7 Overall Evaluation
9.1 Tables of values of biological effect monitoring parameters
177
(mg/m³)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Toluene 141 92 4.9g
(GSD 19.7)
74 5.0g
(GSD 18.8)
STENGEL et al. (1998)
Toluene < 3802 45 10.6
(2.6 - 577.0)
45 11.5
(4.4 - 55.7)
NG et al.
(1990)
5 1.85g 5 1.28g Overnight urine samples
Styrene 113
5 4.03g 5 2.33g End-oft-shift-samples;
2 exp./0 controls >
upper ref. limit of 20
178
Albumin (mg/g creatinine) Concentration
(mg/m³)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls Main
compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Styrene 100 20-300 65 6.4g
(GSD 2.2)
0.5 – 105 212 (33 positive
tests)
58 5.2 < 10 a production work
18 7.3 > 10 a production work
Not reported
179
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
- - End-of-shift values after
day of aircraft de-icing, longitudinal study, no
- - End-of-shift values in
period without de-icing,
180
Albumin (mg/g creatinine) Concentration
(mg/m³)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls Main
compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Controls with shift work (from petroleum refinery) controls without shift-work;
64 exposed also in BOOGAARD et al.
Data after morning of one day with exposure 0.26
-9.39
15 3.60
(SD 2.32)
Data after afternoon of one day with exposure 1,3-DCP
16 1.99
(SD 1.26)
Data on late evening of one day with exposure
OSTERLOH and FELDMAN (1993)
181
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Data next morning after one day of exposure
OSTERLOH
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls Main
compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Data from same group of workers after and before working season
BROUWER et al. (1991)
182
Albumin excretion (µg/min) Concentration
(mg/m³)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls Main
compounds
TWA Range No. Mean2
(SD or SEM)
Values given for control group only
a: arithmetic mean, if not otherwise indicated
g: geometric mean; GSD: geometric standard deviation
1: TWA varied between 10 and 50 % of Swedish hygiene limit for toluene (300 mg/m³) and xylene (350 mg/m³) 2: values given in ppm in original reference
3: 1,3-dichloropropene: roughly equal mixture of Z/E-isomers 4: reported exposure level on average 0.5 x threshold limit values
5: In the original reference, values are given as unitless "albumin/creatinine ratios" which most likely correspond to g albumin/g creatinine 6: sum of hexanes at most workplaces exceeded TLV
7: values given as mg albumin/mmol creatinine in original reference; (MG creatinine: 113,12 g/mol)
183
(mg/m³)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Toluene 141 92 50.4g
(GSD 16.8)
Styrene 100 20-300 65 63g
(GSD 21.7)
- - End-of-shift values after
day of aircraft de-icing , no control group
- - End-of-shift values in
period without de-icing,
184
ß2M (µg/g creatinine) Concentration
(mg/m³)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls Main
compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Controls with shift work Controls without shift-work,
64 exposed workers also in BOOGAARD et al. (1993)
BOOGAARD and CAUBO (1994)
185
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Median (range)
No. Meana (SD or SEM)
Median (range)
Styrene 20 – 100 52 191
(SD 187)
140 48 259
(SD 393)
134 (0 - 1840)
Peak concentrations up to 925 mg/m³
Toluene 300 – 400 42 112
(SD 75)
97 48 259
(SD 393)
134 (0 - 1840) Xylene,
toluene
see1 40 255
(656)
99 48 259
(SD 393)
134 (0 - 1840)
ASKERGREN et al. (1981a)
1,3-DCP 1.9 - 18.9 12 109.9
(65.3 - 350.9)
8 76.4
(45.0 - 174.3)
Data from same group of workers before and after working season, 8 out of 28 urine samples excluded because of pH
< 5.5
BROUWER et al. (1991)
186
ß2M excretion (µg/min) Concentration
(mg/m³)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls Main
compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Median (range)
No. Meana (SD or SEM)
Median (range)
Remarks Reference
Toluene containing solvent mixtures
4 39 0.086
(SEM 0.007)
36 0.088
(SEM 0.011)
KRUSELL et al.
(1985)
a: arithmetic mean, if not otherwise indicated
g: geometric mean; GSD: geometric standard deviation
1: TWA varied between 10 and 50 % of Swedish hygiene limit for toluene (300 mg/m³) and xylene (350 mg/m³) 2: values given in ppm in original reference.
3: 1,3-dichloropropene: roughly equal mixture of Z/E-isomers 4: reported exposure level on average 0.5 x threshold limit values
5: In the original reference, values are given as unitless "albumin/creatinine ratios" which most likely correspond to g albumin/g creatinine 6: sum of hexanes at most workplaces exceeded TLV
7: values given as mg albumin/mmol creatinine in original reference; (MG creatinine: 113,12 g/mol)
187
RBP (µg/g creatinine)
Concen-tration
(mg/m³) Exposed workers Non-exposed controls
Main compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
5 69.2g 5 40.89g Overnight urine samples
Styrene 113
5 33.14g 5 35.58g End-oft-shift-sample
VERPLANKE
Toluene < 3802 45 159
(18 - 2274)
45 88
(26 - 557)
prevalence of elevated values (³ 265 µg/g)
- - End-of-shift values after
day of aircraft de-icing , no control group Ethylene
glycol
33 50.47g (GSD 1.66)
- - End-of-shift values in
period without de-icing , no control group
GERIN et al.
(1997)
3Concentration of retinol-binding protein (RBP) in urine of solvent-exposed workers - results from cross-sectional studies
188
RBP (µg/g creatinine)
Concen-tration
(mg/m³) Exposed workers Non-exposed controls
Main compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM) often in exposed group
MUTTI et al.
Data after morning of one day with exposure
OSTERLOH and FELDMAN (1993)
189
(mg/m³) Exposed workers Non-exposed controls
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Median (range)
No. Meana (SD or SEM)
Median (range) 0.26
-9.39
15 16.85
(SD 10.64)
Data after afternoon of one day with exposure
16 17.97
(SD 14.00)
Data on late evening of one day with exposure 1,3-DCP
16 30.88
(SD 35.15)
Data next morning after one day of exposure
OSTERLOH and FELDMAN (1993)
190
RBP (µg/l)
Concen-tration
(mg/m³) Exposed workers Non-exposed controls
Main compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Median (range)
No. Meana (SD or SEM)
Median (range)
Remarks Reference
1,3-DCP 1.9 - 18.9 14 26.9
(16.5 - 72.7)
14 20.0
(8.4 - 36.1)
Data from same group of workers before and after working season
BROUWER et al. (1991)
a: arithmetic mean, if not otherwise indicated
g: geometric mean; GSD: geometric standard deviation
1: TWA varied between 10 and 50 % of Swedish hygiene limit for toluene (300 mg/m³) and xylene (350 mg/m³) 2: values given in ppm in original reference
3: 1,3-dichloropropene: roughly equal mixture of Z/E-isomers 4: reported exposure level on average 0.5 x threshold limit values
5: In the original reference, values are given as unitless "albumin/creatinine ratios" which most likely correspond to g albumin/g creatinine;
6: sum of hexanes at most workplaces exceeded TLV
7: values given as mg albumin/mmol creatinine in original reference; (MG creatinine: 113,12 g/mol).
191
(mg/m³)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Toluene 141 92 2.0g
(GSD 14.5)
74 1.9g
(GSD 14.5)
STENGEL et al. (1998)
113 5 1.06g 5 1.57g Overnight urine samples
Styrene
5 2.38g 5 2.46g End-oft-shift-samples
VERPLANKE
End of last workday values
4N-acetyl-ß-D-glucosaminidase (NAG)activity in urine ofsolvent-exposed workers - results from cross-sectional studies
192
NAG (U/g creatinine) Concentration
(mg/m³)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls Main
compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM) from figures; high values more frequent in exposed groups
YAQOOB et al. (1993)
58 6.5 < 10 a production work
18 10.0 > 10 a production work
Not reported
No correlation with TCA-excretion;
193
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM) group; values in original reference reported as
0.46 - 19.18 Low participation; no
control group
194
NAG (U/g creatinine) Concentration
(mg/m³)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls Main
compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Controls with shift work (oil refinery workers) control without shift-work;
64 exposed workers also in BOOGAARD et al. (1993)
Data after morning of one day with exposure 0.26
-9.39
15 2.44
(SD 0.91)
Data after afternoon of one day with exposure
16 2.72
(SD 1.05)
Data on late evening of one day with exposure 1,3-DCP
16 2.79
(SD 1.40)
data next morning after one day of exposure
OSTERLOH and
FELDMAN (1993)
195
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls Main
compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
a: arithmetic mean, if not otherwise indicated; g: geometric mean; GSD: geometric standard deviation
1: TWA varied between 10 and 50 % of Swedish hygiene limit for toluene (300 mg/m³) and xylene (350 mg/m³) 2: values given in ppm in original reference
3: 1,3-dichloropropene: roughly equal mixture of Z/E-isomers 4: reported exposure level on average 0.5 x threshold limit values
5: In the original reference, values are given as unitless "albumin/creatinine ratios" which most likely correspond to g albumin/g creatinine 6: sum of hexanes at most workplaces exceeded TLV
7: values given as mg albumin/mmol creatinine in original reference; (MG creatinine: 113,12 g/mol) 8: values given as µmol 4-methylumbelliferon/(h g creatinine) in original reference
196
ß-Galactosidase (U/g creatinine) Concentration
(mg/m³)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls Main
compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Median (range)
No. Meana (SD or SEM)
Median (range)
Remarks Reference
5 1.89g 5 1.44g Overnight urine samples
Styrene 113
5 1.18g 5 1.20g End-oft-shift-samples
VERPLANKE and HERBER (1998)
Tetrachloro-ethene
7.9 1 - 221 82 2.12 19 2.32 VERPLANKE
et al. (1999)
ß-Galactosidase (U/l) Concentration
(mg/m³)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls Main
compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Median (range)
No. Meana (SD or SEM)
Median (range)
Remarks Reference
1,3-DCP 1.9 - 18.9 12 2.4
(1.7 - 5.6)
11 1.9
(1.1 - 7.2)
Data from same group of workers before and after working season
BROUWER et al. (1991)
a: arithmetic mean, if not otherwise indicated
g: geometric mean; GSD: geometric standard deviation
Tab. 9.5ß-galactosidase (ßGal) activity in urine of solvent-exposed workers - results from cross-sectional studies
197
(mg/m³)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Toluene 141 92 5.2g
(GSD 13.2)
74 5.3g
(GSD 13.3)
STENGEL et al. (1998)
5 3.60g 5 3.04g Overnight urine samples
Styrene 113
5 4.49g 5 3.35g End-oft-shift-samples
VERPLANKE
198
AAP (U/l) Concentration
(mg/m³)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls Main
compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)
Data from same group of workers before and after working season
BROUWER et al. (1991)
a: arithmetic mean, if not otherwise indicated
g: geometric mean; GSD: geometric standard deviation
1: TWA varied between 10 and 50 % of Swedish hygiene limit for toluene (300 mg/m³) and xylene (350 mg/m³) 2: values given in ppm in original reference
3: 1,3-dichloropropene: roughly equal mixture of Z/E-isomers 4: reported exposure level on average 0.5 x threshold limit values
5: In the original reference, values are given as unitless "albumin/creatinine ratios" which most likely correspond to g albumin/g creatinine 6: sum of hexanes at most workplaces exceeded TLV
7: values given as mg albumin/mmol creatinine in original reference; (MG creatinine: 113,12 g/mol).
199
Total protein (mg/g creatinine) Concentration
(mg/m³)
Exposed workers Non-exposed controls Main
compounds
TWA Range No. Meana
(SD or SEM)