Munich Personal RePEc Archive
The Institutions-Growth Nexus: Stages of Development
Nawaz, Saima
Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE), Pakistan
1 December 2011
Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/36961/
MPRA Paper No. 36961, posted 26 Feb 2012 20:43 UTC
! "!
# "
" $% & ''()$**+
! " "! " , )-..
"" "! !
" ) /
# " " " ! "
" " .
""! " " " " ! 0 " ! "!
" 1 & &
0 "
! "# # $ "%
!
"! ! " 23 4 " " ! 1 - 5
& ' &
& ! 6 '+ 7 8 6 '+ 7 9" 6 '+ 7
" ! " " ""!
" 4 # " " "
! : : 6 '';7 " ! '< '<%) '+'
. 6 '';7 ) (< = 6 ''(7
'(*) ''* " "
" / "" 8 6 '''7 ! $<
" "
" !
. "! > " 6$**%7 " " #!
& " " 6$**(7 "
! "
" "
" " "
" # " "
"! "!
" = " "
" " "
" ! " " " "
# "!
?&@ " " "
" 6? '';7 3 # &"
- 6$* *7 ! " "
# " ""!
"! " " " $
"" ! "!
" . ""! !
# " $% &
''()$**+ "! ! "
" "
! ) " ! ! " ! ! "
"! " 2 ! - " . . 5 6 , )-..7
0 . ! "! & "
"" A $ # " "
"
" ! " B 1 " "
% " ; "
2 . "! C " " 6$* 7
" / ! " ! ! "
" ! ! " ! "
"
(& ")) ' & &* + ",'
1 ! " " " !
! " " " " " ! ! 3
" " ! ! " " "
" " " " ! & " > 6$* *7
A
& " > 6$* *7 2 "
" " 5 6 ''*7
2 " ! ""! "!
5 "
! !
! " ! !
" "
6. ! " '' 7 9 !
" ! !
6 '' 7 9 "" ! ! ! 0 " !
6/ "" 8 '''7 1 "" "
" "!
" 6 ''*7 3 " !
! " " ! " !
" "" " ! " 6= 8 ''(7
" " "
" "
"
6= '' D . " ''$7 # 0
" "" A
E " - "
# " ! " " # " !
" # " ! " "!
# 3 " " " "
! " " " !
3 " ! & )
" " " "! " "
"!
" "! " " " "
# " ! " 6= ''*7 3 "
! " . " ! ""!
" B "
" ! " " 6 ';(7 > 6 '+(7 ?
6 '++7 6 '+ 7 = " " "
"! "" A
! "
E
!# " " " !#
" #
- !# $ % "
! " " " ! # & %
! 4 " "! "" "A
'( '( '( '( )'( *+), '( - '( '( .
E '(
!# / '( " " " !# / $ %
'( - !# / $ % )'(
" !# / & % +), '(
! # / * $ % '( #
- !# / - & %
B " " "! ? > " 6 ''$7 . " 6 ''$7
" ( & (" + &)& -
" ( . /
0
# " "!
/ " !
! " # " ! " "
# ! # " ! "
! " ! &" " " "
" 0 = ! " " "
" " " " ! "
! " "
0 # /
! ! ! "
3 " " @ "" " 6 ''(7 " =
" 6$** 7 "! 2- " . . 6-..75
! ! # " " #
" ! " ! " & "" = 6 '';7
2 ! -..5 " "" "
"" " " -.. " ! ! @ "" "
6 ''(7 ? ! =" "" = 6 ''+7 "
"
! " ! ! " "! " 2 ! - "
. . 5 6 , )-..7 0 " !
" ! A 7 2 7 ) " ! 7
" " " # " ! " 7 "
! "" # " ! " 5
. # #
3 " " $% &
''()$**+ $% & "!
" " ! "" " 6 & # " & " "
7 E " + & ( 1 &
* 1 &
" E " = F 2E " "
3 6E 375 2 E " " < * G E 5 " ! / "
6$* *7 " " E " = F 2E "
- 3 6E-375 #
" A 7 2C & " !5 7 2 " "
" ! C " 5 7 2- 1 5 7 2> " ? 5 7 2> " !
H " !5 7 2@ " 5% "" " 0 " ! # " !
"
% 4 " " E " = A
" I I I #
- & *(<+ J
K - B +* " " (%
3 - ' + (+ B
" " )* ;* C & " ! )* *%
> " ? 6 " 7
)" 0
/ #
C " 9 . . . #
> " - @ 6>L- L @7 B $ *(<+ %%+; B<* ;B *$
- @ - > 6>L- L @L-7 B $ B +* % $+ ) % $' $% %B
" - > 6 L-7 B $ (% * +B ) %+ ; B$
- M - 6- L- 7 B $ *% ( B< $ * %$ <$
3 M - 63L- 7 B $ $< ' * %< ' + (+ B
9 69 7 B $ *+ ;' ++ *+ ' %' %%B +
@ " @ 6@L@7 B $ )* $$ * '( ) '$ $ B'
> " ? 6>L?7 B $ )* *% * '( )$ B$ $ B<
> " ! H " ! 6>LH7 B $ )* $' *< )$ <B B<
- 1 6-L17 B $ )* * )$ B+ $ $B
" " " ! 6 L 7 B $ )* B * +B ) '< <(
C & " ! 6CL&7 B $ )* ;* * << )$ B* *;
9 "" 3 " 3 # 63 7 B $ * ** $ ( )% '< % (<
"( ) )-
" " "! " $);
" " " ! "
"! " " $ " " "! " "
" "" # " ! " # 6
" " $7 " " " -
" " !
3 ""!
3 "
6 " $7
)" 0
# &) $0112 3445%
C " . " . " $ . " B . " % . " ; . " ( . " < . + 3 " >L- L @ )* $$%N )* $*<N )* $%; )* $ ; )* $%<N )* $$ )* $%$ )* $$
6* B7 6* <7 6* (%7 6* %*7 6* B<7 6* ;(7 6* %%7 6* %+7 3 * **;*B * ** +' * **%%< * **%B+ * **< + * **%+' * **;++ * **%+;
6* *$;+7 6* *$(%7 6* *$((7 6* *$< 7 6* *$<$7 6* *$(+7 6* *$(<7 6* *$('7
3L- B+%NN $+ NN B$+NN B'$NN %**NN B+'NN B; NN B+<NN
6* ;*%7 6* ;$+7 6* ;''7 6* ;$B7 6* ; '7 6* ;;*7 6* ;%*7 6* ;$;7
CL& )* B%
6* + 7
L * *B(BNN
6* '+7
-L1 )* *$ *
6* '$7
>LH * *;;<
6* <+7
>L? * **< $N
6* $;*7
@L@ * *%*<NN
6* '$7
3 * **B$*NN
6* *+'*7
@ ) %;( ) B + ) *+' ) ;; ) BB* ) %'+ ) '< ) %'$
6 '<<7 6$ **+7 6$ +; 7 6$ $*%7 6$ *($7 6$ %''7 6$ B((7 6$ $(%7
9 $% $% $% $% $% $% $% $%
>) 0 * %*B * %$* * %*; * %*% * %*< * %*B * %*; * %*%
A > N O* NN O* *; NNN O* *
4 " $ + ! " ! "
E ""!
" - "!
" &
. ""! P " " " !F P " " F
P " F
" 0 " !
0 " ! - 6 " $7
" ! )-.. " ! )
-.. " " $% & " B
" " " &"" # " !
" # " " 3 " -
! ""!
3 6 - 7
""! "
" ""! ;
" " 4 ""! 6 # - 7
? " " B ""!
"" P@ " F P " " F
""! "" "
P " F * %$ 6 ; 7
P " " F * +$ 6 7 P> " ! 0 " !F P
F P " " " !F P " !F "" #
""! "" "
)" 6
- (( $0112 3445%
C " . " . " $ . " B . " % . " ; . " ( . " < . +
>L- L @ 6) 7
* $ * $% * $* * $% * $( * $$ * $ * $%
6* *<+*7 6* *++<7 6* *<;<7 6* *+ 7 6* *' 7 6* *'*%7 6* *<(<7 6* *+;*7 3 "
>L- L @ )
* ***%$$
)
* ***%$;
)
* ***%%$
NN
)
* ***%B' N
)
* ***%%*
NN
)
* ***%$%
N
)
* ***%$$
)
* ***%B$
N 6* ***$<
<7
6* ***$(
$7
6* ***$$B 7
6* ***$;
B7
6* ***$$$
7
6* ***$%
'7
6* ***$<
'7
6* ***$$
'7
-L- )* < )* *B )* )* $B )* *''+ )* < )* ; )* *'
6* $; 7 6* B*B7 6* $;+7 6* $%<7 6* $+;7 6* $(+7 6* $;;7 6* $<B7
3L- * '+N * ''N * $* N * ''N * 'BN * '<N * 'BN * ''N
6* B7 6* *'7 6* *<7 6* *'7 6* <7 6* *+7 6* *%7 6* *<7
9 * *(+(NN
N
* *(( NN N
* *(%%NN N
* *(<$NN N
* *(% NN N
* *('$NN * *('%NN N
* *(( NN N 6* * ; 7 6* *$%*7 6* *$B;7 6* * (;7 6* *$B 7 6* *$+*7 6* * <*7 6* *$;(7 L- ) (;BNN ) (<BNN ) (';NN ) (+ NN ) (<BNN ) ($+NN ) (B*NN ) ((;NN 6* +B 7 6* <+'7 6* <<$7 6* <;(7 6* +*'7 6* <<'7 6* <%;7 6* <;(7
@L@ * %$*NN
6B *;+7
>L? * +$ N
6$ +<;7
>LH * %+(
6 $B$7
-L1 * ++'
6B $;<7
L * *$(;
6B ;<$7
CL& * $*'
6$ $'+7
3 * $$BNN
6 %<<7
@ ) $'B ) *(* )* ((< )* <%* )* ;;+ ) B(B ) % ) * %
6B '<B7 6$ '($7 6$ ('%7 6B B $7 6$ ;B 7 6$ (%+7 6B BB<7 6$ <('7
"
9
$++ $++ $++ $++ $++ $++ $++ $++
"
@
$% $% $% $% $% $% $% $%
A > N O* NN O* *; NNN O* *
9 "" " 6 " #7 "
! -
* $$B ; 6 " B7
""! " "
" "
!
" ) " & " "!
1 & " "! > " "
& 1 & " % " ;
> " & "" 1
& / 1 &
& @ " @ * (*' 6
; 7 & " (+' 6 7 1
& " "! > " ? * $;; 6 *
7 & $ (%' 6 ; 7 1 & 3
> " ! H " ! "! 6 7 1 & "
&
- 1 " " " ! C & " !
# ""! " /
" 1 &
& 6 " % Q " ;7
"" " " ""!
" / " # 1 & 6 ;+
; D " ;7 & 6* % + ;
D " %7 " "
" " " " !
)" 7
- (( $0112 3445%
C " . " . " $ . " B . " % . " ; . " ( . " < . +
>L- L @ 6) 7
)* +$ )* ++ )* <+ )* $ ; )* $B% )* $$B )* +( )* ''
6* ;B7 6* ;(7 6* (*7 6* (<7 6* <$7 6* ; 7 6* ;;7 6* (+7 3 "
>L- L @
* ***('* * ***<<; * ***(*B * ** *( * ***<;' * ** * * ***+%% * ***+'' 6* ** *%7 6* ***'*
*7
6* ** %7 6* ***'<
'7
6* ***''
$7
6* ***++
<7
6* ** BB7 6* ** **7
-L- )* <+ )* << )* +< )* < )* B$ )* (+ )* $(BNN )* (*
6* (;7 6* <B7 6* %*7 6* < 7 6* < 7 6* (<7 6* $$7 6* (*7
3L- * *;B% * *%;' * *(<* * *B++ * *% B * *%<( * *+B * *% <
6* *<<%7 6* *+$ 7 6* *<BB7 6* *<<(7 6* *+<<7 6* *<(B7 6* *(*;7 6* *<';7
9 * *(<+NN
N
* *((%NN N
* *(<'NN N
* *<B;NN N
* *(<;NN N
* *(($NN N
* *<+(NN N
* *((+NN N 6* *$*(7 6* *$*(7 6* * <%7 6* *$%<7 6* *$;<7 6* *$; 7 6* * '(7 6* *$ %7
L- **< * +'+ *$B B;+ * %B( * (*+ ;*; *(*
6B *'B7 6$ '%$7 6B B'7 6$ <;(7 6$ <<*7 6$ ;'B7 6B %+<7 6$ ';(7
@L@ * (*'NN
6 $%$7
>L? * $;;NNN
6 $%*7
>LH )* ';$
6* ++%7
-L1 $ %
6 *'*7
L '<
6 B <7
CL& + %
6 'B$7
3 * % +NN
6* (%+7
@ )$ %B$ )$ B<( )$ %'% )% <*( )$ ;($ )$ <;; )B % )B *(
6< *%(7 6( ;'B7 6< $+'7 6( +B(7 6( $( 7 6( %%;7 6< <<<7 6( +$*7
"
9
'( '( '( '( '( '( '( '(
"
+ + + + + + + +
A > N O* NN O* *; NNN O* *
)" 8
" - (( $0112 3445%
C " . " . " $ . " B . " % . " ; . " ( . " < . +
>L- L @6 ) 7
* <<N * +BN * ;* * *<(( * +'N * $$ * <<N * (%
6* *' <7 6* *%7 6* B*7 6* ;7 6* * 7 6* %$7 6* *' $7 6* $;7 3 "
>L- L @
)+ <B )*; )+ *% )
*;
)* *** B ); *< )
*;
)* *** *$ <' )
*;
)< < )
*;
)+ '+ )
*;
6* *** *$
7
6< % )
*;7
6* *** B$
7
6+ '$ )
*;7
6* *** BB 7
6% <% )
*;7
6' $; )
*;7
6' ;< )
*;7
-L- )* B + )* B'% )* ;(B )* B%; )* % B )* B%( )* %' )* ;
6* B* 7 6* %*B7 6* ; +7 6* % $7 6* ;$$7 6* % $7 6* B('7 6* ;$(7
3L- * *%*% * *<+; * ** * *'$* * *($; * (% * * *$ * *<
6* *'+$7 6* BB7 6* % 7 6* *+;$7 6* %+7 6* $<7 6* * 7 6* ;B7
9 * **$;< )* * $ )* * 'B )* * ;' )* **; < )* *$+$ * * $ )* *$*$
6* * +$7 6* *$<<7 6* *$B$7 6* *$$;7 6* *$% 7 6* *B + 7
6* * +*7 6* *$'B7
L- ; + NNN % 'B%NN
N
% B<BNNN % <B<NN N
% +B+NNN B <;%NN ; (';NN N
% B BNN N
6 '('7 6 ;+'7 6 ;B*7 6 (';7 6 <' 7 6 ;*+7 6 '+*7 6 B$'7
@L@ (+'N
6$ +<<7
>L? $ (%'NN
6$ <+;7
>LH % $*$N
6$ $*B7
-L1 * <;B
6B *B$7
L ; $'$
6B <$$7
CL& BB
6 ;*'7
3 ;+NN
6 %$ 7
@ $ (;< B +;$ < ' ++% % B$( * +'; )* %( ; ;+
6$ <*;7 6$ ' '7 6% '*$7 6$ $$$7 6; <%B7 6B ;'7 6% B% 7 6B 'B(7
"
9
<$ <$ <$ <$ <$ <$ <$ <$
"
( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
A > N O* NN O* *; NNN O* *
& )' &
!
" ! !
! . ""! "
" " "
9
"
" "! 1 & &
"! " "
" 0
"
"9" " "
& " Q > 8 & $* * " "
6$7A )BB
& " @ " 4 " & Q ? 8 $**( . "
R '(6$7A *B) *<
&" 8 & Q - @ $* * " 0 " !A
& "" . < = 9 ''; & " " " )
" (+6 7A$');
= > 8 '' 1
*(6$7A%*<)%%B
= > 8 ''( ! 6 7A )$<
= = & Q 8 @ ''( " ! 1 8 "
*( *B<) *%%
=" " > Q = ''+ 3 " ! "
" +<6 7A ;) %B
= = @ Q E 4 $** @ ) -..
" " <B6B7AB'<)B++
@ "" 4 1 0 " - Q ? 4 ''( > A "
) ! 6B7AB(B)B+'
/ "" > 1 Q 8 @ 3 ''' E !
R %6 7A+B) (
8 1 ? '+ ! " #
@ A @ J !
: Q : ''; 3 A ) !
" " 8 " 1 " <6B7A$*<)$$<
? > Q > " ''$ & ! "! ) !
& 1 > +$6%7A'%$)'(B
? , 8 Q 8 = ''; /
" 1 A / "" @ 6 7 /
" 1 6B7A$B* )$B<*
? > 1 '++ 9 " 8 " . ! 1
$ 6 7AB)%$
. - > . Q E " ''$ &
*<6$7A%*<)%B<
. ''; @ *6%7A(+ )< $
. ! : . " & Q C ! > E '' "" " A 3 "
*(6$7A;*B);B*
@ '+ $ # ,
@ ''* " # @
.&A @ J ! ,
@ '' 3 % ;6 7A'<) $
9" . '+ ! # " # "
# / A , " J !
> & Q 4 $**% 3 " A !
! "
'6$7A B ) (;
> . '+( 3 " 8 " " " 1 !
'%6;7A **$) *B<
" > ';( & !
<*A(;)'%
C " 1 Q " $* " 0 " !
" A " ! & # ' # "
# 6(7A$<%)$''
" , )"
)
> >
& & B . " ! &
$ = " & % . " &
B = & ; . " 1 &
% = & ( " &
; @ & < : 1 &
( @ 1 & + &
< / : 1 & ' - &
+ 3 & $* " &
' 3 & $ &
* 8 1 & $$ ? &
? & $B " &
$ . 1 & $% C &
