and sharing with colleagues.
Other uses, including reproduction and distribution, or selling or licensing copies, or posting to personal, institutional or third party
websites are prohibited.
In most cases authors are permitted to post their version of the article (e.g. in Word or Tex form) to their personal website or institutional repository. Authors requiring further information
regarding Elsevier’s archiving and manuscript policies are encouraged to visit:
http://www.elsevier.com/copyright
ContentslistsavailableatSciVerseScienceDirect
Materials Science and Engineering A
j ou rna l h o me p a g e :w w w . e l s e v i e r . c o m / l o c a t e / m s e a
Precipitation microstructure and age-hardening response of an Mg–Gd–Nd–Zn–Zr alloy
J.H. Li
a,c,1, G. Sha
a,b,∗, T.Y. Wang
a, W.Q. Jie
c, S.P. Ringer
a,baAustralianCentreforMicroscopyandMicroanalysis,TheUniversityofSydney,MadsenBuildingF09,Sydney,NSW2006,Australia
bARCCentreofExcellenceforDesigninLightMetals,TheUniversityofSydney,Sydney,NSW2006,Australia
cStateKeyLaboratoryofSolidificationProcessing,NorthwesternPolytechnicalUniversity,Xi’an,710072,China
a r t i c l e i n f o
Articlehistory:
Received14December2010 Receivedinrevisedform11June2011 Accepted25October2011
Available online 3 November 2011
Keywords:
Magnesiumalloys Precipitation Agehardening Atomprobetomography Transmissionelectronmicroscopy
a b s t r a c t
PrecipitatesinanMg–3.6Gd–2.8Nd–0.6Zn–0.4Zr(wt.%)alloyagedfortimesupto70hat200◦Chave beencharacterisedusingtransmissionelectronmicroscopyandatomprobetomography.Theprecipitate phasesknownas,and1occurduringthisageing.ThesoluteelementsNd,ZnandGdpartition significantlyintotheseprecipitates.Theenhancedageinghardeningresponseafteraged70hismainly attributedtotheprecipitationofand1withanumberdensitybyafactorof10lessthanthatof andprecipitatesformedafter3hageing.
Crown Copyright © 2011 Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Magnesiumalloysareattractiveduetotheirspecificstrength, providing potential for weight reduction in automotive and aerospaceapplications[1,2].TheMg–NdbasedalloyssuchasZM- 6 in Chinaand ML10 in Russia exhibit a strongage hardening responseandhavebeenusedinvariousstructuralairframecom- ponents.However,thehightemperaturemechanicalpropertiesof theseandotherMg–Ndbasedalloysareinadequatefortechnologi- calapplicationsabovetemperaturesof250◦C.Thedevelopmentof Mgalloysforthesehighertemperatureapplicationsremainsasig- nificantresearchtargetfortheinternationalmaterialscommunity [3–18]andthisisalsothegeneralsubjectofthiscontribution.
Heavyrareearth(HRE)elementssuchasNd,Gd,Y,Dy,Er,Sc,Tb andSm,havebeenusedwidelytoimprovethemechanicalproper- tiesofMgalloysatbothroomandelevatedtemperatures[3–12].
Indeed,mosthigh-strengthMgalloyssuchasWE54/43andQE22 containHREelements.ThelevelofalloyingadditionoftheHREele- mentsisacriticalconcerninalloydevelopmentanddesignbecause ofbothmaterialcostsandthedesiretohavethealloyaslightas
∗Correspondingauthorat:AustralianCentreforMicroscopyandMicroanalysis, TheUniversityofSydney,MadsenBuildingF09,Sydney,NSW2006,Australia.
Tel.:+61290369050;fax:+61293517682.
E-mailaddresses:jie-hua.li@hotmail.com(J.H.Li),gang.sha@sydney.edu.au (G.Sha).
1 Currentaddress:ChairofCastingResearch,theUniversityofLeoben,Austria.
possible.Thishasdrivensignificantresearchinrecenttimes:(e.g.) Nieatal.[17]havedemonstratedthatsmalladditionsofZnstim- ulateanagehardeningresponseinMg–GdalloysthatpossessGd contentsthatarebelowthelevelordinarilyassociatedwithasig- nificantageingresponse.Moreover,combinedadditionsofGdwith ZntoMg–Ndalloyshavebeenreportedtoimprovethemechani- calpropertiesofthealloys,particularlyatelevatedtemperatures [11,12].Itisexpectedthattheimprovementofmechanicalprop- ertiesoftheseMg–Gd–Nd–Znalloysshouldbecorrelatedtothe precipitatesmicrostructuresformedduringageingtreatment.To date,thereisalackofdetailedinvestigationstorevealtheevolu- tionofprecipitatesmicrostructureandthepartitioningofsolutes duringageingthesealloys.
In this paper, transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and atom probe tomography (APT) have been employed to char- acterise precipitates microstructures formed during ageing a quinary Mg–3.6Gd–2.8Nd–0.6Zn–0.4Zr(wt.%)alloy.Quantitative APTanalysisaimstorevealthepartitioningbehaviourofsolutes.
Comprehensivestructuralinformationobtainedfromacombina- tionofTEMandAPTcharacterisationswillhelptoelucidatethe precipitationreactionsandtounderstandthenanostructurepro- vidinghardeningeffectinthealloy.
2. Experimentalprocedures
TheMg–3.6Gd–2.8Nd–0.6Zn–0.4Zr(wt.%)alloywasprepared from pure Mg (99.9%), Zn (99.9%), Nd (99.9%), Mg–28Gd and 0921-5093/$–seefrontmatter.Crown Copyright © 2011 Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.msea.2011.10.092
2 J.H.Lietal./MaterialsScienceandEngineeringA534 (2012) 1–6
Fig.1.AgehardeningresponseofMg–3.6Gd–2.8Nd–0.6Zn–0.4Zr(wt.%)alloyaged at200◦C.Forcomparison,theresultoftheGd-freealloyisalsoincluded.
Mg–33Zr (wt.%) master alloys in an electric resistance furnace undertheprotectionofananti-oxidizingflux,andthencastinto asandmould.Solutiontreatmentwasperformedinasaltbathat 520◦Cfor18h,followedbyquenchingintocoldwaterandthen ageingin oilat200◦Cfor upto100h. Vickershardnesstesting wasperformedusingaLECOHardnessTester(LV700AT)with10N loadand15sdwelltime.EachdatapointreportedinFig.1repre- sentsanaverageofatleast10measurements.Thefoilspecimens forTEMwere preparedby twinjetelectro-polishing ina solu- tionof25%HClO4and75%methanolcooleddownto−40◦Cwith avoltageof20V,andthenusinglow energybeamionthinning forsurfacecleanness.TEMexaminationswereperformedusinga CM12operatingat120kVandaJEOL-3000Foperatingat300kV.
Thesamplesforatomprobeanalysiswerecutandmechanically groundtosquarerodsofapproximately0.5mm×0.5mm×15mm, andthensharpenedbymicro-electro-polishing.APTanalyseswere performedusinganImagoLEAPTM3000operatingataspecimen temperatureof20K,20%pulsefractionandunderultrahighvac- uumconditions.
Atom probe data sets were carefully reconstructed using an approach outlined recently by Gault and co-workers [19].
The maximum separation algorithm was employed to identify solute-richprecipitatesandtheconcentrationofthematrixwas measuredafter removingidentifiedprecipitates[20,21].Nd, Gd and Znwereselected as precipitationsolutesand a separation distance of 0.8nm and the minimum size of 15 solute atoms wereused intheprecipitateidentification[22].A selectionbox analysismethod wasused tomeasure precipitate composition.
Suchmethodscanconvolutenon-systematicerrorswhereirreg- ularmorphologiesareinvolved.Selectionboxmethodsalsotend to minimise the influence of ion trajectory overlaps that can occurinmulti-componentsystemssuchashere,whereelements withwidely varying evaporative fields are involved. The aver- agecompositionofprecipitateswasmeasuredfromtheircentral 2nmregion.
3. Resultsanddiscussion
3.1. AgehardeningresponseoftheMg–Gd–Nd–Zn–Zralloy
Fig. 1 reveals the age hardening response of the quinary Mg–3.6Gd–2.8Nd–0.6Zn–0.4Zr(wt.%) alloy.For comparison, the resultof theGd-free alloyis alsoincluded. It is clearthat the age hardening response of the alloy containing 3.6wt% Gd is higher than that of Gd-freealloy. It should be noted that the
hardnessof thequinary alloyincreasedquicklyduring thefirst 1.5h at 200◦C, witha hardnessincrease from 65HV of an as- quenched sample to 85HV of a sample aged for 1.5h. The 20HV hardness increment is equivalent to 30% of the initial hardness of the as-quenched sample. This fast age-hardening response canbedirectly correlatedtothestrongerpartitioning ofNdinMg–Ndbasedalloys[13].Thenitreachedaplateau-like range before reachingpeak hardnessafter 70h. Furtherageing led toover-ageing and a progressive decrease in hardness.On thebasis of theseresults, thesamples agedat 0h(as-quench), 3h, 14h and 70h were selected for TEM observationand APT analysis.
3.2. TEMcharacterisationofprecipitatesinthe Mg–Gd–Nd–Zn–Zralloy
Fig.2showsatypicalbrightfield(BF)TEMimageandthecor- respondingselectedareaelectrondiffraction(SAED)patternand energydispersiveX-ray(EDX)spectratakenfromtheas-quench Mg–3.6Gd–2.8Nd–0.6Zn–0.4Zr (wt.%) alloy.Only some particles containingZr(Fig.2c)arerarelydistributedinthe␣-Mgmatrix.
No otherprecipitatesarepresent inthemicrostructure(Fig.2a and b). These Zr particles were believed to play an important roleinthegrainrefinementofMgalloy,buthavenogreateffect ontheprecipitationstrengthening due totheirsparsedistribu- tion.
Fig.3showsaseriesofrepresentative[0110]MgBFTEMimages andthecorrespondingSAEDpatternsofsamplesagedat200◦Cfor 3h,14hand70h.Notwithstandingthewell-knowndifficultiesin achievinglarge,uniformlythinregionsoffoilinMgalloyscontain- ingmultipleHREs,thismicroscopyconfirmsthepresenceofafine anduniformdispersionofprecipitatesinalloftheseageingcon- ditions.Afterageingfor3h,theSAEDpatternin[0110]Mgzone axisoftheMgmatrix,asshowninFig.3b,wasobservedcontain- ingtheweakdiffractionstreaksat1/2(2110)Mgand1/2(2114)Mg (markedwithawhitearrow),indicatingthatprecipitatesformed inthealloy.ThephasepossessesaDO19crystalstructurewith ahexagonalunitcellofa=b=0.64nmandc=0.52nm[8]andit wasreportedtohaveastoichiometryMg3X[10].Theprecipi- tateshaveageneralhabitplaneparallelto{21 10}Mg.Inaddition tothoseweakdiffractionstreaksofprecipitates,theextremely weakdiffractionofprecipitatesat1/2(2112)Mg,markedwitha blackarrowinFig.3b,wasobservedinthe[0110]MgSAEDpattern.
Thissuggeststhatalownumberdensityofprecipitatesco-exist withthemorenumerousprecipitatesatthisstageofageing.The
phaseisknowntohaveabase-centredorthorhombicunitcell a=0.640nm,b=2.223nm,c=0.521nm[8]andstoichiometryMg5X [10].
Afterageingfor14h,diffractionintensityat1/2(2112)Mgwas stronger in the[0110]Mg SAEDpatterns (markedwitha black arrow in Fig.3d),suggesting that more  precipitatesformed.
Afterageingfor70h, aweakdiffractionspotclearlyadjacentto 1/2(2110)Mg,as marked witha black box in Fig.3f, indicates thepresenceof1 inthemicrostructure.Thisphasepossessesa face-centredcubicunitcellwitha=0.72nmandstoichiometryof Mg3X[6,8,10].Theorientationrelationshipsbetweentheprecipi- tatessuchas,,1andthematrixareinagreementwiththose reportedpreviously[6,8,10].Thus,theprecipitationsequencein thisquinaryMgalloyduringageingissupersaturatedsolidsolution (SSSS)→(D019)→(bco)→1(fcc).phase(aface-centred cubicunitcellwitha=2.223nmandstoichiometryofMg3X[6])has beenconsideredtotheequilibriumphaseinthealloy,itmayeven- tuallyprecipitate,althoughitwasnotobservedover70hageingat 200◦C.
Fig.2.TEMbrightfieldimage(a),correspondingSAEDpattern(b)andEDXanalysis(c)takenfromtheas-quenchMg–3.6Gd–2.8Nd–0.6Zn–0.4Zr(wt.%)alloy.
3.3. APTcharacterisationofprecipitatesintheMg–Gd–Nd–Zn–Zr alloy
Fig. 4 provides a series of three-dimensional atom maps recorded from atom probe experiments on specimens of the Mg–3.6Gd–2.8Nd–0.6Zn–0.4Zr(wt.%)alloyafterageingat200◦C for(a)3h(b)14hand(c)70h.Itisclearthatallthreeofthemain soluteelements,Nd,GdandZnweredirectlyimagedwithinthe precipitates.Usingthezonelinesandpolesobservedfromthefield desorptionimageavailableinatomprobemicroscopy,theview directionsofthetomogramsprovidedcanbespecificallydefined, e.g.theviewdirectionofimagesinFig.4a–cis[0001]Mg.Byexam- iningasmallregimemarkedwithwhitesolidlinesinFig.4aata highmagnification,atomicplanes(0110)Mgand(0111)Mgwere clearlyresolvedinFigs.5aandb.Threeelongatedprecipitatesare present in thesmall volume.A platelet precipitate habitingon {0110}Mg isprobably.Thissuggestionisconsistentwiththe habitplane{0110}Mg of inMg alloysreportedin literatures [16,18].Arodprecipitatehabitingon{2110}Mgonlyseparatedby oneortwoatomicplanesfromtheplateletmaybeidentifiedas
,asseeninFig.5b.Byexaminingtheprecipitatesfromdifferent viewdirections,wefoundthatmostprecipitateswereelongated withtheirlongitudinalaxisparallelto[0001]Mg.Thisobservation isinagreementwithpreviousTEMobservationsfor,and1
[6,10].
Fromthe[0001]Mgviewdirection,thesizeoflargeprecipitates wasfoundtoincreasewithageingtime(Fig.4),whichisnoteasyto seefromthewholeanalysedvolumeduetotheoverlapofthehigh numberdensityofprecipitates(Fig.4b).Mostoftheprecipitates
formedbetween3hand70hageinghaveelongatedmorphology along[0001]Mg,whichareeffectiveobstaclestobasalslip[23].It isalsonoteworthythatthenumberdensityofprecipitatesappears tobehighestinthesampleaged3handthatthisprogressively decreaseswhencomparedtothenumberdensitiesofprecipitates afterageingfor14hand70h.Ouranalysisoftotalnumberdensity revealsthattherearelessprecipitatesbyafactorof10inthesam- pleaged70hat200◦Ccomparedtothesampleaged3handyetthe hardnessis10%higherinthe70hsample.Thedecreaseinprecipi- tatenumberdensityisincontrasttoanincreaseinhardnesswith increasingageingtimefrom3hto70h,probablyimplyingthatthe differentprecipitatesformedunderdifferentageingtimehadthe differentpotencyinproducingstrengtheningeffect.Giventhatthe formationofmoreand1precipitateswiththeincreaseofageing timeasrevealedbyTEMcharacterisationdescribedpreviously,we canconcludethattheand1aremorepotenthardeningobsta- clesthanthephaseinthealloy.Interestingly,similarconclusion hasbeendrawninafewotherMg–REalloysincludingWE54alloy aged at 250◦C [6] and Mg–2.0Gd–1.2Y–1.0Zn–0.2Zr (at.%)alloy agedat225◦C[10],wherethepeak-agedmicrostructurecontains predominantlytheand1phases.
Theaveragecompositionsoflargeprecipitatesformedatdif- ferent ageing time are shown in Fig. 6a. Since APT chemical compositionanalysisindicatedthatsoluteconcentrationincrease withprecipitatesize,andTEMSAEDanalysisconfirmedtheco- existenceofand,and1indifferentageingconditions,it isreasonabletoassumeherethatlargeprecipitatemeasuredat3h shouldbecorrespondingto,andlargehigh-solute-concentration precipitatesobservedat70hcorrespondto1.TheGdconcentra- tionwithinthelargeprecipitateswaseffectivelyunchangedduring
4 J.H.Lietal./MaterialsScienceandEngineeringA534 (2012) 1–6
Fig.3. [0110]MgbrightfieldTEMimagesandcorrespondingSAEDpatternsfromthemicrostructureofMg–3.6Gd–2.8Nd–0.6Zn–0.4Zr(wt.%)alloysamplesagedat200◦C forvarioustimes:(aandb)3h,(candd)14hand(eandf)70h.
Fig.4.CombinedatommapsofNd(red),Gd(blue)andZn(green)obtainedfromMg–3.6Gd–2.8Nd–0.6Zn–0.4Zr(wt.%)alloysamplesagedat200◦Cfor(a)3h,(b)14hand (c)70h,inaviewdirectionclosetothe[0001]Mgzoneaxis.(Forinterpretationofthereferencestocolorinthisfigurelegend,thereaderisreferredtothewebversionof thearticle.)
Fig.5.Highresolutionimagesofasmallregion(asmarkedwithwhitesolidlinesinFig.3a)obtainedfromMg–3.6Gd–2.8Nd–0.6Zn–0.4Zr(wt.%)alloysamplesagedat200◦C for3h,inviewdirectionscloseto[2 110]Mg(a)and[0001]Mg(b)zoneaxesrespectively.
Fig.6.Soluteconcentrationsoflargeprecipitates(a)andmatrix(b)inMg–3.6Gd–2.8Nd–0.6Zn–0.4Zr(wt.%)alloysamplesagedat200◦Cfrom3hto70h.
70hofageingat200◦C.However,theZnandNdconcentrations withintheprecipitatesincreasedwithincreasingageingtime.The Nd:Znratiooftheprecipitateswasapproximately1.6:1through- outtheageingsequenceexaminedhere,whichissimilarto,though slightlylessthanthe2:1ratioreportedfromTEM-basedenergy dispersiveX-rayspectroscopy(EDXS)microanalysisofprecipi- tatesinasimilaralloy[16].TheprecipitateswererichestinNdof allsolutesandtheconcentrationofthiselementincreasedfrom
∼11 to∼15at.%duringageing.Thisisalsoclosetotheaverage compositionof15at.%measuredbyEDXS[16].Acombinedcon- centrationofMgandZnis84at.%,andacombinedconcentration ofNdandGdis16at.%inlargeprecipitates(likely)formedafter ageingfor3h.Thisgivesthelargeprecipitateswithastoichimetry of(Mg,Zn)5(Nd,Gd).Thestoichimetryisconsistentwithhaving Mg5NdreportedinbinaryMg–Ndalloy[13].Incontrast,thecom- positionofthelargeprecipitatesformedafterageingfor70hthat werethoughttobe1phaseonthebasisoftheSAEDanalysis,Fig.3, gives(Mg,Zn)4(Nd,Gd).ThisisincontrastwithMg3Xproposedby previousresearch[6,8,10].FurtherAPTinvestigationisnecessary tomeasurethechemistryof1 inover-agedsample.Ithasbeen reportedthattheprecipitatesformedinbinaryMg–Ndalloyspos- sessarangeofcompositionsfromMg5NdtoMg9Nd[16,18].We concludethatthetransformationsfromtoand1arerelated tofurtherenrichmentofNd,ZnandGdsolutesintheprecipitates.
Thesoluteconcentrationsinthematrixdecreasedduringageingat 200◦Cfrom3hto70h,asindicatedinFig.6b.Theseresultsindicate thatsignificantsoluteshavepartitionedintotheprecipitates.The lowconcentrationsofNd,GdandZnmeasuredinthematrixafter ageingfor70hindicatethattheequilibriumsolubilityofNdshould belessthan0.13at.%inthisMgalloyandthatthesolubilityofGd shouldbelowerthan0.23at.%.ThismayexplainwhyGddoesnot seemtopartitionintoanyofthe,,or1precipitatesphases observedintheselowGdcontentalloys[16].
4. Conclusion
TheprecipitatesequenceintheMg–3.6Gd–2.8Nd–0.6Zn–0.4Zr (wt.%)alloyduringageingat200◦Cover70his→→1.The precipitateshavea lamella-likemorphologywithalongitudinal axisparallelto[0001]Mg.ThesoluteelementsNd,ZnandGdpar- titionsignificantlyintotheprecipitates(, and1).Thepeak hardnessat70hisincoincidencewithalownumberdensityofpre- cipitates(and1)inthemicrostructureofthealloybutwitha highfractionofthetotalsolutesassociatedwithprecipitation.The enhancedageinghardeningresponseafteraged70hwasmainly attributedtotheprecipitationofand1precipitateswithanum- berdensitybyafactorof10lessthanthatofandprecipitates formedafter3hageing.
Acknowledgments
The authors are grateful for scientific and technical input and support from the Australian Microscopy & Microanalysis ResearchFacility(AMMRF)nodeattheUniversityofSydney.J.H.
LialsowishestothanktheChinaScholarshipCouncilforfinancial support. Thiswork is partly supportedby theDoctorate Foun- dationofNorthwesternPolytechnicalUniversityundergrantno.
(CX200705).
References
[1]B.Smola,I.Stulíková,F.vonBuch,B.L.Mordike,Mater.Sci.Eng.A324(2002) 113–117.
[2]J.Grobner,R.Schmid-Fetzer,J.AlloysCompd.320(2001)296–301.
[3]S.M.He,X.Q.Zeng,L.M.Peng,X.Gao,J.F.Nie,W.J.Ding,J.AlloysCompd.427 (2007)316–323.
[4]B.L.Mordike,Mater.Sci.Eng.A324(2002)103–112.
[5] V.Neubert,I.Stulíková,B.Smola,B.L.Mordike,M.Vlanch,A.Bakkar,J.Pelcová, Mater.Sci.Eng.A462(2007)329–333.
6 J.H.Lietal./MaterialsScienceandEngineeringA534 (2012) 1–6
[6]J.F.Nie,B.C.Muddle,ActaMater.48(2000)1691–1703.
[7]I.Stulikova,B.Smoloa,B.L.Mordike,Phys.StatusSolidiA190(2002)5–7.
[8]T.Honma,T.Ohkubo,K.Hona,S.Kamado,Mater.Sci.Eng.A395(2005)301–306.
[9]J.H.Li,W.Q.Jie,G.Y.Yang,ActaMetall.Sinca10(2007)1077–1081.
[10]T.Honma,T.Ohkubo,S.Kamado,K.Hono,ActaMater.55(2007)4137–4150.
[11]J.H.Li,W.Q.Jie,G.Y.Yang,Trans.NonferrousMet.Soc.China18(2008)s27–s32.
[12]J.H.Li,W.Q.Jie,G.Y.Yang,RareMet.Mater.Eng.37(2008)1751–1754.
[13] T.J.Pike,B.Noble,J.LessCommonMet.30(1973)63.
[14]P.A.Nuttall,T.J.Pike,B.Noble,Metallography13(1980)3.
[15] R.Wilson,C.J.Bettles,B.C.Muddle,J.F.Nie,Mater.Sci.Forum419–422(2003) 267–272.
[16] L.R.Gill,G.W.Lorimer,P.Lyon,Adv.Eng.Mater.9(2007)784–792.
[17]J.F.Nie,X.Gao,S.M.Zhu,Scr.Mater.53(2005)1049–1053.
[18]P.J. Apps, H. Karimzadeh,J.F. King, G.W. Lorimer,Scr. Mater. 48(2003) 1023–1028.
[19]M.P.Moody,B.Gault,L.T.Stephenson,D.Haniel,S.P.Ringer,Ultramicroscopy 109(2009)815–824.
[20]J.M.Hyde,C.A.English,Microstructuralprocessesinirradiatedmaterials,in:
R.G.E.Lucas,L.Snead,M.A.J.Kirk,R.G.Elliman(Eds.),MRS2000FallMeeting Symposium,Boston,MA,2001,p.27.
[21] D.Vaumousse,A.Cerezo,P.J.Warren,Ultramicroscopy95(2003)215.
[22]G.Sha,J.H.Li,W.Q.Jie,S.P.Ringer,in:K.U.Kainer(Ed.),Proceedingsof8th InternationalConferenceonMagnesiumAlloysandtheirApplications,Wiley- VCHVerlagGmbH&Co.KGaA,Weinheim,2009,pp.40–46.
[23] J.F.Nie,Scr.Mater.48(2003)1009–1015.