IsMarket-OrientedReformProducinga“Two-Track”Europe?EvidencefromElectricityandTelecommunications Clifton,JudithandDíaz-Fuentes,DanielandFernándezGutiérrez,MarcosandRevuelta,Julio MunichPersonalRePEcArchive

(1)

Munich Personal RePEc Archive

Is Market-Oriented Reform Producing a

“Two-Track” Europe? Evidence from Electricity and Telecommunications

Clifton, Judith and Díaz-Fuentes, Daniel and Fernández Gutiérrez, Marcos and Revuelta, Julio

Universidad de Cantabria, Spain

2011

Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/33018/

MPRA Paper No. 33018, posted 27 Aug 2011 14:44 UTC

(2)

! " # $ %$ &$

% " '())* %

!"

+ , - . "

- -, / 0 ,

- . , ,$ 1 "

- $ +

/ , 2 . ", , - -

/ 2 / ,

/ - % ! 3 - $ 4

" 2 , /

5 / 06 / / , / 0 -

" , 0 / ,

/ , - / 0 - " $

# $ %

,

! " # $ %$ &$

% " '())* %

7 8 " . 8 "

- - - ,

- . 8 , $ %

" - - .

$

2 8 2 ,

9 8 : ,

9- : ,

- ; < , ! $

"

8 - 5 6

8 , ,

"

8 . 8 -

, $

(3)

&

!"# $% ##&'( )

*

+ $ '

*

$, - )- . ##/ 0 ##!'(

$1 ##/'( 2 !"#

* ( 3

!!# +

$4 ##5 4 6 ##5'(

% 7 + (

8

( .

( 4

$9 7 ##:' 2

$. . ##!'

( 7

;

$ , ##/'( . +

<

= $, >3, ###'(

, $ ,'

< ?

, > @ A7 B

C +

=

= $ , ##" '(

1

$. . ##5 , )- . # #'( >

(

. , + +

+ $) ( '( 7

+

( +

9 7 9

B $ ##"' . > , $ ##"'

(4)

D

B $ # #' 6 ,) $ ##5 # #'( .

,

+ + +

$ , ##5 # #'(

>

A C( 0

9 % $ !!#' A

(C 4 $ !55'

?

+

E +

+ = ( >

*

+ ( 2 ( $ ##"' +

( >

( 2 (

$4 ( ##5'( 2

4 $ !!5' 6 ,) $ ##5'

=

(

*

= = (

A C

? +E E F (

*

3 G $3G'

7 !!# (

> ( > +

3G 7

+ ( >

( 1

$ '

$ ' ( .

= (

6 6 ,) 9 7

, )- . $ # '(

(5)

/

'( % %

( 8 3G 7

> 3G 7 *

( > 3G E % >

!5#

$. ##/'( 7 !!#

= , $,

, - )- . ##: ##" ) 7 # #'( 9

$4 ##"'(

!"# $% ##!'

(

* +

> H $, , - )- . # '(

(

3G 7

(

3G 7 +

$, # #'( 8 7

+ + $% * !!:'

<

( 7 + *

$, # #'( 3G <

+ $, , - )- .

##&'(

( >

> 7 % + ,

( >

+ * + =

$ + ##:'( .

( 9 , + * +

$ , ##/'( @

+

8) /5&F ##! 8) @ :F ##! = I ##! 7

( 2

+ (

(6)

&

+ (

4

( >

$2 !!5'(

$ 2 !"5 2

###'(

? E

<

$4 # #'( 6

A C

= $% > ###'(

< (

9

* $B ##&'(

G > $ ##:' A C

A C

( ,

<

+

+ (

>

( 2 , ) . $ ##!'

( > , $ ##5 # #'

7 % + ( 9

+

$ , ##5 6 ,) ##5'(

) * %

> +

? E

*

$. 7 ## '( 4 +

( >

(7)

:

. . $ ##5'( >

$GJ 8 ##5 ( ##5'

<

$ ( ##"'(

8 *

(^D%

2 4 7 $247 '

( 7 9 $ ##D'

) % 7K , H $ # #'E 3G BH @ $ !!:' 4

, ) $ !!:' 2 + $ !!5' 4 , +

$ ## '( 2 +

( % +

= +

( 2 < + $ !"#' +

( 6 ,

" + +

( 7 , , -

)- . $ ##&' 4 . B $ ##5' . .

$ ##5 ##!' , )- . $ # #'

( >

+

$ ( ##5? 5":'(

>

?

E ( >

G > $ ##:' +

+ E

$ ' (

? ( ,

+ +

+ (

( , +

(

D. * F *

0 ) 0 $ ##5'(

(8)

"

D( >

+ (

( 7

##: " 4 $ , ##" '( )

A C(

$ '( 4

? A C

A C

( . ##:

4 7 247 . 7 $617

##:' . $ 1 ##:'( .

+ (

( .

4 $ !!5'

? $ 'E $ +

'E $ 'E $ 'E

$ 'E $ '(

6 ,) $ ##5'

? F F

(

*

+ +

? $

16> % @6L ) 4 161 % @6L ) 247 'E $

'E $

2 B27 ,61) $2 7 '

31 0 87 >L 247 $8 '

( >

$4 !!5E 6 ,) ##5' *

=

( 9

4 $ !!5' 6 ,) $ ##5'

A C A C

+ + +(

3

F ( > 247 4

8 ( >

(9)

5

*

+ ( ,

$162637 86

' $

= 7 1) = '( >

(

( .

? $='E * $>'

<

+ ( .

$='

$?' + ( .

= > F ? + (

+ % , - .

>

> (

< $

' ( 7 :&

3G ( )

(

3G +

(

<

$ '( .

( 7

3G 7 ( 9 :&

?

( > "&

:& "/( .

(

( . (

(10)

!

" &( %

%

/0 1 /0 1 /0 1

0

% (

(

% (

(

% (

(

% (

(

% (

(

% (

( 16> % @6L ) #(#D: #(# # #(#5 MM #( #"MMM #(#! MM #(#:"M

! ND& #(#D: #(# #(#D #(#/: #(##5 #(#"

&# :/ #(##" #(# 5 #(#/ #(##& #( 5MM #(# 5 :& "/ #(#"# #( &M #( DDMM #( "&MMM #(D#DMMM #( :DMMM O"/ #(# / #( 5 MM #( !&MMM #( 5:MMM #(//&MMM #( /MMM 2 B27 ,61) #(#/!M #(#D" #(#D #(#: #(#:"M #(#!/MM 31 0 87 >L #(#DD #(#/ #(#!!MM #( !MM #( &"MMM #( /MMM

2 8761 #(# / #(#:! #( &MMM #(# # #( D:MMM #(# #

3 " D 87617 #(#&" #(##! #(# #( #&MM #(# 5 #(#:5

/ 87617 #(#5&M #(#!DMM #(#/! #(# / #(#!# #(#:D

O/ 87617 #(# " #(##: #(#&! #( #&M #(# : #(#!"

162637 86 #(##& #( &5MMM #( /!MMM #( #DMMM #( ::MMM #( /&MMM

4 DD" ##: DD" ##: DD" ##:

5 % ' #(/: D/( ! &(&" (#D ##(!! #&(D

" 6 % ' #(#&! #(## #(### #(### #(### #(###

M 7 #P MM &P MMM P

% ; @/ " 9A))B":$

1

( 8 > ( 7

( > <

( 9 3G 3G( 8

7

3G( % 7

3G ( 6

>

(

= > ( >

$?'( 9 7

( .

(

?

( >

(11)

# ( >

Q +

( < +

+ + ? +

( .

( 9

( .

7 3G( 7

7

$>' F

$?' $='( , =

+ $ + >' F

$ ?'( 3G

>

= ?(

" '(

/0 1 /0 1

, ( , ( , ( , (

, # !#!M "#MMM # D& D !##MMM

61 % @6L ) # ## # #D # &5MMM # &"MMM 161 % @6L ) # D # :#MMM # //"MMM # D &MMM

! 8 ND& # # : # &MMM # # D # #//

8 &# :/ # /D&MMM # #"DMMM # #D# # #MMM 8 :& "/ # "&!MMM # /MMM # /5M # "MMM 8 O"/ ## MMM # #&MM # "#MMM # /DMMM 8 2 B27 ,61) # #": # #&"MM # # # # D MMM 8 31 0 87 >L # 5"MMM # D"MMM # # 5 # " MMM 2 1% %4 87 # MMM # D:&MMM # D&DMMM # &#5MMM

3 " 1% %4 87 # ##/ # # DMMM # # MMM # #DDMMM

162637 86 # "5/MMM # 5 MMM # &!MMM # &:MMM 7 1) = # : DMMM # "&"MMM # : :MMM # !D MMM

4 ::/& !/D& ::/& !/D&

7 & !" D5"(:& 5& #! D:! 5#

" 6 7 # # # #

8 R 8

M 7 #P MM &P MMM P

% ; @/ " 4& 9A))C: @&% 9A))C:$

(12)

8 2

8 ( >

( +

( > 4

. B $ ##5' 3 &

### ##/

( >

(

##:( 6

. . $ ##5'

3

& $ ### ##/'( >

+ ( 6

( . ( +

F + ( 9

+ ( )

(

( .

(

>

( .

+ ( >

( >

$ ' *

=

(13)

(

?

7%7 +

( %

=

+ ( 4 7 3G

( 3G

7 E $ # #'

##&( 7

##!

( 1 =

3 % 7

(

% ?

( 6 +

( ,

+ ( >

+ ( > 4

+ ( >

+

?

(

+ +

3G 7 =

(

> + (

>

< ( >

( 6

+

( B ,

+ = $ , ##" ' +

=

3 (

. ,

(

9 =

(14)

D

( 3G

6.B % A7 9 7 C ###

$6.B % # #'( > 4 A,

C (

4> A4>

C ##5

( 7 1 , $,1 '

# # A C

##! #

$,1 # #'( 9 A C

> % + , $,%> # #'

##"( > H 7 <

##! # #

$

6 # #'( 4 (

9

+ ( .

+

(

9

98%7>861B %( 79 1B>61 )( ##: A8 ,

@ C 7 S@ 0 D & D::(

986, 19 ( ##D A> 8 3 7 7 C 3 ,(

,( ( ! , = - ; #

D 1 (

937>89@ 91 B60 81% 1> ##" E = " = ,

9 B , % 9 5 !(

49,,2 6,,2 ( .@68 6 %( B9%4986 %( ##5 A>

< ? & 3 C

#% F 0 - = ##5 # ) 7 9

7 3 K 7 % (

491, ( ##" A@ ?

C # = " "5 $D'

DD D& (

4934L ( ##5 A@< T C + / $ ' (

4 11 >> %( ,66G )( 9))9%7 8 , ,( ## A@ 6 , U

1 > @ 2 . C %

D $ ' :" !/(

4 8B 1( # # A4 C . 8( ,( ( AG , ;

" 0 > 6 + 79B (

(15)

/ 46B1 >> B( 64 8%911 B( ##5 A@

? C #

= " "! $DF/' /: /5&(

438) 1 8( !!5 > " - ; . , @

6 . > (

43817 ( ,89 .68) ( ) @16> 9( !!: A8 8

3 C % ( : $/' (

, # # = " ! H AB " $

% - - 38@? ( = ( (

, >3, ### V , 7 B <

4 ? , >3,(

, 8 91 @( )6861W6 8( .@68 6 %( ##! A

+ ?

3C #% F 0 - = ##! #! ) 7

9 7 3 K 7 % (

,@ .>61 I( ,6%X1 .( )X9W .3 1> 7 )( ##& A Y

, U 6 , 7 B C = "

- / " $D' / " //D(

,@ .>61 I( ,6%X1 .( )X9W .3 1> 7 )( ##: A

3 !:# ## C? U

= " = , D $&' "D: "&:(

,@ .>61 I( ,6%X1 .( )X9W .3 1> 7 )( ##" ( + - "

& # ; & / 0 4 -

+ 1 L + % (

,@ .>61 I( ,6%X1 .( )X9W .3 1> 7 )( # A.

% , ?

C E I ,(

,@ .>61 I( )X9W .3 1> 7 )( # # A 3

? < C # = " 5

$ ' 5 D (

,@ .>61 I( )X9W .3 1> 7 )( # V. A C

A Q C? 6 ,)< " = ,(

,1 $ # #' A 4 7 C

?FF ( ( F F (* U Z R/#"[[[+ R[ R.

# . #

,%> $ # #' A6 8 F&D F ##"C

?FF ( ( F Z Z F7 6 ( U R [ R#!## " !5##

5"5:"[ R Z [ R7 P #3 #

I # (

,6%X1 .( )X9W .3 1> 7 )( ##/ 7 J" %

7- (

) 8S 9( @WG60 >W .( G609,7 0( 76379 1( $ '#

% - 0 AG , @ F1 L +F) ? 9 (

)398> 8( %9 198 9( 7\1,2 W ,2]@ W I( $ # #' A>

7 C -, D $ '

": 5&(

)346 7 3( 79 @9,91 8( # # A

? C # = "

5 $ ' D D D&:(

, ##/ ! , (

(16)

&

, ##" + , 7 " - + , ! + ,

" - ,(

, ##" " AC); % 4

4 ,(

, ##5 I / E 4 = # - D

)B 2 , 4 1 5(

, ##5 K # / E % %6F#5F"/5(

, # # E / ; , 0 D )B 2

, 4 1 (

. ) 89@ >89) ,6%% 77 61 ##" E

= , 1 I 7 /(

. 68 6 ,( 0( .@68 6 %( ##5 A) . U

, < 7 3 8 3C #% F 0 - =

##5 ) 7 9 7 3 K

7 % (

. 68 6 ,( 0( .@68 6 %( ##! A> 1 +

, < ? 3 &C #% F 0 - = ##!

/ ) 7 9 7 3 K

7 % (

.@68 6 %( ##/ + ; - F 4 E

= G(B( G((B , % > (

.8 L 4( 7( 7>3>W 8 9( ## A , @ 2

8 UC 7 S@ /# /D&(

B917 I( 7( ##& A , , ? )

4 7 , UC E% F 0 - =

% 4 7 3 % (

B]% W @646 9( !!: V> , = > 8

) B % + < % ( " $/' /! :&(

2 87,2%91 9( !"# 2 , ,;

- , 2 3 (

26)B761 B( %( !!5 A> C

7 D: $ ' :: ! (

26)B761 B( %( ### A UC

4 D/ $ ' D " D !(

26BB %( G( 26 @@7 B( % @%91 )( ##" A, G

4 $G4 '? F

G4 UC = , D# $ ' & &5(

1 $ 17> >3>6 19, 619@ ) 7>9)X7> ,9' ##: =

% 1 (

17> >3> .68 B60 81% 1> # # $ 4 - " -

" , @ , 6 (

G921 %91 )( >29@ 8 8( 2( ##: A9 ( 3 %

3 C = # $ ' D/(

G^7W B 4( 894 1 %( ##5 A, C

= " ! 5 5D (

%9I61 B( !!: - - @ ? 8 (

%917 @@ 8( ##! + 4 % , @ ? 8 (

% @@ 98) 8( ##& = = " ; -,

+ + GL') G(() , ? , 3

(

(17)

:

%3@@9 19>291 7( >29@ 8 8( ### A4 C F 0 -

= % ## " ) %

> (

1 4 8L )( %( ##/ A 1 + C % F 0 - =

D , 7 [ 8 % (

6 ,) ##5 - + ; = -

/ - 6 ,)(

6 ,) # # , 0 6 ,)(

6.B % # # % # % -,; A))( A)G) @ 6.B %(

617 ##: 2 % , @ 617(

8) /5&F ##! ' " . -

J - (

8) :F ##! ') " .

- , " " (

@G%917 I( ##: - ; , 2

2 (

091 )668 1 ( 091 ) 9@@ 7( ##5 A8

? C

4 / # % "/ &D &D/(

091 ) 9@@ 7( ##! A UC #

= " 5# $/' & &/&(

9))9%7 ,( @761 ,( # # A) , 7 4

7 UC @2 = : ? :/" ::5(

9))9%7 8 , ,( 489W 8 G( 29% G( %9>2 3 @( 91B (

##" A . 6 * 7 * % C =

F 0 - = #" , , 3 9 (

9))9%7 8 , ,( 291,6,G 8( !!5 A)

@ 3G 8 3 % + C % ! $D' !& D !(

@438 ,( G( 2988 761 8( 7( !"5 A>

? C

4 $ ' : 5!(

2 > 2 9) I( ,( 9>>919L9G 7( G( 091 2630> 1 B( @( B @76 4(

8( ##5 A, +

? C

% , $&' 5" !#5(