OVERVIEW OF MELCOR ACTIVITIES IN CIEMAT (2012)
C. López, M. García, E. Fernández, L.E. Herranz Unit of Nuclear Safety Research
CIEMAT, SPAIN
Scenarios Addressed
• Plant analysis
Spanish NPP (CSN) MELCOR 2.1
• Fuel degradation in the presence of air
SFP (OECD-SFP project) MELCOR 1.8.6 YV 3084 SFP BWR:
Spanish NPP (ARTIST-Ext ) MELCOR 2.1 PWR:
BSAF (CSN, OECD project) MELCOR 2.1
Plant analysis BWR, PWR
1.8.4 1.8.5 1.8.6 2.1
SNAP COR SNAP
Converter COR
Converter
Inputs updating:
Automatic conversion to 2.1:
• MELGEN
• MELCOR “by hand”
Automatic conversion to 2.1:
• MELGEN
• MELCOR “by hand”
Execution
M2.1.3226 M2.1.4206 M2.1.4803 BWR
PWR
Post-processing:
PTFread1.76.xla PTFread1.77.xla
PTFread *.xlam Not supported (Office 2003)
• Corruption of files sent by e-mail:
license.request → *.zip
• Post-processing of MELCOR 2.1 case with PTFread1.76:
- water density
Others:
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
0 10 20 30 40
time [hr]
Mass [kg/m**3]
CVH-RHO.1.200
Output
Output
1.E-02 1.E+01 1.E+04 1.E+07 1.E+10 1.E+13
0 5 time [hr] 10 15 20
Mass [kg]
RN2-DFBBT-22-a RN2-DFBBT-152-a RN2-DFBBT-10-a Estimate DF pool
• Corruption of files sent by e-mail:
license.request → *.zip
• Post-processing of MELCOR 2.1 case with PTFread1.76:
- water density - Cumulative DF
SRV: FL 362
DC: FL 20
Others:
RN2-DFBBT-3622-a?
RN2-DFBBT-202-a?
RN2-DFBBT-3622-a?
RN2-DFBBT-202-a?
• Corruption of files sent by e-mail:
license.request → *.zip
• Post-processing of MELCOR 2.1 case with PTFread1.76:
- water density - Cumulative DF
Others:
?
THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION!!
SBO
IC11SBO
noICSBO
ICadSBO
SRVopSBO
SVIC S-RVs
LOOP
IC111. BWR: CSN
Spanish NPP BWR-Mark I
1400 MWth
Systems analyses:
Unit 1 Fukushima-like scenario
Core
&
RPV
PCV Reactor
Building Total
COR cells 41 - - 41
CVs 6 3 11 20
FLs 8+5 4+3 15 35
HSs 14 7 25 46
Z1: 0.00 Z2: 0.884
Z3: 2.371 Z4: 3.105 Z5: 3.840
Z6: 4.575 Z7: 4.715 Z8: 5.204 Z9: 6.100 Z10: 6.997 Z11: 7.894 Z12: 8.791 9.185
4
CV 330 Bypass CV 340
Core Channel
CV 320 Lower Plenum
BAF TAF
SRVs
SVs FL (Valve, TF) Failures
IC CF (Steam Sink) (Water Source)
1. BWR: CSN
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 time (h)
DW pressure (MPa)
SBO_IC11 SBO_ICad WW vent open
IC Effect SV Effect
Time shift
IC performance → late and slower
degradation of fuel.
→ similar Containment evolution
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 time (h)
DW Pressure (Mpa)
SBO_IC11 SBO_SV Steam
Non condensable
DW Fail DW Fail + Vent
SV operation → similar fuel degradation.
→ different Containment evolution.
1. BWR: CSN
2. BWR: CSN, BSAF Project
Starting point: previous BWR NPP
• Detailed plant model
COR: 4 x 13
BAF TAF
COR: 3 x 12
WW DW
2. BWR: CSN, BSAF Project
Input development of the 3 NPP→ Excel worksheet
2. BWR: CSN, BSAF Project
Focus: Implementation of the ARI3SG correlation in MELCOR 2.1:
3. PWR: ARTIST-Ext Project
Scope: -“Near field” deposition (break stage) -“Dry conditions” (no pool scrubbing)
4 2 1
1 2
p
TB Stk
Stk 009 Re
. 0 exp 47 .
0 ⋅
⋅
−
⋅
= η
~ 2 0 m
Objective: Aerosol retention in the Secondary Side of a Steam Generator.
ARI3SG
Scenario:
SGTR:
- Double-ended rupture SG.
-SG PORV failed Open.
-Bypass sequence.
3. PWR: ARTIST-Ext Project
Spanish PWR: 2614 MWth 3 loops
- Filter implementation by Control Function
Approach:
ARI3SG
Filter
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 38 40 Time (h)
cp1_CVH- LIQLEV.300 SG Top
SG Bottom Tube breach
Top tube bundle
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
0
SG water level (m)
SG Bottom Tube breach
3. PWR: ARTIST-Ext Project
Dry
ONGOING ANALYSES
SFP tests:
• Complete LOCA in SFPools
• BWR/PWR fuel assemblies
• Zr air oxidation leading to cladding ignition
2 Scenarios modeled:
4. SFP: OECD-SFP Project
• 1x1
• 1x4
1x1:
SFP-PWR 1X4
Gas Circulation
Natural Convection
Forced Convection
Measurements Zero rates (R2)
Material properties
Radiation modeling
Material emissivities
View factors System
properties
Cp: MgO, SS, Al
ZrO
2thickness
Gap thickness Rack
as HS
SS, ZrO2
Arbitrary radiation paths
(NNHTR)
CL-1 → RK-1 → CL-2 → RK-2
Gap model CL inner surf.
emissivity set
FCELR
FSSCN Low values ignition in R1
4. SFP:
PWR 1x1
PWR 1x1 PWR 1x4 PWR 1x4
4. SFP: OECD-SFP Project
Center