7KRPDV %UlXQLQJHU
,QWHUQDWLRQDOH
,QVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLN
'LH :DKO YRQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ IU GLH
~1eeresbodenbehörde&DPSXV 9HUODJ )UDQNIXUW,1HZ <RUN
Zuerst ersch. im Campus-Verlag, Frankfurt am Main, 2000. - ISBN 3-593-36631-2
Konstanzer Online-Publikations-System (KOPS)
URN: http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:bsz:352-opus-79935 URL: http://kops.ub.uni-konstanz.de/volltexte/2009/7993/
,QKDOW
$EELOGXQJV XQG 7DEHOOHQYHU]HLFKQLV 9RUZRUW GHU +HUDXVJHEHU
9RUZRUW GHV $XWRUV
.DSLWHOO
3UREOHPH LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU ,QVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLN 'LH 1HXRUGQXQJ GHV 0HHUHVERGHQV
,QWHUQDWLRQDOH .RRSHUDWLRQ XQG ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ (LJHQVFKDIWHQ YRQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ 9HUHLQEDUXQJHQ EHU (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ $XIEDX GHU $UEHLW
.DSLWHO
'LH LQKDOWOLFKHQ ,QWHUHVVHQ GHU 6WDDWHQ DP 7LHIVHHEHUJEDX
$NWHXUH XQG ,QWHUHVVHQ
'LH 9HUUHFKWOLFKXQJ GHU 0HHUHVERGHQQXW]XQJ
5HFKWOLFKH XQG ZLUWVFKDIWOLFKH $XVJDQJVODJH 6FKHLWHUQ LP HUVWHQ 9HUVXFK GLH 'ULWWH 6HHUHFKWVNRQIHUHQ]
(UIROJ LP ]ZHLWHQ 9HUVXFK GLH 1HZ <RUNHU 9HUHLQEDUXQJ
(LQ |NRQRPLVFKHV 0RGHOO GHV 7LHIVHHEHUJEDXV
0DUNWOLFKHV XQG VWDDWOLFKHV 2UGQXQJVPRGHOO
9RONVZLUWVFKDIWOLFKH $XVZLUNXQJHQ
'UHL 5HJHOXQJVJHJHQVWlQGH GHV 7LHIVHHEHUJEDXV :LUWVFKDIW XQG 3ROLWLN ]ZHL .RQIOLNWVWUXNWXUHQ
'LH ZLUWVFKDIWOLFKH 6LWXDWLRQ GHU 6WDDWHQ 'LH SROLWLVFKH 6LWXDWLRQ GHU 6WDDWHQ 'LH LQKDOWOLFKHQ ,QWHUHVVHQ
HLQH ZLUWVFKDIWOLFKSROLWLVFKH .RQIOLNWVWUXNWXU $EOHLWXQJ GHU 6WDDWHQSRVLWLRQHQ
hEHUSUIXQJ GHU +\SRWKHVHQ 3URJQRVH YRQ 6WDDWHQSRVLWLRQHQ
.DSLWHO
5HJHOQIU GLH 0HHUHVERGHQQXW]XQJ
'LH 9HUKDQGOXQJVHUJHEQLVVH LP 9HUJOHLFK 3RVLWLRQV XQG 5HSUlVHQWDWLRQVUHJHOQ
.RPSHWHQ] 3UR]HGXUDO XQG $EVWLPPXQJVUHJHOQ 'LH 0HQJH DOWHUQDWLYHU 5HJHOQ
$JHQGD6HW]XQJ
.DSLWHO
'LH *HVWDOWXQJ YRQ 5HJHOQ
'LH %HGHXWXQJ LQVWLWXWLRQHOOHU 5HJHOQ
$QVlW]H ]XU (UNOlUXQJ LQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQ :DQGHOV .RQ]HSWLRQ GHU :DKO YRQ 5HJHOQ
.DSLWHO
'LH (UNOlQPJ LQVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLVFKHU (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ
([NXUV 5lXPOLFKH 0RGHOOH NROOHNWLYHU (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ 'DV 0HGLDQZlKOHUWKHRUHP
4XDOLIL]LHUWH 0HKUKHLWHQ (LQVWLPPLJNHLW XQG GHU 6WDWXV TXR
0HKUNDPPHUUHJHOQ Agenda~Setzung
=XVDPPHQIDVVXQJ
'LH 0RGHO,LHUXQJ LQVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLVFKHU (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ 6WXIH 'LH %LOGXQJ YRQ 5HJHOSUlIHUHQ]HQ 6WXIH 'LH $JJUHJDWLRQ YRQ 5HJHOSUlIHUHQ]HQ 3DUDPHWHU GHU 5HJHOZDKO
$SSUR[LPDWLRQVPRGHOO GHU :DKO YRQ 5HJHOQ 0RGHOOYHUJOHLFK
.DSLWHO
'LH 9HUKDQGOXQJ GHV 0HHUHVERGHQUHJLPHV
'LH %HZHUWXQJ DOWHUQDWLYHU 5HJHOQ
3LYRWDOH $NWHXUH XQG (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ XQWHU 5HJHOQ (UZDUWXQJVQXW]HQ DXV 5HJHOQ XQG 5HJHOSUlIHUHQ]HQ
9HUlQGHUXQJ GHU 5HJHOSUlIHUHQ]HQ
9RP .RQVHQV ]XP 0HKUNDPPHUSULQ]LS
6FKHLWHUQ XQG (UIROJ
(IIL]LHQ] XQG )DLUQHVV GHU 5HJHOZDKO
%HZHUWXQJ GHU (UJHEQLVVH
.DSLWHO
,QVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLN LQ LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ 9HUKDQGOXQJVV\VWHPHQ
%HVFKUlQNWH 8QVLFKHUKHLW
,QWHUHVVHQDXVJOHLFK GXUFK 0HKUNDPPHUV\VWHPH
$QKDQJ
/LWHUDWXUYHU]HLFKQLV
6DFKLQGH[
$EELOGXQJV XQG 7DEHOOHQYHU]HLFKQLV
$EELOGXQJ 'DV 0HKUNDPPHUSULQ]LS LP 5DW GHU %HK|UGH
$EELOGXQJ 5HLQHV .RRUGLQDWLRQVVSLHO XQG UHLQHV .RQIOLNWVSLHO
$EELOGXQJ 6HFKV LGHDOW\SLVFKH 9HUKDQGOXQJVVLWXDWLRQHQ
$EELOGXQJ 1LFKW.RRSHUDWLRQ LP *HIDQJHQHQGLOHPPD
$EELOGXQJ .RRSHUDWLRQ GXUFK ,QVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUXQJ
$EELOGXQJ (UNOlUXQJVVFKHPD LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU
9HUHLQEDUXQJHQ EHU (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ
$EELOGXQJ 6HHUHFKWOLFKHV .RQIOLNWGUHLHFN
$EELOGXQJ 0DUNWJOHLFKJHZLFKW PLW XQG RKQH 7LHIVHHSURGXNWLRQ
$EELOGXQJ 0DUNWJOHLFKJHZLFKW EHL 0HQJHQEHVFKUlQNXQJ
$EELOGXQJ 0DUNWJOHLFKJHZLFKW EHL 0HQJHQVWHXHU
$EELOGXQJ :LUWVFKDIWOLFKH .RQIOLNWVWUXNWXU
YRQ 6WDDWHQ
$EELOGXQJ 3ROLWLVFKH .RQIOLNWVWUXNWXU YRQ 6WDDWHQ
$EELOGXQJ .RQIOLNWVWUXNWXU YRQ 6WDDWHQ EH]JOLFK
GHU GUHL 5HJHOXQJVJHJHQVWlQGH
$EELOGXQJ 6WDELOLWlW LP =ZHLNDPPHUV\VWHP
$EELOGXQJ +LHUDUFKLH LQVWLWXWLRQHOOHU 5HJHOQ
$EELOGXQJ =ZHL6WXIHQ.RQ]HSWLRQ GHU :DKO
YRQ 9HUIDKUHQVYRUJDEHQ
$EELOGXQJ *OHLFKJHZLFKW EHL HLQIDFKHU 0HKUKHLW
$EELOGXQJ *OHLFKJHZLFKWH EHL 9LHUIXQIWHO0HKUKHLW
XQG (LQVWLPPLJNHLW
$EELOGXQJ *OHLFKJHZLFKW EHL =ZHLGULWWHO0HKUNDPPHUUHJHO
$EELOGXQJ *OHLFKJHZLFKW EHL HLQIDFKHU 0HKUKHLW
XQG $JHQGD6HW]HU
$EELOGXQJ 7HLOVSLHOSHUIHNWH *OHLFKJHZLFKWH
$EELOGXQJ (QWVFKHLGXQJVEDXP YRQ (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ
EHU XQG XQWHU 5HJHOQ
$EELOGXQJ 2UJDQLVDWRULVFKHU $XIEDX GHU 0HHUHVERGHQEHK|UGH
$EELOGXQJ $OWHUQDWLYH 5HJHOQ LQ 9HUVDPPOXQJ XQG 5DW
$EELOGXQJ (QWVFKHLGXQJVEDXP GHU 9HUIDKUHQVYRUJDEHQ
$EELOGXQJ 3LYRWDOH $NWHXUH GHU 9HUVDPPOXQJ
$EELOGXQJ 3LYRWDOH $NWHXUH GHV 5DWHV
EHL *UXSSHQUHSUlVHQWDWLRQ
$EELOGXQJ 3LYRWDOH $NWHXUH GHV 5DWHV EHL *UXSSHQ
UHSUlVHQWDWLRQ XQG =ZHLGULWWH0HKUNDPPHUUHJHO
$EELOGXQJ *OHLFKJHZLFKWH LQ GHU 9HUVDPPOXQJ
$EELOGXQJ *OHLFKJHZLFKWH LP 5DW EHL *UXSSHQUHSUlVHQWDWLRQ
$EELOGXQJ *OHLFKJHZLFKWH LP 5DW EHL *UXSSHQUHSUlVHQWDWLRQ
XQG 0HKUNDPPHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ
$EELOGXQJ (UZDUWXQJVQXW]HQ GHU 6WDDWHQ DXV 5HJHOQ
$EELOGXQJ (UZDUWXQJVQXW]HQ GHU 6WDDWHQ DXV 5HJHOQ
$EELOGXQJ '\QDPLVFKH 9HUKDQGOXQJHQ
$EELOGXQJ (IIL]LHQ] XQG )DLUQHVV GHU 5HJHOZDKO
$EELOGXQJ 6LFKHUKHLW XQG 8QVLFKHUKHLW
EHL GHU (UZDUWXQJVELOGXQJ
7DEHOOH /DQGSURGXNWLRQ YRQ 0HWDOOHQ
7DEHOOH .RQVXP YRQ 0HWDOOHQ
7DEHOOH 9RONVZLUWVFKDIWOLFKH %HGHXWXQJ GHU 0HWDOO
SURGXNWLRQ XQG 0HWDOONRQVXPWLRQ
7DEHOOH 7HFKQRORJLVFKHU (QWZLFNOXQJVVWDQG
XQG (QWZLFNOXQJVKLOIH
7DEHOOH 0DFKWSROLWLVFKH 6LWXDWLRQ
XQG SROLWLVFKH 6\VWHPW\SHQ
7DEHOOH 9HUWHLOXQJ GHU 6WDDWHQSRVLWLRQHQ EH]JOLFK
GHU GUHL 5HJHOXQJVJHJHQVWlQGH
7DEHOOH 6WDDWHQSRVLWLRQHQ QDFK ZLUWVFKDIWOLFKHQ
*UXSSHQ
7DEHOOH 9DULDEOHQ GHU PXOWLYDULDWHQ $QDO\VH
GHU 6WDDWHQSRVLWLRQHQ
7DEHOOH 'HWHUPLQDQWHQ GHU 6WDDWHQSRVLWLRQHQ
OLQHDUH 5HJUHVVLRQ
7DEHOOH hEHUSUIXQJ GHU +\SRWKHVHQ ]XU %LOGXQJ GHU
6WDDWHQSRVLWLRQHQ
7DEHOOH :LUWVFKDIWOLFKH %HGLQJXQJHQ PDFKWSROLWLVFKH
6LWXDWLRQ XQG SROLWLVFKH 6\VWHPW\SHQ
7DEHOOH 9HUWHLOXQJ GHU SURJQRVWL]LHUWHQ 6WDDWHQSRVLWLRQHQ
]X GHQ 5HJHOXQJVJHJHQVWlQGHQ
7DEHOOH $QVlW]H ]XU (UNOlUXQJ GHU :DKO
YRQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ LP 9HUJOHLFK 7DEHOOH .RPSHWHQ] XQG $EVWLPPXQJVUHJHOQ
GHU 9HUVDPPOXQJ
7DEHOOH .RPSHWHQ] XQG $EVWLPPXQJVUHJHOQ GHV 5DWHV
7DEHOOH (UZDUWXQJVQXW]HQ GHU 6WDDWHQ
7DEHOOH 5HJHOSUlIHUHQ]HQ GHU 6WDDWHQ
7DEHOOH 5HJHOSUlIHUHQ]HQ GHU 6WDDWHQ QDFK
ZLUWVFKDIWOLFKHQ *UXSSHQ
7DEHOOH %HREDFKWHWH 5HJHOSUlIHUHQ]HQ GHU 6WDDWHQ
7DEHOOH (UZDUWXQJVQXW]HQ GHU 6WDDWHQ
7DEHOOH 5HJHOSUlIHUHQ]HQ GHU 6WDDWHQ
7DEHOOH (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ GHU GUHL 5HJLPH
7DEHOOH %HZHUWXQJ GHU GUHL 5HJLPH
7DEHOOH 6WDDWHQ PLW QHJDWLYHP 1HWWR(UZDUWXQJVQXW]HQ
EH]JOLFK HLQHP GHU GUHL 5HJHOXQJVJHJHQVWlQGH 7DEHOOH $OWHUQDWLYH /|VXQJHQ GHV $XVZDKOSUREOHPV
9 RUZRUW GHU +HUDXVJHEHU
'HU YRUOLHJHQGH %DQG GHU 6FKULIWHQUHLKH EHKDQGHOW HLQ 7KHPD GHU LQWHUQD WLRQDOHQ .RRSHUDWLRQ GHU 6WDDWHQ :LH NDQQ PDQ GLH (LQLJXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ ,Q GXVWULH XQG (QWZLFNOXQJVOlQGHUQ DXI HLQH LQWHUQDWLRQDOH 0HHUHVERGHQEHK|U GH ]XU 5HJHOXQJ GHV 7LHIVHHEHUJEDXV WURW] JURHU ,QWHUHVVHQXQWHUVFKLHGH HUNOlUHQ" 'HU $XWRU HQWZLFNHOW GD]X HLQH SRVLWLYH SROLWLVFKH 7KHRULH GHU ,Q VWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLN XQG ZHQGHW VLH HPSLULVFK DXI GLH LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ 9HUKDQG OXQJHQ DQ GLH ]XU 6HHUHFKWVNRQYHQWLRQ XQG ]X HLQHU 'XUFKIXK UXQJVYHUHLQEDUXQJ IXKUWHQ GLH GLH 0HHUHVERGHQEHK|UGH HUVW DUEHLWVIDKLJ PDFKWH )KUHQGH ,QGXVWULHVWDDWHQ ZLH GLH 86$ *UREULWDQQLHQ XQG GLH
%XQGHVUHSXEOLN 'HXWVFKODQG VDKHQ VLFK QLFKW LQ GHU /DJH GHU 6HHUHFKWVNRQ YHQWLRQ ]X]XVWLPPHQ 0LW GHU 'XUFKIXKUXQJVYHUHLQEDUXQJ ZXUGH KLQJHJHQ HLQH .RQVHQVO|VXQJ JHIXQGHQ GLH GLHVH 6WDDWHQ DN]HSWLHUHQ NRQQWHQ 'LH (LQLJXQJ ZXUGH ZHVHQWOLFK GXUFK GLH (LQIXKUXQJ HLQHV 0HKUNDPPHUSULQ]LSV HUUHLFKW GXUFK GDV GLH 0DMRULVLHUXQJ YRQ 6WDDWHQ PLW JHPHLQVDPHQ ZLUW VFKDIWOLFKHQ ,QWHUHVVHQ DP 7LHIVHHEHUJEDX YHUKLQGHUW ZHUGHQ NDQQ RKQH GDVV DXI GDV IXU 2EVWUXNWLRQHQ HLQ]HOQHU 6WDDWHQ DQIDOOLJH (LQVWLPPLJNHLWVSULQ]LS ]XUFNJHJULIIHQ ZHUGHQ PXVV
'HU 9HUIDVVHU HQWZLFNHOW HLQH =ZHLVWXIHQWKHRULH ]XU (UNOlUXQJ GHU (LQL JXQJ DXI LQWHUQDWLRQDOH $ENRPPHQ EHL IROJHQGHU $XVJDQJVVLWXDWLRQ 'LH 6WDDWHQ N|QQHQ NHLQHQ 9HUWUDJ ]XU DEVFKOLHHQGHQ 5HJHOXQJ GHU VDFKSROLWL VFKHQ 7KHPHQ VFKOLHHQ XQG PVVHQ VLFK GDKHU DXI 5HJHOQ IXU NQIWLJH (QW VFKHLGXQJHQ HLQLJHQ 'LH 6WDDWHQ YHUKDQGHOQ QLFKW XQWHU HLQHP 6FKOHLHU GHU 8QZLVVHQKHLW VRQGHUQ KDEHQ 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ EHU LKUH ZDKUVFKHLQOLFKHQ NQIWLJHQ ,QWHUHVVHQ 'LHVH ,QWHUHVVHQ GHU 6WDDWHQ VLQG QLFKW JOHLFK VRQ GHUQ YHUVFKLHGHQ VR GDVV ,QWHUHVVHQNRQIOLNWH YRUSURJUDPPLHUW VLQG 'LH (LQLJXQJ DXI 5HJHOQ PXVV GXUFK 9HUKDQGHOQ KHUJHVWHOOW ZHUGHQ VR GDVV VLH
QXU ]XVWDQGH NRPPW ZHQQ NHLQ 6WDDW JHJHQEHU GHP 6WDWXV TXR VFKOHFKWHU JHVWHOOW ZLUG
'HU 9HUIDVVHU PXVV GLHVH 7KHRULH QLFKW DE RYR HQWZLFNHOQ (U NDQQ DXI GHU 7KHRULH OHJLVODWLYHQ (QWVFKHLGHQV RGHU DXFK DXI GHU |NRQRPLVFKHQ 9HU IDVVXQJVWKHRULH DXIEDXHQ 'RFK NHLQH GLHVHU 7KHRULHQ OlVVW VLFK DXI GLH EH VRQGHUH 6LWXDWLRQ GHU LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ ,QVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLN LQ HLQHP EHVWLPP WHQ HQJ EHJUHQ]WHQ *HELHW DQZHQGHQ ,Q VROFKHQ 6LWXDWLRQHQ NRPPW HV HQW VFKHLGHQG GDUDXI DQ GDVV GLH 5HJHOSUlIHUHQ]HQ GHU $NWHXUH DXV LKUHQ LQKDOW OLFKHQ ,QWHUHVVHQ DEOHLWEDU VLQG GDVV GLHVH $EOHLWXQJ GLH XQVLFKHUHQ 5DQGEH GLQJXQJHQ EHL GHU ([WUDSRODWLRQ LQ GLH =XNXQIW DQJHPHVVHQ EHUFNVLFKWLJW XQG GDVV VFKOLHOLFK GLH NROOHNWLYH (QWVFKHLGXQJ DOV 9HUKDQGOXQJVHUJHEQLV HUNOlUEDU VHLQ PXVV
)U GLH HPSLULVFKH hEHUSUIXQJ GHU 7KHRULH VLQG JOWLJH XQG ]XYHUOlVVLJH
$QJDEHQ EHU GLH 3RVLWLRQHQ GHU 6WDDWHQ ]X GHQ 9HUKDQGOXQJVJHJHQVWlQGHQ ]HQWUDO 'HU $XWRU JUHLIW GDEHL HLQHUVHLWV DXI GLH 3ROLWLNYRUVWHOOXQJHQ GHU 6WDDWHQ ]XUFN GLH VLFK GHQ 9HUKDQGOXQJVSURWRNROOHQ GHU 'ULWWHQ 6HHUHFKWV NRQIHUHQ] HQWQHKPHQ ODVVHQ 'LHVH GHFNHQ QXU GHQ =HLWUDXP YRQ ELV DE 6LH N|QQHQ PLW REMHNWLYHQ ZLUWVFKDIWOLFKHQ XQG SROLWLVFKHQ ,QGLNDWR UHQ GHU GDPDOLJHQ =HLW SURJQRVWL]LHUW ZHUGHQ XQG GLH HQWVSUHFKHQG JHVFKlW]
WHQ 5HJUHVVLRQVSDUDPHWHU N|QQHQ GDQQ ]XVDPPHQ PLW GHQ DXI GHQ QHXHUHQ 6WDQG JHEUDFKWHQ ,QGLNDWRUHQ ]XU 6FKlW]XQJ GHU 9HUKDQGOXQJVSRVLWLRQHQ IXU GLH 'XUFKIXKUXQJVYHUHLQEDUXQJ LQ GHQ HU -DKUHQ JHQXW]W ZHUGHQ 'LHVH VRUJIDOWLJH 6FKlW]XQJ GHU ,QWHUHVVHQ GHU $NWHXUH HUODXEW GLH %HUHFKQXQJ GHU (UZDUWXQJVQXW]HQ GLH GLH 6WDDWHQ YRQ HLQ]HOQHQ P|JOLFKHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJV UHJHOQ IXU GLH 0HHUHVERGHQEHK|UGH KDEHQ
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
*HVLFKWVSXQNW JHUHFKWIHUWLJW
9RUZRUW GHV $XWRUV
'LH YRUOLHJHQGH $UEHLW ZXUGH LP 1RYHPEHU DQ GHU )DNXOWlW 8U 6R]L DOZLVVHQVFKDIWHQ GHU 8QLYHUVLWlW 0DQQKHLP DOV 'LVVHUWDWLRQ DQJHQRPPHQ 'LH *XWDFKWHU ZDUHQ 3URIHVVRU 'U )UDQ] 8UEDQ 3DSSL XQG 3URIHVVRU 'U 7KRPDV .|QLJ %HL 3URIHVVRU 'U )UDQ] 8UEDQ 3DSSL KDEH LFK YRU HLQHP KDOEHQ -DKU]HKQW DOV ZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH +LOIVNUDIW EHJRQQHQ XQG EHU GLH -DKUH KLQZHJ VRZRKO VWHWLJH )|UGHUXQJ DOV DXFK DXIPXQWHUQGHQ =XVSUXFK HUIDKUHQ 7KRPDV .|QLJ KDW GDV 3URMHNW QLFKW QXU NULWLVFK EHJOHLWHW XQG YRUDQJHWULH EHQ XQVHUH =XVDPPHQDUEHLW ]HLJW GDVV VLFK LP XQLYHUVLWlUHQ /HEHQ GXUFKDXV .RRSHUDWLRQVJHZLQQH HU]LHOHQ ODVVHQ %HLGHQ *XWDFKWHUQ JLOW IXU LKUH 8QWHU VWW]XQJ EHVRQGHUHU 'DQN
)U GHQ HPSLULVFKHQ 7HLO GHU 8QWHUVXFKXQJ NRQQWH DXI 'DWHQ HLQHV )RU VFKXQJVSURMHNWHV ]XU 'ULWWHQ 6HHUHFKWVNRQIHUHQ] ]XUFNJHJULIIHQ ZHUGHQ 'HU /HLWHU GHV 3URMHNWHV 3URIHVVRU 'U 5REHUW / )ULHGKHLP 8QLYHUVLW\ RI 6RXWKHUQ &DOLIRUQLD /RV $QJHOHV KDW GLHV JUR]JLJ XQG lXHUW KLOIVEHUHLW XQWHUVWW]W ,Q GHU 8QWHUVXFKXQJVSKDVH KDEH LFK KLOIUHLFKH $QPHUNXQJHQ YRQ YLHOHQ 6HLWHQ EHNRPPHQ &RUQHOLD +DQQ 7KRPDV 6FKXVWHU XQG 9RONHU 6WR FNH KDEHQ VLFK PLW GHU .RPPHQWLHUXQJ YRQ 0DQXVNULSWWHLOHQ VFKZHUH 6WXQ GHQ EHUHLWHW XQG 0DUWLQ .LUFKQHU REODJ HLQ ZHLWHUHV 0DO GLH NULWLVFKH *H VDPWVFKDX $QNH 6FK|E KDW DOO GLHV DXFK XQG GDUEHU KLQDXV QRFK YLHO PHKU JHOHLVWHW ,FK EHGDQNH PLFK EHL DOOHQ %HWHLOLJWHQ
)LQDQ]LHOO HUP|JOLFKW ZXUGH GDV 9RUKDEHQ GXUFK HLQ 6WLSHQGLXP GHU *UD GXLHUWHQI|UGHUXQJ GHV /DQGHV %DGHQ:UWWHPEHUJ GDV 0DQQKHLPHU =HQW UXP IXU (XURSlLVFKH 6R]LDOIRUVFKXQJ ERW LQ GLHVHU =HLW HLQH LGHDOH Arbeits~
DWPRVSKlUH 6FKOLHOLFK VFKXOGHW GDV =XVWDQGHNRPPHQ GLHVHV %XFKHV YLHO PHLQHQ (OWHUQ GLH PLW XQHUVFKWWHUOLFKHP 9HUWUDXHQ QLH =ZHLIHO DP *HOLQJHQ GHV *DQ]HQ OLHHQ
.DSLWHOO
3UREOHPH LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU ,QVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLN
'LH 1HXRUGQXQJ GHV 0HHUHVERGHQV
$P $SULO EHHQGHWH GLH 'ULWWH 6HHUHFKWVNRQIHUHQ] (Third United Nations Conference on (he Law of (he Sea, 81&/26 ,,, PLW GHU 9HUDE VFKLHGXQJ GHU 6HHUHFKWVNRQYHQWLRQ GHU 9HUHLQWHQ 1DWLRQHQ LKUH $UEHLW hEHU DFKW -DKUH KLQZHJ KDWWHQ GLH 7HLOQHKPHUVWDDWHQ DXI LQVJHVDPW HOI 7D JXQJHQ EHU HLQH XPIDVVHQGH 1HXRUGQXQJ GHV 6HHUHFKWV YHUKDQGHOW *HJHQ VWDQG GHU .RQIHUHQ] ZDUHQ GLH PHLVWHQ %HUHLFKH PDULWLPHU 1XW]XQJV XQG
%HVLW]VWlQGH 'D]X JHK|UWHQ GLH $XVJHVWDOWXQJ GHU 5HFKWH XQG 3IOLFKWHQ GHU +DQGHOV XQG GHU PLOLWlULVFKHQ 6FKLIIIDKUW LQVEHVRQGHUH YRQ 'XUFKIDKUWV UHFKWHQ XQG 6LFKHUKHLWVEHVWLPPXQJHQ )UDJHQ GHV PDULWLPHQ 8PZHOWVFKXW ]HV GHU 7LHIVHHYHUNDEHOXQJ XQG GHV =XJDQJV YRQ %LQQHQVWDDWHQ ]X GHQ :HOWPHHUHQ :HLWHUH 5HJHOXQJVEHUHLFKH XPIDVVWHQ GLH %HVLW] EH]LHKXQJV ZHLVH 1XW]XQJVUHFKWH DQ GHQ PLQHUDOLVFKHQ 5HVVRXUFHQ VRZLH GHU (UG|O XQG (UGJDVYRUNRPPHQ LQ GHQ QDWLRQDOHQ +RKHLWVJHELHWHQ HQWODQJ GHU .VWHQ XQG DXI GHP 0HHUHVERGHQ MHQVHLWV GHV %HUHLFKV QDWLRQDOHU +RKHLWVEHIXJQLV VH %LV KHXWH JLOW GDV $ENRPPHQ PLW VHLQHQ $UWLNHOQ XQG QHXQ $QQH[HQ GLH QDKH]X DOOH HUGHQNOLFKHQ $VSHNWH GHU 1XW]XQJ XQG (UKDOWXQJ GHU 0HHUH NRGLIL]LHUHQ DOV GDV XPIDVVHQGVWH 9HUWUDJVZHUN GHV 9|ONHUUHFKWV
'HU .RQIHUHQ] YRUDXVJHJDQJHQ ZDUHQ ]DKOUHLFKH %HPKXQJHQ GHU 9HU HLQWHQ 1DWLRQHQ 81 GDV ELV GDKLQ ZHLWJHKHQG GHP 9|ONHUJHZRKQKHLWV
, 8QLWHG 1DWLRQV &RQYHQWLRQ RQ WKH /DZ RI WKH 6HD 81 'RN AlCONF.62/122. 10.
'H]HPEHU 7H[W LQInternational Legal Materials II
UHFKW HQWVSULQJHQGH 6HHUHFKW ]XVDPPHQ]XIXKUHQ XQG IRUW]XHQWZLFNHOQ 'LH (UVWH *HQIHU 6HHUHFKWVNRQIHUHQ] YRQ KDWWH ]ZDU YLHU .RQYHQWLRQVHQW ZUIH EHU GDV .VWHQPHHU XQG GLH $QVFKOXVV]RQH GLH +RKH 6HH GLH )L VFKHUHL XQG GHQ )HVWODQGVRFNHO ]XVWDQGH JHEUDFKW GLHVH VFKULHEHQ MHGRFK LP :HVHQWOLFKHQ EHVWHKHQGHV 5HFKW RKQH $QVSUXFK DXI HLQH XPIDVVHQGH XQG HLQKHLWOLFKH 2UGQXQJ IHVW 'LH =ZHLWH *HQIHU 6HHUHFKWVNRQIHUHQ] LP -DKU EOLHE VRJDU Y|OOLJ HUJHEQLVORV .LPPLQLFK I ,Q HLQH QHXH 3KDVH WUDW GLH (QWZLFNOXQJ LQ GHQ VHFK]LJHU -DKUHQ DOV GLH MXQJHQ 6WDDWHQ GHU HUVWHQ DIULNDQLVFKHQ 8QDEKlQJLJNHLWVZHOOH LKU 6WUHEHQ QDFK JOHLFKEH UHFKWLJWHU 7HLOKDEH DQ GHU 6WDDWHQJHPHLQVFKDIW PLW GHU )RUGHUXQJ QDFK HLQHU 1HXJHVWDOWXQJ GHU ZHOWZLUWVFKDIWOLFKHQ 2UGQXQJ YHUEDQGHQ .HLQ =XIDOO LVW GDKHU GDVV GLH ]X GLHVHU =HLW DXINRPPHQGH )UDJH QDFK GHU $XVEHXWXQJ GHU ELVODQJ XQJHQXW]WHQ /DJHUVWlWWHQ YRQ PLQHUDOLVFKHQ 5HVVRXUFHQ DXI GHP VWDDWVIUHLHQ 5DXP GHV 7LHIVHHERGHQV ]X HLQHP ]HQWUDOHQ 7KHPD EHL GLHVHQ
%HPKXQJHQ ZXUGH 6FKOLHOLFK YHUVSUDFK GHU $EEDX GHU 0HHUHVERGHQUHV VRXUFHQ GLH 5HDOLVLHUXQJ YRQ WDWVlFKOLFKHQ =XJHZLQQHQ
(QWVSUHFKHQG EHIDVVWH VLFK GHU :LUWVFKDIWV XQG 6R]LDOUDW GHU 9HUHLQWHQ 1DWLRQHQ PLW GHU )UDJH LQZLHZHLW GLH PDULQHQ 5HVVRXUFHQ LP EHVRQGH UHQ ,QWHUHVVH GHU (QWZLFNOXQJVOlQGHU JHQXW]W ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ (LQH ,QLWLDWLYH GHV PDOWHVLVFKHQ 81%RWVFKDIWHUV $UYLG 3DUGR LP -DKUH HU|IIQHWH LQ GLHVHU +LQVLFKW QHXH 3HUVSHNWLYHQ IXU GLH $XVJHVWDOWXQJ GHU 7LHIVHHQXW]XQJV UHFKWH 3DUGR IRUGHUWH HLQ $ENRPPHQ GDV GLH 7LHIVHH XQG GHQ 0HHUHVERGHQ DXHUKDOE GHU QDWLRQDOHQ +RKHLWVDQVSUFKH ]XP JHPHLQVDPHQ (UEH GHU 0HQVFKKHLW(common her;tage mank;nd) HUNOlUW XQG GHUHQ DXVVFKOLHOLFK IULHGOLFKH 1XW]XQJ LP ,QWHUHVVH GHU 0HQVFKKHLW UHJHOW +LQWHUJUXQG ZDU GLH
%HIUFKWXQJ YRQ (QWZLFNOXQJVOlQGHUQ DEHU DXFK YRQ NOHLQHUHQ LQGXVWULDOL VLHUWHQ 6WDDWHQ GLH ZHQLJHQ JURHQ ,QGXVWULHQDWLRQHQ GLH EHUHLWV +DXSWNRQ VXPHQWHQ GHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ 0HWDOOH ZDUHQ ZUGHQ DXIJUXQG LKUHV WHFKQR ORJLVFKHQ 9RUVSUXQJV DXFK ]XP DOOHLQLJHQ $XVEHXWHU GHU 7LHIVHHPLQHUDOLHQ ZHUGHQ 'LHVHQ 1XW]XQJVEHVWUHEXQJHQ YRQ SRWHQWLHOOHQ .RQVXPHQWHQ VWDQGHQ JOHLFKZRKO GLH ,QWHUHVVHQ GHU 6WDDWHQ JHJHQEHU GLH /DQGSURGX]HQ WHQ GHU 0HWDOOH ZDUHQ XQG LKUHQ $EVDW] GXUFK HLQH LQWHQVLYH 7LHIVHHSURGXN WLRQ JHIlKUGHW VDKHQ
'LH PDOWHVLVFKH ,QLWLDWLYH IXKUWH VFKOLHOLFK ]XU (LQVHW]XQJ HLQHV 0HHUHV ERGHQDXVVFKXVVHV GHU ]ZHL 5HVROXWLRQHQ GHU *HQHUDOYHUVDPPOXQJ EHU HLQ 1XW]XQJVPRUDWRULXP XQG GHQ common herüage-Charakter GHV 0HHUHVER GHQV DXI GHQ :HJ EUDFKWH :ROIUXP 'D GLHVH 5HVROXWLRQHQ ]ZDU
NHLQH XQPLWWHOEDUH 4XHOOH ELQGHQGHQ 9|ONHUUHFKWV MHGRFK ZLFKWLJH )DNWRUHQ LQ GHVVHQ )RUWVFKUHLEXQJ VLQG 9HUGURVV XQG 6LPPD .ULVVOHU I EHIXUFKWHWHQ GLH IXKUHQGHQ ,QGXVWULHQDWLRQHQ YRQ GHQ 5HJH OXQJVEHVWUHEXQJHQ GHU 6WDDWHQPHKUKHLW YRQ (QWZLFNOXQJVOlQGHUQ YRU YROOHQ GHWH 7DWVDFKHQ JHVWHOOW ]X ZHUGHQ 'RFK WURW] GHV 3URWHVWHV GHU 9HUHLQLJWHQ 6WDDWHQ JHJHQ GLH VFKOHLFKHQGH $QHLJQXQJ YRQ +RKHLWVJHZDOW GXUFK GLH 9HUHLQWHQ 1DWLRQHQ 3RVW ZDU GHU :HJ ]X HLQHU ZHLWHUHQ 6HH UHFKWVNRQIHUHQ] JHHEQHW 'LHVH ZXUGH ]ZLVFKHQ XQG XQWHU %HWHL OLJXQJ YRQ 'HOHJDWLRQ QDKH]X DOOHU VRXYHUlQHQ 6WDDWHQ LQ HOI 7DJXQJHQ LQ 1HZ <RUN &DUDFDV XQG *HQI DEJHKDOWHQ
(QWVSUHFKHQG GHU ZLUWVFKDIWOLFKHQ XQG URKVWRIISROLWLVFKHQ %HGHXWXQJ GHU GHQ 0LQHUDOLHQYRUNRPPHQ ]XJHPHVVHQ ZXUGH XQG GHU GDUDXV UHVXOWLHUHQGHQ XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ ,QWHUHVVHQ ZHOFKH GLH 6WDDWHQ PLW GHU 7LHIVHHUHVVRXUFHQ QXW]XQJ YHUEDQGHQ ZXUGH GLH 1HXRUGQXQJ GHU 7LHIVHHQXW]XQJVUHFKWH ]X HLQHP ]HQWUDOHQ 7KHPD GHU .RQIHUHQ] ,P 0LWWHOSXQNW VWDQG GHU 7HLO GHU 6HHUHFKWVNRQYHQWLRQ GHU GLH (LQULFKWXQJ HLQHU ,QWHUQDWLRQDOHQ 0HHUHVER GHQEHK|UGH(lntemaüonal Seabed Authorüy, ,6$ YRUVDK LQ GHU GLH 6WDDWHQ ]XNQIWLJ JHPHLQVFKDIWOLFK EHU GLH JHQDXHQ %HGLQJXQJHQ HLQHV 0LQHUDOLHQ DEEDXV HQWVFKHLGHQ VROOWHQ :HVHQWOLFKHU *HJHQVWDQG GHU $XVHLQDQGHUVHW ]XQJHQ ZDUHQ )UDJHQ GHU 5HSUlVHQWDWLRQ XQG GHU (QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ GDV KHLW LQ ZHOFKHU :HLVH GLH XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ 6WDDWHQLQWHUHVVHQ LQ GHU %HK|U GH UHSUlVHQWLHUW ZHUGHQ NRQQWHQ VR GDVV HLQH GDXHUKDIWH HIIL]LHQWH XQG LQWH UHVVHQDXVJOHLFKHQGH 1XW]XQJ P|JOLFK LVW
,P (UJHEQLV VDK GHU (QWZXUI IXU HLQH 6HHUHFKWVNRQYHQWLRQ YRU GDVV MH ZHLOV YLHU 6LW]H LP 5DW GHP ]HQWUDOHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVRUJDQ GHU %HK|UGH IXU GLH ZLFKWLJVWHQ .RQVXPHQWHQ ,QYHVWRUHQ XQG 3URGX]HQWHQVWDDWHQ UHVHU YLHUW ZUGHQ 6HFKV 6LW]H VROOWHQ DXVVFKOLHOLFK (QWZLFNOXQJVOlQGHUQ ]XVWH KHQ XQG GLH YHUEOHLEHQGHQ 6LW]H DXV GHU 0LWWH GHU 9HUVDPPOXQJ YHUJHEHQ ZHUGHQ VR GDVV HLQH DXVJHZRJHQH JHRJUDSKLVFKH 6LW]YHUWHLOXQJ LP JHVDPWHQ 5DW JHZlKUOHLVWHW VHL $EELOGXQJ 'HQQRFK HQWVFKORVV VLFK EHL GHU 6FKOXVVDEVWLPPXQJ HLQH NOHLQH 0LQGHUKHLW YRQ 6WDDWHQ XQWHU LKQHQ GLH ZLUWVFKDIWOLFK XQG SROLWLVFK IKUHQGHQ ,QGXVWULHVWDDWHQ %XQGHVUHSXEOLN
1DFK $UW $EV GHU 6HHUHFKWVNRQYHQWLRQ XPIDVVW GLH GULWWH *UXSSH ZHVHQWOLFKH ([SRUWHXUH GHU 0LQHUDOLHQ GLH LP 7LHIVHHEHUJEDX JHZRQQHQ ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ 'D GLH /DQGSURGXNWLRQ DXFK PLWWHOIULVWLJ GLH 7LHIVHHSURGXNWLRQ EHUVWHLJHQ ZLUG VLQG LQ GHU GULWWHQ *UXSSH GH IDFWD GLH /DQGSURGX]HQWHQ GHU 0LQHUDOLHQ UHSUlVHQWLHUW
'HXWVFKODQG ,WDOLHQ *UREULWDQQLHQ XQG GLH 9HUHLQLJWHQ 6WDDWHQ ]XU (QW KDOWXQJ RGHU VRJDU ]XU $EOHKQXQJ GHV .RQYHQWLRQVHQWZXUIHV 6LH VDKHQ LKUH ,QWHUHVVHQ QLFKW DXVUHLFKHQG LQ GHU %HK|UGH EHUFNVLFKWLJW
AbbildungDas Mehrkammerprinzip im Rat der Behörde 5DW 0LWJOLHGHU GHU %HK|UGH
Kammer 1 Kammer 2 Kammer 3 Kammer 4
6WDDWHQ DXV 6WDDWHQ DXV 6WDDWHQ DXV 6WDDWHQ DXV VRQVWLJH GHU *UXSSH GHU GHU *UXSSH GHU GHU *UXSSH GHU GHU *UXSSH GHU 6WDDWHQ
.RQVXPHQWHQ ,QYHVWRUHQ ([SRUWHXUH (QWZLFNOXQJV OlQGHU
W
ZDKO9HUVDPPOXQJ DOOH 0LWJOLHGHU GHU %HK|UGH ZLUWVFKDIWOLFKH *UXSSHQ JHRJUDSKLVFKH *UXSSHQ
.RQVXPHQWHQ ,QYHVWRUHQ 3URGX]HQWHQ $IULND $VLHQ VWHXURSD /DWHLQDPHULND (QWZLFNOXQJVOlQGHU XQG .DULELN :HVWHXURSD XQG DQGHUH 7URW] GHU PHKUKHLWOLFKHQ %HIXUZRUWXQJ EHGURKWH GLH DEOHKQHQGH +DOWXQJ GHU ZHQLJHQ IXKUHQGHQ ,QGXVWULHVWDDWHQ HUQVWKDIW GLH )XQNWLRQVIlKLJNHLW GHV 5H JLPHV 'D VLFK GHU 7LHIVHHERGHQ DXHUKDOE QDWLRQDOHU -XULVGLNWLRQ EHILQGHW RIIHULHUWH GDV JHOWHQGH NRQYHQWLRQHOOH 9|ONHUUHFKW GHQ 6WDDWHQ HLQHQ IUHLHQ
=XJDQJ GLH DP HKHVWHQ LQ GHU /DJH ZDUHQ GLH 5HVVRXUFHQ ZLUWVFKDIWOLFK ]X QXW]HQ 'LH YHUKDOWHQH (XSKRULH GHV -DKUHV GDUEHU LQ HLQHU HLQ]LJDUWL JHQ PXOWLODWHUDOHQ 9HUKDQGOXQJ EHU HLQ]HOQH 7KHPHQNRPSOH[H HLQHQ
%HLQDKH.RQVHQV ]ZLVFKHQ ,62 6WDDWHQ KHUJHVWHOOW ]X KDEHQ ZLFK VFKQHOO GHU %HIXUFKWXQJ GDVV RKQH GLH %HWHLOLJXQJ GHU ,QGXVWULHVWDDWHQ NHLQH /|
VXQJ GHV JOREDOHQ 1XW]XQJVSUREOHPV P|JOLFK VHLQ ZUGH (UVFKZHUHQG NDP KLQ]X GDVV HLQLJH 6WDDWHQ GD]X EHUJLQJHQ GLHMHQLJHQ %HVWLPPXQJHQ GHU 6HHUHFKWVNRQYHQWLRQ GLH VLFK QLFKW DXI GLH 0HHUHVERGHQIUDJH EH]RJHQ DOV 9|ONHUJHZRKQKHLWVUHFKW ]X EHWUDFKWHQ XQG GDUEHU KLQDXV DXI GHP :HJH QDWLRQDOHU *HVHW]JHEXQJ UHFKWOLFKH 5DKPHQEHGLQJXQJHQ W8U HLQH HLJHQVWlQ GLJH 1XW]XQJ GHU 5HVVRXUFHQ VFKXIHQ *DOGRULVL XQG 6WDYULGLV
8QWHU GLHVHQ 8PVWlQGHQ VFKOXJ GLH DOV =XVDPPHQVFKOXVV GHU (QWZLFN OXQJVOlQGHU DXIWUHWHQGH *UXSSH GHU YRU LQ 1HXYHUKDQGOXQJHQ EHU GLH
ZHVHQWOLFKHQ 6WUHLWIUDJHQ HLQ]XWUHWHQ XQG GLH ,QGXVWULHVWDDWHQ ]X HLQHU %HWHL OLJXQJ DP 0HHUHVERGHQUHJLPH ]X EHZHJHQ ,Q HLQHU YHUDEVFKLHGHWHQ 'XUFKIXKUXQJVYHUHLQEDUXQJ ZXUGHQ GHQ ,QGXVWULHQDWLRQHQ JURH =XJHVWlQG QLVVH EHL GHU 3URGXNWLRQVOLPLWLHUXQJ LP 7LHIVHHEHUJEDX XQG LQVEHVRQGHUH EHL GHU 9HUWHLOXQJ YRQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHFKWHQ LQ GHQ 2UJDQHQ GHU %HK|UGH JH PDFKW 8QWHU DQGHUHP YHUIXJHQ QXQ GLH 9HUHLQLJWHQ 6WDDWHQ DOV HLQ]LJHU 9HUWUDJVVWDDW EHU HLQHQ VWlQGLJHQ 6LW] LP 5DW :HLWHUKLQ ZLUG PLW GHU 'XUFKIXKUXQJVYHUHLQEDUXQJ GDV 3ULQ]LS HLQHU *UXSSHQUHSUlVHQWDWLRQ HQW VFKHLGHQG GXUFK (LQIXKUXQJ HLQHU 0HKUNDPPHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHO JH VFKlUIW 'LH LP 5DW UHSUlVHQWLHUWHQ *UXSSHQ ZHUGHQ DOV .DPPHUQ EHWUDFKWHW ZLFKWLJH (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ GHU %HK|UGH N|QQHQ QXQ QXU GDQQ PLW HLQHU =ZHL GULWWHO0HKUKHLW GHU 5DWVPLWJOLHGHU JHIlOOW ZHUGHQ ZHQQ NHLQH GHU YLHU .DP PHUQ (LQVSUXFK HLQOHJW 'DPLW VROOWH LQVEHVRQGHUH JHZlKUOHLVWHW ZHUGHQ GDVV GLH UHLFKHUHQ ,QGXVWULHVWDDWHQ GLH YRUQHKPOLFK ZLFKWLJH .RQVXPHQWHQ YRQ 0LQHUDOLHQ XQG ,QYHVWRUHQ LP 7LHIVHHEHUJEDX VLQG QLFKW YRQ HLQHU 0HKU KHLW GHU (QWZLFNOXQJVOlQGHU EHUVWLPPW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ
'LH 1HXUHJHOXQJ GHU 5HSUlVHQWDWLRQV XQG (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ ZDU RI IHQVLFKWOLFK HLQH QRWZHQGLJH %HGLQJXQJ IXU GLH =XVWLPPXQJ GHU ,QGXVWULH VWDDWHQ 2IIHQ PXVV MHGRFK EOHLEHQ RE GDV DXVJHKDQGHOWH 5HJLPH GHQ HUZDU WHWHQ $XVJOHLFK ]ZLVFKHQ XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ 6WDDWHQLQWHUHVVHQ WDWVlFKOLFK ]X OHLVWHQ YHUPDJ ,QGHU /LWHUDWXU ]XU 6HHUHFKWVNRQIHUHQ] ZXUGH GLH )UDJH PLW ZHOFKHQ 9HUIDKUHQVUHJHOQ GLH ]XNQIWLJH 5HVVRXUFHQQXW]XQJ JHVWHXHUW ZHU GHQ VROO GDV KHLW ZHOFKH 0HFKDQLVPHQ W8U GLH ]XNQIWLJH /|VXQJ RIIHQHU 6WUHLWIUDJHQ EHUHLWJHVWHOOW ZHUGHQ VHOWHQ JHVWHOOW 9LHOPHKU XQWHUVXFKHQ GLH PHLVWHQ 6WXGLHQ VROFKH .RQIOLNWH HWZD KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU 9HUWHLOXQJ YRQ $E EDXUHFKWHQ GHU (UKHEXQJ YRQ *HEKUHQ RGHU GHU (LQULFKWXQJ YRQ 6DQNWL RQVPLWWHOQ IXU GLH XQPLWWHOEDU HLQH /|VXQJ JHIXQGHQ XQG YHUWUDJOLFK YHUHLQ EDUW ZHUGHQ NRQQWH :LH DEHU ZHUGHQ .RQIOLNWH EHU (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ JHO|VW GHUHQ :LUNXQJHQ VLFK HUVW LQ GHU =XNXQIW ]HLJHQ ZHUGHQ" 6FKOLHOLFK ELQGHQ VROFKH IRUPDOHQ 9RUJDEHQ GLH 6WDDWHQ ODQJIULVWLJ XQG VFKUlQNHQ LKUHQ +DQGOXQJVVSLHOUDXP HLQ ZDV LP SULQ]LSLHOOHQ :LGHUVSUXFK ]XP 3ULQ]LS GHU 6WDDWHQVRXYHUlQLWlW LQ GHQ LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ %H]LHKXQJHQ VWHKW 6ROOWH GLHV
$JUHHPHQW UHODWLQJ WR WKH LPSOHPHQWDWLRQ RI3DUW ;, RIWKH 8QLWHG 1DWLRQV &RQYHQWLRQ RQ WKH /DZ RI WKH 6HD RI 'HFHPEHU 81 'RN $O5(6 -XOL 7H[W LQInternational Legal Materials 6HHUHFKWVNRQYHQWLRQ XQG 'XUFKIKUXQJVYHUHLQEDUXQJ ELOGHQ QDFK $UW GHU 9HUHLQEDUXQJ HLQ JHPHLQVDPHV 5HFKWVLQVWUXPHQW
QLFKW DXVJHSUlJWH .RQIOLNWH KHUYRUUXIHQ RGHU 9HUHLQEDUXQJHQ EHU LQWHUQDWL QDOH ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ HUVFKZHUHQ" 'LH )UDJH QDFK JHHLJQHWHQ 5HJHOQ GHU 5H SUlVHQWDWLRQ XQG $JJUHJDWLRQ YRQ 6WDDWHQLQWHUHVVHQ YHUZHLVW VRPLW DXI HLQ JUXQGOHJHQGHV 3UREOHP LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU ,QVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLN
7DWVlFKOLFK H[LVWLHUW HLQH 9LHO]DKO LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU 2UJDQLVDWLRQHQ GHUHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ XQG 5HJHOQ GLH +DQGOXQJVIUHLKHLW GHU 0LWJOLHGVWDDWHQ VWDUN EH VFKUlQNHQ XQG VRJDU YRP 3RVWXODW GHU 6WDDWHQJOHLFKKHLW DEZHLFKHQ 6R N|Q QHQ EHLVSLHOVZHLVH GLH 9HUHLQWHQ 1DWLRQHQ PLW *HQHUDOYHUVDPPOXQJ XQG 6L FKHUKHLWVUDW DOV =ZHLNDPPHUV\VWHP DXIJHIDVVW ZHUGHQ LQ GHP ]ZDU HLQH
EHUVWLPPXQJ HLQ]HOQHU 6WDDWHQ ]XOlVVLJ LVW QLFKW MHGRFK GHU $XVVFKOXVV GHU ]XP 9HWR EHUHFKWLJWHQ *URPlFKWH ,P 9|ONHUUHFKW ZLUG JOHLFKZRKO YRQ GHU SULQ]LSLHOOHQ *OHLFKKHLW GHU 6WDDWHQ DXVJHJDQJHQ $EZHLFKXQJHQ YRQ GHU one state one vote-Regel ZHUGHQ YRUQHKPOLFK XQG VHKU DOOJHPHLQ DXI GLH OKHJHPRQLH FROOHFWLYH GHV JUDQGHV SXLVVDQFHV ]XUFNJHIXKUW *XJJHQKHLP 'LH 9HUQDFKOlVVLJXQJ GHU 5HJHOZDKO LVW DEHU DXFK GDUDXI ]XUFN ]XIXKUHQ GDVV GLH (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ GHU PHLVWHQ 5HJLPH QLFKW XQPLWWHOEDU ELQGHQG IXU LKUH 0LWJOLHGVWDDWHQ VLQG 'LH QDKH OLHJHQGH 6FKOXVVIROJHUXQJ LVW GDVV QDFK ZLH YRU QXU HLQ .RQVHQV GLH IUHLZLOOLJH ,PSOHPHQWDWLRQ XQG 'XUFK VHW]XQJ YRQ (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ JDUDQWLHUW XQG PHKUKHLWOLFKHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJV UHJHOQ GHVKDOE HLQH XQWHUJHRUGQHWH %HGHXWXQJ ]X]XVFKUHLEHQ LVW 5LWWEHUJHU 'LH ,QWHUQDWLRQDOH 0HHUHVERGHQEHK|UGH VWHOOW GLHVEH]JOLFK QXU HLQ DE ZHLFKHQGHV )DOOEHLVSLHO GDU GD DXFK JHJHQOlXILJH (QWZLFNOXQJHQ LP 9|ONHU UHFKW ]X YHU]HLFKQHQ VLQG =XP HLQHQ OlVVW VLFK HLQH JHVWHLJHUWH .RPSOH[LWlW YRQ IRUPDOHQ 9HUIDKUHQVYRUJDEHQ EHREDFKWHQ GLH HWZD PLWWHOV 0HKUNDP PHUV\VWHPHQ GLIIHUHQ]LHUWH 9HUWHLOXQJHQ YRQ 0LWVSUDFKH XQG (QWVFKHL GXQJVUHFKWHQ YRUVHKHQ :ROIUXP 6R ZLUG EHLVSLHOVZHLVH PLW GHP YHU PHLQWOLFKHQ (QGH GHV KHJHPRQLDOHQ =HLWDOWHUV GLH )UDJH QDFK HLQHU 5HIRUP GHU (QWVFKHLGXQJVVWUXNWXUHQ LP 816LFKHUKHLWVUDW ZLHGHU YHUVWlUNW GLVNX WLHUW )DVVEHQGHU =XP DQGHUHQ JHZLQQHQ LQWHUQDWLRQDOH 2UJDQLVDWLR QHQ DQ %HGHXWXQJ GHUHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ XQPLWWHOEDU ELQGHQG IXU LKUH 0LW JOLHGHU VLQG :ROIUXP (LQ %HLVSLHO KLHUIXU LVW GLH (XURSlLVFKH 8QL RQ GHUHQ 5HFKWVDNWHQ HLQH ZDFKVHQGH 5HOHYDQ] JHJHQEHU GHU QDWLRQDOHQ
*HVHW]JHEXQJ ]XNRPPW ZHLWHUH %HLVSLHOH ILQGHQ VLFK EHL LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ
*UHPLHQ EH]LHKXQJVZHLVH 2UJDQLVDWLRQHQ ]XU 1XW]XQJVYHUZDOWXQJ VWDDWV IUHLHU 5lXPH ZLH GHU .RQIHUHQ] GHU 3DUWHLHQ GHV 0RQWUHDOHU 3URWRNROOV RGHU GHU ,QWHUQDWLRQDOHQ 0HHUHVERGHQEHK|UGH
,P %HUHLFK GHV 9|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
'LH LQ GLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJ DXIWUHWHQGHQ )UDJHQ VROOHQ DP %HLVSLHO GHV 0HHUHVERGHQUHJLPHV HQWODQJ ]ZHLHU 7KHPHQNRPSOH[H XQWHUVXFKW ZHUGHQ
=XP HLQHQ ELOGHWHQ GLH XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ 6WDDWHQLQWHUHVVHQ DQ GHU 0HHUHVER GHQQXW]XQJ GHQ $XVJDQJVSXQNW IXU VRZRKO GDV YRUOlXILJH 6FKHLWHUQ GHU 9HUKDQGOXQJHQ DOV DXFK GHQ VSlWHUHQ (UIROJ PLWWHOV GHU (LQULFKWXQJ HLQHV PXOWLNDPHUDOHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVV\VWHPV =XQl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
=XP DQGHUHQ VLQG RIIHQVLFKWOLFK 6FKHLWHUQ XQG (UIROJ GHU 9HUKDQGOXQJHQ ZHVHQWOLFK LQ GHU LQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQ )RUP EHJUQGHW PLW GHU GLH 0HHUHVERGHQ QXW]XQJ ]XNQIWLJ EHWULHEHQ ZLUG 'HV :HLWHUHQ LVW GHVKDOE QDFK GHU 9HUWHL OXQJ YRQ 5HFKWHQ XQG 3IOLFKWHQ LQ GHU %HK|UGH ]X IUDJHQ GLH HLQLJHQ 6WDDWHQ VR XQDN]HSWDEHO HUVFKLHQ GDVV VLH HLQ 6FKHLWHUQ GHU .RQYHQWLRQ LQ .DXI QDKPHQ :DUXP ZDU KLQJHJHQ GLH 0RGLILNDWLRQ GHU 9HUIDKUHQV XQG (QW VFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ JHHLJQHW HLQH XQLYHUVHOOH =XVWLPPXQJ ]XP 9HUWUDJVZHUN ]X HU]LHOHQ" 'LH %HDQWZRUWXQJ GHU )UDJHQ XQWHU ZHOFKHQ 5HJHOQ HLQH ODQJ IULVWLJH .RRSHUDWLRQ YRQ 6WDDWHQ P|JOLFK LVW XQG ZLH VROFKH LQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQ
$UUDQJHPHQWV HUGDFKW XQG HLQJHULFKWHW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ LVW YRQ JUXQGOH JHQGHU 5HOHYDQ] IXU GLH .RRSHUDWLRQ YRQ 6WDDWHQ LQ GHU LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ 3ROL WLN GLH PLW HLQHU VWHWLJ ZDFKVHQGHQ $Q]DKO LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU 5HJLPH XQG 2U JDQLVDWLRQHQ ZHLWHUKLQ DQ %HGHXWXQJ JHZLQQW
AbbildungReines Koordinationsspiel und reines Konj/iktspiel VSLHOHQ ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ NHLQH 5ROOH RGHU VLQG IXU GDV (UUHLFKHQ EHVWLPPWHU (U JHEQLVVH QRWZHQGLJ .RQIOLNWIUHL VLQG 6LWXDWLRQHQ LQ GHQHQ GLH $NWHXUH GLH YHUVFKLHGHQHQ $XVJlQJH GHU 9HUKDQGOXQJVVLWXDWLRQ LQ JOHLFKHU :HLVH EHZHU WHQ $OV NRQIOLNWWUlFKWLJ PVVHQ KLQJHJHQ VROFKH HLQJHVWXIW ZHUGHQ LQ GHQHQ GLH =LHOH GHU $NWHXUH JHJHQVlW]OLFK VLQG XQG GDPLW GHUHQ %HZHUWXQJHQ VLFK GLDPHWUDO JHJHQEHUVWHKHQ /XFH XQG 5DLIID $EELOGXQJ ]HLJW EHLGH 0|JOLFKNHLWHQ DP %HLVSLHO YRQ ]ZHL $NWHXUHQ GHQHQ MHZHLOV ]ZHL +DQGOXQJVDOWHUQDWLYHQ ]XU 9HUIXJXQJ VWHKHQ ,Q GHQ =HOOHQ GHU 0DWUL]HQ VWHKHQ GLH LQGLYLGXHOOHQ %HZHUWXQJHQ GHU (UJHEQLVVH GXUFK GHQ HUVWHQ XQG GHQ ]ZHLWHQ $NWHXU GLH DOV $XV]DKOXQJHQ 1XW]HQ *HZLQQH RGHU 3UlIHUHQ ]HQ YHUVWDQGHQ ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ ,Q GHQ IROJHQGHQ %HLVSLHOHQ JHEHQ GLH =HO OHQZHUWH OHGLJOLFK GLH 5HLKHQIROJH ZLHGHU LQ GHU GLH UHVXOWLHUHQGHQ (UHLJQLVVH SUlIHULHUW ZHUGHQ 0LW ]ZHL EHZHUWHWH (UHLJQLVVH ZHUGHQ VROFKHQ PLW HLQV EHZHUWHWHQ YRUJH]RJHQ XQG VR ZHLWHU
,P VRJHQDQQWHQ UHLQHQ Koordinatio~spiel 6FKHOOLQJ HUUHLFKHQ GLH EHLGHQ $NWHXUH LKUH HUVWH 3UlIHUHQ] ZHQQ VLH LKUH +DQGOXQJHQ DXIHLQDQ GHU DEVWLPPHQ XQG HQWZHGHU GLH $OWHUQDWLYHQ D XQG F RGHU GLH $OWHUQDWLYHQ E XQG G ZlKOHQ 'DV UHLQH .RRUGLQDWLRQVVSLHO LVW NRQIOLNWIUHL XQG .RRSHUDWLRQ ]ZLVFKHQ GHQ EHLGHQ 6SLHOHUQ LVW P|JOLFK XQG VRJDU ZDKUVFKHLQOLFK %HLGH
$NWHXUH KDEHQ HLQ ,QWHUHVVH GDUDQ GDVV HLQHV GHU EHLGHQ (UHLJQLVVH DXI GHU +DXSWGLDJRQDOHQ HLQWULWW 'D GLH LQ GHU 0DWUL[ VSH]LIL]LHUWHQ :HUWH GLH HLQ]L JH %HZHUWXQJVJUXQGODJH IXU GLH :DKO ]ZLVFKHQ GHQ MHZHLOLJHQ $OWHUQDWLYHQ ELOGHQ VROOHQ JLEW HV IXU NHLQHQ GHU EHLGHQ 6SLHOHU HLQHQ *UXQG HLQVHLWLJ YRQ GHU 9HUHLQEDUXQJ DE]XZHLFKHQ 0DQDKPHQ ]XU 6LFKHUXQJ GLHVHU $EVSUD FKHQ VLQG DOVR QLFKW HUIRUGHUOLFK ,P (UJHEQLV ZLUG HLQHV GHU EHLGHQ (UHLJQLV VH DF RGHU EG HLQWUHWHQ
UHLQHV .RRUGLQDWLRQVVSLHO UHLQHV .RQIOLNWVSLHO G
$NWHXU F
E
$NWHXU D G
$NWHXU F
E
$NWHXU D
,QWHUQDWLRQDOH .RRSHUDWLRQ XQG ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ
'LH )UDJH RE ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ LQ GHQ LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ %H]LHKXQJHQ EHUKDXSW ZLFKWLJ IXU GLH (UUHLFKXQJ RGHU (UKDOWXQJ YRQ .RRSHUDWLRQ KLHU YHUVWDQGHQ DOV HLQH EHZXVVWH .RRUGLQDWLRQ YRQ +DQGOXQJHQ ]ZLVFKHQ $NWHXUHQ 2\H VLQG EHKHUUVFKWH EHU HLQLJH =HLW GLH 'HEDWWH ]ZLVFKHQ YHUVFKLHGH QHQ $QVlW]HQ LP )RUVFKXQJVEHUHLFK LQWHUQDWLRQDOH 3ROLWLN
$XVJDQJVSXQNW GHU .RQWURYHUVHQ ZDU GLH $QDUFKLH GHU 6WDDWHQZHOW GLH XQWHU 9HUZHLV DXI GDV Y|ONHUUHFKWOLFKH 3ULPDW GHU 6WDDWHQVRXYHUlQLWlW LQ GHQ LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ %H]LHKXQJHQ IHVWJHVWHOOW ZXUGH 'D 6WDDWHQ DOV 9|ONHUUHFKWV VXEMHNWH QDFK LQQHQ XQG DXHQ VRXYHUlQ XQG GDPLW LGHDOW\SLVFK QXU GHP HL JHQHQ :LOOHQ XQWHUZRUIHQ VLQG VW|W GHU lXHUH 6RXYHUlQLWlWVDQVSUXFK QXU GDQQ DXI :LGHUVWDQG ZHQQ HU PLW GHP DQGHUHU 6WDDWHQ NRQIOLJLHUW 6HLGHO PDQQ =ZDU VF:LHW GLHV GLH (QWVWHKXQJ YRQ 2UGQXQJ QLFKW SULQ ]LSLHOO DXV ZHQQ GHU 6RXYHUlQLWlWVDXVEXQJ PDFKWSROLWLVFKH *UHQ]HQ LQ HL QHP XQJOHLFKJHZLFKWLJHQ LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ 6WDDWHQV\VWHP JHVHW]W ZHUGHQ $ QDUFKLH EHLQKDOWHW DEHU GLH $EZHVHQKHLW HLQHU KLHUDUFKLVFKHQ DXI =ZDQJ EH JUQGHWHQ 2UGQXQJ LQ GHU DOOH 6WDDWHQ HLQHU EHUJHRUGQHWHQ ,QVWDQ] XQWHU ZRUIHQ VLQG 0LOQHU )ROJH GLHVHV 8PVWDQGHV LVW GLH VFKZDFKH $XVELO GXQJ YRQ 0HFKDQLVPHQ ZHOFKH GLH (LQKDOWXQJ YRQ IUHLZLOOLJHQ 9HUSIOLFK WXQJHQ GHU 6WDDWHQ XQPLWWHOEDU JDUDQWLHUHQ N|QQWHQ $Q GLH 6WHOOH GHU LP ,QQHQYHUKlOWQLV YRQ 6WDDWHQ EOLFKHQ ]HQWUDOHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ XQG LKUHU KLHUDUFKLVFKHQ 'XUFKVHW]XQJ GXUFK OHJLWLPLHUWH ([HNXWLYHQ WULWW KLHU GLH 6HOEVWNRRUGLQDWLRQ YRQ IRUPDO JOHLFKZHUWLJHQ 6WDDWHQ $XVJHKHQG YRQ GLHVHU 6LWXDWLRQ PDFKWH VLFK GHU 6WUHLW ]ZLVFKHQ GHU QHRUHDOLVWLVFKHQ XQG GHU OLEHUDOHQ 6FKXOH LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU 3ROLWLN DQ GHU )UDJH IHVW RE NRRSHUDWLYHV 9HUKDOWHQ LQ HLQHU :HOW YRQ (JRLVWHQ P|JOLFK VHL
8QWHU =XKLOIHQDKPH VSLHOWKHRUHWLVFKHU .RQ]HSWH ODVVHQ VLFK VRZRKO XQWHU VFKLHGOLFKH 0|JOLFKNHLWHQ IXU .RRSHUDWLRQ DOV DXFK GLH %HGHXWXQJ ZHOFKH HLQ]HOQH $QVlW]H ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ ]XZHLVHQ DQ YHUVFKLHGHQHQ LGHDOW\SLVFKHQ 9HUKDQGOXQJVVLWXDWLRQHQ YHUGHXWOLFKHQ 6FKHOOLQJ 6WHLQ
>@ $OV 9HUKDQGOXQJVVLWXDWLRQ RGHU $NWHXUVNRQVWHOODWLRQ HLQHU 9HUKDQGOXQJ VROOHQ GLH +DQGOXQJVP|JOLFKNHLWHQ GHU EHWHLOLJWHQ $NWHXUH XQG LKUH %HZHUWXQJHQ P|JOLFKHU 3ROLWLNHUJHEQLVVH GLH DXV GHP =XVDPPHQVSLHO LKUHU +DQGOXQJHQ UHVXOWLHUHQ EH]HLFKQHW ZHUGHQ -H QDFKGHP ZLH lKQOLFK RGHU XQWHUVFKLHGOLFK GLH %HZHUWXQJ GHU 3ROLWLNHUJHEQLVVH GXUFK GLH $NWHXUH DXVIDOOW LVW .RRSHUDWLRQ PHKU RGHU ZHQLJHU ZDKUVFKHLQOLFK EH]LHKXQJVZHLVH
,P UHLQHQ .RQIOLNWVSLHO 6FKHOOLQJ WULWW GHU ,QWHUHVVHQJHJHQVDW]
]ZLVFKHQ EHLGHQ $NWHXUHQ LQ YROONRPPHQHU )RUP DXI 2SSRQHQW SUlIHULHUW GLH EHLGHQ (UHLJQLVVH GLH DXV D XQG F EH]LHKXQJVZHLVH EXQG G UHVXOWLHUHQ XQG EHZHUWHW GLH (UHLJQLVVH DXI GHU 1HEHQGLDJRQDOHQ DOV ]ZHLWEHVWH 6HLQ
*HJHQVSLHOHU RUGQHW GLH (UHLJQLVVH KLQJHJHQ LQ XPJHNHKUWHU 5HLKHQIROJH DQ .RRSHUDWLRQ LVW KLHU QLFKW ZDKUVFKHLQOLFK GD HV NHLQH (UHLJQLVVH JLEW ZHOFKH GLH $NWHXUH GXUFK NRRSHUDWLYHV 9HUKDOWHQ YHUKLQGHUQ RGHU KHUEHLIXKUHQ P|FKWHQ (QWVFKHLGHQG LVW MHGRFK GDVV DXFK GDV LQ $EELOGXQJ GDUJHVWHOO WH UHLQH .RRUGLQDWLRQVVSLHO NHLQHU ,QVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUXQJ LP 6LQQH HLQHU 9HU VWlQGLJXQJ 5HJHOXQJ 6LFKHUXQJ RGHU 'XUFKVHW]XQJ YRQ LQGLYLGXHOOHQ +DQG OXQJHQ EHGDUI GD GLH .RPPXQLNDWLRQ DOOHLQ GLH (UUHLFKXQJ GHU *HZLQQH VLFKHUW 9HUVWlQGLJHQ VLFK GLH EHLGHQ $NWHXUH EHLVSLHOVZHLVH DXI GLH MHZHLOL JHQ +DQGOXQJHQ D XQG F GDQQ KDW NHLQHU GHU EHLGHQ HLQHQ $QUHL] HLQVHLWLJ YRQ GLHVHU $EVSUDFKH DE]XZHLFKHQ GD HLQH HLQVHLWLJH 9HUOHW]XQJ ]XP LQGLYL GXHOO ZLH NROOHNWLY VFKOHFKWHUHQ (UJHEQLV IXKUHQ ZUGH XQG DXFK HLQH ]ZHL VHLWLJH 9HUOHW]XQJ NHLQHQ 9RUWHLO EUlFKWH
(LQH %HGHXWXQJ NDQQ ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ LQ ,QWHUDNWLRQVVLWXDWLRQHQ ]XNRPPHQ LQ GHQHQ GLH 6WDDWHQ VRZRKO JHPHLQVDPH DOV DXFK JHJHQVlW]OLFKH ,QWHUHVVHQ KDEHQ 6ROFKH mixed motive-Situationen JHVWDWWHQ GHQ $NWHXUHQ GXUFK .R RSHUDWLRQ LQGLYLGXHOOH *HZLQQH ]X HU]LHOHQ GLH EHL HLQHP QLFKWNRRSHUDWLYHQ 9HUKDOWHQ QLFKW P|JOLFK ZHUGHQ LP *HJHQVDW] ]X UHLQHQ .RRUGLQDWLRQVVSLH OHQ XQWHUVFKHLGHQ VLFK DOOHUGLQJV LKUH %HZHUWXQJHQ GHU HLQ]HOQHQ (UHLJQLVVH VR GDVV HLQ .RQIOLNW EHU GHQ ,QKDOW RGHU GLH (LQKDOWXQJ GHU .RRSHUDWLRQV YHUHLQEDUXQJ YRUOLHJW $EELOGXQJ 'LH +DQGOXQJVDOWHUQDWLYHQ GHU 6WDD WHQ ZHUGHQ HQWVSUHFKHQG GHQ ,QWHUDNWLRQVHUJHEQLVVHQ DOV .RRSHUDWLRQ F XQG DOV 6HOEVWKLOIH RGHU 'HIHNWLRQ G EH]HLFKQHW 6QLGD >@
9RQ GHQ P|JOLFKHQ [6SLHOHQ EHL GHQHQ GLH $NWHXUH GLH YLHU UHVXOWLHUHQGHQ (UHLJQLVVH VWULNW RUGLQDO RUGQHQ N|QQHQ YHUEOHLEHQ VHFKV ZHQQ DQJHQRPPHQ ZLUG GDVV D %HZHUWXQJHQ V\PPHWULVFK E JHPHLQVDPH .RRSHUDWLRQ IXU EHLGH EHVVHU LVW DOV JHPHLQVDPH 'HIHNWLRQ VRZLH F HLQVHLWLJH 'HIHNWLRQ JHJHQEHU HLQVHLWLJHU .RRSHUDWLRQ YRUJH]RJHQ ZLUG 5DSRSRUW XQG *X\HU %UDPV 'DV .RRUGLQDWLRQVVSLHO EHL 6QLGDO ZLUG LP )ROJHQGHQ PLW .RRUGLQDWLRQVVSLHO PLW 9HUWHLOXQJVNRQIOLNW =DQJO XQG =UQ EH]HLFKQHW LQ GHU /LWHUDWXU JlQJLJ LVW HEHQIDOOV GHU %HJULII %DWWOH RI WKH 6H[HV 'HU %HJULII GHV )HLJOLQJ6SLHOV IXU GLH VHFKVWH 3UlIHUHQ]NRQVWHOODWLRQ EHUXKW DXI GHU DPHULNDQLVFKHQ %H]HLFKQXQJ &KLFNHQ*DPH 'DV +DUPRQLHVSLHO EH ]HLFKQHW 6FKDUSI PLVVYHUVWlQGOLFK DOV UHLQHV .RRUGLQDWLRQVVSLHO REZRKO LP +DUPRQLHVSLHO NHLQH .RRUGLQDWLRQVOHLVWXQJ QRWZHQGLJ LVW
AbbildungSechs idealtypische Verhandlungssituationen
$NWHXU $NWHXU
F G F G
$NWHXU , F $NWHXU , F
G ,, G
7\S +DUPRQLH 7\S 9HUVLFKHUXQJ ,
$NWHXU $NWHXU
F G F G
$NWHXU , F $NWHXU F
G G
7\S 9HUVLFKHUXQJ ,, 7\S .RRUGLQDWLRQVVSLHO PLW 9HUWHLOXQJVNRQIOLNW
$NWHXU $NWHXU
F G F G
$NWHXU , F $NWHXU F
G G
7\S *HIDQJHQHQ 7\S )HLJOLQJ
GLOHPPD
9|OOLJ SUREOHPORV VLQG +DUPRQLHVLWXDWLRQHQ %HLGH 6WDDWHQ SURILWLHUHQ DP PHLVWHQ YRQ .RRSHUDWLRQ XQG HV JLEW NHLQHQ $QUHL] ]XU 'HIHNWLRQ EH]LH KXQJVZHLVH NHLQH )XUFKW YRU HLQHU HLQVHLWLJHQ .RRSHUDWLRQ ,P *HJHQVDW]
]XP UHLQHQ .RRUGLQDWLRQVVSLHO JLEW HV HLQH GRPLQDQWH 6WUDWHJLH IXU GLH EHL GHQ $NWHXUH VR GDVV ZHGHU $QUHL]H ]XU .RRSHUDWLRQ JHVFKDIIHQ ZHUGHQ PVVHQ QRFK NRPPXQL]LHUW XQG 9HUKDOWHQ EHUKDXSW NRRUGLQLHUW ZHUGHQ 'D LQ +DUPRQLHVLWXDWLRQHQ NHLQH .RRUGLQDWLRQVOHLVWXQJ QRWZHQGLJ LVW JUHQ]W .HRKDQH +DUPRQLH YRQ .RRSHUDWLRQ DXV $XV SUDJPDWLVFKHQ *UQGHQ VROOHQ GLH $N WHXUVVWUDWHJLHQ DXFK LP +DUPRQLHVSLHO DOV .RRSHUDWLRQ XQG 'HIHNWLRQ EH]HLFKQHW ZHUGHQ
(LQH 6WUDWHJLH $ GRPLQLHUW HLQH 6WUDWHJLH % ZHQQ EHL EHOLHELJHQ +DQGOXQJHQ GHV DQGHUHQ $NWHXUV EH]LHKXQJVZHLVH GHU DQGHUHQ $NWHXUH QXU JOHLFK EHZHUWHWH XQG ]X PLQGHVW HLQPDO HLQ EHVVHU EHZHUWHWHV ,QWHUDNWLRQVHUJHEQLVVH DXIWUHWHQ N|QQHQ 2UGHV KRRN
PXVV 'LH 9HUIROJXQJ LQGLYLGXHOOHU ,QWHUHVVHQ IXKUW XQPLWWHOEDU ]X JHPHLQ VDPHQ *HZLQQHQ
,Q GHQ 9HUVLFKHUXQJVVSLHOHQ , XQG UHVXOWLHUW ]ZDU GLH .RRSHUDWLRQ EHL GHU 6WDDWHQ FF LP LQGLYLGXHOO XQG NROOHNWLY RSWLPDOHQ (UJHEQLV $OOHUGLQJV NDQQ GLH )XUFKW GHU 6SLHOHU YRU GHP XQJQVWLJVWHQ (UJHEQLV GF IXU 6SLHOHU EH]LHKXQJVZHLVH FG IXU 6SLHOHU GLHVH ]XU 'HIHNWLRQ YHUDQODVVHQ GD QXU HLQH HLJHQH 'HIHNWLRQ LKQHQ JDUDQWLHUW GDVV GDV IXU VLH XQJQVWLJVWH (UJHEQLV QLFKW HLQWULWW 'LH 3UlIHUHQ]RUGQXQJ GHU 6SLHOHU LP 9HUVLFKHUXQJVVSLHO OlVVW GHVKDOE WURW] JHPHLQVDPHU *HZLQQH GLH 'HIHNWLRQ GHU 6SLHOHU HUZDUWHQ GG 'LH UHDOLVWLVFKH 7KHRULHVFKXOH VLHKW LQ GLHVHU 9HUKDQGOXQJVVLWXDWLRQ GLH 8Q P|JOLFKNHLW LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU .RRSHUDWLRQ UHSUlVHQWLHUW GD XQWHU GHQ %HGLQ JXQJHQ GHU $QDUFKLH NRRSHUDWLYHV 9HUKDOWHQ QLFKW JHVLFKHUW ZHUGHQ N|QQH :DOW] 6WDDWHQ ZUGHQ GHVKDOE HKHU YHUVXFKHQ PD[LPDOH 9HUOXVWH ]X UHGX]LHUHQ DOV PD[LPDOH *HZLQQH ]X HU]LHOHQ YJO 2\H 6SLHOH GHV YLHUWHQ 7\SV ZHUGHQ LQ GHU /LWHUDWXU RIWPDOV ]XU ,OOXVWUDWLRQ YRQ 3UREOHPVL WXDWLRQHQ KHUDQJH]RJHQ LQ GHQHQ GLH 5HDOLVLHUXQJ HU]LHLEDUHU *HZLQQH GXUFK 9HUWHLOXQJVNRQIOLNWH ]ZLVFKHQ GHQ 6WDDWHQ HUVFKZHUW ZLUG .UDVQHU
>@ hEHUEOLFN EHL =DQJO XQG =UQ 'LH 3UlIHUHQ]RUGQXQJ GHU $N WHXUH LQ GLHVHQ .RRUGLQDWLRQVVSLHOHQ PLW 9HUWHLOXQJVNRQIOLNW LPSOL]LHUHQ GDVV DXV NROOHNWLYHU ZLH LQGLYLGXHOOHU 6LFKW GLH 1HEHQGLDJRQDOH EHVVHUH (UJHEQLVVH HQWKlOW 7KH SUREOHP LV QRW KRZ WR JHW WR WKH 3DUHWR IURQWLHU EXW ZKLFK SRLQW DORQJ WKH IURQWLHU ZLOO EH FKRVHQ .UDVQHU >@ 'D VLFK GLH EHLGHQ 6SLHOHU VFKZHUOLFK DXI HLQHV GHU EHLGHQ ZQVFKEDUHQ (UJHEQLVVH HLQLJHQ N|QQHQ EHVWHKW GLH *HIDKU HLQVHLWLJHU 'HIHNWLRQ ZDV LP VFKOHFKWHV WHQ (UJHEQLV GG HQGHW
,Q VRJHQDQQWHQ *HIDQJHQHQGLOHPPD6LWXDWLRQHQ YHUVSULFKW GHQ $NWHXUHQ GLH HLQVHLWLJH 'HIHNWLRQ GHQ K|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bKQOLFK GHP *HIDQJHQHQGLOHPPD JHIlKUGHQ DXFK LP )HLJOLQJ6SLHO GLH $QUHL]H XQLODWHUDOHU 'HIHNWLRQ GLH .RRSHUDWLRQ
GHU EHLGHQ $NWHXUH $OOHUGLQJV IXKUW GLH 'HIHNWLRQ EHLGHU KLHU ]XP GHQNEDU VFKOHFKWHVWHQ (UJHEQLV IXU EHLGH 6HLWHQ 'DV EHGHXWHW LQVEHVRQGHUH GDVV GHU ]ZHLWH 6SLHOHU VROOWH GHU (UVWH JODXEKDIW VHLQH 'HIHNWLRQ DQGURKHQ VLFK EHV VHU DOV )HLJOLQJ NRRSHUDWLY YHUKlOW GF GHQQ GHU 'URKXQJ VWDQG KlOW XQG HEHQIDOOV GHIHNWLHUW GG
'LH LGHDOW\SLVFKHQ 9HUKDQGOXQJVVLWXDWLRQHQ OHJHQ GHQ 6FKOXVV QDKH GDVV VLFK VRZRKO GLH &KDQFHQ IXU .RRSHUDWLRQ LQ GHQ LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ %H]LHKXQJHQ DOV DXFK GLH 5ROOHQ GLH ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ GDEHL VSLHOHQ N|QQHQ MH QDFK .RQILJX UDWLRQ GHU ,QWHUHVVHQODJHQ XQWHUVFKHLGHQ 6R EHGDUI HV LQ UHLQHQ .RRUGLQDWL RQVVSLHOHQ GHU .RRUGLQDWLRQ YRQ +DQGOXQJHQ XP JHPHLQVDPH *HZLQQH ]X VLFKHUQ ,QWHUQDWLRQDOHQ ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ NRPPW KLHU GLH %HGHXWXQJ ]X GDVV PLW GHU (LQULFKWXQJ YRQ 6HNUHWDULDWHQ )DFKJUHPLHQ RGHU UHJHOPlLJHQ *H VSUlFKVUXQGHQ GLH QRWZHQGLJHQ ,QIRUPDWLRQHQ DXVJHWDXVFKW ZHUGHQ GLH HLQH .RRUGLQDWLRQ GHU $NWHXUVKDQGOXQJHQ HUP|JOLFKHQ .RRSHUDWLRQVVLFKHUQGH /HLVWXQJHQ ZLH .RQWUROOH RGHU 'XUFKVHW]XQJ PVVHQ GLHVH $UUDQJHPHQWV QLFKW HUEULQJHQ GD VLFK GLH ,QWHUHVVHQ GHU $NWHXUH DXI GLH JHPHLQVDPH 9HU PHLGXQJ XQNRRUGLQLHUWHU +DQGOXQJHQ EHVFKUlQNHQ ,Q .RRUGLQDWLRQVVSLHOHQ PLW 9HUWHLOXQJVNRQIOLNWHQ WUHWHQ ]XVlW]OLFKH GLVWULEXWLYH 3UREOHPH ]XWDJH VR GDVV HV 0HFKDQLVPHQ HWZD NROOHNWLYHU (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ EHGDUI ZHL FKH GLH $XVZDKO XQG 'XUFKVHW]XQJ HLQHV GHU EHLGHQ P|JOLFKHQ (UHLJQLVVH KHUEHLIXKUHQ
,QVWLWXWLRQHOOH $UUDQJHPHQWV N|QQHQ DXFK LQ *HIDQJHQHQGLOHPPD 6LWXDWLRQHQ GLH .RRSHUDWLRQ YRQ 6WDDWHQ XQG GDPLW GLH 9HUZLUNOLFKXQJ JH PHLQVDPHU ,QWHUHVVHQ HUOHLFKWHUQ +LHU VLQG 5HJHOQ Q|WLJ GLH LQGLYLGXHOOHV 9HUKDOWHQ YRUVFKUHLEHQ VLFKHUQ XQG GXUFKVHW]HQ 7ULWW GLH 'LOHPPD 6LWXDWLRQ ZLHGHUKROW DXI GDQQ NDQQ VLFK HLQH VWDELOH .RRSHUDWLRQ KHUDXVELO GHQ ZHQQ ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ LQ GHU )RUP YRQ HYROXWLRQlU HQWVWDQGHQHQ .RQYHQ WLRQHQ RGHU LQWHQWLRQDO XQG H[SOL]LW YHUHLQEDUWHQ 9HUWUlJHQ GLH +DQGOXQJVDO WHUQDWLYHQ GHU $NWHXUH GDXHUKDIW YHUlQGHUQ $[HOURG 5HIOH[LYH $Q VlW]H LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU 3ROLWLN EHWRQHQ KLHU GLH 5ROOH GLH ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ EHL GHU +HUDXVELOGXQJ JHPHLQVDPHU NRJQLWLYHU .RQ]HSWLRQHQ GHU 5HDOLWlW XQG GDPLW YRQ $XV]DKOXQJVPXVWHUQ VSLHOHQ VR GDVV 'LOHPPD6LWXDWLRQHQ LQ +DUPRQLHVLWXDWLRQHQ EHUIXKUW ZHUGHQ N|QQWHQ YJO HWZD +DDV :LOOLDPV XQG %DEDL
=XVDPPHQIDVVHQG EHGHXWHW GLHV GDVV ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ EHU GLH %HUHLWVWHOOXQJ YRQ ,QIRUPDWLRQHQ XQG 6DQNWLRQVSRWHQ]LDO RIIHQVLFKWOLFK HLQHQ %HLWUDJ ]XU .RRSHUDWLRQ OLHIHUQ N|QQHQ 8QNODU EOHLEW MHGRFK LQZLHIHUQ 5HJHOQ IXU GLH
(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ HLQHQ VSH]LILVFKHQ %HLWUDJ OLHIHUQ GHU EHU GLH (LQULFK WXQJ DOOJHPHLQHU LQVWLWXWLRQHOOHU $UUDQJHPHQWV KLQDXVJHKW 9HUVXFKW PDQ EHLVSLHOVZHLVH GLH SULQ]LSLHOOH .RQIOLNWVWUXNWXU GHU 0HHUHVERGHQQXW]XQJ LQ HLQHU 9HUKDQGOXQJVVLWXDWLRQ ]X UHSUlVHQWLHUHQ GDQQ HUVFKHLQW IROJHQGH 'DU VWHOOXQJ P|JOLFK $EELOGXQJ
$XV 'DUVWHOOXQJVJUXQGHQ ZLUG GLH 9HUKDQGOXQJVVLWXDWLRQ LQ GLHVHU XQG GHU IROJHQGHQ
$EELOGXQJ LQ HLQHUQ VHTXHQWLHOOHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVEDXP UHSUlVHQWLHUW 'LH .QRWHQ VWH KHQ IU 6SLHOHU /LQLHQ IU GHUHQ +DQGOXQJVDOWHPDWLYHQ XQG GLH :HUWH DP REHUHQ (Q GH GHV (QWVFKHLGXQJVEDXPHV VWHOOHQ GLH LQGLYLGXHOOHQ %HZHUWXQJHQ GHU (UHLJQLVVH GXUFK GLH $NWHXUH GDU *HVWULFKHOWH /LQLHQ YHUELQGHQ 3XQNWH HLQHU ,QIRUPDWLRQVPHQJH GDV EHGHXWHW LQ $EELOGXQJ $NWHXU ZHL EHL VHLQHU (QWVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ F XQG G QLFKW ZHOFKH :DKO $NWHXU , JHWURIIHQ KDW
AbbildungKooperation durch Institutionalisierung
R ,
R
, , , ,$XI GHU HUVWHQ 6WXIH HQWVFKHLGHQ GLH $NWHXUH XQG EHU GLH (LQULFKWXQJ GHU ,QVWLWXWLRQ,ZREHL LP )DOOH HLQHU 1LFKWEHUHLQVWLPPXQJ NHLQH ,QVWLWXWLR QDOLVLHUXQJ HUIROJW XQG GLHVH )lOOH ZLHGHUXP LP *HIDQJHQHQGLOHPPD HQGHQ (QWVFKHLGHQ VLFK EHLGH $NWHXUH IXU , GDQQ JLOW IXU +DQGOXQJHQ GLH (LQVWLP PLJNHLWVUHJHO 1XU ZHQQ EHLGH $NWHXUH EHU LKUH SULQ]LSLHOOHQ +DQGOXQJVDO WHUQDWLYHQ EHUHLQNRPPHQ ZHUGHQ GLHVH +DQGOXQJHQ DXFK DXVJHIXKUW LQ DOOHQ DQGHUHQ )lOOHQ EOHLEW GHU 6WDWXV TXR HUKDOWHQ ZDV ]X $XV]DKOXQJVZHU WHQ YRQ QXOO IXKUW ,P LQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQ 7HLOVSLHO VWHOOHQ QXQ DXFK QHEHQ HLQL JHQ 6WDWXVTXR$OWHUQDWLYHQ VlPWOLFKH .RRSHUDWLRQVKDQGOXQJHQ JOHLFKJH ZLFKWLJH /|VXQJHQ GDU VR GDVV GLH $NWHXUH NHLQ ,QWHUHVVH DQ HLQHP HLQVHLWL HLQVHLWLJHQ %LQGXQJ 9HUOXVWH HUZDUWHQ VR GDVV GDV 1LFKW]XVWDQGHNRPPHQ HLQHU .RRSHUDWLRQ PLW GHP $XV]DKOXQJVZHUW QXOO SURJQRVWL]LHUW ZHUGHQ NDQQ
(LQHQ $XVZHJ DXV GLHVHP 'LOHPPD HUP|JOLFKW GLH (LQULFKWXQJ HLQHV 5H JLPHV LQ GHP GLH EHLGHQ $NWHXUH LKUH +DQGOXQJHQ PLWWHOV HLQHU NROOHNWLYHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJ DXIHLQDQGHU DEVWLPPHQ ,P )ROJHQGHQ VROO GDYRQ DXVJHJDQJHQ ZHUGHQ GDVV LQGLYLGXHOOH +DQGOXQJHQ GDQQ DXVJHIXKUW ZHUGHQ GUIHQ ZHQQ EHLGH $NWHXUH GLHV ]XYRU QDFK GHU (LQVWLPPLJNHLWVUHJHO EHVFKORVVHQ KDEHQ
$EELOGXQJ ]HLJW GLH $EIROJH HLQHU P|JOLFKHQ ,QVWLWXWLRQHQHLQULFKWXQJ XQG HLQHU DQVFKOLHHQGHQ LQKDOWOLFKHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJ LQ HLQHP PHKUVWXILJHQ (QW VFKHLGXQJVEDXP
R
R, ,
AbbildungNicht-Kooperation im Gefangenendilemma
$XVJDQJVSXQNW VLQG ]ZHL $NWHXUH EH]LHKXQJVZHLVH $NWHXUVJUXSSHQ HLQ (QWZLFNOXQJVODQG $NWHXU VRZLH HLQ 6WDDW PLW KRKHP ,QGXVWULDOLVLHUXQJV JUDG $NWHXU -HGHU GHU EHLGHQ $NWHXUH YHUIXJW SULQ]LSLHOO EHU ]ZHL +DQGOXQJVDOWHUQDWLYHQ =XP HLQHQ NDQQ HU LQ HLQHP 0HHUHVERGHQUHJLPH NR RSHULHUHQ D XQG F ]XP DQGHUHQ VLFK QLFKW DP 5HJLPH EHWHLOLJHQ XQG LVW GDQQ QLFKW GHVVHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ XQG 5HJHOQ XQWHUZRUIHQ E XQG G ,Q GHU $E ELOGXQJ VLQG GLH $XV]DKOXQJHQ GHU $NWHXUH XQG IXU GLH YLHU P|JOLFKHQ (UHLJQLVVH DQJHJHEHQ GLH HLQH *HIDQJHQHQGLOHPPD6LWXDWLRQ EHVFKUHLEHQ
%HLGH $NWHXUH SURILWLHUHQ YRQ HLQHU .RRSHUDWLRQ LQ HLQHP LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ 5HJLPH DXIJUXQG GHU 5HVVRXUFHQQXW]XQJ VRZLH GHU 5HFKWVVLFKHUKHLW GHV 5HJLPHV JHJHQEHU GHP 6WDWXV TXR GHU DOV )ROJH GHU 1LFKW+DQGOXQJHQ E XQG G JHJHEHQ VHLQ VROO $OOHUGLQJV PVVHQ EHLGH $NWHXUH IXU GHQ )DOO HLQHU
JHQ $EZHLFKHQ YRQ GHU NROOHNWLYHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJ KDEHQ %HWUDFKWHW PDQ GLH EHLGHQ $NWHXUH QLFKW DOV HLQ]HOQH 6WDDWHQ VRQGHUQ DOV (QWZLFNOXQJVOlQGHU HLQHUVHLWV XQG ,QGXVWULHVWDDWHQ DQGHUHUVHLWV GDQQ UHSUlVHQWLHUW GLH (LQVWLP PLJNHLWVUHJHO HLQH $UW 0HKUNDPPHUSULQ]LS QDFK GHP (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ QXU PLW =XVWLPPXQJ EHLGHU 6WDDWHQJUXSSHQ P|JOLFK VLQG 9RUDXVVHW]XQJ LVW QD WUOLFK GDVV GHUDUWLJH NROOHNWLYH (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ DXFK EHIROJW ZHUGHQ GDV KHLW GXUFKVHW]XQJVIlKLJ VLQG 'LHV LVW MHGRFK HLQ 3UREOHP DQGHUHU $UW *H JHQVWDQG GHU YRUOLHJHQGHQ )UDJHVWHOOXQJ LVW KLQJHJHQ GLH )XQNWLRQ GLH 5H JHOQ GHU NROOHNWLYHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ ]XNRPPHQ VROO
2IIHQ PXVV DQ GLHVHU 6WHOOH EOHLEHQ ZHOFKH :LUNXQJHQ YRQ 5HJHOQ DXVJH KHQ ZHQQ QLFKW ]ZHL VRQGHUQ EHU 6WDDWHQ YHUVXFKHQ LKUH XQWHUVFKLHG OLFKHQ ,QWHUHVVHQ LQ (LQNODQJ ]XEULQJHQ 'DEHL LVW GLH )UDJH ZHOFKH IRUPDOHQ 9RUJDEHQ GLH NROOHNWLYH (QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ VWHXHUQ VROOHQ DOOHV DQGHUH DOV HLQIDFK ]X EHDQWZRUWHQ (LQ *UXQG GDIXU LVW GDVV HV RSWLPDOH 5HJHOQ QLFKW JHEHQ NDQQ HLQ ]ZHLWHU *UXQG OLHJW LQ ]ZHL %HVRQGHUKHLWHQ YRQ 9HUHLQED UXQJHQ EHU 5HJHOQ QlPOLFK LKUHU 8QYROOVWlQGLJNHLW XQG LKUHU 'DXHUKDIWLJ NHLW
(LJHQVFKDIWHQ YRQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ
.ROOHNWLYH (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ OHJHQ IHVW ZLH *UXSSHQ YRQ $NWHXUHQ LKUH XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ EHU GLH $XVJHVWDOWXQJ EHVWLPPWHU (UHLJQLV VH ]XVDPPHQIDVVHQ (LQH EHVRQGHUH %HGHXWXQJ NRPPW GHP 8PVWDQG ]X GDVV HV VLFK XP .ROOHNWLYHQWVFKHLGXQJHQ LQ ]ZHLIDFKHU +LQVLFKW KDQGHOW 6LH VLQG NROOHNWLYH (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ GDV KHLW VLH ZHUGHQ YRQ HLQHU *UXSSH YRQ
$NWHXUHQ JHPHLQVDP JHWURIIHQ XQG VLH VLQG NROOHNWLYLHUWH (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ XQG GDPLW IXU HLQH $GUHVVDWHQJUXSSH YHUELQGOLFK 6DUWRUL (QW VFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ DJJUHJLHUHQ GHPQDFK GLH LQGLYLGXHOOHQ 3ROLWLNYRUVWHOOXQJHQ RGHU 3UlIHUHQ]HQ GHU %HWHLOLJWHQ ]X HLQHU HLQ]HOQHQ NROOHNWLYHQ 3UlIHUHQ]
RUGQXQJ ZREHL VLFKHUJHVWHOOW VHLQ VROOWH GDVV GDV (UJHEQLV GLH 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ GHU %HWHLOLJWHQ LQ DQJHPHVVHQHU :HLVH ZLGHUVSLHJHOW
(LQLJH GHU 6FKZLHULJNHLWHQ GLH PLW NROOHNWLYHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ YHUEXQGHQ VLQG ZHUGHQ DP %HLVSLHO HLQHU HLQIDFKHQ $EVWLPPXQJVVLWXDWLRQ GHXWOLFK GLH EHUHLWV 0DUTXLV GH &RQGRUFHW EHVFKULHEHQ KDW $QJHQRPPHQ GUHL 3HUVRQHQ $ % XQG & EHVWLPPHQ PHKUKHLWOLFK EHU GLH $XVZDKO YRQ HLQHU
O
YRQ GUHL $OWHUQDWLYHQ x, y XQG z. 'DEHL VHLHQ GLH 3UlIHUHQ]RUGQXQJHQ GHU%HWHLOLJWHQ YRQ GHU EHVWHQ ]XU VFKOHFKWHVWHQ $OWHUQDWLYH ZLH IROJW JHJHEHQ
$ % &
x Z Y
Y x Z
Z Y x
,QVEHVRQGHUH VLQG GLH 2UGQXQJHQ WUDQVLWLY GD EHLVSLHOVZHLVH GHU HUVWH %HWHL OLJWH PLW[JHJHQEHUy XQGy JHJHQEHU]DXFK[JHJHQEHU]SUlIHULHUW %H JLQQHQ GLH GUHL %HWHLOLJWHQ QXQ PLW GHU SDDUZHLVHQ $EVWLPPXQJ EHU GLH GUHL
$OWHUQDWLYHQ GDQQ IXKUW GLH HLQIDFKH 0HKUKHLWVUHJHO ]X (QWVFKHLGXQJV]\NOHQ GD $OWHUQDWLYH x JHJHQEHUy HLQH 0HKUKHLW YRQ $ XQG % ILQGHW zJHJHQ
EHUx YRQ %XQG & DEHU DXFKy JHJHQEHUz YRQ $ XQG & :HOFKH GHU GUHL $OWHUQDWLYHQ OHW]WOLFK DXVJHZlKOW ZLUG LVW RKQH ZHLWHUH $QQDKPHQ QLFKW YRUKHU]XVDJHQ SDUDGR[ PXVV HUVFKHLQHQ GDVV XQWHU GHU HLQIDFKHQ 0HKU KHLWVUHJH LQGLYLGXHOOWUDQVLWLYH 3UlIHUHQ]HQ LQ LQWUDQVLWLYH 3UlIHUHQ]HQ GHV .ROOHNWLYV YHUZDQGHOW ZHUGHQ 'DV VRJHQDQQWH &RQGRUFHW3DUDGR[RQ ]HLJW GUHLHUOHL (UVWHQV DJJUHJLHUHQ VHOEVW HLQIDFKH (QWVFKHLGXQJVYRUJDEHQ ZLH GLH 0HKUKHLWVUHJHO QLFKW QRWZHQGLJ VLQQYROOH WUDQVLWLYH 3UlIHUHQ]NRQILJXUD WLRQHQ LQ HEHQVR VLQQYROOH NROOHNWLYH 3UlIHUHQ]HQ =ZHLWHQV LVW QLFKW HLQGHXWLJ YRUKHUVDJEDU ZHOFKH (QWVFKHLGXQJ OHW]WOLFK JHWURIIHQ ZLUG REZRKO GLH 3Ul IHUHQ]HQ DOOHU %HWHLOLJWHQ EHNDQQW VLQG 'ULWWHQV NRPPW QHEHQ GHU $EVWLP PXQJVUHJHO ZHLWHUHQ LQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQ 9RUJDEHQ HWZD ZLH RIW DEJHVWLPPW ZLUG XQG ZHU DOV $JHQGD6HW]HU 9RUVFKOlJH ]X $EVWLPPXQJ EULQJHQ GDUI HLQH ZHVHQWOLFKH %HGHXWXQJ ]X
'LHVHV %HLVSLHO LVW MHGRFK NHLQHVZHJV DW\SLVFK IXU NROOHNWLYH (QWVFKHL GXQJVVLWXDWLRQ 7DWVlFKOLFK JLEW HV QDFK $UURZV VRJHQDQQWHP 8Q PlJOLFKNHLWVWKHRUHP NHLQHQ 0HFKDQLVPXV ]XU $JJUHJDWLRQ EHOLHELJHU $N WHXUVSUlIHUHQ]HQ EHU GUHL RGHU PHKU $OWHUQDWLYHQ GHU GLH IROJHQGHQ YLHU SODXVLEOHQ $QIRUGHUXQJHQ DQ HLQH NROOHNWLYH (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHO HUIXOOHQ ZUGH +LQLFK XQG 0XQJHU I
- Pareto-Prinzip: ZHQQ DOOH %HWHLOLJWHQ LQGLYLGXHOOx JHJHQEHUy YRU]LHKHQ GDQQ ZLUG DXFK NROOHNWLYxJHJHQEHUy YRUJH]RJHQ
Transitivität: ZHQQ NROOHNWLY x JHJHQEHUy XQGy JHJHQEHU z SUlIHULHUW ZLUG GDQQ ZLUG DXFKxJHJHQEHUzSUlIHULHUW
Unabhängigkeit von irrelevanten Alternativen: :LUG NROOHNWLY x JHJHQ
EHUy YRUJH]RJHQ GDQQ JLOW GLHV DXFK ZHQQ VLFK LQGLYLGXHOO GLH %HZHU WXQJ DQGHUHU $OWHUQDWLYHQ lQGHUW
_ Ausschluss der Diktatur: HV JLEW NHLQHQ %HWHLOLJWHQ GHVVHQ 3UlIHUHQ] XQ PLWWHOEDU ]XU NROOHNWLYHQ 3UlIHUHQ] ZLUG
$OOH YLHU %HGLQJXQJHQ VWHOOHQ RIIHQVLFKWOLFK YHUQQIWLJH $QIRUGHUXQJHQ DQ NROOHNWLYH (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ GDU 'DV 5HVXOWDW YRQ $UURZ ]HLJW GDVV HV NHLQH RSWLPDOHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ JHEHQ NDQQ VRQGHUQ DOOH 5HJHOQ HLQH RGHU PHKUHUH $QIRUGHUXQJHQ QLFKW HUIXOOHQ XQG XQHUZQVFKWH (LJHQVFKDIWHQ DXIZHLVHQ 'LH (LQULFKWXQJ YRQ 9HUIDKUHQ ]XU NROOHNWLYHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVILQ GXQJ HUIRUGHUW GHPQDFK YRQ GHQ $NWHXUHQ GLH PHKU RGHU ZHQLJHU EHNDQQ WHQ 9RU XQG 1DFKWHLOH YRQ YHUVFKLHGHQHQ $UUDQJHPHQWV DEZlJHQ ]X PV VHQ +LQ]X NRPPW GDVV GLH (LQIXKUXQJ YRQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVYHUIDKUHQ VSH]LIL VFKHU $EPDFKXQJHQ KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU %HVHW]XQJ YRQ *UHPLHQ GHU 0HKUKHLWV NULWHULHQ HWF ]X HLQHP =HLWSXQNW EHGDUI ZHOFKHU GHU NROOHNWLYHQ (QWVFKHL GXQJVILQGXQJ EHU NRQNUHWH 3ROLWLNLQKDOWH YRUDXVJHKW $XFK LQWHUQDWLRQDOH 9HUHLQEDUXQJHQ ]ZLVFKHQ 6WDDWHQ ]XU .RRSHUDWLRQ LQ HLQHP 3UREOHPIHOG VLQG ODQJIULVWLJ ZHQQ QLFKW VRJDU DXI HLQHQ XQEHVWLPPWHQ =HLWUDXP KLQ DQJHOHJW ,KUH 'DXHUKDIWLJNHLW VWHOOW GLH YHUKDQGHOQGHQ 6WDDWHQ SULQ]LSLHOO YRU GLH $XI JDEH VFKRQ KHXWH GLH $XVZLUNXQJHQ GHU 9HUHLQEDUXQJ LQ GHU =XNXQIW HLQ VFKlW]HQ XQG EHZHUWHQ ]X PVVHQ
8QDEKlQJLJ YRQ GLHVHP ]HLWOLFKHQ $VSHNW XQWHUVFKHLGHQ VLFK 9HUHLQED UXQJHQ MHGRFK KLQVLFKWOLFK GHV *UDGHV LKUHU 9ROOVWlQGLJNHLW 'HU NODVVLVFKH 9HUWUDJ LVW LGHDOW\SLVFK YROOVWlQGLJ GD HU DOOH P|JOLFKHQ (YHQWXDOLWlWHQ GXUFK
$XIQDKPH HQWVSUHFKHQGHU %HVWLPPXQJHQ UHJHOW XQG GLHVH LQ HLQHP LP 9RU KLQHLQ HLQGHXWLJ GHILQLHUWHQ 6LQQH YHUELQGOLFK PDFKW $OV XQYROOVWlQGLJ RGHU DOV UHODWLRQDOH 9HUWUlJH N|QQHQ GDQQ 9HUHLQEDUXQJHQ EH]HLFKQHW ZHUGHQ GLH QLFKW DOOH P|JOLFKHQ ]XNQIWLJHQ 6LWXDWLRQHQ ]X EHUFNVLFKWLJHQ YHUVXFKHQ VRQGHUQ GLH /|VXQJ GHV ,QWHUGHSHQGHQ]SUREOHPV LQ GLH =XNXQIW YHUODJHUQ 5LFKWHU XQG )XUXERWQ ,P OHW]WHQ )DOO HLQLJHQ VLFK $NWHXUH QLFKW DXI NRQNUHWH 3ROLWLNLQKDOWH DEHU DXI HLQH 9RUJHKHQVZHLVH HWZD 9HUIDK
5HDOLWHU VLQG 9HUHLQEDUXQJHQ VWHWV XQYROOVWlQGLJ GD QLH VlPWOLFKH (YHQWXDOLWlWHQ EHUFNVLFKWLJW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ $OV XQYROOVWlQGLJ VROOHQ LP )ROJHQGHQ VROFKH 9HUHLQ EDUXQJHQ EH]HLFKQHW ZHUGHQ ZHOFKH GLH 0|JOLFKNHLW EH]LHKXQJVZHLVH 1RWZHQGLJNHLW YRQ VSlWHUHQ $NWHXUVHQWVFKHLGXQJHQ DQVWHOOH EORHU 9HUWUDJVHUIOOXQJ DXVGUFNOLFK YRUVHKHQ
UHQV XQG (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ QDFK GHU LQKDOWOLFKH (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ ]X NQIWLJ XQG YRQ )DOO ]X )DOO JHWURIIHQ ZHUGHQ 6LH VWHOOHQ OHGLJOLFK GLH 5DK PHQEHGLQJXQJHQ IXU GDV ]XNQIWLJH $NWHXUVKDQGHOQ EHUHLW VR GDVV GLH WDW VlFKOLFKHQ .RQVHTXHQ]HQ LQGLUHNW DXV GHU 9HUHLQEDUXQJ UHVXOWLHUHQ
=XVDPPHQIDVVHQG LVW GDYRQ DXV]XJHKHQ GDVV DXV 6LFKW GHU $NWHXUH GLH :D: YRQ 5HJHOQ LQ PHKUHUHU +LQVLFKW HLQH VFKZLHULJH $XIJDEH LVW (UVWHQV ZHUGHQ ]LHOJHULFKWHW KDQGHOQGH $NWHXUH NDXP DXVVFKOLHOLFK LKUH PRPHQWD QHQ ,QWHUHVVHQ EHUFNVLFKWLJHQ XQG YHUIROJHQ VRQGHUQ PVVHQ VLFK YLHOPHKU
*HGDQNHQ EHU LKUH ZDKUVFKHLQOLFKHQ ,QWHUHVVHQ PDFKHQ GLH VLH ]XNQIWLJ EHL GHU ,PSOHPHQWDWLRQ GLHVHU 5HJHOQ KDEHQ ZHUGHQ (QWVSUHFKHQGHV JLOW IXU LKUH 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ EHU GHQ .UHLV GHU ]XNQIWLJ %HWHLOLJWHQ XQG %HWURIIHQHQ VRZLH GHUHQ LQKDOWOLFKHQ =LHOH =ZHLWHQV VHW]W HLQH 9HUHLQEDUXQJ EHU 5HJHOQ GLH $EVFKlW]XQJ GHU P|JOLFKHQ XQG ZDKUVFKHLQOLFKHQ :LUNXQJHQ GLHVHU 5H JHOQ YRUDXV GLH ZLH GDV %HLVSLHO GHV &RQGRUFHW3DUDGR[RQV ]HLJW VFKZLHULJ VHLQ NDQQ 'ULWWHQV HUIRUGHUW GLH (LQULFKWXQJ YRQ 5HJHOQ IXU JHZ|KQOLFK GDVV XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ EHU GLH $XVJHVWDOWXQJ GHU 5HJHOQ LQ (LQ NODQJ ]X EULQJHQ VLQG $XI GHU $QDO\VHHEHQH VWHKHQ GDPLW GUHL )UDJHQ LP 0LWWHOSXQNW
EH]JOLFK GHUDauerhaftigkeit: :HOFKH 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ EHVLW]HQ GLH $NWHX UH EHU GLH =XNXQIW LQVEHVRQGHUH KLQVLFKWOLFK LKUHU HLJHQHQ ,QWHUHVVHQ XQG GHU ,QWHUHVVHQ GHU DQGHUHQ $NWHXUH"
EH]JOLFK GHU Unvollständigkeit: :HOFKH 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ EHVLW]HQ GLH $N WHXUH EHU GLH :LUNXQJHQ YRQ DOWHUQDWLYHQ 5HJHOQ"
EH]JOLFK GHU Vereinbarkeit: :LH N|QQHQ VLFK GLH $NWHXUH XQWHU GHU 5DQGEHGLQJXQJ GHV 3ULPDWV GHU 6WDDWHQVRXYHUlQLWlW LQ GHU LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ 3ROLWLN EHL PLWXQWHU XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ DXI GLH (LQULFKWXQJ YRQ 5HJHOQ HLQLJHQ"
'LH YRUDQJHJDQJHQHQ EHUOHJXQJHQ YHUGHXWOLFKHQ GLH 6FKZLHULJNHLWHQ GLH VLFK VRZRKO IXU GLH $NWHXUH GLH EHU VROFKH 5HJHOQ HQWVFKHLGHQ DOV DXFK EHL GHU (UNOlUXQJ GHU 5HJHOZDKO HUJHEHQ (UIROJW GLH 5HJHOHLQULFKWXQJ DEVLFKWV YROO XQG ]LHOJHULFKWHW GDQQ HUIRUGHUQ LQVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLVFKH (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ LP *HJHQVDW] ]X GLUHNWHQ XQG YROOVWlQGLJHQ 9HUHLQEDUXQJHQ EHU NRQNUHWH 6DFKJHJHQVWlQGH YRQ GHQ %HWHLOLJWHQ GLH P|JOLFKHQ :LUNXQJHQ GHU LQVWLWX WLRQHOOHQ 9RUJDEHQ DXI GDV +DQGHOQ LQ ]XNQIWLJHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVVLWXDWLRQHQ DEVFKlW]HQ ]X PVVHQ
(UNOlUXQJVJHJHQVWDQG GHU YRUOLHJHQGHQ 8QWHUVXFKXQJ LVW GLH (LQULFKWXQJ YRQ IRUPDOHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ GLH 9HUWUDJVSDUWHLHQ LQ LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ 9HUKDQGOXQJVV\VWHPHQ YRUQHKPHQ 8QWHUVXFKW ZHUGHQ VROOHQ GLH *UQGH IXU GLH LQVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLVFKH 1LFKW(LQULFKWXQJ YRQ 5HJHOQ GXUFK UDWLRQDO KDQGHOQGH VWDDWOLFKH 9HUKDQGOXQJVWHLOQHKPHU 'D GDYRQ DXV]XJHKHQ LVW GDVV GLH 6WDDWHQ QLFKW YRQ GHU (LQULFKWXQJ LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ DOV VROFKHQ VRQGHUQ YRQ VSlWHUHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ EHU NRQNUHWH 3ROLWLNLQKDOWH SURILWLHUHQ GLH XQWHU GLHVHQ 5HJHOQ JHWURIIHQ ZHUGHQ ELHWHW VLFK HLQH ]ZHL VWXILJH .RQ]HSWLRQ GHU LQVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLVFKHQ :DKO DQ ,Q HLQHP HUVWHQ 6FKULWW PVVHQ GLH LQVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLVFKHQ 3UlIHUHQ]HQ EHU (QWVFKHLGXQJV UHJHOQ DXV GHQ (UZDUWXQJHQ GHU $NWHXUH EHU ]XNQIWLJH 6LWXDWLRQHQ EH VWLPPW ZHUGHQ +LHUIXU LVW HLQH 7UDQVIRUPDWLRQ LKUHU LQKDOWOLFKHQ ,QWHUHVVHQ ]X 3UlIHUHQ]HQ EHU DOWHUQDWLYH 5HJHOQ ]X OHLVWHQ ,Q HLQHP ]ZHLWHQ 6FKULWW PXVV DQJHJHEHQ ZHUGHQ ZHOFKH VSH]LILVFKH 5HJHO GLH $NWHXUH GDQQ NROOHN WLY DXVZlKOHQ $Q GLHVHU 6WHOOH LVW QDFK GHU 9HUWHLOXQJVIXQNWLRQ YRQ LQWHUQD WLRQDOHQ ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ IXU GLH 6WHXHUXQJ JOREDOHU ,QWHUHVVHQJHJHQVlW]H ]X IUDJHQ =HQWUDOH *U|H VLQG GHPQDFK GLH ,QWHUHVVHQ GHU 6WDDWHQ KLQVLFKWOLFK HLQHU P|JOLFKHQ $XVJHVWDOWXQJ GHU 3ROLWLN LQ HLQHP 3UREOHPIHOG
(LQH lKQOLFKH .RQ]HSWLRQ GHU ,QVWLWXWLRQHQZDKO VWHOOW 0RUDYFVLN DOV DOOJHPHLQHQ $QDO\VHUDKPHQ GHV OLEHUDOHQ ,QWHUJRXYHUQHPHQWDOLVPXV YRU 'DQDFK VLQG GUHL 3KDVHQ LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU .RRSHUDWLRQVYHUHLQEDUXQJHQ ]X XQ WHUVFKHLGHQ GLH VLFK DXI GLH QDWLRQDOH 3UlIHUHQ]ELOGXQJ GLH LQWHUJRXYHUQH PHQWDOHQ 9HUKDQGOXQJHQ EHU 3ROLWLNLQKDOWH XQG GLH ,QVWLWXWLRQHQZDKO EH]LH KHQ 1DFK 0RUDYFVLN HLQLJHQ VLFK GLH QDWLRQDOHQ $NWHXUH LQ GHU ]ZHLWHQ 3KDVH GLUHNW DXI GLH %HGLQJXQJHQ LKUHU LQKDOWOLFKHQ =XVDPPHQDUEHLW LQVWLWXWLRQHOOH 5HJHOXQJHQ GLHQHQ OHGLJOLFK GHU $EVLFKHUXQJ RGHU (UOHLFKWH UXQJ GHU LQKDOWOLFKHQ 9HUHLQEDUXQJ /HW]WHUH VROOHQ YROOVWlQGLJ VHLQ LKUH .RQVHTXHQ]HQ HLQGHXWLJ XQG DEVFKlW]EDU 'HPJHJHQEHU ZLUG LQ GLHVHU 8Q WHUVXFKXQJ GHU XQVLFKHUH &KDUDNWHU GHU 5HJHOZDKO EHWRQW (QWVFKHLGXQJVUH JHOQ ZHUGHQ DOV ,QVWUXPHQWH ]XU *HVWDOWXQJ SROLWLVFKHU (QWVFKHLGXQJVSUR]HV VH YHUVWDQGHQ GHUHQ :LUNXQJHQ QLFKW PLW 6LFKHUKHLW DQJHJHEHQ ZHUGHQ N|Q QHQ $EELOGXQJ ]HLJW GDV GHU 6WXGLH ]XJUXQGH OLHJHQGH (UNOlUXQJVVFKH PD PLW GHP GLH :DKO YRQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ LQ LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ 9HUKDQG OXQJVV\VWHUQHQ LQ GUHL 6FKULWWHQ DEJHOHLWHW ZHUGHQ VROO
nationales politisches System
internationales Verhandlungs-
system 8QWHUVXFKXQJV
HEHQH
internationales I'erhandlungs-
system
, Präferenz-
+
bildung, Präferenz-
+
bildung, Präferenz-
+
aggregation$EVFKOXVV VRZLH 5DWLI,NDWLRQ LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU 9HUHLQEDUXQJHQ ]X 3ROLWLNLQKDOWHQ XQG (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ 3ROLWLNSRVLWLRQHQ GHU QDWLRQDOHQ 5HJLHUXQJHQ
EH]LHKXQJVZHLVH LKUHU 'HOHJLHUWHQ DXI GHU LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ 9HUKDQGOXQJVHEHQH
5HJHOSUlIHUHQ]HQ GHU QDWLRQDOHQ 5HJLHUXQJHQ EH]LHKXQJVZHLVH LKUHU 'HOHJLHUWHU DXI GHU
LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ 9HUKDQGOXQJVHEHQH 1DWLRQDOH ,QWHUHVVHQ XQG 5HVWULNWLRQVVWUXNWXUHQ
,QWHUHVVHQ QDWLRQDOHU SULYDWHU XQG SROLWLVFKHU
$NWHXUH LQVWLWXWLRQHOOH SROLWLVFKH XQG ZLUWVFKDIWOLFKH 5DQGEHGLQJXQJHQ
Ableitung der kollektiven Entscheidung Ableitung der
Regel- präferenzen 8QWHUVXFKXQJV
VFKULWW
Ableitung der Politikpositionen
$XVJDQJVSXQNW VLQG GLH SROLWLVFKHQ XQG ZLUWVFKDIWOLFKHQ 5DQGEHGLQJXQJHQ GHU 6WDDWHQ GLH DOV QDWLRQDOH ,QWHUHVVHQ XQG 5HVWULNWLRQVVWUXNWXUHQ GLH 3RVL WLRQHQ EH]JOLFK GHU LQKDOWOLFKHQ $XVJHVWDOWXQJ HLQHV 3UREOHPIHOGHV EHVWLP PHQ 'LH $EOHLWXQJ GLHVHU 3ROLWLNSRVLWLRQHQ GHU 6WDDWHQ LVW =LHO GHV HUVWHQ 8QWHUVXFKXQJVVFKULWWHV 'LH 3ROLWLNSRVLWLRQHQ ELOGHQ ZLHGHUXP GHQ $XV JDQJVSXQNW IXU GLH 5HJHOSUlIHUHQ]HQ GHU 6WDDWHQ GLH LQ HLQHP ]ZHLWHQ 6FKULWW XQWHUVXFKW ZHUGHQ =LHO GHV GULWWHQ 6FKULWWHV LVW GLH (UNOlUXQJ GHU NROOHNWLYHQ (LQLJXQJ EH]LHKXQJVZHLVH 1LFKWHLQLJXQJ GHU 6WDDWHQ LQ LQWHUQDWL RQDOHQ 9HUKDQGOXQJVV\VWHPHQ HLQ $ENRPPHQ DE]XVFKOLHHQ *HKW PDQ YRQ GHU 9RUVWHOOXQJ VRXYHUlQHU XQG JOHLFKEHUHFKWLJWHU 6WDDWHQ LQ GHQ LQWHUQDWLR QDOHQ %H]LHKXQJHQ DXV GDQQ EHGDUI GHU $EVFKOXVV HLQHU ELQGHQGHQ 9HUHLQED UXQJ GHU IUHLZLOOLJHQ =XVWLPPXQJ GHU 9HUKDQGOXQJVSDUWQHU 6ROFKH LQWHUQD
AbbildungErklärungsschema internationaler Vereinbarungen über Entscheidungsregeln
9HUHLQEDUXQJHQ EHU (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ
WLRQDOHQ 9HUHLQEDUXQJHQ ZHUGHQ QRUPDOHUZHLVH GXUFK 6WDDWHQGHOHJDWLRQHQ GLH DOV $JHQWHQ LKUHU QDWLRQDOHQ 5HJLHUXQJHQ DXIWUHWHQ DXVJHKDQGHOW XQG EHQ|WLJHQ RIWPDOV GHU DQVFKOLHHQGHQ 5DWLILNDWLRQ GXUFK QDWLRQDOH (QWVFKHL GXQJVWUlJHU $OOHUGLQJV VWHKHQ QDWLRQDOHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVWUlJHUQ OHGLJOLFK GLH EHLGHQ 2SWLRQHQ HLQHU $QQDKPH RGHU $EOHKQXQJ GHU 5DWLILNDWLRQVYRUODJH ]XU 'LVSRVLWLRQ VR GDVV GLH HLJHQWOLFKH $XVZDKO GHU 9HUIDKUHQ XQG 5HJHOQ DXI GHU 9HUKDQGOXQJVHEHQH YRUJHQRPPHQ ZLUG .|QLJ XQG +XJ ,P )RO JHQGHQ ZLUG GHVKDOE YRQ HLQHU (LQELQGXQJ GHU QDWLRQDOHQ 5DWLILNDWLRQVHEHQH DEJHVHKHQ XQG ]XU (UNOlUXQJ GHU 5HJHODXVZDKO DXVVFKOLHOLFK GLH (QWVFKHL GXQJVHEHQH GHU 6WDDWHQGHOHJLHUWHQ EHWUDFKWHW 'HOHJDWLRQHQ ZHUGHQ DOV HLQ KHLWOLFKH $NWHXUH YHUVWDQGHQ ZREHL GLH 9HUKDQGOXQJVIXKUHU GLH ,QWHUHVVHQ GHU 'HOHJDWLRQ XQG GDPLW LKUHU 5HJLHUXQJHQ LQ GHQ 9HUKDQGOXQJHQ YHUWUHWHQ XQG ]LHORULHQWLHUW KDQGHOQ
$XV WKHRUHWLVFKHU 3HUVSHNWLYH VLQG ]ZHL $UWHQ YRQ 3KlQRPHQHQ ]X HUNOl UHQ QlPOLFK GLH Bildung von Präferenzen LP HUVWHQ XQG LP ]ZHLWHQ 6FKULWW GLH DOV HLQ LQWHUQHU 3UR]HVV HLQHV MHGHQ $NWHXUV DXIJHIDVVW ZLUG VRZLH GLH Aggregation von PräferenzenLP GULWWHQ 6FKULWW GLH VLFK DOV HLQ 3UREOHP NRO OHNWLYHQ +DQGHLQV GDUVWHOOW 3UlIHUHQ]HQ ZHUGHQ JHPHLQKLQ YHUVWDQGHQ DOV GLH LQGLYLGXHOOH =XZHLVXQJ YRQ VXEMHNWLYHQ :HUWHQ DQ (UHLJQLVVH *HJHQVWlQGH 3HUVRQHQ HWF 1DFK GLHVHU .RQ]HSWLRQ YHUHLQHQ 3UlIHUHQ]HQ ]ZHL .RPSR QHQWHQ ]XP HLQHQ GLH VXEMHNWLYH :HUWVFKlW]XQJ HLQHU 3HUVRQ VHLQ ,QWHUHVVH JHJHQEHU P|JOLFKHQ (UHLJQLVVHQ ]XP DQGHUHQ GLH HEHQVR VXEMHNWLYHQ 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ RGHU 7KHRULHQ GDUEHU ZHOFKH (UHLJQLVVH EHUKDXSW P|J OLFK VLQG 3UlIHUHQ]HQ N|QQHQ GHVKDOE DOV DEJHOHLWHWH 3UlIHUHQ]HQ YHUVWDQGHQ ZHUGHQ QlPOLFK DEJHOHLWHW DXV GHU 9HUNQSIXQJ YRQ GHQ HKHU IXQGDPHQWDOHQ 3UlIHUHQ]HQ ,QWHUHVVHQ HLQHUVHLWV XQG 7KHRULHQ GDUEHU ZLH GLHVH 3UlIH UHQ]HQ XQWHU GHQ JHJHEHQHQ 5DQGEHGLQJXQJHQ ]X YHUZLUNOLFKHQ VLQG DQGH UHUVHLWV 'LH 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ HLQHU ,QWHUHVVHQ HLQHU 7KHRULH XQG HLQHU 6WDWXVTXR.RPSRQHQWH 9DQEHUJ XQG %XFKDQDQ %UlXQLQJHU XQG .|QLJ HUODXEW GLH 8QWHUVXFKXQJ GHU %LOGXQJ YRQ 3ROLWLN XQG 5H JHOSUlIHUHQ]HQ GHU 9HUKDQGOXQJVSDUWQHU 'LH 3ROLWLNSRVLWLRQHQ GHU 5HJLH UXQJHQ ZHUGHQ GHPQDFK EHLVSLHOVZHLVH YRQ LKUHP ,QWHUHVVH DQ :LHGHUZDKO
(LQ %HLVSLHO KLHUIU LVW %HFNHUV %HVFKUHLEXQJ SULYDWHU .RQVXPHQWHQ GXUFK VRJHQDQQWH +DXVKDOWVSURGXNWLRQVIXQNWLRQHQ EHL ZHOFKHQ ]ZLVFKHQ ]ZHL $UWHQ YRQ *WHUQ ]X XQWHUVFKHLGHQ LVW HUVWHQV GHQ HLJHQWOLFKHQ =LHOHQ ]XP %HLVSLHO 1DK UXQJ XQG ]ZHLWHQV DEJHOHLWHWHQ =LHOHQ ]XP %HLVSLHO %LOGXQJ GLH DOV 5HVVRXUFHQ ]XU 3URGXNWLRQ GHU HLJHQWOLFKHQ =LHOH HLQJHVHW]W ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ
JHOHLWHW ZREHL LKUH 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ PLW ZHOFKHQ 0LWWHOQ GLHVH DP EHVWHQ ]X HUUHLFKHQ VHL GLH 7KHRULHNRPSRQHQWH GDUVWHOOW 'LH 5HJHOSUlIHUHQ]HQ GHU 'HOHJLHUWHQ DXI GHU 9HUKDQGOXQJVHEHQH ZLHGHUXP ZHUGHQ YRQ LKUHP ,QWHUHV VH DQ 3ROLWLNLQKDOWHQ EHVWLPPW GLH 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ GHU 'HOHJLHUWHQ EHU GLH :LUNXQJHQ YRQ DOWHUQDWLYHQ 5HJHOQ ELOGHQ GDEHL GLH 7KHRULHNRPSRQHQWH GHU 3UlIHUHQ]ELOGXQJ
%LVODQJ ZXUGH GHQ .RQILJXUDWLRQHQ YRQ 5HJHOSUlIHUHQ]HQ EHL GHU ,QVWLWX WLRQHQZDKO ZHQLJ $XIPHUNVDPNHLW JHVFKHQNW GD HQWZHGHU GLH $QQDKPH HLQHU *OHLFKYHUWHLOXQJ HUZDUWHWHU 3UlIHUHQ]HQ GHU $NWHXUH JHWURIIHQ %XFKD QDQ XQG 7XOORFN 6WHXQHQEHUJ XQG 'LPLWURYD RGHU GLH PLWWHOED UHQ (UJHEQLVVH GHU 5HJHOZDKO ZLH XQPLWWHOEDUH (UJHEQLVVH DXV GLUHNWHQ 9HU HLQEDUXQJHQ EHKDQGHOW ZXUGHQ 0RUDYFVLN (LQH UHDOLVWLVFKH 'DU VWHOOXQJ GHU 3UlIHUHQ]ELOGXQJ VROOWH KLQJHJHQ ]ZHLHUOHL EHUFNVLFKWLJHQ =XP HLQHQ VLQG VLFK GLH $NWHXUH VRZRKO EH]JOLFK GHU ]XNQIWLJHQ 5DQGEHGLQ JXQJHQ GHU 5HJHODQZHQGXQJ DOV DXFK GHU ]XNQIWLJHQ ,QWHUHVVHQ GHU $NWHX UH QLH YROONRPPHQ VLFKHU =XP DQGHUHQ KDEHQ VLH LP $OOJHPHLQHQ ]XPLQGHVW KLQUHLFKHQG NRQNUHWH (UZDUWXQJHQ EHU ]XNQIWLJH .RQIOLNWVLWXDWLRQHQ ZDV GLH $QQDKPH JOHLFKYHUWHLOWHU 3UlIHUHQ]HQ HLQVFKUlQNW .RQ]HSWLRQHOO VROOHQ EHLGH $VSHNWH GXUFK GLH %HWUDFKWXQJ GHU 3UlIHUHQ]ELOGXQJ DOV HLQHU (QW VFKHLGXQJ XQWHU 5LVLNR EHUFNVLFKWLJW ZHUGHQ 'LH %HZHUWXQJ HLQHU (QW VFKHLGXQJVUHJHO NDQQ GDQQ DOV HLQ (UZDUWXQJVQXW]HQ EHU ZDKUVFKHLQOLFKH 3ROLWLNHQWVFKHLGXQJHQ EHL ULVNDQWHQ 3ROLWLNSRVLWLRQHQ XQG ULVNDQWHQ 5DQGEH GLQJXQJHQ GDUJHVWHOOW ZHUGHQ %UlXQLQJHU XQG .|QLJ D
,P *HJHQVDW] ]XU $EOHLWXQJ GHU 3ROLWLNSRVLWLRQHQ XQG GHU 5HJHOSUlIHUHQ ]HQ VWHOOW GHU GULWWH 6FKULWW GHU 3UlIHUHQ]DJJUHJDWLRQ HLQHQ (UNOlUXQJVJHJHQ VWDQG DXI GHU NROOHNWLYHQ (EHQH GHV 9HUKDQGOXQJVV\VWHPV GDU ,QIROJH GHV Y|ONHUUHFKWOLFKHQ 3ULPDWV GHU 6WDDWHQVRXYHUlQLWlW HUJLEW VLFK GDV NROOHNWLYH +DQGOXQJVSUREOHP GHU 'HOHJLHUWHQ EHU 5HJHOQ DOV HLQH bargaining- 6LWXDWLRQ 'LH 8QWHUVXFKXQJ HLQHU P|JOLFKHQ (LQLJXQJ GHU 'HOHJLHUWHQ DXI GLH (LQULFKWXQJ YRQ 5HJHOQ VROO PLW +LOIH VSLHOWKHRUHWLVFKHU 0RGHOOH YRUJH QRPPHQ ZHUGHQ 8QWHUVXFKXQJV]LHO LVW DXV GHQ ]XYRU EHVWLPPWHQ $NWHXUV SUlIHUHQ]HQ EHU 5HJHOQ VRZLH GHQ (LJHQVFKDIWHQ GHU 9HUKDQGOXQJVVLWXDWLRQ
%HGLQJXQJHQ DE]XOHLWHQ GLH HLQH (LQLJXQJ RGHU 1LFKWHLQLJXQJ GHU $NWHXUH HUNOlUHQ +LHU LVW HWZD YRQ %HGHXWXQJ RE 1RUPYRUVWHOOXQJHQ GHU $NWHXUH LQ GLH LQVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLVFKH :DKO YRQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ HLQIOLHHQ
6R LVW HLQH LPSOL]LWH $QQDKPH GHU |NRQRPLVFKHQ 7KHRULH GHU 9HUIDVVXQJ GDVV $NWHXUH EHL DOOWlJOLFKHQ VXEVWDQ]LHOOHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ HLQH ,QWHUHV
VHQGXUFKVHW]XQJ LP 5DKPHQ GHU EHVWHKHQGHQ 2UGQXQJ DOV OHJLWLP HUDFKWHQ XQG VLFK GHVKDOE GXUFK HLQH UHLQ LQGLYLGXDOLVWLVFKH HLJHQQXW]EHVWLPPWH +DQGOXQJVRULHQWLHUXQJ DXV]HLFKQHQ .RQVWLWXWLRQHOOH (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ EHU 5HJHOQ KLQJHJHQ VHLHQ DXI GLH (UUHLFKXQJ HLQHV *UXQGNRQVHQVHV DXVJHULFK WHW GHU EHU 7DJHVIUDJHQ XQG NXU]IULVWLJH ,QWHUHVVHQ KLQDXVJHKHQ VROO 3RPPHUHKQH =ZDU ZXUGHQ )UDJHQ QDFK JHUHFKWHQ 9HUKDQG OXQJVHUJHEQLVVHQ DXFK LP )RUVFKXQJVEHUHLFK LQWHUQDWLRQDOH 3ROLWLN GLVNXWLHUW GRFK IlOOW GLH (UNOlUXQJ GHU 9HUKDQGOXQJVHUJHEQLVVH VFKZHU ZHQQ QXU XQ VSH]LILVFKH $QJDEHQ EHU GLH *HZLQQH GHU 6WDDWHQ YRUOLHJHQ EH]LHKXQJVZHL VH GLHVH VFKZHU ]X TXDQWLIL]LHUHQ VLQG ,Q GHU YRUOLHJHQGHQ 8QWHUVXFKXQJ VROO GLHV GXUFK GLH XPIDVVHQGH (UKHEXQJ YRQ $NWHXUVLQWHUHVVHQ YHUPLHGHQ ZHU GHQ
$XIEDX GHU $UEHLW
=LHO GHU QDFKIROJHQGHQ $XVILLKUXQJHQ LVW GHP DOOJHPHLQHQ $QDO\VHUDKPHQ ]XU 8QWHUVXFKXQJ LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU .RRSHUDWLRQ HLQH VSH]LILVFKH .RPSRQHQWH ]XU $QDO\VH ODQJIULVWLJHU XQG XQYROOVWlQGLJHU 9HUHLQEDUXQJHQ EHU LQVWLWXWLR QHOOH $UUDQJHPHQWV KLQ]X]XILLJHQ (QWVFKHLGHQGH .ULWHULHQ VROOHQ GDEHL QLFKW QXU GLH $QJHPHVVHQKHLW GHU 0RGHO,LHUXQJ GHU 5HJHOHLQULFKWXQJ VRQGHUQ DXFK GLH $QZHQGEDUNHLW GHV 0RGHOOV LQ NRPSOH[HQ 6LWXDWLRQHQ VHLQ GLH LQ GHU LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ 3ROLWLN HLQH 9LHO]DKO YRQ $NWHXUHQ XPIDVVHQ N|QQHQ ,Q GHQ IROJHQGHQ .DSLWHOQ ZHUGHQ GLH DQJHVSURFKHQHQ 3UREOHPH LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU ,QVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLN DXV WKHRUHWLVFKHU XQG HPSLULVFKHU 3HUVSHNWLYH EHOHXFKWHW 'LH )DOOVWXGLH ]XP 0HHUHVERGHQUHJLPH VROO GDEHL VRZRKO QHXH GHWDLOOLHUWH (LQVLFKWHQ LQ GDV 3UREOHP GHU 1XW]XQJ JOREDOHU *HPHLQVFKDIWVJWHU DOV DXFK LQ GLH )RUPHQ LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU .RRSHUDWLRQ LQ HLQHP ZHLWHUHQ 6LQQH OLHIHUQ
$XVJDQJVSXQNW LQWHUQDWLRQDOHU ,QVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLN VLQG NRQIOLJLHUHQGH 6WDDWHQLQWHUHVVHQ LQ HLQHP 3ROLWLNEHUHLFK ,P QlFKVWHQ .DSLWHO VROOHQ ]X QlFKVW GLH 3UREOHPVWUXNWXU GLHVHV .RRSHUDWLRQVEHUHLFKV XQG GLH 5DKPHQEH GLQJXQJHQ GHU 9HUKDQGOXQJHQ ]XU 6HHUHFKWVNRQYHQWLRQ XQG ]XU 'XUFKILLK UXQJVYHUHLQEDUXQJ KHUDXVJHDUEHLWHW XQG V\VWHPDWLVLHUW ZHUGHQ =XU 8QWHUVX FKXQJ GHU 9HUKDQGOXQJVVLWXDWLRQ VLQG GLH SROLWLVFKHQ XQG ZLUWVFKDIWOLFKHQ
$XVJDQJVODJHQ GHU 6WDDWHQ ]X EHOHXFKWHQ GLH DOV QDWLRQDOH ,QWHUHVVHQ XQG
,
O
5HVWULNWLRQVVWUXNWXUHQ GLH 3RVLWLRQHQ EH]JOLFK GHU LQKDOWOLFKHQ $XVJHVWDO WXQJ GHV 3UREOHPIHOGHV EHVWLPPHQ
,P :HLWHUHQ ZLUG GHU WKHRUHWLVFKH %H]XJVUDKPHQ GHV (UNOlUXQJVSUREOHPV GLVNXWLHUW XQG HLQ 0RGHOO GHU LQVWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLVFKHQ :DKO YRQ (QWVFKHL GXQJVUHJHOQ IRUPXOLHUW 'D GLH :DKO YRQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ DOV HLQ EHVRQ GHUHU )DOO LQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQ :DQGHOV DXIJHIDVVW ZHUGHQ NDQQ ZHUGHQ DXV GHU DOOJHPHLQHUHQ 3HUVSHNWLYH GHU ,QVWLWXWLRQHQWKHRULH GLH 8UVDFKHQ XQG %HGLQ JXQJHQ VROFKHU 3UR]HVVH EHOHXFKWHW 'LH =XVDPPHQILLKUXQJ GLHVHV )RU VFKXQJVVWUDQJHV PLW GHU YHUKDQGOXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ 'LVNXVVLRQ GHU 7HLOGLV ]LSOLQ GHU LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ %H]LHKXQJHQ HUODXEW GLH )RUPXOLHUXQJ HLQHV 0R GHOOV GHU :DKO YRQ (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ LQ LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ 9HUKDQGOXQJVV\V WHPHQ $EVFKOLHHQG ZLUG GDV YRUJHVFKODJHQH 0RGHOO ]XU (UNOlUXQJ GHU LQ VWLWXWLRQHQSROLWLVFKHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ EHL (LQULFKWXQJ GHU 0HHUHVERGHQEH K|UGH YHUZHQGHW
