Munich Personal RePEc Archive
Optimal pricing and quality of academic journals and the ambiguous welfare
effects of forced open access: a two-sided model
Mueller-Langer, Frank and Watt, Richard
Max Planck Institute for Intellectual Property and Competition Law; International Max Planck Research School for Competition and Innovation (Mueller-Langer), University of Canterbury (Watt)
25 April 2012
Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/40191/
MPRA Paper No. 40191, posted 20 Jul 2012 18:20 UTC
Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2045956
TILEC Discussion Paper
TILEC
Optimal Pricing and Quality of Academic Journals and the Ambiguous Welfare
Effects of Forced Open Access: A Two-Sided Model
By
Frank Mueller-Langer, Richard Watt DP 2012-019
ISSN 1572-4042
April 25, 2012
http://ssrn.com/abstract=2045956
Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2045956
&AE:>2= 'C:4:?8 2?5 (F2=:EJ @7 4256>:4
"@FC?2=D 2?5 E96 >3:8F@FD .6=72C6 S64ED
@7 @C465 &A6? 446DD +H@*:565 $@56=
C2?< $F6==6C#2?86C 2?5 ):492C5 .2EE
()')
.6 2?2=JD6 @AE:>2= AC:4:?8 2?5 BF2=:EJ @7 2 >@?@A@=:DE:4 ;@FC?2= 2?5 E96 @AE:>2=:EJ @7 @A6? 2446DD :? 2 EH@D:565 >@56= +96 AC65@>:?2?E 2DA64E @7 E96 >@56= E92E 56E6C>:?6D E96 BF2=:EJ =6G6=D 2E H9:49 @A6?
2446DD :D @AE:>2= :D E96 ?2EFC6 @7 E96 C6=2E:@?D9:A 36EH66? C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD :? 2 ;@FC?2= !? 4@?EC2DE E@ AC6G:@FD =:E6C2EFC6 H6 LCDE=J D9@H E92E E96C6 6I:DE D46?2C:@D :? H9:49 @A6? 2446DD :D 2 762EFC6 @7 9:89 BF2=:EJ ;@FC?2=D *64@?5 H6 L?5 E92E C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E 2?5 E9FD 7@C465 @A6? 2446DD 564C62D6D ;@FC?2= AC@LED 3FE 92D 2>3:8F@FD D@4:2=
H6=72C6 6S64ED
$F6==6C#2?86C 4@?E24E 2FE9@C $2I '=2?4< !?DE:EFE6 7@C !?E6==64EF2= 'C@A6CEJ 2?5
@>A6E:E:@? #2H $2CDE2==A=2EK $F?:49 6C>2?J >2:= 7C2?< >F6==6C
=2?86C:A >A8 56 .2EE 6A2CE>6?E @7 4@?@>:4D 2?5 :?2?46 ,?:G6CD:EJ @7 2?E6C3FCJ 'C:G2E6 28 9C:DE49FC49 %6H/62=2?5 >2:= C:492C5 H2EE42?E6C3FCJ 24 ?K +9:D C6D62C49 36?6LEE65 7C@> 2 +:=3FC8 #2H2?5 4@?@>:4D 6?E6C +!# !!' 8C2?E +96 2FE9@CD 2C6 >@DE 8C2E67F= 7@C E9:D L?2?4:2= 2:5 .6 E92?< "@D67 C6I= !G2? '?8 2?5 D6>:?2C A2CE:4:A2?ED :? 2C46=@?2 9C:DE49FC49 2?5 $25C:5 7@C G2=F23=6 4@>>6?ED
Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2045956
&AE:>2= 'C:4:?8 2?5 (F2=:EJ @7 4256>:4
"@FC?2=D 2?5 E96 >3:8F@FD .6=72C6 S64ED
@7 @C465 &A6? 446DD +H@*:565 $@56=
$)'%*)!%$
4256>:4 ;@FC?2=D 24E 2D A=2E7@C>D FA@? H9:49 2FE9@CD 4@>>F?:42E6 E96:C :562D E@ C6256CD D DF49 ;@FC?2=D ?665 E@ 2EEC24E 3@E9 2FE9@CD 2?5 C6256CD :? @C56C E@ 36 23=6 E@ AC@G:56 E96:C D6CG:46 H9:49 :D 36?6L4:2= E@ 3@E9 C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD @H6G6C E96 :?E6CC6=2E:@?D9:A 36EH66? 2FE9@CD 2?5 C6256CD @?
E96 ;@FC?2= A=2E7@C> :D >@C6 4@>A=6I E92? 2 D:>A=6 >66E:?8 A=246 H96C6 :562D 2C6 6I492?865 )6256CD 2EEC24E 2FE9@CD E@ 2 ;@FC?2= 2?5 2FE9@CD 2EEC24E C6256CD E@ 2 ;@FC?2= 2?5 3@E9 2C6 2EEC24E65 E@ 9:896C BF2=:EJ ;@FC?2=D
+96 :?E6C6DE:?8 A2CE @7 E96 H9@=6 :DDF6 @7 24256>:4 AF3=:D9:?8 G:2 ;@FC?2=D :D E96 724E E92E 2D E96 :?E6C>65:2CJ E96 ;@FC?2= 65:E@CD >2<6 564:D:@?D C682C5 :?8 C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD E92E 2C6 4CF4:2= E@ E96 L?2= @FE4@>6 @7 E96 BF2=:EJ E92E E96 ;@FC?2= 249:6G6D '6C92AD E96 >@DE :?E6C6DE:?8 >@56= @7 2 ;@FC?2=
@44FCD H96? E96 ;@FC?2= 24ED :? @C56C E@ >2I:>:D6 AC@LE !? DF49 2 D46?2C:@
E96 ;@FC?2= >FDE 564:56 E96 DF3D4C:AE:@? AC:46 7@C C6256C 2446DD E96 2FE9@C 766 DF3>:DD:@? 2?5@C AF3=:42E:@? 766D 2?5 E96 @G6C2== BF2=:EJ @7 E96 ;@FC?2=
2== H:E9 E96 @3;64E:G6 @7 249:6G:?8 >2I:>2= AC@LE !E :D 3J ?@ >62?D @3G:@FD 7@C 6I2>A=6 E92E AC@LED H:== 36 >2I:>:K65 3J >2I:>:K:?8 E96 BF2=:EJ @7 E96
;@FC?2= %6:E96C :D :E 4=62C 9@HE96 C6256C DF3D4C:AE:@? AC:46 D9@F=5 2S64E E96 2FE9@C 766 2?5 G:46G6CD2
!? E96 AC6D6?E A2A6C 2 >@56= @7 2 ;@FC?2= 2D 2 EH@D:565 A=2E7@C> :D 6I A=@C65 :? @C56C E@ 4@?D:56C D@>6 @7 E96 AC:?4:A2= 2DA64ED @7 E9:D 4@>A=6I >2C
<6E +96 A2A6C 255D E@ 2 C6=2E:G6=J J@F?8 =:E6C2EFC6 E92E 4@?D:56CD 24256>:4
;@FC?2=D :? EH@D:565 >2C<6ED "6@? 2?5 )@496E $4236 2?5 *?J56C +96 >@56= :D D:>A=:L65 E@ @?6 :? H9:49 2 D:?8=6 >@?@A@=:DE:4 ;@FC?2=
AC@G:56D E96 D6CG:46 @7 AF3=:D9:?8 24256>:4 A2A6CD 7@C 3@E9 C6256CD 2?5 2F
&E96C @3;64E:G6D >2J 2=D@ 36 4@?D:56C65 Q E96 ;@FC?2= >:89E 24E :? @C56C E@ >2I:>:D6 :ED :>A24E 724E@C @C :E >:89E 24E :? @C56C E@ >2I:>:D6 C6256CD9:A 5:SFD:@? @7 :562D AF3=:D965
E9@CD !E :D C6=2E65 E@ E96 >@?@A@=J A=2E7@C> >@56= 3J C>DEC@?8 !?
4@?EC2DE E@ C>DEC@?8 9@H6G6C E96 A=2E7@C>ND F=E:>2E6 @3;64E:G6 :D E@
49@@D6 :ED OBF2=:EJP 2?5 >FDE 2=D@ >2<6 2? @AE:>2= 49@:46 @7 3@E9 E96 C6256C DF3D4C:AE:@? AC:46 2?5 E96 2FE9@C 766 .6 2=D@ 2?2=JD6 E96 6S64ED @7 2 C6>@G2=
@7 4@AJC:89E @? ;@FC?2=D 24256>:4D 2?5 D@4:2= H6=72C6 !E :D :? E9:D C6DA64E E92E H6 36=:6G6 @FC 2?2=JD:D :D 5:S6C6?E 7C@> 6I:DE:?8 H@C<D DF49 2D "6@? 2?5 )@496E 2?5 $4236 2?5 *?J56C
+96 2DDF>AE:@? E92E E96 ;@FC?2= :D 7F==J >@?@A@=:DE:4 :D 4CF4:2= E@ E96
>@56= !7 E96C6 H6C6 @E96C ;@FC?2=D 4@>A6E:?8 7@C 3@E9 C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD E96 C6DF=ED @7 E96 >@56= H@F=5 46CE2:?=J 36 5:S6C6?E @H6G6C 3C:?8:?8 4@>
A6E:E:@? :?E@ E96 >:I :D 6I46DD:G6=J 4@>A=6I D@ 7@C ?@HH6 92G6 AC676CC65 E@
@?=J =@@< 2E 2 >@?@A@=:DE:4 ;@FC?2= :? @C56C E@ 7@4FD @? E96 :DDF6 @7 @A6? 24 46DD 2?5 4@AJC:89E +92E D2:5 @FC >@56= 42? 2=D@ 36 :?E6CAC6E65 2D 2 >@56=
@7 >@?@A@=:DE:4 4@>A6E:E:@? :? 2 H2J E92E H:== 36 >256 4=62C :? E96 A2A6C
*64@?5 H6 @?=J DEF5J E96 42D6 @7 2? @?=:?6 ;@FC?2= C2E96C E92? 2 ;@FC?2= E92E AF3=:D96D :? 92C5AC:?E 7@C>2E +9:D D:>A=:L6D E96 2?2=JD:D 2D :E 2==@HD FD E@
C62=:DE:42==J 2DDF>6 E92E E96 >2C8:?2= 4@DE @7 DFAA=J:?8 C6256CD :D K6C@ +9:C5 :? @C56C E@ 86E 4C:DA E96@C6E:42= C6DF=ED :E :D ?646DD2CJ E@ >2<6 2 =2C86 ?F>36C
@7 2DDF>AE:@?D C682C5:?8 E96 C6=2E:@?D9:AD 36EH66? E96 5:S6C6?E G2C:23=6D 2?5
@? E96 H2J E96 5:S6C6?E G2C:23=6D 2S64E E96 @3;64E:G6 7F?4E:@? )2E96C E92?
>2<:?8 2== @7 E96 C6=6G2?E 2DDF>AE:@?D 2?5 E96? AFEE:?8 7@CH2C5 E96@C6E:42=
C6DF=ED H6 92G6 AC676CC65 E@ 42CCJ @FE 2? 2?2=JD:D 32D65 FA@? ?F>6C:42= D:>
F=2E:@? @H6G6C E96 >2:? DECF4EFC2= 2DDF>AE:@?D :? E96 >@56= H9:49 2C6
=:?62C 56>2?5 2?5 6:E96C =:?62C @C 4@?42G6 AC@5F4E:@? 7F?4E:@?D 2C6 C6=2E:G6=J DE2?52C5 :G6? E96D6 DECF4EFC2= 2DDF>AE:@?D E96 >@56= @?=J 4@?E2:?D 2 D:?
8=6 56E6C>:?:?8 A2C2>6E6C E@ H9:49 H6 8:G6 2 DA64:L4 G2=F6 7@C @FC ?F>6C:42=
D:>F=2E:@?D ?J ?F>36C @7 @E96C D:>F=2E:@?D 42? 36 86?6C2E65 3J D:>A=J 2=E6C:?8 E96 G2=F6D @7 E9:D A2C2>6E6C
@C D:>A=:4:EJ H6 2=D@ 2DDF>6 E96 LI65 4@DE @7 E96 ;@FC?2= E@ 36 K6C@
!? 724E @FC D:?8=6 A2C2>6E6C E96 6S64E @7 ;@FC?2= BF2=:EJ @? E96 G6CE:42= :?E6C46AE @7 E96 56>2?5 7@C ;@FC?2= D6CG:46D 3J 3@E9 2FE9@CD 2?5 C6256CD 42? 2=D@ 36 DA=:E :?E@ EH@
5:S6C6?E A2C2>6E6CD @?6 7@C 6249 D:56 @7 E96 >2C<6E .6 92G6 6=64E65 E@ 2DDF>6 E96D6 EH@
6S64ED E@ 36 6BF2= D:>A=J 2D H6 92G6 ?@ 4@?G:?4:?8 6G:56?46 E@ E96 4@?EC2CJ
.6 2C6 :?E6C6DE65 :? E96 7@==@H:?8 2DA64ED @7 E96 ;@FC?2= >2?286>6?E :CDE=J :D :E A@DD:3=6 E92E @?6 @7 E96 EH@ AC:46D E96 C6256C AC:46 2?5 E96 2FE9@C AC:46 42? 36 @AE:>2==J D6E E@ K6C@ !D :E ECF6 E92E 2 ;@FC?2= E92E 5@6D @AE:>2==J D6E E96 C6256C AC:46 E@ K6C@ : 6 2? O@A6? 2446DDP ;@FC?2= :D 492C24E6C:K65 3J 2 =@H6C BF2=:EJ =6G6= E92? 2 4=@D65 2446DD ;@FC?2= : 6 @?6 H:E9 2 DEC:4E=J A@D:E:G6 DF3D4C:AE:@? AC:46 7@C C6256CD 2D :D @7E6? E9@F89E E@ 36 ECF6 $4236 2?5 *?J56C @HH@F=5 E96 C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E :? E96 A2A6CD AF3=:D965 :>A24E FA@? E96 @AE:>2= 49@:46D @7 2 ;@FC?2= 3@G6 2==
H6 42=4F=2E6 E96 H6=72C6 6S64ED @7 E96 C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E :? @FC D:>F=2E:@?D .6 L?5 D6G6C2= ?6HC6DF=ED E92E 255 E@ E96 =:E6C2EFC6 :CDE=J H6 L?5 E92E E96C6 6I:DE D46?2C:@D :? H9:49 @A6? 2446DD : 6 2? @AE:>2= C6256C AC:46 6BF2= E@ K6C@ :D 2 762EFC6 @7 =@H6C BF2=:EJ ;@FC?2=D 2?5 @E96CD :? H9:49 :E :D 2 762EFC6 @7 9:896C BF2=:EJ ;@FC?2=D +96 AC65@>:?2?E 2DA64E @7 E96 >@56= E92E 56E6C>:?6D E96 BF2=:EJ =6G6=D 2E H9:49 @A6? 2446DD :D @AE:>2= :D E96 ?2EFC6
@7 E96 C6=2E:@?D9:A 36EH66? C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD :? 2 ;@FC?2= 3@G6 2== H6 D9@HE92E E96 4@?4=FD:@? @7 E96 >@56= @7 $4236 2?5 *?J56C H9@
L?5 E92E @A6? 2446DD :D >@C6 =:<6=J E@ 36 2 762EFC6 @7 =@H6C BF2=:EJ ;@FC?2=D :D
?@E 86?6C2==J ECF6 *64@?5 H6 L?5 E92E C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E 2?5 E9FD 7@C465
@A6? 2446DD H:== =:<6=J :?4C62D6 3@E9 C6256CD9:A 2?5 2FE9@CD9:A H:== 564C62D6
;@FC?2= AC@LED 2?5 >2J :?4C62D6 D@4:2= H6=72C6
%"
+96 ;@FC?2= 49@@D6D BF2=:EJ E96 AC:46 492C865 E@ C6256CD 2?5 E96 AC:46 492C865 E@ 2FE9@CD .6 2DDF>6 E92E E96 ;@FC?2= 24ED :? @C56C E@ >2I:>:D6 AC@LED :G6? E96 49@:46 E96 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD :D 6?5@86?@FD=J 8:G6? 3J 2?5 E96 ?F>36C @7 2FE9@CD :D 6?5@86?@FD=J 8:G6? 3J
.6 2C6 :?E6C6DE65 :? E9:D 2DA64E 3642FD6 @7 E96 C646?E AC@G@42E:G6 A2A6C 3J *E6A96?
*92G6== E92E 25G@42E6D 23@=:D9:@? @7 4@AJC:89E :? D4:6?E:L4 AF3=:42E:@?D
!? E9:D A2A6C H6 EC62E BF2=:EJ C2E96C =:89E=J !E :D 2 49@:46 G2C:23=6 @7 E96 ;@FC?2= 3FE H6 5@ ?@E DA64:7J @C >@56= 9@H E92E 49@:46 :D >256 !? C62=:EJ BF2=:EJ :D 4@?EC@==65 3J E96
;@FC?2= G:2 E96 C676C66 AC@46DD !? E96 AC6D6?E A2A6C H6 D:>A=J 2DDF>6 E92E 8:G6? 2 49@:46
@7 2 A2CE:4F=2C =6G6= @7 BF2=:EJ E96 ;@FC?2= C646:G6D 6?@F89 DF3>:DD:@?D @7 2E =62DE E92E =6G6=
@7 BF2=:EJ E@ L== E96 ;@FC?2= H:E9 4@?E6?E
@E9 E96 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD 2?5 E96 ?F>36C @7 2FE9@CD :D 56E6C
>:?65 :? A2CE 3J E96 BF2=:EJ 49@D6? +96 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD 2FE9@CD 92D 2 5:C64E 56A6?56?46 @? E96 AC:46 492C865 E@ C6256CD 2FE9@CD +96 56A6?56?46
@7 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD @? E96 AC:46 492C865 E@ 2FE9@CD 2?5 E96 ?F>36C @7 2F E9@CD @? E96 AC:46 492C865 E@ C6256CD :D :?5:C64E +96 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD :D A2CE:2==J 56E6C>:?65 3J E96 ?F>36C @7 2FE9@CD 2?5 G:46 G6CD2
+96D6 2DDF>AE:@?D C6M64E C62=:EJ )6256CD 49@@D6 E@ C625 2 ;@FC?2= 56 A6?5:?8 @? :ED 4@?E6?E H9:49 :D 8:G6? 3J E96 ?F>36C @7 A2A6CD :? :E 2?5 E96 BF2=:EJ @7 E9@D6 A2A6CD 2?5 E96 AC:46 492C865 E@ C6256CD FE9@CD H2?E E@ AF3=:D9 :? 2 ;@FC?2= 8:G6? E96 BF2=:EJ @7 E96 ;@FC?2= E96 2F5:6?46 C624965 2?5 E96 4@DE :?G@=G65 :? AF3=:D9:?8 +96 724E E92E E96 EH @ 7F?4E:@?D 2?5 2C6 :?E6C56A6?56?E H:E9 E96 G2=F6 @7 6249 56A6?5:?8 :? A2CE FA@? E96 G2=F6 @7 E96 @E96C 42AEFC6D E96 EH@D:565
>2C<6E 762EFC6 @7 24256>:4 ;@FC?2=D 2D A=2E7@C>D 7@C C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD
!? C62=:EJ H6 42? F?56CDE2?5 E96 EH@ 7F?4E:@?D 2?5 :? EH@ 5:S6C6?E H2JD 3@E9 @7 H9:49 H:== 36 6IA=@:E65 :? E96 A2A6C :CDE 7@C 8:G6? G2=F6D @7 2?5 D2J 2?5 H6 D9@F=5 F?56CDE2?5 E@
36 2 56>2?5 7F?4E:@? :? E96 D6?D6 E92E :E C6=2E6D E96 AC:46 7@C C625:?8 E@ E96
?F>36C @7 C6256CD H9@ AFC492D6 &? E96 @E96C 92?5 7@C 8:G6? G2=F6D @7 2?5 D2J 2?5 H6 D9@F=5 F?56CDE2?5 E@ 36 2 AC@5F4E:@?
7F?4E:@? :? E96 D6?D6 E92E A2A6CD 96C6 2FE9@CD 2C6 H92E 2EEC24E C6256CD E@ 2 ;@FC?2= !? E96 D2>6 H2J :D 282:? 2 56>2?5 7F?4E:@? 2?5 :D 2 AC@5F4E:@? 7F?4E:@? E9:D E:>6 C6M64E:?8 E96 56A6?56?46 @7 E96 ?F>36C @7 2FE9@CD E92E 2C6 2EEC24E65 E@ 2 ;@FC?2= @? E96 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD
@7 E92E ;@FC?2= @C 2?5 H6 >2<6 E96 7@==@H:?8 2DDF>AE:@?D
+9FD E96 56>2?5 7F?4E:@?D 2C6 ?682E:G6=J D=@A65 2?5 E96 AC@5F4E:@? 7F?4
@C :?DE2?46 :D E96 DF> @7 DF3>:DD:@? 766 2?5 AF3=:42E:@? 766
E:@?D 2C6 A@D:E:G6=J D=@A65 2?5 H62<=J 4@?42G6 .6 2=D@ 2DDF>6 E92E
+96 LCDE @7 E96D6 :D 2 G6CJ ?2EFC2= 2DDF>AE:@? Q C6256CD AC676C 36EE6C BF2=:EJ A2A6CD +96 D64@?5 :D ?@E D@ @3G:@FD +96 8C62E6C :D E96 BF2=:EJ @7 2 ;@FC?2=
E96 8C62E6C :D E96 H:==:?8?6DD @7 2FE9@CD E@ DFAA=J A2A6CD E@ E92E ;@FC?2= 7@C E96 - :>A24E 2?5 7@C E96 724E E92E 9:896C BF2=:EJ ;@FC?2=D 2C6 =:<6=J E@ C6249 2 =2C86C 2F5:6?46 2?5 E9FD 2C6 >@C6 =:<6=J E@ 36 4:E65 FE E96 8C62E6C :D E96 BF2=:EJ 9FC5=6 E96 76H6C H:== 36 E96 A2A6CD AF3=:D965 7C@> E9@D6 DF3>:EE65 +9FD H9:=6 2 9:89 BF2=:EJ ;@FC?2= H:== 92G6 2 =2C86C D6E @7 A2A6CD 7C@> H9:49 E@
49@@D6 E96J 2C6 >@C6 D6=64E:G6 :? E96:C 49@@D:?8 +96 2DDF>AE:@? E92E E96C6 2C6 >@C6 AF3=:D965 2FE9@CD H96? BF2=:EJ 8@6D FA :D 32D65 >@C6 E92? 2?JE9:?8 6=D6 FA@? @3D6CG2E:@? E =62DE :? E96 L6=5 @7 64@?@>:4D ;@FC?2=D E9@D6 2E E96 E@A @7 E96 BF2=:EJ =2556C 2C6 EJA:42==J 23=6 E@ AF3=:D9 >2?J A2A6CD H9:=6 :E :D E96 ;@FC?2=D @7 =@H6C A6C46:G65 BF2=:EJ E92E >2J DECF88=6 H:E9 L?5:?8 A2A6CD E@ AF3=:D9
!? :8FC6 H6 D9@H 3@E9 E96 56>2?5 4FCG6 2DA64E 2?5 E96 AC@5F4E:@?
7F?4E:@? 2DA64E @7 E96 ;@FC?2= A=2E7@C> 2=H2JD E2<:?8 BF2=:EJ E@ 36 LI65 +96 FAA6C =67E92?5 0=@H6C C:89E92?51 A2?6= D9@HD E96 56>2?5 4FCG6 2DA64E @7 0 1 2?5 E96 FAA6C C:89E92?5 A2?6= D9@HD E96 AC@5F4 E:@? 7F?4E:@? 2DA64ED :8FC6 9:89=:89ED 2 G6CJ :>A@CE2?E 2DA64E @7 E96 ;@FC
?2=D >2C<6E !E :D EH@D:565 2?5 D@ E96 49@:46 @7 C6256C AC:46 2 56E6C>:?2?E
@7 E96 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD 42??@E 36 E2<6? :?56A6?56?E=J 7C@> E96 49@:46 @7 2FE9@C AC:46 H9:49 :D 2 56E6C>:?2?E @7 E96 ?F>36C @7 2FE9@CD +96C6 :D @?=J
@?6 4@?D:DE6?E 49@:46 :? E9:D 8C2A9 H9:49 :D =236=65 2D A@:?E :? E96 D@FE9 H6DE BF25C2?E &?=J H:E9 E92E 49@:46 @7 AC:46D H:== E96 ?F>36C @7 2FE9@CD
!? E96 AC6D6?E A2A6C H6 23DEC24E 2H2J 7C@> >@56=:?8 E96 C676C66 AC@46DD F?56C H9:49 A2A6CD 2C6 D4C66?65 7@C BF2=:EJ 6C6 2== E92E :D :>A@CE2?E :D E@ C64@8?:D6 E92E :D E96
?F>36C @7 A2A6CD E92E 6?5 FA 36:?8 AF3=:D965 2?5 E92E H:== 36 56E6C>:?65 3J E96 ?F>36C
@7 A2A6CD E92E 2C6 DF3>:EE65 564C62D6D H:E9 2FE9@C AC:46 2?5 :?4C62D6D H:E9 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD 2?5 E96 BF2=:EJ @7 E96 ;@FC?2= +96 2DDF>AE:@? E92E E96 ?F>36C @7 A2A6CD AF3=:D965 :?4C62D6D H:E9 BF2=:EJ C6M64ED E96 2DDF>AE:@? E92E DF3>:DD:@?D @7 DFR4:6?E BF2=:EJ :?4C62D6 :? BF2=:EJ
:8FC6 +H@D:565 >2C<6E 56>2?5 2?5 AC@5F4E:@? 7F?4E:@?D 2?5 AC@LE
36 4@?D:DE6?E H:E9 E96 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD H96C6 E96 DFA6CD4C:AED C676C E@ 6?5@86?@FD 6BF:=:3C:F> G2=F6D
!>28:?6 E92E 7C@> E96 D:EF2E:@? 5C2H? :? :8FC6 E96 ;@FC?2= 564:565 E@ :?4C62D6 E96 C6256C AC:46 =62G:?8 E96 2FE9@C AC:46 F?492?865 .92E H@F=5 36 E96 6S64E :? E96 8C2A9 +96 :?4C62D6 :? C6256C AC:46 H:== 42FD6 2 D9:7E 2=@?8 E96 56>2?5 4FCG6 7@C E96 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD E9FD C65F4:?8 @H6G6C E96 AC@5F4E:@? 7F?4E:@? 7@C C6256CD H:== :ED6=7 D9:7E D:?46 :E :D A2C2>6E:D65 3J E96 C6256C AC:46 *:?46 H6 2DDF>6 E92E E96 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD :D 2 564C62D:?8 7F?4E:@? @7 E96 AC:46 7@C C625:?8 E96 AC@5F4E:@? 7F?4E:@? H:== D9:7E 5@H?H2C5D +96C6 :D 2 C6DF=E:?8 D9:7E 2=@?8 E96 AC@5F4E:@? 7F?4E:@? 7@C E96 ?F>36C @7 2F E9@CD %6IE E96 56>2?5 7F?4E:@? 7@C E96 ?F>36C @7 2FE9@CD :D A2C2>6E:D65 3J E96 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD +96 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD 92D 564C62D65 H9:49 H:== D9:7E E96 56>2?5 7F?4E:@? 7@C E96 ?F>36C @7 2FE9@CD :?H2C5D :?2==J E96 ?F>36C
@7 2FE9@CD 92D 2=D@ 366? 564C62D65 H9:49 H:== D9:7E E96 56>2?5 7F?4E:@? 7@C E96 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD :?H2C5D +96D6 D9:7ED H:== 4@?E:?F6 F?E:= 2 ?6H 6BF:=:3 C:F> A@:?E :D 2EE2:?65 .6 2DDF>6 E9C@F89@FE E92E E96 6BF:=:3C:F> AC@46DD
pa
;FDE 56D4C:365 :D DE23=6 :? E96 D6?D6 E92E 7@C 2?J E96 4FCG6D 25;FDE DF49 E92E E96C6 :D 2 A2:C E92E 2C6 >FEF2==J 4@>A2E:3=6
'%.)(
+96 AC@LED E92E E96 ;@FC?2= >2<6D 42? 2=D@ 36 C6AC6D6?E65 8C2A9:42==J 2E
=62DE 7@C E96 2DDF>AE:@? E92E E96 ;@FC?2= :D 7F==J @?=:?6 @?=J 2?5 E9FD 92D ?@
>2C8:?2= 4@DED +96 AC@LED 62C?65 3J E96 ;@FC?2= 2C6
!? :8FC6 H6 42? D66 E96 AC@LED >256 7C@> E96 C6256C D:56 @7 E96 >2C<6E 2?5 E96 2FE9@C D:56 @7 E96 >2C<6E +96 DF> @7 E96D6 EH@ C64E2?8F=2C 2C62D :D E96 E@E2= AC@LE +@ :==FDEC2E6 E96 6S64E @7 2 F?:=2E6C2= :?4C62D6 @7 E96 C6256C AC:46 :D E@ 564C62D6 E96 AC@LE :? E96 2FE9@C >2C<6E D:?46 E96 2FE9@C AC:46 DE2JD 4@?DE2?E 2?5 E96 ?F>36C @7 2FE9@CD 564C62D6D 2?5 E@ 492?86 E96 AC@LE :? E96 C6256C >2C<6E :? DF49 2 H2J E92E :E >2J :?4C62D6 @C 564C62D6 :E 8@6D 7C@> 2 E2== E9:? C64E2?8=6 E@ 2 D9@CE6C 3FE H:56C @?6
'%.) #,!#!(!$ !(!%$(
+96 ;@FC?2= 49@@D6D :? @C56C E@ >2I:>:D6 AC@LE .6 >@56= E9:D C64FCD:G6=J :CDE 9@=5 BF2=:EJ 2E D@>6 LI65 =6G6= 2?5 8:G6? E92E BF2=:EJ H6 2?2=JD6 E96 @AE:>2= AC:4:?8 A@=:4J @7 E96 ;@FC?2=
+96? 8:G6? E96 @AE:>2= AC:46D 7@C 6249 BF2=:EJ =6G6= H6 4@?D:56C E96 @AE:>2=
BF2=:EJ E92E E96 ;@FC?2= D9@F=5 49@@D6
:CDE=J E9@F89 7@C 2?J 8:G6? :E :D ?646DD2CJ E@ D:>F=E2?6@FD=J D@=G6 E96 EH@ 6BF2E:@?D 2?5 7@C E96 EH@ 6BF:=:3C:F>
=6G6=D @7 C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD 2?5 +96 AC@LE @7 E96
;@FC?2= 2DDF>:?8 E92E E96C6 2C6 ?@ >2C8:?2= 4@DED @7 DFAA=J:?8 C6256CD :D
+96 56C:G2E:G6D @7 E9:D H:E9 C6DA64E E@ E96 EH@ AC:46D 2C6
H96C6 2?5 2CCJ:?8 @FE E96 :>A=:65 D64@?5 56C:G2E:G6D :E EFC?D @FE E92E 2 DFR4:6?E 4@?5:E:@? 7@C AC@LED E@ 36 4@?42G6 :? E96 AC:46 :D
2?5
DDF>:?8 4@?42G:EJ E96 EH@ LCDE@C56C 4@?5:E:@?D 7@C @AE:>2= 49@:46D @7 E96 EH@ AC:46D 2C6
2?5
E96 D:>F=E2?6@FD D@=FE:@? @7 H9:49 8:G6 FD E96 EH@ @AE:>2= AC:46D 2D 7F?4E:@?D @7 E96 BF2=:EJ 2?5 +96 :?5:C64E AC@LE 7F?4E:@? :D E96?
+9:D :D H92E >FDE ?@H 36 >2I:>:D65 H:E9 C6DA64E E@
!#&"!. #%"(
!? @C56C E@ D66 9@H E96 >@56= H@C<D H6 2DDF>6 E9C66 5:S6C6?E 3FE D:>:=2C G6CD:@?D @7 :E 249 @7 E96 E9C66 >@56=D :D 492C24E6C:K65 3J =:?62C 56>2?5 7F?4E:@?D 7@C 3@E9 C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD 2?5 E96J 5:S6C H:E9 C6DA64E E@ E96 568C66 @7 4@?42G:EJ @7 E96 EH@ AC@5F4E:@? 7F?4E:@?D *A64:L42==J :? >@56=
H6 2DDF>6 E92E 3@E9 AC@5F4E:@? 7F?4E:@?D 2C6 2S64E65 3J 5:>:?:D9:?8 C6EFC?D : 6 E96J 2C6 3@E9 4@?42G6 7F?4E:@?D !? >@56= E96 AC@5F4E:@? @7 C6256CD E2<:?8 2FE9@CD 2D 2? :?AFE 92D 5:>:?:D9:?8 C6EFC?D : 6 :D 4@?42G6 H9:=6 E96 AC@5F4E:@? @7 2FE9@CD E2<:?8 C6256CD 2D E96 :?AFE :D 2DDF>65 =:?62C !?
>@56= E96 C6256C AC@5F4E:@? 7F?4E:@? :D =:?62C 2?5 E96 2FE9@C AC@5F4E:@?
7F?4E:@? :D 4@?42G6
!? 6249 @7 E96 E9C66 >@56=D E96 56>2?5 7@C>F=2E:@? :D 8:G6? 3J 2 =:?62C 7@C> H:E9 G6CE:42= :?E6C46AE : 6 >2I:>F> 762D:3=6 AC:46 6BF2= E@ +9FD 8C62E6C =6G6=D @7 BF2=:EJ 4@CC6DA@?5 E@ A2C2==6= D9:7ED @7 E96 EH@ 56>2?5 4FCG6D .6 92G6 ?@ A2CE:4F=2C C62D@? E@ 2DDF>6 E92E E96 6S64E @7 2 >2C8:?2= 492?86 :?
BF2=:EJ FA@? E96 56>2?5 4FCG6 @7 C6256CD :D 2?J 5:S6C6?E E@ E96 D2>6 6S64E 7@C
2FE9@CD *@ :? E96 :?E6C6DED @7 <66A:?8 @FC >@56= 2D F?4=FEE6C65 2D A@DD:3=6 H6 2DDF>6 E92E E9:D 6S64E :D 6BF2= 7@C 3@E9 D:56D @7 E96 >2C<6E
%" !#!$!( !$ ')*'$( %$ %) (!(
!? E9:D >@56= H6 2DDF>6
%@E:46 E92E E96D6 EH@ 6BF2E:@?D 42? 36 HC:EE6? 2D
H96C6 7@C )642== E92E 3@E9 @7 2?5 2C6 4@?DEC2:?65 E@ 36 A@D:E:G6 D@ H6 2C6 C6DEC:4E65 E@ A2C2>6E6C G2=F6D DF49 E92E 7@C E92E :D H6 42? @?=J 4@?D:56C AC:46D E92E D2E:D7J 7@C
!E :D 62DJ E@ D9@HE92E E96 D@=FE:@? E@ E96 EH@ 6BF2E:@?D 2?5 @FED:56
@7 E96 EC:G:2= D@=FE:@? 2E :D 2E
+96 AC@LED @7 E96 ;@FC?2= 2C6 8:G6? 3J
+96 AC@LE 7F?4E:@? :D A6C764E=J DJ>>6EC:4 :? E96 EH@ AC:46D +92E :D E96 7F?4E:@? :D @7 E96 7@C>
H96C6
+9FD :E >2<6D ?@ 5:S6C6?46 E@ E96 AC@3=6> 9@HH6 =236= @FC AC:46 G2C:23=6D !? E96 @AE:>2= D@=FE:@? :E >FDE 36
ECF6 E92E .6 42? FD6 E9:D :?D:89E E@ 96=A FD D@=G6 E96 >2I:>:K2E:@?
AC@3=6> .6 255 E96 C6DEC:4E:@? E@ E96 6I:DE:?8 C6DEC:4E:@?D 7@C *F3DE:EFE:?8 E9:D LCDE C6DEC:4E:@? :?E@ E96 @3;64E:G6 7F?4E:@? 8:G6D
6C6 D@ E92E +96 LCDE@C56C 4@?5:E:@? 7@C 2? @AE:>2=
D@=FE:@? :D
H96C6 +9:D 6BF2E:@? 42? 36 6IAC6DD65 2D +96 D64@?5 @C56C 4@?5:E:@? @? E9:D >2I:>:K2E:@? AC@3=6> :D H9:49 :D E E96 DE2E:@?2CJ A@:?E H9:49 :D F?:BF6 @? E96 C2?86
H6 92G6 +9FD E96 D64@?5
@C56C 4@?5:E:@? :D D2E:DL65 2E E96 @AE:>2= D@=FE:@? !? D9@CE E96 EH@ @AE:>2=
AC:46D 7@C >@56= 2C6 :56?E:42= =:?62C 7F?4E:@?D @7 BF2=:EJ
%" !#!$!( !$ ')*'$( )% *) %'(
.6 ?@H2DDF>6
!? AA6?5:I H6 D9@H E92E E96 @AE:>2= AC:46D :? E9:D >@56= 2C6
+96 EH@ @AE:>2= AC:46D 2C6 8C2A965 :? :8FC6
!? E96 D:>F=2E:@?D E92E H6 92G6 5@?6 H6 E@@< 2=E9@F89 :E :D C6=2E:G6=J D:>A=6 E@
q
:8FC6 $@56= @AE:>2= AC:46D
!? :8FC6 H6 42? D66 E92E H6 2C6 2DDF>:?8 E92E :E :D ?@E A@DD:3=6 7@C E96 ;@FC?2= E@ A2J C6256CD E92E :D E96 C6256C AC:46 42??@E 36 ?682E:G6 !?
C62=:EJ E96 @AE:>2= C6256C AC:46 6BF2E:@? 5:4E2E6D ?682E:G6 C6256C AC:46D 7@C 2== BF2=:EJ =6G6=D 23@G6 E96 BF2=:EJ =6G6= H9:49 :D E96 DEC:4E=J A@D:E:G6 D@=FE:@? E@ :8FC6 D9@HD E96D6 ?682E:G6 AC:46D 2D 2 52D965 4FCG6
*:?46 :E :D ?@E C62=:DE:42==J 762D:3=6 E@ A2J C6256CD @? E92E C2?86 @7 BF2=:EJ
=6G6=D E96 ;@FC?2= H@F=5 36 C6DEC:4E65 E@ E96 4@C?6C D@=FE:@? H:E9 H 9:49 :D :?5:42E65 3J E96 4@?E:?F2E:@? @7 E96 D@=:5 4FCG6 2=@?8 E96 2I:D +9FD E96
@AE:>2= C6256C AC:46 :D 2 A:646H:D6 7F?4E:@?
+9:D 2=D@ 2S64ED E96 @AE:>2= 2FE9@C AC:46 .96? E96 C6256C AC:46 :D C6 DEC:4E65 E@ E96 @AE:>2= 2FE9@C AC:46 :D ?@ =@?86C 8:G6? 3J 6BF2E:@?
D :E 92AA6?D 23@G6 E96 @AE:>2= 2FE9@C AC:46 :D =:?62C 2?5 6BF2= E@
+9FD E96 2FE9@C AC:46 8C2A9 :? :8FC6 :D 2=D@ A:646H:D6 2D 42? 36 D66? 3J E96 <:?< :? E96 @AE:>2= 2FE9@C AC:46 8C2A9 2D 5C2H? D@=:5 E96 52D965 4FCG6 :D E96 4@?E:?F2E:@? @7 E96 @AE:>2= 2FE9@C AC:46 H9:49 H@F=5 2DDF>6 ?682E:G6 C6256C AC:46D 2C6 762D:3=6
D66 E92E E2<:?8 2?J @E96C A@D:E:G6 G2=F6 H@F=5 ?@E 2=E6C E96 D92A6D @7 E96 8C2A9D @3E2:?65
@?=J E96:C G2=F6D
*66 AA6?5:I
pa, pr
pa
pr
q0
%" !#!$!( !$ ')*'$( )% ''(
&FC E9:C5 >@56= :D E96 @AA@D:E6 @7 >@56= *A64:L42==J :? >@56= H6 2DDF>6
:G6? E96 DJ>>6ECJ 36EH66? >@56=D 2?5 :E :D DEC2:89E 7@CH2C5 E@ D66 E92E E96 D@=FE:@? H:== 36 6I24E=J E96 @AA@D:E6 2D :? >@56= E92E :D
q
:8FC6 $@56= @AE:>2= AC:46D
+96 D2>6 4@>>6?ED 2D 7@C :8FC6 2AA=J 3FE ?@HE96 K@?6 @7 BF2=:E:6D 7@C H9:49 E96 C6256C AC:46 :D D6E E@ 2D 2 4@C?6C D@=FE:@? :D H 96C6 :D E96 A@D:E:G6 D@=FE:@? E@ &? E9:D K@?6 282:?
*66 AA6?5:I
pa, pr
q0
pa
pr
!(*((!%$
&FC D:>F=2E:@?D D6CG6 E@ D9@H2 4@FA=6 @7 :>A@CE2?E A@:?ED 2D C682C5D AC:4 :?8 !E :D 4CF4:2= E@ E96 C6DF=ED H9:49 @7 E96 AC@5F4E:@? E649?@=@8:6D 92D E96 564C62D:?8 C6EFC?D .96? 3@E9 E96 AC@5F4E:@? @7 C6256CD FD:?8 2FE9@CD 2D 2?
:?AFE 2?5 E96 AC@5F4E:@? @7 2FE9@CD FD:?8 C6256CD 2D 2? :?AFE 2C6 4@?42G6 AC@5F4E:@? AC@46DD6D E96? @FC D:>F=2E:@? A@:?ED E@ E96C6 36:?8 ?@ BF2=:EJ
=6G6=D 7@C H9:49 6:E96C AC:46 8@6D E@ K6C@ +9FD :? E92E >@56= E96C6 :D ?@
D4@A6 2E 2== 7@C @A6? 2446DD 2D 2? @AE:>2= AC:4:?8 DEC2E68J &? E96 @E96C 92?5 H96? E96 AC@5F4E:@? @7 C6256CD 92D 564C62D:?8 C6EFC?D E@ E96 255:E:@? @7 2F E9@CD 3FE E96 AC@5F4E:@? @7 2FE9@CD :D =:?62C :? C6256CD >@56= E96? @FC D:>F=2E:@? C6G62=D E92E :E 364@>6D @AE:>2= 7@C E96 ;@FC?2= E@ 36 @A6? 2446DD : 6 E@ 492C86 C6256CD 2 AC:46 @7 K6C@ H96? E96 BF2=:EJ @7 E96 ;@FC?2= :D C6=2 E:G6=J 9:89 +9FD :? E9:D >@56= @A6? 2446DD :D 2 762EFC6 @7 9:89 C2E96C E92?
=@H BF2=:EJ ;@FC?2=D +9:C5=J H96? :E :D E96 2FE9@C AC@5F4E:@? AC@46DD E92E 92D 564C62D:?8 C6EFC?D E@ E96 255:E:@? @7 C6256CD 2?5 E96 C6256C AC@5F4E:@?
7F?4E:@? :D =:?62C E96? H6 86E E96 @AA@D:E6 C6DF=E @A6? 2446DD :D 2 762EFC6 @7
@AE:>2= ;@FC?2= AC:4:?8 @?=J 7@C G6CJ =@HBF2=:EJ ;@FC?2=D +96D6 C6DF=ED A@:?E E@ :E ?@E 36:?8 86?6C2==J ECF6 E92E @A6? 2446DD ;@FC?2=D 2C6 @7 =@H6C BF2=:EJ 2D 92D 366? 2C8F65 :? E96 AC6G:@FD =:E6C2EFC6 $4236 2?5 *?J56C
!E :D 2=D@ :?E6C6DE:?8 E92E @FC D:>F=2E:@?D C6G62= E92E E96C6 :D D4@A6 7@C
?682E:G6 2FE9@C AC:46D :? EH@ @7 @FC D46?2C:@D D@>6E9:?8 E92E :D C2E96C C2C6 E@ L?5 :? E96 C62=H@C=5 @7 ;@FC?2= >2?286>6?E !? >@56= H6 86E G6CJ =@H BF2=:EJ ;@FC?2=D 92G:?8 E@ A2J 2FE9@CD :? @C56C E@ 2EEC24E E96> E@ AF3=:D9 :?
E96 ;@FC?2= H9:=6 :? >@56= :E :D G6CJ 9:89 BF2=:EJ ;@FC?2=D E92E A2J E96:C 2FE9@CD
%#&')!+ $"-(!(
.6 ?@H4@>A2C6 6249 @7 @FC E9C66 >@56=D 8C2A9:42==J =@@<:?8 2E E96 G2=F6D
@7 2 D6C:6D @7 :>A@CE2?E 6?5@86?@FD G2C:23=6D .6 =@@< 2E E96 =6G6= @7 AC@LE
@3E2:?65 E96 =6G6= @7 D@4:2= H6=72C6 2?5 E96 D92C6 @7 E@E2= D@4:2= H6=72C6 E92E
:D C6E2:?65 3J 24256>:4D C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD 2== 2D 7F?4E:@?D @7
.6 92G6 2=C625J 56E6C>:?65 23@G6 E96 @AE:>2= AC:46D :? 6249 @7 E96 E9C66
>@56=D +96 @E96C 8C2A9D 2C6 E96? 2== 56C:G65 7C@> E9@D6 @AE:>2= AC:46D +96 62D:6DE H2J E@ D9@H E96 24EF2= 6BF2E:@?D :?G@=G65 :D E@ C642== E92E E96 6BF:=:3C:F> ?F>36CD @7 3@E9 2FE9@CD 2?5 C6256CD2?52C6 3@E9 7F?4E:@?D
@7 E96 EH@ @AE:>2= AC:46D ?5 D:?46 E96 EH@ @AE:>2= AC:46D 2C6 3@E9 7F?4E:@?D
@7 BF2=:EJ E96? D@ 2C6 3@E9 2?5 7F?4E:@?D @7 BF2=:EJ +96? H92E6G6C :D E96 >@56= :?G@=G65 E96 6BF:=:3C:F> =6G6= @7 AC@LED :D ;FDE
+@ 42=4F=2E6 H6=72C6 H6 =@@< 2E E96 DFCA=FD C6E2:?65 3J 24256>:4D E96 D6E @7 C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD A=FD AC@LED +@ 4@?D:56C E96 H6=72C6 @7 2425 6>:4D H6 FD6 E96 4@?46AE @7 4@?DF>6C DFCA=FD &FC 56>2?5 4FCG6D 7@C E96
;@FC?2=ND D6CG:46D 3J 3@E9 C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD 2C6 =:?62C E9FD O4@?DF>6C DFC A=FDP @? 6249 D:56 @7 E96 >2C<6E :D 2 EC:2?8=6 *:?46 @FC 56>2?5 4FCG6D 2C6
7@C 2?5 H 96C6 :D 6:E96C
@C 56A6?5:?8 @? E96 >@56= E96 G6CE:42= :?E6C46AE : 6 E96 AC:46 2E H9:49 BF2?E:EJ 8@6D E@ :D +96 2C62 @7 E96 EC:2?8=6 @? D:56 @7 E96 >2C<6E :D
:G6? E9:D E@E2= H6=72C6 :D 8:G6? 3J
2?5 E96 D92C6 @7 H6=72C6 E92E :D C6E2:?65 3J 24256>:4D :D 8:G6? 3J
+96 8C2A9D @7 E96 AC:?4:A2= G2C:23=6D @7 E96 E9C66 >@56=D 2C6 8:G6? :? +23=6
)642== E92E :? >@56=D 2?5 2? F?C6DEC:4E65 2?2=JD:D H@F=5 D6E ?682E:G6
== @7 E96 8C2A9D 92G6 366? 86?6C2E65 FD:?8 E96 $F' A24<286 :? *4:6?E:L4 .@C<
C6256C AC:46D 7@C D@>6 C2?86D @7 BF2=:EJ +9:D :D ?@E C62=:DE:42==J 762D:3=6 2?5 D@ :? C62=:EJ @? E9@D6 C2?86D @7 BF2=:EJ E96 C6256C AC:46 H@F=5 36 D6E 2E +9:D 92D 366? E2<6? :?E@ 244@F?E :? 2== @7 E96 8C2A9D E92E 2AA62C :? +23=6 E92E :D E96 8C2A9D 7@C >@56=D 2?5 2C6 24EF2==J A:646H:D6 7F?4E:@?D @C 2==
@7 E96 D:>F=2E:@?D 7C@> 96C6 @? H6 92G6 FD65
" %#&'!(%$ % #%"( $
>@56= >@56= >@56=
AC@LE
0 1 2 3
0 10 20
q
0 1 2 3
0 10 20
q
0 1 2 3
0 10 20
q
H6=72C6
0 1 2 3
0 50 100
W(q)
q
0 1 2 3
0 50 100
W(q)
q
0 1 2 3
0 50 100
W(q)
q
D92C6
0 1 2 3
0.0 0.5 1.0S(q)
q
0 1 2 3
0.0 0.5 1.0S(q)
q
0 1 2 3
0.0 0.5 1.0S(q)
q
!? 2== @7 @FC >@56=D E96 =6G6= @7 AC@LE E92E E96 ;@FC?2= 62C?D :D 2=H2JD DEC:4E=J :?4C62D:?8 :? BF2=:EJ +9FD ;@FC?2= >2?286CD H:== 2=H2JD DEC:G6 E@
A=246 2?5 E96J 92G6 2=D@ 2== 366? :?56A6?56?E=J 4964<65 FD:?8 $2E96>2E:42 == @7 E96 H@C<:?8 369:?5 E96 24EF2= 8C2A9D H2D 2=D@ 5@?6 3J 92?5 6E2:=D 2C6 2G2:=23=6 7C@> E96 2FE9@CD FA@? C6BF6DE
Ƈ(q) Ƈ(q) Ƈ(q)
:?4C62D6 E96 A6C46:G65 BF2=:EJ @7 E96:C AF3=:42E:@? !? 6DD6?46 ;@FC?2=D H:== 2E D@>6 A@:?E CF? :?E@ 2 42A24:EJ 4@?DEC2:?E @? 6:E96C 2FE9@CD @C C6256CD E92E H:== 56E6C>:?6 E96 6I24E =6G6= @7 BF2=:EJ E92E E96:C ;@FC?2= 2EE2:?D !? E92E H2J @FC >@56= 42? 2=D@ 36 :?E6CAC6E65 2D @?6 @7 >@?@A@=:DE:4 4@>A6E:E:@?
H96C6 E96 6?E:C6 A@AF=2E:@? @7 D2J 2FE9@CD :D 5:G:565 :?E@ >FEF2==J 6I4=FD:G6 DF3D6ED @?6 7@C 6249 ;@FC?2= +96 BF2=:EJ @7 E96 ;@FC?2= :D E96? 56E6C>:?65 3J H96? E96:C 2==@42E65 ?F>36C @7 2FE9@CD :D C624965 .6 92G6 ?@E >@56==65 E96 56E2:=D @7 E9:D AC@46DD 96C6 3FE C2E96C H6 =:>:E @FCD6=G6D E@ 2 >@C6 :?7@C>2=
5:D4FDD:@? 36=@H
*@4:2= H6=72C6 2D 56L?65 3J E96 E@E2= DF> @7 4@?DF>6C DFCA=FD @? 3@E9 D:56D
@7 E96 >2C<6E A=FD ;@FC?2= AC@LED :D DEC:4E=J :?4C62D:?8 :? ;@FC?2= BF2=:EJ +9FD E96 8C62E6C :D E96 =6G6= @7 BF2=:EJ E92E ;@FC?2=D 42? 2EE2:? E96 8C62E6C :D E96 =6G6=
@7 D@4:2= H6=72C6 @H6G6C E96 H2J E92E H6=72C6 :D D92C65 2>@?8 E96 >2C<6E A2CE:4:A2?ED :D 282:? 4C:E:42==J 56A6?56?E FA@? E96 >@56==:?8 2DDF>AE:@?D !?
@FC >@56= 5:>:?:D9:?8 C6EFC?D @? 3@E9 AC@5F4E:@? 7F?4E:@?D E96 24256>:4D 2?5 E96 ;@FC?2= D92C6 H6=72C6 6BF2==J C682C5=6DD @7 E96 BF2=:EJ @7 E96 ;@FC?2=
!? E96 @E96C EH@ >@56=D E96 D92C6 @7 E@E2= DFCA=FD E92E :D C6E2:?65 3J C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD 72==D 36EH66? =:>:ED 3@E9 FAA6C 2?5 =@H6C D BF2=:EJ :?4C62D6D E96 D92C6 @7 H6=72C6 C6E2:?65 3J :?5:G:5F2=D :?4C62D6D 3FE :D ?6G6C 8C62E6C E92? :? >@56= 2?5 :? >@56= !E 2=D@ ?6G6C 72==D 36=@H :? 3@E9
>@56= 2?5 >@56= E92E :D :? E9@D6 EH@ >@56=D E96 C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD :?
288C682E6 2=H2JD C6E2:? 2 DEC:4E=J =2C86C D92C6 @7 E@E2= DFCA=FD E92? 5@6D E96
;@FC?2= D@ =@?8 2D BF2=:EJ :D DEC:4E=J A@D:E:G6
+96 A:646H:D6 ?2EFC6 @7 E96 8C2A9D :? +23=6 56D6CG6 4@>>6?E +96 8C2A9D H96C6 E96 A:646H:D6 6=6>6?E 92D E96 8C62E6DE 6S64E 2C6 E96 8C2A9D @7 E96 D92C6 @7 24256>:4DN H6=72C6 :? E@E2= H6=72C6 !? :8FC6D >@56= 2?5
>@56= H6 D9@H =2C86C G6CD:@?D @7 E96D6 EH@ 8C2A9D %@E:46 E92E :? >@56=
E96 D92C6 @7 24256>:4 H6=72C6 :? E@E2= H6=72C6 :D :?4C62D:?8 FA E@ E96 A@:?E 2E H9:49 E96 C6256C AC:46 8@6D E@ K6C@ 2?5 :D 564C62D:?8 27E6C E92E E96 52D965
=:?6 :?5:42E6D H96C6 E9:D D92C6 H@F=5 8@ :7 :E H6C6 762D:3=6 E@ A2J C6256CD !?
:8FC6 H6 42? D66 E96 56E2:=65 8C2A9 @7 24256>:4 H6=72C6 2D 2 7C24E:@? @7 E@E2= H6=72C6 :? >@56= !? >@56= E96 D92C6 @7 24256>:4 H6=72C6 :? E@E2=
H6=72C6 :D 2=H2JD :?4C62D:?8 3FE :E :D =@H6C E92? :E H@F=5 36 :7 C6256CD 4@F=5 36 A2:5 @? E96 D64E:@? @7 E96 8C2A9 7@C H9:49 E96 ;@FC?2= :D @A6? 2446DD
0 1 2 3 4 5
0.5 0.6 0.7
q S(q)
:8FC6 *92C6 @7 24256>:4 :? E@E2=
H6=72C6 >@56=
0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6
0.50 0.55 0.60 0.65
q S(q)
:8FC6 *92C6 @7 24256>:4 :? E@E2=
H6=72C6 >@56=
/)( % '#%+" % %&-'! )
.6 42? 2?2=JD6 E96 :DDF6 @7 4@AJC:89E 3J D:>A=J ?@E:?8 E92E H96? E96C6 :D 4@AJC:89E AC@E64E:@? :? A=246 E96 ;@FC?2= 42? 24E :? E96 >2C<6E 7@C C6256CD 2D 2 >@?@A@=:DE H9:=6 :7 E96C6 :D ?@ 4@AJC:89E E96? E96 ;@FC?2= :D 72C >@C6
@A6? E@ 4@>A6E:E:@? 7C@> @E96C AF3=:D96CD :?4=F5:?8 2FE9@CND @H? H63D:E6D 6E4 +9FD 2DDF>6 E92E E96 >@56=D 2?2=JD65 23@G6 2C6 E9@D6 4@CC6DA@?5:?8 E@ E96 6I:DE6?46 @7 4@AJC:89E AC@E64E:@? 2?5 E92E H96? 4@AJC:89E AC@E64E:@?
:D =:7E65 *92G6== E96? E96 ;@FC?2= ?@ =@?86C 86ED E@ 49@@D6 E96 C6256C AC:46 H9:49 :D LI65 2E +9:D D:>A=:L6D E96 >@56= D:8?:L42?E=J
%@H E96 AC@LE E92E E96 ;@FC?2= 62C?D :D 6BF2= @?=J E@ H92E :E 42? 62C?
7C@> 2FE9@CD !? AA6?5:I H6 D9@H E92E E96 @AE:>2= 2FE9@C AC:46D H96?
4@AJC:89E :D C6>@G65 2C6
" *) %' '!(
*$' %%&-'! )
$@56= $@56= $@56=
J 4@>A2C:?8 E96D6 AC:46D H:E9 E96 @AE:>2= 2FE9@C AC:46D F?56C 4@AJC:89E H6 42? D66 E92E E96 C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E D6CG6D E@ :?4C62D6 E96 @AE:>2= 2FE9@C AC:46 :? 2== E9C66 >@56=D !? 4@?EC2DE E@ E96 42D6 @7 4@AJC:89E AC@E64E:@? ?@H
E96 @AE:>2= 2FE9@C AC:46D :? >@56=D 2?5 2C6 DEC:4E=J A@D:E:G6 2?5 =:?62C 7@C 2== =6G6=D @7 BF2=:EJ
.6 ?@H 4@>A2C6 E96 E9C66 >@56=D 3@E9 H:E9 2?5 H:E9@FE 4@AJC:89E .6 AC6D6?E D@>6 C6DF=ED 3@E9 :? 23D@=FE6 G2=F6D 2?5 :? C6=2E:G6 G2=F6D .6 LCDE=J =@@< 2E E96 C6=2E:G6 4@>A2C:D@?D E92E :D D2J H6 2C6 :?E6C6DE65 :? E96 G2C:23=6 H96C6 42? C6AC6D6?E E96 @AE:>2= 2FE9@C AC:46 AC@LED H6=72C6
@C D92C6 @7 H6=72C6 #6E 36 E96 G2=F6 @7 F?56C 2 C68:>6 @7 4@AJC:89E AC@E64E:@? 2?5 =6E 36 :ED G2=F6 H96? 4@AJC:89E :D C6>@G65 +96? H6 2C6 :?E6C6DE65 :? E96 C6=2E:G6 492?86 :? 7C@> E96 C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E
!E EFC?D @FE E92E :? >@56= 2== @7 E96 C6=2E:G6 492?86D 2C6 :?56A6?56?E @7 E96 =6G6= @7 BF2=:EJ 2?5 E9FD 42? 36 8:G6? 2D 2 DA64:L4 A6C46?E286 492?86 !?
E96 @E96C >@56=D E96 C6=2E:G6 6S64E 7C@> C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E 5:S6CD 2D BF2=:EJ 492?86D !? +23=6 2== @7 E96 8C2A9D D9@H? 2C6 A:646H:D6 D:?46 6G6? F?56C 4@AJC:89E E96 :?23:=:EJ E@ A2J C6256CD :>A=:6D E92E 7@C E96 C2?86D @7 BF2=:EJ H96? :E H@F=5 36 @AE:>2= E@ A2J C6256CD E96 C6256C AC:46 >FDE 36 D6E 2E +9FD E96 C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E 92D ?@ 6S64ED 2E 2== @? E9@D6 K@?6D @7 BF2=:EJ .6 42? ?@HD66 E92E E96C6 2C6 D@>6 D:8?:L42?E 5:S6C6?46D 36EH66? >@56=D 2?5 .9:=6 :? 2== @7 E96 >@56=D E96 ;@FC?2= =@D6D AC@LE H96? 4@AJC:89E :D C6>@G65 @? E96 K@?6 7@C H9:49 E96J H@F=5 =:<6 E@ 492C86 2 A@D:E:G6 C6256C AC:46 3FE E96 A6C46?E286 =@DD :? AC@LE :D 564C62D:?8 :? >@56= 2?5 :?4C62D:?8 :? >@56= +92E :D :? >@56= E96 9:896C :D E96 =6G6= @7 BF2=:EJ @7 E96 ;@FC?2=
E96 D>2==6C :D E96 A6C46?E286 =@DD :? AC@LED H96? 4@AJC:89E :D C6>@G65 H9:=6 :? >@56= E96 @AA@D:E6 :D ECF6
+96 23D@=FE6 G2=F6D @7 @FC G2C:23=6D H@F=5 36 2=E6C65 3J D:>A=J 492?8:?8 7@C 6I2>A=6
@FC 2DDF>AE:@? @? E96 G2=F6 @7 @H6G6C 2D H6 D92== D66 E96 23D@=FE6 G2=F6 4@>A2C:D@?
8:G6? :D DE:== :?E6C6DE:?8
" /) % '#%+" % %&-'! ) '")!+ $
>@56= >@56= >@56=
1 2 3
-2 0 2
q
Rel. change
1 2 3
-10 0 10
q
Rel. change
AC@LE
0 1 2 3
-1.0 -0.5
0.0 q
Rel. change
0 1 2 3
-1.0 -0.5
0.0 q
Rel. change
H6=72C6
1 2 3
-1.0 -0.5
0.0 q
Rel. change
1 2 3
-1.0 -0.5
0.0 q
Rel. change
D92C6
1 2 3
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
q
Rel. change
1 2 3
-0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3
q
Rel. change
+96 C6=2E:G6 2?2=JD:D @7 E96 6S64E @7 C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E @? AC@LED :D :?E6C6DE:?8 3FE >@C6 6?=:89E6?:?8 :D E96 2?2=JD:D @7 E96 23D@=FE6 =@DD :? AC@LED :? >@56=D 2?5 !? :8FC6D 2?5 H6 D9@H E96 23D@=FE6 492?86 :? AC@LED 7@C E96D6 EH@ >@56=D +96 :>A@CE2?E E9:?8 E@ ?@E:46 23@FE :8FC6D 2?5 :D E96 9F86 5:S6C6?46 :? E96 D42=6 @7 E96 G6CE:42= 2I:D .9:=6 :? 3@E9 >@56=D F?56C 4@AJC:89E E96 =6G6=D @7 AC@LE 2EE2:?65 2C6 E96 D2>6 D66 +23=6 C@H E96 C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E :? >@56= C6DF=ED :? 2 C6=2E:G6=J D>2== 23D@=FE6 =@DD :? AC@LED 2E""BF2=:EJ =6G6=D @FED:56 @7 E9@D6 7@C H9:49 E96 C6256C AC:46 F?56C 4@AJC:89E H@F=5 36 D6E 2E H9:=6 :? >@56= :E C6DF=ED :? 2 D:>:=2C=J D>2==
=@DD 7@C D>2== =6G6=D @7 BF2=:EJ 36=@H23@FE 3FE G6CJ =2C86 23D@=FE6
=@DD :? AC@LED 7@C 9:89 BF2=:EJ ;@FC?2=D
1 2 3
-0.08 -0.06 -0.04 -0.02 0.00 0.02
q
Change
:8FC6 3D@=FE6 492?86 :? AC@LE 7C@> C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E >@56=
0 1 2 3
-20 -10
0 q
Change
:8FC6 3D@=FE6 492?86 :? AC@LE 7C@> C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E >@56=
.9:=6 E96 C6=2E:G6 6S64E FA@? ;@FC?2= AC@LE :? >@56= :D D66>:?8=J =2C86 7@C =@H6C =6G6=D @7 BF2=:EJ E96D6 =@DD6D 2C6 7@C G6CJ =@H =6G6=D @7 AC@LE 2?JH2J )6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E :? >@56= 92C5=J 2S64ED E96 AC@LED @7 ;@FC?2=D 2E 2?J BF2=:EJ =6G6=D @H6G6C C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E =625D E@ =2C86 AC@LE =@DD6D H96?
AC@LED 2C6 =2C86 :? >@56= 2 >F49 >@C6 56G2DE2E:?8 C6DF=E !7 7@C 6I2>A=6
;@FC?2=D 5:5 92G6 D@>6 LI65 4@DED @7 @A6C2E:@? 2D :D =:<6=J :? E96 C62= H@C=5 E96? C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E H@F=5 =625 E@ E96 4=@DFC6 @7 @?=J G6CJ =@H BF2=:EJ
;@FC?2=D :? >@56= 3FE :E 42? =625 E@ E96 4=@DFC6 @7 9:89 BF2=:EJ ;@FC?2=D :?
>@56= +96 C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E 2D DF886DE65 3J *92G6== >2J 36 2 C2E96C 52?86C@FD DEC2E68J :? 2 D46?2C:@ =:<6 E92E @7 >@56=
!? E96 H6=72C6 2?2=JD:D :? >@56= E96C6 :D 2 C2E96C =2C86 K@?6 @7 A@D:E:G6 H6=72C6 82:?D :? A6C46?E286 E6C>D H96C62D :? >@56= E96 K@?6 @7 H6=72C6 82:?D :D >F49 D>2==6C 2?5 E96 C6=2E:G6 82:?D 2C6 2=D@ D>2==6C +9FD 2DDF>:?8 E92E D@4:2= H6=72C6 :D E96 A@=:4J @3;64E:G6 :E H@F=5 2AA62C E92E C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E
>:89E 36 2 C62D@?23=6 A@=:4J :? >@56= 3FE ?@E :? >@56= +9:D :?EF:E:@? 42?
282:? 36 4@?LC>65 3J =@@<:?8 2E E96 23D@=FE6 492?86D :? H6=72C6 7C@> C6>@G2=
@7 4@AJC:89E :? :8FC6D 2?5 82:? H6 ?665 E@ =@@< 2E E96 D42=6 @7 E96 G6CE:42= 2I:D !? >@56= :8FC6 H9:=6 E96C6 :D 2 G6CJ D>2== ?682E:G6 A2CE
@7 E96 8C2A9 2E =6G6=D @7 BF2=:EJ 36=@H23@FE E96 D42=6 @7 E96D6 =@DD6D :D
E@E2==J :?D:8?:L42?E 4@>A2C65 E@ E96 82:?D 2E =2C86C BF2=:EJ =6G6=D !? D9@CE :? >@56= C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E =625D E@ 92C5=J 2?J 52?86C @7 H6=72C6 =@DD 2?5 C6=2E:G6=J :?E6C6DE:?8 FAH2C5D @7 23@FE H6=72C6 82:?D 7@C 2=>@DE 2==
=6G6=D @7 BF2=:EJ
1 2 3
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
q
Change
:8FC6 3D@=FE6 492?86 :? D@4:2=
H6=72C6 7C@> C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E
>@56=
0 1 2 3
-20 -15 -10 -5
0 q
Change
:8FC6 3D@=FE6 492?86 :? D@4:2=
H6=72C6 7C@> C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E
>@56=
&? E96 @E96C 92?5 4@?D:56C E96 23D@=FE6 H6=72C6 492?86 :? >@56= :8FC6 !? E9:D 8C2A9 E96C6 :D 2 A@D:E:G6 D64E:@? 36EH66? =6G6=D @7 BF2=:EJ @7 2?5 23@FE == @7 E96 C6DE @7 E96 8C2A9 =:6D 36=@HE96 9@C:K@?E2= 2I:D 2?5 2E C6=2E:G6=J =2C86 ?F>36CD H9:49 :>A=:6D E92E C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E =625D E@
=2C86 H6=72C6 =@DD6D 7@C E9@D6 =6G6=D @7 BF2=:EJ +9FD :? >@56= E96 C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E 42? :>AC@G6 H6=72C6 7@C =@H =6G6=D @7 BF2=:EJ 3FE E96 :>AC@G6>6?E :D
>:?:D4F=6 H96C62D 7@C 9:896C =6G6=D @7 BF2=:EJ E96 492?86 :? D@4:2= H6=72C6 :D
?682E:G6 2?5 D:8?:L42?E
:?2==J H6 4@>>6?E @? E96 =2DE C@H @7 +23=6 +96 C6=2E:G6 492?86 :?
E96 D92C6 @7 H6=72C6 E92E 8@6D E@ 24256>:4D :D 564C62D:?8 :? BF2=:EJ :? >@56=
2?5 :?4C62D:?8 :? BF2=:EJ :? >@56= +92E :D H96? 4@AJC:89E :D C6>@G65
!?5665 E96 ?682E:G6 D64E:@? @7 E96 8C2A9 42??@E 6G6? 36 5:D46C?65 F?=6DD E96 G6CE:42=
D42=6 :D 492?865 3J 2 724E@C @7 23@FE
82:? E9:D A@D:E:G6 A2CE 42??@E 36 5:D46C?65 :? E96 8C2A9 F?=6DD H6 492?86 E96 G6CE:42=
D42=6 3J 2 724E@C @7 23@FE
:7 H6 2C6 :? >@56= H9:=6 E@E2= H6=72C6 :D >F49 >@C6 =:<6=J E@ 8@ FA E96 D92C6 @7 E9:D H6=72C6 E92E 244CF6D E@ 24256>:4D 5C@AD !7 H6 2C6 :? >@56=
E96 D92C6 @7 24256>:4 H6=72C6 :? E@E2= H6=72C6 C:D6D H96? 4@AJC:89E :D C6>@G65 3FE :E :D >@C6 =:<6=J E92E E@E2= H6=72C6 5C@AD .6 2C6 2=D@ 23=6 E@ A6C7@C>
2 H6=72C6 2?2=JD:D 7@C C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD D6A2C2E6=J !7 E92E :D 5@?6 E96? :E EFC?D @FE E92E C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E :? 6:E96C >@56= =625D E@ =6DD 2FE9@C H6=72C6 2?5 >@C6 C6256C H6=72C6 2?5 E96 82:? :? C6256C H6=72C6 @FEH6:89D E96 =@DD :?
2FE9@C H6=72C6 @H6G6C D:?46 :? C62=:EJ C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD 2C6 86?6C2==J E96 D2>6 A6@A=6 24256>:4D :E :D AC@323=J >@C6 :?E6C6DE:?8 E@ 4@?D:56C E96 DF>
@7 H6=72C6 8@:?8 E@ E96 C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD
%$(!')!%$ % &!)- %$()'!$)(
3@G6 H6 92G6 ?@E65 E92E :? @C56C E@ 4@?D:56C D@>6 568C66 @7 4@>A6E:E:@? :?
@FC >@56= :E H@F=5 36 C6=6G2?E E@ :>A@D6 42A24:EJ 4@?DEC2:?ED @? 3@E9 @7 E96 EH@ D:56D @7 E96 >2C<6E !? E9:D H2J E96 ;@FC?2=D >2C<6E 42? 36 E9@F89E @7 2D
@A6C2E:?8 :? 2? 6?G:C@?>6?E @7 >@?@A@=:DE:4 4@>A6E:E:@? 7F== 4@?D:56C2E:@?
@7 42A24:EJ 4@?DEC2:?ED :? E96 D:>F=2E:@?D E92E H6 92G6 5@?6 @7 E96 >@56= H@F=5 255 BF:E6 2 =2C86 ?F>36C @7 ?6HD46?2C:@D E@ 4@?D:56C .6 766= E92E :E :D 36DE E@ =62G6 2 56E2:=65 2?2=JD:D @7 :E E@ 7FEFC6 C6D62C49 2=E9@F89 :E :D H@CE9H9:=6 E@ >6?E:@? 96C6 9@HE9:?8D H@F=5 A=2J @FE
,?56C 2 42A24:EJ 4@?DEC2:?E E96 ;@FC?2= 4@F=5 4@F?E @? 2 46CE2:? >2I:>F>
?F>36C @7 3@E9 C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD +96 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD 2C6 3@E9 :?4C62D:?8 7F?4E:@?D @7 BF2=:EJ :? 2== @7 E96 >@56= 4@?L8FC2E:@?D E92E H6 92G6 FD65 +9FD 2=E9@F89 E96 ;@FC?2=ND AC@LE :D 2=D@ :?4C62D:?8 :? BF2=:EJ E96
;@FC?2= H@F=5 ?@E 36 23=6 E@ D6E BF2=:EJ 2C3:EC2C:=J 9:89 2D 2E D@>6 A@:?E :E H@F=5 CF? @FE @7 6:E96C C6256CD @C 2FE9@CD !? E9:D H2J E96 42A24:EJ 4@?DEC2:?ED
@H6G6C :7 H6 H6C6 E@ 4@?D:56C 24256>:4D 2E 5:S6C6?E F?:G6CD:E:6D 2?5 D:?46 E96 2F E9@CD9:A 2E D@>6 F?:G6CD:E:6D :D D:8?:L42?E=J 9:896C E92? 2E @E96CD 9:89 C2?<65 F?:G6CD:E:6D G6CDFD =@H C2?<65 @?6D @? 2 D42=6 @7 AF3=:42E:@?D E96? H6 >:89E H2?E E@ 42=4F=2E6 C6256C 2?5 2FE9@C H6=72C6 D6A2C2E6=J E F?:G6CD:E:6D H:E9 =@H AF3=:42E:@? @FEAFED E96 24256>:4D 2C6 >2:?=J C6256CD +96D6 F?:G6CD:E:6D H@F=5 2AA2C6?E=J 82:? D:8?:L42?E=J 7C@> C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E +96 D2>6 >2J ?@E 36 ECF6 :? F?:G6CD:E:6D H:E9 2 9:89 ?F>36C @7 AF3=:42E:@?D
*66 $F6==6C#2?86C 2?5 .2EE 7@C 7FCE96C 56E2:=D
H@F=5 56E6C>:?6 E96 L?2= BF2=:EJ 249:6G65 :? E96 >@56=
+96 :?EC@5F4E:@? @7 42A24:EJ 4@?DEC2:?ED H@F=5 92G6 :>A@CE2?E 6S64ED H96?
E96 C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E :D 4@?D:56C65 ,?=6DD E96 C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E D@>6 9@H H6C6 E@ 2=E6C E96 3:?5:?8 4@?DEC2:?E D@>6E9:?8 E92E H@F=5 D66> ?@E E@
36 =@8:42= E96? E96 42A24:EJ 4@?DEC2:?ED 92G6 E96 A@E6?E:2= E@ :?E6CG6?6 :? E96 H6=72C6 2?2=JD:D @7 E96 AC6G:@FD D64E:@?
+2<6 7@C 6I2>A=6 @FC >@56= .96? 4@AJC:89E :D C6>@G65 D@4:2= H6=72C6 :?4C62D6D 3J 2C@F?5 C682C5=6DD @7 E96 =6G6= @7 BF2=:EJ @H6G6C :? E92E
>@56= E96 C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E H:== 2=D@ :?4C62D6 E96 ?F>36CD @7 3@E9 C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD 2E 6249 =6G6= @7 BF2=:EJ +9:D :? EFC? :>A=:6D E92E E96 42A24:EJ 4@?DEC2:?E >FDE ?@H3:?5 2E 2 =@H6C =6G6= @7 BF2=:EJ 2?5 D@ :? E96 6?5 E96 L?2= BF2=:EJ E92E :D 24EF2==J 249:6G65 :D 564C62D65 *:?46 D@4:2= H6=72C6 :D 2?
:?4C62D:?8 7F?4E:@? @7 BF2=:EJ E96C6 :D 2? @SD6EE:?8 6S64E @? D@4:2= H6=72C6 E92E >2J @C >2J ?@E 4@F?E6C32=2?46 E96 82:? E92E :D :?:E:2==J 7@F?5 3J C6>@G:?8 4@AJC:89E
$@56= H@C<D :? 2 D:>:=2C H2J E@ >@56= :? C6DA64E @7 E9:D 42A24:EJ 4@?DEC2:?E 6S64E )6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E H:== :?4C62D6 D@4:2= H6=72C6 2E 2=>@DE 2== =6G6=D @7 BF2=:EJ 7@C H9:49 @A6? 2446DD H2D ?@E @AE:>2= H:E9 4@AJC:89E :?
A=246 3FE :E H:== 2=D@ :?4C62D6 E96 ?F>36CD @7 3@E9 C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD 2E 6249 BF2=:EJ =6G6= +9FD E96 42A24:EJ 4@?DEC2:?E H:== 3:?5 2E 2 =@H6C =6G6= @7 BF2=:EJ 2?5 D@ L?2= BF2=:EJ 249:6G65 H:== 8@ 5@H? +96 D@4:2= H6=72C6 82:?D 2C6 2E =62DE A2CE:2==J @SD6E 3J E96 H6=72C6 =@DD @7 2 =@H6C BF2=:EJ =6G6= &?
E96 @E96C 92?5 :? >@56= E96 @AA@D:E6 @44FCD )6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E :D
=:<6=J E@ :?4C62D6 D@4:2= H6=72C6 3FE :? E92E >@56= E96 ?F>36CD @7 C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD 2C6 564C62D65 2E 6249 =6G6= @7 BF2=:EJ H96? 4@AJC:89E :D C6>@G65 +96 42A24:EJ 4@?DEC2:?E E96? H@F=5 3:?5 2E 2 9:896C =6G6= @7 BF2=:EJ E92? 367@C6 :>A=J:?8 2 H6=72C6 82:? E92E 2E =62DE A2CE:2==J @SD6ED E96 =@DD6D 7C@> C6>@G2=
82:? E9:D :D 2DDF>:?8 E92E E96 @AE:>2= C6256C AC:46 H:E9 4@AJC:89E H2D ?@E D6E 2E
!7 @A6? 2446DD H6C6 @AE:>2= F?56C 4@AJC:89E E96? @7 4@FCD6 ?@ 6S64E 2E 2== 92AA6?D H96?
4@AJC:89E :D C6>@G65
!? C6=2=:EJ E9:D @?=J 92AA6?D :? >@56= H96? BF2=:EJ :D 23@G6 2 46CE2:? E9C6D9@=5 @H6G6C E96 E9C6D9@=5 :D 2E 2 =@H =6G6= @7 BF2=:EJ 2?5 36=@H E9:D E9C6D9@=5 2=E9@F89 E96
?F>36CD @7 24256>:4D D6CG65 24EF2==J :?4C62D6 E96 492?86 :D C2E96C :?L?:E6D:>2=
@7 4@AJC:89E
!E :D :>A@DD:3=6 E@ <?@H H9:49 @7 E96 EH@ 6S64ED E96 5:C64EJ H6=72C6 6S64E 2E 6249 =6G6= @7 BF2=:EJ 7C@> C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E @C E96 :?5:C64E H6=72C6 6S64E
@7 E96 492?86 :? BF2=:EJ 5F6 E@ E96 42A24:EJ 4@?DEC2:?ED :D E96 =2C86C @H6G6C DEF5J:?8 E9:D 6S64E H@F=5 >2<6 2? :?E6C6DE:?8 6IE6?D:@? E@ E96 AC6D6?E A2A6C
%$"*(!%$(
== @7 @FC 4@?4=FD:@?D 2C6 32D65 FA@? ?F>6C:42= D:>F=2E:@? 2?5 A2CE:4F=2C 7F?4E:@?2= 7@C>D 2?5 D@ D9@F=5 36 C625 H:E9 5F6 42C6 @H6G6C E96 @?=J G2C:23=6 :? @FC >@56= :D E96 6S64E @7 2? :?4C62D65 =6G6= @7 BF2=:EJ FA@? E96
?F>36C @7 C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD E92E :D E96 G6CE:42= :?E6C46AE @7 @FC 56>2?5 4FCG6D :S6C6?E G2=F6D 7@C E9:D G6CE:42= :?E6C46AE H@F=5 492?86 E96 ?F>36CD H6 86E 3FE ?@E E96 DECF4EFC6 @7 E96 >@56=D
&FC 4@?4=FD:@?D 2C6 E96 7@==@H:?8 :CDE=J H:E9 C682C5 E@ E96 C6=2E:@?D9:A 36EH66? ;@FC?2= BF2=:EJ 2?5 @A6? 2446DD :? 2 4@AJC:89E AC@E64E65 C68:>6 : 6 E96 DE2EFD BF@ @FC >@56= DF886DED E92E :E :D %&+ ECF6 E92E @A6? 2446DD
;@FC?2=D H:== ?646DD2C:=J 92G6 =@H6C BF2=:EJ E92? 4=@D65 2446DD ;@FC?2=D 2D 92D 366? DF886DE65 :? E96 =:E6C2EFC6 !?5665 H6 L?5 E92E F?56C 2AAC@AC:2E6 AC@LE
>2I:>:D2E:@? @? 3@E9 D:56D @7 E96 ;@FC?2= >2C<6E E96C6 6I:DE 4@?L8FC2E:@?D F?56C H9:49 :E :D E96 9:896C BF2=:EJ ;@FC?2=D E92E H:== 92G6 E96 @A6? 2446DD 7@C>2E @FC >@56= .6 2=D@ 92G6 2 >@56= >@56= :? H9:49 @A6? 2446DD :D ?6G6C 2 762EFC6 @7 2? @AE:>2==J AC:465 ;@FC?2=
*64@?5 H:E9 C682C5 E96 9JA@E96D:K65 C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E 2D DF886DE65 3J *92G6== H6 L?5 E92E C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E H:== 92G6 2 5:S6C6?E 6S64E 56A6?5:?8 FA@? E96 4@?L8FC2E:@? @7 E96 >2C<6E .6 L?5 D46?2C:@D :? H9:49 C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E H:== 92G6 92C5=J 2?J 6S64E @? AC@LED 3FE H:== :?4C62D6 D@4:2= H6=72C6 7@C 2=>@DE 2== BF2=:EJ >62DFC6D >@56= 2?5 @E96C D46?2C:@D :? H9:49 C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E H:== 92G6 2 D6C:@FD ?682E:G6 6S64E @? E96 AC@LED
@7 9:89 BF2=:EJ ;@FC?2=D 2?5 E92E H:== C65F46 D@4:2= H6=72C6 >@56= +9FD 282:? H6 42??@E F?2>3:8F@FD=J DFAA@CE C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E 3FE ?@C 42? H6 F?2>3:8F@FD=J DFAA@CE :ED 4@?E:?F65 C6E6?E:@? !? @FC >@56= H6 L?5 E92E
C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E :D F?2>3:8F@FD=J D@4:2= H6=72C6 :>AC@G:?8 3FE :E H:==
2=D@ 92G6 2 D6C:@FD ?682E:G6 6S64E @? ;@FC?2= AC@LED !7 E96 C62= DE2E6 @7 E96 H@C=5 :D D@>6E9:?8 =:<6 >@56= E96? C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E :D =:<6=J E@ 36 2 36?6L4:2= D@4:2= A@=:4J 3FE :E >2J 92G6 E@ 36 244@>A2?:65 3J 2? 2=E6C?2E:G6 3FD:?6DD >@56= 7@C AF3=:42E:@? @7 D4:6?E:L4 H@C<
+9:D A2A6C DF886DED D6G6C2= 5:C64E:@?D :? H9:49 7FEFC6 C6D62C49 4@F=5 36 5:C64E65 :CDE=J :E H@F=5 36 >@DE :?E6C6DE:?8 E@ G6C:7J 6>A:C:42==J H9:49 :7 2?J @7 @FC E9C66 >@56=D :D >@DE =:<6=J E@ 36 C62=H@C=5 C6=6G2?E $@56=D 2?5 AC@G:56 DFAA@CE 7@C C6>@G2= @7 4@AJC:89E H9:=6 >@56= 5@6D ?@E +96 4C:E:42= :DDF6 :D H96C6 E96 5:>:?:D9:?8 C6EFC?D =:6 :D :E E96 AC@5F4E:@? @7 C6256CD H:E9 2FE9@CD 2D 2? :?AFE E92E DFS6CD 5:>:?:D9:?8 C6EFC?D @C C2E96C :D 5:>:?:D9:?8 C6EFC?D 2 762EFC6 @7 E96 AC@5F4E:@? @7 2FE9@CD H:E9 C6256CD 2D 2?
:?AFE .6 42? E9:?< @7 =@8:42= C62D@?D E@ DFAA@CE 6:E96C 2C8F>6?E '6C92AD 2? 6>A:C:42= 6I2>:?2E:@? 4@F=5 E9C@HD@>6 =:89E @? E9:D :DDF6 *64@?5 @FC
>@56= 92D 366? 42=:3C2E65 H:E9 2 D:?8=6 A2C2>6E6C 7@C E96 6S64E @7 :?4C62D65 BF2=:EJ FA@? E96 56>2?5 7@C ;@FC?2= DA246 3J 3@E9 2FE9@CD 2?5 C6256CD .9:=6 4@?D:56C:?8 5:S6C6?E G2=F6D @7 E9:D A2C2>6E6C H:== ?@E 2=E6C @FC >@56= :? 2?J D:8?:L42?E >2??6C :E H@F=5 46CE2:?=J 36 @7 :?E6C6DE E@ 4@?D:56C E92E E96 6S64E :D 5:S6C6?E 7@C 2FE9@CD 2D 7@C C6256CD @:?8 D@ H@F=5 F?32=2?46 E96 >@56= 2?5 H@F=5 46CE2:?=J 92G6 E96 A@E6?E:2= E@ 2=E6C D@>6 @7 @FC 4@?4=FD:@?D @H6G6C 282:? :E :D G6CJ 92C5 E@ E9:?< @7 4@?G:?4:?8 C62D@?D H9J 2? :?4C62D6 :? ;@FC?2=
BF2=:EJ H:== 2EEC24E ?6HC6256CD :? 2 ?@E23=J 5:S6C6?E H2J E@ 9@H:E 2EEC24ED
?6H2FE9@CD +9:C5 E96 >@56= 86?6C2E6D DA64:L4 7@C>F=2D 7@C E96 ?F>36CD @7 C6256CD 2?5 E96 ?F>36CD @7 2FE9@CD 7@C 6249 BF2=:EJ =6G6= +96 C2E:@ 36EH66?
E96D6 EH@ 8:G6D FD E96 ?F>36C @7 C6256CD A6C AF3=:D965 A2A6C D@>6E9:?8 E92E H6 >2J 2DD@4:2E6 H:E9 E96 O:>A24EP @7 E96 ;@FC?2= FCE96C E96 :>A24E 724E@C
&? E96 @?6 92?5 E96 255:E:@? @7 C6256CD :?E@ E96 2FE9@C AC@5F4E:@? 7F?4E:@? :D E96 255:E:@? @7 ?6HF?:ED @7 A6C764E=J DF3DE:EFE23=6 :?AFED H9:49 EC25:E:@?2==J H@F=5 36 E9@F89E E@ :?G@=G6 5:>:?:D9:?8 C6EFC?D @C E9:D C62D@? A6C92AD >@56= :D C62=:DE:4 @H6G6C @?
E96 @E96C 92?5 6G6? E9@F89 255:E@?2= 2FE9@CD 2C6 ?@?A6C764E DF3DE:EFE6D 7@C AC@5F4:?8 C6256CD DFC6=J 6249 C6256C 92D 2 DEC:4E E:>6 3F586E 4@?DEC2:?E 7@C C625:?8 A2A6CD 2?5 D@
255:?8 A2A6CD :D E96 255:E:@? @7 2 G2C:23=6 2==36:E ?@? A6C764E=J DF3DE:EFE23=6 :?AFE E@
2 LI65 E:>6 :?AFE H9:49 282:? H6 >:89E E9:?< H@F=5 :>A=J 5:>:?:D9:?8 C6EFC?D >2<:?8
>@56= C62=:DE:4
E92E :D 923:EF2==J FD65 6 8 3J !*! H9:49 :D 4:E6D A6C A2A6C AF3=:D965 42?
36 D66? 2D ?@E9:?8 >@C6 E92? C6256CD A6C A2A6C E:>6D E96 AC@323:=:EJ E92E 2?J 8:G6? C6256C H:== 6?5 FA 4:E:?8 E96 A2A6C 96 @C D96 C625D :? 2 7@==@HFA A2A6C
!E H@F=5 36 @7 8C62E :?E6C6DE E@ 2EE6>AE E@ :56?E:7J 2? 2AAC@AC:2E6 7F?4E:@?
7@C E96 AC@323:=:EJ @7 4:E:?8 2D 2 7F?4E:@? @7 E96 BF2=:EJ @7 E96 ;@FC?2= 2CE:4=6 C625 D@ E92E @FC >@56= >2J E96? 36 2AA=:65 5:C64E=J E@ 2? 2?2=JD:D @7 E96 G2=:5:EJ @7 E96 !*! :>A24E 724E@C 2D 2? :?5:42E@C @7 ;@FC?2= BF2=:EJ @FCE9 E96 ;@FC?2= E92E H6 92G6 >@56==65 :D 2? @?=:?6 AC@5F4E @?=J +9:D D:>A=:L6D E9:?8D 2D C682C5D E96 4@DED @7 CF??:?8 E96 ;@FC?2= 2?5 E9FD E96 ;@FC?2=ND AC@LE 7F?4E:@? .6 H@F=5 9@H6G6C 36 :?E6C6DE65 :? 2 G6CD:@? @7 E9:D >@56=
36:?8 2AA=:65 E@ ;@FC?2=D H:E9 3@E9 92C5AC:?E 2?5 @?=:?6 7@C>2ED 2?5 23@G6 2== 2 ;@FC?2= H:E9 2 9J3C:5@A6? 2446DD A@=:4J 2 A@=:4J :? H9:49 E96 2FE9@C 42? 564:56 2?5 A2J 2 4@CC6DA@?5:?8 766 E@ E96 ;@FC?2= :? @C56C E@ 92G6 E96 2CE:4=6 AC:465 2E K6C@ E@ C6256CD :?2==J @FC >@56= 92D A2:5 D42?E 2EE6?E:@?
E@ 4@>A6E:E:@? @G6C ;@FC?2=D @FC >@56= :D C62==J 2 >@?@A@=:DE:4 ;@FC?2= @C 2E >@DE 2 >@?@A@=:DE:42==J 4@>A6E:E:G6 ;@FC?2= 2?5 D42?E 2EE6?E:@? E@ E96 AC64:D6 >2??6C :? H9:49 BF2=:EJ :D 49@D6? : 6 E96 C676C66 AC@46DD 44@F?E:?8 7@C 6:E96C @C 3@E9 @7 E96D6 762EFC6D H@F=5 8C62E=J :>AC@G6 E96 >@56= 2=E9@F89 H6 9JA@E96D:K6 2E 2 D:8?:L42?E :?4C62D6 :? 4@>A=6I:EJ
)676C6?46D
C>DEC@?8 $ @>A6E:E:@? :? +H@D:565 $2C<6ED !&#
! ! !$
"6@? * 2?5 " )@496E O+96 'C:4:?8 @7 4256>:4 "@FC?2=D +H@*:565 $2C<6E '6CDA64E:G6P # ! ! !&# #!!
!$
$4236 $ " 2?5 $ *?J56C O&A6? 446DD 2?5 4256>:4 "@FC
?2= (F2=:EJP # ! ! '(
$4236 $ " 2?5 $ *?J56C O4256>:4 "@FC?2= 'C:46D :? 2 :8:E2= 86 +H@*:565 $2C<6E $@56=P !&# ! ! ! )$$ !) @?EC:3FE:@?D CE:4=6
$F6==6C#2?86C 2?5 ) .2EE O@AJC:89E 2?5 &A6? 446DD 7@C
*4:6?E:L4 .@C<DP '( ! ! ! $# ! !")#% $$&$
*92G6== * O*9@F=5 @AJC:89E @7 4256>:4 .@C<D 36 3@=:D965P
!&# ! )$$
AA6?5:I &AE:>2= AC:46D :? >@56= F?56C 4@AJ C:89E AC@E64E:@?
+96 EH@ D:>F=E2?6@FD 6BF2E:@?D 2?5 42? 36 HC:EE6? 2D
H96C6 7@C @E9 @7 2?5 2C6 4@?DEC2:?65 E@ 36 A@D:E:G6 .6 2C6 C6DEC:4E65 E@ A2C2>6E6C G2=F6D DF49 E92E 7@C E92E :D H6 42? @?=J 4@?D:56C AC:46D E92E D2E:D7J 7@C !E :D 62DJ E@ D9@HE92E E96 D@=FE:@? E@ E96 EH@ 6BF2E:@?D 2?5 @FED:56 @7 E96 EC:G:2= D@=FE:@? 2E :D 2E +96 AC@LED @7 E96 ;@FC?2=
2C6 8:G6? 3J
C@> E96 56L?:E:@?D @7 E96 EH@ 7F?4E:@?D H6 42? D66 E92E AC@LE :D ?@H 2 E9:C5@C56C 7F?4E:@? @7 6249 AC:46
@?D:56C LCDE E96 @AE:>2= C6256C AC:46 +96 EH@ 56C:G2E:G6D @7 E96 AC@LE 7F?4E:@? H:E9 C6DA64E E@ 2C6
+96 LCDE@C56C 4@?5:E:@? 7@C 2 >2I:>F> :D
H96C6 IEC24E:?8 E96 4@>>@? 724E@C H6 92G6 *:?46 H 6 92G6
*F3DE:EFE:?8 7@C E9:D C625D +96 L?2=
D@=FE:@? :D 8:G6? 3J
+9:D D@=FE:@? :D F?:BF6 @? E96 C2?86 *:?46 @FC D@=FE:@? :D F?:BF6 :? @C56C E@ 6?DFC6 E92E :E :D 2 >2I:>F> H6 ?665 E@ D9@H E92E E96 D64@?5@C56C 4@?5:E:@? 9@=5D 2E E92E D@=FE:@?
BF2E:@? :D *F3DE:EFE:?8 E9:D :?E@ @FC D64@?5@C56C 4@?5:E:@? H6 86E
H9:49 9@=5D 7@C 2?J +9FD :D :?5665 2 >2I:>F>
*64@?5 4@?D:56C E96 @AE:>2= 2FE9@C AC:46 +96 LCDE EH@ 56C:G2E:G6D @7 E96 AC@LE 7F?4E:@? H:E9 C6DA64E E@ 2C6
+96 LCDE@C56C 4@?5:E:@? :D
+96 D64@?5 @C56C 4@?5:E:@? :D
H9:49 FA@? DF3DE:EFE:?8 7@C C65F46D E@
%@H ?@E6 E92E :D ;FDE
@C
,D:?8 E96 BF25C2E:4 7@C>F=2 H6 <?@H E92E E96 EH@ C@@ED @7 E9:D 6BF2E:@?
D2E:D7J
*:>A=:7J:?8 H6 86E
.6 42? D66 7C@> E96 D64@?5@C56C 4@?5:E:@? E92E E96 9:896C @7 E96D6 EH@
C@@ED :D 2 >:?:>F> 2?5 E96 =@H6C :D E96 >2I:>F> +9FD E96 @AE:>2= 2FE9@C AC:46 :D 8:G6? 3J
!? @C56C E@ L?5 E96 6I24E @AE:>2= AC:46D 7@C C6256CD 2?5 2FE9@CD 3@E9 2D 7F?4E:@?D @7 @?=J E96 ;@FC?2= BF2=:EJ H6 D:>F=E2?6@FD=J D@=G6 E96 EH@
