!
"
#
$
% #
% $
%
%
"
& %
% %' %()
*+,-.%*+,.*%/0.1
Ê Ê
Ê
Ê
Ê
! "##
##$ % &''(
#
'
# &)*+( ,
' - . "
'
*
½
¾
!"# $" %!
%!
'
" - . 01 2
# " 2
3
. .
#! .&4'5(
,# .
& 6( ' &*( # # #
# #
.2 7
2 8
" ,
# " 2
" # $ . 7
" " # $ %
" &( #
. #
$
.2' &)(
3 3
3
3
34
1 .2
&( #
, "
, "
" , " -
.2 "
&'(" #
# # 9
# # &+( &:( '
$
" .2' '2
$ &3(&4( &3( #
.2'" 2
, # " #
" " ,
"#$#
. 8 &4(
.
"
3 6
3
3
Ê
Ê
3
3
3
!"
# "
$ % $ & !"
! % !
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
exact solution Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
3
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
−10
−5 0 5
10 exact solution
Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
*)4
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
exact solution Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
'4
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
−10
−5 0 5
10 exact solution
Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
43
- ; 1 ! 6 3
3
#
9 " "7 # !
# 7 "
#
&3(
1 .2' &6(
<#'$ "#
/ $ % &6(# #
- .2
# " , # .
. .2'
=" & '( .2 "
#" #
#"# %$
.2'
## % .
#### " .
$
% 7 8 ' # "
.2' .
=" / "
,2" " 2
## %
#
."#" "#"
"
#"
" , % ##
. "
" # -
" %8 *
" "
% #
8 6 - #
" % "
%
# # .
"
" 7
" "
8 4 7 # # > "
" #
>"
%. # "
. = . "
? " &' (
'
Ê
. Ê Ê
Ê
Ê
$ Ê ''
/ Ê
$ $
9&6'(''"
$ $
8 "# " 1
" $ #
-
! ' $
Ê
; Ê
; Ê
- # " 2
"'
;@ Ê
;@
##
;$ $
/
Ê
;
%
; Ê
;
! A " .2
! "
.2' 8 .2' "# " 2
B "
;$ ; Ê
;
; 9 &'( '
."
' &
( 3
! ' /
- " / C
$
C
; C
%
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
,#"
C
C
#" # ¾
<#
@
@
'*
" 7
@
"
'*
'6
@
Æ
'* ". '&*(
"'6.'!' %
"
!
) " "
@
@
@
@
!*
$ $
%
@
$
@
$ $
@
;
@
@
;
;
8$
@
$ "
@
/
9 !
@
@@
@
A"
@
@
@
@@
@
%"
@
$
@
$ -"
@
;
@
@@
@
@
;
¾
"
" ! ) !
!
- .2'
&*(
Ê
% / Ê
%
.
;
%
"
3! ;
>.# 7#
% #
,' ! 2
;
- # A" '
#"
'4
'4
#"
':
')
'5
" "
% /
"2
" "':2'5
'+
'3
'
' # .
%$ '+ " ,
; ;
''
&6(,''
# ''
/
A"''
, 9, ' " "
-" '3 # .
## ' '
#"
! , '' 9
'*
;
.
,#"
;;
? '+2' ' 2
#
." # #
, '' " "
" " ' ,
$ " #
&364( #
#$. " # ,
" 7
" .
, .
.
#
#
' " =- 9D E" 2
92D Æ .
$ , %
" 2
" - '#
num. method
inherent ODE
num. method inherent ODE discretized DAE discretized DAE
decoupling decoupling
+ constraints (discretized) + constraints
- ';
# " ':2'5 '
'+ , '32'
B" " 2
,
1 " ##
## '3
## ,
- " "7
%=-
.2' '
&(
*
;
;
;
&(
;
9D # Æ .
A" 9D
#""
&!(
!
"# *'
!
;
;
;
;F
;
&!(
;
F
!
"#
,#"
!
A2
" =-
92D
=- 9D 2
" " !
.2
B.
!
% G2
H
;;
&
(
&
(
;
=-
F
9D
# - ' 2
* *'
*#"
&(
**
&(
*6
*4
.$".$""! "**2*4
" 9D*'
- .
&%(
;
%
=-
&%!(
;
F
%
!
%
9D " . % ! %
" "**2*4
& (
& (
& (
*:
& (
& (
*)
*5
9D # "
. $".$" "! "*:2*5
B # "
*: ,#" *5"
*)
. . "*:2*5 2
#"# =- 9D
' 77 ¾
%"*:2*5
' , ! '+2'
7 - '
& (
*+
& (
*3
*
" . $".$" "!
"*:2*5"*+2*
& (
*'
& (
**
& (
*6
%. *'2*6
!
"
& (
3
& (
3
"
& (
3
% " ?= # ? *
" - '
%!
& !+ !
"
'".# 3 %
! 7! "
.2 &'( ¾
!
" "
" " - #
2
2
7
,- . /$! "" !"
3 3
3
3
6
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 0
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
exact solution Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
3'3
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
1 exact solution
Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
3'5
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
exact solution Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
3':
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
1 exact solution
Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
34'
- *; 1 6 3
#
#
!"+ "+ "
! 34 0 $ *
!"
/ !" ! !+ !
'+ /$ $!" !)&
3
3
3
Ê 3 ! !
+! $ )
B
6'
# "
&'( " 6'
? "
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 0
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
exact solution Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
3'3
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
1 exact solution
Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
3'5
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
exact solution Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
3':
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
1 exact solution
Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
34'
- 6; 1 6 3
#
#
- " ." 6'
C
C
C
6*
.Æ C
C
C
C
C
C
9 6*
C
C
&'( -
% '' 6*.&"6'. &
&&'
8$ " "
A . B" 2
3
3 3
3 3
3
3
3
C
C
3
C
Ê
;
3
C
Ê
;
."#
# - 4 1
" 2
0 0.5 1 1.5
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
1 exact solution
Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
3
0 0.5 1 1.5
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
exact solution Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
*)4
0 0.5 1 1.5
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
1 exact solution
Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
'4
0 0.5 1 1.5
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
exact solution Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
43
- 4; 1 ! 6 3
3
#
9 &6(
$ Ê
!
$ $
' '
'
'
$ '
'
'
Ê " ( )
$
$ ) $
. ' ' "
C
3Ê
3 C
Ê
33
% Ê
, # 6*
C
C
"".# " 2
#
"# -
66
64
6' "# 6*
"
- .2'
1 " .2'" 2
#"
"# "
1 ) ! "! )*
C
C
)) )2
6:
B ! 66 9
7 C
C
B
$
3
-
# *
+
*+ Ê
% "
@
@
@
* * C
*
@
@
+
+
C
+
@
C
* C
+
C
C
@
3 A"3
B 64 9
#"
C
C
% #
+ *+ Ê
% "
@
@
@
C
* C
@
C
*
@
@
C
+
C
@
C
+
0". "
@
@
@
C
C
@
@ C
@
C
* C
@
@
C
@
C
+
C
$
@
C
$
@
C
*33
%
# ¾
<# '* " 7
@
6)
'* '6 " #
7 9 .2'"
Ê
% # #
"
1 * !)
)-
Ê
65
, #6)$ % #
"# $
3 -
#
% "
@
@
@
@
@
@ @
@
@
@
@
@
@ @
@
1"#. "
@
@
@
@ @
@
@ @
$
@
$
@
3 $
$
3 ¾
6: 7 6: $
# "
"
" 6: !
" #
" # 6'"
"" "
% " B
.
B " #
, ,
,, ,, 6+
% "
) !
)3 !+!,
"#
C
; , C
;, C
; ,,
% '' C
C
-"
C
C
, ,
C
C
, ,
¾
) !
)3 !+! ,
"#
C
; , C
;, C
; ,, - %
''$ C
C
A"
C
C
, ,
C
C
, ,
¾
1 6' 2
" 6+ - "
" ?
=- 6'C
=-
6+ I 8*
&(
63
,
&,(C
,,
C
6
8 "
&(
,
&, (C
,,
C
C
3
%#
&(C
C
,
&,(C
&C (
,,
C
8"
82
'
& (C
C
,
&,(C
&C (
,,
C
6'
0"6'" $
C
6*
- "
"
4 /$56
) C
)3 ,
"#
+
C
C
C
C
& (C
+
C
"3-
% 6:"
C
' % 6: # 2
" &'( ""
!"01 "
.
# >. #
! $ - "
"&4($
"=- 9D
> "# " ¾
,
&, (C
&(
,, 3
0"6'" 6*
&(C
C
3
8 ""
"
&
C (
C
3 66
% =-
.,
C 8 #"
C
3 "3- 667
C
0 "
C
9
6*
C
? ='"
,
&,(C
& (C
,,
0"6'"
!"
C
& (C
C
8
C
3#
C
C
-
"C . " 6'
C
C
C
C
& (C
¾
$7 !
+ + +!
3
3 3
3 3
3 3
3 3
.
3
3
+
64
G v(t)
e e
C (t)
1
1 C 2 2
- :; ?
3'4
' "
+63'4'+
63'4'
. *34'
3
33.3*4 5
3 3
3
Ê
;
"
Ê
;
3
! $- ! ""!
+ ! )7
! 4 /$ 56
)C
)3 ,
"#
+ '
& (C
C
&
(
6:
C
C
C
3
- =- - 2
6:
- 9D #
0 5 10
−1 0 1 2 3
t
e 1
exact solution Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
0 5 10
−4
−2 0 2 4 6 8
t
j
exact solution Implicit Euler Method BDF2 RadauIIA−Method
- ); 1 . .2' 64
73'
' 8
=-
6' C
6+ " " %2
65 -
C
3
C
3 $3-
* % 65 > "
&4(
- ?=*
,
&,(C
& (C
,,
0"6'" 6*
&(C
C
& (C
C
" 6 "
!
C
%$ ? =*
& (C
C
&
(
, "6'"
? =*
,
&,C(
&C (
3
,,
3
C
C
3
% 6* # # ¾
" # $ % $ &
1 .2' ' ! # &3
9
Ê
'*
4
Ê " 9,
4'
;
-
> "2# "
Ê
" "
% > " 9,
#
% > "
# > ,#" " 4
/ " $ >
? ## ## '
%
# !
%.
# ! , .
# !
.2
1 & ""+ ! 4
$
'+! Ê
4*
46
;
-
" !
C Ê
C !
4* !"; C
"
4*
3
3
.2'
I 464*"
¾
- " #" "
?3#"4
44
&
8 "/0 3
'+
0
4:
Ê
Ê
3 4)
3
"?4 $4)
; -
3 # #
" 9, "
0
¾
A" #" #" >
#
- (1 3 2
#"!4' #&3(
8 Ê Ê
# 2
#" Ê Ê
B Ê 2
Ê
2 " . "
" # Ê Ê
.
2
%
;.
Þ Ä
Þ
% % Ê Ê
% Ê
Ê
1" #
4 & +
@
Ê
!" @ @
'
@
@
45
@
@ 4+
@
@
43
3
. " 9D >2
#" > # "
4 &
" + 56 ""
&
@
+
@
@
@
Ò
@
@
Ò
Ò
@
$3 + "9
# 9, ¾
A #""
& " "+
3 +
3 +
!"
"+ !+ 3 ("
& " 8 5: "
"+
3 +
3 +
!"
- .2'' 2"
3 4
- . /
@3
@
0/3
3 4'
"
@
@
0
4*
#? 4#"" >
@
@
0
46
3##
=" &'*'(
4& 2&& 42&!"+
2&*
8 "
+ ;+
@
@
0 2
2/3
3
3
3
8"
4 ;43
@
@
0 2
3
+ " !
( ! 8
"+ + "9
! 8 !
4 # 4' #2
="$
;C
" .2'
C C C 44
C;
C
3!
1 C
C %
'44# 9, >
>#
+ ;+
@
@
0 2
2/3 4:
> ' # #
3 3
3
3
3 4)
%'
4 ;43
@
@
0 2
3
3
3
2/3 45
B > "
##"
# "
8 #
>
2
> $
&
(
5 $ 4+
5 /3" 7
8 $ #"#"2
6;
!+
67 3
8 " 2&7 @;
@
0;
! 3 3
3
3
8
" 2&-
+ " "
!"! 8 "+
8 +"9 !
$ ! 8
4
;43
@
@
0 2
3
3
3
5
! ? 4: # 0 /
3 % 9, # 0 / 3
"
; % 9,
%6 - #"
%6%6
0
60
7
7
B@;
7
@
'
3
7
@ 9,!#"" ¾
' #
- # " 2
% "
> . " 2
"# $ ., ,
! 7 " # $ .
- . 2
! " " "
" ' 8
"# "" - 2
.2'
# " > >
".2' >"
% 6: "
>" % 65
# " $6:
! " # 2
" #
6:! #
"
#$
A .2' ' # &
( ?
#" "-2=-
!
&(
Æ
$-
Æ
2 ?
2
#
$ 3 # .
2
;
$3
5
;
&(
&(
$-
&(
;
1
5
3 $-
%
&2(
2
5
Æ
$- '
* % "
*:*)*5 #
"2
"5
Æ
B
Æ
;
2
$3-
& (
&
Æ(
1 "
*:
2
-"
#
. 2
.
2
. 5
Æ
.
Æ
*
7 1 "*$"
" 7
"*
. # Æ
3$3
.
2
.
5
=-# 3
,
8 " 9D
( )
" "" ;
"#8 9 !! " 89 9
98 8 + !( 89 898 9
1 !% "# 8 % 8 8% %
$ %$ 9 %9 %
1 ! ! % 8 8
8 $ % %8 3 %8 3
%8 3%
&8(
3%
&8(
3
1 ! "# % ! 8 %
88" %8 8
%83%
&8(
&8(
%
&8(
&8(
J A B
/ 9 8 %988%8
%98 %98 3 8 " %8 3
%8 3 -" %
&8(
%
&98(
%
9&8(
3 2
" %
&8(
J # #""
/ 9 %"%9 9988 ¾
# $%& A
/ $
! 7 #
? / ="
- /
;
3
3
3
3
0 #
/
"#
,, 3 =
,
&,(
&(
3 ='
,,
=*
,
&,(
&(
=6
0! " "$" $
,
,
3" ?==
,
=* ,
,, 3 ?=#
,
&,(
,
&, (
B " # #
,
,
,
&, (
&
(
& (
" ? = =' ,
,, 3?=#
,
&,(
,
&, (
,
,
2
# =6 ¾
" 4! " < ,;
"#
,,
=4
,
&,(
& (
=:
,, 3 =)
,
&,(
&(
3 =5
0! " "$" $
8
,
,
=4
" #?= ,
,, 3 " ? =
,
&,(
,
&, (
B"# #
,
,
=: 8
,
=)
,,
3
1,
,, 3
?=#
,
&,(
,
&, (
& (
I ? =
,
&,(
&(
& (
3
=5
¾
&( 8"
""8 0K8A A6++*+42'3
&'(
! 2
/ 2I# L=
L 0$J '33325
&*( 1
# 1
+5+
&6( ! 1 0 0"
" =<% 8 ++5
&4( "
#
$%&' 8 "
01 KA % '5
'333*M:'
&:( ()* + ,-! 92D
K A 0 M'
+++6+M:
&)( . ( , 0 8 2
N 8"8 0K1 '+56):M)'5
&5(
(
! 1
I# "D B900J 3N3
&+( (-
2
% ?7+5:
&3( ,/ +0!
, "
.2' 2 80 K 1
6*4++5*':M*6:
&( + ,-!
-
" 2I# L = L 0$J
'333M'3
&'( + ,-! &' 1 " 2
.2 2I# L = L 02
$J '33M34
&*(
.2' M 90
4+5+65M)
&6(
" 2I# L
= L 0$J '3332'
&4(
#
1-! "7 "
# . 2I#
= L 0$J ++2'% 0A
&:( !,!""
"A I# "J A ID++5