Munich Personal RePEc Archive
Bolívar and the Millennium Development Goals
Espinosa Espinosa, Aarón and Alvis Arrieta, Jorge and Toro González, Daniel
Universidad Tecnológica de Bolívar
27 November 2007
Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/5986/
MPRA Paper No. 5986, posted 28 Nov 2007 14:29 UTC
♠
∗
! " # $
% &'''(
$
) # ( * * * (
+ , *#
* # -
# ( # %
* # $ *
# * &'./,
-*# ( ( ( ( 01 2,
34.( 5.'( 6&7
3, 3 *
% &''' .78 # # 1 0 # ( $
* * * - * * -
( ( 9* : ( # $ #
# , ) # ( 9* - # * 4&
# ( - # # * # - % &'./ 9* #
-*# ,
* 3 2 ( 9* $ ) ! "(
; * ) # $ # 0 (
210 ( - * $ <) *
# =,
♠2 $ 2 # 1 0 !210 ", ; #
&''>,
∗ ? * # # 0
!0 ", $ @ ( ; * ) # $
# 0 $ ( # # $
* 9* # # * ): ) $ ) !210 (
) # "( : * !21 AB 12"( A: ! " $ #
# * ( 4' $ 4. * &''>,
( $ # #
* * * # ( # 9*
* ( * * #* $ ,
2 ( 9* *$ * * # ( $
# # $ #* 9* #
* ( * # -*# *
* C
o ? * # $ # # D # $ - # (
# 1 3 - ,
o * * ( * #* $ % #
* ( # # ( # $
- #* - : # * ,
o ? # * # #*
# * : $ * # #* ,
o * # # #
# * $ 2 # ,
o * # * # # $
# $ # ,
o % # # 9* # # # ,
- * # # # $ *
# $ * ,
o ; # ( # # % 9* + * # +#
#* ,
*# * * * # C * ! * "
D # # ( # # ( (
# $ * ,
* # ( $ #*
$ # * % &'./,
: # $ # 9* #
D # -*# E/ #* # ,
* D # >(
# ( # # # ( $ #
* $ # ,
2 + # ( * $ # # ,
33, ) D # #
# * # 9* # ) )
$ # * # D * * ,
) * &/,8>/ F#&( &'G ) ) $ &,4G H
# # # $ # % $ : # , ? # E/
#* ! * ."( $ # ) $ # H
I* ( ) $ 9* H * 9* H $ I (
) $ , # ) * * #
# ( +( 3 5 ( 3 ;* 3 I ,
#
;* C ,
* * $ (
$ # : * * $ # ( 9* #
, ( - * @
( # ( $ 2 ) ,
* # ( * # - $ # ( $ $ * * (
- J # $ I !J ", ? . *#
# #* ,
* #* J #
! " # $ # % ! " !
) ( I 2 ( I # ( I 5 I* ( $ ,
? 5 @ ( 5 ( 2 % ( ? ( I ? $ 5 ,
# A ? ( ( I ; ( # D( K 1* $ ) * ,
I ) * ( ( - ( 9* ( 2 $ *:,
) ( J # ( ) # ( I ( I * 1 #* ( * # $
,
9* ) # ( $ A ( I ) ( I ( - ( ( I L F (
* ( * ( I 5 ? # ( @ * ( ) # ( I ) $ ) ,
;* C ,
( + ) 2 &''/( .,7>7,884 - ( * /'G
* * # ( ) , D # :
#* ( 9* - *
# , - - ( - .884 M/G
* ( # 9* 4/G * , I # (
&''/ * * #* - # 9* C >EG
- # #* , # #
* ) ) # *: ,
# # #
# # $ # 9* - D # * *
, + # - # # 9* - #
* * # # C # # *
# , I + 2 $ ) 3 (
.88/ $ - &''M +# !9* - $ "
# * 4'' # ( # #* ) ( ) # $
*:,
? # # * $ *
$ # * # # * *
$ # , ( + # &' % * *
* 4,'8 # &,/ # - ( * 9*
# C /,48 #* # - .87/B.88'(
/,&8 .88/B&''',
* ( # * * ( #
./ % ( 9* .87/ E'G ( * &''/ 44G +
+ # , ( !./BME % " # * #
C # .87/B&''/( /M,&G M.G( * 9* *
!# $ M/ % "( *$ 4,8G /,7G
# # ! .", + # # # *
# ! &",
&
' () " 2 # !.87/B.884B&''/"
.884
7G MG EG &G 'G &G EG MG 7G
'E % .' .E %
&' &E % 4' 4E % E' EE % /' /E % M' ME %
>' >E %
7' % #
;* C 1 ( ) .884
A #
*
&''/
7G MG EG &G 'G &G EG MG 7G
'E % .' .E %
&' &E % 4' 4E % E' EE % /' /E % M' ME %
>' >E %
7' % #
;* C 1 ( ) &''/
A #
*
*+&
7G MG EG &G 'G &G EG MG 7G
' E %
.' .E %
&' &E %
4' 4E %
E' EE %
/' /E %
M' ME %
>' >E %
7' % #
;* C 1 ( ) .87/
A #
*
1 C # # ! 9* - " % # ,
' () " 2 # + ( &''/
7G MG EG &G 'G &G EG MG 7G
'E % .' .E %
&' &E % 4' 4E % E' EE % /' /E % M' ME %
>' >E %
7' % #
;* C 1 ( ) &''/
A #
*
0
7G MG EG &G 'G &G EG MG
'E % .' .E %
&' &E % 4' 4E % E' EE % /' /E % M' ME %
>' >E %
;* C 1 ( ) &''/
A #
*
5*
7G MG EG &G 'G &G EG MG 7G
'E % .' .E %
&' &E % 4' 4E % E' EE % /' /E % M' ME %
>' >E %
7' % #
;* C 1 ( ) &''/
A #
*
# * # # ( 9* #
# * $ # # $ , 2 # ( #
* ( * ( * ( $ # ./ % - , I
# ( # : 9* *# * #
* ,
- - ( 23 4,7G .88' $ &''/( # #
4G( # # # + # * , #
# - * * * C &'''B
&''/ # * % &,>G( +# * -
&,/G,
* ( # ( * ( * B
# ! * " # 9* - # *
# ! * # # ", (
# NN( +# * # ) #*
&''' $ &''M ! &' # .'' # ",
0 - - # * # # *$
23 - #* , ( -
#* $ - # # ( + #
# 9* # # * - (
* # $ ( $ # ,
,
# ( 9* ! * $ "
- #* ( * # * #* #*
J # .87>B&''4, ( D
* * ( ( #* #
23 - .87> .> % # 9* 9*: 9*
# 23 - , 2 ( !
" # O B #* *
: # ,
) # 4 ! 9* "( #* $ *#
% ( * ( # 23
- ( *$ *# , # ( # #* - (
# - #* ! " #*
) $ * ! * "C # .87>( 9*
# 9* # ,
&, ) #* ( .87>B&''4
I # !5 " ! * "
-. - -. - -.&- -.,- -./-
+/ ++ +* *- * * * * *& *, */ *+ ** - - - - -
0"1!234#"5!"#6
7&8 -8
&8 -8
&8 -8
.& .- .& .- .&
%5 34 #" 2 *+/6
""34#"2*+/7--6
;* C ) * * 5 + ,
1 C D # 23 - * #* ,
/
! "
90 D # $
- #
90 ? * *
90 2 # * : $
* # #*
90 5 * #
90 & * D* $ *
90 , ) # @3AB ( # $
*
90 / #
90 + ; # * #*
333, #
, ? - &'./
# #
- -*# , A % &'./( *
#
! "( 9* -
* E/ #* # $ *
* # # ! &",
* * (
* ,
I * ( *# 9* *
* # # % # C
# * ( ( 9*
-*# 9* #* !$ *
# " # $
# * &'./H #
# -*# 9* (
# ( H $ 9*
- # ) # ,
! .C 1 * ,
&C * * $ * #* ,
4C 1 * ,
EC C # # # # . $ / % ,
/C C ,
MC # C 3 # $ * ,
>C 1 * ,
7C # # % ,
! 5 .C 1 * ,
&C % # * ,
4C @ # ,
EC 44 E/ #* *# # # # . $ / % , @ *
$ 2, /C 1 * ,
MC 3 # $ * ,
>C 1 * ,
7C # % ,
+
! :
.C 2 ( $ * , C 1 3,
&C # ! ", C * ,
4C * #* ,
EC 1 * ,
/C C # # $ # $ # ,
MC 2 @3A I ,
>C ) * * * $ ,
7C * # % ,
, ?
9 : % ;03 ; ; 94 ; < ; = >; 4
? * # #* # ( * #
9* 9* - !# 1 3"( 9* !# ?
2 $ ? 3 "( !9* - 9* * $ *
* * * ( $ * * #* # $ 9*
$ - !# # * # 3 A 3)@", ( *
* * *$ # *
,
? # 5 5 % ! . * # ( .88'B&'./(
* ,
? ! 5 % # # # 9* *
- # ,
5 * # # C
% &/,4 * * O /4,7G &7,/G( ( # B
* , # : # ? 2 !?2",
% 5 * # # O &',EG 7,7G( ( ..,M * * B
9* D # , *# # #
* * ? 3 !?3",
% &,7G .,/G 9* # # * ,
% # * # O .'G 4GB % # / %
# ,
% & 5 8,/ * * O .> >,/GB 9* *# #
# # # ,
# ( 9* #
*# # # &'./ C
*
., ? # !# : ?2 $ ?3"C I - # *
# &''&( # # #
# , &''/ /&,8G
?2( $ .4,4G # # # * ! (
", ) # * &''/ E8,>G $ ./,>G( #
! .",
&, ? # ( * * 9*
, 9* # # P 1
3 - !1 3", &''/( # MM,7G -
* * - C " @ * H "
A # H " * + ( * * $ #
H " # H $ " 3 % # .. % ,
# * # # % &>,MG, * #* !) ( 1 3
&M,.G" * # ( 9* &. E/ #*
# 1 3 * # # , ? #* I $ ) #
! 8E,4G $ 84,EG"( !J " ( #
- ,
.,., ? $ ) # &''&B&''/
67,8
53,1 55,8 52,9
30,4
13,8 18,0
13,3
56,1 52,7 52,5 49,7
21,5 18,0 17,4 15,7
0 20 40 60 80
2002 2003 2004 2005
Bolívar Línea de Pobreza Bolívar Línea de Indigencia Colombia Línea de Pobreza Colombia Línea de Indigencia
;* C 52 ,
4, ? # * * #* # $ 9*
$ - , P ) @ !3)@"( # 9* D # (
( -*# $ # - #
* # * , 3)@ # O
9* ( ( #* 9*: B * >4,8
% &''E( # >7,7,
I * - *$ 3)@ : M>, * # # (
9* #* !) ( 3)@ 7',>( $ * M7,E &''4"
# ( 9* E4 #*
# # ! .,&",
) ( # % $ * ( 3)@
# /',&, 0 9* #* #
#* * !# 9* (
* * "C >4G #* *
&'./C
? 2 C &7,/G
? 3 C 7,7G
-
# # , #* 3)@ #*
4. .,
( P A*# !3 A"( * # #* #
9* # # * * ( * $ * ( $
* ( #* # # - #
# ! .,4", &''E 3 A # * ',>7,
E, 0 * # . 9* - # ( * #
* # / % $ % / $ 8 % , #
( * # / % ( #* #
! 8,8G" - # * # ! >G", 9* 9*
.' .'' % # $ # * , I
* # .888 ! .& % .''"( #
( I* ( ) $ * ) ) ( $ $ $ @ * :
( * D ,
.,&, P ) @ !3)@"
#* ( &''4
' /' .''
) 5 )A31
? I55 1)55 Q A 1) 1)?? 5 I 53) 5) ?)3)0)5 15 1 ??1)3??5
? ) 5 1A 3??I 1 I 13I?I 1 )53II 1 ; 51 1I 153 ?1 )53I53 @3? 0? 2 R 12313?? I5 35 53A5 ? I)31?3@ 51 0?2 II5? I 1I 1 0 1 1 2I 1I 1)31I 1? 3 0 10 @5 I5 31I 2? @3 1I 1@3?? 10 @JI 1 2 ?)? ) 0)05 )05 13603I30) 1I3 3 3? I055 1?5 I?31
Promedio Bolívar 70.7
;* C 210 B 12( I : ,
.,4, P A*#
$ ) # ( .88'B&''E ! % "
'(>
'(>>
'(>/
'(>7
'(>.
'(>7
'(>M
'(>8
'(M7 '(>
'(>&
'(>E '(>M '(>7 '(7
.88' .88M &''' &''E
) #
;* C 21 AB 3 # A*# ,
.,E, * $ *
S .' % $ ) # ( &''/
9,9
1,1
9,1
3,2 7
1,3
5,4
1,1 0
2 4 6 8 10 12
Desnutrición global (< 5 años)
Desnutrición aguda (< 5 años)
Desnutrición global (5-9 años)
Desnutrición aguda (5-9 años) Bolívar Colombia
;* C 1 B @ ,
&'./C 4G
9 : % 9' ; ; 0 ; 3? 4@ 3 ; 3A ;
I + * ( 9* # # , ?
* * 9* * # ) ) #
, T + # .(E # $ * 9* * -
*$ .9* # * 9* * ,
D # : + * - *
- ( 9* #* # # -*# , - - (
* - - * * E4G(
* - # * : &, # (
# ( ) ( * % * - * 4G $ MG
4( 9* #* # # *
,
D 9* * ! "
# ,
? % " 5 % ! * # *
% $ % #* % &'./,
? 5 % $ 5 - * - % C
% # .G . $ &E % , 3 * # (
* * .''G * ! ( # $ * "( $
84G * * # ,
% .',M % * # ./ $ &E % ,
% &,4G * $ # ,
;! ) % 5 &''/( # * # .4,7G
./ % $ # ( * # 9* * 8,MG # # % , 1
( * #* ( * ( )
# !>,.G"( $ ( #* # I ; ( ( ) ( (
5 ( @ * $ 9* # * 4'G ! &,.", : # (
# # ! &,&",
. ( H 1 !&''E", <2 ( $ * ) #
# NN3=, 1U..( , 44BM., ) ) # , # &''E,
& ( !&''>", < ) ) C V6*: - # W=, 2
I # * 5 ( ) , ) 3 ( &> &''>,
4 ( H ; 5* !&''>", 2 $ * ) ( &''&B&''/, 2
I # * 5 ( ) , ) 3 ( &> &''>,
&,., # # $
./ % ( # ( &''/
Analfabetismo (pob.> 15 años)
0% 10% 20% 30% 40%
CARTAGENAACHI ALTOS DEL ROSARIOARROYOHONDOARJONAARENAL BARRANCO DE LOBACANTAGALLOCLEMENCIACALAMARCORDOBACICUCO EL CARMEN DE BOLIVARHATILLO DE LOBASAN ESTANISLAOSAN CRISTOBALMARIA LA BAJASAN FERNANDOMONTECRISTOSAN JACINTOMARGARITAMAGANGUEEL GUAMOMAHATESMORALESEL PEÑONRIO VIEJOMOMPOSREGIDORPINILLOS SAN JACINTO DEL CAUCASAN JUAN NEPOMUCENOSANTA ROSA DEL SURSAN MARTIN DE LOBATALAIGUA NUEVOSANTA CATALINASOPLAVIENTOSANTA ROSAVILLANUEVASAN PABLOZAMBRANOTURBACOTURBANATIQUISIOSIMITI
Promedio Bolívar 13.8%
;* C ? * ) &''/
&,&, # # $
./ % ( $ ) # &''' B &''/
Analfabetismo (pob.> de 15 años) 2000 - 2005
12,2%
13,9%
9,6%
9,6%
12,2%
12,0%
10,6%
8,0% 7,5% 7,8% 7,6% 7,2%
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
10%
12%
14%
16%
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Bolívar Colombia
Fuente: ENH, cálculos PNHD
;* C ? * ) &''/
&,4, ) * * * +
( &''4 O &''M
4 B " 1! " % % ! " " 1! #
! -- 7 --,
95,27
38,5 53,11
67,79
58,8 83,18
91,37
105,91
62,98 63,37
57,96 57,58
40,31 40,28
33,74 35,11
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
2003 2004 2005 2006
%286
Tasa Bruta de Cobertura Preescolar Tasa Bruta de Cobertura Primaria Tasa Bruta de Cobertura Secundaria Tasa Bruta de Cobertura Media
;* C ? * ( I *
# ,
./ &E % ( # &''/
/,/G( * # !E,&G", I + : ( * # - # !M,7G"(
* # #* !E,.G"H $ ( * !.',MG" *
!4,8/G",E
;C # 5 " " 1! ( # ./ $
&E % &''/ 7,M( # !7,8 % ", I # (
* : ( #* !8 % * " 9* # $
! - # + 7,. % ( # "/,
" % ! " " 1! &''M * * * *
7E,MG( * * # # 7/G,
( * * /7,7G( 9* #* * # # &''4(
E * 1A 21 A,
/ * 21 A 1A O 1 ) &''/,
* 47,/G, 2 # * * 8/,&G( 9* *$ *
&''/ ! .'/,8G"H * ( * * * M&,8G( # : #
% &''/( $ * # E',4G( * # &''/,
&,4 * * ,
* &''M( * * * #
* ( # &,4, 1 (
* # + * * ( 9*
* # 9* ( 9* 9* # $ *
# * * - &'./,
* ) $ *:( #* ( * #*
* C ) ( * * * # % &''' $
&''M( 77G 8>GMH * ( *: * ( $ 9*
&''& $ &''/ * # * # MMG>, #
# ( * #* $ ) # % &''/ &,E,
&,E, ) * * * + #* ( &''/
'('' .'(''
&'('' 4'('' E'('' /'('' M'(''
>'('' 7'('' 8'('' .''(''
)?5 )?1)3 )3)0) )51 I15I?3 I1)53I? 1)53I )1?? I2?@31 I1)31?)0) @3??10@ 51 I15I?I05 051 553 AI 55QA1 2I 05) I1;511 A3??? I101120)1 )A3 J51 I1)31 51? 10T ?I?5I53 I12? I1I13I? I333 53? I1531? 5?I 3603I3 ?)51?3@5 2313??I ?0 ?2R1 ?3010@ I1)?31 535 )5 53@3 551)?
)*!G" Bolívar : 86%
5 ++8
;* C * ( I * # H ) $ *:( 1
" " 1! ? * 2 * I # # % &''/
#* ( /X $ 8X( # *
$ , # ( /X * * * # /E,M(
# ( 9* * /M,&, 1 ( .' 4/ #* #
* # ! &,/",
* # ( 8X * * #
# : , ? * * # /M,&( /8,7
# ( $ * #* # * # ! &,M",
M I * )
> 1, ) ( * &''& $ &''/( * C !/
$ M % " 7.G .'>GH # !> .. % " .'/G .'7GH * !.& ./ % " 8'G .'.GH $
# !.M .> % " MMG >/G, *: * * C M&G 7&GH # 8/G
7MGH * /7G MEH $ # E'G E/G,
&,/ $ &,M, 5 * # # 2 * I 5 /X $ 8X ( * $ ( &''/
Pruebas SABER 2005 Matemáticas Grado 5º ODM2
48 50 52 54 56 58 60 62
ALTOS DEL ROSARIOARROYOHONDOARJONAARENALACHI BARRANCO DE LOBACANTAGALLOCARTAGENACLEMENCIACALAMARCORDOBACICUCO EL CARMEN DE BOLIVARHATILLO DE LOBASAN ESTANISLAOSAN CRISTOBALMARIA LA BAJASAN FERNANDOMONTECRISTOSAN JACINTOMARGARITAMAGANGUEEL GUAMOMAHATESMORALESEL PEÑONRIO VIEJOMOMPOSPINILLOSREGIDOR SAN JACINTO DEL CAUCASAN JUAN NEPOMUCENOTIQUISIO (PUERTO RICO)SANTA ROSA DEL SURSAN MARTIN DE LOBATALAIGUA NUEVOSANTA CATALINASOPLAVIENTOSANTA ROSAVILLANUEVASAN PABLOZAMBRANOTURBACOTURBANASIMITI
Promedio Bolívar 54,6
Promedio Nacional 56.2
Pruebas SABER 2005 Matemáticas Grado 9º ODM2
20 30 40 50 60 70
ALTOS DEL ROSARIOARROYOHONDOARJONAARENALACHI BARRANCO DE LOBACANTAGALLOCARTAGENACLEMENCIACALAMARCORDOBACICUCO EL CARMEN DE BOLIVARHATILLO DE LOBASAN ESTANISLAOSAN CRISTOBALMARIA LA BAJASAN FERNANDOMONTECRISTOSAN JACINTOMARGARITAMAGANGUEEL GUAMOMAHATESMORALESEL PEÑONRIO VIEJOMOMPOSPINILLOSREGIDOR SAN JACINTO DEL CAUCASAN JUAN NEPOMUCENOTIQUISIO (PUERTO RICO)SANTA ROSA DEL SURSAN MARTIN DE LOBATALAIGUA NUEVOSANTA CATALINASOPLAVIENTOSANTA ROSAVILLANUEVASAN PABLOZAMBRANOTURBACOTURBANASIMITI
Promedio Bolívar
56,2
Promedio Nacional
59,8
;* C ? * ( 1
) " !" ? * # # # &''M(
# &''E ! &,>", ( &''M #
, I # $ $ # (
* * # # $ * ,
) ( &''E $ &''/ * E,.G $ 4,>G( # , I
9* < * 9* - *
# ( 9* * ( * $ *#
# * , 1 * * * ( *#
*# * ( * # *
#* - # =7,
? # &''4 O &''M
* ( # &,7, # #
* # ( # 'G &''E( $
&''M 4,7G, 2 ) ( * ( 4,.G EG # # ( #
* # # # # ,
7I * ( 2 * ( ) * &''M,
&
&,>, ( &''4B&''M
Eficiencia del sistema educativo de Bolívar: Tasa de deserción según niveles 2003 - 2006
8,26
6,4
8,7
6,9
3,4 4,6 3,2
5,0 9,27
1,2 0,5 3,9
8,04
0,1 4,34 2,8
0,0 1,0 2,0 3,0 4,0 5,0 6,0 7,0 8,0 9,0 10,0
2003 2004 2005 2006
(%)
I I 5)3 1 25 I) ? 5 I I 5)3 1 253 53
I I 5)3 1 I )01 53 I I 5)3 1 3
;* C ? * I * # ,
&,> &C (
) " !" % 5 " % 4 B
# % !" D! ! -- 7 --,
1,8 4,9
3,4
1,9
0,18 0,2
5,5 4,6 4,57
4,0
2,7 2,61
3,8
1,8 1,5 1,5
0,0 1,0 2,0 3,0 4,0 5,0 6,0
2003 2004 2005 2006
(%)
I 5 23 1)3 25 I) ? 5 I 5 23 1)3 253 53
I 5 23 1)3 I )01 53 I 5 23 1)3 3
;* C ? * I * # ,
9 : % 9 9A ; 3' ; 0;0 0 9 'E 9 = ; ; 9 9 F; 0 ;
# * : $ #* - * # # $
* -*# + # % , # (
# #* # ( ( $ - #
* * * , * * D #
( % # # * # $ 9* : (
) # * ,
! " # *
,
? % ! # * : % # $ * (
# &''/( $ % &'./,
? 5 % $ 5 - * C
,
% * # % ( # # * $
$ # * * ,
% 3# # $ # * * +
# ( # #* ( ( (
) ( 9* $ * # &''7 $ # # &'./,
% 3 $ # * # 9* : # $
# ( # I # 3 # $ I #
# ,
3 # # 4'G #*
# $ + ,
A !" !% # : ? 3 * 1 ? ( % * 9*
# .'' # - ) # .// &''/( # 9*
* >M, * ! .'' # - "C
* .E/,M( # 9* * 7/, ( #
# $ # # * *
-*# ,
5# 5 : ? * #*
9* # : , # ( #
# ;* 2+ ( % &''/( #* 9* #* * 44,4G
( E.,4G ( 'G * ( E4,MG ( /7,/G
: ( MEG $ 4',/G ,
9 : % 0 3 ; 9 ; 30;0 3 ; 3
? 5 % ! * # %
# / % ,
5 . # C
% 5 * .> #* # # # / % ,
% 5 * .E #* # # # . % ,
% $ # * * 8/G( 2 # 3 #*
!2 3" # / % #* $ ,
# ( 9* # *# #
&'./ C
., % 5 % ! 5 ! ! C ( 9* &''/ * 8,8 #* #
# ! E,.", - # * *
9*: ( ./ * * O * B * # &''& $
&''/( 9* - # *# - # &'./( # 9*
+ # * # # ,
/
E,., 5 # # . % ! .,''' "
.>(&
./(8 .M(4 .M(.
&E(/
&4(/
..(7 8(8
' .'
&' 4'
&''& &''4 &''E &''/
) #
;* C 1 B @ ,
.& E/ #* O &MGB *# # C * ( I ( I 5 I* (
I 2 ( I ( * * ( I # ( I ; ( I ( ( ? $
- , ? #* ( 5 @ $ I ) # , ) ( 9*
* # # $ # #
* * - ( * # .7,. #* .,''' %
! E,&",
E,&, 5 # # . % #* ( &''E !
.,''' "
.7(.
.4(8
&'(7 4&(E
&'(>
&4(4 7(>
&4(&
47(7 E>('
&&(.
4/('
&/(4 4'(.
&'(7 .7(.
.>(7 4/(E ./('
&M(4 47(.
7(E
E&(.
.7(/
./(8 .'(.
.4(/
.&(8
ME(/
&4(&
&&(E M(>
./(7
&>(>
4(.
.4(4 8(E
.4(8
M/(>
&.(' .4('
&8(&
48(&
' .' &' 4' E' /' M' >'
) 5 1
)A3
? I ? 5 I 53
5 1 ?
5 1
55 Q A 1
55 1) ?
) ? 5
) 1 ??
)3)0) ) 5
)? 1)3
? ) 5 1 ?3@ 5
? 0
? 2 R 1
A 3?? ?
1 0
A I
5 53 53 ?
1 )53I 2 I 5 ? I 2313?? I
5 3 5
53 @3
I 1 )53I ?
I 1 I 13I?
I 1 ; 51 1
I 1 )31
I 1 )31 ? ) 0)
I 1 0 1 1 2 0) 1
I 1 5 31 ?
I 1 2 ?
I 1 ) ?31
I 1 5 I
I 1 5 I ? I05
I3 3 3 I 2? @3 1
? 3 0 10 @ 3603I3
05 )
05 1
@3?? 10 @
J 5 1
5 4 B *.*
;* C 1 B @ ,
&'./C .E #*
.,'''
+
&, ? 5 % ! 5 ! " !" C ( * # #* * #
*# # # % &'./, ) # E,4( &''/ #
# % .4,> # ,
E,4 5 # # / % ! .,''' "
&.(&
.8(8 .8(E .8(/
&>(7 &>(E
.E(> .4(>
' .'
&' 4'
&''& &''4 &''E &''/
) #
;* C 1 B @ ,
4, ? " ! " 1! # " 1! !) !% ( # ! # (
$ * : " $ 2 ! ( : $ ", - # *
* ( # 2, % ( &''/( #* 9*
* #* * * 7M,7G # / % ( .' *
# ! E,E", 2 * ( 2 # ./ * , I # (
* 9* 9* - # * ( * 9*
.88/ - # * 8/G 2 ! E,/",
E,E, 2 % * %
* ) # $ (
&''M
7&
>>(7
77(.
77(4 8'
>8(/
7M(7
>>(4
>'
>/
7' 7/
8' 8/
.88/ &''' &''/ &''M
) #
;* C 2 # 32 3I ;( 2 I ,
E,/, 2 % * %
* 2 ) # $ ( &''M
84(E
>7(/
78(. 7M(.
8/(8
>E(7
7'(& 74(.
/' M'
>' 7' 8' .''
.88/ &''' &''/ &''M
) #
;* C 2 # 32 3I ;( 2 I ,
&'./C 8/G
&'./C 8/G
&'./C .> #*
.,'''
*
9 : % & 9 ; ; ; 0 < ; = 90 3A;
? 5 % ! , * % &'./ # # *
,
? 5 % 5 *# C
% 5 * # # E/ #* .'' # ,
% 8'G #* * # ,
% 8/G * $ ,
% 3 # * #: D* #
>/G $ M/G ./ .8 % ,
% & ( # ./G( 9* - #
# ,
% , 5 * /,/ # #* # * * ,
# % 5 !% 4 B ( 9* # *# #
&'./ C
., 5 % 5 % ! ( # E/
#* .'' # , - - ( # &''/ *
# 8E( &. * * # ) # ( >4,., 0
9* - # # H ( $
( - *# # * ! /,.",
/,., # ) # $ !G , .'' # ",
74(8
8/(>
8&(E 8E('
7E(E >>(7 >7(>
>4(.
/' M'
>' 7' 8' .''
&''& &''4 &''E &''/
) #
;* C ( 1 , ) * 21 A,
&, ? % !" 1! # % # # ! " ) " # * &''/
#*$ # .''/ * (
- * &''E ! /,&", I # ( ) ( *
* # # # * , 0 #* #
# # ( ( * 8/G
! /,4",
&'./C E/
-
/,&, 2 ) # $ ( &''4B&''/
8>(.G 8>(4G
8M(EG
8/('G
8/(MG
8M(EG
84G 8EG 8/G 8MG 8>G 87G
&''4 &''E &''/
) #
;* C ( 1 , ) * 21 A,
/,4, 2 #* ( &''/
88(/G 7>(.G 7&(MG
78(.G78(EG 84(7G 77('G
>8(&G 8M('G 77(MG /E(&G
84(&G 8>(8G 7'(7G
84(EG 78(>G
8M(>G 8/(/G 7M(>G
77(MG 7M(8G
8'(.G 7>(8G
>8(4G /4('G
88(&G 8E(>G
87(.G
>.(>G
8M(MG 7.(.G
87(4G
MM(7G 78(8G
8M(/G 8&(4G M>(8G
88(/G 87(/G 7>(MG
>>(EG 8>(&G 8>('G8>(7G 8'('G
'G &'G E'G M'G 7'G .''G
) 5 )A31
? I ? 5 I 53 5 1 ?
5 1
55 Q A 1
55 1) ?
) ? 5
) 1 ??
)3)0) ) 5
)? 1)3
? ) 5 1 ?3@ 5
? 0
? 2 R 1
A 3?? ?1 0
A I
5 53 53 ?1 )53I 2 I 5 ? I 2313?? I
5 3 5
53 @3
I 1 )53I ?
I 1 I 13I?
I 1 ; 51 1
I 1 )31
I 1 )31 ? ) 0)
I 1 0 1 1 2 0) 1
I 1 5 31 ?
I 1 2 ? I 1I 1) 5 I?31
I 1 5 I ? I05
I3 3 3 I 2? @3 1
? 3 0 10 @3603I3
05 )
05 1
@3?? 10 @
J 5 1
;* C ( 1 , ) * 21 A
4, ( 5 ! G " !% 5 H !
#* # .' % ( .' $ .E % ( $ ./B.8 % " #* * * , &''/(
&'./C .''G
E/,&G( * # * # # &'G
# ,
/,E, 2 # ) # $ ( &''& $ &''/
'(7>G '(7.G
&.(7G &.(EG &&(>G &&(4G E/(EG
EE(/G
'(8'G '(8'G
&.(>G &.(MG
&&(MG &&(/G E/(&G
&&(/G
'G .'G
&'G 4'G E'G /'G
!.'B.E" !.'B.E"
) #
!./B.8" !./B.8"
) #
!.'B.8" !.'B.8"
) # ! "
) #
! "
&''&
&''/
;* C ( 1 , ) * 21 A,
9 : % , 9 4; 3 A3>7 30;. ; ; ; 3; = 0 '
? 5 % ! / $ # * &'./ #
@3ABI3 ,
* 5 % 5 C
% .,&G ./ $ E8 % ,
% 5 * &'G # ( # *
# ,
% 5 * &'G # # B- * 9* 9* &'.'B&'./
* ,
5 % ! + $ # * * # $
# # ,
) # * # * C
% # *$ 7/G #* # .887 $ &'./,
% 5 * E/G &''4 $ &'./ # * ,
% A 7'G #* .887 $ &'./,
% 5 * # .'G( $ # # (
#* . $ &( .,7'' #
# ,
# % 5 !% 4 B ( 9* # *# #
&'./ C
&'./C
&'G
., ? 3!" !" 5 G ! . *$ # *
E/E $ EM& .'' # - &''/( # , - &'./ *
# * # # ! M,.",
M,., 3 # $ * ( &'''B&''/ !1+# .'' # - "
EE4
4&/ 4'/ 4'/
7MM
E/E
.>7 &EE
E74 E74
./8 EM&
'
&/' /''
>/' .,'''
&''' &''. &''& &''4 &''E &''/
# *
;* C 21 A( I ,
&, ? # !" !) "" 1! # A3>I .# , #*
* * ( * 9* &''/( ( /,/
.'' # - ( .& # 9* &''. ! M,&",
M,&, 2 @3A I ! .'' # - ,"
'(E> '(E.
'(''
.('M
/(//
' .
&
4 E / M
&''. &''& &''4 &''E &''/
;* C I ,
9 : % / '; ; 3 ; ; 9 343 30;0 ; 43 ;
? 5 % ! * 9* $
# $ ( $ * # * *
$ # # $ # *# *
!I " $ * # ) &,
# ( * * * ( * *
!2 0 $ ) 9* ( &''M"( #* 9*
# 9* # # # C # *
* ( # ( $ # ( # $ * $
# , # *$ * 9*
H ( > * #
* * * - # # ,
( ) # * # C
% 5 * # 4' # - , 9* ,
% ) I # 2 9* 1 1 * !I211"(
* .M/ # * - ,
% # &'.' *# * ,
2 * ( 5 % - * # ( &'./( 9*
* , - ) # # # C
% 3 >,> # * * * * * * * ( $ 8,& #
- * * * ,
% 3 # &,4 # +# * * * * #
* ( $ .,8 # * * # ,
2 + # ( 5 % 9* # # # &'.'
# .'' # - * * , ) # -
# * EG - 9* # ,
# ( 9* # *# #
&'./ C
., ? " % " "% G " !% . * *
# , 2 * * # 88,EG *
$ 7.,MG * &'./, - - ( - # .7 *
# !7.,EG # 88,EG"( $ /' * * *
!4M,&G 7.,MG # " ! >,.", I * E/ #* # *
* * * # # ( $ * # I 5 ? # ( - $ I
) * : 4'G, ( * # J
$ ? ,
&, ? " % " !% . # # C E' * *
* ( $ M7 * * ( 9* + # 9*
# - # *
#* ! >,&", # !&M" E/ #* # *
! >,4"H ( ( 9* $ # #*
# * ,
>,., ) * * * ) # $ ( &''/
>.('
7.(E
4M(&
74(E
8E(4
E>(.
'
&' E' M' 7' .''
! " !0 " !5* "
) #
! "
) #
!0 "
) #
!5* "
! " !0 " !5* "
) # ! " ) # !0 " ) # !5* "
;* C 21 A 1 B) &''/,
>,&, ) * ) # $ ( &''/
EE(4M
/>('&
&(48
>4(.
78(>
.>(7
'
&' E' M' 7' .''
! " !0 " !5* "
) #
! "
) #
!0 "
) #
!5* "
! " !0 " !5* "
) # ! " ) # !0 " ) # !5* "
;* C 21 A 1 B) &''/,
) * * * $ ( &''/
;" "%
286
; " !%
286
9* >.(' >(>
M'(7 8(&
>'(8 ..('
# MM(& ..(M
? //(4 .M(/
M>(4 4'(7
;* C 0 * 2 ( I 2 # ,
&'./C
0 C 88,EG
5* C 7.,MG
&'./C 0 C 8>,MG 5* C >',8G
&
>,4, ) * * * $ #* ( &''/
* *
8/(E 7'(8
>E(M M/(>
M>(.
7'(' 84(E
>8(E /M(8 4'('
7'('
>8(4
>M(.
4.(7
>'(' /'(8
/&(' /7(4
M'(E M8(4
78(4 4/('
7E(7 E7(8
/4(7
&(8
M7(M 84(' ME(4 E7(4
M&(.
M4(4
>E(8 /M(/
E7(&
E7(E 4E('
>>(.
M'(7 7M(4
88(.
7>(4 //(&
8/(8 4&(M
M>(' 7.(>
' &' E' M' 7' .''
CA RTA GENA ARJONA A RROYO HONDO CA LA M AR CLEM ENCIA M A HA TES SA N CRISTOBA L SA N ESTA NISLA O DE KOSTKA SA NTA CA TA LINA SA NTA ROSA DE LIM A SOPLA VIENTO TURB A CO TURB A NA VILLA NUEVA CORDOBA EL CA RM EN DE B OLIVAR EL GUA M O M ARIALA B AJA SA N JA CINTO SA N JUA N NEP OM UCENO ZA M BRA NO A CHI M A GA NGUE M ONTECRISTO P INILLOS SA N JACINTO DEL CAUCA TIQUISIO CICUCO HA TILLO DE LOBA M ARGA RITA M OM P OX SA N FERNA NDO TA LAIGUA NUEVO A LTOS DEL ROSA RIO B ARRANCO DE LOBA EL P EÑON REGIDOR RIO VIEJO SAN M A RTIN DE LOBA A RENAL DEL SUR CANTA GALLO M ORA LES SA N PA B LO SANTA ROSA DEL SUR SIM ITI B olívar (sin Cartagena) Total B olívar (co n Cartagena)
>&(4 .4('
'(' '(' '('
4.(M '('
'(' '(' '(' '(' '('
E.(7 '('
'(' .>(>
'(' '(' '('
&4(4 '(' '('
.4(.
'(' ..(>
'(' .7(>
'(' '(' '('
.>(4 8(E
&'(M '('
&.(E '(' '('
4.(&
4'(7 '('
&>(E /.(&
E7(E /E(E '('
..(>
E4(.
' &' E' M' 7' .''
CARTAGENA ARJONA ARROYO HONDO CA LA M AR CLEM ENCIA M A HATES SA N CRISTOBA L SAN ESTANISLAO DE KOSTKA SANTA CATALINA SANTA ROSA DE LIM A SOPLAVIENTO TURBA CO TURBA NA VILLA NUEVA CORDOBA EL CA RM EN DE BOLIVAR EL GUAM O M A RIA LA BAJA SAN JA CINTO SAN JUA N NEPOM UCENO ZAM BRA NO ACHI M AGA NGUE M ONTECRISTO PINILLOS SAN JACINTO DEL CA UCA TIQUISIO CICUCO HATILLO DE LOBA M ARGARITA M OM POX SA N FERNANDO TALAIGUA NUEVO ALTOS DEL ROSARIO BARRANCO DE LOBA EL P EÑON REGIDOR RIO VIEJO SA N M ARTIN DE LOBA ARENAL DEL SUR CA NTAGA LLO M ORA LES SAN PAB LO SA NTA ROSA DEL SUR SIM ITI Bo lívar (sin Cartagena) Total B o lívar (co n Cartagena)
;* C 0 * 2 ( I 2 # ,
9 : % + 9 ; ; ; 3; ; 03; ; ; 0 ; 9 9
9* # * (
# # * D ( ( # * #
$ * # # $ 9* * # * ,
# : 9* #
* # !# .M"(
# # !# .>" $ - # * (
* ( # $ #* !# .7",
,
# ( # - * * * +
! $ " $ * !# .&", ? *
# * # *
, ? ( ( * # * + (
( - 9* # $ $ *$
* ( # $ 9* * (
* ,
0 5# C ) " # % 8 * # /&,EG #
% &''/, M/G #* * # # (
&7 E/ #* ( # 9* 4/G * # # ,
- - ( * ( # ( *
# $ # * * + # $ #* $ #
,
#* 9* # % # * C * ( I 5
I* ( ) $ ) , ( #* @ * ( ) # ( I ( ) * $
- ( # # # % ! 7,.",
7,., # % ; ( &''/
Bolívar y municipios Indicador de desempeño Fiscal 2005
0 20 40 60 80
CARTAGENAACHI ALTOS DEL ROSARIOARROYOHONDOARJONAARENAL BARRANCO DE LOBACANTAGALLOCLEMENCIACALAMARCORDOBACICUCO EL CARMEN DE BOLIVARHATILLO DE LOBASAN ESTANISLAOSAN CRISTOBALMARIA LA BAJASAN FERNANDOMONTECRISTOSAN JACINTOMARGARITAMAGANGUEEL GUAMOEL PEÑONMAHATESMORALESRIO VIEJOMOMPOSREGIDORPINILLOS SAN JACINTO DEL CAUCASAN JUAN NEPOMUCENOSANTA ROSA DEL SURSAN MARTIN DE LOBATALAIGUA NUEVOSANTA CATALINASOPLAVIENTOSANTA ROSAVILLANUEVASAN PABLOZAMBRANOTURBACOTURBANATIQUISIOSIMITI
Promedio Bolívar 52,46%
;* C ) * * B 12
8 # # 1 2 ! 12" + *
* #* C * * # ( # * * (
1 ( * ( # * (
- ( ' .'' # $ # # % ,
/
3@, I # ( * #
>( #
# ( - 9* : # # -
# # 9* - - % &'./,
V2 9*: # W A $ C
., 2 * # B 9* -*# (
# * * . ! $ - # D # ", ) #
8( * * * $ * #
# ( # : 1 3 - !1 3"( $ $*
# # * E( # *
# , ( 9* #* * * *
( # $ # # ,
8, 5 * * * $ # # ! 9* " $ *
* * $ # ! - "
' .'
&' 4' E' /' M'
>' 7' 8' .''
' .' &' 4' E' /' M' >'
43 2 % 6
%"""%286
-
&
&- /&
- - - ,- +-
% !) !% J C
%!""%286
;* C ? * 21 A( 1 B) &''/ $ ! 32 3I ; ",
&, 2 9* $* * # - #* ( * -*#
*$ , - - ( * # # - #
9* D * $ * # , ?
# ( $ * * #* ( (
$ * * *
# , 2 ( > OI # B #
9* * # # # # #
,
? * # - # $ :
# # ( * # - I # # *
!I #"( * # #* 9* -
# # ( * - - - *# (
* #* ( # $ $ ,
+
- 9* *# - $ # # #
* * # ( # ) 9* ( #
- ) $ # * # I* ( # *
9* * # * ( $
# B # ( ,
# ( * D # # 9*
# # # #* , * 9*
# * # #* $ # ,
# ( D % # *
$ ( : * ( #: *
# # ( * ( * ( * 9* (
( : ! $ * "( ,
* # # 9* #
D # % &'./,
@, ) * $ #
# #* #
! ", # * * (
* # $ ( #
- # * - % &'./, 1 ( 9*
9* # $ * # $( (
# ( # C % # * (
# ( # * # +# #* # !44 E/"(
* * $ 2( # * # $ * $
# # # % #* ,
# * * # . ! $ - #
D # " $ > ! # ", # ( *
#* * ( * $
, *# * # C
1 3 - !1 3",
>( # * * * $
( # #* # * 9* ( # #
* ( # * (
* ( ( # # ) 9* $ - ) (
# * # 9* D # $ *# # #
-*# # ,
# ( - &'./ 9* #
9* # * # $ * # *
*
* H # 9* : ( # #*
# H # # # ( # # $
# ( * - # $ *
# H * # ( # * @3A I $ #
# % #* * 9* *$
,
? * 9* # * &'./(
# * > # ( *$ * #
# 9* * # 9* #
* # * ,
D ( *# * - # 9* 210 $ *
3 2 ( 9* $ ) ! " 0
# #* $ # ( 9*
*# * # #* $ *$ #
* 9* # # $
B ,
o 5 + ( 0 ( ) # ) # ) (
) ) # ( 0 ? ,
1U.'( # # &''M,
o ( H 1 !&''E", <2 ( $ *
) # # NN3=, * 1U..( , 44BM., )
) # , # &''E,
o ( !&''>", < ) ) C V6*: - # W=,
2 I # * 5 ( ) , ) 3 ( &>
&''>,
o ( H ; 5* !&''>", 2 $ * ) ( &''&B&''/, 2
I # * 5 ( ) , ) 3 ( &>
&''>,
o 2 0 $ ) 9* !&''M",
!
