D TYn]_ j TYQ

D\ "

D\ ‡ \ S

E\NQ^WVWYQ]VhvzhvGHlXLFd_]TVFsRQ^Fw _cE1giQ^Wg %[lQ^TVF/H+WELnPn]T9_rO|E_]TYXLFrn]K[PXL\WYQ^Z ZBTV_Jw 5Q^T H+WELnPncQ^F v \ Q^F_ ‡

n]K[]TYMPb_

j

Q^[BORXL[][PQ^O_PQ^F H+WELnPn]T9_rO|E_]TYXLF tD\qTYn]_

j

TYQ<H+WELncn]T9_rOLE_]TYXLF

j Q ncT Q^[]FGEWVsRXL[]TV_]bZqprn

DOZ8KXL_]brQ ncQ v

\Q^wxQ^TYMcbFrQ^_ j TYQ JFw#EbW j Q^[+KNX|n]TV_]TVmRQ^F ">Q^TYn]KTYQ^WYQ|t j TYQmRXLZ H+WELnPn]T9_rO|E_PXL[qEWYn+KX|n]TV_]TVm?Q^[]OLEFF_

p[ j Q^F v

B

^{TYn]_ j} TYQ$ JFw#EbW j Q^[3mRXLZ T Q^[]FGEWVsRXL[]TV_]bZyprn gioWYncMPbWVTYMPbrQ^[5Q^TYnPQ<EWYnqKNX|n]TV_]TVm?OWELncn]T‡ _rw TYQ^[]_PQ^F t TVF TV[]O8WVTYMPbORQ^TV_qFrQ^sdE_]TVmRQ^F ">Q^TYn]KTYQ^WYQ|v

C

^{s|TV\_ j TYQ} lFw#EbWKNX|n]TV_]TVmRQ^[!">Q^TYn]KTYQ^WYQ EF t j TYQlmRXLZ T Q^[]FGEWVsRXL[]TV_]bZyprn g†oWYnPMPbWVTYMcbrQ^[-Q^TYnPQ EWYn5FrQ^sdE_]TVmO8WELnPn]T9_rw TYQ^[]_ p[ j Q^F thpF j

D

^{TYn]_ j TYQ}

JFw#EbW j Q^[ ORXL[][PQ^O8_lEWYn FrQ^sdE_]TVm<Q^[]O|EFFd_PQ^F "5Q^TYnPKTYQ^WYQ|v

SlTYQ 3 ;89*/. K s|TV\_

j

TYQ Eb[PnPMPbrQ^TVFWVTYMcbORQ^TV_EF t j

ELnPn…Q^TVF w phgioWVWVTVs Eprn

j

Q^[4(Q^[]_PQ^TVWVpFs

j

Q^[

"5Q^TYnPKTYQ^WYQCsRQ^wxXLsRQ^FrQ n ">Q^TYn]KTYQ^W+[]TYMPb_]TVs O8WELnPn]T9_rw TYQ^[]_ TV[ j v 'TVFrQ J\rnPMcbGo_]w pFs j Q^[ 3 ;89* . 9

OLEFF Q^[ gXLWVsRQ^FyZBTV_]_PQ^WYnSUTVm8TYn]TYXLF j Q^[ JFw#EbW j Q^[ORXL[][PQ^O8_PQ^FyH+WELnPnPT9_rOLE_]TYXLFrQ^F j p[PMPb j TYQ lFw#EbW

EWVWYQ^[JH+W ELnPn]T9_rO|E_]TYXLFrQ^F vn Q^[]s|TV\_Un]TYMPb giXLWVsRQ^F j Q3`rXL[]Z…Q^W

Accuracy = A + D A + B + C + D

dVhvAV

kJF_PQ^[ = */( :3<6 mRQ^[Pn]_PQ^b_!Z)EF j TYQEb[PnPMPbrQ^TVFWVTYMcbORQ^TV_xt j ELncn!Q^TVFEWYn+KX|n]TV_]TVm/OWELncn]T9_rw TYQ^[]_PQ n

"5Q^TYnPKTYQ^W TV[]OWVTYMcbCKNX|n]TV_]TVmTYnP_xv

P recision = A A + B

dVhvAW

( .'rTYn]_ j TYQ Eb[PnPMPbrQ^TVFWVTYMcbORQ^TV_xt j ELnPn Q^TVFyKNX|n]TV_]TVmRQ n ">Q^TYn]KTYQ^WEprMPb…EWYnnPXLWYMPbrQ nQ^[]O|EFFd_ TV[ j v

SlTYQ ncQ n „?E BWo |_ln]TYMPb TYQUgiXLWVs|_lE\rnPMcbGo_]wxQ^F

Recall = A A + C

dVhv3u

ˆ8XLWVWYQ^F<mRQ^[PnPMPbTYQ j Q^FrQ!/.8KNQ^[]TVZ…Q^Fd_PQ3ZBTV_PQ^TVFGEF j Q^[ mRQ^[]s|WVTYMPbrQ^F -Q^[ j Q^F tTYn]_ Q n ncMPb TYQ^[]TVsrt Q 5Q^TVWYn

ƒ'[PQ M^TYn]TYXLFpF j vJQ MxEWVW-Eprn j Q^F Q^TVFwxQ^WVFrQ^F /.hKQ^[]TVZ…Q^F_PQ^F ZBTV_PQ^TVFGEF j Q^[ w pmRQ^[]s|WYQ^TYMcbrQ^F v lprn

j TYQ nPQ^Z EU[]pF j 5Q^[ j Q^F/ƒ'[PQ M^TYn]TYXLF/pF j vJQ MxEWVW Xg_ w pCQ^TVFrQ^Z Q^TVFw TVsRQ^F Q^[]_ ORXLZq\TVFTYQ^[]_xv

'TVF sRQ^\[coprMPbWVTYMcbrQ n „E w p[…HJXLZy\TVFGE_]TYXLF mRXLF ƒ'[PQ M^TYnPTYXLF pF j vJQ MxEWVW TYn]_ j ELnmRXLF T Q TYn

%) D u|u V j Q_rFTV_]TYQ^[]_PQ

F

^{FO'( .: 89*/( vnB\NQ^[PQ MPbFrQ^_ j ELnsRQ} TYMPb_PQ^_PQCbGE[]Z…XLFTYnPMcbrQC„/TV_]_PQ^W Eprn vJQ MxEWVW pF j ƒ[PQ M^TYn]TYXLF v

F _β = (β ² + 1)P rec(h)Rec(h) β ² P rec(h) + Rec(h)

dVhvl

β

^{s|TV\_ j} TYQ>[PQ^WE_]TVmRQpE+Q TYMPb_]pFsqw TYnPMcbrQ^Fƒ'[PQ M^TYnPTYXLF…pF j vJQ MxEWVWGEF v|e F j Q^[vJQ^sRQ^W TV[ j

β = 1

sRQ nPQ^_]w _xtrnPX j ELnPn>\NQ^Tj Q Q^[]_PQ!s|WYQ^TYMcbCsRQ TYMcbd_PQ^_ -Q^[ j Q^F v

?

!&)('-K*- BP/BP-$-. &)e 74'.0-&

* p[ H+WELnPn]T9_rO|E_]TYXLF p[ j Q^F j TYQ%TVF H3EKTV_PQ^Whz \Q nPMcb[]TYQ^\Q^FrQ^FT Q^[]FmRQ^[ giEb[PQ^FBQ^TVFsRQ nPQ^_]w _( JK[]TYX‡

[]Tw p[ H+W ELnPn]T9_rO|E_]TYXLF n]TYQ^brQ zhv}hvS t 5 Srvl n]TYQ^brQ)zhv}hv} t j

TYQ ˆ (+„ n]TYQ^brQ)zhv}hvD 3pF

j

X+ETVmRQ

" ECZRQ n n]TYQ^brQ%zhv}hvz vxSUTYQ nPQ (Q^[ g†Eb[PQ^Fqn]TVF j TVZvlEbZ…Q^F j Q n H % NMpF j LM?O z|{|{|{

ƒEORQ^_PQ nJTVF = pT TVFd_PQ^s|[]TYQ^[]_xv= T nP_PQ^WVWV_ j E[%\Q^[JbTVFGEprntolKNQ^[cE_PXL[PQ^FCw p[lEp_PXLZ)E_]TYncMPbrQ^F

SUp[PMPbhg&%b[]pFsCmRXLF H+[PQ^pw mLEWVT

j

TYQ^[]pFsRQ^F pF

j w p[">Q n]_]TVZBZypFsCmRXLF4pFd_PQ^[PncMPbTYQ

j

WVTYMPbrQ^F E%h‡

_PQ^O8[]TV_PQ^[]TYQ^Fw p[ (Q^[ g&%s|pFsrv* p[ SUp[PMPbhg&%b[]pFs j Q^[/.hKQ^[]TVZ…Q^F_PQ!ORILFFrQ^FZBTV_ „/TVFTVFs)„E[]_

mRXL[]mRQ^[cE[]\NQ^TV_PQ^_PQqS!E_PQ^FZBTV_]_PQ^WYnlQ^TVFrQ npolKQ^[cE_PXL[Pn j TV[PQ^O_UEprn j Q^[JS!E_PQ^Fd\GEFO<Q7.h_][cEbTYQ^[]_ -Q^[ ‡

j Q^F v J\\TVWj pFs VhvD D wxQ^TVs|_ j Q^F lphg\GEp Q^TVFrQ n .8KNQ^[]TVZ…Q^Fd_PQ n>ZBTV_ = pT v JK[]TYXL[]T p[ j QJw p[

H+WELnPnPT9_rOLE_]TYXLF mRQ^[5Q^F j Q^_xtTVF j Q^Z w pFGoLMPbrnP_ Ephg+EWVWYQ^F [cETVFTVFsRn]\NQ^TYn]KTYQ^WYQ^F UnPnPXLw TE_]TYXLFrn][PQ ‡

sRQ^WVFsRQ^WYQ^[]F_ p[ j Q^F vSUTYQ vJQ^sRQ^WVsRQ^FrQ^[]TYQ^[]pFs Q^[ gXLWVs|_PQ!g%[JQ^TVFrQ^F4ˆpKKXL[]_JmRXLF D pF j Q^TVFrQ^F

HlXLF_

j

Q^Fw -Q^[]_JmRXLF V|{ vSUTYQ+Q^[]wxQ^ps|_PQ^F vJQ^sRQ^WVF p[

j

HlXLFOWVprn]TYXLF sRQ_rWV_PQ^[]_xvhSUTYQJsRQ_rWV_PQ^[]_PQ^F vlQ^sRQ^WVF$ p[ j Q^FEphg j TYQ Q n]_ j E_PQ^FCEFsRQ >EF j _xthpZ nPTYQ

w p<O8WELnPn]T9_rw TYQ^[PQ^F v">Q^T j Q^[lˆ (+„ p[ j Q3Q^TVFWVTVFrQxE[PQ^[JH!Q^[]FrQ^WZBTV_p\ {ht{ D

mRQ^[-Q^F j Q^_xv

i7' 55"5-. $'&)('**,BC.07)BP-K(3-:&

SUTYQ EbW5sRQ Q^TVs|FrQ^_PQ^[ Q n]_ j E_PQ^F TYn]_ Q^Fd_PnPMcbrQ^Tj Q^F j g%[ Q7.EO8_PQ l\rnPMPbGo_]w pFsRQ^F w pO %Fhg_]TVsRQ^[

`rQ^bWVO8WELnPn]T9_rO|E_]TYXLFrQ^F v

n]TVF j (Q^[]_][cosRQXLbFrQv%rMcOO|Ephg]v%v%rMPO8O|Ephg>_][]TV_]_qFdp[3\NQ^T^u8v3u EWVWYQ^[9(Q^[]_][cosRQ Ephgv %n%\NQ^[ ‡

TYQ^s|_ j TYQ JFw#EbW j Q^[+FrQ^sdE_]TVmRQ^F ">Q^TYn]KTYQ^WYQ|vNSUTYQ nPQ pFs|WYQ^TYMPbrQ (Q^[]_PQ^TVWVpFs<mRXLFKX|nPTV_]TVmRQ^F?pF j

FrQ^sdE_]TVmRQ^F">Q^TYn]KTYQ^WYQ^F \NQ^[PQ^TV_PQ^_B\Q^TVZ '[]wxQ^psRQ^F j Q^[ [cETVFTVFsRn]\NQ^TYn]KTYQ^WYQƒ'[PXL\WYQ^Z…Q|v Q^[ j Q^F

\NQ^T j TYQ nPQ^[ (Q^[]_PQ^TVWVpFs j TYQ [cETVFTVFsRn]\NQ^TYn]KTYQ^WYQqw phgioWVWVTVsEprn j Q^[E+Q ncEZy_]Z…Q^FsRQyEWVWYQ^[ (Q^[]_][cosRQ

sRQ^wxXLsRQ^F t ORILFFrQ^F j TYQT Q^[]FdmRQ^[ g†Eb[PQ^F Ephgs|pF j4j Q^[3sRQ^[]TVFsRQ^F JFw#EbW j Q^[qKX|n]TV_]TVmRQ^F ">Q^TYn]KTYQ ‡

WYQORQ^TVF„?X

j

Q^WVW'w p[3w pmRQ^[]WoLnPn]TVsRQ^F (XL[]brQ^[Pn EsRQ…mRXLF v %rMPO8OLEphg>WYQ^[]FrQ^F v klZ

j

TYQ nPQ^Z ƒ'[PXL\WYQ^Z

w p\NQ^sRQ^s|FrQ^F t p[ j Q^F4w pFGoLMcbrn]_!mRQ^[]wxQ^[][]_PQˆ_]TYMcbK[PXL\Q^F \TELnPQ j n EZBKWYQ n g %[ j ELn [cETVFTVFs

mRQ^[5Q^F j Q^_xv5ˆTYQ p[ j Q^F Q^[]wxQ^ps|_xt'TVF j Q^Z „?Q^FsRQ^F mRXLF

D

{|{|{pF j z|{|{|{ ">Q^TYn]KTYQ^WYQ^F Eprn j Q^[

E+Q n EZq_]Z…Q^FsRQ ZBTV_ Q 5Q^TVWYns|WYQ^TYMPbrQ^[ lFw#EbW-mRXLF KNX|n]TV_]TVmRQ^F pF j FrQ^sdE_]TVmRQ^F">Q^TYn]KTYQ^WYQ^F Q^Fd_ ‡

FrXLZBZ…Q^F p[ j Q^F v lWYn Q nP_ j E_PQ^FrncE_]w j TYQ^F_PQ^F EWVWYQ %\[]TVsRQ^F:(Q^[]_][cosRQ|v ">Q^T j TYQ nPQ^[y„?Q^_]brX j Q

\NQ n]_PQ^bd_ j TYQ E+Q g†Eb[xt j ELncn j TYQ…ˆ_]TYMcbK[PXL\QFTYMcbd_![PQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TVm/TYn]_xvS!ELnUbGE_Uw p[!`rXLWVsRQ|t j ELnPn

\NQ^Tw 5Q^T'pFd_PQ^[PnPMcbTYQ

j

WVTYMPbrQ^F ˆ_]TYMPbK[PXL\NQ^F -Q^TV_qEprncQ^TVFGEF

j

Q^[!WVTYQ^sRQ^F

j Q T Q^[]FrQ^[]sRQ^\FTYnPnPQ…Q^[]w TYQ^WV_

5Q^[ j Q^F ORILFFrQ^F v-ˆ8X p[ j Q<TVF Q^TVFrQ^Z T Q^[]FWEphg3Ephg j Q^[ `me S+`YvJQ^K[coLncQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLF ZBTV_ j Q^[

ˆ (+„ \NQ^TrQ^TVFrQ^[ [cETVFTVFsRn]Z…Q^FsRQlmRXLF D {|{|{ ">Q^TYn]KTYQ^WYQ^FQ^TVFrQJƒ'[PQ M^TYn]TYXLF)mRXLFJu u8t3u W tdQ^TVFcvlQ MxEWVW

! #"$$%'&()*+,-./-$01)*032456879):01 5;4 "<1)*=?>@("$%'&A

B.C0D -E246FAGH"0I&JKLNMJK"$@OPM%'&8246QR' 52S6(TUM"PV0JKJK<""XWJKY"JK(

LZ+,[\^]$_,_@`a! bSc!dea@fg?TTThi

+ / 9

l\\TVW

j

pFs VhvD D vTVF /.hKQ^[]TVZ…Q^F_JTVF>= T

mRXLFu|uhtu pF

j

Q^TVFrQ M M^p[cELMZBmRXLF uKu8t3u l tTVF)Q^TVFrQ^Z EF

j

Q^[PQ^FJT Q^[]FWEphg p[

j Q j

EsRQ^sRQ^F Fdp[

Q^TVFrQ ƒ'[PQ M^TYnPTYXLF…mRXLF S<u8tz D t|Q^TVFvJQ MxEWVWmRXLF l {htSdu pF j Q^TVFrQ' M M^p[cELMZmRXLF)u D tAV|z Q^[][PQ^TYMcbd_xv

(Q^[]wxQ^[][]_PQJˆ_]TYMcbK[PXL\Q^F)nPTVF j gXLWVs|WVTYMcbBORQ^TVFrQ>s|p_PQ (%EWVTj TYQ^[]pFsRnPn]_][cE_PQ^s|TYQ|v TVFrQ>\Q nPncQ^[PQ (%EWVTj TYQ ‡

[]pFsRnPnP_][cE_PQ^s|TYQJTYn]_ j TYQlH+[PQ^pw m|EWVTj TYQ^[]pFsrv ">Q^T j Q^[>H+[PQ^pw mLEWVTj TYQ^[]pFs TV[ j j TYQtE!Q ncEZq_]Z…Q^FsRQ

j Q^["5Q^TYnPKTYQ^WYQ…TVF Q^TVFrQ…mRXL[]sRQ^sRQ^\NQ^FrQ$ lFw#EbW-mRXLF "5WYIMcORQ^F KGE[]_]TV_]TYXLFTYQ^[]_xv lFrnPMPbWVTYQ RQ^F j -Q^[ ‡

j Q^F TYQ j Q^[]brXLWV_ T Q^[]FWophgiQ j p[PMcbsRQ g%b[]_xv>e F ]Q j Q^Z T Q^[]FWEphg TV[ j Q^TVF EF j Q^[PQ^[ "-WYX8MPO EWYn

[cETVFTVFsRn]Z…Q^FsRQmRQ^[-Q^F j Q^_xt EWVWYQ%\[]TVsRQ^F "5WYIMcORQ^F j TYQ^FrQ^FEWYn Q nP_]Z…Q^FsRQ^F v SlTYQ `rQ^bWYQ^[][cE_PQ

TV[ j %\NQ^[qEWVWYQBSlp[PMcbWophgQsRQ^ZBTV_]_PQ^WV_xt pZ Q^TVFrQBn]_cE\TVWYQ^[PQ 'TVFrnPMcbGo_]w pFsCw pO %Fhg_]TVsRQ^[3`rQ^bWYQ^[

w pQ^[]ZBTV_]_PQ^WVF v

">Q^TEWVWYQ^FyTVZ giXLWVsRQ^F j Q^F! l\rnPMPbFTV_]_ j XLOpZ…Q^F_]TYQ^[]_PQ^F T Q^[]FWophgQ^F p[ j Q%Q^TVFrQ%wxQ^bFhgiELMcbrQ-H+[PQ^pw^‡

m|EWVTj TYQ^[]pFsEFsRQ -Q^F j Q^_xv

' '*)(' B ?2 H0 2

* pFGoLMcbrn]_ p[ j Q^F j TYQ T Q^[]FdmRQ^[ g†Eb[PQ^F4EphgEWVWYQq„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ D } D

>pF j EWVWYQ (Q^[]_][cosRQ$iz

D u V l W

EFsRQ 5Q^F j Q^_xv E\Q^WVWYQVhv}+s|TV\_-Q^TVFrQ^F "l\NQ^[]\WVTYMPO %\NQ^[ j TYQ T Q^[]FrQ^[]sRQ^\FTYnPncQ|vhˆTYQ' p[ j Q^F)g%[ j TYQ

j [PQ^T \Q nPMcb[]TYQ^\Q^FrQ^FJvJQ^K[coLncQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLFrQ^F \Q^T mTYQ^[%Q^TVFsRQ ncQ^_]w _PQ^F T Q^[]FmRQ^[ giEb[PQ^F<Q^[]w TYQ^WV_xv JFbGEF j

j

Q^['[]sRQ^\FTYncnPQ!WELnPnPQ^F/n]TYMPb giXLWVsRQ^F

j

Q">Q XL\GELMPb_]pFsRQ^F/Z)ELMcbrQ^F

•

^{SUTYQ `me S+` pF jqj} TYQ'\TVFGo[PQ^vJQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TYXLF Q^[]w TYQ^WYQ^Fy\Q^TEWVWYQ^F T Q^[]FdmRQ^[ g†Eb[PQ^F j Q^p_]WVTYMPb

\Q nPncQ^[PQ '[]sRQ^\FTYnPnPQqEWYn

j

TYQ vJQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TYXLFCZBTV_

j

Q^FCXL[]TVs|TVFGEWYQ^F?„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ^F v

•

^{SUTYQ (Q^[ g†Eb[PQ^F 5KSrvl pF j ˆ (+„ WVTYQ} giQ^[]F?brQ^[cEprnP[cEsRQ^F j s|p_PQ'[]sRQ^\FTYnPnPQnPX-XLbWg&%[ j TYQ `nme S+` EWYnlEprMcbCg&%[ j TYQ3\TVFGo[PQ]vJQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TYXLF v SUTYQˆ (U„ Q^[]w TYQ^WV_UEphg j Q^[ `nme S+`

vJQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TYXLFQ^TVF `‡f„?QxELn]p[PQUmRXLFuKu8tu V pF

j

Ephg

j

Q^[5\TVFGo[PQ^F vlQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLFQ^TVF

` ‡f„?QxELn]p[PQqmRXLF?u l t3uLz v"5Q^T 5 Srvl TV[ j Q^TVF/`‡f„?QxELn]p[PQ3mRXLF4u|uhtD uaEphg j Q^[ `nme S+`

pF j mRXLFCu Wht} l aEphg j Q^[ \TVFGo[PQ^FsvlQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLF?Q^[][PQ^TYMPbd_xv

•

^{SUTYQ T} Q^[]FrQ^[]sRQ^\FTYncnPQ)EWVWYQ^[9(Q^[ g†Eb[PQ^FwxQ^TVsRQ^F4Fdp[qsRQ^[]TVFsLg%s|TVsRQkJF_PQ^[PnPMPbTYQ j QBw TYncMPbrQ^F j Q^[!\TVFGo[PQ^F4pF j4j Q^[ `nmeS+` vJQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TYXLF v ">Q^T JK[]TYXL[]T'\NQ^_][cos|_ j ELn!`‡f„/QxELn]p[PQ

g %[ j TYQ `me SU`‡fS!E[Pn]_PQ^WVWVpFs W|}ht} V 5ob[PQ^F j Q n5g&%[ j TYQ+\TVFGo[PQ3S!E[Pn]_PQ^WVWVpFs W|zhtu W

\Q^_][cos|_xv "5Q^T j Q^[ˆ (+„ pF j X+ETVmRQ " ECZRQ n nPMPbFrQ^Tj Q^_ j TYQ `meS+` S!E[Pn]_PQ^WVWVpFs?ncXLsdE[

nPMPbWYQ Mcbd_PQ^[ E\ v ">Q^T j Q^[ˆ (+„\NQ^_][cos|_ j ELnB` ‡f„?QxELn]p[PQ g&%[ j TYQ `me S+` S!E[Pn]_PQ^WVWVpFs

uKu8tu V t j EsRQ^sRQ^FC\NQ^_][cos|_JQ n>g&%[ j TYQ!\TVFGo[PQ3S!E[Pn]_PQ^WVWVpFsu l t3uLz v

e F Q^TVFrQ^[Bw -Q^TV_PQ^F (Q^[Pn]prMcbrn][PQ^TVbrQ p[ j Q j Q^[…`r[cEsRQ FGELMPbsRQ^sdEFsRQ^F t5XL\ j TYQ TVFhg%b[]pFs j Q^[

ˆ_PQ^ZBKNQ^WYn]_PQ^prQ^[

D

u|u

l

Q^TVFrQ^F TVFrprnPnJEphg j TYQ JF j Q^[]pFsRQ^F j Q^[ (Q^[]_][cosRQ!bGE_]_PQ|vrSUTYQqˆ_PQ^ZBKQ^W‡

n]_PQ^prQ^[ TV[ j pF_PQ^[yEF j Q^[PQ^Z Ephg pTV_]_]pFsRQ^FmRXLF(Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRn]K[coZBTYQ^F Q^[]brXL\Q^FpF j bGE_

+ / 9

lK[]TYXL[]T

`nme S+` „/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ "-TVFGo[PQq„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ ol[]TVs|TVFGEWYQ3„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ

M M^p[cELMZ u|}htS l u|}ht{|} u;Srt}

ƒ[PQ M^TYn]TYXLF V Wht{Ku V|}htAV l SrtuKu

vlQ MxEWVW uLzhtl u WhtSdu D[l t}|u

`‡f„?QxELn]p[PQ W|}ht} V W|zhtu W }|{htz;S

5 Srvl

`nme S+` „/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ "-TVFGo[PQq„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ ol[]TVs|TVFGEWYQ3„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ

M M^p[cELMZ u|uhtl u u|uhtAV|z l zhtAV|z

ƒ[PQ M^TYn]TYXLF u l tAW D u l t} l z;SrtD u

vlQ MxEWVW u|uht3u l u Vht}|z uSrtl V

`‡f„?QxELn]p[PQ u|uhtD u u Whtl } } WhtAV;S

ˆ (U„

`nme S+` „/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ "-TVFGo[PQq„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ ol[]TVs|TVFGEWYQ3„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ

M M^p[cELMZ u|uht3u

D u|uht

l

z z WhtAW V

ƒ[PQ M^TYn]TYXLF uKu8t{ W u l tl W l t3uL}

vlQ MxEWVW u l tl W u l tAV l D {|{

`‡f„?QxELn]p[PQ uKu8tu V u l t3uLz D Wht{ W

XUETVmRQ" E[ZRQ n

`nme S+` „/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ "-TVFGo[PQq„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ ol[]TVs|TVFGEWYQ3„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ

M M^p[cELMZ

l l t}|z

l

uhtAW W

l

u8tS S

ƒ[PQ M^TYn]TYXLF }Ku8t

l

z S D

t3uLz }|zht{ l

vlQ MxEWVW u l tu|} l Srt}Ku u u8t3uLz

`‡f„?QxELn]p[PQ V D tD S V Vhtl } S)VhtS D

E\NQ^WVWYQ Vhv}hv)"l\NQ^[]\WVTYMPO %\Q^[ j TYQ T Q^[]FrQ^[]sRQ^\FTYnPnPQ

lK[]TYXL[]T

`me SU` „?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ "5TVFGo[PQ3„?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ ol[]TVs|TVFGEWYQ3„?Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ

M M^p[cELMZ u|}htS l u|}ht{|} u;Srt}

ƒ'[PQ M^TYn]TYXLF V Wht{Ku V|}htAV l SrtuKu

vJQ MxEWVW uLzhtl u WhtSdu D[l t}|u

`‡f„/QxELnPp[PQ W|}ht} V W|zhtu W }|{htz;S

5 Srvl

`me SU` „?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ "5TVFGo[PQ3„?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ ol[]TVs|TVFGEWYQ3„?Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ

M M^p[cELMZ u|uht

`me SU` „?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ "5TVFGo[PQ3„?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ ol[]TVs|TVFGEWYQ3„?Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ

M M^p[cELMZ u|uht3u D u|uhtl z z WhtAW V

`me SU` „?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ "5TVFGo[PQ3„?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ ol[]TVs|TVFGEWYQ3„?Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ

M M^p[cELMZ u|zhtz|} u|}htz V l l t{;S

ƒ'[PQ M^TYn]TYXLF SdzhtS S S<u z VhtAV

l

vJQ MxEWVW u Vht

D D l

{htz|z u D tD

u

`‡f„/QxELnPp[PQ V;Srtz;S V|uhtzKu }Ku8tAW;S

E\Q^WVWYQ VhvSrv9"J\NQ^[]\WVTYMPO$%\Q^[ j TYQtT Q^[]FrQ^[]sRQ^\FTYnPnPQU\NQ^T lprnPnPMcbWVprnPn j Q^[ D u|u l w p[%rMPO8sRQ^O|Ephg_PQ^F

(Q^[]_][cosRQ

j Ew p sRQ g&%b[]_xt j ELncn…m8TYQ^WYQH+pF j Q^F TVb[PQ8(Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRn]mRQ^[]_][cosRQO %F j TVs|_PQ^F v lWVWYQ!(Q^[]_][cosRQ|t

j

TYQ+TVZ 5dEb[ D u|u l w p[%rMPO8sRQ^OLEphg_' p[

j

Q^F t p[

j

Q^F

j

EbrQ^[ mRXLZ T Q^[]FK[PXLwxQ nPnlEprn]sRQ ncMPbWYX|nPnPQ^F v

E\Q^WVWYQ VhvS wxQ^TVs|_ j TYQ!'[]sRQ^\FTYncnPQ j TYQ nPQ^[tT Q^[]FW ophgQ|v „EFn]TYQ^bd_xt j ELnPn j TYQDlQ^[cEprnPFGEbZ…Q j Q^[

D

u|u

l w p[%rMPO8sRQ^O|Ephg_PQ^F!(Q^[]_][cosRQUORQ^TVFrQ^F<n]TVs|FT9_rO|EFd_PQ^F 'TVFrprnPn Ephg j TYQ pGEWVTV_co_ j Q^[iT Q^[]FrQ^[ ‡

sRQ^\FTYnPncQ+FTVZBZq_xv

TYQ \Q^[PQ^TV_Pn…\Q nPMcb[]TYQ^\Q^F tpFd_PQ^[PnPMcbrQ^Tj Q^F n]TYMcb j TYQ T Q^[]FrQ^[]sRQ^\FTYnPncQ/EWVWYQ^[ (Q^[ g†Eb[PQ^F g&%[ j TYQ

`meSU`?pF

j…j

TYQJ\TVFGo[PQ vJQ^K[coLncQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLF Fdp[sRQ^[]TVFsLg&%s|TVsrv TVF EU[]pF j…j

E1g&%[O|EFF)nPQ^TVF t j ELnPn

j TYQ+\NQ^T `nme S+` pFd_PQ^[Pn]prMcbd_PQ DUop_rs|ORQ^TV_ j Q^[ „?Q^[]Z)EWYQ!FTYMcbd_ mRXLF j Q^Z \TVFGo[lQ^[ giELnPnP_PQ^F (XL[ ‡

bGEF j Q^FrnPQ^TVF j Q^[ „?Q^[]OZ)EWYQUpFd_PQ^[PncMPbTYQ j Q^F 5Q^[ j Q^F<OLEFF v8klZ j ELn5w p %\NQ^[]K[%hg Q^F t p[ j Qlg&%[

]Q j Q^F6(Q^[]_][cEs4\NQ n]_]TVZBZy_xtTVF TYQ^m8TYQ^WYQ^F# >_]_][]TV\p_PQ^F n]TYMPb j TYQ `meS+` vlQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLF mRXLF

+ / 9

JFw#EbW j Q^[ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ JFw#EbW j Q^[ (Q^[]_][cosRQ

D

W;S<uSd{

z uLz W l u

} D { l { D

S u V V|z

V D V|u l

W D D {|}

u D { W W

l D zKu u

u } l W

D { l {

D D zKu

D z S

E\NQ^WVWYQtVhvAVhv '[]sRQ^\FTYn j Q n (Q^[]s|WYQ^TYMPbrn w TYnPMcbrQ^F j Q^[' `nme S+`pF j j Q^[>\TVFGo[PQ^F vJQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE1‡

_]TYXLF

j

Q^[y\TVFGo[PQ^F vJQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TYXLF pFd_PQ^[PnPMcbrQ^T

j

Q^_xv ">Q^T D W D }|z|}8(Q^[]_][cosRQ^F wxQ^TVs|_Bn]TYMcb Q^TVF kJF_PQ^[ ‡

nPMPbTYQ j w TYnPMPbrQ^F j Q^[ `me S+`NvJQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TYXLF pF jj Q^[-\TVFGo[PQ^F vlQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLF v lWVWYQ^[ j TVFsRn

Q7.8TYn]_]TYQ^[PQ^F Fdp[-Q^FTVsRQ (Q^[]_][cosRQ|t \NQ^T j Q^FrQ^F n]TYMcb j TYQ DUop_rs|ORQ^TV_pF j j ELn (XL[]ORXLZBZ…Q^F \NQ^T

Z…Q^b[ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ^F4pF_PQ^[PnPMPbrQ^Tj Q^_ nPTYQ^brQ E\Q^WVWYQ VhvAV vNSUTYQ n+TYn]_+Q^TVFrQqZ…ILs|WVTYMcbrQ '[]OWo[]pFs g&%[

j Q^F<sRQ^[]TVFsLg%s|TVsRQ^F?kJF_PQ^[PnPMPbTYQ j?j Q^[ T Q^[]FrQ^[]sRQ^\FTYnPnPQq\Q^T j Q^FC\Q^Tj Q^FsvlQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLFrQ^F v

TYQ<nPMcbrXLF \NQ nPMPb[]TYQ^\NQ^F wxQ^TVsRQ^F j TYQ!(Q^[ g†Eb[PQ^F 5 Srv

l

pF j ˆ (+„ brQ^[cEprn][cEsRQ^F j Q '[]sRQ^\FTYncnPQ

nPX5XLbWNg%[ j TYQ `meS+` EWYn EprMcb g %[ j TYQU\TVFGo[PQ vJQ^K[coLncQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLF v 'TVFrQ '[]O8Wo[]pFsg&%[5\NQ^Tj Q

(Q^[ giEb[PQ^F?OLEFF?FTYMPb_!sRQ^sRQ^\Q^F 5Q^[ j Q^F t j E…g&%[ j TYQyZ…Q^TYn]_PQ^F@T Q^[]FdmRQ^[ g†Eb[PQ^F4ORQ^TVFrQ>brQ XL[]TYQ^F

w p['[]ORQ^FFdpFs TVb[PQ^[ lF -Q^F j \GE[]ORQ^TV_!Ephg'Q^TVFrQ^Z S!E_PQ^FrncE_]wqQ7.hTYn]_]TYQ^[PQ^F v

` %[ j TYQ ˆ (+„apF j Q7.h_]O8WELnPn]T9_rO|E_]TYXLFrnPncEphgsdE\Q^F p[ j Q>mRXLF 5RXRELMcbTVZ…n ) "!$#&%(') z|{|{|z GQ^TVF

n]_cE_]TYn]_]TYnPMcbrQ n T Q^[]FZ…X j Q^WVW%Q^Fd_ TYMPORQ^WV_xvefZ FGoLMcbrn]_PQ^F H3EKTV_PQ^W TV[ j4j TYQ ncQ n3„/X j Q^WVW'w p['[]O8Wo1‡

[]pFs j Q n s|p_PQ^FFT Q^[]FrQ^[]sRQ^\FTYnPnPQ n j Q^[…ˆ (+„;Ephg j Q^[ `nme S+` vlQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLF EFsRQ >EF j _xv

S+E j TYQ nPQ n „?X j Q^WVW Ephg j Q^['" ELn]TYn j Q^[ DUop_rs|ORQ^TV_PnPmRQ^[]_PQ^TVWVpFs)mRXLF IL[]_PQ^[]F<Q^F_ TYMPORQ^WV_ p[ j Q|t

OLEFFqQ n FTYMPb_ Ephg j TYQ\TVFGo[PQ^vJQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TYXLF EFsRQ -Q^F j Q^_ 5Q^[ j Q^F vQ^TV_PQ^[PQ /.8KNQ^[]TVZ…Q^Fd_PQ%ZBTV_

EF j Q^[PQ^F S!E_PQ^Frnco_]wxQ^F<n]TVF j FrXL_ -Q^F j TVsrtrpZ j TYQ4"J\NQ^[]WYQ^sRQ^FbrQ^TV_ j Q^[ `me SU` vJQ^K[coLnPQ^F_cE_]TYXLF

w pCEF j Q^[PQ^FfvJQ^K[coLncQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLFrQ^FCw pCpFd_PQ^[Pn]prMcbrQ^F v

e F j TYQ ncQ^ZaH3EKTV_PQ^W TV[ j<j ELn>s|p_PQ T Q^[]FrQ^[]sRQ^\FTYn j Q^[lˆ (+„ Ephg j Q^[ `me S+`vlQ^K[coLnPQ^Fd_cE_]TYXLF

EFbGEF j j Q nn]_cE_]TYn]_]TYncMPbrQ^F T Q^[]FZ…X j Q^WVWYnBmRXLF 5RXRELMcbTVZ…n ) "! # %(') z|{|{|z pFd_PQ^[Pn]prMcbd_xv-ˆ8Q^TVF

„?X

j

Q^WVW'\NQ -Q^TYnP_

j

TYQ lF 5Q^F

j

\GE[]ORQ^TV_ mRXLF ˆ (U„?nqEphg Q7.h_]OWELncn]T9_rOLE_]TYXLFrn EphgsdE\NQ^F v lphg

j

Q^[

" ELn]TYn mRXLF n]_cE_]TYn]_]TYncMPbrQ^F 'TVsRQ^FrncMPbGE1g_PQ^F Q^Fd_ TYMPORQ^WV_PQ=5dXRELMPbTVZ…n O\>E_ ‡fHlXLFwxQ^K_PQ?EWYnB„?X j Q^WVW

g&%[ Q7.h_]OWELncn]T9_rOLE_]TYXLFrn EphgsdE\NQ^F v

X+ELMPb j Q^[ '[]Wop_PQ^[]pFs j Q nJn]_cE_]TYn]_]TYncMPbrQ^F T Q^[]FZ…X j Q^WVWYnUQ^[giXLWVs|_ j TYQ lF 5Q^F j pFs<Ephg j TYQ (Q^[ ‡

n]TYMcbrQ^[]pFsRn j E_PQ^F v 'TVFrQ lF 5Q^F j pFs j Q n>„/X j Q^WVWYn5OLEFF ]Q j XMcb Q^[PnP_5FGELMcb<Q^[g XLWVs|_PQ^[ [cEFrn gXL[ ‡

Z)E_]TYXLFTVF `nmeS+` „/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ3Q^[ giXLWVsRQ^F v* p[ l\rnPMPbGo_]w pFs

j

Q^[ 'TVs|FdpFs Q^TVFrQ n S!E_PQ^FrncE_]wxQ n

g&%[lQ^TVFrQ `meS+` [cEFrn giXL[]Z)E_]TYXLF TV[ j Q^TVFrQyDUQ^p[]TYn]_]TVO/EFsRQ^sRQ^\NQ^F v J\rnPMcbWVTYQ RQ^F j TV[ j/j TYQ

SUTVKWYXLZ)E[]\NQ^TV_ w pCQ^TVFrQ^[ mRQ^[>EF j _PQ^F l[]\Q^TV_lE\sRQ^s|[PQ^Fw _xv

" "

"

SUTYQ`pFO8_]TYXLFrn-Q^TYnPQ

j

Q^[yˆ (U„ p[

j

QBTVF4H3EKTV_PQ^W-zTVZ J\rnPMcbFTV_]_yzhv}hvD Q^[]W op_PQ^[]_xv n p[ ‡

j Q sRQ ncEs|_xt j ELnPn j TYQ…ˆ (U„ sRQ^FGEp j TYQBDOZ8KQ^[PQ^\NQ^FrQ!5obWV_xt j TYQ…EWVWYQ KX|nPTV_]TVmRQ^F?pF j FrQ^sdE_]TVmRQ^F

">Q^TYn]KTYQ^WYQUZBTV_>Z)E.8TVZ)EWYQ^Z l\rn]_cEF j _][PQ^FF_xvSlTYQ ncQUDpZ8KQ^[PQ^\NQ^FrQJbGE_ w p ]Q j Q^Z "5Q^TYnPKTYQ^WZBTVFh‡

j Q n]_PQ^FrnJQ^TVFrQ^F J\rnP_cEF

j

mRXLF

δ

^v

δ

^{TV[ j vUEF j Q^Fs|W†v . *21 6 j} Q^[JDpZ8KQ^[PQ^\NQ^FrQ+sRQ^FGEFFd_xv S!ELn+giXLWVsRQ^F j Q >brQ XL[PQ^Z wxQ^TVs|_xt j ELnPn j TYQ…HJXLZy\TVFGE_]TYXLF mRXLF Q^TVFrQ^Z s|[PXRQ^FUvlEF j ZBTV_qQ^TVFrQ^Z

FTYQ

j

[]TVsRQ^F [cETVFTVFsRn]gQ^bWYQ^[!w pQ^TVFrQ^[+brXLbrQ^F@E+Q^FrQ^[cEWVTYnPTYQ^[]pFsRn]sRQ^FGEpTVs|ORQ^TV_3g&%b[]_xv ` %[

j

Q^F4Q^[ ‡

>E[]_PQ^_PQ^F/`rQ^bWYQ^[ TV[ j Q^TVFrQyˆ8MPb[cEFORQ EFsRQ^sRQ^\Q^F v

G ! # - *.G ,+ #xdx) d7

2(4(+*; . *;, (;, ( (:(+*+* . ,(

ε(Err ⁿ (h SV M ))

^{(6 (+* &IO , ( K:(+*} )*/(;6)6)8961 .: (+* (+6 7 . 8

SlTYQ ncQ!ˆ8Mcb[cEFORQ+wxQ^TVs|_xt j ELnPn j TYQ3ˆ8MPbW%rnPncQ^WVs|[PIRQ^F j Q^[ vlEF j

δ

^{t j TYQtT oFsRQ j Q^[} S+XLOpZ…Q^F_]mRQ^Od‡

_PXL[PQ^F

R

^{pF j<j Q^[} [cETVFTVFsRn giQ^bWYQ^[

ξ

^{n]TVF j v}

kJZ JprnPn EsRQ^F %\NQ^[Q7.8_]O8WELnPn]T9_rO|E_]TYXLFrncEphg sdE\Q^F _][PQRNQ^F w pORILFFrQ^F tg&%b[]_PQ 5dXRELMPbTVZ…n j TYQ

O\>E_ ‡fHJXLFwxQ^K_PQEWYn3sRQ^FrQ^[PQ^WVWYQ nq„?X j Q^WVWQ^TVF v nyE\rn]_][cEbTYQ^[]_3mRXLFQ^TVFwxQ^WVFrQ^F Q7.8_]O8WELnPn]T9_rO|E_]T‡

XLFrncEphgsdE\NQ^F<pF

j

\NQ^[]pbd_lEphgg&%Fhg n]_cE_]TYnP_]TYnPMPbrQ^F 'TVsRQ^FrnPMPbGE1g_PQ^F

•

^{DlX8MPb j} TVZ…Q^FrnPTYXLFGEWYQ^[l„?Q^[]OZ)EWYn][cEpZ

Q7.h_]O8WELnPn]T9_rO|E_]TYXLFrn]K[PXL\WYQ^Z…QJbGE\NQ^F…Q^TVFrQ^F)brX8MPb j TVZ…Q^FrnPTYXLFGEWYQ^F „?Q^[]OZ)EWYnP[cEpZv Q^FF

]Q

j Q n!XL[]_xt

j

ELn TVF Q^TVFrQ^Z S+XLO8pZ…Q^Fd_BQ^[PnPMcbrQ^TVFd_xtEWYn„/Q^[]O8Z)EW>\Q^_][cELMcbd_PQ^_ TV[

j t bGE1‡

\NQ^F$ Q7.h_]O8WELnPn]T9_rO|E_]TYXLFrn]K[PXL\WYQ^Z…QU\Q^TQ^TVFTVsRQ^F$EprncQ^F j S+XLO8pZ…Q^Fd_PQ^F D {|{|{|{3pF j Z…Q^b[

SUTVZ…Q^Frn]TYXLFrQ^F v

•

ˆKGo[]WVTYMPb/\Q nPQ^_]w _PQqSUXLO8pZ…Q^Fd_]mRQ^O8_PXL[PQ^F

SUTYQ lFw#EbW j Q^[ Z…ILs|WVTYMcbrQ^F?„?Q^[]OZ)EWYQqTYn]_ s|[PXrv5RQ j Q nJS+XLO8pZ…Q^Fd_+Q^Fd_]bGoWV_ ]Q j X8MPbCFp[

Q^TVFrQlOWYQ^TVFrQ JFw#EbWpFd_PQ^[PncMPbTYQ

_PXL[PQ^FCn]KGo[]WVTYMcb\NQ nPQ^_]w _Jn]TVF j v

•

DlQ^_PQ^[PXLsRQ^FrQ^[ E+Q^\[cEprMPb/mRXLF XL[]_PQ^F

(Q^[5EF j _PQ+S+XLO8pZ…Q^Fd_PQ+Q^Fd_]bGEWV_PQ^FCˆ8MPbW%rncnPQ^W-IL[]_PQ^[xtE\NQ^[5Q n%s|TV\_-ORQ^TVF$XL[]_xt j ELn>EWVWYQ^F

mRQ^[5EF

j

_PQ^F S+XLO8pZ…Q^Fd_PQ^F sRQ^Z…Q^TVFrncEZ TYn]_xv%S+XLO8pZ…Q^Fd_PQEprn

j

Q^[s|WYQ^TYMPbrQ^F H3E_PQ^sRXL[]TYQ

ORILFFrQ^F/Eprn mRQ^[PncMPbTYQ j Q^FrQ^F XL[]_PQ^F\Q nP_PQ^brQ^F v

•

DlXLbrQ^[pvJQ j pF j EFw s|[cEF j

SUTYQ Z…Q^TYn]_PQ^F S+XLOpZ…Q^F_PQJQ^Fd_]bGEWV_PQ^F Z…Q^b[>EWYn%Q^TVF XL[]_-w p[ ">Q n]_]TVZBZypFs j Q^[5H+WELnPnPQ^Fh‡

w psRQ^brIL[]TVs|ORQ^TV_xv 'F_ gQ^[]F_3Z)EF

j

TYQBMPbGE[cEO8_PQ^[]TYn]_]TYnPMcbrQ^F„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ|tNORILFFrQ^F

j

TYQ mRQ^[]\WVTYQ ‡

\NQ^FrQ^F IL[]_PQ^[ TVZBZ…Q^[lFrXMcbw pQ^TVFrQ^ZasRQ TYnPncQ^F EU[cE j<j Q^FCeFbGEWV_ \NQ nPMPb[PQ^TV\NQ^F v

•

^{* TVKhg nPMPbrQ nE+Q nPQ^_]w}

S!ELn * TVKhg ncMPbrQ@E+Q nPQ^_]wCZ…X j Q^WVWVTYQ^[]_ j TYQCD+op_rs|ORQ^TV_Pn]mRQ^[]_PQ^TVWVpFs mRXLF XL[]_PQ^F TVF FGE_%[ ‡

WVTYMPbrnPK[cELMPbWVTYMPbrQ^F Q7.8_PQ^F %K D

u;Sdu fvGS!ELntE!Q nPQ^_]wq\NQ ncEs|_( Q^[ j Q^F XL[]_PQqFGELMcb

TVb[PQ^['XL[]_]bGop_rs|ORQ^TV_JsRQ XL[

TYQ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,dprQ^Fw

tf _r

^{j Q n}

r

‡†bGop_rsRn]_PQ^F XL[]_PQ n(

tf r = 1

r · tf r max

dWhv}

tf _{r max}

^{TYn]_ j TYQ Q^[]Zg}[PQ-,prQ^Fw j Q n bGop_rsRn]_PQ^F XL[]_PQ nxv

„?EF j Q^WV\[PXL_]mRQ^[]_PQ^TVWVpFsRQ^F -M )! D u V|u+wxQ^TVsRQ^F Q^TVFrQ?FrX8MPb sRQ^FGEprQ^[PQ JFKGELn]‡

n]pFsrvGˆTYQ -Q^[ j Q^F j p[PMPb<giXLWVsRQ^F j Qq`GXL[]Z…Q^WEFsRQ^sRQ^\Q^F

tf _i = c (k + r) ^φ

dWhvS

SlTYQtEUWYQ^TYMPbpFsy\NQ nPMcb[PQ^TV\_ j Q^F!* prncEZBZ…Q^FbGEFsyw TYncMPbrQ^F j Q^Z D+op_rs|ORQ^TV_Pn][cEFs

r

^{pF j}

j Q^[Q^[]ZBbGop_rs|ORQ^TV_

tf _r

^{v ˆTYQ$ TV[ j j Q n]bGEWV\ EprMcb} sRQ^FrQ^[cEWVTYn]TYQ^[]_PQ n * TVKhg nPMPbrQ nE+Q ncQ^_]w sRQ^FGEFFd_xv

5RXRELMcbTVZ…n bGE_>sRQ^wxQ^TVs|_xt j ELnPn H+WELncn]T9_rOLE_]TYXLFrn EphgsdE\NQ^F thsRQ^FrQ^[PQ^WVW nPQ^KNQ^[cE[]TYQ^[]\GE[ n]TVF j t -Q^FFCnPTYQ

n]TYMcbEWYn'O\>E_ ‡fHJXLFwxQ^K_PQyWELnPnPnPQ^F v8` %[

j

pF_PQ^[PQyˆ8MPb[cEFORQq\Q TYQ nPQ^F v

% ! # xd

ˆ8Q^KGE[]TYQ^[]\GE[]ORQ^TV_BTVZBKWVTVw TYQ^[]_xt

j

ELnPn

j

Q^[ [cETVFTVFsRn gQ^bWYQ^[BFpWVW>TYn]_xv (XL[cEprncnPQ^_]w pFs?g %[

j

TYQ$ lFh‡

-Q^F j \GE[]ORQ^TV_ mRXLF >brQ XL[PQ^Z D TYn]_5Q^TVFrQ3ˆ8MPb[cEFORQUg&%[ j TYQUZ)E.8TVZ)EWYQ'pO8WVTj TYnPMcbrQToFsRQ

R

^{j Q^[}

SUXLO8pZ…Q^Fd_]mRQ^O8_PXL[PQ^F v SUTYQ 'pO8WVTj TYnPMcbrQcT oFsRQ j Q nqSUXLO8pZ…Q^Fd_]mRQ^O8_PXL[Pn Q^TVFrQ n3S+XLOpZ…Q^F_PQBZBTV_

l

IL[]_PQ^[]F4OLEFF4FTYMcbd_3s|[PIRQ^[yEWYn

l

^{nPQ^TVF v `} %[![PQxEWYQBS+XLOpZ…Q^F_]mRQ^O_PXL[PQ^F TYn]_ j TYQ nPQ)ˆ8MPb[cEFORQ FTYMPbd_qK[cow TYnPQsRQ^Fdpsrv S!ELn * TVKhg nPMcbrQcE+Q nPQ^_]w TV[ j EFsRQ >EF j _xt pZ Q^TVFrQsRQ^FGEprQ^[PQˆ8Mcb[cEFORQ

g%[

R

EFsRQ^\NQ^Fw p<ORILFFrQ^F v

SlTYQ lFFGEbZ…Q|t j ELnPn j TYQ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,dprQ^FwxQ^FyTVF ]Q j Q^Z SUXLO8pZ…Q^Fd_ j Q^Z sRQ^FrQ^[cEWVTYn]TYQ^[]_PQ^F * TVKhg nPMPbrQ^F

E+Q nPQ^_]w)sRQ^brXL[PMcbrQ^F t TVZBKWVTVw TYQ^[]_yFTYMcbd_xt j ELnPn Q^TVF\NQ n]_]TVZBZq_PQ nXL[]_qZBTV_Q^TVFrQ^[qsRQ TYncnPQ^F D+oph‡

_rs|ORQ^TV_…TVF Q j Q^Z SUXLO8pZ…Q^Fd_)mRQ^[]_][PQ^_PQ^F TYn]_xv'S!ELn * TVKhg nPMcbrQsE+Q nPQ^_]wCn Es|_BFdp[Eprnxt j ELncn j ELn

r

‡†bGop_rsRn]_PQ XL[]_ZBTV_…Q^TVFrQ^[BsRQ TYnPncQ^F DUop_rs|ORQ^TV_BmRXL[]ORXLZBZy_xv%e F pF_PQ^[PnPMPbTYQ j WVTYMcbrQ^F S+XLO8ph‡

Z…Q^Fd_PQ^FOLEFF j ELn

r

‡†bGop_rsRn]_PQXL[]_UmRQ^[PnPMPbTYQ j Q^FncQ^TVF vGS!ELnlgXLWVsRQ^F j Q T Q^ZBZ)EmRQ^[]\TVF j Q^_ j TYQ T oFsRQ j Q^[JS+XLO8pZ…Q^Fd_]mRQ^O8_PXL[PQ^FCZBTV_ j Q^Z * TVKhg ncMPbrQ^F E+Q ncQ^_]wRv

# +€*. ','&(- $ 21 , d < . € + .Nx 1+ 7

SlTYQ E_PncELMcbrQ|t j ELnPn j TYQ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,prQ^FwxQ^F j Q^Z * TVKhg nPMPbrQ^F E!Q nPQ^_]w sRQ^brXL[PMPbrQ^F t8bGE_%Q^TVFrQ^F n]_cE[‡

ORQ^F 'TVFrprnPn Ephg j TYQcT Q^[]Fd\GE[]ORQ^TV_mRXLF Q7.8_]O8WELnPn]T9_rO|E_]TYXLFrncEphgsdE\Q^F vS+ELn * TVKhg nPMPbrQ E+Q nPQ^_]w

TVZBKWVTVw TYQ^[]_xt

j

ELnPn

j

TYQ Z…Q^TYn]_PQ^F XL[]_PQ nPTYMPb)FTYMcbd_5Xg_ TYQ

j

_PQ^[PnPMPbTYQ j WVTYMcbrQ^F XL[]_PQ

d

brXMcbTYn]_xv Q^FF j ELn+* TVKhg nPMcbrQ]E+Q nPQ^_]w!FTYMcbd_JsRQ^WV_PQ^F '%[ j Q|tORILFFd_PQ n]TYMPbQ^TVF?Q^TVFwxQ^WVFrQ n XL[]_

l

^{‡†Z)EW TYQ j} Q^[]brXLWYQ^F tNnPX j ELnPn j Q^[US+XLO8pZ…Q^Fd_]mRQ^O8_PXL[+Q^TVFrQ'pO8WVTj TYnPMPbrQ T oFsRQCmRXLF

i

bGo_]_PQ|v5„/TV_ j Q^Z * TVKhg nPMPbrQ E+Q nPQ^_]w/Q^[]bGoWV_ Z)EF j EsRQ^sRQ^F mRQ^[]s|WYQ^TYMcbd\GE[<O8p[]wxQ SUXLO8pZ…Q^Fd_]mRQ^O8_PXL[PQ^F pF j Q^TVFrQ^FFTYQ j []TVsRQ^F Q^[]_3g&%[

R ²

^{TVF j} Q^[ˆ8MPb[cEFORQ)g&%[ j TYQ)Q^[>E[]_PQ^_PQ E+Q^FrQ^[cEWVTYn]TYQ^[]pFsRn]KNQ^[ gXL[]Z)EFwRv

SlTYQ%HJXLZq\TVFGE_]TYXLFmRXLF T Q^ZBZ)E D pF j T Q^ZBZ)Elz ZBTV_ >brQ XL[PQ^Z D g&%b[]_ w p!giXLWVsRQ^F j Q^Z []sRQ^\FTYn

(+6 (+* .< (+*+861 :(:(+* ( 6 (;*896(+*@ (;* *;,(+68 & O 6 . ;: 70( */. 6 61>. 8

TYQ5\Q^[PQ^TV_Pn'\NQ nPMcb[]TYQ^\Q^F…\NQ^[]pbd_ j ELn„/X j Q^WVWhmRXLF45RXRELMcbTVZ…n-Ephg n]_cE_]TYn]_]TYnPMcbrQ^F 'TVsRQ^FrnPMcbGE1g_PQ^F v

klZ Q n Ephg j TYQ (Q^[Pn]TYMcbrQ^[]pFsRn j E_PQ^F/EF 5Q^F j Q^Fw p ORILFFrQ^F thZ%rnPnPQ^F<obFWVTYMPbrQ!nP_cE_]TYn]_]TYnPMPbrQ'T‡

sRQ^FrnPMcbGE1g_PQ^FEprMcb/g&%[ j TYQ ncQyS!E_PQ^FsRQ^WV_PQ^F v "5Q^[PQ^TV_PnUTVFH3EKTV_PQ^WV p[ j QyTVZ l\rnPMcbFTV_]_ VhvzhvD

giQ n]_]sRQ n]_PQ^WVWV_xt j ELncn n]TYMPb j TYQ (Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRn j E_PQ^F j p[PMcb/Q^TVFrQ^FbrX8MPb j TVZ…Q^Frn]TYXLFGEWYQ^F4„?Q^[]OZ)EWYn]‡

[cEpZapF j nPKGo[]WVTYMPbC\NQ nPQ^_]w _PQ 'TVsRQ^FrncMPbGE1g_Pn]mRQ^O_PXL[PQ^F4Eprn]wxQ^TYMcbFrQ^F v

(XL[cEprnPncQ^_]w pFs g%[ j TYQB„?X j Q^WVWVTYQ^[]pFs j Q^[3S!E_PQ^FEWYn O\>E_ ‡fHJXLFwxQ^K_yTYn]_ j TYQ 'TVFd_PQ^TVWVpFs j Q^[

>_]_][]TV\p_PQ<Q^F_Pn]K[PQ MPbrQ^F j TVb[PQ^[ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,dprQ^Fw , (;* +*/( 8 (+6 K BTVF brX8MPbh‡$ : 1 :1 * (;8)(+6 9 t

ZBTV_]_PQ^W‡ ( 78< +* (;8)(+6 K 3pF j FTYQ j []TVsLg[PQ-,prQ^Fd_PQ +* (;8)(+6 K >_]_][]TV\p_PQ|v SUTYQ Q^[]Z‡

g[PQ-,dprQ^Fw3g%[JQ^TVF >_]_][]TV\p_

a _i

Q^[]s|TV\_Un]TYMcb/EWYnUˆpZBZ…Q j Q^[ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,prQ^FwxQ^F j Q n >_]_][]TV\p_PnlTVF EWVWYQ^F8(Q^[]_][cosRQ$iz D u V l W>pF j \NQ^[PQ MPbFrQ^_JnPTYMPb<giXLWVsRQ^F j Q^[]Z)E RQ^F

tf (a _i ) =

w#EbW†v'SUTYQ vUEFs|w#EbW D Q^[]bGoWV_ j ELn >_]_][]TV\p_)ZBTV_ j Q^[)brIMcbrn]_PQ^F Q^[]Zg[PQ-,prQ^FwRvnBbGEF j Q^WV_

n]TYMcb j E\NQ^T%pZ j ELn >_]_][]TV\p_y„?k D

{|{|} `rXL[]_PnPMcb[PQ^TV\pFs'"l\NQ^[PnPMPbprnPn3mRXL[PnPMcb %rnPnPTVs !ZBTV_ Q^T‡

FrQ^[ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,prQ^Fw mRXLFV|}|z W|u

D

vUSlTYQ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ „?k z;S &">Q^s|TVFF j Q nsvlQ^Fd_PQ^F\Q^w psRn?\NQ^T

Q ‡(Q^[Pn]TYMPbrQ^[]pFsRQ^F t „?k V|z & lphgbrQ^\pFsFXUQ^prQ^TVFd_][]TV_]_ t „?k V W e Fdm|EWVT

j

Q^[]OWo[]pFs O8WYQ^T‡

FrQ)e Fdm|EWVTj TV_co_3pF j „?k D {;S<u & l\WEphgOv TYn]TVORXLw prnPMcbWEs !_][PQ^_PQ^F j EsRQ^sRQ^F Fdp[Q^TVFZ)EW Ephg

pF j \NQ^WYQ^sRQ^F j TYQbTVFd_PQ^[PnP_PQ^F vUoFsRQ|veF l\\TVWj pFsNWhvD TYn]_ j Q^[vlEFs j Q^[ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ sRQ^sRQ^F

j TYQ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,dprQ^Fw EphgsRQ^_][cEsRQ^F v Jprn j Q^[9(Q^[]_PQ^TVWVpFs j Q^[! Q^[]Zg[PQ-,dprQ^FwxQ^F Q^[]s|TV\_qn]TYMcbQ^TVFrQ

'TVFd_PQ^TVWVpFs TVF)brX8MPbh‡ctZBTV_]_PQ^W‡pF j FTYQ j []TVsLg[PQ-,prQ^Fd_PQ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ|v8DlX8MPbhg[PQ-,dprQ^F_PQ >_]_][]TV\p_PQlbGE1‡

\Q^FQ^TVFrQ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,prQ^Fw mRXLFZ…Q^b[ D {|{{|{|{hv ">Q^TZBTV_]_PQ^Wg[PQ-,prQ^Fd_PQ^F >_]_][]TV\p_PQ^F\NQ^_][cos|_ j TYQ

Q^[]Zg[PQ-,dprQ^Fw3w TYncMPbrQ^F

D

{|{ pF j D

{|{B{|{|{hv >_]_][]TV\p_PQ!ZBTV_ Q^TVFrQ^[ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,prQ^FwqmRXLF 5Q^FTVsRQ^[

EWYn D {|{/n]TVF j FTYQ j []TVsCg[PQ-,dprQ^F_PQ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ|v SUTYQ$ >_]_][]TV\p_PQTVF j Q^F j [PQ^T5H3E_PQ^sRXL[]TYQ^F Z%rncnPQ^F

J\\TVW

j

pFs]WhvD v 'TVFd_PQ^TVWVpFs

j

Q^[ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ TVFBbrX8MPbh‡ct|ZBTV_]_PQ^W‡ pF

j

FTYQ

j

[]TVsLg[PQ-,prQ^Fd_PQ >_]_][]TV\p_PQ

EFbGEF j TVb[PQ^[ Q^[]Zg[PQ-,prQ^FwxQ^F

FdpF ]Q -Q^TVWYnyTVF j TYn pFO8_PQ)„?Q^FsRQ^FKNX|n]TV_]TVmRQ^[3pF j FrQ^sdE_]TVmRQ^[e F j TVOLE_PXL[PQ^F nPX TYQ)TV[][PQ^WYQ^mLEF_PQ^[

„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ KGE[]_]TV_]TYXLFTYQ^[]_ -Q^[

j

Q^F vhSUTYQ TVFd_PQ^TVWVpFs…Q^[ giXLWVs|_5EFbGEF j j

Q^[io jj

n vlE_]TYX‡Q^[]_PQ

j

Q^[

>_]_][]TV\p_PQ|vGSUTYQ o jj nOvUE_]TYXTYn]_' TYQ+giXLWVs|_ j Q_rFTYQ^[]_(

< # # ,0,0& h#I7

E9*%(6 */(1 6 :

E

^{, 7(+* . :0* : ;:( 6 ;: (-,}

P (E)

^{:;, 7 ( 707: 70('C 6 (+*;, .<:}

P r(E)

1 − P r(E) .

^dWhvl

E9*>@K (( * (1<6 : : (

E ₁

^{86 7}

E ₂

^{-, 7(+6 . :0* : ;:( 6 ;: (-, (+6}

P (E ₁ )

^{896 7}

P (E ₂ )

^{:;, 7 (}

707: .<,D 7 . : &)(+*G:LN,-6 : 70(+* 707: / 6

E ₁

^{@;89* 707:>/ 6}

E ₂

^{Q 2( 7 7: . ,3:;, :9 ,}

70(3C 6 (+*+, .:

` %[ j TYQ (Q^[Pn]TYMcbrQ^[]pFsRn j E_PQ^F\NQ^wxQ^TYMPbFrQ^_

E ₁

^j ELn'[PQ^TVs|FTYnxt j ELnPn+TVFQ^TVFrQ^Z w p[%rMPO8sRQ^O|Ephg_PQ^F (Q^[]_][cEs j ELn >_]_][]TV\p_

a _i

mRXL[]ORXLZBZy_xv

E ₂

^{TYnP_ j ELn} '[PQ^TVs|FTYnxt j ELnPn TVF3Q^TVFrQ^Z giXL[]_]sRQ nPQ^_]w _PQ^F (Q^[]_][cEs j ELn >_]_][]TV\p_

a _i

mRXL[]ORXLZBZq_xv SUTYQ]o jj n mRXLF

E ₁

^{\Q^[PQ} McbFrQ^_Jn]TYMPbgXLWVsRQ^[]F j Q^[]Z)E RQ^F

P r(E ₁ )

>_]_][]TV\p_PQZBTV_!Q^TVFrQ^Z o jj n vlE_]TYX$Q^[]_!s|[PIRQ^[3EWYn D n]TVF j KX|n]TV_]TVmRQe F j TVOLE_PXL[PQ^F t >_]_][]TV\p_PQ

ZBTV_ Q^TVFrQ^Z o jj n vlE_]TYX Q^[]_yOWYQ^TVFrQ^[EWYn D n]TVF j FrQ^sdE_]TVmRQ efF j TVO|E_PXL[PQ^FpF j >_]_][]TV\p_PQ)ZBTV_

Q^TVFrQ^[o jj nOvlE_]TYXmRXLF

D

n]TVF j TV[][PQ^WYQ^mLEF_PQq„?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ|v

SUTYQ ">Q^[PQ MPbFpFs j Q^[]o jj n vUE_]TYX Q^[]_PQ…Q^[]s|TV\_xt j ELnPn+g&%[ j TYQ EU[]pKKNQ j Q^[!brXMcbhg[PQ-,prQ^Fd_PQ^F

>_]_][]TV\p_PQ!ORQ^TVFrQ+KNX|n]TV_]TVmRQ^F ]Q j XMcb g%Fhg FrQ^sdE_]TVmRQ3e F j TVOLE_PXL[PQ^FCQ7.hTYn]_]TYQ^[PQ^F ve F j Q^[EU[]pKKNQ j Q^[

ZBTV_]_PQ^Wg[PQ-,dprQ^F_PQ^F >_]_][]TV\p_PQ)s|TV\_3Q nqz|u KX|nPTV_]TVmRQBpF j S)V FrQ^sdE_]TVmRQ…e F j TVOLE_PXL[PQ^F v D } KX|nPTV_]TVmRQ

pF j }|u4FrQ^sdE_]TVmRQ/e F j TVOLE_PXL[PQ^F _][PQ^_PQ^F \NQ^T j Q^F FTYQ j []TVsLg[PQ-,dprQ^F_PQ^F >_]_][]TV\p_PQ^F Ephg]v n…s|TV\_

ORQ^TVFrQ!TV[][PQ^WYQ^m|EFd_PQ^F?„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ|v

'TVFrQ "J\NQ^[Pn]TYMPb_%\NQ^[ j TYQ3efF j TVO|E_PXL[PQ^Fs|TV\_ l\\TVWj pFs Whvzhv

klZ mRXLF j Q^FypF_PQ^[PnPMPbTYQ j WVTYMcbrQ^F$'TVsRQ^FrncMPbGE1g_PQ^F j Q^[ Q^TVFwxQ^WVFrQ^F (Q^[]_][cosRQ5w pE\rnP_][cEbTYQ^[PQ^F t TV[ j

Q^TVF _ Z8KTYnPMPbrQ^[ (Q^[]_][cEs\NQ^_][cELMPb_PQ^_xv 'TVF j p[PMPbrnPMcbFTV_]_]WVTYMPbrQ^[ (Q^[]_][cEs?TYnP_ j p[PMcb l „?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ

sRQ^ORQ^FFwxQ^TYMcbd_xvz V j TYQ ncQ^[

l

„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ…ORXLZBZ…Q^F \NQ^T%KNX|n]TV_]TVmRQ^F ">Q^TYn]KTYQ^WYQ^F Eprn j Q^[ „/Q^FsRQ

j Q^[>brX8MPbhg[PQ-,dprQ^F_PQ^FCFrQ^sdE_]TVmRQ^FCe F j TVOLE_PXL[PQ^F v5dQ j XMcb_][]TV_]_ ORQ^TVFrQ n j TYQ nPQ^[ „?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ+TVFQ^TVFrQ^Z

j p[PMcbrnPMPbFTV_]_]WVTYMcbrQ^F?FrQ^sdE_]TVmRQ^F (Q^[]_][cEsEphg]v

E\Q^WVWYQ WhvD s|TV\_lQ^TVFrQ^F "J\NQ^[]\WVTYMPO %\NQ^[ j TYQq[PQ^WE_]TVmRQ^F?D+op_rs|ORQ^TV_PQ^F j Q^[+EF j Q^[PQ^F/„?Q^[]OZ)EWYQ|v

">Q^T JF -Q^F j pFs j Q^['ƒ'[PXLwxQ^F_]w#EbWYQ^F Ephg j TYQ j p[PMcbrnPMPbFTV_]_]WVTYMcbrQ lFw#EbW„/Q^[]O8Z)EWYQ>O|EFF j TYQ ncQ

E\Q^WVWYQ j TV[PQ^O8_ TVF j ELn>giXLWVsRQ^F j QO\>E_ ‡fHlXLFwxQ^K_ %\NQ^[PnPQ^_]w _5Q^[ j Q^F

O\>E_! zMVM'V ft brXMcbhg[PQ-,prQ^Fd_

AWM zMrz|u ft {M D S)V ft ZBTV_]_PQ^Wg[PQ-,prQ^Fd_

{M {M

D } ft {MG{Mr}|u ft FTYQ j Q^[]TVsLg[PQ-,prQ^Fd_

Im Dokument L Ht j TYQ Q^TVFrQQ^TVWVZ…Q^FsRQ (Seite 54-67)