• Keine Ergebnisse gefunden

Corporategovernance,affirmativeactionandfirmvalue:evidencefrompost-apartheidSouthAfricanfirms Ntim,collinsgandOpong,kwakukandDanbolt,jo MunichPersonalRePEcArchive

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Aktie "Corporategovernance,affirmativeactionandfirmvalue:evidencefrompost-apartheidSouthAfricanfirms Ntim,collinsgandOpong,kwakukandDanbolt,jo MunichPersonalRePEcArchive"

Copied!
44
0
0

Wird geladen.... (Jetzt Volltext ansehen)

Volltext

(1)

Munich Personal RePEc Archive

Corporate governance, affirmative action and firm value: evidence from

post-apartheid South African firms

Ntim, collins g and Opong, kwaku k and Danbolt, jo

University of Glasgow

11 July 2010

Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/32297/

MPRA Paper No. 32297, posted 18 Jul 2011 12:38 UTC

(2)

!

" # $%

! "

# # " $%&' (

! " !

(

" & $% & ) *+, -..-

-../ " " !

! 0 1( 2 "

" "

(

# (

$ %

" "

" ( 2 "

" " #

(

$ ! %

( " " "

# #

( "

" #

( ' !(

& !

(3)

*

%) "*+, %*)

"

3 4 5 # *,/+

# " ! "

# 6 # 4 -.*. ( $ "

" " " # "

( ! " #

" ( 7

" # "

-..,8 9 # 4 6 -.*. "

" " 4 : *,,+8 ;

2 < 4 = -..+ (

; 5 % 4 7 -..>

? 0

9 9 : 4 9 -..>8 2 4 : -..@ ( 6 (

-.*. " ? 0

" " (

" # " "

4 6 -..+8 ; 4 ; -..A (

4

<< -.., ( $ "

(4)

-

? 0 "

!

5 ; # 4 -..,8 6 ( -.*.

) "

% 4 5 # -..B8 ; 4

C -..>8 4 D -..@8 ; ( -..+8 ; # 4 7 -..,8

$ 4 E -.*. ( $ "

" ( # "

! " (

" ! (

$ 0

" ! ( $ "

-..- : 6 : %%

! " #

" " " (

" # "

$%&' ( #

#

! # "

" -.*. (

(5)

B

! "

" # ?

!

# : # 4 : : # -..- ( C

# "

! " 9

-../8 D -.., ( C

5 4 -..B8 -.*. " #

# (

6 "

#

# " 5 4 -..B ( $ " ! # "

" "

: 5 -../8 5 4 -..A (

% " !

"

# # " $%&' (

% " !

(

3 # ! 3 9 "

( E

! "

(6)

>

" ! "

< # " ( % " # ?

! ( 7 "

! *+, -..-

-../ @. -..- : 6 : %% (

" "

! ! (

" " " !

# # (

7 " !

" "

" (

C " "

! ! 0 "

" # ( C "

" ! 0 1

"

( 2 "

"

" " !

# 0 1( C

" "

# ! (

(7)

@

" ( ! !

! ( "

" # (

- *) . %" % %*) )+ - "%*" /% " ,"

( 7 #

" 0 "

5 4 -..B ( #

(

" ; 4 : *,,@

! " $ -..A (

" #

$ 4 $ -..+ ( E

" " # 5 4 -..B "

% *,,A8 3 9

6 -../ " # : 6 -..-8 D -.., ( %

! "

! " (

C " (

" *,,> : % -..- : %% 4

< -.., " D

(8)

+

5 " D

D ( E

* B !

F 0 -.*. (

F 0 #

?

! "

# # " D #

" $%&' >

! ( !

( 7 ! -..B

; # " "

" (

"

" ( %

"

! "

(

" !

) ( 7 ! ( -..B

D -..@ ; # ( -.., ! " !

) " "

( % ( -..+ ;

(9)

/

; -..A " )

"

( G

( E ; ( -..> "

2 < ( -..> ; ( -..+

" (

6 ( -.*.

"

"

( 9

# ( ; # -..* ; # ( -..+ ; # : -../ $ -..A

<H < -..A " !

6 : % & <

( " # : 4 9

-..>8 2 4 : -..@8 5 ( -..,

" ( C

( -.*.8

6 ( -.*. ? #

!

: 4 9 -..>8 5 ( -.., ( 7 ! 9 -... ? 0

: 9 -..> 2

(10)

A

: -..@ *

(

!

" # " ( 7 " *+,

# :

4 9 -..>8 2 4 : -..@ "

" (

" !

: %% " # ? 0 # 2 4 : -..@8 5 ( -..,

! #

" $%&' (

" " " !

# 0 # ( 7

" !

"

(

+ )+ " " - -*+*/* 0

+ +

C -,* - 3 B*'*-'-../

* ( G * "

" 3

" (

(11)

,

% *

E "

( " !

( " "

" (

" I 0 -..- -..+

0 -..B -../

(B " ( 7 "

$ -..A

? -..B (

" #

( $ " * <

" : 4 9 -..>8 5 ( -..,

( !

: 4 9 -..>8 2 4 : -..@

" "

" ( )

* *+,

-,*> A>@

(

(12)

*.

" &! +

C ! "

@. : %%

I * " - B #

> @

( !(

3 "

(

C ( 7 #

( -..B < -.., (

" ; ( -..+ !

" 5 ( -..,

! # ( !

>

! # " $%&' (

" F*0 @. : %%

F.0 " ( E 0

" < .J *..J " !

( "

( -..B " (

7 # " "

; # ( -..+

(13)

**

" "

( " !

; ( -..+ ( "

" ; ( -..> ( 7 "

"

( -..B8 $ -..A8 5 ( -..,

" " ( !

3 4 5 # *,/+ "

" (

# " 0

1 @( 7 " 4 G *,,> # #

# # ( %

# 0 0 (

0 "

0 # $ 4 $ -..+ (

" " ! (

- !

< #

" "

" (

% -

7 " " "

" " 2 4 :

(14)

*-

-..@ ( "

( -.*. ( ;

$ -..A (

3 *,A+

" F " 0 ( %

"

! " 3 *,A+ (

# ; ( -..+ ( ;

" : 4 9 -..>

( ! " !

< ! " (

# # ?

; # ( -..+8 6 ( -.*. ( $ "

# " (

7 "

< 2 *,A*

( $ " " < ( 7

" 0

" 0 " " $ 4

$ -..+8 6 ( -.*. ( E

"# " " ( 7 " $

-..A8 -.., " " (

" -..B -../

(15)

*B

(+ C9

I

=

+ +

+

= !

*

*

*

*

*

. β β ε

α *

" I

0 1 ! (

α. (

% !(

! "

! < !

< $

"# (

ε (

1 / %

" : *,,+ !

( C9

* ( E

"

! ( < %

& # ' ! ! ! " ( E !

# " (

" ( % " - + "

( ( ( %

" /

(16)

*>

" "

(

( E " !

"(

% 2 3 %45 7

&

' ! ! ! % ! "

! < ! < $

( ! )

* ( 9 ! ! )

I

! )

%

! !

' !

&

ε β

β β

β β

β α

+ +

+ +

+ +

+

=

=*

@

>

B -

* .

-

/ & 3/ 45 F " 0

3 *,A+ ( & (

; 2 -..> & " <

" ( $ " ! & " < !

( # # 3

*,A+ " ! " " !

" " &(

& ! ! ) * ( D

! ! )

I

(17)

*@

! )

%

! !

' !

&

ε β

β β

β β

β α

+ +

+ +

+ +

+

=

=*

@

>

B -

* .

B

6 7 *( 36/'*8)45 " #

" 3 4 5 # *,/+ ( %

# " " !

" $ 4 $ -..+ ( $

# " ' ! ( % ;

( -..+ ' ! ! < ! ( "

: *,,+ " "

" "

" ' !( !

" ' ! " ' ! ;

( *,,@8 D -.., ( ' ! ! ! )

* ( ! ! ! )

I

! )

%

! !

&

' !

ε β

β β

β β

β α

+ +

+ +

+ +

+

=

=*

@

>

B -

* .

>

% *( 3%) *8)45 2

; ( *,,@ ( $

" ! ! ( %

" " " 4 :

*,,+ " ! " ! <

! ( " ! !(

(18)

*+

! ! ! ! ) * ( $

! ! ! )

I

! )

%

' !

&

! !

ε β

β β

β β

β α

+ +

+ +

+ +

+

=

=*

@

>

B -

* .

@

6 9 36 %: 45 9 "

$ 4 $

-..+ ( ; -.., "

" ( <

% ( " ( -.*. " !

! " % (

! < ! < $

( " % ( ; <

! ! ) * ( !

! ) I

! )

! !

' !

&

%

ε β

β β

β β

β α

+ +

+ +

+ +

+

=

=*

@

>

B -

* .

+

3#45 7 ! # "

(

* ! (

I

(19)

*/

*

*

*

*

@

*

>

* B

* -

*

* .

=

+ +

+

+ +

+ +

=

!

%

! !

' !

&

ε β

β

β β

β β

α

/

%"% / " ,/

" + , " & !

B ( % "

0 .(/- ! B(+./" *(@+

" # ( C

! " " "

( 7 ! +J B

@. ! ,AJ >, @. " " +*J @.

! "

(

% B

B "

" ( 7 ! " /AJ

" +>J "

! (

& % ' ! ! ! " !

" (

2 4 : -..@8 6 ( -.*. (

(20)

*A

C9 C9

( >

!

# " G 0

0 ( ;

(

% >

! "

!

" ? ! ( E

" "

#0 2 E (

C9

( C " : 4 9 -..>8

5 ( -..,

" # (

" ( 7 ! # "

"

( % < " "

(

" */ 3 4 " & !

(21)

*,

@ C9 ( B @

" > ,

A

@ ( B @

" .(..B K(..* ( $ "

B @

(

> , @ (

% @

"

( "

" # (

0

+*J A.J ! "

# +J *, ! .(..B *(@+ *(+@ + , ( C

; # ( -..+8 6 ( -.*.

"

: 4 9 -..>8 2 4 : -..@8 5 ( -.., (

" > , @

" ( 7 ! <

" "# " "

< (

% " $ -..A

(22)

-.

! ; ( -..+ $

4 $ -..+ (

!

! #

! ( " !

" "

" 5 4 -..B ( $ "

! " #

" ( # : # 4 : : # -..-

" # (

% -.*.

" #

# !

( "

# "

( E " "

! " (

+ C9 ( B +

"

> ,

@ ( B

+ " .(..-

(23)

-*

K(..* ( B + "

" (

" "

> , +(

% +

" .(..* .(..A(

" "

" # (

( E ! : %%

3 0 # #

" # (

# " "

( %

" " < B (

" #

# " 5 4 -..B (

" " ? " "

" # (

? "

" ! # " " (

(24)

--

"*6, ) ) /0 %

C # !

! "

( " !

( % " ! "

! " ! (

" 1 / ; 314 3<4

C " ( 7 " C9 / "

! " (

" (

C

+K(..* (

< " +K(.@

" " # "

( D " < ;

( -..+ ? -.., ( " " : *,,+

" / " - +

,( " - +

" ( (

( % "

*. / "

( !

(25)

-B

" "

"

(

/ - / ( 5

A / +K(.*

"

' ( %

; ( -..+8 5 (

-.., " # ( C

A / <

" " #

" ( " <

; ( -..+ -.., (

% /

/

( 7 B "

+K(..* "

( ( "

( "

B < "

" # "

" ( "

# " " "

(26)

->

# ( % "

"

(

> / # "

? "

# " # ( # "

3 0 *,A+ F "0

" # (

@ / " #

" " ( %

" < " #

" " # " " #

( 7 " +

" "

" # " (

" " (

7 / / " "

" "

(

2 8 & / 2

% "

! " ( 7 "

(27)

-@

" " ! I L

# L ! (

" " (

-..B8 6 ( -.*. ( " ! "

6C 6( A

! " ( B > C9

" " " @

+ ( C " B

+ @J (

" #

0 (

% A

; ( -..+ " ! "

" ( @.

" (

" "

I " @>J 8 *-J #

*.J 8 *AJ 8

+J ( "

" " -. /"

" " " -.J( C

/ A A -. /"

(28)

-+

+K(*.

" (

7

" ?

$ -..A8 -.., "

C9 (

" $ -..A -.., " !

( * "

*+A *+, ( C !

, A "

+K(*. (

C #

# "

(

, "0 )+ *) /, %*)

" !

*+, -..-

-../ @. -..- : 6 : %% (

( $

" ! ( $ "

# " "

(29)

-/

" # " $%&'

! " ( #

F 0 F # -0 (

! "

" " #

(

7 " "

0

" # ( 2

" #

! ( " #

" " "

# " # ( C

" " #

" # (

( E ! " #

? " "

#

" (

< #

" " (

" !

(30)

-A

" ( 5

"

( $ "

" ! ( (

" " (

E

" # "

" " #

" " # (

# (

7 (

" #

# " " " # (

#

"

" ( % %

2 2 % : 3

( # " "

" #

(

(31)

-,

7 " ( E

" ( E

" " !

" "

( " - 9

(

# (

)*

*( I 2 ; 2 2 7 6 5 D 2 C6

C 5 ; " ; # % 9 -...I +B (

! < 9 M,(> 9 -...I ,

6+(- MA-* I C 5 7 6 D 2 C6

; # % 9 -...I *B ( "

! (

-( 7 " " $ -..A8 (

-.*. " *** " ! "

-,* (

B( % # 6 ( -.*. ( $

" " "

0 0

"# $ $ -..+ 6 ( -.*. ( -..-

0

-..- : %% -..-(

>( G * " *-- " 0

" 0 ( 7 -A

" (

@( 7 6C # 6

" ( !

" "

6C " ! # 6 ( " "

! 6C 6( G

; # ( -..+8 $ 4 $ -..+ (

6C # 6 ! "

( "

"

: 4 9 -..>8 -.., (

+( 7 # 4

"

" " ? ( G

* . . " , 1 2 - "

(32)

B.

" , "

. -3 (

/( " 6 ( -.*. " "

*J ,,J ( $ " " " "

" ( "

C9 (

A(

" ? -..B

" G -.., " , / / /

( 7 "

! (

,( " ; ( -..+ "

, " ," , ; ( -..+I -+/

( / , " ," ,

! ? @J ( "

C9 ( ( (

*.( ! !

? -..B8 ; ( -..+ ( C ! !

( $ ! !

( $ " " ; ( -..+8 9 # 4 6

-.*. - / "

! ( ?

? -..B8 ; ( -..+ ! ( "

! ? *.J ! ( E

! (

(33)

B*

)+%.

/ % 2 6 ' & %%

%CD *I ;C 62 2%6 C6 D2 CED 6 $%G

*( E C'52 (

-( E ! (

B( E ? ! D 2 (

>( E (

@( E 0 (

+( E ! D 2 (

/( E 0 (

A( E C'520 (

,( E 0 (

*.( E 0 (

**( E 0 ! (

*-( E

(

*B( ! (

*>( E (

*@( E ? D 2 (

*+( E D 2(

*/( E (

*A( E 0 0 (

*,( E (

-.( E D 2 (

-*( E D 2(

--( E (

-B( E 0 0

(

->( E 0 (

-@( E (

-+( E 0 (

-/( E "

0 @.J (

%CD -I C)D %D D2 )2% %D

-A( E (

-,( E - D 2 "

! (

B.( E D 2(

B*( E (

B-( E 0 0 (

BB( E (

(34)

B-

%CD BI 6% : 5 D 5 D %D 6D 9 )2% D2 CD 6C9

B>( E # (

B@( E # 0 0 (

B+( E

# (

B/( E !

(

BA( E " # "

(

%CD >I %D 6 2 ) %D ;%9% N 6 GC6 %D DCD 7%D D % 9

B,( E " "

# " " " "

# " !

(

>.( E " "

" (

>*( E " $%&'

(

>-( E #

(

>B( E " "

(

>>( E ! (

>@( E 0 * " * "

(

>+( E 0 * *

(

>/( E

(

%CD @I D C)6 %D &C9)D 6N C5G9% D D2 D7C6 5 D

>A( E "

: %% (

>,( E " "

? (

@.( E " #

! (

(35)

BB

" " )

" ( 4 : ( 6( *,,+( 7

" (

B*I B// BA,(

6( &( 4 < ( -..,( (

*/I B/+ BA/(

( -.*.( ) I

: < ( (

; ( 3( 4 : ;( *,,@( I

0 ( AI *A B*(

; 6( D( 4 C 6( -..>( I

# ( ! @I

,* *.>(

; &( 5 % ;( 4 7 ( -..>(

I

( ! -AI -.@ -B+(

; # 9( ( 4 7 ( -..,( E O

--I /AB A-/(

; ( 2 < E( 5( 5( 4 = $( -..+( " #

(" ! *-I ->, -AB(

; ( ( 4 2 3( -..>( ):

( " ! *>I @@ ++(

; ( 4 ; ;( -..A( (

*>I -@/ -/B(

; # ;( ( -..*( # 6 (

"! # -I A, *.A(

; # ;( ( 4 : &( ( -../( 0 #

O % ( "! $ >I />, /,+(

; # ;( ( 3 $( 4 : E( -..+( 2 0

# O : ( $ % " ! & '

--I B++ >*B(

E( G( $( $ ( 9( 4 E ( -.*.( !

( *AI -B> ->,(

:( $( 4 G ( E( *,,>( ! 0 1(

! -BI /. />(

9 9 -...(() ( * & +) * !! , # 4

9 $ : (

3( ( E( 6( 4 6 ( C( -..+( 2 " # " # #

O ! 0 ! (

+*I +@@ +A/(

:( 3( 5( 4 D &( ;( -..@( (

+.I -A@, -A,>(

2 9( ( *,A*( < (5 , , - /

BI *A* *,,(

2 < E( ( 4 = $( -..>( !

# I 0 " ! *.I -+/ -,B(

(36)

B>

2 ( 4 : ( $( -..@( I

( +.I *>+* *>,B(

)( 4 <H < 5( -..A( I & < (

*+I *,> -.,(

G( % 63( 4 5 # ( -..B( (

" ! 6**AI *./ *@@(

G( 5( -..,( < I ):(

" *@I BA@ >.>(

? 2( D( -..B( ! 5D " N #I 5 " $ (

$ 6( 4 $ 5( -..+( 5

0 % BBI *.B> *.+-(

$ 2( -..A( I

# ! ( B@I ,*- ,>-(

: 5 %( -../(

( *@I *>-, *>>*(

: ( *,,> 4 -..-(- ) 5

3 I % 2 (

3 5( ( *,A+( " # ( !

" ! /+I B-B B-,(

3 5( ( 4 5 # E( $( *,/+( I

" ( " ! BI B.@ B+.(

: # ( 4 : : # D( -..-( I

: %% ( ) ! -I B.@ B*/(

: 9( 7( 4 9 %( -..>(

# ( *.I /.B /-A(

9 # 2( 7( 4 6 ( C( -.*.( C

( " ! >,I *A+ -.@(

9 # ! 9 -../( L 6

P ! Q( *@I ,+ *..(

5 ( 4 D( -..B( I ( % ( G( C (

! % ) . ' % ) % % ) ->/

-@*( E C 2(

5 5( 4 ( -..A(

3 ! I (

>BI -A >>(

5 5( ( ; # ( 4 ;( -..,( 2

# O ! " (

# BB -@> -+-(

D ( ( -..,( ! !

! ) ! 5) "I )

"(

G 5( ( -..,( I

( --I >B@ >A.(

6 ( # ( 4 G( -.*.(

I ( *AI

A/ *.+(

(37)

B@

6/ =

G

7 /, + / . ! 8 . -

5 1 + / 9#0# 0 ::; /, 3 +

% A* -/(A

; +/ -B(.

+- -*(B

B+ *-(>

B* *.(/

$ / -(>

> *(>

C B *(.

1 + / <# #::8:

9 I 7 " 0 -A

7 " 0 ,> *-- >*(,

+ / = . , / #>< ?@8#

7 /, + ! 8 . -

+ / = . , / /, 3 +

% @* B.(-

B@ -.(/

; BB *,(@

-> *>(-

*, **(-

$ B *(A

B *(A

C * .(+

+ / = . , / #>< #::8:

I 3 9 (

(38)

B+

6/ 1

&

7 & ' &

1 6 " .-,,, # " .B@.* R" .B>@*

# " .-,,, (

6C J 6 " .*-@. " .-,,, (

6 J (

% ! @. : %%

# * @. . " 8

" .J *..J(

% 2 ( % ! , !

# (

; %= D (

;9:CED G " @J

(

%D CED G (

9 & J 6 " .B-@@ " .-,,, (

! &

C5 * . "

;% > * G " 2

4 4 N :G5 . " (

G S J 6 ! " .>+.* " .-,,, (

6C 9% * # # . " (

6 J 6 " .B-@@ # (

6CE J 0 " .*..* 0 0 (

%D2) 6N 2 I R 8

R 8 8 R

(

9D D " .-,,, (

N 6 2 -..B -../ (

! I 2 #

(

(39)

B/

6/ >

2 & A>@ 7 N

& 5 5 ( 2 ( 5 ! 5

0 1 *(@+ *(B> .(+/ B(+. .(/-

6 .(** .(*- .(*> .(BA .(*,

.(-A .(-@ .(A, -(B+ .(>A

.(+* .(+> .(*, .(,A .(.+

" .(+, .(/A .(-/ *(.. .(..

; < ,(/@ *.(.. B(+/ *A(.. >(..

; # " .(+- .(+@ .(*A .(,- .(*.

% " .(/> .(A- .(-B .(,A .(.,

9 .(*A .(*+ .(*> .(@+ .(.@

" .(*- .(*> .(-+ .(A, .(>>

! .(*B .(.A .(*@ .(++ .(./

.(B- .(*, .(B* .(/A .(.*

7 < @(A+ +(.- .(>A /(AB >(->

.(B- .(.. .(>/ *(.. .(..

< .(/B *(.. .(>> *(.. .(..

.(-- .(.. .(>* *(.. .(..

! 7 - (

(40)

BA

6/ ?

5 ! & A>@ 7 N

& 1 % % ; %= ;9:CED %D CED 9 & 6CE $ G S 9D 6 ;% > 6C 9% C5

1 (BATTT (-+TTT (*/TTT (.B (-.TTT (*BTTT (.,T (B,TTT (*-TTT (>.TTT (*BTTT (*/TTT (*ATTT

% (B>TTT (/@TTT (@+TTT (*+TTT (B.TTT (.> (.* (*-TT (@,TTT (.AU (>.TTT (>*TTT (>>TTT

% (->TTT (/BTTT (@@TTT (.AU (B.TTT (.> (*.T (.> (@-TTT (.AU (B*TTT (B,TTT (>/TTT

; %= (*-TTT (@ATTT (@*TTT (*.T (B*TTT (*/TTT (*.T (./ (@BTTT (.AU (B,TTT (BATTT (B*TTT

;9:CED (.> (*ATTT (.AU (./ (>*TTT (.> (.- (.+ (*>TTT (.- (.- (.B (*>TT

%D CED (*@TTT (B*TTT (B-TTT (-ATTT (B/TTT (.@ (./ (./ (-ATTT (.@ (*.T (-+TTT (->TTT

9 & (*-TTT (.. (.B (*BTTT (*.T (*.T (./ (BBTTT (*,TTT (@,TTT (.* (.,T (*+TTT

6CE $ (.AU (.> (.,T (.,T (.B (.@ (.,T (.> (*BTTT (*.T (.* (.- (.B

G S (B*TTT (-.TTT (*-TTT (.AU (.@ (.AU (B-TTT (.+ (.,T (>*TTT (.AU (.@ (.*

9D (.AU (@BTTT (@*TTT (@.TTT (*ATTT (-+TTT (*BTTT (*-TTT (.> (*.T (>BTTT (>>TTT (>.TTT

6 (B.TTT (-BTTT (*ATTT (.AU (.@ (.AU (@/TTT (./ (B,TTT (.> (.- (.@ (.+

;% > (*>TTT (>*TTT (B*TTT (B/TTT (.+ (*BTT (.B (.- (.* (>-TTT (.AU (-@TTT (-ATTT

6C 9% (*/TTT (>.TTT (BATTT (B/TTT (.> (*ATTT (.> (.* (*.T (>-TTT (*.T (-+TTT (>>TTT

C5 (*,TTT (>-TTT (>/TTT (B*TTT (*BTT (->TTT (*BTTT (.> (.,T (B/TTT (*>TTT (-ATTT (>@TTT

! 7 G 0 " 0

( TTT TT T U (*J *J @J *.J " ( & " I 0 1

% ! " " < % # " ' ! " ! !

& " ! < ! < $

(( - (

(41)

B,

6/ @

C9 6 6 0 % ! % &

! ( -..B -..> -..@ -..+ -../

?

2 E

7

< !

(.>

(++

*(,A ,(*@TTT

A>@

(BA (>/

-(>@

*-(BATTT A>@

(*A (@>

-(.+

@(,/TTT

*+,

(-@

(>, -(-.

/(>BTTT

*+,

(*, (@- -(*B +(/>TTT

*+,

(*+

(@A -(.*

>(,@TTT

*+,

(-*

(@*

-(*+

+(ABTTT

*+,

%

<

! 7 <

"

"#

;

%

N -..>

N -..@

N -..+

N -../

R R 'R R 'R 'R R R

(A+ (.. TTT (..B (.. TTT

(+/ (..TTT (..> (..TTT

(** (.,U (.A (+>

(** (.*TT (*A (.. TTT (.> (+A (.@ (..TTT (-, (..TTT (.@ (>B (>, (..TTT (.> (@*

(*> (BA (-. (.@T (*A (.*TT (-. (.BT (-B (..TTT

(>B (.. TTT (..B (.* TT (*. (*. U

(./ (@, (*, (.* TT

(*- (.*TT (.* (>>

(., (.A U (BA (.. TTT (., (>- (>B (.@ T (.> (+B (*@ (>-

(>> (..TTT (..> (.-T

(-> (.>T (.B (>.

(-B (..TTT (*A (..TTT (.@ (B+

(.+ (.>T (-+ (..TTT (.* (@A (>+ (.*TT (.@ (+>

(*A (-/

(+- (..TTT (..- (.*TT (BA (.*TT (.A (+@

(-. (.@T (*B (.*TT (.> (B/

(*- (.*TT (B* (..TTT (*, (-B (@B (.*TT (.B (>>

(-* (>A

(@+ (..TTT (..* (.,U (*- (.+U (./ (>A (*A (.@T (*> (.BT (.- (B, (.B (.AU (-- (..TTT (., (B.

(-@ (.+U (.A (>@

(-. (-.

(@A (.. TTT (..@ (.* TT

(*> (*B (*- (*. U (-+ (.. TTT (.+ (.A U (.@ (>@

(.* (*.U (B> (.. TTT (./ (B- (@> (.* TT (., (BA (-- (-.

! I ( TTT TT T U (*J *J @J *.J " (

-..B ( -

(

(42)

>.

6/ A

C9 6 6 0 % &

! ( -..B -..> -..@ -..+ -../

?

2 E

7

< !

(.>

(+A

*(,.

A(A.TTT A>@

(B+

(@B -(-B

**(>-TTT A>@

(*/

(++

-(.A

>(,ATTT

*+,

(-- (@A -(*@

+(>/TTT

*+,

(*A (+>

-(.-

>(,*TTT

*+,

(*@

(+A -(*.

>(A.TTT

*+,

(-.

(@@

-(*>

+(*-TTT

*+,

%

<

! 7 <

"

"#

;

(

%

N -..>

N -..@

N -..+

N -../

'R R 'R R 'R 'R R R

(+. (..TTT (..- (..TTT

(@+ (..TTT (..A (..TTT (** (*.U (.> (+@

(*- (.*TT (-B (.* TT (.A (@>

(-. (.*TT (-A (..TTT (./ (>B (B+ (..TTT (.+ (>>

(./ (BA (*A (.@T (*/ (.*TT (*, (.*TT (-B (.*TT

(-A (.* TT (..B (.@ T

(*B (.@T (.B (+B (*. (.AU (*A (./ U (.- (+, (-- (.*TT (BB (..TTT (.> (>/

(*, (.,U (.A (BA (*@ (>*

(>/ (..TTT (..B (.* TT (*+ (.BT (./ (@>

(-- (..TTT (*> (., U (.+ (@A

(-> (.* TT (B, (.. TTT (.+ (>/

(-B (.* TT (., (-, (*@ (>-

(>A (..TTT (..* (.+U

(*> (./U (.A (>B (*- (./U (-. (.AU

(., (>, (*, (.*TT (-. (..TTT (., (BB (*A (*.U (.@ (+.

(** (BA

(-@ (.*TT (..* (.,U (*- (.+U (.+ (BA (-. (.*TT (*A (*.U (*. (>B (*A (.*TT

(B+ (..TTT (.> (++

(-> (.BT (.B (>, (.A (>*

(B, (..TTT (..> (.* TT (*/ (.*TT (*> (.,U

(*+ (.*TT (*B (.,U (., (>@

(-+ (.*TT (-> (..TTT (.+ (>A (*, (*.U (./ (B*

(*, (B-

! I ( TTT TT T U (*J *J @J *.J " (

-..B ( -

(

(43)

>*

<

6 6 " 9 - /

2 A,

! ( % 9

9

; #( "

$

% ( "

?

; <

>

0

;

?

2 E

7

< !

(>- (>B -(BA

*-(+,TTT A>@

(*- (/*

*(,A

>(A>TTT A>@

(-.

(+B -(*A /(@.TTT

A>@

(-+

(@.

-(-*

A(+*TTT A>@

(>.

(>/

-(-B ,(,.TTT

A>@

(>@

(>.

-(>.

**(++TTT A>@

% 9

; # "

% "

; <

B#

"#

<

! 7 <

"

;

%

N -..>

N -..@

N -..+

N -../

R 'R 'R R 'R R R R R 'R R 'R 'R R

(-. (.. TTT (.> (.@T (.A (.+U (.+ (.*TT (** (..TTT (*B (..TTT (*> (.*TT (*/ (.*TT (.+ (@>

(*B (.*TT (*/ (..TTT (.* (>/

(.+ (-A (.A (BB (-, (.@T (-. (*.U (-B (.,U (BA (..TTT (>/ (..TTT (*- (.@T (>A (..TTT

(.A (-.

(.* (*A (*. (./U (.@ (>B (.- (*/

(.B (@.

(*- (.@ T (.A (.@ T (*A (.* TT (-- (.. TTT (./ (+/

(-A (.. TTT (.@ (/+

(*> (.,U (./ (/*

(.A (+@

(*. (>B

(@> (..TTT (.+ (..TTT (.A (.*TT (*- (.*TT (*. (.*TT (.* (-A

(*. (.*TT (-- (..TTT (*B (..TTT (.- (-/

(.A (B.

(.> (>.

(.* (@.

(.B (>A (-. (.@T (., (>B (./ (BA (*. (*,

(+. (.. TTT (.A (.. TTT (.B (+B (., (.. TTT (./ (@A (.> (+- (.+ (+@

(.@ (*>

(*A (.. TTT (.* (A*

(.+ (>B (** (.* TT (.> (>- (., (@, (** (.AU (.> (>.

(.+ (-A (.A (B.

(,A (.. TTT (., (.*TT (.* (+, (.@ (B*

(., (.@T (*. (*A (*, (./U (*. (.,U (.A (.. TTT (*. (.,U (,+ (..TTT (.A (B.

(.* (+@

(,> (.. TTT (B. (.* TT (+@ (..TTT (*- (*A (-- (.*TT (*> (>, (-. (>.

(-> (B,

(>> (.. TTT (..+ (.* TT

(.> (>A (.* (BB (.A (.* TT (-B (.* TT (B@ (.. TTT (., (*A (.A (-.

(-+ (.* TT (BB( .. TTT (.- (>+

(*A (.* TT (*B (B.

(-- (.* TT (.+ (>/

(*A (B.

(B> (.* TT (*+ (.AU (-> (.. TTT (B* (.. TTT

! I ( TTT TT T B (*J *J @J *.J " (

-..B ( -

(

(44)

>-

6/ C

6 6 ; 7 & G ! E % !

! " 7 !

! ( 6 0 1 0 1

?

2 E

7

< !

(.@

(++

*(,B A(>.TTT

A>@

(-/

(@- -(-.

+(@.TTT A>@

(.B (+@

*(,@

/(A.TTT A>@

(B*

(>- -(>.

/(>+TTT A>@

(.- (+,

*(A+

-(,ATTT A>@

(->

(@+

-(*B

>(/ATTT A>@

(>, (>B -(@-

*+(>*TTT A>@

%

E %

<

! (

7 <

"

"#

"#

"#

;

%

N -..>

N -..@

N -..+

N -../

R R R 'R R 'R 'R R R R R

(,A (..

(*. (.. TTT

(A/ (.. TTT (.B (.*TT (.- (>B (.A (., U (.> (+*

(*B (.@ T (.* (+A (-+ (..TTT

(-/ (..TTT (.- (@>

(./ (B*

(>* (.*TT (*> (.,U (B@ (.*TT (B. (.*TT (-A (.*TT (B/ (.*TT

(,+ (*@

(BB (.. TTT

(,> (*B (B@ (..TTT

(.>(B+

(.- (+>

(*+ (..TTT (-. (.. TTT (B* (.. TTT (*. (.>T (B+ (..TTT (B> (.@ T (*A (.,U (.B (+*

(.> (@.

(-A (.AU (** (*B (*. (*/

(>. (..TT

(.A (-, (..B (.> T

(*, (>A (..B (./ U

(*+ (.@ T (.* (@B (*B (.* TT (B> (.. TTT (.@ (B+

(.- (-@

(-> (.. TTT

(.> (B*

(-@ (.@ T (./ (BA (., (-, (*. (*>

(-B (.@ T (>@ (.. TTT (@+ (.. TTT

(-> (*+

(..* (., U (./ (B+

(.> (-*

(*> (.@ T (-@ (.. TTT (.+ (>>

(*- (.@ T (B* (.. TTT

(./ (*@

(*> (.AU (.@ (B@

(., (-, (B- (.. TTT (>B (.. TTT (>. (.. TTT (@B (.. TTT

! I ( TTT TT T U (*J *J @J *.J " (

-..B ( - (

Referenzen

ÄHNLICHE DOKUMENTE

This effect proved to be of an non negligible extent, since while increasing by one point compared to its standard deviation, intelligence is likely to directly involve an

Internal corporate governance and firm financial performance: evidence from South African listed firms K

Results in Column A show that politically connected firms associated with at least one member of the Bundestag have significantly higher stock market returns than independent

The findings suggests that (a) public firms are relatively more responsive to a monetary contraction vis-à-vis their private counterparts; and, (b) quoted firms lower their

Chair for Business and Intellectual Property Law at the University of

In particular, beside the implementation of the initial model of Allayannis/Weston (2001) where they find that hedging is only positively correlated with firm value without

Ntim, Collins G and Opong, Kwaku K and Danbolt, Jo and Dewotor, Frank. University

This research seeks to distinguish the relationship of debt to firm performance based on the conditions of Debt- Constraint Expropriation (DCE) and Debt-Facilitate