Munich Personal RePEc Archive
Budget Rules, Fiscal Consolidation and Government Spending:Implications for Federal Transfers
Pinaki, Chakraborty
National Institute of Public Finance and Policy (NIPFP), New Delhi, Centre for Development Studies –JNU, Trivandrum, Kerala
July 2008
Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/30938/
MPRA Paper No. 30938, posted 17 May 2011 09:17 UTC
∗
!
"" #
$ !
#%# &
' ( '
( ( '
( ' )*
∗ ! + " ! , ! - . /
0 1 #
' !
'
&+
" 2
*334#35 &+ 6
!
' !
&"+
)
7
08 . *3341
9 ! (
: +
0+ 1
( )*
! +
0 1 #
6 2
0&"+ 1 *335#3; , !
( < ! ! " 2 +
0+ 1 *33=#*3)3 & !
>?
<
0 . *33@1
( ?
( 7 #
!
#
!
( ! ( ' (
)* ( '
!
( $
'
$
7
( #
)* !
! ( ' ( '
7 ( (
( ' ( )* 2
A 7 " 7!
7
77! # ( " 7 !
7 7 ! ( ( ' (
)* " '
! "
B 6 2
!
#" &+
( " 0
)1 #"
=4 ) );;5#;; *336#3C &+
* C &+ *333#3) *336#3C
3 6C *334#35 0:-1 #"
(
&+
) *333#3) *334#35 0:-1 7
&+ )
!
3 =#
# $ %
0 &+ 1
*333#3) *33)#3* *33*#36 *336#3C *33C#3= *33=#3@
*33@#
34 -
*334#
35:-
##&'( ##&(( ##&)( #*&+# ##&,# #(&*) #(&,( #(&+'
$% - .&/# .&/( .&0+ .&./ /&*# .&+' /&(* /&(/
" D 6 C; 6 64 6 =) 6 64 6 4) 6 @3 6 5) 6 ;3
" E 3 C@ 3 C; 3 == 3 =@ 3 @6 3 @; 3 4= 3 4;
" - 3 4@ 3 4= 3 44 3 @5 3 43 3 43 3 4) 3 @4
F 3 6* 3 6C 3 6C 3 6@ 3 6C 3 66 3 66 3 6*
G 3 =5 3 @4 3 @) 3 =; 3 @6 3 @) 3 @) 3 =5
1 - #&.* #&)( #&)/ #&#. #&.# #&') #&') #&(/
)&(# )&#, )� )&#+ )&'* )&00 .&(, .&)*
" * C) * *; * 6) * C6 * C; * @6 * 4; * ;3
& ) 53 ) 5; ) 5@ ) 4@ ) 5) * )C * C5 * =3
2- #'&,0 #'&,( #'&/0 #'&)0 #(&+0 #(&(' #(&+. #(&/0
.&/( /&** /&*/ .&+, .&,) .&(( .&'* .&#'
7 * C@ * 4C * 5@ * ;6 * 4; * 6= * 6) * );
) *) ) *C ) *@ ) *) ) ); ) )C ) )= ) )@
G & " ) ;= * 3* ) ;C ) 5C ) 5@ ) 4C ) 5C ) 45
)&+0 )&0( )&.) )&(* )&#+ )&#. )&.' )&),
2 '&*) (&,+ (&,# '&*. (&/, (&.+ (&,* (&0'
E B: 3 *C 3 *3 3 *= 3 *C 3 *@ 3 *5 3 6* 3 6C
2- #&0# #&/( #&+( (&(. (&'# (&'( (&/+ (&0,
G ) C5 ) C* ) C; ) ;3 ) ;= * )4 * =6 * =6
H B 3 *6 3 *3 3 C6 3 6C 3 6@ 3 )= 3 )@ 3 *=
3 (&.. (&/* (&(. (&./ #&#/ *&(* *&#' 4*&(/
3 )&(/ )&(# )&#/ )&,# '&)0 (&.( (&,( (&.(
5 ! 3 #&,* #&)0 #&'* #&,, *&/, *� *&.# *&')
$ 3 (,&(/ '*&'# '(&*) ''&#/ '(&/, '(&/( '*&/* (+&'0
" . :7 " "
, ! #" 7 *!
" ' ! !
+ ! "
$ : ! : ! & ! I ! 8
5! 8 $ :
7 '
6 &"+
( 3 35 .
(**.4*/ (**04*,
+ + + +
, 0J* 331
$ : ! 8 ,
0JC 331
$ : ! & ! : ! 8 ! I
F 0J) 331
I ! A F
0J6 331
F ! ! F
! 9 ! A !
A B
0K) 331
F ! & ! A ! B
0
≤
6 331, ! G ! H !
! & A ! 8
" H ! & A ! , ! G !
9 ! F !
8 !
" 0: + 1. " :
7 !
'
$
*333#3) !
7
!
"
*334#35
*333#3)! &+
C @) &+ * = ! :- *334#35 7 !
! '
*333#3) *334#35!
!
) 7 A
!
# ! 2 6
C @) C 5)
C *) C )@
C *@
6 C4
* =* * 5*
* =*
C 55 C **
C )5 C *@
6 5@
6 5) C =;
3 33 ) 33
* 33 6 33 C 33
= 33
@ 33
*333#3) *33)#3* *33*#36 *336#3C *33C#3= *33=#3@ *33@#34 - *334#35:-
0&"+1
& + A & +
! 2
0 61 , ! !
2
! '
' "
07 1
);;3#;) *333#3) *33)#3* *33*#36 *336#3C *33C#3= *33=#3@ *33@#34
L " == C == ) =6 ) =C ; =6 6 =) 5 C; * C; C
" L " CC @ CC ; C@ ; C= ) C@ 4 C5 * =3 5 =3 @
L " - =; 56 =4 *4 =@ *= =5 )* == =) =C @; =6 5* =6 ;*
" L " - C3 )4 C* 46 C6 4= C) 55 CC C; C= 6) C@ )5 C@ 35
" . 7 " *334
#
0 C1 7
#) C= &+
4 6 );;3#;) ! )
! );;3 2! 5
&+
#
, !
!
) 5 5 3
0 &+ 1
" L G " "
-
+
&
+
&
);=3#=) 6 6 3 @C 6 ;C C 4= #) C= #3 5)
);@3#@) = ) * 6= 4 C= 5 C; #6 6; #) 3C
);43#4) = 5C * 5C 5 @5 ; =) #6 @4 #3 56
);53#5) 4 5* C C5 )* 6 )6 C; #= @4 #) );
);;3#;) @ ;@ C 46 )) @; )C 6 #4 6C #* @)
);;)#;* 4 C* C ;) )* 66 )C 5C #4 C* #* =)
);;*#;6 4 3= = )* )* )4 )C C6 #4 65 #* *@
);;6#;C 4 ** = 34 )* *; )C *) #@ ;; #) ;*
);;C#;= 4 @C C C6 )* 34 )C 64 #@ 46 #* 6
);;=#;@ 4 6 C *) )) =) )6 45 #@ C5 #* *4
);;@#;4 @ ;* C *= )) )4 )6 C@ #@ =C #* *;
);;4#;5 @ ;C C *= )) ); )6 4@ #@ 5* #* =4
);;5#;; @ CC 6 46 )3 )4 )C * #4 4@ #C 36
);;;#33 5 )C 6 4; )) ;6 )= )) #@ ;4 #6 )5
*333#3) 5 )* C *; )* C) )C @5 #@ =@ #* *4
*33)#3* 5 =; C *6 )* 5* )= 3* #@ C6 #* *
*33*#36 5 C* C 3@ )* C5 )C @; #@ *4 #* *)
*336 3C 4 )5 C *; )) C4 )= =5 #5 C #C ))
*33C#3= 4 =5 C 6C )) ;* )= C* #4 5C #6 =
*33=#3@
-
4 @5 = )5 )* 5@ )@ 3; #5 C) #6 *6
*33@#34 :-
4 5C = 6C )6 )5 )@ ); #5 6= #6 3)
#
! (
( (
!
$
( , !
*334#35 ) 4= &+ 7 !
& 27 !
, ! !
H " $ : G !
8 ! 8 ! A 9 !
*33=#3@ )*
+ !
' 6 &+ *334#35!
( # 7
=!
# !
#
7 F F #
!
. 5 $% 6 3
);;3#;) *333#3) *33)#3* *33*#36 *336#3C *33C#3= *33=#3@ *33@#34 *334#35
G 3 C* 3 C; 3 =6 3 C5 3 C5 3 C@ 3 C; 3 C5 3 C5
3 C3
+ - 3 ** 3 66 3 6= 3 6* 3 *4 3 6* 3 6) 3 6* 3 6*
G = 3* 5 4) )3 56 5 ;5 ; 44 ; @C )3 5C )3 56 )3 ;5
C 46
+ - * *@ C 3C = 35 6 56 6 @4 6 55 6 *C * 4@ * 4@
( #
0" @1
);;;#33 *33@#34 G
! 2
7
!
! ! (
*
, !
A ! ! !
/ 5 2- 2
07 1
);;;#33 *33@#34 + -
+ -
$ ""
"
"
-
"
"
"
-
"
"
"
-
"
"
"
-
"
@65 C4= 4@4 5); )*; 6CC )5@ *=)
: ==@ C36 6=; **) #);4 #)5* #53 *)*
& *3C) **C* *4;= 66C4 4== ))3= 53) @=
& A ;;= )3;3 )36) ;5) 6@ #)3; @6 5;
, 4@3 456 5)@ 546 =@ ;3 )@C )@C
8 4@3 @;= 5=5 ))3C ;5 C3; );6 )6@
8 4;= =*; ;)C =;) )); @* )6* =)
F 4@= =43 ==3 4=) #*)= )5) #=) 4)*
F 535 @*6 ;45 ;56 )43 6@3 *); )3=
G @;* 6;3 =@C 64@ #)*4 #)C #)@ @5=
A 4=4 @3@ 44; ;=* ** 6C@ 4) ))=
A 46= 65= 5@@ =;C )6) *3; *=) @*3
H 5@6 C;= )363 @)) )@@ ))@ *** )3*
9 6=@ 6)5 C)) 6@3 == C* )@@ )56
$ : @4= 636 =@; 665 #)3@ 6= #6C *3;
3 C=6 3 4*; 3 @C6 3 5@3 3 =4* 3 @6@
" . " " 0 :71
* 0*334! )*=61! <
7 ! ! !
& ! C5 !
! (
(
! 2 !
?
4! ;6
! ' F + 0=4 1! F ,
+ 0** 1 F $ 0)6 1 G !
" " H -&
7 ! 0 51
# #
!
( ! #
# ""
0 @1
0 8 !4% 3
*33@#34 0 -1
0 1
*334#35 0:-1
0 1
*33@#34 0 -1
0 M 1
*334#35 0:-1
0 M 1
F )4)* @= *64* 5* 6 4; C 45
F - **= @= 63C == 3 =3 3 @)
F , $ ==C4 45 @@6) )* *5 )6 64
F , + ))=)5 5C )))3C 4C *= =3 ** 6;
F $ + 6 )3 3 3) 3 3*
F H - )== 5= )55 ) 3 6= 3 65
F + *=C=* @@ *56;= =) =@ 6= =4 *C
! "# $$ $ $
F 7 ==3 @33 ) ** ) *)
& C=)@@ C6 C;@3@ 4* )33 )33
, 5 4 8 9 07 1
"" H -& F&"N
5 & =4 ))5 )66
))4 ))6 ;;
**6 *C@ 43)
C4 @=
9 *4 )4 4*
: ! )35 )C )=3
; < )4= *)5 )5;
= < ;= 6; ;4
= )6 )3 C)
8 ! 5 & )@C *@5 CCC
8 C; 6; @@
$ ))* **) C@C
5 9 C; )C )3)
9 )*3 )** C;5
1 == *C 45
> 5 ))) C5 )6=
? 4* == )=C
, ! (
# ! !
@!
! # #
"" , !
# ""
!
#
& 3
, # !
#
$ ;
);;3#33 *334#35! $
)C A # '
2
$
! ' ! ! #
$
$ #
'
#
& #
#
!
! $
# ( .
µ β
α + + + +
=
−( #
; 7
! 2
# 7
# ! 7
!
+ 2
+ . +
B 0+ 10 #)1
B 0 1
+
" 5 )4= 03 ;;1
0*1
! % # O #
&FF $ A 0*3331O P
=M O 0*1 # Q
&# O R # O
S" 2 Q # ( &#
7 #
(
)6
! ! !
# 7
! ( ' (
)*
( '
"& 27 @ 7
)* ' ( '
#%#
' <
? 0)* !
)C1 )3! 5)
)* ;*
4
' ( !
( '
#* !
! " ! # $ %
!
!
!
!
!
!
% & !' (
)* )) !
# !
C )6 4 )6
( '
)*
! ( ( '
( ' !
' ! )* !
( ( '
!
7 ( ! #
7 !
0 # 1 0)*
! )4;1 7 ! ! (
0)*
! )4;1 ( '
!
S 2
' ( ' )=
63 !
! ! #
! #
0)* ! )531 7 ! #
! ( ' #
( !
*33*#36!
)* ! #
45 =* 7 ;3 ;)
! 4* 4*
))! ( ' (
@4! 5)) )*
)3! )4* " !
=544 ( ' ( );@*C
( ' )*
( )33 ( '
( ' )* ( ' (
= C= !
(
)3!
( ' ! ( *)C3)@
)C*@C3 )*
( ' )@ 5 *; 3*
)* C )6 4 )6
)
* + ,-
)*
. ( /
. 01% 2
. (
/
3 ! 0+%
4 "
5 +
6 7 +
- (
# "
% & !' (
(
) 7 ! 8! 9! + 4 +!- * + ! :
( ; !
< * + !
= 7 >
# ) 7 ! 8! 9! + 4 +!- * + ! :
< * + !
< !
#
% 7 & #? ! ' (
( '
)6 $ ( ' 0 )= 63
1 )* ! (
2 *4
64 = *33=#3@ *33;#)3 , !
( ' ! *; C C) 34
( ' =3
! 65 ;3
)*
$ ( ' ! 3 6)
&+ )*
!
( '
! 2 '' 7
2 6 &+ !
(
T T 0
)* 1U T
T )C
( ' )*
( '
! " # $ % &
.
# / ! , #
( $
# / " *
" ' "&
! " # $
# / ! , #
( $
# / " *
" ' "&
# / ! , #
( $
) / " *
" ' "&
5 & # %+ - ' #
* 01% 2 1% 2 ! + +% + !
+ + % ! ! + ,- ! !'
% 7 & #? ! ' (
7 T T!
C) ;6
=5 == 0" )C1 );
=5 34 C) C=
)* 7 ( ' !
@C ==
@6 7 ( ' !
( ' !
!
( "
) ( + + ,-
!
'
.
01% 2
"
#
# "
#
# )
7 ! 8! 9! + 4 +!- * + ! :
( ; !
< !
= 7 >
% & ' ()* +( , (* , ( *
) +! * + ! ) % !
* + !
!! > !
"
"%;
3 -
3 !
* + !
8 % @
A !
A 9
A
4 ! !
4 %
4 >! - 4 2 5 > +
*% ; , 99
# 5 +%
# %
% & +( - ' (' *+(- *-(+-
. ( ( ( (
% 7 & #? ! ' (
, ! ( ! ( '
*; = 63 =
7 *; =
! # #
*3)36 )* 0 )=1 !
( ( ' !
( #
) & % *
( .
+ " *
) ( + + ,- )* ,
) / B $ %
, -& * "
) ( + + ,- )* ,
=! # $ % /
/ 0 # !
'(- +'*(- * )( '* (' ')- (* --+*(
% 7 & #? ! ' (
$ *; = ! #
*6); ; )* #
!
( ' 0" )=1 !
*C ;
0" )=1 (
7
! )=#
45 C4
!
. % *
*
. 1 " * ( ! 0
# $ %
5 * ( $ "
: ! "
#
. 1 " )( ! 0
# $ %
5 * ( $ "
: ! "
#
% 7 & #? ! ' (
