• Keine Ergebnisse gefunden

112 Religion in Philosophy and Theology

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Aktie "112 Religion in Philosophy and Theology"

Copied!
26
0
0

Wird geladen.... (Jetzt Volltext ansehen)

Volltext

(1)
(2)

Religion in Philosophy and Theology

Editors

Helen De Cruz (St. Louis, MO) · Asle Eikrem (Oslo) Thomas Rentsch (Dresden) · Hartmut von Sass (Berlin) Heiko Schulz (Frankfurt a. M.) · Judith Wolfe (St Andrews)

112

(3)
(4)

Josiah Royce

Pragmatist, Ethicist, Philosopher of Religion

Edited by

Christoph Seibert and Christian Polke

Mohr Siebeck

(5)

Christoph Seibert is Professor of Systematic Theology, Ethics, and Philosophy of Religion at the University of Hamburg.

Christian Polke is Professor of Systematic Theology and Ethics at the Faculty of Theology of the Georg-August-University of Göttingen.

orcid.org/0000-0002-2915-1326

ISBN 978-3-16-159857-9 / eISBN 978-3-16-159858-6 DOI 10.1628/978-3-16-159858-6

ISSN 1616-346X / eISSN 2568-7425 (Religion in Philosophy and Theology)

The Deutsche Nationalbibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliographie;

detailed bibliographic data are available at http://dnb.dnb.de.

© 2021 by Mohr Siebeck, Tübingen, Germany. www.mohrsiebeck.com

This book may not be reproduced, in whole or in part, in any form (beyond that permitted by copyright law) without the publisher’s written permission. This applies particularly to repro- ductions, translations and storage and processing in electronic systems.

The book was printed on non-aging paper by Laupp & Göbel in Gomaringen and bound by Buchbinderei Nädele in Nehren.

Printed in Germany.

(6)

#$+!"#('

,=:6GI>8A:HI=6I6G:EG:H:CI:9>CI=>H7DD@<D768@ID68DC;:G:C8:DC"DH>6=

*DN8:6II=:/6G7JG< 6JH>C 6B7JG<=:A9>C'8ID7:G ,=:N6G:HJE EA:B:CI:97NILD;JGI=:G8DCIG>7JI>DCH;GDBI=::9>IDGH

G6I=:GADC<I>B:=6HE6HH:97:IL::CI=:68IJ6A8DC;:G:C8:6C9I=:EJ7A>

86I>DCD;>IH;>C9>C<H AAI=:BDG:L:;>GHID;6AA:MEG:HHDJG<G6I>IJ9:IDI=:

6JI=DGH;DGI=:>GE6I>:C8:6C9LDJA9A>@:IDI=6C@I=DH:E:GHDCHL=DHJEEDGI:9 I=>HEGD?:8I>C9>;;:G:CIL6NHHIG>9)J>8@6C9C9G:6=A:GH;DG7DI=G:K>H>C<

I=:C<A>H=K:GH>DCHD;CDCC6I>K:6JI=DGH6C9EGDD;G:69>C<(6JA6J99:G

%6G@JH >G8=DL +>BDC "JC<C>8@:A 6C9 &DG6 %:N:G ;DG I=:>G 6HH>HI6C8: >C 8DBE>A>C<I=:>C9:M:H6C967DK:6AA'A>K:G.DGC;:A9;DG=>H=:AEL>I=6AAHI:EH

>CB6CJH8G>EIEG:E6G6I>DC

$6HI7JICDIA:6HIL:I=6C@I=:EJ7A>H=>C<=DJH:%D=G+>:7:8@;DG6AAHJE EDGI6C9I=::9>IDGD;I=:H:G>:H[*:A><>DC>C(=>ADHDE=N6C9,=:DAD<N\(GD;

!C<DA;- 6A;:GI=;DG=>HL>AA>C<C:HHID>C8AJ9:I=>H7DD@>CI=:H:G>:H

6B7JG<TII>C<:C+:EI:B7:G

=G>HIDE=+:>7:GI

=G>HI>6C(DA@:

(7)
(8)

!$$#(#('

8@CDLA:<9B:CIH .

!CIGD9J8I>DC

%"*##"'""'&

#,'*"%!'&!" &!

<+>0.(.3

,DL6G96AD76A(=>ADHDE=>86A>H8DJGH:DC*:A><>DC

*DN8:*:G:69H#6CI6C9 :<:A>CI=:$><=ID;"6B:H6C9(:>G8:

,=:G:7N'E:C>C<[/>C9DLHIDH>6C,=DJ<=I\

/90:;67/",0),9;

,=:I=>86A&J8A:JHD;*:6A>IN

*:;A:8I>DCHDCI=:DJC96I>DCHD;*DN8:^H,=:DGND;#CDLA:9<:

6<.3(:5+,9:65

/=6I(=>ADHDE=N%:6CIID"DH>6=*DN8:

")( "'#!!("', '&##, ',

>(@5,#<5:;(33

/:G::HI>C:9ID:%DG6A6>AJG:H

*DN8:^HI=>86A!CH><=IH6C9 >H8@CDLA:9<B:CID;'JG!C:K>I67A:%DG6A 6>AJG:

3,?(5+,903076=0M

*DN8:6C9%:69DCI=:DJC96I>DCHD;I=>8H

(.5<:"*/3,;;,

[2Y38=DDH:NDJG86JH:6C9H:GK:>I \

,=:!C9>K>9J6A>O6I>DCD;I=:%DG6A$6L688DG9>C<ID+>BB:A6C9*DN8:

(9)

'/0:3=4=<B3<BA

.!!!

/90:;0(5632,

$DN6AIN6C9DK:C6CI

'C*DN8:^H+E>G>IJ6ADBBJC>I6G>6C>HB

"'%$%'" #(&+$%"

""#'&# ('

!6),9;<4405.:,=033,

*DN8:^H(=>ADHDE=ND;*:A><>DC

G>I>86AEEG6>H6A

,:*/,05+,

[23G:A><>DCD;I=:HD8>6A8DCH8>DJHC:HH \

*DN8:^H,G6CHA6I>DCD;=G>HI>6C*:A><>DC>CID+D8>6A(=>ADHDE=N

6C9 >HDC8:EID;!CI:GEG:I6I>DC

,026"*/<3A

,=:-CHJGE6HH67A:DD9

*:8DCH>9:G>C<*DN8:^H,=:D9>8N

(9;05&,5+;,

[,=:!CI:GEG:I:GL=D>CI:GEG:IH6AAID6AA \

,=:EEGD68=D;*DN8:>C >H$6I:G/DG@HIDI=:!9:6D;I=:7HDAJI:Z

>CDCK:GH6I>DCL>I=I=:!9:6D;D96H6450;<+69,(30;(;0:;GDB#6CI K>6 :<:AIDI=:$6I:G+8=:AA>C<

$>HID;DCIG>7JIDGH

!C9:MD;&6B:H

!C9:MD;+J7?:8IH

(10)

#(&$)($#

%&'#$%'"%&'"#

II=:IJGCD;I=:8:CIJGN"DH>6=*DN8:6ADC<H>9:/>AA>6B"6B:HL6H HJG:ANDC:D;I=:BDHIEGDB>C:CI;><JG:HDC&:LC<A6C9^H>CI:AA:8IJ6AH8:C:

GJ8:#J@A>8@=6H9:H8G>7:9I=:H:96NH>C9:I6>A6H[,=:DA9:C<:\D;6B 7G>9<:%6HH68=JH:IIH (:G=6EHI=:8=6G>HB6I>86JG6D;7DI=I=:=JB6C>I>:H 6C9I=:H8>:C8:HL=>8=L6H6HHD8>6I:96ABDHI:M8AJH>K:ANL>I= 6GK6G9-C>

K:GH>IN>HC:K:G6<6>CID7:G:E:6I:9 DL:K:GI=:ILD<>6CIH6HL:AA6HI=:>G 76IIA:G:<6G9>C<I=:7HDAJI:HJ;;:G:99>;;:G:CI;6I:H 'C:D;I=:B/>AA>6B

"6B:H=6H7:8DB:DC:D;I=:BDHIEDEJA6G6C9L:AA@CDLCH8=DA6GHH>C8:I=6I I>B:=>HLDG@H=6K:C:K:G7::C;DG<DII:C6C9BDG:DK:GI=:N=6K:7:8DB:

>C;AJ:CI>6A >C 9>;;:G:CI 6G:6H D; G:H:6G8= I=GDJ<=DJI I=: LDGA9 *DN8: L6H EGDK:9G><=IL=:C>C6B:BDG>6A699G:HH?JHIDC:N:6G6;I:G"6B:H^9:6I==:

H6>9[AG:69NL>I=>C6N:6GD;=>H9:6I==:2H8 "6B:H ( 3=6H7:<JCID 68FJ>G:HDB:I=>C<D;68A6HH>8G6C@6C99><C>IN !C;JIJG:I=>HG6C@6C99><C>IN L>AAADC<>C8G:6H: \

HDC:D;I=:;DJC9:GHD;EG6<B6I>HB7:H>9:H=6GA:H+ (:>G8:"6B:HHDDC 7:86B: I=: <>6CI D; B:G>86C E=>ADHDE=>86A EHN8=DAD<>86A 6C9 G:A><>DJH I=DJ<=IL=:G:6H=>H8DAA:6<J:6C9C:><=7DG>C!GK>C<+IG::I"DH>6=*DN8:

[&:LC<A6C9^H\K:GH>DCD; :<:AHJ;;:G:969>;;:G:CI;6I: 'CAN69:869:

6;I:G=>H9:6I=DC+:EI:B7:G=>HLG>I>C<HH::B:9ID7:DJI96I:9 6C9 =>H LDG@ ;:AA >CID D7A>K>DC '; 8DJGH: HDB: B:B7:GH D; 6GK6G9^H NDJC<:G<:C:G6I>DCEG:H:GK:9HDB:D;*DN8:^H8GJ8>6A>CH><=IH6C98DCI>CJ:9 IDLDG@DCH>B>A6G>HHJ:H />AA>6BGC:HI D8@>C<ADD@:96II=:FJ:HI>DCD;

D96C9A6G:C8:!GK>C<$:L>HG:H:6G8=:9I=:;>:A9D;AD<>8HIDB:CI>DC?JHI ILDD;I=DH: &:K:GI=:A:HH6HI=:;>GHI<:CJ>C:B:G>86CH8=DDAD;I=DJ<=I DI=:G;><JG:HEA6N:9I=:A:69>C<GDA:H9JG>C<I=:G:HID;I=:<DA9:CN:6GHD;

EG6<B6I>HB >C8AJ9>C< 6BDC<HI DI=:GH "D=C :L:N :DG<: :G7:GI %:69 6C9+>9C:N DD@ ,=:;68II=6I:L:N6C9%:69>CE6GI>8JA6GH=6G:9I=:>C I:G:HIHD;HD8>6AE=>ADHDE=N6C9B:I6E=NH>8HL>I=*DN8:L6HG:A:<6I:9IDI=:

; GJ8: #J@A>8@'63 %7A3 =4 ;3@71/< #67:=A=>6G /;0@7253 /AA/16CA3BBA S 16A:-C>K:GH>IN(G:HH&:L 6K:C$DC9DC

"DH>6=*DN8:c/>AA>6B"6B:H6C9I=:(=>ADHDE=ND;$>;:d>C"DH>6=*DN8:*7::7/;

/;3A/<2"B63@AA/GA=<B63#67:=A=>6G=4743%68B>AA6C&:L1DG@a

; "D=C#66<cB:G>86C!CI:GEG:I6I>DCHD; :<:A "DH>6=*DN8:fH(=>ADHDE=ND;$DN 6AINd#$a

(11)

6@7AB=>6&3703@B/<26@7AB7/<#=:93

768@<GDJC9 ;I:GI=:6C6ANI>86AIJGC>CI=:B>99A:D;I=:8:CIJGNI=:G:

L6H6C6ABDHI8DBEA:I:ADHHD;>CI:G:HI>C*DN8: :HE>I:I=>HE=>ADHDE=:GH HJ8= 6H "D=C +B>I= Z GJ8: #J@A>8@ 6C9 "D=C "

%8:GBDIIZ6HL:AA6H6;:LDI=:GHEJ7A>H=:9>BEDGI6CIHIJ9>:H DC*DN8: CDI=:GN:6GHE6HH:9=DL:K:G7:;DG:6869:B>8H7:86B:;JAAN 6L6G:D;I=:>BEDGI6C8:D;*DN8:^HI=>C@>C<6H>IG:A6I:HIDI=:8=6AA:C<:H6C9 EGD7A:BH D; DJG 8DCI:BEDG6GN >CI:AA:8IJ6A 6C9 HD8>6A A>;: /=D I=:C L6H

*DN8:C9L=N>H=>HI=>C@>C<HI>AA>BEDGI6CI;DGJHID96NCHL:GHIDI=>H A6II:GFJ:HI>DCL>AA7:EG:H:CI:9L>I=>CI=:HIJ9>:HD;I=>H8DAA:8I>DC DL:K:G HDB:H=DGIG:B6G@H699G:HH>C<I=:;DGB:GFJ:HI>DCH=DJA96AHD7:<>K:C>CI=>H

>CIGD9J8I>DC

"DH>6=*DN8:L6HI=:;DJGI=HJGK>K>C<8=>A9D;6EDDG;6B>AND;[/:HI:GC:GH\

>CG6HH.6AA:N6A>;DGC>67DGCDC&DK:B7:G ,=GDJ<=DJI=>HA>;:

I>B:=:G:B6>C:98DCC:8I:9L>I=I=:(68>;>88D6HI6C9I=:HJGGDJC9>C<6G:6H ,=>H 6AG:69N 9>HI>C<J>H=:9 =>B ;GDB BDHI D; I=: DHIDC>6C B6C96G>CH D;

L=DB6ABDHI6AA<G:LJE>CI=:L:6AI=N;6B>A>:HD;I=:6HI8D6HI *DN8:HIJ9

>:9E=>ADHDE=N6C98A6HH>8H6II=:C:LAN:HI67A>H=:9-C>K:GH>IND;6A>;DGC>6 L=:G:=:G:8:>K:9=>H ;I:GHE:C9>C<6C6869:B>8N:6G>C:GB6CN;>GHI

>C :>9:A7:G<I=:C>C$:>EO><6C9A6I:GDC>CTII>C<:CL=:G:6ADC<H>9:DI=

:GH=:6II:C9:9I=:A:8IJG:HD; :GB6CC$DIO:=:G:8:>K:9=>H(= DC[,=:

!C9:E:C9:C8:D;I=:(G>C8>EA:HD;#CDLA:9<:\;GDB"D=CH DE@>CH-C>K:GH>IN 6C9I=JH7:86B:D8IDGD;(=>ADHDE=N>C *DN8:B6GG>:9#6I=:G>C: :69 6C9 G:IJGC:9 ID =>H =DB: JC>K:GH>IN >C 6A>;DGC>6 6H 6 I:68=>C< 6HH>HI6CI >C C<A>H=A6C<J6<:6C9A>I:G6IJG: >H;>GHIL:AA@CDLC7DD@#/,!,30.06<::

7,*;6-/036:67/@L6HEJ7A>H=:9>CI=6IH6B:N:6G=:L6H6EED>CI:9 6HH>HI6CIEGD;:HHDG6I 6GK6G9-C>K:GH>IN *DN8:HI6N:9>C6B7G>9<:%6HH6 8=JH:IIHG><=IJCI>A=>H9:6I=>CH:GK>C<;GDB6H(GD;:HHDGD; >H IDGND;(=>ADHDE=N8=6>G>C<=>H9:E6GIB:CI;DG;DJGN:6GH;GDB6C96AHD 7:8DB>C< I=: A;DG9 (GD;:HHDG D; &6IJG6A *:A><>DC %DG6A (=>ADHDE=N 6C9

>K>A(DA>IN6I 6GK6G9-C>K:GH>IN JG>C<=>H;DJG9:869:HD;6869:B>8HIJ9N 6C9LDG@6II=>HG:CDLC:986BEJH=:LGDI:6C9EJ7A>H=:9BDG:I=6C69DO:C 7DD@H6ADC<H>9:B6CNDI=:G6GI>8A:H>C8AJ9>C<#/,"7090;6-6+,95/036:6 7/@ =>H >;;DG9 $:8IJG:H#/, &693+ (5+ ;/, 5+0=0+<(3 .DAH

<;305,:6-:@*/636.@#/,/036:67/@6-6@(3;@

#/, "6<9*,: 6- !,30.06<: 5:0./;: 6C9#/, 96)3,4 6- /90:;0(50;@

!CI=:;>C6A9:869:D;=>HA>;:*DN8:9:9>86I:9BDHID;=>H>CI:AA:8IJ6A LDG@IDI=:8DCC:8I>DCH7:IL::CB:I6E=NH>8HHD8>6AE=>ADHDE=N6C9AD<>8H

DG 7>D<G6E=>86A 9:I6>AH G:<6G9>C< *DN8:fH A>;: 6C9 =>H >CI:AA:8IJ6A 9:K:ADEB:CI 8;

"D=CA:C9:CC>C<'63743/<2'6=C56B=4=A7/6%=G13 *:K>H:96C9ME6C9:99>I>DC .6C9:G7>AI-C>K:GH>IN(G:HH&6H=K>AA:$DC9DC

(12)

<B@=2C1B7=<

6C96HHJ8==:L6H6AHDI=::M:8JIDGD;(:>G8:^HJCEJ7A>H=:9LG>I>C<H7G>C<>C<

I=:BID 6GK6G9

*DN8:L6H679(.4(;0:;I=DJ<=6EG6<B6I>HID;=>HDLC@>C9 !IL6H6;I:G

=>HH:G>DJHHIJ9>:HDC(:>G8:^HH:B>DI>8H>CE6GI>8JA6GI=6I=:JC9:GHIDD9=>H DLCI=>C@>C<ID7:6@>C9D;[67HDAJI:EG6<B6I>HB\L>I=6HIGDC<KDAJCI6G>HI>8

>BE68I DL:K:G=>HI=:DGND;>CI:GEG:I6I>DCL=>8=>HCDI=>C<:AH:I=6C6I=:

DGND;8DBBJC>IN8A:6GAN9:BDCHIG6I:HI=:EG6<B6I>HIEG>C8>EA:HD;=>HLDG@

&:>I=:GE:G8:EI>DCCDG8DC8:EI>DC86C7:I=:HI6GI>C<ED>CI;DGDJGJC9:GHI6C9

>C<D;G:6A>IN6C9DJGH:AK:H7JII=:68I>K:[/>AAID!CI:GEG:I\L=>8=H=DLH I=6I=JB6C7:>C<H6G:H:B>DI>86C>B6AHDCAN86E67A:D;68I>C<688DG9>C<ID G:6HDC 6C9 IDL6G9H I=:>G H:A;9:I:GB>C:9 <D6AH 6H 6 8DAA:8I>K: '; 8DJGH:

*DN8:C:K:G<6K:JE=>H8DC8:GCD;G:8DC8>A>C<I=:'C:L>I=I=:%6CNI=:

7HDAJI:6C9I=:I:GC6AL>I=I=:*:A6I>K:6C9I=:,:BEDG6A6C9=>HHDAJI>DC

>HC:>I=:GBDC>HI>8CDG9J6A>HI>87JIG:;:GHID6I=>G9@>C9D;6II>IJ9:I=:L>AA ID>CI:GEG:IL>I=>C6JC>K:GH6A8DBBJC>IN ,=:G:;DG:8DBBJC>IN>HI=:JAI>

B6I:EG>C8>EA:D;7DI==>HB:I6E=NH>8H6C9=>HE=>ADHDE=ND;A>;:

*DN8:L6H6AL6NH69,30.06<:;/052,96AI=DJ<=6;I:G=>HNDJI==:G:;JH:9 ID=6K:6C6GGDL6;;>A>6I>DCL>I=6CN8=JG8=8DC<G:<6I>DC :L6HG6>H:97N6 BDI=:GL=DL6H6IGJANE>DJHE:GHDCGDDI:9>CK6C<:A>86A>HB6C9L=D:9J 86I:9 =:G 8=>A9G:C >C I=: HE>G>I D; I=: 7>7A: ,=:G:;DG: ;GDB K:GN :6GAN DC

*DN8:L6HIG6>C:9>CI=:G:69>C<D;H8G>EIJG: %6N7:CDDI=:GG:EG:H:CI6I>K:

D; I=: B:G>86C E=>ADHDE=>86A IG69>I>DC G:;A:8IH BDG: 7>7A>86A =:G>I6<: I=6C 9D:H*DN8:I=GDJ<==>HG:;:G:C8:IDB:I6E=DGH6AAJH>DCH6C9E6G67A:H DL :K:G6H6G:A><>DJHI=>C@:G=:G:B6>C:9EG>C8>E6AAN6B:I6E=NH>8>6CL=DG:

E:6I:9AN>CK:HI><6I:H#/, <,:;0656-6+L=>8=>HI=:I>IA:D;DC:D;=>HBDHI 8DCIGDK:GH>6AE>:8:H GDB=>HK:GN;>GHIEJ7A>86I>DCI=:FJ:HI;DGI=:7HDAJI:

I=6I<J6G6CI::HI=:EDHH>7>A>IND;IGJI=6C9:GGDG6HL:AA6H<DD96C9:K>A6C9 L=>8==6H6I:A:DAD<>86AE:GHE:8I>K:DCI=:JC>K:GH:L6H:HH:CI>6A;DG*DN8:

*:A><>DCI=:G:;DG:G:EG:H:CIHB6C^HEG68I>86A6C9L>AA>C<Z6HL:AA6HG:6HDC 67A:6C98G>I>86A>CI=:7:HI86H:H8:C6G>DZH:6G8=;DGI=:JAI>B6I:B:6C>C<

D;=>HDLCA>;:6HL:AA6HI=6ID;=>H;:AADLH^A>K:H

,=>H >H L=N *DN8: L6H 6AHD 8DCH>9:G:9 ID 7: 6C,;/0*0:; K:C 6I 6 K:GN NDJC< 6<: *DN8: H=6G:9 6 L:6@C:HH ;DG +8=DE:C=6J:G 6C9 +E>CDO6 6C9 6

@>C9D;E:HH>B>HBI=6IL6H9::EAN8DC8:GC:967DJII=:+D8G6I>8FJ:HI>DCD;

6C ]:M6B>C:9 A>;: ^ : L6H I=:G:;DG: >C>I>6AAN 8DC8:GC:9 L>I= DK:G8DB>C<

BDG6AH@:EI>8>HB6H:MEDJC9:9JEDC>C#/,!,30.06<::7,*;:6-/036:67/@

/=6I=:A6I:GLGDI:67DJI"6B:H6AHD6EEA>:HID=>BH:A;I=6II=::I=>86A>BE68I H=6E:96AAD;=>HLG>I>C<H !CDC:H:CH:I=:FJ:HI;DG6<DD9A>;:6C9I=:FJ:H I>DC[/=D6B!\6AL6NH;>IID<:I=:G 'C:^H9::9H6G:L=6IB6@:HDC:^HA>;:

B:6C>C<;JA *DN8:^H>CI:AA:8IJ6A9:K:ADEB:CII=:G:7NG:K:6AH6H=>;I;GDB6C 6AA IDD H>BEA: EDH>I>DC D; I=: =6GBDC>O6I>DC D; 9>;;:G:CI >9:6AH IDL6G9H I=:

C:K:G:C9>C< I6H@ D; 7J>A9>C< 8DBBJC>I>:H L>I=>C 6C9 I=GDJ<= B6C@>C9 7N L6ND;68G>I>86AHE>G>ID;IGJ:6C9BJIJ6AADN6AIN !C6CN86H:6II=::C9D;=>H

(13)

6@7AB=>6&3703@B/<26@7AB7/<#=:93

A>;:*DN8:7:86B::K:CBDG:8DCK>C8:9I=6I;DG:K:GN=JB6C7:>C<B6N7:

:K:C;DGD9>I>HIGJ:I=6I

c364H 6 ;68I NDJG H:A; >H CDI 6C 6;;6>G D; I=>H BDB:CI 1DJG H:A; A>@: NDJG =6EE>C:HH DG JC=6EE>C:HHA>@:NDJG;6>AJG:DGHJ88:HH>H6=>HIDGN69G6B66A>;:FJ:HI3`41DJGDLC IGJ:H:A;H>BEAN9D:HCDICDL:M>HIID7:@CDLC !I7:ADC<HIDI=:E6HI6C9I=:;JIJG:6HL:AA 6HIDI=:EG:H:CI6C9NDJGL=DA:A>;:>HC::9:9ID:B7D9N6C9IDA>K:DJIL=6I>IB:6CH d

,=:;DAADL>C<HIJ9>:H;D8JHDC*DN8:^HEG6<B6I>HB:I=>8H6C9=>HE=>ADHD E=ND;G:A><>DC:MEG:HH9>;;:G:CIE:GHE:8I>K:H6C9IGNID6CHL:GI=:;>GHIFJ:H I>DC6HIDL=N=>HI=>C@>C<>HHI>AA>BEDGI6CI;DGJHID96N ,=DJ<=I=:N8:GI6>CAN 9>;;:G >C I=:>G K6G>DJH 6EEGD68=:H I:MIJ6A 76H:H 6C9 ;>C6A 6EEG6>H6AH D; =>H I=DJ<=I6AA6JI=DGHH=6G:68DBBDC>CI:G:HI,=:NL6CIID9>H8DK:GI=:G>8=

C:HHD;6CDJIHI6C9>C<E=>ADHDE=>86AI=>C@:G6C9I=JH7G>9<:I=:<6E7:IL::C 8DCI>C:CIH6C9E=>ADHDE=>86AIG69>I>DCH

!C=>H7GD6976H:9DE:C>C<HIJ9N<+>0.(.3H:IHI=:E=>ADHDE=ND;"D H>6=*DN8:6<6>CHII=:768@<GDJC9D;L=6I=:8DCH>9:GHID7:ILDEGD7A:B6I>8 6G:6HL>I=>C8DCI:BEDG6GNE=>ADHDE=NI=:HEA>I7:IL::C8DCI>C:CI6A6C96C6 ANI>8E=>ADHDE=N6C9I=:HIGDC<I:C9:C8ND;I=:E=>ADHDE=ND;G:A><>DCIDC6G GDL>IH;D8JHIDHJ7?:8IB6II:GHD;=G>HI>6C>IN +>C8:*DN8:^HB6IJG:E=>ADH DE=N>HCDIDCAN76H:9DC68G:6I>K:G:8:EI>DCD;=6GA:H+ (:>G8:^HH:B>DI>8H 7JI6AHD9>HEA6NH6K>I6A>CI:G:HI>CH>6CG:A><>DJHI=DJ<=IG:IJGC>C<ID=>H LDG@B6NI=:G:;DG:D;;:G68DBEG:=:CH>K:6AI:GC6I>K:IDI=:H:ILDEGD7A:B6I>8 E=>ADHDE=>86ADEI>DCH &6<AJC;DA9H=>H6G<JB:CI>CI=G::B6>CH:8I>DCH !CI=:

;>GHI=::MEADG:HHDB:D;I=:B:I=D9DAD<>86A6C9HJ7HI6CI>6A8A6>BHD;*DN8:^H HD86AA:9[H:B>DI>8IJGC\8DBB:CI>C<DC=>HG:69>C<HD;(:>G8:6C99>HI>C

<J>H=>C<;DJGBD9:HD;8DBBJC>IN !CI=:H:8DC9H:8I>DC=::MEADG:HI=:J GDE:6C768@<GDJC9D;*DN8:^HE=>ADHDE=>86AI=>C@>C<I=:G:7NE6N>C<HE:8>6A 6II:CI>DCIDI=:K:GN>BEDGI6CI7JID;I:CC:<A:8I:9,*;<9,:656+,95+, (30:4;GDB !C=>H>CI:GEG:I6I>DCD;I=:H:A:8IJG:H=:B6>CAN=><=A><=IH

;DJGED>CIHI=6I6G:D;9:8>H>K:>BEDGI6C8:;DGI=:>CI:AA:8IJ6A9:K:ADEB:CID;

*DN8:#6CI^HJC9:GHI6C9>C<D;I=:=JB6CH:A;6H6C:I=>86A8DC8:EI+8=:A A>C<^H6EEGD68=IDI=:8DC8:EID;I=:7HDAJI: :<:A^H9>6A:8I>88DBE6G:9ID (:>G8:^HH:B>DI>8H6C9*DN8:^HDLC:M6B>C6I>DCD; :<:AL>I=E6GI>8JA6GG:;

:G:C8: ID I=:/D564,5636.0, +,: ,0:;,: >C6AAN &6<A >CH>HIH I=6I *DN8:

A:6GCH6ADI;GDB :<:A7JIC:K:GI=:A:HH[86G:;JAAN6KD>9H7:8DB>C<6 :<:

A>6C \,=:A6HIH:8I>DC>H9:KDI:9ID=>HA>;:ADC<>CI:G:HI>CH>6CG:A><>DJH8JA IJG: 'CI=:DC:=6C9&6<A8DBE6G:HI=:8DC8:EID;ADN6AIN6H>I6EE:6GH>C

=>HA6I:GLDG@L>I=&:DDC;J8>6C>HB6C9DCI=:DI=:G=::MEADG:HI=:L6NH

>CL=>8=*DN8:>C8DGEDG6I:H>9:6H;GDB >C9J>HB6C9J99=>HB>CID=>HDLC

"DH>6=*DN8:c,=:+:A;d>C"DH>6=*DN8:/B3*@7B7<5A=::31B7=<=4(<>C0:7A632 /<2&1/BB3@32*=@9A.DA :9 6C9>CIGD9J8:97NG6C@% 'EE:C=:>B,=D:BB:HG>H IDA-#a

(14)

<B@=2C1B7=<

LDG@ :8DC8AJ9:HL>I=;6GG:68=>C<G:B6G@H67DJII=:EDI:CI>6AD;*DN8:^H BJAI>;68:I:9E=>ADHDE=ND;G:A><>DC;DGDJGEG:H:CI<AD76A>O:9LDGA9

/=:G:6H&6<AB6>CAN9:6AHL>I=I=:A6I:G*DN8:/90:;67/",0),9;^H6GI>8A:

<D:H768@IDHDB:D;=>HK:GN:6GAN7JIC:K:GI=:A:HH8:CIG6A6C967>9>C<>C H><=IH8DC8:GC>C<I=:;DJC96I>DCHD;@CDLA:9<: !CI=:>CIGD9J8I>DC+:>7:GI :MEA6>CH=>H=:GB:C:JI>86A6EEGD68=L=>8=>H:MEG:HH:97NI=:B:I6E=DG>86A E=G6H:6C[:I=>86ACJ8A:JHD;G:6A>IN \ :;JGI=:G6HH:GIHI=6I>CHDB:D;I=:

A:II:GHLG>II:CID/>AA>6B"6B:H*DN8:K:GN8A:6GAN:MEG:HH:HI=:>9:6D;[:I=

>86AE=>ADHDE=N\7:>C<I=:[=><=:HIE=>ADHDE=N \,=JH:I=>8HH::BHID7:G:

<6G9:96H7904(7/036:67/0( !CI=:;DAADL>C<I=G::H:8I>DCH+:>7:GIJC;DA9H I=:EG:HJEEDH>I>DCH6C9HDB:D;I=:8DCH:FJ:C8:HHJGGDJC9>C<I=>H>9:6L=>8=

8DCI6>C7DI=>9:6A>HI>86C9EG6<B6I>HI>8BDI>K:H :7:<>CH7NE6N>C<6II:CI>DC ID I=: 68I>K: G:A6I>DC6A 6C9 I:BEDG6A 8DCHI>IJI>DC D; 8DC8G:I: :ME:G>:C8:

L>I=>C*DN8:^HI=>C@>C<I=:G:7N:BE=6H>O>C<I=:;68II=6II=:K6A>9>IND;?J9<

B:CI67DJI6;68ID;:ME:G>:C8:>HCDIHDB:I=>C<I=6I>H<>K:C7JIHDB:I=>C<

L=>8=C::9HID7:68I>K:AN9:K:ADE:97N8DCI:MIJ6AHD8>6A6C9I:BEDG6A:M I:CH>DC <6>CHII=>H768@9GDE+:>7:GI:ME6C9H=>HHIJ9ND;I=:HIGJ8IJG:D;

I=:;DJC96I>DCHD;@CDL>C<6H=:9:6AHL>I=I=:G:A6I>DCH=>E7:IL::C>CI:GHJ7

?:8I>K>IN 6C9 C6IJG: >C I=: H:8DC9 H:8I>DC ;I:G 8DCHIGJ>C< I=: :ME:G>:CI>6A EGD8:HH D; @CDL>C< 6H 6C DC<D>C< HIGJ<<A: L>I= C:<6I>K>IN =: I6@:H JE

*DN8:^H L:AA@CDLC 9>;;:G:CI>6I>DC 7:IL::C I=: [LDGA9 D; 9:H8G>EI>DC\ 6C9 I=:[LDGA9D;6EEG:8>6I>DC\6H6B:I=D9DAD<>86AHIG6I:<NID9:6AL>I=I=:G:A6 I>DCH=>EEGDE:GAN :D;;:GH6;JC8I>DC6A6C9EG6<B6I>8>CI:GEG:I6I>DCD;I=:H:

ILDE:GHE:8I>K:H !CI=:A6HIH:8I>DC+:>7:GI9G6LHHDB:8DCH:FJ:C8:H;GDB

*DN8:^HDJIADD@HDC:ME:G>:C8:6C9@CDLA:9<:6C96EEA>:HI=:BIDI=:FJ:H I>DCD;IGJI=6H>I>H9:6AIL>I=>C#/,/036:67/@6-6@(3;@

DBE6G:9L>I=&6<A6C9+:>7:GI6<.3(:5+,9:65>HCDIHDBJ8=>CI:G :HI:9>C6CNE6GI>8JA6GE=>ADHDE=>86AEGD7A:BDGHE:8>;>8HJ7?:8IB6II:GG6I=:G

=::CFJ>G:H67DJI*DN8:^HH:A;JC9:GHI6C9>C<6H6E=>ADHDE=:G (:G=6EHDC:

8DJA9 6G<J: I=6I =: EDH:H 6 @>C9 D; B:I6E=>ADHDE=>86A FJ:HI>DC 67DJI I=:

B:6C>C<D;7:>C<:C<6<:9>CHJ8=6C>CI:AA:8IJ6A:CI:GEG>H: /=>AHII68@A>C<

I=>HFJ:HI>DC=:H>BJAI6C:DJHANIG>:HID6HH:HHI=:EG:H:CI8DC9>I>DCD;8DC I:BEDG6GN E=>ADHDE=N >C I=: - + I=GDJ<= I=: A:CH D; =>H >CI:GEG:I6I>DC D;

*DN8: H 6 HI6GI>C< ED>CI C9:GHDC 8=DDH:H LG>I>C<H >C L=>8= *DN8: :M EG:HH:H=>BH:A;6H6E=>ADHDE=:GL=DJC9:GHI6C9HE=>ADHDE=N>C67GD69H:CH:

6H69:BD8G6I>8[L6ND;A>;:\I=6I>HGDDI:9>CDJG:K:GN96N:ME:G>:C8:H6C9 G:;A:8I>DCHG6I=:GI=6C6C6GGDL>CI:AA:8IJ6AEGD?:8IG:A6I>C<IDDCAN6;:LE:D EA: +::C >C I=>H A><=I ID 7:8DB: JCE=>ADHDE=>86A LDJA9 EG>C8>E6AAN B:6C

;6>A>C<ID8G>I>86AANG:;A:8I6C9I=:G:;DG:JC9:GHI6C9I=:B:6C>C<D;DC:^H:M E:G>:C8:H !CI=>H<:C:G6AH:CH:E=>ADHDE=N;DG*DN8:>HH::C6H6CJC9:GI6@

>C<>CL=>8=6ABDHI:K:GNDC:>H67A:IDE6GI>8>E6I: -C;DGIJC6I:ANI=>HHIGDC<AN EG6<B6I>HI>8Z6C9:K:C+D8G6I>8ZBDI>K:>H8DJCI:G76A6C8:97N68:GI6>C[6G GD<6C8:\L=>8=Z>C6(A6IDC>8H:CH:Z6HHJB:HE=>ADHDE=:GHID7:[67DK:I=:

(15)

6@7AB=>6&3703@B/<26@7AB7/<#=:93

DG9>C6GN;DA@H \MEADG>C<I=>HI:CH>DC;DGBHDC:A>C:D;I=DJ<=IL>I=>CI=:

6GI>8A: 'I=:G>BEDGI6CI6HE:8IHD;C9:GHDC^H>CI:GEG:I6I>DC>C8AJ9:I=:;DA ADL>C<>GHII=6I<>K:CI=:;>C>IJ9:D;=JB6CI=>C@>C<E=>ADHDE=N>CKDAK:H 6E:GB6C:CI[>CI:AA:8IJ6AL6C9:G>C<\H:8DC9I=6IDC:=6HID86G:;JAANG:8DC H>9:GI=:=>HIDGND;E=>ADHDE=>86AI=DJ<=I6C9I=>G9I=6IE=>ADHDE=N>HEG:

H:CI:9CDI6H68DBE:I>I>DCD;>C9>K>9J6AB6HI:GB>C9H7JIG6I=:G6H6HD8>6A 6C99:BD8G6I>8:C9:6KDG H68DCH:FJ:C8:C9:GHDC8DC8AJ9:HI=6IE=>ADH DE=:GHBJHIA:6GCID9>H8DK:G[E=>ADHDE=N>C>IHDI=:GK:CJ:HZBJH>8ED:IGN HEDGIH;>ABA>I:G6IJG:6C9HDDC \

!C=>H6GI>8A:>(@5,#<5:;(33>H8DC8:GC:9L>I=6K:GN:A:B:CI6GN>C H><=I>CID*DN8:^H:I=>8HL=>8==6H7::CHNHI:B6I>86AAN9:K:ADE:9>C#/,!, 30.06<::7,*;6-/036:67/@6C9A6I:G>C#/,/036:67/@6-6@(3;@ GDB,JC HI6AA^H>CIGD9J8IDGNG:B6G@H>IH::BHD7K>DJHI=6II=>H:I=>86A>CH><=I>HD;6 E6G69DM>86AHIGJ8IJG:H>C8:>ID7A><6I:HJHIDG:<6G9DJGH:AK:H6H68IDGHL=D6G:

HIG>K>C<ID68IBDG6AAN6C9;><=I:K>A>CI=:LDGA96C96II=:H6B:I>B:=:

G:B>C9HJHI=6I>CHD9D>C<L:L>AAC:8:HH6G>AN;6>A6C96G:I=:G:;DG:>CC::9 D;6[HJE:G=JB6C9:A>K:G:G \,=JH:I=>8H;>C6AANG:;:GHIDG:A><>DC ;I:GDJI A>C>C<I=:EGD7A:B,JCHI6AA9:6AHL>I=>I>CILDB6>CHI6<:H >GHIAN=:H=DLH BDG:8ADH:AN=DL*DN8:^HI=:H>HI=6I=JB6CH6G::HH:CI>6AANBDG6A;6>AJG:H

>HAD86I:9L>I=>CI=:6G<JB:CID;#/,!,30.06<::7,*;6-/036:67/@6C96AHD

=DL>I>HA>C@:9ID=>HE=>ADHDE=ND;G:A><>DC *:A><>DJH;6>I=:C8DJG6<:HJHID 8DCI>CJ6AANEJGHJ:I=:BDG6AEGD?:8I[@CDL>C<I=6IDJG:;;DGIH6G:6I7:HIE6G I>6A68IJ6A>O6I>DCHD;I=:9>K>C: \+:8DC9AN=:699G:HH:HILDL:AA@CDLC8G>I

>8HD;*DN8:^H:I=>8HD;ADN6AINC6B:AN+>BDC#:AA:G6C9(:I:GJHH :86G:

;JAANJC;DA9HI=:>G6G<JB:CIH6C99>H8JHH:HI=:K6G>DJH<GDJC9HDCL=>8=I=:>G 8G>I>FJ:>H76H:9 !CHD9D>C<=:E6NHE6GI>8JA6G6II:CI>DCIDI=:[6GID;ADN6AIN\

6C9I=:>CHI>IJI>DCHD;BDG6A:9J86I>DCDGIG6>C>C< >C6AAN,JCHI6AA8DC8AJ9:H I=6I9:HE>I:HDB:I=:DG:I>86AH=DGI8DB>C<H>C*DN8:^H:I=>8H7DI=EGDB>C:CI 8G>I>FJ:HB6@:I=:H6B:;DJC96I>DC6AB>HI6@:I=:N8DBEA:I:ANDK:GADD@I=:

;68II=6I688DG9>C<ID*DN8:=JB6C7:>C<H86CCDI=:AE7JI;6>ABDG6AAN ,=:

8G>I>86AHI6C96G9D;[ADN6AINIDADN6AIN\BJHII=:G:;DG:7:JC9:GHIDD96<6>CHI I=>H6CI=GDEDAD<>86ADG:K:CDCIDAD<>86A768@<GDJC9

3,?(5+,9030676=0M8DCI>CJ:HI=:9>H8DJGH:67DJI*DN8:^HBDG6AI=:DGN 7N8DBE6G>C<>IID:DG<: :G7:GI%:69^HL6ND;8DCHIGJ>C<:I=>8H K:C>C

=>H>CIGD9J8I>DC>A>EDK>aB6@:H8A:6GI=6I=:>H>CI:G:HI:9>CI=:EDI:CI>6AD;

6<:CJ>C:EG6<B6I>HI>8L6ND;9D>C<:I=>8H6C9I=6I=>H9>H8JHH>DCD;*DN8:

6C9%:69H:GK:HI=>H<:C:G6A>CI:G:HI :8DCK>C8>C<ANH:A:8IHI=G::6HE:8IH L=>8=DCI=:DC:=6C96G:G:A:K6CI;DG7DI=E=>ADHDE=:GHL=>AHIDCI=:DI=:G I=:N6G:BD9:A:96IA:6HI>CE6GI>C9>;;:G:CIL6NH >GHID;6AA>A>EDK>a>C IGD9J8:H I=: EHN8=DAD<>86A 8DC8:EI D; >B>I6I>DC L=>8= >H HJG:AN D; 9:8>H>K:

>BEDGI6C8:ID*DN8:H>C8:688DG9>C<IDI=:E=>ADHDE=:GH:A;8DCH8>DJHC:HH :KDAK:HI=GDJ<=EGD8:HH:HD;G:H>HI6C8:6C9>B>I6I>DC ,=JH*DN8:6H8G>7:H6 BDG6A9>B:CH>DCID>B>I6I>DC7,9:,6C>9:6I=6I>HH:K:G:AN8G>I>8>O:97N%:69

(16)

<B@=2C1B7=<

L=D ED>CIH DJI I=6I >B>I6I>DC 6H 6 BDG6A 86I:<DGN 6AG:69N EG:HJEEDH:H 6 B:6C>C<;JAHNB7DA>8>CI:G68I>DC 88DG9>C<ID>A>EDK>a^HG:69>C<I=:B:C I>DC:99>;;:G:C8:B><=I7:=:AE;JA>C86G:;JAAN9>HI>C<J>H=>C<7:IL::CILD6E EGD68=:HIDBDG6AI=:DGNL=>8=>CI=:86H:D;*DN8:>H6BDG:[9>6A:8I>86A\

6C9[KDAJCI6G>HI>8\I=:DGND;BDG6A>9:CI>IN:B7:99:9L>I=>C6C>9:6A>HI>8I=:

DG:I>86A;G6B:LDG@6C9>CI=:86H:D;%:69>H6BDG:[EG6<B6I>8I=:DGND;

>CI:G68I>DC\6C9BDG6A>9:CI>IN +>C8:I=:8DCH:FJ:C8:HD;I=:H:9>;;:G:CI6E EGD68=:HID:I=>8HEG:H:CII=:BH:AK:H>CDI=:G6HE:8IHI=6I6G:8:CIG6AID6CN BDG6AI=:DGNI=:C:MIILDH:8I>DCH9:6AL>I=I=:EGD7A:BD;BDG6ADG9:G;GDB I=:E:GHE:8I>K:HD;>9:6A>HB6C9C6IJG6A>HB6C9;>C6AAN6ADC<H>9:I=:JC>K:G H6A8A6>BHL>I=>C*DN8:^H6C9%:69^HI=:DG>:H DC8:GC>C<I=>HA6HIED>CI>A

>EDK>aHIG:HH:HI=:D7K>DJHH>B>A6G>IN7:IL::CI=:[8DBBJC>IND;>CI:GEG:I6 I>DC\6C9I=:[<:C:G6A>O:9DI=:G \ :8DC8AJ9:HL>I=G:B6G@H67DJII=:EDI:C I>6AD;6EG6<B6I>HI>8DG>:CI6I:9BDG6AI=:DGN>CE6GI>8JA6G;DG6EEA>:9:I=>8H

(.5<:"*/3,;;,L:>CI:G:HI>C*DN8:^HBDG6AI=:DGN>H8:CI:G:96GDJC9I=:

8DC8:EID;H:A;G:6A>O6I>DC ,=>H>H6C>CI:G:HI>C<BDK:>CI=:9>H8DJGH:67DJI

*DN8:7:86JH:>I6AADLH6C>CI:GEG:I6I>DCD;=>HE=>ADHDE=N>CI:GBHD;68G>I>

86AI=:DGND;BD9:GC>C9>K>9J6A>HB +8=A:II:>HL:AA6L6G:D;I=:;68II=6I>C I=::;;DGIID9:K:ADECDGB6I>K:H8=:B:HID6HH:HHI=:K6G>DJHJC9:GHI6C9>C<H D;H:A;G:6A>O6I>DCDC:D;I:C:C8DJCI:GH6E:8JA>6GE=>ADHDE=>86A>C6GI>8JA68N

!CDG9:GIDD;;:G6C6AI:GC6I>K:IDI=>HJCEA:6H6CIH>IJ6I>DC6C9>IHJC9>;;:G:CI>

6I:98=6G<:H6<6>CHII=:>9:6D;H:A;G:6A>O6I>DC6HI=6IL=>8=;DHI:GHC6G8>H H>HBDG=:9DC>HB=:9G6LHJEDC:DG<+>BB:A^H;6BDJH:HH6N[6H>C9>

K>9J:AA::H:IO\[,=:$6LD;I=:!C9>K>9J6A\6C9"DH>6=*DN8:^H:I=>8HD;

ADN6AIN DI=8DC8:EIH6G:JC9:GHIDD96<6>CHII=:8DBBDC768@9GDED;#6CI^H EG68I>86AE=>ADHDE=NL=>8=+8=A:II:>CI:GEG:IHK>6 :<:A^H8G>I>86A6EEG6>H6AD;

#6CI +::C>CI=>HA><=IH:A;G:6A>O6I>DC>H;6G;GDB7:>C<:>I=:GC6G8>HH>HBDG

=:9DC>HB6C9>CK:GN<:C:G6AI:GBH>I86C7:I6@:CIDB:6C[H:A;9:9>86I>DC D;6C>C9>K>9J6AID6A6L \!CI=:;DAADL>C<+8=A:II:JC;DA9H6C99::E:CHI=:

B:6C>C<D;I=>H8:CIG6A>9:6;>GHIAN7NG:;:GG>C<ID+>BB:A^HHD8>D=:GB:C:J I>86AG:8DCHIGJ8I>DCD;#6CI^H86I:<DG>86A>BE:G6I>K:6H[>C9>K>9J6AA6L \8 8DG9>C<AN*DN8:^HE=>ADHDE=ND;ADN6AIN>HI=:CJC9:GHIDD96H7:>C<6I=:D G:I>86AHJEEA:B:CIID+>BB:AL=>8=EGDK>9:H6HD8>DDCIDAD<>86A;DJC96I>DC ID=>H=:GB:C:JI>86A6EEGD68= :=><=A><=IHI=:>BEDGI6C8:D;*DN8:^H8DC 8:EID;[H:8DC9DG9:GADN6AIN\ADN6AINIDADN6AIN6H6CDGB6I>K:B:I=D9DAD<

>86A 9:K>8: ;DG B:9>6I>C< 7:IL::C I=: >C9>K>9J6A 86JH: 6C9 HD8>6A >CI:G:HIH +8=A:II:8DC8AJ9:HI=6IIDI6@:688DJCID;I=:>CH><=IHD;7DI=I=>C@:GH[B><=I 7:6;>GHIHI:E>CI=:9>G:8I>DCD;6C:I=>8HD;H:A;G:6A>O6I>DCI=6I>H6L6G:D;

B6?DGBDG6AE=:CDB:C6>CDJG8DCI:BEDG6GNL:HI:GCLDGA9 \

!C=>H:HH6N/90:;0(5632,G:8DCHIGJ8IH*DN8:^HA6I:EDH>I>DCDCBDG6A HD8>6A6C9EDA>I>86AB6II:GH6H6@>C9D;HE>G>IJ6A8DBBJC>I6G>6C>HB :G:>C

=:9D:HCDIB:6C6G:A><>DJHANC6GGDL;DGBD;EDA>I>86AE=>ADHDE=N7JIG6I=:G 6L6ND;I=>C@>C<I=6I>CH>HIHDCI=:IG6CHBDG6A6C9IG6CHEDA>I>86A9>B:CH>DCH

(17)

6@7AB=>6&3703@B/<26@7AB7/<#=:93

D;8DBBJC6AA>;:6H7:>C<I=:K:GNHDJG8:D;=JB6C@>C9^H67>A>INID;ADJG>H=

L>I=>CHD8>:I>:H $DN6AIN6HI=:[I=>G96II>IJ9:D;L>AA\IG6CH8:C9H7DI=>C9>

K>9J6AH:A;6HH:GI>DC6C9G69>86AH:A;C:<6I>DC7NIG6CH;DGB>C<I=:FJ:HID;E:G HDC6A>9:CI>IN>CIDI=:8DBBDC8DC8:GCD;9>;;:G:CI@>C9HD;8DBBJC>I>:H;DG L=>8=68G>I>86AADN6AINIDL6G9HI=:86JH:D;I=:H:8DBBJC>I>:H>H:HH:CI>6A DL:K:G9>;;:G>C<;GDB*DN8:^HDLCLDG9HN:IHI>AA8ADH:ID=>H>CI:GEG:I6 I>DC>I>H[8DK:C6CI\I=6IG:EG:H:CIHI=:@:NHIGJ8IJG:D;6CND;I=:IGJ:*DN8 :6C8DBBJC>I>:H DAADL>C< *>8=6G9&>:7J=G^HJC9:GHI6C9>C<D;I=:=G>H I>6CGDDIHD;B:G>86C9:BD8G68N>I>HEDHH>7A:IDH::I=6II=:>9:6D;8DK:

C6CI86C=:AE8A6G>;NL=N6C9>CL=>8=L6N6CNHJ88:HH;JA8DBBJC>IN9:

E:C9HJEDC6HE>G>ID;8G>I>86AADN6AIN !C8DC8AJH>DC(DA@:H=DLH7N6G<J>C<

L>I=*DN8:;DG6[L>H:EGDK>C8>6A>HB\I=6IID96NL:6G::K:CBDG:>CC::9D;

6 8DBBJC>I6G>6C :I=DH D; 8>I>O:CH=>E DC: L=>8= >H CDI C6GGDLB>C9:9 7JI L=>8=8DCH>HIHD;;DGBHD;BJIJ6AH:A;:C<6<:B:CID;E:DEA: (J7A>8G:HEDC H>7>A>IN86CDCAN;ADJG>H=L=:CE:DEA:H::I=:G:HJAIHD;I=:>G8DBBDC8DCH>9 :G6I>DCH 6C9 9:6A>C<H 6H I=:N :ME:G>:C8: I=:BH:AK:H ID 7: :>I=:G 7:II:G DG LDGH:6H6G:HJAID;7:>C<8D6JI=DGHD;I=:>G8DBBDCA>;: ,=:G:7N>I>HH=DLC I=6I9:BD8G68N6HL:AA6H6CN[<G:6I\DG[7:ADK:98DBBJC>IN\G:EG:H:CIH6 I:A>8>9:6L=>8=86CC:K:G7:;JAANG:6A>O:9L>I=>CI=:8DCI:MID;:6GI=AN8DC 9>I>DCH6C9>BEA>8>IANI=:G:;DG:8DCI6>CH6C>CIG>CH>8HE>G>IJ6AIG6CH8:C9>C<

9>B:CH>DC

HI=:EG:K>DJH:HH6NH=6K:6AG:69N>C9>86I:9G:A><>DC>H6K:GN>BEDGI6CI I=:B:D;*DN8:^HE=>ADHDE=NDC:B6N:K:C6HHJB:I=6I>I>HI=:8:CIG6AHJ7

?:8IL=>8=>BEA>:HI=6I=>HE=>ADHDE=N86CDCAN7:EGDE:GANJC9:GHIDD9>;>I>H G:<6G9:9 6H E=>ADHDE=N D; G:A><>DC !C =>H 6GI>8A:!6),9; <4405.: ,=033, 6EEA>:H=>BH:A;IDI=:I6H@D;8G>I>86AAN6EEG6>H>C<*DN8:6H6EGD;DJC9E=>ADH DE=:GD;G:A><>DCL=D>H;6GBDG:>C;AJ:C8:97NB:G>86CEG6<B6I>HBI=6C7N :GB6C!9:6A>HB +>C8::K:GN8G>I>FJ:C::9H6I=:DG:I>86A;G6B:D;G:;:G:C8:

L>I=>CL=>8=>I86CDE:G6I:&:K>AA:7:<>CH=>H9>H8JHH>DCD;*DN8:7NHI6I>C<

=>HDLCJC9:GHI6C9>C<D;G:A><>DC !C<:C:G6AG:A><>DC6H8DCHIGJ:97N&:

K>AA: B:6CH [:C<6<:B:CI L>I= JAI>B68N \ ;I:G =6K>C< GDJ<=AN :MEA6>C:9 L=6I[JAI>B68N\B:6CH>CDCIDAD<>86A6C98DHBDAD<>86AI:GBH=:6H@HL=>8=

:M>HI:CI>6A8=6AA:C<:HI=:H:JAI>B6I:HEDH:6HI=:N6EE:6G>C=JB6CA>;: :

>9:CI>;>:HI=:8DCI>C<:C8ND;I=:LDGA9I=:EGD7A:BD;BDG6A8=D>8:6C9G><=I :DJHC:HHI=:EGD7A:BD;E:GHDC6A>CI:<G>INDGL=DA:C:HHI=::C<6<:B:CID;

DI=:GH6C9I=:FJ:HI>DCD;I=:B:6C>C<D;A>;: ,=JHG:A><>DC6H[:C<6<:B:CI L>I=JAI>B68N\:B7G68:H6AAD;I=:B &DLI=:9:8>H>K:ED>CID;I=:6G<JB:CI 8DCH>HIH >C I=: ;68I I=6I >C I=: ;DAADL>C< E6GIH D; =>H :HH6N &:K>AA: 6EEA>:H I=:H:;>K:@>C9HD;=JB6C:C<6<:B:CIL>I=JAI>B68NID*DN8:^HE=>ADHDE=ND;

G:A><>DC6C9>CHJ8=6L6N>HI=JH67A:ID9:I:8II=:>BEG:HH>K:E=>ADHDE=>86A 68=>:K:B:CIH6HL:AA6HI=:H:K:G:H=DGI8DB>C<HD;=>HI=>C@>C< !CI=:86H:

D;I=:A6II:G=:8G>I>8>O:H;DG:M6BEA:I=:6ABDHI8DBEA:I:A68@D;6C:HI=:I>8 9>B:CH>DCD;G:A><>DCL>I=>C*DN8:^HLDG@

(18)

<B@=2C1B7=<

,:*/,05+,8DCI>CJ:HI=::CFJ>GN>CIDI=:EG:HJEEDH>I>DCH6C9>BEA>86 I>DCHD;*DN8:^HE=>ADHDE=ND;G:A><>DC !C=:G:HH6NH=:8DCK>C8>C<AN6G<J:H I=6I=>HHD8>6AE=>ADHDE=N>H7:HIJC9:GHIDD96H6[IG6CH;DGB6I>DC2Y3D;=G>H I>6CDG*:;DGB:9>;CDIBDG:HE:8>;>86AAN(6JA>C:;6>I= \C9H>C8:I=:E=>

ADHDE=:G>HDC:D;I=:B6>CEGDI6<DC>HIH>CI=>HEGD?:8II=:G:7N8DCIG>7JI>C<ID I=::HI67A>H=B:CID;I=:IGJ:8DBBJC>IN>CL=>8=I=:H6AK6I>DCD;B:CB><=I D88JGE=>ADHDE=N>IH:A;688DG9>C<ID*DN8:7:8DB:H6[HDI:G>DAD<>86A:CI:G EG>H: \ 6K>C<EGDK>9:9I=>H<:C:G6AI=:H>H$>C9:<D:HDCID:MEADG:HDB:D;

>IH I:8=C>86A 6C9 DCIDAD<>86A >BEA>86I>DCH :HE:8>6AAN 7N 8DBE6G>HDC L>I=

(:>G8:^H 8DC8:EI D; >CI:GEG:I6I>DC 6C9 G:EG:H:CI6I>DC >GHIAN =DL:K:G H=:

IG68:H*DN8:^HA>;:ADC<>CI:G:HI>CJC9:GHI6C9>C<I=:;DJC96I>DCHD;8DBBJ C>IN768@ID=>H:ME:G>:C8:HL>I=I=:HIGJ<<A:H6C9:K:CI=:ADHHD;8DBBJ C>IN>C6A>;DGC>6 !IL6H>CI=>H:6GANH:II>C<I=6II=:8:CIG6ABDI>K:H;DG=>H E=>ADHDE=NL:G:7DGC !CA6I:GN:6GH=:9>H8DK:GHI=:8DC8:EID;>CI:GEG:I6I>DC 6HI=:8GJ8>6AB:6CH7NL=>8==:E=>ADHDE=>86AAN8DB:HIDI:GBHL>I==>H8DC 8:GC67DJII=:8DBBJC>IN6C9>I>H=>H8DCI68IL>I=(:>G8:L=>8=<J>9:H=>B

>CI=>H9>G:8I>DC DL:K:G$>C9:6G<J:HI=6IDC:H=DJA9CDIDK:GADD@HDB:

>BEDGI6CI9>;;:G:C8:H7:IL::C(:>G8:^H6C9*DN8:^H8DC8:EIHD;>CI:GEG:I6I>DC ,=JHH=:LDG@HDJI>C9:I6>AHDB:D;I=:BDHI>BEDGI6CIG:HE:8IH>CL=>8=

*DN8: BD9>;>:H (:>G8:^H JC9:GHI6C9>C< D; I=: EGD8:HH D; >CI:GEG:I6I>DC >

C6AAN=:GI=DGDJ<=9>H8JHH>DCD;I=:H:ILDBD9:AHA:69HIDI=:8DC8AJH>DCI=6I 688DG9>C<ID*DN8:>I>HCDADC<:GEDHH>7A:ID9>HI>C<J>H=G:6A>IN6C9>CI:GEG:

I6I>DC 7DI= 8DC8:EIH 86GGN I=: H6B: B:6C>C< AI=DJ<= $>C9: DC I=: DC:

=6C9H::BHID8DCH>9:GI=>HBDK:ID7:G:<G:HH>K:I6@>C<6768@H:6I7:=>C9 I=:K:GN8DBEA:M(:>G8:6CBD9:ADCI=:DI=:G=6C9H=:=><=A><=IHI=:;68I I=6I*DN8:^H8DC8:EID;8DBBJC>IN>H:K:C[G>8=:GI=6CI=6ID;(:>G8: \!CI=:

A6HIH:8I>DCH=:8DC8AJ9:HI=6I;DG*DN8:HD8>6A8DCH8>DJHC:HH>H>C;68I6 G:A><>DC76H:9JEDC6C>CI:GEG:I6I>DCD;=G>HI>6C;6>I=

,=6I*DN8:I=GDJ<=DJI=>HA>;:I>B:HIGJ<<A:HL>I=I=:EGD7A:BD;:K>A>H6 L:AA@CDLC;68I /=:I=:G=:L6HHJ88:HH;JA>C=>H:;;DGI>H8:GI6>CAN6FJ:HI>DC I=6I>HHI>AADE:CID9:76I: ,026"*/<3AEDH:HI=>HH6B:FJ:HI>DC>C=>H8G>I>86A 6EEG6>H6AD;*DN8:^HI=:D9>8NL=>8==:>CI:GEG:IH6H7:>C<6[;JAA;A:9<:9;/, 6+0*@\6C9B6@:HI=:HIGDC<:HIEDHH>7A:8A6>BI=6I>I<>K:H6HJ;;>8>:CI6CHL:G IDI=:HD86AA:9[EGD7A:BD;"D7 \,=>H>HL=N;DG*DN8::K>ABJHI7:8DC H>9:G:9ID7:6C:8:HH6GNE6GID;I=:67HDAJI::ME:G>:C8:D;I=:9>K>C:7DI=

AD<>86AAN 6C9 DCIDAD<>86AAN ,D EJI >I >C =>H DLC LDG9H [,=: :I:GC6A LDGA9 8DCI6>CH:I=H:B6C: \+8=JAO86G:;JAAN6C6ANO:HI=:9>;;:G:CIINE:HD;6G<J B:CIH7DIIDBJEIDE9DLCL=>8=A:69*DN8:IDL6G9HI=>HI=:H>H6C9;>C6AAN 8DC8AJ9:HI=6I=>HI=:D9>8N[JAI>B6I:AN;6>AH\H>C8:>IG:HIHJEDC6C[JCHDAK67A:

9>A:BB6 \!C68IJ6A;68II=>HDK:G6AA6HH:HHB:CIC::9HID7:JC9:GHIDD9L>I=>C I=:I=:DG:I>86A;G6B:LDG@I=6I+8=JAO6EEA>:HID*DN8:^HI=>C@>C<D;:K>A !C I=:A><=ID;6=:JG>HI>8H8=:B:=:DG<6C>O:H=>H6EEGD68=L=>8=8DCI6>CHEDH H>7A:BD9:AHD;699G:HH>C<I=:EGD7A:BD;:K>ADCEJG:AN>CI:AA:8IJ6A<GDJC9H

(19)

6@7AB=>6&3703@B/<26@7AB7/<#=:93

DAADL>C<I=>HH8=:B:DC:86C9>HI>C<J>H=6I=:DG:I>86ADEI>DCL=>8=HDAK:H I=:EGD7A:B7NH>BEAN6AADL>C<>IID9>H6EE:6G;GDBILDG:9J8I>DC>HIBD9:AH I=:DAD<>86ADCIDAD<>86AG:9J8I>DC>HB6HL:AA6H;GDB8DB7>C6I>DCH7:IL::C I=:A6II:G K:C>;+8=JAOH=6GEAN8G>I>8>O:HJ<JHI>C:;DG7:>C<JC67A:IDE6N 6II:CI>DCIDI=:G:6A:M>HI:C8:D;:K>A=:C:K:GI=:A:HH6HH:GIHI=6I*DN8:^HLDG@

BJHI7:8A6HH>;>:96H6INE:D;DCIDAD<>86AG:9J8I>DC>HB;DAADL>C<J<JHI>C:

+::C>CI=>HA><=II=:6AG:69N>C9>86I:99>A:BB6L=>8=*DN8:86CCDIHDAK:

6BDJCIHIDI=:;DAADL>C<[>I=:GI=:G:>HCDI=:D9>8NDGDCIDAD<>86AG:9J8 I>DC>HB;,9;0<4 565 +(;<9 \ !C I=: ;DAADL>C< H:8I>DCH D; I=: 6GI>8A: +8=JAO 9>H8JHH:HILDB6?DGD7?:8I>DCHI=6I8DJA97:G6>H:96<6>CHI=>H>CI:GEG:I6I>DC 6C9;>C6AANED>CIHID=>HDLCI=:DAD<>86AED>CID;K>:LL=>8==:8=6G68I:G>O:H 6H[E6G69DM>86ACDCG:9J8I>DC>HB \

,=:KDAJB:8ADH:HL>I=6HIJ9NL=>8=>C68:GI6>CG:HE:8I>H8A:6GAN8DC C:8I:9ID&6<A^HDE:C>C<:HH6NH>C8:7DI=:BE=6H>O:I=:IG69>I>DCD;:GB6C

!9:6A>HB 6H 6C >C;AJ:C8>C< ;68IDG >C *DN8:^H E=>ADHDE=N JI L=:G:6H &6<A EG>B6G>AN;DAADLH*DN8:^HDLCG:;:G:C8:HIDI=>HIG69>I>DCDCI=:I:MIJ6A76H>H D;=>H,*;<9,:6-6+,95+,(30:4(9;05&,5+;,>HBDG:9>G:8IAN8DC8:GC:9 L>I=I=:I=:DG>:HD;HDB:D;I=:BDHI;6BDJH:GB6CE=>ADHDE=:GH ,=JH=>H HIJ9ND;;:GH6[HNHI:B6I>88DBE6G>HDC\D;I=:[A6I:*DN8:L>I=#6CI :<:A 6C9>CE6GI>8JA6GI=:A6I:G+8=:AA>C< \,=:EG:B>H:D;I=>HJC9:GI6@>C<B6N E:G=6EHH::BG>H@N7JI>IHJG:AN>HCDIL>I=DJI6CNG:6HDC67A:;DJC96I>DCH>C8:

=:8DCH>9:GH*DN8:^H8DC8:EID;I=:7HDAJI:6H6E6GI>8JA6GK6G>6I>DCD;6;6G BDG:<:C:G6AJC9:GHI6C9>C<D;I=:7HDAJI:6H6450;<+69,(30;(;0: ,=:I=:H>H

=: 9:K:ADEH 8DBEG>H:H D; 6I A:6HI ILD E6GIH >GHIAN *DN8: >H I6@:C ID 7: 6 EG6<B6I>HIL=DEG:HJEEDH:HI=:>GG:9J8>7A:;68I>8>IND;:ME:G>:C8:6C9I=:EG>

B68ND;EG6M>HH:8DC9AN=:EDH>I>DCH=>BH:A;BJ8=8ADH:GIDI=:HI6C8:D;I=:

A6I:+8=:AA>C<I=6CI=6ID; :<:AH>C8:7DI=9>;;:G;GDBI=:A6II:G>CI=:>GH@:E I>86A6II>IJ9:IDL6G9HI=:CDI>DCD;[IDI6A8D=:G:CI>HB\6C9I=:8DBEA:I:[HJ7 A6I>DCD;EG6M>H>CIDI=:DGN \/:C9I:6G<J:H=>HI=:H>H>CILDE6GIH!CI=:;>GHI H:8I>DC=:G:8DCHIGJ8IH;>K:A:K:AHDCL=>8=*DN8:^H8DC8:EID;8DBBJC>IN 6HG:6A>IND;I=:+E>G>I>H9:H><C:9I=:9>G:8I>DCD;I=:6G<JB:CI>H9:K:ADE:9

;GDBI=:=>HIDG>86AIDI=:B:I6E=NH>86A ,=:H:8DC9H:8I>DCDJIA>C:HHDB:D;

I=:B6>C;:6IJG:HD;I=::GB6C9:76I:G:<6G9>C<I=:7HDAJI:;GDB#6CI^H G:<JA6I>K:>9:6AD;D96H6450;<+69,(30;(;0:K>6 :<:AIDI=:A6I:+8=:AA>C<

L=>8=6G:>CIJGC8DBE6G:9IDI=:A6I:*DN8:[DI=<GDJC9>9:6A>HBL>I=>C I=:EDHI :<:A>6CEG6<B6I>8>CH><=II=6IEG6M>HEGD8::9HI=:DGN6C97DI=9:

;:C9I=:>9:6A>HI>8>CH><=II=6I=JB6C7:>C<H6G:6IIJC:9IDI=:LDGA96C9I=6I

I=:NH:6G8=;DGL=DA:C:HH;DGI=:7HDAJI: \

(20)

#,$"'

B/:71E6<:CJB7:GHG:;:GID;DDICDI:H

C9:GHDCDJ<A6H* ; C9:GHDC"6B:H

CH:ABD;6CI:G7JGN CO6A9X6ADG>6 E:A#6GA'IID G>HIDIA:

GBHIGDC<C9G:L6BE7:AA J<JHI>C:

JM>:G*6C96AA ; 4;

N:GA;G:9"JA:H

6G6@6B>G>

6G9L:AA"DC:H:A>6

:AA6=*D7:GI& 4;

:CB6@=ADJ;A>

:G<HDC :CG>

:GCHI:>C*>8=6G9 D:I=>JH

DH6CFJ:I:GC6G9 G69A:N G6C9DB*D7:GI J8==:>B,=DB6H JG6C:AA>.>C8:CI

67DI*>8=6G9 6GHDC*68=:A 6K:AA+I6CA:N

:H6GO6GN$

A:C9:CC>C<"D=C S

A>;;DG9/>AA>6B#

DC6CI"6B:H DC;J8>JHa DGG>C<IDC*D7:GI+

JGGN,DBBN

6A;:GI=!C<DA;- 6GL>C=6GA:H

6K>9HDC,=DB6H;

:H86GI:H*:CU

:L:N"D=C;;

; ;

>AI=:N/>A=:AB

B:GHDC*6AE=/6A9D E>@JG

69C:GDC6A9 6A@: 6GIBJI

:J:G768=$J9L><

>8=I:"D=6CCDIIA>:7 ;

>A>EDK>jA:M6C9:G;

A:I8=:G:DG<:(

DJHI%6II=:L ;

DM#:AA:GK:ANC JAA:G%6G<6G:I

JHH(:I:Ga

:DG<>>:I:G 4

>AB6C6C>:AD>I D:I=:"D=6CC/DA;<6C<

DGH@>(=>A>E

67:GB6H"ZG<:C 69DI(>:GG:

6AA"DH=J6%

6JHB6C6GA*

:<:A:DG< /

;;;4a a

;44a a;

:>CG>8=*>8=6G9

D8@>C</>AA>6BGC:HI 9f DA768=(>:GG:,=

(21)

<23F=4!/;3A

WA9:GA>CG>:9G>8=

DD@+>9C:N DIID>H>A7:GI DJH:G&6I=6C DL>HDC:DG<: ; JB768=#6GA,=:D 4 JB:6K>9

!CC>H*D7:GI

"6B:H/>AA6B S;

aa

;;;

4

"6GK>H9L6G9

"6HE:GH#6GA;

"D6H 6CH;;

"DC6H 6CH

#66<"D=C

#6AA:C DG68:

#6CI!BB6CJ:A;

a

;;

a;

;;

;a

#:<A:N"6FJ:ANCCC#

#:AA:G+>BDCa;

#:CI:K:GA:N

#>:G@:<66G9+_G:C

#A:>C><"D=C

#D8=CIDCG>:9G>8=

#GZ<:G%6AI:DB>C>@

#J@A>8@GJ8:

#J=C,=DB6H

#ZC< 6CH

$6CB6C=6GA:H*D8@L:AA

$:>7C>ODII;G>:9/

$:>9:8@:G#JGI ;

$:L>HA6G:C8:!GK>C<

$>C9::H8=:

$D:L:C7:G<"68D7 4

$D8@:A6>C

$DIO: :GB6CC

%69O>6*DB6C

%6=DL6A9%6GNG>D9N

%6CI:G:II:"

%6G8:A67G>:A

%6G<6A>IK>H=6>

%6GA:ND7

%6GM#6GA

%8:GBDII"D=C" 4

%:69:DG<: :G7:GI;;;

a;

%:C@:=G>HIDE=

%>AA:G6K>9$

%>AA:G"D=C/>AA>6B

%>H6@=:GNA

%DGG>H=6GA:H/ 4

%JAA>C*>8=6G9(

%JGC6<=6C+8=:>A6

&6<A$J9L><; S 44

&6<AD8:@6A :GI6

&6CO(6IG>O>6

&:K>AA:*D7:GI ; S

&>:7J=G *>8=6G9 a 4

&>:IOH8=:G>:9G>8=

'7:N:H:@:G:6C6C6I=

'EE:C=:>BG6C@% 44 4a 4 S

(6G@:G#:AAN (6JA;

(:>G8:=6GA:H+6C9:GH;a

;;

a;;

;a (:GGN*6AE=

(:I:GHDC%>8=6:A$

(A6ID (DA6CN>%>8=6:A (DA@:=G>HI>6C;

(G6II+8DII$

(JIC6B >A6GN

(22)

<23F=4!/;3A

*6?8=B6C"D=C 4

*6C9DAE=A>O67:I=

*6LAH"D=C4 4

*DGIN*>8=6G9

*DH:BDCI :CGN

*DH:C+I6CA:N

*DH:CI=6A+6C9G6

*DN8:"DH>6=aaa aaa;a aaa aaaa

*JHH:AA:IG6C9

+6CI6N6C6:DG<:

+8=69:L6A9I/DA;<6C<

+8=:AA>C<G>:9G>8=/ "

a;a +8=>AA:G:G9>C6C96CC>C<+8DII +8=A:<:AG>:9G>8=

+8=A:>8=:GI J7:GI +8=A:II:%6<CJH +8=B>II6GA

+8=DE:C=6J:GGI=JG +8=JAO :>@D;4 +8=JAO/6AI:G

+8=L6GIO:C?6B>C +:>7:GI=G>HIDE=

+:AOC>8@(=>A>E +=6@:HE:6G:/>AA>6B

+B>I="D=C ;;

4 ; +=6@JG,JE68

+>BB:A:DG<;a;

+DE=D@A:H +E>CDO66GJ8=9:

+EG><<:,>BDI=N$ + +L>C7JGC:*>8=6G9

,6NADG=6GA:H;

,6NADG%69:A:>C::6J7>:C ,:HHB6C$>H64

,=DB6H ,DB6H:AAD%>8=6:A ,J/:>B>C<;

,JCHI6AAL6NC:

.>6A:A6J9>D%

/6AO:G%>8=6:A /:7:G%6M;

/:>C=6C9A:G9>C6C9;

/:C9I:%6GI>C /:HIDGC:A 4 /=>I:%DGIDC /G><=I*>8=6G9

16C<JGDC<

16D0>CO=

(23)
(24)

#,$)('

7HDAJI:a;

a aaa

8I>DCA33/:A=>CI:G68I>DC;

a;a

;;a

;

M>6A<:a

:>C<A33/:A=DCIDAD<N;

;a

;a

:IG6N6Aa

J99=>HBa;

=6G>INA33/:A=ADK:

=G>HI>6C>INa

;

;;a a

DBBJC>IN;a

; a;

aa a;

a 7:ADK:9;;

a D;>CI:GEG:I6I>DC>CI:GEG:I:GH a

a JC>K:GH6Aa;

DBBJC>I6G>6C>HB;a

DC;J8>6C>HBa DCH8>DJHC:HHa

;aa;

;

;

DCI>C<:C8N8DCI>C<:CI a

DK:C6CIa

JAIJG:a

:BD8G68N9:BD8G6I>8;;

a

E>HI:BDAD<N:E>HI:B>8;

a I=>8Ha;a

aaa

;;

K>A;a;

a ME:G>:C8:a

aa;

a

;a

;a;a

;

6>AJG:;a

;;

>C>IJ9:;>C>I:;;

;a;

a

;

D9;

;a;;

;aa

;aa DD9;

;

;;a a

67>I;

>HIDGN;a a

;a

!9:6A;

;;

(25)

<23F=4&C0831BA

a

;;

!9:6A>HBa;

a;;;

;;

;;;

;

!B>I6I>DC;a

!C9>K>9J6A>C9>K>9J6A>IN;;

;aa;

;;;aa aa

;aa

;a

;;a a

!C9>K>9J6A>HB;;

!CH><=Ia;

;a a;;;;

;

;;

;

!CI:G68I>DC

;;;;

!CI:GEG:I6I>DCa

;a a aa;

a

!CI:GHJ7?:8I>K>INA33/:A=8DBBJC>IN

;aa

#CDLA:9<:a

;

;

$D<>8;;;

;a

;;;;;

a;;

$DK:

a

$DN6AINaa;

a;a

;a;a

;;a a

%:6C>C<B:6C>C<;JA;

;;aa;;

;aa

;a a;;;

;;a

%:I6E=NH>8H;;;

;aa;

;

;;a;

a;;

%DG6ABDG6AH;a;

aa;;

aa

;;

;a;

;;

a A6La;

a DG9:Ga

&6IJG6A>HBa

&6IJG:a

a =JB6CC6IJG:

'7A><6I>DCa

;

'CIDAD<NDCIDAD<>86Aa

;;a

;;

;;a

'G9:Ga;

a

;

(:GHDC;;;

a;a;

a;

(=>ADHDE=Na

(AJG6A>HBEAJG6A>IN

;;

(G6<B6I>HBa;;

;;a;;;

a (GDK>C8>6A>HBa (HN8=DAD<N

(JGEDH:;;;

;;

*:6A>IN;;a;

;;

;;;

(26)

<23F=4&C0831BA

a;a a

*:9J8I>DC>HB

*:A><>DC;;aaa aa;;a aa

+:A;aaaa a;a

;;;

+:A;G:6A>O6I>DCa;

+:B>DI>8HH:B>DI>8;aa

;

+:B>DH>H;a

+><Ca a

+D8>:INa;;

; +E>G>I;;;

;a

;a

+J7?:8IHJ7?:8I>K>IN;

;

,=:D9>8Na

,=:DAD<N;;;

;

,=DJ<=I;;

;a

;;;

,GJI=;;;a a

;;a

-AI>B6I:JAI>B68N;

a

; -C>INa

;;;

;a

.6AJ:;;

;

;;a

/>AA;

aa a;;

;;a;

;

a />AAID!CI:GEG:I;;

Referenzen

ÄHNLICHE DOKUMENTE

24 Sufitum kann demnach laut Ibn ʿAǧība wie folgt definiert werden: „Die Annahme aller guten Eigenschaften und das Verlassen aller schlechten Eigenschaften.“ 25 Oder:

novativen Ansätzen theologischen Denkens gesucht. Kauf mans Ansatz einer Theologie als „imaginative construction“ stellt mit seinem radi- kalen, konstruktivistischen Verständnis

And, simultaneously, we dis- cover some of the deep structures of modern philosophy that are prefigured in Luther, whether we read Kant or Fichte, Hegel or Schelling, Kierkegaard

Second, there are issues of personal and social life: Is it true that love and compassion enable more fulfilling and meaningful kinds of human relations than do liberal notions

ʿAbd al-Ghanī al-Nābulusī and the Intellectual and Religious History of the 17 th –18 th -Century World of Islam.. Lejla Demiri and

Denn – und das ist die These dieser Arbeit – die in Lindbecks Buch “The Nature of Doctrine” zur Anwendung kommenden Auffassungen von Religion, Dogma und Theologie eignen sich

Second, Schleiermacher also understood sociability to be vitally important for religion and vice-versa, declaring in his fourth speech on religion that religion is “the most

Liest man das Verhältnis der klas- sischen deutschen Philosophie zum Judentum aus dieser begrifflichen Perspek- tive, so zeigt sich gerade eine Vielschichtigkeit und