• Keine Ergebnisse gefunden

Trade and Wage Inequality in Developing Countries: South-South Trade Matters

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Aktie "Trade and Wage Inequality in Developing Countries: South-South Trade Matters"

Copied!
56
0
0

Wird geladen.... (Jetzt Volltext ansehen)

Volltext

(1)

Munich Personal RePEc Archive

Trade and Wage Inequality in Developing Countries: South-South Trade Matters

Gourdon, Julien

CERDI

March 2007

Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/4824/

MPRA Paper No. 4824, posted 12 Sep 2007 UTC

(2)

! ! "

#

$

! "# $ ! "% & %$ "$'( ) * +($

+$ # ,$! , $ +$-$) ,$" +$ $) "! " +$

& # "# $ !$! & %$ "$'( ) * " , ++)$ "# ,$ +$-$) "% # (" $!.

$ % +$ )$ +! , $

$# " ) % # ) # "%$ / !$+ & + !0 )) " $"! -$ !$# . ! "# $ !$!

& %$ "$'( ) * )) +$-$) "% # (" $!. ! "+ $# $ $# ! , $ , " " ) & "# ,$ # (" $!.

&'( ) *+" &," -,

. ) / " $ / "

(3)

0

$ $) "! /$ &$$" +$ ) /$ ) 1 " "+ "$'( ) * !

$#$ -$+ # "! +$ /)$ $" " " $#$" *$ !. " $% " & & )+

, 0$ ! /$ ! $ , !$ ! $ * " +$-$) "% # (" $!.

"#$ " "% "$'( ) * $ $+ # "! /* $# " , ! ! & ()+ /$ ) &$

! "+ "! " # ! ! ! ()+ (! $ # # (" * ! $# ) 1$ "

$ +(# " $ % +! & # ! # , -$ +- " %$.

"#$ ("!0 ))$+ ) / ! $ /("+ " # " $ +$-$) "% & )+ "+

!0 ))$+ ) / $ /("+ " # " $ +$-$) $+ & )+2 %) / ) 1 "

! ()+ $ $ $ /$ !! # $+ & " "# $ !$ " $ $) -$ +$, "+

("!0 ))$+ ) / " # (" $!2 $ $/* $!() "% " $+(# " " & %$

"$'( ) *. &$-$ 2 $, # ) $- +$"#$ + $! " !( ! $3 $# $+

$!() . (+ $! " "# ,$ + ! /( " + " "+ #)$ #( $!() ! "+

! (+ $! " & %$! "+ , ")* " "# $ ! "% & %$ "$'( ) * +( "% +$

) /$ ) 1 " 4 $" " " ,$ # " # (" $!5. 6 #$+ & ! ("$3 $# $+ $!() !$-$ ) ! (+ $! - +$ $3 ) " "! # "#$ " "% & %$

"$'( ) $! +( "% +$ ) /$ ) 1 " 4 )+/$ % "+ -" #0 78895. $ , " $3 ) " " (!$+ ! $ !0 ))$+ / !$+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$

"# $+ " +$ ) /$ ) 1 " & # - ! $ & %$ !0 ))$+

& 0$ ! " "+ ( # (" $!.

" ! $ 2 !$ " $ $3 ) " " $ + $# " +$.

+$-$) "% # (" * , % +$ & " $ +$-$) "% # (" *.

$"#$ $ , # " & %$ "$'( ) * " ! # !$ , * " # $! "+ $

#) !! # ) ) $ ,($)! " $!() . $"2 0 "% " ## (" ( ( 4 5 +$2 &$ # ,$ / #0 $ $ $# !0 )) / !$+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$

" # "! +$ "% !$# / !$+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$ $ " # / !$+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$.

(4)

, ( !( "% ! $ ! " "%2 %) / ) 1 " " ")* )$ +! "# $ ! "%

( 4 5 +$2 /( $ + $# " "+ # , ! " +$ !

)! # "%$+. $ +$ ! # $+ ( /$ &$$" +$-$) "% # (" $!2 "+

, $ +$-$) "% # (" $! $ " & $3 "% , "( # ( $!. "+$$+ ( ( +$ " & ## (" ! ("+ & ! )) +$-$) "% # (" * ,$ # "+ !$ +$ "+ ("+ :7 $ #$" %) / ) ,$ # "+ !$ +$.

+$ ) /$ ) 1 " ! ("+$ ""$+ ! +$-$) ,$" 2 & -$ %$

)$-$)! ("+ "$ + $ :;< )$-$)!. ! +$-$) "% # (" * , 0$ ! /$# ,$ , $ , " $ +$-$) "% # (" $!2 "+ ( ( $ +$

) /$ ) 1 " & )) , ")* # "#$ " ( ( +$:2 &$ "$$+ $3 , "$

#) !$)* $ +$ ) # $! "+ $ , # " "$'( ) *7.

6 ! 2 " ## (" "% $ $ %$"$ * " $ ( &$ , % + !# -$ ( $ , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $! $ $ = $ "> # (" $!

, "% +$-$) "% # (" $! "+ ! ( ( +$ & )) "# $ !$ & %$

"$'( ) * " !$ , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $!. " ! # !$2 $ $# ! $ ")*

"! ! " #) !! # ) ( +$ $ *.

$# "+2 +$ ) /$ ) 1 " & $ " ( $ " # (" $!

# ()+ )! / "% "$'( ) * , "% & 0$ ! !$ & -$ $ !0 ))!

"$$+$+ +?(! $ "$& $# " ) % $! /$"$ $+ , "# $ !$+

$# " , # " $% " & )$ $ $ ! &$ $ )$ /$ "+. $ $ $ '($! "

! & ) "0 +$ ) /$ ) 1 "2 $# " ) % # ) # "%$ "+ & %$

"$'( ) *. $-$ ) ! (+ $! ) "0 $,2 (! "% !0 )) / !$+ $# " ) % # )

# "%$. &$-$ 2 !0$) "+ ) (% $ 478875 ! &$+ $#$" )* 2

+/ 12

03 " "

" 4

% 5 64/!

+787

(5)

9

# "#$ " "% $ "+ @2 & ! $ !$# / !$+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$

"+ " $ !0 )) / !$+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$ & # , $ ! $3 ) "

& %$ "$'( ) *. 0 "% ! $ ! $# -$2 &$ $3 ) $ +$ "# $ !$!

, $ 6 " !0 )) " $"! -$ !$# ! " " ("!0 )) " $"! -$ !$# !

# , -$)* +$.

"#$ " "% "$'( ) * &$ ")* #(! " & %$ "$'( ) * & # !

#) !$! $ $+ # "! ) $ ,($)! ". ! $- (! ! (+ $! "

& %$ "$'( ) * # "#$ "$+ ")* # (" * # !$ ! (+ $! 4, ")* "

,$ # " # (" $!5 /$# (!$ $ ) #0 # , /)$ & %$ + # !!

# (" $!. &$-$ +$-$) "% # (" $! $ $ $ %$"$ (! "+ ! + #() / " %) / ) $!() ! , # (" * # !$ ! (+ $!. (+ $! "

"$)! +$-$) "% # (" $! (!$+ " # $ # $" ! & # ,$ !( $ "$'( ) * " "# ,$ "+ ! "#)(+$ $ $-$"($ , # ) "+ " ( )

$! ( #$!. $#$" )* &$ -$ + ##$!! , %$"$ (! + !$ " " $ "+(! * & %$ "$'( ) *. $ $ &$ +$ ) & & %$ "$'( ) * # !!

"+(! $! "+ " /$ &$$" & 0$ ! ! (!( ) " $ ) $ ( $ " & %$

"$'( ) *.

$ $# !$)*2 $ , * ( !$ ! $ ! $!$" "$&

$!() ! " $ ! ( #$! & %$ "$'( ) $! " , "( # ( "% 0 "% "

## (" ( ( +$. $ (!$ & +$ !2 $ ! "$ ,$ !( $!

+$ ) /$ ) 1 " & +$-$) $+ # (" $! "+ $ !$# "+ "$ ,$ !( $!

+$ ) /$ ) 1 " & +$-$) "% # (" $! . " "#)(+ "% $,

!(##$!! -$)* "+ %$ $ " " $! , " & %$ "$'( ) *2 &$ /!$ -$

"# $ ! "% & %$ "$'( ) * ! , $ +($ $ ( ( +$

) /$ ) 1 " " $ #) !! # ) +$ ) /$ ) 1 " & " $ "

# (" $!. " #)(! $ "% ( ! , )$ +$-$) "% # (" $! ## + "%

, / %

(6)

:

$ "# ,$ &$ # " /!$ -$ ! $ $# ! , $ , " " , ++)$

"# ,$ # (" $! ! "#$ " +$ $ # , -$ +- " %$ , ++)$

"# ,$ # (" $! ! $+ % +! " $ ,$+ $!0 )) " $"! *.

$ !$# "+ ( !$ ! $)(# + $ $ ) "0 /$ &$$" $ + $# " +$

"+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$2 %( "% , % $3 ) " & * &$ / "

+ $ $" $!() ! ( ( +$ "+ ( +$ " & %$

"$'( ) *. (+ $! ) "0 +$ ) /$ ) 1 " "+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$

!!(,$ "# $ ! "% , ! , # "$! -$ "# $ !$+ & %$

"$'( ) * " +$-$) "% # (" $! /* " +(# "% !0 )) / !$+ $# " ) % # )

# "%$ 4 A 5. $# -$)* (! "% $!$ , # "$! $'( $! !0 ))$+ & 0$ !

"+ "# $ !$! $ $) -$ +$, "+ !0 ))$+ & 0$ ! $ -$ # ()+

"# $ !$ $ +(# - * "+ $ $,("$ " !$ !0 ))$+ & 0$ !.

&$-$ 2 !0$) "+ ) (% $ 478875 +$, "! $ " , "* # !$! !

$ !$# / ! A +$ $ , "$! A B $ $# " $) -$ #

#$!2 " ! # / !. ! "% 4 )) "%5 !0 )) $, $ # (!$+ /* A ! # "#$" $+ " !0 )) " $"! -$ 4("!0 )) " $"! -$5 !$# !. $"#$ &$

/!$ -$ " +$-$) "% # (" $!2 +$ "# $ !$! , $ 6 " !0 )) " $"! -$ !$# ! " " ("!0 )) " $"! -$ !$# ! # , -$)*

+$. ! # ()+ $3 ) " & * +$ "# $ !$! & %$ "$'( ) * " )) +$-$) "% # (" $! "+ " ")* " , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $!.

" # $ ( $!() !2 &$ /!$ -$ ! "# $ ! "% ! $ +$

"# $ !$! & %$ "$'( ) * )) +$-$) "% # (" $!. $# "+ ! "# $ ! "% & %$ "$'( ) * +($ +$ # ,$! , $ +$-$) ,$"

+$ $) "! " +$ & # "# $ !$! & %$ "$'( ) * "

, ++)$ "# ,$ +$-$) "% # (" $!. +2 $ # +$ )$ +!

, $ $# " ) % # ) # "%$ / !$+ & + !0 )) " $"! -$ !$# "# $ !$

& %$ "$'( ) * )) +$-$) "% # (" $!. 6 ( 2 ! "+ $# $ $# ! , $ , " " ) & "# ,$ # (" $!.

(7)

;

$ $, "+$ $ # $ ! % " 1$+ ! )) &!. $# " 7

$!$" ! ) $ ( $ $- $& " +$ ) /$ ) 1 " "+ & %$ "$'( ) * "

+$-$) "% # (" $!. $# " $!$" ! ( # ! $ .

$# " 9 $!$" ! $ +$!# -$ ! ! #! " )) ! $# ! +$ "+

+$ " ( + / !$ & # # "#$ "! C< +$-$) "% # (" $! :;DC 7888 7D , "( # ( "% "+(! $! "+ & # ! / !$+ " # "+

) $ %% 4788C5. $# " E $!$" ! $ $!() ! # "#$ " "% ( !!(, "

" $ , # +$ "+ +$ " & %$ "$'( ) $! & "

$! , "+ ! ,$ /(! "$!! # $#0. $# " C $!$" ! $ $!() ! &

!*! $, $! , . $# " D # "#)(+$!.

$ # (# ) $ ( $ $ =! "+ +> $ * 4 .$. # $"+ &,$" / !$+

$ *5 " $ +$ $ , " " ! & %$ "$'( ) * ! $ # $! "+$"#$

/$ &$$" +(# #$! "+ # #$!. ! , ) $! " "# $ !$ "

$ $) -$ #$ % + $!() ! " " "# $ !$ " $ $) -$ $ ( " $

# (!$+ " $"! -$)* +(#$ % +. " $3 $"! " $ / -$

" )*! ! # "! +$ ! # )2 !0 ))$+ "+ ("!0 ))$+ ) / ( ! $ $)$- "

# ! +(# ". $"#$ ("!0 ))$+ ) / ! $ /("+ " # " $ ( 2 $ $+ # " $ $ * ! $ $ ( "! ("!0 ))$+ ) / (

! ()+ "# $ !$ )) & "% +$ ) /$ ) ! ".

$ $3 $ $"#$ $ ! ! " "$&)* "+(! ) !$+ $# " , $! & !

$+(# " " & %$ "$'( ) * $ $""$!! & ! " +(#$+ " $ :;C8!

"+ :;D8!. ! & ! $ $ $ # "! ! $" & =! "+ +> +$ $ *

(8)

1

& # $+ # ! +$ ) /$ ) ! " ! ()+ /$"$ $ ) # ))* /("+ "

# 4 +2 :;;92 :;;D5. &$-$ 2 $ %$"$ ) * ! , ! #

( # ,$ ! /$$" # ))$"%$+ /* "(,/$ ! (+ $! # (" $!

$"$+ ( +$ , $ $#$" )*2 , ! )* " ,$ # 4!$$ !(,, *

$!() ! " /)$! : "+ :/5.

// "! 4:;;C52 $3 , )$2 $3 , "$! $ # "%$! " $ ! (# ( $

& %$! $ +$ ) /$ ) ! " " )$ "+ "+! 2 ) (% $ # " $"

!0 ))$+ ) / ( " , ! $3#$$+! $ # " $" " $3 !2 $ $ ( "!

!0 ))$+ ) / ( % $& )) & "% ) /$ ) ! ". %% "+ $)/ (, 4:;;C5 "+ $ "# $ !$ " $ $ ( "! $+(# " " $3 # # " /( $+

$ !$ $) -$ & %$! !0 ))$+ & 0$ ! "+ ! $ $# ! % $! "

+$+ !$# !. 6$$"! "+ "! " 4:;;D5 ! & $ ,$ # "

F, '( ) + !B " $ " $3 # # (!$+ ! %" # " "# $ !$ " $

$) -$ +$, "+ !0 ))$+ & 0$ ! " $ / +$ $% " & $ . // "! "+ "+) "% 4:;;;5 "-$! % $ $ # "%$! " $) -$ & %$! "+

" $ !( )* "+ +$, "+ !0 ))$+ ) / ( " ! # /$ $ "+ $

+$ ) /$ ) ! ". $* "+ $ !0 )) $, (, !$ $

) /$ ) ! " ! $!() # "%$! " $ ! (# ( $ ) / ( +$, "+.

A$*$ "+ ). 4:;;;5 (!$ ,$ !$ $! # "+ "+ ) "% $ ,

# $) " /$ &$$" $""$!! "+ & %$ "$'( ) * " )$. "! " "+

! " 4:;;;5 $3 , "$ $ # "%$! " / & %$! "+ $, ) *,$"

!0 ))$+ "+ ("!0 ))$+ & 0$ ! $ +$ ) /$ ) ! " " $3 # . $* "+

) )$ - " " $, ) *,$" )$-$)!2 /( ! %" # " "# $ !$ " !0 ))$+

& 0$ !B $) -$ & %$!. $* )! ! & $ %" # , " $! "+ !$

$ - )* "- )-$+ " $3 , 0$ ! * % $ & %$! !0 ))$+ ) / ( . 6 " ))*2 A 1 )2 $$" "+ ). 4788:5 "+ " "# $ !$ " $ $ ( "!

# ))$%$ $+(# " )) & "% +$ ) /$ ) ! ". &$-$ 2 # " *

! (+ $! $ +$-$) "% # (" $!2 $ $ & ! " $" # "%$ "

-$ )) & %$ "$'( ) *. $#$" )*2 ) " "+ "%( "$ 4788 5 "+

(9)

8 , $"$ " $3 ) "! !, )) & %$ $, (, " %$" "

"+ ) " - # "+ '( $ 4788E5 "+ +$# $ ! "% ! "# $ !$

"$'( ) * / " " $ "+(! * & %$! "+ " $ ##( " & %$! "

+$-$) "% # (" $!.

(!2 $ $- +$"#$ " +$ ) /$ ) ! "! & # -$ /$$" , )$,$" $+

" $ ) ! & +$# +$! 4, ")*2 /( " $3#)(! -$)*2 " ,$ # 52

!(%%$! ! ! -$ $) "! /$ &$$" +$ ) /$ ) ! " "+ & %$

"$'( ) *. ! "+ "% ! #)$ )* # " * $ $+ # "! $ + " ) $ * " $ " " ) +$.

6 ! ( ! -$ ## (" $+ $ $ %$"$ * , "% +$-$) "%

# (" $! " (, " # )2 %( "% ! ,$ +$-$) "% # (" $! + + "

$!$" # , -$ +- " %$ " ("!0 ))$+ ) / . (!2 $3 ) " $ + $ $"#$ ) /$ ) 1 " " & %$ "$'( ) * /$ &$$" " ,$ # " "+

! " # (" $!2 + 4:;;D5 !(%%$! ! $ , "% +$ ) #*

$ , ! , " /* , 0 "% ! " & $" " ,$ # " # (" $!

) /$ ) 1$+2 $* &$ $ " ) "%$ ("!0 ))$+ ) / /("+ " 2 /$# (!$ "+

"+ " + ) $ +* ##$!!$+ " $ " " ) , 0$ !. (! # " *

! ! " # (" $! & # ) /$ ) 1$+ $ ) $ 2 ,$ & $" $* &$ $ ("!0 ))$+ ) / /("+ " 2 " ,$ # " # (" $! &$ $ " $) -$)*

/("+ " " ("!0 ))$+ ) / .

" $ ! ,$ -$ "2 - ! 4:;;C5 $!$" ! , +$) " & # $ #$" )

* $! ! ! $ - ) / ) * # (" *B! # ! +(# "

! ()+ /$ !!$!!$+ " $) " % ( # (" $! & ! , )

$"+ &,$" !2 $ " " $) " $ & +$ " $ " " ) $# " ,*.

(!2 $ - ) / ) * # ! ! ()+ /$ # "! +$ $+ , $) -$2 "+

(10)

7

" , " /! )( $2 $ ! $# -$. , $ ! " $ , +$) ! $ $) -$

! " $ # (" * , "%! $ # (" $! & " ! &" # "$

+ -$ ! # ". # # "$ # , !$! # (" $! & ! , ) 2 (% "

+$" # )2 # $"+ &,$" !. ! % -$! $ # # (" * + $ $"

# , -$ +- " %$ "! +$ ! # "$2 )$ + "% ! $# ) ! "

+(# ". " ! ,$& 02 +$ ) /$ ) ! " # " !$ $ +$, "+

!0 ))$+ ) / ( " +$-$) "% # (" * ! ) "% ! , "% $ # (" $! !

# "$2 ! $) -$)* % !( )* !0 ))$+ ) / .

$-$ ) ! (+ $! " & %$ " " ,$ # 4 ! " "+ "! " :;;;5 "+

("!0 ))$+ ) / " $"! -$ !$# ! &$ $ $# $+ & $ % $! ! +$ $ ,. !$ "+(! $! $3 $ $"#$+ $ ) %$!

$+(# "! +( "% +$ $ ,. ! (11) "% # ! &! = $ "# $ !$

" $ !0 )) $, (,> ! $3 # )* & )$ ,($)! " $+ # ! ! "#$

+$ ) /$ ) 1 " & ! # "#$" $+ " ("!0 ))$+ ) / " $"! -$ !$# !2

"+ ! $ $# " ,* & +$ $ ( " ("!0 ))$+ ) / ! ()+ +$# $ !$.

! "

$# "+2 +$ ) /$ ) 1 " /$"$ ! $ ("!0 ))$+ ) / " $"! -$

"+(! * " +$-$) "% # (" $! /( )$ +! )! $ ! "+(! *

# - $! " $"! -$ " ("!0 ))$+ ) / ( , $ ( & #

# ()+ "# $ !$ "$'( ) $! 4" /)* (% 6 5. & $ $# ! # ()+

"# $ !$ $) -$)* +$, "+ !0 ))$+ ) / " +$-$) "% # (" $! +( "%

+$ ) /$ ) 1 " $ "+(! * $ $# "+ $ ##( " $ $# .

$ "+(! * $ $# +$ )! & $ ! !0 )) " $"! -$

" $ ,$+ $ % +! +(# " , +$-$) $+ +$-$) "% # (" $!.

$ +$ ! $ ) & 6 # "%$! $ ! (# ( $ +(# " "+

"# $ !$! $ ! #0 # ) +$-$) "% # (" $!. 6$$"! "+ "! "

(11)

+2 4:;;C5 +$-$) , +$) & # !!(,$! $ +(# " ! , )$ " )

% + $'( $! " $ ,$+ $ % +! & - * "%

"! !0 ))$+ "+ ("!0 ))$+ ) / . $ , +$) !(%%$! ! $

! %$! +(# " & # +$, "+ )$!! !0 ))$+ ) / ( 4/* $ ,$ !( $

$ +- "#$+ # (" *5 & )) /$ "! $ $+ $ )$!! +$-$) $+ # (" $!

& $ $ ("!0 ))$+ ) / ! $) -$)* # $ $ . &$-$ 2 $ 0 "+ ) / ! # ( ))* +$, "+$+ ! !0 ))$+ & $" ?(+%$+ , $ $ ! $# -$ $ +$-$) "% # (" $!.

$ ##( " $ $# +$ )! & $ # $ + #$

# "%$ " $ $# " ,* "# $ !$+ $ +$, "+ "+ - +( )! # ()+

$" # # "%$ , " %$ ! "+ $!! " )!2 & $-$ $ "+(! *. %%

"+ $)/ (,B! & 0 4:;;C5 " $3 # $ ! $ ##( " $ $#

!$$,! , $ $)$- " " $ "+(! * $ $# $3 ) " & %$ "$'( ) *.

# $ %

+)*2 $ , " ) $ " -$ $3 ) " " +$, "+ ! ! ! $ "#)(! "

$# " ) % # ) # "%$ & # # , ) # $! !$ (!)* $ $+ # ". $ "#)(! " + $ $"#$! " $# " ) %* " $ & %$ ) $ ( $ +$ )! &

/ !$+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$. " ++ " ) $ $# +$ ) /$ ) ! " ! + " ) & $ %" $# " ) %* ! $!() / 6 "+ "# $ !$+

, !. ! + $ $" $#$" , +$)! ! &2 !0 )) / !$+ $# " ) % # )

# "%$ # " /$ "+ $# )* "+ )* "+(#$+ /* +$ ) #* G!$$

$3 , )$2 $" % H $ + $ 4788 52 #$, %)( 4788 5 % " $ ).

4788 5I.

) %$ $ ) $ ( $ %($! +$ ) /$ ) 1 " # "

"# $ !$ & %$ "$'( ) $! - $ , , # "$!. ( ! %($

!$ , ! "# $ !$ $ +$, "+ !0 ))$+ ) / (!$ & $!$

, # "$! "+ , -$ $ +(# - * !0 ))$+ & 0$ ! "#)(+$!

(12)

++

!0 )) / !$+ $# " # ) # "%$ 4 ! " "! " :;;;2 "+) "% // "!

788:2 " ! "+ ). 78895.

! " "+ "! " 4:;;;5 "+ $ +$ $ , + + ) * /(

$ # ! "#)(+ "% $ %" + $# "-$! ,$" 2 $3 $" "2

"+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$ &$ $ )! , " . A$*$ 2 ? ! "+ $ % 4:;;;5 "+ ! , ) $ $# +$ $ , " & %$ "$'( ) * " )$

/$# (!$ !0 )) " $"! -$2 $! ( #$ / !$+ "+(! $! $3 "+$+ )) & "%

) /$ ) 1 ". / # $2 #0$ ! " "+ $$" 4788:5 "+ )) & "% $

$3 $"! -$ +$ ) /$ ) 1 " " A 1 ) " $ :;;8!2 -$ %$ & %$ " $ +$+ !$# $)) # , $+ $ " " +$+ !$# 4$-$" $ +?(! "%

$+(# "2 $3 $ $"#$ $ #.52 "+ $ ")* # $% * & ! ! $+

+$#) "$ &$ $ $ % )* $+(# $+ /$# (!$ $ $ ( "! $+(# " &$" ( .

$* %($ $!$ $!() ! $ # "! ! $" & $ $ ! " $" ! " $ +$+ !$# " $ & 0$ $" "% ( 2 "+ # , )$,$" * /$ &$$"

"$& $# " ) % $! / (% " /* %) / ) 1 " "+ !0 ))$+ ) / .

& ' (

6 ( 2 & )$ , ! & 0 ! #(!$+ " $" ) $3 ) " "! $ "# $ ! "% "$'( ) * /$ &$$" !0 ))$+ "+ ("!0 ))$+ & 0$ !2 $ !0 ))

$, (, ) "$ # "" ())* $3 ) " $ "# $ !$ " "$'( ) * "

+$-$) "% # (" $!. $-$ ) ! (+ $! # "! +$ "+(! * & %$ $, (,! !

" ) $ " -$ # ""$) (% & # +$ ) /$ ) 1 " , * -$

# " /( $+ & %$ "$'( ) *. "+(! * & %$ $, (,! $ $ $

& 0$ & %$! # "" /$ $3 ) "$+ /* /!$ - /)$ & 0$

# # $ ! #! !(# ! %$"+$ 2 %$2 $+(# "2 $3 $ $"#$2 $ #.2 /( # " /$

/( $+ & 0$ !B "+(! * ) ".

+$ ) /$ ) 1 " "+(#$+ # "%$! " "+(! * & %$ $, (,! # ()+

# " /( $ "# $ !$! " $ & %$ "$'( ) * /$ &$$" !0 ))$+ "+

(13)

+0 ("!0 ))$+ & 0$ !. +$ ) /$ ) 1 " )$ +! +$#) "$! " "+(! * & %$

$, (,!2 & %$ "$'( ) * /$ &$$" !0 ))$+ "+ ("!0 ))$+ & 0$ ! # ()+

"# $ !$ $ "+(! $! & $ ) %$! #( ! $ $ "$! $, ) * "%

% $ ! $ ("!0 ))$+ & 0$ ! "+ $!$ "+(! $! + $ ) &$!

& %$ $, (,! $ $ ,.

$ $ $- +$"#$ " & $! "! -$ "+(! * & %$ $, (,! $ +$

$ ,! ! , 3$+. ,$ ! (+ $! "+ " !! # " /$ &$$" ! "+

"+(! * & %$ $, (,! 46$) # " 4788:5 $3 # 2 -#" 02 A) ,2 )+/$ %2 "+ # +* 478895 A 1 )52 & )$ $ ! "+ ! -$

!! # " /$ &$$" +$#) "$! "+ "+(! * & %$ $, (,! 4 )+/$ %

"+ -#" 0 478895 ) ,/ 5. 6$) # " 4788:5 $ ! ! -$

!! # " /$ &$$" +$#) "$! " , ) #$"!$! "+ "+(! * & %$

$, (,!. (!2 " ) ,/ "+ $3 # 2 +$ ) /$ ) 1 " , % -$

)$ + "# $ !$+ & %$ "$'( ) * (% $ "+(! * & %$ $, (,

# ""$)2 $! $# ))* ! "#$ #( ! " $!$ # (" $! &$ $ $ ) %$! "

("!0 ))$+ ) / " $"! -$ "+(! $! "+ $ !$# ! & $ ) %$!

#( ! + $ ) &$! & %$ $, (,! $ $ , 4 " ! 2

)+/$ % "+ -#" 0 4788955.

)

& ! "+ "% $ ! (+ $! $- $&$+ / -$2 $ $ $, " , "

'($! "! ! & $ # "?$# ( $ +$ ) /$ ) ! " , * $" "#$

!0 )) +$, "+! # " /$ %$"$ ) !$+ )) +$-$) "% # (" $!. $# "# ) "%

$!$ $!() ! ! + #() /$# (!$ $* # -$ + $ $" # (" $! "+ ,$

$ +! 4 "+ # ()+ $ $ $ /$ $ )$# "% + $ $" $) "! !5 "+

/$# (!$ $* (!$ + $ $" ! $# # "! "+ - /)$ +$ " "!. !

$ ! , $ + !# "#$ "% ! $ # $ +$! %" $ !( -$*! ,

+$-$) "% # (" $! $" # "%$! , *$ *$ 2 , 0 "% # , ! "!

(14)

+,

# !! *$ ! + #() . "$ # "#)(! " $,$ %$! ! &$ ! ()+ (!$

# !! # (" $! ! (+ $! " +$ (!$ " , %$"$ (! + !$ "+

)) & # (" * # $% 1 " /$ &$$" ) & "+ , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $!

& # , % /$ -$ * , " .

$#$" ! (+ $! (!$ # !! # (" $! + !$ 4 /)$ :/5. J ( "+ $ )$

4788E5 ! &$+ $ $# " ) % # ) # # ( $* ,$ !( $ & ) / +(# - * 4& ( ) "0 "% , !52 + $! " "# $ !$ + $# )* & %$

"$'( ) * /( )) &! +$-$) "% # (" $! /$ ! $# ) 1$+ " , $ !0 )) " $"! -$ +(# ! " $ $3 ! "+ $"#$ "# $ !$ & %$ "$'( ) $!

"+ $# )*9.

)) $ # !! # (" * ! (+ $! (!$2 $ + !$ , 6 $$, " "+ ! $"+

4788:5 & # - +$! & %$ + $ $" ##( "! " $ # "+(! * "+

)) &! ,$ !( $ & %$ "$'( ) * , "% & 0$ ! " $ # "+(! *. $

# -$ %$ " )) ! + ,$"! "!2 &$-$ 2 ! /)$, # "+ %,$" *.

) (% $ $ $ :EC # (" $! " ) " :;< :;;;2 $ # # (" * + $!

" - +$ + 4 ##( " ) & %$!5 $-$ * *$ . $ *$ )* # (" *

# -$ %$ - $! /$ &$$" 9< "+ DC. ##( "! "#)(+$+ )! - * ,

# (" * # (" *. $ -$ % -$" # (" * $-$" & $" + $!

- +$ $ ""( ) + 2 $ ##( " ) # -$ %$ ! " "$#$!! )*

(" , $ # *$ . ! "% $ )* ! + !$ , ) $! !$ (!)*

$+(#$ $ ! , )$ "+ $3#)(+$ !$-$ ) ) & "# ,$ # (" $!.

94 < "

"

= " +771 / "

"

" . +778

"

(15)

+9

$ $#$" ! (+* , ) " - # "+ '( $ 4788E5 (!$ )! " " $ "+(! * & %$ + ! $ ! " + !$ . ! # )) &! (! "% ) %$

! , )$ ! "#$ !$ + $ $ ! $ # ))$# . &$-$ $ , ) # "! $ + $ $" ! "#$ " + "% ! $ & %$ "$'( ) $! $ !$# / !$+ & $ $ !

$* $ !0 )) / !$+ " $ $ ! (+ $!.

! )! " $ $! $3 , "$ $ $3 $" & # +$ ) /$ ) ! " !

# $) $+ " "# $ ! "% & %$ "$'( ) *2 $% + "% $ # ( ( +$ " & ## (" ! ("+ & ! )) +$-$) "% # (" * ,$ # "+ !$ +$. ++ $!! $!$ !!($!2 $ )) & "% !$# " $!$" !

! ,$ "$& $- +$"#$ $% + "% $ , # +$ ) /$ ) ! " " # !$

( ( +$ $) -$ ( +$.

# # 4

%

#

# % +71: +788

6 *>/

#

*>/

*>/

# % +781 +77,

/ ? - %

'

7

+719 +787

$

@

& *

?

"

?

+7;2 +77;

>

( >=

(

# %

$

@ (

/

$

( " *>/

(16)

+:

+789 +772 "

*

*>/

!

"##

? " ? 6

+719 +77:

>

72 @

+2

( 4

(

%

0

!

$ %&

' %( "##

A

+78+ +777

# 6

& /

"

!

"##) 4

+77, +771

>

(

# B4

C B4

/ %

<

* +% & "##)

?

+71; +78;

$

@

? ?

, + "##)

# % +788 +779 +779 0222

@

( =

'

!

* +% & "##-

?

+789 +778

>

72 @

+2 /

(

# C

4 /

(

"

!

* +% & "##.

?

+789 +778

/

( / / (

0 "##.

/

+78, 0222

/

( /

"

(

(17)

+;

# # 4

%

#

1

"##

8, +78, +778

72 @

+2 (

>=

$

"##) +2, +78, +778

>

6

( >=

$ %

*

*>/

!

2( 3 4

"##.

02

+78: +778 9

@

(

%

%

(

"

%

%

/ + %

, "##.

++8 +78, +777 72 +71: +777

/

D /=

/

-$$

(

(

! " #

$ $3 ) $ & $3 $"! "! $) -$ $ $3 ! $"#$ = ( ( >

+$ "+ & %$ "$'( ) * " +$-$) "% # (" $!.

6 ! 2 ! , ) )* + 4:;;D52 &$ %($ ( ( +$ , %

$3 ) " "# $ ! "% & %$ "$'( ) * " , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $! ! $* +

" $!$" # , -$ +- " %$ " ("!0 ))$+ ) / " $"! -$ !$# ! "

! ( ( +$. $ -$ 2 &$ )! $3 $# "# $ ! "% $ ! $

( ( +$ $) -$)* ( +$ # ()+ " # $ !$ & %$

"$'( ) * " ) & "# ,$ # (" $!2 ! "#$ , ! ! ()+ /$ )$!! " $"! -$

" % !0 )) ) / "+ $3 ! , $ " $"! -$ " ) & !0 )) ) / . $ !

&$ -$ (!$ # !! # (" $! + !$ " +$ # $% 1$

(18)

+1

# (" $! ## + "% $ "# ,$. $ # !$ (!$ " " $ "+(! *

& %$ + ! $ ! " + !$ 2 ! " ) " - # "+ '( $ 4788E52 ! &$ +$ ) $

& !$# / !$+ & %$ "$'( ) $!. $ $ # , /)$ & !

# ! "#$2 " #)(! $ "% "+(! $! /* $ " $"! * " !0 )) ) / 2 &$

& )) /!$ -$ & # "$! -$ " "# $ ! "% & %$ $) -$)* $ $

!$# !. $ $3 $# " , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $! & %$ " % !0 )) ) / "+(! $! "# $ !$ , $ +)* & %$! " ) & !0 )) ) / "+(! $!.

! %(,$" ! )! $) $+ $ & %$ "+(! * $, (,

$3 ) " " ,$" "$+ $ ) $ "+ (!$+ " !$-$ ) ! (+ $! " "

,$ # " # (" $! $3 ) " & %$ "$'( ) * 4 )+/$ % "+ -#" 0 4788E5. +$ )$ +! #( "+ "# $ ! "% , " " $ %

!0 )) ) / "+(! $! "+ +$ & )) )$ + , ")* "+

"# $ ! "% , " " $ ) & !0 )) ) / "+(! $! ! # ()+ $3 ) "

& * +$ # ()+ "# $ !$ , $ " $ "+(! * & %$ "$'( ) * "

+$.

$# "+2 &$ $3 ) $ +$ "+ +$ -$ + $ $" , # !

# "#$ " "% !$# / !$+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$. +$ )$ +! , $ "# $ ! "% # , $ " " !0 )) " $"! -$ % +! " +$2 , % / "% $# " ) % # ) # "%$ , $ / !$+ & +! !0 )) " $"! -$ !$# ! "

+$. $ $ % "2 (! "% " " $ "+(! * & %$ + ! $ ! " + !$ !

!( /)$ $% + "% ( # ! "#$ &$ ")* #(! " & %$! " $ # "+(! *.

$ ,$ 4:;;<5 ! , +$ $ %(,$" " !$-$ ) $ ! !

!$# / !2 "+ " # / ! ! $)$- " $ "# ,$ + ! /( ".

0 ))$+ / !$+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$ ! # "#$" $+ " ("!0 ))$+

" $"! -$ !$# ! & ()+ /$"$ ("!0 ))$+ & 0$ ! " $ %$"$ )

$'( ) / (,2 & )$ !0 ))$+ / !$+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$ # "#$" $+ "

(19)

+8

!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ "+(! $! & ()+ /$"$ !0 ))$+ & 0$ !. &$-$ 2

$ ,$ B! %(,$" $! ! " $ !!(, " 3$+ +(# #$!2 & # ! (") 0$)* )+ +( "% +$ ) /$ ) 1 ".

$#$" )*2 !0$) "+ ) (% $ 478875 -$ # "! +$ $+ $ F!$#

/ !B $# " ) % # ) # "%$. $* $!$" , +$) & $ $ ! $ !$#

/ ! $# " ) % # ) # "%$ $ " $ # / ! +$ $ , "$! $

$ $# " $) -$ & %$!2 $-$" " # !$ )$3 /)$ #$! 4# " * $ ,$

& !!(,$+ 3$+ #$!5. $# " # ) % $!! " !$# & )) $" ))*

!$ / ) *. $# " # ) # "%$ ##( ! " $ !0 )) " $"! -$ !$# 2

$" !0 ))$+ & %$! ,(! !$ ! $) -$ / ) * ))! / #0 ! % " ) )$-$). ##( ! " $ ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ !$# 2 $" ("!0 ))$+

& %$! ,(! !$. $ )) $# " # ) # "%$ , $ ! 4" ")* A 5

! "#$ "* +- "#$! , % !$ !$# / ) *. $* $! $ , +$) "

@ "+ "+ "+ +$# $ ! "% & %$ "$'( ) * " D8B! & ! +($

A " ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ !$# ! "+ "# $ ! "% & %$ "$'( ) * " <8B!

& ! +($ A " !0 ))$+ " $"! -$ !$# !.

! !(%%$! ! $!$ # $ ! ! ()+ ) 0 !0 ))$+2 ("!0 ))$+ "+

"$( ) $# " # ) # "%$ !$$ $ $ ! " , # " & %$!. $ , #

!$# / ! # " /$ !(,, 1$+ #$! 6 % & ! $ " $ !0 ))$+

" $"! -$ !$# !2 $" !0 ))$+ & %$! $"+ !$ $) -$ ("!0 ))$+

& %$!. A( #$! 6 % & ! $ " $ ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ !$# !2

$" !0 ))$+ & %$! $"+ )) $) -$ ("!0 ))$+ & %$!. (!2 $ $ $, # ) ! $%* ! $3 , "$ & $ $ #$ 6 # "%$ ! , $ # "#$" $+ " $ !0 )) ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ !$# !. ! #

# " ! ! & ! (+ $! !$$0 + #(,$" & $ $ #$ $# " # )

# "%$! $ ##( "% & " !$# ! /( " # , $ # !! !$# !.

" ( ,$& 0 +$ "+ +$ &$ # ()+ $,

+ $ $"#$ " !$# / !$+ ## + "% $ + $# " +$.

(20)

+7

" $ $3 ! +$2 +$ $""$!! $" ))* "# $ !$! "" - "2 0" &)$+%$ "+ +(# - * /* $"# ( % "% ,! "+ "$& & *!

# , $ $. "#$ +$-$) "% # (" *2 +$ )$ +! $3

("!0 ))$+ ) / " $"! -$ % +!2 ! & ()+ )$ + $ # (" * , -$ ! ) / +(# - * " ! ("!0 ))$+K " $"! -$ !$# /$ # , $ -$

$) -$ $ +$-$) "% # (" $! " $ " $ " , 0$ . " $

# " *2 " # !$ +$ & $ $ # (" $! +$ $) -$)* , $ "

!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ +(# ! ! & ()+ )$ + "# $ ! "% # , $ " "+

) / +(# - * " !$ , $ !0 ))$+ " $"! -$ "+(! $!.

$ " # % &

$ $3 ) " 0$! ) #$ & $ + " $) "% $

$# " ,$ # " )*! ! !$# " 9. $ (!$ $ + / !$ $#$" )* ( + $+ /*

# "+ ) $ % 4788C5. $ + / !$ "#)(+$! " , " " / ) $ ) +$ ) &!2 +(# "2 ) / 2 ++$+ - )($ "+ & %$! " :8: # (" $!

-$ $ $ + :;DC 7889. $ "+(! * #) !! # " ! $ + % )$-$)

$- ! " 72 & # # -$ ! 7< , "( # ( "% !$# !.

/)$ 7 $!$" ! $$ % ( ! +$-$) "% # (" $! 4!$$ ""$3 :

#) !! # "5 $ # "%$ /$ &$$" :;<8 "+ 7888 " $ + $# "

+$ ,$ !( $+ /* ) $3 ! "+ ) , ! , "( # ( $+

+(# !. $ /!$ -$ $ $3 "! " ( ( +$ ))

+$-$) "% # (" $! 4 (% )* , :; :<L $3 ! "+ ; :7L , ! " :;<8 E E8L $3 ! "+ 8 98L , ! " 78885.

!$$,! +$-$) "% # (" $! -$ $ ))* /$"$ $+ , ! $3 "+$+

( ( +$2 "+ # "#$ "! , ")* $ , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $!

& # ,() ) $+ $ ! $ +$ /* -$.

(21)

02

' " "

5 ( / 6 7 / 8 9 8 9 / / 6 7 5 (

80 0 ; ; 9 0 1 2 / 7 0 0 : : , 8 88 :

8+ 2 1 ; 8 9 0 7 / 2 8 : , , 2 72 7

8+ , + 1 0 8 +9 0 8 9 9 2 9 0 + : 72 0

5 ( / 6 7 / 8 9 8 9 / / 6 7 5 (

;9 9 +0 2 02 2 , ; / 7 + , +1 8 +2 7 12 2

:8 ; 7 + 0; , ; 2 / 0 : 0, 2 1 : ;1 2

:2 2 , 0 0; 1 02 + 8 9 9 8 ,2 8 : , :7 +

! ' *

/)$ $!$" ! $ ! $ $3 ! "+ , ! ## + "% $$

#)(! $ ! +(# ! #) !! $+ /* !0 )) ) / " $"! * 4!$$ ""$3 7

#) !! # " , 5. $ !$$ " 7888 $ # $! +$-$) "%

# (" $! $ $3 $) -$)* , $ !0 ))$+ " $"! -$ % +! = >

4E9L ) $3 !5 "+ $3 $&$ ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ % +! = >

4 8L5 " ) & "# ,$ # (" $! 4 $! $# -$)* 77L "+ EDL5. !

$- +$"#$ !$$,! /$ # "! ! $" & $ " " ) ++$ # , -$

+- " %$ ! +$ "$+ /* $) -$ # $"+ &,$" !.

!

: ; 8

4 %

: ; 8

4 %

# D

( ( ,8 + 09 : :+ 8 07 ; +7 + :0 0

# ( +8 ; 0+ 8 07 , +; ; +8 , 0; ;

3 ( 9, , :, 1 0+ , :, 8 ;0 ; 0, 2

#

( ( :2 + 0+ ; :, 9 ,8 , 00 : 98 1

# ( +: 7 0+ 1 07 , 0+ 0 0+ 8 01 1

3 ( ,9 2 :; 1 +8 1 92 : :: 1 0: 9

(

( ( ;8 7 08 9 ;2 2 :1 0 0, , :; :

# ( +1 0 +7 , 0; 1 02 9 0: 1 07 0

3 ( +, 7 :0 , +9 , 00 9 :+ 2 +1 8

(22)

0+

$ $ $2 ! + 4:;;D5 !(%%$! $+2 ! $) ! $3 ) " "# $ ! "%

& %$ "$'( ) * " , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $! ! "#$ $ $" "% $ ) &

"# ,$ ) $ & )+ ! ) 0$)* -$ ) $ $+ $ # , -$

+- " %$ , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $! " ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ !$# !. !

$ " ! /$$" $ $+ )(,/ 4 " ! 2 )+/$ % "+ -#" 0 4788952 $3 # 4 "! " "+ ! " 4:;;;52 /$ ! " 4788855 "+ A 1 ) 4 -#" 02 A) ,2 )+/$ % "+ # +* 4788955.

/)$ $-$ )! $ + ! /( " , "% !$# ! + $! " # "%$

) # !! # (" $! "+ ,$2 ) (% , ++)$ ( "# ,$ # (" $! -$

)$!! ) / #$ " ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ !$# ! 4E7L5 # , $+ ) &

"# ,$ # (" $! 4EDL5. "+ ! ) #0 ) / $ )) # " + $! "

# " , + " ) $3 $# "! & $ $ ) / ! ()+ $ )) # $ ,

!$# ! & +$#) " "% ! $ !$# ! & "# $ ! "% ! $. ! !(%%$! !

$ +?(! ,$" $ ) / , 0$ +$ ) /$ ) 1 " ##( $+

(% $) -$ & %$ +?(! ,$" ! "+ " (% ) / $ )) # "

# !! !$# !2 $ $/* - "% " $ $# " $ & %$ $, (,. " !(,2 +$ ) /$ ) 1 " )$ +! +$#) "$! " "+(! * & %$ $, (,!2 & %$

"$'( ) * /$ &$$" "+(! $! # ()+ "# $ !$ $ "+(! $! & $

) %$! #( ! $ $ "$! $, ) * "% % $ ! $ ("!0 ))$+

& 0$ ! "+ $!$ "+(! $! + $ ) &$! & %$ $, (,! $

$ ,.

- *)*! *" 4:;<E5 "+! # # " $" # # $ ! #! $

$)$- " " $ +$ +$-$) "% # (" $! /( /!$ -$! $!$

# # $ ! #! - * ## + "% $ + $# " +$. $ "+!

+$-$) "% # (" $! $3 , $ !0 ))$+ "+ # ) " $"! -$ +(# !

$ ( " $ & )$ $* , , $ !0 ))$+ "+ # )

" $"! -$ +(# ! , $ " , $ ( .

(23)

00

/)$ 9 +$ )! $ ! $! $ # +(# #)(! $ % !0 )) ) /

" $"! -$ 4 52 ,$+ (, !0 )) ) / " $"! -$ 4 5 "+ ) & !0 )) ) / " $"! -$ 4 52 " $ / ) $ ) +$ ) & /$ &$$" % ( ! # (" $!. !

- *)*! *" 4:;<E52 &$ /!$ -$ $3 ! , ( $ " # (" $!

$ ( $ " # (" $! $ , $ " $"! -$ " % !0 ))$+ ) / 4 5

" $3 ! $ " # (" $! 4992<L -$ !(! <27L5 "+ )$!! " $"! -$

" ("!0 ))$+ ) / 4 2EL -$ !(! 992;L5. $ ! ,$ ,$2 , ! , ( $ " # (" $! $ , $ " $"! -$ " ("!0 ))$+ ) / " ,

$ " # (" $! 47C2 9L -$ !(! :<29L5 "+ )$!! " $"! -$ " !0 ))$+ ) / 49C27L -$ !(! C72;L5. $ $!() ! )+ & $" &$ +$# , !$ +$-$) "%

# (" $! " $$ % ( !. A +)* ! $ 0 "% $!$ ! !(%%$!

( ( +$ $3 ! $) -$)* )$!! ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ +(# ! "+

, ! $) -$)* , $ ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ +(# !2 ! , * )$ + "# $ ! "% "$'( ) * $) -$)* ( +$.

$ (

0222 '% /

! #

D

# ( ! #

D

# (

(

( ( 99 7 ,, : +8 9 0; 9

# ( +; 7 0+ ; +8 1 01 9

3 ( ,8 0 99 8 ;0 7 9; 0

# D

( ( ,: 7 0, 0 08 0 ,9 0 +: , 0: 0 0, : :0 2

# ( +: , 02 0 +8 0 +7 0 +; + 0: 2 00 0 +9 8

3 ( 98 7 :; ; :, ; 9; ; ;8 ; 97 8 :9 , ,, ,

#

( ( ,7 7 ,1 ; ,2 : +7 7 02 9 00 , 0; 0 9: ,

# ( +8 7 00 : 00 7 0; 2 +8 9 08 : ,+ , +; 1

3 ( 9+ , ,7 7 9; ; :9 0 ;+ 0 97 0 90 : ,8 2

(

( ( ;7 2 :; 8 :, + 9, : +7 + ,, 1 08 : ,8 8

# ( +: 1 02 8 02 0 +7 + 0, : 0, 2 07 + 09 2

3 ( +: 0 00 9 0; ; ,1 , :1 9 9, 9 90 9 ,1 0

&$ /!$ -$ $ $3 ! $"#$ +$ $) "! , "%

+$ +($ $ $ %$"$ * /$ &$$" +$-$) "% # (" $!. ! ! # "! ! $"

(24)

0,

& "# $ ! "% " $ "+(! * & %$ "$'( ) * " , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $!.

&$-$ &$ /!$ -$ )! +$ , ) $! , $ , ! ("!0 ))$+

" $"! -$ +(# ! "+ $&$ $3 ! ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ +(# ! "

+$ )) ! ! +$-$) "% # (" $! 4$-$" ) & "# ,$5. !

# ()+ )$ + "# $ ! "% & %$ "$'( ) * )) +$-$) "% # (" $! "+

" ")* " , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $!.

! %

$ $3 $" $# " ) % # ) # "%$ ! " $"+ %$" (! $! "!$

" $"! $+ # , $ " , / + 4!$$ #$, %)(2 788 52 "$ # ()+

%($ +$ & ! "+ $# )* $! "! /)$ $ "# $ !$ " " $ "+(! * & %$ "$'( ) *E.

/)$ E ! &! $ # $) " /$ &$$" ! $! /* + $ $" "$ !2 "

$3 "+ " , 2 & 6 " $$ + $ $" #)(! $ ! "+(! * +$-$) "% # (" $!. 6 ! # , ( $+ ! M ) % ) % 4: 5 ) % @2

& " $'( ) ) / N! ! $. $ # ) ! #0! $ +$ -$+ ,

"-$! ,$" !$ $! (! "% $ $ $ ( ) "-$" * , +$) & ;L +$ $# " $. $ ) / ! $ ! $'( ) $ & %$ / )) + - +$+ /* $ - )($ ( ( . $ # $ # $" ! $ %$"$ ))* -$ * ) &2 &$-$ !$$,!

& $" $ ! $ $ " "$ " $3 "+ " , ! % $!

$ 6 " ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ !$# ! ! )! $ % $! 2 & )$ & $" $

! $ , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" * ! % 4 " $3 ! " , !5 $ 6 "

("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ !$# ! ! ) &. $ -$ $3 ! ) & "# ,$ # (" *

$ ! -$)* # $) $+ & % 6 " !0 ))$+ " $"! -$ !$# !.

: $ +77: B

022, 4 022,

(25)

09

) * +,

= 3 * 8 8 3 * / 8 3 * 8

'% 5 ( #6 -) 2 292 2 2::

/ 7 2 21: 2 2:0 2 22:

/ <#6""- 2 21+ 2 281

8 9 2 2;2 2 287 #6 ="

/ 5 ( #6 - 2 2+1 2 200

/ 7 2 227 #6 # #6 #

/ <#6")= 2 219 2 270

8 9 2 2+8 2 290 2 2+1

)

# +

& &$ $! & ( ( +$ $# ! " $ "+(! * & %$ "$'( ) * " +$-$) "% # (" $!.

-

$ / ! # $% $!! " $'( " /$ $! , $+ ! $ )) & "%

+ 0 , 9

+" ;1 +" 8

β β β β ε

= =

 

= + + +   + + +

  4:.:5

$ $ &$ $3 $#

β

0E2"

β

,F2

β

9E2

$ ,$ !( $ " $ "+(! * & %$ "$'( ) * " # (" * " $ $ +

2 "(! "% $ ! "+ + +$- " $ ) % , & %$ /* "+(! *

4 ) $ " -$)* (! "% $ ) "+$3 " /(! "$!! # $#05. 3 ) " * - /)$! "#)(+$ $ !( )* (, " # ) " $ $# " ,* 4

& # , % $# $ $) -$ # #$ !0 ))$+ "+ ("!0 ))$+ ) / 2

"+ ! $ $) -$ #$ ) / " !0 ))$+ " $"! -$ "+(! * "+ "

("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ "+(! *. $ $3 $# " "# $ !$ " $ !( )*

!0 )) & )) +$# $ !$ " $ "+(! * & %$ "$'( ) *. $ "#)(+$ )! $ %"

+ $# "-$! ,$" 4 & # ! 6$$"! "+ "! " 4:;;D5 ! &$+

# ()+ "# $ !$ & %$! " "+(! $! " $"! -$ " !0 ))$+ ) / . 6 )$ +!

(26)

0:

"! $ +(# "! , ( & # $ !0 )) " $"! -$

$) -$)* $ ( . 6 " ))* &$ ++ "# ,$ $ # 4 # " ) , # $# " , # +$-$) ,$" & # , % # " & %$ "$'( ) *. $

! $! +$ 4 "+ ( 4 ) ( (

" "+(! $! $ $! $# -$)*

= + "+ +

= .

$ (!$ & " $! , " +$ # " ) # (" * ! $# #

$ $ %$"$ * & # , % $3 ) " + $ $"#$! " & %$ "$'( ) * , "% # (" $!. $ -$ 2 " + "% !2 &$ $ #) !$ $) "! "

# "%$ $ " " )$-$) & # ! , $ !( /)$ ! $# # ".

$ (!$ $$ *$ ! -$ %$! $ + " +$ # " ) !$ )

# $) "! "+ &$ ++ +(,, $! $'( ) : $ $ + $ :;;8 2

&$ + ! ! "#$ (,/$ $1 4 # , "% " # " , #! $ $ !5

! &! $ $) "! % & "+ "# ,$ "$'( ) * !(++$")*

# "%$+ " $ :;;8!. )) $ # $ # $" ! $!$" /(! ! "+ + & $ $ # $# ".

" $ /(! "$!! # $#02 &$ & )) (!$ $ # (" * "+(! * + ,$"! " $ + / !$ $! $ , +$) / -$ " & %$! " ("!0 ))$+ ) / " $"! -$

"+(! $! "+ " !0 ))$+ ) / " $"! -$ "+(! $! $ " " $ "+$3

& %$ "$'( ) *. $ + '( " )$ " )*!$! & $ $ &$ $! , $ $ " ) $# " ,$ # ! $# # " $ 7E '( " )$ "+ DE '( " )$ " $ + ! /( " & %$ /* "+(! *.

- .

& * $! $ )$-$) "# ,$ " +$-$) "% # (" * ! +$ $ , " "%

$ $ $# +$ -$ !(! +$ ! $! $ $'( " 4:.:5

+ $ $" #)(! $ ! # (" $!2 ) & "# ,$2 , ++)$ "# ,$ "+ , ++)$ ( "# ,$. $ $ &$ / " $ )) & "% ! $# # "! & $ $ &$ $! $

(27)

0;

, # +$ ) &! 4 " , ! "+ $3 !5 & $$ ! ! % ( !

# (" $! 4, ++)$ ( 2 , ++)$2 ) &5

" + " 0 " , " 9

"

" =G+" 0" , +" ;1 +" 8

β β β β

ε

 

= + + +  

 

+ + + = = 4:.75

$ $ &$ $3 $#

β

0E2"

β

,F2"

β

9 O8 M ) & "+

β

9P8 M , ++)$ (

-

$ "-$! % $ " & $ $" ) $ $# !$# / !$+ $# " ) % # )

# "%$. " ! ! $# # "2 &$ ,$ !( $ $ !$# / !$+ $# " ) % # )

# "%$ (! "% ) / +(# - * " ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ !$# "

) / +(# - * " !0 ))$+ " $"! -$ !$# !.

$ #$$+ " & ! $ !. 6 ! " $'( " :. 2 &$ $! , $ $ , # +$ "+ +$ " $ !$# / !$+ & + ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$

"+(! $!2 " & # ! $ / +(# - * " ("!0 ))$+

) / " $"! -$ !$# ! 4 5 ) / +(# - * " !0 ))$+ ) / " $"! -$

!$# ! 4 5C.

+ 0 , 9

+" ;1 +" 8

α α α α

ε

= + + +   + + +

 

= =

4:. 5

" $ /(! "$!! # $#0 &$ +$ ) & $# " ) % # ) # "%$ (! "% 6 "+$3 & # ! , $ $ " ) / +(# - * & # ! ! "%)*

# $) $+ & $ & %$. &$-$ ! # "! +$ /)* $+(#$! ( "$) +$-$) "% # (" $!.

;D A ? =

=

=

(28)

01

$"2 " $'( " :.92 &$ & )) $! ! ,() "$ (!)* $ , # -$ !(!

+$ "+ ("!0 ))$+ !$# / !$+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$ " " $ "+(! * & %$ "$'( ) *.

+ 0 , 9 :

+" ;1 +" 8

β β β β β

ε

 

= + + + +

 

+ + + = = 4:.95

&$ & )) %$ + $# $ $# $ + $# " +$2

β

92 "+ " "+ $#

$ $# 2 (% $ !$# / !$+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$2

α

9H

β

: " #

$ $! $ !0$) "+ ) (% $ 478875 , +$) ! ()+ # "! ! 2 " $

!$# "+ $! 2 (!$ & %$ "$'( ) * , "% & 0$ ! " $ $! - /)$2 ! "#$

# ()+ $ /- (! "# $ ! "% ) / +(# - * " !$#

$) -$ " $ "# $ !$ $) -$ & %$! " ! !$# .

" $ !$# " D &$ & )) (!$ !*! $, $! , $! # " ) /)$,

$"+ %$"$ *. $ $% $!! " $!$" $+ / -$ !$! ! ,$ # ))$"%$!

$! , ". ! $3 ) " * - /)$! 4 +$ $""$!! "+ $ %" + $#

"-$! ,$" 5 $ ) 0$)* /$ ? " )* $"+ %$" (! & & %$ "$'( ) *.

#

$ (!$ $ ( + $+ + / !$ # "+ ) $ % 4788C5 & #

% -$! (! + / ) $ ) +$2 +(# " "+ ++$+ - )($2 "+ & %$! /*

"+(! *. " & %$ "$'( ) * )! # ,$! , $ + / !$ & $ $ &$

# "! (# $ ! "+ + +$- " " $ ) % & %$! ! " !$-$ ) ! (+ $!

4 "+) "% "+ // "! 788:2 , 788 2 " ! "+ ). 78895.

"#$ " "% +$ $""$!! &$ (!$ & ,$ !( $! +$ "

, "( # ( $ +(# ! 4$3 ! "+ , ! , "( # ( $+ +(# ! "

( ( " , "( # ( $+ !$# !5. $ )! (!$2 ! /(! "$!! $! 2

# "! (# $+ " +?(! $+ +$ 4#) !$ $ " " +$

(29)

08 ) /$ ) 1 "5 "+ +$2 / !$+ " % - * , +$) 4!$$ ""$3 C5.

$ (!$+ $ + , 478895 ,$ !( $ $ %" + $#

"-$! ,$" "+ $ + " $+(# " # ,$ , A "+ $$ 478885. (

! , )$ # "! ! ! " ("/ ) "#$+ "$) + !$ CD +$-$) "% # (" $!.

6 $ # 2 $ + !$ "#)(+$! , ! < /!$ - "! 4 "+ , " ,(, 752

# "! ! "% *$ -$ %$! ! "" "% $ :;DC 7887 $ +. , "% $

+$-$) "% # (" $!2 77 $ , (/ " # 2 :7 , ! 2 ::

, $ ++)$ ! "+ # 2 "+ 77 , " ,$ # "+ $

//$ ". ""$3 : - +$! $ ()) ) ! # (" $! " $ ! , )$.

/ 0

& ( ,

/)$ C ! &! $!() ! & $" &$ + $ ! $# # " $'( " 4:.75 "

(! "% $ ! "+ + +$- " " ) % & %$! 4 5 /* "+(! *. )(,"!

: 9 $!$" $!() !.

$ $ %" + $# "-$! ,$" $"+! "# $ !$ & %$ "$'( ) * !

!(%%$! $+ /* 6$$"! "+ "! " 4:;;D5. ! 6 ##( ! " !$# ! $"

, $ !0 )) " $"! -$ " " $ ,$ " !$# ! " +$-$) "% # (" $!. $ /!$ -$ ! # "#$ "! ")* ( $ , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $! 4# )(," 75

& $ $ 6 $ , $ , " "+ & $ $ !0 ))$+ ) / ! , $ $!$" . "

" $ $! "% $!() # "#$ "! $ , # $+(# " )$-$). $-$ ) ! (+ $!

4J ( "+ $ )$ 788E5 "+ $ $+(# " )$-$) "# $ !$ & %$

"$'( ) * & $ $ ! ! ()+ "# $ !$ $ !( )* $+(# $+ & 0$ ! "+

+$# $ !$ $) -$)* $ $,("$ ". ! $!() )+! & $" &$ + "

# " ) ,$ $ +2 /( &$ ++ +(,, $! $ +!2 ! " /)$ C2

(30)

07 ! $ $# ! " ) "%$ ! %" # " ! # " , $ $ $ # ) $+ # "

4! %" # " )* "$% -$5.

" +$ $! $ $ $# $ +$ $" "2 &$ "#)(+$ $

+$ & ( $) -$ +$ & 4 Q 5. $ !$$ +$

& ! ( $ " # (" $! "# $ !$ & %$ "$'( ) * $) -$)* +$ &

" $ " # (" $!2 " "# $ !$ :L " $ ! $ ! ( +$ $) -$

" +$ "# $ !$ " $ "+(! * & %$ "$'( ) * /* 8.87DL.

/ (

" ) -

4 D

#

# (

$ * 1 * 1 * 1 * 1

>= 2 20; 2 +29 2 2;8 2 279

2 ;1 0 ;8 2 7: + ,8

*>/ 2 982 + 2+; 2 2;2 2 1,1

+ :7 0 77 2 +0 2 ;7

' 2 299 2 2,8 2 22: 2 +21

+ 77 2 12 2 28 0 28

@ ! 2 201 2 20, 2 2,9 2 208

, 99 0 09 0 ;, + 11

> I I I I

> I I I I

- 9+9 7; +17 +,7

! ;1 +, 0: 07

6 2 +7 2 :+ 2 +, 2 0:

)) $ $! , "! $!$" /(! ! "+ + $ !.4

+2JK :JK +J

! # "+ + $ $3 ) " " ! $!() & ()+ /$ $ $3 ! $"#$

( +$ $) "! 4$.%. " $ "+(! * ! $# ) 1 "52 , "%

+$-$) "% # (" $!. $ $ $ ( ( +$ & ()+ /$ "# $ ! "%

& %$ "$'( ) * , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $! 4) 0$ $ "

+$5 "+ +$# $ ! "% "$'( ) * ) & "# ,$ # (" $!. $ /!$ -$

! $ $# ! , $ ! %" # " , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $! 4# )(," 72 5

" ) & "# ,$ # (" $! 4# )(," 95 ! &$ # ()+ $3 $# ! "#$ ) &

(31)

,2 "# ,$ # (" $! $!$" # , -$ +- " %$ " ("!0 ))$+ ) /

$) -$)* )) $ $ ! ( $ " # (" $!.

& %

/)$ D ! &! (! $ $! , "! $'( " 4:. 5. $ /!$ -$ + "%

& ! ( $ " # (" $! $ " & " $ " # (" $! +$# $ !$! $ / !$+ " $# " ) % # ) # "%$ & + ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ !$# 4 A 52 ) (% ! $ $# ! " ! %" # " , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $!. !

# , ! ( !!(, " # "#$ " "% $ # +$ "# $ !$!

# , $ " "+ ) / +(# - * " , )+)* !0 )) 4 5 "+ % !0 )) 4 5 "+(! $! & $ $ ! +$ "# $ !$! # , $ " "+ ) /

+(# - * " ) & !0 )) " $"! -$ 4 5 "+(! $!. &$-$ $ & "

!'( $+ " ( $% $!! " ! ) &2 $3#$ , ++)$ ( "# ,$ # (" $!

4# )(," 75 ! !$ $!() ! ,(! /$ 0$" & # ( ".

2 ( "

" ) -

4 D

#

# (

7 3 7 3 7 3 7 3

>= 2 +9; 2 097 2 0:; 2 217

2 1, 2 87 2 8+ 2 02

*>/ + ;:8 9 ,12 + 8:: 9 7,;

2 1+ + 92 2 9+ + +9

' 2 098 2 ;+1 2 2;, 2 ,,;

+ 80 + 0: 2 +8 + 8,

@ ! 2 28, 2 21+ 2 200 2 +1:

0 +: + 8, 2 08 0 +,

> I I I I

> I I I I

- 9+9 7; +17 +,7

! ;1 +, 0: 07

6 2 27 2 ,0 2 28 2 +2

)) $ $! , "! $!$" /(! ! "+ + $ !.4

+2JK :JK +J

(32)

,+

$3 &$ /!$ -$ $ , # ! !$# / !$+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$ "

& %$ "$'( ) * " /)$ < 4$'( " :.95. ! $3 $# $+ ! !$# / !$+

$# " ) % # ) # "%$ & + ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ !$# +$# $ !$ & %$

"$'( ) * # !! "+(! $!2 )) % ( # (" $!. "#$ &$ ## ("

$ $ $# (% !$# / !$+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$ $ $!() ! " +$

-$ !(! +$ )+! , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $!. $ $ % " $ $ ! "

! %" # " $ $# ) & "# ,$ # (" $! ,$ " "% ) & "# ,$

# (" $! $ "# $ ! "% $ $# " & %$ "$'( ) * +$ ##( ! ")*

(% $ !$# / !$+ $# " ) % # ) # "%$2 & $ $ ! $ % ( !

# (" $!2 $* -$ / $ $# 2 + $# "+ "+ $# .

3 * ( "

#

" ) -

4 D

#

# (

* 1 * 1 * 1 * 1

>= 2 21+ 2 212 2 220 2 +8;

+ 87 0 2; 2 2, , +0

*>/ 2 07+ 2 1+, 2 2+7 2 88,

+ 28 0 2+ 2 2: + +8

' 2 29, 2 209 2 2,0 2 2:7

+ 21 2 9: 2 9, + +;

D A ? 2 218 2 298 2 2;0 2 +,1

9 8: 0 9: , 0: : 92

@ ! 2 20, 2 202 2 2,+ 2 2+9

, 0; + 80 0 +9 + 9,

> I I I I

> I I I I

- 9+9 7; +17 +,7

! ;1 +, 0: 07

6 2 ,2 2 :: 2 +8 2 :0

)) $ $! , "! $!$" /(! ! "+ + $ !.4

+2JK :JK +J

(33)

,0

$ %) / ) $ $# 4 "+ $# "+ + $# 5 +$ $) -$ +$ !

% -$" " /)$ ;D. $"#$ &$ /!$ -$ /$ "% $" $+ & + +$

$ " +$ $# , ")* + $# )* $ , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $!

! "#$ $* " $!$" # , -$ +- " %$ " ("!0 ))$+ ) / "+ -$

+$# $ ! "% & %$ $, (, " $ ("!0 ))$+ " $"! -$ "+(! * )) & "%

+$ ) /$ ) 1 ". $ $ $# (% $ !$# / !$+ $# " ) % # )

# "%$ & + !0 ))$+ " $"! -$ !$# ! ! , ")* , " $ ) &

"# ,$ # (" $!. ! "+ $# $ $# ! , $ , " " ) & "# ,$

# (" $! 4C L -$ !(! DL5 & $ $ ! " , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $! $ + $#

$ $# ! $ % $! 4 ("+ ;8L5. &$-$ $ # , ! " /$ &$$" ( $ , ++)$ "+ , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $! + $! " # " , ( $3 $# "!

! "#$ $ + $# $ $# ! , $ , " , ++)$ "# ,$ # (" $!.

4 5 (

" #

$# Q )) $

++)$

++)$ &

"+ $# $ $# 8.88D 8.889 8.87<

$# $ $# 8.87E 8.877 8.8 D

) $ $# 8.8 7 8.87C 8.8 ; 8.89E

$ "+ $# 77L :EL 9L C L

$ $# D<L <EL ;CL DL

? 1 8 B

& -

$ $ )! " $ $! $+2 ! /(! "$!! $! 2 " " )*1 "% + $# )*

- " " & %$ /* "+(! * $ " (% " "+$3 & %$

"$'( ) *. $ $ &$ # ()+ (!$ $ ,$ " & %$ + $ $" #)(! $ !2 ! (!$+

1 @ !

D A ?

* % "

+ 21 + 21H 2 28, H 2 218 G 2 221 + 21H2 20,

G 2 20: 2 2,0

(34)

,,

$ +$!# -$ ! ! #! ("!0 ))$+ ) / " $"! -$2 , )+)* !0 ))$+ ) / " $"! -$ "+ % !0 ))$+ ) / " $"! -$. &$-$ /* + "% ! &$ ) !$

" , " " # "%$! , "% "+(! $!. ! & * &$ + '( " )$

" )*!$! & $ $ &$ $! , $ $ " ) $# " ,$ # ! $# # " $ 7E '( " )$ "+ DE '( " )$ " $ + ! /( " & %$ /* "+(! *. !

)) &! (! $! $ , # " & %$ / %) / ) K)$-$) $" " "

+$ "+ !$# )$-$) $" " " +$. " ! ! $# # " " & %$!

/* "+(! * &$ (!$ $$ *$ ! -$ %$! $ + " +$ # " ) !$ )

# $) "! "+ &$ )! ++ +(,, $! /* "+(! * "+ /* $ +.

!$ $!() ! " $ "+(! * + / !$ & $ $ &$ $! , $ '( " )$

$% $!! "! " & %$ /* "+(! * 4 ""$3 9.:5 # , $- (! $!() !. $

! & " # )(,"! : "+ 7 ( ( +$ $) -$)* (

+$ +$# $ !$! "$'( ) * $ 7E $ #$" )$ & %$ , $ " $ DE $ #$" )$ & %$ 4 8.8C -$ !(! 8.8 95 ,$ " "% ! "# $ !$!

& %$ "$'( ) *<. $ /!$ -$ $ ! ,$ , # " $ + $ $" #)(! $ ! +$-$) "% # (" $! 4# )(,"! C52 $3#$ $ ) & "# ,$ # (" $!

4# )(,"! D "+ <5 & $ $ $ , # ! "-$ !$+;. ! !(%%$! $+ " $

$- (! 2 ) & "# ,$ # (" $! $!$" # , -$ +- " %$ "

("!0 ))$+ ) / $) -$)* )) $ $ ! ( $ " # (" $!:8. $ '( " )$

$! , "! " / +(# - * 4 ""$3 9.75 ! &2 ( (

+$ $) -$)* ( +$ "# $ !$! , $ ) / +(# - * "

!$# ! & $ $ ! ) / +(# - * ! ) $ +* $ % $! "+ +$# $ !$!

) / +(# - * " ) & +(# - * !$# !.

84 +J

0: 1: 2 207J

7 +J

0: 1: 2 2:2J

2 298J

+24 +J

0: 1: 2 291J

Referenzen

ÄHNLICHE DOKUMENTE

important policy suggestion that India, Pakistan and Bangladesh within SAARC need to intensify their trade policy reforms to remove existing policy constraints hindering

In this study we examined, with a dataset of 90 developing countries for the time period 1978-97, the two questions of whether free trade reduces the risk of political instability

Trade volumes are found to be sensitive to real exchange rate movements but nominal depreciations have a limited long-run impact on trade volumes and the trade balance, as

Trade liberalisation and wages in South African manufacturing..

Whereas for middle income country the impact of S-S trade on increasing wage inequality is mainly direct (through the fact that they are the North in this S-S trade) for

Moreover, hierarchical models have been employed in other branches of economics such as consumer behaviour theory and the theory of the firm (e.g. However, there has been very

Munich Personal RePEc Archive. Developing Countries in Light

Our work is currently being funded by, among others, the Bradlow Foundation, the United Kingdom’s Department for International Development, the European Commission, the British