• Keine Ergebnisse gefunden

ValuechainanalysisofPaprikaandBird’sEyeChilliesinMalawi Makoka,DonaldandChitika,RollinsandSimtowe,Franklin MunichPersonalRePEcArchive

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Aktie "ValuechainanalysisofPaprikaandBird’sEyeChilliesinMalawi Makoka,DonaldandChitika,RollinsandSimtowe,Franklin MunichPersonalRePEcArchive"

Copied!
110
0
0

Wird geladen.... (Jetzt Volltext ansehen)

Volltext

(1)

Value chain analysis of Paprika and Bird’s Eye Chillies in Malawi

Makoka, Donald and Chitika, Rollins and Simtowe, Franklin

University of Malawi, Centre for Agricultural Research and Development

1 July 2010

Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/27785/

MPRA Paper No. 27785, posted 02 Jan 2011 19:09 UTC

(2)
(3)

! " #!$!

% ! !&$ '(

)*&!$$( $ $ + %( '!

, , - .//0

! 1'(

'!

! " ! # "

#

(4)

$ $

! !

% && % & &

' (

) )*

%

) )

# + # +

,- , - (

& ! & . !

& ,) & , )

'/ " ' . " /

, !

(5)

23 ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 4

0 1 2 . ! & ,) & 3 00

0 4 - 01

.3 5 ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 26

1 0 ! 5 , 04

63 ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, .0

4 6 16

4 0 16

4 1 ) , 16

4 4 & 11

4 7 8 11

4 9 11

/3 ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, .4

7 6 1:

7 0 0 ! . 1:

7 0 1 ) , 46

7 0 4 & 40

7 0 7 8 & 8 40

7 0 9 40

7 1 # / . & . , 40

7 4 & . ) ! 44

7 7 ; ! . 44

7 9 # ! . & . 47

7 < - & . 2 = ) , 4<

7 > & & & . 2 = ) , 4>

73 ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, /2

9 6 70

9 0 & ) 70

9 1 & - 74

9 1 0 ! # !# 166<(1600 74

9 1 1 ' ' 166: 74

9 1 4 )* % ! 1666 77

9 1 7 , & & 0:?> 79

9 1 9 % & 1664 79

9 1 < 2 # 166: 79

9 1 > $ % & 1669 7<

9 1 ? % & 1666 7<

9 1 : & 166? 7>

9 1 06 ! ) & ! ) 0::9 7>

9 1 00 , & 0::> 7?

9 4 7:

83 9 9 ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 70

(6)

< 6 96

< 0 , & . 2 = ) , & 96

< 1 ! 3 91

< 4 / % ( ) 94

< 7 / 97

< 9 $ @ 9>

< < & & $ 9?

< < 0 A & . 2 = ) , $ 9?

< < 1 & . 2 = ) , $ 9:

< < 4 & ! . <0

< > & ! . <1

< > 0 2 . <1

< > 1 & <9

< > 4 - & <>

< ? $ ( , & . 2 = ) , <?

:3 ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :2

> 6 >0

> 1 . >0

> 0 0 # ! >0

> 0 1 ! ! >1

> 0 4 , ! >1

> 0 7 % >4

> 0 9 & >7

> 0 < & )* >9

> 0 > & . ! & ! >9

> 0 ? ! >>

> 1 , >?

;3 5 ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ;0

? 6 ?6

? 0 ! ?6

? 0 0 ( & ?6

? 0 1 ( & ?0

? 0 4 ( & ?0

? 1 ! & . 5 , ! ?0

? 4 ! 2 = ) , 5 , ?9

? 7 # & . 2 = ) , = 5 , ?>

? 9 5 8 @ . & . 2 = ) , 5 , ?:

? < & . 2 = ) , 5 , :6

43 5

5, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 47

: 6 :9

: 0 & . 2 = ) , :9

: 1 ' . & . 2 = ) , :<

: 1 0 & , :<

: 1 1 ! . , :>

: 1 4 , ::

: 4 / 066

(7)

: 7 060 203 ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 20.

06 6 061

06 0 & 061

06 1 ! . 064

06 4 064

06 7 , ) ! 3 067

<<<, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 207

(8)

5

. . !

! ' . . !

. . = " .

. ,

. ! 2 ! " ! & ! 8

* ,

.

- ! . & 3 ! !B) ,

. , ! , ! $ .

. .

' . 8

! $ " ! " , ! "

& " ! 2 " % " & )* " & . !

& ! " ' . .

" @ " % " " %. . " %. " !@

' . * 3

# " % " & # " ! ! . . " " % . "

. , ! . . .

# ; % . * .

; # !

*

' . "

! " #!$!

% ! !&$ '(

.0 ) => .020

?

(9)

, ( ( & , ) & ,)

3 % % & 3 . (

( . = .

3 & ,)

3 " , . = = $ 1606

3 " * .

. = !

! " @ " % " " %. . " %. " !@

. = ( "

" @ .

* . =

. ! .

. =

(

3 " . =

! ( "

* 0? .

166:C1606 " 76 =

( " "

! (

.

. ( 3

. " # =

!;>:"69>C8 .

!;00"994C8

(10)

! . & . "

! % .

! " . ( C (

! ! . * .

. * ) " .

! . ( "

D " =

"

( % " ! " , ! " & "

( * . " (

) " ; ( "

. = ! "

"

. = E =

D * @

. (

" (

* " . "

. . " D "

@ . / "

" " . .

* ( & ,) 3 3

23

* ! "

! = " >6 = *

(11)

( . . "

# !

. . ( * ,

" ! 0:::

( . " "

" " . .

" " D

( "

& . ,

. " % . 1666

! . !

.

F0"466 F1"666 "

3 , D " #

! " %#/ " "

& . !

0::6 , &

= " % "

* = " !

8 " .

$ "

.

.

" . "

. " * " " " .

.

(12)

. =

2,. + 1% ) $ $ + %( '! $#( % @(+$

! , ( ( @ !

0::: ! ,

( "

* 166<" ! ,

* ! @ D " @ + ,

E E E

E "

, / 166: ( 3 &

, ) & ,) & ,) 3 ! "

%. . " " % " %. ( , & ,) 3

% % & &

% &&0 #( & ! *@(+$!A( B $#( C% @(+$ !" $ ! "& D"+ ( "C!+( C% )+(%" $ #!1#D A )( & % ($" (A( C + &C($!$!A( ("" B *!% " (=( +#! !(" C C%! $#% )1# + &&(%+!

)C1% ! 1 B $#( & @ % C =(%" ! $#(!% %("C(+$!A( A )( +# ! "

3 " 3 (-C(+$(

%(") $"

- 0G .

- 1G D . =

- 4G . .

- 7G ( . =

! " # $ % &

% & & ' & % # ' #& (#

% &# ' % # ( ( & & ) ( &

' % # * +

(13)

- 9G . . =

3 >"966 . = "

1"966 3

. " ! !) .

! !) " " .

& ,) 3 " , . = =

$ 1606 3 " *

. . = !

! - -

* 0

2,6 (C %$ $%)+$)%(

G , 1 3

, 4" 3

! - D D , 7"

. .

= < , > 3 .

. = ( $ " ?

(14)

.3 5

. =

! A )( +# ! ("+%!*(" $#( B) % 1( B

+$!A!$!(" %(E)!%( $ *%! 1 C% )+$ B% & ! !$! C%!& %= C% )+$! > $#% )1# !BB(%( $ C# "(" B C% )+$! $ $#( B! + ")&(% ; . ! " 1666E ! . . " 166:E ; @ " 166<

* .

. H .I

.

!

. ; . ! 1666 " G

"

E

3 "

. .E

.

.

* " . =

" " G . "

D D " $ 1 0 .

(15)

!1)%( .,23 $(C" (%$ ( ! $#( $) =

&C ( $ 3 (" $) =

$ 1 0" .

" . . =

! ! "

G

! , !$(% $)%( (A!('

. . =

! " & ,) 3 . "

3 3 & . =

! 3 4

" . =

! " ! .

! .

$ ,

( & * -

.- #&

( (

/ % #

( ,

0 # 1 *

2 -

(

( 3 *

4 * (

# ( 4 5

4 * (5

# ( 4 5

# ( 4 5

36 (

(16)

+ " ! @ D " " - " " ,

!! , !+= (A!('

! $

($(%&! ( $#( (-$( $ $ '#!+# $#( C !+= ( A!% &( $ ")CC %$" % ! #!*!$ C C%! *!% " (=(

+#! !("> C% )+$! > + ")&C$! $% ( G

! # !# 166<

' ' 166:

)* % ! 1666

- ! & 0::9

, & & 0:?>

% & 1664

! % & 1661

% - ! & 1666

2 # , 166:

$ % & 1669

% & 1666

& 0::?

! ) & 0::9

, & 0::>

* " "

. =

!!! , (A!(' B "$!$)$! % &(' % '!$#! $#( C C%! *!% " (=( +#! !(" ")*D

"(+$ %"

(17)

. = (

* ( " . = "

! ! $ "

& . ! " , ! " % "

&C ( $ 3 9) $!$ $!A( 9) !$ $!A( ="!"

. D D

" . = !

. = ! $ " , ! "

% / $ / / "

. = & ,) 3

" % " " %. . " %. !@ /

& ,) 3 @

@ .

! = =

16:

= 1 0 /

16: " 00? 9< .

= 1 0" .

" % " %. . @

!@ =

" %. . " %.

(18)

!1)%( .,.3 C B '! # '! 1 $) = %( "

!@

%

@

(19)

* ( .,23 !"$%!*)$! B " &C ( # )"(# " *= !"$%!+$

!"$%!+$

C%!

C% )+(% !% F" (=( +#! !(" C% )+(% $

14 6 14

@ 16 6 16

% 46 6 46

6 0< 0<

%. . . 11 74 <9

%. 6 0> 0>

!@ 14 6 14

6 09 09

$ 22; 42 .04

D

" "

. " . . = " "

. =

. . = " "

&C ( $ 3 )( # ! ="!"

"

" .

. = "

G

. = E

# . = E

!

(20)

(

5 @ . . =

E

'/ " ' . " / . =

E

! .

. E

) . E

(21)

63

= )&2" 1669

! = /

# " " " + ! = =

% . " 166: 3

. = "

" . " .

! 6,2 "("

2 = ) 7

" = "

" . ! 2 = )

* ," 1660 .

D @ . ) " % "

! ) " ) " " J

.

6,. + 1!+ !$! "

2 = ( " 0"966

/ 16 46 , " 0<

, * " 41 , , " G

<66 0"166 )*

$ " *

8 9 ?(< 9 8 "

8 , ( " ( (

*

(22)

!1)%( 6,63 (+$ % 1( % )+$! B !% " =( #! !(" ! '! 244;D.004

0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000

1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009

Area (ha) and Production (tonnes) of chillies

mt ha

)%+(3! $

!1)%( 6,23 %&(% ! $#( B!( B *!% " (=( +#! !("

)%+(3 # $ $ ( *= )$# %"

(23)

6,6 ("$" !"( "("

, . E , " "

" - % *

"

. " , , " / "

- . E

" " , . ; $" , "

$ , * E # #

6,/ %A("$! 1

, . 1K 4 & . 4 7

- - , , @ 0 4

0"666 . 4"666 .

6,7 %=! 1

C

. 7 > $ > 9 ?

" . . .

04L *

" (

(24)

!1)%( 6,.3 !% " =( #! !(" (! 1 %!( *= & D"+ ( % )+(%,

)%+(3 # $ $ ( *= )$# %"

(25)

!1)%( 636 !% " =( #! !(" )( # ! % 1%(""!

)%+(3 !"(% "" +! $(" .008

$ 4 4 =

" " "

" "

*

5

7 ,- 8649-

0 -

0 7 &&

-

- 4

4 ( : 4 ( ;

, 49 8, < , 9 .

, /8;/4, /

-

- 1

4 ( -

;

; =

&

4 (

/= 1 %

; =

- *

% 1

% .

-6 9;/8 >664

7 - &

-

- !; = "

- 6

* ? #

(26)

6,8 5 * % ($" B % !% " =( #! !("

.

' ' # ) " 166:

* ( 6,.3 5 * #! ! % ($" &C($!$!

4 1 . 3 .

( . 3 . "

; " # " $ , . "

' 3

(27)

* ( 6,63 5 * #! ! % ($" &C($!$!

G

"

&

-

8 8

&

8

! * * E

" 2 @

8

E E

/ ?6 L

; E

E

! 3 *

E

&

E

D E

8

3 " E

3 E

& % # , E

/ " % " +

, 3

E

E

) E

M (

# ' ) =

. (

E

! 3 "

E

) = .

.

( E

E

E ,

% " ; 3

" "

* E

# )

D E

) .

)

# . E

5 .

(28)

$

C

* EE ) =

"

*

8

E

$ E

$

; 3 "

"

* E

! "

D E

&

= E

- . .

.

,

E

*

- @ E

( ( E

- E ,

E

&

E

E . E 8

E

. D

. E

"

' E

'

E

"

& . ,

"

" ) #

.

"

. "

"

06

G ; 166<

(29)
(30)

/3

/,0 $% )+$!

& . ! 0::9 , + "

+ ), " 166< " , + .

" & @ .

" &

" . &

8 " " &

0::>

& . " , ! 0::>

. . " D .

" # ! . ( *

* . "

( . " ' 8 / @ !

& " ! )* & , " .

" "

! * .

& . ! " & ! 0::?

/,2,2 "( % ($"

& . " " "

"

. G

. . " C / :6L .

"

C E " .

. "

(31)

. ) # . # "

# 2 # , " " 06L

E & . *

46L

!1)%( /,23 C%! ! "& # (% B %&(% " B!(

)%+(3 # $ $ ( *= )$# %"

/,2,. + 1!+ !$! "

& . = >(:

0?66 17(76 ,

. (

" 2 @ " , " 8 " ! * " ! " " + "

" " ! @ D ! A "

" " " &

8 < 6 N < ? ?66

466 966 . "

(32)

1 4 ! ( 0 <! ( & ! "

1664 " 1664

/,2,6 ("$" !"( "("

, . 2 ! " , " "

" " J " - , "

" " " "

/,2,/ %A("$ "$ %A("$ 1(&( $

& . . (

06(16L

& . * " *

*

/,2,7 %=! 1

. 0 6

. . 4(7

' . D @ . .

$ . E # 0G .(

. . E # 1G .( C . E # 4G .(

* 19L E # 7G

/,. 5 * )$ B C%! #! !("

! * . .

" " " & .

"

& . . . "

. .

! .

(33)

* ; ! 1669 <6"666

. !

/ @

" . " "

' " !

. " *

D . *

& . 0966 17 , 41 ,"

( 8 < < 9 ?66

" E (

466 966 . "

1 4 ! ( 0 <! ( " 1664

. G . . "

C / :6L . "

C E

" .

. " . )

# . # " # 2 # , "

" 06L E & .

* 46L

' * " 06L "

E " <L(:L .

. E . "

" " C

" *

(34)

. " "

*

/,6 #( C%! + &= ! '!

. "

@ & . 0::9

" 4" ?64

. 900" 7?: !

! $ " 0" 9<9 ! 1" ?1< &

07 ! 77 ! . ) :

061 . ! " 1606 & .

@ " " % . ! *

) "

. . ! E " , " !

) " % & ! *

. )* . " @

. . ( " * .

%#/ / " * " .

* G

* )* " "

" ( M @ "

. .

D D ' " * .

/,/ (= %( " ! $#( + % ($

.

. .

(35)

. ! @ & .

! & ! & ! "

" . 7

"

& ! = " "

& !

) N

" . D D

. D 8 " & !

. ( > 0 >

/,7 5 * % ($" B % C%!

, . . D & . " .

"

; " 166< .

. $ "

"

" * . "

D

(36)

!1)%( /,.3 5 * % ($" B % C%!

!" # $% &! '( !%" ) * +" ,"! -"./ !

(37)

!1)%( /,63 @ % &C %$! 1 % ($" B % C%! > .00/

! %"

# $ %

* ,

! "

' (

- " . / !

)%+(3 + "$(% .004

/,8 ($)% " $ * )% B % C%! !% " =( #! !("

! # . !

166? . .

= 7 4 * "

. . 166<C166>

(38)

* ( /,/3 ($)% $ * )%> %( (A( %!+( !( B % C%! #! !(">

.008H.00:

% C (A( ($)% $

H# 2

($)% $ * )%

HC(%" =.

%( (A(

=!( H#

%( (A(

%!+(

H 1

- ( 4"?00 09 1 9<? 7 007 07

47"4:4 006 0"107 :> <6

& .

" #$%&'( )* *$( #&(+'&

- ( 17"00> <9 167 :< 6:

0>?"<64 76> 70? 79 :4

,

" #&#%,)& ('& ,## ''+-(

)%+(3 $) = .00;

. #+ /

(+ / 0

166<C6> " . =

(

8 " .

( "

!;069C " 7 4" (

. =

( "

(

. = (

/,: "$ !$! $!A(" $ % & $( C%! !% " =( #! !("

"

. = 0::6 " 5(%& D '! % & $! B

%$!+) $)%( % @(+$ , & ! '

# +" 3 3 ( G

(39)

! E E

. "

*

" 3 " . "

! # " 0::: (

- " ! ' %$!+) $)%(

% C" (A( C&( $ % @(+$ " 2 .

3 3 "

. ! # " 166? 3

!@ - !@ @ E " ; ! 3 ; E

@ E %. .

.

$ $ G! &($" & # (% %&(%" "" +! $!

. = + . " ! ! 3

$ $ 3

- !

3 =

G $ " 3

D ( D @ D

" 3 + .

2 * 7 0 " D ! 2

.

(40)

- /,23 G! &($" & # (% %&(%" "" +! $!

+ . $ = 0::> ! 3

, 5 / , , C5/,

0::7" " , C5/, . !

@ .

! 3 " , C5/, . =

@ " . =

. $ " , C5/, *

. D 0:::" + .

$ = 9"666

% $ !

, " + . ! "

166 " + .

. &

166?C6: " + . ) ( $

& $ & "

" $ & &

. ) ,/! 166:" + .

$ "

! 3 $ 3 + .

. =

# + . " " " .

16 ;

!;0>9 F0 16

(41)

!1)%( /,23 !+$)%(" B% & G! &($" & # (% %&(%" "" +! $! ! ) @(

+ . $ & 166? & + .

$

!;0>9C F0 16

16 ;

(42)

73

7,0 $% )+$!

& . = " " D .

. " " D

. ( @

* *

. =

! * * . =

7,2 !+= A!% &( $

! =

" @ " 0::: 8 "

@

" * "

! # +"

0::: ! 8

0::: 166: ! # " 0::: ! 8

3 G

( !

E

. * @

* E

D E

. .

E

* . E

" E

(43)

D

A!"! "$ $(&( $ B % "C!+(" C% )+$! '!$#! $#( %$!+) $)% (A( C&( $ $% $(1= G

12 (&#&% 3 4 #&%&&& 5

(%&&& 5 % " % 3

3 3

3 6+

! $ "

@ ,

! 8 " * 166:"

"

! ! # 0::: E ! # 166? E ;

; 0::? . ! 166?

! .

"

5 5

5 + 5 0

! 7 " 8 (&&$% " + 5

3

9 " 3 %

+

% 8 " + :

" % + 5

" 3 %

; +

(44)

7,. !+= (A!('

. = (

* * . =

$ " " (

! " ##$% #

! # !#

*

. " !#

G " "

" "

!#

. G

!# .

" !#

- * . .

! @ D " + @ " E

- * "

@ E

. .

E

. * E

! * @ .

& ' & !& '& " ! ##("

' " <L

" "

(45)

* . =

' .

G

' . <L

@ .

' ( .

*

. & .

(

' ( "

( . . =

@ (

( @ . "

. " (

C "

. =

) & *+ , ! ###"

1666 )* & 3

* "

' * @ . = "

* "

(46)

. = " "

* .

=

- . / / ! (01"

, & & 0:?>

= D " *

. = G

* .

D

"

, / ! ##)"

% 1664

!

* . . = "

" "

( D

$ 2 3 ! ##("

# 166: "

* @ "

. @

.

. *

* . .

(47)

. = *

2 #

1 4 , / ! ## "

$ % & 1669 @

" " " D

@ * .

*

. =

. "

.

. = G

$ "

.

*

0 , 3 / ! ###"

3

"

" .

. @ " .

=

(48)

. = G

) 3

&

& =

&

& .

)

( 3 3 / ! ##0"

&

!

! ,

"

. =

!) G

) ( !)

) %#/ !)

" " !)

# & & &

! ) $

# * / ! *" ! (( "

! )

. = G

) ! ) 3 D " "

.

(49)

) ! ) )

& )* & 5

& 8 ! )

.

. / ! ((1"

(

' "

. = G

) )

E

) D

E

) .

E

. .

* E

3 E

) . E

* . E

) *

E

$ E

(50)

)

E

) "

" " . " .

7,6 !"+)""!

. = " 8 " *

. .

. =

" ! $ " .

"

. ( ! .

* .

! 8 * 166:

.

=

(51)

83 9 9

8,0 $% )+$!

D D . .

$ ! 1606 "

. =

" " "

8,2 # % +$(%!"$!+" B C%! !% " =( #! !(" % )+(%"

. =

" @ " % " " %. . " %. " !@

= < 1 /

0>7 " :? 9< .

= < 1" .

" % " %. . %. = "

%. . %.

* ( 8,.3 !"$%!*)$! B " &C ( # )"(# " *= !"$%!+$

!"$%!+$ C%! C% )+(%

!% F" (=( +#! !("

C% )+(% $

14 6 14

@ 16 6 16

% 46 6 46

6 0< 0<

%. . . 11 74 <9

%. 6 0> 0>

!@ 14 6 14

6 09 09

00? :0 16:

5 /3.*% 6 ! # #"

(52)

D

" "

. " . . " "

. =

. . = " "

. =

< 4 17L ( (

= 47L . 0>L

$ " 3

. )

. = "

<

* . ( 7 =

4 3 . =

* "

(53)

* ( 8,63 # % +$(%!"$!+" B B %&(%" " &C ( B % $#( # )"(# ")%A(=

$(1 %=

# % +$(%!"$!+

C%!

1% '(%"

I22;

5% '(%" B *!% " (=(

+#! !("

I42

$ I.04

(- B #( B # )"(# J

$ 0> 47 17

! ?4 << ><

77 7> 74

A * 7 4 7

A 9 > <

++)C $!

$ O . :> :> :>

1 0 1

0 0

C 0 0

%& * )% C %$!+!C $!

$ :0 ?: :6

& ( : ? :

% . 6 0 0

8,. @ % )%+(" B + &(

& . = . 3

$ < 0" ?:L "

3 9L 4L

. 3

" . .

(54)

!1)%( 8,23 @ % )%+(" B + &( & 1 C%! !% " =( #! !(" % )+(%"

8,6 C(% $! B DB %& $(%C%!"("

. (

. =

. =

" 76 (

( " 3

. = . (

" < 7

( 76

0 0

0 0

" ! "

' 1 " (

# %,

2

(55)

* ( 8,/3 D 5 5

+$!A!$= (%+( $ J

$ 4> 9

# 01 9

2 01 9

' 01 9

, < 4

/ 0? >

4> 9L (

$ " "

@ " / "

0? >L

. * "

8,/ $#(% +% C" 1% '

, 166?C6: *

< 9

. !

@ " " :6L

@ 166?C166: )* @ ! =

" , 0::> @

@ ,71 "

(56)

! ' @ "

@ # D 99L " D

74L & . 7:L 79L

" " "

D

' @ :6L "

. "

& . @ " " % " %. . !@ "

" %. . " %.

* ( 8,73 % C %$! B # )"(# 1% '! 1 !BB(%( $ +% C" J

% C ' ( K $+#!"! !& # $ $ # $ * = K!&* #= $

! @ 066 066 :> 066 :9 ?1 ?> ?? :7

# >? 9? 9: ?> 99 70 9> 71 <6

& . 066 066 << 6 40 6 066 6 7:

, 0> 74 19 04 9? ?1 4: 76 74

2 6 6 6 :4 <4 066 6 066 79

& <? 79 41 04 41 1: 91 07 4?

7? 49 4? 04 11 < : 14 17

2 91 <9 10 6 9 < 7? 0> 0:

- 6 6 6 6 49 1: 6 6 0<

, 6 6 10 ?6 < 6 7 6 07

6 04 46 6 1 6 11 04 00

(

. @

. $ < 1 . 0?L

1606 : ?L 166: !@

. 06 :L 166?C6: 4> :L 166:C1606

$

, ! " !

(57)

!@ * . "

!1)%( 8,.3 % C %$! B $ $ # )"(# + $( $ C C%! ! .004 ! .020

!" #

3 4 3 5 " ( ( 5 $6

7 ( 7 (

$ " = 0?L 1606

07 ?L 166: .

= %.

40L 166: 0?L 1606 $ < 4 " "

%. . "

(58)

!1)%( 8,63 % C %$! J B $ $ # )"(# + $( $ #! !(" ! .004 ! .020

!"#

! $ ( ( ( 6 % & % !

!! "

!! "

76 L =

166?C6: 166:C06

* ( "

"

=

8,7 (%$! !K(% "(

& . = . @

166:C06 $ < 7" 3 9? >L @

8 " @

=

C ; @

@ = "

@

(59)

!1)%( 8,/3 % C %$! B %&(%" '# "( (%$! !K(% B % C%! % #! !(" ! .004H20 ( "

)

)

!""

8 "

8,8 % )+$! % +$!+(" & 1 )%A(=( %&(%"

8,8,2 !( B % C%! !% " =( #! !(" & 1 &C ( %&(%"

. 166?C6: 4>9 ; C $ < 9

1:9; C8 " * %

. & ( & (;

$ "

(60)

!1)%( 8,73 C%! !( ! ! 1% &" C(% (+$ %(

)

$%&'

- % ! 7

9,

7 : 7

, $

:

;

1 :

8,8,. (( ="$(&" ! C%! !% " =( #! !(" %&! 1

. ! " (

0 ! $

! $ ( @ %#/ E 1 (

. = *

( *

" "

" 3 74L

< <

D

" * % "

D . 0>L "

01L 01L

. ( .

.

D .

(61)

* ( 8,83 % C %$! B C%! (( J ++(""( B% & !BB(%( $ )%+("

!"$%!+$

)%+(

( K ' $+#!"! # $ $ K!&* $

& 74 4? 4< 99 76 74

- 0< 0: 07 16 04 0>

$ 07 40 6 9 04 01

2 C ( 06 < 10 16 6 01

6 6 6 6 16 9

2 0 6 > 6 > 4

& %#/ 6 < > 6 6 4

% $ ! 6 6 6 6 > 1

$ * 0 6 > 6 6 1

& 6 6 > 6 6 1

' " < >

& (M 4<L " 09L

& (M

(62)

* ( 8,:3 % C %$! B "(( J ++(""( B% & !BB(%( $ )%+(" !" 11%(1 $( *= A %!($=

%!($=

)%+( C C%!D

E)((

C%!D

")C%(&(

C C%!D ! 1

$( 1 2

$

- 10 6 6 00 0>

& 4< ?4 066 9< 77

$ 04 6 6 00 00

2 1 0> 6 6 4

2 C ( 09 6 6 6 00

$ * 1 6 6 6 1

& %#/ 7 6 6 6 4

& 1 6 6 6 1

1 6 6 11 9

% $ ! 1 6 6 6 1

5 /3.*% 6 ! # #"

8,8,6 )%+(" B B %& $! % )+$! % ($! 1

. =

. - .

* " " % ( @ < ?

.

* ( 8,;3 )%+(" B B %& $! C%!

)%+( B B %& $! (%+( $ J

# * 16

/ * %#/ > 9

06

C- 09

$ C 46

/ 0> 9

(63)

< ?" . 46L .

* 16L .

$ * %#/ .

. ! ! @

. " 09L 5

8,: %!+(" %( " $#( + % ($

8,:,2 )=(%" B C C%!

& . $ < < :6L .

. 06L

( . .

( ! " , ! !

(

. "

(64)

!1)%( 8,83 )=(%" B C%! B% & %&(%"

)

)

!"(

$ !! " ! ' : " !

, ( $ < > >0L

( 1?L

0 ?L "

!1)%( 8,:3 )=(%" B #! !(" B% & %&(%"

)

)

)

!"(

$ !! " ! ' : " ! . $

(65)

. . $ < >

3 >6L J " J

!1)%( 8,;3 (%+( $ 1( B %&(%" ( ! 1 C%! ! !BB(%( $ $#" ! .004

* , % % *,!% $6 1 $6

!#"(

$ < ? . ! . J J

- . %

$ . .

(66)

!1)%( 8,43 (%+( $ 1( B %&(%" ( ! 1 #! !(" ! !BB(%( $ $#" ! .004

% *,!% $6 1 $6

!#"(

8,:,. %!+( ( " !$=

3 D 8

* D

$ < 06 J

8 ! J "

E "

D

. . / " .

" D

/ " % 8 "

. /

. .

(67)

!1)%( 8,203 A(% 1( C%! %!+(" $#( % C %$! B %&(%" ( ! 1 C%! $ $# $ %!+(

!&(

*, % ! % *, *,!% ,:," $6 26 1$6 3$6

!"" !&

7 . . $ " " ! ( <0= 7 <$(>(:=

. . "

!;796C. ! !;466C. ! >6L

! $ < 00

. .

.

. " "

(68)

!1)%( 8,223 A(% 1( #! !(" %!+(" $#( % C %$! B %&(%" ( ! 1 #! !(" $ $# $ %!+(

!&(

; & ;( ? ?( &# 6 %#

!"" # !" &

! !! " <0= 7 <$(>:=

8,:,6 ( $! "#!C *($'(( % (%" % )+(%"

$ D

- $ < 01

.

* D

!1)%( 8,2.3 ( $! "#!C B %&(% '!$# )=(%

(69)

) " " * +

!! " 7 ( & !

!#""

. $ : 7 . ," $

8,; %&D (A( &C($!$!A( ("" B C%! !% " =( #! !("

# . *

" ( 166?C6:

( . !;00"994 < :

.

(70)

* ( 8,43 5% "" %1! " B % C%! ! DB(

+$!A!$= !$ ' ( K $+#!"! # $ $ K!&*

!%(+$ C)$"

!;C8 966 <66 <96 966 766 946

, !;C8 1"666 1"966 1"196 1">96 1"?96 1"7>6

$ @ !;C8 01"666 01"196 00"796 01"666 01"196 00"::6

& . !;C8 >96 9<6 0"666 0"966 0"666 :<1

* )%

% !;C8 7"9<> <"7>9 <"479 7"9?6 4"79< 9"6?0

!;C8 4"109 7"010 9"164 4"79< 4":66 4":>:

& !;C8 1"974 1"??? 0":7< 1"1?: 0">96 1"1?4

' !;C8 4"111 4"1?0 7"6>1 4"776 4"714 4"7??

!;C8 0"796 1?6 0"166 9>9 0"766 :?0

8 !;C8 4"6<? 4"1?0 1"?66 4"796 1"7:> 4"60:

!;C8 0":6> 1"066 0"9>< 0"691 0"1<? 0"9?0

# !; 1"166 4"1?0 1"9>6 1"6?0 1"406 1"7??

& . !; 966 066 966 >96 966 7>6

$#(% + "$"

, !; 096 066 096 166 166 0<6

!; 6 466 6 6 6 <6

$ C)$ "$ H 6;>0:. /.>22: /2>:2. 6;>8.6 74>.0/ /6>4/8

!( 1H 6.2 6:7 6.0 6/7 6;: 874

( ! 1 C%!+( H 1 2/; 2/0 2/7 270 .07 27;

5% "" )( !;C8 7>"96? 91"966 7<"766 90">96 >:"449 99"7::

5% "" %1! H 4>/6; 20>6;6 />8;; 26>2.: .0>262 22>776

$ = " !; >:"666 < 06 8 "

*

?> 9 L

; @ )& = 166:C1606 "

" " 166?C6: % "

.

. "

(71)

* ( 8,203 5% "" %1! " B % !% " =( #! !(" ! DB(

PP 01 "

166:C06 166?C6:

. = "

=

0"?66 ; C8 & = @

+$!A!$= !$ !& LL # $ $ #= # $ * = 5

!%(+$ C)$"

!;C8 996 <?6 ?66 ?>9 >1< 19

, !;C8 6 4"966 4">96 1">66 17?> 96

$ @ !;C8 6 7"966 01"966 6 7196 66

& . !;C8 >96 ?66 <96 7?9 <>0 19

* )%

% !; 7"141 7"1?> 9":49 7"?66 7?04 96

!; 4"?<9 4":97 7"66< 4"<71 4?<< >9

& !; 1":<7 4"679 4"04> 1":77 4611 96

' !; 4"4?: 4"10: 4"?74 4"06> 44?: 96

$ @ !; 6 1"796 7"<91 4"7?4

1<7< 19

8 !; 9":74 1"<97 9"971 4">71 77>6 19

!; 1"947 0"1<> 0">:6 0"441 0>46 >9

# !;C8 1"097 0"749 1"066 0"066 0<:> 19

& . !; >96 716 <?6 9>9 <6< 19

$#(% + "$"

, !; 6 196 466 196

166 66

!; 966 166 6 6 0>9 66

$ C)$ "$ !;C8 47">94 66

!( ; C8 764 179 4?< 0<7 1:: 96

( ! 1 C%!+( !;C; 769 414 4:> 4:9 4?6 66

5% "" )( !;C8 0<4"109 >:"049 094"171 <7">?6 004"?06 66

5% "" %1! H 267>7;/ /8>/:/ 206>77: 67>:/7 :4>07:

& . = ! - 0?L

. 166:C1606 " 76 =

' . " ( " *

# !; >:"69>C8

. !; 00"994C8

(72)

:3

:,0 $% )+$!

. . "

8 "

4 166? ! # "

" ! 8

. .

* ! 8 166:"

! "$!$)$! B% &(' % "$!C) $(" $#( % (" B A %! )"

"$ (# (%" ! "(+$ % % ")*D"(+$ %> ")+# " C% )+(%"> 1 A(% &( $> C%!A $( ! "$!$)$! "> 5 ">

($+, $#(!% + % ! $! 1 &(+# !"&> $#( # %$!+) $)% "(+$ % ! '! !" +)%%( $ = ) %1 !K(

C(% $(" '!$# )$ + % ! $! 1 &(+# !"& % " 3

. (

.

= ( !

:,. $ (# (%"

. . =

" G

:,2,2 5 A(% &( $ B '!

& . = " ,

! $ ! ' ,

" 8 ! "

. = 8

. !

( * 1 ( 3 @

- & +

(73)

:,2,. B%!+ A("$ '! $

166<" ! (

( D

* . / " 1"<66

! 7" ! . " " "

= " " @ !" 166: $ " ! (

9"666 ! *

. = ! 166:" ! * 1>6 . ?6

= . * "

; " 8 ;

. ! ( "

!; 106C; ( . " !;0:9C; ( . 166: $

= " " 2 , " !;706C; " !;4?6C;

!;1?9C; "

:,2,6 #(($ # '!

, ! ( , " +

0::7 " ! 0::9 ! @ D 1660 , . !

0::9 " .

' " !

' , ! " "

@ .

0::9 " ! 09"666

! . ,

6 19 " ?9 . . " Q<6

2 @ N 6 ? " <76 . "

Q719

,; # ; 4 1 ' 1 # ;: # +

(74)

:,2,/

% * = ! ' 46 *

* .

. " % D 3

. " & ,) 3 *

= " ; ) " " %

. " " ! "

" 166: 1600 > 0

. 3 % = !

* ( :,23 .004D.022 &("$!+ (" B %

&("$!+

("

.004 .020 ("$!& $( .022 ("$!& $(

$(&

9) $!$=

1

)(

&! !

! + ) ! 1

9) $!$=

1

)(

&! !

! + ) ! 1

9) $!$=

1

)(

&! !

! + ) ! 1

8 ?9"106 >6 0 060"119 >0 4 000"47? ?4 7

! 4"9<7 7 ? >"664 > : >>"644 : 1

5 0?"4?? > 1 0?"?>< < 4 16"><7 > 7

8 9"741 7 7 <":?7 7 : >"<?1 9 >

)%+(3 $ + (+$( B% &

% = 3 * = 166:" * 161

" * * 14? 1606 / *

$ > 0 * * % 1606 1600

(75)

!1)%( :,23 .004D.022 &("$!+ (" B %

,-%.

? , @ A" B% !! " 7 : "

<B" $ = <B" $ =

)%+(3 $ + (+$( B% & ,

:,2,7 )+ $! % )+(

& . ! " @ "

2 166:" = %. .

2 . " * 9 1606"

& * . , " 166

%. . " ! 2 . *

" " ; "

2 8 " D

$ * " & (

4 = 4 . 166: 8 "

166:" 076 =

"

(76)

:,2,8 % "1 *( % )+( -C %$"

& * ! *

" @ " " ; $ ) "

8 " * . "

= " % 166:"

!;766C;

% !;796C; 166: . " 96

%

:,2,: C%! "" +! $! B '!

. 0::? ! )*

& , !)&, - 0::: " & ! .

= (

. & ! "

& ! = * " %

& ! % .

( * 7<">96

1664 $ > 1

& ! " * . "

D " & ! * D

. ( " @ " "

( $ " & ! ( .

. 3 & . & ! "

) ) & ! 1664 166< 8 " )

" .

" " & ! !;4:

* . ( .

" $ > 1

(77)

" 166?

! $ & ! =

!1)%( :,. 3 )&*(% B (&*(%" .000D.004

!//+

)%+(3

! & ! 1661 $ > 1 99"666 1661"

" 166: & ! 9"966 & !

1661 ( . 1660"

. " (

. 1661 8 " .

1661 .

:,2,:,2 @ % "$% ! $" +! 1

& ! " , " & ! 9"966

" " " & !

!;0"666

$ " , ! " ! ) " ; " "

. " & !

(78)

" !;06"666 . "

" & ! "

& ! .

& ! = ( " .

" & !

' " & !

& ! " (

:,2,; $ + %( '!

! , %#/ . E

( ( ( @ ! 0:::"

! ,

( "

* ! " + " ! @ D @

3 ! " .

) @ )& !@ & ,) 3 "

3 & ,) 3 . (

( . = .

3

:,2,4 !A! +!($= 1%!+) $)%( ($' %

, % . , %) ! . "

@ " @

! , %)

!

"

. , %) .

= " ! $

(79)

8 / @ ! 8/ /!9 , %)

8/ /! . =

. "

:,2,20 '! -C %$ % & $! ) +!

! )* & , !)&,

! = * " !)&, * "

" *

!)&, . (

* . " !)&, ! * "

& (

. . !)&,

. = *

. !)&,

*

:,. % ! $! & 1 $#( !BB(%( $ "$!$)$! "

*

. = ( * & !

. . " & !

$ " "

. . .

( * " .

.

@ 4 % &# 6 : ; 1 !@646;" 1 #

( ; 1 + A A #1 ! "' @646;

5

"+ 8 % (

B

"+ 6 : & ## B

"+ 8 & ## 1 B

%"+ < ( 1 % # * % % # 1 1 1

& +

@ 1 % ' @646; # % ( 1 -, / : (

: +

(80)

3 . " ! $ "

" %#/ " C *

" ! .

! " .

. " = "

. ( "

" (

+ )"! "

! # @ * (

. @ !

# !# ( '

# &

. . 8 "

* "

. " . "

. "

. " .

$ " . *

!

( " * .

.

(81)

;3 5

;,0 $% )+$!

A )( +# ! ("+%!*(" % 1( B A )(D ! 1 +$!A!$!(" %(E)!%( $ *%! 1 C% )+$ B% & !$"

+ +(C$! $ $#( B! + ")&(% ; . " 1666E ! , . @" 1660" ! . . " 166:

" = . " @

( .

$ * " & . ( !

) ! .

A )( +# ! " ")CC = +# ! "

' (

" "

" " "

" "

" " "

,- " 166:

( "

. "

,- " 166: " "

" .

;,2 ! +$ %"

;,2,2 & D + ( % )+(%"

& . ( ! ( "

. "

(82)

. !@ "

( . , <

;,2,. %1(D + ( % )+(%"

3 ( . ! ! !

! " !@ .

= $ "

D D . =

" ! * != * .

;,2,6 %1(D"+ ( % (%" % +("" %"

% 3 . ! " !

% ! ( . .

, ! " ! " =

. " % >

;,. #( '! C%! )( # ! C

$ ? 0 . " .

!1)%( ;,23 #( '! C%! )( # ! C

(83)

<, < 4

< C .

0 & * 4 & *

!"#$#%&

7 *

& 1 4 & *

& ; - #&

4 # - #

;

8 & # *

- #

'#$#('

7 *

& ; - #&

8 & # *

- #

) '##$#('

& *

&

&

8 & # *

(84)

! . ? 0

& . / .

" ( ( " . " .

$ " . %

% = .

% . $

? 1" ! 7">66 ; 166: >"666 ;

1606 ! .

!1)%( ;,.3 1 +# % % )+$! *= , .004D.020

9, % , < := C !, < A =

G / %

3 ( . (

. ( " , ! "

! " ! ! " % $ !

> ! .

166: . " ( . !;076C;

!;>9C; 2<

' ; 1 & & * 1 & 5

> 5 4 *C& & !# & " 1 # 1 * * B

(85)

' " . "

. & . . . 96 066. 8 & ! 1664 "

(-C %$ C + 1! 1 . . "

.

. *

" . * (

"$ % 1( . .

#

, . . $ " "

.

$ %1(D"+ ( $% (%"HC% +("" %"" * -

. $ * . " . . (

" . 0? . 077 019 ; .

" F 6 6:C; 166:

" "C!+( & )B +$)%! 1 + &C !(" *% (%""

* . " ; ) "

" % # ! = .

F1 96( F4 66C; 166:

. " "C!+( & )B +$)%! 1 + &C !("

. " %($ ! ")C(%& % ($""

+ ")&(%"

> 5 4 *C .& & 1 * #&

> 5 4 *C 1 # = # # D & #

> 5 8 1 & +

@ 1 % ' ; / & & & & * #

! 7"+ ; ( 1 + @ 1 % ' , % ; 1 & & *

& +

(86)

. $ ? 0 C *

. . C . "

( . . $ * " , !

! . . )

" )

. . !

;,6 #( '! !% " =( #! !(" )( # !

= ? 4

. " =

> &

" ! (

? 0 (

( " 3

( (

! " , " ! ) " % " & "

= " " (

$ * " 166: . " & )*

066 !;766C; "

% !;796C;

' . " "

" .

7 % : ( 1 ( # ' 1 % &

# ( # # ! % ,-8, ' "+

(87)

!1)%( ;,63 '! !% " =( #! !(" )( # !

!0 # "

# C < C .

7 * & ; - #&

7 *

8 & # *

* +'

8;*

; - #&

& # - & ( >

3

8

- #

) '##$#(' !"#$#%&

(88)

$ . ! " = " 2 ,

. 0? ; , 2 "

. 16 ; . . *

. " = * . ) "

" ! ) " 8 ;

* .

! .

' ) " . "

" " "

. .

. "

;,/ 5 A(% +( B $#( C%! !% " =( #! !(" )( # !

"1 A(% +( %(B(%" $ $#( C '(% $# $ ( C =(% ! $#( +# ! & = (-(%+!"(

A(% $#( $#(% C =(%" ,- " 166: "

" D " 2 !

. = = ( " .

" * D "

" .

! . ? 0 ? 4 "

. . !

) " ; $ * " ! (

. D . D

. " *

D

? 0 3 . = (

(89)

* ( ;,23 # % +$(%!"$!+" B $#( @ % =(%" ! $#( C%! !% " =( #! !(" )*D"(+$ %

# % +$(%!"$!+" #(($ #

' $

)1#

$(%C%!"(" $

B%!+ A("$

'!

! $ )+ $! % )+(

A

*

0< 4 7 46 0

, *

& . C

& . ,

& . & .

,

, ,

5 & .

* 166:

( 71 0 1>? 6 6

5 ,

* 166:

( 6 ?6 161 9

0 / 71 " 07 * . 8 "

! ) '

, !

& ,) 3 " "

, ! " % && % %

. = ( ? 0" %

* * = " .

. = / . " % *

= " " % " "

! . & .

" !

% . ! "

. ( C ( !

! . * .

. * ) " .

! .

( " D

(90)

;,7 (%$!+ %!K $ ! 1(" ! $#( C%! !% " =( #! !(" )( # ! "

7 8

8 + .

" .

, .

" . * "

! "

! ! * " @

09 16 # "

# , = !

3 != # "

D . .

D . $ " " !

( . = " .

/ . C . (

. " . .

. D

9 : 8

,$ * " ( .

" ! '

" !

. '(A(%> ! $(%D

B!%& + C(% $! " $#( *)=(%"HC% +("" %H(-C %$(% (A( !" + ! 1, .

. . " "

@ . "

(91)

;,8 C1% ! 1 $#( C%! !% " =( #! !(" )( # ! "

5 D . .

( ; .

! " 1660 5

. D ,- 166: "

. G

% +("" )C1% ! 1 (

% )+$ )C1% ! 1N

"

) +$! )C1% ! 1N *

.

. = C% +("" )C1% ! 1

"

.

. = .

= ( 7 4 $ "

166? .

. !; 09 16 !; <9 66 !; 069C

166<C6> ( "

!;006 66 !;76> 66" " .

, 3 .

(

* ! / " ! *

( " D

!

(92)

. . !

& . =

1% &!+ C% +$!+(" * @ '

" D

$ " " (

*

( = 466

0?6 06"666 " 0 ? C

," 1660 . " 1 6 C

. N 6 7?

C 6 4> C . ! # " 166?

1606 . = < < 06

% )+$ )C1% ! 1 ! = . =

! * . ( "

" .

. (

. ? 7

(93)

!1)%( ;,/3 + %!$( C%! ' (% A ! * ( ! ! )C(%& % ($" ! '!

)%+(3 !+$)%( $ ( *= )$# %"

),/ & . ! . 166:

(-C %$! 1 C C%! C ' (% !" $ ( "$ .,7 $!&(" & %(

C% B!$ * ( $# "( ! 1 %!( C C%! $ * " 166: 07 ! .

!; 9 " 1? . *

" !; 7

" " * (

$ < 9 0 ; .

D C *

166:" !;49?C; " . !;166C;

$ " $

(94)

. , ! 2

- )* -)

" 0 ; !;<91 96

!;74? . 8 "

Referenzen

ÄHNLICHE DOKUMENTE

One objective of this paper is to give an introduction to the meaning of the terms poverty and vulnerability, and to present an overview about different concepts. This will be done

Third, the performances of both China and Germany in terms of their GVC participation are examined and compared by making use of three different TiVA-based

The Cambridge Guide to American Theatre 9 contains no entry on Tully, although The Bird of Paradise is indexed in the entry on Oliver Morosco, the play’s producer, without reference

explain part of the non-adoption puzzle for hybrid maize. Empirical evidence

Wir haben unsere Webseite runderneuert und dabei Platz geschaffen für neue Rubriken, neue Features und ein neues Fortbildungsmodul. Tägliche News mit Neu igkeiten rund um

How can we use it, having realised that abstract labour pertains to the social relations of production, rather than to the productive forces, and that it is just the labour time

Because participants consistently chose highly rewarded targets, this observation could arise due to the choices themselves or because higher choice-trial proportions

Madhuca indica Gmel.; Pongamia pinnata (L.) Pierre.; Salvadora oleoides Decne.; Salvadora persica Linn.; Jatropha curcas Linn.; Balanites aegyptiaca (L.) Delile.; Sapindus