• Keine Ergebnisse gefunden

Etablierung und Anwendung einer durchflusszytometrischen Methode für die Vitalitätsbestimmung von P. aeruginosa, B. cepacia und S. aureus in Mischkulturen

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Aktie "Etablierung und Anwendung einer durchflusszytometrischen Methode für die Vitalitätsbestimmung von P. aeruginosa, B. cepacia und S. aureus in Mischkulturen"

Copied!
182
0
0

Wird geladen.... (Jetzt Volltext ansehen)

Volltext

(1)

!

!

!

"#$%&'()*+,!*+-!.+/(+-*+,!('+()!-*)012&*3345#67(#)'301(+!

8(#16-(!29)!-'(!:'#$&'#;#3%(3#'77*+,!<6+!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!"#$%&'()*+,$=!-"#.%/$.)$!*+-!0"#$'&%',!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

'+!8'301>*&#*)(+!

!

?'33()#$#'6+!

"#$!%$&'()#()!*+,!'-'*+./,01+(!2$'*+,!

!

?6>#6)'+,(+'(*)!

@?)ABC+,AD!

!

34(!5/6&789()7!:'$0!;<)+$!

)+=7!'.>!?@7A@7BCD?!/(!:'$/+(=+$)!E%$F)+=/$)+G!

!

)+(+1./)H!*#$01!*/+!I'-#&HJH!K<$!L+$K'1$+(,8!#(*!MN,H+.H+01(/-!

*+$!OHH4834(82#+$/0-+8P(/3+$,/HJH!:')*+=#$)!

!

Q$4.4H/4(,-4../,,/4(>!!

Q5!5$7!R34((+!2+(F+&!EL4$,/HFG!

!

Q$4K7!5$789()7!P*4!;+/01&!E2#H'01H+$G!

!

Q$4K7!5$7!M#,'((!:<&&+$!E2#H'01H+$/(G!

!

Q$4K7!5$7!S1$/,H/'('!S4$*+,!E2#H'01H+$/(G!

!

+/()+$+/01H!'.>!B?7A@7?ABT!

Q$4.4H/4(,-4&&4U#/#.!'.>!?V7BA7?ABT!

!

(2)

9!

.%3#)$0#!

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

.7*2#3)2-)! '(*! 2$'.8,6+0/K/0! ,H'/(/()! 4K! 47* )$+#$"! #,/()! K&#4$+,0+(H&N! &'=+&+*!

'(H/=4*/+,! '(*! Z1+'H! )+$.! '))&#H/(/(! E^2_GW! $+,6+0H/3+&N7! I4$! 46H/.#.! ,H'/(/()! 04(*/H/4(,W!H1+!014/0+!4K!=#KK+$!4$!,4&#H/4(W!/(!Z1/01!='0H+$/'!'$+!,#,6+(*+*W!'(*!H1+! '66&/+*! '.4#(H! 4K! ,H'/(/()! $+')+(H! 4$! K&#4$+,0+(H&N804(`#)'H+*! 6$4H+/(! E'(H/=4*N! 4$! ^2_G! Z+$+! 0$#0/'&7! 5#+! H4! 3'$/'H/4(,! =+HZ++(! ,6+0/+,W! K4$! 3/'=/&/HN! *+H+$./('H/4(! /(! ./[+*! 0#&H#$+W! ,H'/(/()! 04(*/H/4(,! Z+$+! *+K/(+*! ',! '! 04.6$4./,+! =+HZ++(! 46H/.#.! 04(*/H/4(,!*+H+$./(+*!=+K4$+!/(!6#$+!0#&H#$+!H+,H/()7!!

I/('&&NW! K4$! ,'.6&+! 6$+6'$'H/4(! '(*! ,H'/(/()W! ;/()+$! ,4&#H/4(! Z/H1! '**/H/4(! 4K! )&#H'$'&*+1N*+W! 64H',,/#.! 01&4$/*+! '(*! =43/(+! ,+$#.! '&=#./(W! '(*! '! MR];! 2$++(! 9! */&#H/4(!4K!V![!BAa!'(*!'!Q9!04(0+(H$'H/4(!4K!V!b)!.Y8B!Z+$+!'66&/+*7!X1+,+!04(*/H/4(,! '&&4Z+*! K4$! +KK/0/+(H! ,6+0/+,! */,0$/./('H/4(! #,/()! /..#(4K&#4$+,0+(0+! 4K! .7* 2#3)2-)! '(*! 2$'.8,6+0/K/0! &'=+&/()! 4K! 47* )$+#$"W! '(*! ,#=,+U#+(H&N! K4$! 6$46+$! *+H+0H/4(! 4K! 3/'=&+!'(*!*+'*!='0H+$/'7!!

(3)

99! ]N!'66&N/()!H1+!+,H'=&/,1+*!K4#$804&4#$!.+H14*W!3/'=/&/HN!4K!!7*)#+$,-(&")W!.7*2#3)2-)! '(*!47*)$+#$"*Z',!*+H+$./(+*!/(!.4*+&8./[+*!0#&H#$+,!*#$/()!a?!1!4K!0#&H/3'H/4(7!X1+! ./[+*! 0#&H#$+,! 04.6$/,+*! HZ4! 4$! H1$++! ,6+0/+,7! 9(! 6'$'&&+&! Z/H1! K&4Z! 0NH4.+H$/0! '('&N,+,W!UX8;IYQ!'('&N,+,!Z+$+!6+$K4$.+*!K4$!*+H+$./('H/4(!4K!,6+0/+,8,6+0/K/0!0+&&! 04(0+(H$'H/4(,7!! S4.6'$/,4(!=+HZ++(!6#$+!'(*!./[+*!0#&H#$+!+[6+$/.+(H,!$+3+'&+*!0480#&H#$+!+KK+0H,! =',+*!4(!4=H'/(+*!*/KK+$+(0+,!K4$!+3+$N!,6+0/+,!/(!)$4ZH1!*N('./0,!'(*!K4$!47*)$+#$"! /(!3/'=/&/HN!*N('./0,7!M#=,H$'H+!04.6+H/H/4(!'(*!'(H')4(/,.!Z+$+!$+04)(/F+*!/(!./[+*! 0#&H#$+,! ',! H1+! .'`4$! $+',4(,! /(! 01'()/()! H1+! *N('./0,7! 9(! 6'$H/0#&'$W! /(! ./[+*! 0#&H#$+,! Z/H1! .7* 2#3)2-)W! !7*)#+$,-(&")! )$+Z! K',H+$! '(*! 43+$! +[H+(*+*! H/.+! 6+$/4*,! H1'(! /(! 6#$+! 0#&H#$+,7! I#$H1+$.4$+W! K4$! '&&! ./[+*! 0#&H#$+,W! )$4ZH1! '(*! 3/'=/&/HN! *'H'! ,#))+,H+*! '(! 4#H04.6+H/()! 4K! .7*2#3)2-)! '(*! 47*)$+#$"7! 2$4ZH1! 4K! .7*2#3)2-)! Z',! */$+0H&N! /(1/=/H+*! =N! !7*)#+$,-(&")W! Z1+$+',! 0+&&,! 4K! 47*)$+#$"! Z+$+! *'.')+*! =N!

!7*)#+$,-(&")W!Z1/01!$+,#&H+*!/(!&4,,!4K!.+.=$'(+!/(H+)$/HN!'(*!0+&&!&N,/,7!9(!6'$H/0#&'$W!

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

O3+$'&&! H1+! 4=H'/(+*! $+,#&H,! +.61',/F+*! 6$+*4./('(0+! 4K! !7*)#+$,-(&")* 43+$!

.7*2#3)2-)* '(** 47*)$+#$"* /(! ./[+*! 0#&H#$+,! #(*+$! H1+! '66&/+*! 04(*/H/4(,W! *#+!

H4!+KK/0/+(H! ,#=,H$'H+! 04(,#.6H/4(! '(*! +KK+0H/3+! '(H')4(/,H/0! '0H/4(! ')'/(,H! H1+! 4H1+$!HZ4!,6+0/+,7!

I4$! H1+! K/$,H! H/.+W! ',! 6$43/*+*! =N! H1+! (+Z! K&4Z! 0NH4.+H$/0! .+H14*W! H1+! 3/'=/&/HN! 4K!

!7*)#+$,-(&")8*.7*2#3)2-)*'(*!47*)$+#$"*Z',!',,+,,+*!*#$/()!0480#&H/3'H/4(!/(!./[+*!

0#&H#$+,7! _**/H/4('&&NW! Z/H1! H1+! 6$+,+(H+*! ,H#*NW! H1+! 64H+(H/'&! 4K! K&4Z! 0NH4.+H$N! K4$! ,6+0/+,8,6+0/K/0!0+&&!04#(H/()!/(!H1$++8,6+0/+,!./[+*!0#&H#$+,!1',!=++(!*+.4(,H$'H+*7! !

! !

(4)

999!

?$+>3$,*+,!!

:+/(!)'(F!=+,4(*+$+$!5'(-!)+1H!'(!Q$4K7!5$7!P*4!;+/01&W!*+$!./$!/(!:')*+=#$)!*/+! :c)&/01-+/H! )+=4H+(! 1'HW! #(H+$! 1+$34$$')+(*+(! ]+*/()#()+(! .+/(+! Z/,,+(8 ,01'KH&/01+(! _$=+/H+(! '.! Y+1$,H#1&! K<$! ]/46$4F+,,H+01(/-! '(! *+$! OHH4834(82#+$/0-+8 P(/3+$,/HJH!,4Z/+!'.!:'[8Q&'(0-89(,H/H#H!*#$01F#K<1$+(7!5'$<=+$!1/('#,!=+*'(-+!/01! ./01!=+/!/1.!K<$!*/+!'($+)+(*+(!K'01&/01+(!5/,-#,,/4(+(W!*/+!-4(,H$#-H/3+!d$/H/-!#(*! */+!I$+/$J#.+!=+/!*+$!2+,H'&H#()!.+/(+$!Q$4`+-H+7! Q$4K7! 5$7! S1$/,H/'('! S4$*+,! #(*! Q$4K7! 5$7! M#,'((! :<&&+$! *'(-+! /01! ,+1$! K<$! /1$! 9(H+$+,,+!'(!.+/(+$!_$=+/H!#(*!K<$!*/+!]+$+/H,01'KH!F#$!]+)#H'01H#()!*+$!5/,,+$H'H/4(7! %/(!)$4e+$!5'(-!)+1H!'(!S4$/('!M/+Z+$H!#(*!Y/'(+!2+/,&+$W!*/+!./01!/.!Y'=4$!=+/!*+$! L4$=+$+/H#()!#(*!5#$01K<1$#()!34(!%[6+$/.+(H+(!+[F+&&+(H!#(H+$,H<HFH+(7! 5+,!^+/H+$+(!*'(-+!/01!2+$'&*!]+(,01W!;'&K!X<()&+$!#(*!:'(*N!_0-+$.'((!3/+&.'&,! K<$!*/+!'#e+$4$*+(H&/01!)#H+!]+$+/H,01'KHW!:4H/3'H/4(!#(*!Y+/,H#()!=+/!*+$!]+'$=+/H#()! #(*!I+$H/),H+&&#()!/1$+$!_=,01&#,,'$=+/H+(7!!

I<$! */+! :c)&/01-+/H! *+$! f#HF#()! *+,! 5#$01K&#,,FNH4.+H+$,! '.! :'[8Q&'(0-89(,H/H#H! *'(-+!/01!5$7!d'H`'!]+HH+(=$40-!#(*!_(*$+'!I40-+7!

9(,=+,4(*+$+! =+*'(-+! /01! ./01! =+/! .+/(+(! d4&&+)+(! #(*! I$+#(*+(! ]`c$(! \+N(/,01W! ;4=+$H! g'(-+W! M#,'((! I$+#(*! #(*! g'('! ;c*/)! K<$! */+! +$K$/,01+(*+(! 2+,6$J01+W! */+! h4KK+(+(!O1$+(iW!*',!I++*='0-!#(*!*/+!Z/HF/)+(!:4.+(H+7!!

:+/(! 5'(-! )+1H! '#01! '(! I+&/0/H',! \',+Z/(-+&W! S&'#*/'! ]+,HW! f'(0N! ^N(,+$,-/! #(*! ;#['(*$'!;+1(+$!K<$!/1$+!P(H+$,H<HF#()!/.!Y'=4$'&&H')7! 5'$<=+$! 1/('#,! =+*'(-+! /01! ./01! =+/! X14.',! :#(*W! _((+)$+H! I$'#+(*/+(,H! #(*! M#,'((!]+1&/()!K<$!/1$+!\/&K+!=+/!*+$!]+ZJ&H/)#()!'*./(/,H$'H/3+$!_#K)'=+(W!,4Z/+!=+/! ;4=+$H! ;+1(+$W! 2+$*! M01'01H,01(+/*+$! #(*! %/)=+$H! ;/+Z'&*! K<$! */+! ,01(+&&+! #(*! #(-4.6&/F/+$H+!\/&K+!=+/!9X8I$')+,H+&&#()+(7!! 5+,! ^+/H+$+(! =+*'(-+! /01! ./01! =+/! '&&+(! ^+))+KJ1$H+(! *+,! Y+1$,H#1&,! #(*! *+$! I'01)$#66+!]/46$4F+,,H+01(/-!K<$!*/+!'()+(+1.+!"+/H7!!!

%/(! )$4e+$! 5'(-! )+1H! '(! .+/(+! )+,'.H+! I'./&/+W! /(,=+,4(*+$+! '(! _((+&/+! ;<)+$W! ;/H'!;c*/)W!X14.',!;c*/)W!d&'#,!I/+=+&-4$(!#(*!S'$4&'!M01'01H+=+0-7!!

"#! )#H+$! Y+HFH! *'(-+! /01! g'('W! *+$! 5'.+! .+/(+,! \+$F+(,W! K<$! */+! ,H+H+! .+(H'&+! P(H+$,H<HF#()W! K<$! /1$! )$4e+,! L+$,HJ(*(/,! #(*! */+! F+/H&/01+(! I$+/$J#.+! =+/! *+$! I+$H/),H+&&#()!.+/(+$!5/,,+$H'H/4(7!!!

(5)
(6)

!"

!"#$%&'()*+),-#",'.

#$%&'()&"************************************************************************************************************************"+! ,(-.%(/0-/"***************************************************************************************************************"+++! 1'.23'0-/"405"%62$%&%&3-78/6-"#'$68&6-"********************************************************************"+!! +-9(2&%:6'468)9-8%"********************************************************************************************************"!! #$.;'40-/%<"0-7"=>5$?2:6'468)9-8%"***********************************************************************"!+++! @*! 18-268&0-/"0-7"A?&8:(&8?-"76'"#'$68&"*******************************************************************"@! B*! C96?'6&8%)96"D'0-72(/6-"***********************************************************************************"E! B*@*! F(.&6'86226"A8%)9/6568-%)9(G&6-"***********************************************************************"E! B*@*@*!H0-/6-8-G6.&8?-6-":?-"I(&86-&6-"58&"A0.?:8%487?%6"***********************************"E! B*@*B*!!"#$%&'&()"")#*$+,(&")"****************************************************************************"J! B*@*K*!-$*./&0%#*,)"1#2)1,)"************************************************************************************"L! B*@*M*!34)2/50&1&11$"")$*#$""********************************************************************************"N! B*@*E*!F6%?-76'968&6-"85"A6&($?28%50%":?-"!67)#*$+,(&")"0-7"-671#2)1,)"********"@@! B*@*O*!A?7622<A8%)9.02&0'6-"G;'"%>%&65(&8%)96"P-&6'%0)90-/6-"*************************"@B! B*B*! ,0')9G20%%4>&?56&'8%)96"#-(2>%6":?-"F(.&6'86-"**********************************************"@K! B*B*@*!#22/6568-6%"I'8-48Q"76'",0')9G20%%4>&?56&'86"*******************************************"@K! B*B*B*!#0G468)9-0-/R",('%&6220-/"0-7"1:(2086'0-/"76'",(&6-"******************************"@L! B*B*K*!,6&6.&8?-":?-"F(.&6'86-"58&&62%"S20?'6%46-45('.86'0-/"***************************"BM! B*B*K*@*!+-&'(4622023'6"S20?'6%46-45('.86'0-/6-"********************************************"BO! B*B*K*B*!1T&'(4622023'6"S20?'6%46-45('.86'0-/6-"*******************************************"BN! B*B*M*!S20?'6%46-4$(%86'&6"!8&(28&3&%(-(2>%6":?-"F(.&6'86-"*********************************"KB! B*B*M*@*!U62)96"4622023'6-"!?'/3-/6"$6%&8556-"786"!8&(28&3&V""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" WU(--"8%&"68-"F(.&6'805"&?&VX"*************************************************************"KB! B*B*M*B*!S20?'6%46-4G3'$656&9?76-"40'"!8&(28&3&%$6%&8550-/"***********************"KK! B*B*M*K*!F6%&8550-/"76'"!8&(28&3&"8-"A8%)9.02&0'6-"*****************************************"KE! K*! A(&6'8(2"0-7"A6&9?76-"*************************************************************************************"KJ! K*@*! Y6'%&6220-/":?-"HZ%0-/6-R"I0GG6'"0-7"A6786-"*************************************************"KJ! K*@*@*!#'$68&%2Z%0-/6-"0-7"I0GG6'"************************************************************************"KJ! K*@*B*!A6786-"********************************************************************************************************"M@!

(7)

!+" K*@*K*!S('$%&?GG2Z%0-/6-"G;'"786"S20?'6%46-45('.86'0-/"*************************************"MB! K*@*M*!U6846-.685(//20&8-8-"G;'"786"S20?'6%46-45('.86'0-/"*******************************"MB! K*@*E*!#-&8.Z'Q6'"G;'"786"+550-G20?'6%46-45('.86'0-/"****************************************"MK! K*B*! F(.&6'86-%&3556"**********************************************************************************************"ME! K*K*! [02&8:86'0-/":?-"F(.&6'86-"********************************************************************************"ME! K*K*@*![02&8:86'0-/"(0G"#/('Q2(&&6-"***********************************************************************"ME! K*K*B*![02&8:86'0-/"8-"=)9;&&62.?2$6-"********************************************************************"MO! K*K*K*![02&8:86'0-/":?-"8)'250&9)14#*7:#:$(,"G;'"\C<]SHI"***********************************"ML! K*M*! ,0')9G20%%4>&?56&'8%)96"#-(2>%6"*********************************************************************"MN! K*M*@*!A6%%Q'?4670'"*********************************************************************************************"E^! K*M*B*!I'?$6-$69(-720-/"0-7"S3'$0-/"****************************************************************"EE! K*M*K*!1:(2086'0-/"70')9G20%%4>&?56&'8%)96'",(&6-"*********************************************"EL! K*E*! U68&6'6"(-(2>&8%)96"A6&9?76-"**************************************************************************"O^! K*E*@*!_Q&8%)96",8)9&6"58&&62%"=Q6.&'?Q9?&?56&'86"**********************************************"O^! K*E*B*!=Q6486%<%Q648G8%)96"[?-46-&'(&8?-"58&&62%"\C<]SHI<#-(2>%6"********************"O^! K*E*K*!H6$6-74622.?-46-&'(&8?-"58&&62%"I2(&&6-(0%%&'8)9"***************************************"OB! K*E*M*!F6%&8550-/":?-"=0$%&'(&<"0-7"A6&($?28&.?-46-&'(&8?-6-"*************************"OK! K*O*! S20?'6%46-458.'?%.?Q86":?-"F(.&6'86-"************************************************************"OM! K*O*@*!#0G-(956-"58&"765"H(%6'<=)(--8-/<A8.'?%.?Q"H=A"E@^"************************"OE! K*O*B*!#0G-(956-"58&"765"S20?'6%46-458.'?%.?Q"#T8?:6'&"@KE"*************************"OO! K*J*! =&(&8%&8%)96"I';G:6'G(9'6-"*********************************************************************************"OJ! K*J*@*!S<&6%&"40'"`$6'Q';G0-/"76'"Y?5?/6-8&3&"76'"!('8(-46-"****************************"OJ! K*J*B*!&<C6%&"405"!6'/268)9":?-"A8&&62a6'&6-"*******************************************************"OL! K*L*! b9658.(286-28%&6"************************************************************************************************"ON! K*N*! D6'3&6<"0-7"A(&6'8(286-28%&6"******************************************************************************"J@! M*! 1'/6$-8%%6"********************************************************************************************************"JK! M*@*! 1&($286'0-/"70')9G20%%4>&?56&'8%)96'"A6&9?76-"**********************************************"JK! M*@*@*!+550-G20?'6%46-4"40'"=Q6486%<%Q648G8%)96-",6&6.&8?-"*****************************"JO! M*@*B*!UD#"40'"D'(5<%Q648G8%)96-",6&6.&8?-":?-"367)$*#$""*******************************"L@! M*@*K*!A6&9?76"40'"F6%&8550-/"76'"!8&(28&3&"********************************************************"LE!

(8)

VII

4.1.3.1.Optimierung der Vitalitätsfärbung für einzelne Spezies ... 86

4.1.3.2.Etablierung einer einheitlichen Färbemethode für die Vitalitätsbestimmung in Mischkulturen ... 94

4.1.4. Sind Bakterien mit intakter Membran vermehrungsfähig? ... 100

4.1.5. Spezies-spezifische Vitalitätsbestimmung in Mischkulturen ... 101

4.2. Vitalität und Wachstum in Rein- und Mischkulturen ... 104

4.2.1. Drei-Spezies-Mischkultur ... 104

4.2.2. Zwei-Spezies-Mischkulturen ... 109

4.2.3. Wachstumsanalyse mittels quantitativer DZM ... 118

5. Diskussion ... 122

5.1. Methode zur Vitalitätsbestimmung in Mischkulturen ... 122

5.1.1. Spezies-spezifische Detektion für die Mischkulturanalyse ... 123

5.1.2. Anpassung der Vitalitätsfärbebedingungen an die Spezies ... 125

5.1.3. Vierfarbenprotokoll für die Spezies-spezifische Bestimmung ... 129

5.2. Effekte der Mischkultivierung auf die Vitalität und das Wachstum von P. aeruginosa, B. cepacia und S. aureus ... 132

6. Zusammenfassung ... 139 7. Ausblick ... 141 Literaturverzeichnis ... 143 Abbildungsverzeichnis ... 158 Tabellenverzeichnis ... 160 Anhang ... i

A1 Eigene Publikationen und sonstige Beiträge ... ii

(9)

!"""#

!"#$%&'()*+,'(-,./0"1234%&4567(5*,

# $%&'()*+,# -.)./01+*+,# 23456# 234.78353,9*08+:7# $%%;# $%%/9<*+,# $0.7=93>8$# $0.7=93>8.+)=?#$# $@5# $+:98,3)*35/,/7:9# $ABC# D3$0=93A8?8C.(/+3B:078+.# $9:# $9:+/+# $4# $+7/&E(F.(# $3G# $<.+/+3G1=?/+# $GH# $<.+8C/+7(/F18CF1:7# $G>># $?.(/&:+/C01.#I/&(88(,:+/C?.+34*97*(C:??9*+,!J.+,9;! "#$%&'()!*+,$!-./0.%$!-1//$'0&1)K!! -00# 2.%341/5$%&(3'$,('&(348?F9.L## -H# -:+<F:CC# -F# -:C.+F::(# -M3N# -:+<.(:.:#J6(/OO8+/:K#C/?F9/0/O89/:!B.&7/+#N# -M$# P/+<.(:9%*?/+!J.+,9;!617&)$!8$%.#!(/6.#&)K!!

0$IH# 0=09/C01.C# $<.+8C/+?8+8F18CF1:7# J.+,9;# '+'/&'! (5$)18&)!

#1)1,418,4(0$K# >Q# I*&8R/C)/<8C.#J.+,9;#'+80&'!9&6%18&8K# >Q5$# >:(%8L=O9*8(.C)./+</:).7:7! >QGP# P.,*9:78(#<.(#G(:+C?.?%(:+3B./7OS1/,&./7#%./#>Q!J.+,9;#'+80&'!9&6%18&8!0%()8#$#6%()$!'1)5.'0()'$!%$:./(01%K# >1# 4:+:9#J.+,9;!'4())$/K! >15# 5*(019/017&:+:9#JA.99O.9<K#

>A"># -/9<R.(,9./01#<.(#)=78?.7(/C01.+#A/C78,(:??.#J.+,9;#-+01#$0%&'!;&801:%(#!<#(:$!-1#,(%&81)K#

>8$# >8.+)=?#$#

>8+#$# >8+0:+:R:9/+#$#

>!# !:(/:7/8+C&8.OO/)/.+7#J.+,9;!'1$99&'&$)0!19!7(%&(0&1)K!

5$H"# TUVW35/:?/</+323H1.+=9/+<89#

(10)

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

(11)

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`# (.9:7/R.#Q9*8(.C).+)./+1./7.+#J.+,9;#%$/(0&7$!9/.1%$8'$)'$! .)&08K## PDM# P/%8+*&9./+CS*(.# (PDM# (/%8C8?:9.#P/%8+*&9./+CS*(.#

P/+,.(9EC*+,#-a8F7# N@T#P/+,.(9EC*+,#?/7#bVbc#?,#?BbVbc#d#-M$# 3N#6G$V#X#I#4>9#*+<#

P3H[# P3H1=08.(/71(/+#

PG# P:*?7.?F.(:7*(#

M$4# M.&*+<S(:+7/&E(F.(#

MH# 4*()F:CC#J.+,9;!841%0!,(88K#

(12)

Y"# # # MM># M./7C7(.*9/017#J.+,9;#8&5$!8'(00$%#/&:40K! G:%;# G:%.99.# GH[# !GP"M3H18CF1:73[5G$#H*OO.(# GP"M# G(/CJ1=<(8L=?.71=9K3:?/+8?.71:+! G3PQBH# G.(?/+:9.(#P.C7(/&7/8+CO(:,?.+79S+,.+F89=?8(F1/C?*C# PG# P:*?7.?F.(:7*(# `[$3N# B/$A!$.%1,$(.8!B.&7/+#"# `!# `97(:R/89.7# !Z4# R/7:9.#Z.99&8+).+7(:7/8+# e6$# e./).+&./?:,,9*7/+/+#J.+,9;#>4$(0!:$%#!(::/.0&)&)K##

eA_# e.97,.C*+<1./7C8(,:+/C:7/8+!J.+,9;!C1%/5!;$(/04!D%:()&E(0&1)K!#

(13)

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d# Q# Q3e.(7#O'(#Q3G.C7# 3# O# Q(./1./7C,(:<#O'(#C7:7/C7/C01.#H('OR.(O:1(.+# 3# O/# H>P3[OO/)/.+)F:(:?.7.(#O'(#MF.)/.C#/############J]G3PQBH3$+:9=C.K### 3# O"^M# H>P3[OO/)/.+)F:(:?.7.(#O'(#"^M##############J]G3PQBH3$+:9=C.K#### 3# IQ"# ?/779.(.#Q9*8(.C).+)/+7.+C/7S7#J.+,9;##$()! 9/.1%$8'$)'$!&)0$)8&0+K# PQ`# D5$H"f# $+):19#5$H"3O9*8(.C)/.(.+<.(#[(./,+/CC.## 3# D"^M# <.O/+/.(7.#:%C89*7.#Z.99):19#"^M#####################J]G3PQBH3$+:9=C.K# 3# DMg-P# $+):19#Mg-P#6(..+#"3O9*8(.C)/.(.+<.(#[(./,+/CC.# 3# DG3PQBHV#/# :%C89*7.#Z.99):19#<.(#MF.)/.C#/#%.C7/??7#?/77.9C#]G3PQBH3$+:9=C.# ,.# _5# 8F7/C01.#5/017.## 3# _5Wcb# 8F7/C01.#5/017.#%./#Wcb#+?# 3# _5Wbb# 8F7/C01.#5/017.#%./#Wbb#+?# 3#

_5WcbV(.OV/# P.O.(.+)#_5"+8&*9:7/8+#<.(#A:*F7&*97*(#Wcb#./+.(#MF.)/.C#/#O'(# 3#

_5WcbV!4V/# ,.?.CC.+.#_54*97/R/.(*+,# Wcb#<.(#!8(&*97*(#+:01#NVc#1# 3#

H# B./C7*+,# e#

(14)

Y"""# F"^M# $+):19#6.+&8F/.+#/?#6.+8?#R8+#-=!F$F.)&# 3# P2# -.C7/??71./7C?:h#./+.(#P.,(.CC/8+# 3# C5# M7:+<:(<:%\./01*+,# # 0 5V

C

# M7:+<:(<:%\./01*+,#<.(#.(O:CC7.+# M/,+:9/+7.+C/7S7.+#/?#I.CC&:+:9#0# PQ`# 2 5 C # !:(/:+)### # 7# Z./7# 1# 7H# H('O,(Eh.#O'(#73G.C7## 3# !# Q9'CC/,&./7CR89*?.+## ?B# !$+:9=C.# ZS19:+:9=C.R89*?.+# ?B# !4*97*(## Q9'CC/,&./7C,.C:?7R89*?.+#<.(#4*97*(# ?B# !23I4V/# Q9'CC/,&./7CR89*?.+#<.(#i.\./9/,.+# MF.)/.C#/#)*(#"+8&*9:7/8+#/+#Z\./3MF.)/.C3 I/C01&*97*(# ?B# !X3I4V/# Q9'CC/,&./7CR89*?.+#<.(#i.\./9/,.+# MF.)/.C#/#)*(#"+8&*9:7/8+#/+#5(./3MF.)/.C3 I/C01&*97*(# ?B# !P4V/# Q9'CC/,&./7CR89*?.+#<.(#i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

(15)

Y"!# Y787V#<.O/+/.(7V#/# <.O/+/.(7.#(.9:7/R.#AS*O/,&./7#787.(#Z.99.+#<.(#MF.)/.C#/# 3# 0 ) # ?/779.(.#B/017/+7.+C/7S7#<.(#.(O:CC7.+#M/,+:9/+7.+C/7S7.+#/?#I.CC&:+:9#0# J,.8?.7(/C01.(#I/77.9\.(7K## PQ`#J%./# Q9*8(.C).+)K## )0V# B/017/+7.+C/7S7#./+.C#H:(7/&.9C#/?#I.CC&:+:9#0# PQ`#J%./#Q9*8(.C).+)K# # # 6(/.01/C01.C#M=?%89# -.)./01+*+,# [/+1./7## !# [L7/+&7/8+C&8.OO/)/.+7# B#?893N#0?3N# "# Q9*8(.C).+)]*:+7.+:*C%.*7.# 3# # #

(16)

N#

89,:5(245;'(),'(-,<1;53=;51(,-4%,!%"45;,

-:&7.(/.+# &8??.+# %./# ?/&(8%/.99.+# "+O.&7/8+.+# /?# I.+C01.+# 1S*O/,# /+# &8?F9.L.+# I/C01,.?./+C01:O7.+# /+# ./+.(# !/.9):19# R.(C01/.<.+.(# MF.)/.C# R8(;# Z\/C01.+# <.+# $(7.+# &E++.+# ./+C./7/,.# 8<.(# \.01C.9C./7/,.# -.)/.1*+,.+V# \/.# );-;# I*7*:9/C?*CV# $+7:,8+/C?*C# 8<.(# 48??.+C:9/C?*CV# %.C7.1.+# %)\;# C/01# :*C%/9<.+;# 5/.C.# %.C7/??.+# /+# .(1.%9/01.?# I:h.# </.# MF.)/.C3Z*C:??.+C.7)*+,# ./+.(# %:&7.(/.99.+# 6.?./+C01:O7#C8\/.#</.#)./79/01.#[+7\/0&9*+,#<.(#$+):19#<.(#"+</R/<*.+#./+.(#i.<.+# MF.)/.C;#Q89,9/01#&E++.+#</.#-.)/.1*+,.+#:*01#<.+#!.(9:*O#*+<#<.+#M01\.(.,(:<# ./+.(# F89=?/&(8%/.99.+# "+O.&7/8+# %../+O9*CC.+;# Q.(+.(# &E++.+# </.# "+7.(:&7/8+.+# )\/C01.+# <.+# MF.)/.C# <.(# I/C01,.?./+C01:O7# </.# e/(&C:?&./7# ./+,.C.7)7.(# $+7/%/87/&:# ,.,.+'%.(# 4(:+&1./7C.((.,.(+# /?# P:1?.+# <.(# ?.</)/+/C01.+# -.1:+<9*+,# %../+O9*CC.+;# Z*(# %.CC.(.+# $*O&9S(*+,# <.(# &8?F9.L.+# !8(,S+,.# /+# %:&7.(/.99.+# I/C01,.?./+C01:O7.+# /+# "+O.&7/8+.+# C/+<# C8?/7# </.# "<.+7/O/&:7/8+# <.(# MF.)/.C# *+<# </.# ^*:+7/O/)/.(*+,# :%C89*7.(# MF.)/.C3CF.)/O/C01.(# Z.99):19.+# /?# )./79/01.+# !.(9:*O# R8+# 181.?# "+7.(.CC.;# Z*<.?# /C7# </.# [(O:CC*+,# <.(# !/7:9/7S7# <.(# ./+).9+.+#MF.)/.CV#/+C%.C8+<.(.#)*(#`+7.(C*01*+,#<.(#e/(&C:?&./7#R8+#$+7/%/87/&:V# R8+# ,(8h.(# -.<.*7*+,;# 5/.# MF.)/.C3Z*C:??.+C.7)*+,# /+# I/C01,.?./+C01:O7.+# &:++# :+1:+<# <.(# $+:9=C.# <.C# G.(?/+:9.+# P.C7(/&7/8+CO(:,?.+79S+,.+3 H89=?8(F1/C?*C# JG3PQBHK# %.C7/??7# \.(<.+V# \/.# %.(./7C# /+# ):19(./01.+# R.(EOO.+79/017.+#M7*</.+#<:(,.9.,7#\8(<.+#/C7#JA*99:(#.7#:9;#2bbWj#4:7C/R.9:#.7#:9;#2bbcj# 49./+C7.*%.(#.7#:9;#2bbkj#B/*#.7#:9;#Nllmj#P8,.(C#.7#:9;#2bbXj#G1/.C#.7#:9;#2bbmK;#5/.# M7*</.# R8+# G(871:# $0! (/=#/C7# ./+.# <.(# \.+/,.+# M7*</.+V# </.# </.# G3PQBH# )*(# ^*:+7/O/)/.(*+,# :%C89*7.(# MF.)/.C3CF.)/O/C01.(# Z.99):19.+# ./+C.7)7.;# 5/.# [/+O'1(*+,# ./+.C# /+7.(+.+# ^*:+7/O/)/.(*+,CC7:+<:(<C# J"^MKV# ./+.C# NWM#(/%8C8?:9.+# P/%8+*&9./+CS*(.+3# J(PDMK# 6.+O(:,?.+7C# ./+.(# %.&:++7.+# -:&7.(/.+CF.)/.C# ?/7# ./+.(# <.O/+/.(7.+# Z.99):19V# .(9:*%7.# </.# ^*:+7/O/)/.(*+,# <.(# Z.99):19.+# JG(871:# .7# :9;# 2bb2K;#5/.C.#]*:+7/7:7/R.#G3PQBH#I.718<.#J]G3PQBHK#\*(<.#/+#<.(#5/CC.(7:7/8+#R8+# M01?/<7# O'(# </.# -.C7/??*+,# <.(# MF.)/.C3CF.)/O/C01.+# Z.99&8+).+7(:7/8+# /+# ./+.(# %:&7.(/.99.+# I8<.993I/C01,.?./+C01:O7V# %.C7.1.+<# :*C# <(./# O'(# B*+,.+/+O.&7/8+.+# R8+# I*&8R/C)/<8C.3H:7/.+7.+# (.9.R:+7.+# MF.)/.C# G8$.51#1)(8! ($%.:&)18(V#

2.%341/5$%&(! '$,('&(# *+<# @0(,4+/1'1''.8! (.%$.8V# :<:F7/.(7# *+<# R:9/</.(7# JM01?/<7#

2bbkj# M01?/<7# .7# :9;# 2bbmK;# I/71/9O.# </.C.(# I.718<.# \*(<.# <:C# e:01C7*?# <.(# ,.+:++7.+# MF.)/.C# /+# <.O/+/.(7.+# I/C01&*97*(.+# /+# >1.?8C7:734*97/R/.(*+,.+# /?#

(17)

2# -/8(.:&78(# 01:(:&7.(/C/.(7;# Z*<.?# \*(<.# R8+# M01?/<7# $0! (/=# ./+# ?:71.?:7/C01.C# I8<.99#O'(#<:C#e:01C7*?#/?#>1.?8C7:7#.+7\/0&.97V#\.901.C#/+#48?%/+:7/8+#?/7#<.+# e:01C7*?C<:7.+# </.# "<.+7/O/)/.(*+,# *+%.&:++7.(# "+7.(:&7/8+.+# )\/C01.+# <.+# MF.)/.C# .(?E,9/017.# JM01?/<7# .7# :9;# 2bNNK;# "+# ./+.(# \./7.(O'1(.+<.+# M7*</.# R8+# P/.<.9.# *+<# P./019# \*(<.# <:('%.(# 1/+:*C# </.# ]G3PQBH3I.718<.# )*(# `+7.(C*01*+,# <.(# e/(&C:?&./7# <.C# $+7/%/87/&*?C# >.O7:)/</?# :*O# <:C# e:01C7*?# <.(# O'(# B*+,.+/+O.&7/8+.+# R8+# I*&8R/C)/<8C.3H:7/.+7.+# (.9.R:+7.+# -:&7.(/.+CF.)/.C# /+# <.O/+/.(7.+# I/C01&*97*(.+# ./+,.C.7)7# JP/.<.9.# :+<# P./019# 2bNNK;# Z\:(# .(9:*%7# </.# ]G3PQBH# </.# ]*:+7/7:7/R.# -.C01(./%*+,# <.(# e:01C7*?C<=+:?/&# <.(# ./+).9+.+# MF.)/.C# /+# I/C01&*97*(.+V# i.<801# 9/.O.(7# </.C.# I.718<.# &./+.# !/7:9/7S7C<:7.+V# <:# </.# )*# ]*:+7/O/)/.(.+<.+# (PDM36.+O(:,?.+7.# :*C# <.(# ,.C:?7.+# Z.99F8F*9:7/8+# <.(# i.\./9/,.+#MF.)/.C#,.\8++.+#\.(<.+;#5/.#!/7:9/7S7#<.(#./+).9+.+#-:&7.(/.+CF.)/.C#/C7# i.<801# %./# <.(# `+7.(C*01*+,# <.(# e/(&C:?&./7# R8+# $+7/%/87/&:# R8+# .+7C01./<.+<.(# -.<.*7*+,V# /+C%.C8+<.(.# \.++# </.# Z.99C01S<.+# +/017# )*(# B=C.V# C8+<.(+# +*(# )*?# !.(9*C7# \.C.+79/01.(# ).99*9S(.(# Q*+&7/8+.+# O'1(.+V# \/.# );-;# <.(# I.?%(:+/+7.,(/7S7;# 5.(# [/+C:7)# <.(# ]G3PQBH3I.718<.# /+# 48?%/+:7/8+# ?/7# ./+.(# I.718<.# )*(# -.C7/??*+,# <.(# MF.)/.C3CF.)/O/C01.+# !/7:9/7S7# \'(<.# ./+.# ,.+:*.(.# -.C01(./%*+,# <.C# <=+:?/C01.+# e:01C7*?CR.(1:97.+C# <.(# O'(# B*+,.+/+O.&7/8+.+# R8+# I*&8CR/C)/<8C.3H:7/.+7.+# (.9.R:+7.+# <(./# MF.)/.C# /+# <.(# I/C01&*97*(# .(?E,9/01.+# *+<# )*?# %.CC.(.+# !.(C7S+<+/C# <.(# )\/C01.+# <.+# MF.)/.C# :*O7(.7.+<.+# e.01C.9%.)/.1*+,.+#%./7(:,.+;#

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bNNK;# 5:('%.(# 1/+:*C# .(?E,9/017# <.(# [/+C:7)# O9*8(.C).+)?:(&/.(7.(# MF.)/.C3 CF.)/O/C01.(# I:(&.(?89.&'9.# )*(# QS(%*+,# R8+# -:&7.(/.+V# );-;# ?8+8&98+:9.(# $+7/&E(F.(V#<.+#D:01\./C#<.(#MF.)/.C#?/7#<.(#<*(01O9*CC)=78?.7(/C01.+#$+:9=C.;## #

(18)

X# Z/.9#<.(#1/.(#R8(9/.,.+<.+#$(%./7#\:(#</.#[7:%9/.(*+,#./+.(#I.718<.#)*(#-.C7/??*+,# <.(# MF.)/.C3CF.)/O/C01.+# !/7:9/7S7# <.(# O'(# B*+,.+/+O.&7/8+.+# R8+# I*&8R/C)/<8C.3 H:7/.+7.+# (.9.R:+7.+# -:&7.(/.+CF.)/.C# G=! ($%.:&)18(V# 2=! '$,('&(# *+<# @=! (.%$.8# /+# I/C01&*97*(.+# *+7.(# $+\.+<*+,# <.(# 5ZI;# 5/.# !/7:9/7S7# <.(# -:&7.(/.+# \*(<.# <*(01# <.+# D:01\./C# <.(# I.?%(:+/+7.,(/7S7# <.(# Z.99.+# ?/77.9C# <*(01O9*CC)=78?.7(/C01.(# $+:9=C.# %.C7/??7;# "+# $+9.1+*+,# :+# </.# M7*</.+# :+<.(.(# $*78(.+# .(O89,7.# </.# !/7:9/7S7C%.C7/??*+,# :+1:+<# <.(# 58FF.9OS(%*+,# <.(# -:&7.(/.+# ?/7# <.+# D*&9./+CS*(.+3%/+<.+<.+#Q9*8(.C).+)O:(%C78OO.+#Mg-P#6(..+#"#*+<#H(8F/</*?/8</<# JH"K#J-:(%.C7/#.7#:9;#2bbbj#6(.,8(/#.7#:9;#2bbNK;#H"#</.+7.#)*(#"<.+7/O/&:7/8+#787.(#Z.99.+# ?/7# F.(?.:%/9/C/.(7.(# I.?%(:+V# Mg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e./).+&./?:,,9*7/+/+# Je6$V# .+,9;# >4$(0! :$%#!

(::/.0&)&)KV# .(:(%./7.7;# 5/.# 48?%/+:7/8+# %./<.(# QS(%.?.718<.+# ?/7# <.(# Mg-P#

6(..+#"#@# H"#3#!/7:9/7S7COS(%*+,# .(9:*%7.# </.# 5/C&(/?/+/.(*+,# <.(# <(./# (.9.R:+7.+# MF.)/.C#/+#I/C01&*97*(F(8%.+#/+#<.(#<*(01O9*CC)=78?.7(/C01.+#$+:9=C.;#

5:# C/01# </.# <(./# (.9.R:+7.+# MF.)/.C# 1/+C/0179/01# /1(.C# Z.99\:+<:*O%:*C# *+<# /1(.(# ?.7:%89/C01.+#QS1/,&./7.+#R8+./+:+<.(#*+7.(C01./<.+V#\*(<.+#</.#-.</+,*+,.+#<.(# !/7:9/7S7COS(%*+,V# );-;# </.# Q9*8(.C).+)O:(%C78OO&8+).+7(:7/8+V# )*+S01C7# O'(# i.<.# ./+).9+.# MF.)/.C# :+,.F:CC7;# IE,9/01.(\./C.# %../+O9*CC7# <:('%.(# 1/+:*C# <.(# F1=C/898,/C01.#Z*C7:+<#<.(#-:&7.(/.+#</.#H.+.7(:7/8+#<.(#Q:(%C78OO.#/+#</.#Z.99.#:%.(# :*01# </.# e.01C.9\/(&*+,# <.(# Q:(%C78OO.# ?/7# <.?# %/898,/C01.+# Z/.9?89.&'9# J>8?:C# :+<#!/R.C3P.,8#NllkK;#[C#\*(<.+#<.C1:9%#QS(%.7.C7C#O'(#i.<.#MF.)/.C#?/7#-:&7.(/.+# :*C#*+7.(C01/.<9/01.+#e:01C7*?CF1:C.+#<*(01,.O'1(7;##

Z*(#-.C7/??*+,#<.(#!/7:9/7S7#<.(#-:&7.(/.+#/+#I/C01&*97*(.+#?/7#./+.?#./+1./79/01.+# QS(%.F(878&899# \*(<.+# 48?F(8?/CC%.</+,*+,.+# :+1:+<# <.(# )*R8(# O'(# </.# i.\./9/,.# MF.)/.C#.(?/77.97.+#8F7/?:9.+#-.</+,*+,.+#<.O/+/.(7#*+<#:*O#<.(.+#[/,+*+,#O'(#i.<.#

(19)

T# MF.)/.C# '%.(F('O7;# A/.(%./# \*(<.# :*01# </.# 48?F:7/%/9/7S7# ?/7# <.+# .7:%9/.(7.+# )\./# QS(%.?.718<.+# )*(# MF.)/.C</C&(/?/+/.(*+,# %.('0&C/017/,7;# $9C# P.C*97:7# \*(<.# ./+# O9*8(.C).+)%:C/.(7.C#!/.(O:(%.+F(878&899#O'(#</.#5ZI#.7:%9/.(7;#`+7.(#$+\.+<*+,#<.(# .7:%9/.(7.+#I.718<.#\*(<.#</.#!/7:9/7S7#R8+#G=!($%.:&)18(V!2=!'$,('&(#*+<#@=!(.%$.8# /+# I8<.993I/C01&*97*(.+# /?# M01'77.9&89%.+V# %.C7.1.+<# :*C# )\./# %)\;# <(./# MF.)/.CV# 01:(:&7.(/C/.(7;# Z*CS7)9/01# \*(<.# <:C# e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

Z/.9# <.(# )*C:??.+,.O:CC7.+# $+:9=C.+# \:(# </.# *?O:CC.+<.# `+7.(C*01*+,# <.C# [/+O9*CC.C# <.(# I/C01&*97/R/.(*+,# :*O# </.# !/7:9/7S7# *+<# <:C# e:01C7*?# <.(# ./+).9+.+# MF.)/.C#\S1(.+<#<.(#4*97/R/.(*+,;## # e.C.+79/01.# "+1:97.# <.(# R8(,.9.,7.+# $(%./7# \*(<.+# R8?# $*78(# /+# %.,*7:017.7.+# /+7.(+:7/8+:9.+# Q:01?:,:)/+.+# /+# .+,9/C01.(# MF(:01.# /+# [(C73$*78(.+C01:O7# R.(EOO.+79/017# JP',.(# .7# :9;# 2bNTj# P',.(# .7# :9;# 2bN2K;# "?# $+1:+,# <.(# $(%./7# /C7# ./+.# <.7:/99/.(7.# n%.(C/017# :+# (.9.R:+7.+# \/CC.+C01:O79/01.+# -./7(S,.+# <.C# $*78(C# <:(,.C7.997;## # # #

(20)

c#

>9,?741%4;5*674,@%'(-2=)4(,

>989, A=#;4%54224,<5*67)4045(*67=B;4(,

6.,.+C7:+<# <.(# `+7.(C*01*+,.+# \:(# ./+.# I8<.993I/C01&*97*(V# %.C7.1.+<# :*C# )\./# 8<.(# <(./# *+7.(C01/.<9/01.+# -:&7.(/.+CF.)/.CV# <.O/+/.(7# )*C:??.+,.C.7)7# :*C# <.+# M7S??.+# G8$.51#1)(8! ($%.:&)18(# H$_NV# 2.%341/5$%&(!'$,('&(# 5MI# m2kk# *+<#

@0(,4+/1'1''.8!(.%$.8# $G>>#2l2NX;# 5/.# MF.)/.C# &8??.+# :9C# [((.,.(#

F89=%:&7.(/.99.(#"+O.&7/8+.+#<.(#B*+,.#R8+#I*&8R/C)/<8C.3H:7/.+7.+#R8(;##

"+#<.(#5/CC.(7:7/8+#R8+#M01?/<7V#\*(<.+#</.#<(./#,.+:++7.+#-:&7.(/.+C7S??.#O'(#</.# I8<.993I/C01&*97*(# :*O,(*+<# R.(,9./01%:(.(# e:01C7*?C01:(:&7.(/C7/&:# :*C,.\S197;# !8(:*C,.,:+,.+# \:(.+# 4*97/R/.(*+,C7.C7C# ?/7# :017# *+7.(C01/.<9/01.+# O'(# B*+,.+/+O.&7/8+.+# R8+# I*&8R/C)/<8C.3H:7/.+7.+# (.9.R:+7.+# M7S??.# JO'+O#MF.)/.CV# /+C,.C:?7#:017#M7S??.V#JM01?/<7#2bbkKK;##

#

>98989, C'()4(5(B4#;51(4(,31(,D=;54(;4(,05;,<'#135*&5-1*4,

5/.# <(./# MF.)/.C! G=! ($%.:&)18(V# 2=!'$,('&(# *+<# @=!(.%$.8! )S19.+# )*# <.+# \.C.+79/01.+#[((.,.(+#F89=%:&7.(/.99.(#"+O.&7/8+.+#<.(#B*+,.#R8+#I.+C01.+#?/7#<.(# [(%&(:+&1./7# I*&8R/C)/<8C.# JM=+8+=?o# Z=C7/C01.# Q/%(8C.V# >QV# .+,9;# '+80&'! 9&6%18&8K# J6/99/,:+#NllNKK;#>Q#/C7#</.#:?#1S*O/,C7.+#R8(&8??.+<.#:*78C8?:93(.).CC/R#R.(.(%7.# 4(:+&1./7# /+# <.(# ?/77.9.*(8FS/C01.+# -.RE9&.(*+,;# [/+.?# -.(/017# <.(# e.97,.C*+<1./7C8(,:+/C:7/8+# JeA_V# .+,9;# C1%/5! ;$(/04! D%:()&8(0&1)K# )*O89,.# 7(/77# </.C.# /+# [*(8F:# /+# ./+.?# R8+# 2bbb# %/C# Xbbb# QS99.+# %./# D.*,.%8(.+.+# :*O# JeA_# P.F8(7# 2bb2K;# 5/.# 4(:+&1./7# \/(<# <*(01# ./+.+# 5.O.&7# /?# 6.+# <.C# G(:+C?.?%(:+F(87./+C# >QGPV# <.?# C8,.+:++7.+# P.,*9:78(# <.(# G(:+C?.?%(:+3 B./7OS1/,&./7# %./# >Q# J>QGPV# .+,9;# '+80&'! 9&6%18&8! 0%()8#$#6%()$! '1)5.'0()'$!

%$:./(01%K# 1.(R8(,.(*O.+# JP/8(<:+# .7# :9;# NlklK;# 5:C# H(87./+# >QGP# C7.997# ./+.+#

>198(/</8+.+34:+:9# /+# <.(# Z.99?.?%(:+# R8+# [F/71.9).99.+# .L8&(/+.(# _(,:+.# <:(# J5(*??#.7#:9;#NllbK#*+<#</.+7#<:('%.(#1/+:*C#)*(#P.,*9:7/8+#:+<.(.(#"8+.+34:+S9.# J6(.,.(#.7#:9;#NllWK;#"+O89,.#<.C#6.+<.O.&7C#OS997#</.#$&7/R/.(%:(&./7#<.C#4:+:9C#<*(01# /+7(:).99*9S(.C# )=&9/C01.C# $<.+8C/+?8+8F18CF1:7# J0$IHV# .+,9;# '+'/&'! (5$)18&)!

#1)1,418,4(0$K# :*C# JQ(/)).99# .7# :9;# NlkWj# P./+1:(<7# .7# :9;# 2bbNK;# 5:C# 1:7# /?#

e.C.+79/01.+#</.#M7E(*+,#<.C#7(:+C?.?%(:+.+#>198(/<3#*+<#D:7(/*?/8+.+7(:+CF8(7C# /+# <.+# [F/71.9).99.+# :99.(# .L8&(/+.+# _(,:+.# )*(# Q89,.;# 5.(# <:<*(01# ,.C7E(7.#

(21)

W# [9.&7(89=7:*C,9./01# O'1(7# )*(# $*C7(80&+*+,# *+<# [(1E1*+,# <.(# !/C&8C/7S7# <.C# Q9'CC/,&./7CO/9?C#/?#.L7(:).99*9S(.+#P:*?;#5:R8+#C/+<#</.#M019./?1S*7.#<.(#*+7.(.+# $7.?\.,.# R8+# >Q3H:7/.+7.+# C01\.(# %.7(8OO.+;# A/.(# &:++# <.(# )S1.# M019./?# +*(# C01\.(# :%O9/.h.+# *+<# %.1/+<.(7# C8?/7# <.+# $%7(:+CF8(7# R8+# Q(.?<&E(F.(+# :*C# <.(# B*+,.;# 5/.# C8,.+:++7.# ?*&8)/9/S(.# 49S(*+,V# ./+# I.01:+/C?*C# <.(# :+,.%8(.+.+# "??*+:+7\8(7V#\/(<#%.C8+<.(C#%../+7(S017/,7#J4+8\9.C#:+<#-8*01.(#2bb2j#H*01.99.# .7#:9;#2bb2K;#5/.C.(#!8(,:+,#%.,'+C7/,7#?:h,.%9/01#</.#-.C/.<9*+,#<.(#/?#D8(?:9O:99# &./?O(./.+# M019./?1:*7# ?/7# -:&7.(/.+# *+7.(C01/.<9/01.(# MF.)/.C;# A/.(%./# (./01.(+# C/01# /+C%.C8+<.(.# 1*?:+F:718,.+.# -:&7.(/.+:(7.+# :+V# \.901.# "+O.&7/8+.+# <.(# B*+,.+C019./?1S*7.#1.(R8((*O.+#J`9(/01#.7#:9;#Nllkj#e8(9/7)C01#.7#:9;#2bb2K;#$+#<.(# M7.99.#C./#.(\S1+7V#<:CC#/+#<.(#B/7.(:7*(#+.%.+#<.(#-../+7(S017/,*+,#<.(#?*&8)/9/S(.+# 49S(*+,#\./7.(.#`(C:01.+#O'(#</.#[7:%9/.(*+,#%:&7.(/.99.(#B*+,.+/+O.&7/8+.+#%./#>Q3 H:7/.+7.+# %.C01(/.%.+# \.(<.+;# A/.()*# \/(<# <.(# B.C.(# :*O# R.(EOO.+79/017.# B/7.(:7*('%.(C/017.+# J5E(/+,# :+<# 6*9%/+C# 2bblj# 6/%C8+# .7# :9;# 2bbXj# A:*C.(# .7# :9;# 2bNNj# B=0):&# .7# :9;# 2bb2K# R.(\/.C.+;# I/7# )*+.1?.+<.?# 4(:+&1./7CR.(9:*O# \.(<.+# </.# B*+,.+/+O.&7/8+.+# ?./C7# 01(8+/C01# ?/7# C01\.(\/.,.+<.+# Q89,.+# O'(# <.+# 6.C*+<1./7C)*C7:+<# <.(# >Q3H:7/.+7.+;# 5/.# 01(8+/C01.# "+O.&7/8+# O'1(7# )*# F.(?:+.+7.+# [+7)'+<*+,C(.:&7/8+.+# <.C# "??*+C=C7.?CV# </.# ?/7# O8(7C01(./7.+<.(# 4(:+&1./7C<:*.(# )*(# M01S</,*+,# <.C# B*+,.+,.\.%.C# *+<# <.?# :99?S19/01.+# P'0&,:+,# <.(# B*+,.+O*+&7/8+# O'1(7# JG'??9.(# :+<# 4/.\/7)# Nlllj# g:+,# .7# :9;# 2bNNK;# 5.(# <:(:*C# (.C*97/.(.+<.(# $*CO:99# <.(# B*+,.+O*+&7/8+# C7.997# </.# 1S*O/,C7.# G8<.C*(C:01.#R8+#>Q3H:7/.+7.+#<:(#J6.8(,.#.7#:9;#2bblK;##

-:&7.(/.99.# B*+,.+/+O.&7/8+.+# \.(<.+# /?# Q:99.# R8+# >Q# /+# <.(# P.,.9# ?/7# $+7/%/87/&:# /+7.+C/R# %.1:+<.97V# &E++.+# i.<801# <:<*(01# %/C1.(# +*(# ./+,.<S??7# \.(<.+;# >1(8+/C01.#B*+,.+/+O.&7/8+.+#%9./%.+#<.+#H:7/.+7.+#./+#B.%.+#9:+,#.(1:97.+#Jg:+,# .7#:9;#2bNNK;#5/.#[9/?/+/.(*+,#<.(#"+O.&7/8+#\/(<#/?#e.C.+79/01.+#<*(01#<:C#$*O7(.7.+# :+7/%/87/&:3(.C/C7.+7.(#F:718,.+.(#M7S??.#.(C01\.(7#J6.8(,.#.7#:9;#2bblj#B=0):&#.7# :9;# 2bb2K;# Z*<.?# &E++.+# /+# 01(8+/C01.+# "+O.&7/8+.+# /?# Z*,.# <.(# $<:F7:7/8+# <.(# -:&7.(/.+# :+# <:C# M019./?1:*7?/9/.*# <*(01# ,.+.7/C01.# !:(/:7/8+# /?# H1S+87=F3 R.(S+<.(7.# Z.99.+# :*O7(.7.+V# \.901.# ?/7*+7.(# -/8O/9?.# %/9<.+# &E++.+V# </.# ,.,.+# $+7/%/87/&:#)*CS7)9/01.+#M01*7)#%/.7.+#JA:*C.(#.7#:9;#2bNNj#B=0):&#.7#:9;#2bb2K;## B*+,.+/+O.&7/8+.+# /?# Z*C:??.+1:+,# ?/7# >Q# C/+<V# \/.# %.(./7C# ./+,:+,C# .(\S1+7V# F89=%:&7.(/.99;#5/.C.#"+O.&7/8+.+#\.(<.+#/+#&9/+/C01.+#M7*</.+#:?#1S*O/,C7.+#?/7#<.+# $(7.+# @=! (.%$.8V# G=! ($%.:&)18(V# 2=! '$,('&(! *+<! ;($#1,4&/.8! &)9/.$)E($# :CC8)//.(7#

(22)

m# J6/99/,:+#NllNj#A:((/C8+#2bbmK;#5/.#Z*C:??.+C.7)*+,#</.C.(#I/C01,.?./+C01:O7.+# S+<.(7# C/01# /?# B:*O.# <.(# 4(:+&1./7;# eS1(.+<# ;=!&)9/.$)E($! *+<! @=! (.%$.8! 8O7# %./# H:7/.+7.+# /?# 4/+<.C:97.(# R8(&8??.+V# 7(.7.+# 2=!'$,('&(# *+<# G=! ($%.:&)18(# 1S*O/,.(# %./#.(\:01C.+.+#H:7/.+7.+#:*O#Jg:+,#.7#:9;#2bNNK;##

$&7*.99.# M7*</.+# /+# $+\.+<*+,# +.*.(# &*97*(*+:%1S+,/,.(3?89.&*9:(%/898,/C01.(# D:01\./C?.718<.+V#\/.#);-;#<.(#G3PQBHV#%.(/017.+#<:,.,.+#1S*O/,.(#R8+#MF.)/.C3 (./01.(.(#I/C01,.?./+C01:O7.+#%./#B*+,.+/+O.&7/8+.+#R8+#>Q3H:7/.+7.+#JA:((/C#.7#:9;# 2bbmj#P8,.(C#.7#:9;#2bbXj#P8,.(C#.7#:9;#2bNbj#M/%9.=#.7#:9;#2bbkK;#5/.#`+7.(C*01*+,# <.C# [/+O9*CC.C# <.(# MF.)/.C3Z*C:??.+C.7)*+,# <.(# I/C01/+O.&7/8+.+# :*O# <.+# 4(:+&1./7CR.(9:*O# \/(<# /+# </.C.?# Z*C:??.+1:+,# )*+.1?.+<# /+# <.+# Q8&*C# +.*.(# Q:01C7*</.+#,.C7.997#J49.F:03>.(:i#.7#:9;#2bNbj#Z.?:+/0&#.7#:9;#2bNNK;##

Z*C:??.+O:CC.+<# /C7# O.C7)*1:97.+V# <:CC# F89=%:&7.(/.99.# "+O.&7/8+.+# <.(# *+7.(.+# $7.?\.,.# /?# Z*C:??.+1:+,# ?/7# >Q# </.# P.,.9# C/+<# Jg:+,# .7# :9;# 2bNNK;# 5.C# e./7.(.+# 1:7# /+# 181.?# I:h.# <:C# $*O7(.7.+# R8+# e.01C.9\/(&*+,.+# )\/C01.+# <.+# MF.)/.C# ./+.# p+<.(*+,# <.(# MF.)/.C3Z*C:??.+C.7)*+,# /?# )./79/01.+# !.(9:*O# R8+# I/C01/+O.&7/8+.+#)*(#Q89,.;## # >989>9, !"#$%&'&()",)#*$+,(&")-$9C# !.(7(.7.(# <.(# 6:77*+,# G8$.51#1)(8# C/+<# </.# -:&7.(/.+# <.(# MF.)/.C# G=!($%.:&)18(# C7S%01.+OE(?/,V# 6(:?3+.,:7/RV# ?8+8F89:(# F89=7(/01# %.,./h.97# *+<#

%/9<.+# &./+.# MF8(.+# :*C;# Z*<.?# \:01C.+# </.# -:&7.(/.+# O:&*97:7/R# :+:.(8%# *+<# %.7(./%.+# 01.?88(,:+87(8F1.+# [+.(,/.C78OO\.01C.9;# Q'(# G=!($%.:&)18(# /C7# </.# -/9<*+,# R8+# \:CC.(9EC9/01.+# O9*8(.C)/.(.+<.+# H/,?.+7.+V# *;:;# R8+# H1.+:)/+.+V# 01:(:&7.(/C7/C01#JQ*01C#:+<#M019.,.9#2bbmK;##

5/.# MF.)/.C# /C7# 1*?:+# F:718,.+# *+<# &8??7# *%/]*/7S(# /+# O.*017.+# A:%/7:7.+# /+# <.(# `?\.97#R8(V#7(/77#:%.(#:*01#R.(?.1(7#/+#4(:+&.+1S*C.(+#/+#e:C01%.0&.+V#G8/9.77.+V# *+<# 5*C01.+# :*O# JM7./+?.7)# 2bblK;# G=!($%.:&)18(# 7(/77# 1S*O/,# %./?# I.+C01.+# :9C# [((.,.(#R8+#4(:+&.+1:*C/+O.&7/8+.+V#*;:;#A:(+\.,C3V#e*+<3#*+<#B*+,.+/+O.&7/8+.+V# C8\/.#R8+#"+O.&7/8+.+#/?#Z*C:??.+1:+,#?/7#6(*+<&(:+&1./7.+V#*;:;#[(%&(:+&1./7.+V# :*O# JM7./+?.7)# 2bblK;# -./# >Q3H:7/.+7.+# ,.97.+# </.# -:&7.(/.+# </.C.(# MF.)/.C# :9C# A:*F7.((.,.(#01(8+/C01.(#"+O.&7/8+.+#<.(#B*+,.+#J6/99/,:+#NllNj#68R:+#:+<#5.(.7/0# NllWj#A:*C.(#.7#:9;#2bNNK;#5/.#MF.)/.C#/C7#%.&:++7#O'(#</.#-/9<*+,#./+.(#!/.9):19#R8+# !/(*9.+)O:&78(.+V# </.# ?:h,.%9/01# )*(# H:718,.+.C.# R8+# "+O.&7/8+.+# /?# I.+C01.+#

(23)

k# %./7(:,.+;#Z*#<.+#Q:&78(.+#)S19.+#[L878L/+.V#H(87.:C.+V#H/,?.+7.#*+<#69=&89/F/<.# J5E(/+,# NlkmK;# -:&7.(/.+# </.C.(# MF.)/.C# &E++.+# [L8F89=C:001:(/<3# J[HM3K# M01/017.+V# /?# e.C.+79/01.+# :*C# $9,/+:7V# :+# <.(# S*h.(.+# Z.99?.?%(:+# :*C%/9<.+;# 5/.C.# M01/017# </.+7# <.+# Z.99.+# :9C# M01*7)V# );# -;# ,.,.+# :+<:*.(+<.+# 8L/<:7/R.+# M7(.CC#8<.(#F.(?:+.+7.(#$+,(/OO.#<.C#"??*+C=C7.?C#<.(#e/(7C).99.+#JM/?FC8+#.7#:9;# Nlkkj# M/?FC8+# .7# :9;# NlklKV# C8\/.# )*(# $<1SC/8+# :+# _%.(O9S01.+V# );-;# :+# [F/71.9).99.+#J58/,#.7#:9;#Nlkmj#P:?F1:9#:+<#H/.(#NlkcK;#-./#01(8+/C01.+#"+O.&7/8+.+# ?/7# G=! ($%.:&)18(# /C7# </.# n%.(F(8<*&7/8+# R8+# $9,/+:7# 01:(:&7.(/C7/C01V# \.901.# )*# ./+.?# ?*&EC.?# H1S+87=F# O'1(7# JM7./+?.7)# 2bblK;# G=!($%.:&)18(# /C7# ,.,.+# ./+.# !/.9):19# R8+# $+7/%/87/&:# /+7(/+C/C01# (.C/C7.+7# %)\;# /C7# /+# <.(# B:,.# +.*.# P.C/C7.+).+# %./# :+1:97.+<.(# -.1:+<9*+,.+# ?/7# $+7/%/87/&:# <*(01# ,.+.7/C01.# $<:F7:7/8+# :*C)*%/9<.+#Jg:+,#.7#:9;#2bNNK;#"+#<.?#Z*C:??.+1:+,#/C7#</.#[LF(.CC/8+#R8+#I*97/3 [OO9*L3H*?F.+C=C7.?.+# R8+# G=! ($%.:&)18(# 1.(R8()*1.%.+V# </.# )*?# :&7/R.+# $*CF*?F.+#R8+#$+7/%/87/&:#*+<#:+<.(.+#I89.&'9.+#:*C#<.(#Z.99.#O'1(.+#JA:*C.(#.7# :9;#2bNNj#B/#.7#:9;#NllTj#B=0):&#.7#:9;#2bb2j#H889.#2bbNK;## 5:('%.(#1/+:*C#C/+<#G=!($%.:&)18(#)*(#H8F*9:7/8+C</017.3:%1S+,/,.+#6.+(.,*9:7/8+# J^MV!.+,9;#?.1%.#!8$)8&):K#%.OS1/,7;#5/.#H8F*9:7/8+C</017.#\/(<#)\/C01.+#<.+#Z.99.+# ?/77.9C#O(./,.C.7)7.(#01.?/C01.(#-87.+C78OO.V#C8,.+:++7.(#D3$0=918?8C.(/+.#9:078+.V# R.(?/77.97#JP/.<.9#.7#:9;#2bbNK;#M=C7.?.#<.C#^M#C/+<#?:h,.%9/01#:+#<.(#P.,*9/.(*+,# <.(# [LF(.CC/8+# R8+# !/(*9.+)O:&78(36.+.+# C8\/.# -/8O/9?3:CC8)//.(7.(# 6.+.# %.7./9/,7# Je1/7.1.:<#.7#:9;#2bbNK;## # >989E9, .$*/0&1%#*,),2#3)2,)-"+# <.(# 6(*FF.# 2.%341/5$%&(3'$,('&(348?F9.L# J-00K# \.(<.+# +:1# ?/7./+:+<.(# R.(\:+<7.#MF.)/.C#<.(#6:77*+,#2.%341/5$%&(#J%/C#Nll2#G8$.51#1)(8V#Jg:%**01/#.7# :9;# Nll2KKV# *;:;# 2=! '$,('&(V# 2=! #./0&71%()8H! 2=!'$)1'$,('&(V# )*C:??.+,.O:CC7;# 5.+# $*78(.+# 5(.R/+.&# *+<# I:1.+71/(:9/+,:?# )*O89,.# \/(<# )\/C01.+# Nm# ,.+.7/C01# R.(C01/.<.+.+V# :%.(# F1S+78=F/C01# R.(,9./01%:(.+# MF.)/.C# *+7.(C01/.<.+# J5(.R/+.&# :+<# I:1.+71/(:9/+,:?# 2bNXK;# !.(7(.7.(# </.C.(# 6(*FF.# C/+<# 6(:?3+.,:7/RV# C7S%01.+OE(?/,V# F89=7(/01# F89:(# %.,./h.97# *+<# %/9<.+# &./+.# MF8(.+# :*C;# Z*?# e:01C.+# \/(<# M:*.(C78OO# R8(:*C,.C.7)7# J8%9/,:78(/C01# :.(8%K# *+<# </.# [+.(,/.,.\/++*+,#.(O89,7#01.?88(,:+87(8F1#J68R:+#.7#:9;#NllWK;#5/.#MF.)/.C#/C7#O'(#

(24)

l# /1(.# 181.# !/.9C./7/,&./7# 1/+C/0179/01# <.(# )*# R.(\.(7.+<.+# 8(,:+/C01.+# !.(%/+<*+,.+# :9C#4819.+C78OO3#*+<#[+.(,/.]*.99.#%.&:++7#JI:</,:+#:+<#I:(7/+&8#2bbWK;##

-:&7.(/.+#<.C#-00#&8??.+#*%/]*/7S(#/+#<.(#`?\.97#R8(o#/+#-E<.+V#/?#e:CC.(#*+<#:+# HO9:+).+;# M/.# 7(.7.+# :%.(# :*01# 1S*O/,# /+# 4(:+&.+1S*C.(+# /+# &8+7:?/+/.(7.+# 5.C/+O.&7/8+C9EC*+,.+#*+<#:*O#?.</)/+/C01.+#6.(S7.+#*+<#I:7.(/:9/.+#:*O;#!.(7(.7.(# <.(# -00# ,.97.+# :9C# 1*?:+# F:718,.+# *+<# 9EC.+# R8(# :99.?# "+O.&7/8+.+# %./# /??*+,.C01\S017.+# H:7/.+7.+# :*C;# M8# &8??.+# B*+,.+V# e./017./93# *+<# e*+</+O.&7/8+.+# C8\/.# -9*7R.(,/O7*+,.+# *+<# A:(+\.,/+O.&7/8+.+V# /+C%.C8+<.(.# /+# 4(:+&.+1S*C.(+#/+#!.(%/+<*+,#?/7#<.?#[/+C:7)#R8+#4:71.7.(+V#R8(#JM7./+?.7)#2bblK;## 5:('%.(# 1/+:*C# &8??.+# -003-:&7.(/.+# /+# 01(8+/C01.+# "+O.&7/8+.+# <.(# B*+,.# R8+# >Q3H:7/.+7.+#R8(#J68R:+#:+<#5.(.7/0#NllWK;#5/.#MF.)/.C#C/+<#/+#<.(#B:,.#./+.#,(8h.# !/.9):19# .L7(:).99*9S(.(# !/(*9.+)O:&78(.+# )*# %/9<.+;# Z*# <.+# Q:&78(.+# )S19.+# [L878L/+.V# H(87.:C.+V# B/F:C.+# *+<# M/<.(8F18(.V# \.901.# )*(# H:718,.+.C.# %./# "+O.&7/8+.+# /?# I.+C01.+# %./7(:,.+# JI:1.+71/(:9/+,:?# .7# :9;# 2bbcK;# -:&7.(/.+# <.C# -00# \./C.+# <:('%.(# 1/+:*C# ./+.# 181.# /+7(/+C/C01.# P.C/C7.+)# ,.,.+'%.(# ./+.(# !/.9):19# R8+# $+7/%/87/&:# :*O# JB/H*?:# NllkK;# Z*(# P.C/C7.+)# 7(:,.+# ?/7*+7.(# B/F8F89=C:001:(/<.#JBHMK#:+#<.(#S*h.(.+#Z.99?.?%(:+#J!/+/8+35*%/.9#:+<#689<%.(,# 2bbXKV# I*97/3[OO9*L3H*?F.+C=C7.?.# JP*C178+# .7# :9;# 2bNXK# *+<# </.# QS1/,&./7# )*(# -/9<*+,#R8+#-/8O/9?.+#J!:+#$0&.(#.7#:9;K#%./;## -:&7.(/.+#<.C#-00#C/+<#)*?#^M#%.OS1/,7;#M8#\/(<#</.#[LF(.CC/8+#R8+#./+.(#!/.9):19# R8+#!/(*9.+)O:&78(36.+.+##<*(01#^M#(.,*9/.(7#J!.+7*(/#.7#:9;#2bbTK;# # >989F9, 45)3061&2&22$",)$*#$"-$9C#!.(7(.7.(#<.(#6:77*+,#@0(,4+/1'1''.8#C/+<#</.#-:&7.(/.+#<.(#MF.)/.C#@=!(.%$.8# &*,.9OE(?/,#J&8&&8/<KV#6(:?3F8C/7/RV#+/017#CF8(*9/.(.+<#*+<#*+%.\.,9/01#JQ*01C#:+<# M019.,.9# 2bbmj# ":+<898# 2bbbK;# 5/.# Z.99.+# 7.+</.(.+# )*(# $,,(.,:7/8+V# /+# Q8(?# R8+# G(:*%.+# 8<.(# A:*O.+# JM1:F/(8# 2bbNK;# M7:F1=98&8&&.+# \./C.+# /?# $99,.?./+.+# ./+.# C.1(# 181.# G89.(:+)# ,.,.+'%.(# G(80&.+1./7# *+<# 181.+# M:9),.1:97.+# :*O# JI:</,:+# :+<# I:(7/+&8# 2bbWK;# $9C# 6(:?3F8C/7/R.# -:&7.(/*?# /C7# </.# Z.99\:+<# R8+# @=! (.%$.8# +/017#R8+#./+.(#S*h.(.+#I.?%(:+#*?,.%.+;#5/.#Z.99\:+<#%.C7.17#/?#e.C.+79/01.+# :*C# ]*.(R.(+.7)7.+# H.F7/<8,9=&:+C01/017.+V# :*C# G./018+CS*(.+V# B/F87./018+CS*(.+# *+<# H(87./+.+# J$%%;# N,J$KK;# 5:C# H.F7/<8,9=&:+('0&,(:7# %.C7.17# :*C# C/01# \/.<.(189.+<.+# h3NVT#R.(&+'FO7.+# D3$0.7=9,9*&8C:?/+.+# *+<# D3$0.7=9?*(:?/+3

(25)

Nb# CS*(.+#JQ*01C#:+<#M019.,.9#2bbmK;#"?#Q:99.#R8+#@=!(.%$.8#C/+<#</.#+:1%././+:+<.(# 9/.,.+<.+# G.7(:F.F7/<C./7.+&.77.+# R8+# D3$0.7=9?*(:?/+CS*(.V# \/.# /+# $%%;# N#J-K#<:(,.C7.997V# <*(01# H.+7:,9=)/+%('0&.+# ]*.(R.(+.7)7# J":+<898# 2bbbK;# 5/.# H.F7/<8,9=&:+C01/017# C7.997# ./+# ,*7.C# $+,(/OOC)/.9# O'(# </.# Q9*8(.C).+)?:(&/.(*+,# <.(# Z.99.+# ?/77.9C# B.&7/+.+# <:(;# [/+# \./7.(.C# >1:(:&7.(/C7/&*?# O'(# @=!(.%$.8# C7.997# </.# -/9<*+,# R8+# 48:,*9:C.# <:(V# \.901.# </:,+8C7/C01# )*(# "<.+7/O/)/.(*+,# <.(# MF.)/.C# /+# <.(#49/+/&#,.+*7)7#\/(<#J6:7.(?:++#2bblK;##

# !""9,8,G422H=(-,31(,47-)$*#$"9,,

I!J# Z.99\:+<C7(*&7*(# 6(:?3F8C/7/R.(# -:&7.(/.+# JQ*01C# :+<# M019.,.9# 2bbmKV# ?8</O/)/.(7K;#

H.F7/<8,9=&:+('0&,(:7# %.C7.17# :*C# :97.(+/.(.+<.+# h3NVT# R.(&+'FO7.+# D3$0.7=9,9*&8C:?/+.+# J690D$0V# ,(:*.# P.017.0&.K# *+<# D3$0.7=9?*(:?/+CS*(.# JI*(D$0V# %./,.# P.017.0&.K;#

IAJ#H.F7/<8,9=&:+]*.(R.(+.7)*+,#/+#<.(#Z.99\:+<#R8+#@=!(.%$.8#JJD:R:((.#:+<#M01+..\/+<# NlllKV# ?8</O/)/.(7K;# D:1%././+:+<.(# 9/.,.+<.# G.7(:F.F7/<C./7.+&.77.+# R8+# D3$0.7=93 ?*(:?/+CS*(.#JI*(D$0K#C/+<#'%.(#H.+7:,9=)/+%('0&.+#?/7./+:+<.(#R.(%*+<.+;# # -:&7.(/.+# <.(# MF.)/.C# @=! (.%$.8# \:01C.+# O:&*97:7/R# :+:.(8%# *+<# %.7(./%.+# 01.?88(,:+87(8F1.+#M78OO\.01C.9#J6:7.(?:++#2bblK;#A.L8C.+#\/.#69*&8C.#\.(<.+# '%.(#</.#69=&89=C.#*+<#<.+#H.+78C.3H18CF1:73e.,#)*#H=(*R:7#:%,.%:*7#JM7(:C7.(C# :+<# e/+&9.(# NlWXK;# `+7.(# :.(8%.+# -.</+,*+,.+# \/(<# H=(*R:7# 8L/<:7/R# )*# $0.7=93 >8.+)=?$#J$0.7=93>8$K#<.0:(%8L=9/.(7#J6:(<+.(#:+<#B:C0.99.C#NlW2K;#eS1(.+<#<.C# e:01C7*?C# \/(<# $<.+8C/+7(/F18CF1:7# J$GHK# R8(\/.,.+<# <*(01# $%%:*# R8+# $0.7=93 >8$# )*# $0.7:7# ,.\8++.+# JM8?.(R/99.# .7# :9;# 2bbXK;# `+7.(# :+:.(8%.+# -.</+,*+,.+# <:,.,.+# \/(<# H=(*R:7# )*(# 6.\/++*+,# R8+# $GH# )*# B:&7:7# (.<*)/.(7# JQ.((./(:# .7# :9;# 2bNXK;##

5/.# MF.)/.C# @=! (.%$.8# /C7# 1*?:+# F:718,.+# *+<# &8??7# *%/]*/7S(# R8(o# /+# -E<.+V# M7:*%V#B*O7V#/?#e:CC.(#C8\/.#/+#B.%.+C?/77.9+V#R8(#:99.?#/+#I/901F(8<*&7.+#J":+<898# 2bbbK;# 5:('%.(# 1/+:*C# &898+/C/.(.+# C/.# 8O7?:9C# </.# A:*7# *+<# M019./?1S*7.# <.C#

(26)

NN# I.+C01.+# J6:7.(?:++# 2bblK;# -:&7.(/.+# <.(# MF.)/.C#@=!(.%$.8# C/+<# 1S*O/,# [((.,.(# R8+# 98&:9.+# A:*7/+O.&7/8+.+V# </.# 8%.(O9S019/013./7(/,# JH/0&.9V# $%C).CC.V# H*C7.9O9.017.# J"?F.7/,8KK# R.(9:*O.+;# -./# I.+C01.+# ?/7# ,.C01\S017.(# "??*+:%\.1(# &E++.+# 7/.O3 /+R:C/R.#"+O.&7/8+.+#R.(*(C:017#\.(<.+#J6:7.(?:++#2bblK;#B.7)7.(.#\.(<.+#1S*O/,#/?# 4(:+&.+1:*C#:*C,.1.+<#R8+#e*+</+O.&7/8+.+V#*;:;#<*(01#</(.&7.+#48+7:&7#?/7#<.+# AS+<.+# <.C# ?.</)/+/C01.+# H.(C8+:9C# %./# <.(# !.(C8(,*+,# <.(# e*+<.+V# :%.(# :*01# C=C7.?/C01V# *;:;# <*(01# <:C# B.,.+# R8+# 4:71.<.(+V# 1.(R8(,.(*O.+;# 5/.C.# "+O.&7/8+.+# &E++.+# )*(# [+7)'+<*+,# <.(# $7.?\.,.# JM/+*C/7/CV# H+.*?8+/.KV# <.(# 6.9.+&.# J$(71(/7/CKV# <.C# 4+801.+?:(&C# J_C7.8?=.9/7/CKV# <.C# A.().+C# J4:(</7/CKV# <.(# A/(+1:*7# JI.+/+,/7/CK#8<.(#)*#-9*7R.(,/O7*+,.+#JM.FC/CK#O'1(.+#JI:</,:+#:+<#I:(7/+&8#2bbWK;# Z*<.?# &8??.+# "+O.&7/8+.+# ?/7# @=! (.%$.8# %./?# I.+C01.+# /?# Z*C:??.+1:+,# ?/7# [(%&(:+&1./7.+#R8(;#@=!(.%$.8#,.1E(7#)*#<.+#\.C.+79/01.+#[((.,.(+#R8+#"+O.&7/8+.+# <.(#B*+,.#R8+#>Q3H:7/.+7.+#J6/99/,:+#NllNK;#5:('%.(#1/+:*C#\.(<.+#-:&7.(/.+#</.C.(# MF.)/.C# :*01# ?/7# B.%.+C?/77.9R.(,/O7*+,.+# 8<.(# <.(# [(&(:+&*+,# :?# 78L/C01.+# M0180&C=+<(8?# :CC8)//.(7# J6:7.(?:++# 2bblK;# Q'(# </.# H:718,.+.C.# </.C.(# 4(:+&1./7.+# /C7# </.# :*C,.F(S,7.# QS1/,&./7# R8+# @=!(.%$.8# )*(# -/9<*+,# ./+.(# !/.9):19# .L7(:).99*9S(.(# !/(*9.+)O:&78(.+V# \/.# [L878L/+.V# H(87.:C.+# *+<# B/F:C.+# J":+<898# 2bbbKV#R8+#,(8h.(#-.<.*7*+,;## -:&7.(/.+#<.(#MF.)/.C#C/+<#R8+#D:7*(#:*C#,.,.+'%.(#h3B:&7:?3$+7/%/87/&:#JH.+/0/99/+V# >.F1:98CF8(/+.K# .?FO/+<9/01# J6:7.(?:++# 2bblK;# q.<801# C/+<# /+# 4(:+&.+1S*C.(+# M7S??.#?/7#P.C/C7.+).+#<*(01#</.#R.(?.1(7.#*+<#i:1(.9:+,.#$+7/%/87/&:71.(:F/.#R8+#

@=!(.%$.8# "+O.&7/8+.+# :*O,.&8??.+;# 5:)*# )S19.+# </.# /+# <.(# 49/+/&# C.1(# 1S*O/,#

:*O7(.7.+<.+#I.71/99/0/+3(.C/C7.+7.+#@=!(.%$.8#JIPM$K#M7S??.V#:*01#?*97/3(.C/C7.+7# ,.+:++7V# </.# )*CS7)9/01# ,.,.+'%.(# $+7/%/87/&:# :+<.(.(# 49:CC.+# (.C/C7.+7# C/+<# J6:7.(?:++#2bblK;## # >989K9, A4*1(-4%745;4(, 50, <4;="125*0'*, 31(, !7-)#*$+,(&"), '(-, .7-2#3)2,),,

"?# Q:99.# R8+# G=! ($%.:&)18(! *+<# 2=! '$,('&(# /C7# </.# `?\:+<9*+,# R8+# 69*&8C.# )*# W3 H18CF18,9*08+:7# '%.(# )\./# *+7.(C01/.<9/01.# M78OO\.01C.9\.,.# 01:(:&7.(/C7/C01# JB.CC/.# :+<# H1/%%C# NlkTK;# Z*?# ./+.+# &:++# 69*&8C.# </(.&7# /?# Z=78C89# <*(01# H18CF18(=9/.(*+,# *+<# :+C019/.h.+<.# _L/<:7/8+# R8?# Z\/C01.+F(8<*&7# 69*08C.3W3F18CF1:7# )*# W3H18CF18,9*08+:7# *?,.\:+<.97# \.(<.+;# Z*?# :+<.(.+#

(27)

N2# &:++# </.# 69*&8C.# .L7(:).99*9S(# /?# H.(/F9:C?:# <*(01# ?.?%(:+,.%*+<.+.# A=<(8,.+:C.+# )*# 69*08+:7# %)\;# '%.(# 69*08+:7# )*# 234.78353,9*08+:7# J23456K# 8L/</.(7#\.(<.+#JP8%.(7C#.7#:9;#NlmXK;#M8\819#69*08+:7#:9C#:*01#23456#&E++.+#'%.(# 7(:+C?.?%(:+.#G(:+CF8(7.(3M=C7.?.#/+C#Z.99/++.(.#:*O,.+8??.+#\.(<.+;#69*08+:7# *+<# 23456# &E++.+# O.(+.(# /?# Z=78C89# <*(01# H18CF18(=9/.(*+,# %)\;# <*(01# H18CF18(=9/.(*+,# *+<# :+C019/.h.+<.(# _L/<:7/8+# )*# W3H18CF18,9*08+:7# *?,.\:+<.97# \.(<.+# JP8%.(7C# .7# :9;# NlmXKV# \.901.C# <:++# \./7.(# '%.(# <.+# [+7+.(358*<8(8OO3e.,#:%,.%:*7#\.(<.+#&:++#JB.CC/.#:+<#H1/%%C#NlkTK;## # >989L9, <1-422+<5*67#'2;'%4(,B$%,*/*;40=;5*674,M(;4%*'67'()4(,, 5/.# 4*97/R/.(*+,C%.</+,*+,.+# <.(# /+# </.C.(# M7*</.# *+7.(C*017.+# I8<.993 I/C01&*97*(.+#*+7.(C01./<.+#C/01#R8+#<.+#O'(#</.#B*+,.+/+O.&7/8+#R8+#>Q3H:7/.+7.+# 01:(:&7.(/C7/C01.+# &)!7&71# -.</+,*+,.+;# 5:# C/01# </.# F89=%:&7.(/.99.# B*+,.+/+O.&7/8+# /+#./+.?#H:7/.+7.+#./+)/,:(7/,#R.(1S97#&E++.+#C=C7.?:7/C01.+#M7*</.+#)*(#[(O:CC*+,# <.(# Je:01C7*?C3K#5=+:?/&# <.(# ./+).9+.+# MF.)/.C# /+# ./+.?# 8<.(# /+# ?.1(.(.+# H:7/.+7.+# :9C# F:(:99.9.# *+<# (.F(8<*)/.(%:(.# [LF.(/?.+7.# &)! 7&71# &:*?# <*(01,.O'1(7# \.(<.+;# [C# R:(//.(7# );-;# </.# Z*C:??.+C.7)*+,# <.(# MF.)/.C# /+# <.(# "+O.&7/8+# /+# $%1S+,/,&./7# R8+# <.(# %/C1.(/,.+# G1.(:F/.# C8\/.# R8?# $97.(# <.C# H:7/.+7.+# J49.F:03 >.(:i# .7# :9;# 2bNbj# P.+<.(C# .7# :9;# 2bbNK;# 5/.# I8<.993I/C01&*97*(# 1/+,.,.+# .(9:*%7V# :*01#\.++#</.#!.(,9./01%:(&./7#)*#./+.(#F89=%:&7.(/.99.+#&)!7&71#B*+,.+/+O.&7/8+#+*(# 7./9\./C.# ,.,.%.+# /C7V# </.# >834*97/R/.(*+,# <(./# O'(# >Q3(.9.R:+7.(# -:&7.(/.+C7S??.# *+7.(# <.O/+/.(7.+# *+<# &8+7(899/.(7.+# e:01C7*?C%.</+,*+,.+V# );-;# %./# /<.+7/C01.+# CF.)/O/C01.+# e:01C7*?C(:7.+# /?# -/8(.:&78(# /?# >1.?8C7:7# JM01?/<7# .7# :9;# 2bbmK;# 5/.C.# I8<.993I/C01&*97*(.+# C7.99.+# C8?/7# ,../,+.7.# !.(C*01C:+8(<+*+,.+# )*(# C=C7.?:7/C01.+#`+7.(C*01*+,#<.C#[/+O9*CC.C#<.(#>834*97/R/.(*+,#:*O#<:C#e:01C7*?# *+<# <.(# !/7:9/7S7# <.(# ./+).9+.+# MF.)/.C# <:(;# 5:('%.(# 1/+:*C# &:++# <.(# [OO.&7# R8+# $+7/%/87/&:# :*O# </.# ./+).9+.+# MF.)/.C# /+# I/C01&*97*(.+# *+7.(C*017# \.(<.+# JP/.<.9.# :+<# P./019# 2bNNj# M01?/<7# .7# :9;# 2bNNK;# 5.C# e./7.(.+# ./,+.7# C/01# </.# !.(C*01C:+8(<+*+,# :*01# )*(# C=C7.?:7/C01.+# `+7.(C*01*+,# R8+# e.01C.9%.)/.1*+,.+#)\/C01.+#<.+#MF.)/.CV#);-;#<*(01#</.#)./79/01.#[(O:CC*+,#<.C# D/R.:*C# <.(# [LF(.CC/8+# (.9.R:+7.(# H(87./+.# ?/77.9C# H(87.8?3$+:9=C.# J49*,.# .7# :9;# 2bN2K;# $+# </.C.(# M7.99.# C./# :*01# <:(:*O# 1/+,.\/.C.+V# <:CC# &)! 7&0%1# G.C7C# /+# <.(# &9/+/C01.+#Q8(C01*+,#)*(#`+7.(C*01*+,#<.(#[?FO/+<9/01&./7#R8+#-:&7.(/.+#,.,.+'%.(#

(28)

NX# $+7/%/87/&:# /+# <.(# P.,.9# ?/7# P./+&*97*(.+# <*(01,.O'1(7# \.(<.+;# "+# F89=%:&7.(/.99.+# "+O.&7/8+.+#\/.#/+#<.(#B*+,.#R8+#>Q3H:7/.+7.+#&:++#i.<801#<*(01#e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

@=!(.%$.8V# ./+.# .(1E17.# e/(&C:?&./7# <.C# h3B:07:?3$+7/%/87/&*?C# >.O7:)/</?# ,.,.+# G=!($%.:&)18(#/?#!.(,9./01#)*(#P./+&*97*(#O.C7#JP/.<.9.#:+<#P./019#2bNNK;#

#

>9>9, N'%67B2'**&/;104;%5*674,!(=2/*4,31(,A=#;4%54(,

>9>989, !22)4045(4*,D%5(&5O,-4%,N'%67B2'**&/;104;%54,

5/.# 5ZI# C7.997# ./+# 7.01+/C01.C# H:(7/&.9?.CCR.(O:1(.+# <:(V# <:C# </.# ^*:+7/O/)/.(*+,# ./+).9+.(# H:(7/&.9# C8\/.# </.# ?*97/F:(:?.7(/C01.# >1:(:&7.(/C/.(*+,# ./+).9+.(# H:(7/&.9# 1/+C/0179/01# F1=C/&:9/C01.(# *+<# %/898,/C01.(# I.(&?:9.# .(9:*%7;# 5/.C.# G.01+/&# \/(<# R8(\/.,.+<# ?/7# <.(# O9*8(.C).+)%:C/.(7.+# $+:9=C.# %/898,/C01.(# H:(7/&.9V# ?./C7# .*&:(=87/C01.(# 8<.(# F(8&:(=87/C01.(# Z.99.+V# :CC8)//.(7;# 5/.# H:(7/&.9# ./+.(# H(8%.C*CF.+C/8+# \.(<.+# /?# e.C.+79/01.+# ?/77.9C# ./+.C# Q9'CC/,&./7C1'99C7(8?C# R.(./+).97# *+<# \/.# /+# <.(# :?# 1S*O/,C7.+# R8(&8??.+<.+# 7.01+/C01.+# 5ZI348+O/,*(:7/8+# <*(01# ./+.+# 8<.(# ?.1(.(.# B/017C7(:19J.+K# ,.O'1(7;# -./?# 5*(01]*.(.+# <.(# H:(7/&.9# \.(<.+# R.(C01/.<.+.# M7(.*9/0173# *+<# Q9*8(.C).+)C/,+:9.# C/?*97:+# <.7.&7/.(7;# B.7)7.(.C# C.7)7# </.# I:(&/.(*+,# <.(# H:(7/&.9# ?/7# .+7CF(.01.+<.+# Q:(%C78OO.+# 8<.(# ./+.# [/,.+O9*8(.C).+)# R8(:*C;# -./# <.(# `+7.(C*01*+,# R8+# Z.99.+# .(?E,9/01.+# Q9*8(.C).+)?:(&/.(*+,.+V# \.901.# ,.)/.97# 8<.(# /+</(.&7# ).99*9S(.# I.(&?:9.V# M7(*&7*(.+# 8<.(# Q*+&7/8+.+# :+)./,.+V# </.# >1:(:&7.(/C/.(*+,# %)\;# </.# 49:CC/O/)/.(*+,# R8+# Z.99F8F*9:7/8+.+# 1/+C/0179/01# C7(*&7*(.99.(# 8<.(# F1=C/898,/C01.(# [/,.+C01:O7.+;# M7(.*9/017C/,+:9.# &E++.+# )*<.?# $*OC019*CC# '%.(# </.# M7(*&7*(# R8+# Z.99.+V#\/.#I8(F1898,/.#*+<#6(:+*9:(/7S7V#,.%.+;#

$9C# $97.(+:7/R.# )*(# O9*8(.C).+)%:C/.(7.+# G.01+/&# .L/C7/.(.+# 5*(01O9*CC)=78?.7.(# %./# <.(# </.# R.(./+).97.+# H:(7/&.9# ?/77.9C# ./+.C# A'99C7(8?.C# <*(01# ./+# .9.&7(/C01.C# Q.9<# ,.O'1(7#\.(<.+;#5/.#[(O:CC*+,#<.(#p+<.(*+,#<.C#.9.&7(/C01.+#Q.9<.C#<*(01#</.#Z.99.# .(9:*%7# </.# ^*:+7/O/)/.(*+,# R8+# Z.99.+# C8\/.# </.# C7(*&7*(.99.# >1:(:&7.(/C/.(*+,# R8+#

(29)

Z 2 O : : . < # ! . Z 2 5 O9 : [ : . D < ! I 4 . H H Z. b 5: * * [/+ * /+ D: . !" I. 48 +, HI HI .99 bN :# 8 C +# C +. :0 .C "" .C 8+ , IG IG F b 8(. CC 5 C# .C 01 C#I "9, CC +O/ 9;# G2 GT F8 bj# .C C0 5* C C# 1O I > C, , , 2# T# 8F 5 /+ C) 01 * C7( > O8 I. >, ,. ,* ,4 O O' F* 5 +# ) 19/ (0 (E > 89, .C . .( *(: 4 O' '( *9 : . /. 01 E? >8 ,. CC .6 S :7 1 '(# (# : R + .h 1O ? 8? . C, 67 7# 7/8 01 M 8 :7/ R/< < +) h9 O9* ?* ? + ,. 74 8+ 1# M. (: /8 <# /. )? /0 *C *+ F < .( 40 O +# # ./ :+ 8+ . .C ?: 01 CC +, F* <# (S 0 O' O' #. /7C +, +. .7# C. : 1# C) ,C *7. \ S7 = '(# ' ./0 C7 ,. .+ : .( (& : )= C7 . \/ 7. =;5 ( (# 0&, 7(. .# +# :9 (# &/ :* =7 7. (C (< .C 5* O' ,/& .* Q J ;# . *O# 78 .0 C# <# C#. *6 O9 '+ &$ *9 Q9* J> 2 $ .(7 < 8? 01 ) < . 67 9* +O $%! 9/0 *8 >8 2b $ 7. </ ? 1+ )* <: (9 74 *8 O#I % 01 8( 8* bN $( .( . ?. +/ *( :C S 4% 8( I 0. 17 (. *9 N2 (% (# .C .7 C (# C# S* %,! . I. .6 7! .C 97. 2K %. C. . 0 M Q *7. ! C) .C 6$ JM C) . KK ./7 -.C (# 1 M7 Q* . ' ). CC $K MM ). (3 ;# 7# -C#< % 1. 7. * (7 'B" .+ CF Ko# M .+ 3Z # -: < %. .+ .* + 7;# "= +) F: H > +) ZS < :& * .C +V# *. & # = )% :(: HI >V# )#J S1 </ &7. (0 C7 .( &7/ ' %: : I . JQ 19 /. . 01 7. 8 (* 8 ,4 :C ? IG .+ QB 9. .# (/ 1O .1 8F *+ 8+ 45 C/ ?. GN +, B2 .(# . O9* 17# F7 +, +C ( /. .7 N# ,9 2K 8 O .+ * , /C ,V CF (4 .(7 . O' ;# Kj# 8< O9 +) C ,( C0 V# F( 4* 7. (; '( 8 H < * ). C (* 01 ! (/+ *,N .# #5 (# 8&5 HI . 8 .9 ) *+ 1. !/ +) N 5 ! 5$ I .(# 8(. 9. = +< .+ /C )/ ' ? . !8 $! G : . .+ =78 <9 +# C* F '% ? .7. 8( 8 Gc :* C) +# 8? 9. * *: F# 6 ?* .& (\ 8' c#O *0 ) ? ., * :9 < 7 *97 &7 \S '( O' 01 . ?. ,. + /C <. B2 7/F 78 S( (0 '(# 1# + . .7 .+ < C/. .(# 2' F: (. (7C 00$ (8 " +) ./+ 7(/ +< <# . ( 5 '* :( .+ C7 $% 8 "? )% + /C <V . (* 5 ** (: +# 7(. %! 7. ? %: , C0 V#\ .9. *+ 5Z *& :? C .* /&: .# F :C . 01 \ . +, ZI &/ ?. C/+ *9 :4 Q F. C/. .C 1. \/. & ,# I /; .7 +< /0 40 Q9* .< . C. .#! .# 7( # 1 7( <# 01 0K *8 <: (7 .7) ! #/ (8 * : 10 (/C H 17! j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h + :* Z. JH /& JQ .7 C* ,. C7. h , *7. .9 HI &: QB N 7# : *+ .+ . 9/0 ,. . 9. I :4 B NT : +, +< 997 0 .+ /9. .+ IG 40K NK T# 9;# ,# <# 7V# 1# +;# .# # +;# GV# Kj# Kj# # # # # # # # # # # # # #

(30)

Nc# !8(:*CC.7)*+,# O'(# </.# I.CC*+,# /C7# ./+# A'99O9'CC/,&./7CC7(8?# J.+,9;# 84$(04! 9/.&5!

80%$(#KV# <.(# :*C# ./+.?# P.C.(R8/(# <*(01# $+C:*,.+# R8+# B*O7# '%.(# ./+.+# M019:*01# <*(01# </.# 5*(01O9*CC).99.# J$%%;# 2K# ,.F*?F7# \/(<;# "+# <.(# 5*(01O9*CC).99.# \/(<# </.# H(8%.C*CF.+C/8+# ).+7(/.(7# /+# ./+.?# C01+.99.(# O9/.h.+<.+V# 9:?/+:(.+# A'99O9'CC/,&./7CC7(8?#)*(#!.(./+).9*+,#*+<#)*(#QE(<.(*+,#<.(#Z.99.+#)*?#B/017C7(:19# ./+,.9./7.7# J1=<(8<=+:?/C01.# Q8&*CC/.(*+,K;# 5/.# H(8%.# \/(<# .+7\.<.(# </(.&7# <*(01# ./+.#?878(%.7(/.%.+.#MF(/7).#./+,.C8,.+#8<.(#<*(01#<:C#[/+9./7.+#./+.C#B*O7C7(8?C# /+# <:C# H(8%.+,.OShV# %./# 9*O7</017R.(C019/.h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e.99.+9S+,.# J?8+801(8?:7/C01K# *+<# 181.(# [+.(,/.9./C7*+,# .().*,.+;# q.# +:01# 7.01+/C01.(# 48+O/,*(:7/8+# <.C# 6.(S7.C# C/+<# ./+# 8<.(#?.1(.(.#B:C.(#./+,.%:*7;#I/71/9O.#&(.*))=9/+<(/C01.(#B/+C.+#\/(<#<.(#B:C.(C7(:19# ,.%'+<.97# *+<# :*O# ./+.?# O.C7.+# H*+&7# /+# <.(# 5*(01O9*CC).99.# ,.9.+&7# J6/R:+# 2bbNKV# <.(#R8+#<.+#Z.99.+#<*(01]*.(7#\/(<;#$?#C8,.+:++7.+#I.CCF*+&7#7(/OO7#<.(#B:C.(C7(:19#

:*O# </.# Z.99.;# 5.(# Q9'CC/,&./7CC7(8?# R.(9S*O7# /?# (.017.+# e/+&.9# )*?# B:C.(C7(:19############ J$%%;# 2K;# -./# ?.1(.(.+# B:C.(+# \.(<.+# </.# ./+).9+.+# M7(:19.+# /+# <.(# P.,.9# :*O#

R.(C01/.<.+.V# /+# P/017*+,# <.C# H(8%.+O9*CC.CV# :*O./+:+<.(O89,.+<.# I.CCF*+&7.# O8&*CC/.(7;#5*(01]*.(.+#</.#Z.99.+#<.+#I.CCF*+&7V#\/(<#<:C#B/017#<.C#B:C.(C#:+#<.+# Z.99.+# ,.C7(.*7# %)\;# R8+# <.+# Z.99.+V# );-;# <*(01# /+7(:).99*9S(.# 48?F:(7/?.+7.V# ,.%(801.+;# 5:C# M7(.*9/017# *+<# <:C# ,.%(801.+.# B/017V# /?# Q89,.+<.+# )*C:??.+# :9C# M7(.*9/017# %.)./01+.7V# \.(<.+# /+# ./+.?# R8(<.(.+# e/+&.9%.(./01# C8\/.# /?# (.017.+# e/+&.9# )*?# <*(01C7(:19.+<.+# B:C.(9/017# '%.(# B/+C.+# *+<# 5.7.&78(.+# :%,.,(/OO.+;# M7(.*9/017C/,+:9.# /?# R8(<.(.+# e/+&.9%.(./01V# /+# <.(# P.,.9# )\/C01.+# bVcr# *+<# Nbr# JM1:F/(8# 2bbb%KV# \.(<.+# :9C# !8(\S(7CC7(.*9/017# JQM>V# .+,9;# 91%>(%5! 8'(00$%! /&:40K# %.)./01+.7# *+<# C/+<# *;:;# :%1S+,/,# R8+# <.(# 6(Eh.# <.(# <*(019.*017.7.+# Z.99.;# 5:C# M/,+:9#&8((.9/.(7#:%.(#+/017#</(.&7#?/7#<.(#Z.99,(Eh.V#<:#.C#:*01#R8?#-(.01*+,C/+<.L# )\/C01.+#Z.99.#*+<#*?,.%.+<.+#I.</*?#:%1S+,7;#5:C#QM>#/C7#<:1.(#:9C#6(Eh.+3 (.9.R:+7#)*#%.7(:017.+;#5/.#M7(.*9/017C/,+:9.#/?#lbr#e/+&.9#\.(<.+#:9C#M./7C7(.*9/017# JMM>V#.+,9;#8&5$!8'(00$%!/&:40K#%.)./01+.7;#5:C#MM>#\/(<#<*(01#./+.#48?%/+:7/8+#:*C# B/017%(.01*+,# /?# "++.(.+# <.(# Z.99.# )\/C01.+# <.+# /+7(:).99*9S(.+# 48?F:(7/?.+7.+#

Referenzen

ÄHNLICHE DOKUMENTE

In dieser Arbeit wurde am Beispiel einer 10 ml Probe, die aus einer Produktstufe mit einem Volumen von 100 l entnommen wird, berechnet, dass rein statistisch

Im Herbst des ersten Jahres kann man nach dem Abräumen der Beete auf den Beeten auf  denen im zweiten Jahr die Mischkulturen Mediterran - Zucchini und Aubergine und/oder 

Dafür wird 1 ppb Toluol-D3 in unterschiedlicher Menge zu den Mengen Toluol pipet- tiert, sodass am Ende in jedem Headspace-Vial 5 ml mit einer errechneten Konzentration von To- luol

Auf dem Podere l’Aione (DOC Montescudaio, Toscana), dem aufstrebenden 5-Hektar-Betrieb von Doris und Robert Wälti, wird mit der Eidgenössischen Forschungsanstalt für Obst- Wein-

Es ist wichtig festzuhalten, dass die Dynamik auch vom Most abhängig ist, wobei die Stämme 280 und 281 sowohl im Pinot noir als auch im Sangiovese während der ganzen Gärung vorhan-

Ausgehend von diesen Werten und unter der Annahme, dass das Probevolumen bei einer realen Bioaerosolmes- sung etwa 1 m 3 beträgt und die DNS-Extraktion mit einer

In den am Universitäts KrebsCentrum (UCC) Dresden etablierten interdiszi- plinären onkologischen Fallbespre- chungen, sogenannte Tumorboards, werden zwischen Spezialisten

Schnittsalat, Radieschen und Karotten können sehr gut immer wieder nachgesät werden, andere Samen verschenkt oder an anderen Orten der Natur zurückgegeben