Analytische Philosophie – Peter Bieris Frage nach der richtigen Art, Philosophie zu betreiben

REPLIK

Analytische Philosophie

Peter Bieris Frage nach der richtigen Art, Philosophie zu betreiben

Von ANSGAR BECKERMANN (Bielefeld)

I.

In Ferdinand Fellmanns Orientierung Philosophie¿QGHWVLFKGLHIROJHQGHODXQLJH&KDUDNWH- ULVLHUXQJGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLH

Ä,Q SKLORVRSKLVFKHQ 6HPLQDUHQ HUNHQQW PDQ >VSUDFKDQDO\WLVFKH 3KLORVRSKHQ@ DXI GHQ HUVWHQ%OLFNDQLKUHPIRUVFKHQ$XIWUHWHQXQGGHU9HUYHPLWGHUVLHJDQ]H7DIHOQYROO- VFKUHLEHQ :DV VLH VFKUHLEHQ VLQG LQ GHU 5HJHO WULYLDOH %HLVSLHOVlW]H VRZLH ORJLVFKH

=HLFKHQ GHUHQ YLUWXRVH %HKHUUVFKXQJ DOOH (UVWVHPHVWHU EHHLQGUXFNW 'D‰ VLH YRQ GHU

*HVFKLFKWHGHU3KLORVRSKLHYRU%HUWUDQG5XVVHOOXQG*HRUJH(GZDUG0RRUH>«@DXJHQ- VFKHLQOLFKZHQLJ1RWL]QHKPHQXQGVLFKDXI:LWWJHQVWHLQ:LOODUG9DQ2UPDQ4XLQHXQG

*HRUJ +HQULN YRQ :ULJKW DOV 5HIHUHQ]DXWRUHQ EH]LHKHQ NRPPW LKUHP 0RGHUQLWlWVEH- ZX‰WVHLQ ]XJXWH >«@ >$OOH VSUDFKDQDO\WLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKHQ@ YHUHLQW >«@ HLQ SUDJPD- WLVFK XQG UHDOLVWLVFK DXVJHULFKWHWHV 'HQNHQ GDV VHLQHQ DPHULNDQLVFKHQ 8UVSUXQJ QLFKW YHUOHXJQHQ NDQQ 'DV PDFKW GHQ &KDUPH GLHVHU *UXSSH YRQ 3KLORVRSKHQ DXV GLH UHLQ SUREOHPRULHQWLHUWGHQNHQ'DJHJHQVLQGVLHGHQKXPDQLVWLVFKJHELOGHWHQ*HLVWHUQK|FKVW VXVSHNWZHQQQLFKWJDUXQV\PSDWKLVFK.DQQPDQGRFKRIWJHQXJHUOHEHQGD‰GLHDQD- O\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKHQIRUPDOERPEDVWLVFKH$SSDUDWXUHQIU(LQVLFKWHQHLQVHW]HQGLHDXV GHU7UDGLWLRQOlQJVWYHUWUDXWVLQG³)HOOPDQQ

'LHVH.DULNDWXUN|QQWHPDQJHWURVWEHLVHLWHOHJHQJlEHHVQLFKWDXFKJHZLFKWLJHUH6WLPPHQ GLH GLHVHU$UW GHV 3KLORVRSKLHUHQV LQ]ZLVFKHQ HEHQIDOOV HKHU NULWLVFK JHJHQEHUVWHKHQ ,Q VHLQHP$XIVDW]Was bleibt von der Analytischen Philosophie?GHUVLFKZLHGDV'RNXPHQW HLQHUHQWWlXVFKWHQ/LHEHOLHVWOLVWHW3HWHU%LHUL±PLWVHOWVDPHPSXEOL]LVWLVFKHQ(FKR±DOOHV DXI ZDV LKP DQ GHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKLH PLVVIlOOW XP DP (QGH GDIU ]X SOlGLHUHQ

* 'LHEHLGHQQDFKIROJHQGHQ%HLWUlJHUHDJLHUHQDXIGLH.ULWLNGHUDQDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHGLH3HWHU

%LHULLP+HIWGLHVHU=HLWVFKULIWYRUJHOHJWKDW

1 9JO]XGLHVHP$XIVDW]DXFK%HFNHUPDQQ

2 *H\HU

GDVVHVZHGHUDQDO\WLVFKHQRFKNRQWLQHQWDOH3KLORVRSKLHJHEHQVROOWHVRQGHUQHLQIDFKQXU 3KLORVRSKLH

(UVWDXQOLFKDQ%LHULV$XIVDW]LVWGDVVHUDXIGLH$QIlQJHGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLH

±DXIGLH=HLWHQLQGHQHQQRFK]LHPOLFKNODUZDUZDVPDQZROOWHXQGZDVQLFKW±QXUEHL- OlX¿JHLQJHKW'DEHLVLQGJHUDGHGLHVH$QIlQJHIUHLQ9HUVWlQGQLVGHVVHQZDV$QDO\WLVFKH 3KLORVRSKLHDXVPDFKWRGHUDXVPDFKWHHQRUPZLFKWLJ:HUIHQZLUGHVKDOE]XQlFKVWHLQHQ

%OLFN]XUFN

,FKKDOWHHVIUNHLQHJXWH,GHHVFKRQ)UHJH0RRUHXQG5XVVHOOVR]XVDJHQUFNZLUNHQG ]X$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKHQ]XHUNOlUHQ³'LH$QDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKLHEHJLQQWPLW:LWWJHQ- VWHLQXQGGHP:LHQHU.UHLVXQGLKU*UXQGLPSHWXVLVWantimetaphysischMDVRJDUantiphilo- sophisch6LQQYROOVLQGDOOHLQ$XVVDJHQGLHVLFKGXUFK(UIDKUXQJEHVWlWLJHQRGHUZLGHUOHJHQ ODVVHQ'LHHLQ]LJHQOHJLWLPHQ:LVVHQVFKDIWHQVLQGGLH(UIDKUXQJVZLVVHQVFKDIWHQ,QLKUHP 0DQLIHVWWissenschaftliche Weltauffassung – der Wiener KreisVFKUHLEHQ&DUQDS+DKQXQG 1HXUDWKÄ>(@VJLEWQXU(UIDKUXQJVHUNHQQWQLV>«@+LHUPLWLVWGLH*UHQ]HIUGHQ,QKDOWOHJL- WLPHU:LVVHQVFKDIWJH]RJHQ³6FKRQLPTractatus LVWGLHVH$XIIDVVXQJJDQ]GHXWOLFK6LQQ- YROO VLQG QXU (OHPHQWDUVlW]H XQG ORJLVFKH 9HUNQSIXQJHQ YRQ (OHPHQWDUVlW]HQ /RJLVFKH XQGPDWKHPDWLVFKH6lW]HVLQG*UHQ]IlOOHVLHVDJHQQLFKWVEHUGLH:HOWVLHVLQGGDKHU]ZDU QLFKWXQVLQQLJDEHUVLQQORV(UVWVSlWHU¿QGHWVLFKLQGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHHLQ2UWIU /RJLNXQG0DWKHPDWLN0DQEHJLQQWzwei $UWHQVLQQYROOHU$XVVDJHQ]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQDQD- O\WLVFKH$XVVDJHQXQG$XVVDJHQGLHVLFKGXUFK(UIDKUXQJEHVWlWLJHQRGHUZLGHUOHJHQODVVHQ XQGUHWWHWGHU/RJLNXQGGHU0DWKHPDWLNHLQHQ3ODW]LQGHPPDQLKUH$XVVDJHQIUDQDO\- WLVFKHUNOlUW'RFKGDEHLEOHLEWGLH)UDJH8QGZDVLVWPLWGHU3KLORVRSKLH"'LH$QWZRUWGLH PDQDOOJHPHLQ¿QGHWODXWHW'HU3KLORVRSKLHEOHLEWQXUGLH6SUDFKDQDO\VH$EHUZLHSDVVW 6SUDFKDQDO\VHVHOEVWLQGHQ5DKPHQGHUOHJLWLPHQ:LVVHQVFKDIWHQ",PTractatus JLEW:LWW- JHQVWHLQHLQHUDGLNDOH$QWZRUW$XFK6SUDFKDQDO\VHLVWHLJHQWOLFKQLFKWP|JOLFK3KLORVRSKLH P|FKWHEHU6SUDFKHXQGGDV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ6SUDFKHXQG:HOWUHGHQDEHUJHQDXGDVJHKW QLFKW5HGHQNDQQPDQQXUEHU*HJHQVWlQGH±PLW6lW]HQGLH6DFKYHUKDOWHDXVGUFNHQGDV KHL‰WGLHEHVDJHQGDVVGLH*HJHQVWlQGHVRXQGVRYHUNHWWHWVLQGÜber 6DFKYHUKDOWHUHGHQ NDQQPDQQLFKWXQGGDPLWDXFKQLFKWEHU6lW]H=ZDUNDQQPDQ6SUDFKHYHUZHQGHQXP GHQ+|UHU/HVHUGD]X]XEULQJHQEHVWLPPWH'LQJHULFKWLJ]XVHKHQEHUGLHPDQHLJHQWOLFK QLFKWUHGHQNDQQDEHUGLHVH6SUDFKYHUZHQGXQJLVWVWUHQJJHQRPPHQVLQQORV'DVIKUW]X GHP3DUDGR[RQGDVVPDQGLH/HLWHU±GLHVHVLQQORVHQ6lW]H±ZHJZHUIHQPXVVQDFKGHP PDQJHVHKHQKDWZDVVLHXQVVHKHQOHUQHQVROOWH

1HXUDWKVFKHLQWHLQDQGHUHV9HUVWlQGQLVYRQ6SUDFKDQDO\VHJHKDEW]XKDEHQIULKQZDU VLH HLQH JDQ] QRUPDOH HPSLULVFKH :LVVHQVFKDIW$EHU EHL GHQ PHLVWHQ DQDO\WLVFKHQ 3KLOR- VRSKHQGLHVHU=HLW¿QGHWVLFKNHLQHNODUH$QWZRUWDXIGLH)UDJHQDFKGHP6WDWXVYRQ6SUDFK DQDO\VH±DPHKHVWHQQRFKGLH7KHVH6SUDFKDQDO\VHVHLNHLQH7KHRULHVRQGHUQHLQH7lWLJNHLW GDKHUVWHOOHVLFKGLH)UDJHQDFKLKUHP6WDWXVDOV:LVVHQVFKDIWJDUQLFKW.ODULVWDOOHUGLQJV ZDVPLW6SUDFKDQDO\VHHUUHLFKWZHUGHQVROO0LWLKUHU+LOIHVROOHUVWHQVJH]HLJWZHUGHQGDVV HVQXUGLH]ZHLJHQDQQWHQ$UWHQYRQVLQQYROOHQ6lW]HQJLEWXQGHVVROO]ZHLWHQVJH]HLJWZHU- GHQGDVVGLH6lW]HGHUNODVVLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLH0HWDSK\VLNOHW]WHQ(QGHVDOOHVLQQORVVLQG,Q VHLQHP$XIVDW]Überwindung der Metaphysik durch logische Analyse der SpracheVFKUHLEW

&DUQDSNODUXQGHLQGHXWLJVHLQ=LHOVHLÄDXIGLH)UDJHQDFKGHU*OWLJNHLWXQG%HUHFKWLJXQJ GHU0HWDSK\VLNHLQHQHXHXQGVFKlUIHUH$QWZRUW]XJHEHQ>«@$XIGHP*HELHWGHUMetaphy- sik >«@IKUWGLHORJLVFKH$QDO\VH]XGHPQHJDWLYHQ(UJHEQLVGDVVdie vorgeblichen Sätze dieses Gebiets gänzlich sinnlos sind³&DUQDSI

3 1DWUOLFKNDQQPDQGDVPLWJXWHQ*UQGHQDXFKDQGHUVVHKHQYJOHWZD*ORFN

:LHIU&DUQDS+DKQXQG1HXUDWKVRLVWZLHZLUVFKRQJHVHKHQKDEHQDXFKIUGHQ :LWWJHQVWHLQGHVTractatus Ä0HWDSK\VLN³HLQ1DPHIUGLHLOOHJLWLPHWUDGLWLRQHOOH3KLORVR- SKLH/HJLWLPH3KLORVRSKLHLVWIULKQ.ULWLNGHU6SUDFKH

Ä7KHRQO\OHJLWLPDWHWDVNRISKLORVRSK\LVDQDO\WLFDQGHOXFLGDWRU\,WQHLWKHUDLPVDWWKH GLVFRYHU\RIQHZWUXWKVQRUVKDUHVWKHSLHFHPHDOPHWKRGVRIWKHVFLHQFHV)RUWKHUHDUH QRSKLORVRSKLFDOSURSRVLWLRQVµ3KLORVRSK\XQOLNHVFLHQFHLVQRWDERG\RIGRFWULQHEXW DQ DFWLYLW\ RI FODULI\LQJ QRQSKLORVRSKLFDO SURSRVLWLRQV WKURXJK ORJLFDO DQDO\VLV >«@³

*ORFN

'LHVH$XIIDVVXQJYRQ3KLORVRSKLHKDW:LWWJHQVWHLQLQVHLQHQVSlWHUHQ6FKULIWHQ]ZDUZHLWHU HQWZLFNHOWDEHUGLH*UXQGOLQLHEOLHEGLHVHOEH±GLH$EOHKQXQJGHU,GHHHVN|QQHVRHWZDV ZLH HLQH VXEVWDQ]LHOOH 3KLORVRSKLH JHEHQ 8QG GLHVH ,GHH ¿QGHW VLFK LQ XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHU )RUPDXFKEHLDQGHUHQ9HUWUHWHUQGHU3KLORVRSKLHGHUQRUPDOHQ6SUDFKHZLHHWZD5\OH

II.

:HQQPDQGLHPHWDSK\VLNXQGSKLORVRSKLHNULWLVFKH(LQVWHOOXQJGLHDOOH9HUWUHWHUGHUDXI- VWUHEHQGHQ$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHHLQWHPLWGHPYHUJOHLFKWZDVKHXWHXQWHUGHP1DPHQ Ä$QDO\WLVFKH 3KLORVRSKLH³ EHWULHEHQ ZLUG NRPPW PDQ QLFKW XPKLQ ]X]XJHEHQ GDVV VLFK YLHOHVJUXQGOHJHQGYHUlQGHUWKDW8QGGLHVLVWXPVRYHUEOIIHQGHUDOVHVREHUÀlFKOLFKJHVH- KHQJDUNHLQHQHUNHQQEDUHQ%UXFKLQGHU(QWZLFNOXQJGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHJHJHEHQ ]X KDEHQ VFKHLQW 0HKU RGHU ZHQLJHU XQPHUNOLFK GDUDXI ZHLVW %LHUL Y|OOLJ ]X 5HFKW KLQ NHKUWHQGLHWUDGLWLRQHOOHQ7KHPHQGHU3KLORVRSKLH]XUFNELVGLHEHUNRPPHQH3KLORVRSKLH HLQHYROOVWlQGLJH:LHGHUDXIHUVWHKXQJIHLHUQNRQQWH:LHZDUGDVP|JOLFK":LHNRQQWHHV]X VROFKHLQHPJUXQGVWU]HQGHQ8PVFKZXQJNRPPHQ"

,QGHU5HJHOZHUGHQKLHU]ZHL1DPHQXQG]ZHL:HUNHDQJHIKUWGLHGHQ8PVFKZXQJ YLHOOHLFKWQLFKWZLUNOLFKHLQOHLWHWHQDEHUGRFKHLQGHXWOLFKHV=HLFKHQGDIUZDUHQGDVVHWZDV LQ*DQJJHNRPPHQZDU±4XLQHVTwo Dogmas of EmpiricismYRQXQG3HWHU)6WUDZ- VRQVIndividuals YRQ 'LHV WULIIW QXU ]XP 7HLO ]X :HQQ LFK HV ULFKWLJ VHKH ZDU GHU ZLFKWLJVWH*UXQGGHV8PEUXFKVGDV6FKHLWHUQGHVHPSLULVWLVFKHQ6LQQNULWHULXPV

6FKRQ3RSSHUKDWWHVLFKJHZHLJHUWYRQHLQHPÄ6LQQNULWHULXP³]XVSUHFKHQXQGYRUJH- VFKODJHQVWDWWGHVVHQGHQ$XVGUXFNÄ$EJUHQ]XQJVNULWHULXP³]XYHUZHQGHQ6lW]HGLHVLFK HPSLULVFK IDOVL¿]LHUHQ ODVVHQ VLQG ZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH 6lW]H 6lW]H EHL GHQHQ GDV QLFKW GHU )DOOLVWJHK|UHQQDFK3RSSHU]ZDUQLFKWLQGHQ%HUHLFKGHU:LVVHQVFKDIWHQVLQGGHVKDOEDEHU QRFKODQJHQLFKWVLQQORV'RFKZHQLJHU3RSSHUV9RUVFKODJ]XU*WHDOVYLHOPHKUGLH(UNHQQW- QLVGDVVDXFK]HQWUDOHZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH$XVGUFNHZLHÄ(OHNWURQ³RGHUVRJDUÄ0DVVH³GHQ VWUHQJHQ$QIRUGHUXQJHQGHVHPSLULVWLVFKHQ6LQQNULWHULXPVQLFKWJHQJHQIKUWHGD]XGDVV GLHVHV.ULWHULXPLP/DXIHGHUYLHU]LJHUXQGIQI]LJHU-DKUHGHV-DKUKXQGHUWV6FKULWWIU 6FKULWWDXIJHJHEHQZXUGH'RFKGDPLWZDUGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHHLQ]HQWUDOHV:HUN- ]HXJ]XU'HVWUXNWLRQGHUWUDGLWLRQHOOHQ3KLORVRSKLHDEKDQGHQJHNRPPHQ:HQQ7HUPLQLZLH Ä(OHNWURQ³XQGÄ0DVVH³NHLQHQNODUHQHPSLULVFKHQ*HKDOWKDEHQZDUXPVROOWHPDQGDVYRQ

$XVGUFNHQ ZLH Ä3ULQ]LS³ RGHU Ä*RWW³ HUZDUWHQ":HQQ 6lW]H ZLH Ä(OHNWURQHQ KDEHQ HLQH 5XKHPDVVHYRQÂ^-28*UDPP³HLQHQ6LQQKDEHQZDUXPVROOWHQGDQQ6lW]HZLHÄ*RWW LVWGHU6FK|SIHUGHU:HOW³VLQQORVVHLQ"'HU)DOOGHVHPSLULVWLVFKHQ6LQQNULWHULXPVZDUZHQQ PDQPLUGLHVHV%LOGYHU]HLKWGLH(LQEUXFKVWHOOHGXUFKGLH]XQlFKVWHLQPDOGLHWUDGLWLRQHOOH SKLORVRSKLVFKH 7HUPLQRORJLH LQ GLH$QDO\WLVFKH 3KLORVRSKLH ]XUFNNHKUHQ NRQQWH 8QG LQ

602

GHUHQ*HIROJHNDPHQDXFKGLH3UREOHPHGHUWUDGLWLRQHOOHQ3KLORVRSKLH]XUFNXQG]ZDULQ UDVDQWHP7HPSRXQGRKQHGDVVGLHVJUR‰HV$XIVHKHQKHUYRUULHI

$P YHUEOIIHQGVWHQ ZDU YLHOOHLFKW GLH :LHGHUNHKU GHU QRUPDWLYHQ (WKLN 1DFK YLHOHQ -DKUHQLQGHQHQVLFKHWKLVFKHhEHUOHJXQJHQ±GHU,GHHIROJHQG3KLORVRSKLHPVVHVLFKDXI 6SUDFKDQDO\VHEHVFKUlQNHQ±DOOHLQDXI0HWDHWKLNEHVFKUlQNWKDWWHQZDUHVKDXSWVlFKOLFK ZRKODQJHVWR‰HQGXUFK-RKQ5DZOV¶A Theory of Justice YRQSO|W]OLFKZLHGHUP|JOLFK

EHU)UHLKHLWXQG*HUHFKWLJNHLW]XUHGHQEHUGHQ6WDWXVXQJHERUHQHQ/HEHQVXQGEHUGHQ 8PJDQJPLW6WHUEHQGHQ6FKRQLQGHQVLHE]LJHU-DKUHQGHV-DKUKXQGHUWVEOLHEVRPLWQXU GLH )HVWVWHOOXQJ 'DV 3URMHNW GHUAbschaffung GHU 0HWDSK\VLN GXUFK ORJLVFKH$QDO\VH GHU 6SUDFKHZDUJUDQGLRVJHVFKHLWHUW

5FNEOLFNHQGNDQQPDQDOVRVDJHQGDVVGLH$QDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKLHursprünglich GXUFK ]XPLQGHVWHLQHGHUIROJHQGHQGUHL7KHVHQJHNHQQ]HLFKQHWZDU

(1) ZielGHU3KLORVRSKLHLVWGLHhEHUZLQGXQJGHU0HWDSK\VLNGXUFK6SUDFKDQDO\VH 'LHHLQ]LJHOHJLWLPHAufgabe GHU3KLORVRSKLHLVWGLH$QDO\VHGHU$OOWDJVRGHU

:LVVHQVFKDIWV6SUDFKH

'LHHLQ]LJHMethodeGLHGHU3KLORVRSKLH]XU9HUIJXQJVWHKWLVWGLH0HWKRGHGHU 6SUDFKDQDO\VH

$EHU VSlWHVWHQ JDE HV NDXP QRFK MHPDQGHQ GHU DXFK QXU HLQH GLHVHU7KHVHQ XQWHU- VFKULHEHQKlWWH0LWDQGHUHQ:RUWHQ'LH$QDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKLHLQGHP6LQQHLQGHPGLH- VHU$XVGUXFN LQ GHU HUVWHQ +lOIWH GHV -DKUKXQGHUWV YHUVWDQGHQ ZXUGH ZDU SDVVp 'LH traditionelle $QDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKLHZDUODXWORVXQWHUJHJDQJHQ

III.

*LEW HV WURW]GHP HWZDV ZDV DXFK KHXWH QRFK DOOH DQDO\WLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKHQ HLQW XQG YRQ DQGHUHQ3KLORVRSKHQDEJUHQ]W"%LHULVSULFKWYRQHLQHUÄ5HLKHYRQJHGDQNOLFKHQ(OHPHQWHQ DXIGLHPDQLPPHUZLHGHUWULIIWZHQQ$XWRUHQGLHVLFKDOVDQDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKHQYHUVWH- KHQLKU6HOEVWELOG]XP$XVGUXFNEULQJHQ>«@'LHVHLGHRORJLVFKHQ(OHPHQWHVLQGGDVHLQ- ]LJH0DWHULDODQGHPPDQVLFKRULHQWLHUHQNDQQ³%LHUL=XGLHVHQJHGDQNOLFKHQ (OHPHQWHQ]lKOWLQVHLQHQ$XJHQ

± GLH$XIIDVVXQJGDVV3KLORVRSKLHHLQÄQRUPDOHV³Fach LVW

± GDVEHVRQGHUH*HZLFKWGDVDXIEHJULIÀLFKH.ODUKHLW±LP6LQQHYRQExaktheit IRUPDOVSUDFKOLFKHU=ZHLJRGHUÜbersichtlichkeit QRUPDOVSUDFKOLFKHU=ZHLJ±

JHOHJWZLUG

± GLHEHVRQGHUH5ROOHGHUformalen Logik ± GLHEHVRQGHUH5ROOHGHVÄsemantic ascent³

,FKZHUGHDXIHLQLJHGLHVHU3XQNWH]XUFNNRPPHQ,Q%LHULV$XI]lKOXQJZHUGHQDEHUHLQLJH LQKDOWOLFKH3XQNWHDX‰HU$FKWJHODVVHQGLH]XPLQGHVWIUHLQHJHZLVVH=HLWIUGDV6HOEVWYHU- VWlQGQLVGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHQRFK]HQWUDOHUZDUHQ,QHUVWHU/LQLHGHQNHLFKDQGLH JUR‰HWissenschaftsnähe GHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHXQGLKUHQDXVJHSUlJWHQAntimentalis- mus'DV(UVWHPDJIUGHQQRUPDOVSUDFKOLFKHQ=ZHLJGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHZHQLJHU ]XWUHIIHQ'RFKZLUKDWWHQVFKRQJHVHKHQGDVV]XPLQGHVW]X%HJLQQGHVIRUPDOVSUDFKOLFKHQ

603 DZPhil 56 (2008) 4

=ZHLJHVGLH(UIDKUXQJVZLVVHQVFKDIWHQDOVHLQ]LJOHJLWLPH:LVVHQVFKDIWHQJDOWHQ$XFKQDFK- GHPGLH,GHHHLQHV0RQRSROVGHU(UIDKUXQJVZLVVHQVFKDIWHQDXIJHJHEHQZXUGHlQGHUWHVLFK QLFKWVDPKHUDXVJHKREHQHQ6WDWXVGHQYLHOHDQDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKHQGHQHPSLULVFKHQ:LV- VHQVFKDIWHQHLQUlXPWHQ'DV]HLJWVLFKEHVRQGHUVEHL4XLQHDEHUDXFKEHL6HOODUVZHQQHU EHLQLFKWO|VEDUHQ.RQÀLNWHQ]ZLVFKHQGHPÄPDQLIHVW³XQGGHPÄVFLHQWL¿FLPDJH³GHU:HOW /HW]WHUHPGHQ9RUUDQJJLEW⁴8QGJDQ]GHXWOLFK]HLJWHVVLFKEHL'DYLG/HZLV0LW%H]XJDXI GLH0DWKHPDWLNVFKUHLEW/HZLVLQParts of Classes

Ä0DWKHPDWLFVLVDQHVWDEOLVKHGJRLQJFRQFHUQ3KLORVRSK\LVDVVKDN\DVFDQEH7RUHMHFW PDWKHPDWLFV IRU SKLORVRSKLFDO UHDVRQV ZRXOG EH DEVXUG >«@ +RZ ZRXOGyou OLNH WKH MRERIWHOOLQJWKHPDWKHPDWLFLDQVWKDWWKH\PXVWFKDQJHWKHLUZD\VDQGDEMXUHFRXQWOHVV HUURUVQRZWKDWphilosophy KDVGLVFRYHUHGWKDWWKHUHDUHQRFODVVHV"&DQ\RXWHOOWKHP ZLWKDVWUDLJKWIDFHWRIROORZSKLORVRSKLFDODUJXPHQWZKHUHYHULWPD\OHDG",IWKH\FKDO- OHQJH\RXUFUHGHQWLDOVZLOO\RXERDVWRISKLORVRSK\¶VRWKHUJUHDWGLVFRYHULHVWKDWPRWLRQ LVLPSRVVLEOHWKDWD%HLQJWKDQZKLFKQRJUHDWHUFDQEHFRQFHLYHGFDQQRWEHFRQFHLYHGQRW WRH[LVWWKDWLWLVXQWKLQNDEOHWKDWWKHUHLVDQ\WKLQJRXWVLGHWKHPLQGWKDWWLPHLVXQUHDO WKDWQRWKHRU\KDVHYHUEHHQPDGHDWDOOSUREDEOHE\HYLGHQFH>«@DQGVRRQDQGRQad nauseam"1RWPH³/HZLVI

bKQOLFK GDFKWH /HZLV EHU GLH HPSLULVFKHQ :LVVHQVFKDIWHQ EHVRQGHUV GLH 3K\VLN :HQQ

EHUKDXSWHWZDVGDQQLQIRUPLHUWXQVGLH3K\VLNGDUEHUZLHGLH:HOWEHVFKDIIHQLVW:HQQ GLH3K\VLNXQVVDJWGDVVHV7HLOFKHQXQG)HOGHUJLEWGDQQJLEWHVNHLQHQSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ

*UXQGGDUDQ]X]ZHLIHOQ

Ä$QGHUHVHKHQLQZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHQ7KHRULHQQXUKLOIUHLFKH,QVWUXPHQWH]XU9RUKHUVD- JHYRQ%HREDFKWXQJHQRGHU]XU.RQVWUXNWLRQYRQ*HUlWHQ)U/HZLVNRPPWGDVQLFKW LQ)UDJH:LUKDEHQ]ZDUNHLQH*DUDQWLHGDVVXQVHUHEHVWHQ7KHRULHQZDKUVLQG±ZLU N|QQHQQLFKWHLQPDOEHZHLVHQGDVVGLH:HOWQLFKWHUVWYRUIQI0LQXWHQHQWVWDQG±DEHU VRODQJH ZLU NHLQH NRQNUHWHQ 9HUGDFKWVPRPHQWH JHJHQ VLH KDEHQ VROOWH XQV GDV QLFKW GDYRQDEKDOWHQXQVHUHQ7KHRULHQ]XYHUWUDXHQXQG]XJODXEHQGDVVVLHGLH:HOWLQHWZD ZHQQ DXFK VLFKHU QLFKW JDQ] NRUUHNW HUIDVVHQ :RUDQ VROOWHQ ZLU VRQVW JODXEHQ ZHQQ QLFKWDQXQVHUHEHVWHQ7KHRULHQDQVFKOHFKWHUH7KHRULHQ"2GHUDQJDUQLFKWV"³6FKZDU]

I

3KLORVRSKLVFKHhEHUOHJXQJHQVLQGGHPJHJHQEHUSULQ]LSLHOO]ZHLWUDQJLJ:HQQVLHGHQ(UJHE- QLVVHQ HWDEOLHUWHU :LVVHQVFKDIWHQ ZLGHUVSUHFKHQ GDQQ KDW IU /HZLV PHLVW GLH 3KLORVRSKLH NOHLQEHL]XJHEHQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHhEHUOHJXQJHQVLQGLQVHLQHQ$XJHQLQGHU5HJHOIUDJZU- GLJHUDOVZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH(UJHEQLVVH'LHVH7HQGHQ]]XPZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHQ5HDOLVPXVGLH DQDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKHQRIWGHQ9RUZXUIGHV6]LHQWLVPXVHLQJHWUDJHQKDWVFKHLQWPLULQGHU 7DWHLQHZHVHQWOLFKH*HPHLQVDPNHLWGHUPHLVWHQDQDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKHQ]XVHLQ±HEHQVR ZLHGLHGDPLW]XVDPPHQKlQJHQGH7HQGHQ]]XP1DWXUDOLVPXV⁵

'LH7KHVHYRQGHU(LQKHLWVZLVVHQVFKDIWJHK|UWH]XGHQH[SOL]LWHQ3URJUDPPSXQNWHQGHV :LHQHU.UHLVHV8QGDXFKQDFKGHU(UNHQQWQLVGDVVGLH:LVVHQVFKDIWHQQLFKWLQGHP6LQQH HLQH(LQKHLWELOGHQZLHPDQVLFKGDVXUVSUQJOLFKYRUJHVWHOOWKDWWHlQGHUWHVLFKQLFKWVDQ

4 Ä>,@QWKHGLPHQVLRQRIGHVFULELQJDQGH[SODLQLQJWKHZRUOGVFLHQFHLVWKHPHDVXUHRIDOOWKLQJVRI ZKDWLVWKDWLWLVDQGRIZKDWLVQRWWKDWLWLVQRW³6HOODUV

5 Ä,IFXUUHQWDQDO\WLFSKLORVRSK\FDQEHVDLGWRKDYHDSKLORVRSKLFDOLGHRORJ\LWLVXQTXHVWLRQDEO\

QDWXUDOLVP³.LP

GHQQDWXUDOLVWLVFKHQ*UXQGEHU]HXJXQJHQGHUPHLVWHQDQDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKHQ9LHOOHLFKW LVWHVXQSDVVHQGGLH9HUWUHWHUGHVQRUPDOVSUDFKOLFKHQ=ZHLJHVGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLH DOVÄQDWXUDOLVWLVFK³]XEH]HLFKQHQDEHUGHUDQWLPHQWDOLVWLVFKH*UXQG]XJEHL:LWWJHQVWHLQXQG 5\OHLVWXQEHUVHKEDU

0LUVFKHLQWGDVVGHU9RUUDQJGHUHPSLULVFKHQ:LVVHQVFKDIWHQXQGGLH7HQGHQ]]XP1DWX- UDOLVPXVHLQHZHVHQWOLFKH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQ$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKHQXQGLKUHQ*HJQHUQ PDUNLHUHQPDUNLHUWHQ"1HKPHQZLUQRFKHLQPDOGDV=LWDWYRQ)HUGLQDQG)HOOPDQQÄ>$OOH VSUDFKDQDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKHQ@YHUHLQW>«@HLQSUDJPDWLVFKXQGUHDOLVWLVFKDXVJHULFKWHWHV 'HQNHQGDVVHLQHQDPHULNDQLVFKHQ8UVSUXQJQLFKWYHUOHXJQHQNDQQ'DVPDFKWGHQ&KDUPH GLHVHU *UXSSH YRQ 3KLORVRSKHQ DXV GLH UHLQ SUREOHPRULHQWLHUW GHQNHQ 'DJHJHQ VLQG VLH GHQKXPDQLVWLVFKJHELOGHWHQ*HLVWHUQK|FKVWVXVSHNWZHQQQLFKWJDUXQV\PSDWKLVFK³)HOO- PDQQEHPHUNWKLHUHWZDVJDQ]5LFKWLJHVQlPOLFKGLHDEOHKQHQGH+DOWXQJYLHOHUGHXWVFKHU XQGHXURSlLVFKHU3KLORVRSKHQGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHJHJHQEHU:RUDXIEHUXKWGLHVH

$YHUVLRQ"1XUDXIGHUYHUPHLQWOLFKHQ7DWVDFKHGDVVDQDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKHQEHU]XJHULQJH .HQQWQLVVHGHU3KLORVRSKLHJHVFKLFKWHYHUIJHQ"2GHUGDUDXIGDVVVLHÄIRUPDOERPEDVWLVFKH

$SSDUDWXUHQIU(LQVLFKWHQHLQVHW]HQGLHDXVGHU7UDGLWLRQOlQJVWYHUWUDXWVLQG³"1HLQPLU VFKHLQWHVVLQGGHU6]LHQWLVPXVXQGGHU1DWXUDOLVPXVGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHJHJHQ GLH DQ .DQW +HJHO 6FKRSHQKDXHU 1LHW]VFKH RGHU +HLGHJJHU RULHQWLHUWH 3KLORVRSKHQ HLQH XQEHUZLQGOLFKH$EQHLJXQJHPS¿QGHQ

'DPLWHUJLEWVLFKDEHUDXFKHLQHUQHXWHU*UXQG]XGHU)UDJHREHVdie$QDO\WLVFKH3KLOR- VRSKLHEHUKDXSWQRFKJLEW'HQQHVKDWGHQ$QVFKHLQDOVREGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLH LQGHQOHW]WHQ-DKUHQQLFKWQXULKUDQWLPHWDSK\VLVFKHUVRQGHUQDXFKLKUV]LHQWLVWLVFKHUXQGLKU QDWXUDOLVWLVFKHU,PSHWXVYHUORUHQJHJDQJHQVLQG6LQG3ODQWLQJDXQG6ZLQEXUQHVLQG/RZH XQG *DOHQ 6WUDZVRQ VLQG 8ZH 0HL[QHU XQG %DUU\ 6PLWK QRFK DQDO\WLVFKH 3KLORVRSKHQ"

:HQQPDQGLHVH)UDJHPLW-DEHDQWZRUWHWQLPPWPDQ$EVFKLHGYRQYLHOHPZDV]XPLQGHVW GHU 0HKUKHLW GHU DQDO\WLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKHQ HLQPDO JHPHLQVDP ZDU *LEW HV WURW]GHP QRFK HWZDVZDVVLHDOOHHLQWXQGYRQDQGHUHQ3KLORVRSKHQDEJUHQ]W"

IV.

.RPPHQZLU]XUFN]XGHQVFKRQDP$QIDQJGHVOHW]WHQ$EVFKQLWWVDQJHVSURFKHQHQLGHROR- JLVFKHQ(OHPHQWHQGLH%LHUL]XIROJHGDV6HOEVWELOGGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHDXVPDFKHQ )U%LHULLVWGLHVHV6HOEVWELOG]XJOHLFKHLQ6WHLQGHV$QVWR‰HVLQVHLQHQ$XJHQVROOWH$QD- O\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKLHVROOWH3KLORVRSKLHEHUKDXSWLQYLHOIDFKHU+LQVLFKWnicht VRVHLQZLH VLHVLFKVHOEVWYHUVWHKW8QWHUDQGHUHPNULWLVLHUW%LHULGDVVGLHIRUPDOH/RJLNHLQH]XJUR‰H 5ROOHLQGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHVSLHOH$XIGLHVHQ3XQNWVSLHOWMDDXFK)HOOPDQQDQ XQGGLHVHU3XQNWHUNOlUWZDUXPHVGXUFKDXVVLQQYROOLVW3ODQWLQJDXQG0HL[QHUIUDQDO\- WLVFKH3KLORVRSKHQ]XKDOWHQ%LHULVFKUHLEWÄ$XIIlOOLJLVWZLHZHQLJ>GLHQHXHQORJLVFKHQ 6\VWHPH@XQVEHLVXEVWDQ]LHOOHQSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ)UDJHQJHQW]W KDEHQ³1RFKVFKOLPPHU 'LHVWDUNH2ULHQWLHUXQJDQ(QWZLFNOXQJHQGHUIRUPDOHQ/RJLNKDEHEHZLUNW

ÄGDVV3KLORVRSKLHPDQFKPDODXV]XVHKHQEHJDQQZLH6FKDFKRGHU+REE\PDWKHPDWLNXQG GDVVGLH)UDJHVWHOOXQJHQZLH/RJHOHLHQNODQJHQ6WXGHQWHQZXUGHQGDGXUFKDEJHVFKUHFNW 1LFKWZHLOVLHGLHIRUPDOHQ'LQJHQLFKWYHUVWDQGHQ'HU*UXQGZDUHUQVWHU6LHHUNDQQWHQ VLFKPLWLKUHU MotivationGLHVLH]XU3KLORVRSKLHJHEUDFKWKDWWHLQGHQ7H[WHQQLFKWPHKU ZLHGHU0LUVHOEVWJLQJHVQLFKWDQGHUV0DQZDUDXIGLH6XFKHQDFKHLQHPXPIDVVHQGHQ

9HUVWlQGQLVGHU:HOWXQGXQVHUHU6WHOOXQJLQLKUJHJDQJHQXQGIDQGVLFKSO|W]OLFKLQGHQ +lQGHQSDUWLNXODULVWLVFKHU7HFKQLNHU³

'LHVH'LDJQRVHKDOWHLFKIU]XWLHIVWXQJHUHFKWXQGHKUOLFKJHVDJWLFKELQQRFKQLHHLQHP DQDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKHQEHJHJQHWGHUYHUVXFKWHVHLQH*HJQHUPLWORJLVFKHQ7ULFNVHUHLHQ DXIV.UHX]]XOHJHQ⁶6LFKHUODXIHQORJLVFKH)RUPDOLVPHQPDQFKPDOLQV/HHUH$EHUZHQQ ZLU]XQlFKVWDQGLH$QIlQJHGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHGHQNHQLVWGLHKLOIUHLFKH5ROOHGHU DXI)UHJHXQG5XVVHOO]XUFNJHKHQGHQQHXHQ/RJLNXQEHVWUHLWEDU2KQH)UHJHVÃ(QWGHFNXQJµ YRQ4XDQWRUHQXQGPHKUVWHOOLJHQ3UlGLNDWHQXQGRKQHVHLQH,GHHGDVVHVVLFKEHL4XDQWRUHQ XP$XVGUFNHIU%HJULIIH]ZHLWHU6WXIHKDQGHOWVRZLHGLHVLFKDXVGLHVHU,GHHHUJHEHQGH QHXH )RUPHOVSUDFKH ZlUHQ XQV YLHOH ORJLVFKH =XVDPPHQKlQJH EHL ZHLWHP QLFKW VR NODU ZLH VLH HV KHXWH VLQG 0DQ GHQNH QXU DQ 3UREOHPH ZLH GLH 6WHOOXQJ XQG GHQ %HUHLFK YRQ 4XDQWRUHQRGHUGLH6WHOOXQJYRQ1HJDWLRQV]HLFKHQXQG$XVGUFNHQZLHÄQRWZHQGLJ³XQG ÄP|JOLFK³'HU([LVWHQ]TXDQWRULVWXQVVRJHOlX¿JGDVVZLUJDUQLFKWPHKUVHKHQGDVVHUVW GXUFKVHLQH(LQIKUXQJHLQQHXHV9HUVWlQGQLVGHV:RUWHVÄH[LVWLHUHQ³P|JOLFKZXUGH±HLQ 9HUVWlQGQLVGDVGDQQVSlWHUGXUFKGLHIUHLHQ/RJLNHQZLHGHUSUREOHPDWLVLHUWZXUGH%LHUL DEHUEHKDXSWHW

Ä:DVKDWXQVGLHHSLVWHPLVFKH/RJLNEHLGHU)UDJHQDFKGHQ*UHQ]HQXQVHUHV:LVVHQV EHLP 9HUVWlQGQLV GHU VNHSWLVFKHQ +HUDXVIRUGHUXQJ RGHU EHL GHU$QDO\VH YRQ 6HOEVWHU- NHQQWQLVJHQW]W"'DV9HUVWlQGQLVXQVHUHU0RGDOEHJULIIHLVWIUGLH3KLORVRSKLHYRQDOOHU JU|‰WHU %HGHXWXQJ )LQGHW PDQ MHGRFK GDV ZRUDXI HV DQNRPPW LQ GHQ PRGDOHQ .DO- NOHQ"8QGZLVVHQZLUVHLWGHU)RUPDOLVLHUXQJNRQWUDIDNWLVFKHU.DONOHZLUNOLFKEHVVHU ZDVHLQ1DWXUJHVHW]LVW"³(EG

%LHULV8UWHLOLVWKLHUlX‰HUVWHLQVHLWLJXQGHUXQWHUVFKOlJWGDVV/RJLNQLFKWQXUDXV.DONOHQ EHVWHKW:LOO HU ZLUNOLFK EHVWUHLWHQ GDVV GLH 0|JOLFKH:HOWHQ6HPDQWLN XQVHU9HUVWlQGQLV GHU0RGDOEHJULIIHHQWVFKHLGHQGYRUDQJHEUDFKWKDW":LOOHUEHVWUHLWHQGDVVGLHVH6HPDQWLN IUHLQH9LHO]DKOSKLORVRSKLVFKHU3UREOHPHYRQJU|‰WHU%HGHXWXQJLVW",QPHLQHQ$XJHQLVW RIIHQVLFKWOLFKGDVVGLHPLWGHU0|JOLFKH:HOWHQ6HPDQWLNYHUEXQGHQHQQHXHQ$XVGUXFNV ZHLVHQEHLYLHOHQ3UREOHPHQHLQHNODUHUH)RUPXOLHUXQJHUP|JOLFKHQ'DVJLOWIUVRYHUVFKLH- GHQH3UREOHPHZLHGHQRQWRORJLVFKHQ*RWWHVEHZHLVGLH,GHQWLWlWVWKHRULHLQGHU3KLORVRSKLH GHV*HLVWHVGDV3UREOHPGHU.DXVDOLWlW:HUEHVWUHLWHWGDVVVLFKGXUFK/HZLV¶Counterfactuals XQVHU9HUVWlQGQLVGHU:DKUKHLWVEHGLQJXQJHQNRQWUDIDNWLVFKHU.RQGLWLRQDOVlW]HHQWVFKHLGHQG YHUEHVVHUWKDWGHUEHVWUHLWHWGDV2IIHQVLFKWOLFKH

$XFK GLH 6XFKH QDFK H[SOL]LWHQ 'H¿QLWLRQHQ GLH %LHUL HEHQIDOOV NULWLVFK EHXUWHLOW KDW LQPHLQHQ$XJHQREZRKORGHUYLHOOHLFKWJHUDGHZHLOVLHLQYLHOHQ)lOOHQHUIROJORVZDUYLHO ,QWHUHVVDQWHV ]X 7DJH JHI|UGHUW 'LH 'LVNXVVLRQ XP GHQ %HJULII GHV :LVVHQV VHKHQ YLHOH DXFK%LHULLQ]ZLVFKHQDOVHLQPHKURGHUZHQLJHUQXW]ORVHV$XVWDXVFKHQYRQ%HLVSLHOHQXQG

*HJHQEHLVSLHOHQ'DVPDJVRVHLQ7URW]GHP*HWWLHUV(QWGHFNXQJYRQ)lOOHQLQGHQHQZLU QLFKWYRQ:LVVHQVSUHFKHQZUGHQREZRKOGLHGUHL%HGLQJXQJHQGHVWUDGLWLRQHOOHQ:LVVHQV- EHJULIIV±:LVVHQ JHUHFKWIHUWLJWHZDKUHhEHU]HXJXQJ±DOOHHUIOOWVLQGZDUHLQZLFKWLJHV (UJHEQLV8QGGLHDQGLHVH(QWGHFNXQJDQVFKOLH‰HQGH'LVNXVVLRQKDWGLH(UNHQQWQLVWKHRULH HLQHUKHEOLFKHV6WFNZHLWHUJHEUDFKW8QWHUDQGHUHPGDGXUFKGDVVQXQSO|W]OLFKGLH%HGHX- WXQJYHUOlVVOLFKHU0HFKDQLVPHQGHUhEHU]HXJXQJVJHZLQQXQJ]XPHUVWHQ0DOULFKWLJJHZU- GLJWZXUGH*DQ]RKQH=ZHLIHOZXUGHQLQGLHVHU'LVNXVVLRQDOWH=XVDPPHQKlQJHNODUHUXQG

6 9JO*H\HU

606

QHXH=XVDPPHQKlQJHEHUKDXSWHUVWVLFKWEDUJHPDFKWVRGDVVZLUGDVJHVDPWH)HOGKHXWH VHKUYLHOEHVVHUYHUVWHKHQDOVIUKHU

'LHVLVWJDQ]JHQHUHOOHLQQLFKW]XXQWHUVFKlW]HQGHU)RUWVFKULWWGHQGLH3KLORVRSKLHGXUFK GLH$QZHQGXQJ DQDO\WLVFKHU 0HWKRGHQ LQ GHQ OHW]WHQKXQGHUW -DKUHQ JHPDFKW KDW 2E ZLU LQGHU5HOLJLRQVSKLORVRSKLHGLHVRJHQDQQWHQ*RWWHVEHZHLVHRGHUGLH6WUXNWXUGHV3UREOHPV GHVhEHOVQHKPHQREZLULQGHU(UNHQQWQLVWKHRULHGDV3UREOHPGHV6NHSWL]LVPXVRGHUGHQ

%HJULIIGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJQHKPHQREZLULQGHU6SUDFKSKLORVRSKLHGLH)UDJHQHKPHQZLH VSUDFKOLFKH$XVGUFNH]XLKUHQ%HGHXWXQJHQNRPPHQRGHUVFKOLH‰OLFKLQGHU3KLORVRSKLH GHV*HLVWHVGLH)UDJHQDFKGHU1DWXUDOLVLHUEDUNHLWGHV0HQWDOHQJDQ]JHQHUHOOYHUVWHKHQZLU GLHVH3UREOHPHKHXWHVHKUYLHOEHVVHUDOVYRU-DKUHQ

*HUDGHEHLGHPOHW]WHQ3XQNWZLUGPDQFKPDODOOHUGLQJVHLQJHZDQGWGDVVVLFKGLH'LV- NXVVLRQKHXWHVRVHKULQLPPHUUDI¿QLHUWHUH'HWDLOGLVNXVVLRQHQYHUVWULFNWKDWGDVVGDV*DQ]H NDXPQRFKDQGHUVDOVHLQ*ODVSHUOHQVSLHOJHVHKHQZHUGHQNDQQ0LUVFKHLQWGDVZHLWJHKHQG IDOVFK6LFKHUNDQQQLFKWMHGHUGHQ'HEDWWHQXPHLQH]ZHLGLPHQVLRQDOH6HPDQWLNHWZDVDEJH- ZLQQHQ$EHUVLHVWHOOHQHLQHQJDQ]ZHVHQWOLFKHQ%HLWUDJQLFKWQXU]XU6SUDFKSKLORVRSKLH VRQGHUQDXFK]XU3KLORVRSKLHGHV*HLVWHVGDU8QGZDVGLH6SUDFKSKLORVRSKLHDQJHKW0|FK- WHMHPDQGEHVWUHLWHQGDVVGLHVH'LV]LSOLQRKQHGLH%HLWUlJHYRQ)UHJH5XVVHOO:LWWJHQVWHLQ

$XVWLQ4XLQH.ULSNH'DYLGVRQXQG.DSODQKHXWHVHKUYLHOlUPHUZlUH"9RQZLHYLHOHQ

%HLWUlJHQDX‰HUKDOEGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHLP-DKUKXQGHUWNDQQPDQbKQOLFKHV VDJHQ"=XUFN]XU3KLORVRSKLHGHV*HLVWHV0LUVFKHLQWGDVVPDQXPGHQ%HJULIIGHU6XSHU- YHQLHQ]WDWVlFKOLFKQLFKWKHUXPNRPPWZHQQHVXPGDV9HUVWlQGQLVGHV9HUKlOWQLVVHVYRQ

*HLVWXQG.|USHUJHKW$XFKKLHUKDWDOVRHLQHKHUWHFKQLVFKHU%HJULIIHLQHQHQRUPHQ)RUW- VFKULWWLP9HUVWlQGQLVGHU6DFKHHUP|JOLFKW

V.

'HU.HUQGHV8QEHKDJHQV%LHULVDQGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHRIIHQEDUWVLFKPHLQHU0HL- QXQJQDFKDOOHUGLQJVYRUDOOHPLQVHLQHU.ODJHGDVVDQDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKHQYHUVXFKWKlWWHQ GLH3KLORVRSKLH]XSURIHVVLRQDOLVLHUHQVLH]XHLQHPÄQRUPDOHQ³)DFKXQWHUDQGHUHQZHUGHQ ]XODVVHQ

Ä'LH DQDO\WLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKHQ KDEHQ YHUVXFKW GLH 3KLORVRSKLH ]Xprofessionalisieren 6LHKDEHQYHUVXFKWVLHQDFKGHP0RGHOOHLQHUExpertenkultur ]XEHWUDFKWHQ±QDFKGHP 0RGHOOHLQHU$NWLYLWlWDOVRGLHVLFKQLHGHUVFKOlJWLQ)DFK]HLWVFKULIWHQ)DFKOH[LND)DFK- NRQJUHVVHQ XQG *HVHOOVFKDIWHQ LQ GHQHQ VLFK GLH )DFKNROOHJHQ ]XVDPPHQVFKOLH‰HQ VRZLHLQHLQHUZHLWOlX¿JHQDXVJHIHLOWHQ)DFKVSUDFKHGLHDX‰HUKDOEGHU0DXHUQGHU$ND- GHPLHNHLQ0HQVFKYHUVWHKW$XFKGLH5KHWRULNYRQÃSKLORVRSKLVFKHU)RUVFKXQJµXQGYRQ SKLORVRSKLVFKHQÃ)RUVFKXQJVSURMHNWHQµJHK|UWGD]X³I

'HU 9HUVXFK GHU 3URIHVVLRQDOLVLHUXQJ PXVV QDFK %LHUL DEHU VFKHLWHUQ 'HQQ )lFKHU VHLHQ GXUFKÄHLQHQ7KHPHQEHUHLFKXQGHLQH0HWKRGH³GH¿QLHUW8QGEHLGHVJlEHHVLQGHU 3KLORVRSKLH QLFKW ,Q GHU 3KLORVRSKLH JlEH HV ZHGHU HLQH ÄVWDELOH IDFKOLFKH 0DWUL[³ QRFK HLQÄPHWKRGRORJLVFKHV5HSHUWRLUHGDVHLQHQDXIEHUVFKDXEDUHQDFKYROO]LHKEDUH:HLVHYRQ 7KHPD]X7KHPDYRQ3UREOHP]X3UREOHPIKUWH³'DVPDJVFKRQVHLQ$EHUJLOWGLHV QLFKWDXFKIUDOOHDQGHUHQ:LVVHQVFKDIWHQ":HOFKHÄVWDELOHIDFKOLFKH0DWUL[³ZUGHHWZD GLHYHUVFKLHGHQHQ%HUHLFKHGHU3K\VLNRGHUGHU%LRORJLH]XVDPPHQKDOWHQ"*LEWHVLQGLH- VHQ:LVVHQVFKDIWHQZLUNOLFKHLQÄPHWKRGRORJLVFKHV5HSHUWRLUHGDVHLQHQDXIEHUVFKDXEDUH

DZPhil 56 (2008) 4

QDFKYROO]LHKEDUH:HLVH³YRQGHU4XDQWHQWKHRULH]XU+\GURG\QDPLNRGHUYRQGHU0ROHNXODU ELRORJLH ]XU9HUKDOWHQVIRUVFKXQJ IKUHQ ZUGH" 0HLQHV:LVVHQV LVW GDV QLFKW VR (V ZlUH DXFK ]X YLHO YHUODQJW )lFKHU ELOGHQ NHLQH PRQROLWKLVFKHQ 6WUXNWXUHQ 8QG VLH ZHUGHQ LQ GHU 5HJHO NHLQHVZHJV GXUFK HLQHQ HLQKHLWOLFKHQ .DQRQ YRQ 0HWKRGHQ ]XVDPPHQJHKDOWHQ )lFKHUVLQGFKDUDNWHULVLHUWGXUFKHLQHQ6HWYRQPHKURGHUZHQLJHU]XVDPPHQKlQJHQGHQ)UD- JHQ YRQ PHKU RGHU ZHQLJHU ]XVDPPHQKlQJHQGHQ 3UREOHPHQ 8QG GLHV VFKHLQW PLU OlVVW VLFKDXFKYRQGHU3KLORVRSKLHVDJHQ-HGHQIDOOVLVWHVFKDUDNWHULVWLVFKIUGDV9HUVWlQGQLVYRQ 3KLORVRSKLHGDVYRQYLHOHQDQDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKHQJHWHLOWZLUG%LHULGDJHJHQEHWRQWGLH 9HUJlQJOLFKNHLWSKLORVRSKLVFKHU)UDJHVWHOOXQJHQ

Ä>D@(ULQQHUWVLFKQRFKMHPDQGDQGLH3UREOHPHPLWGHQHQ&DUQDSLPAufbau]XNlPSIHQ KDWWHRGHU*RRGPDQLQThe Structure of Appearance">E@:HUZHL‰QRFKZDVHVDOOHV IU:|UWHUZDUHQGHUHQ*HEUDXFKGLH6FKOHUYRQ$XVWLQXQWHUVXFKWHQLQGHPVLHJDQ]H -DKUJlQJHYRQMind IOOWHQ">F@6FKUHLEWQRFKMHPDQGEHUgrue RGHUbare particulars"

>G@hEHUGLH)UDJHZLHVLFK6LQQHVGDWHQ]XGHQ2EHUÀlFKHQYRQ'LQJHQYHUKDOWHQ">H@,VW GLH8QEHVWLPPWKHLWGHUhEHUVHW]XQJQRFKHLQOHEHQGLJHV7KHPD">I@2GHUGLHYLHOHQYLH- OHQ6SLHODUWHQYRQ6XSHUYHQLHQ]">J@'LH5HNRQVWUXNWLRQGHV8WLOLWDULVPXVLQGHQ.DWH- JRULHQYRQ6QHHG">K@3DU¿WV*HGDQNHQH[SHULPHQWH]XSHUVRQDOHU,GHQWLWlW"³(EG (VPDJVFKRQVHLQGDVVHVLQGHU3KLORVRSKLH0RGHVWU|PXQJHQJLEWGLHVLFKPHKURGHUZHQL- JHUVFKQHOODEZHFKVHOQ$EHUDXFKGDVVFKHLQWPLULQDQGHUHQ:LVVHQVFKDIWHQQLFKWDQGHUV]X VHLQ8QG'HP3KLORVRSKLHYHUVWlQGQLV]XIROJHGDVZLHPLUVFKHLQWVHKUYLHOHDQDO\WLVFKH 3KLORVRSKHQWHLOHQJLEWHVDXFKHLQH5HLKHÃ]HLWORVHUµ)UDJHQGLHVHLWGHP%HJLQQGHU3KLOR VRSKLH⁸LPPHUZLHGHUJHVWHOOWZXUGHQXQGGLHQRFKKHXWHIUGLH3KLORVRSKLHNHQQ]HLFKQHQG VLQG'D]XJHK|UHQÃJUR‰Hµ)UDJHQZLH

± *LEWHVHLQHQ*RWW"

± :DVNDQQPDQa prioriZLVVHQ"

± /lVVWVLFKGDV3UREOHPGHU,QGXNWLRQO|VHQ"

± :RULQEHVWHKWGLH%HGHXWXQJVSUDFKOLFKHU$XVGUFNH"

± ,QZHOFKHP9HUKlOWQLVVWHKHQ.|USHUXQG*HLVW]XHLQDQGHU"

± +DEHQZLUHLQHQIUHLHQ:LOOHQ"

± *LEWHVREMHNWLYH:HUWH"

± /DVVHQVLFKPRUDOLVFKH1RUPHQUDWLRQDOEHJUQGHQ"

± :DVLVWHLQHJHUHFKWH*HVHOOVFKDIW"

± :DVPDFKWHLQH6DFKHVFK|Q"

$EHUDXFKÃNOHLQHUHµ)UDJHQZLH

'LH$QWZRUWHQDXIGLHVH±QDWUOLFKQXUUKHWRULVFKJHPHLQWHQ±)UDJHQODXWHQZRKO>D@1HLQZHLO GHU3KlQRPHQDOLVPXVHLQH3RVLWLRQLVWGLHKHXWHNDXPQRFK$QKlQJHUKDW>E@:RKONDXPQRFKHL- QHU>F@1DWUOLFKLVWgrue LPPHUQRFKHLQ7KHPDLQGHU'HEDWWHXPGDV,QGXNWLRQVSUREOHP>G@(KHU QLFKWREZRKOGLH)UDJHQDFKGHQGLUHNWHQ2EMHNWHQGHU:DKUQHKPXQJLPPHUQRFKYLUXOHQWLVW>H@

-DVLFKHU>I@(EHQIDOOVREZRKOLQ]ZLVFKHQNODULVWZHOFKH6SLHODUWHQUHOHYDQWVLQGXQGZHOFKHHKHU QLFKW>J@1HLQ>K@-DVLFKHU

8 2GHU]XPLQGHVWVHLWGHP=HLWSXQNW]XGHPGLHVH)UDJHQÃHQWGHFNWµZXUGHQ

± :DVLVWLP+LQEOLFNDXIVSUDFKOLFKH%HGHXWXQJSULPlU±6lW]HRGHU:|UWHU"

± 6LQG(LJHQQDPHQVWDUUH%H]HLFKQHU"

± +DEHQ(PRWLRQHQHLQHNRJQLWLYH.RPSRQHQWH"

± .|QQHQ(PS¿QGXQJHQDOVUHSUlVHQWDWLRQDOH=XVWlQGHDXIJHIDVVWZHUGHQ"

± :HOFKH5ROOHVSLHOHQ6LQQHVGDWHQEHLGHU:DKUQHKPXQJ"

± 6LQG)DUEHQUHDO"

± :DVVSULFKWIUGHQ([WHUQDOLVPXVLQGHU(UNHQQWQLVWKHRULH"

± *HQLH‰HQ(PEU\RQHQYRQ$QIDQJDQGHQYROOHQ6FKXW]GHU0HQVFKHQUHFKWH"

'LHVH)UDJHQVLQGGHP3KLORVRSKLHYHUVWlQGQLV]XIROJHGDVLFKKLHULP$XJHKDEHzeitunab- hängige SachfragenGHUHQ%HDQWZRUWXQJPDQsystematisch LQ$QJULIIQHKPHQNDQQ3KLOR- VRSKLHistGLHVHP3KLORVRSKLHYHUVWlQGQLV]XIROJHQLFKWVDQGHUHVDOVGHU9HUVXFKHEHQGLHV]X WXQ±GHU9HUVXFKLQV\VWHPDWLVFKHU:HLVHUDWLRQDOH$QWZRUWHQDXIGLH6DFKIUDJHQ]X¿QGHQ GLHGDV7KHPHQVSHNWUXPGHU3KLORVRSKLHDXVPDFKHQ'LH0HWKRGHGHV3KLORVRSKHQLVWGDEHL QHEHQGHU%HJULIIVDQDO\VHLQDOOHU5HJHOGLH$QDO\VHDUJXPHQWDWLYHU=XVDPPHQKlQJH'DEHL ZHUGHQDXFK$UJXPHQWHYRQDQDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKHQDOVHWZDVDXIJHIDVVWZDVnicht UHODWLY LVW]XHLQHUEHVWLPPWHQ=HLWHLQHUEHVWLPPWHQ.XOWXURGHUHLQHPSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ6\VWHP

%LHULGDJHJHQEH]ZHLIHOWGDVVHVHLQH]HLWORVH5DWLRQDOLWlWJLEW(UEHWRQWGLHÄNRQWLQJHQWH>Q@

5DQGEHGLQJXQJHQIUXQVHU9HUVWlQGQLVYRQ9HUQXQIW³XQGHUNULWLVLHUWGLHJHJHQWHL- OLJH$XIIDVVXQJ

Ä)UHJH XQG 5XVVHOO XQG VSlWHU /HXWH ZLH &DUQDS XQG +HPSHO JDEHQ GHU DQDO\WLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKLHHLQHEHVWLPPWH,GHHYRQ5DWLRQDOLWlWPLWDXIGHQ:HJ(VZDUGLH,GHHHLQHU XQLYHUVHOOHQKLVWRULVFKXQZDQGHOEDUHQ5DWLRQDOLWlW'DVZDUHLQFDUWHVLDQLVFKHVXQGNDQ- WLVFKHV(UEHXQGHVSDVVWHSHUIHNW]XUIUKHUEHVSURFKHQHQ$EOHKQXQJGHV3V\FKRORJLV- PXV(VJHULHWPLW.XKQXQGGHPVSlWHQ:LWWJHQVWHLQLQV:DQNHQ³(EG

%LHUL EHPHUNW ]X 5HFKW GDVV HV LQQHUKDOE GHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKLH ]X GLHVHP7KHPD NHLQHHLQKHLWOLFKH0HLQXQJJLEW$EHUPLUVFKHLQWGDVVGLH0HKUKHLWGHUDQDO\WLVFKHQ3KLOR- VRSKHQKLHUHKHU)UHJH5XVVHOO&DUQDSXQG+HPSHOIROJW)UVLHVFKHLQWHVXQYHUQQIWLJ DQ]XQHKPHQGDVV'HVFDUWHV¶*RWWHVEHZHLVH]XVHLQHU=HLWJDQ]LQ2UGQXQJZDUHQIUXQV KHXWHDEHULKUH*OWLJNHLWYHUORUHQKDEHQ(VNDQQLQLKUHQ$XJHQQLFKWVHLQGDVV3ODWRQ]X VHLQHU=HLWPLWVHLQHU,GHHQOHKUH5HFKWKDWWHZlKUHQGGLHVH3RVLWLRQVFKRQIU.DQWQLFKW PHKU JOWLJ ZDU 'DV KHL‰W QDWUOLFK QLFKW GDVV VLFK GLH (YLGHQ]ODJH QLFKW lQGHUQ NDQQ (UVWnachdem 5XVVHOOGLH3DUDGR[LHQGHU)UHJHVFKHQ$ULWKPHWLNHQWGHFNWKDWWHPXVVWHMHGHU

±DXFK)UHJH±DN]HSWLHUHQGDVVPLWGLHVHU7KHRULHHWZDVQLFKW2UGQXQJZDUVorher ZDU )UHJHGXUFKDXVJHUHFKWIHUWLJWVLHIUZDKU]XKDOWHQ8QP|JOLFKLVWDEHUGDVVHVEHLgleicher (YLGHQ]ODJHIUHLQH3HUVRQUDWLRQDOVHLQNDQQHLQH7KHRULHIUZDKU]XKDOWHQIUHLQHDQGH- UHGDJHJHQQLFKW(LQ]ZLQJHQGHV$UJXPHQWLVWIUDOOHJOHLFK]ZLQJHQG±QLFKWQXUIUGLH 0HQVFKHQHLQHUEHVWLPPWHQ=HLWRGHUHLQHVEHVWLPPWHQ.XOWXUNUHLVHV8QGHLQ:LGHUVSUXFK LVWHLQ:LGHUVSUXFK±QLFKWQXUHLQ:LGHUVSUXFKIUGLH$QKlQJHUGHU7UDQV]HQGHQWDOSKLORVR- SKLHRGHUGHU3KlQRPHQRORJLH

$XVGLHVHQ$XIIDVVXQJHQHUJLEWVLFKHLQZHLWHUHV0HUNPDOGHVYRQPLUDQJHVSURFKHQHQ 3KLORVRSKLHYHUVWlQGQLVVHV±GLHhEHU]HXJXQJGDVVHVVRHWZDVZLH SKLORVRSKLVFKHSchulen HLJHQWOLFKQLFKWJHEHQNDQQ0|JOLFKVLQGQXUXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH$XIIDVVXQJHQXQG3RVLWLRQHQ DEHU GLHVH VLQG JHJHQHLQDQGHU QLFKW VR DEJHVFKRWWHW GDVV HLQ$XVWDXVFK YRQ$UJXPHQWHQ XQP|JOLFKZlUH*DQ]LP*HJHQWHLO(VJLEWQXUHLQHQJUR‰HQSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ'LVNXUVLQ

GHP MHGHU DUJXPHQWDWLY ]X GHQ$XIIDVVXQJHQ GHU MHZHLOV DQGHUHQ 6WHOOXQJ QHKPHQ NDQQ 'LHVLVWDXFKGHU*UXQGGDIUGDVV3KLORVRSKLHarbeitsteilig EHWULHEHQZHUGHQNDQQ:HQQ GLH$XIJDEH YRQ 3KLORVRSKLQQHQ XQG 3KLORVRSKHQ QLFKW LVW JUR‰H 6\VWHPH ]X HQWZHUIHQ VRQGHUQDQGHU.OlUXQJ]HLWEHUJUHLIHQGHUSKLORVRSKLVFKHU)UDJHQPLW]XZLUNHQGDQQN|QQHQ DXFKNOHLQH%HLWUlJHHLQHQ)RUWVFKULWWEHGHXWHQ6LHPVVHQQXUDXIHLQHJHPHLQVDPH)UDJH EH]RJHQVHLQXQGKHOIHQGHU$QWZRUWDXIGLHVH)UDJHQlKHU]XNRPPHQ

$OOHUGLQJV 3KLORVRSKLH XQWHUVFKHLGHW VLFK LQ HLQHP 3XQNW UHFKW GHXWOLFK YRQ DQGHUHQ )lFKHUQ6LHNDQQNDXPKRIIHQLKUH)UDJHQHLQIUDOOH0DOGH¿QLWLY]XEHDQWZRUWHQ'HU

*UXQG GDIU LVW HLQIDFK 3KLORVRSKLVFKH )UDJHQ ZHUGHQ ZHGHU GXUFK %HZHLVH QRFK GXUFK

%HREDFKWXQJHQRGHU([SHULPHQWHHQWVFKLHGHQ9LHOPHKUNDQQPDQVLFKGHU%HDQWZRUWXQJ GLHVHU)UDJHQQXUDUJXPHQWDWLYQlKHUQ$OOH$UJXPHQWHEHUXKHQMHGRFKDXI3UlPLVVHQXQG GLHVH3UlPLVVHQN|QQHQLKUHUVHLWVZLHGHULQ=ZHLIHOJH]RJHQZHUGHQ1LHPDQGYHUIJWEHU HLQHQDUFKLPHGLVFKHQ3XQNWGHUEHUMHGHQ=ZHLIHOHUKDEHQZlUHQLHPDQGNDQQVLFKDXI 3UlPLVVHQ VWW]HQ GLH QLFKW DQJHJULIIHQ ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ 'DV ]HLJW VLFK VFKRQ GDUDQ GDVV DOOHDQJHEOLFKVLFKHUHQ3UlPLVVHQLQGHU*HVFKLFKWHGHU3KLORVRSKLHWDWVlFKOLFKLUJHQGZDQQ HLQPDOEH]ZHLIHOWZXUGHQ6HOEVWGLHORJLVFKHQ:DKUKHLWHQZDUHQYRQGLHVHP6FKLFNVDOQLFKW DXVJHQRPPHQ'HVFDUWHVHWZD±DOVRHLQ3KLORVRSKGHUZLHNDXPHLQDQGHUHUQDFKHLQHP DUFKLPHGLVFKHQ 3XQNW GHV 'HQNHQV JHVXFKW KDW ± ZDU GHU 0HLQXQJ GDVV GLH *HVHW]H GHU /RJLNGHP:LOOHQ*RWWHVXQWHUOLHJHQ8QGGDUDXVIROJWGDVVZLUXQVVHOEVWEHLGHQORJLVFKHQ :DKUKHLWHQLUUHQN|QQHQ1XQJLEWHVVLFKHUJXWH$UJXPHQWHGLH]HLJHQGDVVGLH*HVHW]H GHU /RJLN QLFKW YRP :LOOHQ *RWWHV DEKlQJHQ N|QQHQ$EHU QDWUOLFK EHUXKHQ DXFK GLHVH

$UJXPHQWHDXI3UlPLVVHQGLHPDQEH]ZHLIHOQNDQQ6HOEVWLQGLHVHP3XQNWLVWDOVRNHLQH GH¿QLWLYH(QWVFKHLGXQJP|JOLFK

)RUWVFKULWWEHVWHKWLQGHU3KLORVRSKLHGHVKDOEQLFKWGDULQHLQHQ.DQRQDOOJHPHLQYHUELQG- OLFKHU$QWZRUWHQ]XHQWZLFNHOQ)RUWVFKULWWLQGHU3KLORVRSKLHEHGHXWHWGDVVZLUGLHP|J- OLFKHQ$QWZRUWHQXQGLKUH.RQVHTXHQ]HQEHVVHUYHUVWHKHQ(VJHKWGDUXPHLQHQP|JOLFKVW XPIDVVHQGHQhEHUEOLFNEHUGLH$QWZRUWHQ]XJHEHQGLHPDQDXIHLQH)UDJHJHEHQNDQQXQG KHUDXV]XDUEHLWHQZHOFKH,PSOLNDWLRQHQGLHVH$QWZRUWHQKDEHQZRUDXIPDQVLFKIHVWJHOHJW KDWZHQQPDQGLHHLQHRGHUGLHDQGHUH$QWZRUWDN]HSWLHUW'DPLWZLUG]XJOHLFKNODUZDVIU XQGZDVJHJHQGLHVH$QWZRUWHQVSULFKW'DHVIUDOOH3RVLWLRQHQLQGHU3KLORVRSKLH3URXQG .RQWUDDUJXPHQWHJLEWZLUGEHLGLHVHP9RUJHKHQNHLQH$QWZRUWDOVGLHHLQ]LJP|JOLFKHRGHU DOVGLHHLQ]LJUDWLRQDOHDXVJH]HLFKQHW'DYLG/HZLVKDWGDVLQGHU(LQOHLWXQJ]XPHUVWHQ%DQG seiner Philosophical PapersVHKUVFK|QIRUPXOLHUW

Ä:KHWKHURUQRWLWZRXOGEHQLFHWRNQRFNGLVDJUHHLQJSKLORVRSKHUVGRZQE\VKHHUIRUFH RIDUJXPHQWLWFDQQRWEHGRQH3KLORVRSKLFDOWKHRULHVDUHQHYHUUHIXWHGFRQFOXVLYHO\2U KDUGO\HYHU*|GHODQG*HWWLHUPD\KDYHGRQHLW7KHWKHRU\VXUYLYHVLWVUHIXWDWLRQ±DW DSULFH>«@ZKHQDOOLVVDLGDQGGRQHDQGDOOWKHWULFN\DUJXPHQWVDQGGLVWLQFWLRQVDQG FRXQWHUH[DPSOHVKDYHEHHQGLVFRYHUHGSUHVXPDEO\ZHZLOOVWLOOIDFHWKHTXHVWLRQZKLFK SULFHVDUHZRUWKSD\LQJZKLFKWKHRULHVDUHRQEDODQFHFUHGLEOHZKLFKDUHWKHXQDFFHSWDEO\

FRXQWHULQWXLWLYHFRQVHTXHQFHVDQGZKLFKDUHWKHDFFHSWDEO\FRXQWHULQWXLWLYHRQHV2QWKLV TXHVWLRQZHPD\VWLOOGLIIHU$QGLIDOOLVLQGHHGVDLGDQGGRQHWKHUHZLOOEHQRKRSHRI GLVFRYHULQJVWLOOIXUWKHUDUJXPHQWVWRVHWWOHRXUGLIIHUHQFHV³/HZLV[

:LHJHVDJWGLHVH$XIIDVVXQJLPSOL]LHUWQLFKWGDVVHVLQGHU3KLORVRSKLHNHLQHQ)RUWVFKULWW JLEW:HQQHVJHOLQJW]XNOlUHQZDVHLQHEHVWLPPWH3RVLWLRQJHQDXLPSOL]LHUWZHOFKH$UJX- PHQWHIUGLHVH3RVLWLRQUHOHYDQWXQGZHOFKH$UJXPHQWHGH¿QLWLY]XP6FKHLWHUQYHUXUWHLOW VLQG ]XP %HLVSLHO ZHLO VLH QLFKW ]HLJHQ ZDV VLH ]HLJHQ VROOHQ NDQQ GLHV HLQHQ ZHVHQW- OLFKHQ)RUWVFKULWWGDUVWHOOHQ)RUWVFKULWWLQGHU3KLORVRSKLHEHGHXWHWLP$OOJHPHLQHQQLFKWGLH

610

/|VXQJVRQGHUQGLH.OlUXQJYRQ3UREOHPHQ,VWHVQLFKWGDVZDVDXFK%LHULYRUVFKZHEW"

)DOOVMDVROOWHPDQYLHOOHLFKWEHWRQHQGDVVGLH]LWLHUWH3DVVDJHYRQHLQHPGHUDQJHVHKHQVWHQ DQDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKHQEHUKDXSWVWDPPW

(V IlOOW PLU QLFKW OHLFKW ]X HUNHQQHQ ZDV %LHUL DQ GHP JHUDGH JHVFKLOGHUWHQ 3KLORVR- SKLHYHUVWlQGQLVDXV]XVHW]HQKDWXQGLQVEHVRQGHUHZHOFKH$OWHUQDWLYHLKPYRUVFKZHEW1LFKW DXIJHEHQZLOOHUGLHGXUFKGLH$QDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKLHHUZRUEHQHQ6WDQGDUGVEHJULIÀLFKHU .ODUKHLWXQGDUJXPHQWDWLYHU5DWLRQDOLWlW

Ä%HLEHKDOWHQVROOWHPDQDXIMHGHQ)DOOGLH0D‰VWlEHYRQ.ODUKHLWXQGJHGDQNOLFKHUhEHU- VLFKWZHOFKHGLHDQDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKLHJHVHW]WKDW6LHVLQGYRQEOHLEHQGHP:HUWDXFK LP8PJDQJPLWGHQ6FKOVVHOWH[WHQDXVGHU*HVFKLFKWHGHU3KLORVRSKLH'HU8QWHUVFKLHG LP1LYHDX]ZLVFKHQ+LVWRULNHUQGLHMHQH0D‰VWlEHHUIOOHQXQGVROFKHQGLHHVQLFKWWXQ LVWJHZDOWLJ³

.HLQ (LQVSUXFK (XHU (KUHQ$EHU ZDV GLH ,QKDOWH XQG =LHOH GHU 3KLORVRSKLH DQJHKW IJW

%LHULKLQ]X

Ä$Q>«@EHVVHUHQ7DJHQZUGHLFKVDJHQ>$QDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKLH@KDWVHKUZRKOHLQH

=XNXQIW,FKVHKHVLHLP3URMHNWHLQHUGHVNULSWLYHQ0HWDSK\VLNGHU(UIDKUXQJGLHVLFKGLH YLHOHQVSUDFKDQDO\WLVFKHQ(LQVLFKWHQGLHVHU3KLORVRSKLH]X(LJHQPDFKWRKQHVLFKLUJHQG- ZHOFKHQ'RJPHQ]XYHUVFKUHLEHQZHGHUTXLQHDQLVFKHQQRFKZLWWJHQVWHLQLDQLVFKHQ0DQ N|QQWHGDV3URMHNWDXFKLQNDQWLVFKHQ:RUWHQEHVFKUHLEHQOrientierung im Denken(LQH 2ULHQWLHUXQJ LQ GHU ZLU XQV YHUJHZLVVHUQ ZLH ZLU EHU XQV XQG XQVHUH (UIDKUXQJ GHU :HOW GHQNHQ XQG YLHOOHLFKW GHQNHQ PVVHQ ZHQQ HV HLQH YHUVWlQGOLFKH :HOW VHLQ VROO

>«@'LH2ULHQWLHUXQJLP'HQNHQGLHPDQDXIGLHVH:HLVHHUZLUEWLVWPDQFKPDODXFK YRQSUDNWLVFKHU%HGHXWXQJHWZDEHLPRUDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ7KHPHQ'RFKGDUXPJHKWHV PLUQXUDP5DQGH:LFKWLJHULVWPLUGLHJHGDQNOLFKHhEHUVLFKWDOVVROFKH:HQQPDQVLH JHZRQQHQKDWLVWPDQHLQDQGHUHU0HQVFKDOVYRUKHU³

,VWGLHhEHUVLFKWGLH%LHULYRUVFKZHEWHLQHDQGHUHDOVGLHEHUGLHLFKJHUDGHJHVSURFKHQ KDEH":DVJHQDXLVWGDPLWJHPHLQWGDVVÄZLUXQVYHUJHZLVVHUQZLHZLUEHUXQVXQGXQVHUH (UIDKUXQJGHU:HOWGHQNHQXQGYLHOOHLFKWGHQNHQPVVHQZHQQHVHLQHYHUVWlQGOLFKH:HOW VHLQVROO³"*HK|UWGD]XGDVVZLUQDFKZLHYRUYHUVXFKHQGLHWUDGLWLRQHOOHQ)UDJHQGHU3KL- ORVRSKLH]XEHDQWZRUWHQRGHUJHKWHVXPJDQ]DQGHUH)UDJHQ":DVJHQDXVLQGGLH3UREOHPH PLWGHQHQVLFK%LHUL]XIROJHGLH3KLORVRSKLHEHVFKlIWLJHQVROOWH"8QGZDUXPVROOWHHVHLQ=LHO GHU3KLORVRSKLHVHLQGDVVPDQGXUFKGLH%HVFKlIWLJXQJPLWLKUHLQDQGHUHU0HQVFKZLUG"

6FKRQUHODWLYIUKLQVHLQHP$XIVDW]¿QGHWVLFKGLH3DVVDJH

Ä6WHOOHQZLUXQVYRUZLUYHUEULQJHQHLQHQ0RQDWGDPLWYRUPLWWDJVGDVJournal of Phi- losophy ]XOHVHQXQGQDFKPLWWDJVGLH:HUNHYRQ6HQHFD0RQWDLJQH1LHW]VFKH&HVDUH 3DYHVHXQG)HUQDQGR3HVVRD'DQQEHNRPPHQZLUHLQ*HIKOGDIUGDVVPLWGHU3URIHV- VLRQDOLVLHUXQJGHU3KLORVRSKLHGXUFKGLHDQDO\WLVFKHQ$XWRUHQHWZDVJDQ]1HXHVJHVFKH- KHQLVWXQGGDVVHVQLFKWVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKLVW³⁹

9 +DQMR*ORFNKDWHLQLQWHUHVVDQWHV6SLHOYRUJHVFKODJHQGHVVHQ3RLQWHGLH)UDJHLVWZHOFKH1DPHQ PDQ LQ %LHULV$XI]lKOXQJ GXUFK ZHOFKH DQGHUHQ HUVHW]HQ NDQQ *ORFN .DQQ PDQ GLH ]ZHLWH*UXSSHYRQ1DPHQHUVHW]HQGXUFKÄ3ORWLQ9LFR+DPDQQ6FKHOOLQJXQG+HJHO³RGHUGXUFK Ä+HLGHJJHU'HUULGD,ULJDUD\'HOHX]HXQG.ULVWHYD³",QGLHVHP6LQQHN|QQWHPDQDXFKIUDJHQRE GDVÄ1HXH³GDVQDFK%LHULHUVWGXUFKGLH$QDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKLHLQV6SLHOJHNRPPHQLVWQLFKW

611 DZPhil 56 (2008) 4

$XFKKLHUN|QQWHHVXPXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH)UDJHQJHKHQDEHUDXFKGDUXPGDVV%LHULVLFKHLQH andere ArtZQVFKWPLWGLHVHQ)UDJHQXP]XJHKHQ0|FKWHHUGDVVGLH3KLORVRSKLHHVVD\LV- WLVFKHU ZLUG XQG DXIK|UW V\VWHPDWLVFK QDFK EHJUQGHWHQ$QWZRUWHQ ]X VXFKHQ"$XI MHGHQ )DOOSÀLFKWHWHU5RUW\LQGHU$XIIDVVXQJEHL

ÄGDVV SKLORVRSKLVFKHU )RUWVFKULWW QLFKW LP JHGXOGLJHQ 9HUIROJHQ YRQ NOHLQWHLOLJHQ )RU- VFKXQJVSURMHNWHQHLQHUXQLYHUVHOODUEHLWHQGHQ9HUQXQIWEHVWHKWVRQGHUQLQEHUUDVFKHQGHQ /HLVWXQJHQ XQVHUHU GXUFK XQG GXUFK NRQWLJHQWHQ LGLRV\QNUDWLVFKHQ (LQELOGXQJVNUDIW³

,FKELQGDJDQ]DQGHUHU0HLQXQJ'DEHLVROOGLH%HGHXWXQJGHU/HLVWXQJHQGHU(LQELOGXQJV- NUDIWNHLQHVZHJVJHVFKPlOHUWZHUGHQ.HLQH:LVVHQVFKDIWNDQQRKQHVLHDXVNRPPHQ$OOH ZLUNOLFK QHXHQ ,GHHQ VLHKH 1HZWRQ VLHKH (LQVWHLQ EHUXKHQ DXI GHU )lKLJNHLW GLH 'LQJH HLQPDOY|OOLJQHXXQGDQGHUV]XVHKHQ$EHUEHGHXWHWGDVGDVVGDVJHGXOGLJH9HUIROJHQYRQ NOHLQWHLOLJHQ)RUVFKXQJVSURMHNWHQQLFKWDXFKYLHO]XPSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ)RUWVFKULWWEHLWUlJW IUGLHVHQ)RUWVFKULWWVRJDUXQHUOlVVOLFKLVW"

(VJLEWVRHWZDVZLHSKLORVRSKLVFKH(VVD\LVWLN±HLQJHLVWUHLFKHV6FKUHLEHQEHUGLHVXQG GDVRKQHGDVVPDQGHQ(LQGUXFNKlWWHGDVVVLFKKLHUMHPDQGV\VWHPDWLVFKEHPKHQZUGH HLQVDFKOLFKHV3UREOHPYRQDOOHQ6HLWHQ]XEHOHXFKWHQXQGVRHLQHU/|VXQJQlKHU]XEULQJHQ 0DQYHUJOHLFKHHWZD7H[WHYRQ.DQWXQG0RQWDLJQH'LHVH$UWGHVSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ6FKUHL- EHQVKDWGXUFKDXVLKUH%HUHFKWLJXQJ±QLFKWQXUGDQQZHQQVLHGHQ/HVHUXQWHUKlOWGDVNDQQ PDQYRQ.DQWVKritik der reinen VernunftVLFKHUQLFKWHUZDUWHQXQGYLHOOHLFKWVRJDUHUEDXW VRQGHUQEHVRQGHUVGDQQZHQQVLH8QRUGQXQJLQHLQHIHVWJHIDKUHQH'LVNXVVLRQEULQJWXQGVR QHXH6LFKWZHLVHQDXIVFKRQEHNDQQWH3UREOHPHHUP|JOLFKW$EHUSKLORVRSKLVFKH(VVD\LVWLN NDQQQLHGHQ.HUQGHVSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ7XQVDXVPDFKHQ-HGHQIDOOVGDQQQLFKWZHQQPDQ GLHVHV7XQDOVGHQsystematischen9HUVXFKDXIIDVVWUDWLRQDOH$QWZRUWHQDXI6DFKIUDJHQ]X HUDUEHLWHQ¹⁰'LHVJHKWDXIGLH'DXHUQXULQV\VWHPDWLVFKHQ$EKDQGOXQJHQGLH±GDV]HLJWVLFK DXFKLQDQGHUHQ:LVVHQVFKDIWHQ±LQGHU5HJHOHKHUHLQHWURFNHQH.RVWVLQG

+DQMR*ORFN]LWLHUWLQVHLQHP%XFKWhat is Analytical Philosophy?+DR:DQJGHU$QDO\- WLVFKH3KLORVRSKLHDOVÄZLVVHQVFKDIWV]HQWULHUW³FKDUDNWHULVLHUWXQGYRQGHUÄNXQVW]HQWULHUWHQ³ 3KLORVRSKLH:LWWJHQVWHLQVDEJUHQ]W

Ä8QOLNH5XVVHOO&DUQDSDQG4XLQH:LWWJHQVWHLQLVDUWFHQWHUHGUDWKHUWKDQVFLHQFHFHQ- WHUHGDQGVHHPVWRKDYHDGLIIHUHQWXQGHUO\LQJPRWLYHIRUKLVVWXG\RISKLORVRSK\³:DQJ

0DQFKPDOGHQNHLFKGDVVHV%LHULlKQOLFKVLHKW±GDVVHUHLQHNXQVW]HQWULHUWH3KLORVRSKLH DQVWUHEW XQG GLH ZLVVHQVFKDIWV]HQWULHUWH 3KLORVRSKLH VHKU YLHOHU DQDO\WLVFKHU 3KLORVRSKHQ DEOHKQW6HLQH9RUOLHEHIU:LWWJHQVWHLQXQGGHQQRUPDOVSUDFKOLFKHQ=ZHLJGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKLHVLQGMDGHXWOLFKJHQXJ

GRFKVFKRQIUKHUYRUKDQGHQZDU.DQQPDQ]XP%HLVSLHOÄGDVJournal of Philosophy³HUVHW]HQ GXUFKÄGLH:HUNH$ULVWRWHOHV¶'HVFDUWHV¶XQG.DQWV³"

10 Ä6\VWHPDWLVFK³KHL‰WKLHUQDWUOLFKQLFKWGDVVHVXPGLH(UULFKWXQJJUR‰HU6\VWHPHJLQJHVRQGHUQ XPHLQJHRUGQHWHVXQGNRQWUROOLHUWHV9RUJHKHQEHLGHPPDQ6FKULWWIU6FKULWWXQGP|JOLFKVWRKQH HWZDV]XEHUVHKHQYHUVXFKWVHLQHP=LHOQlKHU]XNRPPHQ

VI.

:DVNDQQÄ$QDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKLH³KHXWHQRFKKHL‰HQ"*ORFNKDWLQVHLQHP%XFKWhat is Analytical Philosophy?HLQHJUR‰H=DKOYRQ9RUVFKOlJHQGHQ%HJULIIÄ$QDO\WLVFKH3KLORVR- SKLH³]XSUl]LVLHUHQJUQGOLFKXQGDXVIKUOLFKXQWHUVXFKW6HLQ(UJHEQLVLVWLP:HVHQWOLFKHQ QHJDWLY$OOH9HUVXFKHHLQHVRGHUPHKUHUH0HUNPDOHDQ]XJHEHQGLHJHQDXGHQ3KLORVRSKLQQHQ XQG3KLORVRSKHQJHPHLQVDPVLQGGLH]XU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHJHUHFKQHWZHUGHQPVVHQ VLQGJHVFKHLWHUW¹¹$QJHVLFKWVGLHVHV%HIXQGHVVFKOlJW*ORFNOHW]WHQ(QGHVYRUÄ$QDO\WLVFKH 3KLORVRSKLH³DOVHLQHQGXUFK)DPLOLHQlKQOLFKNHLWHQFKDUDNWHULVLHUWHQ%HJULII]XYHUVWHKHQ Ä7KH ¿UVW LV WKH LGHD WKDW DQDO\WLF SKLORVRSK\ VKRXOG EH H[SODLQHG LQ WHUPV RIfamily

resemblances:KDWKROGVDQDO\WLFSKLORVRSKHUVWRJHWKHULVQRWDVLQJOHVHWRIQHFHVVDU\

DQGVXI¿FLHQWFRQGLWLRQVEXWDWKUHDGRIRYHUODSSLQJVLPLODULWLHVGRFWULQDOPHWKRGROR- JLFDODQGVW\OLVWLF7KXVFXUUHQWDQDO\WLFSKLORVRSKHUVPD\EHWLHGWR)UHJHDQG5XVVHOO LQWKHLUORJLFDOPHWKRGVRUWRORJLFDOSRVLWLYLVPDQG4XLQHLQWKHLUUHVSHFWIRUVFLHQFHRU WR:LWWJHQVWHLQDQGOLQJXLVWLFSKLORVRSK\LQWKHLUFRQFHUQZLWKWKHa prioriPHDQLQJDQG FRQFHSWVHWF³*ORFN

Ä>$@QDO\WLFSKLORVRSK\LVDKLVWRULFDOWUDGLWLRQKHOGWRJHWKHUE\WLHVRILQÀXHQFHRQWKHRQH KDQGIDPLO\UHVHPEODQFHVRQWKHRWKHU³*ORFN

'DVLVWHLQVHKULQWHUHVVDQWHU9RUVFKODJ$EHULVWHVZLUNOLFKZLFKWLJHLQH$QWZRUWDXIGLH )UDJHÄ:DVLVW$QDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKLH"³]X¿QGHQ",FKPXVVJHVWHKHQGDVVPLFKGLHVH$QW- ZRUWZHQLJHUXQGZHQLJHULQWHUHVVLHUW'DJHKWHVPLUZLH3HWHU%LHUL$XFKLFKP|FKWHYLHO HKHUKHUDXV¿QGHQZDVJXWH3KLORVRSKLHLVWXQGZLHPDQGLHVH3KLORVRSKLHEHWUHLEHQVROOWH¹² 0HLQH$QWZRUWHQVLQGGDEHLDEHUJDQ]DQGHUHDOVGLHYRQGHQHQLFKYHUPXWHGDVVVLH%LHUL JHIDOOHQZUGHQ%HVRQGHUV]ZHL'LQJHVLQGPLUZLFKWLJ

'LH$XIIDVVXQJGDVVHVLQGHU3KLORVRSKLHGDUXPJHKWLQV\VWHPDWLVFKHU:HLVHUDWLRQDOH

$QWZRUWHQDXIGLH6DFKIUDJHQ]X¿QGHQGLHGDV7KHPHQVSHNWUXPGHU3KLORVRSKLHDXVPD- FKHQGDVVHVGDEHL6WDQGDUGVGHU5DWLRQDOLWlWJLEWGLHIUDOOHLQJOHLFKHU:HLVHJHOWHQXQG GDVVHVGHVKDOEOHW]WHQ(QGHVQXUHLQHQJUR‰HQSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ'LVNXUVJHEHQNDQQ 'LH$XIIDVVXQJ GDVV GLH$UEHLW GHU 3KLORVRSKLH QXU GDQQ HUIROJYHUVSUHFKHQG JHOHLVWHW ZHUGHQNDQQZHQQPDQYHUVXFKWGLHYHUZHQGHWHQ%HJULIIHLQDOOLKUHQP|JOLFKHQ/HVDUWHQ VRNODUXQGDUJXPHQWDWLYH=XVDPPHQKlQJHVRWUDQVSDUHQWZLHP|JOLFK]X PDFKHQZREHL (UJHEQLVVHGHUPRGHUQHQ/RJLNEHUDOOGD]XEHUFNVLFKWLJHQVLQGZRHVGHU6DFKHGLHQW

11 1HEHQYLHOHPDQGHUHQJHKW*ORFNDXFKDXIGLHYRQPLUEHKDQGHOWHQ0HUNPDOHÄ0HWDSK\VLNNULWLN³ Ä:LVVHQVFKDIWVQlKH³ Ä1DWXUDOLVPXV³ XQG ÄEHVRQGHUH %HWRQXQJ GHU /RJLN³ HLQ XQG IKUW SHQLEHO DXIZHOFKHGHUJHPHLQKLQDOVDQDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKLQQHQXQG3KLORVRSKHQJHOWHQGHQ3HUVRQHQGLHVH 0HUNPDOHHUIOOHQXQGZHOFKHQLFKW$XFKEHLGLHVHQ0HUNPDOHQJLOWGDVVNHLQHVDXIDOOH]XWULIIW

12 (VJLEWHLQHKEVFKH$QHNGRWHEHUGHQ*UQGXQJVNRQJUHVVGHUGesellschaft für Analytische Philo- sophie,PHUVWHQ(QWZXUIGHU6DW]XQJZDUYRUJHVHKHQGDVZDV$QDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKLHDXVPDFKW ]XPLQGHVWNXU]]XFKDUDNWHULVLHUHQ$QDO\WLVFKH3KLORVRSKLHLVWLQEHVRQGHUHU:HLVHEHJULIÀLFKHU .ODUKHLW XQG DUJXPHQWDWLYHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW YHUSÀLFKWHW 'DUDXIKLQ JLQJ )ULHGULFK .DPEDUWHO DQV 5HGQHUSXOWXQGVDJWHHUIUHXHVLFKGDVVPDQRIIHQNXQGLJJHZLOOWVHLHLQH*HVHOOVFKDIWIU(UODQ- JHU.RQVWDQ]HU 3KLORVRSKLH ]X JUQGHQ GHQQ VFKOLH‰OLFK VHLHQ HV GLH (UODQJHU XQG .RQVWDQ]HU GHQHQGLHVH0HUNPDOHEHVRQGHUVZLFKWLJVHLHQ*HOlFKWHUXQG*HPXUPHOLP6DDO9LHOOHLFKWVROOH PDQGRFKOLHEHUJOHLFKHLQH*HVHOOVFKDIWIUJXWH3KLORVRSKLHJUQGHQ

(VJLEWLQ]ZLVFKHQKHUYRUUDJHQGH(LQIKUXQJHQLQGLHYHUVFKLHGHQHQ%HUHLFKHGHU3KLORVR- SKLH±]XP%HLVSLHOGDV%XFKPhilosophy of Religion: An IntroductionYRQ:LOOLDP5RZHLQ GHPGLHVHEHLGHQ$VSHNWHJXWHU3KLORVRSKLHDXIJHUDGH]XKHUYRUUDJHQGH:HLVHYHUZLUNOLFKW XQGPLWHLQDQGHUYHUEXQGHQVLQG0HLQHU0HLQXQJQDFKNDQQPDQ3KLORVRSKLHQLFKWEHVVHU EHWUHLEHQ8QGGHVKDOEZQVFKHLFKPLUQDWUOLFKGDVVGLHVH$UWGHV3KLORVRSKLHUHQVQRFK VHKUYLHOPHKU$QKlQJHUJHZLQQWDOVVLHKHXWHVFKRQKDW

Prof. Dr. Ansgar Beckermann, Universität Bielefeld, Fakultät für Geschichtswissenschaft, Philosophie und Theologie, Abteilung Philosophie, Postfach 10 01 31, 33501 Bielefeld

Literatur

%HFNHUPDQQ$(LQOHLWXQJLQ33UHFKWO+J*UXQGEHJULIIHGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLH 6WXWWJDUW±

%LHUL3:DVEOHLEWYRQGHU$QDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLH"LQ'HXWVFKH=HLWVFKULIWIU3KLORVRSKLH -J+HIW±

&DUQDS 5 6FKHLQSUREOHPH LQ GHU 3KLORVRSKLH 1DFKZRUW YRQ *QWKHU 3DW]LJ )UDQNIXUW0

$XÀ%HUOLQ

&DUQDS5hEHUZLQGXQJGHU0HWDSK\VLNGXUFKORJLVFKH$QDO\VHGHU6SUDFKHLQ(UNHQQWQLV :LHGHUDEGUXFNLQ+6FKOHLFKHUW+J/RJLVFKHU(PSLULVPXV±GHU:LHQHU.UHLV0QFKHQ

±

&DUQDS5+DKQ+1HXUDWK2:LVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH:HOWDXIIDVVXQJ±GHU:LHQHU.UHLV:LHQ 9HU|IIHQWOLFKXQJHQ GHV9HUHLQV (UQVW 0DFK:LHGHUDEGUXFN LQ + 6FKOHLFKHUW +J /RJLVFKHU (PSLULVPXV±GHU:LHQHU.UHLV0QFKHQ±

)HOOPDQQ)2ULHQWLHUXQJ3KLORVRSKLH:DVVLHNDQQZDVVLHZLOO5HLQEHNEHL+DPEXUJ

*H\HU&K6RUJHGLFKQLFKWGHQNHLQ)UDQNIXUWHU$OOJHPHLQH=HLWXQJ6HSWHPEHU

*ORFN+-$:LWWJHQVWHLQ'LFWLRQDU\2[IRUG

*ORFN+-:KDWLV$QDO\WLF3KLORVRSK\"&DPEULGJH

.LP-7KH$PHULFDQ2ULJLQVRI3KLORVRSKLFDO1DWXUDOLVPLQ-RXUQDORI3KLORVRSKLFDO5H- VHDUFK±

/HZLV'&RXQWHUIDFWXDOVEHUDUE$XÀ2[IRUG

/HZLV',QWURGXFWLRQLQGHUV3KLORVRSKLFDO3DSHUV%G2[IRUGL[±[LL /HZLV'3DUWVRI&ODVVHV2[IRUG

4XLQH:927ZR'RJPDVRI(PSLULFLVPLQGHUV)URPDORJLFDOSRLQWRIYLHZ$XÀ 1HZ<RUN

5RZH:3KLORVRSK\RI5HOLJLRQ±$Q,QWURGXFWLRQ$XÀ:DGVZRUWK 6FKZDU]:'DYLG/HZLV0HWDSK\VLNXQG$QDO\VH'LVVSKLO%LHOHIHOG 6HOODUV:)6FLHQFH3HUFHSWLRQDQG5HDOLW\/RQGRQ

6WUDZVRQ3),QGLYLGXDOV/RQGRQ

:DQJ+%H\RQG$QDO\WLF3KLORVRSK\&DPEULGJH0DVV

:LWWJHQVWHLQ / 7UDFWDWXV ORJLFRSKLORVRSKLFXV :LHGHUDEGUXFN LQ GHUV 6FKULIWHQ %G )UDQNIXUW0±