• Keine Ergebnisse gefunden

Recruitment of Overeducated Personnel : Insider-Outsider Effects on Fair Employee Selection Practices

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Aktie "Recruitment of Overeducated Personnel : Insider-Outsider Effects on Fair Employee Selection Practices"

Copied!
42
0
0

Wird geladen.... (Jetzt Volltext ansehen)

Volltext

(1)

Recruitment of Overeducated Personnel:

Insider-Outsider Effects on Fair Employee Selection Practices

Oliver Fabel Razvan Pascalau

Research Paper Series Thurgauer Wirtschaftsinstitut

No. 18

january 2007

Konstanzer Online-Publikations-System (KOPS) URL: http://www.ub.uni-konstanz.de/kops/volltexte/2007/2941/

URN: http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:bsz:352-opus-29413

(2)

We analyze a standard employee selection model given two institutional constraints: first, professional experience perfectly substitutes insuffcient formal education for insiders while this substitution is imper- fect for outsiders. Second, in the latter case the respective substitution rate increases with the advertised minimum educational requirement. Optimal selection implies that the expected level of formal education is higher for outsider than for insider recruits. Moreover, this difference in educational attainments in- creases with lower optimal minimum educational job requirements. Investigating data of a large US public employer confirms both of the above theoretical implications. Generally, the econometric model exhibits a ‘good fit’.

Recruitment of Overeducated Personnel:

Insider-Outsider Effects on Fair Employee Selection Practices

january 2007

ABSTRACT

Prof. Dr. Oliver Fabel, Chair for Managerial Economics, in particular Business Policy, Faculty of Law, Economics and Politics, Department of Economics, University of Konstanz, Box D144, 78457 Konstanz, Germany; Tel.: +49-(0)7531-88-2990/-2992; Fax: +49-(0)7531-88-4456

Razvan Pascalau, Department of Economics, Finance & Legal Studies, Culverhouse College of Commerce and Business Administration, University of Alabama, 200 Alston Hall Box 87-0224, Tuscaloosa, AL, 35487, USA; Tel.: +1-205-348-7592

Keywords: employee selection, overeducation, adverse impact, insiders vs outsiders

JEL-Classfication: M51 (Firm Employment Decisions; Promotions), J53 (Labor-Management Relations;

Jurisprudence), J78 (Labor Discrimination; Public Policy), I21 (Analysis of Education)

We thank M. Rauber, Konstanz, for very helpful comments on a preliminary version of this paper.

Oliver Fabel

oliver.fabel@uni-konstanz.de University of Konstanz Thurgau Institute of Economics

Razvan Pascalau

rpascala@cba.ua.edu University of Alabama

(3)

! "#$%&'()$*&#

!"#"$%&&'( ")"$' *+ ",-&.'"$ /0 1$"" 2. ",-&.' /#3/)/34%&0 %2 5/0 6/&&7 8.6")"$( 25"$"

%$" 26. /,-.$2%#2 0"20 .1 $"94&%2/.#0 .$ /#02/242/.#%& $4&"0 65/:5 %;":2 25" 0"&":2/.#

.1 ",-&.'""07 </$02( 0"&":2/.# :$/2"$/% ,402 =" )%&/3%2"3 %#3( /# -%$2/:4&%$( >4%&/?:%@

2/.# $">4/$","#20 ,402 =" 0"2 $"%0.#%=&' 2. %)./3 3/0:$/,/#%2/.# :5%$9"0 4#3"$ A/2&"

BCC .1 25" D/)/& E/9520 F:2 .1 GHIJ7G A. 25" "K2"#2 25%2 ,",="$0 .1 ,/#.$/2' 9$.4-0(

6.,"#( .$ 3/0%=&"3 /#3/)/34%&0 :%# :&%/, 2. 5%)" =""# 0.:/%&&' "K:&43"3 1$., .=2%/#/#9 25" $"0-":2/)" 1.$,%& "34:%2/.# .$ 2$%/#/#9( >4%&/?:%2/.# $">4/$","#20 :%# =" $4&"3 "K@

:"00/)"&' 5/95 %#3 0"2 1.$ 25" -4$-.0" .1 -$")"#2/#9 04::"0014& %--&/:%2/.#0 1$., 25"0"

9$.4-07 D.,-&%/#20 :%# =" ?&"3 6/25 25" 1"3"$%&!"#$% !&'%()&*+, -''(.,#+/,) 0(&1

&/22/(+ L!!-0M 65/:5 5%0 =""# "02%=&/05"3 2. "#1.$:" #.#@3/0:$/,/#%2.$' ",-&.',"#2 02%#3%$307

+/#:" GHNO( 25"!!-0 5%0 =""# -4=&/05/#93+/4(.& 5#/6*%/+*2 (+ !&'%()** 7*%*81 ,/(+ 9.(8*6#.*27 A5" %=.)"( 0.@:%&&"3 PQ/0-%$%2"R .$ PF3)"$0" C,-%:2R /004" $"&%2"0 2.

"34:%2/.#%& %0 6"&& %0 2. "K-"$/"#:"@=%0"3 0"&":2/.# :$/2"$/%7S T.$".)"$( 25" $"0-":2/)"

&/,/2%2/.#0 /# :5..0/#9 ,/#/,4, >4%&/?:%2/.# 02%#3%$30 %--&' 2. ",-&.'"" 0"&":2/.# /#

9"#"$%& @ /7"7 2. $":$4/2/#9 #"6 -"$0.##"& %0 6"&& %0 2. /#2"$#%& -$.,.2/.# 3":/0/.#0 %#3(

.1 :.4$0"( 2. :%0"0 65"$" /#2"$#%& %#3 "K2"$#%& %--&/:%#20 :.,-"2"7U Q%,%9" :&%/,0 .1 /#3/)/34%& %--&/:%#20 :%# 2540 :.#:"$# 6$.#914& #.#@5/$/#90 %0 6"&& %0 #.#@-$.,.2/.#07J A. "#04$" ">4%& 2$"%2,"#2 .1 :4$$"#2 ",-&.'""0 %#3 .1 #"6 "#2$%#20( 25"!!-0 25"$"@

1.$" 9"#"$%&&' -$"1"$0 >4%&/?:%2/.# $">4/$","#20 2. =" 3"0:$/="3 /# 2"$,0 .1 #":"00%$' 0V/&&0 %#3 %=/&/2/"0( $%25"$ 25%# 1.$,%& "34:%2/.#%& 3"9$""0 .$ '"%$0 .1 "K-"$/"#:"7W

A5/0 :.#02/242/.#%& /,-"$%2/)" 2. "#04$" ">4%& ",-&.',"#2 .--.$24#/2/"0 :.,=/#"0 6/25 % 0":.#3 0"2 .1 $4&"0 $..2"3 /# 25" ",-&.'"$X0 9"#"$%& 342' 2. -$.)/3" Y.= 0":4$/2'

%#3 :%$""$ 3")"&.-,"#2 9/)"# /#3"?#/2" 2"$, &%=.$ :.#2$%:207I <%/$ 0"&":2/.# 02%#3%$30 ,%' 2540 $">4/$" 2. =" %&2"$#%2/)"&' -5$%0"3 /# 2"$,0 .1 1.$,%& "34:%2/.#%& $">4/$"@

,"#20 %#3 04=02/242" -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" :$/2"$/% @ /# -%$2/:4&%$( /1 ?$,0 3. #.2 .-"$%2" ",-&.'"" 2$%/#/#9 -$.9$%,07 Z4=&/: 0":2.$ ",-&.'""0 %$" %33/2/.#%&&' :.)"$"3

G+"" D%$&0.# LS[[W( -7 GSI @ GUSM 1.$ %# %::.4#2 .1 .$/9/#0 %#3 :.#0">4"#:"0 .1 #.#@3/0:$/,/#%2/.#

&%6 %#3 -$":"3"#:" :.4$2 3":/0/.#0 :.#:"$#/#9 25" ",-&.'"" 0"&":2/.# -$.:"007

S\ GI[N7GG /#!!-0 LGHNOM7

U+""( 1.$ /#02%#:"( ]K%,-&" GJ /# ]]^D LS[[IM7

J+"" !42,%# LS[[U( S[[JM 1.$ %# .)"$)/"6 .1 -$":"3"#:" :%0"0 %#3 :.4$2 3":/0/.#07

W+"" 0":2/.# GW@C_ PZ$.%:2/)" Z$")"#2/.#R ]]^D LS[[IM7

ID&%$3' LS[[UM7

G

(4)

=' 25" <.4$2""#25 F,"#3,"#2 $/952 2. ]>4%& Z$.2":2/.# -$.5/=/2/#9 25"/$ ",-&.'"$ 2.

)/.&%2" 25"/$ :.#02/242/.#%& $/9520 /# ,%V/#9 -"$0.##"& 3":/0/.#07N 8"#:"( :/)/& 0"$)/:"

",-&.'""0 :%# 2'-/:%&&' 3",%#3 %3,/#/02$%2/)" %#3 .12"# ")"# Y43/:/%& $")/"6 .1 %3)"$0"

",-&.',"#2 3":/0/.#07 A5" 1"3"$%& 9.)"$#,"#2 /20"&1 5%0 25"$"1.$" :.,,/22"3 2. % 0"2 .1 $4&"0 &%/3 .42 /# 25"-'*.$,/+: ;$+#$%< =#$%/>8$,/(+ 7,$+6$.62 4(. 5*+*.$% 78?*61

#%* 9(2/,/(+27O <.$ 0-":/?"3 5/"$%$:5/:%& -.0/2/.#0( 25/0 ,%#4%& &/020 "34:%2/.#%& 3"9$""

%#3 25" :.$$"0-.#3/#9 04=02/242" -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" $">4/$","#20 65"# 0"&":2/#9

",-&.'""0 1.$ )%:%#2 Y.=07

+4:5 ,%#4%&0 :%# =" 1.4#3 25$.495.42 25" *+ -4=&/: 0":2.$7H 8.6")"$( 25" $"0-":@

2/)" -$/#:/-&"0 %$" &/V"&' 2. =" %--&/"3 /,-&/:/2&' .$ "K-&/:/2&' /# ,%#' -$/)%2" ?$,0 %0 6"&&7 84,%# $"0.4$:"0 3"-%$2,"#20 6/25/# ?$,0 25"# "#04$" :.,-&/%#:" 34$/#9 25" "#@

2/$" $":$4/2,"#2 -$.:"00 @ 5"#:"( 1$., %3)"$2/0/#9 25" Y.= .-"#/#9 2. 25" ?#%& :.#2$%:2

#"9.2/%2/.#07 D.#0">4"#2&'( 0"22/#9 >4%&/?:%2/.# $">4/$","#20 /# 0"&":2/.# -$.:"00"0 /0 04=Y":2 2. % 26.1.&3 0"2 .1 &/,/2%2/.#0` 25" 02%#3%$30 25",0"&)"0 ,402 =" $"%0.#%=&"

04:5 %0 #.2 2. "K:&43" >4%&/?"3 /#3/)/34%&07 T.$".)"$( -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" 9%/#"3 /#

0/,/&%$ @ 2'-/:%&&'( $"a":2/#9 :%$""$ 2$%:V0( 5/"$%$:5/:%&&' /#1"$/.$ @ -.0/2/.#0 6/25/# 25"

?$, :%# 04=02/242" 1.$ % &%:V .1 1.$,%& "34:%2/.#7 ]:.#.,/:%&&' 0-"%V/#9( 25"0" $4&"0 :.#02$%/# 25" 40" .1 /#1.$,%2/)" 0/9#%&0 /# ",-&.'"" 0"&":2/.# -$.:"00"0 25%2 :.,=/#"

-$"@0"&":2/.# %::.$3/#9 2. 3.:4,"#2"3 "34:%2/.#%& 3"9$""0 %#3 -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:"

6/25 1.&&.6@4- Y.=@/#2"$)/"60 .$ .25"$ 2"02/#9 -$.:"34$"07

^$9%#/b%2/.#%& %#3 %00"00,"#2 -0':5.&.9' 2'-/:%&&' %004,"0 25%2 25" 54,%# $"@

0.4$:"0 3"-%$2,"#2X0 9.%& /0 2. ,%K/,/b" 25" ?$,X0 P42/&/2'R 1$., ",-&.'"" 0"&":2/.#7 ]:.#.,/:%&&'( 25/0 .=Y":2/)" %,.4#20 2. ,%K/,/b/#9 25" "K-":2"3 .#@25"@Y.= %=/&/2' .1 25" 9$.4- .1 $":$4/207G[ ^4$ 25".$"2/:%& ,.3"& 3")"&.-"3 ="&.6 %49,"#20 25" )"$' =%0/:(

02%#3%$3@2"K2=..V 42/&/2' %#%&'0/0 .1 -"$0.##"& 0"&":2/.#GG2. /#:&43" 25$"" 02.:5%02/:%&&'

N+"" D%$&0.# LS[[W( -7 NWU @ NWIM7

OA5/0 ,%#4%& /0 4-3%2"3 %#3 -4=&/05"3 L6/25.42 -4=&/:%2/.# 3%2"M =' 25" *+ ^c:" .1 Z"$0.##"&

T%#%9","#2( d%05/#92.# Q7 D7

HA5" e"6 f.$V +2%2" Q"-%$2,"#2 .1 D/)/& +"$)/:"0X )/"6 .1 g#.6&"39"@+V/&&@F=/&/2'@h%0"3 T/#/,4, i4%&/?:%2/.#0 @ 0"" T%$2/# LS[[WM @ 2540 -$.)/3"0 %# /#2"$"02/#9 0":.#3 "K%,-&" 0/#:" /2 0"20 .42 2.

3"?#" %# P">4/)%&"#:" ">4%2/.#R 2. :.,-42" 04=02/242" -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" $">4/$","#207

G [8.&&/#9 LGHHOM -$.)/3"0 % 04$)"' .1 ,.3"& 02$4:24$"07 +:5,/32 %#3 84#2"$ LGHHOM 04$)"' 25" .$/9/#0

%#3 3")"&.-,"#2 .1 25/0 %--$.%:57

G GT.$" $"?#"3 $":"#2 >4%#2/2%2/)" %--$.%:5"0 /# %00"00,"#2 -0':5.&.9' 1.:40 .# 25" $/0V $"34:2/.#

%0-":20 .1 :.,=/#/#9 -$"@0"&":2/.# %#3 3/;"$"#2 2"020 2. %00"00 P42/&/2'R7 Q" D.$2" LS[[[M -$.)/3"0 % 3/0:400/.# .1 25" 05.$2:.,/#90 .1 25" 02%#3%$3 %--$.%:5"0 %#3 25" $"0-":2/)" $","3/"07 F&0.( 54,%#

$"0.4$:"0 ,%#%9","#2 /#:$"%0/#9&' ",-5%0/0"0 25" -$.:"34$%& ";":20 /# .$9%#/b/#9 P1%/$R ",-&.'"" 0"@

S

(5)

/#3"-"#3"#2 -$"3/:2.$0` "34:%2/.#%& %22%/#,"#2( -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:"( %#3 2"02 0:.$"07 A5" %/, /0 2. /#)"02/9%2" 25" ":.#.,/: ";":20 /#34:"3 =' 25" %=.)" :.#02$%/#20 .# 25"

40" .1 0/9#%&07 +-":/?:%&&'( 6" %004," 25%2 25" ?$, /0 :.,,/22"3 2. -"$1":2&' 04=02/242"

-$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" 1.$ 1.$,%& "34:%2/.# 65"# 3"%&/#9 6/25 %--&/:%2/.#0 .1 :4$$"#2

",-&.'""0 65/&" 25/0 04=02/242/.# /0 &"00 25%# -"$1":2 1.$ %--&/:%#20 1$., .420/3" 25"

?$,7 Q4" 2. /#:$"%0"3 &"9%& $/0V( 25" $"0-":2/)" 04=02/242/.# $%2" %--&/"3 2. .420/3"$

%--&/:%2/.#0 /#:$"%0"0 6/25 5/95"$ ,/#/,4, "34:%2/.#%& $">4/$","#207

^1 :.4$0"( 6/25 /#1.$,%2/)" 0/9#%&0 25" -$.=%=/&/2' .1 ="/#9 5/$"3 ,.#.2.#/:%&&' /#:$"%0"0 /# %&& 25$"" 0/9#%& )%&4"07 8.6")"$( 9/)"# 25" :.#02$%/#20 %=.)"( 25" "K-":2"3

"34:%2/.#%& %22%/#,"#2 .1 .420/3"$ $":$4/20 "K:""30 25%2 .1 :4$$"#2 ",-&.'""07 <4$25"$(

25" 6"39" ="26""# 25" 26. 9$.4-0X "K-":2"3 "34:%2/.#%& &")"&0 6/3"#0 %0 ,/#/,4,

"34:%2/.#%& $">4/$","#20 %$" 3":$"%0"37 d" :%# 25"# 04=Y":2 25/0 0"&":2/.# ,.3"& 2.

",-/$/:%& 2"02/#9 40/#9 % 3%2% 0"2 04--&/"3 =' % &%$9" *+ -4=&/: ",-&.'"$7 A5" 3%2%

%&&.60 2. :.#2$.& 1.$ % #4,="$ .1 :5%$%:2"$/02/:0 25%2 %$" 0-":/?: 2. % -%$2/:4&%$ Y.=@

.-"#/#9( 0"&":2/.# -$.:"00( %#3 /#3/)/34%& %--&/:%#27 d" ?#3 25%2 .4$ ":.#.,"2$/: ,.3"&

%:5/")"0 % P9..3 ?2R /# 3"0:$/=/#9 25" ?$,X0 $":$4/2,"#2 ="5%)/.$7 T.$" /,-.$2%#2&' '"2( /2 $%25"$ 02$.#9&' 04--.$20 25" ":.#.,/: ,":5%#/0,0 3"$/)"3 1$., .4$ 25".$"2/:%&

%--$.%:57

+/#:" 25" 0",/#%& 6.$V .1 <$"",%# LGHNIM %#3 Q4#:%# %#3 8.;,%# LGHOGM( #4@

,"$.40 ",-/$/:%& 0243/"0 1.$ %&,.02 %&& 3")"&.-"3 ":.#.,/"0 5%)" $"-.$2"3 25%2 .)"$"@

34:%2/.# /#:$"%0"0 6%9"0 %#3 ",-&.',"#2 -$.=%=/&/2/"07 F&0.( 25" .)"$"34:%2/.# ";":2 /0 02$.#9"$ 1.$ Y.=0 25%2 $">4/$" 4#0V/&&"3 .$ &.6"$@0V/&&"3 &%=.$ 25%# 1.$ 0V/&&"3 Y.=07GS 8.6")"$( 25" "K-&%#%2/.#0 .;"$"3 1.$ 25"0" ",-/$/:%& ?#3/#90 5%)" 0. 1%$ ,.02&' =""#

&%=.$@,%$V"2 .$/"#2"37 ],-5%0/b/#9 /#"c:/"#2 /#)"02,"#2 /# %=/&/2' 0/9#%&0( %$94,"#20 3"$/)"3 1$., +-"#:"X0 LGHNUM 25".$' .1 &%=.$ ,%$V"2 0/9#%&/#9 %#3 A54$.6X0 LGHNWM 25"@

.$' .1 Y.= :.,-"2/2/.# :.,-"2" 6/25 +%22/#9"$X0 LGHHUM %00/9#,"#2 25".$' %::.$3/#9 2. 65/:5 =.25 4#",-&.',"#2 %#3 .)"$"34:%2/.# ,/$$.$ 25" 0%," -$.=&", .1 %&&.:%2/#9 5"2"$.9"#".40 &%=.$ 2. 5"2"$.9"#".40 Y.=07GU +/#:" 25" &%22"$ /,-&/"0 25%2 .)"$"34:%2/.#

,%' .#&' =" P-"$:"/)"3R( ,"%04$/#9 .)"$"34:%2/.# 2. .=2%/# :.$$":2 "02/,%2"0 .1 $"24$#0 2. "34:%2/.#%& /#)"02,"#20 =":.,"0 -/).2%& /# 25" $"0-":2/)" ",-/$/:%& 6.$V7GJ

&":2/.#7 <.$ %# .)"$)/"6 0"" E'%# %#3 Z&.'5%$2 LS[[[M7

G S+"" !$..2 %#3 T%%0"# )%# 3"# h$/#V LS[[[M7

G U8%$2.9 LS[[[M7

G JA5" 0243/"0 =' h%4"$ LS[[SM( hj:5"& %#3 Z.&&,%##@+:54&2 LS[[UM( D5")%&/"$ LS[[UM( T"/"$ "2 %&7 LS[[JM( d/$2b %#3 F24V"$"# LS[[WM( %#3 h$'#/# "2 %&7 LS[[IM %$" /&&402$%2/)" 1.$ 25" )%$/"2' .1 -.00/=&"

":.#.,"2$/: %--$.%:5"0 %#3 -$.)/3" $":"#2 %--&/:%2/.#0 2. 3/;"$"#2 :.4#2$/"07

U

(6)

F0 /0 %&0. 6"&& V#.6#( 2$%/#/#9 -$.9$%,0 .1 ?$,0 -$"3.,/#%#2&' 2%$9"2 25" ,.$" >4%&@

/?"37GW F::.$3/#9 2. 25" :%$""$ ,.=/&/2' %--$.%:5(GI %::"-2/#9 P4#3"$>4%&/?"3 6.$VR /# "%$&' :%$""$ 02%9"0 25"# "#5%#:"0 25" /#3/)/34%&X0 :%$""$ -$.9$"007GN ^#&' 25/0 &%2@

2"$ "K-&%#%2.$' %--$.%:5 25"$"1.$" "K-&/:/2&' $"&%2"0 2. 54,%# $"0.4$:"0 3")"&.-,"#2 6/25/# ?$,0 %#3 5%0 @ 2. .4$ V#.6&"39" @ % 0/#9&" 2/," 0. 1%$ =""# "K-.0"3 2. 2"02/#9 40/#9 ?$,@&")"& 3%2%7 8"#:"( !$."#")"&3 %#3 8%$2.9 LS[[UM 3",.#02$%2" 25" )%&/3/2' .1 25" :%$""$ ,.=/&/2' %--$.%:5 1.$ Y.=0 05"&2"$"3 6/25/# % ?$,X0 /#2"$#%& &%=.$ ,%$V"27 D.#0">4"#2&'( 25"' :.#:&43" 25%2 25" .)"$"34:%2/.# ";":2 .# 6%9"0 :%##.2 =" %22$/=42"3 2. ?$, ?K"3 ";":20 =42 $%25"$ $"a":20 02$%2"9/: 3":/0/.#0 .1 ?$,07 A5" :.#2$/=42/.# .1 .4$ %#%&'0/0 /0 25"# 26.1.&3` ?$02( 6" :.#?$, 25" "K/02"#:" .1 %# .)"$"34:%2/.# ";":2 .# 5/$/#9 -$.=%=/&/2/"0 /# %# "#)/$.#,"#2 /# 65/:5 25" ?$, -"$:"/)"0 /20"&1 %0 % &%=.$

,%$V"2 ,.#.-.&/027 +":.#3( 6" 05.6 25%2 @ %49,"#2/#9 25" :%$""$ ,.=/&/2' %--$.%:5 @ 25/0 0"&":2/.# ="5%)/.$ ,%' %:24%&&' =" /#34:"3 =' /#02/242/.#%& :.#02$%/#207

A5" $",%/#3"$ .1 25/0 -%-"$ /0 .$9%#/b"3 %0 1.&&.60` 2. ="9/# 6/25 25" #"K2 0":2/.#

/#1.$,0 %=.42 25" 0"&":2/.# -$.:"00 %0 /2 5%0 =""# 3"0:$/="3 /# /#2"$)/"60 6/25 25"

?$,X0 54,%# $"0.4$:"0 3"-%$2,"#27 !/)"# 25/0 3"0:$/-2/.#( 6" 3")"&.- 25" 25".$"2/:%&

,.3"& %#3 3"$/)" 2"02%=&" 5'-.25"0"07 +":2/.# U 25"# -$.)/3"0 % 3"0:$/-2/.# .1 25"

3%2%( 3")"&.-0 25" ":.#.,"2$/: %--$.%:5( %#3 $"-.$20 .4$ ",-/$/:%& ?#3/#907 A5" -%-"$

:.#:&43"0 6/25 % 04,,%$' %#3 3/0:400/.#7

+ ,-. $-.&%.$*) /00%&/)-

+1! 2.3)%*0$*&# &4 $-. *#3$*$($*&#/5 3.$$*#6

A5" 25".$"2/: ,.3"& 2. =" 2"02"3 ",-/$/:%&&' %3%-20 25" 02%#3%$3 $":$4/2,"#2 ,.3"& /#

26. 6%'07 </$02( 6" /#2$.34:" 0-":/?: %004,-2/.#0 :.#:"$#/#9 25" 0">4"#2/%& 02$4:24$"

.1 25" 0"&":2/.# -$.:"00 %#3 25" =/#3/#9 .$ #.#@=/#3/#9 #%24$" .1 ,/#/,4, >4%&/?:%2/.#

$">4/$","#207 A5"0" %004,-2/.#0 %$" 3"$/)"3 1$., >4%&/2%2/)" /#2"$)/"60 6/25 "K":42/)"

,%#%9"$0 .1 25" 54,%# $"0.4$:" 3"-%$2,"#2 .1 25" ?$, 04--&'/#9 /20 3%2%7 +":.#3(

G W+"" "7 97 B/9#.&"0 "2 %&7 LS[[JM 1.$ % 04$)"' %#3 % $":"#2 ",-/$/:%& /#)"02/9%2/.#7

G I+/:5"$,%# %#3 !%&.$ LGHH[M7

G NC# 25/0 $"0-":2( 8"$0:5 LGHHGM 5%0 %&$"%3' #.2"3 25%2 .#@25"@Y.= 2$%/#/#9 .--.$24#/2/"0 :.,-"#0%2"

1.$ 25" #.#@-":4#/%$' :.020 %00:.:/%2"3 6/25 Y.= 3/00%2/01%:2/.#7 <.$ !"$,%#'( hj:5"& LS[[[M 05.60 25%2(

:.#2$.&&/#9 1.$ 14$25"$ 2$%/#/#9( 25"$" "K/02 #. 0'02",%2/: ";":20 .1 Y.= 3/00%2/1%:2/.# .# -$.34:2/)/2'7

J

(7)

02%2/02/:%& /#3"-"#3"#:" %#3 .25"$ 0/,-&/1'/#9 %004,-2/.#0 0"$)" 2. V""- 25" %#%&'0/0 :&"%$&' 2$%:2%=&" /# % ,4&2/@-$"3/:2.$ "#)/$.#,"#2 %#3 2. 5/95&/952 25" 3$/)/#9 ":.#.,/:

,":5%#/0,0 .1 25" $":$4/2,"#2 -$.:"007

A5/0 -$.:"00 /0 ="02 3"0:$/="3 %0 % 02"-@6/0" -$.:"34$"7 C2 ="9/#0 65"# 25" ?$,X0

$"0-.#0/=&" ?#%#:/%& "K":42/)" .c:"$ L@!-M %9$""0 2. % Y.= .-"#/#9 3",%#3"3 =' 25"

L&/#"M 3"-%$2,"#2 .1 ",-&.',"#2 LA(!M7 C# % ?$02 02"-( 25" 54,%# $"0.4$:"0 3"-%$2,"#2 LBCM %#3A(! ,402 25"# %9$"" .# 25" :&%00/?:%2/.# .1 25" Y.= /# 2"$,0 .1 25" =4#3&"

.1 2%0V0 "K-":2"3 2. =" :%$$/"3 .42( /20 5/"$%$:5/:%& %#3 .$9%#/b%2/.#%& /,="33"3#"00(

%#3 25" ,/#/,4, "34:%2/.#%& %#3 -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" $">4/$","#207 A5/0 %9$"","#2 3"2"$,/#"0 % 0%&%$' $%#9" 65/:5 :%# &%2"$ .#&' =" 02$"2:5"3 =' 0-":/%& :.#0"#2 .1@!-7 A5" /#2"$)/"60 $")"%&"3 25%2BC:.#0/3"$0 25" ?$, @ =' 1%$ ="/#9 25" &%$9"02 ",-&.'"$

/# 25" $"9/.# @ 2. )/$24%&&' -.00"00 ,.#.-0.#' -.6"$7 C# 1%:2( $")/0/.#0 .1 25" 0%&%$'

$%#9" ='@!- :.#02/242" )"$' $%$" "K:"-2/.#07 !"#"$%&&'( 25" ?$,X0 0%&%$' $%#9"0 %$"

04c:/"#2&' %22$%:2/)" 1.$ %--&/:%#207

C# % 0":.#3 02"-( BC ,402 %3)"$2/0" 25" Y.= .-"#/#90 -4=&/:&' @ /7"7 =' -.02/#90

%#3 3"-%$2,"#2%& ,%/& 6/25/# 25" ?$,( )/% #"60-%-"$ %30( %#3 .# 25" /#2"$#"27 k.=0 .1 25" 0%," :&%00/?:%2/.# 65/&" %&&.:%2"3 2. 3/;"$"#2A(!0 %$" %3)"$2/0"3 Y./#2&'7 8"#:"(

2'-/:%&&' % $":$4/2,"#2 -$.:"00 %/,0 %2 5/$/#9 % 9$.4- .1 %--&/:%#207 A5" %3)"$2/0","#20 :.,,4#/:%2" 25" Y.= :&%00/?:%2/.#( 0%&%$' $%#9"0( %#3 25" ,/#/,4, "34:%2/.#%& %#3 -$.1"00/.#%& $">4/$","#207 +4=0">4"#2&'(BC$":"/)"0 %--&/:%2/.#0 1$., 6/25/# %#3 .42@

0/3" 25" ?$, 65/:5 :.#2%/# )"$/?%=&" 3.:4,"#20 :.#:"$#/#9 "34:%2/.#%& %22%/#,"#20 %#3 -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:"07 C#2"$#%& %--&/:%2/.#0 %$" ,.2/)%2"3 =' 25" :5%#:" 2. #"9.2/%2"

% 5/95"$ 0%&%$' 6/25/# 25" 0%&%$' $%#9"7 BC $"0"$)"0 25" $/952 2. $"Y":2 %--&/:%2/.#0 1.$ 1.$,%& $"%0.#0 @ "797 /1 25" -$.1"00/.#%& >4%&/?:%2/.# .1 25" :%#3/3%2" /0 .=)/.40&' /#%3">4%2"7

F0 ",-5%0/b"3 34$/#9 25" /#2"$)/"60(BC/0 ,%/#&' :.#:"$#"3 6/25 ,/#/,/b/#9 25"

&"9%& :.020 %00.:/%2"3 6/25 -.2"#2/%& 3/0:$/,/#%2/.# :5%$9"0 =$.4952 %9%/#02 25" ?$, =' 4#04::"0014& %--&/:%#207 +-":/?:%&&'( .4$ ?$, ="/#9 % -4=&/: ",-&.'"$ .=0"$)"0 25%2 0:$""#/#9 %--&/:%2/.#0 .# 9$.4#30 .1 1.$,%& "34:%2/.# ="%$0 25" $/0V .1 PF3)"$0" C,@

-%:2R :5%$9"07 F&25.495 25" ?$, "#:.4$%9"0 /20 ",-&.'""0 2. "#$.&& /# 14$25"$ "34:%2/.#

-$.9$%,0 %#3 .=2%/# 1.$,%& 3"9$""0( /2 %&0. %::"-20 25%2 -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" :%# 04=@

02/242" 1.$ &%:V/#9 "34:%2/.#%& 3"9$""07 !/)"# 25" %$94,"#2 25%2 "34:%2/.#%& 02%#3%$30 ,%' :.#:"%& 3/0:$/,/#%2.$' -$%:2/0"0( 25" $%2" .1 04=02/242/.# /0 -"$:"/)"3 %0 /#:$"%0/#9

W

(8)

6/25 ,/#/,4, "34:%2/.#%& $">4/$","#207GO

A%V"# 2. /20 25".$"2/: "K2$","( 6" 25"$"1.$" %004," 25%2 %--&/:%#20 65. :%# 3.:4@

,"#2 25%2 25" 04, .1 25"/$ "34:%2/.#%& %#3 -$.1"00/.#%& %:5/")","#20 "K:""30 25" 04, .1 25" $"0-":2/)" 26. ,/#/,4, $">4/$","#20 :%##.2 =" 0:$""#"3 .427 C# -$/#:/-&"( 25/0 $4&"

%--&/"0 2. %&& %--&/:%2/.#07 8.6")"$( 0/#:" Y.= $">4/$","#20 %#3 25"/$ :.$$"0-.#3/#9 3"@

0:$/-2/.#0 %&6%'0 :.#2%/# 0.," ?$,@0-":/?: "&","#20( 25" &"9%& $/0V .1 0:$""#/#9 /0 &.6"$

65"# 3"%&/#9 6/25 %--&/:%2/.#0 1$., .420/3" 25" ?$,7 A5".$"2/:%&&'( 6" %004," 25%2 25" -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" :&%/,"3 =' .420/3"$0 /0 3/0:.4#2"3 65"# :5":V/#9 65"25"$

%# %--&/:%2/.# ,""20 25" ,/#/,4, $">4/$","#207GH A5" %=.)" 25"# /,-&/"0 25%2 25"

$"0-":2/)" 3/0:.4#2 $%2" 3":$"%0"0 /# 25" %3)"$2/0"3 ,/#/,4, "34:%2/.#%& 02%#3%$37 C# 25" 25/$3 02"- .1 25" $":$4/2,"#2 -$.:"00( %&& %--&/:%#20 65.( 9/)"# 25" 3/;"$"#:"

/# 0:$""#/#9 /#0/3"$0 %#3 .420/3"$0( -%00 25" $"0-":2/)" 0"&":2/.# :$/2"$/% %$" 25"# -..&"3

%#3 04=Y":2"3 2. 25" 0%," 0"2 .1 Y.=@0-":/?: %=/&/2' 2"0207 A5"0" 2"020 %&6%'0 /#:&43" Y.=

/#2"$)/"60 6/25 %#3 1.$,%&&' ")%&4%2"3 ='A(!7 D.#3/2/.#%& .# 25" Y.= 2'-"( .25"$ 2"020 .1 :.9#/2/)" %=/&/2/"0 %#3l.$ #.#@:.9#/2/)" 0V/&&0 ,%' =" %33"37 ])%&4%2/#9 25" $"04&20 .1 25"0" 2"020(A(! ,%V"0 5/0 5/$/#9 :5./:"0 2. =" /,-&","#2"3 ='BC7 8.6")"$( ="1.$"

#"9.2/%2/.#0 6/25 25" 04::"0014& %--&/:%#20 ="9/#(BC :%$$/"0 .42 % $%2/.#%&/2' :5":V .1 A(!X0 :5./:"07 ^4$ /#2"$)/"60 $")"%&"3 25%2BC 0-":/?:%&&' %/,0 2. "#04$" 25%2 2"02 02%#3%$30 5%)" #.2 =""# L$"@M3"?#"3 2. ,""2 % 0-":/?: %--&/:%#2X0 -$.?&"7

+4,,%$/b/#9( 26. )"$/?%=&" 0/9#%&0 @ "34:%2/.#%& 3"9$"" %#3 -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:"

@ %$" %)%/&%=&" 1.$ 0:$""#/#9 %--&/:%#20 2. =" -%00"3 .# 2. 2"02/#97 8.6")"$( .#&' 25"

04, .1 25" 26. 6/25 -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" 3/0:.4#2"3 /# .420/3"$ %--&/:%2/.#0 ,402 ,""2 25" :42@.; :$/2"$/.#7 A"02/#9 25"# :.#02/242"0 % :.02&' %:2/)/2' 65/:5 9"#"$%2"0 '"2

% 25/$3 0/9#%&7

A5"$" :&"%$&' "K/020 02%2/02/: :.$$"&%2/.# ="26""# 25"0" 0/9#%&07 <.$ /#02%#:"( 5.&3/#9

%9" :.#02%#2( 25" 34$%2/.# .1 1.$,%& "34:%2/.# %#3 -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" 05.4&3 ="

#"9%2/)"&' :.$$"&%2"37S[ F&0.( 25" 3"9$"" .1 1.$,%& "34:%2/.# %#3 %# /#3/)/34%&X0 -"$@

G OA. -42 /2 ,.$" =&%#V&'( /1 % 9%$3"#"$X0 Y.= 6.4&3 =" %3)"$2/0"3 2. $">4/$" % Z5Q /# =.2%#/:0( ")"$'

&"00 "34:%2"3 ,",="$ .1 % 0.:/%&&' 3/0%3)%#2%9"3 9$.4- 65. :.4&3 -$.)" 2. 5%)" "K-"$/"#:" /# &%6#

,.6/#9 :.4&3 04::"0014&&' :&%/, 2. 5%)" =""# 3/0:$/,/#%2"37

G H8"#:"( % 2.- "K":42/)"X0 0":$"2%$' ,%' =" $">4/$"3 2. -.00"00 % hF@3"9$""7 8.6")"$( 0/#:" 25/0

$">4/$","#2 3."0 #.2 %--&' 2. 0":$"2%$' -.0/2/.#0 /# 9"#"$%&( /#2"$#%& :%#3/3%2"0 .# % :%$""$ 2$%:V :%##.2

=" "K:&43"37 C# :.#2$%02( .420/3"$0 :%# =" 0:$""#"3 .42 =' :&%/,/#9 25%2 25" -.0/2/.# $">4/$"0 ?$,@0-":/?:

V#.6&"39"7 8"#:"( 25"/$ -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" /0 P3/0:.4#2"3R7

S [],-/$/:%&&'( 6" :%# :.#2$.& 1.$ 25/0 ";":2 =' "#2"$/#9 %9" %0 %# "K-&%#%2.$' )%$/%=&"7 +"" F#3"$0.#

I

(9)

1.$,%#:" /# :.9#/2/)" %=/&/2' 2"020 05.4&3 =" -.0/2/)"&' :.$$"&%2"37SG 8.6")"$( %004,/#9 02.:5%02/: /#3"-"#3"#:" ="26""# 0/9#%&0 0"$)"0 2. /3"#2/1' 25" ":.#.,/: ,":5%#/0,0 3$/)/#9 25" .42:.," .1 25/0 -$.:"00 .1 0:$""#/#9 %#3 2"02/#97

+1+ ,-. 7&'.5

+1+1! 8/3*) /33(70$*&#3 /#' #&$/$*&#3

!/)"# 25" %=.)"( &"2 .#@25"@Y.= %=/&/2'!=" /3"#2/:%&&' %#3 /#3"-"#3"#2&' 3/02$/=42"3

"!#$ %!!".)"$ 25" 26. -.-4&%2/.#0 .1 %--&/:%#20 3"#.2"3 /#0/3"$0 %#3 .420/3"$07 <4$25"$(

25" 3"9$"" .1 1.$,%& 0:5..&/#9&( -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:"'( %#3 -.2"#2/%& 2"02 0:.$"0(

%$" V#.6# 2. =" /3"#2/:%&&'( /#3"-"#3"#2&'( %#3 02%#3%$3 #.$,%&&' 3/02$/=42"3 .)"$ 25"0"

26. -.-4&%2/.#07 F0 404%&(#!)"%#3 *!)"() ! "&$ '$ (#( 3"#.2" 25" 02%#3%$3 #.$,%&

3/02$/=42/.# %#3 3"#0/2' 14#:2/.#07

BC5%0 :%$$/"3 .42 -$"@2"020 2. )%&/3%2" 25%2

!$+%,"&%,#'%,$(%- LGM 65"$" - $ "!&$ %!%" /0 % ,"%04$","#2 "$$.$ 6/25 ./0!-$ )" $ & 1.$ ) ! "!$ &$ '$ (#7 F0 "K-&%/#"3 %=.)"( 6" %&0. %004," 25%2 ./0!&$ '" $./0!&$ (" $ ./0!'$ (" $ &7 C#

:.#2$%02( &"21!&%&3"#.2" 25" :."c:/"#2 .1 :.$$"&%2/.# ="26""# %=/&/2' %#3 25" -$"3/:2.$

)() ! "&$ '$ (#7 A5"#(+ $#%#3 ,& $ '!"((!

" 7 A. L0/9#/?:%#2&'M ":.#.,/b" .# 0-%:"

%#3 #.2%2/.#( 6" %004," 25%21!#$1!"$2/# 25" 1.&&.6/#97 A5/0 %004,-2/.# 3."0 #.2 /,-&' 25%2 25" 26. 0/9#%&0 %$" /3"#2/:%&7 E%25"$( 25"' .#&' 0"$)" ">4%&&' 6"&& %0 %=/&/2' -$"3/:2.$07 <4$25"$ 0/,-&/1'/#9 #.2%2/.#0( &"21!$$17

e.6( 04--.0" 25%2BC$">4/$"0 ,/#/,4, "34:%2/.#%& >4%&/?:%2/.#3%#3 -$.1"00/.#%&

"K-"$/"#:"42. 0"&":2 %# %--&/:%#2 1.$ 14$25"$ 2"02/#97 m"25)&&%'%#3'&3%47 e.2" 25%25)$"!&$("%#3 3"#.2" 25" $"0-":2/)" 3/02$/=42/.# %#3 3"#0/2' 14#:2/.#0 =' ))!5)"%#36)!5)"7 <4$25"$( %&& %--&/:%#20 65.0" 2"02 0:.$" 0%2/0?"0(%76/&& %:24%&&'

=" 5/$"37 !/)"# 25" /#02/242/.#%& :.#02$%/#20 3"0:$/="3 %=.)"( 25" "K-":2"3 %=/&/2' .1

"2 %&7 LS[[JM :.#:"$#/#9 25" /#2"$%:2/.# .1 :.,,.#&' 40"3 -$"3/:2.$07

S GC# 25/0 $"0-":2( 6" ,402 %004," 25%2BCX0 2"02 3"0/9# 3."0 #.2 0/,-&' $"-&/:%2" 25" ";":20 .1 0:$""#/#9 /#5"$"#2 2. "34:%2/.#%& -$.9$%,07

N

(10)

/#0/3"$ $":$4/20 :%# 25"# =" 3"$/)"3 %0

8)"!*3$ 4$ 7#$ LSM

#%%!

!1!"8"&'5)%'#%1!#8"''5) %'#%1!$8"('(%7#"

$

#%%!

#( (2

$ !

"

5) 9))!5)"

!+)))!'""%1

$ !

*

( 9#!("

!+)# !7""

% 7

<.$ .420/3"$0 &"2 : ! !&$+" 3"#.2" 25" P3/0:.4#2R 1%:2.$ ,"%04$/#9 25" 1$%:2/.#

.1 %# .420/3"$X0 3.:4,"#2"3 -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" 25%2 >4%&/?"0 1.$ 25" Y.= .-"#/#9

%3)"$2/0"3 =' 25" ?$,7SS A. 1.:40 .# 25" /#1.$,%2/.#%& %0-":20 .1 25" 0:$""#/#9 -$.:"00(

6" %004," 25%2 25/0 P3/0:.4#2/#9R .1 .420/3"$0X -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" .#&' %;":20 25"

-.00/=/&/2' 2. "#1.$:" 25" 0:$""#/#9 :$/2"$/%3%#347 ]&0"( /2 ="%$0 #. LP$"%&RM ";":20 .#

25" -$"3/:2.$ )%&4" .1 -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:"7 F0 3/0:400"3 %=.)"( 6" 0-":/?:%&&' %004,"

25%2:$:!3"( 6/25:!!3";&( %#3,-.+"!:!3" $ +7 A540( %0BC$%/0"0 25" ,/#/,4,

"34:%2/.#%& $">4/$","#2( %# .420/3"$X0 -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" /#:$"%0/#9&' 0"$)"0 %0 % 04=02/242" 1.$ &%:V/#9 1.$,%& "34:%2/.#7

m"22/#9 5, $ &%:!3"'( #.2" 25%2 5, $ "!&$+ % !:!3""!"7 A5"#( 3"#.2" 25"

$"0-":2/)" 3/02$/=42/.# %#3 3"#0/2' 14#:2/.#0 ='),!5,*:!3""%#36,!5,*:!3""7 8"#:"(

25" "K-":2"3 %=/&/2' .1 .420/3"$ $":$4/20 :%# =" .=2%/#"3 %0

8,"!*3$ 4$ 7#$ LUM

#%%!!

1!"8"&'5,%'#%1!#8"''5,%'#%1!$8"('(%7#"

$

#%%!

&

' (2

(

+ % !:!3""!

$ !

"

5, 9),!5,*:!3""

!+)),!'*:!3"""%1

$ !

*

( 9#!("

!+)# !7""

)

* 7

^=)/.40&'( 25" %=.)" :%&:4&%2/.#0 .1 "K-":2"3 %=/&/2/"0 3",%#3 25%2 =.25 9$.4-0 .1 %--&/:%#20 %$" 04c:/"#2&' &%$9"7 <.$ 0/,-&/:/2'( 6" 14$25"$ %004," 25%2 25"' %$" .1 /3"#2/:%& 0/b""7 !/)"# 25%2 25"$" %$"< .-"#/#90( 25" $":$4/2,"#2 -$.:"00 ,402 25"#

"#04$" 25%2

!+)# !7""

&

' +

-#).,

,+))-!'"- )

*$ <

" LJM

S S^=)/.40&'( /2 6.4&3 =" ,.$" %3">4%2" 2. %004," 25%2 %# /#3/)/34%& .420/3"$X0 -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:"

/0 04=Y":2 2. % 3/0:.4#2 1%:2.$!65"$"!:.#02/242"0 % $%#3., )%$/%=&" 6/25 "K-":2"3 )%&4""7 A540(

%::.4#2/#9 .#&' 1.$ 25" "K-":2"3 )%&4" .1 3/0:.4#2/#9 /,-&/"0 25%2 25" 3/02$/=42/.# .1!/0 /#3"-"#3"#2 .1 25" /#3/)/34%&X0 0/9#%& -$.?&"!#$ %$ &"7

O

(11)

65"$" /0 /0 2%V"# 2. =" 0,%&&"$ 25%# .#"7 A5" ?$,X0 .=Y":2/)" 2. =" /,-&","#2"3

='BC/0 3"?#"3 %0 ,%K/,/b/#9 25" "K-":2"3 %=/&/2' 81"!*3$ 4$ 7#$

.

-#).,

,+))-!'"-

8-"!*3$ 4$ 7#

$.

-#).,!+))-!'"" LWM

.1 /20 #"6 $":$4/20 #"2 .1 25" :.020. %00.:/%2"3 6/25 25" %=/&/2' 2"0207 <.&&.6/#9 25"

&/2"$%24$" .# 2"02/#9 1.$ $":$4/2,"#2( 25"0" :.020 %$" ?K"3 %#3 $"a":2BCX0 :5./:" .1 25"

2"02 3"0/9#7SU ^=)/.40&'( #. 04:5 :.020 ,402 =" /#:4$$"3 /1 25" $":$4/2,"#2 3":/0/.#0 %$"

=%0"3 .#&' .# 25" "34:%2/.#%& %#3 -$.1"00/.#%& /#1.$,%2/.# 04--&/"3 =' 25" %--&/:%#20 25",0"&)"07

+1+1+ 9)%..#*#6 /#' $.3$*#6 :*$- &#5; &#. 6%&(0 &4 /005*)/#$3

<.:400/#9 .# 0"&":2/#9 $":$4/20 1$., .#&' .#" 9$.4- .1 %--&/:%#20 0"$)"0 ="02 2. /&&402$%2"

25" ":.#.,/: ,":5%#/0, 9.)"$#/#9 25/0 -%$2/:4&%$ $":$4/2,"#2 -$.:"007 8"#:"( 2. ="9/#

6/25( 0"2),!'" $ +/# LWM %#3 LJM %=.)"7 A540( 6" %004," 25%2 25"$" %$" .#&' /#2"$#%&

%--&/:%2/.#07 A5" $"0-":2/)" m%9$%#9"@14#:2/.# :%# =" 3"$/)"3 %0

*) $ =!7"!

8)"!*3$ 4$ 7# )."

% !+)=!7""

/ ,-.

*#"#!8)"!*3$ 4$ 7# 0

)>)

#

!+)# !7"",

+)))!'"- )<

"

%

LIM 65"$"

=!7" $

1 + /1#!7"!!&$+/

& /1#!7" $ & LNM

3"#.2"0 %# /#3/:%2.$ 14#:2/.# 65/:5 %&&.60 2. :%-24$" 25" .--.$24#/2' :.02 #%24$" .1.7 A5" ?$02@.$3"$ :.#3/2/.#0 :%# =" $"%$$%#9"3 2. '/"&3`

=!7" 08)"!*3$ 4$ 7# ).) ,-.

*#"#!8)"!*3$ 4$ 7# 1 $

+ 2

&( LOM

/1#!7"

1%

$ 2

&n

S UA5/0 %004,-2/.# 3."0 #.2 :.#a/:2 6/25 25" 1%:2 25%2 P2"02/#9R ,%' .#&' :.#0/02 .1 Y.= /#2"$)/"607 A5" 2/," 25%2A(!@,%#%9"$0 6/&& 5%)" 2. 0-"#3 .# 04:5 /#2"$)/"60 /0 -$"%$$%#9"3 %#3 $"0"$)"3 ='BC7 A5" #4,="$ .1 %--&/:%#20 25"# .#&' %;":20 25" 34$%2/.# .1 25" %)"$%9" /#2"$)/"6 %#3( 2540( 25" >4%&/2' '.1 25" $"0-":2/)" /#1.$,%2/.#7

H

(12)

? ! "3$ 4#0 >)!+)# !7"" % =!7"

6)!'".$ LHM

%!( (2

!+)))!'""

3

')

$ !

"

5) 9)), 5)-

!+)))!'""

4 n

7 0 >),

+)))!'"-

$ LG[M

%!1

!+)# !7""

/ 7)

$ !

*

( 9#!("

!+)# !7""

0

( /1=!7" $ +7

A5"0" :.#3/2/.#0 /,,"3/%2"&' $")"%& 26. /,-.$2%#2 -$.-"$2/"07 </$02( %::.$3/#9 2. LHM(

BC6/&& #")"$ 0"2 0"-%$%2" "34:%2/.#%& %#3 -$.1"00/.#%& ,/#/,4, $">4/$","#20 /1 %--&/@

:%2/.#0 :%# .#&' :.," 1$., 6/25/# 25" ?$,7 +":.#3( .#&' /1BC 3":/3"0 .# %33/2/.#%&

2"02/#9( %# .-2/,4, $":$4/2,"#2 -.&/:' ,%' =" :5%$%:2"$/b"3 =' =%&%#:/#9 25" ,%$9/#%&

$"24$#0 1$., 0"22/#9 %--&/:%2/.# %#3 2"02/#9 02%#3%$307 ^25"$6/0"( "K-":2"3 %=/&/2' /0 0/,-&' 3"2"$,/#"3 =' :5..0/#9'04:5 %0 2. 0%2/01' LJM 1.$# !7" $ &7

C#)"02/9%2/#9 LOM 25"# $")"%&0

18) &8)"!*3$ 4$ 7# ).) ,-.

*#"#!8)"!*3$ 4$ 7#$ LGGM ).%%!1

$ !

*

( 9#!("

!+)# !7"")%!( (2

$ "!

"

5) 9)), 5)- ))

5'6 7

)))!'"

65"$"'6/0 3"?#"3 =' 5

+)))!'"6 7

$/07 F::.4#2/#9 1.$ LJM 9/)"# 25" %=.)" %004,-2/.#

25%2),$ +(,-.*#"#!18) $). @&7 F33/2/.#%& 2"02/#9 :%# 2540 =" .-2/,%& /1 25"

$"0-":2/)" :.020 %$" &.67 F&0.( 25" :."c:/"#2 .1 :.$$"&%2/.# ="26""# %=/&/2' %#3 25" 2"02 0:.$"1 05.4&3 =" &%$9" $"&%2/)" 2.265/:5 $"a":20 25" :.$$"&%2/.# ="26""# %=/&/2' %#3 25" 0/9#%& :.#2"#2 .1 25" %--&/:%2/.# 3.:4,"#207 k.= /#2"$)/"60 %$" &/V"&' 2. >4%&/1' /#

25/0 $"0-":27SJ

<.$ 25" $",%/#3"$( 6" 6/&& %004," 04:5 %# /#2"$/.$ 0.&42/.#7 C# 25" -$"0"#2 :%0"( /2 /,-&/"0

18 7)9!

* (%'2$%$&#$%*&&

: 28

')9!

" 5) 2%'(#%3#&

#(#%"&&

: $ +) .,

+)))!'"- 6)!'"%!8

')9!

" 5) 2%'(#%3#&

#(#%"&&

: ;+7 LGSM

S J+"" "7 97 Q%V/# %#3 F$,02$.#9 LGHOHM %#3( 3/02/#94/05/#9 0"&":2/.# :$/2"$/% /# 9$"%2 3"2%/&( E.="$20.#

%#3 +,/25 LS[[GM7

G[

(13)

F0 "K-":2"3( 25" 2"02/#9 :.020 /#34:" % 3/02.$2/.#7 C# :.#0">4"#:"( 0"&":2/.# %::.$3/#9 2. 2"02 0:.$"0 /0 P.)"$R@$"02$/:2/)"7

+"22/#9))!'" $ +/# LWM %#3 LJM( 25"# %&&.60 2. :5%$%:2"$/b" 25" %&2"$#%2/)" 0:"#%$/.

.1 5/$/#9 .#&' 1$., % -..& .1 .420/3"$07 ^#&' 06/2:5/#9 04-"$0:$/-20( 25" ?$02@.$3"$

:.#3/2/.#0 6/25 $"0-":2 2. =!7" %#3 7 $"02%2" LOM %#3 LG[M 1$., %=.)"7 f"2( LHM /0

$"-&%:"3 ='(

40 >,!+)# !7"" % =!7"

6,!'".$ LGUM

(%!2

!+)),!'""

(

+ % !:!3""! 3

')

$ !

"

5, 9),, 5,-

!+)),!'""

4 n

30 >,!+)# !7"" % =!7"

6,!'".$ LGJM

(%!2

!+)),!'""

(

+ % !:!3""! 3

')

$ !

"

5, 9),, 5,-

!+)),!'""

4

% (%!2:$!3":!3"

6,!'"

5

+ % !:!3""! 7!"

$ !

"

5, 9),, 5,-

!+)),!'"" (

65"$" 6" 5%)" ,%3" 40" .1 25" -$.-"$2/"0 .1 25" #.$,%& 3/02$/=42/.# 2. .=2%/# LGJM7 A%V/#9 25" &/,/203, -.1 25" E8+ .1 LGUM %#3 LGJM( 25/0 :.$#"$ 0.&42/.# )/.&%2"0 LJM 0/#:" %&& %--&/:%#20 6.4&3 =" 0:$""#"3 .427 <4$25"$( 2%V/#9 25" $"0-":2/)" &/,/203, )- /,-&/"0 25%2 25" "K-":2"3 0/9#%& )%&4"0 %$" b"$.7 8"#:"( 25" %--&/:%#20X 3.:4,"#20 6.4&3

#.2 =" 40"3 1.$ 0:$""#/#9 %2 %&&7 8.6")"$( 0/#:" 25/0 /#1.$,%2/.# /0 :.02&"00 1.$ 25" ?$,(

25/0 :.$#"$ 0.&42/.# :%# %&0. =" $4&"3 .427 F9%/#( %# /#2"$/.$ 0.&42/.# /0 "#04$"3 /1 /2 /0 .-2/,%& 2. 2"02 25" %--&/:%#207 A5" -$":"3/#9 %$94,"#20 25"# /,-&' 25%2 25/0 0.&42/.#

,402 =" :5%$%:2"$/b"3 ='&@ :!3"@+7

D.,-%$/#9 LGUM %#3 LGJM 6/25 LHM $")"%&0 25%2 25" /#2"$/.$ 0.&42/.# /,-&/"0 3/02/#:2&' 0"-%$%2" ,/#/,4, "34:%2/.#%& %#3 -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" $">4/$","#20 /# 25" .420/3"$@

$":$4/2,"#2 :%0"7 <$., % -4$"&' /#1.$,%2/.#%& ":.#.,/:0 -"$0-":2/)"( P3/0:.4#2/#9R 25"

-$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" .1 .420/3"$0 /#:$"%0"0 25" -$":/0/.# .1 25" 0/9#%& 5, 65/:5 /0 04=Y":2"3 2. 25" :42@.; :$/2"$/.#'7

A6. ";":20 25"# 3"2"$,/#" %# .-2/,%& /#:$"%0" /# -$":/0/.#7 </$02( %0:!3"3":$"%0"0(

25" 26. 0/9#%&0'%#3&:.#2%/#"3 /#5,:%# /#:$"%0/#9&' =" 40"3 0"-%$%2"&' 2. -$"3/:2 GG

(14)

.#@25"@Y.= %=/&/2'7 f"2( 25" -.0/2/)" ";":2 .1 25/0 0/9#%& 0"-%$%2/.# .# 25" -$":/0/.# .1 5,/0 2$%3"3@.; %9%/#02 25" 1%:2 25%2 -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" %&0. $":"/)"0 &"00 6"/952 %0

% -$"3/:2.$ .1 %=/&/2'7 C# 25" "K2$","( 1.$:!3" $ &( "K-"$/"#:" /0 #.2 40"3 1.$ 0:$""#/#9

%2 %&&7

+1+1< =.)%(*$*#6 4%&7 $:& *#'.0.#'.#$ 0&&53 &4 *#3*'.%3 /#' &($3*'.%3

!/)"# 25" 3"0:$/-2/.# .1 25" /#02/242/.#%& 0"22/#9 6/25 ,%#3%2.$' -4=&/: Y.= %3)"$2/0"@

,"#20(BC.$9%#/b"0 25" $":$4/2,"#2 -$.:"00 2. ,%K/,/b" LWM 04=Y":2 2. LJM7 f"2( :5%$@

%:2"$/b/#9 25" 0.&42/.# 3."0 #.2 %33 14$25"$ %#%&'2/: /#0/95207 A5" $"0-":2/)" ?$02@.$3"$

:.#3/2/.#0 6/25 $"0-":2 2. 25" ,/#/,4, "34:%2/.#%& %#3 -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" $">4/$"@

,"#20(3%#34( ,"$"&' :.#2%/# 6"/952"3 04,0 .1 25" 2"$,0 /# LGUM( LGJM( %#3 LHM7 A5"

6"/9520 %$" 9/)"# ='.

-#).,6!'"A.

-#).,

,+))-!'"- 7

8"#:"( 25" :5%$%:2"$/b%2/.#0 %=.)" :%$$' .)"$ /# 25" 0"#0" 25%2( /1 @ 9/)"# 25" :.020 .1 2"02/#9 @ 25" 2"02 0:.$"0 %$" 40"3 1.$ 0"&":2/.#( 25" 0.&42/.# =%&%#:"0 25" ,%$9/#%& $"@

24$#0 1$., 40/#9 %&& 25$"" 0/9#%&0 1.$ $":$4/2,"#27 +"-%$%2" "34:%2/.#%& %#3 -$.1"00/.#%&

"K-"$/"#:" 02%#3%$30 6/&& 25"# =" %3)"$2/0"3 =42 .#&' "#1.$:"3 /# 0:$""#/#9 .420/3"$

%--&/:%2/.#07 A5"0" %#%&'2/: :.#:&40/.#0 /,-&' 25" 1.&&.6/#9 5'-.25"0"0 1.$ ",-/$/:%&

2"02/#9`

BD< -#,2/6*. .*8.#/,2 $.* 8?$.$8,*./E*6 F) ?/:?*. *6#8$,/(+$% %*G*%2 ,?$+ /+2/6*. .*1 8.#/,2H

+/#:" /#0/3"$ %--&/:%2/.#0 $"0",=&" 25" :4$$"#2 02$4:24$" .1 "34:%2/.#%& %22%/#,"#20 /# 25" ?$,X0 &%=.$ 1.$:"( #"6 ",-&.'""0 25"$"1.$" %--"%$ 2. =" P.)"$>4%&/?"3R7 8.6")"$(

",-/$/:%& 04--.$2 1.$ BD :.4&3 %&0. $"a":2 25" :%$""$ ,.=/&/2' %--$.%:57 C# :.#2$%02(

25" 1.&&.6/#9 0-":/?:%&&' %33$"00"0 25" 0:$""#/#9 ,":5%#/0, /#5"$"#2 2. 25" $":$4/2,"#2 ,.3"& %=.)"`

BI< J?* K(G*."#$%/>8$,/(+L *M*8, (+ ,?* :.(#' (4 (#,2/6*. .*8.#/,2 /+8.*$2*2 N/,? %(N*.

&/+/&#& *6#8$,/(+$% 2,$+6$.62 2*, 4(. 2#88*224#% $''%/8$+,2H

F0 "K-&%/#"3 %=.)"( &.6"$ ,/#/,4, "34:%2/.#%& $">4/$","#2038*,*./2 '$./F#2 /#@

GS

(15)

:$"%0" 25" -.00/=/&/2' .1 P3/0:.4#2/#9R 25" -$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" .1 .420/3"$07SW A5/0 -.&/:' /0 .-2/,%& =":%40" /2 /#:$"%0"0 25" -$":/0/.# .1 25" 0:$""#/#9 -$.:"007 +/#:" 25"

";":2 .#&' %--&/"0 2. .420/3"$ %--&/:%2/.#0( $":$4/2/#9 1.$ Y.=0 65/:5 %$" %3)"$2/0"3 2.

$">4/$" $%25"$ &.6 "34:%2/.#%& 3"9$""0 05.4&3 $"04&2 /# $"&%2/)"&' ,.$" P.)"$>4%&/?"3R

#"6 ",-&.'""07

< >70*%*)/5 /#/5;3*3

<1! ,-. '/$/

C# T%' S[[U( 25" ?$, @ % &%$9" *+ -4=&/: ",-&.'"$ @ /#2$.34:"3 %# .#&/#" $":$4/2/#9 0'02",7 +2%$2/#9 6/25 25/0 3%2"( %&& Y.= %--&/:%#20 6"$" $">4/$"3 2. L%&0.M ?&" %# "&":@

2$.#/: %--&/:%2/.# %#3 .=2%/# &.9@/# 40"$#%,"0 %#3 -%006.$307 8"#:"( .4$ 3%2% :.)"$0 25" 2/," -"$/.3 1$., 25" /#2$.34:2/.# .1 25/0 0'02", 2. <"=$4%$' S[[I7 C2 /0 14$25"$

$"02$/:2"3 2. $%#V@%#3@?&" ",-&.'"" .$ &%=.$"$ -.0/2/.#0n $":$4/2,"#2 -$.:"00"0 %/,"3 %2

?&&/#9 "K":42/)" -.0/2/.#0 %$" "K:&43"37 ^4$ 3%2% 0"2 :.,-$/0"0 .12234&.=0"$)%2/.#0 .1 /#3/)/34%&0 65. L%M ?&"3 :.,-&"2" %--&/:%2/.#0 34$/#9 25/0 2/,"@0-%# %#3 L=M "#2"$"3

% $":$4/2,"#2 -$.:"00 65/:5 5%3 $"%:5"3 % ?#%& 3":/0/.# =' 25" "#3 .1 .4$ .=0"$)%2/.#

-"$/.37 F0 :%# =" 0""# 1$., A%=&" G( 25"$" 6"$"+(55.1 04:5 -$.:"00"07

A5" 3%2% 0"2 :.#2%/#0 /#1.$,%2/.# :.#:"$#/#9 25" "34:%2/.#%& %22%/#,"#20 .1 %&&

:%#3/3%2"0 65.0" %--&/:%2/.# 6%0 1.$6%$3"3 2. 25"A(!07 F0 :%# =" )"$/?"3 1$., A%=&"

S( %&& -.00/=&" *+ 3"9$""0 @ /7"7 3.:2.$%2"( ,%02"$( =%:5"&.$( 0.," :.&&"9" "34:%2/.#( 5/95 0:5..& 3"9$""( 5/950:5..& ">4/)%&"#2 3"9$"" L5!AM( %#3 .#&' 0.," 5/95 0:5..& "34:%2/.#

@ :%# =" 1.4#3 %,.#9 =.25 25" %--&/:%#20 %#3 25" $":$4/207 A5" .#&/#" $":$4/2,"#2 0'02", 14$25"$ $">4/$"0 2. "#2"$ 25" %--&/:%#2X0 6.$V "K-"$/"#:"( %9"( 9"#3"$( $%:"( %#3 25" $":$4/2,"#2 :5%##"& =' 65/:5 05" 5%3 =""# %22$%:2"37 ]%:5 %--&/:%2/.# /0 &/#V"3 2.

% Y.=@.-"#/#9 1.$ 65/:5 25" 3%2% 0"2 -$.)/3"0 25" "K-":2"3 3%2" .1 :.,,"#:/#9 6.$V(

-.0/2/.# 2/2&"(A(!( %#3 2'-" .1 %--./#2,"#2 LO(F J)'*M7 A5" &%22"$ $%#9"0 1$.,+1.$

D.#2/#9"#2l^#@D%&& m%=.$ L#. ="#"?20M 2.61.$ E"94&%$l<4&&@A/," ],-&.'"" L"&/9/=&"

1.$ ="#"?20M7

S Wd/25/# 25" :4$$"#2 1$%,"6.$V( 25" 2'-/:%& P:"2"$/0 -%$/=40R :&%40" -%$2/:4&%$&' /,-&/"0 25%2 .25"$

Y.= :5%$%:2"$/02/:0 L2":5#/:%& )07 %3,/#/02$%2/)"( 04-"$/.$ )07 /#1"$/.$ 5/"$%$:5/:%& -.0/2/.# "2:7M %$" 5"&3 :.#02%#27

GU

(16)

*-.# .4$ $">4"02(BC%&0. 04--&/"3 25" $"0-":2/)" %3)"$2/0"3 $">4/$"3 &")"&0 .1 "3@

4:%2/.#( 25" ]>4%& ],-&.',"#2 ^--.$24#/2' L!!-M :.3" #4,="$0 65/:5 /#:$"%0" /#

02"-0 .1 +&-./#20 1$., +&L"K":42/)"( %3,/#/02$%2/)" %#3 ,%#%9"$/%& -.0/2/.#0M 2. 3&

L0"$)/:" %#3 ,%/#2"#%#:" -.0/2/.#0M( 25" <%/$ m%=.$ +2%#3%$30 F:2 02%240 L@P7QM 65/:5 2%V"0 .# 25" )%&4"+/1 25" Y.= /0 "K",-2 L#. .)"$2/," -%'M %#3 b"$. .25"$6/0"( %#3 25"

6.$V-&%:" 0:.$"0 L5.$6*M7 A5" &%22"$ $"a":2 "K-":2%2/.#0 :.#:"$#/#9 25" #":"00%$' 0V/&&0

%#3 "K-"$/"#:"( 25" :.,-&"K/2' .1 25" 2%0V0 %#3 :$"%2/)/2' $">4/$"3 /# "K"$:/0/#9 25",(

25" Y.=X0 /,-%:2 .# 25" ?$,X0 ,/00/.#( "K-.04$" 2. /#2"$#%& %#3 "K2"$#%& :.#2%:20( 25"

3"9$"" .1 3/0:$"2/.# /# 3":/0/.# ,%V/#9( -5'0/:%& 02$"00( %#3 6.$V/#9 :.#3/2/.#07 A5"

6"/9520 %00.:/%2"3 6/25 25"0" 1%:2.$0 %$" 3"2"$,/#"3 :.#0"#04%&&' ='BC %#3 25"A(!

-$/.$ 2. %3)"$2/0/#9 25" Y.= .-"#/#97 A5" $"0-":2/)" 0:.$" :%&:4&%2"3 %0 % 6"/952"3 04, .1 25"0" 1%:2.$0 25"# 3"2"$,/#"0 25" :.,-"#0%2/.# $%#9"7

Q"?#/#9 .)"$>4%&/?:%2/.# %0 -.00"00/#9 % 5/95"$ 25%# 25" %3)"$2/0"3 "34:%2/.#%&

&")"&( 25" ?$02 "#2$/"0 /# 25" =.22., -%$2 .1 A%=&" U $")"%& 25%2 25" ,%Y.$/2' .1 25"

$":$4/20 @ /7"7 748@ 6"$"(G*."#$%/>*6( 65/&"258%:24%&&' -.00"00"3 Y402 25" ,/#/,4,

$">4/$"3 "34:%2/.#%& 3"9$"" L*R$8,%) "#$%/>*6M7 C1 25" %--&/:%2/.#0 6"$" 1.$6%$3"3 =' 3/$":2 :.#2%:2 1$., %A(! LA0AM .$ .25"$ /#2"$#%& $"1"$"#:" LSCM( 6" :&%00/1' 25" $"@

0-":2/)" %--&/:%#20 %0 /#0/3"$07 A5"' :.#02/242"++B58.1 %&& %--&/:%#207 F&& .25"$ $":$4/2@

,"#2 :5%##"&0 @ /7"7 /#/2/%2"3 =' 6"=@=%0"3 Y.= -.02/#9 =.%$3( 25" ?$,X0 .6# 6"=0/2"(

#"60-%-"$ %3)"$2/0","#20 LTNQ6M( Y.= #.2/:"0 0"#2 2. :.&&"9"0 .$ 4#/)"$0/2/"0 LOT3M .$ 2. 25" 02%2" ",-&.',"#2 .c:" L7!-M( %#3 .25"$ L-C0M @ /# 04, 3"?#" .420/3"$

%--&/:%2/.#07 d" :.,=/#" 25" ?$02 26. .1 25" %=.)" 2. =" :&%00/?"3 %0 6"=@$":$4/2,"#2 :5%##"&0 LU*FC8M7

F0 05.6# /# A%=&" U( 25"' %::.4#2 1.$ 25.0"338.1 25" %--&/:%2/.#0 65/:5 3.4=2&"00&' :.," 1$., .420/3" 25" ?$,7 C#0/3"$0 LSCVA0AM 25"# 1.$, 25" &%$9"02 9$.4- %,.#9

$":$4/20 65. %$"#+6*."#$%/>*67 C# :.#2$%02( .420/3"$0 :.#02/242" 25" &%$9"02 9$.4- %,.#9 25" 5/$"3 (G*."#$%/>*6 %--&/:%#207 A5/0 .=0"$)%2/.# :&"%$&' 0499"020 25%2 /#0/3"$ %#3 .420/3"$ %--&/:%2/.#0 $":"/)" $%25"$ 3/;"$"#2 %--$%/0%&0 34$/#9 25" $":$4/2,"#2 -$.:"007

<1+ ,-. .)&#&7.$%*) 7&'.5

A5" 3"-"#3"#2 )%$/%=&"7,$,#2 /# 25" $"9$"00/.# $"-.$2"3 /# A%=&" J 2%V"0 .# 25" )%&4"

+/1 25" %--&/:%#2 /0 5/$"3 %#3 b"$. .25"$6/0"7 D5%$%:2"$/b/#9 25" -%$2/:4&%$ Y.= .-"#@

/#9(5.$6*( 25$"" 3"-%$2,"#2@2'-"0 6/25/# 25" ?$, L25" :"#2$%& %3,/#/02$%2/.#( 25"A(!

GJ

(17)

%3,/#/02$%2/.#( %#3 2":5#/:%& 04--.$2 %#3 0"$)/:"0M( 25"!!- :.3" #4,="$( 25"@P7Q 02%240 )%$/%=&"( %#3O(F J)'* 0"$)" %0 3"-"#3"#2 )%$/%=&"07 A5" :5%$%:2"$/02/:0 .1 25"

-%$2/:4&%$ $":$4/2,"#2 -$.:"00"0 %$" :%-24$"3 =' 25" #4,="$ .1 %--&/:%2/.#0 .1 /#3/)/34@

%&0 65. -.00"00 % 5/95"$ 25%# 25" ,/#/,4, $">4/$"3 "34:%2/.#%& 3"9$"" L-G*."#$%/>*6M

%#3 25" 2.2%& #4,="$ .1 Y.=@:%#3/3%2"0 LQ''%/8$,/(+2M7 C# %33/2/.#( 25" #4,="$ .1 %-@

-&/:%2/.#0 65/:5 40"3 25" 0%," $":$4/2,"#2 :5%##"& LQ''%HW2 C8M $"a":20 25" /#3/)/34%&X0 :.,-"2/2/)" "#)/$.#,"#27

F0 "K-&%/#"3 %=.)"( %# /#0/3"$ %--&/:%2/.# /0 3"?#"3 =' 25" 40" .1 /#2"$#%& $"1"$"#:"07 C#:&43/#9 25" $":$4/2,"#2 :5%##"& 65/:5 5%0 %22$%:2"3 % -%$2/:4&%$ .420/3"$ %--&/:%#2 25"# 0"$)"0 2. "K%,/#" 65"25"$ 25"$" "K/020 % 3.,/#%#2 1.$, .1 %22$%:2/#9 -.2"#2/%&&' 04::"0014& :%#3/3%2"0 1$., .420/3" 25" ?$,7 ^25"$ )%$/%=&"0 :5%$%:2"$/b/#9 25" /#3/)/3@

4%& %--&/:%#2 %$"Q:*(7*R L">4%& 2.+/1 25" %--&/:%#2 /0 ,%&"M( -$.1"00/.#%&!R'*./*+8*(

%#3 25" ,/#.$/2' 02%240 LT(+1U?/,*M7SI *#1.$24#%2"&'( 25" 3%2% .#&' %&&.60 2. /3"#@

2/1' 65"25"$ 25" /#3/)/34%& -.00"00"0 L+M .$ 3."0 #.2 -.00"00 L&M %3">4%2" -$.1"00/.#%&

"K-"$/"#:"0 Y439"3 ='BC7 F0 404%&( 6" %&0. /#:&43" 25" 0>4%$" .1 25" /#3/)/34%&X0 %9"

2. %&&.6 1.$ % #.#@&/#"%$ %9"@-$.34:2/)/2' -$.?&"7 F0 3/0:400"3 =' d..&3$/39" LS[[S(

-7 WJIM( /#:&43/#9 =.25 25" /#3/)/34%&0X0 %9" %#3 "K-"$/"#:" /# 25" $"9$"00/.# 0"$)"0 2.

/3"#2/1' % -.2"#2/%& %9"@3/0:$/,/#%2/.# ";":27

D&"%$&'( 25" )%$/%=&"0 :5%$%:2"$/b/#9 25" %--&/:%#2X0 "34:%2/.#%& =%:V9$.4#3 %$" .1 V"' /#2"$"027 A5" )%$/%=&"!6#8$,/(+ $%#9"0 1$.,&1.$ :.,-&"2"3 ?$02 9$%3" 2.+91.$ % 3.:2.$%2" 3"9$""7 A5/0 :.3/#9 .1 "34:%2/.#%& %22%/#,"#20 40"3 ='BC%&0. ,/$$.$0 25"

/#3/)/34%&X0 2/," 0-"#2 /# 1.$,%& "34:%2/.#7 =#$%/>8$,/(+2%V"0 .# 25" )%&4"(L+(&M /1 25" %--&/:%#2 /0 .)"$>4%&/?"3 L"K%:2&' >4%&/?"3( 4#3"$>4%&/?"3M $"&%2/)" 2. 25" %3)"$2/0"3 ,/#/,4, "34:%2/.#%& &")"&7 A. :%-24$" % -.00/=&" #.#@&/#"%$ "34:%2/.#@-$.34:2/)/2' $"@

&%2/.#05/- 6" %&0. /#:&43" 25" $"0-":2/)" 0>4%$"0 .1 25"0" 26. )%$/%=&"07 E":%&& 25%2 .4$

25".$"2/:%& ,.3"& -$"3/:20 25%2 25" /#0/3"$ ";":2 .# 25" 5/$/#9 -$.=%=/&/2' ,%#/1"020 /#

-$.1"00/.#%& "K-"$/"#:" 04=02/242/#9 1.$ % &%:V .1 1.$,%& "34:%2/.#7 A540( 6" ?#%&&' /#@

:&43" 25" $"0-":2/)" /#2"$%:2/.# )%$/%=&"0!R'H S+2H(!6#8H S+2H( %#3=#$%H S+2H ="26""#

!R'*./*+8*(!6#8$,/(+ %#3=#$%/>8$,/(+%#3 25" /#0/3"$ 02%2407

<$., 25" 3"0:$/-2/.# .1 25" /#02/242/.#%& 0"22/#9 %&0. $":%&& 25%2BC%#3A(! %9$""

.# 25" 0-":/?:%2/.# .1 25" Y.= .-"#/#9 /# 25" ?$02 02"- .1 25" $":$4/2,"#2 -$.:"007 A5/0 0-":/?:%2/.# /0 40"3 2. :%&:4&%2" 25" 6.$V-&%:" 0:.$" L5.$6*M %#3 /0 -4=&/:&' %3)"$2/0"37 C# 25" 0":.#3 02"-( 25" ?$, 0""V0 2. ?&& ")"$' Y.= .-"#/#9 6/25 25" ="02 %)%/&%=&" %--&/@

S IT.$" 3"2%/&"3 "25#/: :&%00/?:%2/.#0 3/3 #.2 -$.)" 02%2/02/:%&&' 0/9#/?:%#27

GW

(18)

:%#27 F&25.495 BC02$/:2&' .)"$0""0 25%2 25" Y.= 0-":/?:%2/.#0 %$" #.2 $")/0"3 34$/#9 25" 0"&":2/.# -$.:"00( "K-":2%2/.#0 :.#:"$#/#9 25" $"&%2/)" 0:%$:/2' .1 >4%&/?"3 %--&/:%#20 ,%' #")"$25"&"00 %;":2A(!X0 ";.$20 2. #"9.2/%2" % 5/95"$ 0:.$"7 +/#:" % 5/95"$ 0:.$"

/,-&/"0 % ,.$" 9"#"$.40 0%&%$' $%#9"( 25"$" ,%' 25"$"1.$" "K/02 % 0":.#3 /#3/$":2 ";":2 .1 25" >4%&/?:%2/.# 02$4:24$" 6/25/# 25" 9$.4- .1 %--&/:%#20 .# 25" 5/$/#9 -$.=%=/&/2'7

8"#:"( 6" :5..0" % JN(17,$:* P*$2, 7"#$.*2 LI7P7M $"9$"00/.# %--$.%:57 +-":/1@

/:%&&'(5.$6* /0 /#02$4,"#2"3 2. %::.4#2 1.$ "#3.9"#"/2'7 A5" 25$"" 3"-%$2,"#2@2'-"0 -$.)"3 2. :.#02/242" %3">4%2" /#02$4,"#207 A. %)./3 ,4&2/:.&&/#"%$/2'( 2":5#/:%& 04--.$2

%#3 0"$)/:"0 :.#02/242"0 % ="#:5,%$V 3"-%$2,"#2@2'-"7 F0 "K-&%/#"3 %=.)"( 25" 1.4$25 /#02$4,"#2 /0 25" #4,="$ .1 .)"$>4%&/?"3 %--&/:%#207 E":%&&/#9 .4$ 25".$"2/:%& ,.3"&(

25" -$"0"#:" .1 /#0/3"$0 05.4&3 /#34:" % 5/95"$ $/0V .1 &"9%& :.0207 D.#0">4"#2&'( 25" ?$, 6.4&3 &.6"$ 25" %3)"$2/0"3 $">4/$"3 ,/#/,4, "34:%2/.#%& %#3 "K-"$/"#:" &")"&0 6/25.42

%&2"$/#9 /20 -.&/:' 2. :.,-42" 25" 6.$V-&%:" 0:.$"07

F0 /0 6"&& V#.6#( 5"2"$.0V"3%:/2' 6/&& /#34:" /#:.#0/02"#2 "02/,%2.$0 /# =.25 -$.=/2

%#3 &.9/2 $"9$"00/.#07 8"#:"( 6" /,-&","#2 T4$-5' %#3 A.-"&X0 LS[[SM %--$.%:5 2.

:.$$":2 25" 02%#3%$3 "$$.$0 %#3 $"-.$2 25" $"04&20 1.$ 25" &/#"%$ -$.=%=/&/2' ,.3"& LP9;M /# A%=&" J7 <.&&.6/#9 d..&3$/39" LS[[S( -7 JNHM( 6" 14$25"$ 40" % 5"2"$.0V"3%:/2'@$.=402 :.)%$/%#:"@,%2$/K $"9$"00/.# 25$.495.42 25" $",%/#/#9 %#%&'0/07 ^#&' 1.$ :.,-%$/0.#

%#3 $.=402#"00 :5":V0( 6" %&0. $"-.$2 25" ,%$9/#%& ";":20 40/#9 =.25 &.9/2 %#3 -$.=/2 ,.3"&0 /# A%=&" I7

<1< ,-. %.6%.33*&# %.3(5$3

</$02( 6" %33$"00 25" >4%&/2' .1 .4$ "02/,%2" $"-.$2"3 /# A%=&" J %#3 ="9/# =' :%$$'/#9 .42 25" B$#2&$+ 2"02 1.$ "#3.9"#"/2'7 <.&&.6/#9 d..&3$/39" LS[[S( -7 UIG %#3 -7 JNGM( 6" /#0"$2 25" -$"3/:2"3 $"0/34%&0 1$., 25" $"34:"3 1.$, /#2. 25" ,%/# $"9$"00/.#

">4%2/.# %#3 2"02 65"25"$ 25" $"0-":2/)" :."c:/"#2 /0 02%2/02/:%&&' 3/;"$"#2 1$., b"$.7 A5" $"0-":2/)"C@02%2/02/: %22%/#0 25" )%&4"+3B+27 A540( 6" 02$.#9&' $"Y":2 25" #4&& .1

#. "#3.9"#"/2'7 A5/0 $"04&2 9"#"$%&&' :.#?$,0 25" %3">4%:' .1 25" I7P7@%--$.%:5 2.

:%-24$" 25" 0-":/?: 1"%24$"0 .1 25" ?$,X0 $":$4/2,"#2 -$.:"007

e.2" 25%2 25" :."c:/"#2 .# 25" #4,="$ .1 .)"$>4%&/?"3 %--&/:%#20 /0 -.0/2/)" %#3 5/95&' 0/9#/?:%#27 A5/0 ?#3/#9 :.#?$,0 25%2BC %#3A(! %9$"" .# 5/95"$ 6.$V-&%:"

0:.$"0 65"# 25"' "K-":2 ,.$" 5/95&' >4%&/?"3 Y.= :%#3/3%2"07 +-":/?:%&&'( .#" ,.$"

GI

Referenzen

ÄHNLICHE DOKUMENTE

B. Investigating the impact of trade openness on poverty with a linear classical poverty model employing a set of control variables employed by similar studies in the

While most of the studies have been concentrated on the development a credit scoring model based on the logistic regression with the dependent variable representing

The business model concept has many different usages such as converting company’s competence into economic value (Teece, 2010), creating value from an innovative solution (Chesbrough

Firstly, ASIC devices are solely developed for mining bitcoins and as the level of difficulty of mining bitcoins has gone through a tremendous rise since the launch of the

They highlight that transformational leaders are focused on the future and hence value creativity and innovation and can create environments that enable collaboration towards

Secondly, if expected correlations are found be- tween gaps in earnings and pension income and attitudes toward role of women in family life and labour market, it could

Current paper examines the effect of outward foreign direct investment (OFDI) on home country labor market using matched employer-employee dataset, which covers entire population

They are also perceived by many elements in the Japanese government as a critical solution to the overall population crisis that can preserve what Japan does not want to