DF (w) TYn]_ j TYQ lFw#EbW j Q^[3S+X

nPXLF

j

Q^[]F EWYnO 8+, (+610(+6 .1: / 6 *;, (+6

j

E[]sRQ n]_PQ^WVWV_xv%SUTYQ nPQ vlQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLFrn]g XL[]Z

EprMcb TV[ j EprMPb?EWYn" EsL‡fXg‡ XL[ j n ‡ lFrncE_]w X j Q^[JEWYn (Q^O8_PXL[][cEpZ j E[Pn]_PQ^WVWVpFs \NQ^wxQ^TYMPbFrQ^_xv

`meSU` TYn]_yQ^TVF „?E rt pZ XL[]_PQ TVF j Q^[ (Q^O8_PXL[][cEpZ j E[Pn]_PQ^WVWVpFs4w p sRQ TYMPbd_PQ^F pF j w 5E[

ZBTV_]_PQ^WYn j Q^[ (+* * (;8)(+6+@" ,(+* +*/(;8 (;6 KpF j j Q^[P 8 (+6 , * (;8)(+6+@ 7 ;8< (;6, * (;F

O8pZ…Q^Fd_PQ|t j TYQ j ELnXL[]_

w

^{ZBTVF j Q} n]_PQ^FrnBQ^TVFZ)EW Q^F_]bGEWV_PQ^F v„?EF sRQ^b_ j E mRXLF t j ELnPnXL[]_PQ|t j TYQqTVF -Q^FTVsRQ^FS+XLOpZ…Q^F_PQ^FmRXL[]ORXLZBZ…Q^F tE\NQ^[JbGop_rs TVZ EO8_]prQ^WVWYQ^F?S+XLO8pZ…Q^Fd_!Ephg_][PQ^_PQ^F t

nPQ^b[!s|p_PQ)SUQ nPO[]TVK_PXL[PQ^F4g&%[ j Q^FeFbGEWV_ j TYQ nPQ nySUXLO8pZ…Q^Fd_PQ nyn]TVF j v 'TVFbrXLbrQ n E+Q TYMcbd_yncXLW‡

WYQ^F/EWYncXBTVFd_]pTV_]TVm XL[]_PQ!ZBTV_UQ^TVFrQ^ZabrXLbrQ^F

tf (w, d)

^{‡ Q^[]_UpF j Q^TVFrQ^Z} sRQ^[]TVFsRQ^F

df(w)

^{‡Q^[]_}

D

^j TYQ)S+XLO8pZ…Q^Fd_PQ^FORXLWVWYQ^O8_]TYXLF t j TYQ j Q^[ E+Q TYMPb_]pFs?w ps|[]pF j QWVTYQ^s|_ & [cETVFTVFsRn ‡ Z…Q^FsRQ t EWYncX

| D |

^{j TYQ lFw#EbW j} Q^[qS+XLO8pZ…Q^Fd_PQ)TVF j TYQ nPQ^[qHlXLWVWYQ^O_]TYXLF v S!ELn `eS+`‡wE+Q TYMPb_

Q^TVFrQ n XL[]_PQ n

w

^TVZ SUXLO8pZ…Q^Fd_]mRQ^O8_PXL[3Q^TVFrQ n!S+XLOpZ…Q^F_PQ n

d

ORXLZq\TVFTYQ^[]_ j TYQ \NQ^Tj Q^FsRQ nPMPbTVW‡ j Q^[]_PQ^F lFhgiXL[ j Q^[]pFsRQ^F TYQ+giXLWVs|_(

tf idf (w, d) = tf (w, d) ∗ idf (w)

^i}hvz

SUTYQ vlQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLFQ^TVFrQ nlS+XLO8pZ…Q^Fd_PQ n

d

Q^[]s|TV\_Un]TYMPb?Q^Fd_Pn]K[PQ McbrQ^F j Eprn j Q^[lQ^WYQ^Z…Q^F_ 5Q^TYnPQ^F

„/pWV_]TVKWVTVOLE_]TYXLF j Q n (Q^O8_PXL[Pn j Q^[ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,prQ^Fw^‡Q^[]_PQ j Q n S+XLOpZ…Q^F_PQ n ZBTV_ j Q^Z e S+`‡(Q^O8_PXL[

j

„/TV_%DlTVWgQJmRXLF$ `me S+`4ORILFFrQ^F Eprn%_PQ^ZBKNXL[cEWYQ^F S+E_PQ^F TVF)`rXL[]Z mRXLF *Q^TV_][PQ^TVbrQ^F<X

j

Q^[ '[PQ^TVsL‡

FTYnPncQ-,dprQ^FwxQ^F „/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQsRQ^FrQ^[]TYQ^[]_ -Q^[ j Q^F vefF j TYQ nPQ^Z l\rnPMcbFTV_]_ 5Q^[ j Q^Fyw 5Q^T8„?ILs|WVTYMPbORQ^TV_PQ^F

mRXL[]sRQ n]_PQ^WVWV_xv

'TVFrQ„?ILs|WVTYMPbORQ^TV_\NQ n]_PQ^b_ j E[]TVF t j TYQlF j Q^[]pFs mRXLF >_]_][]TV\p_ 5Q^[]_PQ^F TVF *Q^TV_][PQ^TVbrQ^F X j Q^[

'[PQ^TVs|FTYncnPQ-,dprQ^FwxQ^F?w pC\NQ^_][cELMPb_PQ^F vNefF j TYQ ncQ^Z `GEWVW \Q ncMPb[PQ^TV\_ j TYQ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,prQ^Fw , (+* * (;F

;8)(+6 9 t TYQqXg _ j Q^[ Q^[]_lQ^TVFrQ nl\Q n]_]TVZBZy_PQ^F >_]_][]TV\p_PQ n

a _i

n]TYMcbCTVFFrQ^[]bGEWV\4Q^TVFrQ^[ *Q^TV_][PQ^TVbrQ

c _j

^{oF j Q^[]_xv ` %[!Q^TVFrQ} *Q^TV_][PQ^TVbrQBZBTV_ *Q^TV_]KpFO8_PQ^F

t _j , j = 1, . . . , n

^{\NQ^[PQ} MPbFrQ^_qn]TYMcb j TYQ Q^[]Z‡

g[PQ-,dprQ^Fw3Q^TVFrQ n >_]_][]TV\p_PQ n

a i

S+E\NQ^T \NQ^wxQ^TYMPbFrQ^_

a _i (t j )

^{j Q^F Q^[]_ j Q} n >_]_][]TV\p_PQ n

a _i

^{w pZ} *Q^TV_]KpFO8_

t _j

^v

'TVFrQ…EF j Q^[PQ…„?ILs|WVTYMPbORQ^TV_q\NQ^_][cELMPb_PQ^_ j ELn lphg_][PQ^_PQ^F4mRXLF„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYn5Q^[]_PQ^F v efF j TYQ ncQ^Z `GEWVW

\Q nPMcb[PQ^TV\_ j TYQ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,prQ^Fw, (+*"+*/( 8 (+6 K|t TYQ-Xg_'Q^TVF\Q n]_]TVZBZy_PQ n >_]_][]TV\p_

a _i

TVFFrQ^[]bGEWV\

Q^TVFrQ^[/*Q^TV_][PQ^TVbrQ

c _j

mRXL[]ORXLZBZy_xt j vb v TYQ%Xg_

w(a i ) 6 = 0

^{TYnP_xv#` %[Q^TVFrQ} *Q^TV_][PQ^TVbrQ%ZBTV_ *Q^TV_]KpFO_PQ^F

t j , j = 1, . . . , n

^{\NQ^[PQ} MPbFrQ^_n]TYMPb j TYQ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,dprQ^Fw Q^TVFrQ n >_]_][]TV\p_PQ n

a i

j EFFygiXLWVsRQ^F j Q^[]Z)E RQ^F

tf (a _i , c _j ) =

n

X

j=1

I _j

^ZBTV_

I _j =

( 0 : a i (t j ) = 0 1 : a _i (t j ) 6 = 0

i}hvAV

S+E\NQ^T \NQ^wxQ^TYMPbFrQ^_

a _i (t _j )

^{j Q^F Q^[]_ j Q} n >_]_][]TV\p_PQ n

a _i

^{w pZ} *Q^TV_]KpFO8_

t _j

^v

SlTYQ 7 ;8< (+6,+*/( 8 (+6 KQ^Fd_Pn]K[]TYMcbd_+\NQ^T \Q^Tj Q^F?S+Q_rFd_]TYXLFrQ^F j Q^[ lFw#EbW j Q^[ *Q^TV_][PQ^TVbrQ^F t TVF

j Q^FrQ^F j Q^['Q^[]_ j Q n >_]_][]TV\p_PQ n

a _i

^{ZBTVF j Q} n]_PQ^FrnlQ^TVFZ)EW sRQxoF j Q^[]_ p[ j Q|v

df (a i ) = k { c j ∈ C | tf (a i , c j ) > 0 } k

^i}hvAW

SUQ^[ `e S+` ‡ Q^[]_ g%[ Q^TVF >_]_][]TV\p_

a _i

^{TVFQ^TVFrQ} *Q^TV_][PQ^TVbrQ

c _j

^{\Q^[PQ} McbFrQ^_ln]TYMcb<giXLWVs|WVTYMPb/EWYn(

tf idf (a i ) = tf(a i , c _j )log k C k df (a i )

i}hv3u

e Z H3EKTV_PQ^W z p[

j

Q^F TVZ l\rnPMPbFTV_]_ zhvz j

TYQUƒbGELnPQ^F

j Q n>H!S+Sl‡fƒ'[PXLwxQ nPnPQ n>mRXL[]sRQ nP_PQ^WVWV_xv8e F j

Q^[

ƒ'[cE.hTYn%Q^[5Q^TYnPQ^FnPTYMPb j TYQ mRXL[]\Q^[PQ^TV_PQ^F j Q^F ƒ'bGELnPQ^F tdTVFrn]\Q ncXLF j Q^[PQ j TYQ lprn5EbW j Q n * TYQ^Wj E_PQ^Fh‡

ncE_]wxQ n#t j TYQ (XL[]mRQ^[cE[]\NQ^TV_]pFs!pF j j TYQ [cEFrn]gXL[]Z)E_]TYXLF tREZ wxQ^TV_ ‡pF j E[]\Q^TV_PnPTVFd_PQ^Frn]TVmhn]_PQ^F vLSUTYQ

M^WYQ^mRQ^[PQ (XL[]mRQ^[cE[]\NQ^TV_]pFs

j

Q^[3S!E_PQ^F4\NQ^FrIL_]TVs|_ V|{1‡ l {

j Q n l[]\Q^TV_PncEphg&5EF

j n j Q n+sRQ ncEZq_PQ^F

ƒ'[PXLwxQ ncn ! D u|u|ufv)E+[%F j Q j E1g%[-n]TVF j t j ELnPn'm8TYQ^WYQ (XL[]mRQ^[cE[]\NQ^TV_]pFsRnPnPMPb[]TV_]_PQUFrX8MPb…TVZBZ…Q^[

nPQ^WV\rnP_UK[PXLs|[cEZBZBTYQ^[]_!-Q^[ j Q^FZ!%rnPnPQ^FpF j4j TYQ lprn>EbW'sRQ Q^TVs|FrQ^_PQ^[! lWVsRXL[]TV_]bZ…Q^F4g %[ j TYQ ncQ

(XL[]mRQ^[cE[]\NQ^TV_]pFs j ELn[]sRQ^\FTYnlQ^TVFrQ n †_][]TEW‡ EF j ‡fQ^[][PXL[ ƒ'[PXLwxQ nPnPQ n j E[PnP_PQ^WVWV_xv

S!ELnJ„/TVFTVFs„E[]_lƒ[PX Q^O8_JbGE_UQ nJn]TYMcbCw pZ * TYQ^WsRQ nPQ^_]w _xt j TYQ (XL[]mRQ^[cE[]\Q^TV_]pFs pF j/j TYQ lW‡

sRXL[]TV_]bZ…Q^FGEprn>EbW%w p4mRQ^[PQ^TVFhg†ELMPbrQ^F pF j w p?mRQ^[]\NQ nPnPQ^[]F v SUTYQBe j Q QbTVFd_PQ^[ j Q^Z „/TVFTVs„E[]_

lFrncE_]w \NQ^[]pbd_-Ephg j Q^Z g†EWVWV\GELn]TYQ^[]_PQ^F ˆ8McbWVTYQ RQ^F vdS!ELng†EWVWV\GELn]TYQ^[]_PQlˆ8MPbWVTYQ RQ^F sRQ^bd_ j E mRXLF Eprn#t

j ELnPnqQ nqQ^TVFhg†ELMPbrQ^[qTYnP_xt Q^TVFrQ lphgsdE\NQBw pWYI|nPQ^F t -Q^FF j TYQT I|n]pFs?Q^TVFrQ^[yobFWVTYMPbrQ^F JphgsdE\NQ

\NQ^OLEFF_JTYn]_xv „CTVFTVFs „?E[]_l\TYQ^_PQ^_UQ^TVFrQykJZBsRQ^\pFs<EF t j TYQqQ nJQ^[]WEp\_xt j TYQ (XL[]mRQ^[cE[]\Q^TV_]pFs

j Q^[5S+E_PQ^F j p[PMPbw phg&%b[PQ^F vhSlTYQ j Ew p\NQ^FrIL_]TVs|_PQ^FJolKNQ^[cE_]TYXLFrQ^F -Q^[ j Q^F TVF`rXL[]Z mRXLF4(XL[]mRQ^[ ‡

E[]\NQ^TV_]pFsRn]ORQ^_]_PQ^F Z…X j Q^WVWVTYQ^[]_xv'SUTYQ nPQ (XL[]mRQ^[cE[]\NQ^TV_]pFs|ORQ^_]_PQ^F \NQ^wxQ^TYMPbFrQ^_B„CTVFTVFs4„E[]_yZBTV_

j Q^Z">Q^s|[]T9R`'oWVWYQ|vSlTYQ ncQ!`oWVWYQ-Q^[ j Q^F/Q^\NQ^FrnPX TYQ j TYQ3Q^TVsRQ^F_]WVTYMPbrQ^FS!E_PQ^F<TVFCQ^TVFrQ^Z „?Q^_cE1‡

Z…X j Q^WVWhZ…X j Q^WVWVTYQ^[]_xvTVF \5XLZBKTVWYQ^[%Q^[]Z…ILs|WVTYMPb_ j TYQ Jprn]g %b[]pFs j Q nEWVWYQ nxv|` EWVWVZ…X j Q^WVWYQ ORILFFrQ^F

Ephg'Q^TVFrQ^[ Q^\KWE_]_ giXL[]Z mRQ^[PI;R Q^Fd_]WVTYMcbd_-Q^[ j Q^F v SUTYQ nJQ^[]Z…ILs|WVTYMPb_3EF j Q^[PQ^F ">Q^Fdp_]wxQ^[xt n]TYQ+g&%[

TVb[PQ!Q^TVsRQ^FrQ^F JF -Q^F j pFsRQ^F?w p<Z…X j T9_rw TYQ^[PQ^F v

klFd_PQ^[PnPMcbTYQ j WVTYMPbrQ prQ^WVWYQ^F4n]_PQ^WVWYQ^FefFhgiXL[]Z)E_]TYXLFrQ^Fw pZ „/TVFTVFs „?E[]_+ƒ'[PX ]Q^O_UpF j/j Q^Z „/T‡

FTVFs3„E[]_%ˆ<Z8n]_PQ^Z w p[ (Q^[ g&%s|pFsrv 'TVFBs|p_PQ^[5ˆ_cE[]_]KpFO8_'TYn]_ j TYQ>„/TVFTVFs3„?E[]_ Q^\rnPQ^TV_PQ>pFh‡

_PQ^[ ! "#$rv S+Q^[ „/TVFTVFs „E[]_ JFrncE_]w TV[ j TVF

"%OpF j !$#! z|{|{|zft "%OpF j !$#! z|{|{|}ft % BQ^_JEW†vGz|{|{ D ft

% Q^_JEW†vGz|{|{|{ pF j %&!OpF j % Bz|{|{|{ \NQ nPMcb[]TYQ^\Q^F v

e F j TYQ nPQ^ZaH3EKTV_PQ^W nPXLWVW Q^TVF "J\NQ^[]\WVTYMPO %\NQ^[ j ELn „CTVFTVFs…„E[]_lˆ<Z8nP_PQ^Z sRQ^sRQ^\NQ^F 5Q^[ j Q^F vrSUTYQ

Q^TVFwxQ^WVFrQ^F HJXLZBKNXLFrQ^Fd_PQ^F j Q^[>ˆ<Zhn]_PQ^Z)E[PMcbTV_PQ^O_]p[>mRXLF„/TVFTVFsy„E[]_%pF jj TYQJklZ…nPQ^_]w pFs j Q n

TVZ mRXL[]brQ^[]TVsRQ^F?H3EKTV_PQ^WYn mRXL[]sRQ nPMcbWEsRQ^FrQ^F `meSU` olKNQ^[cE_PXL[Pn5Q^[ j Q^FC\NQ nPMPb[]TYQ^\NQ^F v

J\\TVWj pFs SrvD s|TV\_Q^TVFrQ^F "l\Q^[]\WVTYMcO%\Q^[ j TYQ5ˆ<Z8n]_PQ^Z)E[PMcbTV_PQ^O_]p[mRXLFy„/TVFTVFsJ„E[]_xvxH!Q^[]Fd\NQ ‡

n]_cEF j _PQ^TVW j Q^[ l[PMPbTV_PQ^O8_]p[ TYn]_>Q^TVF<„/Q^_cEZ…X j Q^WVWNg %[>„?Q^_cE j E_PQ^F t j ELn5ncXLsRQ^FGEFFd_PQ3„fSL‡f„/X j Q^WVW†v

S+ELnˆ<Zhn]_PQ^Z \Q n]_PQ^b_Eprn'Q^TVFrQ^Z \5XLZBKTVWYQ^['pF

j

Q^TVFrQ^[s|[cE_GnPMcbrQ^F "5Q^Fp_]wxQ^[PXL\Q^[ oLMcbrQ|t

j

TYQ-mRQ^[ ‡

nPMPbTYQ j Q^FrQ$ j TV_PXL[PQ^Fw p[9(Q^[ g&%s|pFs/nP_PQ^WVWV_xv „CTV_3DlTVWgiQ j Q^[ j TV_PXL[PQ^F ORILFFrQ^F j TYQ…„?Q^_cE j E_PQ^F

EFsRQ^WYQ^s|_ 5Q^[ j Q^F v Q^TV_PQ^[PQ^['">Q n]_cEF j _PQ^TVWTYn]_>Q^TVFrQQ^\KWE_]_ giXL[]Zv JphgsdE\QJpF j `rpFO_]TYXLF j Q n

„/Q^_cEZ…X

j

Q^WVWYnxt

j Q n^\5XLZBKTVWYQ^[Pn-pF j…j

Q^[ Q^\KWE_]_ giXL[]Z 5Q^[

j

Q^FTVZ giXLWVsRQ^F

j

Q^F)FGobrQ^[-Q^[]Wop_PQ^[]_xv

l\\TVWj pFscSrv

D v"J\NQ^[]\WVTYMPO %\Q^[ j ELn „CTVFTVFs„?E[]_lˆ<Zhn]_PQ^Z

' +H',+H' F "2D5 F 952 LC#A6F-2 6F-2 B 2N5 F 952

S!ELnJ„?Q^_cE j E_PQ^FZ…X j Q^WVW „fS j TYQ^Fd_ j Ew p tGe FhgiXL[]Z)E_]TYXLFrQ^F?nPX-XLbW %\Q^[ j TYQ3w p/EFGEWrZhn]TYQ^[PQ^F j Q^F

S!E_PQ^F EWYn EprMcb %\Q^[ j Q^F ƒ'[PXLwxQ nPn j Q^[ TYnPncQ^FrnPQ^Fd_ j Q McOpFs w p n]KNQ^TYMPbrQ^[]F v 'Fd_PnPK[PQ MPbrQ^F j

5Q^[

j

Q^F w 5Q^T' J[]_PQ^F mRXLF S+E_PQ^F pFd_PQ^[PncMPbTYQ

j

n]TYQ5Q^[ j Q^F/TVF/„CTVFTVFs)„E[]_lEWYntE+Q nPMPbGo1g_Pn j E_PQ^F +80:6 ( : :%7 . ,. 5\NQ^wxQ^TYMPbFrQ^_xv * pZ EF j Q^[PQ^F

e FhgXL[]Z)E_]TYXLFrQ^F$%\Q^[ j TYQUˆ8Mcb[]TV_]_PQ|t j TYQ j p[PMPbsRQ g&%b[]_ 5Q^[ j Q^F tdpZ j TYQE+Q nPMcbGo1g_Pn j E_PQ^FTVF)Q^TVFrQ

g&%[

j

ELn T Q^[]FrQ^F sRQ Q^TVs|FrQ^_PQ vJQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TYXLF w p %\NQ^[ g%b[PQ^F v SUTYQ nPQ4e FhgiXL[]Z)E_]TYXLFrQ^F -Q^[

j

Q^F

TVFQ^TVFrQ^Z ` EWVW MxELnPQJgiQ n]_]sRQ^WYQ^s|_xv XUQ^\Q^F j Q^[qklFd_PQ^[PncMPbrQ^Tj pFs j Q^[q\Q^Tj Q^FS!E_PQ^Fd_ ZKNQ^F TV[ j

w TYnPMcbrQ^F4Q^TVFrQ^[UORXLFwxQ^K_]TYXLFrQ^WVWYQ^FpF j Q^TVFrQ^[+[PQ^WE_]TYXLFGEWYQ^F l\rn]_][cEO_]TYXLFrncQ^\Q^FrQ pFd_PQ^[PncMPbTYQ j Q^F v

* p["5Q ncMPb[PQ^TV\pFs j Q^[E+Q nPMcbGo1g_Pn j E_PQ^F Ephg j Q^F \Q^Tj Q^F J\rn]_][cEO8_]TYXLFrnPQ^\NQ^FrQ^F Q7.hTYn]_]TYQ^[]_ j ELn

ORXLFwxQ^K_]TYXLFrQ^WVWYQ4pF j j ELn [PQ^WE_]TYXLFGEWYQS+E_PQ^FZ…X j Q^WVW†v S+Q^[<`GEWVW TV[ j Ephg j Q^[<ORXLFwxQ^K_]prQ^WVWYQ^F

'\NQ^FrQ+TVF`rXL[]Z j Q n ` EWVWVZ…X j Q^WVWYnJZ…X j Q^WVWVTYQ^[]_xv lWVWYQ j [PQ^T „/X j Q^WVWYQ-Q^[ j Q^FCTVZ gXLWVsRQ^F j Q^FFGobrQ^[

Q^[]Wop_PQ^[]_xv

Mp7<* L3j&</-)B3j&<- 9 A- MO7<BP-&'b43j"'- 9

S!ELn ORXLFwxQ^K_]TYXLFrQ^WVWYQS!E_PQ^FZ…X j Q^WVW$ 6 (H ,-8 .%7 . ,. 70(; \NQ^[]pbd_/EphgQ^TVFrQ^[ olFd_PXLWYXLs|TYQ|v

„/TV_qDlTVWgQ j Q^[ olFd_PXLWYXLs|TYQ -Q^[ j Q^F j TYQ E!Q nPMPbGo1g_Pn j E_PQ^FTVF `rXL[]Z mRXLF HJXLFwxQ^K_PQ^F 6 ( H ,:

pF j ">Q^w TYQ^bdpFsRQ^F * (;. ,3 6):G: H: w TYnPMcbrQ^F j Q^F)HlXLFwxQ^K_PQ^FZ…X j Q^WVWVTYQ^[]_xvRSUTYQ nPQ „?X j Q^WVWVTYQ^[]pFs

E\rn]_][cEbTYQ^[]_mRXLF j Q^[_PQ MPbFTYnPMcbrQ^F vJQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TYXLF j Q^[cE+Q nPMPbGo1g_Pn j E_PQ^F TVF j Q^[ S!E_PQ^F\GEFOv

ˆ_cE_]_3E\rn]_][cEO8_PQ^[3S!E_PQ^Fd\GEFO8FGEZ…Q^FORILFFrQ^F4TVZ ORXLFwxQ^K_]prQ^WVWYQ^FS!E_PQ^FZ…X j Q^WVW%mRQ^[Pn]_coF j WVTYMPbrQ

">Q^s|[]T9R Qw p[">Q^wxQ^TYMPbFdpFs j Q^[3HJXLFwxQ^K_PQ|t >_]_][]TV\p_PQ…pF j ">Q^w TYQ^bpFsRQ^FmRQ^[-Q^F j Q^_!-Q^[ j Q^F v

">Q^TYn]KTYQ^WYQyg&%[+HlXLFwxQ^K_PQ…n]TVF j wRv"+v$ pF j ! v 5o[PQ j EFFQ^TVF ">Q^TYn]KTYQ^Wg&%[

Q^TVFrQ ">Q^w TYQ^bdpFs w TYnPMcbrQ^F

j

TYQ nPQ^F \NQ^T

j

Q^F HJXLFwxQ^K_PQ^F vl` %[

j

ELn lFWYQ^sRQ^F pF

j

">QxE[]\Q^TV_PQ^F

j Q nBORXLFwxQ^K_]prQ^WVWYQ^F S!E_PQ^FZ…X j Q^WVWYnn]_PQ^bd_)TVZ „CTVFTVFs „?E[]_ ˆ<Zhn]_PQ^Z j Q^[)HlXLFwxQ^K_PQ j TV_PXL[w p[

(Q^[ g&%s|pFs n]TYQ^brQ l\\TVWj pFsSrvz v

Mp7<*.0- A7<B3j&<7 #- ` 3j"'- 9

SUTYQ3ORXLFwxQ^K_]prQ^WVWYQ'\NQ^FrQ3ZyprnPn!Ephg j TYQqQ^TVsRQ^F_]WVTYMPbrQ^FS!E_PQ^F t TYQyn]TYQ3TVZ [PQ^WE_]TYXLFGEWYQ^F4S+E_PQ^Fh‡

Z…X

Q^F v S!ELn3[PQ^WE_]TYXLFGEWYQ

„?X j Q^WVW'n]KNQ^TYMPbrQ^[]_3e FhgiXL[]Z)E_]TYXLFrQ^F t TYQ j TYQBS!E_PQ^F4TVF j Q^[+S!E_PQ^F\GEFO?sRQ^bGEWV_PQ^F -Q^[ j Q^F v 'TVF

s|[cEKbTYnPMcbrQ^[ j TV_PXL[ pF_PQ^[Pn]_%_]w _ j TYQ l\\TVWj pFs j Q^[ TVZ ORXLFwxQ^K_]prQ^WVWYQ^FCS!E_PQ^FZ…X j Q^WVW Z…X j Q^W‡

WVTYQ^[]_PQ^FCHlXLFwxQ^K_PQ3ZBTV_ TVb[PQ^F >_]_][]TV\p_PQ^F?Ephg j TYQ3Q^Fd_Pn]K[PQ McbrQ^F j Q^F?S!E_PQ^F\GEFO_cE\NQ^WVWYQ^F v

l\\TVWj pFscSrvzhvrS+Q^[ HlXLFwxQ^K_PQ j TV_PXL[

l\\TVW

j

pFscSrv}hvrS+Q^[ `GEWVWYQ

j

TV_PXL[

Mp7<* 7 9 b43j"'- 9

'TVF` EWVWTYn]_+TVF j Q^[ Q^[]ZBTVFrXLWVs|TYQ)mRXLF„sS<Q^TVFrQ l\hgXLWVsRQmRXLF ˆ8MPb[]TV_]_PQ^F v 'TVF ˆ8MPb[]TV_]_3\NQ n]_PQ^bd_

TVF j Q^[ lF 5Q^F j pFsQ^TVFrQ n olKQ^[cE_PXL[Pnxv olKNQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^F?g %b[PQ^FS!E_PQ^Fd_][cEFrn giXL[]Z)E_]TYXLFrQ^F TYQ wRv"+v

SUTYn]O8[PQ^_]TYn]TYQ^[]pFsrt "5Q^bGEF

j

WVpFs mRXLF giQ^bWYQ^F

j

Q^F Q^[]_PQ^F t ls|s|[PQ^sdE_]TYXLF mRXLF >_]_][]TV\p_PQ^F X j Q^[

j TYQ []wxQ^ps|pFsmRXLF ˆ8Q-,prQ^FwxQ^F j p[PMcb v X+ELMPb TVb[PQ^[$ Jprn]sdE\NQCEphg j Q^[)ORXLFwxQ^K_]prQ^WVWYQ^F '\Q ‡

FrQ -Q^[ j Q^F w -Q^T' l[]_PQ^F mRXLF olKNQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^F pF_PQ^[PnPMPbTYQ j Q^F olKNQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^F t j TYQQ^TVF HlXLFwxQ^K_BEWYn

lprn]sdE\NQ…Q^[]wxQ^psRQ^F pF j nPXLWYMcbrQ|t j TYQQ^TVF >_]_][]TV\p_…EWYn lprn]sdE\NQ)Q^[]wxQ^psRQ^F v JWVWYQJolKQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^F

bGE\NQ^Fƒ E[cEZ…Q^_PQ^[xt TYQ!wRv"+v j ELn 'TVFsdE\Q^ORXLFwxQ^K_UX j Q^[ j ELn JprnPsdE\Q >_]_][]TV\p_PQ|v J\\TVWj pFs

SrvS3s|TV\_5Q^TVFrQ^F "l\Q^[]\WVTYMcO%\Q^[ j TYQpolKQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^F t j TYQ TVZ „CTVFTVFs „?E[]_5ˆ<Zhn]_PQ^Z w p[ (Q^[ g%s|pFs

n]_PQ^brQ^F v'e Z `GEWVWVZ…X

j

Q^WVW TV[

j j

TYQ J\hgiXLWVsRQ

j

Q^[ ˆ8MPb[]TV_]_PQ/n]KNQ^w T9_rw TYQ^[]_xv 'TVF s|[cE_GnPMcbrQ^[$

j

TV_PXL[

pF_PQ^[Pn]_%_]w _ j ELn '[Pn]_PQ^WVWYQ^F pF j j ELn$ lFKGELnPnPQ^F mRXLF `'oWVWYQ^F v lp_PXLZ)E_]TYnPMcb %\NQ^[]K[%hg_PQ lFh‡

5Q^F j \GE[]ORQ^TV_Pn]\Q ncMPb[coFO8pFsRQ^FQ7.8TYnP_]TYQ^[PQ^FCg&%[UEWVWYQ olKQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^F v ˆTYQqsRQ 5ob[]WYQ^TYn]_PQ^F t j ELnPnlFdp[

s %WV_]TVsRQ]olKNQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^FORQ^_]_PQ^FQ^[]wxQ^ps|_-Q^[ j Q^F v

l\\TVW

j

pFsSrvSrv)"l\NQ^[]\WVTYMPO %\Q^[

j

TYQ olKQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^F/mRXLFC„CTVFTVFs…„E[]_

' +H'*&(' . 2 B A(C -02 B

S+Q^[<„sS \5XLZBKTVWYQ^[bGE_ j TYQ lphgsdE\NQ|t j TYQmRQ^[PnPMPbTYQ j Q^FrQ^F olKQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^F j Q n<` EWVWVZ…X j Q^WVWYnCTVF

Eprn g&%b[]\GE[PQ nlˆ T4w p %\NQ^[PnPQ^_]wxQ^F vklFd_PQ^[Pn]_%_]w _ TV[j<j TYQ nPQ JphgsdE\NQ j p[PMcb?ˆKNQ^w T9_rOLE_]TYXLFrQ^F t

j TYQTVFh‡%pF j lprn]sdE\QqQ^TVFrQ nolKNQ^[cE_PXL[Pn j Q_rFTYQ^[PQ^F v * pZ ">Q^TYn]KTYQ^W Q^[]bGoWV_lQ^TVF olKQ^[cE_PXL[xt j Q^[

g&%[UQ^TVF4\NQ n]_]TVZBZy_PQ n >_]_][]TV\p_qEWVWYQ pKNQ^W'ZBTV_+gQ^bWYQ^F j Q^F Q^[]_PQ^FQ^F_ gQ^[]F_xt EWYn'TVFsdE\Q j Q^F

X+EZ…Q^F j Q n >_]_][]TV\p_PQ nxv JWYn JprnPsdE\QqWVTYQ gQ^[]_UQ^[UQ^TVF/FrQ^prQ nlHlXLFwxQ^K_xvSUTYQ S!E_PQ^Fd\GEFO8_cE\Q^WVWYQ

w p j

TYQ nPQ^ZaHJXLFwxQ^K_ Q^F_]bGoWV_ Fdp[ pKQ^W XLbFrQUgiQ^bWYQ^F

j Q Q^[]_PQUg&%[

j

ELn n]KQ^w T9_rw TYQ^[]_PQ >_]_][]TV\p_xv

' +H'*)(' .102 2 95 5%A-BC

* pZ „CTVFTVFs„E[]_Bˆ<Zhn]_PQ^Z sRQ^brIL[]_BQ^TVFrQwxQ^Fd_][cEWYQ Q^\KWE_]_ giXL[]Zv'SlTYQ ncQ Q^\KWE_]_ giXL[]Z Q^[ ‡

Z…ILs|WVTYMcbd_ j Q^FI;RNQ^F_]WVTYMPbrQ^F lprn]_cEprnPMPbpF j j TYQ-S+XLO8pZ…Q^Fd_cE_]TYXLFBmRXLFBQ7.hKXL[]_]TYQ^[]_PQ^FB`'oWVWYQ^F v* p[

(Q^[PI;R Q^Fd_]WVTYMcbdpFsQ^TVFrQ n ` EWVWYQ nJEphg j Q^[ Q^\KWE_ giXL[]Z-Q^[ j Q^FFp[ j TYQUORXLFwxQ^K_]TYXLFrQ^WVWYQ^F/„?Q^_cE1‡

j E_PQ^F j Q n>`GEWVWYQ n %\Q^[]_][cEsRQ^F v ">Q^Fdp_]wxQ^[xt j TYQlTVZ vJQ^KNX|n]TV_PXL[aZBFGELMPb [PQ^WYQ^m|EFd_PQ^F`'oWVWYQ^F<n]prMPbrQ^F t

5Q^[ j Q^F j p[PMPb?Q^TVFrQ!FGE m8TVs|TYQ^[]\GE[PQ vlQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLF j Q^[ ORXLFwxQ^K_]prQ^WVWYQ^F/„?X j Q^WVWYQ3pFd_PQ^[Pn]_%_]w _xv

">Q^Tj Q!TVFH3EKTV_PQ^W} TVZ J\rncMPbFTV_]_U}hvSrvzBmRXL[]sRQ n]_PQ^WVWV_PQ^F/„?ILs|WVTYMPbORQ^TV_PQ^F?w p[ „/Q^[]O8Z)EWYn]sRQ^FrQ^[]TYQ ‡

[]pFsZBTV_…DlTVWgQ mRXLF `me S+` p[ j Q^F EWYnBHJXLFwxQ^K_PXLKNQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^F TVF „/TVFTVFs4„?E[]_B[PQxEWVTYn]TYQ^[]_xv

HlXLFwxQ^K_PXLKQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^F Q^[]bGEWV_PQ^F EWVWYQ)EWYn 'TVFsdE\NQ…Q^TVFHJXLFwxQ^K_ypF j Q^[]wxQ^psRQ^FZBTVF j Q n]_PQ^Frn3Q^TVF

ZBTV_ j Q^Z JprnPsdE\Q^ORXLFwxQ^K_<mRQ^[]O8F %Khg_PQ nf\5XLWVpZBF ˆ8Q^_xv SUTYQ„sSL‡ E\Q^WVWYQ oUƒ $ ƒ v U„ˆ $

ƒE[cEZ…Q^_PQ^[]FGEZ…Q ol\]Q^O8_]_ Z8K Z8K

>brQ e FKp_,\5XLFrM Q^K_ HlXLFwxQ^K_ 'TVFsdE\Q

>brQ#ˆ8Q^WYQ M^_PQ j >_]_][]TV\p_PQ n >_]_][]TV\p_]WVTYn]_PQ 'TVFsdE\Q

>brQ >TVZ…Q#ˆ_cEZBK >_]_][]TV\p_ 'TVFsdE\Q

>brQ H!QZ >_]_][]TV\p_ 'TVFsdE\Q

>brQ olp_]Kp_,\5XLFrM Q^K_ HlXLFwxQ^K_ lprn]sdE\Q

E\Q^WVWYQ Srv

D vGƒ E[cEZ…Q^_PQ^[Pn]KNQ^w T9_rO|E_]TYXLFrQ^F/g&%[ j TYQ `me S+` olKNQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^FTVFC„/TVFTVFs)„E[]_

Q^F_]bGoWV_ j TYQƒE[cEZ…Q^_PQ^[Pn]KNQ^w T9_rOLE_]TYXLF4g&%[ Q j Q^FNolKQ^[cE_PXL[xv E\Q^WVWYQ SrvD s|TV\_UQ^TVFrQ^F "l\Q^[]\WVTYMcO

%\NQ^[ j TYQ)ƒE[cEZ…Q^_PQ^[xt j TYQ j TYQ)FrQ^prQ^FFolKNQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^F EWYn!'TVFsdE\NQQ^[>E[]_PQ^F \w 3vEWYn lprn]sdE\NQ

Q^[]wxQ^psRQ^F vSUQ^[yƒ E[cEZ…Q^_PQ^[ 2:( (;( , (/7 34,2,-* ;89,( :<Q^Fd_]bGoWV_ j TYQT TYnP_PQ j Q^[ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ|t g%[ j TYQ

`nmeS+` „/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ)Q^[]wxQ^ps|_-Q^[

j

Q^F nPXLWVWYQ^F v 2:( (;TYn]_

j

Q^[Bˆ8MPbW%rnPnPQ^W†t

j

Q^[qQ^TVFrQ!*Q^TV_][PQ^TVbrQ

Tj Q^Fd_]T9_rw TYQ^[]_xv 2: ( ( ,. H/TYn]_ j ELn >_]_][]TV\p_xt j ELn j TYQ *Q^TV_]KpFO8_PQ j Q^[ *Q^TV_][PQ^TVbrQyEFs|TV\_xv

SUTYQ lF -Q^F

j

\GE[]ORQ^TV_ mRXLF `me SU`<EWYn olKNQ^[cE_PXL[ w p[ „?Q^[]O8Z)EWYn]sRQ^FrQ^[]TYQ^[]pFs g&%[ *Q^TV_ ‡wm '[PQ^TVs|FTYn][PQ^TVbrQ^F

TV[ j EF?Q^TVFrQ^Z `GEWVWV\Q^TYnPKTYQ^W pF_PQ^[Pn]prMPb_xv nJbGEF j Q^WV_!n]TYMcbCpZ _PQ^ZBKXL[cEWYQ S!E_PQ^F %\NQ^[ (Q^[Pn]T‡

McbrQ^[]pFsRn]mRQ^[]_][cosRQqpF j ƒE[]_]FrQ^[ j Q^[ vJQ^Fd_PQ^FGEFrnP_cEWV_+ˆ TYnPn T TgQ|v

">Q^mRXL[ j TYQ/S!E_PQ^F j Q^_cETVWVWVTYQ^[]_<\Q nPMcb[]TYQ^\Q^F -Q^[ j Q^F t TV[ j w pFGoLMPbrnP_ j TYQ`[cEsRQ nP_PQ^WVWVpFs mRXL[ ‡

sRQ n]_PQ^WVWV_xvn…giXLWVs|_)Q^TVFrQ<O8p[]wxQCS!E[Pn]_PQ^WVWVpFs mRXLF EF j Q^[PQ^F J[]\NQ^TV_PQ^F w p[$ lFGEWrZhnPQ j Q^[ ˆ TYnPn

T TgiQ ‡fS!E_PQ^F v

S!EFGELMPb -Q^[ j Q^F j TYQ j p[PMcbsRQ g%b[]_PQ^F /.hKQ^[]TVZ…Q^F_PQyQ^[]Wop_PQ^[]_xvSUTYQ!FrXL_ 5Q^F j TVsRQ (XL[]mRQ^[cE[]\Q^T‡

_]pFs j Q^[S!E_PQ^F p[ j Q/ZBTV_DlTVWgiQ j Q nTVF H3EKTV_PQ^WSmRXL[]sRQ n]_PQ^WVWV_PQ^F „CTVFTVFs „E[]_ ‡ ˆ<Z8n]_PQ^Z…n

mRXL[]sRQ^FrXLZBZ…Q^F v-SlTYQ<Q^TVFwxQ^WVFrQ^F ˆ8MPb[]TV_]_PQ -Q^[ j Q^F TVF l\rnPMcbFTV_]_ VhvSrvD \NQ nPMPb[]TYQ^\NQ^F v%SUTYQ lFh‡

5Q^F j pFs j Q^[ T Q^[]FdmRQ^[ g†Eb[PQ^F?Ephg j TYQUmRXL[]mRQ^[cE[]\Q^TV_PQ^_PQ^F?S!E_PQ^FQ^[ g XLWVs|_PQ!ZBTV_ DlTVWgiQlmRXLF>= T

% "# Q^_UEW†vrz|{|{ D t %) ! # )Q^_JEW†vGz|{|{|zfv lphg

j

TYQ4S+Q^_cETVWYn TV[

j

TVF l\rnPMPbFTV_]_sVhvSrvz

Q^TVFsRQ^sdEFsRQ^F v efF l\rnPMPbFTV_]_VhvSrv}-Q^[ j Q^F j TYQ3Q^[]w TYQ^WV_PQ^F '[]sRQ^\FTYnPncQ3mRXL[]sRQ n]_PQ^WVWV_xv

SUTYQ sRQ nP_PQ^WVWV_PQ lphgsdE\NQ \NQ n]_PQ^b_ j E[]TVF t j Q^FZ…ILs|WVTYMcbrQ^F v%rMcOO|Ephg Q^TVFrQ^[ (Q^[PnPTYMPbrQ^[]pFs…Eprn j Q^F

(Q^[Pn]TYMcbrQ^[]pFsRn j E_PQ^F mRXL[]brQ^[]w prncEsRQ^F v-klFd_PQ^[Q^TVFrQ^Z v%rMcOO|Ephg!mRQ^[Pn]_PQ^bd_Z)EF j TYQ<mRXL[]wxQ^TV_]TVsRQ

">Q Q^F j TVs|pFs3Q^TVFrQ^[OLEKTV_cEWV\TVWj Q^F j Q^FT Q^\Q^Frn]mRQ^[PnPTYMPbrQ^[]pFs5Q^sRQ^Fv%rMPO8_][]TV_]_'X j Q^['H%F j TVs|pFsrv

S+Q^Z (Q^[Pn]TYMcbrQ^[]pFsRn]FrQ^bZ…Q^[TYn]_ TVFqQ^TVFrQ^Z nPXLWYMPbrQ^F`GEWVW j Q^[EO_]prQ^WVWYQ *Q^TV_ 5Q^[]_ j Q^[ (Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFs

Eprn]w pw#EbWYQ^F v ` %[JQ^TVFrQ (Q^[Pn]TYMcbrQ^[]pFsRn]sRQ nPQ^WVWYnPMcbGE1g_+\NQ

j

Q^p_PQ^Ffv%rMcOO|ophgiQ+TVZBZ…Q^[lQ^TVF8(Q^[]WVprn]_ ‡

sRQ nPMcbGo1g_xt j EOp[]w^g []TYn]_]TVs)H3EKTV_cEW \Q nPMcbGER_ -Q^[ j Q^F?ZqprnPn \w 3v Q^Fd_Pn]K[PQ McbrQ^F j Qy` TVFGEFw ZBTV_]_PQ^W

FTYMcbd_JWoFsRQ^[ g []TYn]_]TVs…pF jCj EZBTV_ sRQ TVFFd\[]TVFsRQ^F j EFsRQ^WYQ^s|_ 5Q^[ j Q^FCORILFFrQ^F v

SUp[PMPb H+WELnPn]T9_rO|E_]TYXLF j Q^[9(Q^[PnPTYMPbrQ^[]pFsRn]mRQ^[]_][cosRQ TVFw 5Q^TiEU[]pKKNQ^F TV[ j mRQ^[Pn]prMPb_xt j TYQBsRQ ‡

n]_PQ^WVWV_PQ lphgsdE\NQ)w p WYI|nPQ^F vSUTYQ Q^TVFrQ E+[]pKKQ \NQ^TVFbGEWV_PQ^_ j TYQ (Q^[]_][cosRQ|t j TYQ\Q^[PQ^TV_Pnw p[%rMcOd‡

sRQ^O|Ephg_ p[

j

Q^F t j TYQEF

j

Q^[PQsE+[]pKKQ \NQ^TVFbGEWV_PQ^_

j

TYQ (Q^[]_][cosRQ|t

j

TYQ [PQ^sRQ^WV[PQ MPb_…giXL[]_]sRQ g%b[]_

p[ j Q^F v S!ELn j p[PMPb j TYQBQ^[ giXLWVs|_PQBH+W ELnPn]T9_rO|E_]TYXLFsRQ -XLFFrQ^FrQ TYnPncQ^F t O|EFF j Ew p4mRQ^[-Q^F j Q^_

5Q^[ j Q^F t|H+pF j Q^FBw pyTj Q^F_]T9_rw TYQ^[PQ^F t j Q^[PQ^F (Q^[]_][cosRQ>[%rMPO8OLEphgsRQ g†ob[ j Q^_n]TVF j vLSlTYQ nQ^[]Z…ILs|WVTYMcbd_

Q nxt1„?E[]ORQ^_]TVFsRnP_][cE_PQ^s|TYQ^FBw p Q^F_ TYMPORQ^WVF t j Q^F v %rMPO8OLEphgrw p mRQ^[]bTVF j Q^[]FpF jyj TYQ-TVZ ">Q j E[ gin g†EWVW

+ / 9

FrXL_ -Q^F

j

TVsRQ^Ff_rFGEFw TYQ^WVWYQ^Ffv %rMPO8WEsRQ^Fw p\NQ^[PQ MPbFrQ^F v

SlTYQ w p[ (Q^[ g&%s|pFssRQ n]_PQ^WVWV_PQ^FS!E_PQ^Fn]TVF j TVFQ^TVFrQ^[]ov O\ T ‡fS!E_PQ^Fd\GEFO4sRQ nPKQ^TYMcbrQ^[]_xv ˆTYQ

n]_PQ^WVWV_ Q^TVFrQ^F JprnPw psBEprn j Q^ZaS+E_cE5E[PQ^brXLprnPQqmRXLF/ˆ TYnPn T TgiQ j E[xv * p[ S!E_PQ^Fd\GEFO sRQ^brIL[PQ^F

TVFrn]sRQ ncEZq_ D z E\NQ^WVWYQ^F t j

TYQ %\NQ^[ D VfvJQ^WE_]TYXLFrQ^F ZBTV_PQ^TVFGEF

j

Q^[BmRQ^[]O8F %Khg_nPTVF

j v l\\TVW

j

pFs

VhvD s|TV\_ Q^TVFrQ^F "J\NQ^[]\WVTYMPO$%\Q^[ j ELn>S!E_PQ^Fd\GEFOhnPMPbrQ^Z)EhvrS!ELn E\sRQ^\TVWj Q^_PQ!S!E_PQ^Fd\GEFOhnPMPbrQ^Z)E

TYn]_+mRQ^[]s|WYQ^TYMPbd\GE[ ZBTV_ j Q^Z TVF < 4Q^_lEW†v D u|u l \NQ nPMPb[]TYQ^\NQ^FrQ^F ˆ8McbrQ^Z)Ehv S+XL[]_ TV[ j4j ELn

S+E_cE5E[PQ^brXLprnPQymRXLF/ˆ TYnPn T Tg Q!mRXL[]sRQ nP_PQ^WVWV_xv

efF j Q^[ E\Q^WVWYQ…„@o%$ (+( v nPTVF j4j TYQ (Q^[]_][cosRQ…sRQ n]KNQ^TYMPbrQ^[]_xv SUTYQ E\Q^WVWYQ…bGE_qz|}CˆKGEWV_PQ^F

pF j D

S)W|uBuKu

l

*Q^TVWYQ^F v E\Q^WVWYQ Vhv

D

s|TV\_JQ^TVFrQ^F "l\Q^[]\WVTYMcO %\NQ^[ j TYQ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ j TYQ ncQ^[ E\NQ^WVWYQ

pF j Q^[]Wop_PQ^[]_JTVb[PQ">Q j Q^p_]pFsrv

l

uhvAV EWVWYQ^[ (Q^[]_][cosRQqn]TVF j H3EKTV_cEWVWYQ^\NQ^Frn]mRQ^[Pn]TYMcbrQ^[]pFsRQ^F t-Q^TV_PQ^[PQ9(Q^[PnPTYMPbrQ^[]pFsRncE[]_PQ^Fn]TVF j

vJQ^Fd_PQ^FmRQ^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRQ^Fi}hvl trH+[cEFORQ^FmRQ^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRQ^F i{hvAW t '[-Q^[]\rn]pFhg†obTVs|ORQ^TV_Pn]mRQ^[Pn]T‡

MPbrQ^[]pFsRQ^F izhvAV >pF j `rXLF j n]sRQ^\pF j Q^FrQ T Q^\NQ^Frn]mRQ^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRQ^F#i}hvAW v

'TVFCQ^TVFwxQ^WVFrQ^[ (Q^[]_][cEs\Q nP_PQ^bd_lEprnlQ^TVFrQ^Z X j Q^[JZ…Q^b[PQ^[PQ^F=(Q^[]_][cEsRn]_PQ^TVWYQ^F t j Q^FCnPXLsRQ^FGEFF_PQ^F

E[]TgORXLZBKXLFrQ^F_PQ^F v e F j Q^F E[]TgORXLZBKXLFrQ^F_PQ^F -Q^[ j Q^F j TYQ!ORXLFO8[PQ^_PQ^F8(Q^[]_][cEsRn]ORXLF j TV_]TYXLFrQ^F

gQ n]_]sRQ^WYQ^s|_xv * pQ^TVFrQ^Z (Q^[]_][cEsCsRQ^brIL[PQ^F j p[PMPbrnPMcbFTV_]_]WVTYMPb w -Q^T E[]TgORXLZBKXLFrQ^F_PQ^F vˆTYQ…n]TVF j

TVF

j

Q^[ S+E_PQ^F\GEFO TVF

j

Q^[E\NQ^WVWYQ3„ o%$ `H oU„?ƒ E\sRQ^WYQ^s|_xv SlTYQ ncQ E\NQ^WVWYQ+bGE_l} D ˆKGEWV_PQ^F

pF j z D u;S l z V vJQ^TVbrQ^F v

SlTYQ E\NQ^WVWYQ+„ o%$ ƒ v Q^F_]bGoWV_ efFhgiXL[]Z)E_]TYXLFrQ^F %\Q^[ (Q^[Pn]TYMcbrQ^[]pFsRn]_PQ^TVWVFrQ^bZ…Q^[xvˆ TYnPniT TgiQ

\Q^wxQ^TYMcbFrQ^_5EWVWYQ (Q^[Pn]TYMcbrQ^[]pFsRn]_PQ^TVWVFrQ^bZ…Q^[ EWYnƒ E[]_]FrQ^[xv8SUTYQ ƒ E[]_]FrQ^[ -Q^[ j Q^F %\Q^[ vlXLWVWYQ^F j Q^F

(Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRn]mRQ^[]_][cosRQ^F4w psRQ XL[ j FrQ^_xv n TV[ j w TYnPMPbrQ^Fm8TYQ^[ l[]_PQ^F/mRXLF vJXLWVWYQ^F?pFd_PQ^[PnPMcbTYQ ‡

j Q^F

•

(Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRnPFrQ^bZ…Q^[

S+Q^[ (Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRnPFrQ^bZ…Q^[lTYn]_ j Q^[lƒ E[]_]FrQ^[xt j Q^[ ZBTV_ j Q^Z (Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRnPpFd_PQ^[]FrQ^bZ…Q^F

j

Q^F8(Q^[Pn]TYMcbrQ^[]pFsRn]mRQ^[]_][cEs<E\rnPMPbWVTYnPnP_xv

•

(Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]_PQyƒQ^[PncXLF

SUTYQ4(Q^[PnPTYMPbrQ^[]_PQ ƒQ^[PncXLF TYn]_ j Q^[ƒ E[]_]FrQ^[xtEphg j Q nPnPQ^F v TYn]TVORX j TYQ4(Q^[Pn]TYMcbrQ^[]pFsE\sRQ ‡

nPMcbWYX|nPnPQ^F p[ j Q|v

•

ƒ'[coZBTYQ^Fw#EbWYQ^[

S+Q^[ ƒ'[coZBTYQ^Fw#EbWYQ^[UTYn]_ j Q^[JƒE[]_]FrQ^[xt j Q^[ j TYQ3ƒ[coZBTYQ^FC\NQ^w#EbWV_xv

J\\TVW

j

pFsJVhvD vrS!E_PQ^Fd\GEFOhnPMPbrQ^Z)E

+ / 9

E\Q^WVWYQ VhvD v ">Q nPMPb[PQ^TV\pFs j Q^[ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ3TVF j Q^[ E\WVWYQq„@o%$ ( (v

J\\TVWj pFs Vhvzhv JprnPw ps j Q^[ E\NQ^WVWYQ3„@o%$ ( (v

•

">Q^s %Frn]_]TVs|_PQ^[

SUQ^[ "5Q^s %FrnP_]TVs|_PQ TYn]_ j Q^[%ƒE[]_]FrQ^[xt j Q^[%\Q^TG`'oWVWVTVs|ORQ^TV_ j TYQ (Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRnPWYQ^TYn]_]pFs Q^[]bGoWV_xv

(Q^[PnPMcbTYQ j Q^FrQ)ƒE[]_]FrQ^[3ORILFFrQ^FTVZ vUEbZ…Q^FQ^TVFrQ n (Q^[]_][cEsRQ n j TYQs|WYQ^TYMcbrQcvlXLWVWYQ…Eprn%\Q^F t ncX

O|EFF…Q nwRv"+v|w -Q^T ">Q^s %Frn]_]TVs|_PQ sRQ^\Q^F v '\NQ^FrnPX!O|EFF…Q^TVFBpF j…j Q^[PnPQ^WV\NQ ƒE[]_]FrQ^[%Z…Q^b[PQ^[PQ vlXLW‡

WYQ^F TVFFrQ^bGE\Q^F v TVFrQUƒ Q^[PnPXLF O|EFFwRv"+v (Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRnPFrQ^bZ…Q^[ pF j ƒ'[coZBTYQ^Fw#EbWYQ^[ nPQ^TVF vhSUTYQ

* prXL[ j FpFsyw TYnPMcbrQ^F j Q^F)ƒE[]_]FrQ^[]F t j Q^FcvJXLWVWYQ^F…pF j)j Q^F4(Q^[]_][cosRQ^F)sRQ ncMPbTYQ^bd_5ZBTV_%DlTVWgQ j Q^[

E\Q^WVWYQU„ o%$ ƒ vOv oTv8DUEF j Q^WV_>Q n-nPTYMPb \Q^TQ^TVFrQ^Z ƒE[]_]FrQ^[>pZ j TYQ (Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]_PQ+ƒ Q^[PnPXLF tncX

Q^F_]bGoWV_ j TYQ E\NQ^WVWYQl„@o%$ `8v oTe FhgXL[]Z)E_]TYXLFrQ^F %\NQ^[ j TYQ TVb[-w psRQ^_PQ^TVWV_PQ^F E[]TgORXLZBKXLFrQ^Fh‡

_PQ^F v

SUTYQ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ mRXLF (Q^[]_][cosRQ^F t E[]TgORXLZBKXLFrQ^F_PQ^F pF

j

vJXLWVWYQ^F ORILFFrQ^F 5ob[PQ^F j j

Q^[ (Q^[ ‡

_][cEsRn]WEphgwxQ^TV_5sRQxoF j Q^[]_ 5Q^[ j Q^F vhkJZ Z…ILs|WVTYMPbrQJF j Q^[]pFsRQ^F FGELMcbbGEWV_PQ^F<w p)ORILFFrQ^F thn]TVF j)j TYQ

pKQ^W j Q^[ E\Q^WVWYQ^F4„@o%$ ` H oU„?ƒ t„@o%$ (+( v pF j „@o%$ ƒ vOv oT wxQ^TV_]WVTYMPbsRQ n]_PQ^Z‡

KNQ^WV_xvde F EWVWYQ^F j [PQ^T E\Q^WVWYQ^F s|TV\_>Q n ]Q -Q^TVWYn5w 5Q^T >_]_][]TV\p_PQ|t j TYQ j Q^F E %WV_]TVs|ORQ^TV_PnPwxQ^TV_][cEpZaQ^T‡

FrQ n pKNQ^WYn5EFsRQ^\NQ^F v 5RQ j Q n pKNQ^W TVF „ o%$ `H oU„?ƒth„@o%$ ( (v \w 3v„@o%$ ƒ vOv oT

[PQ^K[coLnPQ^F_]TYQ^[]_%nPXLZBTV_Q^TVFrQ^F * prn]_cEF j Q^TVFrQ^[ E[]TgORXLZBKNXLFrQ^Fd_PQ|tQ^TVFrQ n (Q^[]_][cEsRQ n'\w 3v|Q^TVFrQ^[vlXLW‡

WYQ|v * p Q^TVFrQ^Z (Q^[]_][cEsrt5Q^TVFrQ^[ E[]Tg ORXLZBKXLFrQ^F_PQX

j

Q^[ Q^TVFrQ^[cvJXLWVWYQ<sRQ^brIL[PQ^F Z…Q^b[PQ^[PQ pKQ^W

TVF j Q^[Q^F_Pn]K[PQ MPbrQ^F j Q^F E\Q^WVWYQ|v E\Q^WVWYQ „@o%$ ( (v Q^Fd_]bGoWV_ g %[ Q j Q^F (Q^[]_][cEs j p[PMPbh‡

nPMcbFTV_]_]WVTYMPb nPQ MPbrn pKNQ^WrpF j E\NQ^WVWYQ „@o%$ `H oU„/ƒ Q^Fd_]bGoWV_%g %[ ]Q j Q'E[]TgORXLZBKXLFrQ^F_PQUTVZ

SUp[PMPbrncMPbFTV_]_Jm8TYQ^[ pKNQ^W†v

+ / 9

J\\TVW

j

pFssVhvz mRQ^[

j

Q^p_]WVTYMcbd_

j

ELn!ƒ[]TVFw TVK

j

Q^[ pKNQ^WVwxQ^TV_Pn]_PQ^ZBKNQ^WVpFs/EFbGEF

j

Q^TVFrQ n lprn]w psRn

j Q^[ E\NQ^WVWYQy„@o%$ (+( v !v SlTYQ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ (+( e (poX pF j ( ( e ">e ˆsRQ^\NQ^F j Q^F@E %WV_]TVsL‡

ORQ^TV_Pn]wxQ^TV_][cEpZ Q^TVFrQ n pKQ^WYn EF vS!E[%\Q^[)bTVFGEprn j XLO8pZ…Q^Fd_]TYQ^[]_ j ELn >_]_][]TV\p_ j Q^F [cEFrn‡

EO_]TYXLFrn]wxQ^TV_]KpFO8_xt j vb v j Q^F *Q^TV_]KpFO_…w p j Q^Z Q^TVFrQ JF j Q^[]pFs „Cp_cE_]TYXLF j p[PMPbsRQ g&%b[]_

p[ j Q|v S!ELn >_]_][]TV\p_ (+( XUS pv Q^[]Wop_PQ^[]_ j Q^FE+[]pF j g%[ ]Q j Q j p[PMPbsRQ g&%b[]_PQlF j Q ‡

[]pFsrvSUTYQ E+[%F j Qn]TVF j j p[PMPbFXlpZBZ…Q^[]F ORX j TYQ^[]_xv lFbGEF j j Q^[! l\\TVWj pFs TV[j j TYQ„/ph‡

_cE_]TYXLFrn]sRQ nPMPbTYMcbd_PQ)w -Q^TYQ^[9(Q^[]_][cosRQ j E[]sRQ nP_PQ^WVWV_xv kJZ j TYQ pKQ^W j Q^[!\NQ^Tj Q^F(Q^[]_][cosRQB\NQ nPnPQ^[

mRXLFrQ^TVFGEF j Q^[qpFd_PQ^[PncMPbrQ^Tj Q^F w pORILFFrQ^F t nPTVF jj TYQ pKNQ^W%TVF j Q^[ J\\TVWj pFs/pFd_PQ^[PnPMcbTYQ j WVTYMPb

giE[]\WVTYMcb?Z)E[]O8TYQ^[]_xv JWVWYQ pKQ^W g&%[ j Q^F (Q^[]_][cEs ZBTV_ j Q^[+(Q^[PnPTYMPbrQ^[]pFsRn]FpZBZ…Q^[ D W;Sdz|} n]TVF j

_%[]OTYn5bTVFd_PQ^[]WYQ^s|_ pF j EWVWYQ pKNQ^WGg&%[ j Q^F (Q^[]_][cEsZBTV_ j Q^[ (Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRn]FpZBZ…Q^[pV|{

D W n]TVF j

mTYXLWYQ^_]_>bTVFd_PQ^[]WYQ^s|_xvG` %[>\NQ^Tj Q+(Q^[]_][cosRQ!Q7.8TYn]_]TYQ^[PQ^FncQ MPbrn''TVF_][cosRQ!TVF j Q^[ E\Q^WVWYQ|t j vb vh\NQ^Tj Q

(Q^[]_][cosRQ p[ j Q^Fg&%FhgZ)EW sRQxoF j Q^[]_xv

'*&(',+-'365 950 50 9E2 0 ?2 9E %52 "F-2 B. 952

SlTYQ!S!E_PQ^FCnPTVF j<j p[PMPbgiXLWVsRQ^F j Q3n]_cE_]TYnP_]TYnPMPbrQTVsRQ^FrnPMPbGE1g _PQ^FCsRQ^ORQ^FFwxQ^TYMcbFrQ^_(

•

^{d Rd#x d1x €**1 #?&A.G ,", hx7}

v%rMcOO|Ephg \Q^_][]T9RN_qFp[ u8v3u EWVWYQ^[ (Q^[]_][cosRQ|v SUTYQ%(Q^[]_PQ^TVWVpFs j Q^[q[%rMPO8sRQ^O|Ephg_PQ^F (Q^[ ‡

_][cosRQ!O|EFF<Z)EFTVZ ˆTVFFrQ!mRXLF % Q^_JEW†vGz|{|{

D

EWYn mRQ^[]wxQ^[][]_PQ9(Q^[]_PQ^TVWVpFs)\NQ^wxQ^TYMPbFrQ^F v

•

^{I- 2, )*&# rd} U'1G+2&A-  †(&xr€

e Frn]sRQ ncEZq_Js|TV\_ Q n D D[l

>_]_][]TV\p_PQ|vQ^FFCZ)EF j TYQQ^[]_PQ j Q^[ FrXLZBTVFGEWYQ^F >_]_][]TV\p_PQ3TVF

w prnco_]w WVTYMcbrQJ\TVFGo[PQ >_]_][]TV\p_PQJ_][cEFrn giXL[]ZBTYQ^[PQ^F '%[

j

Q|t'%[

j Q Z)EF z D[lD Sd{ D >_]_][]TV\p_PQ

Q^[]bGEWV_PQ^F vde F)nPX!Q^TVFrQ^Z brXMcb j TVZ…Q^Frn]TYXLFGEWYQ^F 'TVsRQ^FrnPMPbGE1g_Pn][cEpZ mRQ^[PncEsRQ^F„?Q^_]brX j Q^F j Q^[

m8TYn]prQ^WVWYQ^FCS!E_PQ^FTVFrn]KNQ^O_]TYXLFpF j n]_cE_]TYn]_]TYnPMcbrQ3„/Q^_]brX j Q^F v

•

^{L'- )&xRRx} +'1G)*&(- f(& ).NxG)

%[ j QqZ)EF j TYQ! lprn]K[cos|pFsRQ^FEWVWYQ^[ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ TVF?\TVFGo[PQ! >_]_][]TV\p_PQy_][cEFrn giXL[]ZBTYQ^[PQ^F t

Q^[]bTYQ^WV_PQ!Z)EFCnPKGo[]WVTYMPbC\NQ nPQ^_]w _PQ 'TVsRQ^FrncMPbGE1g_Pn]mRQ^O_PXL[PQ^F v

SlTYQ ncQ 'TVsRQ^FrncMPbGE1g_PQ^FZ)ELMPbrQ^F j TYQ+HJXLZBKWYQ7.hTV_co_ j Q^[ S!E_PQ^F j Q^p_]WVTYMPb vSUTYQ9*Q^TV_Pn]_PQ^ZBKWVpFs j Q^[

S+E_PQ^F Q^[]brILbd_ j TYQlHJXLZBKWYQ7.hTV_co_'-Q^TV_PQ^[xvh` %[ j TYQT I|n]pFs j Q^[ lphgsdE\NQ Z!%rnPnPQ^F j TYQpvlXLb j E_PQ^F

TVFQ^TVFrQ^FC„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYn][cEpZ%\NQ^[]_][cEsRQ^F 5Q^[ j Q^F t Ephg j Q^FsT Q^[]FmRQ^[ giEb[PQ^F4EF 5Q^F j \GE[Un]TVF j v

SUTYQ-\Q nPMcb[]TYQ^\Q^FrQ^F)ˆ TYnPn8T TgiQ ‡fS!E_PQ^F5E[PQ^F\Q^[PQ^TV_Pn w 5Q^TVZ)EWE+Q^sRQ^Frn]_cEF j mRXLF lFGEWrZhnPQ^F vLˆ8X‡

5XLbW

j

TYQ5ƒ'[PX ]Q^O_]s|[]pKKNQ Sd{|z 5 &) !$# ! ?Q^_JEW†vGz|{|{|zft

j

TYQ%TVZ TVFd_PQ^[PnPQ^Z…Q n]_PQ^[z|{|{ D mLz|{|{|z

pF j TVZ ˆ8XLZBZ…Q^[PnPQ^Z…Q n]_PQ^[3z|{|{|z EZ T Q^b[PnP_]pbW g&%[lH%Frn]_]WVTYMcbrQefF_PQ^WVWVTVsRQ^Fw j Q nU`GELMPb\Q^[PQ^TYMcbrn

e FhgXL[]Z)E_]TVO j Q^[ kJFTVmRQ^[Pn]TV_co_ S+XL[]_]ZqpF j n]_cE_]_ g†EF j t1EWYnEprMcb 5dQ^Frn` TYnPnPQ^WYQ^[ TVFynPQ^TVFrQ^[ SlTVKWYXLZ)E[ ‡

\NQ^TV_ lF 5Q^F

j

pFs…Q^TVFrQ n S!E_cEq„/TVFTVFsL‡(Q^[ giEb[PQ nlEphg (Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRn

j

E_PQ^F+ % ) ) !0)4z|{|{|}

\NQ giELncn]_PQ^F<n]TYMPb<ZBTV_ j TYQ nPQ^F/S+E_PQ^F v ">Q^Tj Q l[]\NQ^TV_PQ^F<\Q^[%rMcO8n]TYMcbd_]TVsRQ^F j TYQ+wxQ^TV_]WVTYMPbrQqSUTVZ…Q^Frn]TYXLF

j Q^[S!E_PQ^F…pF_PQ^[PnPMPbTYQ j WVTYMcb v ob[PQ^F j…j TYQ ƒ'[PX ]Q^O8_]s|[]pKKQ TVF)TVb[PQ^F)kJF_PQ^[Pn]prMPbpFsRQ^F j TYQ>wxQ^TV_ ‡

WVTYMcbrQ SlTVZ…Q^FrnPTYXLF FTYMcbd_%Q7.hKWVTVw TV_mRQ^[-Q^F j Q^_bGE_xt p[ j Q^FBTVF j Q^['SUTVKWYXLZ)E[]\Q^TV_ j TYQ>S!E_PQ^FBFGELMPb

bGop_rsRQ^F?ˆ8Q-,prQ^FwxQ^FCpF_PQ^[Pn]prMPb_xv eZ giXLWVsRQ^F j Q^F -Q^[ j Q^F/\Q^Tj Q lFrnco_]wxQ!O8p[]w!mRXL[]sRQ n]_PQ^WVWV_xv

')(',+H' AHBE2 B ?2 ;=A 7 > > AGE92 2?B7 > 09E 50 F-2 B205

'TVFyQ^[Pn]_PQ^[ lFrncE_]w j Q^[ ƒ[PX Q^O8_]s|[]pKKQ%\Q nP_cEF j3j E[]TVF t1Eprn j Q^FqS!E_PQ^F j Q^[ ƒE[]_]FrQ^[ lphginPMPbWVprnPn

%\NQ^[ j TYQv%rMcOO|Ephg&5Eb[PnPMcbrQ^TVFWVTYMPbORQ^TV_lQ^TVFrQ n (Q^[]_][cEsRQ n>w p<Q^[]bGEWV_PQ^F v Jprn j Q^[>ƒ E[]_]FrQ^[]_cE\NQ^WVWYQ

p[ j Q^F<wxQ^bF >_]_][]TV\p_PQ3Eprn]sRQ >obWV_xv* prnco_]w WVTYMcb p[ j Q!Q^TVF<\TVFGo[PQ n >_]_][]TV\p_ E . 8Eprn

j Q^F vJXLb j E_PQ^FsRQ^FrQ^[]TYQ^[]_xv lWYn8T Q^[]FdmRQ^[ g†Eb[PQ^F…O|EZ…Q^FBQ^TVF 'Fd_PnPMcbrQ^Tj pFsRn]\GEpZBWYQ^[]FrQ^[5pF j Q^TVFrQ

ˆ (+„ w pZ 'TVFrncE_]wRv|„/TV_ j Q^Z 'F_PnPMPbrQ^Tj pFsRn]\GEpZBWYQ^[]FrQ^[ p[ j Q>Q^TVFrQ>ƒ'[PQ M^TYn]TYXLFBmRXLF VKu pF j

Q^TVF vJQ MxEWVW8mRXLF

l

{ Q^[][PQ^TYMPb_xv|„CTV_ j Q^['ˆ (+„ p[ j Q%\NQ^T j Q^[\NQ n]_PQ^FyƒE[cEZ…Q^_PQ^[PQ^TVFrn]_PQ^WVWVpFsqQ^TVFrQ

ƒ'[PQ M^TYnPTYXLF…mRXLF D D pF j Q^TVFcvJQ MxEWVWrmRXLF VKu Q^[]w TYQ^WV_xvdSUTYQ S!E_PQ^F p[ j Q^F EpRQ^[ j Q^Z ZBTV_%DlTVWgiQ

mRXLF UnPnPXLw TE_]TYXLFrn][PQ^sRQ^WVFEFGEWrZhn]TYQ^[]_xv SUTYQBQ^F_Pn]_PQ^brQ^F j Q^FvlQ^sRQ^WVF p[ j Q^F4FGELMPb j Q^Z >_]_][]TV\p_

v %rMPO8OLEphg!TVF j Q^[ HJXLFO8WVprn]TYXLF sRQ_rWV_PQ^[]_xv n Q^[]sdE\Q^F n]TYMPb HJXL[][PQ^WE_]TYXLFrQ^F w TYnPMcbrQ^F Q^TVFTVsRQ^F

>_]_][]TV\p_PQ^F v SlTYQ ncQ!HJXL[][PQ^WE_]TYXLFrQ^F 5E[PQ^F ]Q j X8MPb<FTYMPb_ln]TVs|FT9_rO|EFd_lTVF<\Q^w ps Ephg8v %rMPO8OLEphg]v

lprn j Q^F '[]sRQ^\FTYnPncQ^FEWVWYQ^[%klFd_PQ^[Pn]prMcbdpFs OLEFF j Q^[-ˆ8McbWVprnPnsRQ^wxXLsRQ^F 5Q^[ j Q^F t j ELnPn j TYQ ƒ E[]_ ‡

FrQ^[ j E_PQ^FORQ^TVFrQ3[PQ^WYQ^mLEF_PQ^F/e FhgXL[]Z)E_]TYXLFrQ^F/w p[ (XL[]brQ^[PncEsRQ3mRXLFsv %rMPO8OLEphg'Q^Fd_]bGEWV_PQ^F v

lF j Q^[]pFsRQ^F4TVF j Q^[+KNQ^[PnPILFWVTYMPbrQ^F ˆTV_]pGE_]TYXLFQ^TVFrQ n!ƒ E[]_]FrQ^[Pnxt TYQ wRv"+v j Q^[!H3Ephg5Q^TVFrQ n!D+Eph‡

nPQ n#t8DUQ^TV[cE_JX

Q^[ S+E_PQ^F\GEFO<FTYMPb_JsRQ n]KNQ^TYMPbrQ^[]_xv SlTYQ ncQ

'[PQ^TVs|FTYncnPQ>ORILFFrQ^F…Fdp[%TVF j TV[PQ^O_ %\NQ^[ j TYQlF j Q^[]pFsqQ^TVFrQ n (Q^[]_][cEsRQ n%X j Q^[Q^TVFrQ nnPQ^TVFrQ^[ E[]Tg‡

ORXLZBKNXLFrQ^Fd_PQ^F\NQ XL\GELMPb_PQ^_-Q^[ j Q^F vGSUQ nPbGEWV\ \NQ^_][cELMPb_PQ^_PQ j TYQ+ƒ'[PX ]Q^O_]s|[]pKKNQ+TVFQ^TVFrQ^Z w -Q^T‡

_PQ^F lFrncE_]w j TYQ lF j Q^[]pFsRQ^F j Q^[ E[]TgORXLZBKNXLFrQ^Fd_PQ^F vd„/TV_'DJTVWgiQ5mRXLF JK[]TYXL[]T p[ j Q>mRQ^[Pn]prMcbd_xt

_ ZKTYnPMcbrQ (Q^[coF j Q^[]pFsRQ^FBmRXLF (Q^[]_][cEsRn]Z…Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ^FTVFyw p[%rMcOsRQ^O|Ephg_PQ^F (Q^[Pn]TYMcbrQ^[]pFsRn]mRQ^[]_][co1‡

sRQ^F w p<Q^Fd_ j Q MPORQ^F vGSlTYQ ">Q Q^F j TVs|pFs j Q^[ ƒ'[coZBTYQ^Fw#EbWVpFs 5E[ Q^TVFrQ+MPbGE[cEO8_PQ^[]TYn]_]TYnPMcbrQ JF j Q ‡

[]pFsrt

TVFsRn-FTYMPb_5EWYn-H+[]TV_PQ^[]TVpZ w p[ (XL[]brQ^[PncEsRQ

mRXLF v %rMPO8OLEphgmRQ^[-Q^F j Q^_ -Q^[ j Q^F v

SUTYQ '[]sRQ^\FTYnPncQ!ORILFFrQ^FgiXLWVsRQ^F j Q^[]Z)E RQ^FCTVF_PQ^[]K[PQ^_]TYQ^[]_ 5Q^[ j Q^F

+ / 9

D v SUTYQ3S!E_PQ^FCQ^Fd_]bGEWV_PQ^F?ORQ^TVFrQ![PQ^WYQ^m|EFd_PQ^FefFhgiXL[]Z)E_]TYXLFrQ^FCw p[ (XL[]brQ^[PncEsRQ3mRXLFsv %rMPO8OLEphg

X j Q^[

p[PMcbsRQ g%b[]_PQ^F lFGEWrZ8nPQ^F

j

n]TYQ g&%[ j TYQsv %rMPO8OLEphgmRXL[]brQ^[PncEsRQCpFsRQ Q^TVs|FrQ^_ nPTVF j v 'TVFrQ JFGEWrZhnPQ j Q^[ (Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRn j E_PQ^F

mRQ^[Pn]K[]TYMPb_JTVF j TYQ nPQ^[JDlTVFrn]TYMcbd_JZ…Q^b[ '[ gXLWVsrv

'*)('*& ' A-BE2 B ?2 ;=A 7> > FH2?B 0!;=A 52 B ; 2

2 :<2

5RQ^Frny` TYnPncQ^WYQ^[ypF_PQ^[Pn]prMPb_PQ TVF nPQ^TVFrQ^[SUTVKWYXLZ)E[]\Q^TV_ %) ) )!)4z|{|{|} j TYQ ˆ TYncn]T TgiQ ‡fS!E_PQ^F

FGELMPb bGop_rsRQ^F JF j Q^[]pFsRn]Zyprn]_PQ^[]F v lprn j TYQ nPQ^F „Cprn]_PQ^[]F mRQ^[Pn]prMPb_PQCQ^[xtvlQ^sRQ^WVF w p Q^[]wxQ^ph‡

sRQ^F tpZaZBTV_ TVb[PQ^[JDlTVWgiQ j TYQ!wxQ^TV_]WVTYMPbrQ!'Fd_ TYMPO8WVpFs mRXLF/efF_PQ^[]mLEWVWYnPQ-,prQ^FwxQ^FCmRXL[]brQ^[Pn EsRQ^FCw p

ORILFFrQ^F vefF lFWYQ^bFdpFs EF j Q^F lFrncE_]wmRXLF DUILKKFrQ^[ KNK=M)z|{|{|z JQ^Fd_ TYMcORQ^WV_PQ 5RQ^Frn

`TYncnPQ^WYQ^[%Q^TVFrQ^F$ lWVsRXL[]TV_]bZqprn-w p[ lp…F j pFsqmRXLFbGop_rsRQ^F e Fd_PQ^[]m|EWVWVZqprnP_PQ^[]F vE+Q^_][PQ^FF_-FGELMcb

j Q^F<g %Fhg'mRQ^[PnPMcbTYQ j Q^FrQ^F (Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRncE[]_PQ^F t5Q^F j Q^_PQy` TYnPnPQ^WYQ^[UnPQ^TVFrQ^F lWVsRXL[]TV_]bZqprn!Ephg j TYQ

E[]TgORXLZBKXLFrQ^F_PQ^F j E_PQ^FEF vhSUTYQ+efF_PQ^[]mLEWVWYQ!Q^[]wxQ^ps|_PQ3Q^[ Eprn j Q^F *Q^TV_]Z)E[]ORQ^F j Q^[lF j Q^[]pFh‡

sRQ^F vR„CTV_5DJTVWgiQ>mRXLF$ lWVWYQ^FrnwxQ^TV_]WVTYMcbrQ^[5e Fd_PQ^[]m|EWVWVWYXLs|TVO !0!0=M

D u l

S<GgXL[]ZypWVTYQ^[]_PQlQ^[ vlQ^WE_]TYXLFrQ^F

w TYnPMPbrQ^F j Q^F/Q^[]wxQ^ps|_PQ^F/e Fd_PQ^[]m|EWVWYQ^F v

Slp[PMcb ` TVWV_PQ^[]pFsFGELMcbQ^WV_]wxQ^TV_)pF j T EphgwxQ^TV_ %\NQ^[]K[%hg _PQQ^[ j TYQ<sRQ g pF j Q^FrQ^F vJQ^sRQ^WVF Ephg

wxQ^TV_]WVTYMPbrQ(Q^[coF j Q^[]pFsRQ^F vUSUTYQ4`TVWV_PQ^[]pFs FGELMPb j Q^[ Q^WV_]wxQ^TV_/Q^[]sdE\ pFd_PQ^[/EF j Q^[PQ^Zt j ELnPn

„CTV_]_PQ j Q^[qu|{LQ^[ 5Eb[PQmTYQ^WYQ (Q^[]_][cosRQ…w p[%rMPO8sRQ^OLEphg_ p[ j Q^F v SUTYQ n!TYn]_3Ephg j TYQ 'TVFhg&%b[]pFs

j Q^[3nPXLsRQ^FGEFFd_PQ^F ˆ_PQ^ZBKQ^WYn]_PQ^prQ^[qTVZ JK[]TVW

D

u|u

l w p[%rMcOw phg&%b[PQ^F v SUTYQˆ_PQ^ZBKNQ^WYn]_PQ^prQ^[3O|EFF

EphgQ^[]_]KGEKTYQ^[PQ|tEphg

j Q n'DUEF j Q^WYn]mRQ^[]ORQ^b[Pn%Q^[]brXL\Q^F 5Q^[ j Q^F v|SlTYQ'TVFhg%b[]pFs j Q^[-ˆ_PQ^ZBKNQ^WYn]_PQ^prQ^['mRQ^[cEFWELnPn]_PQ>m8TYQ^WYQ

H+pF j Q^F tTVb[PQ (Q^[Pn]TYMcbrQ^[]pFsRQ^FEphgw pWYI|nPQ^F v

5RQ^Frn` TYnPnPQ^WYQ^['mRQ^[Pn]prMcbd_PQlQ^TVFrQ v%rMPO8O|Ephg n]mRXL[]brQ^[Pn EsRQ nPX5XLbWrpFd_PQ^[>EWVWYQ^TVFTVsRQ^[ (Q^[-Q^F j pFs j Q^[

E[]TgORXLZBKXLFrQ^F_PQ^F j E_PQ^F EWYnyEprMPbTVF HJXLZq\TVFGE_]TYXLF ZBTV_qS!E_PQ^F Eprn j Q^F (Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRnPmRQ^[ ‡

_][cosRQ^F v ">Q^T'\Q^T

j

Q^F kJF_PQ^[Pn]prMPbpFs/ORXLFF_PQ)Q^[3ORQ^TVFrQ vJQ^sRQ^WVFw p[ (XL[]brQ^[PncEsRQ…mRXLF v %rMPO8OLEphg

E\sRQ^WYQ^TV_PQ^F v

* prncEZBZ…Q^FhgiELncnPQ^F j WoLnPnP_…n]TYMPb ncEsRQ^F t j ELnPn…Q n)TVF j Q^F mRXL[]sRQ nP_PQ^WVWV_PQ^F klFd_PQ^[Pn]prMcbdpFsRQ^F FTYMPb_

sRQ^WVpFsRQ^F?TYnP_xtQ^TVFrQ^F lFrncE_]w w p[+(XL[]brQ^[Pn EsRQmRXLF v %rMPO8OLEphg-w pf_rF j Q^F vNSUTYQ \TYn]brQ^[!Q^[]w TYQ^WV_PQ^F

'[]sRQ^\FTYncnPQ!WELnPnPQ^F<w 5Q^T Z…ILs|WVTYMPbrQ]v%rMcO8nPMcbW%rnPnPQ!w p

D

vJSlTYQ4S!E_PQ^F nPTVF j FTYMPbd_E j o,dpGE_C[PQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_]TYQ^[]_ -XL[ j Q^F t j vb v TVF j Q^F S!E_PQ^F n]_PQ MPORQ^F

[PQ^WYQ^mLEF_PQ efFhgiXL[]Z)E_]TYXLFrQ^F t j TYQ5TVF

j

Q^F

j

p[PMcbsRQ g%b[]_PQ^F lFGEWrZhnPQ^FyFTYMcbd_%Q^[]O|EFFd_ p[

j

Q^F v

zhvJSlTYQ!S!E_PQ^FCQ^F_]bGEWV_PQ^FCORQ^TVFrQyefFhgiXL[]Z)E_]TYXLFrQ^Fw p[ (XL[]brQ^[PncEsRQ3mRXLFsv%rMcOO|Ephg v

"5TYn]brQ^[5FTYMPb_ pFd_PQ^[Pn]prMcbd_ p[ j Q j TYQ+D+op_rs|ORQ^TV_5mRXLF (Q^[]_][cEsRncoF j Q^[]pFsRQ^F v efF j Q^[' JFFGEbZ…Q|t

j ELnPn bGop_rsRQ lF j Q^[]pFsRQ^FBQ^TVFrQ n (Q^[]_][cEsRQ n Jprn j []prMPO!mRXLFyklFw phg[]TYQ j Q^FbrQ^TV_ j Q n H+pF j Q^F nPTVF j t

ORILFF_PQ j TYQ"5Q^[%rMcO8nPTYMPbd_]TVs|pFs mRXLF!(Q^[]_][cEsRncoF j Q^[]pFsRQ^F t j TYQ (XL[PncEsRQ!mRXLF v%rMcOO|Ephg Q^[]Z…ILsL‡

WVTYMcbrQ^F v 'TVFrQ `nme S+` S!E[Pn]_PQ^WVWVpFs<\NQ^[%rMPOhn]TYMPb_]TVs|_ j TYQDUop_rs|ORQ^TV_+mRXLFlF j Q^[]pFsRQ^F v S+EbrQ^[

5Q^[ j Q^FBTVF j Q^[mRXL[]WVTYQ^sRQ^F j Q^F)SUTVKWYXLZ)E[]\NQ^TV_PQ^F j TYQ (Q^[PnPTYMPbrQ^[]pFsRn j E_PQ^F…TVFBQ^TVFrQ^[ `meS+`/S+E[ ‡

n]_PQ^WVWVpFs)FrQ^pCEFGEWrZ8n]TYQ^[]_xv

' ',+H' AHB ;=2 B BH205

SUTYQFrXL_5Q^F j TVsRQ (XL[]mRQ^[cE[]\NQ^TV_]pFs j Q^[ (Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRn j E_PQ^F! p[ j Q'ZBTV_DJTVWgiQ j Q n „/TVFTVFsJ„E[]_

ˆ<Zhn]_PQ^Z…n j p[PMPbsRQ g&%b[]_xv * pFGoLMcbrn]_ TV[ j j ELn ORXLFwxQ^K_]TYXLFrQ^WVWYQ<S!E_PQ^FZ…X j Q^WVW5Q^[Pn]_PQ^WVWV_xv S!EFGELMPb

ORILFFrQ^F j TYQ9(XL[]mRQ^[cE[]\Q^TV_]pFsRnPncMPb[]TV_]_PQyTVZ `GEWVWVZ…X j Q^WVW Z…X j Q^WVWVTYQ^[]_ -Q^[ j Q^F v

? .0*PB,- 9 #-:& "-K*L3j&1/- <B3j&<- 9 A-&NMO7<BP-&'b43j"'- 9 A*

SUTYQ+\NQ^Tj Q^FS+E_PQ^F\GEFO_cE\NQ^WVWYQ^F„ o%$ (+( v pF j „ o%$ (+( v e S -Q^[ j Q^FEWYn HJXLFwxQ^K_PQ

Z…X

j

Q^WVWVTYQ^[]_xv* p[ „/X

j

Q^WVWVTYQ^[]pFs

j

Q^[ E\NQ^WVWYQ%„@o%$ ( (v TV[

jyj

ELn HJXLFwxQ^K_ &)(+*;,-* .(210( EFsRQ ‡

WYQ^s|_xvSlTYQ E\NQ^WVWYQl„@o%$ (+( v e S TV[ j)j p[PMcb j ELn%HJXLFwxQ^K_ &)(+*;,-*/.1:6B [PQ^K[coLncQ^Fd_]TYQ^[]_xvh` %[

]Q j Q n' >_]_][]TV\p_PQ j Q^[ \NQ^Tj Q^F E\NQ^WVWYQ^F TV[ j Q^TVFQ^Fd_PnPK[PQ MPbrQ^F j Q n >_]_][]TV\p_ w p j Q^FHJXLFwxQ^K_PQ^F

EFsRQ^WYQ^s|_xv J\\TVWj pFs Vhv}BwxQ^TVs|_ j ELnUHJXLFwxQ^K_ &)(+*+,-*/.0(21(^v SUTYQyHlXLFwxQ^K_PQqZBTV_ j Q^F >_]_][]TV\p_PQ^F

5Q^[ j Q^F Ephg j TYQS!E_PQ^Fd\GEFO8_cE\Q^WVWYQ^F E\sRQ^\TVWj Q^_xv J\\TVWj pFs VhvSwxQ^TVs|_ j TYQ l\\TVWj pFs j Q^[

>_]_][]TV\p_PQ+g&%[ j ELnJHlXLFwxQ^K_ &)(+*;,-*/.0(210(^v

? .0*PB,- 9 #-:& "-K* 7 9b43j"'- 9 A*

* pFGoLMcbrn]_ TV[ j Q^TVFC\TVFGo[PQ n >_]_][]TV\p_ E .<8Q^[]wxQ^ps|_xvSUTYQ nPQ n >_]_][]TV\p_UFTVZBZq_ j Q^F Q^[]_

D

EF t -Q^FF j Q^[ (Q^[]_][cEs4w p[%rMcOsRQ^O|Ephg_ p[ j Q<pF j bGE_ j Q^F#Q^[]_){C\NQ^T>FTYMPb_)Q^[ gXLWVs|_PQ^Z

v %rMPO8OLEphg]v

+ / 9

l\\TVWj pFs Vhv}hvrHlXLFwxQ^K_ &)(+*;,-*/.0(210(

?

.0*,BP- 9 A-& -1r&1-K* :r& 11.d-:& BhBC.!'$)BP-)* g12L1L7'$)e J\\TVWj pFscVhvAVqs|TV\_ Q^TVFrQ^F>"l\NQ^[]\WVTYMPO %\NQ^[

j TYQFrXL_ -Q^F j TVsRQ^F olKNQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^F w p[ '[Pn]_PQ^WVWVpFs j Q n \TVFGo[PQ^F >_]_][]TV\p_Pn E . 8^v'„CTV_DJTVWgiQ

j Q nolKNQ^[cE_PXL[Pn : (+* %(3C 6 (/7 (/.<,-89*/( (;( ,D 6 5Q^[ j Q^FEWVWYQ! >_]_][]TV\p_PQyEprn]sRQ >obWV_xt j TYQ3efFhgiXL[ ‡

Z)E_]TYXLFrQ^F%\Q^[ j TYQ lF j Q^[]pFsRQ^F mRXLF (Q^[]_][cosRQ^F Q^[ g†ELnPnPQ^F v n…bGEF j Q^WV_)n]TYMPb j E\NQ^T pZ j TYQ

>_]_][]TV\p_PQ 3 (+6 70(+*+861 : 6)8< (;* t35(+6 70(;* 8961: 7 .<,-8< pF

j

35(+6 70(+*+8961:;.<*+,iv35(+6 70(;* 8961:+6)8 F

(;*5TYnP_ j TYQ'giXL[]_]W EphgiQ^F j Q lF j Q^[]pFsRn]FdpZBZ…Q^[xt035(+6 70(;* 8961: 7 .<,-8< TYn]_ j ELn S+E_]pZtLEF j Q^Z j TYQ

JF j Q^[]pFsQ^[ giXLWVs|_PQpF j 3 (+6 7(+* 8961: . *;,+s|TV\_ j Q^FNE+[]pF j g%[ j TYQ j p[PMPbsRQ g&%b[]_PQ lF j Q^[]pFs

EF v JWVWYQ]E+[%F j Q3n]TVF j<j p[PMPb XJpZBZ…Q^[]FCORX j TYQ^[]_xv

„CTV_BDlTVWgQ j Q ncolKQ^[cE_PXL[Pn16 (; 8)(+*; -Q^[ j Q^F EFbGEF j j Q n >_]_][]TV\p_Pn 3 (+6 7(+* 8961: . *;,

EWVWYQ+[%rMPO8sRQ^OLEphg_PQ^F=(Q^[]_][cosRQynPQ^WYQ^O_]TYQ^[]_†ˆ8Mcb[]TV_]_ (K( ,3 6 70(;** 8)( ;10( . 8;,(+6 &)(;*+,-*/.0(210( v

'TVF (Q^[]_][cEs4OLEFF ]Q j X8MPb FGELMPb Q^TVFrQ^Z v %rMPO8OLEphg+[PQxEO8_]TVmTYQ^[]_BpF j j EFGELMPb Q^[]FrQ^p_…w p[%rMPO‡

OLEphg_-Q^[ j Q^F v` %[lnPXLWYMcbrQ9(Q^[]_][cosRQyZqprnPn j ELn pKQ^WZBTV_ j Q^[lbrIMcbrn]_PQ^F lF j Q^[]pFsRn]FdpZBZ…Q^[

l\\TVWj pFs VhvSrv l\\TVWj pFs j Q^[ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ j Q n HlXLFwxQ^K_PQ n (Q^[]_][cELQ^sRQ Ephg j TYQ!S!E_PQ^F\GEFOLE_ ‡

_][]TV\p_PQ j Q^[ E\NQ^WVWYQ3„ o%$ (+(v

g&%[ v %rMPO8OLEphgl\Q n]_]TVZBZy_ -Q^[ j Q^F v'SUTYQ nsRQ^WVTVFs|_ZBTV_…DJTVWgiQ j Q n olKNQ^[cE_PXL[Pn!<H)( C (/7 , . ,, +:

†ˆ8Mcb[]TV_]_ 4( :+, 8961 70(+* . .(+6 3 (+6 70(+*+861 : 6)8< (;* v

lWVWYQ+(Q^[]_][cosRQ|t j TYQlFGELMcbCQ^TVFrQ^Z v%rMcOO|Ephg[PQxEO8_]TVmTYQ^[]_ pF j FTYMcbd_JQ^[]FrQ^p_ w p[%rMcOsRQ^O|Ephg_' p[ ‡

j Q^F t -Q^[ j Q^F Q^F_ gQ^[]F_xv S!Ew p 5Q^[ j Q^F j TYQNolKQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^F+6@ A (; †ˆ8Mcb[]TV_]_ &)(+* ;86 7N t

(+6 (+* (/.<,-89*/( <6 :+,-*+8 ,3 6 †ˆ8MPb[]TV_]_ 5(;*/(+6L@ '7<861 pF j 6 (; 8)(+*; †ˆ8MPb[]TV_]_

358: . :) 7(+* * 8)( ;10( . 8;, (+6 &)(+*;,-* .(210( ,9 (/. ,' (+*+861 \NQ^FrIL_]TVs|_xv X+ELMPb j Q^[ JF -Q^F j pFs

j TYQ nPQ^[ olKQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^Fn]TVF j EWVWYQ (Q^[]_][cosRQy\Q nP_]TVZBZq_xt j TYQqFGELMcb?Q^TVFrQ^[tvJQxEO8_]TVmTYQ^[]pFs Q^[]FrQ^p_lw ph‡

[%rMcOsRQ^O|Ephg_ p[ j Q^F v

e Z FGoLMcbrn]_PQ^FCˆ8MPb[]TV_]_ -Q^[ j Q^FEWVWYQl[%rMPO8sRQ^OLEphg_PQ^F (Q^[]_][cosRQUQ^[]ZBTV_]_PQ^WV_xt8\NQ^T j Q^FrQ^F ORQ^TVFrQvJQxEO‡

_]TVm8TYQ^[]pFsqn]_cE_]_]sRQ gpF j Q^FbGE_xvdSlTYQ n%sRQ nPMPbTYQ^b_-ZBTV_]_PQ^WYn j Q^[ olKNQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^F 6 3<6< A (; †ˆ8MPb[]TV_]_

&)(+* (6 1 8691! pF j 6 (; 8)(+* †ˆ8MPb[]TV_]_ 3580:; . :70(;* * 8)( ;10( . 8;, (+6 &)(;*+,-*/.0(210(P :F

6 ( (/. , 2(+*+8961 v

SUTYQ)„?Q^FsRQEWVWYQ^[ [%rMPO8sRQ^O|Ephg_PQ^F (Q^[]_][cosRQQ^[]bGoWV_ Z)EF j p[PMPb j TYQ%(Q^[PQ^TVFTVs|pFs j Q^[y[%rMcOsRQ ‡

O|Ephg_PQ^F:(Q^[]_][cosRQ)ZBTV_3pF j XLbFrQcvlQxEO_]TVm8TYQ^[]pFs †ˆ8Mcb[]TV_]_ &)(+* (6 1 8691 v SUQ^[ olKQ^[cE_PXL[

(+6 (+* (/.<,-89*/( <6 :+,-*+8 ,3 6 Q^[]wxQ^ps|_ j ELn\TVFGo[PQ >_]_][]TV\p_ E . 8 †ˆ8MPb[]TV_]_ <6 :+,-*+8 ,3 6

(6 ( : 6N */(;6'34,2,-* +8,( : 8)( . 8 v S!ELn >_]_][]TV\p_ E . 8bGE_Jg&%[+EWVWYQ [%rMcOsRQ^O|Ephg_PQ^F

(Q^[]_][cosRQ j Q^F Q^[]_

D v

* p[Je j Q^Fd_]T9_rw TYQ^[]pFsEWVWYQ^[lFTYMPbd_Uw p[%rMPO8sRQ^O|Ephg_PQ^F (Q^[]_][cosRQ TV[ j w pFGoLMPbrn]_lZBTV_]_PQ^WYn j Q n olKNQ ‡

[cE_PXL[Pn : (+* %(3C 6 (/7 (/.<,-89*/( 6 :+,-*+8 ,3<6 j ELn' >_]_][]TV\p_ &)(+*;,-* .1 :6B j Q n HlXLFwxQ^K_PQ n &)(+*;,-* . 1F

:B :yEprn]sRQ >obWV_xv S!ELnlQ^[Pn]_PQ^WVWV_PQ3HJXLFwxQ^K_ TV[ j ZBTV_ j Q^F[%rMPO8sRQ^O|Ephg_PQ^F (Q^[]_][cosRQ^FCmRQ^[PQ^TVFTVs|_

+ / 9

J\\TVWj pFsJVhvAVhv)"J\NQ^[]\WVTYMPO %\NQ^[ j TYQyˆ8Mcb[]TV_]_PQqTVF/„CTVFTVFsR„E[]_Jw p[ [Pn]_PQ^WVWVpFs Q^TVFrQ nJ\TVFGo[PQ^F

>_]_][]TV\p_PQ nOv%rMcOO|Ephg

†ˆ8Mcb[]TV_]_ &)(;*/( 6 1 8961 70(+* &)(+*;,-* .(210( -,586 7 :06 ( 8)( .<8 v ` %[BEWVWYQFTYMPbd_w p[%rMcOsRQ ‡

O|Ephg_PQ^F (Q^[]_][cosRQbGE_ j ELn >_]_][]TV\p_ E . 8FGELMPb j Q^[ (Q^[PQ^TVFTVs|pFs<giQ^bWYQ^F j QQ^[]_PQ|v S+Q^[

olKNQ^[cE_PXL[ 3 : :1 6%( . 8+,& .<8)(BQ^[PnPQ^_]w _!EWVWYQqg Q^bWYQ^F j Q^F Q^[]_PQyZBTV_ j Q^Z Q^[]_3{ †ˆ8MPb[]TV_]_ *F

:(;,@ (+6 (:(+6 70(+* (;*+, ( v

BhBC. !'$)BP7$<* " 7'4

XJTYMcbd_3EWVWYQyz|})„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ

j Q nlHlXLFwxQ^K_Pn'&)(;*+,-*/.0(210(…ORILFFrQ^F?w p[ E+Q^FrQ^[]TYQ ‡

[]pFs mRXLF `me S+`<„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ^F3brQ^[cEFsRQ^wxXLsRQ^F5Q^[ j Q^F vn ORILFFrQ^F3Fdp[ „/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ'\NQ^[%rMPOhn]TYMPbh‡

_]TVs|_'5Q^[ j Q^F t j TYQ+ORQ^TVFrQUg Q^bWYQ^F j QQ^[]_PQyEphg5Q^TYnPQ^F<pF j<j TYQ!n]TYMPb<TVFFrQ^[]bGEWV\ j Q^[ mRQ^[]_][cEs|WVTYMPbrQ^F

T EphgwxQ^TV_ oF j Q^[]F v SUTYQ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ &)(+* : ;:(+*+8691:;. *;,3pF j N :0*+8691oF j Q^[]F nPTYMPbFTYMcbd_%\NQ^[

j TYQ *Q^TV_xv SUTYQ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ (+6 (+*/..10(+6,-89*)pF j &J * :K *210( (+* . , (+* -Q^TYnPQ^F?giQ^bWYQ^F j QQ^[]_PQBEphg]v

SUTYQ>Q^[5obF_PQ^F…mTYQ^[ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ'5Q^[ j Q^FBgiXLWVs|WVTYMPbBFTYMPb_'w p[^E+Q^FrQ^[]TYQ^[]pFs3mRQ^[5Q^F j Q^_xvRSUTYQ >_]_][]T‡

\p_PQ &)(+*;,-* . 1:6Bqt03 (+6 70(+*+861 : 6)8< (;* t35(+6 70(;* 8961: 7 .<,-8<t * :;.8 / 6)pF j * :;. :

ORILFFrQ^FCQ^\NQ^Fhg†EWVWYn FTYMPb_ \Q^[%rMcO8nPTYMPbd_]TVs|_ -Q^[ j Q^F vGSlTYQ3mRQ^[]\WVTYQ^\Q^FrQ^F D S >_]_][]TV\p_PQ-Q^[ j Q^FpFh‡

_PQ^[PnPMcbTYQ j WVTYMPb 5Q^TV_PQ^[]mRQ^[-Q^F j Q^_('TVFrQ n j Q^[ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ TV[ j mRXL[ j Q^[ `meS+` [cEFrn]g XL[]Z)E_]TYXLF

TVF\TVFGo[PQl„?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ %\NQ^[ g%b[]_ j TYQlEF j Q^[PQ^F

D } 5Q^[ j Q^F pFZBTV_]_PQ^WV\GE[5TVF `meS+`„?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ

_][cEFrn giXL[]ZBTYQ^[]_xv

-&<-. 5-. $'&)( + 3j& !& 11.0-& ` -.aL<bc7 A-& S!ELn >_]_][]TV\p_ 3 (+6 7(+* 8961: . *;,'s|TV\_ j Q^F E+[]pF j g&%[

j TYQ lF j Q^[]pFs+Q^TVFrQ n (Q^[]_][cEsRQ n'EF v#e Frn]sRQ ncEZy_Q7.hTYn]_]TYQ^[PQ^F

D

z|}OE+[%F j Q|v*5Q^TdmRXLFqTVbFrQ^Fy\Q j Q^ph‡

_PQ^Fv %rMPO8OLEphg]t -Q^TV_PQ^[PQ j [PQ^Tr_][PQ^_PQ^F…TVZBZ…Q^[TVZ * prn EZBZ…Q^FbGEFsqZBTV_ v %rMPO8OLEphg Ephg v|SUTYQ nPQ5g&%Fhg

EU[%F j QyZ%rncnPQ^F/\NQ^T j Q^[ lF -Q^F j pFs j Q^[tT Q^[]FdmRQ^[ g†Eb[PQ^FEprn]sRQ nPMcbWYX|nPnPQ^F -Q^[ j Q^F vNSUTYQq[PQ nP_ ‡

WVTYMcbrQ^F D D[l Q^[]_PQ

j Q n >_]_][]TV\p_Pn 35(+6 70(;* 8961: . *+,-Q^[

j

Q^F?TVF\TVFGo[PQ >_]_][]TV\p_PQy_][cEFrn gXL[]ZBTYQ^[]_

n]TYQ^brQ l\\TVW

Q^TVF FrQ^prQ n „/Q^[]O8Z)EW sRQ^FrQ^[]TYQ^[]_xvhSUTYQUnPXyQ^[]bGEWV_PQ ‡

FrQ^F >_]_][]TV\p_PQ5Q^[ j Q^F/ZBTV_ j Q^Z X+EZ…Q^F/„?k .\Q^wxQ^TYMcbFrQ^_xt 5XL\Q^T . g%[ j TYQ \5X j Q^FdpZBZ…Q^[

n]_PQ^b_xvd` %[%Q^TVF pKQ^W FTVZBZq_>„/k . j Q^F$Q^[]_

D

EF t 5Q^FF j ELn >_]_][]TV\p_ 35(+6 70(+*+8961:;.<*+, j Q^F

Q^[]_/. bGE_xv|Slp[PMcb j TYQ nPQ (XL[]sRQ^brQ^Frn5Q^TYnPQJQ^F_Pn]_PQ^bd_-Q^TVF…„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYn][cEpZ ZBTV_ D } D „?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ^F v

` -.aL<bc7 A*P('-:&<-.5-. $'&)( b ABp! #e - + 3j&6 M kJZ `me S+` „/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQBw psRQ^FrQ^[]TYQ^[PQ^F t

TV[ jBj TYQ lF j Q^[]pFsRn]sRQ nPMcbTYMPb_PQ ]Q j Q n (Q^[]_][cEsRQ n-\Q^_][cELMcbd_PQ^_xv lWVWYQ' pKNQ^WGQ^TVFrQ n (Q^[]_][cEsRQ n -Q^[ ‡

j Q^FsRQ^Z)o CTVb[PQ n *Q^TV_Pn]_PQ^ZBKNQ^WYnyEphgin]_PQ^TVsRQ^F j ncXL[]_]TYQ^[]_xv ` %[ j TYQ D } pFmRQ^[coF j Q^[]_PQ^F >_]_][]TV\p_PQ

5Q^[ j Q^F `nmeS+`„?Q^[]OZ)EWYQUFGELMcb j Q^[>Q^[PnP_PQ^F j Q^[>TVF H3EKTV_PQ^W }3TVZ l\rnPMPbFTV_]_J}hvSrvzy\NQ nPMPb[]TYQ ‡

\NQ^FrQ^F (%E[]TEFd_PQ<Q^[]wxQ^ps|_xvSUTYQ nPQ (%E[]TEFd_PQ<Q^[ g†ELnPn]_ j TYQ lF j Q^[]pFs4mRXLF >_]_][]TV\p_-Q^[]_PQ^F v5S+Q^[

Q^[]Zg[PQ-,prQ^FwQ^F_Pn]K[]TYMPb_ bTYQ^[ j TYQ lFw#EbW j Q^[ lF j Q^[]pFsRQ^F t j TYQ)Q^TVF >_]_][]TV\p_

a _i

^{5ob[PQ^F j}

j Q^[ T EphgwxQ^TV_lQ^TVFrQ n (Q^[]_][cEsRn

c _j

^{Q^[} g†Eb[PQ^FbGE_xv

tf (a i , c j ) = k { x ∈

*Q^TV_]KpFO8_PQ

l\\TVWj pFssVhv3u)TVWVWVprn]_][]TYQ^[]_ j TYQ">Q^[PQ MPbFdpFs j Q^[ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,dprQ^Fw…g%[ j TYQ sRQ^FGEFFd_PQ^F

D

}„?Q^[]O‡

Z)EWYQ|v

+ / 9

l\\TVWj pFs VhvAWhv [cEFrng XL[]Z)E_]TYXLF j Q n >_]_][]TV\p_PQ n 3 (+6 7(+* 8961: . *;, TVF<\TVFGo[PQ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ

l\\TVW

j

pFs Vhv3u8v">Q^[PQ McbFdpFs

j

Q^[ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,dprQ^Fwqg%[

j

TYQ!XL[]TVs|TVFGEWYQ^F?„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ

l\\TVWj pFs Vhvl v">Q^[PQ MPbFpFs j Q^[ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,prQ^Fw3g&%[ j TYQ!\TVFGo[PQ^FC„?Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ

` %[

j

TYQyFrQ^pQ^[]wxQ^ps|_PQ^F4\TVFGo[PQ^F?„?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ! TV[

jj

TYQqw 5Q^TV_PQ (%E[]TEFd_PQ w p[ E!Q^FrQ^[]TYQ^[]pFs mRXLF

`meSU` „?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ^F Q^TVFsRQ ncQ^_]w _ n]TYQ^brQ4H3EKTV_PQ^Wy} J\rnPMcbFTV_]_/}hvSrvz v SUTYQ nPQ (%E[]TEF_PQ\NQ ‡

_][cELMcbd_PQ^_ j ELn (XL[]ORXLZBZ…Q^F?mRXLF >_]_][]TV\p_ 5Q^[]_PQ^F vNSlTYQ! Q^[]Zg[PQ-,dprQ^Fw Q^[ giELncn]_ bTYQ^[xt TYQqXg_JQ^TVF

lF

j

Q^[]pFsRn]s|[]pF

j

Ephg_][]TV_]_xv

tf (a i , c _j ) = k { x ∈

*Q^TV_]KpFO8_PQ

| a _i = 1 } k

^dVhvz

l\\TVWj pFs Vhv

l

mRQ^[ j Q^p_]WVTYMcbd_ j TYQ">Q^[PQ MPbFdpFs j Q^[ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,prQ^FwRv

SUTYQ 8< (;6, * (;8)(+6+@4Q^TVFrQ n >_]_][]TV\p_PQ n

a i

Q^Frn]K[]TYMPb_ j Q^[ lFw#EbW j Q^[9(Q^[]_][cosRQ…ZBTV_3Q^TVFrQ^[

(+* +* (;8)(+6+@s|[PIRQ^[lEWYnJ{hv

df(a i ) = k { c j ∈ C | tf (a i , c j ) > 0 } k

^dVhv}

? .0/-:$)(H$'&)( + 3j& i-.d(H #-132141*[.0- 1.1<*-&)BP7<B3j&<-& 'TVF (Q^[]s|WYQ^TYMPb j Q^[ `nmeS+`svlQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLF

ZBTV_ EF j Q^[PQ^F vJQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TYXLFrQ^FnPXLWVW j Q^F (XL[]_PQ^TVW j Q^[ `nme S+` vlQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLF<\NQ -Q^TYnPQ^F v n

5Q^[

j

Q^Fw -Q^T (Q^[]s|WYQ^TYMPbrn][PQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TYXLFrQ^FQ^[]wxQ^ps|_xv

` %[ j TYQ?Q^[PnP_PQfvlQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLF 5Q^[ j Q^F j TYQ

D S „?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ^F mRQ^[5Q^F j Q^_xt j TYQ/TVZ l\rnPMPbFTV_]_

>_]_][]TV\p_cEprn>EbW\Q nPMcb[]TYQ^\Q^F p[ j Q^F vSUTYQ3wxQ^TV_]WVTYMPbrQSUTVZ…Q^Frn]TYXLF j Q^[lS!E_PQ^F TV[ j FTYMcbd_+\NQ ‡

[%rMcO8n]TYMcbd_]TVs|_xv'">Q^T (Q^[]_][cosRQ^F XLbFrQ v %rMPO8OLEphg! TV[j j ELn w pWYQ^_]w _ s %WV_]TVsRQ pKNQ^W+mRQ^[-Q^F j Q^_xv

">Q^T/(Q^[]_][cosRQ^FZBTV_3Q^[ giXLWVs|_PQ^Z v%rMPO8O|Ephg TV[ j4j ELn+WYQ^_]w _PQmRXL[ j Q^Z v%rMcOO|Ephg-s %WV_]TVsRQ pKQ^W

Eprn]sRQ >obWV_xv l\\TVW

j

pFs VhvumRQ^[

j

Q^p_]WVTYMcbd_

j

TYQ Jprn 5EbW

j

Q^[ pKQ^W†v

lWYnNw -Q^TV_PQ^vJQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TYXLF TV[ j Q^TVFrQ'\TVFGo[PQ%S+E[PnP_PQ^WVWVpFs sRQ 5obWV_xv1efZE+Q^sRQ^Frn E_]ww p[ `meS+`

vlQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLFQ^[g†ELnPn]_ j TYQ nPQ+S!E[Pn]_PQ^WVWVpFsBFdp[ j ELn' lphg_][PQ^_PQ^F mRXLF lF j Q^[]pFsRQ^F<\w 3v JF j Q ‡

+ / 9

l\\TVWj pFs Vhvuhv'[]wxQ^ps|pFs j Q^[OvJQ^K[coLncQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLFCZBTV_ j Q^FXL[]TVs|TVFGEWYQ^F/„?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ^F

l\\TVWj pFs Vhv

D

{hv'[]wxQ^ps|pFs j Q^[ \TVFGo[PQ^FsvlQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLF

[]pFsRn]s|[%F j Q^FpF j FTYMPb_ j TYQJDUop_rs|ORQ^TV_xv„?E_]brQ^Z)E_]TYnPMcb)Wo |_%nPTYMPb j ELn TYQ>gXLWVs|_5Eprn j [%rMPORQ^F

bin(a i ; c _j ) =

( 1 : a i

p[ j Q3TVF

c j

sRQxoF j Q^[]_J\w 3v

a i

_][]TV_]_JTVF

c j

Ephg

0 :

^nPXLFrn]_

dVhvS

l\\TVW

j

pFs VhvD {wxQ^TVs|_

j

TYQ []wxQ^ps|pFs

j

Q^[ \TVFGo[PQ^F vJQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TYXLF v

' '*&(' . -B 9E7LELB FH2 B?2 B 2

g)BP-:L1.3BP-. 5-&

e F j TYQ ncQ^Z J\rnPMcbFTV_]_ -Q^[ j Q^F j TYQ E %_PQ^O8[]TV_PQ^[]TYQ^F 3 ;8*/. K|tL= */( :3<6Gt ( .'pF j F O'(/.:+8* (

mRXL[]sRQ n]_PQ^WVWV_xv SUTYQysRQ^FGEFFd_PQ^FH+[]TV_PQ^[]TYQ^F 5Q^[ j Q^Fw p[ ">Q -Q^[]_]pFs j Q^[ j p[PMPbsRQ g&%b[]_PQ^F /.hKQ^[]T‡

Z…Q^F_PQyQ^TVFsRQ nPQ^_]w _xv ˆTYQ!-Q^[ j Q^F4EFbGEF j/j Q^[+HJXLF_]TVFsRQ^Fw _cE1g Q^W'TVF J\\TVWj pFs Vhvz…Q^[]Wop_PQ^[]_xv

A

+ / 9

\ \ ‡

D\ "

D\ ‡ \ S

E\NQ^WVWYQ]VhvzhvGHlXLFd_]TVFsRQ^Fw _cE1giQ^Wg %[lQ^TVF/H+WELnPn]T9_rO|E_]TYXLFrn]K[PXL\WYQ^Z ZBTV_Jw 5Q^T H+WELnPncQ^F v \ Q^F_ ‡

n]K[]TYMPb_

j

Q^[BORXL[][PQ^O_PQ^F H+WELnPn]T9_rO|E_]TYXLF tD\qTYn]_

j

TYQ<H+WELncn]T9_rOLE_]TYXLF

j Q ncT Q^[]FGEWVsRXL[]TV_]bZqprn

DOZ8KXL_]brQ ncQ v

\Q^wxQ^TYMcbFrQ^_ j TYQ JFw#EbW j Q^[+KNX|n]TV_]TVmRQ^F ">Q^TYn]KTYQ^WYQ|t j TYQmRXLZ H+WELnPn]T9_rO|E_PXL[qEWYn+KX|n]TV_]TVm?Q^[]OLEFF_

p[ j Q^F v

B

^{TYn]_ j} TYQ$ JFw#EbW j Q^[3mRXLZ T Q^[]FGEWVsRXL[]TV_]bZyprn gioWYncMPbWVTYMPbrQ^[5Q^TYnPQ<EWYnqKNX|n]TV_]TVm?OWELncn]T‡ _rw TYQ^[]_PQ^F t TVF TV[]O8WVTYMPbORQ^TV_qFrQ^sdE_]TVmRQ^F ">Q^TYn]KTYQ^WYQ|v

C

^{s|TV\_ j TYQ} lFw#EbWKNX|n]TV_]TVmRQ^[!">Q^TYn]KTYQ^WYQ EF t j TYQlmRXLZ T Q^[]FGEWVsRXL[]TV_]bZyprn g†oWYnPMPbWVTYMcbrQ^[-Q^TYnPQ EWYn5FrQ^sdE_]TVmO8WELnPn]T9_rw TYQ^[]_ p[ j Q^F thpF j

Im Dokument L Ht j TYQ Q^TVFrQQ^TVWVZ…Q^FsRQ (Seite 27-54)