2. Fundamentals 10
2.6. Numerial Methods
2.6.6. The Operator-Splitting method
2.6.6.2. Errors of the method
utilization of the variable step size and order features of the ordinary dierential equation
solver. The result of the seond hemistry operator is a predited solution at
t + 1
, whihthe transportoperator then uses as initialonditionsto omplete the step.
It seems natural, whenperforming any kind ofimplementation ina CFD ode or any other
typeofsoftware, tostartalulatingsimpleproblems beforeattemptingmoreomplexones.
The time and eort required for a alulation is shorter and the results an be more easily
veried with available 1D tools. This way, the rst step in order to ahieve the oupling of
the CFD-solver and the CHEMKIN-pakage has been the simulation of 1D ongurations
assumingonstant properties ofthe gas (onstantdensityand visosity),and negleting the
speies diusion and heat transfer inorder to reprodue the perfetlystirred reator model
in aone-dimensional simulation.
By means of the program SENKIN, we have obtained the solution for
Y k
andT
fromthe following system of dierentialequations:
ρ dY k
dt = ˙ ω k
ρc p k
dT
dt = − X
k
˙ ω k h k
(3.1)
appliedtotheombustionmehanismsof hydrogenandmethane. Theseequationsrepresent
a partiular ase of the speies (2.13) and energy (2.4) transport equation in whih all
omponents of the veloity vetor are equalto zero in the whole domain. They orrespond
to the denition of a perfetly stirred reator, whose desription has been given in setion
1.4.2.3. The solutions given by the 1D tool SENKIN will be used to verify the results
obtained by means of the operator-splittingsheme implemented inFASTEST-3Dfor a 1D
onguration.
A seond step in order to verify the validity of the implementation is the alulation
of hydrogen and methane ombustion in a plug-ow reator (PFR). This model onsiders
following assumptions:
•
Axial ow•
Perfet mixingin radialdiretionbut nomixinginaxial diretion•
Constant density•
Steady stateSymmetry
Inlet
Outlet
Symmetry
Figure3.1.: Linear reator used for
H 2
andCH 4
1D ombustionThe speies and energy transport equations for the plug-ow reator(with
D k , λ = 0
)an be simpliedto:
ρu ∂Y k
∂x = ˙ ω k
ρuc p k
∂T
∂x = −
N
X
k =1
h k ω ˙ k
(3.2)
By foringthe veloitytobe
u = 1
inthe wholedomain,equations 3.2are equivalenttoequations 3.1where the variable
t
has been substituted by the spatialvariablex
.Theomputationalgeometryhasbeenrepresentedingure3.1. Itonsistsofaartesian
grid withalltheells havingequaldimensionsandwithamuhlargernumberofthemalong
the owdiretion (50 for hydrogen and 500 for methane), while the ross setionis divided
in
3 × 3
ells. The boundary onditions used inthe alulation have been presented in thesame gure.
It is well known that mesh size and time step have a very big impat on errors
asso-iated to the operator-splitting sheme ([37℄, [93℄ and [48℄). Several simulations have been
performed for dierent values of these parameters, as well as for dierent temporal
dis-retization shemes,inorder toahievethe requiredknowledge tobeapplyed latterinmore
omplex 2D ongurations. Sine the operator-splitting sheme is applied usually to
un-steady alulations (even inthe ase of steadyproesses), the temporaldisretizationof the
problem issupposedto inuene the aurayof the method,even if not asritiallyas the
spatial disretization [40℄.
Bysalingthegridweanobservethe inueneofthespaingonthe nalsolution. The
time step of the splitting orresponds to twie the time step of the CFD-solver and, thus,
the sheme providesa Strang-type yle:
∆t cf d + 2 × ∆t chem + ∆t cf d
This expression is equivalent to equations 2.79. All 1D and 3D simulations shown in this
workmakeuseofthesameapproahand,therefore,nodesriptionofhemialormehanial
time step willbe madein followingsetions.
To determine the inuene of the grid spaing and the time step inthe results,the two
parametrial analysis presented in the next setions have been performed. They show the
solution of the PFR-problem for stoihiometri mixtures of fuel and air for dierent values
of grid spaing and time step.
Theresultsaregivenasafuntionofthetemporaldisretization(
∆t
),spatialdisretiza-tion (
∆x
) onstant allalong the reator, and of theCourant − F riedrich − Lewis
(CF L
)number, whihis the ratio of a time step to the ellresidene time:
CF L = u∆t
∆x
(3.3)The onvergene riterion for the simulations performed with the ode FASTEST-3D
has been seleted to be equal to
10 − 3
. This value is kept as well for the 2D simulations presented in the next hapter.3.1. Stoihiometri
H 2 − air
ombustionHydrogenwilllikelybeometheprimaryenergyarrierinthefuture. Ononehand,hydrogen
has the potential for utting greenhouse gas emissions as well as reduing rural, urban
and regional air pollution. Besides, there is presently onsiderable interest worldwide in
promoting hydrogen as a fuel for transport. As oil beomes more expensive, hydrogen
may eventually replae it as a transport fuel and in other appliations. This development
beomesmore likelyasfuel ells are developed, with hydrogen asthe preferred fuel,though
storage at vehile sale is a major hallenge. Meanwhile hydrogen an be used in internal
ombustion engines [35℄. The simpliityof some ombustion mehanisms, whih reprodue
withreasonableauraythereationstaking plaeinhydrogenombustion,makesitavery
attrativetopi for omputationalanalysis.
For the ase of hydrogen ombustion, a stoihiometri mixture of fuel and air evolves
aording tothe speies andtemperatureprolesshown ingure3.2and 3.3. These are the
results provided by the SENKIN ode that will be used as referene for the veriation of
the 1D resultsgiven by FASTEST-3D.
The initial temperature is set to
1400
K. The fuel-air mixture is stoihiometri:Y H 2 =
0.028
,Y O 2 = 0.226
andY N 2 = 0.745
and the timestep amounts to1 × 10 − 6 s
. Ignition startsafter
2 × 10 − 5 s
. The temperaturereahes2800
K after2 × 10 − 4 s
.1e-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
0 2e-05 4e-05 6e-05 8e-05 0.0001
MASS FRACTION
TIME (s)
O2 H2 H2O H O OH
Figure3.2.: Speies evolutionin stoihiometri
H 2
ombustiongiven by SENKIN1200 1400 1600 1800 2000 2200 2400 2600
0 2e-05 4e-05 6e-05 8e-05 0.0001
TEMPERATURE (K)
TIME (s)
Figure 3.3.: Temperatureevolution in stoihiometri
H 2
ombustiongiven by SENKINTheresultingspeiesmassfrations(
Y k
)andtemperature(T
)timeevolutionshavebeenompared with the ones resultingfrom the CFD simulations intwo ases:
•
Closed system where time is the onlyindependent variable (PSR)•
Reating owwith onstant properties and nodiusion of speies (PFR)In bothases, theequationssolved by FASTEST-3Dare equivalenttothe onessolved inthe
SENKIN ode (equations 3.1). The equivalene between the perfetly stirred reator and
the plug-ow reator with onstant properties is ahieved through the hange of variable
x = u · t
and eliminatingthe spatial diusion of speies and temperature. The density and the veloity are onstant along the reator. Asu = 1
inthe whole burner, the evolutionsintime forthePSRandinspaeforthe PFRhavetobeoinident. Arst-orderfullyimpliit
algorithmhas been hosen for the time integration.