. [ @CBF>M#@CB>1@>HT>ISBA[T> M F>GE@>R M]IS@ B
@>$=
(@ B$J1@ I)4@CIO @ JSJP@CIPMS@>s @ ISJPBAT>, BEM J1@CI?wxT4IPIS@CR MKB1I+JB1IGIH @ BA>1@> JPM F<M]BLJM]BEJKGIH1@> F>R MKT4I
>@CISJGIH ?QBA>J1@ MrJ1@ I?R:MSIS@CB
@>$\d?QBL@r F*>B>,MOO$= S= TO @> GLB>1R JJS@H1@> R<F*>>
\
!
=
23 22
eff
17 κ
18
19
20
21 a ü
0 0.1 0.2 14.5
15 15.5 16
κa s
1 10 100 1000 V 0 *
normale Parameter Parameter aus Exp.
M(OO1BLGJB>F S={zN GLBA>HR:JNtJ1F>J @;ZA@CIPBA @> M]@ GLGE@sXuH6F>JP@>JHBF*F4ISF*^ = Q@GIH M]JN @CIF4GL@ BAGIH
J1@ I`XuH6F>JP@>J1BLF*F4ISF* @ BHIJ1BE@|O1BEJKH1@U IO @>5BHMc[ M]@>X F>I]F* @ MS@CI
F*B1JiMO1JGIH>1BEMPMS=
B>;J J1BE@X F>ISF* @ M]@ IQF*B1J?J1@ LaSZA@CIPBA @> M
\
@CJM]@ T&
>1@ GE@CBGIH MS@| @CIPJKGIH1BE@OB;>FJ1@CJeXuH6F>JP@>JHBF*F4ISF*^ JiB
! $
zBA>!BGIH MKB>F
H UT*H1@CIP@CI !
CO@CIPMS@*\ ?QBE@^ F*> BA>MO;O$= S=z
IS@GIH MSJ `JP@H1@> R<F*>>$=VM(>J1@ IS@ I UB;>J1@
UB1I?J1BE@Y](> M]@ ISJGIH1BL@J1@TR UT>> MS@> JP@CB>$N
JHBL@#@ M?(F>JF*>J1@ IS@YM IM@J1@CI+M(B1JP?D@CIMcB>F|J1@CI!N#FMS@>$NOA@>5BHMK[ MQ??B1IJ1@*T4I!F>GLGE@
JH@CI( @CI
F>GLGQJ1@CI@X F>F>ISRET4ISIP@CGF<M]BAT*>$\>1BGIH M@J1BE@YwxBB1GLF*> M]@>
FE>J1@CIP@? @ BLGAGIHH@>[CF*H1GL@>$\J1BE@QF*OA@CI F*B
P@J1@> F>GLGdBA>`J1@ T>eB>HJkB;> MS@CIPJKBGIH M]@>
D@CIS@ BAGIH
~ GEBL@F4@>$=
FE>J1@CIP@ !F*>JOA@JHBA>FB;>F4@>NdB LaSZA@CIPBA @> M H1FM) F*>^T=C @>1@ UF*>JH@CI\J$=9H$=J6F>J
OA@ MSI]F*GIH MS@ M]@|R:JPMS@BLJMW@CB> M(B1JSJGIH>1BMSMTF*B1JW@CB>1@?(@ JS@> MSGLBAGIHF4I UT>JSJS@ IS@>§RC
JM]@
UFEB1JSJP@CIS@ JeXqT>MS@> M]BLF>G_NpJ1BE@ F>JP@CISB> M]@>HJSBEM FM>HBA^TM[BJ1@>U UFE>J1@CI>H1B> ?(@F4@>
JH@CJ F*B4JKGIH1@>sX IT*6GLJ?J1@ J %FJS@CIPJPMSI]F*H1GEJ!F*O
J1F>J @7SZA@CISB @> M]@CGEGL@)R:JPM]@ BLJMu>5B1I
B6F>JPBC[ ?(@ BAJ1B @>1JSBT>6F>Gy\J$={H=4@CJ JPBA>Je GB1RC
MKB6FMSBAT>1@> JS@>HR:IP@GIH Mx[B1I
¥ CnLuOA@>1@x UTF4GEBAGIH$\:?(@>> F*B;GIH >5B1IQR GL@ BA>1@
JHBL@twYT>GLGAT>BAJHMS@CBLGGIH1@>xH1F*O @>>1BGIH M @1FR M J1BL@ JS@ GAOA@ I UT4JPJS@E\JT>J1@ IK> @ BA>1@kF4@ ?QBEJSJP@*\
?D@>;> F*BGIHR GL@CB>1@*\ I T4JSJP@>4@U IPM]@ BLGB>F
BL@7dBE@CGL BA> B1JSJ)JHBL@CJP@ @F4@O @>H1@CBM]@> F*B
J1BE@ F*F>@J1@ J+XuH6F>JS@>J1BLF*F4I]FE JtH1F"C
OA@>$\:GUFJSJPMDJSBGIH JGIH ?D@CIKJSF*F4@>$\HFEO @ ID@ BA>1@!JKT4GGIH1@ IP@GIH M)F>IKT4JPJS@( @ ISJGIH1BL@OB>F&@ ISJKGIHH@CBA> M
MSIKT>MK[J1@ B;> ?(F*H1IPJKGIH1@ BA>1GEBAGIH$=L BA>1@`GL@ Mc[ MS@ UTF4GLBGIH1R>@ BEM\lB>J¢J1BE@ JGIH1@CB> MrB>1J F>GLJ(]InC
JSF*GIH1@ F* ?(F*H1IPJKGIH1@ BA>1GEBAGIH1JM]@>\%BEJPMxJHBL@*\J6F>JSJYJ6FJ N*(CXqT>MS@> M]BLF>G J1BE@ @GIH1JS@ GE?QBEIWC
R5B>FWB @;ZA@CIPBA @> M]@ GLGE@>^R:JPMS@ @O @>eJTSGIHe>1BGIH MF F*>[)[BHM]IP@ C @>J^OA@CJKGIHHIS@CBOHM&= B1IU
R GL@ BA>1@ N*BAGIH M]@> JKGIHH@CBA> M N* FBdM[B
B;>1R M]BAT*>1BL@ IS@>\ FEO @ IOA@CB F>I T4JPJS@CIP@>8N*BGIHU MS@>
JZ1BL@ GL@> T=C @>1JPBAGIH M]GEBAGIHs@H1IM]@ BLGAGIHH@> ?(@GIH1JS@ GE?QBEISR5B>F4@>Y@CBA>H@ ?T4GLGE@
£ "¤y\JHBL@WBA>B>1JP@7C
IP@CIkRdBB1GF<M]BAT*>F4F>Ia>1BGIH M @> McH6FGEM]@> JSBA>;J$N?QBEI OA@>5BHMc[ @>^>5B1IuX F>F>IP?D@GIH1JP@CG?QBLISR5B>;F4@>$=
O@>>s F*>J1BE@CJS@@H1IPMS@CBLGGIH1@> ?D@GIH1JP@CG?QBLISR5B>;F4@> F*B
@CBA> @ C @CR MSB4@ JxX F>F>IKZT>M]@> M]BFG
Z1IT PBA[ BL@ IPM&\ RET^TM F*>1JGIH1@CB>1@>J @CBA>>TGIH @ M?F>J JPM UF>ISR@CI F*OF4@ JKGIH1BEIKTMS@CJXqT>MS@> M]BLF>G
BEMK@74@> MKB1@CGEG JTF F>IQF<MSM]ISF>R M]B4@ M> M]@ BLGVH1@ I]F*B1J\lJ6FeJ1BL@YwxT4GEGAT4BJHM]@ BLGAGIHH@> JP@CGO1JPMBAH1IP@
F4@F4@>HJS@CBM]BF4@r @GIH1JS@ GE?QBEISR5B>F F*O1JKGIHHBLIK @>
9 F*GCITECBT>JKG IS@ @>1B>F7=
#
]@ F4@>6F*B1@ IS@b>
T>IK FM]BT>1@> BOU @ IJ1@>XH1F>JS@> UBOA@CIKF4F*>F[B8@CIH6F>GM]@>\ H6F*OA@> ?QBEI
OA@CB`J1@>,R:GLF>JSJPBLJGIH1@> R:JPMS@ @>
H6F>IM]@RSGIHH@CBAOA@> B>J N* sJ1BE@@ MKHTJ1@J1@CJ
9J6FM]FGT>GLGFEZ1JSB>F#F*B
J1BE@ wxBB1GF*> MS@>$\iBMSM]@ GE?D@CIM]@B>J RB1JK[ @ZHMSBAO1BEGLBEM UFM]@> J1@CJ
*IKJ;>B;>F4JKZ1F>I]F* @ MS@CIPJ&F*>F4@ ?FE>JHM&= @>6F*B1@ IS@ J`J6F*[B JPM]@H M&BA>MO1JGIH>1BEMPMez;={~;=qwYBHIK[
[B1J]F*^ @>F4@
F>JSJM&N#?QBLIH6FEO @> J1BE@8N#FM]@>ZB>1R MS@F4@ UF>JPJ
P@ ?(@ BLGLJ @CB> N*BLF*F4I]FE @CBA>;F4@ MSI]F*F4@>$\?B>J[ ?(F>IsJ1BE@OGEBA>1R@R:@CBEMS@JH@CI
GE@CBAGIH5B>;F4@>
F4@F4@> =
=, @>> J1BE@ GL@ BAGIH5B>F>@>¡[BHM]IP@ C @>$\ JKT>GLGEMS@> F>GLGE@,N#FM]@>ZB>1R MS@ F*B
@ BA>1@ I wxB1IW4@GLBE@F4@>$\>pUF* GLBGIH J1@CI RdR<F>GE@>
B;>1R M]BAT*> FEB
J1@> IP@GIH M]@>Rd@ BEM]@>3JH@CI
GL@ BAGIH5B>F4@>
JHBL@i'B;>1R M]BAT*>1@>¢ BEM@J1@ IrKBLGJ1@
$
=QMGLJrlB>HR MSBAT>
U
B1I@J1BL@TN*B4@ IKF4@>[
J1@ I¢wxT4IPIS@CGLFM]BT>1JPG UF*>F>@H6F*OA@>-?QBEI[ ?(@ B` UT*F4GLBGIH1R>@ BEM]@>F4@ M]@ JPM]@ M&N([B @CB>1@>J1@>
F>GEG @ BA>1@ J>T>IK F>GL@> R ISBM]BLJGIH1@>
U
](OA@CIKF4F*>F4Ji BM % \ %
B>J
% # \
B>;J B¡ F>GEG @ BA>1@ JYwx C
U
³TBA F>GEG)J1@CI^H6F>IM]@> RSGIH1@ BAOA@>$\B>J
% ! ¥ ' ! ' !
UB1IsJ1BL@ N*C @ BLGGIH1@>$=N*BL@O=
ECMGIH1JP@ ??B1IKJH@F4@C@ BAGIH M&\ BA>J1@ ?(@ BEM]@ I @> M
@CIK> M
*T XuH6FJS@>
U
BO @ IKF FE>F8@CBA> @CIKH1F>GEMS@> ?QBE@ BA> Gy=
z;= F*>F4@>T^ @>$\ F4@71MSMS@ M
B>;J J6F*JBHIKGIH J1BE@X IKT*ZQT4IM]BT>6F>GEBEM UF<M]JSRET>1JM F*> M]@OA@CJM]BA^TM ??B1IJ1@*= N*BL@ L IKF4@O>1BLJPJS@
J1@ I H6F>IPMS@>¡RSGIH1@ BAOA@>JPM FE @>F*B1J J1@ I
@CJPMS@>$\PJ1BE@ J1@CIN*(C%@CBEGAGIH1@>F*B1J
J1@ IF>IPBF*O1GE@> T&Q=B1@ ISJMJ1BE@L IKF>@O>1BEJSJP@J1@ I N*(C¢%@CBEGAGIH1@>$=iL B>D@CBLJZ1BL@ G
UB1IPJ1BE@ R*T4GEGF*OHBL@CIM]@> N#FM]@>ZB>1R MS@ BEJPM B> M(OO$= S={z[B JP@H1@>$=!N*BL@ GLB>1R>@ RZ6F>GEMS@
>1B M @ BA>>;T4IK F>G R ISBEMSBLJGIH1@CJ @ IKH6FGEM]@> F*>\qJ1BE@ IP@GIH M]@ @ BA>1@>§wx C
U
](OA@CIF F*>F;= N*BE@
X F>I]F* @ MS@CI\qBJ1BE@CJP@>wxT4GLGLF*Z1JY[B @CISIP@CBGIH1@>$\%??B1IKJH@> P@ ?D@CBEGLJiF4GL@ BAGIH[ @CBEMSBAFP BEMSMS@CGEJ
@ BA>1@ J GL@FJPMC J
B6F>IP@ E T> MS@7C FISGAT"C @CI
F*H1IP@>1JvF4@HMSM]@ MaB>;J GF*BdM]@>
T4GF4@>JH@CIK F>JPJS@>N
3547698;:'< =%>@?
A#"% %B.C
* D !
#$
N*BE@ @ ISJM]@>J1IS@ BRZ6F>GEMS@>O @[CBE@H1@> JSBGIH F*B
@CB> >T>IK F>GKR ISBEMSBLJGIH1@CJe @CIH6F>GEMS@>$\J1BE@
0.01 0.1 1 L/ξ 0.5
0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
L b < ψ G 1 > L
L = 4 L = 5 L = 6 L = 8 L = 10 L = 13
0.001 0.01 0.1 1
L/ξ 0.5
0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
L b < ψ G 1 > L
L = 4 L = 5 L = 6 L = 8 L = 10 L = 13
0.01 0.1 1
L/ξ 0.5
0.6
U L L = 4
L = 5 L = 6 L = 8 L = 10 L = 13
0.001 0.01 0.1 1
L/ ξ 0.5
0.6
U L L = 4
L = 5 L = 6 L = 8 L = 10 L = 13
0.01 0.1 1
L/ ξ 0.02
0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07
k B T χ G 1 L -c
L = 4 L = 5 L = 6 L = 8 L = 10 L = 13
0.001 0.01 0.1 1
L/ξ 0.02
0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06
k B T χ G 1 L -c
L = 4 L = 5 L = 6 L = 8 L = 10 L = 13
M(OO1BLGJB>F =zNVRdR<F>GE@>Z1GT>M]J
UB1IrJ1@>BEMPM]@CG?(@ IPMxJH@CJ *IKJ>5B>F>JKZ6F>ISF* @ M]@ ISJ
@CISJM]@
@ BLGL@ 7\JHBL@iRSB1J[C@ZdM]BAOHBLGLBM UFM
[ ?D@CBM]@ @CBLGE@ \B>J J1BL@wxBB1GLF*> M]@>
J1ISBMSM]@i @ BLGL@ 7=6N*BE@
GEBA>1R@`RSZ6FGEM]@ BLJM
UB1I*@ BA>1@>>T4I F>GE@>R:IPBEMSBLJKGIHH@>XuB>1R M&\O @ BqJ1@ I*IS@GIH M]@> H6F*OA@> ?QBEI
@ BA>1@>§wx C
U
](OA@CIF F*>F F*>F4@>T^ @>$=pM GEGL@ N#FM]@>
UB1ITN*(C%@CBLGGIH1@>\
\
EeB>JP>FISB FEO1GL@ tT Q=
GE@ Mc[ M]@> :BL@ IWF*B
@CB>1@> wx C ]@O @ IKF F*>;F=VL J#??B1IKJ1@>
B>J
bB> M]@ IWC
JBGIH M&=DN*BL@GE@ Mc[ M]@ @ BLGL@|[C@CBF>MeJ1BE@bT4I]F*BHJSJ]FEF4@>J1@CI^wx C+HH@T4IPBL@*=a B1I U
??B1IJ1@> N#FMS@>ZB;>1R M]@ BA (@ IS@CBGIH ! ~
OA@>5BHMc[ M&\aB;>J
UB1I
¡
N#FMS@>Z;B>1R M]@ B (@ IS@CBGIH ! ~
S=QN*@CIN#FM]@>1R*T>GLGFEZ1J
UB1I
B>HR MSBAT>HBL@CIM UF*H;>1GLBGIH¢FBHM*?QBE@J1@ IxH1BL@ IF4@[C@CBF>M]@
UB1I
= F>J*JSF*F>MxB>HJxJ6F>J
>5B> N*BE@ rB6F>GLBM UFM J1@CJ@wxT4GEGF*Z1JP@CJBEJPM
UBHI+J1BL@xM(>>6F*H @#@CB>1@CJ+>;T4IK F>GL@> R ISBEMSBLJGIH1@>
XuB>1R MSJ:BL@CGEGL@ BAGIH M @CBA> O1BLJPJKGIH1@> O @ JSJP@CI F>GEJJ1BL@P@>1BF4@
U
BHIJ1@> wx CM(>1J]FMK[*\ F*OA@CI
>1BGIH M JPBAF>HB6R<F*> M&= N*BL@bO@CIPMS@PJ1@CI^L SZQT>H@> M]@>
UB1IeJ1@> wx Cn F>GEG(GLBE@F4@>8BA^ @ IKH1B>
B> J1@ I UF*H1@ J1@ I T4ISF*B1JPJ]F*F4@>$= F*> J6F>I
F*BGIH >1BAGIH M 4@CIF4@CJPJS@>$\sJ6FJSJ J1BL@ JS@
T4ISF*B1JPJ]F*F4@> >5B1I
U
BHI @ BA>1@F>J&^ZHMcTM]BLJGIH1@sM(>> UF*HH@CIKB;>F F*> J1@>
U
]@O @ IKF FE>FF4@ GEMS@>
JT4GLGM]@>\a[*== F*O
% 0 £
¤_=a](>1JP@CIS@N#FMS@>8GLBE@F4@> BA D@CIS@ BAGIH
% $
zS= F*>
JT4GLGM]@>HBAGIH MxB>1@ IP?iUF*H;> MWGLF>JSJP@>$\J6F>JSJJ1BL@HHBL@CIUBOA@CIrJ1BE@e@ McHTJ1@J1@ JWN#FM]@>1R*T>GLGFEZ1J
F4@
B>J1@>1@> @ IPMS@
UBHI§<
FBHM BEM§J1@>1@> F*B1J§J1@ @CI
F>GLG^J1@CIbN*@O>@7C
F>GLGE@CInCnwxT4ISIP@CGLFM]BT>1J
B;>1R M]BAT*>
' @CI BMSMS@CGEMS@> O@CIPMS@>$\Y?D@CGAGIHH@ BA D@CIS@ BAGIH
< '
z* GLBE@F4@>$\ BOA@CIP@CBA>HJPM]BU @>=
N#F>JSJP@CGO @RSZ1BE@CG>5B>
U
BHIiJ1BE@eH6F>IPMS@>RGIH1@CBO @> BA> J1@ I @ JPM]@> T&QN B>M(OO$= S={zz
JPBA>JJ1BL@ ISF*ZH1@>| BEM @ BA>1BF4@> R*T4GEGF*OHBL@CIM]@> N#FMS@>^[BJP@H1@>$\B>Jb[ ?F>IDBA>
T4GAF>@>J1@ I
M(>T4IKJ;>B;>FN)J1BE@sTOA@CIP@ @ BLGL@ BLJM
UB1I
\J1BL@ B> M]@CIP@
UB1I
S=(N*BE@
GEBA>1R@PRSZ6F>GM]@@>1JPM]F*>JB> M]@ I`J1@CI`M(>>6F*H @@ BA>1@ J`>T4IK F>GE@> R ISBM]BEJKGIH1@>
U
]@O @ IKF FE>F4J
?QBL@ BA> M(OO$= S={z\)B>J J1BE@ IS@GIH MS@ B;> MS@CIPM>;>6F*H @Y@CBA>H@CJPwx C
U
]@O @ IKF F*>;F4J=((@ B
JSB>JJ1BL@e BEMSMS@CG?(@ IPM]@eB>;JRB1JK[ @ZHMSBAO1BEGLBEM UFM]@>YF*OF4@O1BLGJ1@ M\OA@CB
J1BE@bwxBBHGF*> M]@>B>;JRSB1J[C@ZdM]BAOHBLGLBM UFMS@>$=%N*BE@ BEMCX F>ISF* @ M]@ I B1IJ1BE@JHIS@CBU
I UT4JPJS@>
??B1IJ1@> P@ ?(@ BLGEJTJS@Z6F>ISFM @ IK BEMSMS@CGM&\VB>J BA F>GLGa*T>
%
O[ ?Y=
$
%
B>J ! xF4@ BEMPM]@ GEM&=
N*BE@` BEMSJ JPBA>J¢*T> F*>> UF*HH@CIK>;J JH@CISJP@CGO @> rB6FGLBEM UFM 6?D@>> F*> ?QBLGEG_\ R<F*>> F*>O @ B
@CBA>H@GE@CBAGIH MS@
U
]@O @ ISGE@F4@>H1@CBMeJ1@CJ>T4I F>G(R:IPBEMSBLJKGIHH@>RSGF>GEBA>F>J`F4@F4@>aUBOA@CI
J1@}wx CJGF>GEBA>F@CIPR>@>;>1@>$=L B>ZH :JSBLR<F>GEBLJGIH1@CI IKB;>J RQUT>> M]@>G IKT4JPJKT 4@ IWCL"C @CR MS@
*T>¢J1@IP@CGLFM]Bb>6F*HH@TGLBE@F4@>J1@>¢XuH6F>JP@> BOA@CIFU F*>F>JKF4@O1BL@ MrOA@CB
JP@CB>$\6? TbJH@CI
H6FI]F>R M]@ IJH@CJ|R:JPM]@ JeT*> @ BA>1@ F*>1BEJKT>MSIKTZA@>8JSR<F>GLF>IS@> T*B1GATOF F>J`[B @ BA>1@
>@CR McT4IPBL@ GLGL@> TB1GTOF4F>J&?(@GIH1JS@ GEM&=N*BL@ ](> M]@ ISJKGIHHBL@JH@ R UT*>> M]@> FEO @ IF*BGIHJB1IKGIH
]@>[B1G UF*>F4GEBAGIH1R@CBM]@> J1@ J MGAFT>ISBEMKHB1J|J1@CIX FI]F* @ MS@CI]FE>Z6F>JPJKB>F4@ IKB1IPJ]F*GIH M JP@CB>$=
FE> JKT4GEGEM]@ F*BHJSJS@ IKJ1@ OA@J1@>1R>@>$\aJ6FJSJJ1BE@CJP@bL IKF4@O>1BEJSJS@F*B1JT@ BA>1@ I`RdBB1GLFM]BT>YBA>
J1@ I
@CJPMS@> T& JPM FE @>$\J1BL@ SF
UB1I
MS@CBEGE?D@CBLJP@`>1BAGIH MTZHMSBA F>GL@L IKF4@O>1BLJPJS@
GEBL@
@ IPM=5 BE@*F*B;GIH BA^ @ I\5J1BL@(X FI]F* @ MS@CI)[B,J1@> I]F*Z;H1@>B>|M(OO$= =zz JSBA>;JBA>bJH@CI
T4GF4@>;J1@> FEO @ GLGL@[B1JSF* @>;F4@
N*BE@ N#FMS@>Z;B>1R M]@ GF*F4@>
UB1I
XuH6F>JP@> UB;O @ IKF F*>;F4JKJ1BGIH M]@K??B1IKJH@QF*B1JaJ1@>ewxBB1GLF*> M]@>HJKGIH>1BMSMKZB>1R M]@>e[B ³
OA@CJM]BA^TM= B1IU
??BHIKJ1@
*~B;>J ³
O @>BdMc[ M=lMBGIH
H1BE@CIKGEBL@F>@>PJ1BL@Ywx C_ @ IPM]@YJBHIKGIH6F*BHJB (@ IS@CBGIH JH@CI+T4I]FEB1JSJSF*F4@>=
UB1I
H6F*OA@>Y?QBLIW@O @>
F>GLGEJ#@CB>1@>ON#FM]@>1R*T>GLG FEZ1Jr4@ ISJKB;GIH M\ ?D@F4@>B>1R GLF"C
IP@CIxL IKF>@O>1BEJSJP@B>J¢JH@CIrJT>IPMrT*H>1@HHBA> JGIH ?QBE@CIPBAF4@>RdBEMKB6FMSBAT>
@>@> McBH@CGLGq[ ?D@CBa>1F*H1@
OA@CBE@CBA>1F*>J1@ ISGLBE@F4@>J1@Ywx C
U
]@O @ IKF'UFE>F4@ J1F*>>F*O @ I?MO1JM F*>JJ6F&T*>sF4@>T^ @>$=
0.01 0.1 1 L/ ξ 0.4
0.5 0.6 U L
L = 3 L = 4 L = 5 L = 6 L = 8 L = 10 L = 13
0.01 0.1 L/ξ 1 0.02 0.04 0.06
k B TL -c χ G
1
V 0 * =1000
0.001 0.01 0.1 L/ξ 1
0.4 0.5 0.6 U L
L = 3 L = 4 L = 5 L = 6 L = 8 L = 10 L = 13
0.001 0.01 0.1 L/ξ 1 0.02 0.04 0.06
k B TL -c χ G
1
V 0 * =1000
0.1 L/ξ 1
0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
L b < ψ G 1 > L
L = 3 L = 4 L = 5 L = 6 L = 8 L = 10 L = 13
0.1 L/ξ 1
0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06
k B TL -c χ G
1
V 0 * = 0.5
0.001 0.01 0.1 L/ξ 1
0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
L b < ψ G 1 > L
L = 3 L = 4 L = 5 L = 6 L = 8 L = 10 L = 13
0.001 0.01 0.1 L/ξ 1 0.02 0.025 0.03 0.035 0.04
k B TL -c χ G
1
V 0 * = 0.5
M(OO1BLGJB>F=zzSN N#FMS@>1RET4GLGLF*Z1J
UBHIH6F>IM]@RSGIH1@ BAOA@>$=xOA@CIP@ @CBEGL@|OA@CB
\
B> MS@CIS@O @ B
S=AN*BL@`GLB>1R>@RSZ6F>GM]@ FEGIH M(J1BE@iM(>>6F*H @T@ BA>1@ J>T>IK F>GL@>R ISBM]BDC
JGIH1@>
U
](OA@CIF F*>F4J\QJHBL@TIP@GIH M]@`JHBL@T@ BA>1@ Jxwx C
U
]@O @ IKF F*>;F4J=QM GLGE@TN#F<M]@>
UB1I
E
B>JH@CI
@CJM]@> T&Q=
B RGIH1GAB1JPJ>TSGIH @CB>1@ (@ @ ISR5B>F [BHIX F>I]FE @ M]@CIO @ JPMSBA^B>F OA@CB wx C
M(>1J]FMK[*NuJ1BE@P6@H1GE@CI&BA> $
%
B>J !OJPBA>J8IP@CGF<M]BF4IT4JSJ\ ?(@ BLG)[E== @ BA>1@PL IH UTH5B>F T>
$
%
B>J F4GE@CBGIH[C@ BEM]BF4@P @CISR GE@CBA>H@CIKB;>FT> !B @ BA>1@> Z6F>JSJP@>JH@> @ IPM @CB>1@>
FJPM
F4GE@CBGIH ?D@CIM]BF4@> wxT4GLGLF*Z1J [B1I@lT4GAF4@xH1FM&=
' # # 0 . /0 , #
F*BZHMKH1@ FiJ1BE@CJP@CJ M(O1JKGIH;>1BEMPM]J(?QBEIKJ|JHBL@( ISF*F4@QJS@ BA>$\ ?QBE@ JSBGIH|J6FJ)XuH6F>JP@>J1BLF*F4ISF*
J1@ I
B6F*> M]@> @GIH6F*>HBLJKGIHH@> H6F>IPMS@>RGIH1@CBO @> BA¦ @CIF4GL@ BAGIHs[BJ1@> R GLF>JSJPBLJKGIHH@>H6F>InC
MS@>RGIH1@CBO @> UF*>JH@CIPM\6? TOA@CB ?QBEIQF>GLJ@X FI]F* @ MS@CI?[B1J UFMc[ GLBGIH [B1I(%@CBEGAGIH1@>[FEH1G J1BE@
%IKT>MPM]@ IKT4IJ>5B>F " B;>JJ1BE@ IS@J;B[CBE@CIPMS@, FJSJS@ iF>ISBEBL@ IS@>YR T>>H@>$=U N*BL@`OA@CBkJ1@>
H6FIPM]@>RSGIHH@CBAOA@> B>JJ1@> N*(C%@CBLGGIH1@> F*BHJ
UBH1IPGLBGIH J1BEJSR5BHMSBL@CIM]@6I]F*F>@x>6F*GIHsJH@CI
MIPM(J1@CJxXuH6FJS@> BOU @ IKF FE>F4J?QBEIKJ H1BL@ I@ M?F>J([B1I BGU R5F4@CJM]@ GLGEM= BEI!?tT4GEGL@>F*BGIHs>1BAGIH M
M(OO1BLGJB>F S={z*NkwxT>;lFBHI]FMSBAT>1@>[B
GEBA>1R J `B;>J
IP@GIH M]J 7=
(@ BAJ1@ (BEGAJ1@ I) BEM z~S\" zB>J =
F4@ M]IP@>> M]@iwWF*Z1BM]@CG P@ ?D@CBLGEJ
UB1I
B>J
F*GIHH@>$=
BLIVH6FEO @>H1BE@CIF*B1JPJKGIH1GEBL@ JSJSGEBAGIHiJ1BL@
@CJM]@ T&5C @T @ MSISBL@uOA@>5BHMK[ M\"B;>JJ1BE@tRdBABC
GLFM]BT>1@> GLBE@
@>
F>JPMF>GLGE@ FEB
J1@CI (I]F b?z*L8B> B1GEBAGIH$=:N#F>J)R:MU F*>;J6F>IKJHJ&:JPMS@ B>HJS@CIP@CI
]@> MS@CIPJKBGIH5B>F>@>bBLJPM`@ BA>1@ Ji BEM 3
\
\pB>J " ~*;=N*BL@ IS@JBSC
[ BL@CIM]@r F>JSJP@
J1@ J?R:M]F*>J6F>IJ1J&:JM]@ J+[C@ BAF>Mt^TSJ1@ I]FM\ F*OA@CI JH@BHMSGLBAGIH|J1@>
L BA>
B1JSJ@J1@ I rB6FE> MS@> @GIH1F*>1BLR'=
xd $fnmA' roH %'#) #) qf)po 3(0(0vfWmro
N*@ I ?QBAGIH MSBAF4JM]@)]@> M]@CIPJKGIH1BE@J`[B1I R GFJSJSBEJKGIH1@>`H6F>IM]@7CnRSGIH1@ BAOA@>SCnRdBABHG FMSBAT>#BEJPMqJ1BL@t FMWC
JSF*GIH1@*\vJ6F>JPJiJ1F>J rB6FE> MS@> M]@ BLGGIH1@>OJS@CB>1@ I UT4JPJS@ UFE>J1@CI> R<F*>>=p]( J6F>J[B J1BEJSR5BSC
MSBL@CIP@>$\ JSBA>;J BA>MO;O$=S={z*,[ ?D@CBwxT>SlFB1ISFM]BT>1@>YFEOF4@OHBLGAJH@ M&\J1BE@ GLB>1R>@
UBHI
B>;JJ1BL@`IS@GIH MS@
UB1I
=AN*BL@ F>JPJS@
BEJPM JS@HHI>1BE@J1IPBAF\'J6F* BEM@ F*>
J1@>L @CR MO @ JSJP@CIWJSBE@H M&=
@[ @CBGIH>1@ M`JPBA>JJ1BE@ *IPM]@`JH@CI#@CB>[C@ GA>1@> IT>MSMS@CIPMS@CBEGAGIH1@>
@ BA>1@PRGIH1@CBO @, BEMTNrB1IKGIH; @ JSJS@ I^ ,B1JPJ F*> JSBGIH§J6F*[B;J1@>1R@>$\ ?D@>> F*>
JPBAGIH,J1BE@@O@GIH1JP@CG?QBLISR5B>;Fe*T4ISJM]@ GLGL@> ?QBLGEG_= B>1R J)O @ B
JSBE@H M) F*>$\ ?QBL@@J1BL@@CB>SC
[ @CGA>H@>P IT>MSMS@CIM]@CBEGAGIH1@> P@ ?D@CBEGLJ@ BA>@ M?FJQF*B1JKF>@CJKGIH; BE@CIPMS@CJ rB6F*> MS@> M]@ BLGAGIHH@>PO1BLGJ1@>=
NrBHIKGIH1JGIH>1BEMPM BLJM JKT4GGIH @ BA>rB6F*> MS@> M]@ BLGAGIHH@> BA> F>GEGL@QBAGIH McB;>F4@>eF4GE@CBGIH1@CI F>JPJS@>$\
F>GEJKT BEJKT>MSIKTZ$\ F*B1JF4@CJGIH BE@CIM&= (@ B
IS@GIH M]@CJ (BEGAJ QJSBL@H MiJ1F>JWF*>J1@ ISJ`F*B1JN
J1BE@i%IKTMSM]@ IPMS@CBLGGIH1@> ?(@ IKJ1@>JB1IGIH¢J6F>J!JPM]F>ISR@T@7:MS@CIK>H@`XqT>MS@> M]BLF>GBA>J1BL@ QBA>>1@>sF4@C
Z1IP@CJPJPM&\ JTYJ6F>JSJ @ J
F>JPM R>@CB>1@+MBHJSJKGIH; BE@CIKB;>FWBA>
C QBAGIH MKB>FxF4BOHM&=">eJ1@CI C QBAGIH MKB>F
J6FEF4@F4@> JKGIH;T> >JPBL@ BLJMq>@CIKF>GL@CBGIH5O6F>Iv BMqJH@CI OA@CB
=E FE>TR<F*>> JPBAGIHTF*>H6F*>;JJ1BL@C
JP@CI (BLGJ1@CI JKGIHT>OF*B1J FGL@>\ ?D@CGAGIHH@M(B1JP?QBEISR5B>F4@>J1F>J`F*B
J6F>JXuH6F>JP@>J1BLF*F4ISF*
H6F<M&NVOA@CBuJ1@ I`R GLF>JSJPBLJKGIHH@>RdBABHGFMSBAT> BEJPMYJ1BE@eL BA>1JGIH1I UF*>HRB;>FsJ1@ I GAB1R MKB6FM]BT>1@> BA>
C !BGIH MKB>F O @ BuF4IKT4JPJS@
UB1IYJ1@> IP@C@> MSI]F*>G @7CXH1F>JS@> UBOA@CIKF4F*>Fs>@CI]FE> M?tT4IM]GLBGIH$\
?D@CBEG JSBGIH J6F*JBHIKGIH J1BL@swxTZZA@CGAB;>F[ ?QBEJKGIH1@> J1@> %@CBLGGIH1@>O @>6F*GIH5O6F>IM]@CI QBA>;>1@>
>1@O @>,J1BL@ JS@3L @CR MKFEBGIHbJ1BE@(%@CBEGAGIH1@> #R GL@ BA>1@ IDB>
C QBAGIH MKB>F=:N*@CJH6F>GO BLJM
J1@ ITIP@C@> MSI]F*>G @7C (@CIP@CBAGIH§OA@CBkJ1@ I rB6F*> M]@>1JSBB1GLFM]BT>4@CIF4I T>JSJS@U IPM&B @CIF4GL@ BAGIH[B1I
R GFJSJSBEJKGIH1@>`RdBB1GLFM]BT>$=7 L dMSIS@
F>GEG>@ BA>1@ JvB;>1@>JHGLBAGIHF4IT4JSJP@> UF*B1JSJP@CIP@>`XvT>M]@> MSBF>GEJ
UB1JSJP@> F>GLGE@+ IT>MSMS@CIPMS@CBEGAGIH1@>F4@>6F*B BA>^J1@>bBA>HBA FrJ1@CI QBA>>1@> GEBL@F4@>$\*B>J|JH@CJKH1F>GAO
R<F*>>JT4IMpJ1@CIvXuH6F>JP@> B;OU @ IKF F*>;F(T*>iJ1@ IVTJB1GEBL@ IPM]@>Y GBHJSJSBF4R>@U BEMV[B w#ISBEJPM]F>GLGE>1BAGIH M
B> MS@CIKH1F>GAOb*T> z $
~~`GLBE@F4@>$\ UF*H>1GEBAGIH ?QBE@OA@CBJH@CI(R GLF>JSJPBLJKGIHH@> RdBAB1GF"C
MSBAT>$= UFEH1IS@>J JPBAGIH B>PJ1@CI!R GF>JPJSBLJGIH1@>¢RdBAB1G FMSBAT>,JHBL@XuH6F>JS@> BOA@CIFU F*>F4JJ1BAGIH MS@ F*O
F*B
? UF>IPMSJ(R<F*B >TGIH UF*>JH@CIPM\:?(F*>JH@CIPMJSBL@!BA
B6FE> MS@> @GIH1F*>1BLJGIH1@> F>GLG
>TGIHJ1@BHM]GEBAGIH[BF4I
U
T4JSJP@CIS@> N*BAGIH MS@>$= N*@CI IB>J BEJPM\vJ1F>JSJiJ1BL@ N*@
T4I BE@CIKB;>FPJ1@CJ
rB6F*> MS@> M]@ BLGAGIHH@>1J JKT*[B1JSF*F4@>8JGIH ?QBE@CIPBAF4@ I&BLJPMB>J8JSBGIH8F*BGIH>TGIH§O @ B F4IT4JSJP@>
JPBAF>1B6R<F*> M|UF*>J1@ IK> R<F*>;>$\ ?iUF*H1IS@>JJ1BE@ @> M]IPBL@CIB>FJ1@CIi @ BLGGIH1@>OF>GLJ F*>[ @CJ O @C
JGIH1ISBE@OA@>s[E=(=J;B1IKGIH J1@>sRSGIH ?(@ IKZB;>1R MxJ1@CI@%IKT>MPM]@CIPR>@ MSM]@ ?OA@CB
ZHI]F>R M]BEJKGIH
F*O;F4@CJGIH1GAT4JPJS@> BLJM&=
UB1I¢JHBL@ @CIPGF*F>@CIKB;>F J1@CI XuH6F>JP@> UB;O @ IKF F*>;F4JKJ1BGIH M]@[B F4I UT4JPJS@ IS@> O@CIPMS@> O @ B
?(F*GIH1JP@>J1@
F*O
$
!JPBA>J BA
=R:JPMS@ FGLJKT[ ?D@CBuL @CR M]@>@CISF*> M? T4IMC
GEBAGIH$N$[B @ BA>1@> JHBL@^ @> MSISBL@ IKB>;FJH@CIY @ BLGGIH1@> F>GEJ F*>;[C@CJWB>J1@>XqT>MS@> M]BLF>GLIPBA>>H@>
OA@CBq BMSM]@ GAF4IT4JSJP@>sXqT>MS@> M]BLF>GL@>
@B;>JJ1@CI(J6F* BEM@4@ IKOB>;J1@>1@>L B>SC
JGIH1I UF*>HRB;>F`J1@CIk GB1R McB6F<M]BAT*>1@> JS@>1R IS@GIH M+J1F*[B$\5B>;J|[B; F*>J1@ IS@>J1BL@ rB1@ M]JKGIH5B>;F
J1@ I
B6F*> MS@> @GIH6FE>1BLJGIH1@>,%@CBEGAGIH1@>F*> JSBAGIHO @ B'F4IKT4JPJS@>,XqT>MS@> M]BLF>GL@>$\4?(F>J(@O @>
F>GLGEJ
[B1I@L> MSR*TZZA@CGB>FJ1@CI?%@CBLGGIH1@>OA@>6F*GIH5O6FIPM]@ I QBA>;>1@>
UBH1IM&=
N#F>JK? T>GLGL@> ?QBEI?>B;>¢F4@>1F*B1@CI@B> M]@ ISJBGIH1@>B>;J BA> lT4IK @CG>
F>JSJP@>$= N#F*[B O1I]FEBSC
GIH1@>[BH@CISJM @ BA>i>@CI> UB>
MSBAF4@ Ja FJSJ
UBHIqJ1BE@JB1IKGIHJ1BL@ rB6F*> M]@> @GIH6F*>HBLRr4@ IKB1IPJ]F*GIH MS@
[B1J UFMK[CGEBAGIH1@^MB1JJ1@H;>B;>F¢J1@ IRGIH1@CBO @>$\pJ1BL@&?QBLI#B>Y@CBA>H@ @ @CR MSB4@> NrB1IGIH @CJSJP@CI
@CI
F>JSJP@>b? T4GEGL@>$= N#F*>>bRQUT>>1@> ?QBEI`>pUF* GLBAGIH§B;> MS@CI (@>5BHMK[B>;FT*>
F>JSJP@>b? T4GEGL@>$= N#F*>>bRQUT>>1@> ?QBEI`>pUF* GLBAGIH§B;> MS@CI (@>5BHMK[B>;FT*>