core percentage
% (.S t3*/+6( -0. )*6 P0! %X R1 ( # %"RR0 .*|1 R R10. )0.D\ &0.
number of selected nodes
number of edges
100 200 300 500
0 500000 1000000 1500000 2000000 2500000
random degree core percentage
( .S/+( -0. *'0 o- %1! ( \ R"%ZP0 .0*1 Z %1.)0.D\ =.
C
P5 < G
2
]
number of selected nodes
percentage of queries processed at level 1
100 200 300 500
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
95_577A:M
2 2
lBn hoCpBhkq
)b
d!eEgih j lBn
6!eChkj98 hkq
H
!#"$%&'()*+,"$%&+)*-+)).0/112,.!(3"&+45*)678"679!5:$;
<
9!).="$>2-9!?7@%3!+'A*@!*"$.B)*+.."@!C*"$?D*."$%EF"9>"G=H%IB.*GJ!K.L
M<
9!+)*:"$)*=H!)* +*"1:.+E53"1#"CEG+)*NO6B"$.GHP+)Q5*"$(GRS"$T++>*3.5.+)Q"$@=1EG+)Q"$.
)*9!!!(3.67/$2-8D*H!HP!8).U$;%4'H%).67+5*UH!)*+6B"1*9!)*+.NKUV8-+
number of selected nodes
speed−up
100 200 300 500
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
78)57 57 2 ?
5D<78d5 A
2
5HJr
QJ T678U:
x
H<78Ur
2 2
4;5pMHEY;AMGQJ 3
"# &('*)+-,/.10 +-2436587 .936: ;=<0 )<2>+-243@?BAC2EDEFEGH+ID
J
,/KL)E:E5M<2 +R+-,iK S PQ+R+-S15
VXWXWUT VXWNe6fhg ZY
" X d eEgih j>lBn
4 l 2il d@hkdBq
H3 <7 AM)EAH
? 2 5 2
2
percentage of queries processed at each level
(5, 5) (5, 10) (5, 20) (10, 5) (10, 10) (10, 20) (20, 5) (20, 10) (20, 20)
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
level 0 level 1 level 2
% ( .SL\T 0.S)+0! \6P,.(.R.S)*0DS+' c ) 1 Z 3 Ro
design
2 d eEgih jIlBnl e 4 Chko>hko@pBhkq
d e
gih jlBn
8 q81ho hkoCp hkq
5:<<`_$Q! 5
2 ? 2
4QJ A5W_4
"tF ")
y ¼ y ¼ y "y "y
VXWXW\[ VXWNe6fhg ZY
2
d!eEgih j lBn 6!e@h j98 hq
" k ?2
7<):<B
?2
VXWXW#V VXWNe6fhg ZY
2
1
4HYG3 V7
Q Md):TV5
2 @
H$<78B pr6 53QJ 5 2 ?
QCMBH) 64 Ad)E\
2
VXWXWZY VXWNe6fhg ZY
y5:N5 5r):`
2
5.<78v3 _7
4<LUQ c "
535 .5 A78Q P<V[5 N5D
! ¯
)HP )9!!(Z.67"G'?"1*[2,X* ()Q"$HT$; 9Q /U2- "$)*).[9!
+4'H%).67+5* )Q"1+):H").!(GNGKZ)*+1EG+)/**"FE=)*9!!!(3.67/$2-W.;\)8L3
<
9+)*
;\G)8"Q ()Q"$H!0K "$-2-*"$?B.]Q"H')-JKL"$@P9',G'I%'.G*+)*E1"$?W' W+
<
9!G*N
$C!G. ;\),*!O4'HP+)*67+5Q+K
)O*Q!."$=)*"GG+/S!B+4'H%).67+5*T2, *!(G)*"H!T'.(! ;\)& .+EG+?
2-+)* H%);\G)67 G *! ;Y")AH)')K [ *+"$)QN + *[67G*G *"1 +67H").!(
"@.9'B)*9!!!.!( *672,X*! Q"$@!.]!K 6B"GO!69Q +/ @!9'&HP+ 9!H !9.[@P
2
% (.SL , oS .0+|1
GHJ S3CN
2
5b5QL55M 54
2
P45LM_
¯
<UBz)5 b " y "
X 2
R4 1N, o S ,/.0+|1 4
5<Br 7
2
56 A78}5:3AMK8E 2 ¥
5<7843 2
<78dHz)5:L LMV!
x
WUT VXWNe6fhg ZY
d!e Egihkj lBn 4 l 2il dChkdBq
:; SH<
d!e Egihkj lBnhkoCpBhq
H
number of selected nodes
number of components
50 100 200 500 800
0 200 400 600 800 1000 random degree
53sMw5b 46
2
8 q8hko\hoCpBhkq
7AUQ! S
<<d6
¯
R4 1N, o S ,/.0+|1
number of selected nodes
speed−up
50 100 200 500 800
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 random degree core percentage file
( . P3* *+'"( o.oS3 .0*1
number of selected nodes
edge quotient
50 100 200 500 800
0 1 2 3 4
random degree core percentage file
% ( .SL i' .( %R! .0 S3 .*|1
}
5 975 5 2
¥ZF"
b F H < 5 4<L 5 2
75 5
2
IH d577LM
7A
2
<78 GCMV5
7
2 2 ?
D<VL
¯
9 ! 2
53)A @
2
2 "
H
W\[ VXWNe6fhg ZY
75 5TQJ p3<L
2
hkoCpBh 6!eCl,8 hd
% (.SL , ' :* .0+|1
<UBz)5 b "
5GY75L 5[V7
2
CrQC 5:H<
2
+67+6&@%)U*"1#@ NTQ" (&LG
<
9!+)*. !.N/12-,+"!!$:(9%"$)Q"$5=8*"$678DQ"1*.?+"
"# O+R. + <(3i:>+ & '*) +-,/.10 +-243i5
<L9[5 .5
"
Q
5
2
5T q#J 54 CG<bQ
2
5 :HIQCMU
2
pVLDAM$B
5tG5 W757[
2G2
B T5LDAM;
5{ A:78 5 Ar5LDAM
:
?
<7847A:
2
")"F"
¼#"
J <S:5QL5:5M
5:H< 5 <):
QCM95 G5 2 "
5653sM
2
! #"$&%'($ )+*-,/.1032547698;:=<>47?@?BAC,D?E*12/0GF9?IHGJK0L*MFN?I2O,D03P9QR,D?ESQT2/U?I?ESWV+XYUK,D?IZ[.CV
*103\MX1?5,D6]2;.1698O,D?I2O,;V^U_QR,D.`QNH3P96N8/0L,/.1ab2I<1c_QR2/?IST69*T.10L?I8/QN8/Z[.10LZ&QNHdS1?EZI69abU692/0G,D036N*e6Nf>Q
P90LFN?I*PN8DQNU1.hgijX18a]QN0L*k03*!,D?E8/?I2O,(47QN2,D.1?l032;2/X1?l4m._QR,(P98DQNUY.12nQR8/?l2/X10G,[QNc1HL?f'698,/.1032
2/U?I?ISCV+X1Ub,D?IZ[.Y*103\MX1?R<C4m.1?E8/?m47?m2;?E,/,/H3?ES]QkU18/0L698/0Cf'698P98/QNU1.12o6Nfp2/0LqI?m03*srutwvxH36NPvzyBg
{
?k?I*1ZE69a@U1QN2/2;?ISeFRQN8;0369XY2|ZIH}QR2/2/?E2~6RfnP98/QNU1.12m0L*M,/669X18m2;,/X1S103?E2I<_2;X1Z[.`QN2mZE69aV
Up69*Y?I*!,;V^03*1S1XYZI?ISP98DQRU1.12@twP98/QNU1.12kc1XY03HL,kXYUp69*ZI6N*1*1?IZB,D?ES-ZI6Na@U69*1?E*M,/2[y<(8/QN03HG4Q&J
QN*1Ss8;6!QNS]a@QNUbP98DQRU1.12I<C4m.1?I8;?~,/.1?~_8;2;,/HLJb*_QNab?IS]QN8/?P98DQRU1.1272;._QNU?IS],/6U?I8Of'698/a
47?EH3H94m0L,/.k69X18z2/U?I?ESWV+XYU ,D?EZ[.1*10L\CXY?QR*1S5,/.1?,+476H}Q,/,D?E8zQN8;?>,[QN:R?I* f'8;69a8;?&QNHV^4698/HLSg
cp6F9?7QNH3H#<47?l47?E8/?70L*!,D?I8;?I2O,D?IS0L* 2;Up?E?ISWV^X1U<90#g?RgL<H36C692;?IHLJj2/U?&QN:M03*YP1<R,/.1?fwQNZB,D698
6Nf>.164aXYZ[.efwQN2O,D?I8Qb2/.1698O,D?E2;,;V^U_QR,/.T\MX1?I8OJZ&QN*ecp?5QN*12O47?E8/?ESX12/0L*1P@aX1HL,/0GV+HL?EFN?IH
]Bnz 03*Y2;,D?IQNS-6Rf|U1H}QR03* ]Bnz g { ?bS1?E2/ZI8;03c?IS<n03*S1?E,DQN03H#<d,/.1?]?AWUp?E8/0GV
a@?E*M,/2Z&QN8;8/0L?IS69XW,oQN*1S2;.1647?ESb,/._QR,ZE69*12;03S1?E8DQNc1HL?70La@U18;6F9?Iab?I*!,0L*U?I8;f'6N8/a@QN*1ZI?
Z&QN*cp?kQRZ[.103?BF9?IS4m0L,/.aX1HL,/0GV+HL?EFN?IH ]Bnz <_03*12O,D?IQNS6NfnUYH}QN0L* ]Bnz <=QNUWV
U1H30L?ISu,D6bQNHLH6Nf,D.1?k*_QNab?ISP98/QNU1.12Eg
6N8/?I6FN?I8I<94?|P!Q&F9?mQjSY?E,[QR03H3?ESQN*1QNHLJC2/0L2>6Nf=ZE69a@U69*1?E*!,;V+0L*1S1X1ZE?ISP98/QNU1.12E<!QN2>,/6
,D.1?~*CXYacp?E86Rf?ISYP9?I203*]c6N,/.b,/.1?~6N8/03PN03*_QNH1QN*1S@,/.1?cp?EH369*1PN03*1PkaX1HG,D0V+H3?BF9?EH1P98DQRU1.
QN*1SCP90LFN?I*Qt¡ 9¢/£;y^V+2;.1698;,/?I2O,;V+U1QR,D.\MX1?I8OJ9,D.Y?xcp?EH369*1PN03*1P2;?&QN8;Z[.2/U_QNZE?kQN*1Su,D.Y?
U18/69c1QNc103HL0L,+J,/._QR,l,D._Q,7\MX1?E8;J@032oU18/6CZI?E2/2;?ISQR,7Q P90GF9?E*sH3?BF9?IH#<CQN*1S]4?~4?I8;?xQNc1HL?,/6
cp?IQN8m69XY,m69X18|,/.1?I698;?E,/03Zx2;,DQR,D?Ea@?E*!,D203*U18DQRZE,D0LZI?Rg
ZI8;X1ZI03QNHU6903*!,,D6¤69XY8b2;Up?E?ISWV^X1U¥,/?IZ[.1*Y03\MX1?T0L2,D.1?2/?EH3?EZE,D0L69*¦6Nfj*Y6WS1?E269*
4m.103Z[.,D.Y?aX1HG,D0GV^H3?BF9?IHdP98/QNU1.`0L2§c1XY03HL,Ig { ?X12/?ES1F9?ZE8/0L,/?I8;0}QY<*_QNab?IHGJe8/QN*1S16Nae<
S1?IP98;?I?R<ZI698;?N<U?I8;ZI?E*M,DQNP9?R<zQN*1ST1H3?ZE8/0G,D?I8;0369*Kt'4m.1?E8/?,/.1?H3QN2;,~69*1?0L2§*16R,j03abab?BV
S10}QR,/?IHGJ`QNUYU1H30LZ&QNc1HL?5,/6QN*!JQN8;c10L,/8DQN8OJP98DQNUY.c1XY,k8/?E\MX1038;?I2jf'X18O,D.1?E8j:M*164mH3?ISYP9?6Nf
0L,D2|2O,D8;X1ZE,/X18/?&yBg
0G,D.ZI6Na@U69*1?E*M,OV+0L*1S1X1ZE?ISP98/QNU1.12E<_H3?ZE8/0G,D?I8;0369*T._QN2j,DXY8/*1?ES6NXY,j,D6uc?,D.Y?
a@692O,|?bZE03?I*!,|6N*1?N<Y4m.Y?I8/?IQN24m0L,/.u8/?IQNHGV¡47698;H3S@P98DQNUY.12I<1SY?IP98;?I?jZE8/0L,/?I8;0369*s2;?I?Ea@2,/6
cp?l,D.1?lcp?E2;,nZ[.16903ZE?Ng~QN*YS169a ZI8;0L,/?I8/0L69*5QNH3ab692O,nQRHL47QJC2H3?IQNS12d,D6§2;H364m03*YPRV+S164m*503*WV
2;,D?IQNS6Nf_2;Up?E?ISWV^X1UQN*1Sh<9.1?I*YZI?N<!2;.164m2n,D.1QR,>ab698/?l2/6NU1.1032O,D0LZ&QR,/?IS2;?IHL?IZE,/0369*ZI8/0G,D?E8/0}Q
,D._QN*;XY2;,2;?IH3?EZE,/03*1P~*16WSY?I2>c!J8/QN*1S16Na QR8/?8;?I\MX1038;?IS0L*698;S1?I8n,/6j69cY,DQN03* 2/U?I?ESWV+X1Uhg
b" w!
2547?@._Q&F9?s2;?I?E*<n,D.Y?]2/?EH3?EZE,D0L69*-6Rf*16CS1?I2 032k,D.1?@ZI8;X1ZI03QNHoUp690L*!, ,/6
69X182/U?I?ISCV+X1U,D?IZ[.Y*103\MX1?Rg|)^,~469X1HLSec? 0L*!,D?I8;?I2O,D03*YPb,/6@S1?BF9?EH369UTf'XY8;,D.Y?I82/?IHL?IZB,D036N*
ZI8/0G,D?E8/0}QxQR*1S,D?I2O,,D.1?Ea 69*FRQN8;0369X12PN8DQNU1.Y2>,D6x?BAC,/8DQNZB,ZEH3X1?E2>4m.103Z[.bZI8;0L,/?I8/0L69*2;X10L,/2
4m.103Z[.sZEH}QN2;2o6NfP98/QNU1.12lc?I2;,Ig 698;?I6F9?E8I<Y8;?&QNHV^4698/HLSP98DQNUY.12lf'8;69a 6N,/.1?I8oZI6N*M,/?BAC,D2E<
2/X1Z[.TQN2|47?EcTP98/QNU1.12E<_?NgP1gL<_ZE69X1HLSc?k03*1ZEH3X1SY?IS03*uf'X18O,D.1?E8?AWUp?E8/03ab?I*!,/2Ig
" .1?E2/?5QNU1UY8/6!QNZ[.Y?I2m,D6S1?B,D?I8;a@0L*1?x*16CS1?x2/?EH3?EZE,D0L69*12|c_QR2/?ka]QR03*1HGJ69*03*!,DX10G,D0L69*g
*16N,/.1?I8lQN0LaZIQN*cp?mS1?BF9?IHL69U1ab?I*!,l6NfhQ$#&%')(+*-,/.0%*|,D6x_*1S@QN*2169UY,D0La]QRHW2;69H3XY,/0369*3L<
0¡g?NgG<_*CXYacp?E8m6NfnHL?EFN?IH32mQR*1Se2;?IHL?IZE,/0369*Y26Rfn*16CS1?E2mJC0L?IH3SY03*1Pc?I2O,~2;Up?E?ISWV^X1Ug
" .1032Z[._QNUW,D?I8ZE69*!,[QN0L*122/69ab?S_QR,DQ¤a@QR,/?I8/03QNHl2/X1U1UYH3?Iab?I*!,DQN8;JK,/6,D.1?u_P9XY8/?I20L*
Z[._QNUY,/?I8Y,D.Y?58/Q&4 S_QR,DQY<_U18;?I2/?E*!,D?ISe03*u,[QRc1X1H}QR8f'698/ag
698/0LP1g>P98/QNU1. aX1HL,/0GV^H3?EFN?IHP98DQRU1.
ZE8/0L,/?I8;0369* v ! "¢#%$ %&' (*)+
,.-/-8/QN*1S169a
,+0#1/032 0#-/4/4 0/-/-/576
2#1/0/4/-6 4 5 - 6
,.-/-S1?EP98/?E?
,+0#1/032
1/03270/1 ,+1,+-/1#1
5 2
,9:71/0/-
,+0 ,
,+032#2 2;,928,92 ,+2
5
4/43:#1#- 1#13:8,+0
5
ZI8;0L,D?E8/0L69* ,/6N,[QRH HL?EF9?EH - H3?BF9?EH , )
,+-/-8DQN*YS169a 0
5=6
,+-/-Up?E8/ZE?I*!,[QNPN?
2#1
-/-Up?E8/ZE?I*!,[QNPN? 57635
- :/:70
ZE8/0G,D?I8;0369* UYH}QN0L* H3?EFN?IH
-HL?EFN?IH
,
4?I0LP9.!,D?ISab?&QN* 2;Up?E?ISWV^X1U
,+-/- 8/QN*1S16Na :#4,.132 g, ,+-/:#0/0/- g- , 5 0#1/0 g- ,/,+4 6 0/4 g- - g
g6 6/35763Yg!
, g :
S1?I2;03P9* ,D6N,DQNH H3?BF9?IH - H3?EFN?IH , HL?EF9?EH 2
S1?I2;03P9* U1H}QR03* H3?EFN?IH
S1?E2/03PN* U1H3QN03* 4?I03PN.M,/?ISa@?IQN* 2;Up?E?ISWV^X1U
: : : :#-/4#0 Yg- ,.0/-32 g1 , g
S1?I2;03P9*
7)
U1H}QN0L* 4?I0LP9.!,D?ESTab?&QN* 2/U?I?ISCV+X1U
V V : : :
:7- U?I8/ZE?I*!,[QRP9? 0 6 4#0/132 63
:7- _HL? 0/1/1/:#-/4 ,+4
28,+43:71/1,
,+0/-2#-#- _HL? ,/, :74,+1 , 6 1
)+ ZE8/0G,D?I8;0369* U1H}QN0L* 4?I0LP9.!,D?ESTab?&QN* 2/U?I?ISCV+X1U
)+ ZE8/0G,D?I8;0369* U1H3QN03* 4?I03PN.M,/?ISea@?IQN* ?ES1P9?k\MX16N,D0L?I*!,
i kgg < " gg zd <Yg§g M "! *$#&% ' %('*),+ '-%.0/
132 *+' %54768+:90' %5;# 2=< .>6@?BA&,C8 # #D+E; (F?B#&; '-AG.0/IH8/?E*M,/03ZE?KJ~QNH3H#<ML*1P9H3?B476C6CS
N H30POh2E<RQ?E4SN?E8/2/?BJ9<
,+4/4 Yg
Q,F TgU 1CVWM7 YX +.Z.$# * %5;A=9[?BA&,Y\]+')(>' < ' ,0*$++E;A=9Z/^C.1?I?B,D26N*Qu,[QRH3:
QR,_x69*12O,[QN*Yqa`*10LFN?I8;2/0L,+JN<
2/2cb2 Y<
2#-/-/2
g
76NHd §gDUfe g ehKi(j @k ?BA&,0' <ml %n? # 2 .0/oz69*YS169*
Z&QRS1?Iab03ZpH8/?E2/2E< ,.4/13: g
76N2n gUfe 7q Kr #s?B#t;u.$#&;u'-v 1 ?-.)( 2 *$ADw . ( 2 / 5gzixHLS1?I*Mc69X18;PRVxTo?E8/H}QRP1< zyX1*WV
Z[.1?E*< ,+4/4/1 g
7XYZ{ |7g}Uf q e g~G ; * %n?/%( 2 ;u.)( 2 * l %n? # 2 *$A .0% *s90*>. . ( 2 *0/J6WZ[.CV
2/Z[.MX1HL2/Z[.18;0Lf,/?I*< ^C,/XY,/,/P!QN8;,I< 2#-/-#- g
N ] " ggJ gMe VW < N gL|g V=7V=z e <5gjog uV= AM#%' ,/. ($#t; '-A# '
8+:90' %5;#2=< .0/ ) " H8;?I2/2E< N QNac18;03S1P9?R< QN2;2IgG< 2#-/-32 g
JTL|g § < kgI VWg < 5g]Re d e <Yg C Vj AM#&% . %(.$v
< .Z.$# * %{/ +* < *$AM# *%; *-,0* %5/* %5% *$A&,Zw>?/%* % 'Bwt *>'-# ' %$;*$AM#&; * %5# * % r ' 5#&%?/%*0/
SYS1032;69*WV
{
?I2;H3?BJ9<W769*Y*<
,+4/4/0
g
{ g V h V=z <Cg¡ V= V ¢k *+(+'F9BAM;P0;A=9£\ .=A&,G+*>.¤;A 1 ; < * 1 ?Zw0+*
l %n? # 2 .c¥8 r # % . ($# . %n?B+,8 # #&%'0?0( 2 /¦H8/6CZNg6N,D. { 698/:M2;.169U¦69*
HLP96RV
8/0G,D.1a§L*1P903*Y?I?I8;03*1Pet{ L
27-/-/-y<W^WU18;03*1P9?E8}z?IZE,/X18/?fQ6N,D?E20L* N 69aV
U1XY,/?I8^WZE03?I*YZI? ,+4/132 < 1 5 b84#1 < 2#-/-8, g
] g ¨e = eª©l<ª~g g3 VWVW 8 X %5;#&; (F?B+3« '-;AM#D ' % k ?BA&,0' <¬l %n? # 2 .
;#2 ? l ;/*$A£ *s9/%+*+* r *F® .*$A(+*0/ QN*1S16Na ^C,D8;X1ZE,/X18/?E2]QN*YS
HLP96RV
8/0G,D.1ab2 0 t 2j¯ !yB< ,+0,$b*,.1/- < ,.4/43: g
^WZ[. |7gM° q =~G ,D± 0; *$AM# *]8+:90' %$;#2=< *$A².0% *$;A³)? 2 % #D+P?BAD?/.Z.>' .A´5#.>.$4c.$v
# * < /¢x69*12;,DQN*1qE?I8Y^WZ[.18;0Lf,/?I* 03* QR,D.1?Ea]Q,D03: X1*1S)+*Wf'698/a@QR,D0L:zQ~8Ig
< g
^C,/8n §g°
e
z
132
*
X
« %+'F9/%n?
<C<
;A=93?BA=9/.R?c90*0/ S1S10L2/69*WV
{ ?I2/HL?EJN<?IQNS103*YP1< QN2;2IgG<
2#-/-/-g
^ { |7g° q g~ <g ¡ V= < N gg e C}3>j .$;A=9 .=+E#t;v *$/*$+
l
%n? # 2
. ' % 1 ; <
*$#x?Zw0+* A´ ' % <
?B#&; '-AD/[H8/6CZNg6N,D.
{
698;:C2;.169U69* HGV
P9698;0L,/.1a¢L*1PN03*1?E?I8/0L*1PkQN*1SLnAWUp?E8/0La@?E*M,/2~t L,QL!
2#-#-32
yB<=^CU18/0L*1P9?I8
z?IZB,DX18;?aQ6N,D?E2~0L* N 69abU1XY,D?E8^WZI0L?I*1ZE? 2 6 -/4 <@6/ b:#4 < 2#-/-32 g
{ QNHd
N
g¡ M #"[ 8$ .=+E#t;+ *$/*$+8+:90' %5;#2=< ' % ) ' %(+*$vsp; %*+($# *-, l %n? # 2
%n?B%;A=9Z/ QR,D.Y?Ia@QR,D0LZ?E2/?IQN8/Z[. ?EUp698O,
-/-Z¯
)
¯70/-<
2#-#-/-g
{ ?I0P gc¡ V= V3 &% .0%n$.>' %$;#D#R . %('&' %5+*>. .A=9*) A´ ' % < ?B#&;u' F,+ /ck6N*12;,DQN*1qI?E8
^WZ[.18;0Lf,/?I*03*
QR,/.1?Ia@QR,/03:]XY*1Se)+*Wf'698/a@QR,D0L: Q8Ig*5
, <
,+4/4/1
g