AMathematicalModeloftheEconomicSystemwithDistributedPropertyRights Kolesnik,Georgiy MunichPersonalRePEcArchive

(1)

Munich Personal RePEc Archive

A Mathematical Model of the Economic System with Distributed Property Rights

Kolesnik, Georgiy

15 May 2010

Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/47680/

MPRA Paper No. 47680, posted 19 Jun 2013 19:24 UTC

(2)

!"

#$%&'(& ! "# $%& #' ()% %#+#", -.-(%" /,() ()% 01#0 %1(. 1,2)(- $,-

(1,34(%$ 5"#+2 -%6%15& 52%+(- ,- #+-,$%1%$ 7)% %8%( #' 01#0 %1(. 1,2)(-

5&&# 5(,#+#+()%%#+#",%9,%+.#'()%"5+52%"%+(-(15(%2,%-,--(4$,%$

*+,- , .

:

;<

/0123'4%.01#0 %1(. 1,2)(-#/+%1-),0#+(1#&%9,%+./%&'51%#"0 %(,

(,#++#+# #0 %15(,6%25"%=5-)%>4,&,31,4"

5 ,6

? :

@

A B

C D

:E DF GHHHE

I

½

A

?

:

?@ @ < @

J@ ;

< @

DK%+-%+L%M&,+2NOPQRL#1M%(5&NOSSRT)&%,'%1U,-)+.NOSQR

T(4&VNOSSE

?

XYDZ1#--"5+[51(NOSQR[51(L# #1%NOOHE?

C :

J@

:

½

!"#"

(3)

? DL \4&&%1 ]\51+%1.$ GHHNE

<

J

? @

J@ ?

< ; :

J@

: J@

^

: J@

_

DB

GHHSE;

@

? @ @

@ J@

` : : :

< J J

J :

?

J@ ?

< J

?

J@

_ < J@ ?

@

J

?

: B

?J

7 8 96

J @J

l

k

^` ^a^b

J@

J@ J

:

Θ k × l

θ ij

(4)

JJ

i

j

^c

θ •j = (θ 1j , . . . , θ kj )

j

^J

θ _i • = (θ i1 , . . . , θ _il )

i

B J@

J d

W i (Θ, C) = l

j=1

θ ij C j = θ ^T _i • C,

^DNE

C = (C 1 , . . . , C l )

^C ^F

:JD

:E

; : e @

J@

d DfgINGHHPE_

@

: :

: ? :

t

Φ j (t, ˜ a j , y)

^@

˜ a j

^<

y

^`

J

J d

C _j (˜ a _j , y) = ∞

t=0

β ^t _j Φ j (t, ˜ a _j , y),

^DGE

β _j

^C ^: ^J@

; J

J <

I J

j

A j

_

A = A 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ A l

B

J :

W i

J

a _i • = (a i1 , . . . , a _il )

^;

:

A k × l

^I

j

^:^:

A

a • j = (a 1j , . . . , a _kj )

^I ^<

j

^`

<

: J@ :

a ij

^< ^{^} ^:

¾

; <

:

θ ij

¾

$ !

& ' ( )*+,-(.+/"0+"011234

! 5 )* 06(. ,-",+"011-34 '

5"

(5)

@ J <

a _•j

J

θ • j

^<

˜ a _j

^d

˜

a j = R j (θ • j , a • j ).

^DhE

` <

a ˜ j

<

y

^J ^{^}

@

: :

? J@ <

y

^DGE ^<

J i<

<

˜ a = (˜ a 1 , . . . , ˜ a l )

C(˜ a)

^F ^DNE

:J < d

W ( Θ, ˜ a ) = ΘC ( ˜ a ).

^DjE

F J

d :

J

R j

^<^:

C j

g

: < : I

Θ

g DhE DjE

W ( Θ, A ) = W ( Θ, R ( Θ, A )) = ΘC ( R ( Θ, A )),

^DkE

R(Θ, A)) = (R 1 (θ •1 , a _•1 ), . . . , R l (θ •l , a _•l ))

? DkE J

k

^:

Γ( Θ )

Θ

^B

W _i ( Θ, A )

^J@

<

a _i • ∈ A

`

A − i

^C

i

^I ^<

i

Θ

a ^∗ _i• ( A − i , Θ )

^d

a ^∗ _i _• ( A − i , Θ ) = arg max

a _i

• ∈ A W _i ( Θ, A ).

? <

a ^∗ _i• (A − i , Θ)

J J@@

;<

¿

A ^∗ ( Θ )

¿

7 '! &

"$

R

& '' '

'

"$

"

(6)

F

Θ

< J @

˜

a(Θ) = R(Θ, A ^∗ (Θ)),

^DQE

C

W(Θ) = W(Θ, A ^∗ (Θ)).

F J

I

x = (x 1 , . . . , x _l )

J d

x j = k

i=1

θ ij , j = 1, . . . , l.

^DPE

I

@ d

U (˜ a ) = k

i=1

W i ( Θ, ˜ a ) = x ^T C (˜ a ).

^DSE

I

U (Θ)

A ^∗ (Θ)

^J@ ^J

Θ

^d

U (Θ) = U (˜ a(Θ)) = k

i=1

W i (Θ),

a(Θ) ˜

^DQE

c

Θ

U (Θ)

I

: @

; < :

:

: aC b :

J@ @ `

: lJ

: :

J J :

? J :J

d

C J

@? <

:

g: :

W i

^:

(7)

: <

:

B :

θ ij = r i θ 1j , ∀ i = 2, . . . , k, ∀ j = 1, . . . , l,

^DOE

r i > 0

^C^:^: ^@

`

Θ ⁰ i

d

W i ( Θ ⁰ , A ) = r i W 1 ( Θ ⁰ , A ) ∀ i > 1,

:

W i (Θ ⁰ , A)

:

DOE J

Θ ⁰

(l + k − 1)

^d

θ = (θ 1 , . . . , θ _l )

^: ^:

(r 2 , . . . , r _k )

^d

Θ ⁰ = rθ ^T ,

^DNHE

r = (r 1 , r 2 , . . . , r _k )

^D

r 1 = 1

^E

g J@

d

Θ ⁰ = ρx ^T ,

^DNNE

x = (x 1 , . . . , x l )

^C

J DPER

ρ = (ρ 1 , . . . , ρ k )

^C^:^:

k i=1

ρ i = 1

_

Θ ⁰

ρ

^J@ ^d

ρ i = r _i k m=1

r m

.

DNHE d

Θ ⁰ = _k

i=1

r _i ρθ ^T .

^DNGE

gDOE J

j

x _j =

k

i=1

θ _ij = θ _j k

i=1

r _i ,

θ = x

k i=1

r i

.

^DNhE

(8)

^ DNNE

<

: `

:

J

U

^_

:

W(Θ, ˜ a)

^DkE

U (˜ a)

^DSE ^DNNE ^J

<

˜ a

^d

W(Θ ⁰ , ˜ a) = Θ ⁰ C(˜ a) = ρx ^T C(˜ a) = ρ U (˜ a).

^DNjE

` <

R

J

`

R

J d J

<

˜ a ^∗

^J@

J

U( ˜ a )

^g ^:

A ^∗

a _i • = ˜ a

i = 1, . . . , k

F

˜

a ^∗ = R(Θ ⁰ , A ^∗ ).

_ J

Θ ⁰

^:

A ^∗

^;<

Γ(Θ ⁰ )

^`

i

^J^J ^:

A ^′

<

˜ a ^′

^d

˜

a ^′ = R(Θ ⁰ , A ^′ ).

FDNjEd

W i (Θ ⁰ , A ^∗ ) = W i (Θ ⁰ , ˜ a ^∗ ) = ρ i U (˜ a ^∗ ) ≥ ρ i U(˜ a ^′ ) = W i (Θ ⁰ , ˜ a ^′ ) = W i (Θ ⁰ , A ^′ ),

A ^∗ = A ^∗ (Θ ⁰ )

F:

U ( Θ )

U (Θ ⁰ ) = max

Θ

U (Θ),

^DNkE

J

DSE

? DNkE `

a

J@ bJ

:,;<6 5

k

W j (Θ)

l

^!

"

9

!'"$ &

! "

(9)

Θ ⁰

^<

Θ

^J

i = 1, . . . , k

W _i (Θ) ≥ W _i (Θ ⁰ ),

^DNQE

g DNQE

U (Θ) > U (Θ ⁰ ),

JDNkE

g

J` J _

Θ

^I<

Θ ⁰

^J@ ^<J

Θ

` :

d

<

˜ a(Θ ⁰ )

^<

Θ ⁰

; J

Θ

Θ ⁰

^J@

< d

W(Θ ⁰ , ˜ a(Θ)) = W(Θ).

^DNPE

? DNNEF

x

Θ ⁰

ρ

^` ^DNjE^d

W(Θ ⁰ , ˜ a(Θ)) = ρ U (˜ a(Θ)) = ρ U (Θ).

^DNSE

DNPE DNSE :

ρ

^DNNE

Θ ⁰

ρ = W(Θ)

U (Θ) .

^DNOE

_ :

A ^∗ (Θ ⁰ )

Θ ⁰

^< ^J

W(Θ)

_ DNkEDNPEDNSE J

i

^d

W _i (Θ) = W _i (Θ ⁰ , ˜ a(Θ)) = ρ _i U(Θ) ≤ ρ _i U (Θ ⁰ ) = W _i (Θ ⁰ ).

^DGHE

J

i

Θ ⁰

Θ

F J@

:,;<6 7 #

Θ

"

(10)

U (Θ)

^DGHE

`

F <

J : J

B J :

J@

@ :

? ;9;. = @8A;

`J < :

@J `

NHHm

θ

(1 − θ)

^:

Θ

Θ =

1 θ 0 1 − θ

.

` J B

_

c

f::J d

P (˜ a) = 1 − ˜ a 1 − ˜ a 2 ,

˜ a = (˜ a 1 , ˜ a 2 )

^C ^{J@ e} ^:

f: J

Π j (˜ a) = (P (˜ a) − c)˜ a j .

< e

˜ a j ≥ 0

^J ^Ie

˜

a 1

˜

a 1 = a 11 .

?

˜ a 2

^<

J@ d

˜

a 2 = θa 12 + (1 − θ)a 22 ,

a 12

a 22

^C ^e

` :

j Φ j (t, ˜ a )

J

Π j ( ˜ a )

^` ^: ^DGE

j

^: ^d

C _j ( ˜ a ) = Π j ( ˜ a )

1 − β .

(11)

J

W 1 (Θ, ˜ a) = Π 1 (˜ a) + θΠ 2 (˜ a), W 2 ( Θ, ˜ a ) = (1 − θ)Π 2 ( ˜ a ).

:

?:aC b J@

θ = 0

B:

A ^∗

^d

a ^∗ ₁₁ = a ^∗ ₂₂ = 1 − c

3 ,

^DGNE

d

Π ^∗ _j = 1 − c

3 2

j = 1, 2.

_

θ = 1

^: ^J

: <d

W 1 ( ˜ a ) = Π 1 ( ˜ a ) + Π 2 ( ˜ a ) → max

˜ a∈ A .

:

A ^∗

a ^∗ ₁₁ + a ^∗ ₂₂ = 1 − c

2 .

^DGGE

F Y

:

W 1 ( Θ, ˜ a )

W 2 ( Θ, ˜ a )

J

θ < 1

a ^∗ ₁₂ ( Θ ) = 0

^e

: Ji

J d

a ^∗ ₁₁ ( Θ ) = (1 − θ)(1 − c)

3 − θ ,

^DGhE

a ^∗ ₂₂ (Θ) = 1 − c

(1 − θ)(3 − θ) .

^DGjE

;

θ = 0

^e ^J ^DGNE ^`

θ → 1 ˜ a ^∗ ₁ (Θ) → 0

˜

a ^∗ ₂ (Θ) = (1 − θ)a ^∗ ₂₂ (Θ) → 1 − c 2 ,

e

:! !

"

(12)

`

Π 1 (Θ) = (1 − θ)(1 − c) ²

(3 − θ) ² , Π 2 (Θ) = 1 − c

3 − θ 2

,

^DGkE

DNE

W 1 ( Θ ) = 1 − c

3 − θ 2

, W 2 ( Θ ) = (1 − θ)(1 − c) ² (3 − θ) ² .

f:

W 1

θ

J@ _

e

θ

< J

_ :d

θ

^< ^<

W 2

θ

ge

Q( Θ ) = ˜ a ^∗ ₁ ( Θ ) + ˜ a ^∗ ₂ ( Θ ) = (2 − θ)(1 − c) (3 − θ) .

f:

Q

θ

^D^GE ^:

:

θ → 1

F

a C Cb :

Y

$

J@ J :J

(13)

Gdi e

Q

Θ

^` ^DNNE^DNOE

DGkE

Θ

^d

Θ ⁰ = 1

2 − θ 1 2 − θ 1−θ 2−θ

1−θ 2−θ

.

F

1−θ 2−θ

N @ N

(1 − θ) ² 2−θ

J

G @ Gg< : :

< J DGkE

`

Θ ⁰

^<

: d

U (˜ a) = Π 1 (˜ a) + Π 2 (˜ a).

B<

e DGGE

_1−c

2

c

W 1 (Θ ⁰ ) = 1 2 − θ

1 − c 2

2 , W 2 (Θ) = 1 − θ 2 − θ

1 − c 2

2 .

? e

J : D hE

:

B C *+

(14)

J

`

J@

J <

:

g

<

_ J@

:

?

J@ J :J : _

` J

? J

(15)

` <

:

` :

<

nN℄ B ? ?@ g_ ` p Y

:

@ e qq? Frg a`

bCGHHSC=#NCgPPCSQ

nG℄ F s d :<

?GFN Cg`d ^ <GHHH

nh℄ f : aI@ : :

J: DfgINEb r `Y

GH JGHHP=#GkQ

nj℄ Z1#--"5+T[51(t 7)%#-(-5+$3 %+%u(-#'#/+%1-),0d5()%#1.#'6%1(,5&5+$

&5(%15&,+(%215(,#+ qqK#'v#&,(,5&w#+#".CNOSQCU#&OjCv QONCPNO

nk℄ [51( t L# #1% K v1#0 %1(. x,2)(-5+$ ()%=5(41% #' ()%y,1" qq K #'v#&,(,5&

w#+#".CNOOHCU#&OSC=#QCv NNNOCNNkS

nQ℄ K%+-%+ L L%M&,+2 ] 7)%#1.#' ()% y,1"dL5+52%1,5&z%)56,#1 !2%+. {#-(

5+${50,(5&T(14(41% qqK#'y,+5+,5&w#+#",-CNOPQCU#& hC=#jCv

hHkChQH

nP℄ L#1M xT)&%,'%1! U,-)+. x L5+52%"%+(t/+%1-),0 5+$ L51M%( U5&45(,#+d

5+w"0,1,5&!+5&.-,- qqK#'y,+5+,5&w#+#",-CNOSSCU#&GH C=#NG C

vGOhChNk

nS℄ L \4&&%1[L]\51+%1.$| }+-,$%6-t4(-,$% t/+%1-),0d!v#&,(,5&7)%#1.#'()%

y,1"qq x!=~K#'w#+#",-CGHHNCU#&hGCvkGPCkjN

nO℄ T)&%,'%1!U,-)+.x 512%T)51%)#&$%1- 5+${#10 #15(% {#+(1#& qqK#'v#&,(,5&

w#+#".CNOSQCU#&OjC=#hCv jQNCjSS

nNH℄ T(4&Vx L5+52%1,5&{#+(1#& #' U#(,+2 x,2)(-dy,+5+,+2v#&,,%- 5+$ ()%L51M%(

'#1{#10 #15(%{#+(1#& qqK#' y,+5+,5&w#+#",-CNOSSCU#&GH C=#NG C

vGkCkj

AMathematicalModeloftheEconomicSystemwithDistributedPropertyRights Kolesnik,Georgiy MunichPersonalRePEcArchive

Munich Personal RePEc Archive