Localization and density of states of disordered low-dimensional systems in a magnetic field

 
 

        !  "#$ ! $ % &$% % '()*() +),& % -./ 01* ! $ .$#$ . 2

 !  3
4 567 01* ! $ 899:

K L BGM K DB K N ABH@>BC OB>PAB Q K L D DB K R =AM>H OA==AP>HH

;<=>?@=AB CAB DEFS<=>=EGHI J

K L BGM K DB K N ABH@>BC OB>PAB Q K L BGM K DB K T >UG VAF?@WA D>=<P CAB DEFS<=>=EGHI XY K XZ K Q XX[ \GBFE=]AHCAB CAF L B<^M<H_F><FF?@<FFAFI L BGM K DB K DG<_`>F a>b \GBFE=]AHCAB CAF L BGPG=EGHF><FF?@<FFAFI L BGM K DB K c G`>HC dEAFAHC>H_AB

DAW>H CAF a>?@eABAE?@F

L @bFEWI L BGM K DB K ;<^H=AB T <eAB

>HC =@A CAHFE=bGMF=>=AF GMMABPEGHFEH FGPA `GgkCEPAHFEGH>`CEFGBCABAC FbF=APF

K

l

@A jBF= S>B= EF ?GH?ABHAC gE=@ =@A `G?>`E]>=EGH GM A`A?=BGHF EH =@E?Wm CEFGBk

CABAC gEBAF EH =@A SBAFAH?A GM > ?GHF=>H= P>_HA=E? jA`C

K

l@A FA?GHC S>B= CA>`F

gE=@ FGPA SBGSAB=EAF GM nGPSGFE=A aABPEGHF EH =@A aB>?=EGH>` o<>H=<P

T >`` pMk

MA?= >HC gE=@ =@A BA`>=AC SBGe`AP GMMBAA MABPEGHF PGhEH_ EH > QD F=>=E?mB>HCGP

P>_HA=E? jA`C

K

fH S>B= J

gA EHhAF=E_>=A =@A >hAB>_AC `G?>`E]>=EGH `AH_=@ GM MABPEGHFEH > q<>FE J

D FbF=AP >F> M<H?=EGH GM> P>_HA=E?jA`C >SS`EAC SABSAHCE?<`>B=G =@A gEBA

K dA

F@Gg =@>= =@A `G?>`E]>=EGH `AH_=@ EH?BA>FAF gE=@ =@A P>_HA=E? jA`C eb ?>`?<`>=k

EH_ =@A ><=G?GBBA`>=EGH M<H?=EGH GM FSA?=B>` CA=ABPEH>H=F

K

aGB F=BGH_ jA`CFm =@A

`G?>`E]>=EGH `AH_=@ F>=<B>=AF >= =gE?A E=F h>`<A gE=@G<= P>_HA=E? jA`Cm EH >_BAAk

PAH= gE=@ SBAhEG<F >H>`b=E?>` >HC H<PABE?>` gGBW

K

l@A ?BGFFGhAB eA@>hEG<B GM

=@A `G?>`E]>=EGH `AH_=@ EF F@GgH =G eA _GhABHAC eb =@A P>_HA=E? S@>FA F@EM=EH_

B>=A

K

dA CABEhA =@EF q<>H=E=b >H>`b=E?>``b EH > _AHAB>`m?`GFAC MGBP

K

dA ?GPS>BA

G<B BAF<`=F gE=@ BA?AH= ArSABEPAH=>` gGBW

K

fH S>B= Qm ?@>S=AB smgA EHhAF=E_>=A =@A FSEH SG`>BE]>=EGH GM =@A ao

T

p _BG<HC

F=>=AF>=jrAC j``EH_ M>?=GBFgE=@EH > PGCA`GMFSEHM<`mHGHkEH=AB>?=EH_ nGPSGFE=A

aABPEGHF

K

dA F@Gg =@>= =B>HFE=EGHF eA=gAAH CEtABAH=`b SG`>BE]AC _BG<HC F=>=AF

>F > M<H?=EGH GM =@A P>_HA=E? jA`C G??<Bm EH >_BAAPAH= gE=@ BA?AH= ArSABEPAH=F

K

dA >`FG EHhAF=E_>=A =@A AtA?= GM =APSAB>=<BAm CEFGBCAB >HC FSEHkGBeE= F?>==ABEH_

GH =@A =B>HFE=EGHF

K

fH ?@>S=AB Z

gA ?GHFECAB =@A SBGe`AP GM > MABPEGH F<eUA?= =G > F=>=E? B>HCGP

P>_HA=E?jA`CgE=@ `>B_A PA>H

K

l@EFSBGe`AP EF>`FG EPSGB=>H=MGB=@A nGPSGFE=A

aABPEGH CAF?BES=EGH GM =@A aB>?=EGH>` o<>H=<P

T

>`` ptA?=

K

dA EHhAF=E_>=A =@A

SBGSAB=EAFGM=@A `G?>`E]AC F=>=AFg@E?@ CA=ABPEHA =@A FSA?=B<P EH =@A =>E`FGM=@A

CAHFE=b GM F=>=AF

K

dA ?>`?<`>=A =@A DAHFE=b GM

R

=>=AF EH =@A =>E`F >F > M<H?=EGH GM

=@A AHAB_b >HC =@A PA>H h>`<A GM=@A

cu

a gE=@EH =@A MB>PAgGBWGM=@A vS=EP<P

a`<?=<>=EGH u A=@GC K dA F@Gg =@>=mHA>B =@A ?AH=BAF GM V>HC>< e>HCFm=@A Dv R

EF > ;><FFE>H M<H?=EGH GM =@A AHAB_bm g@ABA>F =@A AHAB_b CASAHCAH?A GM=@A Dv

R

EF HGHk>H>`b=E? HA>B =@A e>HC AC_A

u

VGW>`EFEAB<H_FhAB@>`=AH <HC CEA y<F=>HCFCE?@=A hGH aABPEGHAH EH HEACBE_CEPAHk

FEGH>`AH

R

bF=APAH

K

DAB ABF=A lAE` eAF?@>M=E_=^ FE?@ PE=CAB VGW>`EFEAB<H_ hGH p`AW=BGHAH EH CE?WAHm

<H_AGBCHA=AH DB>^@=AH EH AEHAP WGHF=>H=AH

u

>_HA=MA`C

K

DAB ]gAE=A lAE` @>HCA`=

hGH AEHE_AH pE_AHF?@>M=AH hGH z{|}{~€ ‚ƒ|{„~ EP aB>W=EGH>`AH o<>H=AHk

@>``AtAW=… ao

T

p† <HC CAP ]<_A@GBE_^ AH

L

BGe`AP hGH FE?@ EH AEHAP F=>=EF?@AHm

]gAECEPAHFEGH>`AH y<M>``FP>_HA=MA`C eAgA_AHCAHm MBAEAH aABPEGHAH

K

fH lAE` J

<H=ABF<?@AH gEB CEA _APE==A`=A VGW>`EFEAB<H_`>^H_A hGH aABPEGHAH

EH AEHAP q<>FEkAEHCEPAHFEGH>`AH

R

bF=AP >`F a<HW=EGH CAF FAHWBA?@= ]<P DB>@=

>H_A`A_=AH

u

>_HA=MA`CAF

K

dEB eABA?@AH CEA w<=GWGBBA`>=EGHFM<HW=EGH CAB

R SAWk

=B>`CA=ABPEH>H=AH <HC ]AE_AHm C>FF CEA VGW>`EFEAB<H_F`>^H_A PE= CAP

u

>_HA=MA`C

>HF=AE_=

K

a<B^ F=>BWA aA`CAB F>==E_^ = CEA VGW>`EFEAB<H_F`>H^ _A eAEP ]gAEM>?@AH E@BAF

dAB=AF EP a>`` G@HA

u

>_HA=MA`Cm EH ^

‡eABAEHF=EPP<H_ ]< eAF=A@AHCAH >H>`b=EFk

?@AH <HC H<PABEF?@AH wBeAE=AH K pF gEBC _A]AE_=m C>FF C>F ^ ‡eAB_>H_FhAB@>`=AH hGH CAB P>_HA=EF?@AH L

@>FAHhABF?@EAe<H_ eAF=EPP= gEBC

K

dEB `AE=AH CEAF >H>k

`b=EF?@ EH >``_APAEHABm_AF?@`GFFAHAB aGBP @ABm<HC hAB_`AE?@AH <HFABA pB_AeHEFFA

PE=U<H^ _F=AH ArSABEPAH=A``AH wBeAE=AH

K

f H lAE`

Q

mO>SE=A` s <H=ABF<?@AH gEB CEA

R SEHSG`>BEF>=EGH CAF ao T p ;B<HC]<k F=>HCFeAE MAF=AH a<^``M>W=GBEH AEHAP u

GCA``hGH HE?@=kgA?@FA`gEBWAHCAHmFSEHeAk

@>M=A=AHz{|}{~€ ‚ƒ|{„~ K dEB ]AE_AH EH ^ ‡eABAEHF=EPP<H_ PE=U<^H_F=AH prk SABEPAH=AHmC>FF ^

‡eAB_>^H_A ]gEF?@AH hABF?@EACAH SG`>BEFEAB=AH ;B<HC]<F=>^HCAH

>`F a<HW=EGH CAF u >_HA=MA`CAF ><M=BA=AH K dEB <H=ABF<?@AH AeAHM>``F CAH pEHi<x CAB lAPSAB>=<Bm ‡HGBCH<H_ <HC R

SEHe>@HgA?@FA`gEBW<H_ ><M CEA ^ ‡eAB_>^H_A K fH O>SE=A` Z eA@>HCA`H gEB C>F L BGe`AP AEHAF aABPEGHF EH AEHAP F=>=EF?@AH y<M>``FP>_HA=MA`C PE= _BGFFAH u E==A`gAB= K DEAFAF L

BGe`AP EF= AeAHM>``F gE?@=E_

M<^B CEA z{|}{~€‚ƒ|{„k N AF?@BAEe<H_ CAF ao T p K dEB<H=ABF<?@AH CEA pE_AHk

F?@>M=AH CAB `GW>`EFEAB=AH y<F=>^HCAm gA`?@A C>F

R SAW=B<P EH CAH R ?@g>H^ ]AH CAB y<F=>HCFCE?@=A eAF=EPPAH K

dEB eABA?@HAH CEA y<F=>HCFCE?@=A EH CAH

R

?@g>^H]AH

>`F a<HW=EGH CAB pHAB_EA <HC CAF PE==`ABAH dAB=AF CAF y<M>``FP>_HA=MA`CF EP

c >@PAH CAB ˆ}€|‰| ‚Š‰‹€‰Œ€{„ u A=@GCA K dEB ]AE_AHm C>FF H>@A CAP yAHk

=B<P CAB V>HC><e>^HCAB CEA y<F=>HCFCE?@=A AEHA ;><xM<HW=EGH CAB pHAB_EA EF=m

gG@EH_A_AH CEA pHAB_EA>e@>^H_E_WAE= CAB y<F=>HCFCE?@=A >H CAH

N

>HCB>H^ CABH

HE?@= PA@B >H>`b=EF?@ EF=

“ ”•–—˜™š—›™•œ ™œ ™ž•Ÿ ¡Ÿ¡  ¢£ž›¡¤ž ¥ J K J dA>W VG?>`E]>=EGH K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K Y J K J K J

DE>_B>PP>=E? >H>`bFEF

K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K J Q J K J K Q l@A BG`A GM P>_HA=E? jA`CF K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K J s J K J K¦ DAS@>FEH_ K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K JZ J K J K [ u

>_HA=E? EPS<BE=EAF >HC FSEHkGBeE= F?>==ABEH_

K K K K K K K J§ J K Q R =BGH_ VG?>`E]>=EGH K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K J¨ J K Q K J R EH_`A L >B>PA=AB R ?>`EH_ K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K J¨ J K Q K Q l@A ©GHkVEHA>B ªk u GCA` K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K Q X « ¬—­œ¡›•˜•–—˜™š—›™•œ ™œ ™ž•Ÿ ¡Ÿ¡  ®¯—œ›¯¤ °™Ÿ¡ž «± Q K J l

@A ><=G?GBBA`>=EGH M<H?=EGH GM FSA?=B>` CA=ABPEH>H=F

K K K K K K K Q s Q K Q l

@A P>_HA=E? S@>FA F@EM=EH_ B>=A

K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K ¦ J Q K Q K J

dEBAF gE=@ FSA?<`>B eG<HC>Bb ?GHCE=EGHF

K K K K K K K K K K ¦ Q Q K Q K Q L >B>eG`E? dEBA K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K ¦ [ Q K¦ u

>_HA=G`G?>`E]>=EGH

K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K ¦ § Q K [ c AFEF=>H?A GM q<>FEk J D gEBAF K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K [[ Q K s R

bPPA=Bb CASAHCAH?A GM VG?>`E]>=EGH EH DEFGBCABAC dEBAFI prk

SABEPAH=>` wH>`bFEF K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K [ s ² ³´¡ ®¯—œ›¯¤ µ—˜˜ ¶·¡–›ž ¸¥ ¦K J l@A fH=A_AB o<>H=<P T >`` ptA?=I e>FE?F M>?=F K K K K K K K K K K K [Y ¦K Q l@A c

G`A GM DEFGBCABI VG?>`E]>=EGHkDA`G?>`E]>=EGH

lB>HFE=EGHF K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K s Q ¦K¦ l@A DAHFE=b GM R

=>=AFI SAB=<Be>=EhA >HC HGHSAB=<Be>=EhA ?>`?<`>k

=EGHF K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K s ¦ ¦K [

VG?>`E]>=EGH EH > F=BGH_ P>_HA=E? jA`C

K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K s § ¦K [ K J

aEA`C =@AGBA=E? >SSBG>?@

K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K s § ¦K [ K Q v=@AB >SSBG>?@AF K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K s ¨ ¦K s l @A aB>?=EGH>` o<>H=<P T >`` ptA?= K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K s Y ¦K s K J L

BGSAB=EAF GM g>hAM<H?=EGHF EH =@A VV `AhA`

K K K K K K K K K s Y ¦K s K Q l@A V><_@`EH F=>=A K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K ZX

¦K s

K¦

n@>B_AC pr?E=>=EGHFI aB>?=EGH>` n@>B_AF >HC aB>?=EGH>`

R =>=EF=E?F K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K Z Q ¦K s K [ d@>= >eG<= DEFGBCABÀ K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K Z ¦ ¸ Á•¤Â•ž™›¡ ៤™•œž ı [ K J l@A n@ABHk R

EPGHF=B>HFMGBP>=EGHI > FEH_<`>B;><_A =B>HFMGBP>=EGH Z s [ K Q l@A PA>H jA`C >SSBGrEP>=EGH K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K Z§ [ K¦ l@A c >HCGP L

@>FA wSSBGrEP>=EGHI ?GHC<?=EhE=b >HC A`A?=BGP>_k

HA=E? BAFSGHFA M<H?=EGH K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K Z¨ [ K [

l@A BG`A GM CEFGBCABI BA>` B>HCGP A`A?=BE? jA`CF >HC j?=E=EG<F B>Hk

CGP P>_HA=E? jA`CF K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K § Q ± Á•¤Â•ž™›¡ ៤™•œž ř›´ žÂ™œ ÆÆ s K J

prSABEPAH=F GH FSEH SG`>BE]>=EGH EH =@A ao

T p K K K K K K K K K K K §§ s K Q L

G`>BE]>=EGH =B>HFE=EGHF >HC ?BGFFEH_F GM naF V>HC>< `AhA`F

K K K K ¨X

s

K¦ R

PGG=@AHEH_ GM =@A =B>HFE=EGHFI CEFGBCAB >HC FSEHkGBeE= AtA?=F

K K ¨ ¦ s K¦K J l@A BG`A GMj?=E=EG<FmEH@GPG_AHAG<FP>_HA=E?jA`CFI FAPEk ?`>FFE?>` =@AGBb K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K ¨ ¦ s K¦K Q R SEHkGBeE= AtA?=F K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K ¨[ s K [

lAPSAB>=<BA F?>`EH_ GM =@A SG`>BE]>=EGH >HC =@A

FSEHkiES _>S K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K ¨ s Ä ¡œž™›£ •Ç ¢›—›¡ž •Ç ៤™•œž ™œ — ȗœ •¤ ¬—­œ¡›™– Ù¡˜  É¥ Z K J

a>E`<BA GM H>EhA SAB=<Be>=EhA =A?@HEq<AF

K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K ¨Y Z K Q R APE?`>FFE?>` BAF<`=F K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K Y Q Z K¦ V>HC>< VAhA` =>E`F K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K Y[ Z K¦K J

o<>`E=>=EhA SE?=<BAI VEMF@E=] >B_<PAH=

K K K K K K K K K K K Y¨

Z

K¦K Q

DABEh>=EGH GM =@A F>CC`A SGEH= Aq<>=EGH

K K K K K K K K K K K JX[

Z

K¦K¦

DEF?<FFEGH GM =@A BAF<`=F

K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K JX§ Æ Á•œ–˜¯ž™•œž ““² Ê ¶Ë—˜¯—›™•œ •Ç ›´¡ ¡™­¡œË—˜¯¡ž •Ç ›´¡ ”—˜—–¡ÌÍ¡˜›Ÿ—¤™ џ—›•Ÿ““± Í Ï•œÌ™œ›¡Ÿ—–›™œ­ Ÿ¡žÂ•œž¡ ǯœ–›™•œ •Ç ÁÞ ž¯ÐÑ¡–› ›• — –•ž›—œ› Í ““¥ Á ʖҜ•Å˜¡ ­¤¡œ›ž “«²

l@A S@bFE?FGMCEFGBCABAC FbF=APF gE=@ BAC<?AC CEPAHFEGH>`E=b@>FeAAH =@A F<ek

UA?= GM EH=AHFA =@AGBA=E?>` >HC ArSABEPAH=>` BAFA>B?@ EH =@A S>F=

¦ X

bA>BF

K

‡H=E` BA?AH=`bm CEFGBCAB g>F >`g>bF >FF<PAC =G eA GM A`A?=BGF=>=E? H>=<BA >HC

?GHHA?=AC gE=@ =@A SBAFAH?A GM EPS<BE=EAF >HC EPSABMA?=EGHF EH =@A ?BbF=>`

K

o<>H=<P EH=ABMABAH?A AtA?=F EH > CEFGBCABAC A`A?=BGF=>=E? SG=AH=E>`CB>F=E?>``b>Mk

MA?= =@A SBGSAB=EAF GM =@A A`A?=BGHE? g>hAM<H?=EGHF

K

w??GBCEH_ =G =@A ?A`AeB>=AC

F?>`EH_ =@AGBb GM `G?>`E]>=EGHm CEFGBCABACm HGHkEH=AB>?=EH_ GHAkCEPAHFEGH>` … J

D†

>HC =gGkCEPAHFEGH>` …QD† FbF=APF >= =@A >eFG`<=A ]ABG GM =APSAB>=<BA >BA EHk

F<`>=GBF FEH?A >`` =@A GHAkS>B=E?`A g>hA M<H?=EGHF >BA `G?>`E]ACm HG P>==AB @Gg

gA>W =@A CEFGBCAB EF

K

l@A ArSGHAH=E>` `G?>`E]>=EGH GM>`` =@A AE_AHF=>=AF @>F eAAH

SBGhAH BE_GBG<F`b MGB J D >HC q<>FE J D FbF=APF K l@A Q D ?>FA EF PGBA CEÙ?<`= =G

=>?W`A FEH?A E= `EAF >= =@A AC_A eA=gAAH PA=>``E? >HC EHF<`>=EH_

K

vH =@A ?GH=B>Bbm

=@BAAkCEPAHFEGH>` FbF=APF Ar@EeE= > CEFGBCAB EHC<?AC PA=>`kEHF<`>=GB =B>HFE=EGH

… u fl† K fH =@A Q D >HC ¦

D ?>FAm =@A GH`b >h>E`>e`A BE_GBG<F BAF<`=F ?GH?ABH =@A

ArSGHAH=E>` `G?>`E]>=EGHGMA`A?=BGHFEH =@A =>E`FGMq<>H=<PkPA?@>HE?>``b >``GgAC

AHAB_b e>HCF

K

l@A >SS`E?>=EGH GM > P>_HA=E? jA`C EHC<?AF ?@>H_AF EH =@A S@>FA GM =@A g>hA

M<H?=EGHF >HC =@<F >tA?=F EH=ABMABAH?A AtA?=F

K c

G<_@`b FSA>WEH_m F<?@ AtA?=F

>BA BAC<?AC C<A =G =@A eBA>WEH_ GM =EPA BAhABF>` FbPPA=Bb

K

wF > ?GHFAq<AH?Am

EH =@A SBAFAH?A GM > F=BGH_ P>_HA=E? jA`Cm =@A `G?>`E]>=EGH `AH_=@ GM A`A?=BGHF EH

q<>FE J

D FbF=APF EF CG<e`AC

K

wF M>B >F QD FbF=APF >BA ?GH?ABHACm =@A EH=ABS`>b

GM CEFGBCAB >HC @E_@ P>_HA=E? jA`CF EF BAFSGHFEe`A MGB =@A fH=A_AB o<>H=<P

T >``

ptA?=

K

fH =@EF BA_EPAm V>HC>< `AhA`F >BA eBG>CAHAC EH=G e>HCF >HC F=>=AF >BA

`G?>`E]AC EH =@A =>E`F GM =@A e>HCF

K

©A>B =@A ?AH=BAF GM V>HC>< e>HCFm =@ABA

>BA FEH_<`>BE=EAF EH =@A `G?>`E]>=EGH `AH_=@ >F > M<H?=EGH GM =@A AHAB_b >HC =@<F

`G?>`E]>=EGHkCA`G?>`E]>=EGH =B>HFE=EGHF EHC<?AC eb =@A P>_HA=E? jA`C G??<B

K

fH =@A >eGhA F?AH>BEGm A`A?=BGHkA`A?=BGH EH=AB>?=EGHF AH=AB GH`b >= HGH ]ABG

=APSAB>=<BA >F > CAS@>FEH_ FG<B?A g@E?@ <SFA=F q<>H=<P EH=ABMABAH?A >HC `Gk

?>`E]>=EGH

K T

GgAhABm =@AEB AtA?=F ?>H eA PGBA CB>P>=E?

K

aGB EHF=>H?Am E= EF gA``

WHGgH =@>= nG<`GPe EH=AB>?=EGHF >`GHA ?>H EHC<?A >

u flm =@A FG ?>``AC u G==k T <ee>BC =B>HFE=EGH K

wH <HCABF=>HCEH_ GM P>Hb ArSABEPAH=>``b GeFABhAC

u flFm

CEFGBCAB >HC EH=AB>?=EGHF EH=G >??G<H=

K

wF BA_>BCF QD FbF=APF EH > F=BGH_ P>_HA=E? jA`Cm =@A EH=ABS`>b GM nG<`GPe

EH=AB>?=EGHF >HC CEFGBCAB `A>CF =G =@A aB>?=EGH>` o<>H=<P

T

>`` ptA?=

K

fH =@EF

BA_EPAm C<A =G EH=AB>?=EGHF >HC @E_@ P>_HA=E? jA`CFm A`A?=BGHF MGBP HAgm ?G`k

`A?=EhA _BG<HC F=>=AF

K ‡

H=E` BA?AH=`bm P<?@ GM G<B <HCABF=>HCEH_ GM =@EF AtA?=

g>F e>FAC GH`b GH =@A F=<Cb GM =BE>` _BG<HC F=>=A g>hAM<H?=EGHF >HC HG= GH >Hb

FbF=AP>=E? SAB=<Be>=EhA >SSBG>?@

K

c

A?AH=`bm > HAg =@AGBb GM =@A ao

T

p @>F eAAH CAhA`GSACm=@A FG ?>``AC nGPk

SGFE=A aABPEGH =@AGBb

K

dE=@EH =@A MB>PAgGBW GM =@EF =@AGBbm > HAg GeUA?=m =@A

nGPSGFE=A aABPEGH …na†m P>CA G<= GM GHA A`A?=BGH >HC >H AhAH H<PeAB GM i<r

q<>H=> >==>?@AC =G E=m EF EH=BGC<?AC

K

f= =<BHF G<= =@>= naF eA@>hA EH P>Hb BAk

FSA?=F `EWA gA>W`b ?GBBA`>=AC MABPEGHF gE=@ F=BGH_`b BAHGBP>`E]AC q<>FES>B=E?`A

AtA?=EhA S>B>PA=ABFC<A =G nakna EH=AB>?=EGHF

K

w= =@A HGHEH=AB>?=EH_ na q<>FEk

S>B=E?`A `AhA`m =@A ao T p GM A`A?=BGHF EF P>SSAC GH=G =@A fo T p GM naF K u >Hb EPSGB=>H= MA>=<BAF GM =@A ao T p ?>H eA >CCBAFFAC >= =@EF `AhA` K

D<A =G =@AEB ?GPSGFE=A H>=<BAm naF ArSABEAH?A > j?=E=EG<F B>HCGP P>_HA=E?

jA`C …

cu

a† EH >CCE=EGH =G =@A Ar=ABH>` GHA >HC =G =@A F?>`>B CEFGBCAB SG=AHk

=E>` C<A =G EPS<BE=EAF

K

vgEH_ =G E=F BA`Ah>H?A EH =@EF AtA?=EhA CAF?BES=EGH GM =@A

ao T pm=@A SBGe`AP GM> MABPEGH PGhEH_ EH > Q D cu

a @>F >==B>?=AC ?GHFECAB>e`A

EH=ABAF= BA?AH=`b

K

a<B=@ABPGBAmF=G?@>F=E?>``b EH@GPG_AHAG<F P>_HA=E? jA`CF ?>H

HGg eA ArSABEPAH=>``b BA>`E]AC EH h>BEG<F g>bF

K

l@EF SBGe`AP EF CEBA?=`b >PAH>e`A =G =@A =@AGBb GM HGHEH=AB>?=EH_ S>B=E?`AF >HC

E= @>F eAAH F@GgH =@>= >

Q

D A`A?=BGH _>F EH > F=>=E?

cu

a eA`GH_F =G =@A ?GHk

hAH=EGH>` <HE=>Bb <HEhABF>`E=b ?`>FF

K

l@ABAMGBAm >`` =@A F=>=AF >BA ArSA?=AC =G eA

`G?>`E]AC EH F<?@ FbF=APF g@AH =@A

cu a @>F ]ABG PA>H h>`<A >HC =@A o<>H=<P T >`` ptA?= G<_@= =G G??<B g@AH =@A >hAB>_A h>`<A GM =@A cu a EF `>B_A K

fH =@EF =@AFEF gA EHhAF=E_>=A =@A `G?>`E]>=EGH GM A`A?=BGHF EH q<>FE J

D gEBAF EH

=@A SBAFAH?A GM > P>_HA=E? jA`C >HC =@A `G?>`E]>=EGH GM MABPEGHF EH QD F<eUA?=AC

=G > B>HCGP P>_HA=E? jA`C gE=@ `>B_A PA>H h>`<A EH =@A =>E`F GM V>HC>< e>HCF

K

dA ?>`?<`>=A =@A `A>CEH_ ArSGHAH=E>` M>?=GB GM =@A CAHFE=b GM F=>=AF EH =@AFA =>E`F

K

dA >`FG F=<Cb =@A FSEH SG`>BE]>=EGH GM =@A ao

T

p _BG<HC F=>=AF EH =ABPF GM HGH

EH=AB>?=EH_ FSEHM<` naF

K

f

H?@>S=AB J

mgA _EhA>H EH=BGC<?=EGH=G FGPAGM=@A PGF=F<??AFFM<` >SSBG>?@AF

=G `G?>`E]>=EGH EH CEFGBCABAC FbF=APF

K

wM=AB CEF?<FFEH_ =@A gA>W `G?>`E]>=EGH

?GBBA?=EGHF =G =@A =B>HFSGB= SBGSAB=EAF GM F<?@ FbF=APFm gA =<BH =G =@A F?>`EH_

=@AGBb GM`G?>`E]>=EGH >HC =@AH =G > jA`Ck=@AGBA=E? >SSBG>?@m=@A F<SABFbPPA=BE?

HGHk`EHA>B ªkPGCA`

K

fH ?@>S=AB

Q

gA EHhAF=E_>=A =@A EHi<AH?A GM > P>_HA=E? jA`C GH =@A `G?>`E]>=EGH

SBGSAB=EAF GM A`A?=BGHF EH q<>FE J

D FbF=APF eb PA>HF GM > FSA?=B>` ?GBBA`>=EGH

M<H?=EGHm=@A ><=G?GBBA`>=EGH GM FSA?=B>` CA=ABPEH>H=

K

l@A >hAB>_AC `G?>`E]>=EGH

`AH_=@ EF CABEhAC >F =@A ?BGFFGhAB `AH_=@ F?>`A MBGP ?GBBA`>=AC =G <H?GBBA`>=AC

AHAB_b `AhA` F=>=EF=E?F

K l

`AH_=@ EH =@A ?BGFFGhAB BA_EGH eA=gAAH =@A GB=@G_GH>` AHFAPe`A …HG P>_HA=E?

jA`C† >HC =@A <HE=>Bb AHFAPe`A …PGCAB>=A`b F=BGH_ P>_HA=E? jA`C†

K

dA CABEhA

=@A P>_HA=E? S@>FA F@EM=EH_ B>=A >H>`b=E?>``b EH > hABb _AHAB>`m?`GFAC MGBP

K l@EF

q<>H=E=b EF F@GgH =G _GhABH =@A ?BGFFGhAB eA@>hEG<B GM =@A `G?>`E]>=EGH `AH_=@

K

aGB F=BGH_ jA`CFm gA F@Gg =@>= =@A `G?>`E]>=EGH `AH_=@ F>=<B>=AF >= =gE?A E=F

h>`<A gE=@G<= P>_HA=E? jA`CmEH >_BAAPAH=gE=@ SBAhEG<F >H>`b=E?>`gGBW

K

DEBA?=

q<>H=E=>=EhA ?GPS>BEFGH gE=@ BA?AH= ArSABEPAH=F EF _EhAH

K fH ?@>S=AB ¦ gA CEF?<FF =@A _AHAB>` =@AGBb GM =@A fo T p >HC =@A ao T p g@E`A EH ?@>S=AB [

gA EH=BGC<?A =@A =@AGBb GM FSEH`AFF nGPSGFE=A aABPEGHF

K

fH =@A

`>==AB ?@>S=AB gA >`FG ?>`?<`>=A ArS`E?E=`b =@A ?GBBA`>=GB GM =@A B>HCGP P>_HA=E?

jA`C ArSABEAH?AC eb naF

K

fH ?@>S=AB s gA EHhAF=E_>=A =@A FSEH SG`>BE]>=EGH GM =@A ao

T

p _BG<HC F=>=AF

>= jrAC j``EH_ M>?=GBF gE=@EH > PGCA` GM FSEHM<`m HGHkEH=AB>?=EH_ nGPSGFE=A

aABPEGHF

K

dA F@Gg =@>= =B>HFE=EGHF eA=gAAH CEtABAH=`b SG`>BE]AC _BG<HC F=>=AF

>F > M<H?=EGH GM =@A P>_HA=E? jA`C G??<Bm EH >_BAAPAH= gE=@ BA?AH= ArSABEPAH=F

K

l@A AtA?= GM =@A j?=E=EG<Fm F=>=E?

cu

a GH =@A FSEH SG`>BE]>=EGH =B>HFE=EGHF EF

>`FG EHhAF=E_>=ACm >F gA`` >F =@A AtA?= GM =APSAB>=<BA >HC FSEHkGBeE= F?>==ABEH_

K

f

H ?@>S=AB Z

gA ?GHFECAB > MABPEGH …A`A?=BGH GB nGPSGFE=A aABPEGH† EH

Q D

F<eUA?= =G > F=>=E?

cu

a gE=@ `>B_A PA>H h>`<A >HC gA EHhAF=E_>=A =@A SBGSAB=EAF

GM =@A `G?>`E]AC F=>=AF g@E?@ CA=ABPEHA =@A FSA?=B<P EH =@A =>E`F GM =@A CAHFE=b

GM F=>=AF

K

l@EF >H>`bFEF AH>e`AF <F =G ?>`?<`>=A =@A CASAHCAH?A GM =@A DAHFE=b

GM

R

=>=AF GH =@A AHAB_b >HC =@A PA>H h>`<A GM =@A

cu

a EH =@A =>E`F gE=@EH

=@A MB>PAgGBW GM =@A vS=EP<P a`<?=<>=EGH

u A=@GC K dA F@Gg =@>=m HA>B =@A ?AH=BAF GM V>HC>< e>HCFm=@A Dv R EF > ;><FFE>H M<H?=EGH GM=@A AHAB_bmg@ABA>F =@A AHAB_b CASAHCAH?A GM =@A Dv R EF HGHk>H>`b=E? HA>B =@A e>HC AC_A K

ߎ×àáØâàØŽ ؏ ãؒŽÔՑԑÕ

ä咐‘æ ’

fH =@EF ?@>S=AB gA >CCBAFF =@A q<>H=<PkPA?@>HE?>` PG=EGH GM > S>B=E?`A EH >

B>HCGPm F=>=E? SG=AH=E>`

K

D<A =G q<>H=<P EH=ABMABAH?A SBG?AFFAFm CEFGBCAB `Gk

?>`E]AF >`` =@A A`A?=BGHE? g>hAM<H?=EGHF EH GHAkCEPAHFEGH>` >HC =gGkCEPAHFEGH>`

FbF=APF

K

fH =@BAA CEPAHFEGHFm > =B>HFE=EGH MBGP PA=>``E? =G EHF<`>=EH_ eA@>hEG<B

G??<BF eb ?@>H_EH_ =@A F=BAH_=@ GM CEFGBCAB

K

dA F=>B= =@EF ?@>S=AB eb CEF?<FFEH_ =@A jBF= q<>H=<P ?GBBA?=EGHF =G =@A ?`>Fk

FE?>` eA@>hEG<B GM CEFGBCABAC FbF=APFm =@A gA>W `G?>`E]>=EGH ?GBBA?=EGHF

K l

@AH

=@A F<SSBAFFEGH GM =@EF AtA?= C<A =G > P>_HA=E? jA`C EF CEF?<FFACm >F gA`` >F =@A

AtA?= GM FSEHkGBeE= F?>==ABEH_ >HC FSEHkiES F?>==ABEH_

K

aEH>``bmgA MG?<FGH PGBA FGS@EF=E?>=ACmHGHkSAB=<Be>=EhA =@AGBEAFGMq<>H=<P

`G?>`E]>=EGH

K

wM=AB SBAFAH=EH_ =@A F?>`EH_ =@AGBb GM`G?>`E]>=EGHmgA eBEAib CEF?<FF

=@A F<SABFbPPA=BE? HGHk`EHA>B ªkPGCA`mg@E?@ @>F `AC =G FE_HEj?>H= >Ch>H?AF EH

=@A F=<Cb GM =@EF SBGe`AP

K

çèç éêëì íîïëðñòëóñîô

fH =@EF FA?=EGH gA gE``?GHFECAB > _>FGMHGHEH=AB>?=EH_ A`A?=BGHF g@E?@ ArSABEAH?A

> F?>`>BSG=AH=E>`õ …Ÿ†?BA>=AC eb > B>HCGP CEF=BEe<=EGH GMF=>=E? EPS<BE=EAF

K l@A

T

>PE`=GHE>Hö÷øQùúûõ …Ÿ†EF=EPAkBAhABF>` EHh>BE>H= …l

c f†

K

dA gE`` >FF<PA =@>=

=@A EPS<BE=EAF >BA CE`<=Am E

K A

K

eG=@ =@A aABPE g>hA`AH_=@ üý >HC =@A B>H_A þ GM

=@A EPS<BE=b SG=AH=E>` >BA P<?@ FP>``AB=@>H =@A PA>H MBAA S>=@ ÿ
ýmg@ABA

ý EF=@A aABPEhA`G?E=b >HC  EF=@A =B>HFSGB==EPAmCAjHAC >F=@A ?@>B>?=ABEF=E?

=EPA >H A`A?=BGH ?>H =B>hA` eAMGBA =@A CEBA?=EGH GME=FhA`G?E=b EFB>HCGPE]AC …MGB>

k?GBBA`>=AC B>HCGP SG=AH=E>`  ?GEH?ECAF gE=@ =@A PGPAH=<P BA`>r>=EGH =EPA

m FAA F<eFA?=EGH J K J K J † K R

APE?`>FFE?>``bm=@A F=G?@>F=E? PG=EGH GMA`A?=BGHFEH > CEFGBCABAC PA=>`>= X EF CAF?BEeAC eb =@A N G`=]P>HH Aq<>=EGH  J  K fH =B>HFSGB= =@AGBb GM PAFGF?GSE?

FbF=APFm =@A `>B_AkCEF=>H?A >HC `GH_k=EPA eA@>hEG<B GM =@A S>B=E?`A …?GPS>BAC

=G ÿ >HC  BAFSA?=EhA`b† EF GM EH=ABAF=I EH =@EF `EPE= =@A

N

G`=]P>HH Aq<>=EGH

FEPS`EjAF CB>F=E?>``bm bEA`CEH_ =@A CEt<FEGH Aq<>=EGH

   ÷ …Ÿ  † X! … J K J †

l@A ?`>FFE?>`=B>HFSGB=GMCEFGBCABAC PA=>`FEF=@ABAeb ?@>B>?=ABE]AC eb =@A CEt<k

FEGH ?GHF=>H=

m g@E?@ EF BA`>=AC =G =@A ?GHC<?=EhE=b ª eb =@A pEHF=AEH BA`>=EGH

ª Q "÷#  m g@ABA  " EF =@A A`A?=BGH ?@>B_A >HC # =@A CAHFE=b GM F=>=AF K fH

=@EF SE?=<BAmq<>H=<P PA?@>HE?F GH`b CA=ABPEHAF =@A F?>==ABEH_ ?BGFF FA?=EGH MGB

A`A?=BGHkEPS<BE=b F?>==ABEH_ EH =@A

N

G`=]P>HH Aq<>=EGH

K

f= g>F BA>`E]AC EH Qm

¦

 =@>= M<HC>PAH=>` q<>H=<P EH=ABMABAH?A AtA?=F bEA`C

?GBBA?=EGHF =G =@A ?`>FFE?>` ?GHC<?=EhE=b

K l

@AFA AtA?=F ?>H eA q<>`E=>=EhA`b <Hk

CABF=GGC eb ?GHFECABEH_ =@A BA=<BH SBGe>eE`E=b GM > S>B=E?`Am E

K A

K

=@A SBGe>eE`E=b

ö$ MGB >H A`A?=BGH g@E?@ F=>B=AC >= > SGEH=

Ÿ >= =EPA X =G >BBEhA >= =@A F>PA SGEH= >= =EPA  K w??GBCEH_ =G aAbHP>Hm =@EF q<>H=E=b EF =@A PGC<`<F Fq<>BAC GM =@A

EH=A_B>` GhAB >`` S>=@F g@E?@ F=>B= >=

Ÿ >= X >HC AHC >= Ÿ >=  I ö$ %& ' ( ' %÷ & ' % ( ' %÷ û & ')*'+ ( ' (, '+ … J K Q † g@ABA ( ' m =@A >PS`E=<CA MGB =@A S>=@ -m EFI ( ' ArS./ 0 1 $ 2 3 … J ø QùúŸ4 ÷ ' …† û õ …Ÿ ' …†††5 … J K¦ † d@AH üý 6 ÿm GH`b ?`>FFE?>` S>=@F @>hA =G eA EH?`<CAC K T AH?Am =@A jBF= =ABP EH Aq<>=EGH J K Q

EF =@A ?`>FFE?>` BA=<BH SBGe>eE`E=b >HC =@A FA?GHC BASBAFAH=F =@A

EH=ABMABAH?A GMh>BEG<F>PS`E=<CAF

K

aGBPGF=S>=@F=@A EH=ABMABAH?A EFHG=AFFAH=E>`

FEH?A =@AEB S@>FAF CEtAB F=BGH_`b >HCm=@ABAMGBAm=@A EH=ABMABAH?A =ABPF >`FG CEtAB

F=BGH_`b

K T

AH?Am =@A >hAB>_A h>`<A GM =@A EH=ABMABAH?A =ABP gE`` h>HEF@ g@AH

F<PPEH_ GhAB >`` S>=@F Qm [  K T GgAhABm GgEH_ =G =@A l c f GM G<B PGCA`m =@A

>PS`E=<CAFGM=EPAkBAhABFAC =B>UA?=GBEAF >BA Aq<>` >HCm=@ABAMGBAm=@A EH=ABMABAH?A

eA=gAAH =@AP ?>HHG= eA HA_`A?=AC

K

wF > BAF<`=m =@A ?GH=BEe<=EGH =G ö$ GM =gG

=EPAkBAhABFAC S>=@F EF

% ( ' %÷ û % (7 ' %÷ û Q8" ( ' (, 7 ' [ % ( ' %÷ … J K [ † E K A K =gE?A E=F ?`>FFE?>` h>`<A K fH ?GBBAFSGHCAH?A =G =@EF AH@>H?APAH= GM `G?>`E]>k

=EGH GM A`A?=BGHFm =@ABA EF > CA?BA>FA EH ?GHC<?=EhE=b

K

VA=9F HGg AF=EP>=A =@A P>_HE=<CA GM =@EF ?GBBA?=EGH

K R

EH?A =@A q<>H=<P PAk

?@>HE?>` gEC=@ GM >H A`A?=BGH S>=@ EF : üým =@A hG`<PA ?GhABAC eb > S>=@ EH >H

EH=ABh>` 3  EF _EhAH eb ü; 7< ý
ý 3  K vH =@A G=@AB @>HCm >H A`A?=BGH FSBA>CF GhAB > hG`<PA …  

†;=÷ >M=AB > =EPA EH=ABh>` 

K

dt

λ

F

F

v

?@ABCD EFEG HDIJDKCL IM N ODPMQ@RKDCODSK@RA TNKUF

=<eA GM gEC=@ : üý =G EH=ABFA?= E=FA`M EF =@A B>=EG GM =@AFA =gG hG`<PAFEH=A_B>=AC

GhAB >`` =EPAF …FAA j_

K J K J †I > : 1 VW =X Y 3  ü; 7< ý
ý …   † ;=÷ ! … J K s†

l@A `GgAB `EPE= GM EH=A_B>=EGH EF  FEH?A =@A CEt<FEGH Aq<>=EGH P>WAF FAHFA GH`b

MGB =EPAF  Z



K

wF BA_>BCF =@A <SSAB `EPE=mE=9F =@A =EPA E= =>WAF MGB >H A`A?=BGH

=G FSBA>C GhAB =@A g@G`A F>PS`A … >FF<PEH_ =@>= [ EF =@A `EHA>B CEPAHFEGH GM =@A

F>PS`A†

K T

AH?Am =@A gA>W `G?>`E]>=EGH ?GBBA?=EGHF =G ª >BA  [  ª :  ª>  Q"÷ 0 \ ] ^ … [  ÿ†ø_ 3 J `H…[øÿ†ø_÷ 3 Q … ÿ 7<  [ 7< †ø_` 3 ¦ … J K Z † w=  Z X

m EHA`>F=E? F?>==ABEH_ SBG?AFFAF …"

7  " 7 >HC " 7  S@GHGH EH=AB>?k

=EGHF† =AHC =G CAF=BGb =@A ?G@ABAH?A GM =EPAkBAhABFAC S>=@F

K

fM gA EH=BGC<?A

> S@AHGPAHG`G_E?>`m kCASAHCAH= S@>FA ?G@ABAH?A =EPA a…† g@E?@ >??G<H=F

MGB >`` =@A S@>FA eBA>WEH_ SBG?AFFAFm > S@>FA ?G@ABAH?A `AH_=@ ?>H eA CAjHAC >F

[a…† b

 a

K

d@AH [a…†EFFP>``AB=@>H =@A >?=<>`CEPAHFEGH GM=@A F>PS`A

[ m [ P<F= eA BAS`>?AC eb [a…† EH MGBP<`>F J K s >HC J K Z …FAA FA?=EGH J K J K¦ † K dA g>H= =G F=BAFF @ABA >_>EH =@>= MGBP<`> J K Z EF h>`EC SBGhECAC =@>= üý 6 ÿ GBm Aq<Eh>`AH=`bm cýÿ d J … cý aABPE g>hA hA?=GB† K u GBAGhABm EH GHA >HC =gG

CEPAHFEGHFm E= M>E`F >= F<Ù?EAH=`b `>B_A `AH_=@ F?>`AF eA?><FA =@A BAC<?=EGH EH

?GHC<?=EhE=b _BGgF >F [ EH?BA>FAF

K

l@EF eA@>hEG<B F=BGH_`b F<SSGB=F =@A F?>`EH_

=@AGBb GM `G?>`E]>=EGHmg@E?@ SBACE?=F =@>= >`` =@A g>hAM<H?=EGHF >BA `G?>`E]AC EH J

C >HC QC FbF=APF C<A =G CEFGBCAB Qm s …FAA FA?=EGH J K Q K J † K

“f“f“ ™—­Ÿ—¤¤—›™– —œ—˜£ž™ž

l@A q<>H=<P ?GBBA?=EGHF =G =@A ?GHC<?=EhE=b >HC =@A BA=<BH SBGe>eE`E=b C<A =G

EH=ABMABAH?A ?>H eA ?>`?<`>=AC EH > PGBA BE_GBG<Fg>b eb =@A <FA GMCE>_B>PP>=E?

=A?@HEq<AF

K

dA gE`` ?GHFECAB =@A HGHEH=AB>?=EH_

T >PE`=GHE>H g  ÷ Qùú û õ …Ÿ† … J K § † g@ABA ùú EF =@A A`A?=BGH AtA?=EhA P>FF >HC õ …Ÿ† EF =@A B>HCGP A`A?=BGF=>=E? SG=AH=E>` K

dA gE`` >FF<PA =@>= õ …Ÿ† EF ;><FFE>H >HC k?GBBA`>=AC >HC =@>= E=F

PA>H EF ]ABGI hõ …Ÿ†i X hõ …Ÿ†õ …Ÿj†i k l …Ÿ  Ÿj † m %õ %÷ …Ÿ  Ÿj † … J K ¨ † g@ABA m EF =@A EPS<BE=b ?GH?AH=B>=EGH K l

@A CEF=BEe<=EGH M<H?=EGH GM =@A CEFGBk

CAB SG=AH=E>` EF > …õ† n ArS  …m %õ %÷† 7<o 3 Ÿ õ …Ÿ†÷ 

>HC =@A CEFGBCAB >hAB>_A EF

CAjHAC >F h !!! ip o 3 õ …Ÿ†> õ  !!! K fH =@A `EPE= GM gA>W CEFGBCABm üý 6 ÿm=@A A`A?=BGHE? FA`MkAHAB_b q ?>H eA >CAk

q<>=A`b AF=EP>=AC EH =@A FA`Mk?GHFEF=AH=

N GBH >SSBGrEP>=EGH R n N w …FAA j_ K J K Q † K

fH =@A BA_EGH ?`GFA =G =@A aABPE AHAB_bm %r

 rý%6 rým =@A EP>_EH>Bb S>B= GM q EF _EhAH eb  Z  I fPq…r  † k 0  Q_ m %õ %÷ #ý … J K Y † g@ABA #ý EF =@A DAHFE=b GM R =>=AF >= =@A aABPE AHAB_b >HC  EF =@A PGPAH=<P

BA`>r>=EGH =EPA >= =@A aABPE AHAB_b

K

aGB k?GBBA`>=AC SG=AH=E>`Fm EF ECAH=E?>`=G

=@A =B>HFSGB= =EPA 

K

l@A BA>` S>B= GM qm =@G<_@ CEhAB_AH=m ?>H eA >eFGBeAC

EH=G >H EBBA`Ah>H= BAHGBP>`E]>=EGH GM =@A AHAB_b

K

f= ?>H eA F@GgH =@>=m EM üý 6 ÿm CE>_B>PF g@ABA EPS<BE=b `EHAF ?BGFF ?>H eA

HA_`A?=AC …MGB =@A FA`M AHAB_b†  Z  K l @ABAMGBAm MGB `>B_A AHAB_EAF r : rým =@A >hAB>_AC BA=>BCAC >HC >Ch>H?AC

;BAAH9F M<H?=EGHF stuvw >BA _EhAH eb

stuvw …Â r† J r  rx y / 0 øQ … J K JX † g@ABA rx ö÷ø Qùú K aG<BEAB =>BHFMGBPEH_ pq K … J K JX †m gA _A= s tu vw …Ÿ  Ÿjz r† s tu vw 2 …Ÿ  Ÿjz r†" 7{ | }|+ { W~ … J K JJ † g@ABA s tuvw 2

EF =@A MBAA A`A?=BGH BA=>BCAC …BAFS

K

>Ch>H?AC† ;BAAH9F M<H?=EGH

K

s CA?>bF GH `AH_=@ F?>`AF GM =@A GBCAB GM ÿ C<A =G A`>F=E? EPS<BE=b F?>==ABEH_

B>HCGPE]EH_ =@A S@>FA GM =@A A`A?=BGHE? g>hAM<H?=EGH >PS`E=<CA …Ÿ 

†

K l@A

;BAAH9F M<H?=EGH s ?>HHG= =@<F _B>FS =@A q<>H=<P AtA?=F CAF?BEeAC EH FA?=EGH J

K J

mg@E?@ G??<B >= `>B_AB `AH_=@ F?>`AF

K

E

p,

p,

E

p’,

E

?@ABCD EFG ‚UDDPDSKCIR@SODPMQDRDCAL@RKUDƒ„…†F‚UDKU@S‡@RKDCRNPP@RDCDTCDODRKOKUDDˆNSK

MDCJ@IR@SHCDDR‰O MBRSK@IR NRŠ KUDŠNOUDŠ P@RD CDTCDODRKOKUD @JTBC@KL SICCDPNKIC ‹ŒŽF

[ Z

ÿ …GBm Aq<Eh>`AH=`bm GH =EPA F?>`AF  Z

 ÿø
ý†m GHA HAACF =G ?GHFECAB

q<>H=E=EAF ?GH=>EHEH_ @E_@AB PGPAH=F GM sm F<?@ >F =@A CEFGBCAB >hAB>_A GM =@A

A`A?=BGH CAHFE=b  …Ÿ † k h% …Ÿ  †%÷i GB =@A >hAB>_AC ?GHC<?=EhE=b ª K fH =@A

MG``GgEH_m gA gE`` ?GHFECAB =@A >hAB>_AC A`A?=BGH CAHFE=b

K R EH?A …Ÿ  † 1 3 Ÿjs t …Ÿ  zŸj  j† , …Ÿj  j† … J K J Q† …g@ABA  Z  j

†m =@A >hAB>_AC CAHFE=b ?>H eA gBE==AH >F

 …Ÿ  † 1 3 Ÿj 3 Ÿjj‘ …Ÿ  zŸj Ÿjj  j †…Ÿj  j †…Ÿjj  j† … J K J ¦ † g@ABA ‘ …Ÿ  zŸj Ÿjj  j† hst …Ÿ  zŸj  †s v …Ÿjj  jzŸ  †i ! … J K J[ †

DE>_B>PP>=E?>``bm =@EF >hAB>_A EF _EhAH eb =@A F<P GM =gG ?`>FFAF GM CE>_B>PFI

> ?`>FF g@ABA =@A =gG S>B=E?`A `EHAF >BA HG= ?GHHA?=AC eb EPS<BE=b `EHAFmbEA`CEH_

=@A SBGC<?= GM =@A EPS<BE=bk>hAB>_AC SBGS>_>=GBF >HC > ?`>FF g@ABA =@Ab >BA

?GHHA?=AC

K

l@A FA?GHC ?`>FF ?GH=>EHF =@A EH=ABAF=EH_ S@bFE?F

K

n`>FFE?>` CEt<FEGH … J K J[ † EF ’?GH=>EHAC’ EH =@A q<>H=<P ?GBBA`>=GB … J K J[ † K R

EH?A ?`>FFE?>``b =@A AhG`<=EGH GM =@A >PS`E=<CA …Ÿ 

† >HC E=F ?GHU<_>=A >PS`Ek

=<CA 

, …Ÿ

†

>`GH_ =@A CEt<FEGH S>=@ >BA HG= EHCASAHCAH=m=@A ?`>FFE?>` CEt<FEGH

EF CAF?BEeAC eb =@A `>CCAB CE>_B>PF F@GgH EH j_ J

K¦K

fH =@AFA CE>_B>PF =@A

EPS<BE=b `EHAF ?GBBA`>=A =@A AhG`<=EGH GM  >HC 

,

>= Aq<>` SGFE=EGHF >HC Aq<>`

=EPAF

K

l@A ?GH=BEe<=EGH GM =@A _AHABE? `>CCAB CE>_B>P gE=@  EPS<BE=b `EHAF ?>H eA gBE==AH >F “” …• –† … J K J s† g@ABA “ … • – † m %õ %÷ & • s t …Â j rj †s v …Â r †

    

,E

p

,E

p’

p

,E’

p’,E’

p’

,E’

p ,E

+

+

...

?@ABCD EF—G ‚UD ˜@™BOIR PNŠŠDC Š@NACNJOF

,E

p

,E

p’

p

,E’

p’,E’

p’

,E’

p ,E

+

+

...

?@ABCD EFšG ‚UD „IITDCIR SCIOODŠ Š@NACNJOF

J û /  –   › ÷ … J K JZ † >HC  j Âû •mr j r û– K R <PPEH_ <S =@A _AGPA=BE? FABEAFGM`>CCABCE>_B>PF

…=@A FG ?>``AC DEt<FGH†mgA _A=

 …• – † J ø / – û › ÷ … J K J§ †

g@E?@ EF EHCAAC =@A aG<BEAB=B>HFMGBP GM=@A SBGS>_>=GB GM =@A CEt<FEGH Aq<>=EGH

… J K J †I  …Ÿ  zŸj  j† œ …    j† … [ _  …   j †† ;=÷ " 7  |}| +ž W Ÿ   ¡ } ¡ + ž … J K J¨ †

d@>= >eG<= EH=ABMABAH?A AtA?=FÀ fM gA =gEF= =@A `>CCAB CE>_B>PF GM j_

K J

K¦

>HC =@AH ArS`GE= =@A =EPAkBAhABF>` EHh>BE>H?A GM G<B FbF=APm gA _A= =@A FG ?>``AC

P>rEP>``b ?BGFFAC CE>_B>PF CASE?=AC EH j_

K J

K [

K

l@AFA CE>_B>PF ?`A>B`b CAF?BEeA

=@A ?GBBA`>=EGH GM =EPA BAhABFAC S>=@F >HC >BA =@<F BAFSGHFEe`A MGB =@A gA>W

`G?>`E]>=EGH ?GBBA?=EGHF =G =@A BA=<BH SBGe>eE`E=b

K

l@A F<P GM P>rEP>``b ?BGFFAC

CE>_B>PF EF ?>``AC > nGGSABGH >HC EF _EhAH eb ¢…Â

Âj – † k  …Â û Âj – †  [ m Z  K

dA ?>H HGg =>WA > ;><FFE>H g>hA S>?WA= GMgEC=@ þ SA>WAC >= =@A GBE_EH >= =EPA

 X

>HC ?>`?<`>=A =@A =APSGB>` AhG`<=EGH GM =@A >hAB>_AC CAHFE=b  …Ÿ  † K fM gA

EH?`<CA eG=@ `>CCAB CE>_B>PF >HC ?BGFFAC CE>_B>PF EH pq

K … J K J ¦ †mgA _A=  …Ÿ  † J … [ _   † ; =÷ …" 7 £ W Ÿ  ¡ û " 7 £ W W † œ …  † … J K JY †

g@ABA œ …  † EF =@A F=AS M<H?=EGH K f= MG``GgF MBGP … J K JY † =@>= =@A >hAB>_AC CAHFE=b >= Ÿ X

EF =gE?A >F `>B_A >F ArSA?=AC MBGP =@A CEt<FEGH Aq<>=EGH C<A =G =@A

nGGSABGHm EH >_BAAPAH= gE=@ =@A q<>`E=>=EhA ?GHFECAB>=EGHF GM FA?=EGH J

K J

K

“f“f« ³´¡ Ÿ•˜¡ •Ç ¤—­œ¡›™– ¦¡˜ ž

n`>FFE?>``bm =@A =B>HFSGB= SBGSAB=EAF GM A`A?=BGHF EH > PA=>` >BA GH`b gA>W`b >Mk

MA?=AC eb > ?GHF=>H= P>_HA=E? jA`C §m >F `GH_ >F =@A EHAq<>`E=b

–¨  © J …g@ABA –¨ "§ø ùª EF =@A ?b?`G=BGH MBAq<AH?b† @G`CF  J  K aGB `>B_AB § …F<?@ =@>= – ¨ « J

†m =@A eAHCEH_ GM ?`>FFE?>` =B>UA?=GBEAF GH =@A F?>`A GM =@A PA>H MBAA S>=@

ÿ EF q<E=A CB>P>=E? >HC EH=ABAF=EH_ S@AHGPAH> G??<B

K

o<>H=<P PA?@>HE?>``bm > gA>W P>_HA=E? jA`C ?>H F=BGH_`b >tA?= =@A dVk

?GBBA?=EGHF=G ª FEH?A E=eBA>WF =@A =EPA BAhABF>` FbPPA=Bb  § m ¨  K l@A >PS`E=<CAF

GM =gG =EPAkBAhABFACm FA`MkEH=ABFA?=EH_ S>=@F - >HC



- >?q<EBA >CCE=EGH>` S@>FA

M>?=GBFI ( ' ¬ ( ' ArS  / " 0ª ­ ' Ê ® 3 Ÿ  ( ' ArS  / _§¯ ° 2  (7 ' ¬ ( ' ArS  / _§¯ ° 2  … J K Q X † g@ABA ° 2 EF =@A q<>H=<P GM P>_HA=E? i<r >HC ° EF =@A P>_HA=E? i<r =@BG<_@ =@A `GGS -K l

@A S@>FA CEtABAH?A eA=gAAH =gG =EPAkBAhABFAC S>=@F EF ±²„€m

³´ Q_

° ø

°

2

m e<= h>BEAF ?GHFECAB>e`b MGB CEtABAH= `GGSF

K l

@ABAMGBAm =@A gA>W

`G?>`E]>=EGH =ABP >?q<EBAF > B>HCGP S@>FA CASAHCEH_ GH =@A `GGS FE]A

K l@A

B>HCGPHAFF GM =@A S@>FA <`=EP>=A`b `A>CF =G =@A F<SSBAFFEGH GM nGGSABGHF >HC

=@<F =G =@A CAF=B<?=EGH GM =@A q<>H=<P EH=ABMABAH?A AtA?=F BAFSGHFEe`A MGB dVI

=@A P>_HA=E? jA`C >?=F >F >H µ‹€¶ CAS@>FEH_ FG<B?A

K

l@A gA>W `G?>`E]>=EGH

?GBBA?=EGHF =G ª >BA HGgI

ªøª : 1 VW =X Y 3  ü; 7< ý
ý …  † ; =÷ h "·¸ a u $ w i … J K Q J † g@ABA h !!!

i EHCE?>=AF >H >hAB>_A GhAB >`` ?`GFACm CEt<FEhA S>=@F

K ‡SGH >hAB>_EH_m gA _A= hA rS… / ³´ …††i k ArS…  

ø¹†m g@ABA ¹ EF >H AtA?=EhA CAS@>FEH_ =EPA

C<A =G §

K

l@A `>==AB q<>H=E=b ?>H eA AF=EP>=AC eb >B_<EH_ =@>= EH=ABMABAH?A EF

CAF=BGbAC g@AH =@A P>_HA=E? i<r =@BG<_@ > CEt<FEhA `GGS GM FE]A …

 ¹† < =÷ EF GM =@A GBCAB GM ° 2 I §  ¹ : ° 2 º ¹ : ÿ÷ ¹ ø  ! … J K QQ†

f= EF HGg F=B>E_@=MGBg>BC =G AF=EP>=A =@A P>_HA=G?GHC<?=EhE=bI

ª…§†  ª¹ * 2 : "÷ 0 » `H ¼ ¹ VW ½¾ 3 Q ¿ ¼ ¹ ½¾ 3 ¦ … J K Q ¦ †

    

l@A EH?BA>FA GM ª >F > M<H?=EGH GM § …HA_>=EhA P>_HA=GBAFEF=>H?A† @>F eAAH Gek

FABhAC MGB > `GH_ =EPA K w= Z X m[ P<F= eA BAS`>?AC eb [a >HC =@A ?@>B>?=ABEF=E?

P>_HA=E? jA`CF >BA CA=ABPEHAC eb =@A ?GHCE=EGH ÿ¹ : [am E

K A K m § : 0ªø"[÷ a K l@EF ?GHCE=EGH EF Aq<Eh>`AH= =G –¨  : 0øaÀý © 0øÀý K fH G<B PGCA` 0øÀý 6 J >HC

=@ABAeb =@A ?@>B>?=ABEF=E? jA`CF >BA FG gA>W =@>= =@A ?GHhAH=EGH>` P>_HA=GBAFEFk

=>H?A EF SB>?=E?>``b ]ABG

K

aGB gEBAF gE=@ CEt<FEhA gEC=@ l d ÿm=@A P>_HA=E? B>=A h>BEAF q<>CB>=E?>``b

gE=@ =@A P>_HA=E? jA`Cm J øa… §†  ¼ W ½ W ¯§÷øÁÂmg@ABA ¯ EF =@A ?BGFF FA?=EGH GM

=@A gEBAm>HC =@A ?GHF=>H= ÁÂ CASAHCF GH =@A _AGPA=Bb GM=@A gEBAm=@A CEBA?=EGH

GM =@A P>_HA=E? jA`C >HC =@A F?>==ABEH_ PA?@>HEFPF  Y



K

aGB Ar>PS`Am MGB > Qk

CEPAHFEGH>` gEBA GM CEt<FEhA ?BGFF FA?=EGH EH > SABSAHCE?<`>B P>_HA=E? jA`Cm E=

bEA`CF ÁÂ

¦K

aGB > gEBA gE=@ e>``EF=E? ?BGFF FA?=EGHm l à ÿm>HC > P>_HA=E? jA`C SABSAHCE?k

<`>B =G E=F ?BGFF FA?=EGHm =@A P>_HA=E? jA`C CASAHCAH?A GM =@A gA>W `G?>`E]>=EGH

?GBBA?=EGH =G =@A ?GHC<?=EhE=b EF gA>WAHAC eb i<r ?>H?A``>=EGH AtA?=F C<A =G

eG<HC>Bb F?>==ABEH_  JX



K f

M =@A P>_HA=E? jA`C EF FG FP>`` =@>= `AFF =@>H GHA

i<r q<>H=<P ´

2

Īø" EF SAHA=B>=EH_ >H >BA> lÿm =@A AtA?=EhA CAS@>FEH_ B>=A J

øa… §† EF q<>CB>=E?>``b EH?BA>FEH_ >F MGB CEt<FEhA ?BGFF FA?=EGHF

K T

GgAhABm E=F

F`GSA EF FP>``ABeb >=`A>F= > M>?=GB løÿm>F > ?GHFAq<AH?A GM=@A i<r ?>H?A``>=EGH

AtA?= GM AC_A =G AC_A FWESSEH_ GBeE=F  JX m JJ  K d@AH §lÿ d ´ 2

m =@A AtA?=EhA CAS@>FEH_ B>=A J

øa…§† g>F MG<HC eb > FAPEk

?`>FFE?>` PA=@GC =G EH?BA>FA GH`b `EHA>B`b gE=@ =@A P>_HA=E? jA`C §  JX

m JJ



K

lG ?GH?`<CAm > gA>W P>_HA=E? jA`C ?>H?A`F =@A `A>CEH_ GBCAB dV ?GBBA?=EGHF

=G =@A CEt<FEGH ?GHF=>H= >HC =@A ?GHC<?=EhE=b

K T

GgAhABm @E_@AB GBCAB ?GH=BEe<k

=EGHF MBGP =@A ±µ‰~{„ |{±~ >`GHA `A>C =G > BAHGBP>`E]>=EGH GM =@A CEt<FEGH

?GHF=>H= AhAH EH =@A <HE=>Bb AHFAPe`AF

K

f= EF CEÙ?<`= =G Ah>`<>=A @E_@AB GBCAB

?GH=BEe<=EGHF CE>_B>PP>=E?>``bm FEH?A =@A U<H?=EGHF eA=gAAH CEt<FGH `>CCAB CEk

>_B>PF …FG ?>``AC ’

T

EW>PE eGrAF’† HAAC =G eA CBAFFAC eb > H<PeAB GM EPS<BE=b

`EHAF

K

l@A SBGe`AP EF AhAH @>BCAB =G =>?W`A gE=@EH FAPE?`>FFE?>` F?@APAF

K fH FA?=EGH J K Q K

Q gA gE`` EH=BGC<?A > jA`C =@AGBA=E? >SSBG>?@ g@E?@ =<BHF G<= =G eA

ECA>` MGB FG`hEH_ SBGe`APF g@E?@ _G eAbGHC `Gg GBCAB SAB=<Be>=EhA ?GBBA?=EGHF

K

u

GBAGhABm gA gE`` FAA =@>= @E_@AB GBCABm F<e=`A q<>H=<P EH=ABMABAH?A AtA?=F CG

`A>C =G `G?>`E]>=EGH GM >`` AE_AHF=>=AF EH `GgkCEPAHFEGH>` FbF=APFm AhAH EH =@A

SBAFAH?A GM > P>_HA=E? jA`C

K

“f“f² ¡Â´—ž™œ­

w= HGH]ABG `Gg =APSAB>=<BAFm =@A EH=AB>?=EGH GM =@A A`A?=BGH gE=@ =@A AHhEBGHk

PAH= S>B=E>``b CAF=BGbF =@A gA>W `G?>`E]>=EGH AtA?=F

K

pHAB_b Ar?@>H_A eA=gAAH

=@A A`A?=BGH >HC =@A AHhEBGHPAH= <SFA=F =@A ?GHF=B<?=EhA EH=ABMABAH?A eA=gAAH

=EPAkBAhABFAC S>=@Fm =@<F F<SSBAFFEH_ =@A nGGSABGH PGCAF

K

     EH>H= CAS@>FEH_ PA?@>HEFP >HC a EF _EhAH eb  7Å mg@ABA Æ Qø ¦ MGB > J kC gEBA >HC Æ J MGB > QkC j`P  J Qm J ¦  K

D<A =G A`A?=BGHkS@GHGH F?>==ABEH_m =@A ArSGHAH= ?BGFFAF GhAB =G Æ [

>=

@E_@ABme<=HG==GG @E_@m=APSAB>=<BAFmM<`j``EH_=@A EHAq<>`E=b cÇ 6 …0÷

øÀý†ÈÂm

g@ABA ÈÂ EF=@A GS=E?>`DAebA S@GHGH MBAq<AH?b  J[



K l

@EF SGgAB ?>H eA FP>``ABm

C<A =G =@A ?GHjHAPAH=m EH q<>H=<P gEBAF

K w= AhAH @E_@AB =APSAB>=<BAFm =@ABA EF > ?BGFFGhAB =G Æ ¦ …EH FGPA >PGBS@G<F PA=>`Fm =G Æ Q † g@E?@ EF >`FG C<A =G A`A?=BGHkS@GHGH EH=AB>?=EGHF  J[  K L

@>FA ?G@ABAH?A EF >`FG gA>WAHAC eb EPS<BE=EAF gE=@ EH=ABH>` CA_BAAF GM MBAAk

CGPmF<?@ >F P>_HA=E? EPS<BE=EAF

K

dA gE`` eBEAib CEF?<FF P>_HA=E? EPS<BE=EAFEH

=@A HAr= FA?=EGH

K

fH J

D >HC QD FbF=APFm =@A S@AHGPAHG`G_E?>` CAjHE=EGH GM a _EhAH EH FA?=EGH J

K J

K¦

EF HG= >SS`E?>e`A >= Ar=BAPA`b `Gg =APSAB>=<BAFm g@AH =@A S@>FA ?G@ABAH?A

`AH_=@ [a eA?GPAF ?GPS>B>e`A =G =@A `G?>`E]>=EGH `AH_=@ [

¨

GM A`A?=BGHE? g>hAk

M<H?=EGHF

K

fM =@A FbF=AP FE]A [ EF >`FG `>B_AB=@>H [¨m=@A SAB=<Be>=EhA =BA>=PAH=

GMCEFGBCAB G<=`EHAC EH =@A SBAhEG<F FA?=EGHF eBA>WF CGgH >HC > HGH SAB=<Be>=EhA

=@AGBb EF ?>``AC MGB

K

“f“f¸ ¬—­œ¡›™– ™¤Â¯Ÿ™›™¡ž —œ  žÂ™œÌ•ŸÐ™› ž–—››¡Ÿ™œ­

fH =@A SBAFAH?A GM P>_HA=E? EPS<BE=EAFm q<>H=<P EH=ABMABAH?A EF S>B=E>``b CAk

F=BGbAC FEH?A =@A A`A?=BGHE? S>=@ EF S>B=E>``b WAS= =B>?W GMm C<A =G =@A iESSAC

EPS<BE=b FSEHF BAhA>`EH_ =@A hEFE= GM >H A`A?=BGH

K

w S@AHGPAHG`G_E?>` P>_HA=E?

F?>==ABEH_ B>=A É ?>H eA EH=BGC<?AC =G >??G<H= MGB =@EF HAg F?>==ABEH_ PA?@>k

HEFP

K

l@A EH=AB>?=EGH AHAB_b GM >H A`A?=BGH gE=@ > F@GB=kB>H_A P>_HA=E? EPS<BE=b

`G?>=AC >= È · ?>H eA gBE==AH >F g É õÉÊ Ë ®¢ · …Ÿ  È · †mg@ABA Ê Ë >HC ¢ · CAHG=A =@A

A`A?=BGH >HC EPS<BE=b FSEHm BAFSA?=EhA`bm >HC õÉ EF =@A F=BAH_=@ GM =@A EPS<BE=bk

A`A?=BGH P>_HA=E? EH=AB>?=EGH

K

wFF<PEH_ =@>= =@A P>_HA=E? EPS<BE=EAF >BA CE`<=A

…E

K A

K

 6 Ɇm=@A F?>==ABEH_ B>=A 0øÉ =>WAF =@A MGBP  J s I 0 É Q_#ý …Ìm %õÉ %÷h ¢Í ÷ i† … J K Q [ †

g@ABA Ìm EF =@A P>_HA=E? EPS<BE=b ?GH?AH=B>=EGH >HC h !!!

i CAHG=AF >H >hAB>_A

GhAB =@A … >FF<PAC† B>HCGP CEBA?=EGHF GM=@A EPS<BE=b FSEHF

K

fMÉ d a…†m=@ABA

EF HG =APSAB>=<BA CASAHCAH?A GM =@A ?GHC<?=EhE=b

K

R

SEHkGBeE=F?>==ABEH_mEH ?GH=B>F= =G P>_HA=E?kEPS<BE=bF?>==ABEH_mCGAFHG=hEk

G`>=A =EPAkBAhABF>`FbPPA=Bb

K T

GgAhABmE=FAtA?= GH =@A ?GHC<?=EhE=b EFHGH =BEhk

E>` FEH?A E= BAhABFAF =@A FE_H GM =@A q<>H=<P ?GBBA?=EGH >HC BAC<?AF =@A F=BAH_=@

eb > M>?=GB GM =gG  J s K l@A ?GHC<?=EhE=b EF =@AH ŠŒƒ Î ƒ =@>H ?`>FFE?>``b ArSA?=AC K

dA gE`` HGg SBGhECA > S@bFE?>` SE?=<BA MGB =@A FSEHkGBeE= AtA?=F MG``GgEH_

BAMABAH?A  JZ



K

e Ï    Ð

>FF<PEH_ > B>H_A GM =@A EPS<BE=b SG=AH=E>` 6 ÿ†I

õ û / õÉÑ…Ò Ò Òj† ® Ê Ë k õ … J û /Ó ® Ê Ë † … J K Qs† g@ABA Ó õÉÑøõ …Ò ÒÒ j †m Ò >HC Òj

>BA =@A A`A?=BGH PGPAH=> eAMGBA >HC >M=AB

F?>==ABEH_

K l

@EFGSAB>=EGHbEA`CF> BG=>=EGHGM Ê

Ë eb >H_`AF Ó · >BG<HC =@A FSEH >rEF K

d@AH > S>B=E?`A EFF?>==ABAC MBGP F=>=A %Òi%Ê

Ë i=G F=>=A %  Ò i%Ê Ë j im=@A >??<P<`>=EhA

AtA?=FGH =@A FSEH >CC <S =G > jHE=A BG=>=EGH

8 F<?@ =@>= %Ê Ë j i 8 %Ê Ë i K l@A P>=BEr GM =@A FSEH BG=>=EGH EFI 8  ?GF… œ øQ†" · uÔÕ a w=÷ / FEH… œ øQ†" 7 · uÔ 7 a w=÷ / FEH… œ øQ†"·uÔ 7 a w=÷ ?GF… œ ø Q †" 7 · uÔÕ a w=÷  … J K Q Z † g@ABA ° m œ >HC ´ >BA p<`AB >H_`AF …FAA  J§ † K

aGB =@A =EPAkBAhABFAC F?>==ABEH_

SBG?AFFm =@A jH>` F=>=A EF %  Ò i%Ê Ë jj im g@ABA %Ê Ë jj i 8 7< %Ê Ë i K l @ABAMGBAm =@A

EH=ABMABAH?A =ABP gE`` ?GH=>EH >H >CCE=EGH>`M>?=GB h Ê Ë jj %Ê Ë j i h Ê Ë %8÷%Ê Ë i K wFF<PEH_ =@>= %Ê Ë i % û J ø Q

im=@A `>==AB P>=BEr A`APAH= eA?GPAF

h Ê Ë jj %Ê Ë j i  FEH ÷ … œ ø Q † û ?G F÷ … œ øQ†ArS… / ° û / ´† ! … J K Q § †

fM =@ABA EF HG FSEH iESm =@AH >`` >H_`AF >BA ]ABG >HC =@A P>=BEr A`APAH= EF J

I gA

@>hA =@A BA_<`>BgA>W `G?>`E]>=EGH ?GBBA?=EGH

K

fM=@A FSEHkGBeE= ?G<S`EH_ EFF=BGH_m

=@A FSEH F=>=A CEt<FAF GH =@A <HE= FS@ABA >HC =@A GBEAH=>=EGHF GM =@A jH>` FSEH

F=>=AF >BA F=>=EF=E?>`

K

l@ABAMGBA =@A >hAB>_A GM … J K Q § † bEA`CF =@A M>?=GB  J øQ …GM

?G<BFAm =@EF BAF<`= CGAF HG= CASAHC GH =@A EHE=E>` F=>=A %Ê

Ë i†

K

wF CEF?<FFAC >eGhAm >H Ar=ABH>` P>_HA=E? jA`C CAF=BGbF =EPA BAhABF>` EHh>BEk

>H?A >HC >?=F >F >H AtA?=EhA CAS@>FEH_ MGB?A

K T

AH?Am EH =@A ?>FA GMFbF=APF gE=@

F=BGH_ FSEHkGBeE= F?>==ABEH_m=@A ?GHC<?=EhE=b F@G<`C CA?BA>FA g@AH =@A P>_HA=E?

jA`C EF =<BHAC GH  J ¦  K l

@EF SBACE?=EGH @>F eAAH ?GHjBPAC ArSABEPAH=>``b  JZ



K

çèÖ ×óØîôÙ íîïëðñòëóñîô

“f«f“ ¢™œ­˜¡ ڗŸ—¤¡›¡Ÿ ¢–—˜™œ­

l@A CEPAHFEGH`AFF?GHC<?=>H?A GM> CkCEPAHFEGH>`P>?BGF?GSE?>``b@GPG_AHAG<F

@bSAB?<eA GM `EHA>B CEPAHFEGH V EF CAjHAC >F

Û … [† k s… [† "÷ ø0 ! … J K Q ¨ † g@ABA s… [† ª[ ; 7 ÷ K

w??GBCEH_ =G =@A GHAkS>B>PA=AB F?>`EH_ =@AGBb GM `Gk

?>`E]>=EGH Qm s

m >=  X

=@A =B>HFSGB= SBGSAB=EAF GM > CEFGBCABAC FbF=AP >BA

CA=ABPEHAC eb

Û

…[† >`GHA

K u

GBA FSA?Ej?>``bmEM gA ?GHFECAB > @bSAB?<eA GM `EHA>B

e Ï    Ý ?GHC<?=>H?A GM =@A `>B_A ?<eA CASAHCF GH`b GH Ü >HC =@A ?GHC<?=>H?A GM A>?@ e`G?WI Û …Ü[† Þ…Ü Û …[†† … J K Q Y †

aGB > ?GH=EH<G<F h>BE>=EGH GM =@A `EHA>B CEPAHFEGH GM =@A FbF=APm gA _A= eb

CEtABAH=E>=EH_ Aq<>=EGH … J K Q Y † Qm sm Z I 3 `H Û 3 `H[ [ Û 3 Û … Ü[† 3 [ J Û 3 Û … Ü[† 3 Ü J Û 3 ޅ Ü Û † 3 Ü k ߅ Û † ! … J K¦ X †

l@ABAMGBAm =@A `G_>BE=@PE? CABEh>=EhA GM

Û EF FG`A`b > M<H?=EGH GM Û E=FA`M K l@EF >B_<PAH= EF GM ?G<BFA h>`EC GH`b EM [ EF `>B_AB =@>H >Hb G=@AB PE?BGF?GSE? `AH_=@

F?>`A GM =@A FbF=AP …üým ÿ†

K fM ߅ Û † Z X

m =@A ?GHC<?=>H?A EH?BA>FAF gE=@ =@A FE]A GM=@A F>PS`Am >HC hE?Ahk

ABF> MGB HA_>=EhA ß

K l

@ABAMGBAm =@A F?>`EH_ M<H?=EGH ß FSA?EjAF =@A =B>HFSGB=

SBGSAB=EAF MGB > FbF=AP EH =@A =@ABPGCbH>PE? `EPE=

K

l@A `EPE=EH_ eA@>hEG<B MGB

=@A ßkM<H?=EGH ?>H eAA>FE`bGe=>EHACI EH=@A `EPE=GMgA>WCEFGBCABmE

K A K MGB Û d J m

=@A FbF=AP F@G<`C F@Gg PA=>``E? eA@>hEG<B >HC =@A ?GHC<?=>H?A EF CAF?BEeAC eb

?`>FFE?>` =B>HFSGB= =@AGBbI s… [† ª[ ; 7 ÷ K T AH?A ߅ Û † 3  Q CASAHCF GH`b GH

=@A CEPAHFEGH>`E=b GM =@A FbF=AP

K fH =@A `EPE= GM F=BGH_ CEFGBCAB … Û 6 J †m =@A ?GHC<?=>H?A @>F =@A MGBP Û …[† n ArS…  [øà†m g@ABA à EF =@A `G?>`E]>=EGH `AH_=@m

>HC =@A ßkM<H?=EGH CASAHCF `G_>BE=@PE?>``b GH

Û m ߅ Û † `H Û û ª ! … J K¦ J †

f= EF =@ABAeb HA_>=EhA EH >Hb CEPAHFEGH MGB FP>``

Û

K

f= EF HGg BA>FGH>e`A =G >FF<PA =@>= =@A F?>`EH_ M<H?=EGH EF > ?GH=EH<G<Fm

PGHG=GHE?>``b EH?BA>FEH_ M<H?=EGH GM

Û

>HC =G CB>g E= eb EH=ABSG`>=EH_ MBGP =@A

>FbPS=G=E? eA@>hEG<B >= `>B_A >HC FP>`` Û …FAA j_ K J K s† K l@EF >FF<PS=EGH EF ?GBk

BGeGB>=AC eb =@A =@AGBb GMgA>W `G?>`E]>=EGHmg@E?@ SBACE?=F HA_>=EhA ?GBBA?=EGHF

=G =@A ?`>FFE?>` ?GHC<?=>H?A EH >Hb CEPAHFEGH K aGB EHF=>H?Am MBGP MGBP<`> … J K Z †

gA Ge=>EH MGB =@A >FbPS=G=E? F?>`EH_ M<H?=EGH EH =@A =gGkCEPAHFEGH>` ?>FAI

߅ Û †  J _ ÷ Û ! … J K¦ Q† l@A jBF= BAF<`= GM =@A F?>`EH_ =@AGBb EF =@>= EH ¦ D =@ABA EF > jrAC SGEH= m CAjHAC eb ߅ Û ¨ † X

m g@E?@ ?GBBAFSGHCF =G =@A PA=>`kEHF<`>=GB =B>HFE=EGH CAF?BEeAC eb

wHCABFGH

K

fM gA F=>B= gE=@ > FbF=AP gE=@ ?GHC<?=>H?A `>B_AB =@>H

Û ¨

m <SGH

EH?BA>FEH_ =@A FE]A GM =@A F>PS`A =@A ?GHC<?=>H?A EH?BA>FAF >HC =@A FbF=AP iGgF

=G =@A PA=>``E? BA_EPA K vH =@A ?GH=B>Bbm EM =@A ?GHC<?=>H?A GM G<B F>PS`A EF FP>``AB =@>H Û ¨ m =@A FbF=AP eA?GPAF >H EHF<`>=GB EH =@A `EPE= [ ¬ á K fH =@A J D >HC Q

D ?>FAm ß EF >`g>bF HA_>=EhA >HC =@ABAMGBA >H EHF<`>=EH_ BA_EPA F@G<`C

>`g>bF eA BA>?@AC EH =@A =@ABPGCbH>PE? `EPE=mHG P>==AB @Gg gA>W =@A CEFGBCAB

EF

e Ï    e

d=3

d=2

d=1

β( g)

ln g

g

c

?@ABCD EFâG ‚UD OSNP@RA MBRSK@IR ãŒ

ä

 NO N MBRSK@IR IM PR

ä F

R

@GB=`b >M=AB=@A gGBWFGH =@A F?>`EH_ =@AGBb GM`G?>`E]>=EGHm> jA`C =@AGBA=E?>`

>SSBG>?@ g>F CAhA`GSAC EH GBCAB =G _EhA > MGBP>`U<F=Ej?>=EGH =G =@A >FF<PS=EGHF

P>CA EH Qm s

K

l@A HAr= FA?=EGH gE`` CA CAhG=AC =G =@EF >SSBG>?@

K “f«f« ³´¡ ϕœÌ”™œ¡—Ÿ ª ̬• ¡˜ wF gA CEF?<FFAC EH FA?=EGH J K J K J m =@A >hAB>_A GM =@A SBGC<?= st…r û – †sv…r†

?GH=>EHFEHMGBP>=EGHGH EH=ABMABAH?A AtA?=F>HC =@<Fq<>H=<P `G?>`E]>=EGH

K fH =@A

CE>_B>PP>=E? GB FAPE?`>FFE?>` =@AGBb GM gA>W `G?>`E]>=EGHm =@>= SBGC<?= ?>H eA

?>`?<`>=AC GH`b SAB=<Be>=EhA`b …EH =@A S>B>PA=AB J øcýÿ† K fH =@A R <SABFbPPA=BE? HGH`EHA>B ªkPGCA` >SSBG>?@m =@A >hAB>_A hs t å sv å 7æ i EF ?>BBEAC G<= Ar>?=`b eb

ArSBAFFEH_ E= >F > M<H?=EGH>` EH=A_B>` GhAB ?`>FFE?>` >HC ;B>FFP>HHE>H jA`CF  J¨  K VA=9F BA?>`` =@A F=>HC>BC EH=A_B>`F 1 ç è é * < 3 ÷ê é ArS…  & · ë ê , · ( ·ë ê ë † _ ç CA= ( … J K¦¦ † 1 ç è é * < 3 ÷ê é êìê , í ArS…  & · ë ê , · ( · ë ê ë † _ ç CA= ( … ( 7< †ì í … J K¦ [ † g@ABA 3 ÷ê é 3 c A ê 3 fP ê 3 ê , 3 ê øQ / >HC î ( P<F= @>hA > SGFE=EhAm BA>` S>B= MGB

e Ï    e ?GHhAB_AH?A K fM gA =>WA î ( / …r û / - î g†m =@A FA?GHC EH=A_B>` bEA`CF 1 ç è é * < 3 ê , é 3 ê é ê í ê , ” ArS… / & · ë ê , · …r û / - g · ë †ê ë † / … / _† ç s í ” CA=…r û / - g ·ë † … J K¦ s† g@ABA -Z X K R

EH?A =@A EPS<BE=b SG=AH=E>` AH=ABF =@A `AM=k@>HC FECA GM … J

K¦

s† GH`b hE> =@A

ArSGHAH=E>` M<H?=EGHm E= EF A>Fb =G =>WA =@A >hAB>_A GM =@A EH=A_B>` MGB ;><FFE>H

CEFGBCAB

K T

GgAhABm SABMGBPEH_ =@EF >hAB>_A CGAF HG= bEA`C =@A >hAB>_A GM =@A

A`A?=BGHE? ;BAAH9F M<H?=EGHm FEH?A =@A BE_@=k@>HC FECA GM … J K¦ s† >`FG ?GH=>EHF =@A CA=ABPEH>H= GM î ( K

lG _A= BEC GM =@EF >gWg>BC CA=ABPEH>H=m pMA=Gh A= >`

K  JY m Q X 

EH=BGC<?AC >H=E?GPP<=EH_ ;B>FFP>HH h>BE>e`AF

K

f= ?>H eA F@GgH =@>= =@A

;B>FFP>HH >H>`G_<AF GM =@A ;><FFE>H ’eGFGHE?’ EH=A_B>` … J K¦¦ m J K¦ [ † _EhA 1 <ïïï ç è é 3ð , é 3ð é ArS…  & · ë ðñ · ( · ë ð ë † CA= ( ! … J K¦ Z † 1 <ïïï ç è é 3ð , é 3ð é ð ì ð , í ArS…  & · ë ðñ · ( · ë ð ë † … ( 7< †ì í CA= ( ! … J K¦ § †

l@ABAMGBAm eb EH=BGC<?EH_ > F<SABFbPPA=BE? ;><FFE>H EH=A_B>` GhAB > FA= GMFbPk

PA=BE? >HC >H=EFbPPA=BE? jA`CFm GHA ?>H A`EPEH>=A =@A <Hg>H=AC CA=ABPEH>H=

K

wH>`G_G<F`bm GHA ?>H CAjHA =@A >hAB>_A GM =@A SBGC<?= GM =gG ;BAAH9F M<H?k

=EGH EH =ABPF GM > PGBA ?GPS`E?>=AC M<H?=EGH>` EH=A_B>` GM =gG FA=F …BA`>=AC =G

=@A st >HC sv BAFSA?=EhA`b† GM ;B>FFP>HH >HC eGFGHE? jA`CFm ?GPSGFEH_ >H

AE_@=k?GPSGHAH= F<SABFbPPA=BE? jA`C hA?=GB …FG ?>``AC F<SABjA`C† ò

K

wM=AB >hk

AB>_EH_m GHA Ge=>EHF >H EH=AB>?=EH_ òók=@AGBbm g@ABA =@A EH=AB>?=EGH F=BAH_=@ EF

SBGSGB=EGH>` =G =@A h>BE>H?A GM =@A B>HCGP SG=AH=E>` …m %õ %÷ MGB =@A SG=AH=E>` … J K ¨ †† K l@A M<H?=EGH>` EH=A_B>` CAjHEH_ hs tsvi EF EHh>BE>H= <HCAB > _BG<S GM =B>HFMGBP>=EGHF ò ¬ ò z

=@A P>=BE?AF  CAjHA > FbPPA=BE? FS>?A >HC ?GHFEF=F

GM=gG e`G?WF GM [

Ò [

P>=BE?AF BA`>=AC =G =@A ?GPS>?= >HC HGH ?GPS>?= FA?=GB GM

=@A S>B>PA=AB FS>?A BAFSA?=EhA`b

K l@A GtkCE>_GH>` e`G?WF >BA S>B>PA=BE]AC eb ;B>FFP>HH h>BE>e`AF K l@A EH=AB>?=EGH =ABP ?>H eA CA?G<S`AC hE> > T <ee>BCk R =B>=GHGhE?@ =B>HFMGBk

P>=EGH eb EH=BGC<?EH_ > HAg ;><FFE>H EH=A_B>` GhAB ¨ Ò ¨ ô P>=BE?AF K l@A HAg

jA`C P<F= ?>S=<BA =@A M<`` FbPPA=Bb GM =@A M<H?=EGH>` EH=A_B>` EH GBCAB =G F<?k

?AAC EH CAF?BEeEH_ q<>H=<P `G?>`E]>=EGH AtA?=F

K

l@ABAMGBAm =@A jA`C ô

P<F= `EhA

EH =@A FbPPA=BE? FS>?A CAjHAC eb =@A P>=BE?AF  >HC EF =@<F ?GPSGFAC GM eG=@

?GPP<=EH_ >HC >H=E?GPP<=EH_ jA`CF

K

wM=AB EH=A_B>=EH_ G<= =@A jA`C òm=@A >?=EGH GM =@A F<SABP>=BE?AF ô eA?GPAF ¯ ô  _0 [ ³ 1 3 Ÿ R =B ô ÷ …Ÿ† û J Q 1 3 Ÿ h Ÿ % R =B`H õ 7< … î Ÿ î  †%Ÿi … J K¦ ¨ †

e Ï    ee g@ABA =@A SBGS>_>=GB õ EF _EhAH eb õ… î Ÿ î  †   î ö÷ Qùú û …– û / †ö ` Q û / 0 Q ô … î Ÿ † 7< … J K¦ Y † >HC ³ Q_ m %õ %÷ø0 EF =@A PA>H `AhA` FS>?EH_ K ö ` EF > ¨ Ò ¨ CE>_GH>` F<SABP>k

=BErmg@GFA <SSAB >HC `GgAB [ Ò [ CE>_GH>` e`G?WF >BA ÷ >HC  ÷ BAFSA?=EhA`b K w FP>`` EP>_EH>Bb S>B= /  … Z X † EF >CCAC =G –

=G >FF<BA =@A ?GHhAB_AH?A GM =@A

EH=A_B>`F

K

R

EH?A EH =@A FAPE?`>FFE?>` `EPE= üý 6 ÿ EH=ABMABAH?A AtA?=F G??<B >= `AH_=@

F?>`AF P<?@ `>B_AB =@>H ÿm =@A S@bFE?F GM `G?>`E]>=EGH EF _GhABHAC eb `GH_ g>hAk

`AH_=@ PGCAF GM ô K l@A AtA?=EhA >?=EGH GM =@AFA PGCAF … J K¦ ¨ † ?>H =@AH eA

Ge=>EHAC eb ArS>HCEH_ >BG<HC =@A @GPG_AHAG<F F>CC`A SGEH= FG`<=EGH GM … J K ¦ ¨ †m g@E?@ F>=EFjAF MGB – X ô / _#ý h Ÿ %…r  î ö÷ Qùú û / 0 Q ô † 7< %Ÿi ! … J K [X † w FG`<=EGH GM =@EF Aq<>=EGH EF ô 2 ö ` m g@E?@ ?GBBAFSGHCF =G =@A R n N w … J K Y † MGB =@A A`A?=BGHE? FA`MkAHAB_b K aGB – X

m =@A BG=>=EGHF ø g@E?@ `A>hA ô

EH

=@A FbPPA=BE? FS>?A bEA`C =@A ?GPS`A=A P>HEMG`C GM F>CC`A SGEH= FG`<=EGHF >F ô

øö

` ø

K

l@A BG=>=EGHFg@E?@ `A>hA ö

`

EHh>BE>H=?>H eA M>?=GBE]AC G<=m`A>hEH_

=@A F>CC`A SGEH= FG`<=EGHF ô

=G eA A`APAH=F GM > FAPEFEPS`A F<SABFbPPA=BE?

FS>?A

K

u

GBAGhABmMGB üý 6 ÿ =@ABA >BA P>FFEhA `GH_E=<CEH>` PGCAF g@E?@ GH`b ?@>H_A

=@A F@GB= CEF=>H?A S@bFE?F …>= `AH_=@ F?>`AF GM =@A GBCAB GM ÿ† >HC ?>H =@<F eA

EH=A_B>=AC G<=

K

l@ABAMGBAm GH`b =B>HFhABFA PGCAF S`>b >H EPSGB=>H= BG`A EH =@A

S@bFE?F GM `G?>`E]>=EGH

K

l@AFA PGCAF SBAFABhA =@A HGHk`EHA>B ?GHF=B>EH= ô ÷…Ÿ† ù K fM GHA ArS>HCF =@A >?=EGH ¯ ô 

>BG<HC =@A F>CC`A SGEH= FG`<=EGHm GHA _A=F

¯ ô  _#ý ¨ 1 3 Ÿ R =B  …  ô †÷ û Q / …– û / †ö ` ô  ! … J K [J †

l@EF >?=EGH CAF?BEeAF =@A F`Gg FS>=E>` i<?=<>=EGHF GM ô

>= jHE=A MBAq<AH?b

–

K

l@AFA PGCAF >BA U<F= =@A CEt<FEGH PGCAFm =@A DEt<FGHF >HC =@A nGGSABGHFm

g@E?@ gA CEF?<FFAC EH FA?=EGH J K J K J K

l@AEB ArEF=AH?A EF =@A ?GHFAq<AH?A GM =@A

FSGH=>HAG<F eBA>WEH_ GM =@A F<SABFbPPA=Bb

K l@A MBAq<AH?b – S`>bF =@A BG`A GM >H Ar=ABH>` jA`C K

l@A jA`C =@AGBb CAF?BEeAC eb =@A >?=EGH … J K [J † >HC =@A ?GHF=B>EH= ô øö ` ú øm ô ÷…Ÿ† ù

…g@ABA ø EF >H >BeE=B>Bb <HE=>Bb F<SABP>=BEr†

eA`GH_F =G =@A ?`>FF GM HGH`EHA>B ªkPGCA`F K w= – X m ¯ ô 

EF EHh>BE>H= gE=@

BAFSA?= =G =@A =B>HFMGBP>=EGH ô ¬ ø ô ú ø ! … J K [ Q†

w ?GHF=>H= P>_HA=E? jA`C ?>H eA =>WAH EH=G >??G<H= eb P>WEH_ =@A BAS`>?Ak

PAH= î  ¬ î  û …"øª† î  ` ʅ î Ÿ † EH MGBP<`> … J K ¦ Y † K l@A CE>_GH>` L ><`E P>=BEr  `

e Ï    e€

@>F =G eA EH=BGC<?AC FEH?A A>?@ F<SABhA?=GB ?GH=>EHF eG=@ HGBP>` >HC ?GPS`Ar

?GHU<_>=A h>BE>e`AF …FAA  J¨



†

K

fM =@A jA`C EF hABb gA>Wm ÿ 6 ÿ¹m E=F AtA?= ?>H eA

?GHFECABAC >F > FP>``SAB=<Be>=EGH >HC > HAg AtA?=EhA >?=EGH MGB =@A F`Gg PGCAF

GM ô

?>H eA Ge=>EHAC eb P>WEH_ >H ArS>HFEGH EH eG=@

 ô

>HC Ê >BG<HC =@A

F>CC`A SGEH= FG`<=EGH GM =@A >?=EGH … J K ¦ ¨ † K l @EF ArS>HFEGH bEA`CFI ¯ ô  _#ý ¨ 1 3 Ÿ R =B   …  ô û / " ª Ê ô  ` †÷ û Q / …– û / †ö ` ô  ! … J K [ ¦ † w??GBCEH_ =G =@EF BAF<`=m =@A CA_BAAF GM MBAACGP GM ô =@>= ?GPP<=A gE=@  ` BAk

P>EH <HSAB=<BeAC eb > P>_HA=E? jA`Cmg@E`A =@GFA CA_BAAF GM MBAACGP g@E?@ CG

HG= ?GPP<=A >?q<EBA > P>FF

K

l@A MGBPABCAHG=A =@A CEt<FEGH PGCAFg@ABA>F =@A

`>==AB BASBAFAH= =@A jA`C FAHFE=EhA nGGSABGH PGCAF

K

l@ABAMGBAm EM =@A jA`C § EF

F=BGH_ AHG<_@ …e<= F=E``F>=EFjAF ÿ 6 ÿ¹†m =@A EHi<AH?A GM =@A nGGSABGHF eA?GPA

HA_`E_Ee`A >HC ?>H eA HA_`A?=ACm EH >_BAAPAH= gE=@ =@A CEF?<FFEGH SBAFAH=AC EH

FA?=EGH J K J K Q K

fH =@EF`EPE==@A FbF=AP ?>H eA AtA?=EhA`b CAF?BEeAC eb [ Ò [ P>=BEk ?AF K

l@A F>CC`A SGEH= FG`<=EGHF >BA =@AH A`APAH=F GM > CEtABAH= FbPPA=BE? FS>?Am

FEH?A =@A =ABP ?GH=>EHEH_ =@A hA?=GB SG=AH=E>` EH … J K [ ¦ † eBA>WF =@A FbPPA=Bb … J K [ Q† K l

@EF AtA?= EF <`=EP>=A`b C<A =G =@A jA`C § eBA>WEH_ =@A =EPAkBAhABF>`

FbPPA=Bb GM =@A

T

>PE`=GHE>H …<HE=>Bb AHFAPe`A†

K

d@AH ÿ¹ eA?GPAF ?GPS>B>e`A =G ÿm =@A EHi<AH?A GM GBeE=>` AtA?=F eA?GPAF

FE_HEj?>H=

K

fH =@EF ?>FA gA AH=AB =@A q<>H=<P

T

>`` BA_EPAmg@E?@ EF HG= ?GBBA?=`b

CAF?BEeAC eb =@A >?=EGH … J K [ ¦ † K

dA gE`` CEF?<FF =@EF BA_EPA EH ?@>S=AB

¦K

fM GHA g>H=F =G F=<Cb FSEH EH=AB>?=EGHF …P>_HA=E? EPS<BE=EAF >HC FSEHkGBeE=

EH=AB>?=EGH†mGHA @>F =G EH=BGC<?A =gG AE_@=k?GPSGHAH=F F<SABjA`CFm ?GBBAFSGHCk

EH_ =G FSEHk<S >HC FSEHkCGgH S>B=E?`AF K l@ABAMGBAm =@A P>=BE?AF ô P<F= @>hA JZ Ò JZ ?GPSGHAH=F K

fH =@A SBAFAH?A GM P>_HA=E? EPS<BE=EAFm =@A FbPPA=Bb GM ô

EF =@A F>PA >F EH =@A SBAFAH?A GM > P>_HA=E? jA`C …=@G<_@ =@A CEPAHFEGH GM

=@A P>=BE?AF EF @E_@AB†m g@ABA>F > FbF=AP gE=@ FSEHkGBeE= EH=AB>?=EGHF …>HC HG

P>_HA=E? EPS<BE=EAF† eA`GH_F =G > HAg FbPPA=Bb ?`>FFm =@A FbPS`A?=E? ?`>FFm EH

g@E?@ =@A =EPAkBAhABF>` FbPPA=Bb GM î

g

EF SBAFABhAC e<= =@A ?AH=B>` FbPPA=Bb EF

eBGWAH

K

f= EF SGFFEe`A =G F@Gg =@>=m EH =@A `EPE= g@ABA =@A CAhE>=EGHF GM =@A P>=BEr ô

MBGP =@A F>CC`A SGEH= FG`<=EGH ö

` >BA FP>``m > SAB=<Be>=EhA ArS>HFEGH GM … J K [J †

bEA`CF=@A q<>H=<P ?GBBA?=EGHF =G =@A ?GHC<?=EhE=b CEF?<FFAC EH SBAhEG<FFA?=EGHF

K

f= @>F eAAH SBGhAH =@>= =@A F<SABFbPPA=BE? HGH`EHA>B ªkPGCA` …©Vªk PGCA`†

EF BAHGBP>`E]>e`A K u GBAGhABm E= @>F eAAH F@GgH =@>= > BAHGBP>`E]>=EGH _BG<S =BA>=PAH= GM … J K [J † EH …Q û

ˠ CEPAHFEGHF bEA`CF =@A F?>`EH_ M<H?=EGH ?GH UA?=<BAC

eb weB>@>PF A= >`

K EH Q



K T

GgAhABm E= EF HG= ?`A>B bA= g@A=@AB =@A ©Vª PGCA`

>HC =@A GHA S>B>PA=AB F?>`EH_ =@AGBb CG ?GBBA?=`b CAF?BEeA =@A PA=>`kEHF<`>=GB

=B>HFE=EGH EH CEFGBCABAC PA=>`F

K R

EH?A =@A F=>=EF=E?>` CEF=BEe<=EGH GM =@A ?GHC<?k

=>H?A

Û

CGAF HG= M<`j`=@A ?AH=B>` `EPE==@AGBAPmGHA ?G<`C _<AFF =@>= =@A >hAB>_A

e Ï    e PGPAH=F GM =@A CEF=BEe<=EGH GM Û F@G<`C eA =>WAH EH=G >??G<H= K l@EF EPSGB=>H=

EFF<A EF ?<BBAH=`b =@A F<eUA?= GM EH=AHFA BAFA>B?@

K

f

H =@A ?>FA GM q<>FEk J

D FbF=APF gE=@ CEt<FEhA gEC=@ l d ÿm =@A >?=EGH … J

K [J

†

?>H eA FEPS`EjACeb =>WEH_EH=G >??G<H=GH`b=@A ]ABG=B>HFhABF>`FS>?A @>BPGHE?F

GM =@A F<SABP>=BEr ô I ¯ ô  _#ýl ¨ 1 3û R =B   … 3 ô 3û †÷ û Q / …– û / †ö ` ô  ! … J K [[ †

l@A >eGhA >SSBGrEP>=EGH EF h>`EC SBGhECAC =@>= =@A H<PeAB Ü

¨ GM =B>HFhABF>` ?@>HHA`F GM =@A gEBA EF `>B_A K f= =<BHF G<= =@>= =@A q<>FEk J D ©VªkPGCA` ?>H

eA FG`hAC Ar>?=`b eb <FEH_ =@A =B>HFMABkP>=BEr PA=@GC

K

l@A e>FE? ECA> eA@EHC

=@EF PA=@GC EF =G BAC<?A =@A M<H?=EGH>` EH=A_B>` GhAB =@A F<SABP>=BE?AF ô =G > CEtABAH=E>` Aq<>=EGH K l@EF EF ?GPS`A=A`b >H>`G_G<F =G CABEhEH_ > R ?@BG^CEH_AB

Aq<>=EGH MBGP =@A ?GBBAFSGHCEH_ q<>H=<PkPA?@>HE?>` aAbHP>H S>=@ EH=A_B>`

K

fH =@A SBAFAH= ?>FAm =@A BG`A GM =@A S>B=E?`A ?GGBCEH>=A EF S`>bAC eb =@A P>=BEr ô

m g@E`A =@A BG`A GM =@A =EPA EF S`>bAC eb =@A ?GGBCEH>=A

û

>`GH_ =@A gEBA

K dA

gE`` CEF?<FF =@EF PA=@GC PGBA Ar=AHFEhA`b EH =@A MG``GgEH_ ?@>S=AB

K fH Q J  m =@A `G?>`E]>=EGH `AH_=@ [¨ GM q<>FEk J

D CEt<FEhA gEBAF g>F Ge=>EHAC

MBGP =@A FS>=E>` CA?>b GM =@A CAHFE=b ?GBBA`>=EGH M<H?=EGHm g@E?@ g>F ?>`?<`>=AC

eb =@A >eGhA PA=@GC

K l@A BAF<`= g>FI [ ¨ ß_0#¯  … J K [ s† g@ABA ¯ EF=@A gEBA ?BGFFFA?=EGH K fH … J K [ s†mß J Q [ ?GBBAFSGHCF=G HG P>_HA=E?

jA`C …GB=@G_GH>` AHFAPe`A†m jHE=A P>_HA=E? jA`C …<HE=>Bb AHFAPe`A† >HC F=BGH_

FSEHkGBeE= F?>==ABEH_ …FbPS`A?=E? AHFAPe`A† GB P>_HA=E? EPS<BE=EAFmBAFSA?=EhA`b

K

fH =@A HAr= ?@>S=ABm gA gE`` CABEhA MGBP<`> … J

K [

s† …<S =G > H<PABE?>` ?GAÙ?EAH=†

eb ?>`?<`>=EH_ > FSA?=B>` ?GBBA`>=EGH M<H?=EGH

8

àü‘ŽáŽ ×àáØâàØŽ ؏

ãؒŽÔÕ‘Ô‘Õ ÖàÖæ Øԑ’

fH =@EF ?@>S=AB gA ?GHFECAB =@A P>_HA=E? jA`C CASAHCAH= `G?>`E]>=EGH EH > CEFGBk

CABAC q<>H=<P gEBA EH > HGHSAB=<Be>=EhA M>F@EGH

K

dA EH=BGC<?A > ?GBBA`>=EGH M<H?=EGHm =@A ><=G?GBBA`>=EGH M<H?=EGH GM FSA?=>`

CA=ABPEH>H=F …w

R

D†mg@E?@ CEtABF MBGP =@GFA EH=BGC<?AC EH =@A SBAhEG<F ?@>S=AB

EH =@>= E= CGAF HG= HA?AFFE=>=A =@A <FA GM =@A M<`` F<SABFbPPA=BE? PA=@GCm e<=

F=E`` SBGhECAF EHMGBP>=EGH GH q<>H=<P `G?>`E]>=EGH

K

dA jHC > ?GH=EH<G<F EH?BA>FA GM =@A `G?>`E]>=EGH `AH_=@ gE=@ =@A P>_HA=E?

jA`CmF>=<B>=EH_ >==gE?A E=F h>`<AgE=@G<= P>_HA=E? jA`C

K

l@A ?BGFFGhAB eA@>hEGB

EF F@GgH =G eA _GhABHAC eG=@ EH =@A gA>W >HC F=BGH_ `G?>`E]>=EGH BA_EPA eb =@A

P>_HA=E? S@>FA F@EM=EH_ B>=A 

7< ¹

K l

@EF q<>H=E=b EF CABEhAC >H>`b=E?>``b EH ?`GFAC

MGBP >F > M<H?=EGH GM =@A B>=EG GM =@A PA>H MBAA S>=@ ÿm=@A gEBA =@E?WHAFF l >HC

=@A P>_HA=E? `AH_=@ ÿ¹

K N

G=@ S>B>eG`E? gEBAF >HC gEBAF gE=@ FSA?<`>B eG<HC>Bb

?GHCE=EGHF >BA ?GHFECABAC

K

v<B BAF<`=F _AHAB>`E]A SBAhEG<F CABEh>=EGHF GM ¹ MGB

CEFGBCABAC gEBAF

K

aEH>``bm gA CEF?<FF =@A >SS`E?>eE`E=b GM =@A >H>`b=E?>` MGBP<`>F =G BAFEF=>H?A

PA>F<BAPAH=F EH =@A F=BGH_ `G?>`E]>=EGH BA_EPA >HC gA ?GPS>BA G<B BAF<`=F gE=@

BA?AH= ArSABEPAH=>` gGBW eb ;ABF@AHFGH A= >`

K Q

Q 

K

w ?GPS>BEFGH gE=@ BA?AH=

H<PABE?>` gGBW EF >`FG P>CA

K

l@A BAF<`=F SBAFAH=AC EH =@EF ?@>S=AB @>hA eAAH S<e`EF@AC EH Q

¦ 

K

Öèç ýþê ëÿóîïîØØêðëóñîô ÿôïóñîô î
êïóØëð êóêØñôëôó

fH =@A SBAhEG<F ?@>S=ABm gA @>hA FAAH =@>= =@A F=<Cb GM F=BGH_ A`A?=BGH `G?>`E]>k

=EGH EH > CEFGBCABAC SG=AH=E>` HA?AFFE=>=AF > HGHSAB=<Be>=EhA >hAB>_EH_ GM SBGCk

<?=F GM;BAAH9F M<H?=EGHF

K

l@EF?>H eA >?@EAhAC eb PA>HF GM=@A F<SABkFbPPA=Bb