• Keine Ergebnisse gefunden

Peer review report 3 on “Economic Effects of a Reservoir Re-operation Policy in the Rio Grande/Bravo for Integrated Human and Environmental Water Management”

N/A
N/A
Info
Herunterladen
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Aktie "Peer review report 3 on “Economic Effects of a Reservoir Re-operation Policy in the Rio Grande/Bravo for Integrated Human and Environmental Water Management”"

Copied!
1
0
0

Wird geladen.... (Jetzt Volltext ansehen)

Jetzt herunterladen ( 1 Seite )

Volltext

(1)

JournalofHydrology:RegionalStudies9(2017)152

Contents lists available atScienceDirect

Journal of Hydrology: Regional Studies

j o u r n a l h o m e p a g e :w w w . e l s e v i e r . c o m / l o c a t e / e j r h

Peer Review Report

Peer review report 3 on “Economic Effects of a Reservoir Re-operation Policy in the Rio Grande/Bravo for Integrated Human and

Environmental Water Management”

1. OriginalSubmission 1.1. Recommendation

MinorRevision 2. CommentstoAuthor:

First,themostimportantimpressionisrelatedtothepotentialpracticeofreservoirre-operationandhydro-economic analysistoimprovemanagementofwaterresourcesandconsequently,topromoteenvironmentalhealth,andtheelaboration ofamorecomprehensivewaterallocationpolicyfortheBigBendReachoftheRioGrande/Bravo.

Second,Ireadwithgreatinterestthemanuscriptdrawnupbytheauthorsandhavehadtheimpressionthatthemain proposedideaispartofalargerresearchproject,orofaresearchteamproject.Thisaspectcanbeexemplifiedbythereduced literaturereviewrelatedtothetopics:1)wateravailabilityintheregion,2)reservoirre-operation,and3)thefeasibilityof providingEFsandadaptingand/oradoptingapolicymechanism.Thereisabsolutelynothingwronghere!However,itis importanttomentionthisaspectinthedocumentsoonecanbetterunderstandtherationaleandresearchobjectivesofthe manuscript.

Next,ifthisresearchcomplementsabiggerresearchprojectasmentionedabove,itwouldbegreattocontinueworking onthisissueandelaborateanEFspolicytobereplicableinsomeothersRGBstudyareas,andindifferentgeographical contexts.

Finally,thenotionoftransboundaryregionisputasideandnotaddressedinasufficientmanner.Iwouldhighlyrecom- mendtoincludethislevelofanalysisinfuturestudiestheauthorswanttoexplore.

Specificcommentsandsuggestionsfortheauthorsareprovidedintheattacheddocument.

ResearchScholar LuzmaFabiolaNava(Ph.D.) IIASA−InternationalInstituteforAppliedSystemsAnalysis,WaterProgram,Schlossplatz1,Laxenburg,Austria

A-2361,Austria

DOIoftheoriginalarticle:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ejrh.2016.08.004.

2214-5818/$–seefrontmatter

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ejrh.2016.12.048

Referenzen

Jetzt herunterladen ( PDF - 1 Seite - 114.31 KB )

ÄHNLICHE DOKUMENTE

China in the Indian Ocean: Part of a Larger PLAN

Recently, China has increased its military activities in the Indian Ocean Region, expanding the range of its navy westward.. It has invested in port facilities in Pakistan, Sri

The Criminalisation of Migration in Europe A State-of-the-Art of the Academic Literature and Research

It finds that criminalisation has, during the past two decades, intensified significantly across the European Union in diverse manifestations: whether via public perceptions

View of Conversational Analysis as a Method for Research on Intercultural Learning: A Report on a Project with the Aim of "Learning by Undertaking Research"

Wie kann diese wissen- schaftliche Haltung gemeinsam mit den entsprechenden forschungspraktischen Fertigkeiten gewinnbringend im Rahmen einer Fachhochschulausbildung vermittelt

A lock-in Transboundary Water Management Regime: the case of the Rio Grande/Bravo Basin

A recent analysis 32 shows that the water availability (7,343 million m 3 /year) is about the same as the water uses and evaporation (7,358 million m 3 /year) in the basin.

A REVIEW OF THE RESEARCH LITERATURE ON BARRIERS TO THE UPTAKE OF ICT BY TEACHERS

Murphy and Greenwood (1998) point out that the problem is exacerbated by a lack of encouragement for students to make use of ICT during teaching practices, but in a later study

A Model for the Optimal Operation of a Single Reservoir for Use of Irrigation

Development of a mathematical model of a water resources system and simulation of its operation over a long trace of synthetic inflows (simulation coupled with a

The Value of Human Life: A Review of the Models

Usher 's analysis describes the shape of the indifference function, or the tradeoff between immediate consumption (wealth) and survival probability that would

Review and Evaluation of Research on the Eutrophication of Lake Balaton -- A Background Report for Modeling

and only in Keszthely Bay. And although the trend is without doubt precarious, no strong effect on the recreational value of the Balaton has become apparent to the average