 10q 20q 30q 40q 50q 60q 70q 80q 90q

Standard model Model with Control 1 Model with Control 2 Model with Control 3

8 3

IJ $

0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50

OLS 10q 20q 30q 40q 50q 60q 70q 80q 90q

Standard model Model with Control 1 Model with Control 2 Model with Control 3