MarketdiﬀerencesinwildandfarmedmarineﬁshintheSpanishseafoodmarket Rodriguez,GonzaloandBande,Roberto MunichPersonalRePEcArchive

(1)

Munich Personal RePEc Archive

Market differences in wild and farmed marine fish in the Spanish seafood

market

Rodriguez, Gonzalo and Bande, Roberto

University of Santiago de Compostela, University of Santiago de Compostela

8 October 2014

Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/59142/

MPRA Paper No. 59142, posted 08 Oct 2014 01:57 UTC

(2)

! " # $ "% & ' (

)*+ # $ # %

, -. ! " # $

"% & ' ( )*+ # $ # %

$ / 0

! " # $ 1# 2 "%

& ' ( )*+ $ 3 # % 4 0 567 8+ )96 :: ;

)*9% ;0 567 8+ ))889)% - 0 % < %

(3)

. / / = = / ;

=/ / / % >/ / ? /

/ / % . / /

" / = / 18:@

# / / 2 " / # / ? %

4/ / " ? / /

%

A B # B ? %

(4)

. / / = = / ;

=/ / / 1 C C % :::B / % ::)B & -

D' ::82% >/ / ? /

/ / % = ? 1 : 62 / / = / /

= % & / / = / = /

= / / # / ? %

4/ " / " / / /

/ "

/ % 4/ / % ::) ; / E ?

/ = 1 ? / 2 1 / 2

/ ? % # / " / !%#%

? 1$ F 8882 / / ? =/

= =/ /

/ 1 / % :: B # G G % :: 2%

/ C C % 1 :::2 / " / A / / =

/ ; / / / 1# / 2

/ / ? = / / 4/ / H ? 4 I /

/ = = / / % ,

/ % 1 : 2 / / = ? = = -

/ / / / !%#% ? % 4/ J ?

% 1 : 2 K / ? / /

A " /%

(5)

/ / = / "

/ /

/ / ? % ? / " /

1E % :::B & % ::*2 ?

" %

L / / / " / / 1 8+:M : :2 = /

A / ; " +%+

= = /

/ = 1 L : 2% # = = /

N ?

/ " 1 8+)2 /

%

! / N / 0 2 /

=B 2 / = " " = A

B 2 / " ? = =

/ # / ? % . / / ; A

" / = A " / %

# / N " / / ?

? # %

/ / " / / " / # /

/ A 18:@ : 2 /

A / ! " " : 1 $

: 72%

4/ = % # / / /

# / ? % # 6 / /

(6)

= / / % # 7 /

# ) # 9 %

# / / / N /

% / " / ; " / /

=/ / ? =

; / / /%

? # / = / / !

/ / / % # / !K

. / N % # ? ;

/ 1 # / ::+2% /

# / ? / ? / /

" / / ? = / /

" = / A " / / = = / / / /

/ = / / ): ? ( " = /

A " % 1J A D ::+2% & / & = /

/ = / / / ? %

L " / / # /

=/ ? = ? 1O P2 =/ ? / = 7 @ ::9

1, # ::*2% L , =/

+%+97 / : / =/ ?

# 1, : 2%

(7)

! # / A

# 0 ,

# / / A /

=/ / /

/ /

= / ,

4/ / " /

/ 1 7

" ? A

31,6%

28,1%

19,2%

18,1%

2,9%

Value

% : %

" : 6%

/ / / 0

+8%8@ " *+%8@

/

# /

/ & /

= " /

7) ::82 = / / /

N

38,8%

33,9%

17,2%

6,7%

3,4%

Quantity

Other

Northern bluefin tuna Turbot

Gilt head sea bream European Seabass

%8@ " % 4/

/ %

/ -+: /

$ %

?

una

(8)

! % # /

# 0 L /# :

! "% # /

# 0 L /# :

0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000

1980 1982 1984 1986 1988

Aqua

0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000

1980 1982 1984 1986 1988

Aqua

= % 8+:- ::8%

: %

= % 8+:- ::8%

: %

1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008

Aquaculture (tn) Catches (Tn)

1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008

::8%

(9)

! #% # /

# 0 L /# :

# =

"

/ N

69 8*)%9

4 ?

# % ;

A -

/ /

/ 98 ))*% ::

# 1 / : 2% J

0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000

1980 1982 1984 1986 1988

Aqua

= % 8+:- ::8%

: %

= / / /

/ ,

N % . ::8

6 9)6%7 1 / :

= = = /

/ / =/

Q /

= 4 ? ? %

" = "

/ ? % .

::8 =/ / 9: ::: $/

/ = 8 6+% =/ / **%+@ =

J ; = /

1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008

/ /

/

: 2 = / /

/

? %

"

/ % . =

=

/ ;

(10)

/ =% ;

/ # / & / %

"

" $

4/ / / =/

, 1, 2% 4/ / =/ ? # "

::* / % #

" E ::* , / : =/ / 96 "

9 % ! ::8 = / =

= % = / / ;

" = / " /

= %

" / ? / " " % / / ?

:: :: / " / /

= / / 1D % ::72% L / / /

# / /

= % . 88 /

/ " /

1 ::+2% $ # / / /

= / / ? = %

" =/ / / / =/ /

= / / %

4 R ? %

(11)

S " / ? T / = / =/ / /

= T 1# 898B % +)2%

> A ?

/ ? / % 4/ =

1 : 62 = A / / 0 2 / / " / / A

/ = ? / ?

B 2 / /

? =/ /

" B 2 / " / # / ? =/

, A / =

/ ; %

! %% J " = , % E % ::*-, %

: %

# 0 , : %

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

01/07 04/07 07/07 10/07 01/08 04/08 07/08 10/08 01/09 04/09 07/09 10/09 01/10 04/10 07/10 10/10 01/11 04/11 07/11 10/11 01/12

Farmed Wild

(12)

! &% J " = , % E % ::*-, % : %

# 0 , : %

! '% J " = , % E % ::*-, %

: %

# 0 , : %

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

01/07 04/07 07/07 10/07 01/08 04/08 07/08 10/08 01/09 04/09 07/09 10/09 01/10 04/10 07/10 10/10 01/11 04/11 07/11 10/11 01/12 04/12

Farmed Wild

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

01/07 04/07 07/07 10/07 01/08 04/08 07/08 10/08 01/09 04/09 07/09 10/09 01/10 04/10 07/10 10/10 01/11 04/11 07/11 10/11 01/12

Farmed Wild

(13)

) 9 * / = /

" (? % ? / / =

" % 4/ / /

= / / / % 4/ "

/ =/ / /

, /% # = ? / / / /

/ % . = ? / /

/ / / / " / / *%:

(? 1 6%6: / =/ 2 =/ / /

+%+: (? 1+%9) / =/ 2% " / /

/ / = / / /

/ / / / / / %

! " / = / / / /

= = % S = " =

/ / / %

"

. / = / % L ?

=/ / A / ? 1

/ / 2 1 =/ / / /

2% 4/ / " / ?

% 4/ / =

1# 8982 / / /

? % / /

/ ? " / / % % /

(14)

% = / % 1 ::)2 " /

? / / ? - / =/ /

= 0 ε

β β − =

− _: 1 2

=/ / / " ? 1 U 2 β:

/ A

=/ β / / = / % . β / / /

= / % 4/ = / / ? %

S = " β U / / = / / " = /

% 4/ / ? / ;

/ = / = %

. / ; / / ? / /

" " / % % =/ / /

% . / / ; / ?

/ % . β: β / A

1 2 / / = % . = /

/ = N / ;

/ = / " % 4/ / / = / " β:

β % 4/ / 1 / ::)2 / E / / % D

× " 1 2 / = "

1V 2 / " / " 1DW ? / K G ::72

/ = 0

+ + Γ + Π + + Π

= ₋ %%% ₋ µ 1 2

(15)

=/ / / Π × ; µ

/ " × "

= / " ; Ω

4/ V " = = 0

+ + Π +

∆ Γ + +

∆ Γ

=

∆ ₋ %%% ₋ ₋ ₊ ₋ ψ 162

> / Γ =− +Π +%%%+Π = %%% − Π =− +Π +%%%+Π % 4/ Π /

- " 1 2% . " .1 2 " / / /

1 - 2 " A 1 2 .1:2 =/ / - / 162

1 2 " % " / / - /

1 2 =/ / / /

/ Π ; % 4/ ? Π

/ / % . /

" / " % . ΠU: /

% :X / " % 4/ =

αβQ

=

Π =/ α β × =/ β /

/ α / N % E / 1 8++ 88 2 "

/ " %

4/ / E / / / ? / / " "

" .1 2 .1:2% " - /

" / / ? =

/ " = = 1 # /= 8+* D , K 8+8

/ 8++ $ / 88 J & 889 $ K :: 2% 4/

/ / = / / " = = /

" = 1$ / 88 2% % , " /

(16)

/ = " / = ? =/ /

" .1 2 / .1:2% . " ?

? = / / /

1 / :: 2 / / ? = /

= = %

4/ J 1 8892 J #/ 1 8882

/ " D 1 D2 " /

% 4/ / / = / / " /

/ " =/ / / " "

/ " / - = / /

N % 4/ " " = /

% / = / ; / % %

/ ; % 4 $ 1 $,2 " /

D " " / " 0

+ +

+

∆ +

=

∆ ₋ ₋

=

−

=

−

: δ δ

α 172

>/ ∆ / / / 1

= / .$ / # $2 δδδδ

" / % 172

/ N / " / " -

% S = " / / -

" =/ / / .1:2 .1 2% J 1 8892 / "

/ " " /

/ = " 0 / /

" / .1 2 / / /

(17)

/ % 4/ " " /

/ " .1 2 .1:2% . / -

/ = " / ; / %

. / " / - = / / " / /

" / / % #/ = / /

" / D = / /

=/ / / / / / /

D / " %

# (

> =/ / / 1 2

.1:2 .1 2 / / " /

= / = / 1= / "

/ / " / " / 6 / ;2% 4

/ / ? - 1 2 / " %

> / " / / KJ## / J/ -J /

4 % > / " " /

A %

(18)

4 % ! %

4 / = " -

/ " / / / -

= 1 " 2 / / 8)@ " % S = " =

/ = = = = / /

:@ " " % & /

" / )@ " / " -

=/ / - /

= %

" / = / D / " /

" % L / - D

/

+ +

+

∆ +

=

∆ ₋ ₋

=

−

=

: − δ δ

α 172

=/ / = / " % & ; =

/ N / " A 172

a. Original variables

V $ & $ &

# 1 A 2 -6% 8 -:% + -8%)6 -8%)+

# 1 2 -7% 8 -:%*7 -8%: -8%:9

# 1 A 2 -6% ) -:%7 - :% 9 - :%67

# 1 2 - %+7 -:%9* -+%+* -+%8)

4 1 A 2 - %+* -:%* -)% * -)% +

4 1 2 - % -:%86 -9%86 -9%87

)

V $ & $ &

# 1 A 2 -6% 6 :%:) -8% + -8%66

# 1 2 -7%) -:% -*%6 -8% 7

# 1 A 2 - %+9 -:% ) -8%98 -8%**

# 1 2 - %*7 -:% + -*%*) -*%+

4 1 A 2 - %+7 -:%9: -)%7 -)%77

4 1 2 - % * -:%9 -9%7* -9%78

D "

(19)

/ = / / " J

J 1 ::82 J 1 8892 / " %

4 %

4

/ = " / / = / / 1

2 / " / - = / 8)@ " =/ /

= N / = / /

" / % . / / / /

/ = ; / / / =

/ % , " / = / " "

" / / " 1 A 2

= / / 1 2 = N /

% 4/ / D / /

/ % 4/ /

" = N / = / /

? =/ / / %

-#

# UY :86

UY )7

# UY 8:6

UY 7 :*:

4 UY 7 +7

UY +:

D = !

6 *86 7 +))

(20)

4 6 / / E / /

" 1=/ / / = - 2% .

/ / " / , ; " # = / )@

" / / N % .

/ / / / / # / ?

%

4 6

% $

J " / 1 % : 62 / # / ? / / = / =

/ ? % $ /

/ / = / % /

" = = / / ? % .

/ = = / = ; / =

/ %

$ / / = / / # / ? =

% % 8:@ / # / / A /

% & " / / / / # /

, ;% " # :%:) " -"

#

U: 8%69 7% 9 :% )9

U )%99 6%+7 :%: *

4

U: 7%:8 7% 9 : :)6

U 7* + 6+7 :%: 8

(21)

? =/ / R / / # 1 2

1 2% # / / / %

4/ " / / / ? / . # /

" / E / ; /

1E -4 % ::*2% & /

" / ? %

E % 1 :::2 / ? = = /

/ 1 =/ / ? 2 # = / %

" / / R / =

" 1& % ::*B / % ::)2 = / /

/ # / ? %

! = ; / / =/ ; / 0

• J # / %

• 4/ " " ; " %

? =/ = / / = / = =

1$ % : 2% . " "

/ = A / = / 1K ::6B V ? % ::* 2

/ " " " / / A

1 , ::+2% # , J 1 ::82 $

% 1 ::82 Z -J D 1 : :2 / "

/ " = A = / / % & /

" / " = A "

1$ % : 2%

. / ; " A 1 2

" 1 / " " /

(22)

/ 2 / / " 1

2% / / ? /

1 " / 2 / / / - / /

? / = / =

/ %

& *

. / # / ? = / /

? / ? ? / /

. J % & " / /

A / / %

4/ / " ? / / % > /

/ / = =

/ / / / / " / = /

A % L / / " / = ?

? / / / A % 4/ = ; /

/ / " /

/ %

? / =

1 " ; " 2 / /

/ / / /

/ " / %

(23)

L / / / A / A

/ % & " / / / /

/ / A / " %

4 / ? = / ? A

/ ? / = / / % . =

/ / / /

/ = % $ A / I

= / / % / ?

1 " / / / 2 = / " / / ?%

/ / /

? " / / ? /

/ / %

/ / ? = = = /

/ / " / / =

/ = / / / ? %

. = / / / / 1 D 2 =

; / / =/ "

= / / / =/ /

%

(24)

' (

E% D% 1 8+)2 T, ? . = A / $ -

J $ / T , - 7%

/ % N[ 4% \ E% % 1 :: 2 , ? A

J % #& > ? J :(: B :: % $ / % %

/ # 4 # % 1 ::)2 $ =

= 0 4/ E ? % % 66 666-

67:%

/ % D%#% L % # / ,% % 1 : 2 !# #/ ?

% ? " > ? J -:8% & /

" / %

4% /N ,% % \% 1 : :2% O, ? # / / , ?

& B $ P% E #

1620 )* M 9+%

C C $% $ ,% D % 1 :::2 . / =

/ / 0 / ? %

% 6 ))-9+%

/ #% 1 8++2% L /

% E / S ? ! " = ? ] %

$ ,% D% K 1 :: 2% # / / /

0 " / JJJ % E .

, :1)20968-9)*%

$ % D% % ' D% S Z ,% % , .% %

1 : 2% $ / N % ;

/ /

/ % ^ J 91 2 )8M 99-

$ J%D%B %V% 1 8882 J 0 ? / !# =

? % A , 6 86M :7%

$ 1 : 72% A M %

/ 0(( % % ( / ( ( A ( ( ;_ %/

$ / E% 1 88 2% A / % E

$ )0 *)- +7%

- , / 1 , 2 1 ::+2 .

" / / A % $

% L : " 0

/ 0(( % % ( / ( ( ( _ " ( ;_ %/

$ 1 : 72% / $ / J %

% : 7 % J L / !

D ; % , : 7 " 0

/ 0(( % % ( / ( ( ( _ %

(25)

L / ! & 1 L2 1 : 2 #

> / A : #L . L / A

%

/ 0((===% % ( (: 9( * * ( * * : %

Z Z % .% 1 ::+2 $ " 0 3

``P a % " . $ # ] *%

Z -J E% F D D% 1 : :2% A =

# % A , 71 2% 76-9

L / ! & 1 L2 1 : 2 .#S#4 4

J 0 ! " = / % V %6% ::: %

# /% ::+% ! # % " 0

/ 0((===% ? % ( /( - - " ( - ( (

D% $ % S Z ,% % % ' D% JC % % 1 ::82%

$ 3 '

; " % . `.. $ & % , 1 3 20

! " J C , %

E #% J #% 4 % b !% 1 :::2 J =

= / / / # / ? % A

, 7 )*-9+%

E C -4 % - -S E% E% -L % 1 ::*2% , ?

/ / ? A F , 0

66- ):%

E / #% 1 8++2% # " E

$ 0 6 - )7%

E / #% 1 88)20 ! " #! $ % ! & ! $ '

(! L; ! " J L; %

K % J% >% 1 ::62% $ = /

" " ? = % . E% % D E% L / / G F % c '

1 %2 ^ / / % D

1 % 686M7::2% > 0 > J / %

D % $% , K 1 8+82% 4/ = / "

% , $ " % E 7:0 :6- 6+%

D # D% Z J E% ,% D ; % . # ,

,% A ' $% 1 ::72 !

::6- ::9% # : " 0

/ 0((===% % ( ( - - - -

- - - - ::6- ::9

DW ? / S% K G ,% 1 ::72 4 # % $

! " J $ ! K %

, K E% % 1 8892 &

% E 9: -9 +%

, , , 1, ,2 1 ::82 , Z

% L " $ '

(26)

% L : : " 0

/ 0((===% % ( ( ( ( - - - -

- ( _ _ _ *-+:)8%

, J N E%,%B # A J% 1 ::*20 O$ '

A 3 P ' $ d % 8 - Z %

)- %

, $ # 1 : 2% . : % " 0

/ 0((===% % ( ( _ _ _ :

& ,% # G G E% D E% # K% V E% S ? % 1 ::*2

, ? % , 1 2

8)- 6%

& -D' % ::8% $ = = 0 /

!# ? % , ) 7 6*- ) %

J A J D 1 ::92% # ? 0 "

" " = ! , % L ,C C 19 2076-))%

J ? #K " K J ,%B : % / = A

/ / K % A

, 91 20 : - 9

J J% #% & 1 8892% ! = /

/ % " = # 96076)-79)%

J % S% J 1 ::82% 4 # , )%:%

L; ! " J L; %

J S% \% #/ 1 8882% " /

% . #% # 1 %2 * ! !+ * ! !+ , ! - .

# -/ , 0 $ # 1-+ ! +)$/ % 6* -7 6%

$ ! " J $ %

J S% \% #/ %E% # / 1 8892% 4 / ;

/ % = ? ] 89 ! " $ %

- %B %B V #% 1 : 62% L % 1& 2 ?

= = / / # /

? % A F , % *0 6+:-68*%

# /= >% 1 8+*2%

% E , :0 *6- :6%

# G G E% , ?= J% V E% S ? % # K% 1 :: 2 4/

/ ? % J / " /

$ / . . / 4

8^/- > & = b %

# %E% 898% 4/ / % , , D %

V ? >% # .% K% S = #% F V $ E% 1 ::*2% $

" " = /0 ; /

% A . )1 2 M 69%