• Keine Ergebnisse gefunden

The european guideline for genetic patents - a regulative institution from the perspective of patent theory

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Aktie "The european guideline for genetic patents - a regulative institution from the perspective of patent theory"

Copied!
18
0
0

Wird geladen.... (Jetzt Volltext ansehen)

Volltext

(1)

Munich Personal RePEc Archive

The european guideline for genetic patents - a regulative institution from the perspective of patent theory

Gilroy, Bernard Michael and Vollpert, Tobias

2002

Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/18965/

MPRA Paper No. 18965, posted 02 Dec 2009 19:59 UTC

(2)

ep'qdnoSe~OtI@AO.I{!~ -

tIloqlep'ed

860f.'f.' - 001 .1~S le~mqxeM - g q:)!eleqq:)~dI

C;OOC;°f:o091 uloqlap'Rd ,+~'+1SlaA1u fl

,+ladIoA °.L ° M.S~IOA "Id10 lAOlI1D °wog °lO °JOld

d!lOdqffUdf'8d

ldp fq'J!S Sn'8 UO!fnf!fSUI dq'JS!f!Iods~unUplO dU!d - dfUdf'8dUdO l~J d!U!Ifq'J!'H dq'JS!~dOlnd d!G

,,

,

..' :

, I

(3)

'U~l'BlA ~t{;)U'Bla u~~unr l~p lO'.J.°W l~p l~t{S~q ~~p 'u~UIt{~ul~'.J.ufl ~t{;)S~P~'.J.sI~'.J.'.J.~m run ~U~~I}{ m~II'B lOA u~P~~I l~'.J.uru'Ba ".J.lt{nl u~'.J.~~t{l~t{;)~SUfl u~t{;)~Iq~t{l~ nz selA 'u~t{;)'Bm nz t{;)~I'.J.n~p ~~l~'.J.'BW l~'.J.q~I~q t{;)~~l~a m~ s~z'.J.nt{;)s'.J.u~'.J.'Bd s~p u~zu~lD ~~p 'u~~unI~~ '.J.t{;)~U 'Hda l~p '.J.~m }{~'.J.~I -od l~p s~ '.J.S~ U~'.J.~~lAZ mnz ".J.S~ ~un'.J.n~p~a l~pU~p~~t{;)s'.J.u~ UOA ~t{;)U'Bla l~p '.J.'.J.~lt{;)S'.J.lOd U~l~'.J.~~lA lill U~~'BlpuruD u~t{;)S~'.J.~u~~ nz ~U'B~nz l~~~ll It{OlAqo 'u~~unpu~lAuv U~'.J.~l}{

-UO}{ ~~lA '.J.lt{1'!lA~~ z'.J.nt{;)S ~t{;)~~I~ l~p U~SS~lAU~~'BIpunlD m~t{;)S!'.J.~u~~ +1~lt{;)SlOAS'.J.t{;)~'H

~~p t{;)lnp pl~lA u~u~~ mnz .u~t{~'.J.S ~~~A\ m~ t{;)~I'.J.n~p ~uru~Plgd-a+d u~'.J.u~~zY:J~ l~U -~~ ~~p ".J.s~~MJn'B I~~~W ~t{;)~Iq~t{l~ ~~lAZ ~~mouo}{Q l~p '.J.t{;)~S sn'B 'Hda ~~p 'iJ'BP 'u~~

-~~Z u~~urut{nlsnv u~pu~~Iol ~~a .}{~ut{;)~'.J.u~D l~p t{;)~~l~a m~ 3+d UOA ~uru~Plgd ~~p '.J.S~ I~~Z s~'.J.l1'!I}{ l~ lt{I . ('Hda) ~1U~I'.J.t{;)~l'.J.u~'.J.'Bdo~a ~'.J.UU'BU~~OS ~~p '.J.s~ fl3 l~p qI'Bt{l~u -u~ u~~unpuTJl3 l~t{;)S~Ut{;)~'.J.u~~ z'.J.nt{;)s'.J.u~'.J.'Bd lnJ +1~rq;)SlOAS'.J.t{;)~'H ~pu~p~~t{;)S'.J.u~ ~~a

~uns~Juaww~snz

(4)

I

Jnz °U;)~U;)~~d UOA u;)z~nN pun UU!s UI;)P q::>~u ;)~~J.!l ;)!P J1}J n;)!~U;)SS;) S~U!pJ;)n~ ;)!S ~S! ~q:>!S J;)q:>S!UI -oUO~2 sny o~un~q:>~;)H UIn1J}{ q:>!lq~s~~~ ;)!S ~;)puy '~Z~;)SJ;)pU'Qu!;)sn~ 'HdH J;)P ~!UI q::>!S ;)!P 'Jn~~J;)~!1 J;)P U! pun J~nJ['l:l~~;)dsun ~U!;)q:>SJ;) ~unJ'l}.l~J3 ;)!Q °rudH ~un~~h\J3 0&) "U;)pJ;)h\ ~J;)PJ2J;)~ pun ~Jq!}J;)~

-~OJ ;)!~Olouq:>;)~O!H J;)P ~;)!q;){) UI;)P Jn~ U;)UO!~!~S;)AUI g'ep" os 'rudH ~un~~h\J3 °z) "U!;)S l;)q~~U;)J z~nq:>ss~q:>;)'H UI;)U;)SS;)UI;)~U'Q !;)q Jnu" q:>!;)J;)H UI;)S;)!P U! 3+d U;)UU2~ q:>~U~Q °u;)~unpuYJ3 J;)q:>S!~Ol -ouq:>;)~U;)~ z~nq::>s~U;)~~d U;)P J1}J ~unpu!}J~;)H ;)u!;) - ~!n~'yn~un ;)q~U!;)q - s~U'Q~U!;) ~J;)J;)!l 'HdH ;)!Q 1

-l~p ue~~ypuruD el[;)S!~elOel[~ e~!~l[;)!Jk\ ~~!Ul[;)sqV Ue~Sle m! UepleM nZ'Ba l.ue~~lJle~U!l[

nz ~sqyes ye!z SeSe!p eul[o 'Pl!M ~l[;)ele~ - 3+d UOA ~urueplgd lep - ye!z Ue~}{;)e~Se~

~sqyes Ue~Sle mell[! e!S ~!eMe!MU! 'Ue.'8~lJle~U!t[ nz run ueJIlldleqIl nz u!t[ ~!e}{ureSJI1!M.

ell[! Jll~ e!mOUO}{Q lep ~l[;)!S sn~ e!u!y~l[;)!l~ue~'Bdo!a e!p 'se ~S! S~~l~!ea sese!p ye!z .uessedU'e uelO~){t:IJ~yeMmfl uepulepu~leA le}{~~S lamm! }{!ul[;)e~ue{) run -o!a lep mn~sl[;)~M. mepueml[eunz ~!m l[;)!S e!p u~ ueml['B1I uel[;)s!~!yodS.'8UnUplO uep run uesgy meyqold sep e~nos 8661 UOA fl3 lep e!u!y~l[;)!l~ue~~do!a e!a .nos uel[e~ z~nl[;)S leSe!p ~!eM e!M run uepleM uel[e!peA z~nl[;)s~ue~~d ue~unpuY13 UOA ~lV el[;)yeM Jn~ '~[ uueM run ~dn~l[leqIl qo 'roM ue~

-~!l~Smn e.'8u~y }{!Ul[;)e~ueo lep l[;)!elea m! lelep puru.'8Jn~ 'epUIll{) e~!u!e PU!S se!a .uo!suem!a epUlepU!l[eq qleMeq~~eMS.'8Un~s!e1 uep eu!e ~!~!ezl[;)!ey.'8 ~!m~p ueq~l[ e~ue~~d .~~sleA l[;)ope[ ~l[;)elA!snpyx3 epuel[e~seq sep ml[! seM 'n!M uye}{;)!M~Uele~!eM eepI euepU'el[lOA eu!e lep '~smelqe~ lepuY13 lep Pl!M mepnz .me~sAs-g+d m! ene~s lelepU'e U'e ueYl[eJ run ~le!~!l!p el[;)!elea e~mm!~seq U!

unu ue;)mosse'H edd~u}{ uepleM s!uqe~13 m! uuep 'roqp!emleAUn S~U!plen~ PU!S e~}{!IJ -uo}{ye!z .qleMeq~~eM. m! e!.'8e~~l~S UeA!~){t:Il~~~ leU!e nz 3+d uel[;)'Bm e.'8~l~leyodouoW uepuepleM l[;)!y~gm ~!m~p e!a .ue~}{l~mleA nz run uel[;)n~lqe.'8 nz A!Snpyxe ~unpuy

-13 eu!es '~l[!epeA ~l[;)e'H sep lepuY13 mep ~ue~~d sep ~p '(3+d) .'8unpy;)!M~u3 run .'8unl[;)SlOd 1m ez!erov uel[e~s~ue ~!~!ezl[;)!eID .(IL 's 'IOO~ lO~!YOW l~A) ~!plIlMz~nl[;)S mn~ue~!3 se~!~s!e~ sy~ ~!l:n~P pun ~n{) ue~!~Js~l[;)el meu!e nz ~unpuY13 eu!e pl!Jk\

~uny!e~le~ue~~d lep ~!W .eye!z ese!p ~l[;)!pyl!MleA }{!~!yodS.'8unUplO lep ley!eJd le~!~l[;)!M sy~ ueseM~ue~~d sea .(J 11 's 'IOO~ ~l[;)eYl[;)S l~A) uepleM ~smelqe~ elepU'e '~leplgJe~

Ue~~~!A!~){t:IS':ij~l[;)S~l!M. ene!zeds IJBP 'Uep!emleA nz l[;)!Yz~~spuru~ ~S! ~!~!ezl[;)!eyo .ue~

-rel[le nz qleMeq~~eMs~Un~s!e1 pun Uele!~U'el~~ nz e~l[;)elsmn~ue~!3 suyepu~H uel[;)s -!~!yodS.'8UnUplO ueml[~'H m! 'se ~S! ueuo!~n~!~suI lel[;)!y~~~~s eq~~Jnv e~U!~!lO eu!3

.caun ~ !81U!:3:

(5)

&

"A run "JA "d~)I '8661 JoqJl:J!a Jepo "J 18& "S '000&

uuna "g"Z eq:J!el~JeA ~unJepJ9JsuO!~~AOUUI Jeq:J!I~~~~S ~!eJl~!pueM~oN run ~!eJl~!sS:I!lnz Jep uo!ssnJls!a U! UA\~~

-

u~~q:>~lSUIn~U~~!a UOA ~unz~~sq:>lna run UO!~!uTJ~a l~p SI~~~!UI '~!~){q:>!I~gW

~!p q:>!S ~~~~!q UIqI 'U~J!~l~U!~ ~'B'B~S l~p uu'e:>{ seUIUI~I!a S~S~!p ~UnpU!A\l~qi} 1nz 'u~zu~nb~su~D l~n~u ~unq:>slOJla 'A\zq UO!~JInp01d 1nz "q"P 'ZU~!zYJa l~q:>S!UIUUJ:..p nz ~q:>!U ~!UIOS s~ ~UIUIO){ nnN UOA S!~ld UI~U!~ ~!W '~n°1:l ~U!~){ Sl~UIq~U1~~ufl s~p m}{I'e:>{s~unp!~q:>s~ua UI! ~I~!ds ~uq:>sn~s~o l~p UU!A\~~u~z~nN ~n~n~u~A~ l~a 'u~uug){ U~p1~A\ ~l~!S!re~l ~UU!A\~D ~U!~){ nnN UOA S!~ld UI~U!~ ~!UI up 'u~ssoIq:>s~~snu u~UIq~U1~~ufl ~~UA!ld q:>lnp ~u~o l~n~u ~unq:>slOJla 'A\zq uo!~){np01d ~!P u~~un~u!p~g U~S~!P l~~un P1!A\ pu~~IoJ U~UIquUUV u~q:>!Iqn u~a

'~~pU~A\l~A IUUI!~do U~p1~A\ u~zu~nb~su~D ~pu~q~~s~q 'q'p 'lOA ZU~!zYJa ~q:>S!~U~S ~~!I '~nm1~ IlllN UOA S~S!~ld S~U!~ ~unz~~ssnu10A ~!P ~sI "s~~no S~S~!P u~z~nu~UI'Bs~o ~IU!ZOS l~p P1!A\ l~ggl~ os UIn

'(

U~~!~lllzqu snul'Bp ~~u~UI'e}{!P~W

'g'z UIn) U~pU~A\l~A PU~~!~su~z~nu UO!~UUI10JuI ~q:>S!~~U~~ ~U~pUUq10A ~U!~ U~UIq~u1~~

-ufl . A\zq u~np!A!puI 1q~UI ~r ]l'BP U~p1~A\ u~ssoIq:>s~~snu UInsuo)l UIOA S!~ld U~A!~!sod U~U!~ q:>lnp pueUI~!U gur 'u~~:>{Unds~q:>!S~~S~~~!reUI!~do gnu ~UUI1~A Sd!ZU!lds~~~!I'eArn s~p ~!~}{~!~mO-~q:>!N ~!a '~q~~s ~un~m1~A 1nz soIU~~SO){ u~~u~urnsuo)l U~~l~!SS~l~~U!

u~nu UO!~UUI10JUI ~q:>sTJ!z~ds ~!P UU~A\ '~q:>!~ll~ uuep P1!A\ 'n~l~U~~ l~~n~SU~SS!M 1m

~!A\ 'zu~nb~su~o l~U!~ UO!~'e:>{°nv ~IUUI!~do ~!a 'u~~so)l !~{l~U!~){ q:>nu1q~o U!~S ~q:yes -lru~A '~I~Pueq ~~SU~SS!M u!a UIn q:>!S s~ ua 'U~p1~A\ u~~OZ~~UU1~q 'U~UIS!ue~lO l~p -u~q~I ~IUUI){l~W ~~sq:>!IP~!q:>sl~~un 1m I~ssnIq:>s l~p 'u~zu~nb~su~o u~uug){ '~US1~A U~~~!l~s~qun d!ZU!lds~~~!reArn sep UI~p !~q '~nD s~q:>!I~u~1Jg U!~ 1m ~I~!ds!~q1~~snw sIV

ZU8!ZYJ~ 8q:>S!UI~UÄp SnS.l8A 8q:>S!':J.~':J.S

a!.Ioaq~~ua~ed .Iap ua~elpun.ID

'UaUIUI'BSnZ puaga!Iq:>sq'e a':J.uaUIn~lV alP

~guJ sq:>~s ~~!uq:>sqV 'u~q~~s ~~~M UI! ~I~!Z l~lq! ~unImJla l~U!~ ~!P 'l'Bp ~!U!I~q:>rn l~p I~~u~W ~!P u~n~~s JUm run l~!A ~~~!Uq:>sqV ~!a '~1~P10J z~nq:>s~u~~ud ~!S u~~unpUTJ1a UOA ~lV ~q:>I~A\ Jn'e '~!~Z pun ~~uIpun~s~q:>~1:l ~PU~P!~q:>s~u~ sIu ~!U!I~q:>!l~U~~udo!g ~!P

~l~~n~{l~ ~~!Uq:>sqV ~pu~~IoJ l~a '~9~I U~~!~Iqu sUI~~sJ:..s~u~~ud U~IUUI!~do S~U!~ ~un~Iu~s -gD l~p !~q ){!~!Iods~uq:>S~l!M l~p UI~Iq01ds~unp!~q:>s~ua sep q:>!S u~u~p gnu '~n~~sa~

(6)

~

.0661 JeJedUIeI)l Jepo 0661 OJ!d~qS run ~JeqI!O ~M~e l~A °ueuo!~!uyea eq:>!Ipe!q:>sJe~un sn~q:>mp q:>!S uepuy I!~~ea UIIt

°as1aM laq:>1al.'ä' u1 a':j.1aM uaf1:ltII1':j.do lap .'ä'untIItII1':j.saa lap 1aq q:>1s ':j.q!.'Bla UO~1vn1~s-11° dpvJ,1 au -13 ~ouaz':j.apaA as1aMlaq:>11.'ä'9tII slaq~qu1':j.ua':j.~d sap ':j.q:>als.'ä'unz':j.nN a.'ä'1lI1an~ apuaqa':j.saq S'ep pun uaq:>n~':ijn~ uaapI aq:>11uq~ uuaM '.'ä'un~l1Mz':j.nq:>s lap IJetIIsnv sep Jn~ "q'p 'sa':j.

-ua':j.~d 8aU1a .'ä'tI'eJtIIns.'ä'unpuaMuv uap Jn~ q:>1s ':j.qa1zaq a':j.1aM a1a 'sa':j.ua':j.~d sau1a a':j.1aM a1P ':j.S1 StIIa':j.sAss':j.q:>alz':j.nq:>s sau1a .'ä'un':j.l~':j.sao mz u01suatII1a a.'ä'1':j.q:>1M a':j.1aA\Z a1a

"~q:>1lds':j.ua .'ä'unpuaMlaA uaq:>s1':j.s110douotII

lap ua':j.so~zualO lap ':j.1a~.'ä'1':j.~.L -'a + d

ua':j.la.'ä'1a':j.sa.'ä' lap uaz':j.nuzualO lap uuaM 'lOA ':j..'ä'a11 ':j.ua~~d sal~tII1':j.do u13 "UaplaA\ nz A1':j.:>re 3+ d U1 'uaqa':j.saq az1aluv pua.'ä'nua.'ä' q:>ou ap~la.'ä' uasa1P lnJ g~p os '.'ä'unuqolaa a.'ä'1puaM':j.ou l~tII1U1tII a1P lapuY13 tIIau1a ':j.la1':j.tI'el'e.'ä' ':j.ua':j.~d sal~tII1':j.do u13 +S1 ~1':j.110d lap aq~.'ä'Jnv uap~q:>s':j.ua nz uap 'zua1zYJ3 laq:>s1tII'eUAp pun laq:>s1':j.~':j.s uaq:>s1Mz 110 dpvJ,1 u1a .'ä'yn~ls.'ä'tI'eA\Z laq~p ~qa':j.s':j.ua ua':j.q:>alStIffi':j.ua.'ä'13 UOA u01':j.1uyaa lap ':j.1W 'a1.'ä'°louq:>a.L lap .'ä'unz~nN apuasS'eJtIIn au1a tIIn~1':j.1az uala.'ä'~1 uau1a lnJ .'ä'1':j.1azq:>1al.'ä' laq~ ':j.lapu1t{laA 'sn~ uazuanbasuao lanau .'ä'unq:>slop3 mz z1aluv uap ':j.1tII'eP pun slaq~qu1':j.ua':j.~d sap auu1A\a.'ä'lodouoW ual'?lodtIIa':j. a1P l'eA\Z ':j.1azJn~1 ala.'ä'u~1 au1a ~uqap s':j.1aslalapuv 'uatIItIIo~ zua1zYJ3 laq:>s1tII~UAp UOA ':j.snpaA tIIaU1a nz sa uu~

lanauq:>s os tIIn laq~ ":j.nwla zua1zYJ3 aq:>s1':j.~':j.s ':j.s11qatII os tIIn 'u~ uaq~tII pua':j.la.'ä' a':j.q:>als.'ä'un.'ä'npaA aA1snlJfXa laq~qu1':j.ua':j.~d lap tIIap U1 ":j.s1 tIIn~1':j.1az lasa1P lazln~ ar

"':j.auq:>1azuua~a.'ä' ':j.1a~.'ä'1':j.lnD lau1as a.'ä'~1 a1P q:>lnp '~'n ':j.ua':j.~d u1a ':j.S1 ':j.~':j.11~a'H lap uI

}{1':j.!IOds'Y~q:>s':j..I1.M. .Iap malqo.Ids.'aunp!aq:>s':j.u'.3: s~a

'zua!zYJ3 laq:>s1':j.~':j.s UOA ':j.snpaA tIIau!a nz a.'ä'~quatIItII~snz uauaqa11q:>saq uaqo a!p q:>lnp ':j.1tII'eP pun uauug~ lapo uanOM ua11{~z ':j.q:>!U s!ald uaA1':j.1sod UtI'ep uap a1P 'ua':j.

-uamnsu°)l Ua~llI';)rlap gnlq;)ssn~mnsuo)l mnz s~u1plaII~ sa ~mmo~ a~q;)alS~Un.'8nJlaA laA!SnPfXa .'ä'unz':j.asq:>lna pun u01':j.llIyaa lap ':j.1W 'zua!zYJ3 laq:>s1tII'eUAp nz ':j.lqnJ pun UatIIqaula':j.u[l a':j.~A11d q:>lnp uazuanbasuao UOA u01':j.~npold a!p ':j.q:>11.'ä'gtIIla Z!alUV las -a!a 'uala!s1f1:1al s1ald uaA1':j.1sod uau!a ualapu~ uau!a tI'e sa':j.n.'ä'suass1M sap ~unssepaq1}

lap ':j.!tII UtI'ep uu~ latIIqaula':j.u[llaa 'Uala!':j.u~l'e.'ä' nz ':j.n.'ä'suass1M tIIap tI'e ':j.q:>als.'ä'unz -':j.nN 8aA1snlJfXa u!a uatIIt{aula':j.u[l uapuaq:>sloJ q:>!al.'ä'lopa tIIap

-

ua':j.ua':j.~d UOA tII1Od

I,~ ,

(7)

V

.nos U;}pJ;}M. U;}~U~~;}~U!;} J;}t{!!U ~q:>!U S~U!pJ;}n~ J;}!q ;}!P Jn~ 'S;}~U;}~~d S;}U!;}

~unpI;}UIuv J;}P !;}q U;}UIt{8Ug'eUISU;}Jt{8JJ;}A ;}PU;}~;}IPunJ'ß ;}~!U!;} 1:IdH ;}!P ~I;}~;}J sn~u!q J;}qnJ'BGt .(89Z .S '9661 U~!I!)ll~A) ~q:>;}1:I UI;}I~UO!~~U - UI;}~J;}!S!UOUIJ~q . J1.n - q:>~u q:>!S U;}~q:>!J ~!;})[~!PU~~S;}qs~q:>;}1:I run ~un)[J!M.s~q:>;}1:I .;}~U;}~~d

;}I~UO!~~U ;}q:>S!~U;}P! ~!;}M.~doJn;} UJ;}PUOS 'U;}q:>s!~doJn;} JY.U!~!JO ;}U!;})[ S~U!pJ;}Ire U;}q;}~S~U;} Vd3 UI!;}q

~unpI;}UIuv ;}!P 1:pJnG .soIs~un)[J!M. U;}q:>s!~doJn;} UI;}U!;} U;}q;}U ~S! ~U;}~~d S;}reUO!~~U U!;} UU;}P 'U;}~!JqnJ;}

U;}~W~SSP;}!I~~!W U;}tq;}ZU!;} J;}P UJ;}~~~U;}~~d U;}P !;}q u;}~unpI;}UIU~I;}n~J'Bd q:>!S g~p '~)[J!M.;}q Vd3 UI!;}q U;}Jt{8JJ;}A U!3 .~;}PU;}M. U;}q:>unw U! Vd3 h'!Ip u~ J;}PO J;}~~~U;}~~d ;}I~UO!~~U ;}tq;}ZU!;} u~ q:>!S J;} qo 'U;}P!;}1:ps~U;} J;}puYJ3 J;}P uU'B)[ q:>1lU'eG .~unpuYJ3 J;}U!;} ~unuu;})[J;}UV run ~unpI;}UIuv Jnz U;}Jt{8JJ;}A h'!Ip J1d3 h'!Ip ~q!;}J1:pS;}q U;}q;}U~G .pJ!M. U!;}S PU;}q;}~~~Iq:>ssn~ ~unq:>;}Jds~q:>;}1:I ;}!P Jill ~un)[nz U!

1:IdH..;}!P ~p 'U;}pJ;}M. ~;}~q:>1l;}q ~q:>!U ~U!pJ;}Ire J;}!q ;}!P ';}~~!uq:>sqV ;}PU;}.ij;}J~;}q )[!uq:>;}~U;}f) ;}!P n;}!z;}ds J~M.Z ~;}~I~qU!;}q U;}UIUI°)[U!;}J;}qJ1 S;}S;}!G .;}~I!;}~J;} ;}~U;}~~d ~U'eIS!q (Vd3) ~ure~U;}~~d ;}1:ps!~doJn3 h'!Ip U;}UIq~1:I U;}SS;}P U! '(Od3) U;}UIÜxO)[U!;}J;}qn~U;}~~d ;}q:>s~doJn3 ;}J;}~I~ h'!Ip ~q;}~S;}q 1:IdH J;}P U;}q;}Ne

~mmO){lOA 1n~~N 1ap u1 s~1a1aq re11a~~w sasa1P g-ep '~la1~uamn~l'B ap1nM. s3 '~IapU'eq

~un){:)ap~u3 au1a 1apo ~unpuY13 au1a mn q:)1s sa qo 'ua~~11~smn a~u~I l~M 'uauaD .a'z 'sI~lla~~w uaq:)s1~oIo1q q:)1I~q:)1su1H .uazua1~q~ 'PU1S ~1trnJz~nq:)s ~q:)1u a1P 'ua~un){:)ap -~u3 uagoIq UOA q:)lI~nap q:)1s a1P 'ua~unpuY13 aq:)s1~oIouq:)a~o1q pu1s ~1~Js~q:)a1~ua~~d

'Hd8: .Iap u1 ~unpuy.I~ .Iap pu~~sua~aD pun .IJ!.I~a8:

'~la1ssed ~q:)1u 1aqs1q ua~~~~sspalI~~1W uaIa1A u1 ~s1 sa1a 'uassnm uassedu~ "Hda 1ap ua~uruap1od uap ("Hda I 'gI '~lY 'I~A) OOO~ !Inr 'O~ mnz sua~sa~~ds S!q ua~~Ipuru~

-s~q:)a1:J uaq:)sy!zads a1q1 ua~~~q ~m~~ua~~d aq:)s1~do1n3 sep q:)n~ sre ua~~~~sspa!I~~1W uauIazu1a a1P IqoMoS t 'Jl'BP uap1aM ~l~Ma~ ~q:)1u uapull1D uaq:)s1q~a sn~ z~nq:)s~ua~~d OM pan ~q:)1u seM pan ~s1 ~1q~J~ua~~d seM 'ua1a1uyap l'BP{ a1s nos malre lOA . (L 16 'S '8661 uu~m1a~~n1 l~A) s~q:)a"H uapua~Ia~ gap n~qm[1 pan -sny uaq:)s1uoml'Bq uau1a u1apuos 'n~qnaN uau1a Jn~ ~q:)1u ~Ia1z a1S .ua.IJ~q:)s nz ua~unpuTJl3 aq:)s1~oIouq:)a~ua~

pan -{)!q 1llJ ~q:)a1~ua~~d sanau ~lIIgA u!a auqo 'az~~spuruD ua~s~1~q:)1M a1P ~la!m1OU

"Hda a1a .ua~reqaq pu~~saa ~Jun){nz U1 q:)n~ uap1aM ua~~~~sspalI~~1W 1ap az~asa~~ua~

-~d uauIazu!a a1a '){1uq:)a~uaD 1ap q:)1a1aa m1 az~asa~~ua~~d uaI~uo1~~u 1ap ~unq:)1aI~

-u~s~q:)a"H au1a ~S! Ia!z 1qI .8661 1Jllr .9 ure uo1ssn){S1a ua~ll~ruqaz 1aqll1au1a q:)~u

"Hda a!p ua~apa1q:)sq~laA ~~"H 1ap pan ~uam~I1~d aq:)S!~dO1n3 sea . (~zlll){a~q~ "Hda

~1m uapua~Iod m1 '~aill{:)1azaq a1ulI~q:)1l~ua~~do1a SI~ ~yn~q) f:"ua~unpuTJl3 laq:)s1~oIou -q:)a~o1q z~nq:)s uaq:)1I~q:)a1 uap 1aqll D3/vv/86 a1ulI~q:)1"H" a1P ~apI!q [13 1ap qI~qlauu1 ){1uq:)a~uaD lap q:)1alaa m1 z~nq:)s~ua~~d 1m a~~IpuruD aq:)1I~q:)a1 apuap1aq:)s~ua a1a 'Hd8: .Iap ~unqa':j.s':j.u~

na .Iap u! a1-ua1-'RduaD .Im a~'RIPun.I~s1-q::>a'H a!G

(8)

9

"~le!ZUelelJ!p le~!eM ~tI;)!U 'HdH lep U! Pl!M uelt{~JleA run uess!U.'ä'nezl3 uetI;)s!A\z .'ä'unp!etI;)sle~ufl leSe!p ueqeN "UepleM ~z~ese.'ä'u!e glieD seu!e .'ä'Unle!A!~:>{V ue~Ie!ze.'ä' run .'ä'un.'ä'~l~leqi) 'UO!~~IOSI lnz e!p 'ue:>{!utI;)e.L e!p PU!S ueltI~JleA etI;)s!.'ä'%utI;)e~ueD "('HdH 6 run 8 "~lV e!MOS 191 "S '8661 eIue!)! 'I.'ä'A) ueUIUIoJIq;)~N uelep pun ueseMeqe'} ezue.'ä' Jn~ tI;)n~ osre 'uepleM ~le!znpold UO!~~UIlOJuI etI;)s!~eue.'ä' e!p tI;)lnp e!p 'uezu~~sqns etI;)!I~UI~S run e~:>{npold epue~retI~ue ueUO!~~UIlOJ -ur etI;)s!~eue.'ä' Jn~ z~ntI;)s~ue~~d lep tI;)!S ~:>{;)el~Sle osueq3 "eueD euIezu!e e!u!'} le~Sle U!

~!UI~P PU!S ess!U.'ä'nezl3 etI;)s!.'ä'%utI;)e~ueD '('HdH ~1 'z "~lV 'I.'ä'A) ueuug:>{ uepleM ~le!Z -npoldel UIe~sf..s uetI;)s!.'ä'°IO!q UIeU!e UOA lepo Uele!ZnpOldel ~sqIes tI;)!S run ue~I~tI~ue ueUO!~~UIlOJuI etI;)s!~eue.'ä' gnUI I~!le~~w setI;)s!.'ä'°IO!H '('HdH I 'E "~lV 'I.'ä'A) pl!A\ ~epueM -leA lepo ~e~!eql~eq '~IIe~se.'ä'letI I~!le~~w setI;)s!.'ä'°IO!q ueuep U! "MZq ~!UI 'ueltI~JleA run ue~retI~ue sese!p lepo uetIe~seq I~!le~~w UIetI;)s!.'ä'°IO!q sn~ e!p 'ess!u.'ä'nezl3 :uep -e!tI;)Sle~un uepu~~sue.'ä'e.'ä's.'ä'unpuTJl3 ue.'ä'!~J~ue~~d !eMZ uetI;)S!MZ pl!A\ 'HdH lep uI

"(816 's '8661 uu~UIle~~n'} 'I.'ä'A) ueuug:>{ ue.'ä'u~Ie.'ä' s!uqe.'ä'l3 uetI;)!eI.'ä' UInz ez~ese.'ä'ln~~N lep Ie!ds egoIq sup tI;)lnp ~tI;)!U Jl'BP ln~~N e!a '~UIUI~~S uetI;)suew UIOA lep '~.'ä'e!pOA :>{!UtI;)e.L lnz .'ä'~l~!eH lepueltIillle~

-!eM u!e g~p '~S! pueqe.'ä'g~w '(891 's '8661 eIue!)! 'I.'ä'A) uetI;)!elle nz .'ä'Iop3 uel~qn~tI;)s -leqn I~sn'e:>{ ueu!e UIn 'Pl!M ~epueMleA pun ~le!InUIloJ ue'.ij~l:>{ln~~N uetI;)s!.'ä'°IO!q UOA Z~~SU!3 UInz eltIe'} etI;)s!utI;)e~ eneu eu!e g~p ulepuos 'eplnM ~:>{;)ep~ue se~uU'e:>{equfl SUM~e g-ep 'puep!etI;)s~ue ~tI;)!U ~S! !eq~a '('HdH Z 'E '~lV) "l'BM uepu~tIlOA u°tI;)S ln~

-~N lep U! se uueM 'u!es .'ä'unpuTJl3 leU!e pu~~sue.'ä'eD uu~p tI;)n~ uU'e:>{ 'Pl!M ~IIe~se.'ä'letI lepo ~le!Ios! .'ä'unqe.'ä'UIfl uetI;)!pn~~U leU!eS sn~ sueltI~peA uetI;)s!utI;)e~ seu!e eJI!H ~!UI

&'er 'I~!le~~w setI;)s!.'ä'°IO!H" :~l~I:>{e.'ä' ~!el~S leSe!p Pl!M e!u!I~tI;)!l~ue~~do!H lep ~!W

'(L91 's '8661

eIue!)! 'I.'ä'A) !es .'ä'!s~Inz ~tI;)!U ~!UIOS z~ntI;)s~ue~~d 'gnUI uepleM ~:>{;)ep~ue tI;)OU lnu run~

(9)
(10)

L

.(al .S '0661 es!eM. run le~a l~A) UepleA\ ~lqme~U!e ~){und~!ez uel1Jw!~do q;)!I~1Jq;)Snese~ wep lOA q;)s!~1JWe~SAS ueuo!~1JAOUUI U'IIP os 'uewwo){ ueuo!~!~SeAU!leqfl nz se uU'R){ lqewle!A .efRw!~do lep t{'Jn1J ~yn~ls~U'RA\Z ~q;)!U '~unpuYlelezU!a SI1J lepo eepI uepueqe"iseq leU!e ~unl){;)!A\~uele~!eM. SI1J qo I1J~e '~~!lq;)S~lOd eq;)s!uq;)e~ eq;)!1~9w I1JW!XtlW lep ~S! ~U!plenV 9

.uelqm ~~!lq;)S~lOd uepuen1Jq -Jn1J ~un){;)ep~ues!SBH e!p Jn1J lqew nz Pl!A\ ~!ezJn1J'I le~u1Jl pueq;)elds~ue ~!W ~ue~1Jd se~ue sepuleq;)!S

~unuqoleH eq;)!el~ e!p lepuyla wep u!e 'le~!UeA\ nz Pl!A\ ~!ezJn1J'I leZln){ ~!W ~ue~1Jd se~!eA\ U!ag -Ufl uepueq:>SloJ meu!e +.'ßu!Ief) "+leA\q:>Sle q:>!Iz+~snz )f!+!IOd 1ep melq01ds.'ßunp!eq:>s -+u3 gop 1ep 'ue.'ß!+q:>!S}{:>n1eq nz ene+s 1eSe!p Tm +S! .'ßTmquemuresnz 1e1e+!eA\ U!3

"Uep1eA\ +.'ß!+q:>!S}{:>n1eq ue.'ß -unI)f:>!A\+uee.'ßlod 1ene!+ue+od +leM 1eSe!p gnm 'Uep1eA\ +lq~A\e.'ß '+leJe!I 3+d 1nJ z!eroy ue.'ß!pueA\+ou I'em!u!m uep gop '+q:>e1z+nq:>s seI'em!+do u!e mq! nos ".'ßun+q:>'e1+eg 70'l{S -dUO 1eU!e U! sre P1!A\ +e+1eA\eq 1eqgq mq! UOA .'ßunpuTJ13 e!p +!ll°A\ 'OOP!S.'ßUnldS1fl1ep sn'eqsny seu!e +!e)fq:>!I.'ß9W e!p 1eqles 1eq'equ!+ue+'ed uep ~J +qe+seq ue+!eA\z mnz

g"P1!A\ +ll{eA\leA ++!lq:>S+lOd ue1e+!eA\ 1nJ suess!A\ue.'ß'elpunlO sep .'ßunpueA\leA 1eU!e +!e)fq:>!I.'ß9W e!p mepTmme!u 9'BP os 'Uep1eA\ +z+nq:>se.'ß +!ezJn'e11e.'ßTmI +!m +ue+'ed se.'ßue ll{es u!e q:>mp 1emm! uo!+ueAuI sI'e eueo ue+gnm 'ueqese.'ßu'e +leA\SUeq:>sUnA\ ne1eue.'ß sre ++!lq:>Sf.I°d 1eq:>S!uq:>e+ P1!M "puep!eq:>s+ue se+ue+'ed sep e+!eM run e.'ßU'!'!1 sn'e UO!+

-'eu!qm°)l sre .'ßunuqoleg 1ese!p m+)fnl+S e!p +S! U!q1e+!eA\ 'lepuTJ13 uep 1nJ .'ßunuqoleg 1ep eqgH ue+nlosq'e 1ep en01+U°)l e!p 1eqn mu +q:>!U +!urep t.'ßloJ1e ue+so)l +sod xe run uez!eroy e+u'e xe ueq:>s!A\z q:>!eI.'ßsny U!3 "(61f: 's 't6611eu1e1) "l,+ue+'ed'e 10J em+:>nl+s 1ed01d eq+ S! +'eqA\ '[ peA "P "muy 'lepuTJ13 uep 1nJ .'ßunuqoleg e!p +S! +u!eme.'ß] +U'e+S -UD:> p1'eA\e1 re1eAO eq+ .'ßU!PIO(H)

" .uep1eA\ +e+q:>'eeq uegg1O 1ep!eq Ie!dsuemm'esnz gop

gnm 'ueuug)f nz Ue1e!+Tm1'e.'ß z+nt:ps+ue+'ed ueI'em!+do eA!+)feds1ed 1eq:>!I+J'eq:>S+1!A\+ures -e.'ß sn'e mfl g"+IepTmq UO!+'eAOUU!S!gog 1epo -Iezu!3 eu!e mn q:>!S se qo 't.'ßU'!'!qq'e UOA'ep e+!eA\- pun e.'ßU'!'!I+ue+'ed uelq'e!1'eA1ene+s uep!eq 1ep IlJ'eM e!p 1eq'e IlJOA\ 'lepuTJ13 uep l1}J sez!e1TmI'em!u!w sep eqgH e!p +q:>!U 1'eA\Z 9'BP os 'e+!eM 1ep .'ßunuqepsny epueq:>

-c)lds+ue eu!e sre '+snpeAs+1lJ'eJlqoM ueueqe!lq:>seq uep Jll'e slepu'e se+ue+'ed seu!e e.'ßU'!'!1 1ep .'ßunuqepsny eu!e +)f1!A\ ueu!e mnz .u1ep!A\le nz !epe!eA\z +S! +q:>!suy 1eSe!G

"Uep1eA\ +e+q:>'e1+eq d:>W 70'l{S -dUO sre uessepe.'ßloJU! gnm zuenbessuo!+'eAouuI 1eU!e .'ßunpuTJ1elezu!3 eper "Uep1eA\ t.'ß!+

-q:>!S}{:>n1eq +q:>!U ez!ero'es.'ßunq:>slod 1eI'em!+do .'ßunmm!+seg 1ep !eq ueuo!+'eAouu!e.'ßlod 1e+1e.'ßgz1eA q:>!I+!ez 1epo 1e+1epU!m1eA 'lepueq!elqsn'e m10d U! ue+so)l ueI'e!zos uepueI -I'eJu'e 1e+~ds e!p ueJ1np 1elJ'eG "(~~1 's '0661 eS!eM run 1e.'ß3 l.'ßA) ue.'ßneZ1e ++!lq:>S+lOd

~

(11)

8

-q:>lnp nz la~u a.'ä'u~quammusnz uaq:>s!uq:>a~o!q asa!p auqo 'uu'(:l}{ uaplaM ~z~asa.'ä'u!a uamS!ue.'ä'lO uaq:>!Ipa!q:>sla~un U! uao u!a fJ'BP pun ~S! ~!I!a~aq uaJll~Iqy uala!A uu snm -S!ue.'ä'lO m! uaf) u!a fJ'BP 'os laqu sa ~S! q:>!Iq~s~uJ. 'Pl!M ~z~nq:>sa.'ä' ~ua~ud mau!a ~!m (uass!Mua.'ä'uIPunlf) sre) uaf) sep lapo (.'ä'unpuaMuy sre) a~um°J. alP qo 'uaq:>um pa!t{:>s -la~ufl uau!a){ sa apl!}M 'a~um°J. lap U! UO!~){u1ld aula asa!p lnu uao sasa!p a~~~q pun uaplaM ~apuaMlaA ua~um°J. U! lnu udD-'l/;)S7V.w-~7UV sep a~uug){ .uala!po:> auaf) asa!p alP 'au!a~old alP laqn a!MOS auaf) ua~apuaMlaA alP laqn uass!M sep ~S! 'uanuqJnu ua.'ä' -unpuaMuy Ua~al){UO){ asa!p lap Jnu 'a!.'ä'%uq:>a~ua.'ä'ulpuruO a!a .(169 pun f79 'S '6661 sua~lug '{.'ä'A) aplnM ~.'ä'nJa.'ä'nz .'ä'U!I~q:>S ua~mm!~saq uau!a ua.'ä'a.'ä' ua.'ä'zua~s!sa'H u!a map 'S!~l'BAON Uml!~ lap s~v.w-.Lfllap lapo apmM ~ulaJ~ua ula~IY sanauq:>s lnJ UO!~UmloJU!

-ql3 aula lap gnu 'd7VWO.L-'l/;)S7V.w-~7UV alP 'g'z puls ){!uq:>a~uao lap a~){llpoldpu3 .('Hdg I 'f; '~lY .g'z '{.'ä'A) uass!Mua.'ä'ulpuruO maq:>s!~aua.'ä' pun ua~){llpoldpu3 uaq:>S!MZ .'ä'unp!aq:>sla~ufl !apau!a){ q:>opaf m!l~ 'Hdg a!a 'nz .'ä'un~napag agotiJ mloua aula aq:>uulg lap ~~!lq:>S~O~ Uala~!aM uap lnJ uauao UOA UO!~){UI\!I alP pun nuqJny uap laqn uass!Mua.'ä'ulpuruO map ~mmo){ ){!uq:>a~uao lap U! apulao .uaplaM ~a~S!ap~Ma.'ä'

~~!lq:>S~lO~ lapuanuqJnu lapueU!aJnu 'la~Juqlanup nos 'uaUO!~UAOUU!s.'ä'unpuaMuy sIU 'puls uaz~nq:>s nz slapue uaUO!~UAOUU!S!seg gup 'q:>!I~nap ~ll:>um Uo!~U~uamn.'ä'lY a!G

:>I!uq=>a':j.uaf) .Iap u! ua!.'a°louq=>a':j.s!s~H pun ua.'aunpuaMuy

'(19 's upuaqa) ,,~ll.'ä'!l (~ua~ud) A~ladold laq aS!:>laxa o~ uallM ap!:>ap o~ A~!I!q!xaIJ alom sell laploq~ua~ud all~

asnu:>aq puu la!pUa gemo:> liMO l!all~ JO SUO!~u:>!Iddu a:>npol~U! uu:> SreA!l ll:>!llM .'ä'U!l -np po!lad all~ asnu:>aq uo!~:>a~old ll~uaI saop uell~ aluJlaM Jo sIaAaI lall.'ä'!t{ sa~ulaua.'ä' [1laA "P .muy 'a.'ä'~1laZln){ puall:>alds~ua pun a~!aM lagol.'ä' ~!m ~ua~ud u!a ~S! ~u!am -a.'ä'] uo!~:>a~old ado:>s ~ull~" 'ua.'ä'!az ualo~ny a!a .pl!M ~apuaMlaA pua+J!~suaz~nu ~ll:>!U

~S1{:)~unz UO!~UAOUUI all:)!IZ~nU apUala!~S!Xa au!a up '(09 's '9661 "re ~a sa~n~uw) "po!lad .'ä'U!~!UM alqul!sapun" aula ~lla~s~ua s3 'uaq:>!alla nz .'ä'unI){:>!M~uaa.'ä'Io~ lap U! .'ä'unldslOA uau!a ulaqlaMaq~~aM uau!as laqnua.'ä'a.'ä' 'u!as ~qnmaq ~sll:>~unz Pl!M uamllaula~ufl sea 'Pl!M ~ll:>!I~ualJglaA aS!aMs.'ä'ueMz ~!urgp pun ~aplama.'ä'ue ~ua~ud mnz .'ä'unpuYl3 a!p loAaq 'uanuqnzsnu aap!s.'ä'urudslfl a!p 'uall:)nslaA sa Pl!M 'ua~!a){ll:>!I.'ä'gW uapuaqa.'ä'la snul'Bp ll:>!S alP uamllaula~ufl sasa!p ~UUa){la pun .'ä'un){:>ap~u3 are~uamupunJ aula uamllaula~

l!

1

"c" ","~C'",C'"c',""J

(12)

6

lapo uauo~~~AOUUI pl~NI. sa~ua~~d sau~a laq~1:{uI laG 'ua~re1:{ sn~la1:{ 1:{~~alaqs~un1:{~SlOd mau~a sn~ la1:{a 1:{~~s la pl~NI. 'uaill{~al ua~so)l ua1:{o1:{ l1:{as ~~m 'Pl1A\ uasa~Nl.a~1:{~~u sa~

-1:{~alz~n1:{~S sau~a ~unz~a{laA a~p ~1:{~~laf) 10A m1:{~ IJep 'Ired uap lnJ lapuTj13 u~a gnw 'aII°'H apuap~a1:{~s~ua au~a sa~ua~~d uapua1:{a~saq sau~a 1:{~~alag m~ ua~un~s~a1~+d UOA ua~u~lq13 sep lnJ ua~sO)llasa~p ~unI~a~laA a~p ~Ia~ds mapnz .('] 098 'S '066T UOSla~

-~M. 'I~A) uaJlnp UaplaNl. ~~s~I1:{~~ulaA ~1:{~1U sma~sAs~ua~~d sau~a suaz~nN sap ~un~

-laNl.aq~lli'esaD lau~a u~ a~p 'ua~so)l ~1:{~~slruaA uasaNl.S~1:{~~laf) apUaplaNl. ~~~Qu sea '(z 'S '666T ~aqoI1 'I~A) gnm UaplaNl. ~I~a~lnaq sa~1:{~alA~snI){x3 sau~a ~unz~a{laA a1:{~~I~Qm au~a lreJlazu~3 m~

lapa~NI. lamm~ g~p os 'uammoJIIIoAun ~~lli'ep s~X'eld lap u~ uaq~alq '~laJa~I a~~aM. alq~~l -~A a~p laqn a~1:{~~laf) a~p 1:{~lnp ~unq~1:{pu~H uassap pun ~1:{~a'H a~la~zTj~poJI sep a1:{~IaNl.

'uauo~~~mloJuI a~a

,( 'B 6fT 'S '866T la~m~Id a~Nl.os '] Of:f: 'S 'f66T laula1 'I~A) ual -a~l~s~al s~u~Jmnz~n1:{~S sap ~unJI~l1:{~su~3 a1:{~~I~nap au~a 886T ~~as 1:{~~s ~9~I 'a~ua~~d a~~aNl. ~~g~ms~U~rn1:{laA ualIfef la08 uap u~ a~1:{~~laf) a1:{~s~u~~lalli'e-'S'fl 'g'z ua~la~~U~l -~D 'l~quuaJIla sn~1:{~lnp ua~ua~~d UOA a~~aM. lap ua~uruapu,! pu~s Jn~{laA~~az m~ 1:{~n~

'ua~~aJI~~~~al~ss~1:{~al~ua~~d uaulazu~a ua1:{~s~Nl.z ua~ua~s~suoJIUI lnu ~1:{~~u uala~~s1Xa ~aq -~a '~a~Iqo agQlf) lasa~p uo~~~~aldla~uI a~p uauap 'a~1:{~~la~~ua~~d lap ua~unp~a1:{~s~u3 ua~~g~mla~al sn~ ~laNl.S~uruIfeJ13 sre ~Sla ~Tjn~1:{ a~~aM. a~p 1:{~~s ~q~la ua~a~u~H 'uap -laNl. uaqa~l1:{~saq uaz~asaf) u~ uU'e}{ sa~ua~~d sau~a a~u~1 a~a 'amalqold a~~u~a s!X'eld a~p u~ ass~u~uuaJI13 ua1:{~s~~aloa1:{~ lap ~unz~asmfllap ~aq a~~aM. alq~~l'eA lap ~~m sa ~q~~

'~~m uaBal~nz IIan~uaAa alq~~l~A~~az a~p lnJ sa~p pual1:{~M. 'pu~s uala~uTjap nz ~~~nap -u~a a~ue xa la~~1~s~unp~a1:{~s~u3 a1:{~s~~~Iods'.ij~1:{~S~l1A\ 1:{~lnp a~~aM. pun a~u~1 uagQ1D a~p g~p 'uammoua~ue aplnNl. '"z~n1:{~s~ua~~d maI~m~~do" UOA apa'H a~p la1:{s~q 1~M.

e~!eM~Ue~Rd .Iep Uo!~!uyea enRue~ufl :le~uRW .Ie~!eMZ

'pulaplQJsuo~~~AOUU~ SI~ puamma1:{s~un1:{~sloJ la1:{a as~aNl.la1:{~~I~Qm ~~m~p ~JI1~NI.

pun ~unu1:{~a'H as~aM. la~su~aJI u~ 1:{~opar pu~~smflmasa~p a~s ~~~l~ 'ass~u~naz13 lnJ a1A\

~laploJ z~n1:{~S ua1:{~~aI~ ~~aldmoJI uap ua~~IPuruD a1:{~s~~aua~ l1}J 'Hdg a~p mapuI 'uaf) sasa~p laqn uass~M. m~ a~1:{~alsmn~ua~~3 lap (a~~aM. pun a~~1lap) ~~~~A~snIJIx3 lap UOA q~ puap~a1:{~s~ua ~u~1:{ uo~~~s~I~a'H ualaa 'ua~unpuaNl.uv la1:{~~Iz~nu IIa~~ua~od 11:{~zIa~A au~a 1:{~~s ~auBQla sauaf) sau~a ~unlassnl1:{~s~u3 lap ~~w :1:{~~I~nap sau~a pl~NI. 'ua~1:{~naI

(13)

01

~~~~UIaIqolds.'aunzual.'aqy lasa~a .(6661"&1'0& UIOA Yd3 sap 66/ L .'aunI~a~~~UIassald l.'aA)

~ga~Iq;}su~a uas&-e1:I lapo ua~los a~s uuaM '~s~ .'a~~J~ua~~d uuep q;}n~ .'aunpuY13 au~a IJep '6661"&1'0& um q;}~Izue~su~~z~aI nz~p pa~q;}s~ua laUIUI~aplaMq;}Saa agolD a~a .(1 't '~lY l.'aA) ~~u~lq;}Saq ua~os lapo uas&-e1:I a~UIUI~~saq Jn~ ~q;}~U .'aunpuY13 au~a q;}~S uuaM 'uaUI -q~usny laq~ ~qn~pa 'uas&-ella~J- pun ua~losuazu~Yd UOA .'aullla~~ua~~d a~p q;}~I~;}l}lpsn~

~a~a~qlaA 1:Ida a~a 'sa~p ua.'a~~~~saq sa~um~ua~~d uaq;}S~~dOln3 sap ua.'aunp~aq;}s~u3

"l~I~un ~q~aIq '~q;}SUl}M uaqa1 UOA ~~a~l~qla~~ua~~d lap uazualD a~p laqa.'az~asao lap 01\\ 'uu~ u~as apa1:I a~p laMq;}S lqaUI lnu ua~oqlaA~ua~~d uaq;}~IZ~~SpUlll.'a UOA puaga~Iq;}sue g~p os 'uaqaslaA uaUIq'l'Iusny ~~UI pun ~q;}~Mq;}Sa.'aq~

q;}S~~~UIa~sAs q;}opaf .'aullla~n~P3 pun .'aunuuauaa lalq~ q~u uaplaM aq;}~alaa ~alp auy .ua~~~s ua~n.'a a~p ua.'aa.'a sago~slaA sap Ire.!! UI~ a~Mos uas&-ella~J- pun ua~losuazueYd Jn~ 'aI~a~pue~saa au~as pun ladlg)! aq;}~Iq;}suaUI uap Jny :uaJll}p uaplaM ~I~a~la ~q;}~U

a~ua~~d uauap u~ '~aIa.'a~saJ .'aun~napaa laq;}s!q~a laqoq UOA aq;}~alaqz~~spulllO ~alp

~umsa.'asu~ uaplaM s3 .uaqa1 UOA "MZq I~~la~~w UIaq;}s~.'a%~q UOA z~nq;}ss~q;}a1:I sap uazualD a~p uaUIUI~~saq (uIa~~~lY 81 UOA sq;}as u~qlaUIUI~) 1:Ida lap aI~aJ- agolO

'~s~ l~qla~~ua~~d ~dn~qlaql} &-eM 'uaplaM uaq:>oldsa.'a uassap uo~~~uyaa ual'BI~ lau~a UOA q;}OU 's.'aueJUInz~nq;}s sap .'aunq -~alq;}Saa ua~:)fexa lau~a UOA lapaM s.'au~plaIre uu~ 'ua~uuo~ uaplaM ~IaUIUI~sa.'a laqs~q a~p 'ua.'aulllq'l'lJ13 uaq;}s~~:)feld uap pun uIa~~~lY uapuaga~Iq;}sue q;}~S uap 'ua.'aun.'a~M13 uapua.'aIoJ uap uI 1a~z sasa~p n~ua.'a 1:Ida a~p q;}~S ~~;}a~s .'aun.'a~M13 'EI lalq~ uI '~qa.'a z~nq;}s lasa~p ~~aM a~M pun ~s~ l'Bqla~~ua~~d &-eM '~a~requ~aq uassap uo~~~uyaa an~ua.'a 78'1{;)~16,qUl au~a ~q;}a1:I a~la~zy~po~ apua.'aa~Iapunl.'ä'nz &-ep uuaM 'q;}~I.'a~l~nz SUIa~sAs~ua~~d sap zua~zHJ3 lap sa ~s~ z~o~ o~sap s~q;}~N "ua.IJeq;}s ~Ia1\\ lap sn~ q;}~Iz~.'a ~q;}~U UIaIqold sasa~p q;}~S ~~I 1:Ida lap ~~UI q;}ny 'pl~M ualql}J ~~a~.'a~~~~s.'aunq;}Slo.!! ua~~u~lq;}Sa.'au~a lau~a nz a~p '~qa~s~ua ~~aqlaq;}~SUn lapuY13 lap ua~~as Jn~ ~~ump pun uaplaM .'a~~gu ual -q'l'IJlaAs~q;}~lao aA~sua~u~ua~so~ q;}lnp~p g~p 'uu~ uaplaM ~la~uyap ~~~xa ~q;}~U a~ue xa s~q;}alz~nq;}s sau~a a~~aMs.'aunpuaMuy a~p IJep 'ua~I~q~saJ q;}~S ~~I puas&-eJuaUIUI~snz

.(tl 's '6861 1~ ~a P~)!l.'aA) uaplaM Ul~q;}SlaA q;}OU Pu~Iq;}s~naa u~ ualq'l'lf E'& .a.z UOA sualq'eJlaA uaq;}Ios sau~a lan~a aq;}~I~~1Uq;}sq;}lnp a~p q;}lnp a~p 'sualq'l'lJlaAs.'aunI~a~la~ua~~d sap ua~so)! a~p ua~

-l~M as~a1\\ aq;}~aI.'a Jny .(6& 's '6661 ~aqOI11.'aA) uaU~Jsn~ uq~ ll}J ua~so~s.'aunz~asq;}lna a~p laqgq af 'uas&-eInz laqa os UIn ua.'aa.'au~q q;}~alaa ua~z~l}q;}sa.'a UIau~as u~ uauo~~~~~UII

(14)

11

.PUIS ualann>{l~ nz ~I~napula a~U'!! xa aIs g-ep 'uaqllq na~loA uapuap -Iaq:>s~ua uap s~uIPlalre ua~so>{~Ial~S uap laqnua~a~ alP 'ualqnqao uaq:>n~urn alP uaUIUIo>{ nzuIHL 1..ue~SO)lleSe!p lesg1sny lepUep!eq;>s~ue u!e PU!S ue~!e){.'B!~!el~ss~q;>el~Ue~'Bd '(vI 'S '6861

"{'B ~e 1l'B)I"{.'BA) e9'BW melepuoseq U! se!P ~1!.'B e!.'B°1ouq;>e~o!H lep q;>!eleH m! flW)ll~~

'(1 IIX 'S 'v661

~m'B~ue~'Bd seq;>s!~doro3 "{.'BA) uele!~ue~'Bd nz ~q;>!U ue.'BunpuTj13 'xep punlf) uepuep!eq:>s~ue ueu!e sme~sAs~ue~'Bd sep ue~so)! e!p ueue~s flW)ll~j ep'Blef)

'(100& q;>nqgelpy run -lq'Bf S'Ba - e!.'B°1ouq;>e~o!H "{.'BA)

le~!eql'B~!W

m {'Bm!xem e~!y~q;>seq uemqeule~u fl lep % 9E leq~ 'e~!~q;>seH 09 S1'B lqem leq~

(leleje!1nz run le~snlsny euqo 'q'p) euu!s Uele.'BUe m! uemqeule~ufl-){!uq;>e~o!H ueq;>s -~nep lep 1eyu~~ sedd'Bu){ u!e q;>!1.'B!pe1 e~~jleA 000& lq'Bf m! q;>°N '(911 's '86611ed!)!

"{.'BA) uez~~1ds~!eqlY ueneu jU~j nz S!q meu!e roll s1!eMef ~!m q;>!1ge!1q;>ssn'B ~h'ej S.'BU!P -leu'B 'uemqeule~ufl eneu E6 xeMZ PU'B1q;>s~nea U! L6/9661 uelq'Bf uep U! uepu'B~s~ue ue.'BUnpU~l.'BSUemqeule~ufl UOA .'Burueplg~ roz sqleMeq~~eM-D!.'Be'H°!H ue~lqnje.'Bq;>rop Smn!le~S!U!mS.'Bunq;>slOjSepunH mOA sep uemq'e'H mI '(01 's '8661 'B~!A "{.'BA) ue~~~!SleA -!UfllepO ue~n~!~su!s.'BUnq;>slo~ sn'B le1~j'Bq;>suess!M eq;>S!lemqeule~un 'e.'Bunf ~s!em PU!S lepu~lf) '~!~q;>seq 'Bml!~ old ueuosled om S1'B le.'B!UeM OS1'B Uel'BM ~~!uq;>sq;>roa mI 'Ule~!eqxe~!w 000 0&1 "B;> ~!m ueml!~-q;>e~o!H OOEI 'BM~e

L661 Ue~le!~s!Xe YSfl uep uI

'se!p ueq;>!1~nepleA uerq'BZ epue.'B1o~ 'ue.'B'Bl~e.'B run ueqe!l~e.'BueloA uemqeule~ufl Ue~le!S -!1'B!zeds 'ueu!err UOA meu'B lOA uelq'Bflepu~lf) ueue.'Bue.'BleA uep U! eproM e!.'B°1ouq;>e~

-uef) run -D!H 'Uel'BM eq;>uelH ue.'Bunf lep lo~omsuo!~'BAOUUI lep leqS!q e!p '(flW)!) uem -qeule~ufl ueq;>s!pu~~s1e~~!m run ueu!e1){ me1{'B lOA uep'Bq;>s ue){;>~1suo!~!uTjea ese!a 'u!es epe'H e!p S.'BeMSeU!e){ OS1'B uu'B){ ue~ue~'Bd UOA ~!e){.'B!S~rnz lep run e~!eMz~nq;>s lep ueuo!~!uTjea ueq;>!1P~~sleAg!mun uoA 'Uemn~lU!e lerqe~ ueu!e Yd3 h'ep e~gnm le!q q;>ny 'UU'e}{ uepleM ~epueMleA ueq;>suew m!eq uo!~'Brnd!u'Bmuq'Bqm!e)! roz q;>S!~eloeq~

9'BP 'Pl!M ~z~~q;>se.'B uelq'BjleA u!e mq! ~!m 'BP '~qe~s 'HdH lep ~!m .'BU'B1){U!3 m! ~q;>!U 19E969d3 ~ue~'Bd e~1!e~le 66611eqmezea m! S'Bp 9'BP '~uu'B){eq esseld e!p q;>rop eproM OOO~ l'Bnlqe~ '1~ my 'PU!S ~le!s!1'B!zeds 'e!.'B°1ouq;>e~o!H .'Bun1!e~q'Ble~ufl '~q;>el~ue~'Bd seq;>s!~doroe Jll'B e!p 'ueqe~sleA ue~s!rof roll q;>!1~z~e1 ueuug){ '~S! .'B!~gu ~dn'Bqleq~ eIs mnxeM 'ueq'Bq ue~!e){.'B!le!Mq;>s uesh'e'H lepo ue~los ue.'B!q~j~ue~'Bd ~q;>!U run uezueYd pun Uele!J. ue.'B!q~j~ue~'Bd UOA .'Bunp!eq;>sle~ufllep ~!m ue~ledx3 ~sq1es g'Bp 'eq;>'Bs~'BJ.

e!p ~S! e!mouo){Q lep ~q;>!S sn'B puep!eq;>s~u3 'nos uepleM ue.'BOZuoAq;>'BU ~q;>!U .'Bueq -uemm'Bsnz mese!p U! e!p 'epuru.'Bnz Uo!~'B~Uemn.'B1Y eq;>s!~s!rof e~le!z!1dmo){ eu!e ~.'Be!1

(15)

~I

q;)OU l'aq'Bp P11M "Bdomg u1 +}{UndS~UnUplOS'a~'BJ. l'an'a1ZYJO u'alq-ef EI +1'as lq'amunu "a~

-'BIs+q;)'a'H l'ap ~un~I)l 'a~1+In.'ä'pu'a 'a1a .U'a}{U'apl'aqn nz {'Bmu1'a q;)OU 'HdH 'a1P '+.'a"al'a~U'B I'aSS1J.1H U1 +'Bq ~uru'a1~'als'apunH 'aq;)s+n'ap 'a1P q;)ny .+mm1+s'a~nz 'a1u1I+q;)ffi l'ap ~unz+'as -mfl l'ap PI'aJ1OA m1 uo1ssn}{S1a u'al'a+1'aM q;)'BU ~uru'aPlod l'ap +'Bq +'Bl'Bdomg l'aa

.+mmo}{nz ~un+n'ap'aH 'amlou'a 'aU1'a S'aq;)1'al'aH-g+d s'as -'a1P Sl'a+}{'Bl'Bq;)Zu'anb'aS u'a+.'a'~ld'a~sn'B s'ap puru~Jn'B U'aSS1MU'a~'B'Ipuruo U'aq;)S1+'aU'a~ m'ap IqoMqo 'u'auO1+'BAOUUI U'aq;)S1uq;)'a+U'a~ run u'auo1+u'aAuI U'aq;)S1+'au'a~ U'aq;)S1MZ +.IJ11+ ~unp -1'aq;)Sl'a+ufl 'au1'a}{ 'a~'BIPunfßs+q;)'a'H 'a1P g'Bp 'q;)mp'Bp }{1+'Bm'alqold 'a1P P11M y~q;)Sl'aA 'u'an'a+ssq'B+S 'aq;)S1+s1mf lnJ I'a++1W 'a1P .'H.P'1 u'alq'aJ u'auq1 run ~unq;)SlOd 'a1P Jn'B u'a;)mos -s'a'H 'alq1 I{'B u'al'a11+U'aZUO}{ 'a1S .U'al'BM 'aq;)U'B1H u'a~unf l'ap lo+omsuo1+'eAouuI l'ap l'aqS1q 'a1P 'sloq'B1 u'al'au1'aPI 'a1P pu1s l'al'a1p'aA .u'a~'alnzsn'B u'a+suno u'alq1 nz +q;)11'aO lOA u'a+1'a}{

-~1n'Bu'a~ufl u'apu'aq'a+s'aq 'a1P 'U'aq'a+Sl'aA ltA'a S'a U'apl'aM u'a~unI1'a+q'BS+q;)'a'H 'alqI 'U'a.IJ'al+

l'a~1u'aM s'a1P P11M 'aUl'aZUO)l 'aPU'al'a1~'e +1'aM+I'aM .+s1 q;)1Iu'a1P +q;)1U "HdH l'ap I'a1Z u'a+~PI -l'a U'a+Sl'a m'ap u1ql'amm1 '+1'a}{~1+~+SUO1+'BAOUUI l'ap ~unl'aplQd l'ap S'BM 'Ul'aplOJnzu1'a z+nq;)ss+q;)'a'H ~unpUlJlg 'aU1'a Jn'B '+1'a}{q;)1I~QW 'a1P l'aqn U'a+1'aql'aq;)1SUfl nz ~yn~IS~U'BMZ S'a +mmo}{ U'a~uru'a1InmlOd l'aS1Z~ld ~1U'aM run u'amq-eusny UOA Iq'BZ 'agOl~ 'au1'a q;)ma .u'an'a+snz+s'aJ l'aMq;)S l'aqS1q +S1 S1X81ds+q;)'a'H 'a1P Jn'B 'HdH l'ap gnyu1g l'apU'al~I}{ u1g

'+'aU.IJQ1'a Ioodu'aO l'ap 'a1P 'uu'B}{ u'ammo}{

u'a~unpu'aMuy l'aq;)1Iz+nu n'a1+u'a+od {q'BZI'a1A l'ap ~unI}{;)1M+ug mz S'a +1ureP 'U'aq;)1I~Qml'a SU'aSS1Mu'a~'BlpuruO m'aq;)S1+'aU'a~ nz ~U'B~nz u'aPU'aq;>1'al+1'aM ~1+1'azq;)1'aI~ l'aq'B u'auq1 'a1P 'u'al'a1+U'Bl'B~ u'a~unpulJlg 'aq;)S1uq;)'a+u'a~ Jn'B z+nq;)ss+q;)'a'H S+1'aSl'au1'a u'auq1 'a1P 'U'aY11q;)S -loA 'a~1+n'apu1'a u'a~unI1'a+q'Bs~unI}{;)1M+ug run -~unq;)slod u'aq;)n'Blq 'u'auuQ}{ nz u'az+nu run Ul'aplQJ +u'a1zYJ'a 'Bdomg U1 }{1uq;)'a+u'aO SlO+}{'aSS+]'eq;)S+11M s'ap u'a;)U'BqO 'a1P mfl

gnIQ;>S

.U'apl'aM +q;)1'an'a +J{u~lq;)s'a~u1'a lq'aS mu l'aq-ep Y11q;)SlOAS+q;)'a'H l'as'a1P +1m uu'B}{

- 'a1~oIouq;)'a+O1H l'ap ~uru'aplQJSUO1+1+S'aAuI - I'a1Z 'a+l'a1InmloJ S~U'B~u1'a 'HdH l'ap u1 S'Ba .u'ammOU'a~lOA +q;)1U U'apl'aM u'aq'BqloA-3+d run U'alOp'aA flW)ll'ap s1'aDIu'a+'BSS'alPy u'apu'ap1'aq;)s+u'a u'ap ~J +1m'Bp +q'a~ sm'a+sf..s+u'a+'Bd s'ap ~un}{11MZ1'alUY 'aq;)s1mouo}{Q 'a1a .u'a~'BIPuru~s+q;)'a1:I u'apu'aq'a~g'Bm l'ap u'auo1+1UlJ'aa l'a+]'equ'a}{;)nI run l'an'BU'a~un S1Uq'a~lg

S'Bp - 'a+.'a'1'az uo1+'B+u'amn~lY 'au'a~U'B~'a~U'elOA 'a1P 'a1M

- pu1s U'a+1'a}{~1+1'al+SS+q;)'al+U'a+'Bd

,C',",""cc"ll,i

(16)

f.'1

aNV'H eqJ, :Ul ~qtP~elq pU~ q+.'auel tuet~d l~mltdo :(0661) .0 'olld~qS ~"H 'tleqll0

'ueq;)ul}W 'f.' 10A 'setlU'gtuet~d ueq;)s~dom3 sep eqlemeYllq;)s ~stm~tuet~d ueq;)Sl~dom3 sep ~~lynv ml tuetSle ~unqeq13 eAlt~t -ue~lde'H :~dom3 ul seZtnq;)stuet~d sep ~unZtnN :(t661) tlU'gtuet~d seq;)Sl~dom3

. L8t-99t 's '8661 '6t 'PH 'y~q;)sueseo run t.:req;)StllM. UOA ~unuplO alP 1l}1 q;)nqlq~r 'OO'HO :ul ~ue~unllet.IneH run uemt:reug~w :fl3lep pun sPu~lq;)stnea )}ltllode~olouq;)eJ, run -s~unq;)slod ela :(8661) 'N '10q)};)l3

"f.'f.'I-LOl 's '06611esSB)l 'mlolul- -1M.A ~tseM. run iSO ul u~UOlt'eAOUUI :tleqlV run )}luq;)eJ, 'y~q;)SUesslM. :('~SlH) '0 "H 'le~UlZtnN ~.d 'le~ull)l ~'3 .H 'lJIZt~m~lD :ul

~q;)lel~leAmetSAS ml tq;)eltuet~d run Uolt~tlmI 'UOlt~AouuI :(0661) .d 'esleM. ~'J, 'le~3

.66~-LL~ 's 'OOO~ '19 'PH 'y~q;)sueseo run t.:req;)StllM. UOA ~unuplO alP 1l}1 q;)nqlq~r 'OO'HO :ul ~lepURM. leq;)Sl~olouq;)et leue~opue run mntsq'J13M. :(OOO~) .H'W 'uuna

'9t8-L~8 's '6661 tsn~nv 'g .0N 'LI 10A 'UOlt~ZlUR~lO l~lltsnpuI 10 l~umor reUOlt~UletuI :ul ~;)ltSBq;)OtS

Sl UOlt~AOuul 10 ~ulmlt eqt ueqM. tuet~d ~ 10 ell1 remltdo eqJ, : (6661)

. A 'ol°;)lUea

.L9-tf.' 's '9661 ~UlldS '1 .0N 'g~ 10A 's;)lmouo;)31° l~umor aNV'H eqJ, :ul ~UOlt~AOuul eAlt~lnmn;) pUR 'A;)l10d tsnltltUR 'edo;)s tuet~d :(9661) . d .H '~u~qO

'6661 ueq;)ul}W '~~lleA ~ulsselH 1l~)l

~tlepu~leA ue)}uea lesun )}luq;)etueD alP e!M. 'eueD lep leuUR1AJ, ela : (6661) 'M. 'suetl~H .In '.Jt?I8 '.J! 'I

.PllM.

ueqe~mn 03/tt/86 elulltq;)n:! lep Uetle)}q;)ll~~lnzufl uepUepleM. leq;)lltq;)lsuelJo lern

-ml uep t!m )}ltll°d alP alM. 'uet.rgM.nzq~ tqlelq se run uesSBl Uetl~M. q;)lS ln~ tlez e~lule

(17)

vI

~u!ldS '1 .0N 'LZ; loA 's;)!mouo;)3 Jo fb'ulnof GNVH etI.L :U! ~SUO!~'BAOUU! Jo uo!snJ -J!P etI~ PU'B u~!sep ~ue~'Bd l'Bm!~do :(9661) .)! '~~eJ{;)°'H ~.d 'n'Beq!~e'H ~.D 'se~n~'BW

.0Z;6-916 's '8661 'Z;1 ':ijeH '.~f .vv 'tJ'etI;)S~l!M uefb'u -o!~'BUle~U! lep ~tI;)e'H :U! ~ue~unpuY13 letI;)s!~oloutI;)e~o!q z~ntI;)S uetI;)!I~tI;)el uep leq~

e!u!l~tI;)rn etI;)S!~dOlne e!p 'e~oloutI;)e~o!g ~J z~ntI;)s~ue~'Bd :(8661) .0 'uuemle~~n1

. (mo'H GO) 'B;)!~!10d 'B!mouo;)3 eG 'BU!~Ue~lY UO!;)'B!;)osy ~'B!U!~Ue~lY 'sel -!Y soueng '6661 'LZ;-E~ ~sn~ny 'UO!~'B!;)ossy ;)!mouo;)3 fb'uo!~'Bule~uI etI.L JO sse~uoD PpoM tI':ijIeM.L etI.L :U! ~UO!~'B~!~!1 Jo ~'BeltI.L etI~ lepun u~!seG ~ue~'Bd :(6661) .0 '~eqol1

.EEE-61E 's 'v661 'gZ; loA 'S;)!l:UOUO;)3 Jo fb'ulnof GNVH :U! ~S!SAfb'ue 1'B;)!l!dme U'B :edo;)s ~ue~'Bd Jo e;)ue~lodm! etI.L :(v661) .f 'leule1

.0EI-Ell 's '0661 ~u!ldS '1 .0N '1Z; loA 's;)!mouo;)3 Jo l'BUlnof GNVH etI.L :U! ~2.eq uo!~;)e~old ~ue~'Bd Jo edo;)s etI~ Pln°tIs p'BOlq MoH :(0661) .d 'leledmel)!

.Z;Z;I-gll 's '8661 'z; .1N '.~f .lg 'ue~unl!e~~!w ISM :U! ~e!~ol°Ut{;)e~o!g run -neo lep ueA!~J{edsled uetI;)!ItJ'etI;)Snese~ run uetI;)!I':ij'BtI;)S -~l!M uep nz 2.~~~!I'Be'H lepo UO!~J{!d :J{!utI;)e~ueo lep U! epueMpuelJ, :(8661) 'w 'lad!)!

.uetI;)u~w 'J{;)eg .H .0 ~'BpeA ~~tI;)els':ij'BtI;)S~l!M setI;)s!~dom3 :(9661) .M 'U'B!I!)!

.Z;91-9g1 's '8661 'g ':ijeH '.~f .6 '~tI;)ellene~s ~ -s':ij'BtI;)S~l!M setI;)S!~dOln3 :U! ~uezu'B~sqns letI;)s~O1o!q ~urue!~ue~'Bd lep emeIqold etI;)s!tI~e run etI;)!I~tI;)el - ue~

-unpuY13 letI;)s!~O1outI;)e~o!q z~ntI;)S mnz e!u!l~tI;)rn-n3 ellen e!G :(8661) ..L 'eIue!)!

.0Z;-6 's '6861 'z;z; ':ijeH '.~f .Z;v '~sue!pneUt{;)S-OdI :U! ~tI;)!eleq9nIJu!3 uetI;)!I~'B'B~S m! uess!ummetI -SUo!~!~seAuI UOA n'Bqqy - e~O1outI;)e~o!g :(6861) .0 'leuse!M ~.1 'zl°tI;)S ~.G.H '1l'B)!

.Z;11-901 's '0661 ~u!ldS '1 .0N '1Z; loA 's;)!mouo;)3 Jo fb'ulnof

(18)

91

.698-098 'S '0661 laqma~das 'v .0N '08 loA 'Ma!Aa'H

;>!mouo;>a u~;>!lamv aqJ., :U! ~s~ua~~d ~;>npold 10 s;>!mou°:>3: aqJ., :(0661) 'W 'uosla~~M

'vl-L 's '8661 '8 'lN '.~r .f.'g '~!~!IOd areUO!~~ula~uI :U! ~a;>u~q;>s~un~nz areUO!~~Ula~

-U! sre sa;>ua!;>s a1!1 'a!~OIouq;>a~O!g pun -uao a!l~snpu!smn~sq;>~M :(8661) .0 '~~!A

'100'l 'W"~ ~m1~u~ld 'q;>ng q;>!alaqs~~IlaA Z.v. d ~~~q;>S~l!M~~l'eW a~!q'!'!1s~un~nz au!a lill ~!~!Iods~unuplO :(100'l) .0 '~q;>aIq;>s

'9v'l-f,'f."l 's 'L861 'g loA 'UO!~~Z!U~~lO re!l~snpuI 10 reUlnOr reUO!~~U -la~uI :U! ~A~u~~la;>ufl lapun mlaJ., ~ua~~d I~m!~do aqJ., :(L861) .W 'u~m~zznby~'H

.191-6vl 's '8661 'f.'1 loA 'I~ulnor M~1 ~oIouq;>aJ., AaIa~lag :U! ~'oO puv AII!1 !Ia 'A ~!Ul01!reO 10 A~!SlaA!ufl 7"l ~S!PlON OAoN .A .;>uI 'q;>a~uauao :(8661) .W 'la!lli!Id

"000'l u!pag '~~paA-mo;>o!g '.~r 'gI '100'l q;>nqgalpv pun -lq~r StJa - a!~oIouq;>aJ.,o!g :.A.o

'6661 laqmazaa .O'l 'uaq;>unw 'sa~m~~ua~~d uaq;>~dolna gap 66/ L ~unI!a~~!maSSald ~S!~l~AON II~d m! 6661"lI'O'l mOA s~m~~ua~~d uaq;>srudoma gap lammm{aplaMq;>sag uagolO lap ~unp!aq;>s~ua lap ~un~napag :. A '0

"100'l uaq;>unw '~lnoquapIO ~a~~1Jnv '9 '~!~!Iods~q;>s~l!M :(100'l) .g 'lO~!IOW

'f.'8-o9 's '9661

CC~~=

Referenzen

ÄHNLICHE DOKUMENTE

Simply imposing a new set of formal laws and institutions without understanding how the customary traditional system works, as has largely been the case in Liberia, may not work:

and ‘interpret’. Inflected forms such as ‘nimmt’ from ‘nehmen’ and ‘geschwommen’ from ‘schwimmen’ are always a problem for dictionary makers. The most common

transport policy guided by social and environnental concern. The raPid groeth of transport infraetructure in Japan has contributed to th6 iEbalances in ragionel

Suggested citation: Global Center on Cooperative Security, Human Security Collective and International Centre for Counter-Terrorism – The Hague, “Addressing the Foreign

Professor Adam Cygan, University of Leicester, in written evidence to the Lords Inquiry on the Role of National Parliaments in the EU, thought that “unlike national

Consequently, the chapters of this thesis are arranged into a conceptual part (Chapters 1 and 2) and an empirical part (Chapters 3 and 4). In Chapter 1, I develop a

Formal responsibility for the industry rests with the Ministry of Tourism and Civil Aviation (MTCA) and the Maldives Tourism Promotion Board (MTPB) and the government also has a

According to German law, smaller companies with 500-2000 employees and certain legal forms have to have one-third employee representatives on their supervisory