Munich Personal RePEc Archive
Vertical Intra-Industry Trade,
Technology and Income Distribution: A Panel Data Analysis of EU Trade with Central-East European Countries
Gabrisch, Hubert
Halle Institute for Economic Research (IWH)
2009
Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/64181/
MPRA Paper No. 64181, posted 24 Jun 2015 00:32 UTC
VERTICAL I TRA I DUSTRY TRADE, TECH OLOGY A D I COME DISTRIBUTIO : A PA EL DATA A ALYSIS OF EU TRADE WITH
CE TRAL EAST EUROPEA COU TRIES
(Received: 8 July 2008; revision received: 23 October 2008;
accepted: December 2008)
! "
# # $ % # % & ' ()
*+ ( ( # ! %
" ! " # "# #,
-. , " # # ,
, " " %
% " ( ( # %
" #
Keywords: #, # , () , ( (
JEL classification index: /*0, /*1
Short title: EU trade with CEE countries
Corresponding address2 % , 3 4 ( 5,6 78 9,
4 5, - +:*+9 # ( 2 " %;
<
I TRODUCTIO
# % " $ #
" % & ' () *1 ( (
4 (( *+5* " # ! # # ,
# # / ! , # #
' % = # ', "
# # = % # # #
% , #
" # , " " #
= % " " , %
"# ! % #
$ # % " > %
% # " ! # ! # " , #
% #
% " ? (( % "
− %# " " " "
,
, # % " % "
# %# *@@+ , % %
" 4A *@@B,
A " *@@C, *@@9, / <+++5,
% , " % " # "
*@@+ , # 4-= *@@:,
7 - *@@9, *@@@, 6 <++15
# , = #
& #' ! # %#, ! ,
% % " #
" , "
( # #
, % " ! " #
B
4 <++:5, #
" % , "
#
# #
# , # <+++ 4 %
" <++<, " <++C ( , D "
<++1 5 3 / 4*@@@5 ! % #
% " , "
% , # %
E "# / E "#
% () (( % % " #
" " % - #
# " % $ #
% % %
, " % , ,
(( ! = " % $ # 4
% 5 "
# 2 *
"# E % , % # #
$ <
" $ % , % B " ,
0 # #
1. COST A D TECH OLOGY ADVA TAGES, A D I COME DISTRIBUTIO I THE THEORY A D EMPIRICISM OF I TRA I DUSTRY TRADE
% # "#
" # 4 % *@9C, '
A ' *@@1 #5 # %
" # %# F , " E %
! #
0
" $ #
, -. # %# F ,
" F -. 4
5 E % % # " #
" " % % # 3
F # # , A 4*@@15
" " -. A ,
! & ' #
# , " ! " #
% , % # #
# - 6 #" 4<+++5 " , " % #
# " # F % , -.
% % " # #
# " %
$ # # " % % 4
<++0> <++15
" , # #
# # " ,
" $ # , % #
% %# 3 " % ,
# (
< , % 2 4i5 $ #
% #
4- 6 #" <+++> 7 7 G <++< (missing from the referenesxxx),
D " <++15 " % %
" F , % (
$ # $ # " 47 *@@9> "
*@@@5 4ii5 % " #2 % !
! # , % " % # "
% ,
% () (( 4 ! , A F <++1, F#
1
H <++15BI " # % " %
%
(! " ,
! ,
" " #, #
4 5
, -. E % % ,
" #, # ,
# # ,
! % / # 6 F 4*@9C5 %
, # %# ! " " "
" " " " "
" % - "
" E % $ #, "# " # E %
# , # 7
" 4 , ! , 7 <++<> 7 7 G
<++<!!!5 07 " ! 7 (" 4<++:5
"# , % % , "
% % , " # %
! "
% # % #
" %# , $ #
, # & " ' 46 " *@9:, BC5
# , % # ,
" % % %
# , / 4*@9C5 , " % "
% 3 4 % 5 #, "# !
#' " " " $ # " 3
, $ # " ,
"# #
" # " " $ # #
:
# " " "
" 2 % %
" $ # # # $ # # "
# " ! $ # #
# % "
#, " $ # 1 #
" # # "
$ # " ,
"# % # #2 " "
"# % , % " , " " "
% % "
/ # 6 F , "# " "
" - 6 #" 4<+++5 / )
( - , ", , -. % ! "#
# ! % -.
# # 2
% -. # "
, $ ,
"# % % ! # % "
() (( %# $ # #
/ , # " # %
2. EMPIRICAL METHODOLOGY
Testing equations: 3 # #
4 " ! 5 ($
4*5 % 2
4*5
t jk t jk t
jk
t jk t
jk t
jk t
jk t
jk
CUDUM DISTA)CE
MAXSIZE
MI)SIZE RELI)DIS
RELTECH RELGDPC
VIIT
, , C
: , 1
, 0
, B
,
<
,
* + ,
β β
β
β β
β β
β
+ +
+
+ +
+ +
+
=
C
J = , # ! " () #j
#k t. % [+,*], "
VIIT, ! # % " !
! # % -. % %
(A ( "# (A I-
% 7 I 7 K % F
-., # #
7 I D(=47 K D(5 4 " 5 -. - I (
, " " "
% " " #
% #, % % ()
4 )-)75: (( # % , # * 4
" <++0, " ! 5 ,
# +
% (A % " # %# J
" # , A % %
# , %
(A % % J $ , " A
" % % % " % #
% (A % 3 " "
-. , " " %
, " , # % %
. " # " ,
% , % " % ()
(( , # () " %
, ! " (), %
%# , " / ! , %
" 4 # . , " #, # 5 " !
% # 4/ . , " 5 / ,
" 4 , % 5 " %
" , " % # %
% # , # %
9
" # # 4 *@*95 " ?
# " # , "
%# $ ! 4/(5 4 (5
/ #, A
# " # , # ,
" # , "
" , %
Predictions on signs: " 4 F 5 # ,
(A -. % ! 4 " " 5 #
4 " 5 # , %
" , ! E % , (A (
% % " " J %# "# 4
5, % " % %
(A I- % % , "
" " F
" # # 4 " 5 "
7 I D( 47 K D(5, F # CJ
# # # " F % -
6 #" 4<+++5 % % , J
! " - I ( " ,
" "
# " " " #
4 )-)75 " , " %
/ #, J
% J % ! , (A % %
" "
Calculation of variables. Methodological issues: %
" , # # ' %
#, % # *@@B,9<+++ <++0 3 *@@B,
( ( # " # # ,
( " " # F % ()
, ) 7 #
@
<++0, " % % (), " % "
! 3 # % ! L *0 ()
4 ! " A ! % "5 L *+ (( , *0+ % # ,
0<+ # , # " A % %
<9+ 4*@@B <+++5 " /(
IIT, VIIT, HIIT: # %# # " %
A # 4 A5 ! CC9 40 " 5 B 9 4 " 5
% I ( % ,
" "" " % !
" % , F # 3
, # & ! $ '
4 <++05, " !
% " , 4 )J5 ! %
3 J " " M*1 %
4 ! , % *@90, *@@@,
" <++C5 F %= % 3
% " % F
4 !5
Figure 1 4*0+!B L 0<+5 # A
# 3 % %# *@@B, " @ %
# % () (( *+ *B
" <* <++0 I , % " " #
# " , " $
" / ! , # % :C
4 # F % 5 * 4. " A 5 <++0 , Figure 2
# # , *1N
% 9+ # , " #
"
, # " $ # $ #
/ #, "
Figure 1 + Figure 2
*+
$ # # 4 5 %
/ , " "
" " % $ # #
/ " B , # $ # " ()
#, " "
Factor endowment and technology differences:
-. , 4GDPCCj,t
GDPCk,t)*+ ! " ( (
- % 4<++1%5 3 "#, #
% # " " "# "# #
4( - % <++:5 3 % ,
% **3
% " "# # %
% % + * "
" "#
Income distribution: # % 4 " 5
$ # " , / 4*@9C5
# # % "
4<5
5 4
* 5 4
, ,
k k d
j d j k
j F h
h ID F
−
− =
Fj,k4 5 % f # j 4()5 k 4 (( 5
h " 4 " 5 d,
[
+, , , *]
,k hj,d hk,d
hj = hd $ # #
, " " $ # #
# " % #
# " , -
6 #" 4<+++5 / #, # % $ #,
Figure 3
**
" % () (( ) ( -
- 6 #" , $ "
*< 3 " j9k %
% " -. % -. *@@B, <+++ <++0
( - % 4<++1%5 % " # "
(3) RELI)DISjk,t= lnFj4hd,j−k5−4*−Fk4hd,j−k55
# % , # "
" , % % ! # "
# " #
% 3 $ # - % 4)I)E3 -(
<++15
Table 1 (A % " "
" # "" !
, ! " " / ! , "
% -. " <0,*++ ( <++0, "
9,C++ ( *@@B <+,*++ <+++ 3 (A ( , ""
"# , " " #
% , " #
% % () (( " #
" # " "
% % # , %
- . # %
Other variables: 47 I D(= 47 K D(5 4 " 5 -. (
! " , % , 7 I D( ((
# 7 K D( () #*B- I ( %
%
Table 1
*<
3. ESTIMATIO RESULTS
4*5 " 4:5 Table 2 "
4 , ! 5 #
! # 4 <5 ! " "
# /(
4B5 405 4*5 4<5 $
I , "
% " % % ! "
" % " 4% , - I ( " 5 3 /( %
" # " *0 ! # " #
" , #
( 4:5 415
$ *+N " , % $
% /( 4B5 ,
# /(
/ /( % % % " 2
" % % , J
" 4B5 405, % "# 4 (A ( 5
" () (( ,
4 (A -. 5 (A -. " " , # =
# J *1 " "
# 4 *5 ! " 4<++C5,
" " -. % , " / " -
4 %
"# % 5 " / " O / % "
4*@@C5, #, # *+N
= # 3 F % , " -
6 #" 4<+++5 4B5, " J () # " #
Table 2
*B
" (( # 47 K D(5 ,
J (( # " # ()
# 405, " " A 4 !Table. A15,
# /( J D( %
" , (A -. (A ( " , ,
, %
# %# 7 " !
7 (" 4<++:5 ! # "
" , # % %
" , " " " "
% # %
"# % % # # % % #
"# I ,
Table 3 % " ,
% " % " " ,
# " , /( % (
, " $
% , $ #
& '2 J % ! F ! #
(A % " ( > , # #
! " F # 3 ,
J F % " %# # F #
/( " A "" /( > "
4 " 5 " % % !
F , % # " , "
A 4*@@15 % # "
Table 3
*0 4. CO CLUSIO S
%= ! # % ()
%# "#, # " "
% " #
3 " , % % "
" 2
% " "
2 "#P 3 % " %
, % %# ( "
% "# "
% -. , # !#
, , $ # #
() (( > " " "# # , % "
% % #,
% " " "
" % # %# #
% ", Q- " $ #
$ #, % #
6 4<++15 % "
H (( " %
# % " 0
" , % " % " #
, " < " " " ! % " #
" ! !
, ! , " % 4 %
F <++<, " F % 5 ,
I I #
"> % #
$ # 4 <++:5
" % # " "
% " % 3
*1
F % % , "
" F %# " %
(( , % $ # #
, " % "
% $ #, % "
" F / % "
" ) # %
" " ,
APPE DIX
Grubel Lloyd index
$ 4<5,Tjk # % j4 5
k 4 " 5, n X% " ! # M
% " " # #i2
( )
5 4
5 4
*
*
*
∑
∑
∑
=
=
=
+
−
− +
= n
i
i k k j
n
i
i k i j n
i
i k i j jk
M X
M X M
X
T 4<5
# 4*9Tjk5 "
% # , Tjk #
, "
, "" " " 3 " "" " 4< " , ! 5, !
# 4 *@@@5 , " " %
" ! "" " , % #
" , $ 4 7 "
! 7 (" <++:5 % "
% 0 " *: 3 #
< " %
%# / , #
*:
% , % " ,
# % = A !,
= ! " *C/ " R / % " 4*@@C5 ""
% A # , "
# *+N ! , #
<++1 # 4<++1, *C5 % % " #
% %# "
" 4<++C5, / " R / % "
Disentangling horizontal and vertical trade
# " " F
! "" " "
, & ' ! # #
4 , ! 5 ) 4 #2 %#
5 # " ,
4 )J5 ! #
! #
4* 5 " 4*S 5 a% " 2
∑
==
m
p k j p jk
Viit t
T
* , ,
, p = 1....m, 2
5
* 4 5 4
5
*
4 a
UVM RUV UVX
a
ijk ijk
ijk = > +
>
− 4B5
3 " , % F # , " ,
$ B # )J T 4*S 5
# " $ # ()' , )J U 4* 5 # $ #
, % # " )J #
" , / " R / % " 4*@@C, <++15 "
" 4 L + <15 $ % #
F " !
)J J " " % #
*C
% " # , !
% # # %
*,+++N # " $ #
ACK OWLEDGEME TS
% ) #
, <++0 " # " %# #
" # / , '
, 7 A " " 4 5,
() (( ,
REFERE CES
% ( , 6 4*@9052 / ' " =
Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv,*<C 4*52 9B @C
" , . ? , 4*@@@52 # $ # Economics of Transition, C4<52
<C1 <@9
, 7 4<++:52 / " # ( )orth American Journal of
Economics and Finance, *C2 <1C <9*
, 7 ? 6 / 4<++152Fragmentation in Europe and East9Asia. Evidence from International Trade and
FDI Data . V A " ,
" , % ( #2 ( ( (! W ) # A ,
/ , % <9 <@, <++1 % 2EE E E " E
KKKK PPPA " , " , % ( #2 ( ( (! W
) # A , / % <9 <@, <++1
, ? -= , ? , 4*@@@52 F # % (
( ( ) Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv,*B1 4*52 :< 9*
, H ? " , 4<++C52 - # ( "
( South9Eastern Europe Journal of Economics, 415<2 *:B *91
, ? , 4*@@@52 X # % CELPE
Discussion Paper0@, ) #
-G F 7 , 4<++<52 " 2
( ) Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, *B9 4<52 <@* B*C
-= , ? , 4*@@:52 # , " (
( ! CEPR Discussion Paper, I *BCC A 2 ( . #
- , H ? 6 #" , 7 4<+++52 - -. # 2
# Review of International Economics, 49502 C:+ CC0
( % 4<++1 52 % ! 4 2EE E E
Table A1 Table A2
*9
( % 4<++1%52 ( # / , I %
2EE E E
( % 4<++:52 ( " 6 "
% 2EE E E
/ #, ( ? 6 F , 4*@9C52 . $ #, # 4 5 2
6 F , 4 52Protection and competition in international trade ! 2 , *0< :*
/ , – , ( 4*@9C52 J I American Economic Review,
4C:512 9*+ 9<<
/ , H 4<+++52 " ( ) ( ( Atlantic
Economic Journal, 4<95*2 9B @<
/ , H – F F , - ? 3Y "Y , 4*@@@52 ( 3 # #
Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 4*B15<2 BBB B0:
/ " R, A –/ % ", 7 4*@@C52 # 2 7 " CEPII Working
Paper,I *@@C +*
/ " R, A ? / % ", 7 4<++152 - " " F J # CEPII Working
Paper,I <++1 *+
% , – " , 7 A 4<++<52 3 # % ( )
PDiscussion Paper, I C, ) Z " , - ( ,
% , ? F , 6 4<++<52 " " IWH Discussion
Papers, I *:*
, – F# H , 4<++152 # " . )BER Working
Paper, I ***0B % " , 7 2 I (
#, - – # , 7 –7 , 4<++<52 = , # #
Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv,4*B95<2 <10 <CC
, ( 4*@9C52 2
Journal of the Japanese and International Economies, *2 :< 9*
, - –A , H 4*@@152 7 2 "
Quarterly Journal of Economics, **+2 C@@ 9B:
6 " , . 4*@9:52 V "# " W 2 6 H " ? " , - 4 52
Structural Adjustment in Advanced Economies " 2 7 , B1 09
A , 7 4*@@B52 # ( ( WIIW Research Reports,I
*@: J 2 3 [ 3 "
A , 7 – " , H 4*@@C52 J () 2
( WIIW Research Reports, I <B0 J 2 3 [
3 "
A , – 3 , / 4*@9+52 - # 2 "
Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 4**:5<2 <9+ <@B
A F, –- 7 – % , 4<++152 " "P (
. ) # 7 2Discussion Paper, I C:
7 7 , H – G , J 4<++<5 2 J F # Weltwirtschaftliches
Archiv*B9 4<52 B0+ ::
7 , 4*@@952 ,Inequality and Poverty during the Transition from Planned to Market Economy
3 , 3 " , -
7 " !, H –7 (" , 4<++:52 - # " "
P ( ) , - ( ,
THE Papers+:E*+
, - 4*@@@52 ( " " 2 % #
MOCT9MOST, 495<2 1* :C
, . 6 4<++052 . 3 . F Quarterly
Journal of Economics, 4**@5<2 :0C :C9
, –7 - , 7 4*@@952 A % = 2 # P
Working Paper, I :, ) # " - % , (
)I)E3 -( 4<++152 $ # - % J < + H 4<++15. % 2EE E E
<++1 * , 43 -< 5
*@
J , 4*@@*52 # 2 " Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv,
4*<C502 :C9 C++
D ", H –3 = , J –D , 4<++152 % # 2 # 1+
*@@< <++* Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 4*0*5B2 1*+ 10*
<+
Table 1
- (A % 40<+ % 5> "
(A -. 4 ( 5
*@@B <+++ <++0
7 @::9 *B*<B *BB<@
BB01 0B99 0@::
" *0@@B <+0++ <0*++
A @CB B++ 0++
(A ( 4 5%
L*4\*@@B\5 L<4\*@@C\5 LB4\<++<\5
7 + +19 + +1+ + +1+
- + +0B + +B9 + +B:
" + *C0 + *:* + *C<
A + ++B + ++B + ++<
(A I-
L* 4\*@@B\5 L< 4\<+++\5 LB 4\<++0\5
7 *@ *B< *@ +*@ *: 0+:
- *< +B@ *< 9BC *0 <0@
" BC @@+ 0C B01 09 +C9
+ 1@+ + 1@+ + <+1
- % () # = (( # >% % > %
Sources2 ( - % 4<++1%, <++:5> )I)E3 -( 4<++15> '
<*
Table 2
J " A
. / !
4*5 4<5 4B5 405 415 4:5
(! #
%
< +1*]] * @*9]] 0 <10]]] * B+:]]] * <<9 * <<0:]]]
(A -. + ++0 + +:@]]] + ++B
(A ( + +*+] + ++:]]] + ++B
(A I- + ++@ + ++0]]] + ++*]]] + ++*]]] + +++ + +++
7 I D( + +:1]]] + *B+]]] + <+B]]] + *@0]]] + +:C]]] + +:@]]]
7 K D( + +00]]] + +C0]]] + 1::]]] + <0:]]] + +1:]]] + +:*]]]
- I ( + 0<0]]] + ++9
)-)7 + +9+]] + *CC]]]
= < + :B@ + 1@< + @@@ + @@@ + *C0 + *9C
$ *1 C90 9 BB@ + @:* + @+@ : +*9 1 @9+
$
%
: 01C ** 011]]
" % 2 4*5, B5, 4152 (A -. , (A -. 4 *5, 7 I D(4 *5,
7 K D(4 *5, (A I- , (A I- 4 *5> 4<5, 405, 4:52 (A ( , (A ( 4 *5, 7 I D(4 *5,
7 K D(4 *5, (A I- , (A I- 4 *5> % " "
]]] *N " , ]] 1N, ] *+N
<<
Table 3
F " A
. / !
4*5 4<5 4B5 405 415 4:5
(! #
%
+ @+C]] + +CC B ::9]]] + 1*@]]] + <B0]]] + 0B1]]]
(A -. + +*9]]] + +1C]]] + +*C]]]
(A ( + ++0 + ++:]]] + ++0]
(A I- + +++ + +++ + ++*]]] + +++]]] + ++*]] + +++]
7 I D( + +*9]]] + +B+]]] + B1B]]] + *+@]]] + +<+]]] + +<1]]]
7 K D( + ++@]]] + +*C]]] + :+:]]] + *<+]]] + +*9]]] + +<*]]]
- I ( + *B1]]] + +09
)-)7 + +BC]]] + +B@
= < + 1:0 + 19C + @C@ + @@B + <*1 + *C:
$ * @C: + 9B@ + BB0 + *9: + C+0 + C<C
$
% 1 C0< 0 BC9
" % 2 4*5, 4B5, 4152 (A -. , (A -. 4 *5, 7 I D(4 *5,
7 K D(4 *5, (A I- , (A I- 4 *5> 4<5, 405, 4:52 (A ( , (A ( 4 *5, 7 I D(4 *5,
7 K D(4 *5, (A I- , (A I- 4 *5> % " "
<B Table A1
J " A
(! #
%
. / !
4*5 4<5 4B5 405 415 4:5
+ ++0 + +01 + C+9]]] + 91+]]]
(A -. + ++C + +<9]] + ++<
(A ( + ++* + ++C]] + ++1
(A I- + ++*]]] + ++*]]] + +++] + ++B] + +++ + +++
7 I D( + +1B]]] + +1B]]] + +<@]]] + +<<]]] + +0<]]] + +0*]]]
7 K D( + +B@]]] + +BC]]] + +<C]] + +19]]] + +0@]]] + +0C]]]
- I ( + *+B]]] + *+B
)-)7 + ++9 + ++*
= < + CB* + C<C + 9@0 + 999 + <<C + <<@
$ : +1: : +:0 * CC0 * C1@
$
% <+ 9*9]]] << +<:]]]
" %
]]] *N " , ]] 1N, ] *+N
<0 Table A2
F " A
A
(! #
%
. / !
4*5 4<5 4B5 405 415 4:5
+ ++: + +1C]]] + <C9]]] + <*1]]] + *9C]]] + <1:]]]
(A -. + ++C]]] + +<C]]] + +*+]]
(A ( + +++ + ++0]]] + ++*
(A I- + +++ + +++]]] + +++]]] + +++] + +++]] + +++]]
7 I D( + +**]]] + +**]]] + +++ + ++B]] + +*B]]] + +*B]]]
7 K D( + +*+]]] + ++*]]] + +00]]] + +*0]]] + +*1]]] + +*B]]]
- I ( + +*9]]] + +*9]]]
)-)7 + ++1]] + ++*]]]
= < + :1* + :0< + 999 + C:@ + *:: + *19
$ + 900 + 91+ + 009 + 01: + @+0 + @*0
$
% *< B9*]] *< *91]]
" %
]]] *N " , ]] 1N, ] *+N
<1 Figure captions (plus sources!)
/ " *2 - % A # # ()
(( 4*@@B <+++, <++05
2 ( % 4<++1 5>
/ " <2 - " # ()
# 4 % A # *@@B, <+++, <++05
2 ( % 4<++1 5> '
/ " B2 - " () " $ #
# (( 4 % A # *@@B, <+++, <++05
2 ( % 4<++1 5> '
*3 *+ = () <++0 <++C #
< " % J > -G F 7 <++<> 7 " !
7 (" , <++:
B # ( " ,
% F % . %# " $ #
0 - F 7 4<++<5, 7 " ! 7 (" 4<++:5, " % % ,
" % $ $ #
1/ 4*@9C, 9*: *@5 " #
: , % F , " . , " #,
F *@@< % F # # # ,
# % F
C GDPk/GDPj % " # F % k j, U *
() (( 2 Lα -. Sβ -.=, ! "
" β, () A 3 4*@9+, <9B5 ,
" 4*@9C5 F # %
9- , / *@@1
@ " " " "" "
<:
*+ -. () " (( % > ,
%
** "# % Q- ! , ! , %# ( -
4 "# 5 , % Q- ,
4 % , ! 5 $
*<- 6 #" 4<+++5 # ) $ " #
" > , % () (( , ((
# ! " () #' %
*B/ ! , . , . -. "
*0 I # /( /( # % % $
*1 7 " ! 7 (" 4<++:5, " "
-. % % # " % ^ #
&
*:/ *@@B, % *B , * @ :@B %
%# ! " " 4<+++ <++05
*C3 " $ !, %
%# J 4*@@*5 " #
