Do cooperative enterprises create social trust?

(1)

Munich Personal RePEc Archive

Do cooperative enterprises create social trust?

Sabatini, Fabio and Modena, Francesca and Tortia, Ermanno

Sapienza University of Rome, Department of Economics and Law

3 July 2012

Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/39814/

MPRA Paper No. 39814, posted 03 Jul 2012 15:19 UTC

(2)

Abstract

! "

! " "" " "

# $ ! % ! "

% " " & '

" ( $ " "

$ $ ) " " $ ) #

Keywords* " ! +

! $ ) ! + #

JEL Codes* , ,- . / /

$ 0 "

1 & 2 3 4 # " !

5 " $ " # 6

2 7 + ! $ ! " " $

7 8 $ 5 " % # 9

#

" . $ + : " 1 1 & 2

3 4

2 ! # * " # ; # # ' * + : < 1 <

2 . + = (( > 1 ? & #

: " " 1 & 2

3 4# * " # ; # #

: " " 1 & 2

3 4 : " ! " @ * # ; # #

(3)

1. Introduction

2 ! $ ! #

! ! !

! ! ! !

$ " # A" A "

! B C

" $

& 2 A @ 3&2@4 &2@ ! !

==- 3 )) ((=4# !

! ! +

! $ $ ! # 6 )

5 ! "" $ !

3 ! + ((=4# "

" ) ! " #

$ ) "

! "" " ! $ D

3 $ (( E ! + ((=E 7 ( (4# ! " "" "

" ! # "

+ ) 9

3 =F 4 7 A9 , 3 ==-4$ "

3 " 5 7 # == E 2 ! ' == == E 7 G ((=4#

$ ) " " " %

37 A9 # ( E ( E H ! ( E

' ( 4# I " ) $ ! !

"" " " ! ! "

" #

! " !

" "" " " # J %

"" "

" " " # @ $

" " " #

2 ! $ A" ! " ) "

" ! " ! $

(4)

3$ " " 4 " !

"" " " ! " " 3 K-=E F FE @ $ =K 4#

! $

! " " 5 "

" " 3' == E L ) L " ==KE H # ((FE ((=4#

@ ! $ "" "" "" " $

! " "

! + #

J % ! "

% " " & ' "

( 3 " " 4# !

% * B ) ! "" $ $ )

$ ) $ ) " $ C#

& $ $ % " 5

#

@" ! " $

" $ ) A ! " $ ) # J $

! $ ) ) " #

" $ " " !

$ ) " $ ) K#-M

>#=M - M "A

# " ! !! " ?

! " " ! " " 5 + ! " "

? "" " "

# " "

#

! " % $ 5 5 "

! $ ) D ! $

" 0 # N $ " $ %

$ ) $ " 5 !

5 0 "" "

! "" " "

) " # 5

(5)

! $ ! $ )

! + A ) ! #

$ $ % $ "

! D " # &

$ " $ ) D " # &

A " ! $ ! $ " 5

"" " B C#

" " $ # " "

$ # #

" " "" " "

# 2 ! ) " " "

" #

2. Motivation of the study and related literature

2 ! + +

! 37 ( (E 7 + ! ( (4# $

" ! + " ! " ! "

$ $ "" "

3N =FF ==>4# & $ ! + "

$ ! ^- ! %

3 A BJ C 4# % !

" % ) ! $ % $ !

" # @ "" $ 5 A $ " A

" # 6 " " $ $

5 $ 3 ! ! + $ $ "

$ 4 $ ! " "

! % # % !

! " ! + ! + $

) ! $ # H 5

- 2 ! + ! #

N $ " " " "

" " $ " " 38 ((K4# J

! ! ! ! + !

! #

(6)

-

$ $ ! ) "

! $ ) ! " ! #

" ! + "" "

A $ $A $ "

" $ " ! ) ! # &

"" ! + 5 ! " $

! 3N ==>4# I $ ! + "

" )

! "" $ 32 ! '

== == E 7 # == * 7 # == E 7 G ((=E 7 G ( 4# 6

! "" " !

"" ! " 37 + !

( (4# ' ) ! ! + "

! ! " " ""

! ) "" $ " # N +

A ! + ) ! $

" ! + 3 ( E ( 4#

N + " ! " 3

6 ) =K-E . =FFE ' == E (((4# $ *

" $ 3

A 4 ! ! 5 " " "

$ ! $ " 3 ! 4

! " # " " ! !

! + " " " 3 ((F4# 2 !

" " ! +

" ! ! # 5 $

" " !

) ! " A ! " ! D $ 3

# ((FE ((=E ! @ ' ( 4# "

! ! ! " ^># : " $

>& $ ! " ! + $A

! ! $ " " $ ! # & + A

) ! 5 5

# N $ "" #

) $ ! " $ ) " ! 5 ""

(7)

>

$ " "

! + " # N $ $ $ "" " ? # #

A "" "" " # @ % $

! " )

" " $ A" ! " ) ! "

! $ #

==( ! $ ! " " ? $

! B ! C " ? " " #

! " " " "

" !

3 ! ' == E ) ==-E L ) L " ==KE / )

L ) ( E H # ((FE ((=4#

@ L ) 3 (( 4* B6 " "" " D

A ! ! $ ) 3 # # $ "

4 $

" C 3 # K 4# & ! A !

" ! 5 3L ) L " ==K4#

" $ ! $ !

" B C " "

! " $ ) " #

A$ " 3 #!# 4

" $ ) " @ # & 3 K-=4 !

$ " " $ " " !

" ) # N " "

! ! " ) $ ! ! " 5 ! ! ! # ,

" " " "

# & 3 F F4 *

B2 0 0 ! #

$ ! ! "

$ " $ 5 " ! " C#

! + E ! " # "

! + 5 ! $

" ! 0 3@ + =K E , ) ! =K>4#

(8)

K

$ $ " ! " $ ) @ $ 3 =K 4 9 3 ==(4# & "

@ $ 3 =K 4 * B8 $ "

" " # &

! " )$ $ 5 ) "

" C 3 =K # -K4# @ ! 9 3 ==( # - 4 B "

"" $A " " "

! 6 C#

& $ 5 ! ! $ A" ! "

) ! 5 "

3$ " " 4 " ! "" " " ! " "

#

@ $ $ 5 " $ ! ! +

"" " " $ ""

$ ) D " # !

! + # ) " " $ "

5 5 $ # @ 7 3 (( #

K -A K >4 $ *

B 5 $ !

5 5 "" # 7 ! 5 A 0 D "

D " 5 ) A 5

0 ! "

" # & $ " $ " " # J

"A ! !# A ! !# " ! )

!! ! $ ! C#

& $ $ " "

! ^K# . ! $ $ A "

" ! ! ! " #

$ $ $ ) ! " ! " #^F

K6 ! $ * $ ) "

"A ! " $ $ ) ! # & ! $

0 $ 0 !# $ 0 0

! 3' ) "" # (( 4#

F6 ! $ ! "" "

3$ ) O4# N " ! ! " "

(9)

F

N $ 5 " "" $ $ )

% " ! 5 5 #

3. Data and descriptive findings

@ & $ ! " %

3 P F K4 " & ' " ( ⁼#

% $ " ! " " "

" # $ " ! ! "

# J ! % B ) !

"" $ $ ) $ ) $ )

" $ C $ $ ) $ $ )

5 # # $ ) 3- M " 4 $ ) 3 M4

$ ) 3 #FM4# 6 " A " $

$ ) ! $ ) $ > = ! 5

KKM " ! ⁽# @ $ 5 $ "

# " " %

$ ) $ # & $ !

$ )

) ! " # K #=M " $ )

$ )A #

Q R

& ! "

" ! "" $ B ! C B ! C

$ ) # : " $ " !

"" " #

= % $ ! $ : "

" ! 1 " : " # " % $

" 1 & 2 3 4 #

! ! F((A=(( $ % " FF-- 3 # #

" % 4 $ 5 " # '

! " $ " ! "

# $ -FK KKK " $ >

> $ " $# => $ #

(1 ! " $ " $ ) #

% " " ) " #

% #

(10)

=

B C $ ! 3 P B $ )

! " C P B $ ) "

C $ $ ! B C4# @ ! $ $ ) D

3" ) " " $ $ "

B$ ) C $ $ ) 5 4#

Q R

$ " !

$ ) A " "A

3 " " " " 4

$ $ ) 5 $ $ ) #

6 $ ! " " " $ ) "

! + # 6 ) + "" "

) "" ! + " $

# $ !

$ ! $ ) ! + !

# N $ $ " $ ) D

" 0 $ 5 " "

" # " $

"A $ " " #

!

+ ! A$ ) # "

) ! $ " " "

! $ " 5

! 3L ! # ((=E H ! S . ! =K E . =F E

, ! (( E ! @ ((=4 " $ 37

(( E ! # ( 4#

& $ ) $ $ ) T

0 " ( 3 4 - 3 4 $ 5

" 5 5 0 + "

5 # 9 $ * # ! # 0

% $ ) $ ) $ 0 5 # # $ ) $ )

$ ) #

(11)

(

# # " 5 " $ ) ! 3 #!#

D $ $ ) ! 4 -# " ! $ ) "

$ ! ># ! " K# "

! F# ! ! 0 =#

" ! #

6 " 2 ! ' 2 @ 32 '2@4 = " #

6 " " 2 '2 ! " % " 3=4#

$ 5 $ ! ! # $

! 3 4 5 3 4 $ ) #

N $ " ! 2 '2@ ! $ #

2 '2@ $ . ) $

" 5 @ 3 @4 # @ " $

2 '2@ $ " 5 # @ ! " " $ ! +

2 D @ 5 5 " $ " # " " $

! $ ! 3 - ! =4 5

>M " $ " $

" " 5 3 ! 4 5 >M " #

6 " $ 5 ! " !

2 D @ # " # 2 @ D "

! % (#F $ ! ! " #

5 $ $ @ 3(#> 4# $

6 32 '2@E (( 4 " % " !

! $ " P " " 0 #

% " ! ! " + ! 3 " !

% ! 4 " $ ! " O YD *

∑

=

−

=

0

0I UU

H J UU I4

.3J

$ UU·UU " % " 5 G 5 " O V 5 "

0 " 0 Y 5 ! ! % " " # @ ! " "

$ H + 2 D @ 3H2@4 5 8 @ 38@ 4 5

+ 3 Q(E ((R4 ! " 2 '2@ #

% " " 2 '2@ " 3 @4

" + A ! " ! " #

& @ 5 ' @5 !# $

# 5 $ ! " 5

$ " $ ! ! 3 M4# 6 " " ! '

2 5 # ! % " 5

" $ " --M# 6 5 ! 8 5 $ L + $

" J $ " $ 3 ! 4

# ! $ 5 A+ $

5 #

(12)

" 5 " @ 5

$ A ! # $ )

% ! 3 " $ " 4 !

" ! 3 " 2 '2@ "

@ @ 5 @4# $ 5 " " $

#

6 ! + " " 3 - =4 "

5 3 4# & $ !

% " A "A ! !

$ " A 3 - K F4 A ! !

$ " " " 3 > =4# @

" $ 5 " " ! " A ! !

# " "" "

3 ! @ ((=E 7 # ( 4#

& 5 ! + ! " ) " "

" 5 " " # 5

$ ) $ $ ) $ ) ! + "

5 # N ! " $ ) D "

" " " ! + # @ !! ! +

5 " $ ) $ ! ! #

+ )

! A$ ) # N

$ " " ! "A

# & $ ! "A !

$ % ) # # $ 5 % " "

" $ ) $ A 5 ! " #

6 " " ! " #

" " " " ! 3 !4 ! " #

"" B C ! "

" ! ! 0 " ! + " ! ! # &

! % " # &

"" " " 5A #

J " $ ) D

! ) T 0 #

(13)

B ! C " "

# $ ! : "" 3 ===4 ! !

$ ! " 3L $ L ==KE

((FE ((=E ! @ ((=4# $ D

) " " " $ ) $

! # 2 ! " D

! " "

3I ( E @ # ( 4# 0 "

$ $ ""

D # 5 " "

5 " ! $ A # "

" ! "

32 # (( E ((=4#

& " $ ! 5 $

" " " $ ) " $

$ ) ! # " $ ) $ " " % " ! $

$ " ! $ "

% * BN $ " C BN $ " " C^-#

' " $ ) ! $ "

$ " ! + # $ ! $ !

$ BJ C B' A % C 3 " 5 L ) L " ==KE

I ( 4# 6 " BJ C ! + $ !

" " D ! "

! 3J =>-E =F 4# 5 " " ! + "

" " D ! #

6 " B' A % C ) B

$ C 3L ) L "

==K # K 4# 5 " " ! +

3 #!# 4 ! ! + #

@ ! " " $ ) D !

$ $ ) 5 " " $ ! # "

-' % $ ! " P B& T" C K P B

C $ P B9 C P B@ " $ C P B@ " $ C - P BJ $ )C > P B

$ )C# @ " ! $ $ $ 5 % " A !

#

(14)

$ ) $ ) ! " " A A"

! " " 3' (((E

(( E @ # ( 4# $ ! " "

% " A A0 # & " $

! " " % " ! $ !

% * BN $ " ! " $ )

C ! AK " #

! " $ ! "

# 8 ! " ( !

% ! 5 $ ' 0

$ ! B9 C ( ! B C ^>#

$ ! ! -A % *

B6 $ ! A : ! ! C $ ! B8

$ !C - ! B8 $ !C# 6 ! ) "

D " ! D " ! " "

$ A : ! " "

$ ! " & #

6 " $ ! ! A * ! ! "

3 # 4 $ A !# " $ A

! ! % * B& D ""

! " C# " $ $ B$ !

"" C B$ "" C $ " #

& $ " ! " . .

# & D . . 3.. 4 " "A ) $

! # & & 9 &

" 3& @ 4 >F> ! ' 2 " (( #

' " K .. #

& $ " * # " " 5 "

& @ 3 ( (4# # " ! " .. # #

.. $ " $ ) D #

" #

>6 " " ! ' "

0 & # N $

5 " #

(15)

Q R

4. Econometric findings

6 $ )

" ! " " "" ! #

$ "" " $ ) " " "

$ ) $ $ ! $ # $

% " " $ ) ! 3 " ! $ ) "

$ ) 4 $ 3& 14# 6 & 1

! # $ " " $

$ " ^K#

6 " *

" $ ) ! "

( $

" $ ) "

( $

" $ ) "

( $

= 



= 



= 



5! " ! =β + # $

"

= <

= < <

= >

$ ! " !# &

" $ ! ∈^#

( )

^(" *

W W

W W W W

W

3 4 ' 3 4 3 4

3 4 ' 3 4 3 4 3 4

3 4 3 4 3 4 3 4

β β

β β β β

β

= = < − = Φ −

= = − ≤ < − = Φ − − Φ −

= = − = − = = − Φ −

$ ^{Φ ⋅}

( )

^#

" # ! "

"" " $ ! "" # & 3 "

K@ " ) $ " ! ! & 1 ! ! #

"" $ $ ! " # 1 " ! " ) "

% #

(16)

-

4 $ " "

! A ! # & 3 "

4 $ # 2 $ " 5 "" #

@ ! " !

! " " # " $ )

5 ! ! ) $ )

" - M# @ " ? # #

" "A 3 4

! " #

Q R

&" $ % 3 4 $ !

! " + " "" " $ $ %

- ! " - M# "" ) ! " !

K#-M 0

" $ ) " ! 3$

! 4 ^F#

" ! ! ! " + " !

"" $ ) " ! # ! "" "

-# 7 !

$ ) " $ ) >#=M

- M "A # @ $

A " " $ ) !

" ! ! " # J

" " ! " ! "

+ " #

7 ! " ) " ! $ )A

K ! " - M# ! ! " "

3 + 4 ! ! # 7 ! $ % ) !

$ " ! +

F1 $ ! " ! " $ " ! " $ ) #

! "" " $ )A " # A

! #=-# 6 ) 5 ! ! ) $ )

" - M# ! "" " % # > 3 A %

-# >4# " ) " % #

(17)

>

$ # N + $ ! " ! "

#

Q - R

6 ) $ " 0 5 ! "

> ! ! ) $ ) 5 #

7 ! 5 ) " ! 0

! # @ 5 " %

$ " "A " $ ) + !

# " ) "

" ! #

@ 5 " D ! "

$ # ' A %

> ! ! " ! % "

$ ) 5 # " ! " !

$ ) $ $ )A # " !

' D 3 (((4 $ " $

B " C " $ B + C# &

D $ B "

A C 3' == # F=?=(4 $ " A

5 $ #

N $ ! + " $ 5 " $

# " $ " ! +

$ ! ! ! ) $ #

5 ! ! + ? $ " !

' A % ! + ? "" !

$ ! 3L ) L " ==KE L ) (( 4# ""

" ! "

$ ) % " $ $ )

" #

& A " ! $ "" $ ) D

$ )A ! " $ ! $

" 5 "" " # 1 "

(18)

K

# 6 ! " ! ! ! "" "

" " ' A % #

" ! $ $ )

# M # M

# 6 ) - # M

! ) $ ) 5 "A

$ ) #

5. Conclusions

! " !

" " #

J " ! !! ) "

" " # $ "

? ! " " ! "

" 5 + ! " " ? "" "

" # "

" " ! ""

" 5 ! ! ! # @ !

" " $ A" ! " ) !

" # "

" "" " ! " #

J " ! !! ! !

#

! $ ! ! " ! ! "" "

5 " $ "

" $ $

" $ 36 ! = E ' ( 4# ! "

" ! " " 5 "" # & $ "

+ 5 $ ! #

N $ 5 5 " " " ! !

# J "A ) "

# $ $ ) $ !

" $ " "

(19)

F

" " " ! + "

$ + + ! #

Tables

# N $ ) $ ) " $

A 3

$ ) 4

' $ ) ' ' '

$ )

2

$ )

% M % M % M % M % M % M

8

! #>> K #== = # F #( ( ( ( (

9 ! K#( ( K#( K >#KF >#> ( ( ( (

9 "" > -#== >( K#-> =F ># > F# K#F (

' -# - - -# - FF # F ^#( ( #>K > (

8 ( >#F >- -# > = K#( -K ^># - # - (

) $ #= (#K( #( (#-F ( ( ( (

$%& '(( )%$ '(( *)$ '(( +), '(( )& '(( )( '((

# N $ ) $ ) " $

A 3

$ ) 4

' $ ) ' ' '

$ )

2

$ )

% M % M % M % M % M % M

9 ! >K (#FF K # -> (# K K (#K ( ( ( (

9 "" > >#>= >( K#F =F K#( ^F#-- K#(F (

' - # > - #(> F - #- K- ^-(#K - K #= F K(

$'$ '(( )%+ '(( *+* '(( +)* '(( )& '(( )( '((

# - . / 0 12 3

(20)

=

# "

8 J # # 5

F # # K (

F # F # - (

F #(> # (

" F #( # ( (

"A F K #(= # = (

3 " 4 F K #( # ( (

: $ ) F K #( # (

1 $ ) F K # # (

F K #(- # (

& -> >#K- A ( #F= A # F # F

5 -> A #-( A(= #F A #=- #=K

! $ F > ># # > K

! $ " F -#> # K

! $ ! K # ( #K= K

' A % F K # - # > (

J F K # # - (

0 F K -#F # F (

' F K # # (

F K -# ( # ( (

F K #= # = -

4

H 3" 4 F K #- #-( (

@! 3 ! 4 F K # K #(=

@ " 3 # 4 F K # > # F (

. $ F # # = (

F # # = (

N ! F # > # K (

' F K # - K (

.. " 5 F K ># #FF # K >-#>F

.. ! " F K #( #( #( #(

.. F K # F #K> # K#>=

(21)

(

# J

!

"" # !

"" # #

#(K # #(K # ( #(> (#K-

# # # - # K # #K

9 " A#(F A(#-> A#(F A(#-> A#(F A(#

"A #( A(# - #( A(# K #(- A(# (

3 " 4 #(- A(# #(K A(#> #( A(# >

: $ ) #(F A(#K- #(= A(#FK A#(> A(#

1 $ ) A#(F A(#=( A#(= A # ( A# ( A # F

# K #= # K #=F # - #

& # > ># # # =

5 A#(- A #KF A#( A #F

! $ #(( (# K #( (# - #( (# =

! $ " #( #K= #( # #( #>K

! $ ! #( #K> #( #-F #( # (

' A % # - #- # > #>- # #K

J #( (#- #( (# - #( (#>(

0 A#( A(#-> A#( A(#KF #( A(#K

' #(( (# F #( (#-> #( #

#( (#KK #( (#F- #(( (#K=

A#( A(# A#( A(# #(( A(#

5 "

H 3" 4 #(( (#(= #( (# F #( (#=-

@! #(> #> #(K #= #(K #

@ " 3 # 4 #(F #> #(F #> #(> ># K

. $ #(F # #(= # ( # ( #K(

#( (#> #( (#-( #(- (#>

' #(( (#(( A#( A(# = #( A(#-

.. " 5 A#(( A(# = A#(( A(# (

.. ! " #-F (#-K # (# F

.. #( (#F #( (#F

J - ( - K - -

' 1 (#(= (#(= (# (

6 (F# ( #=- #=

' X (#(( (#(( (#((

J ! * U "A ! ! U N !

(22)

-# 2 "" " "

"A

2 "" Y K#-M Y # M Y >#=M Y # M Y # M Y - # M

"" "

" $ )

! ""

A

# - 3 # K4

# 3 #K 4

# = 3 # =4

# F 3 #FK4

# 3 #K 4

# K 3 #(-4

References

@ @# @# + N# 3 =K 4# B' & " 2 J ! + #C

6 1.Z&& - 3 4 KKKAK=-#

@ @# # # 3 ( 4# H $ ' !

2 * & : N # '1@ ' 9 # ( >#

@ @# # # 3 ( 4# * 2

N ! H $ ! # 7 8 9 ! F

3 4 F( AF #

@ $ L# 3 =K 4# H " 5 ! 3 4 ? > #

7 6# 2 ,# # , # 2# # 2# 3 == 4# . A ! 2

' 9 2 & * 2 # : ;

6 6 1" )$" ( A F#

7 .# 2 # #2# 3 ( 4# ' $ ! #

8 " J& (# ((KT FKA( A= A #

7 A9 @# , #2# ==-# $ * @

" $ ) : 6 " # # - A- #

7 A9 @# 1 # ' # 3 ( 4# @ 2 " 6 ! . 6 !

& % N & ## < = ( 3 4 >(FA

> #

7 ,# ( (# 4 - 4 " #

7 ! ) * ' ! #

7 ,# '# , # 2# ' .# 3 == 4# " '

2 * 6 $ 7 ; " >>>: . 3"

=(A (#

(23)

7 + ! 2# # 3 ((>4# 6 ) 0 " A

" ## 4 < = -3 4* -A F#

7 + ! 2# # 2# 3 ( (4 " # @ & $ )

* .# 7 2# 7 + ! 3 4 6 ?

. :#L#* 1 ! * -A #

7 G H# 3 ( 4# $ ) D "" " " : ! # :

" " 6 ) ! ' 9# > #

7 G H# @# 3 ((=4# 9 $ $ ! $ )

$ " #7 K - K?- #

2 ,# @# H# ) .# # 3 (( 4# 2 2

@ : #7 8 @ 9 ! -- - A-- #

2 ! 7# S ' ,# 3 == 4 7 " 6 ) 2 * ' $ 2 "

' " 9 $ # 6 1" &%" (F A (-#

2 ! 7# S ' ,# 3 == 4 ' " " J 5 " *

2 6 ) 2 #7 " '(%"K FA #

! @ H# 3 ((=4# & # 5 8 2

A 0 > 3 4 # -=A K(#

! @ H# ' # 3 ( 4# "" "

* # <

= " ( ->>A-F #

! @ H# .# 3 ((=4 @ " $

* " # !

1# 3 4 A 1 5 # & 2

H $ ! #

$ H# L# 3 (( 4 B - 1 0 C " 2 ! *

2 ! : ' #

# 3 ( 4#8 D 1 0 ". * 7 N #

# 3 ( 4# $ # ' $ ) * 2

' N # ! * (F #

# 3 ((=4# J 7 ! " # 7

K3 A 4 -A >>#

7# 3 ( (4# - 6 8 8 # ' #

(24)

# H ! # 3 ( 4# 2 *

" H +) ' 7 % 2 # ' $ ) *

2 ' N # ! * (F #

7# , ! 1# 3 (( 4# 2 $ ! #7 -3-4 -F=A

> #

) # 3 ==-4# - < # 9 $ I )*

' #

H .# + '# / ! .# 3 ((F4# ! ) ) # 7 > 3>4

--KA >((#

H .# + '# / ! .# 3 ((=4# 2 7 5 ! =

7 3 4 (=-A #

N N# 3 ==>4 91 N @* N : # ' #

& 3 ( (4# ! # 1 * & #

, # 2# ) ! 6# N# 3 =K>4# " * ! 7 @! 2

J$ #7 "J =K> 8# 9 # # (-A

>(#

L $ &# L 7# '# . L# ' $A # 3 ==K4#

% # 7 D FK 3=4 = A =F#

L ) # 3 (( 4# @ . " ' " # & N $ ,# 3 4#

D B 1 ? 48 -

: 6 # [ * N 1 2 # (( #

L ) # L " '# 3 ==K4# 2 N @ ' "" @ 2 2

& ! #= 7 3 4 - A FF#

. @# # # 1# 3 =FF4# 7 # 9 $ I )* ' #

! .# 1 !! # 1 ++ # 3 ( 4# N $ : 0 \ @ 5 & ! "

D @! D & # &/@ ' 9 # > - #

@# # 3 ((=4# ' $ )# 6 1"==* ? -#

,# ,# 8 L 0 @#,# S N 6#,# 3 (( 4# ' 2 @ $

! " " # & # L 3 #4

! ) " % ! " # . * ! #

,# # 3 F F4# # . * . ! H 2 #

+ ) N# 9 N# =F # & " 8 7 #

# -=A K(#

(25)

@# ' ) L# $) # 3 ((F4# & % @ "

' ' * #7 ; " > 3 4 >= AK (#

9 # 3 ==(4# : " : # 2 ! *

2 ! : ' #

J # 3 => 4# 1 H $ + ! #7 D 3 4 - =A

-- #

J # 3 =F 4# 6 5 # - B 1 " "

6 # 9 $ N * I : ' #

' ,# ( # " " % !# : " 2 "

. @ ! 2 1A K( J # 1

- ( * *TT" # # # T T ] T K(# "

' 8# 3 ( 4# H 0 # ' " *

2 " $ # 8 * 1&2 3 1 &

2 4* -A > #

' ) "" '# # ' ) "" 9# '# L + # 7# 3 (( 4# 2 7

7 1 * @ 2 1 $ " . 1 1 #7

"FF 3-4* FK=?=( #

' 1# # 3 == 4# 0 1 0- : # ' *

' : ' #

' 1# # 3 (((4#8 1 6 # 9 $

I )* S #

# 3 ((F4# 2 [ " #A 0 > 3 4 >>A

@# 3 K-=4# # . * @# #

! + ,# 3 ((=4# ! ) " #

F( 3 4 -A >(#

)) L 6# 3 ((=4# $ ! #

7 " 3 4* F>A ==#

,# 6# 6 ) .# 3 =K-4# - # N 9#,#

9 $ I )* @ #

#2# 3 ((F4# 6 ) 6 A7 ! ' * A7 ! " &

7 4 " K 3-4 # (F(A (= #

(26)

-

: "" 9# 3 ===4# : ! 2 * . ! " @ 5 "

' # & ! '# S ! &# 3 #4 -

# 6 ! #2#* 6 7 )#

8 8# 3 ((K4# 6 ! @ ! +

#7 : * --A>=#

6 ! # 3 = 4# " "" # "- > A -#

I # 3 ( 4# " ! !A " !

, # 6 1 (3 4 F(A F=#

I # 3 ( 4# H " * J '

, #: 7 =3>4 A =#

/ ) '# L ) # 3 (( 4# H $ # 7 3 K(4 =-A #

(27)

>

Appendix A - Categorical Principal Components Analysis and Factor Analysis

2 !

Model Summary 8

@

2 W

@ 3 ! 4

#KF= # -(

# -K # >

#F= #F

# 2 W @

! #

Correlations Transformed Variables

8 (] 8 (] 8 (] 8 (] 8 (]- 8 (]> 8 (]K 8 (]F 8 (]=

8 (] #((( # ( # ( # - # =F #(=( # K #( - #( =

8 (] # ( #((( # -F # (= # > #(F( # (= #( K # -F

8 (] # ( # -F #((( # F( # -= # K # F # - # -

8 (] # - # (= # F( #((( # # F # # FF #

8 (]- # =F # > # -= # #((( # ( # =- # - # F>

8 (]> #(=( #(F( # K # F # ( #((( # > # #-

8 (]K # K # (= # F # # =- # > #((( # F # (-

8 (]F #( - #( K # - # FF # - # # F #((( # -F

8 (]= #( = # -F # - # # F> #- # (- # -F #(((

- > K F =

! # > # #F( #K - #>F( #>( #-- #-(= #

# ! $ $ " % "

(28)

K

Component Loadings

8 (] # F= #>FF

8 (] # F #->

8 (] #- > # ->

8 (] #-= # (=

8 (]- #K - A#(=

8 (]> #K(K A# K>

8 (]K #K(- A#( F

8 (]F #>K- A# ->

8 (]= #>>= A# K=

8 ' 9 + #

Communalities

& 5

8 (] [ " # # >

8 (] [ " # ( # K

8 (] [ " # > # --

8 (] [ " # # F

8 (]- [ " # ( # K(

8 (]> [ " # #--

8 (]K [ " # K # ((

8 (]F [ " # (= # =F

8 (]= [ " # - # =>

5 * ' @5 !#

(29)

F

Total Variance Explained

& !

5 " %

. !

1 " %

. !

M "

8

2 M

M "

8

2 M

M "

8

2 M

# - F# K F# K #F=K # F # F # >F ># ( ># (

# > ># ( - #>( #FK =#K - #F== # ( -#-F= #F==

#K> F# > > #(>

#K( K#F > K(#FK=

- #>> K# ( KF# =

> #->F ># - F #-

K #- F -#=F =(#- -

F # K -# -( =-#K>-

= # F # - ((#(((

5 * ' @5 !#

(30)

=

Rotated Factor Matrix^a

8 (] [ " #>>F

8 (] [ " #-

8 (] [ " #--

8 (] [ " # >( # =

8 (]- [ " #>(K # F

8 (]> [ " #K F

8 (]K [ " #- K #

8 (]F [ " #>=F

8 (]= [ " #K((

5 * ' @5 !#

1 * 8 5 $ L 9 + #

# 1 ! #