Will growth and technology destroy social interaction? The inverted U-shape hypothesis

(1)

Munich Personal RePEc Archive

Will growth and technology destroy

social interaction? The inverted U-shape hypothesis

Antoci, Angelo and Sabatini, Fabio and Sodini, Mauro

Universiti of Sassari, University of Siena, University of Pisa

2009

Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/18229/

MPRA Paper No. 18229, posted 01 Nov 2009 14:20 UTC

(2)

∗

† ‡,♣ §

!

" #

# $ %

" & #

#

# #

#

' # "

$

# #

# # # #

# ( ) " #

" * " $ +

"

$ , ' "

# " - * "

$ # " " #

" # "

#

# $

∗ " . / . 0 " "

*$ 1 " # ##

" . 23 " # " * 3 4 ! !5

6 23 # & # 7 3 8! !5$ 9

$

†: # ; # +# < # = >

?@ A8 + B # & C $ B

‡: # ; # . > == 4 4?8

+ B # & "$ C $ B

§: # # 7; # > .

D # < 1 8 4E8 @ . + B # & #$ C $ $ $

♣D $

8

(3)

" # "

# # #

$ ; " # #

" 1 " F " # # #

# $ # " F "

" #

2G * G " 8!!A < *

8!!! H * G * 8 + # ? *I # * *

!5$ , * # " '

# # F " #

$

* " "

$ #

# " 2D

# 8!JJ5$ " # " ' $ $

# * " ' " ##

2K 8!J D # 8!! 5$ K #

K * 7 28!A@5 "

"

# $

#

" L & # "

7 # ,

# # : M #

# : " * #

" # - " " #

# #

# 7 "

7 " $ 1

# " * "

# # " $ <

" - "

$

" # #

" # * # * " #

" " 1

L $ + ' # " #

# $ $ $

1 # " # #

F "

" " #

2G * G " 8!!A < * 8!!! H * G * 8 N =

H @ K -* * 4 0

A5$

(4)

% " # "

" F #

" $ ' # #

# # $ $ - # "

" " # $ $

# 0 #

# $

" 7 # "

" = ; "

$ + " # *

" ; $ , #

# # " ;

" $ + * "

" #

# " $

"

* " $

" # # #

"

' # # "

$

' " # " (

) # $ +

" # " * "

$ ## # * " # #

$ + 9 O * #

< . # ( F "

# " # # $

+ 7 " # * "

# 7 " # * )$

+ ' " "

# 1 7

# # $ +" ;

* " 1

- = " # 7

# $ + # 2

5 ' "

2 " # 5$

# # " ;

# ' "

$ N9.

. #7 2 5 "

# $

1 ' ' "

# " $

?

(5)

, ' " " 7

# # "

1 $

" " $ M

"

# $ " #

= # $ 1 F " '

7 # $ "

# $

" " ## *

$ + " " #

" 2 " # " # 5

" ## " 2 $ $ # "

# * " =

5$ +" # 7 " ( ) "

' "

# " $ %

" " #

" # " # # $ +

" # # " # "

# ' F " ## "

# " # " # " #

# " $ # 1

(+ *) . # / 9 28!!?5 '

F # " # " +

" M ' # "

## = # # " ( )$ ;#

# # " "

. #7 2G * G " 8!!A / . $ 8!!A #

8!!J G * ? K -* *

45$

* " #

2 : " " # 4 A " '

5$ # "

# # " # #

# # P

" $

# " " "

$ < " F " " #

7 $ " "

7 ## * " # * 7 # "

" $ "

@

(6)

# #

" $ % # " # #

" $

" ' # "

# - " # $

; " # " *

" F #

" $ % M # " #

$

: # # " #

" 7 #

$ ;# "

2 #

8!!J J5$ + #

# # $ "

# " # "

# "

2 ' 8!!E %F 8!!! < 8!!! 8 . ' 5$

K 28!J 5

# $ 7 # " # #

" # $

% " #

# # F $

' # # # # " #

K 1 28!4J5 " " ( # " # #)

* " " #

7 # * 7 * 2

!5$

# # #

# * # &

85 #

$ # " #

# 2 $ $ # 5 2 $ $ -

# " 5

# " $

5 % - # # " #

* $ " *

" # # # $

# 1 #

* * " # # $ + "

# =

* $ 9 * *

# * " " " #

" # " 2G *

8!AE # 8!J4 . 8!! N , F 8 ?5$

4

(7)

* # #

# = "

# " $ + *

" # $

* * 1

2; 8!J8 N 8!JE K G 8!JA K $

8!!4 0 $ 8!!45$ < # * # # -

" # " # 2. # 8!A

0 $ 8!!45 2 8!!? N

$ 8!!E = * E # J5$

+ * " # '

# ( * ) # "

7 # # "

F $

$

% ' #

# " # "

" * " $ "

' # # # $

' " L

$ < # 2 ?5

M

# & " # #

" * $

" " # # F " #

" # " " # $

0 2 A5 ' " # * #

# # " $

L " # # #

( # # ) " # $

" , 28!AE5& ( -

" # " 1 "

$ $$$ . " #

" " = Q $ F

# " " $$$ $

# # # # # * #

" " $ # #

" )

2 $J 5$

## # 7 F

' $ ;' 8 ;$ $

28! !5 " # "

" $ + ( )

" # ( )&

## ( ) $

E

(8)

; # #

# * ( " ' ) $

" # - "

" # *

# " $ K " * #

" # ##

* 0 2D 4 K !5 2 .

# / E5 2N ? 9 $ K

$ E # $ E5 # " " " $

, * # " "

* $ + 1

( ) F " '

7 # # $

#

& #

# "

$ . '

F 7 # 2( *

)5$ + " = # "

# "

# # "

# ' # "

$

" * " # * 1

# " * "

# # " $

" = # " $

# " # t "

i∈ , # " & Ci t

Bi t . # Bi t

- " # i si t

s t si t di * " Ks t &

Bi t F si t , s t , Ks t 285

- "

7 * "

* ' # $

# i " −si t

" Yi t " $

0 2 4 J5 #

" $ + '

A

(9)

# " # # # $ +

" # # Ci t Yi t Yi t

# "Yi t L

−si t Ks t &

C_i t Y_i t G −s_i t , K_s t 2 5

" F G 285 2 5 #

# 9 ' −si t #

Ci t $ "

# " # #

$

# " &

# " " B

* " # " "

7 # " "

# * " $ %"

'

" # 2" ' # - 5$ ,

" " # 2D # 8!! 5 #

# " # "

# $ 0 2 4 A J5

# " $

" # # ( * )

# " '

7 # $ # #

7

" # &

Ks t H B t , Y t −ηKs t 2?5

Ks t # "Ks t # η >

"Ks t B t Bi t di Y t C t Yi t di

R # "

R # " $

* # 7

" "

$

# " 1 " 285 2 5 2?5&

Yi t −si t K_s^α t Bi t s^ε t s_i⁻^ε t K_s^γ t

Ks t Y t ^β B t ^δ−ηKs t 2@5

J

(10)

ε∈ , " #

7 " α, β, γ, δ > $

9 s t > "

R # " Bi t Bi t " s t

"si t Ks t $ +"

- " * "

$ +" γ > α " #

R # " R #

" $

2@5 B t Y t " " #

" * " Ks t 2

Ks t < 5 "B t Y t $

# " " i &

Ui Ci t , Pi t Ci t b Pi t 245

Pi t " Ci t 7

b > # # "

$ # "

$

# " " # #

# " - $ +"

# # #

# 2 $ $ # #

# " # " 1 *

" * 5$ %

" # "

$ "

" 1 &

Pi t Bi t d Ci t 2E5

# d # " ;

Bi t Ci t "Pi t $ +"d

; $ 9 "

d > # ' " Ui Ci t Bi t

&

∂ Ui

∂Ci∂Bi

− bd dCi Bi

<

# "Bi t #

" # Ci t $ 0

2 A5 # ' F #

" - $ % " #

" # -

# # $ 7 * " # #

( ) # (; )$

!

(11)

/ r " " i− 7 # ' # =

# &

si t

∞

{ Ci t b Pi t }e⁻^rtdt 2A5

- # 2@5$ i # 2A5 *

' "Ks t s t B t Y t B

" "si t i # "

# #$ L

# 2A5 " i

Ks t 2 ( )

"Ks t 5 # ' # = # 2A5$ D L # 2A5

i t " si t # ' # = "

" 245$ # # "Ks t

# #$ , i

si t 7 - "

Ks t 9 L $ + " -

# " "

$

# " " !

$ + # # * #

$ # " $

# i si t Bi t Yi t Ci t

# s t B t Y t C t $ + ## 9 L #

' ' s t B t Y t

' B s t

' &

s t s t

B t s^ε t s ⁻^ε t K_s^γ t s t K_s^γ t s t K_s^γ t Y t −s t K_s^α t −s t K_s^α t

+ ' " # t

s t " # = #&

s −s K_s^α b s^εs ⁻^εK_s^γ d −s K_s^α 2J5

* ' "s Ks$ s t "

# 2J5 s t L 2@5

## 9 L # " &

8

(12)

Ks t Y t ^β B t ^δ−ηKs t

−s t K_s^α t ^β s^ε t s ⁻^ε t K_s^γ t ^δ−ηKs t

−s t ^β s t ^δ K_s^{αβ γδ} t −ηKs t 2!5

β δ # $ 9 #

2!5 # "s t 2 5

"s t 2 R # " L = 5$

B t Y t " " # "

$ " #

* " # "

# 1 $

2!5 " s t Ks t # ' # = "

"Ks t &

s t s^g δ

β δ

' ( ) "

# " $ 9 s^g → " δ → s^g →

"β "δ$

# # ( )

L # 7 $ "

"s t 2

7 " # " " 5$

"# s^∗ t $

% 8$ "γ−α >

s^∗ t







"Ks t ≤ ^{d b}_bε ^γ−α

bεK_s^γ−αt−d b

bε Ks^γ−α t−d b , "Ks t > ^{d b}_bε ^γ−α

28 5

$ " γ−α <

s^∗ t







bεK_s^γ−α t−d b

bε K^γ−αs t−d b "Ks t ≤ ^{d b}_bε ^γ−α

"Ks t > ^{d b}_bε ^γ−α

2885

88

(13)

7

# $ < # # γ α ' "Ks

" "B t Y t b >

" d# " Bi t

Ci t " " Pi t $

+"γ−α > 2 5 * " K_s

F " # s t

" # # "

$ + " * " ( )

2s t > 5$ +" 7 #

( ) # &

# # " #

7 #

Ci t 1 $

+"γ−α < * " Ks

" # # " #

$ " * "

( ) " ( ' )

R # " s t $ % "

* " #

" $

# " L 2@5 * "

1 γ−α < .+

* " " #

" "

# # " $ K

γ−α > * " * F

" " R # "

" # " $

+" # C

B d 245 d b B " ^{d b}_bε ^γ−α

"γ−α > $ + ' 28 5 2885 "

$

& d ' "# $

s^∗ t $ %

s^∗_d t bε

bε, $Ks t

; " "

R # "

# # " $

' # * " # #

" #

# " " " #

8

(14)

# " # $ +

" " "

> s^∗ t >

"Ks t $

9 s^∗ t 28 5 2885 2 5

" " # d # "

B C$ " s^∗ t < s^∗_d t $ +"

# " 2 # "

5 R # " 2 $ $

" # 1 5 "

"Ks t $

!

"

; " # 1 " " F G H

# ' # $

" " 7

- # 2!5$

( ) $ "* ' $ $

& $Ks $

K_s K_s K_s > K_s' K_s ! K_s+

K_s

" 1 # " #

# " . 285$

,$γ−α > ' %

Ks

−ηKs K_s^γ−α

bε Ks^γ−α−d b

β bεK^γ−α_s −d b bε Ks^γ−α−d b

δ K_s^{αβ γδ}−ηKs

28 5

$ ' 'Ks≤ ^{d b}_bε ^γ−α Ks> ^{d b}_bε ^γ−α

,$ γ−α < ' %

Ks

K_s^γ−α bε Ks^γ−α−d b

β bεK^γ−α_s −d b bε Ks^γ−α−d b

δ

K_s^{αβ γδ}−ηKs

−ηKs

28?5

$ ' 'Ks≤ ^{d b}_bε ^γ−α Ks> ^{d b}_bε ^γ−α

9 "d 2 5

# " # # &

8?

(15)

Ks

bε^δ

bε ^{β δ} K_s^{αβ γδ}−ηKs 28@5

# # "

$

& $ - d '

$ $ $ " $ !

γ−α %

,$αβ γδ < ' %

Ks

η bε ^{β δ} bε ^δ

αβ γδ−

Ks

Ks" Ks

$Ks>

,$ αβ γδ ' Ks ,

'

. $ ^bε_bε^δβ δ < η' Ks +

/ $ ^bε_bε^δβ δ > η' $ ) $

Ks 0 " Ks→ ∞ ^bε_bε^δβ δ −η

+" " "

# " - * "

$ # " C

B d > # # # # =

" $

# & $ d > $γ−α > '

1 $ %

. Ks " $

αβ γδ

/ ,$αβ γδ < $ Ks> "

1 " 2 . " 2 / + $ K_s K_s

"K_s < K_s ' K_s K_s

3 ,$ αβ γδ Ks > +

$ ' $ Ks> " 2

3 + $ ' + $

K_s'K_s K_s"K_s < K_s < K_s ' K_s K_s K_s 2 ' $ ^bε_bε^δβ δ > η

$ Ks K_s^∗' K_s^∗

$ Ks'

! s→ ^bε_bε

8@

(16)

+" " "

" # " " #

" * " Ks F

" # s t " #

# "

K_s & * ' " "

* " $ * F "

$

# " 2d > 5 " γ−α <

# = " &

$ . $ Ks

d b bε

γ−α " 4 '

$ αβ γδ 5 ' $

Ks 0

/ ,$ αβ γδ < ' Ks +

Ks> + $

Ks> " " 2 4 +

6 $Ks '

Ks>

3 ,$ αβ γδ ' Ks +

$ Ks> 1 " 2 7

" 2 8 +

8

, # P "

" * " $ 9

P " &

γ−α >

bε^δ

bε ^{β δ} > η αβ γδ

Ks

B "Ks # "

80 " # % & α . β . γ . δ , ε . η .

b d . % & α . β . γ . δ , ε . η . b d .

% #& α . β . γ . δ , ε . η . b d . .

α . β . δ . , γ ε . η . b d .

1' " K^∗ . 2 5 K^∗∗ . 2 5

K^∗∗∗ . 2 5$

84

(17)

- Ks→ ∞$ -

&

s→ bε bε

L 28 5 ( ) 2" Ks→ ∞5 L &

Ks

bε^δ

bε ^{β δ} Ks−ηKs

L 28@5 #

# d 2 C B5$

* " # #

# d # d > #

( # )$ # * "b ε∈ , '

" 7 η $

b # " # 7 " $

"b 1

" $ # # # "

* # " # * #

# $ ' # ' # "

" $ ε

" " $

" # # M

F " "

7 " * " $

# ( # ) ( ) " $ # "

# * $

D # #

" # "

$ # #

* # * "

" 2K 8!!! < < 45$ ,

" = * $

+ # # *

"

* F

$ F " # " "

$ + # *

# " "

" F ( )$

+ " # D # 28!JA 8!JJ5 "

# " " 1

" $

# ε # " #

M * " $

8E

(18)

" E 1 *

H B t , Y t ηKs t 1' " F L $

* " "

$

8

? @

0 " # % & α . β . γ . δ , ε . η .

b d . % α . β . γ . δ , ε . η . b

d . % & α . β . γ . δ , ε . η $? b d . .

α . β . δ . , γ S8 ε . ηS $88 b d .

1' " K^∗ . 2 5 K^∗∗ . 2 5 K^∗∗∗

2 5$

8A

(19)

4 E

# & ' ( )

+ " # # # #

" # # # #

" $ " * #

* "

# & $

# #

# $ # #

# * # # # #

$ < . # 9 O * #

# " # # $ +"

# " #

" " "

# # " # $ * " ' # "

# ## & # "

" # "

$ # "

"

# " $ ' # #

# " * " #

# 1 $ # 2 5 #"

" * " " # # # $

# " * 2<

# ?5$ # # (

) "

" " 7 & " M ' #

# # " *

$ " * #

8J

(20)

( " ) #

# * # #

# " $ ' * " -

# # # " # # *

" 1 #

#

2D * % 8!!@ : * 4 : $ 8!!A5$ +

( ) * 7

$

+ # F

" ' T t " "

&

Y t T t −s t K_s^α t 2845

"T # L &

T t σT t 28E5

σ # "T$

+ ' # s^∗ t

" $

* ,$ $ $ ".7 '

"# s^∗ t $ !

%,$γ−α >

s^∗ t







' $Ks t ≤ ^{d b} _bε^{T t} ^γ−α

bεK^γ−α_s t−d b T t

bε Ks^γ−αt−d b T t $Ks t > ^{d b} _bε^{T t} ^γ−α

28A5

,$γ−α <

s^∗ t







bεK^γ−α_s t−d b T t

bε Ks^γ−αt−d b T t ' $Ks t ≤ ^{d b}_bε ^{T t} ^γ−α

' $Ks t > ^{d b}_bε ^{T t} ^γ−α

28J5

#

+" # C

B 2 $ $ " d 5

s^∗ t bε/ bε B ' # " 7 #

L &

K_s bε ^δ

bε^{β δ} T^βK_s^{αβ γδ}−ηK_s 28!5

8!

(21)

"T F L 28E5$ 9

Ks " Ks "αβ γδ < , " " &

Ks

bε^δ η bε^{β δ}

−αβ−γδ

T ^{−αβ−γδ}^β 2 5

T.9 Ks< 2 5

Ks> $

" " # # "

" . $

+ 9 ".* $ %

,$αβ γδ < ' T Ks "

t→ ∞T t

∞ t→ ∞Ks t ∞ ) $

$Ks.( ) ' )

%

Ks

−αβ−γδ bε ^δ βσ η −αβ−γδ bε^{β δ}

−αβ−γδ

T ^{−αβ−γδ}^β 2 85

$T Ks %

Ks

β

−αβ−γδ T

T. 2 5

T /T σ ^K_K^s

s > ^T_T $ $ ₋_αβ^β₋_γδ >

( ) ' $ Ks

"// t→ ∞" 2 ^?:

,$ αβ γδ ' $ ".* %

Ks t Ks e^{A T} β eβσt−ηtβσ βσ

e^{A T}

β βσ

A ^bε_bε^δβ δ Ks T

" 2 ^@ #

1 " . 1

&

x T^β

Ks⁻^{αβ γδ}

2 ?5

?0 " # & α . β . γ . δ . , ε . η . σ . ,

b . .

@ # "K .0 " # & α . β . γ . δ , ε .

η . σ . , b . .+ & K , T . .

(22)

# &

x T^β

Ks⁻^{αβ γδ}

βT

T − − αβ γδ Ks

Ks

2 @5 x βσ η −αβ−γδ − bε ^δ

bε ^{β δ} −αβ−γδ x 2 45

;L 2 45 &

x^∗ x^∗∗ βσ η −αβ−γδ bε^{β δ}

−αβ−γδ bε ^δ

9 αβ γδ < x^∗∗ >

x ' B 2 @5 x " " 2 5 85 " .

$ " $

+ &

8$ +" C B Ks

" ' γ−α 2

# 5$

$ - # 28!5 "Ks #

2 5 "

Ks # 1 $

+ "

C B "Ks *

" $

A J

8

(23)

#

+"d > s^∗ " T Ks

# $ + " " &

Ks

d b T

bε

γ−α

2 E5

T, Ks s^∗ 2 5

" # s^∗ > 2 5$ 9 " 2 E5

2 5 T "γ−α > 2 "γ−α < 5$

+ s^∗ # Ks

−ηKs < " - ^dK_dT^s −^ηK_σT^s B #

- 2 E5 T Ks $

2 E5 # &

Ks

K_s^γ⁻^α

bε Ks^γ⁻^α−d b T

β bεK_s^γ⁻^α−d b T bε Ks^γ⁻^α−d b T

δ

T^βK_s^{αβ γδ}−ηKs

2 A5

T F L 28E5$

" " # 2 A5 " .

$

, ,$γ−α > ' "/8

% )

( ) "/8 ' $ Ks ; $

t→ ∞" 2 *

,$ γ−α < ' " "/8

$σ/η α−γ ≥ " ' $σ/η α−γ < + '

) $Ks ; $ t→ ∞" 2 ⁴ .;

..

* "

2 E5 # # " -

dKs

dT −^ηK_σT^s 2 E5 " 2 E5$

"Ks s^∗

dKs

dt −ηKs L Ks t Ks e⁻^ηt Ks

"Ks$ γ−α < -

1 2 E5 B

T → ∞ "Ks $

" ' γ−α -

2 E5 " Ks *

F " # $

40 " # % +& α . β . γ . δ . , ε . ηS $ E

σ . , b d . , % ,& αS $? β . γ . δ . , ε . η .

σ . , b d . .

(24)

.

"Ks γ−α > B # 2# α5 "Ks

" #

# 2# γ5 " $

= "Ks γ−α > "

1 $

! - (< N D 2<ND5 T, Ks

$ $ T σ

$ $ Ks g'

< $ σ

9 = 5 ^T_T σ ^K_K^s

s g ^dK_dT^s ^K^s

gKs T

σT B L = 5 " " Ks T CT^g^σ C

$ = 5 - # $

, # " T ' "g C

g C = 5

Ks T CT^σ^g # " T → ∞ -

( ) $ # - ^K_K^s_s → g

t→ ∞$

9 " T = 5 -

" 2 E5B L g# "

& ^g_σ > _γ₋_α _γ₋_α > $ # g > _γ₋^σ_α 2

σ

γ−α> σ5$ " 1 $

! - ( < < N D 2<<ND5 <ND !

$ g >_γ₋^σ_α see F igure^E ..

/ * 28A5 * == 5

s^∗ ^bε_bε t → ∞$ < # #

bε

bε " ' $

+ "T Ks " == 5 " T Ks

( # ) L

# " $ 9 # & "g

C == 5 # # - "

# # = " &

x T^β

Ks⁻^αβ⁻^γδ

1 2 2 ?55 # −αβ−γδ > $

< # # ' s^∗ ^bε_bε 2 $ $ '

5 x 2 2 @55 2 2 855&

E0 " # & α . β . γ . δ . , ε . η . b

d . .

?

(25)

Ks C T^g^σ C ≡ _{βσ η} ⁻₋^αβ_αβ⁻₋^{γδ bε}_γδ ^δ_bεβ δ

−αβ−γδ

g ≡ ₋_αβ^β₋_γδ$ "

βσ

−αβ−γδ >_γ₋^σ_α2 $ $ ₋_αβγδ^β γ−α > 5 T → ∞ Ks

C T^g^σ "x x # 2 2 @55

2 5 == 5 "

g < g2 g > g5 g C g C $

# - 2" T 5 P

Ks C T^g^σ Ks C T^g^σ T → ∞$

9 . ? - T, Ks

. * B - Ks T

Ks T Ks T < Ks T Ks T . # Ks T $

# # # " -

Ks→ 2 ^A 8 8? 8@5$

! 8

88 8

A0 " # % . . & α . β . γ . δ . , ε .

η . σ . , b d . .

@

(26)

8? 8@

$ / 0

% " # * " -

* # $ #

# "

$ . # & "

# "

" " #

# # # $

" # " " " #

" - #

" $ " #

# # " # "

# $ <

" $ *

# 7 "

(# ) ( ) 7 " $ #

# "

" * " $ # "

## = " $

+ " # * "

" &

5 ;

$

5 " ;

" * " # R #

" "

2 $ $ γ−α > 5$

+ 2 5 2 5 # B

(" ) 1 " # 7 # " #

4

(27)

# " # "

- * "

$ %

# " " & " # "

# ' #

( ) #

# # ' 2 # "

5 2 # " 5$

+" 2 5 7 2 $ $

γ−α < 5 - '

$

+ ' "

# B '

" "

# 1 7 # # $ + '

7 # B

# ' " 2

" # 5 "

# " * "

# ' "

$

N9. . #7

2 5 "

# $

# " ' '

- '

2 5 2 5 $ 1

" # "

& # " *

# " # * F " # #

" (

)$

* 1

# .$ J$ : * ;' ; . .

D " 0 , $ . K ? 884 8?J$

*I # * * +$ $ K$ !$ &

; " # ; $ ; ; # < 4? 2 !5 4@@ 4EA

$ / ;$ $ % " .

; # J4 A ?@$

G$ ? D + 9 * ; # . "

# " ; # K T % = 4 @@! @E?$

$ .$ /$ 0 .$ 8$ ; # N

. & ; " . $ : 8?R 8 K

E

(28)

; : . " K $

$ .$ /$ 0 .$ 4$ % . D M

; # N : # $ + & N K$ <$ 2; 5$ ;

# + & " + < $ D #

& D # . $

$ .$ /$ 0 .$ A$ D #

; " . $ " ; # ?4 8 J 8@?$

$ .$ /$ 0 .$ J$ . N

. & D , # $ % ; # 8

8 8?$

K /$ N$ K :$ $/$ !$ + # < N

, $ ; # $ . 8! !$

K * N$ $ 8!A@$ " + $ " .

; # J 8 EJ 8 !?$

K -* $ * $ K$ $ $ 4$ D N

; < & ;# $ ; " . ; # $

8 ? 8 ? 4$

K $ $ 8!J $ D / $ ; # + $ G * ?4

285 !@ 88@$

K $ , $ # K$ < /$ E$ "

+ $ :D& . + # / " . - $

K ,$ ;$ 0 $ =# G$ /$ 8!!4$ K ; &

# " $ # . < J! A8 !@$

K /$ /$ J$ & <

$ " ; # K T % = E4 4 E 4 J$

K $ $ G $ $ 8!JA$ . & # " #

# - # = $ .

. J 8 4 8?J$

K <$ $ 8!!!$ D " % / $ "

# # " . 4EE ?A 4@$

D # $ 8!JA$ 9 # D $ + < =* N$ K =

.$ 2; 5$ ; # +# #& ; # %

" ; # $ 9 O *& . , . $

D # $ 8!! $ " $ D # & ,

. $

D N$ 4$ * $ ; " . ;

# 8 !! 88?$

: " $9$ " # $ 4$ D $ + & .$ : "

$9$ 2; 5$ , * " ; # N $ 9 , $

;$ $ 8! !$ $ %'" D # <

$ 9 # 8! !$

' $ 8!!E$ , : D * . D

" D < ' $ : # @ 8 J! 8 ?$

N $ ?$ 9 9 & 9 "

" +# " + " # , # $ J 8@8 EJ$

A

(29)

N $ , F $ 8$ : # = $

9 O *& . $

N ;$ $ 8!JE$ * # & F "

$ + & D . $

N /$ = .$ H /$ @$ < " D

: # $ # ; # < !@ 4 E 44E$

, $ 8!AE$ / # N $ D # & ,

. $

, # $ 8!J $ < + " * & D =

: $ " ; # / 8@E? 8@J@$

+ # $ $ ;F " D & ;

" # < = $ " " ; # 88285$

G * <$ $ $ 8!AE$ # " * # "

- $ * #& + " < 2 % +5$

G * $ ?$ N N & D D ;

% . # , $ . D 88A ?@8 ?44$

G * $ G " .$ 8!!A$ : D ; # . F

U " ; # 88 2@5 8 48 8 JJ$

/ . <$ / = $ " $ 0 <$ $ 8!!A$

/ % = $ # ; # < . .

" , " # ; #

/VVV0++ ??? ??J$

. $ # / /$ E$ + # & D

D : 9 * : $ # <

A8 ?4? ?A4$

= :$ D$ * $ $ E$ * ' "

$ " . EJ 8@ 844$

9 9$ ,$ :$ , $ ; /$ $ + +

< & # : $ + # K$ ,

D$ 2; 5$ + ; / " $ %'" ; & K * $

%F D$ 8!!!$ , D % D = + $ ;$

2; 5$ : # $ D # ; & D #

. # D$ 8!A $ . # $ D # & D #

. $

. ' .$ $ D : # & + <

$ # < EA 2 5 4@ AA$

. $ $ 8!! $ * = &

$ ; # + : # 8? 488 4 @$

. # <$:$ $ K & D < " #

D ## $ 9 O *& K * $

. # <$:$ / <$ 9 <$O$ 8!!?$ * : # *$

. & . . $

< $ $ K # $ D 9$ 8!!!$ 9 ; +

" N D $ + * $ $ 2; 5$ D

; # # : # $ :D& K * + $

J

(30)

< $ $ $ . / D & N

: 9 D $ . . 8 285 8!! E$

< D$ 4$ : < " % / $ " .

EA 285 88 8?8$

< * :$ 8!!!$ : N N ;' *

D M N D $ " ; # N @ ?J4 @8 $

< K$ # $ ?$ D N $

" ; # 4 285 8EA 8!?$

$ A$ ;# " D ; # :

# & D . $ + % $ * G$ K$ 2; 5$

D / " / < # " . &

$ / 9 O * < $

$ J$ D U " ; # : # $

G * E8 2?5 @EE @!!$

$ !$ D 9 * $ 9 # * "

# ;# " + : # D L $

" ; # ?J @ ! @@ $

/$ ?$ ;# # " = $ K

" + < @8 A48 AA8$

:$ 8$ " D $ + & , $ :$

2; 5& N D & D + D #

. $ 9 O *& . $

# $ .$ $ 8!!J$ D ; # N $

U " ; # 88? !E4 !! $

0 $ =# G$ /$ K ,$ ;$ 8!!4$ 0 L & D

# # $ D # & ,

. $

# K$ , K$ K G$ K $ D $ $ D <$

G $ G $ /$ $ .$ E$ D / & . - $

+ & . .$ 2; 5$ 9 * 9 $ / & $

.$ $ ; # N D $ .

@J @@? @EE$

!