This is a revision of discussion paper FS IV 99-2

discussion papers

Compatibility Investments in Duopoly with Demand Side Spillovers under Different Degrees of Cooperation

Christian Wey

Revised: August 1999

This is a revision of discussion paper FS IV 99-2

4 Lqwurgxfwlrq

@?) 4@h!i|t @i |i ThLTih|) |@| |i }ih |i _i}hii Lu UL4T@|M*|) Lu |i ThL_U|

| UL4T*i4i?|@h) ThL_U|tc |i 4Lhi @*@M*i | t |L @? ?__@* UL?t4ih At t @ UL44L? ui@|hi Lu tLu|@hi 4@h!i|t @?_ ?i|Lh!t ?U*_?} i4@* Lh u@Ut4*i 4@U?it Ai i |i?| |L U @hLt ThL_U|t @hi UL4T@|M*i | L?i @?L|ih t L?i Lu |i 4Lt|

4TLh|@?| _4i?tL?t Lu 4@h!i| t|hU|hic @?_ 4@h!i| TihuLh4@?Ui

W? |t T@Tih i UL?t_ih |Lti 4@h!i|t ? U UL4T@|M*|) @4L?} UL4T*i4i?|@h) ThL_U|t t @Uii_ i TLt|c ic @u|ih €h4tTiU€U t|@?_@h_t @i Mii? it|@M*ti_ AL

@Uii ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|) i TLt|c €h4t @i |L ?_ih|@!i ?it|4i?|t |L 4@!i

|ih ?i*) _ii*LTi_ ThL_U|t UL4T@|M*i | L|ih €h4t< t|@?_@h_ |iU?L*L}it 6Lh i @4T*ic ? |i UL4T|ih ?_t|h) tLu|@hi _ii*LT?} €h4t @t UhLtLu| Lh @U?|Lt

@i |L _iU_i @ML| |i _i}hii Lu UL4T@|M*|) Mi|ii? |ih tLu|@hi @TT*U@|L? ThL }h@4t @?_ |i h@*<t LTih@|?} t)t|i4 W? |t T@h|U*@h U@tic ML| €h4t @i it|@M*ti_

@ t|@?_@h_ |iU?L*L}) |i LTih@|?} t)t|i4 @?_ ti** ? @__|L? UL4T*i4i?|@h) @TT*

U@|L? ThL}h@4t 6h4tTiU€U t|@?_@h_t @hi ? i t|i?Ui i? €h4t _iU_i @ML| |i _i}hii Lu ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|) Lu |ih UL4T*i4i?|@h) ThL_U|t Ai ThTLti Lu |t T@Tih t |L i @4?i €h4t< ?Ui?|it |L ?it| ?|L ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|) U }it hti |L _i4@?_ t_i tT**Lih igiU|t Ai T@Tih @*tL ?it|}@|it |i igiU|t Lu _gihi?|

_i}hiit Lu ULLTih@|L?c @h)?} uhL4 Thi 4@h!i| UL?|@U| |L u** U@h|i*3@|L?

`i |?! Lu i @4T*it *!i UL4T|ih LTih@|?} t)t|i4t @?_ @TT*U@|L? tLu|@hic ?|ih

?i| MhLtiht @?_ iMT@}i _it}?ih |LL*t%L?*?itihUitc Lh |h@?tTLh|@|L? tihUit @?_

|4i|@M*i tUi_*it W? i@U Lu |iti U@titc €h4t tTT*) |L UL4T*i4i?|@h) ThL_U|tG 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U| @?_ i|ih @ UL4T*i4i?|@h) ?Ui 4@h!i| ThL_U|c @t ? |i U@ti Lu

@TT*U@|L? tLu|@hi @?_ iMT@}i _it}?ih |LL*tc Lh @ UL4T*i4i?|@h) tihUic *!i |4i

|@M*i tUi_*itc @t ? |i U@ti Lu |h@?tTLh|@|L? tihUit `*i UL4T*i4i?|@h) ThL_U|t Lu L?i Mh@?_ Mi*L?} |L |i t@4i €h4tTiU€U UL4T@|M*|) t|@?_@h_c UL4T*i4i?|@h) ThL_U|t Lu _gihi?| Mh@?_t @hi ?UL4T@|M*i i? €h4t _L ?L| ?it| ?|L ?|ihMh@?_

UL4T@|M*|) Wuc Liihc @ €h4 ?it|t ?|L ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|) |i UL4Ti||Lh<t 4@tt 4@h!i| _i4@?_ ?Uhi@titc t4T*) MiU@ti UL?t4iht @*i UL4T@|M*|)

AL **t|h@|i |t TL?|c UL?t_ih |i `Lh*_ `_i `iM @t @ }*) t|)*3i_ i @4T*i 6h4t

*!i UhLtLu| @?_ i|tU@Ti M@tU@**) tihi |L _gihi?| 4@h!i|t ? |i 4@tt 4@h!i|

|i) ti** iMT@}i MhLtiht @?_ L? |ih ?Ui 4@h!i|t |i) ti** iMT@}i _it}?ih |LL*t



Lh tihih tLu|@hi |L UL44ihU@* M)iht L @}@? ThL_Ui iMT@}it @?_ L?*?i tihUit ti_ M) UL?t4iht i^TTi_ | MhLtiht *i@h*)c _i4@?_ uLh €h4 <t 4@tt 4@h!i|

ThL_U| E*!i i|tU@Ti<t ?|ih?i| MhLtih }Lit T i? €h4 ?_ih|@!it ?it|4i?|t |L 4@!i |t ?Ui 4@h!i| ThL_U| E*!i UhLtLu|<t iMT@}i _it}?ih |LL*t 4Lhi UL4T@|M*i

| €h4 <t 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U|

N?_ih |iti UL?_|L?t UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t M) €h4 ?Uhi@ti €h4 <t 4@tt 4@h!i|

_i4@?_c @?_ i?Uic }i?ih@|i TLt|i tT**Liht U Mi?i€| €h4 ^ 6h|ih4Lhic i

@tt4i |@| i@U €h4 t @ 4L?LTL*t| L? |i ?Ui 4@h!i| L? U | ti**t tTiU@*3i_

UL4TL?i?|tc *!i i}c iMT@}i _it}?ih |LL*t²

t @? @*|ih?@|ic @?_ @}@?c }*) t|)*3i_ i @4T*i Lu Lh 4L_i* UL?t_ih |h@?tTLh|@|L?

tihUitc @t i}c |i ?|ih?@|L?@* @h*?i ?_t|h) W?|ih?@|L?@* @h*?it @hi Lh}@?3i_ @t M@?_tTL!i ?i|Lh!t L?t_ih |L @h*?itc *!i i}c 4ihU@? h@)t E @?_

h|t h@)t E tit U@}L @?_ tit wL?_L? @t |t Mc LTih@|it |L _L4it|U i?_TL?|t E*!i k@?t@t |) E @?_ ?U E @t i** @t @ |h@?t@|*@?|U hL|i |L |i M Lu |i L|ih @h*?i At 4i@?tc ML| @h*?it tihi M@tU@**) |L 4@h!i|tG Ai _L4it|U 4@h!i|c U t U@**i_ ? Lh T@Tih |i ?Ui 4@h!i|c @?_ |i |h@?t@|*@?

|U hL|ic U t ? Lh |ih4t |i 4@tt 4@h!i| _LT|?} |i M@?_tTL!i ?i|Lh!

t|hU|hic @t @?@*)3i_ M) ijW"Aji < 7V,,ji dbbo @?_ ijW"Aji dbbHoc |i

?i|Lh!t Lu |i |L @h*?it _L ?L| Lih*@Tc i UiT| L? |i |h@?t@|*@?|U hL|i At 4i@?tc

|@| @h*?it @hi 4L?LTL*t|t ? _L4it|U U|)T@h 4@h!i|t L|ih |@? |i |h@?t@|*@?|U

?|ihM 4@tt 4@h!i|c L? U ML| €h4t UL4Ti|i Aihi @hi |L igiU|t i? L?i @h

*?i @_t|t |t |4i|@M*i Lu @hh@* @?_ _iT@h|hi | |i L|ih @h*?i<t |4it Lu @hh@*

@?_ _iT@h|hi @| |t _L4it|U M 6ht|c |i _L4it|U _i4@?_ ?Uhi@tit MiU@ti UL?t 4iht @hi UL??iU|i_ 4U u@t|ih |L |i L|ih @h*?i i? |i) 4@!i Lihtii |h@i*tc @?_

tiUL?_c |i L|ih @h*?i Mi?i€|t ?_hiU|*) @ @? ?Uhi@ti_ _i4@?_ uLh |t |h@?t@|*@?|U

4Wkh lvvxh ri frpsdwlelolw| lqyhvwphqwv lv dovr h{wuhpho| lpsruwdqw lq wkh vwurqjo| lqwhuuhodwhg frp0 sxwhu lqgxvwu| zkhuh rshudwlqj v|vwhpv uhsuhvhqw wkh pdvv pdunhw surgxfwv1 Wr jxdudqwhh frpsdwlelolw|

lv fulwlfdo iru wkh vxuylydo ri dq rshudwlqj v|vwhp1 Iru h{dpsoh/ Dssoh kdg wr pdnh odujh lqyhvwphqwv wr lpsuryh wkh frpsdwlelolw| ri lwv qhz rshudwlqj v|vwhp PdfRV ; zlwk rwkhu upv* dssolfdwlrq vriwzduh/ dv kdv ehhq uhsruwhg e| Pdjd}lq i‚xu Frpsxwhu Whfkqln/ Vhswhpehu/ 4<<:/ ss1 :304/ zkhuh d olvw ri uhpdlqlqj lqfrpsdwlelolwlhv ri PdfRV ; lv suhvhqwhg1

5Wklv pdunhw vwuxfwxuh pljkw eh wkh uhvxow ri orfnhg0lq frpphufldo ex|huv zkr kdyh xqghujrqh vshflf lqyhvwphqwv1

2

hL|i

W? |i hi@*4 Lu Lh 4L_i* i @?@*)3i |i |h@_iLg U i@U €h4 u@Uit i? | 4@!it

?it|4i?|t |L 4@!i |t ?Ui 4@h!i| ThL_U| 4Lhi UL4T@|M*i | |i h@*<t 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U|^e ? |i L?i @?_c i@U €h4 ?|ih?@*3it _hiU|*) |i Mi?i€|t L? |t

?Ui 4@h!i|c @?_ L? |i L|ih @?_c |i TLt|i tT**Lih igiU| uLh |i h@* €h4 L?

|t 4@tt 4@h!i| 4@!it | Mi@i 4Lhi @}}hitti*) tU |@|c L|ih |?}t i^@*c 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL€|t _iUhi@ti uLh |i ?it|?} €h4

`i? €h4t _iU_i @ML| UL4T@|M*|) @u|ih 4@tt 4@h!i| t|@?_@h_ |iU?L*L}it @i @*

hi@_) Mii? it|@M*ti_ |t _iUtL? t ?L| @? i|ihLh _iUtL? ThLM*i4 @t ? |i U@ti Lu @ @?|i t|@?_@h_3@|L? M| h@|ih @ 4@||ih Lu _i}hii^D Ai _i}hii Lu UL4T@|M

*|) _iTi?_t L? |i @4L?| Lu ?it|4i?|t €h4t @hi **?} |L ?_ih|@!i |L _it}? |ih UL4T*i4i?|@h) ThL_U|t Lh tihUit ?*@|ih@**) 4Lhi UL4T@|M*i | |i L|ih €h4<t 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U|^S AihiuLhic ? UL?|h@t| |L |i |h@_|L?@* *|ih@|hi L? UL4T@|

M*|) t|@?_@h_3@|L? @t hiThiti?|i_ M) 8Biij,, < 7B,NAji dbHDoc dbHSoc lB|5 <

7BViN dbHDoc dbHSoc B||jt < -j}OjB dbHHo @?_ L|ihtc U @t uLUti_ L?

|i ULLh_?@|L? ThLM*i4t Lu 4@!?} ThL_U|t i|ih UL4T@|M*i Lh ?L| UL4T@|M*i | h@*t< ThL_U|t i @?|ic Lh 4L_i* *LL!t @| |i ?it|4i?| ?Ui?|i ThLM*i4t i TLt|

@UUh?} uhL4 TLt|i _i4@?_ t_i tT**Liht^. `i @*tL _tUtt L |i @TT*U@|L? Lu

6Wkhuh duh dw ohdvw wzr pruh srvlwlyh ghpdqg vlgh hhfwv iurp pdnlqj lqwhu0dluolqh wlphwdeoh dgmxvw0 phqwv lq wkh lqwhuqdwlrqdo dluolqh lqgxvwu|= Iluvw/ wkhuh lv d srvlwlyh ihhgedfn hhfw ehwzhhq vwurqjhu frpshwlwlrq rq wkh wudqvdwodqwlf urxwh dqg wkh grphvwlf ghpdqg ri wkh lqyhvwlqj up/ dqg vhfrqg/ wkhuh lv dqrwkhu srvlwlyh vslooryhu hhfw iru wkh ulydo rq lwv grphvwlf qlfkh pdunhw dffuxlqj iurp wkh pdunhw h{sdqvlrq hhfw lq wkh krph frxqwu| ri wkh lqyhvwlqj up1 Krzhyhu/ lqfrusrudwlqj wkhvh hhfwv lqwr rxu prgho zrxog pdnh rxu srlqw iru wkh qhhg ri frrshudwlrq hyhq vwurqjhu1

7Zlwk uhvshfw wr dluolqh vhuylfhv/ lw lv txlwh reylrxv wkdw dgmxvwlqj wlphwdeohv lv frvwo|/ dqg wkdw shuihfw doljqphqw lv doprvw xqihdvleoh ehfdxvh ri frqjhvwlwlrq frqvwudlqwv rq hdfk kxe1

8D txlfn orrn dw wkh frpsxwhu lqgxvwu| uhyhdov wkdw pdnlqj d vshfldol}hg vriwzduh shuihfwo| frpsdwleoh zlwk doo rshudwlqj v|vwhpv lv doprvw xqihdvleoh1 Wkh pdq| glhuhqw lqwhuidfhv zlwk roghu yhuvlrqv/ h{lvwlqj rqhv dqg wkrvh zklfk pljkw eh lqwurgxfhg lq wkh ixwxuh lv txlwh odujh1

9Wklv sdshu uhvwulfwv dwwhqwlrq wr wkrvh pdunhwv/ dv zh pd| qg wkhp iru dssolfdwlrq vriwzduh/ zhesdjh ghvljqhu wrrov ru wlphwdeoh vfkhgxohv/ lq zklfk upv fdq pdnh wkhlu qlfkh pdunhw surgxfwv xqlodwhudoo|

frpsdwleoh h{ srvw1 Li/ krzhyhu/ whfkqlfdo lqirupdwlrq lv shuihfwo| surwhfwhg e| sdwhqwv/ wkhq lqwhueudqg frpsdwlelolw| fdq rqo| eh dfklhyhg e| elodwhudo frruglqdwlrq h{ dqwh1

:Dvvxplqj wkdw frqvxphuv ydoxh frpsdwlelolw| ehfdxvh ri srvlwlyh qhwzrun h{whuqdolwlhv lB|5 <

7BViN ^4<;8` h{dplqh upv* lqfhqwlyhv wr frruglqdwh vxqn lqyhvwphqwv rq d sduwlfxodu frpsdwlelolw|

vwdqgdug h{ dqwh1 Surgxfwv uhpdlq shuihfwo| lqfrpsdwleoh li upv gr qrw frruglqdwh ehfdxvh frpsdwlelolw|

@?||ht| *@ @?_ |i ThL|iU|L? Lu ?|i**iU|@* ThLTih|) h}|t @giU| Th@|i ?Ui?|it |L

?Uhi@ti ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|)

h T@Tih t @*tL hi*@|i_ |L |i Lh! M) lit|BAtjA < C6 dbbSo @?_ 8Biij,, <

lB|5 dbbHo U i @4?i L UL4T@|M*|) t@Tit ThL_U| 4@h!i| UL4Ti||L? @?_

€h4t< ?Ui?|it |L ?it| ?|L +:# lit|BAtjA < C6 dbbSo t|_) |i T@||ih?t Lu +:# ?it|4i?|t ? UL4T@|M*i ?i|Lh!t ihi €h4t ti** 4@tt 4@h!i| @?_ ?Ui 4@h

!i| ThL_U|t +:# ?it|4i?|t ?Uhi@ti |i ^@*|) Lu |i 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U|c @?_

|ihiuLhic Mi?i€| ML| _LTL*t|t @ |ih ?Ui 4@h!i|t N?_ih?it|4i?|t hit*|t uhL4

?i}*iU|i_ TLt|i ?i|Lh! i |ih?@*|it ih?it|4i?| 4}| LUUh t|h@|i}U@**) |L ? _Ui |i UL4Ti||Lh |L ?Uhi@ti 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U|t< ^@*|) 5?Ui |i) @tt4i |@|

€h4t< ThL_U|t @hi TihuiU|*) UL4T@|M*i |i) _L ?L| i @4?i |i igiU|t Lu ?it|4i?|t U ?Uhi@ti ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|) 8Biij,, < lB|5 dbbHo @?@*)3i |i Uh|U@*

hL*i Lu UL?t4iht< i TiU|@|L?t UL?Uih??} i@U €h4<t 4@h!i| t3i @?_ ThL_U| ^@*|) ?

@ 4L_i* | ?i|Lh! i |ih?@*|itc ihi €h4t UL4Ti|i ? ih|h@?_ u@tL? W? ML| 4L _i*t L?*) L?i tTT*ih Lu |i 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U| Thi@*t ? i^*Mh4 *i Lh 4L_i*

i @4?it L _LTL*t|U UL4Ti||L? L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i| @giU|t €h4t< ?Ui?|it |L ? it| ?|L UL4T@|M*|) 6?@**)c ML| T@Tiht _L ?L| @?@*)3i L @?||ht| TL*U) |L@h_t Lh3L?|@* ULLTih@|L? @giU|t ThL_U| 4@h!i| UL4Ti||L? @?_ i^*Mh4 UL4T@|M*|)

*ii*t

h @?@*)tt M*_t L? |i TL?iih?} @TThL@U @_LT|i_ M) a?tVij6NA| < cBW`j 6A dbHHo |L @?@*)3i €h4t< +:# ?it|4i?| ?Ui?|it ? @ |Lt|@}i }@4i W? |ih 4L_i* €h4t ULLti +:# *ii*t @| |i €ht| t|@}i @?_ UL4Ti|i L? |i ThL_U| 4@h!i| ? Lh?L| u@tL? @| |i tiUL?_ t|@}i^H 6h4t @hi TihuiU|*) t)44i|hUc ThL_U|t @hi L4L }i?iLtc @?_ +:# ?it|4i?| *i@_t |L @ hi_U|L? ? ?| ULt|t }Lih?i_ M) @ ^@_h@|U ULt| u?U|L? +:# ?it|4i?|t @hi U@h@U|ih3i_ M) TLt|i tT**Lih igiU|t 4i@thi_

lv dq hlwkhu0ru ghflvlrq1 B||jt < -j}OjB ^4<;;`/ .WNAN6ajt ^4<;<`/ ^4<<4d`/ ^4<<4e`/ dqg .A NiA ^4<<5` xvh d prgho ri glhuhqwldwhg frqvxphuv zkhuh d vxevhw ri wkhp kdv d suhihuhqfh iru pl{lqj0 dqg0pdwfklqj surgxfwv ri glhuhqw eudqgv1 Krzhyhu/ lq wkrvh prghov shuihfw frpsdwlelolw| lv dfklhyhg frvwohvvo| h{ dqwh dqg lv dozd|v surwdeoh iru upv/ zklfk duh dvvxphg wr ehkdyh qrqfrrshudwlyho|1

;Vhh QjAi`jt ^4<<3` iru d fulwltxh dqg a?tVij6NA| < cBW`j6A ^4<<3` iru d uhso|1 Wkhlu dqdo|vlv kdv ehhq h{whqghg dqg jhqhudol}hg e| $j NAa| < Xj}j,jit ^4<<4`/ $j NAa|e 7,Bj|t

< Btt6BA ^4<<5`/ lB6jAe ,,ji < ~BA} ^4<<5`/ 756iB ^4<<5`/ XNANi|Bt ^4<<7`/ 7|jit

^4<<8`/ iNa < 7B"6Bi ^4<<:`/ wjB+ < jBi+ ^4<<:`/ # ^4<<:`/ dqg j|| < CN,At"

^4<<<`1 Iru d uhylhz ri wklv olwhudwxuh vhh $j NAa| ^4<<9`1

e

M) |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih qc | f q  W? |i Thiti?Ui Lu TLt|i tT**Lih iu uiU|t €h4 <t +:# ?it|4i?|t _L ?L| L?*) hi_Ui €h4 <t 4@h}?@* ULt|tc M| @*tL €h4

<t 4@h}?@* ULt|t M) |i uh@U|L? q Bi? |Lti UL?_|L?t _<tThi4L?| @?_ a@U^i 4? tL |@| uLh *@h}i tT**Liht tU @t q : fD ULLTih@|L? ? |i +:# t|@}i Lu |i }@4i *i@_t |L }ih ?it|4i?| *ii*t UL4T@hi_ |L @ UL4Ti||i hi}4i ? U i@U

€h4 ULLtit |t +:# i Ti?_|hit ?L?ULLTih@|i*) ? |i L|ih @?_c uLh hi*@|i*)

*L tT**Liht ULLTih@|L? @| |i +:# t|@}i *i@_t |L *Lih ?it|4i?|t |@? UL4Ti||i +:# AihiuLhic |i @|Lht UL?U*_i |@| UL?|h@U|@* @hh@?}i4i?|t U ?_Ui L?|

ThL€| 4@ 43@|L? @| |i +:# t|@}ic *i !iiT?} €h4t Mi@?} UL4Ti||i*) L? |i ThL_U| 4@h!i|c U@? Mi iUi?U) i?@?U?} i? +:# tT**Liht @hi hi*@|i*) *@h}i^b At iUi?U) h@|L?@*i 4}| i*T i T*@? ) @?||ht| @|Lh|it @hi 4U *itt UL?

Uih?i_ @ML| |i @?|UL4Ti||i igiU|t Lu ULLTih@|i hiti@hU UL4T@hi_ |L L|ih uLh4t Lu Lh3L?|@* ULLTih@|L?^f

*_?} L? |i |Lt|@}i uh@4iLh! Lu _LTL*t|U UL4Ti||L? @t _ii*LTi_ M) _<tThi 4L?| @?_ a@U^i4? Lh @?@*)tt i @4?it |i 4T@U| Lu _gihi?| _i}hiit Lu ULLTih@|L?

L? €h4t< UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?| *ii*t | |i €ht| t|@}ic €h4t _iU_i L? |ih UL4T@

|M*|) ?it|4i?| *ii* i|ih ULLTih@|i*) Lh ?L?ULLTih@|i*)c @?_ @| |i tiUL?_ t|@}i

|i) _i|ih4?i ^@?||) *ii*t Lu |i 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U|c @}@?c i|ih UL4Ti||i*) Lh UL**ti*) At }it |i uL**L?} |hii _gihi?| hi}4it Lu ?|ihit|G^

 L4T@|M*|) L4Ti||L? EQ Q G L| €h4t Mi@i ?L?ULLTih@|i*) @| ML| t|@

}it Lu |i }@4i | |i tiUL?_ t|@}i €h4 <t 4@tt 4@h!i| _i4@?_ t ?Uhi@ti_ |L tL4i tT**Lih uhL4 |i h@*<t UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t

2 L4T@|M*|) L44||ii EFQ G | |i €ht| t|@}ic ML| €h4t ULLh_?@|i |ih ? it|4i?| @U||it tL @t |L 4@ 43i |i t4 Lu Lih@** ThL€|t | |i tiUL?_ t|@}i

<Vhh dovr lB|5 ^4<;9` iru dq hduolhu sdshu zklfk hpskdvl}hv wkh vwlpxodwlrq ri lqfhqwlyhv wrzdugv lqyhvwphqwv lq U)G hruwv gxh wr frrshudwlyh djuhhphqwv1

43Dq hduo| hflhqf| udwlrqdoh ri krul}rqwdo frrshudwlrq kdv ehhq suhvhqwhg e| b,,B6tNA ^4<9;`1 Vhh DiNtt6BA < 7BViN ^4<;9`/ cNiaj < CjjWj ^4<<3`/ iNa,j+ ^4<<3` dqg 7BViN < b,,} ^4<<3`

iru d fulwlfdo dvvhvvphqw ri wkh dqwlwuxvw wuhdwphqw ri krul}rqwdo frrshudwlrq lq uhvhdufk dqg lqqrydwlrq1

44Lq wkh iroorzlqj/ wkh uhjlphv duh deeuhyldwhg e| wzr fdooljudsklf ohwwhuv/ zkhuh wkh uvw ohwwhu ghvfulehv upv* uvw0vwdjh ehkdylru hlwkhu dv qrqfrrshudwlyh/ zkdw lv lqglfdwhg e| Q / ru dv frrshudwlyh/ zkdw lv lqglfdwhg e| F1 Wkh vdph phwkrg dssolhv iru wkh vhfrqg ohwwhu zklfk vwdqgv iru upv* ehkdylru dw wkh vhfrqg vwdjh ri wkh jdph1

D

€h4t UL4Ti|i ihi i@U €h4<t 4@tt 4@h!i| _i4@?_ t ?Uhi@ti_ |L tL4i tT**Lih uhL4 |i L|ih €h4<t UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t

@h|i*3@|L? EFFG L| €h4t uLh4 @ U@h|i* @?_ 4@ 43i @| ML| t|@}it Lu |i }@4i L?| ThL€|t

W? hi@*|) _iUtL?t UL?Uih??} UL4T@|M*|) Lu|i? |@!i T*@Ui |? t|@?_@h_3@|L? UL4 4||iit^2 W? Lh 4L_i* |Lti UL44||iit @hi ?|ihThi|i_ @t Lh}@?3@|L?t U ?_Ui L?| ThL€| 4@ 43@|L? | hitTiU| |L €h4t< UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t At tii4t

|L Mi @TThLTh@|i t?Ui UL44||iit _i€?i i T*U| ThLUi_hit |L ULLh_?@|i L? UL4T@|

M*|) t|@?_@h_3@|L? N?_ih |i UL4T@|M*|) UL44||ii EFQ hi}4i i @tt4i |@|

ULLTih@|i hi*@|L?t Mi|ii? €h4t _L ?L| *i@_ €h4t |L UL**_i L? |i L|T| 4@h!i| W?

|t U@ti hi*@|L?t @4L?} €h4t @hi @ )Mh_ Lu ULLTih@|L? @?_ UL4Ti||L?^ N?_ih |i U@h|i*3@|L? EFF hi}4i | t tTTLti_ |@| t|@?_@h_3@|L? UL44||iit @hi @ 4i@?t |L UL**_i L? |i L|T| 4@h!i|c @?_ i?Uic *i@_ |L @? Lih@** U@h|i*3@|L? Lu €h4t

vi|c _itT|i |i ?||i T*@tM*|) Lu _i4@?_ t_i tT**Liht @?_ |i ?ii_ uLh €h4t

|L ?_ih|@!i ?it|4i?|t |L @Uii ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|)c |Lti ?it|4i?| @U||it

@i ?L| Mii? ?ULhTLh@|i_ i T*U|*) ?|L |i |iLhi|U@* *|ih@|hi _i@*?} | hiti@hU L?| i?|hit @?_ | ULLTih@|i t|@?_@h_ ti||?} }hLTt^e W| t @*tL ?|ihit|?} |L ?L|i

|@| |i iUL?L4U *|ih@|hi L? t|@?_@h_3@|L? UL44||iit t thTht?}*) t4@** Ai L?*) UL?|hM|L?t i @hi @@hi @hi 8Biij,, < 7B,NAji dbHHo @?_ DNji"j < QN,,ji dbbDo Ai €ht| T@Tih UL4T@hit UL44||iit @?_ 4@h!i|t @t @*|ih?@|i 4iU@?t4t

|L LihUL4i ULLh_?@|L? u@*hi i? €h4t ULLti Mi|ii? ?UL4T@|M*i t|@?_@h_t i

@?|i Ai tiUL?_ T@Tih hi}@h_t t|@?_@h_3@|L? UL44||iit @t @ 4iU@?t4 Lu UL**iU|i _iUtL? 4@!?} U 4@Tt M)iht< Thiuihi?Uit ?|L t|@?_@h_3@|L? L|UL4it @ L|?}

h*it W? UL?|h@t| |L |Lti T@Tihtc i ?|ihThi| @ t|@?_@h_3@|L? UL44||ii ?L| L?*)

@t @ ULLh_?@|L? _iUi M| @*tL @t @ _iUi |L ?|ih?@*3i TLt|i tT**Liht @4L?}

45Wkh lpsruwdqfh ri lqwhu0up frrshudwlrq rq wkh vwdqgdugl}dwlrq vwdjh lq vriwzduh pdunhwv kdv ehhq hpskdvl}hg e| lB|5 < 7BViN ^4<<;`1

46Iru lqvwdqfh wkh Z6 frqvruwlxp lv d vwdqgdugl}dwlrq frpplwwhh iru dfklhylqj lqwhueudqg frpsdwlelolw|

ehwzhhq zhe eurzvhuv dqg zhe ghvljqhu wrrov1 Lq wklv sduwlfxodu fdvh/ Plfurvriw dqg Qhwvfdsh frpshwh rq wkh eurzvhu pdunhw dqg frruglqdwh wkhlu dfwlylwlhv wrzdugv lqwhueudqg frpsdwlelolw| lq wkh frqvruwlxp +vhh Pdjd}lq i‚xu Frpsxwhu Whfkqln/ Vhswhpehu/ 4<<:/ ss1 ;304/ iru d ghvfulswlrq ri wklv fdvh,1

47Wkh olwhudwxuh rq uhvhdufk mrlqw yhqwxuhv +vhh Irrwqrwh ;, grhv rqo| frqvlghu nqrzohgjh vslooryhuv ehwzhhq upv1 Lqyhvwphqw dfwlylwlhv zklfk jhqhudwh srvlwlyh ghpdqg vlgh hhfwv duh qrw h{dplqhg lq wklv vwudqg ri olwhudwxuh1

S

€h4tc U @UUhi uhL4 UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t LhiLihc *i |Lti T@Tiht |@h}i|

|i tti Lu i @?|i t|@?_@h_3@|L? Lh T@Tih ?it|}@|it €h4t< ?Ui?|it |L it|@M*t UL4T@|M*|) i TLt|c @u|ih t|@?_@h_ |iU?L*L}it @i UL4i ?|L i t|i?Ui^D

Ai 4@? TL?| Lu Lh T@Tih t |@| Lh}@?3@|L?t *!i t|@?_@h_3@|L? UL44||iitc Lh UL_it@h?} @hh@?}i4i?|t ? |i UL?|i | Lu ?|ih?@|L?@* @h*?i tihUitc _L ? }i?ih@*

i*T |L ?|ih?@*3i |Lti tT**Liht @?_ _L *i@_ |L tiUL?_Mit| i*u@hi *ii*t @t *L?} @t

|i) _L ?L| ?_Ui €h4t |L UL**_i L? |i L|T| 4@h!i| 5hTht?}*)c uLh } @*it Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih i*u@hi t ii? }ih ?_ih @ hi}4i ihi €h4t ULLTih@|i

? ML| t|@}it UL4T@hi_ |L Thi UL4Ti||i Mi@Lh ? ML| t|@}it AihiuLhic Lh T@Tih 4}| i*T |L i T*@? ) Lh3L?|@* ULLTih@|L? ? t|@?_@h_3@|L? UL44||iit Lh

?|ih?@|L?@* @h*?i @**@?Uit @hi t@**) ?L| @**i}i_ |L Mi @?|UL4Ti||ic @t *L?} @t | t *4|i_ |L t|@?_@h_3@|L? ttit^S

Ai hit| Lu |i T@Tih t Lh}@?3i_ @t uL**LtG W? 5iU|L? 2 i Thiti?| |i 4L_i*c tL*i uLh

|i tM}@4i TihuiU| i^*Mh@ uLh @** |hii hi}4itc @?_ U@*U*@|i |i i*u@hi 4@ 43?}

€ht|Mit| L|UL4i W? 5iU|L? i UL4T@hi Lh hit*|t @?_ t44@h3i |i TL*U) UL?

U*tL?t W? 5iU|L? e i @?@*)3i |i 4T@U| Lu ?t|||L?t U ?Uhi@ti |i tT**Lih igiU|t }i?ih@|i_ M) UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t 6?@**)c 5iU|L? D UL?U*_it

5 Wkh Prgho

`i TLt| |L €h4t i@U ThL_U?} @ 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U| @?_ @ UL4T*i4i?|@h) ?Ui 4@h!i| ThL_U| 6Lh i@U €h4 i @tt4i |@| |t 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U| @?_ |t ?Ui 4@h!i| ThL_U| t _it}?i_ @UULh_?} |L |i t@4i €h4tTiU€U ?|ihu@Ui |iU?L*L})c tL

48Dsso|lqj rxu sdshu wr wkh lqwhuqdwlrqdo dluolqh lqgxvwu|/ zh pd| lqwhusuhw frghvkdulqj duudqjhphqwv zlwklq dq lqwhuqdwlrqdo dluolqh dooldqfh dqdorjrxvo| wr vwdqgdugl}dwlrq frpplwwhhv1 Wkrvh duudqjhphqwv wlfnhw d wuls wkdw lqyroyhv wudyhoolqj dfurvv wkh qhwzrunv ri erwk dluolqhv dv li wkh wudyho rffxuuhg rq d vlqjoh fduulhu1 Dv uhsruwhg e| ijW"Aji ^4<<;` wkh pdlq ihdwxuh ri wkrvh frghvkdulqj duudqjhphqwv lv wr dfklhyh vfkhgxoh frruglqdwlrq dqg wr lpsuryh dlusruw jdwh sur{lplw|/ vr wkdw frqqhfwlrqv ehwzhhq fduulhuv ehfrph pruh frqyhqlhqw1 Khqfh/ li rqh dluolqh pdnhv wlphwdeoh dgmxvwphqwv/ vr wkdw grphvwlf sdvvhqjhuv zloo qg lw hdvlhu wr frqqhfw wr wkh rwkhu dluolqh/ dq dgglwlrqdo grphvwlf sdvvhqjhu fuhdwhv h{wud uhyhqxhv iru wkh grphvwlf up rq wkh krph pdunhw dqg ehqhwv wkh rwkhu up rq lwv wudqvdwodqwlf urxwh/ vlqfh d iudfwlrq ri dgglwlrqdo sdvvhqjhuv zloo wudyho yld wkh rwkhu dluolqh*v wudqvdwodqwlf urxwh1

49Iru lqvwdqfh/ lB|5 < 7BViN ^4<<;` vwdwh zlwk uhvshfw wr wkh vriwzduh lqgxvwu| wkdw wkh| _nqrz ri qr vxffhvvixo dqwlwuxvw fkdoohqjhv wr frrshudwlrq wr vhw vriwzduh vwdqgdugv1%

.

|@| ML| ThL_U|t @hi TihuiU|*) UL4T@|M*i h}| uhL4 |i t|@h| `|L| @?) ?it|4i?|t

?|L ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|) €h4t< ThL_U|t @hi L4L}i?iLt @?_ €h4t u@Ui @ *?i@h

?ihti _i4@?_ u?U|L? L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i|G^. RE^c ^ ' 'c | ' c 2c 9' c : ' fc @?_ ' ' ^ n ^c ihi R t|@?_t uLh €h4 <t 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U| ThUi

@?_ ^ _i?L|it €h4 <t ThL_U|L? ^@?||) 6h4t @i |i t@4i UL?t|@?| 4@h}?@* ULt|t _i?L|i_ M) Sc U @hi ?Lh4@*3i_ |L 3ihL `i @tt4i |@| i?|h) ?|L |i ?_t|h) t

?ThL€|@M*i @?_ |@| : f L*_tc tL |@| ThL_U|L? t ThL€|@M*i uLh |i ?U4Mi?|t^H wi| t ?L ? _i|@* _itUhMi |i ?@|hi @?_ |i igiU|t Lu UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t

`i uLUt L? ?it|4i?|t ?|L ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|) U 4@!i @ €h4<t ?Ui 4@h!i|

ThL_U| 4Lhi UL4T@|M*i | |i L|ih €h4<t 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U| W? Lh 4L_i* |Lti

?it|4i?|t ?_ih|@!i? M) €h4 c U @hi _i?L|i_ M) % fc @i |L igiU|tG 6ht|c

|i) ?Uhi@ti M)iht< 4@ 44 **?}?itt |L T@) uLh €h4 <t ?Ui 4@h!i| ThL_U|c

@?_ i?Uic Mi?i€| |i ?it|?} €h4 _hiU|*) @ |t ?Ui 4@h!i| W? T@h|U*@hc i _i?L|i M) % €h4 <t UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?| *ii* U ?Uhi@tit €h4 <t ?Ui 4@h!i|

?i| hii?it *?i@h*) @UULh_?} |L %c | ' c 2c @?_ fc _i?L|?} |i UL?t|@?|

4@h}?@* ?Uhi@ti Lu ?Ui 4@h!i| ?i| hii?it At 4i@?tc M)iht Lu €h4 <t ?Ui 4@h!i| ThL_U| @i @ ?uLh4 hitih@|L? ThUi U ?Uhi@tit *?i@h*) | €h4 <t

?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?| *ii*^b Ai 4L?LTL*t|U tTT*ih @TThLTh@|it |i i?|hi UL?t4ih thT*t @?_ hi@*3it UL?t|@?| 4@h}?@* ?i| hii?itc c L? |i ?Ui 4@h!i| uhL4 @__|L?@* ?it|4i?|t^2f W? Lh_ih |L _i@* | t)44i|hU €h4tc i @tt4i

|@| t |i t@4i uLh ML| €h4t

4:Dv lq wkh G*Dvsuhprqw0Mdftxhplq prgho/ zh vxssrvh wkdw wkh ghpdqg ixqfwlrq idfhg e| wkh gxr0 srolvwv lv olqhdu exw/ zlwkrxw orvv ri jhqhudolw|/ zh vxssrvh lwv vorsh lv 41

4;Iru wkh vdnh ri vlpsolflw|/ zh devwudfw iurp dq| furvv0pdunhw sulfh hhfwv ehwzhhq wkh qlfkh dqg wkh pdvv pdunhwv1

4<Lq wkh Dsshqgl{ zh vkrz wkdw wkh olqhdu vshflfdwlrq ri wkh uhgxfhg qlfkh pdunhw surwv grhv dovr dsso| wr dq ruglqdu| prqrsrolvwlf pdunhw vwuxfwxuh zlwk olqhdu ghpdqg1

53Lq rxu prgho vshflfdwlrq/ zh phdvxuh wkh lqyhvwphqw yduldeoh {le| wkh rxwsxw jhqhudwhg e| up l*v frpsdwlelolw| lqyhvwphqwv1 Lw lv qrw dq lqsxw yduldeoh vxfk dv wkh dprxqw ri uhvhdufk hruw1 Lw vkrxog eh fulwlfdoo| qrwhg wkdw a?tVij6NA| < cBW`j6A ^4<;;` dv zhoo phdvxuh wkh dprxqw ri U)G lqyhvwphqw e| lwv rxwsxw/ vxfk wkdw dq lqfuhdvh lq { uhgxfhv pdujlqdo frvwv e| wkh vdph dprxqw1 Wkdw lv/ dq lqfuhdvh lq zkdw g*Dvsuhprqw dqg Mdftxhplq fdoo lqyhvwphqw lv vwulfwo| vshdnlqj wkh uhgxfwlrq lq pdujlqdo frvwv lqgxfhg e| wkh U)G hruw1 Krzhyhu/ wkh| vwdwh wkdw wkhlu lqyhvwphqw yduldeoh phdvxuhv wkh _dprxqw ri uhvhdufk% d up xqghuwdnhv1 Lq frqwudvw wr wkhlu dqg rxu prgho/ lB6jAe ,,ji < ~BA} ^4<<5`

kdyh ghqhg wkhlu lqyhvwphqw yduldeoh dv dq lqsxw yduldeoh1 Iru d frpsuhkhqvlyh frpsdulvrq ri erwk irupxodwlrqv ri wkh U)G vslooryhu hhfw vhh 6i ^4<<;`1

H

5iUL?_c €h4 <t UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?| ?Uhi@tit €h4 <t 4@tt 4@h!i| _i4@?_ MiU@ti UL?t4iht i?L) @ MhL@_ih h@?}i Lu UL4T*i4i?|@h) ThL_U|t @?_ tihUit ? @ 4Lhi UL?

i?i?|c ic ? @ 4Lhi UL4T@|M*i @) At igiU| Mi?i€|t |i h@* €h4 ?_hiU|*) @

@? ?Uhi@ti Lu |t 4@tt 4@h!i| _i4@?_ 5?Ui €h4 <t ?Ui 4@h!i| ThL_U| t UL4T*i4i?

|@h) |L €h4 <t 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U|c UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t Lu €h4 M) |i @4L?|

Lu % *i@_ |L TLt|i tT**Lihtc tU |@| €h4 <t 4@tt 4@h!i| _i4@?_ t tu|i_ L|

@h_ M) |i @4L?| Lu q%c ihi q f t|@?_t uLh |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih W? UL?|h@t|

|L ?uLh4@|L?@* +:# tT**Lihtc UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?| tT**Liht @hi ML?_i_ uhL4

@MLi M) |i ?Uhi@ti ? UL?t4iht< 4@ 44 **?}?itt |L T@) uLh @ 4@h}?@* ?Uhi@ti

? UL4T@|M*|) | |i L|ih €h4<t ?Ui 4@h!i| ThL_U| W?|i}h@|?} |i tT**Lih igiU| ?|L i@U €h4<t ?ihti _i4@?_ tUi_*i }it

RE^c ^c % ' n q% 'c 9' c ' c 2 E

At 4i@?tc UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t M) €h4 _gihi?|@|i |i €h4t< ThL_U|t ? |i ti?ti |@| |i) 4ThLi |i ^@*|) Lu €h4 <t 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U| hi*@|i |L €h4 <t 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U| ? 4ThLi4i?| ? ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|) ?_ih|@!i? M) €h4 c |ihiuLhic ?Uhi@tit UL?t4iht< **?}?itt |L T@) uLh €h4 <t 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U|

L|ic i? UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t @hi |i t@4ic % ' %2c ML| }LL_t @hi TihuiU|

tMt|||it @?_ @i |i t@4i ThUi L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i|( i R ' n q% ^ ^c | 9' Wuc Liihc UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?| *ii*t @hi ?L| |i t@4ic | % : %c |i?

|i }LL_t @hi ih|U@**) _gihi?|@|i_ At 4T*itc iih) UL?t4ih t **?} |L T@) @

^@*|) Thi44 uLh }LL_ 6Lh |i ?__@* ?ihti _i4@?_ u?U|L?t @t tTiU€i_ M) ,^@|L? Ec |i ^@*|) Thi44 _iTi?_t L?*) L? |i _gihi?Ui ? ?it|4i?| *ii*t

@?_ |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih qc tU |@| 4@h!i| U*i@h?} hi^hit R R ' qE% % L|i @*tLc |@| €h4 <t ?__@* 4@tt 4@h!i| _i4@?_ tUi_*i E t ?_iTi?_i?| Lu

|t L? UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t ALti ?it|4i?|t M) €h4 _L L?*) Uhi@|i TLt|i tT**Lih igiU|t uLh |i h@*<t 4@tt 4@h!i| _i4@?_

LhiLihc i @tt4i |@| €h4 <t UL4T@|M*|) ULt| u?U|L?c gc t @ UL?i u?U|L? Lu

|i UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|c %c @?_ }i? M) gE% ' ₂%²c | ' c 2 @?_ : f^2

Lc *i| t |h? |L |i _itUhT|L? Lu |i |Lt|@}i }@4i W? |i €ht| t|@}i @** €h4t

54Dqdorjrxvo| wr wkh frqfdylw| uhvwulfwlrqv lpsrvhg rq wkh U)G surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrq lq wkh prgho ri lB6jAe ,,ji < ~BA} ^4<<5`/ wkh vwulfw frqyh{lw| ri N lpsolhv olp{$4N³ @ 4/ zklfk vhuyhv wr jxdudqwhh h{lvwhqfh ri htxloleuld lq zklfk frpsdwlelolw| lqyhvwphqwv duh erxqghg iurp deryh1

b

t4*|@?iLt*) ULLti |ih UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?| *ii*t @?_ ? |i tiUL?_ t|@}i @**

€h4t _i|ih4?i |ih L|T| L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i| `i UL?t_ih |hii hi}4it | @ h)?} _i}hiit Lu ULLTih@|L? Mi|ii? €h4t N?_ih |i UL4T@|M*|) UL4Ti||L? hi}4i EQ Q €h4t Mi@i ?L?ULLTih@|i*) ? ML| t|@}it Lu |i }@4i N?_ih |i UL4T@|M

*|) UL44||ii hi}4i EFQ ML| €h4t ULLh_?@|i |ih UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t ? @ t|@?_@h_3@|L? UL44||iic M| Mi@i ?L?ULLTih@|i*) ? |i 4@tt 4@h!i| N?_ih |i U@h|i*3@|L? hi}4i EFF €h4t ULLTih@|i ? ML| t|@}it Lu |i }@4ic tL |@| hi*@|L?t ?

|i t|@?_@h_3@|L? UL44||ii *i@_ |L UL**tL? L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i|

W? Lh_ih |L UL4T@hi |i L|UL4it ?_ih |i _gihi?| hi}4ic i @?| |L ?|hL_Ui |i uL**L?} @tt4T|L?tc U @hi ? igiU| |hL}L| |i T@Tih

tt4T|L?  Ai 4@h}?@* ThL€|t L? |i ?Ui 4@h!i| @hi tUi?|*) }G : ^2q_b tt4T|L?  i?thit |@| i@U €h4<t 4@h}?@* ThL€|t L? |i ?Ui 4@h!i|c ic ^{Y E%}_{Y %} ' c

| ' c 2c }i tUi?| ?Ui?|it |L ?_ih|@!i UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t i? €h4t Mi@i ?L?ULLTih@|i*) ? ML| t|@}it Lu |i }@4i EQ Q hi}4i AihiuLhic }i? |@|

tt4T|L?  L*_tc ML| €h4t tTi?_ ? @** hi}4it ?_ih UL?t_ih@|L? @ t|hU|*) TLt

|i @4L?| Lu 4L?i) L? UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t ? i@U t)44i|hU tM}@4i TihuiU|

i^*Mh4

tt4T|L? 2 L4T@|M*|) ULt|t @hi tUi?|*) UL?i G E q s

2 es @?_

E s

2 ₂^b

tt4T|L? 2 E i?thit |@| hi_Ui_ ThL€| u?U|L?t uLh @** hi}4it ? |i €ht| t|@}i Lu |i }@4i @hi t|hU|*) UL?U@i ? UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|tc %c @*L?} |i T@| Lu i^@*

?it|4i?|t At 4T*itc |@| iih) tM}@4i @| |i tiUL?_ t|@}i @t @ ?^i t)44i|hU

@t i^*Mh4²² UULh_?} |L tt4T|L? 2 E i TLt| |@| tt4T|L? 2 Ec @?_

?L| tt4T|L? c t |i M?_?} UL?_|L? uLh |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih q

wi| t ?L _i€?i M) l |i ti| Lu iU|Lht Lu T@h@4i|ihtc | / ' Ec c qc 5 -^e_nc U t@|tu) tt4T|L?  @?_ 2( ic l ' i/ 5 -^e_nmq s

2 ₂^bj²

55Dqdo|wlfdoo| Dvvxpswlrq 5 +l, hqvxuhv wkdw doo hqgrjhqrxv yduldeohv duh qrq0qhjdwlyh dqg doo vhfrqg rughu frqglwlrqv xqghu Q Q / FQ / FF/ dqg wkh zhoiduh pd{lpl}lqj uhjlph/ zklfk zloo eh lqwurgxfhg ehorz/

duh ixooohg1

56Zlwk U. zh ghqrwh wkh vhw ri doo srvlwlyh uhdo qxpehuv lqfoxglqj }hur1

f

`i ?L tL*i |i }@4i M) M@U!@h_ ?_U|L?c ihi i @tt4i |@| €h4t U@??L|

4@!i t_i T@)4i?|t At 4i@?t i@U €h4 @t |L hi@*3i |t T@)Lgt ?__@**) @u|ih

|i tiUL?_ t|@}i Lu |i }@4ic tL |@| R@ T*@)ih<t T@)Lg UL?tt|t Lu |i tiUL?_ t|@}i ThL_U|L? ThL€|t *itt t €ht|t|@}i +:# i Ti?_|hi ElB6jAe ,,ji < ~BA}

dbb2c T 2beo iU@ti Lu |t @tt4T|L? i U@? hit|hU| @||i?|L? |L |i t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 ?_ih i@U hi}4i^2e

W? 5iU|L? 2 i U@*U*@|i |i ?L?ULLTih@|i @?_ ULLTih@|i LT|4@* t|h@|i}it ? |i tiUL?_ t|@}i Lu |i }@4i W? 5iU|L? 22 i *LL! @| |i LT|4@* t|h@|i}it ?_ih @** |hii hi}4it }i? |i LT|4@* t|h@|i}it ? |i tiUL?_ t|@}i Lu |i }@4i W? 5iU|L? 2 i U@*U*@|i |i i*u@hi 4@ 43?} L|UL4i

514 Vhfrqg0Vwdjh Htxloleulxp

L?ULLTih@|i Mi@LhG W? |i tiUL?_ t|@}i €h4 <t ThL€| u?U|L?c c UL?_|L?@* L?

% @?_ %2c t

' E n q% ^ ^^n %

2%²c 9' c ' c 2 E2 Ai t)44i|hU @tLh?L| i^*Mh4 U@? Mi UL4T|i_ |L Mi^2D

^ ' n 2q% q%

c 9' c ' c 2 E

5Mt|||L? Lu ^ ?|L |i ThL€| u?U|L? E2 }it |i hi_Ui_ ThL€| u?U|L? E|i tTihtUhT| Q t|@?_t uLh ?L?ULLTih@|i Mi@Lh ? |i tiUL?_ t|@}iG

' 

bE n 2q% q%²n %

2%²c 9' c ' c 2 Ee

57Wkh v|pphwulf vroxwlrq xqghu wkh FQ dqg wkh FF uhjlph kdv ehhq dgrswhg e| doprvw doo wkh olwhudwxuh wkdw zdv vsdunhg e| wkh vhplqdo zrun ri a?tVij6NA| < cBW`j6A ^4<;;`1 Lw kdv ehhq uhfhqwo|

fulwlfl}hg e| 7B,BA| < 7Buuji ^4<<;`/ ^4<<<` zkr vkrz wkdw mrlqw surw pd{lpl}dwlrq ri lghqwlfdo upv rq wkh lqyhvwphqw vwdjh pd| ohdg wr dv|pphwulf rxwfrphv/ lq zklfk rqh up kdv d odujhu pdunhw vkduh wkdq lwv ulydo1 Krzhyhu/ vxfk dq dv|pphwulf rxwfrph lv rqo| ihdvleoh li upv fdq pdnh vlgh sd|phqwv/ ehfdxvh vdohv uhyhqxh iru wkh up zlwk wkh vpdoohu pdunhw vkduh duh vwulfwo| orzhu lq dq|

dv|pphwulf rxwfrph wkdq lq wkh v|pphwulf htxloleulxp1 Vhh dovr Qjajt < bj+ ^4<<<` zkr vkrz zlwklq wkh g*Dvsuhprqw0Mdftxhplq prgho wkdw wkh v|pphwulf vroxwlrq lv sduhwr0rswlpdo xqghu wkh FQ uhjlph1

58Wkh vhfrqg rughu frqglwlrq iru d surw pd{lpxp lv dozd|v ixooohg1



L**ti Mi@LhG Lc UL?t_ih |i U@ti ihi €h4t ti |i UL44||ii |L UL**_i L?

|i 4@tt 4@h!i| tt4?} @ t)44i|hU tL*|L?c tU |@| ^ ' ^2 ' ^ @?_ %' %2 ' % L*_tc i }i| |i L?|ThL€| u?U|L?

' 2E n q% 2^^ n 2% %² ED

@ 43@|L? )i*_t uLh i@U €h4<t ^@?||it

^ ' n q%

e c ES

@?_ M) tMt|||?} ES ?|L |i L?|ThL€| u?U|L? ED i }i| |i hi_Ui_ L?|ThL€|

u?U|L?c E|i tTihtUhT| F t|@?_t uLh ULLTih@|i Mi@Lh ? |i €ht| t|@}iG ' _ n ₂ ' 

eE n q%²n 2% %²c E.

uLh % ' %2' % ?_ih |i t)44i|hU tL*|L? ^ ' ^2 ' ^ `i ?L |h? |L |i €ht| t|@}i Lu |i }@4i ? U €h4t _iU_i @ML| |ih UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?| *ii*t

515 Iluvw0Vwdjh Htxloleulxp

Bi? €h4t< t|h@|i}it ? |i tiUL?_ t|@}ic i i @4?i ?L |i tM}@4i TihuiU| ?it|

4i?| _iUtL? ? |i €ht| t|@}i ?_ih |i |hii _gihi?| hi}4it

L4T@|M*|) L4Ti||L? EQ Q G W? |t U@ti €h4t _L ?L| ULLh_?@|i |ih UL4T@|M*|) _iUtL?t Atc i@U €h4 t4*|@?iLt*) ULLtit |t ?it|4i?| |L 4@ 43i Ee | hitTiU| |L % At }it @ ?^i t)44i|hU tL*|L? t@|tu)?} EY *Y % ' fc uLh U i }i|^2S

% ' b 2q

b n 2q²c ' c 2c EH

@?_

^ ' E n q

b n 2q² c ' c 2c Eb

ihi |i tTihtUhT| Q Q ?_U@|it |i UL4T@|M*|) UL4Ti||L? hi}4i L|i |@|

tt4T|L?  i?thit |@| |i h}|@?_ t_i Lu ,^@|L? EH t t|hU|*) TLt|i `ic

59Wkh vhfrqg rughu frqglwlrq uhtxluhv ^5<₅ ? 3 ru ? 6s

@5 5=45s1 Wkh vwdelolw| frqglwlrq m_{C {}^{C {}_m^lm ? 4 uhgxfhv wr wkh vdph frqglwlrq dv wkh vhfrqg rughu frqglwlrq1 Lq frqwudvw wr wkh prgho ri a?tVij6NA| < cBW`j6A ^4<;;`/ lq rxu prgho/ wkh vwdelolw| frqglwlrq grhv qrw uhvwulfw wkh vslooryhu sdudphwhu wr d srvlwlyh plqlpxp ohyho dv kdv ehhq ghwhfwhg e| QjAi`jt ^4<<3`1

2

|ihiuLhic i U*_i |i U@tic |@| |ihi 4}| Thi@* TihuiU| ?|ihMh@?_ ?UL4T@|M*|) ?

|i ti?ti |@| ?L €h4 ?_ih|@!it @?) UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t

L4T@|M*|) L44||ii EFQ G Oihic @t ? |i U@ti Lu Q Q c €h4t UL4Ti|i L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i| ? |i tiUL?_ t|@}i OLiihc |i) ULLh_?@|i |ih UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t

|L 4@ 43i |i t4 Lu |ih UL4M?i_ ThL€|t A@| tc |i) uLh4 @ t|@?_@h_3@|L?

UL44||ii *i 4@?|@??} UL4Ti||L? ? |i ThL_U| 4@h!i| `i @i |L 4@ 43i

|i t4 Lu i@U €h4<t ThL€|tc tL |@| i }i| uLh % ' %2 ' % |i UL44||ii<t ThL€|

u?U|L?

' _ n ₂ ' 2

bE n q%²n 2% %²c Ef ihi |i tTihtUhT| FQ t|@?_t uLh |i UL4T@|M*|) UL44||ii hi}4i Ai t)44i|hU ULLTih@|i i^*Mh4 ? UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t @?_ ? ThL_U|L? ULhhitTL?_t |L

|i uL**L?} ?^i tL*|L?^2.

% ' b n 2q

b 2q² c E

@?_

^ ' E n q

b 2q² E2

6hL4 ,^@|L? E i LMtihi |@| ULLTih@|L? L? |i ?it|4i?| t|@}i t tUi?| |L

?_Ui TLt|i ?it|4i?| *ii*tc ii? u 4@h}?@* ?i| hii?it L? |i ?Ui 4@h!i| @hi i^@* |L 3ihL( ic ' f

@h|i*3@|L? EFFG At |h_ U@ti _i@*t | €h4t 4@ 43?} L?| ThL€|t ? ML|

t|@}it Lu |i }@4i | |i €ht| t|@}ic |i hi_Ui_ L?| ThL€| u?U|L?c c t }i? M) ,^@|L? E.c @?_ i LM|@? |i ?^i tL*|L?c t@|tu)?}^2H

% ' e n q

e q²c E

@?_

^ ' n q

e q² c Ee

ihi FF hiThiti?|t |i U@h|i*3@|L? hi}4i wi| t ?L |h? |L |i i*u@hi 4@ 43?}

?it|4i?| @?_ L|T| *ii*t MiuLhi i ** UL4T@hi Lh hit*|t

5:Wkh vhfrqg rughu frqglwlrq uhtxluhv ? 6s

@5 5=45s1

5;Wkh vhfrqg rughu frqglwlrq iru wkh vhfrqg vwdjh uhtxluhv ? 5s1



516 Iluvw0Ehvw Zhoiduh

AL UL4T@hi |i @MLi hit*|t i ?ii_ |L it|@M*t @? iUi?| t|@?_@h_ AihiuLhic *i| t _i€?i €ht|Mit| tLU@* i*u@hi `⁵E^c % @t |i t4 Lu |i UL?t4ih thT*t 7E^c % @?_

|i ThL_Uih thT*t E@tt4?} % ' %2 ' % @?_ ^ ' ^2 ' ^ Bi? Lh tTiU€U@|L? Lu

@? *?i@h ?ihti _i4@?_ tUi_*ic^2b UL?t4ih thT*t t 7E^c % ' 2^²c @?_ |i tLU@*

i*u@hi u?U|L? t }i? M)

`⁵E^c % ' 2E n q% ^^ n 2% %² ED

`i }i| @t |i iUi?| L|T| uLh i@U €h4^f

^ ' n q%

2 ES

Oi?Uic @| |i €ht| t|@}ic |i hi_Ui_ tLU@* i*u@hi u?U|L? t

`⁵ ' 

2E n q%²n 2% %² E.

Ai iUi?| *ii* Lu UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?| uLh i@U €h4 t@|tu)?} |i €ht| Lh_ih UL?_|L? uLh @ i*u@hi 4@ 44 t^

%⁵ ' 2 n q

2 q²c EH

@?_ i?Uic |i i*u@hi 4@ 43?} tL*|L? L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i| t

^⁵ ' n q

2 q² c Eb

ihi |i tTihtUhT| IE ?_U@|it |i €ht|Mit| L|UL4i

6 Frpsdulvrq ri Uhvxowv

W? A@M*i  Lh hit*|t UL?Uih??} ^@?||itc UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|tc @?_ ThUit @hi t44@h3i_c ihi i tTThitti_ |i ?_i MiU@ti Lu t)44i|h)

`i U@? ?L uLh4*@|i |i uL**L?} ThLTLt|L? | hitTiU| |L €h4t< ?it|4i?| *ii*t

5<Uhfdoo doo upv duh dvvxphg wr h{wudfw doo wkh hqwluh frqvxphu vxusoxv lq wkhlu qlfkh pdunhwv1

63Wkh vhfrqg rughu frqglwlrq grhv dozd|v krog1

64Wkh vhfrqg rughu frqglwlrq lv jlyhq e| ? s5 4=74s/ zklfk lv wkh elqglqj frqglwlrq iru dvvxulqj d xqltxh lqwhulru vroxwlrq iru doo uhjlphv xqghu frqvlghudwlrq1

e

A@M*i G 6h4t< ,^*Mh4 "@?||itc W?it|4i?|tc @?_ hUit +i}4i "@?||) W?it|4i?| hUi

Q Q ^ ' ^Enq_bn2q2 % ' ^b32q_bn2q2 R ' ^Enq_bn2q2

FQ ^ ' ^Enq_b32q2 % ' ^bn2q_b32q2 R ' ^Enq_b32q2

FF ^ ' ^nq_e3q2 % ' ^enq_e3q2 R ' ^2Enq_e3q2

IE ^⁵ ' ^nq_23q2 %⁵ ' ^2nq_23q2 R⁵ ' f

hLTLt|L?  6Lh / 5 l |i i^*Mh4 UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?| *ii*t Lu i@U €h4c

%^,c ?_ih |i _gihi?| hi}4itc , ' IEc Q Q c FQ c FFc t@|tu) |i uL**L?} Lh_ih?}G

%⁵ % % % 6h|ih4Lhic

%⁵: % : % : % c

u @?_ L?*) u q : f L*_t Ei^@*|) L*_?} u @?_ L?*) u q ' f

hLLuG 6L**Lt _hiU|*) uhL4 UL4T@h?} EHc Ec Ec @?_ EH 6Lh q ' f i LM|@?

%⁵ ' % ' % ' % ' ",#

hLTLt|L?  t|@|it |@| ULLTih@|i ?it|4i?| @U||) i Uii_t |i UL4Ti||i ?it|

4i?| *ii* ? |i Thiti?Ui Lu TLt|i tT**Liht W?it|4i?| *ii*t UL4i U*Ltit| |L |i

€ht|Mit| U@ti i? €h4t UL**_i ? ML| t|@}it Lu |i }@4i L4T@htL? Lu FQ @?_

Q Q hii@*t @? 4TLh|@?| _gihi?Ui Mi|ii? |i iUL?L4U *|ih@|hi L? +:# tT**Liht

@?_ Lh @?@*)tt Lu TLt|i tT**Liht uLh4 UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t ?i 4@Lh €?_?}

Lu |@| *|ih@|hi t |@| ULLTih@|i +:# @U||it ? |i U@ti Lu FQ i Uii_ UL4Ti

||i hiti@hU *ii*t u @?_ L?*) u |i i |i?| |L U ?uLh4@|L? Lt uhii*) @4L?}

UL4Ti||Lht t hi*@|i*) } W? Lh 4L_i* |t }i?ih@* €?_?} t ?_iTi?_i?| Lu |i i @U| T@h@4i|ih @*i Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih² LLTih@|i ?|ih?@*3@|L? Lu |i TLt|i i |ih?@*|it L? L?| ThL€|t @UUh?} uhL4 i@U €h4t< UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t

65Lq sduwlfxodu/ a?tVij6NA| < cBW`j6A ^4<;;` uhsruw wkh fodvvlfdwlrq {^IEA {^FF A {^FQ A {^{Q Q} iru odujh ydoxhv ri 5 +4> 3=8,/ dqg wkh fodvvlfdwlrq {^IEA {^{Q Q} A {^FFA {^FQ iru vpdoo sdudphwhu ydoxhv ri 5 +> 3=74`/ zkhuh A 3 lv ghwhuplqhg e| wkh vwdelolw| frqglwlrq mC {l@C {mm ? 4 iru wkh Q Q fdvh +vhh QjAi`jt ^4<<3`,1

D

?Uhi@ti ?it|4i?| *ii*tc MiU@ti |i) L|i} |i _t@_@?|@}i _i |L TLt|i tT**

Liht Mi?i€|?} |i UL4Ti||Lh L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i| LhiLihc ?it|4i?| *ii*t ?Uhi@ti ThLTLh|L?@**) | }ih _i}hiit Lu ULLTih@|L?c tL |@| ?it|4i?|t @hi U*Ltit| |L |i

€ht|Mit| *ii* ?_ih |i U@h|i*3@|L? hi}4i EFF

Ai uL**L?} ThLTLt|L? U@h@U|ih3it |i hit*|t uLh |i ^@?||it Lu ThL_U|L?

hLTLt|L? 2 L?t_ih @** / 5 l Ai? uLh @** : f |ihi i t|t @ Uh|U@* @*i qc tU |@| |i i^*Mh4 ^@?||it Lu i@U €h4 L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i|c ^^,c ?_ih |i _gihi?| hi}4itc , ' IEc Q Q c FQ c FFc t@|tu)

^⁵ : ^ ^ : ^c uLh f q qc

| ^ ' ^ u @?_ L?*) u q ' fc @?_

^⁵ : ^ : ^ ^c uLh q q s 2c

| ^ ' ^ u @?_ L?*) u q ' qc ihi q t

D f.Hs hLLuG 5ii TTi?_ ",#

hLTLt|L? 2 t|@|it |@| |i U*Ltit| |L |i tLU@* LT|44 t @| t ThL_Ui_ ?_ih |i UL44||ii UL4T@|M*|) EFQ hi}4i LhiLihc uLh hi*@|i*) *@h}i tT**Lihtc tU |@|

q :t

D t u*€**i_c u**) ULLTih@|i Mi@Lh EFF *i@_t |L }ih ThL_U|L? ^@?||it

|@? Thi UL4Ti||i Mi@Lh EQ Q At thTht?} €?_?} hii@*t @? 4TLh|@?|

_gihi?Ui Mi|ii? UL4T@|M*|) @?_ +:# tT**Liht W? UL?|h@t| |L +:# ?it|4i?|tc U Th4@h*) hi_Ui |i ?| ULt|t Lu |i ?it|?} €h4c ?it|4i?|t ?|L ?|ihMh@?_

UL4T@|M*|) ?iih }i?ih@|i @?) _hiU| @_@?|@}iLt igiU|t uLh |i ?it|?} €h4 L?

|i 4@tt 4@h!i| t @ hit*|c u** ?|ih?@*3@|L? Lu UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t ?_ih

|i U@h|i*3@|L? hi}4i EFF 4}| *i@_ |L }ih ThL_U|L? *ii*t L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i|

UL4T@hi_ |L Q Q @*|L} 4L?LTL*) ThU?} Thi@*t W? |t T@h|U*@h U@tic |i 4@h!i|

i T@?tL? igiU| }i?ih@|i_ M) UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t L|i}t |i 4L?LTL*3@|L?

igiU| _i |L UL**ti Mi@Lh L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i| At hit*| t |i 4Lhi *!i*) |i }ih |i @*i Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih

Ai uL**L?} ThLTLt|L? t|@|it |i i*u@hi hit*|t Lu Lh 4L_i*

hLTLt|L? L?t_ih @** / 5 l Ai? i*u@hic `^,c ?_ih |i _gihi?| hi}4itc , ' IEc Q Q c FQ c FFc t@|t€it |i uL**L?} Lh_ih?}G

`<sup>5</sup> : ` : `c uLh q fc

S

@?_

`<sup>5</sup> : ` `c uLh q fc

ihi ` ' ` u @?_ L?*) u q ' f 6h|ih4Lhic uLh @** fc |ihi i t|t @ Uh|U@* @*i q^Wc tU |@|

` : `c u @?_ L?*) u f q q^Wc

@?_

` `c u @?_ L?*) u q^W q s 2c ihi q^W _b2^s

.ee .H2s

.s s LhiLihc ` ' ` u @?_ L?*) u q ' q^W

hLLuG 5ii TTi?_ ",#

6hL4 hLTLt|L? i tii |@| i*u@hi ?_ih FQ t }ih |@? ?_ih Q Q c i?iih

|i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih t TLt|i Ai ?||L? uLh |t hit*| t |i uL**L?}G 6hL4 hLTLt|L? 2 i !?L |@| ^ : ^ L*_t uLh q : fc tL |@| UL?t4ih thT*t 4t|

@i ?Uhi@ti_ 6h4t< ThL€|t @*tL 4t| @i ?Uhi@ti_c MiU@ti L|ihti €h4t L*_

@i ULti? |i ?L?ULLTih@|i ?it|4i?| *ii*t |? |i ULLTih@|i t|@?_@h_ ti||?}

}hLT AihiuLhic UL?t4ih thT*t @?_ €h4t< ThL€|t ML| ?Uhi@ti ?_ih |i FQ hi}4i UL4T@hi_ |L |i Q Q hi}4i

6hL4 hLTLt|L?  @?_ 2 i LM|@? @ tUi?| UL?_|L? uLh i*u@hi ?_ih FF Mi?}

}ih |@? ?_ih Q Q c ?@4i*) q : t

Dc tL |@| ML| ^@?||it Lu ThL_U|L? @?_

UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?| *ii*t @hi }ih ?_ih FF OLiihc hLTLt|L? tLt |@|

tLU@* i*u@hi ?Uhi@tit ?_ih FF ii? uLh *Lih @*it Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ihc tU

|@| q : q^Wc | q : q^Wc @t |L L*_ 6Lh hi*@|i*) t4@** tT**Lihtc tU |@| f q q^W L*_tc |i u**) ?L?ULLTih@|i tL*|L? EQ Q }it }ih *ii*t Lu L|T|c U L|i} |i tLU@* Mi?i€|t uhL4 hi*@|i*) }ih ?it|4i?|t ?_ih FF

W? UL?|h@t| |L +:# ?it|4i?|t U hi_Ui |i ?it|?} €h4<t ?| ULt|t |L @ *@h}ih i |i?| |@? |i L|ih €h4<t ?| ULt|tc tT**Liht uhL4 UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t _L L?*) Mi?i€| |i h@* €h4 L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i| AihiuLhic M) UL4T@h?} Lh hit*|t | |i

*|ih@|hi L? ULt|hi_U?} +:# tT**Lihtc i U@? UL?U*_i |@| tT**Liht t|i44?} uhL4

?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t }i ii? t|hL?}ih iUi?U) hi@tL?t uLh Lh3L?|@*

.

ULLTih@|L? At 4}| i*T |L i T*@? ) ULLTih@|i ?|ih€h4 hi*@|L?t |?

t|@?_@h_3@|L? UL44||iit Lh @h*?i @**@?Uit | UL_it@h?} @hh@?}i4i?|tc @hi t@**)

?L| @**i}i_ |L Mi @?|UL4Ti||i

iuLhi |h??} |L tL4i i |i?tL?t Lu Lh @MLi @?@*)ttc i @?| |L €?t |i UL4T@htL?

Lu Lh hit*|t | |i uL**L?} ThLTLt|L? U*@ttu)?} |i ThUit Thi@*?} ?_ih i@U hi}4i

hLTLt|L? e 6Lh / 5 l |i i^*Mh4 ThUit L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i|c R^,c ?_ih |i _gihi?| hi}4itc , ' IEc Q Q c FQ c FFc t@|tu) |i uL**L?} Lh_ih?}G

R⁵ R R Rc

| R ' R u @?_ L?*) u q ' f

hLLuG 6L**Lt _hiU|*) uhL4 UL4T@htL? Lu i^*Mh4 ThUitc U @hi Thiti?|i_ ? A@M*i  ",#

UULh_?} |L hLTLt|L? e ThUit ?Uhi@ti 4L?L|L?U@**) | |i _i}hii Lu ULLTih@|L?

5?Ui UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t ?Uhi@ti UL?t4iht< **?}?itt |L T@) uLh |i h@*<t 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U|c } ThUit _L ?L| ?iUitt@h*) hiiU| *Lih UL?t4ih thT*t W?_ii_c @t

? |i FQ U@tic }ih ThUit @hi |i hit*| Lu tLU@**) Mi?i€U@* UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|tc tL |@| ThUit @MLi |i u**) UL4Ti||i *ii* hiiU| }ih ^@*|) Lu |i 4@tt 4@h!i|

ThL_U|

6?@**) *i| t UL4T@hi Lh hit*|t | |i i t|?} *|ih@|hi L? T@h@**i*) ih|U@**) ?

|i}h@|i_ €h4tc U ULLti ThUit Lu |i UL4T*i4i?|@h) ThL_U|t @?_ ThL_U| @hi|) i? ThL_U|t @hi i|ih TihuiU|*) UL4T@|M*i Lh TihuiU|*) ?UL4T@|M*i^e UL44L?

hit*| ? |Lti 4L_i*t t |@| ThL€|t @hi }ih ? @ hi}4i Lu u** UL4T@|M*|) L4 T@|M*|) ?Uhi@tit _i4@?_c @?_ i?Uic ThUitc tL |@| ThL€|t ?Uhi@ti W? UL?|h@t| |L

|t hit*|c Lh @?@*)tt @t tL? |@| €h4t Thiuih |L ULLti hi*@|i*) *L UL4T@|M*|)

*ii*t ? @ Thi*) ?L?ULLTih@|i i?hL?4i?|c MiU@ti UL4T@|M*|) t ULt|*) |L @Uii

@?_ *i@_t |L tT**Lih igiU|t U ? |h? ?Uhi@ti |i h@*<t 4@tt ThL_U| ^@*|)

66Lq rxu zhoiduh dqdo|vlv zh udwkhu xqghuhvwlpdwhg wkh zhoiduh hhfwv jhqhudwhg e| frpsdwlelolw| lq0 yhvwphqwv1 Li zh dvvxph d olqhdu qlfkh pdunhw ghpdqg dqg prqrsrolvwlf sulflqj/ wkhq frqvxphu vxusoxv lv d frqyh{ ixqfwlrq ri wkh vxssolhu*v frpsdwlelolw| lqyhvwphqwv/ lpso|lqj wkdw frrshudwlrq pljkw eh hyhq pruh ehqhfldo iru vrflhw| wkdq lw lv lq rxu prgho1

67Vhh iru h{dpsoh/ B||jt < -j}OjB ^4<;;`/ dqg .WNAN6ajt ^4<;<`/ ^4<<4d`1

H

iuLhi UL?U*_?} |i T@Tih i ?L ?it|}@|i €h4t< ?Ui?|it |L it|@M*t ?t|||L?t U *i@_ |L }ih *ii*t Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih Lhc t4*@h*)c |i }Lih?4i?|<t

?Ui?|it |L uLhUi €h4t |L i U@?}i Th@|i ?uLh4@|L? UL?Uih??} |i |iU?U@* _it}?

Lu ?|ihu@Uitc tL |@| |i @*i Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih ?Uhi@tit

7 Rshq Vwdqgdugl}dwlrq Srolf|

W? @UULh_@?Ui | |i @TThL@U ThLTLti_ M) lB6jAe ,,ji < ~BA} dbb2o i i @4?i |i 4T@U| Lu +aV*!i ?t|||L?t U ?Uhi@ti |i *ii* Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih^D W? UL?|h@t| |L @** hi}4it 4i?|L?i_ @MLi €h4t TLL* @** |ih UL4T@|

M*|) igLh|t ? @? +aV tU |@| @** ?uLh4@|L? UL?Uih??} |i |iU?L*L}U@* ?|ihu@Ui t hii@*i_ |L i@U €h4c @?_ i?Uic UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t MiUL4i 4Lhi igiU|i W?

|i UL?|i | Lu t|@?_@h_3@|L? UL44||iit i 4@) ?|ihThi| @ hi}4i U ?Uhi@tit |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih @t @? RLTi? t|@?_@h_ UL44||iic U _i4@?_t |@| T@h|UT@?|t hii@* @** ui@|hit Lu |i ?|ihu@Ui |iU?L*L}) 54*@h*)c |i }Lih?4i?| 4}| Thti

@? LTi? t|@?_@h_3@|L? TL*U) M) uLhU?} €h4t |L _tU*Lti ?uLh4@|L? UL?Uih??} |i UL4T@|M*|) |iU?L*L})^S Ai uL**L?} |L *i44@t t44@h3i |i UL4T@h@|i t|@|U hit*|t | hitTiU| |L q uLh €h4t< ThL€|t @?_ i*u@hi ?_ih |i _gihi?| hi}4it wi44@  6Lh / 5 lc _gihi?|@|L? Lu |i hi_Ui_ ThL€| u?U|L?tc ^,c ?_ih |i _gi hi?| hi}4it , ' Q Q c FQ c FFc | hitTiU| |L q }it

Y ^&

Y q : fc | & ' FQ c FF N?_ih |i Q Q hi}4i i LM|@? |i uL**L?} Lh_ih?}G

68Pruh suhflvho|/ lB6jAe ,,ji < ~BA} ^4<<5` sursrvh wkdw wkh irupdwlrq ri dq UMY lqfuhdvhv wkh vslooryhu sdudphwhu wr lwv pd{lpxp ohyho/ zklfk lv rqh1 Rxu prgho glhuv iurp wkhluv/ vlqfh wkh| orrn dw lqirupdwlrqdo U)G vslooryhuv1 Lq rxu prgho zkhuh phdvxuhv wkh ghjuhh wr zklfk wkh rwkhu up*v pdvv pdunhw ghpdqg lqfuhdvhv iurp frpsdwlelolw| lqyhvwphqwv/ vxfk d udwlrqdoh iru lqwhusuhwlqj grhv qrw h{lvw1

69Rqh h{dpsoh ri dq rshq vwdqgdugl}dwlrq srolf| lv surylghg e| wkh uhfhqwo| lpsohphqwhg HF Gluhfwlyh rq wkh Ohjdo Surwhfwlrq ri Frpsxwhu Surjudpv zklfk lqwurgxfhv d olplwhg uljkw ri _ghfrpslodwlrq%

zkhuhe| rwkhuzlvh lqiulqjlqj dfwv wkdw rffxu gxulqj wkh frxuvh ri ghfrpslolqj d surjudp +l1h1/ frs|lqj ohv/ wudqvodwlqj remhfw frgh edfn lqwr vrxufh frgh, duh shuplwwhg zkhuh wkh| duh qhfhvvdu| wr jdlq lqirupdwlrq wr doorz vriwzduh2kdugzduh lqwhurshudelolw| +vhh dovr 7W6a|WjA < lNON,a| ^4<<6` dqg 7i6ji < wjB ^4<<8`,1

b

E Bi? f q t

2c |ihi i t|t @ Uh|U@* @*i ' 4@ i^2I2_b c^2qE2.32q_2.E32q2²jc tU |@|

Y

Y q fc u @?_ L?*) u c

@?_ Y

Y q fc u @?_ L?*) u E Bi? t

2 q s

2c i }i|

Y

Y q f hLLuG 5ii TTi?_ ",#

6hL4 wi44@  i LMtihi |@| €h4t ?@4M}Lt*) Thiuih |L hii@* @** hi*i@?| ?uLh 4@|L?t UL?Uih??} |i ?|ihu@Ui |iU?L*L}) |L |ih h@*tc i?iih ULLTih@|L? L? |i UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?| t|@}i t TLttM*i 6Lh |i Q Q hi}4i €h4t 4@) @?| |L _i

?uLh4@|L? |L 4@!i |i h@*<t UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t *itt igiU|ic i?iih |i tT*

*Lih T@h@4i|ih t tUi?|*) *@h}i #tU*Lthi Lu ?|ihu@Ui ?uLh4@|L?t t ?__@**) LT|4@* uLh hi*@|i*) *L *ii*t Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih @?_ tUi?|*) *@h}i _hiU|

Mi?i€|t uhL4 UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|tc Ai ?||L? uLh |t hit*| U@? Mi _ihi_

uhL4 hiUL}?3?} |@| _i |L uhiih_ih Mi@Lh UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t _iUhi@ti uLh

?Uhi@t?} @*it Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih( ic ^{Y %}_{Y q} f OLiihc i^*Mh4 4@tt ThL_U| ThL_U|L?c ^ ' ^nq% c ?Uhi@tit u |i uL**L?} UL?_|L? L*_tG

_ ^

_ q ' 

% n qY % Y q

: f , % : q

Y % Y q

E2f

,@U €h4<t ThL_U|L? ^@?||) L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i| ?Uhi@tit | }ih @*it Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ihc u |i UL?|h@U|L? ? UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t |4it |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih t @UULh_?} |L L?_|L? 2f ?L| |LL *@h}i At t |i 4Lhi *!i*)c |i *Lih

|i ?|@* @*i Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih @?_ |i }ih |i 4@h}?@* ThL€|t L? |i ?Ui 4@h!i|c ^. AihiuLhic u |i ^@?||) i T@?tL? igiU| ?_Ui_ M) }ih *ii*t Lu |i

6:Wkh odwwhu iroorzv iurp wkh idfw wkdw pdjqlwxgh ri wkh ghulydwlyh ^{C {}_C ^QQ ghfuhdvhv zlwk kljkhu ydoxhv ri y1

2f

tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih t *@h}i i?L}c €h4t< ThL€|t ** ?Uhi@ti ? |i Q Q hi}4i i?

€h4t @}hii |L hii@* hi*i@?| ?|ihu@Ui ?uLh4@|L?

Ai uL**L?} *i44@ t|@|it |i ULhhitTL?_?} i*u@hi hit*|t uLh i@U hi}4i

wi44@ 2 6Lh / 5 lc _gihi?|@|L? Lu |i hi_Ui_ i*u@hi u?U|L?c `^,c ?_ih |i _gihi?| hi}4it , ' IEc Q Q c FQ c FFc | hitTiU| |L q }it

Y `^&

Y q : fc | & ' IEc FQ c FF

N?_ih |i Q Q hi}4ic |ihi i t|t @ Uh|U@* @*i ' 4@ i^2I2_b c^qEeD32q_bEb3eq2²j tU

|@| Y `

Y q fc u @?_ L?*) u c

@?_ Y `

Y q fc u @?_ L?*) u hLLuG 5ii TTi?_ ",#

6hL4 wi44@  @?_ 2 i U@? _ihi hLTLt|L? D @?_ S U t44@h3i |i i*u@hi hit*|t Lu @? LTi? t|@?_@h_3@|L? TL*U) @t @ hit*| Lu @ Th@|i @}hii4i?| @?_ t|@|i

?|ihi?|L?

hLTLt|L? D 6Lh @** / 5 lc @?) Th@|i*) i?uLhUi_ ?Uhi@ti Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih q ?Uhi@tit tLU@* i*u@hi ?_ih @** hi}4it , ' Q Q c FQ c FF

hLLuG 6L**Lt _hiU|*) uhL4 wi44@  @?_ wi44@ 2c @?_ hiUL}?3?} |@| uLh f q t

2 ",#

hLTLt|L? D }it U*i@h U| UL?U*tL?t | hitTiU| |L Th@|i @}hii4i?|t U uLhUi

€h4t |L _tU*Lti hi*i@?| ?uLh4@|L?t UL?Uih??} |i ?|ihu@Ui |iU?L*L}) W? @** hi}4i

|Lti @}hii4i?|t *i@_ |L }ih i*u@hi *ii*t

Ai uL**L?} ThLTLt|L? t|@|it |i i*u@hi igiU|t Lu @? LTi? t|@?_@h_3@|L? TL*U) Thti_ M) |i }Lih?4i?| @ hi_U?} |i ThL|iU|L? Lu ?|i**iU|@* ThLTih|) h}|t hLTLt|L? S L?t_ih @** / 5 l ? ?Uhi@ti Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih q i?uLhUi_ M)

|i }Lih?4i?| ?Uhi@tit i*u@hi ?@4M}Lt*) ? |i FQ @?_ |i FF hi}4i N?_ih |i Q Q hi}4ic uLh hi*@|i*) *L *ii*t Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ihc tU |@| f q t

2 2

L*_tc @? ?Uhi@ti Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih }i?ih@|i_ M) t|@|i ?|ihi?|L? ?Uhi@tit i*u@hi u @?_ L?*) u : L*_t( L|ihtic }ih *ii*t Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih

?_Ui *Lih i*u@hi *ii*t

hLLuG 6L**Lt _hiU|*) uhL4 wi44@  @?_ wi44@ 2c @?_ hiUL}?3?} uLh |i Q Q U@ti

|@| L*_t uLh f q t

2 ",#

6hL4 hLTLt|L? S i U@? UL?U*_i |@| @? LTi? t|@?_@h_3@|L? TL*U) i?uLhUi_ M)

|i }Lih?4i?| _Lit @*@)t ?uL*_ tLU@**) Mi?i€U@* igiU|t i? €h4t @hi @**Li_ |L ULLTih@|i Ai t@4i UL?U*tL? 4@) L*_ uLh |i Q Q U@tic i?iih |i *ii* Lu tT**Liht t hi*@|i*) *L OLiihc @? LTi? t|@?_@h_3@|L? TL*U) 4}| hi_Ui i*u@hi i?

€h4t LTih@|i ? @ TihuiU|*) ?L?ULLTih@|i i?hL?4i?| @?_ |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih t hi*@|i*) *@h}i Lh 4@h}?@* ThL€|t L? |i ?Ui 4@h!i| @hi |LL *Lc i?iih |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih t hi*@|i*) *L N?_ih tU UL?_|L?t @? ?Uhi@ti Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih

*i@_ €h4t |L hi_Ui UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t @?_ 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U|L? ^@?||itc tL |@| i*u@hi _iUhi@tit AihiuLhic u ULLTih@|L? @4L?} €h4t t @**Li_ Lh @?@*)tt UL?€h4t |i tTTLt|L? |@| hi*@|i*) i@! ThL|iU|L? Lu ?|i**iU|@* ThLTih|) h}|t UL?Uih??} |i UL4T@|M*|) _it}? t tLU@**) Mi?i€U@* Etii 8Biij,, dbHboc dbbDo W| tL*_ Mi TL?|i_ L| |@| @? LTi? t|@?_@h_3@|L? TL*U) _Lit ?L| @*@)t *i@_ |L }ih _i}hiit Lu ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|)c @t 4i@thi_ M) |i t4 Lu €h4t< UL4T@|M

*|) ?it|4i?|t 6Lh |i Q Q hi}4i }ih @*it Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih |h@?tuLh4

?|L *Lih ?it|4i?| *ii*t At hit*| t|@?_t ? UL?|h@t| |L |i Thit4T|L? |@| i@

!ih ThL|iU|L? Lu ?|i**iU|@* ThLTih|) h}|t _hiU|*) |h@?tuLh4t ?|L }ih _i}hiit Lu UL4T@|M*|) Etii 8Biij,, < lB|5 dbbHc eeo `i?iih | t ULt|*) |L @ @Uii UL4 T@|M*|) i @?|ic @t i @tt4i ? Lh @?@*)ttc Thi*) ?L?ULLTih@|i Mi@Lh ?_Uit

€h4t |L hi_Ui |ih UL4T@|M*|) igLh|t uLh ?Uhi@t?} @*it Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih

8 Frqfoxvlrq

W? |t T@Tih i @i @?@*)3i_ €h4t< ?Ui?|it |L ?_ih|@!i ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|)

?it|4i?|t i TLt|( ic @u|ih 4@tt 4@h!i| t|@?_@h_ |iU?L*L}it @i Mii? it|@M*ti_

W| @t Mii? @h}i_ |@| @Ui?} ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|) i TLt| t ?L| @? i|ihLh _iUtL? ThLM*i4 @t ? |i U@ti Lu i @?|i ULLh_?@|L? L? @ T@h|U*@h ?_t|h) t|@?_@h_

6h4t @i |L ?_ih|@!i ?it|4i?|t ? Lh_ih |L @Uii ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|) `i 22

@i @?@*)3i_ |i 4T@U| Lu |hii Lh}@?3@|L?@* 4L_itc @h)?} uhL4 Thi 4@h!i| UL?|@U|

|L u** U@h|i*3@|L?c L? €h4t< ?Ui?|it |L ?it| ?|L ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|) U

?Uhi@tit |i ^@*|) Lu |i h@*<t 4@tt 4@h!i| ThL_U| @ _i4@?_ t_i tT**Liht

`i @i UL4T@hi_ Lh hit*|t | |i €ht|Mit| hi}4i @?_ @i tL? |@| |i )Mh_

hi}4i FQ c | €h4t ULLTih@|?} | hitTiU| |L UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t @?_ UL4Ti

|?} L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i|c }it tiUL?_Mit| i*u@hi uLh @** ui@tM*i @*it Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih AihiuLhic Lh 4L_i* }it t|hL?} iUi?U) hi@tL?t uLh Lh3L?|@* ULLTih@|L?

@4L?} €h4t @t i 4@) LMtihi | ? t|@?_@h_3@|L? UL44||iit Lh ?|ih?@|L?@* @**@?

Uit U ?ULhTLh@|i UL_it@h?} @hh@?}i4i?|t OLiihc @?||ht| @|Lh|it tL*_

@|U |Lti )Mh_ Lh}@?3@|L?tc t?Ui |i) 4}| Mi ti_ @t @ UL**ti _iUi `*i u** U@h|i*3@|L? *i@_t |L tiUL?_Mit| UL4T@|M*|) *ii*t | ?_Uit 4L?LTL*t|U ThU?}

L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i|c tL |@| i*u@hi t @*@)t *Lih ? |i FF U@ti UL4T@hi_ |L |i )Mh_

hi}4i FQ

`i @*tL uL?_ |@| _iTi?_?} L? |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih i|ih |i UL4T@|M*|) UL4 Ti||L? EQ Q Lh |i U@h|i*3@|L? EFF hi}4i t |i *i@t| _ith@M*i L?i 6Lh hi*@|i*)

*L tT**Lih igiU|t |i Q Q hi}4i }i?ih@|it }ih i*u@hi *ii*t |@? |i FF hi}4i OLiihc uLh hi*@|i*) } *ii*t Lu |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih U@h|i*3@|L? EFF ?Uhi@tit

?it|4i?| @U||) tL 4U |@| i*u@hi t }ih ?_ih FF UL4T@hi_ |L Q Q At hi t*| _i4L?t|h@|it |@| tLU@* T@)Lgt uhL4 ULLTih@|L? |L@h_t ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|)

@hi t}?€U@?|*) }ih |@? |Lti U @hi }i?ih@|i_ M) ULLTih@|L? ? |i Thiti?Ui Lu +:# tT**Liht Ai *|ih@|hi L? +:# ?it|4i?|t | tT**Liht @t tL? |@| u**

U@h|i*3@|L? EFF _Lit ?iih *i@_ |L }ih i*u@hi *ii*t UL4T@hi_ |L Thi UL4Ti||i Mi@Lh EQ Q

Ai TL*U) 4T*U@|L?t @hi |ihiuLhi t|h@}| uLh@h_ W? 4@h!i|t |@| 4ii| Lh tTTLt

|L?tc ULLTih@|L? Lu UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|t ? t|@?_@h_3@|L? UL44||iit tL*_ Mi i?ULh@}i_c *i UL4Ti||L? L? |i 4@tt 4@h!i| @t |L Mi Thitihi_ W? 4@h!i|t | hi*@|i*) *@h}i tT**Lih igiU|t |i Lht| |?} |i }Lih?4i?| UL*_ _L t |L Thii?|

@?) !?_ Lu ULLTih@|L? @4L?} €h4t W? |t U@ti @ u**) ULLTih@|i L|UL4i L*_ Mi Thiuih@M*i |L @ u**) ?L?ULLTih@|i L|UL4i uhL4 @ tLU@* T*@?ih TL?| Lu i

LhiLihc i @i @?@*)3i_ |i igiU|t Lu @? LTi? t|@?_@h_3@|L? TL*U)c i|ih i?uLh Ui_ M) |i t|@|i Lh M) Th@|i @}hii4i?| @4L?} €h4t ? LTi? t|@?_@h_3@|L? TL*U)

@t Mii? ?|ihThi|i_ @t @ *i}@* Lh Th@|i ThLtL? UL4Ti**?} €h4t |L hii@* hi*i@?|

?|i**iU|@* ThLTih|) |L €h4t ThL_U?} UL4T*i4i?|@h) ThL_U|t 5U @ TL*U)c U 2

?Uhi@tit |i tT**Lih igiU|t uhL4 ?|ihMh@?_ UL4T@|M*|) ?it|4i?|tc @t Mii? ThLi_

|L Mi tLU@**) Mi?i€U@*c i?iih €h4t @hi @**Li_ |L ULLTih@|i +it*|t UL?Uih??} |i Q Q c Liihc hi4@? @4M}Lt W? T@h|U*@hc uLh *@h}i *ii*t Lu tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih

@?) uh|ih ?Uhi@ti Lu | *i@_t ML| |L *Lih ?it|4i?| @?_ ThL_U|L? *ii*t W? |t U@tic ?Uhi@t?} |i tT**Lih T@h@4i|ih ?_Uit *Lih i*u@hi *ii*t

`*i 4@?) TiLT*i @TTi@h |L Mi*ii ?||i*) |@| UL4T@|M*|) t 4Lhi UL?_Ui |L UL4Ti||L? @?_ |t TM*U TL*U) tL*_ ThL4L|i Lh 4@?_@|i UL4T@|M*|) |hL}

@? LTi? t|@?_@h_3@|L? TL*U)c Lh 4L_i* t}}it|t @ tL4i@| _gihi?| iG ? LTi?

t|@?_@h_3@|L? TL*U) i?uLhUi_ |hL} hi*@|i*) i@! ThL|iU|L? Lu ?|i**iU|@* ThLTih|) h}|t t ?@4M}Lt*) Mi?i€U@* uLh tLUi|) u €h4t @hi @**Li_ |L ULLh_?@|i |ih

?it|4i?| _iUtL?t ? ULLTih@|i t|@?_@h_3@|L? }hLTt OLiihc i? €h4t @hi LTih@|?} ? @ Thi*) UL4Ti||i i?hL?4i?|c i@! ThL|iU|L? Lu ?|i**iU|@* ThLTih|) h}|t 4}| t|hi?}|i? |i @_ihti igiU|t Lu uhiih_ih Mi@Lhc *i@_?} |L ii? *Lih UL4T@|M*|) igLh|t

t |i 4@? hit*| Lu Lh T@Tihc |ihiuLhic i U@? UL?U*_i |@| |i LT|4@* TL*U) 4 ?

|i hi@*4 Lu Lh 4L_i* t |L @**L ?|ih€h4 ULLTih@|L? ? t|@?_@h_3@|L? UL44||iitc

*i Thitih?} ThL_U| 4@h!i| UL4Ti||L?c @?_ |L @M@?_L? ThL|iU|L? Lu ?|i**iU|@*

ThLTih|) h}|t UL?Uih??} |i hi*i@?| ui@|hit Lu |i ?|ihu@Ui |iU?L*L})

Dsshqgl{

Olqhdu grzqzdug vorslqj qlfkh pdunhw ghpdqg

Zh vkrz wkdw wkh olqhdu vshflfdwlrq ri wkh uhgxfhg qlfkh pdunhw surwv/ y{/ grhv dovr dsso|

wr dq ruglqdu| prqrsrolvwlf pdunhw vwuxfwxuh zlwk d olqhdu grzqzdug vorslqj ghpdqg ixqfwlrq1 Dvvxph up l*v lqyhuvh qlfkh pdunhw ghpdqg lv jlyhq e| s @ P . { k|/ zkhuh s ghqrwhv up l*v qlfkh surgxfw sulfh/ dqg | vwdqgv iru txdqwlw|1 Qrupdol}lqj pdujlqdo frvwv wr }hur/ up l*v qlfkh pdunhw surwv duh jlyhq e| @ +P . { k|,|1 E| vxevwlwxwlqj wkh prqrsro|

vroxwlrq edfn lqwr wkh surw ixqfwlrq zh ghulyh wkh uhgxfhg qlfkh pdunhw surwv a @ _e^ +P . {,²1 Wkhuhiruh/ up l*v wrwdo surwv duh

@ +D . { t t,t.P² 7k .P

5k{5k 4 7k {²=

Zh jhw wkh vdph sd|r vwuxfwxuh dv lq wkh sdshu li y ^₂ dqg ²₂^3/ zlwk A +4@5k,/

krogv1 Frqvlghulqj wkh frqvwdqw whup ^₂² grhv qrw dhfw wkh uhvxowv ghulyhg lq wkh sdshu 2e

txdolwdwlyho|1

Surri ri Sursrvlwlrq 5

Fdvhv Q Q dqg FQ = Iurp +<, dqg +45, zh jhw t @ ^Enq_bn2q2 ^Enq_b32q2 @ t/ ru ^{2 2}/ zlwk htxdolw| kroglqj li @ 31

Fdvhv Q Q dqg FF= Iurp +<, dqg +47, zh rewdlq t @ ^Enq_bn2q2 A ^nq_e3q2 @ t/ zkdw uhgxfhv wr ?t

D1 Wklv jlyhv/ iru doo $ 5 / wkh rughulqj vwdwhg lq wkh sursrvlwlrq1

Fdvhv FQ dqg FF= Frpsdulqj +45, zlwk +47, zh jhw t @ ^Enq_b32q2 A ^nq_e3q2 @ t/ iru doo

$ 5 1

Ri frxuvh/ uvw0ehvw surgxfwlrq txdqwlw|/ t⁵/ lv wkh odujhvw ehfdxvh ri pdujlqdo frvw sulflqj/

zlwk s⁵@ 3/ dqg ehfdxvh ri uvw0ehvw frpsdwlelolw| lqyhvwphqwv/ {⁵/ ehlqj kljkhu frpsduhg wr doo rwkhu uhjlphv1 Wklv suryhv Sursrvlwlrq 51

Surri ri Sursrvlwlrq 6

Fdvhv FQ dqg Q Q = Vxevwlwxwlqj t dqg {/ dqg t dqg { uhvshfwlyho|/ lqwr wkh zhoiduh irupxod +48, dqg frpsdulqj Z dqg Z zh jhw

5;;²+< ²,+D . y,² +< . 5²,²+< . 5²,² 3=

Doo wkuhh whupv lq eudfnhwv duh vwulfwo| srvlwlyh/ vr wkdw Z Z krogv iru doo $ 5 dqg htxdolw| kroglqj iru @ 31

Fdvhv FF dqg Q Q = Vxevwlwxwlqj t dqg {/ dqg t dqg { uhvshfwlyho|/ lqwr wkh zhoiduh irupxod +48, dqg frpsdulqj Z dqg Z zh jhw

+666². 6:<² <5^e,+D . y,² +7 . ²,²+< . 5²,^{2 A@?} 3=

Erwk whupv lq wkh ghqrplqdwru dqg wkh vhfrqg whup lq wkh qxphudwru duh vwulfwo| srvlwlyh iru doo $ 5 1 Fdofxodwlqj wkh urrwv ri wkh uvw whup lq wkh qxphudwru jlyhv irxu uhdo vroxwlrqv/ zlwk rqh ihdvleoh vroxwlrq/ qdpho|/

^W@ 4

<5 t

4:767 :;5s :6s

4=46s

=

Lw lv qrz vwudljkw iruzdug wr fkhfn wkdw Z dqg Z kdyh wr eh rughuhg dv vwdwhg lq wkh sursrvlwlrq1

Fdvhv FQ dqg FF= Djdlq/ zh fdofxodwh Z @ Z dqg rewdlq +666² 496² . 53^e,+D . y,²

+< . 5²,²+7 . ²,² A 3=

2D

Erwk whupv lq wkh ghqrplqdwru dqg wkh vhfrqg whup lq wkh qxphudwru duh vwulfwo| srvlwlyh iru doo $ 5 1 Fdofxodwlqj wkh urrwv ri wkh uvw whup lq wkh qxphudwru jlyhv wzr sdluv ri frqmxjdwh frpsoh{ urrwv/ zlwk qr vroxwlrq dorqj wkh uhdo d{lv1 Lw lv qrz hdvlo| fkhfnhg wkdw Z A Z krogv iru doo $ 5 1 Wklv hvwdeolvkhv Sursrvlwlrq 61

Surri ri Ohppd 4

Wkh uvw sduw ri wkh ohppd iroorzv gluhfwo| iurp glhuhqwldwlrq ri wkh uhgxfhg surw ixqfwlrqv dqg zlwk uhvshfw wr 1 Wkh vhfrqg sduw ri wkh ohppd/ zklfk uhihuv wr wkh Q Q uhjlph/

iroorzv iurp vxevwlwxwlqj +<, dqg +;, lqwr +5, dqg glhuhqwldwlqj zlwk uhvshfw wr 1 Wklv jlyhv

C

C @ 5^5:y+6 5², . 5D+5² 5:,`+D . y, +< . 5², >

vr wkdw wkh vljq ri wkh ghulydwlyh ghshqgv rq wkh vljq ri wkh whup 5:y+6 5², . 5D+5² 5:,=

Wkh vhfrqg whup lq eudfnhwv lv vwulfwo| qhjdwlyh iru doo $ 5 / dqg wkh uvw whup lq eudfnhwv lv qrq0srvlwlyh iru t

21 Khqfh/ wkh ghulydwlyh lv vwulfwo| qhjdwlyh iru t

2 ? s

51 Iru 3 ?t

2 zh jhw wkh iroorzlqj frqglwlrq/ vr wkdw wkh ghulydwlyh lv srvlwlyh=

y A 5D+5: 5², 5:+6 5², y=

Li y y wkh ghulydwlyh lv qrq0srvlwlyh1 Wklv hvwdeolvkhv Ohppd 41 Qrwh/ wkdw y phhwv Dvvxps0 wlrq 4/ zkdw iroorzv iurp y @_2q

b 2.32q² b3Sq²

/ zkhuh wkh vhfrqg iudfwlrq lq eudfnhwv lv vwulfwo|

juhdwhu wkdq rqh1 Krzhyhu/ y pd| qrw frpso| zlwk Dvvxpswlrq 5/ lq zklfk fdvh wkh ghulydwh zrxog dozd|v eh srvlwlyh1

Surri ri Ohppd 5

Wkh uvw sduw ri wkh sursrvlwlrq iroorzv gluhfwo| iurp lqvhuwlqj wkh htxloleulxp ydoxhv ri upv*

lqyhvwphqw dqg surgxfwlrq ohyhov lqwr wkh zhoiduh irupxod +48, dqg glhuhqwldwlqj zlwk uhvshfw wr 1 Vlploduo|/ zh rewdlq iru wkh Q Q fdvh

C Z

C @ ;^<y+< 7², . D+5² 78,`+D . y, +< . 5², >

vr wkdw wkh vljq ri wkh ghulydwlyh lv ghwhuplqhg e| wkh vljq ri wkh whup

<y+< 7², . D+5² 78,=

Iru doo $ 5 / erwk whupv lq eudfnhwv kdyh vwulfwo| rssrvlwh vljqv/ dqg zh jhw wkh iroorzlqj frqglwlrq iru wkh ghulydwlyh ehlqj srvlwlyh=

y A D+78 5²,

<+< 7², y=

2S